Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Human Resource Development Masterclass

Human Resource Development Masterclass artwork

Career Development

Jul 20, 20211 hr 10 minAudio

In this fifth episode of HRD Masterclass, guests Dr. Kim McDonald (Professor Emerita at Purdue University Fort Wayne), and Dr. Rajashi Ghosh (Associate Professor and Department Chair at Drexel University) discuss Career Development and its role within Human Resource Development, including: Definitions of careers and career development. The changing nature of careers in the workplace. The role of HRD professionals in career development. Implications for HRD of the shift of ownership for careers from organizations to individuals. How HRD and HRM work together on career development. In the first part of the episode, Kim and Rajashi meet one-to-one with host, Darren Short. In the second part, the two guests are together to discuss their shared interest in Career Development. For full details on the HRD Masterclass series, visit hrdmasterclass.com. For more information on the Academy of Human Resource Development, visit ahrd.org - by being a member of AHRD, you can access bonus materials not included in this episode. The episode is sponsored by Drexel University’s Human Resource Development and Creativity and Innovation Programs. Find out more at Drexel.edu/soe.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_01So HRT professionals need to be then able to work with HRM so that career development opportunities really make sense from a systems perspective.

SPEAKER_00Welcome to the Human Resource Development Masterclass, the new podcast series from the Academy of Human Resource Development, the organization that leads HRD through research. I'm your host, Darren Short, and throughout this first series, I'll be joined by leading authors, researchers, and scholars to explore the fundamentals of HRD and how those are changing in the 2020s. Our focus for this episode is career development, and we'll be focusing on the changing nature of careers in the workplace, what this means for career development, the role of HRD professionals in career development, and much more.

SPEAKER_00To help me, I'll be joined by two leading scholars. Dr. Kim MacDonald, Professor Emerita, Purdue University Fort Wayne, and Dr. Rajchi Ghosh, Associate Professor and Department Chair at Drexel University. In the first part of the episode, I'll chat one-to-one with each of them, and then for the second part, Kim and Raji are together to explore their shared interest in career development. That discussion is brought to you with the help of the generous support of our sponsor, Drexel University's Human Resource Development and Creativity and Innovation Programs.

SPEAKER_00All of the content you'll hear in this episode was recorded during April and May of 2021. Right, let's dive in to meet my first guest.

SPEAKER_00Prior to joining the faculty there, she worked in training and development. Most of Kim's research has focused on career development, including her co-authored text entitled Career Development, a Human Resource Development Perspective. She's published a number of book chapters and journal articles in career and HRD publication outlets. She recently finished her term serving on the AHRD Board of Directors and also was the editor-in-chief for advances in developing human resources from 2012 to 2015.

SPEAKER_00Hi, Kim. Welcome to the HRD Masterclass podcast. It's great to have you here in our episode focusing on career development.

SPEAKER_02Thanks, Darren. I'm really happy to be here. Excited to talk about something that's near and dear to my heart.

SPEAKER_00You know, I thought we'd start maybe by exploring some terms and definitions so that listeners understand what we mean by career development. And so, how about we begin by exploring what the term HRD means to you and how career development fits into your understanding of HRD?

SPEAKER_02So I would define HRD broadly as this process of growth and learning that hopefully enhances both individual and organizations' potential. I know a lot of people make that distinction between learning and performance. I think they both play a role because I think performance plays a role in that individuals, I believe, continuously want to learn in order to improve themselves and improve their performance.

SPEAKER_02But I probably lean more towards the learning element as being the most significant and important part of HRD. I also think that HRD plays and has an even greater role to play that perhaps isn't quite realized yet, in that I think that HRD can foster hope and meaning for individuals and organizations and the greater community beyond those two entities.

SPEAKER_00So, in light of that definition, how do you see career development fitting in?

SPEAKER_02I'm going to use uh Michael Arthur's definition of a career in that he defines it as an evolving sequence of a person's work experiences over time. And that could be paid or unpaid, which leaves that notion of careers as a very broad type of thing. And so then career development is this ongoing process of planning and managing those work experiences to achieve goals, to create meaning and well-being.

SPEAKER_02And the whole that that's a collaborative process between an individual and an organization. So if you're doing those types of things, obviously you're thinking in terms of learning, performance, and since it occurs within an organizational structure, career development and HRD have this natural linkage, I think.

SPEAKER_00When you look at an organization, if you went into an organization that you hadn't been in before, what do you typically look for to see whether or not the organization is taking career development seriously?

SPEAKER_02Well, I think you look for some real tangible things. Do they have a job posting system? Have they somehow looked at their various jobs and have they created job families? Do they have initiatives that will help to develop individuals? Do they have any kind of mentoring in place? Do they have coaching for employees? I would probably want to know what they do to help their managers help their employees with their careers.

SPEAKER_02Because I do think, especially when you get into organizations that are larger, that first-line supervisor or manager becomes extremely important to employees in terms of their careers. In the past, I've advocated for more career counseling, and that HRD needs to have a better grasp of career counseling and what it means and what it entails and those kinds of things.

SPEAKER_02But just knowing what resources are out there so you can help point employees to various resources beyond the organization to help them with their careers.

SPEAKER_00So it feels like careers have changed a lot. So presumably career development has therefore changed with it. Is that is that true?

SPEAKER_02Oh, definitely. I think careers up until about the 1980s, the 1990s, you know, it was kind of this focus on counseling. There was a focus on helping individuals to choose a vocation, and there were different ways of doing that. And I think that after both world wars, there was a big emphasis on assessments and inventories and that type of thing to help people choose careers and then how to get them into management positions and how to get them into um oh, maybe the pipeline in terms of moving up in the organization, you know, and there were all those kinds of things.

SPEAKER_02And in fact, in the 1960s, I think that the government started to step in more and say, hey, corporations, you need to do more to help with issues like unemployment and um helping individuals progress in organizations, and so a lot of corporations started to have career centers and those kinds of things. But come 1980s, 1990s, you saw this huge shift, I think.

SPEAKER_02First of all, you had more and more women entering the workforce. Um, you had lots of mergers, acquisitions, and organizations downsizing. Uh, you had new technology, which resulted in uh how work was being done, changed, and a lot of times it also meant the elimination of particular jobs. Particularly, I think the number of layoffs and really created it created a tremendous amount of turbulence, but it also I think created so much discomfort on the part of employees and organizations.

SPEAKER_02All of a sudden, employees, you know, were let go of maybe an organization that they had spent 20, 30 years at. I think organizations weren't quite sure. Well, first of all, they downsized a lot of those individuals, but they also, I think, kind of didn't know exactly what they should be doing. And it became much more of an individual needing to take control of their career.

SPEAKER_00And it felt like almost overnight they they kind of passed responsibility for that to the individual. And they I think they labeled it like free agent or something like that. Um, but it was never clear to me whether what they were doing was conscious, i.e., were they deliberately trying to pass this to employees, or was it a default thing, i.e., they didn't know what to do, and therefore the default was the employee ended up ended up having to manage their own career.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, I I don't know for sure. I I have a feeling it was probably a combination of factors. Um you know, they they got this whole notion of organizations needing to be flatter, leaner, meaner. Yeah. So I don't think that there, that there may have been just the personnel to handle to help people. And then yeah, you get um um, you know, globalization where you know they were sending jobs overseas and that type of thing.

SPEAKER_02You had all of those things happening. And so I think I think it was probably a bit of intentional. We just can't do things that we used to do because we don't have the personnel. Um, and then maybe partly it was unintentional, but it was more, oh my gosh, things are moving, things are changing at such a rapid pace that we aren't sure what we can do.

SPEAKER_00Now, what one of the factors that you called out there was the increase in the number of women in the workforce. How did that impact career development and careers in general?

SPEAKER_02It it wasn't just women, but it's just the fact that we we have a more diverse workforce, I think. And that's all good. It does come with a whole host of issues and challenges that organizations have to address. You know, when women start working, it creates more conflicts, perhaps, in terms of just that work-home balance type of thing. You've got an awful lot of uh organizations that weren't quick to move on, okay, women are in the workforce.

SPEAKER_02Um, what do we do to make sure that they get equal access and equal opportunities? We've had a long history of women and underrepresented groups not having equal access or having to deal with discrimination and harassment. So those kinds of things have influenced career development in a lot of ways. And you're dealing with a lot more forces, maybe is the word I'm looking for, or that I'm thinking of.

SPEAKER_02But you're you're dealing with a lot more things than perhaps you did when you had a much more homogenous uh workforce that was made up primarily of men.

SPEAKER_00So it sounds um uh a messier, more complex system to be managing um with many interacting forces at a time when it sounds like organizations have backed away from having, in many cases, having career specialists. So where do you see the that work landing now? As in, do you see HRD people in an organization picking up career development as a part of their role?

SPEAKER_02Yeah, and it's hard to separate those things out. Um, because you know, training and development is, for example, is an important initiative for anyone who wants to further develop their career. So it really uh I think it's hard to parse out and say, well, I only deal with career issues. So I think that, yes, I think HRD can play a huge role in doing those types of things.

SPEAKER_02Like I said, it's it's gotten messy, it's gotten complicated, and it's not just the fact that the workforce is more diverse. You know, you've got lots and lots of economic things that are happening and that have been happening now for, I mean, they've always happened, but it seems to me like the pace of change in terms of our economic environment has just gone crazy.

SPEAKER_02Organizations continually restructure, you've got many more contingent workers, gig workers, you've got a lot of individuals who are in kind of precarious work situations. I just don't think you can separate all of these entities, and it is probably too much to ask HRD folks to be responsible for people's careers.

SPEAKER_02Um, I think it has to be something where you've got to get the individuals responsible for their own careers, and then HRD provides support along with managers.

SPEAKER_00When you look around the workplace now, it sounds like that's clearly one of the challenges that organizations are dealing with from a career perspective. When you take a look around organizations, what other major challenges do you see career development facing at this point? And and how do you see career development changing as a result?

SPEAKER_02Well, um, I think another huge change or another huge challenge is how to deal with technology changes and the fact that many people will probably lose their careers because of technology. Uh, we've already seen a huge increase in automation in, for instance, manufacturing jobs. They project that the next big wave is probably gonna be office and administrative work, where you're gonna see that technology is probably gonna replace a lot of people.

SPEAKER_02Probably already has to some extent, but I think we're gonna see more of that. Uh, just think in terms of all the drivers we have, the Uber drivers, the cab drivers, the truck drivers, and what happens when we start to automate driving. And we've always had those concerns or we've always had those issues over the years, but it just seems like it just is such a rapid pace anymore. I mean, take it, take a recent event that we've all experienced this past year, the the whole pandemic.

SPEAKER_02And we don't know the full impact it's going to have on people's careers. But you know, it's resulted in tons of people being being laid off, unemployed. It's resulted in an awful lot of women having to quit their jobs because they just couldn't handle kids at home, work. It's through technology that we've been able to some extent uh stay in business. And I think that increasingly what we're finding in the field of careers, both in terms of the scholarship of career, the scholarship and organizations, is that need to continually be so aware of the context, the landscape, what's going on from a societal perspective, from an economic perspective, in order to be able to adapt both your own career and in your attempts to help people with their own with their careers.

SPEAKER_00The picture I get is a shift from a period when career development was clearly like owned by the organization, and careers were long-term and they were planned potentially for decades in advance, and they were mostly happened at one organization, to a time now where to an extent the individual is seen as owning their own careers and career development, that they may have multiple careers during their lifetime, some of which they choose to leave, and some they may have to leave because that career goes that career path just goes away.

SPEAKER_00And it presumably becomes really important to individuals that they have the skills to pivot quickly in a career, that they have the skills to transfer themselves from one career path to another when they need to do that.

SPEAKER_02Exactly. And when when you talk about uh what are the skills that individuals need? Well, they they they they need to be employable. So how so organizations can help a lot by providing them with things like training and development opportunities, uh, because it's by having skills and abilities and knowledge that they're going to be more employable.

SPEAKER_02Um they have to be flexible and adaptable, they have to be resilient. Um I think that continuous learning is huge for individuals. But even though I do believe that individuals have a huge, huge role in terms of their careers, I I you know, I still think there's that need for HRD to help.

SPEAKER_02And because there's you know, people would love, I I think an awful lot of people would still love to have security in their jobs. Some people that's not that important, but for some people it is. It's going to be less and less likely that they're going to have that security, probably. But but to get back to what HRD needs to do. You know, steering them towards resources, uh, listening to what they need, and then trying to provide them with uh opportunities both within the organization and outside the organization so that they can continually grow and develop.

SPEAKER_02Um, you know, HRD needs to advocate for inequalities that occur in organizations. They need to be oftentimes the individuals that are saying, now wait a minute, why aren't we offering this training program to this group of individuals? Uh why is there such a huge discrepancy in terms of what this group of individuals get paid versus what this group of individuals get paid?

SPEAKER_02If we are all about helping humans develop within organizations, we have to take an important role in pointing out those inequalities.

SPEAKER_00Okay then, Kim. Thank you so much for our conversation. Please stay with us as we'll be back together later in the episode for a group discussion with my next guest, Raji. But for now, thank you so much, Kim, for your time.

SPEAKER_02Thank you. I've really enjoyed it. And I look forward to our next discussion.

SPEAKER_00My second guest for the episode is Dr. Rajchi Ghosh, Associate Professor of Human Resource Development and Department Chair at Drexel University. Her research explores how different developmental initiatives like mentoring and coaching can facilitate workplace learning and development through building inclusive relational spaces and countering the prevalence of workplace incivility. Rajshi's work has been published in several high-impact peer-reviewed journals. She's also written several book chapters and co-edited books on mentoring and women leader development.

SPEAKER_00Rajshi has been recognized by several awards, including the 2016 Early Career Scholar Award at the AHRD. Rajshi is the Associate Editor of Human Resource Development International, one of the flagship peer-reviewed journals in the field of HRD. Hi, Rajshi. Welcome to the HRD Masterclass podcast. It's great to have you here in our episode focused on career development.

SPEAKER_01It's great to be here. Thank you for having me.

SPEAKER_00I'd like to start by picking up on a topic that Kim raised in her conversation, which is the transition of responsibility for managing careers from the organization to the individual. Do you think that individuals are prepared to take on that responsibility?

SPEAKER_01Thank you, Darren. So first let's think about this a bit more in terms of the transition of responsibility. I would say that responsibility hasn't really been passed on completely. In other words, what I'm trying to say is that previously, if it was employer-oriented career, it's not completely employee-oriented career in organizations. It's somewhat blended. And what I mean by that is that organizations are definitely encouraging or wanting their employees to be more self-directed in terms of managing their career, but they too have a vested interest.

SPEAKER_01So, you know, I would argue that we are somewhat, if you think about this as a continuum from employer-oriented to employee, we are somewhere in the middle in terms of having a blended perspective on how employees' careers should be managed. So having said that, you know, one of the things that definitely organizations are looking for in employees is uh the skill of being self-directed. Now, um, in terms of managing um your career in self-directed ways, what employees then need to do is um kind of have a very clear vision of how what career path they've chosen or the job that they're doing in the organization aligns with their skills, their interests, their motivation, their values.

SPEAKER_01And that's a lot of things, right? So it's not just about then having the right skill for the job, it is also about really reflecting, and this is like deep reflection, about how the job then aligns with what is it that you want to do in life, and how is it that you want to make an impact through the work that you're doing? So, what kind of values do you have that then aligns with the kind of job that you're doing? And these values are, you know, you've developed through your experiences in life in general.

SPEAKER_01So it's not just only your professional domain, but how you know your personal domain of life informs and guides and shapes those values also becomes very important. So the question then really becomes: are individuals prepared to um reflect how those values that they have uh developed through their experiences in both personal and professional um experiences in life align with their jobs and their careers?

SPEAKER_00Do you find then that um as people move through their career, their ability to manage it improves, i.e., they've they've had more time to reflect, more experiences to reflect on, and so they're potentially in a better place to manage their career.

SPEAKER_01I mean, intuitively that makes sense, that um they've had more uh experiences where they've might they might have kind of experienced some kind of a critical incident which has made them um reflect deeper about, you know, how is it what they're doing is really at the end of the day helping them realize some of the um kind of values that they want to live by? So as I said, intuitively it makes sense, but I would also flip the question to say that, you know, what are organizations doing to help not just the juniors but also those who are at the mid-career range and even senior uh individuals in organizational positions, what are organizations doing to help them get that kind of space to do that kind of reflection?

SPEAKER_01Um, what kind of relationships are uh being nurtured or cultivated where individuals would feel safe, psychologically safe, to kind of go to those places to ask those difficult questions about how what they're doing really connects back to their values? And I would even kind of go a step further to say that you know building safe spaces is not enough. You have to build brave spaces where you would be able to then ask those questions that might make you uncomfortable in terms of realizing that maybe what you're doing or how you're approaching the job isn't uh really helping you realize your values, or maybe you're actually doing something that is going contrary to your values.

SPEAKER_01So, having said that, the main point I would try to emphasize here is that the responsibility is dual. It's neither squarely resting on just the individual's shoulder, nor is it squarely resting on the organization's shoulder. It is a shared responsibility. So to say that individuals need to be more reflective about how the career aligns with their values is important, but it is not sufficient.

SPEAKER_01Then what is the organization doing to enable the individual or the employees to have that kind of a reflection and then to act on that reflection?

SPEAKER_00When I look at organizations who are doing that, I tend to see they've created job families and they've created career paths for job families, and they've hopefully aligned HRD and learning paths to those career paths. And having created those structures, I often see organizations then turning around to employees and saying, Well, you manage your own career here. In other words, that they're they're providing a framework and then they're handing over responsibility to the employee to figure out how to move within that framework.

SPEAKER_00So, do you think organizations are doing enough to actually help individuals manage their careers just by providing that framework, or should organizations actually be doing more?

SPEAKER_01I think they should be doing more. Definitely important to have that uh array of different um opportunities, professional development, uh career development opportunities in-house, because that sends a signal to the employees that the organization is uh interested to invest in their career development. But that is not sufficient because um when you then kind of give it uh you know completely to the employees to decide which of these um would really make sense and which of these would really help them realize their values.

SPEAKER_01As I said, there is a systemic component to this, it's not all individual. In regards to how employees, especially those with marginalized identities, would really then make the decision. Do they really have the agency to make the decision? It's easy to say that you know, we have given these uh different opportunities that are available. Now you make the decision as to what really resonates with you. But then what is the process in which that employee then would go about making that decision?

SPEAKER_01It's very important. And that's where the organization also needs to be present in terms of the employee might you know need to think through about what is it at that point in their lives they want to do. They might actually want to have a conversation with their supervisors, they might have a conversation with their colleagues or other important individuals who are you know interested in their development, such as mentors. Now, that those conversations are instrumental in terms of how then the employee would take the next step in their career.

SPEAKER_01And that's where it's not just about skill development, it's about identity development. And organizations cannot just, you know, you know, um shrug off their responsibility when it comes to developing identities of their employees. Um that's where I think um there was a recent paper I read in um, I believe Human Resource Development Quarterly, um, that was on transition coaching. So I think more and more such kinds of interventions need to be um kind of offered to employees, which would help them then engage in such conversations, really envision their future work selves uh through those conversations to be able to make the decision that's right for them.

SPEAKER_00You've talked a lot there about the transition of responsibility around organizations and individuals. And I'm I'm wondering what you see as the implications for HRD. How have you seen those? How have you seen this changing how organizations approach HRD as a result?

SPEAKER_01Yes, I think um, in my understanding, HRD is becoming more and more uh shared responsibility. Um, you know, how is it that learning and development happens? Um it I have seen that, you know, the trend moving towards being more shared than just it being the responsibility of the HRD professionals in the organizations, which I think is a positive trend. Because otherwise it then becomes a bit siloed, right? So if it is perceived as more of a shared responsibility, the supervisors, the leaders in the organizations would start thinking about developing their employees as a natural aspect of what they do or what the leadership role is about.

SPEAKER_01Also, uh, if the employees really are more proactive in terms of thinking about their careers and how is it what skills they have, how is it what identities they have, and all of us have multiple identities. And how those personal, social, and professional identities align needs to be something that the employees should proactively reflect upon. So I think the more it becomes such shared responsibility where employees' leaders are working alongside the HRD professionals in terms of how those different kinds of learning and development opportunities at work might apply or might not apply, and why might it might not apply, I think the job becomes easier.

SPEAKER_01I think the importance or the significance or the relevance of HRD as a field really then gets elevated.

SPEAKER_00Excellent. Now you've talked a little bit about uh mentoring and coaching as we've gone through the conversation, uh, specifically relative to their role within career development. So I'm wondering how how you see that changing over the next 10 years when you take a look at coaching and mentoring, how do you see their role shifting during the 2020s when it comes to career development?

SPEAKER_01Well, I would say definitely um mentoring and coaching would become more about identity work. Um, now that doesn't mean that the skill development aspect of it would become um uh unnecessary. It's definitely still necessary. But what I'm saying is that mentors and coaches would need to have the relational skills needed to invite, to encourage, to enable the employees to engage in that kind of identity work. And what I mean by identity work is to really kind of do a deep dive in terms of how those multiple identities align or not align, and what kind of systemic factors are really then guiding or shaping that alignment or lack thereof.

SPEAKER_01Um the other thing I would also say is that previously or traditionally when we thought about mentoring or even coaching for that matter, we thought about a relationship. So automatically then you know the term relationship pops up in our mind. But uh recently or increasingly I'm seeing that the trend is more about um thinking of such developmental um interactions uh from an episodal perspective than from a long-term perspective.

SPEAKER_01What I mean by that is that um while previously it was believed that if you're a mentor or if you're seeking a mentor, you would ideally want a long-term commitment, a long-term relationship. But more and more it's being understood that even one high-quality interaction can be transformational. So, in other words, and I think in some ways it's liberating. I'll give you an example. Like when I have gone to different conferences, even at the EHRD uh conferences, sometimes I've had really high-quality conversations with scholars in our field that I might not have really developed a long-term mentoring relationship with.

SPEAKER_01But nonetheless, that conversation over a cup of coffee changed my ways of thinking about what I'm researching and uh what I've heard from them as well is that they have definitely taken away some key ways of thinking in new uh you know ways about topics from those conversations as well. So even at a you know, one interaction level, it matters. So the new term that is um actually being proposed in the mentoring research, it's called mentoring episodes.

SPEAKER_01And what they're saying is that if you think about a relationship in terms of house, these episodes are building blocks. So even if you get the opportunity of having one conversation with someone that you want to talk to about your career, about a certain uh topic that interests you, do not give up on that. A lot of times I've seen individuals uh shy away from such opportunities because they think that, well, it might not lead to a long-term commitment, then what's the point?

SPEAKER_01Well, that's an opportunity lost. Even for mentors or coaches, I've seen that sometimes they shy away thinking that, well, this will require me to make a long-term commitment and I just don't have the time. I want to, but I don't have the time. But for them, then again, I would encourage to kind of think of it from a new perspective to say that let's just invest into this one conversation. And even if that might not lead to another conversation or a relationship for that matter, that's okay.

SPEAKER_01Just this one conversation counts. So I think more and more we'll see that that episodal nature of mentoring would gain traction in terms of um, I'm not saying again, it'll replace the long-term uh commitment idea or perspective, but it will be a viable way of engaging uh with your mentee or engaging with your mentor in the years to come. The other thing I will also highlight is traditionally in the literature at least, uh, we've thought about uh when we think about mentoring or coaching, we've thought about it from a 101 um hierarchical dyadic relationship.

SPEAKER_01Um, but now um I think more and more it has been taught from a network perspective. So who is it that you have? I really love this term I'd heard um once is called personal board of advisors. So who is it that you have in your personal board of advisors? And most, I would argue, um go to more than one person for seeking advice, right? So then you start thinking about all those you seek advice from in a mentoring capacity, in a coaching capacity.

SPEAKER_01So it's a combination of formal and informal mentors and coaches who actually populate your personal board of advisors. And when you think about it from a network perspective, the question then is um, how is it they're complementing the support they're providing you? Is it that some of the support you're getting is redundant because you're getting the same kind of support from more than one individual? Sometimes that might be necessary for you, but the question is important to be asked.

SPEAKER_01So you need to then do a needs assessment, as and that's one way to be self-directed, right? So that you do a needs assessment in terms of who is it that you have in your network. So that I think is again something that will become more and more the norm of mentoring and coaching moving ahead.

SPEAKER_00The um you talked about uh episodes and the idea of uh like a personal board of advisors. It it do those sorts of things happen organically, or is there a role for HRD to create spaces for those to occur?

SPEAKER_01I definitely think HRD um can uh enable those kinds of things. One of the things I would say um is building relational skills. I don't think uh, you know, we should take relational skills for granted. Uh, someone might be really a high performer or um, you know, in the kind of job that they are at. That doesn't mean that they'll be a great uh mentor or a mentee or a coach or a coache. They need to have certain relational skills to be able to engage and optimize um their uh development uh in such relational spaces.

SPEAKER_01And so I think being relationally savvy is something that HRD professionals can provide sessions or training to the employees. So that's one way. Um then I would say that really making space for individuals to engage in that needs assessment. So that's kind of a personal level needs assessment about who is it that I have in my network? Is my network diverse enough? Do I have individuals that mostly look like me in my network of people that I seek advice from?

SPEAKER_01Well, that should raise a flag, right? So it's those kinds of assessment uh questions then uh organizations or HRD professionals can make space for so that the employee really kind of takes a pause in the everyday kind of um busy uh schedule and ask themselves like, do I need to work on diversifying my network further so that I get challenged more? So that I'm not just talking to people who are um, you know, who have access to the same kinds of information that I do, but I am reaching out to someone who uh frequents different circles and therefore would give me different kinds of information that will expand the way I'm thinking about things.

SPEAKER_01So definitely I think uh HRD professionals can uh enable developmental network uh perspective of mentoring, they can enable episodal perspective in terms of just emphasizing for the importance and value of even that one conversation that one can have, maybe with someone that they want to.

SPEAKER_00Well, Raji, thank you so much for our conversation today. I've really enjoyed it.

SPEAKER_01Well, I have enjoyed it too. Thank you for the opportunity.

SPEAKER_00Wonderful. Well, let's invite Kim back in for our group conversation.

SPEAKER_01Looking forward to it.

SPEAKER_00Up next, we have the group discussion where my guest Are together to discuss their shared passion for the episode's topic. This discussion is brought to you thanks to the sponsorship support of Drexel University's Human Resource Development and Creativity and Innovation programs. Drexel's MS in HRD is recognized as a program of excellence by the Academy of Human Resource Development, a METS Association for Talent Development Standards. Drexel's MS in Creativity and Innovation, a new MS in creative education and entrepreneurship, provide the tools, techniques, and science for accessing your inner creative spirit.

SPEAKER_00Students develop their creative and innovation mindset to help them achieve career success. Human resource development in creativity and innovation are also offered at concentrations in Drexel's award-winning education doctorate program. 30% tuition discounts are available. Learn more today by visiting drexstall.edu slash so e.

SPEAKER_00Welcome back to the HRD Masterclass podcast. Our focus for this episode is career development, and I've already met one-to-one with Kim McDonald and Raji Ghosh. For the final section of the episode, we're all together for our group chat. So welcome back, Kim and Rogi.

SPEAKER_02Thank you. Wonderful to be here.

SPEAKER_00Okay, so what I'd like to do for the group discussion is to pick on a topic that was explored in both of the one-to-one chats that I had with you, which was that shift of ownership for careers from organizations to individuals. And in light of that shift, I'm wondering what you now see as the business case for organizations investing in employee careers, especially given the possibility that employees can easily switch from one employer to another after they've been invested in.

SPEAKER_01Thank you, Darren, for that question. So going back to what I'd shared earlier, in my understanding, it's kind of blended in terms of that responsibility. So it rests both on the individual's and the organization's shoulders. So I wouldn't say that it has completely shifted to the individual in terms of managing their careers. Now, in light of that, I would say that someone who has a protein career orientation, who is self-directed in managing their careers, would still want the organization to invest in them.

SPEAKER_01In fact, a recent paper in International Journal of Human Resource Management says exactly that, that the so-called idea of this employability paradox, where it's perceived that if someone is very self-directed in managing their careers, they're not likely to be committed to the organization and they might quit their jobs or look for a job elsewhere, is not quite theoretically sound because if you think about this, and they used the social exchange theory lens and signal theory lens.

SPEAKER_01And according to their argument, if someone is self-directed and managing their careers, they are on the lookout for career development opportunities within the organization that they are in. So if the organization offers different options for developing their careers, developing their skills, then they would be more appreciative of the organization. And in exchange of that, then they would be more committed towards the organization. Now there's a twist here.

SPEAKER_01According to the study that they did, it seems that it matters how many career development opportunities are available within the organization. So it's not that if the organization lays out a few options that they will be convinced. Because they are very self-directed and very invested and proactive about managing their careers, the more options they get within the organization, the more the signal they'll receive that the organization is really interested in helping them build their careers, the rise up the ladder, get career development within the organization.

SPEAKER_01So it's the volume of the career development opportunities available that really also matters in terms of convincing them to stay back and flourish within the organization.

SPEAKER_02Offering career development is not a loss of investment in an employee, typically.

SPEAKER_02So I think that there's a real reason for organizations to do things to help employees with their careers. I think there's also, given what's happening in organizations in terms of jobs, um, where jobs are becoming more highly skilled, um, knowledge intensive, and some of that's coming about because of automation, uh eliminating some jobs and those types of things.

SPEAKER_02That there's also an awful lot of times employers lament that they just can't find those skills or that knowledge in uh individuals. And so they also, I think, have a real need to invest in training and development, mentoring, coaching, uh, job shadowing, all of those kinds of things just for a very to to remain competitive.

SPEAKER_00Sounds like there's a real business case then for investing in careers, and that there are many business benefits that flow from that. So if that's the case, what do you see as the role for HRD? And and as part of that, how do you see HRD partnering with HRM and other functions on career development?

SPEAKER_02Well, I definitely think that they need to partner with the more HR management side of the organization. A lot of ways that they can do that is through being in close contact on things like how are jobs changing and job description types of things. Another way that they really need to link with HRM is HRM does more of the benefits, and benefits are absolutely critical to consider when you're talking about people's careers.

SPEAKER_02Um is the organization paying adequately? Do they provide lots of different initiatives that help individuals with all those work life issues that arise? Do they provide for people's physical and psychological safety in the workplace? You know, we we so oftentimes divorce those types of things from development opportunities, but it's really difficult for individuals to really focus on their careers and their career development if those basic benefits aren't doing what they need to do.

SPEAKER_02Um HRD, of course, you know, plays an important role in providing programs for individuals to help them develop. And I think that that role needs to continue. But an awful lot of times there may be individuals beyond the HRD function that are better able to help those individuals with those development opportunities. So I think partnering with managers and making sure that managers know how to develop their employees, reward and rewarding managers for how they develop employees are really important roles that HRD can play in the organization.

SPEAKER_01I couldn't agree more. Unless the managers, the leaders share the responsibility of developing their employees, the culture of the organization will never become developmental. So it's not just the formal training, right? It is the informal learning that happens in day-to-day interactions. And that's where the leaders in the organization need to think of uh developing others as a natural part of their job. And that's where the HID professionals can really work to help the leaders understand that kind of shared responsibility and also become capable.

SPEAKER_01As Kim was saying, um, most of the managers are not relationally skilled to really engage in this work of developing their employees. So then how can they be enabled? And I think HRD professionals can play a huge role there. Also, um, I think just think of it from a systems perspective, right? So HRT professionals need to be then able to work with the other functions, such as HRM, so that what the career development opportunities they make available really make sense from a system sense, uh systems perspective.

SPEAKER_01The other thing that Kim mentioned really stood out was about uh safety. Um, there's this psychology of work theory by Duffy and colleagues, and I was reading up on it because I think earlier when we spoke, we also were kind of debating the relevance of the boundaryless, the protein career orientation to blue-collar workers. So I came upon the psychology of work theory by Duffy and colleagues that talked about three things that need to be in place. One is that the survival need of the employee needs to be addressed.

SPEAKER_01Um, second is their connectedness, their desire for relatedness with other colleagues and social uh connections need to be addressed. And then there, the third one is the self-determination, where they feel valued, they feel that they belong in terms of work that they're doing. There's a fit, there's a sense of fit that needs to be addressed. So if you think of those three needs, then what Kim said in terms of um the HRM, making sure that the benefits, this uh workplace safety is in place, and then the HRD making sure that you know that self-determination, the fit, the sense of connectedness is in place.

SPEAKER_01And then the managers and the leaders stepping up to really um help the employee uh realize that how being connected with uh their supervisors, being connected with their colleagues can really enable them to think about their jobs in new ways and to be engaged in their jobs is really valuable.

SPEAKER_00In your answer there, Raja, you you referenced blue-collar workers. And and I'm interested in as we think through all of this, as to what differences you see on career development by like type of work. For example, does career development look different for blue-collar than it does, say, for high-tech knowledge workers?

SPEAKER_01That's a very interesting question. And I've thought about this question. I've tried to kind of look at some of the recent studies that have been done. Now, there is no doubt that the vocational career development research has predominantly focused on the knowledge-intensive white-collar workers. So I think there is uh really a huge need to do more research studies focusing on blue-collar workers. Now, having said that, some of the recent studies indicated that some of the things in terms of, as I was saying, the self-determination, the value fit with the job that you're doing, is also relevant for blue-collar workers.

SPEAKER_01It's not that it's just applicable to the knowledge-intensive workers. So that still then would be applicable. Then the connectedness piece, going back to the importance of the conversation that I was talking about between the manager and the employee, going back to the career opportunities of mentoring and coaching that I talked about and also Kane mentioned, those are still important. In fact, one of the recent studies that was done on blue-collar workers, and this was in South Africa, um, they found out that they put a lot of value on how the managers treat them.

SPEAKER_01So their sense of like whether I matter in the organization is tied to how they're treated by their bosses. And so again, going back to this uh notion then that the leaders, the frontline leaders, the mid-level leaders, senior leaders in the organization, they need to walk the talk in terms of really then uh being relationally skilled so that they're uh really engaging in conversations, engaging in developing their employees still then is relevant, no matter what type of worker we are talking about.

SPEAKER_01The one distinctive thing that um when you know these studies kind of found out in regards to blue collar workers is that the survival need, going back to that psychology of work theory I was talking about, um, was very strong in terms of that they feel that they need to be providers for their family, and their sense of survival is then kind of tied to whether this job enables them to provide for their family.

SPEAKER_02I agree, and um I think that there's oftentimes a lot of stereotypes that occur in terms of what blue-collar workers, pink collar workers, high-tech information knowledge workers need that we really need to re-examine some of our assumptions and some of our stereotypes about individuals. Several years ago, a couple of my colleagues and I did a uh qualitative study where we went into some organizations and we specifically asked to talk with individuals who were those non-exempt, non-managerial employees.

SPEAKER_02And we went to, I think, four or five different organizations, but one of those organizations really stood out to me in terms of their non-exempt employees because we asked them some basic questions about careers and what they felt about their career and um how they tried to work to develop their career and what they thought the organization was doing to help with their career. And this happened to be an organization that made wiring for medical devices, and this whole notion of do I matter uh came up a lot in that that focus group that we did.

SPEAKER_02Those individuals felt such um a commitment to what they were doing, they felt that they were doing work that was saving individuals' lives, and so they were extremely proud of what they were doing. Um, and that resonated through the entire um interview that we did with them, and I think that that's really important for any individual to feel that sense of what I'm doing makes a difference.

SPEAKER_02It it has meaning.

SPEAKER_01Uh, when I was trying to read up on blue-collar workers specifically, um one of the recent papers I came across in JVB Journal of Vocational Behavior talked about this idea of um you know integrating better integrating social justice into the career theories. And um the social career cognitive theory is one of the popular um and commonly used uh vocational theories. And it talks about the contextual factors, the structural uh, you know, the context and the relevance of how structural barriers might actually impede uh careers.

SPEAKER_01But even though the model kind of includes that, the literature, the research has primarily focused on uh individual level variables in terms of self-efficacy, um, in terms of uh their skill, um, in terms of uh even for that matter, identity. So future research needs to kind of uh really look at the interaction between the individual and the contextual uh factors to better understand um how career development needs to be supported.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, and the sustainable careers literature, which is pretty new, I think the context is just absolutely critical. So I think you're gonna see more of that research coming out. Um the career shocks literature also is all about context as well. Um, so I think that's gonna happen, but it's um it's it's it's tough because it's a lot easier, I think, to focus in on the individual.

SPEAKER_02We already have tons of measurements and scales and all of that type of thing. And we don't, and it just gets complicated when you start looking at the situation.

SPEAKER_01Absolutely. It's much easier to focus on the individual and specifically given that organizations have been called in to be more attentive about DEI, um, I think then it kind of really um becomes uh an important responsibility for the HRD professionals to think what kind of structural inequities might be in place that even though they might come up with career development opportunities and programs in organizations, because of structural barriers, those might be less accessible to certain communities and groups.

SPEAKER_01So it I think it is um really it is difficult, but it is important for them uh to really reflect uh how both the individual and the structural factors come together to uh really enable individuals to be better managers of their careers. And in current times, it's even more critical to shed light on the structural barriers.

SPEAKER_00There must be a point at which um organization's responsibility sort of ends. Um and that if if jobs are going away, for example, an organization can do so much to help an individual prepare for that. But there must be a point at which the responsibility shifts from an organization potentially into into the into the government realm. So I'm wondering what you see as the role of national policy of governments in career development and helping in situations like that.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, I think that there is a huge role that they can play. Um I I think that governments need to work very closely with organizations, with our K-12 system, with our colleges and universities, and our junior colleges and our trade schools to um help ensure that we have people who are ready for jobs and careers.

SPEAKER_02Um I think that certain populations get left behind an awful lot of times in these discussions. Um a lot of our undocumented workers are disadvantaged, are poor employed, our poor workers, poor people, um, people who have been incarcerated, I think oftentimes get left behind. Um, people who live in rural areas don't have as much access, and they don't oftentimes have opportunities to access computers, and if they do, they have really slow internet.

SPEAKER_02So, and I think that COVID kind of brought some of that out. Um, because people all of a sudden had to do things from home, and that oftentimes presented problems for individuals. So I think we have to look at all of those types of things and how the government can um incentivize organizations to do more and do more themselves.

SPEAKER_01I agree with Kim. Um it's like an ecosystem. If you think of this, where in that ecosystem, there are the organizations, there are the educational institutions, both K through 12 higher education, and then there's the government. So in terms of thinking of that pipeline of workers and their careers, and the different junctures they might need counseling about their careers along that trajectory becomes very important.

SPEAKER_01So it cannot be myopic in terms of just the organizations kind of thinking their own way, the higher education institutions thinking their own way, and the government going their own direction. There can be several ways in which that interconnectedness can be realized. For example, government officials, policymakers can sit on advisory boards for higher educational institutions, for organizations. The higher educational institutions, for instance, in my role as department chair, I've been encouraging programs in Drexel to think about instituting external advisory boards that includes such policymakers, that includes industry professionals, so that when we are preparing students in our programs, it doesn't just become about their academic grades, but it also becomes the kinds of skills that they need to be able to then transition into the workforce in a way that they can really benefit.

SPEAKER_01So, in other words, I really think then it becomes important for all the different professionals situated within those different systems to think about what are those intersections? How could they better collaborate with each other so that this pipeline can be better nurtured?

SPEAKER_00Well, unfortunately, we've reached the end of our time for today. I did want to say a big thank you to both of you for all of your time and for the conversations and for being a part of our discussion on career development.

SPEAKER_02Thank you very much, Darren. Yes, thanks, Darren.

SPEAKER_00Thank you so much for joining me for this episode. It was wonderful spending time with Kim and Raji. If you enjoyed this episode, check out our others to explore topics such as strategic HRD, training and development, critical HRD, and much more. New episodes release weekly for this first series of 10 episodes. To learn more about the series, check out HRDmasterclass.com. And to learn about the Academy of Human Resource Development, check out ahrd.org.

SPEAKER_00By becoming a member, you can access extra bonus materials not included in the podcast. Also, don't forget to look into our group discussion sponsor, Drexel University's Human Resource Development and Creativity and Innovation Programs, by visiting their website at drextel.edu. I'm looking forward to being with you in our next episode. Until then, this is Darren Short signing off from the HRD Masterclass.com.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Gendered pathways to work-family balance

    Nov 17, 202634 minAudio

    This fourth episode of Season 6 brings together Dr. Sanghamitra Chaudhuri (Temple University) and Dr. Kyung Nam Kim (Texas A&M University) for a conversation about the 2026 article Gendered Pathways to Work-Family...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Navigating careers in non-traditional work

    Nov 10, 202636 minAudio

    This third episode of Season 6 brings together Dr. Yuanlu Niu (University of Arkansas) and Dr. Jos Akkermans (Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam) for a conversation about the 2026 article Navigating careers in non-traditional...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Silence in the workplace: What do we know from research?

    Nov 2, 202634 minAudio

    This second episode of Season 6 brings together Dr. Matthew Hurtienne (University of Texas at Tyler) and Dr. Heesun Kim (Francis Marion University) for a conversation about the 2024 article Silence in the workplace:...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Diversified mentoring: Living at the intersections of race and gender

    Oct 27, 202634 minAudio

    This first episode of Season 6 brings together Dr. Joshua Collins (University of Minnesota) and Dr. Ague Mae Manongsong (Louisiana State University) for a conversation about the 2023 article “Manongsong, A. M., & Ghosh,...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Season 6 Trailer

    Oct 12, 20262 minAudio

    Welcome to the trailer for Season 6 of Human Resource Development Masterclass - the podcast series from the Academy of Human Resource Development, the organization that leads HRD through research. The sixth season...

    Credit the people on this episode