In this second episode of Season 5, guests Dr. Margaret Driscoll, Dr. Saul Carliner, and Dr. Yvonne Thayer discuss how HRD can respond to AI by exploring: What do we mean by the term AI? What do we know about how AI is changing the workplace and workforce? What examples do we have of how AI is already impacting HRD? How do we see the impact of AI on HRD changing over the next few years? What are the practical implications for HRD professionals? How can HRD professionals prepare themselves for the changes happening? and much more. For full details on the HRD Masterclass series, visit hrdmasterclass.com, and for the bios of the guest scholars visit allbypodcast.com/airesponse. The following file contains recommended resources that support listeners as they reflect on the implications of AI raised during the episode: https://www.allbypodcast.com/s/Sites-Worth-Visiting2docx.pdf For more information on the Academy of Human Resource Development, visit ahrd.org. This episode is sponsored by Concordia University Wisconsin, Earn your Doctorate in Business Administration online. Unlock new career opportunities with a PhD or Doctor of Business Administration from Concordia University Wisconsin. Our flexible, online programs are designed for ambitious professionals seeking to lead, innovate, and drive meaningful change in their industries. With expert faculty, research-driven coursework, and specializations in Financial & Economic Management and Organizational Performance & Change, you'll gain the skills to excel in executive leadership, consulting, or academia. Take the next step in advancing your career - visit earnyourdoctorateonline.cuw.edu today!
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_01Before we start today's episode, I want to draw your attention to the practical PDF resource guide that accompanies today's discussion on AI. The three guests featured in the episode have put together a list of over 30 useful resources that you can use to learn more about AI and its implications for HR. You'll find a link to the guide in the podcast notes and also on the episode website at allbypodcast.com forward slash AI response. That's all one word, AI response.
SPEAKER_01Right, let's start the episode.
SPEAKER_02Not that the tool does it all. We still need the human in the loop. So rather than writing the entire course, we may be instead looking it over, uh editing it, refining it before we send it off to the client for a review.
SPEAKER_01Welcome to Human Resource Development Masterclass, the podcast series from the Academy of Human Resource Development, the organization that leads HRD through research. I'm your host, Darren Short, and here in our fifth season, we're exploring some of the listeners' top how-to questions with the help of leading authors, researchers, and scholars. In this second episode, we're focusing on the question of how HRD can respond to AI. Longtime listeners to the series will recall that we started our exploration of AI with episode 9 of season 4.
SPEAKER_01So if you're interested in AI and its implications for HRD, you may want to revisit that episode after listening to today's. In this episode you'll hear a fascinating conversation that was recorded in December of 2024, and I was joined by three guests. The first is Yvonne Thayer, a workforce development researcher and consultant, a former executive with the Southern Regional Education Board, and a former State Director of Adult Literacy. Yvonne holds a doctorate in adult education from Teachers College at Columbia University.
SPEAKER_01My second guest is Margaret Driscoll, a corporate executive who works at the intersection of enterprise, organisation-wide technology and workplace learning. Margaret currently evaluates technology products, including ones using AI, and she holds a doctorate in adult education from Teachers College. And my third guest is Sol Carliner, Professor and Chair of the Department of Education at Concordia University in Montreal, where his research focuses on the design of instructional and informational materials for the workplace, the management of groups that produce such materials, and related issues of professionalism.
SPEAKER_01And Sol has worked extensively on policies related to job competences for the past decade and a half. Stohl holds a doctorate in instructional technology from Georgia State University. Just visit allbypodcast.com forward slash AI response to learn more about the bios of the three guests and also to connect with our episode sponsors, Concordia University Wisconsin. Earn your doctorate in business administration online. Talking of sponsorship, Human Resource Development Masterclass is only made possible thanks to the wonderful support of our sponsors who cover all of the costs associated with the series and so enable us to release them free of charge to listeners like you.
SPEAKER_01I encourage you to show your thanks by checking them out and letting them know just how much their sponsorship means to you. Today's episode is brought to you thanks to the sponsorship of Concordia University Wisconsin. Unlock new career opportunities with a PhD or Doctor of Business Administration from Concordia University Wisconsin. Our flexible online programmes are designed for ambitious professionals seeking to lead, innovate and drive meaningful change in their industry.
SPEAKER_01With expert faculty, research-driven coursework and specializations in financial and economic management and organizational performance and change, you'll gain the skills to excel in executive leadership, consulting, or academia. Take the next step in advancing your career. Visit earnyourdoctorateonline.cuw.edu today. Right, let's dive into the episode. It's a big welcome to Yvonne, to Margaret, and to Saul.
SPEAKER_01It's great to have all three of you here in the episode on such a fascinating topic.
SPEAKER_02Thank you.
SPEAKER_01Great to be here.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, we're glad to have an opportunity to share some of our thoughts with folks out there today.
SPEAKER_01I think before we dive into the details of it, I'm thinking it could be helpful to take a step back and to make sure that we have a clear understanding as to what we mean by that term AI. What do you see as the term AI meaning and how does it differ from other technologies?
SPEAKER_02What a great way to start. AI or artificial intelligence simply refers to machines that are performing tasks that we typically perform as humans and require human intelligence. So while it sounds incredibly fancy and there is a lot of complexity and technology behind it, think about machines that have the ability to do things like problem solving, speech recognition, understanding language, decision making. And just they sound pretty simple, but let's talk about some of those in terms that we're seeing right now.
SPEAKER_02Problem solving. You think, oh, what do you mean by problem solving? Well, AI is behind things like imagine having the ability with salespeople to have artificial intelligence, listen to the salesperson while they're on a call with a customer, and you have all the background on the things the customers purchase, the kind of challenges the customer has. And in real time, the system is listening in and choosing how to personally coach that individual salesperson, giving them actionable feedback that's dedicated to that person, not generic sales suggestions, but very specific to that salesperson and that customer or problem solving.
SPEAKER_02How many times have we been on the line with a call center trying to get assistance with fixing something? And the agent has to go off and look up answers and get back to us. What if there was an AI agent? And this is a isn't an if there are applications that will be whispering in that agent's ear and coming up with suggestions in real time so the agent doesn't have to put you on hold. Both of those are great examples of AI helping people problem solve in the workplace.
SPEAKER_02Other ones, a little closer to us, we've probably all used Google Lens at some point. We pointed at a plant, an animal, and we get information on what is that plant, what is that animal. So it's image recognition. And again, we're all really familiar with Alexa's series. Those are no surprise to us. That's language understanding. But imagine something like Fini or they're using it to do multilingual customer support. I walk up to you, and it really doesn't matter what language I speak, you'll be able to help me with what gate am I leaving from, where's my luggage in the language I'm familiar with.
SPEAKER_02And, you know, okay, so it does problem solving, it recognizes images, it understands language. How about decision making? That's truly a human feat. Something like Canon Medical, they have an application that will use artificial intelligence to help people make decisions around a patient who comes in in the midst of having a stroke, and it's going to give them much more timely screening of that patient and triage. So artificial intelligence, all these systems are doing things that we would have thought that's something a person does, not a machine.
SPEAKER_02In the past, the programming was very mechanical. These new ones use very sophisticated models and lots and lots and lots of data to help them make you better at making a decision, solving a problem. And keep in mind, these systems are seeing quantum improvements in their performance over time. So we are just in the beginning of something that's uh on the cusp of becoming exponentially better. And these are mimicking human intelligence.
SPEAKER_02These are not old-fashioned technologies that had pre-programmed answers. These are far more dynamic. But keep in mind, these are not in most places going to replace workers. They're going to augment them. They're going to help make us better, make us more productive. And they'll probably make lower-skilled workers more functional.
SPEAKER_01You've touched a little there, Margaret, on changes that are happening in the workplace and potential implications for the workforce. Well, what do we know at this point about the nature of those changes, about how AI is actually changing the workplace and the workforce?
SPEAKER_02Ah, that's that is a huge question. And it is, there's no question, it's changing the workforce. But I think we want to start with the question of what's driving the changes in the workforce? Why are people even looking at AI for the workforce? And it really comes down to the answer being about productivity gains. Where are we able to deploy this? Where we're going to see the most advantage, where the most return for our investment. And what's interesting is where people are seeing big productivity gains. The number one place is the IT organization with artificial intelligence, they can be 67% more productive.
SPEAKER_02Customer service, 57% more productive. And in HR, we can be 41% more productive. So with this kind of productivity, it's changing the workplace. And I think as HR professionals, one of the things that is I find eye-opening is think about AI in the frame of reference for the employee journey. And that's all the way from being a candidate to retirement. And in that journey, what I want to do is just walk us through some of the highlights of where you're going to see these tools.
SPEAKER_02Now, a lot of the tools that we're going to talk about have been around, but they're superpowered with AI and they're really delivering huge productivity gains. So when you say 40%, how could someone be 40% more productive? Think about the amount of time you'd spend on these different points of the journey. Let's start with finding candidates. One thing for us to go through an application tracking system and sort out people. What about our ability to have to go after passive candidates, people that aren't looking for a job?
SPEAKER_02What if we were able to use tools that let us find potential candidates based on their skill or experience? Or what if when we found them, we needed to deliver personalized communication to appeal to them and to be able to analyze their profiles and interact with them online? That's part of the initial start of a candidate's journey. So we could save huge amounts of time with tools that are going to help us do that. Another one that's rather simple is writing job descriptions.
SPEAKER_02How many times have we had to count on, you know, a line of business manager to write a job description and it's either they're looking for the purple squirrel or it's so banal that it's not going to net you any candidates? We have tools now that will write that job description using AI. Or the once we've got that job description written and we're beginning to get in the resumes, we have lots of tools that will let us go through application tracking systems, went through for keywords.
SPEAKER_02But what if we were able to use more sophisticated tools that helped us analyze the candidates' resumes as they come through? And this isn't to say that the candidates aren't without tools of their own. There are brilliant tools. Candidates can put up your job description, their resume, and an application will turn them back a revised resume that better matches the job description that you put out there. Or it'll take a resume and it'll evaluate what jobs that person would actually be good for being applying to a position for.
SPEAKER_02Then once you have in those and for certain jobs, you could have hundreds of resumes for a job. What if you were able to use the predictive analytics and AI tools? What if you could evaluate or rank candidates based on anything from personality to behavioral traits to experience? That's definitely one of the things that are possible. We'll talk maybe a little later about some of the legal ramifications of that, but from a technical point of view, sorting through hundreds of candidates is not the level of effort it used to be.
SPEAKER_02And then actually making the job offer. We know personalization is so critical. AI lets you do the personalization that would have taken us hours before. What if I could make a job offer because I know a lot about what that candidate's interest is and I can personalize the offer? And then as we begin to close up our career, how about predictive retirement? How would I like to know what people are thinking of leaving the organization? Maybe they're changing jobs, there's going to be turnover. Maybe I should anticipate what you know, what uh skills are going to be leaving me.
SPEAKER_02Lots of tools using AI that will help me predict who in my workforce is leaving. So as you think about this journey, AI is touching every piece of it. And there are pieces we didn't talk about. There's obviously listening applications that tell me about people's engagement. There are dozens of more. So if you have a chance, please check out the accompanying list of um resources we're providing with this talk.
SPEAKER_02And we haven't even talked about the other places where we know AI is augmenting. IT, customer service, supply chain, finance, sales. And if you're still kind of dubious about AI, think about these statistics from the economist. One-third of US employees are using AI at work. It doesn't mean their company bought it for them. It means they're using it. And open AI, the people from ChatGTP, 75% of their revenue comes from customers, not from corporate subscriptions.
SPEAKER_02So be be confident that there is no doubt that Gen AI is getting into the workplace. We're bringing it in to make our employees and ourselves more productive, and the workers are bringing it themselves.
SPEAKER_00Well, this will be a team effort in terms of answering this, but I'll start because I'll start with uh learning and development or training and development. And um AI AI has actually been doing work in development of training programs for quite some time. Um one of the oldest ones is machine translation when things need to be translated into another language. Um, and another thing that's been around for more than a decade is um the use of system-generated narration.
SPEAKER_00And at first it used to sound really, really tinny, and you could tell it was fake. Now people cannot tell that it was not a human that actually recorded it. Um, and you've a number of authoring tools have it. The first one I saw was Storyline, um, but I recently had something done for me and it was done in ISPR, so it's not limited to one. In addition, in the area of other aspects of the audio and visual production, um, you see a lot of correction and generation of images done through AI, it's been going that way for a while.
SPEAKER_00So that's been around. What's happened more recently is you see the development of a number of tools that either assist with or can automatically generate entire courses. So if the material is known to the is if the system is trained in the content of the program, the system can generate a fair amount of material. Um, certainly really common, you know, like compliance-related courses, the systems can generate that relatively well.
SPEAKER_00You usually they prompt you for a few things that you may want.
SPEAKER_02Right. And I think kind of they fall into there are ones that, like you were talking about, that do the they have bits of AI in them, and then there are the ones that are purely AI driven. And the ones that are use a lot of AI work off two things. One is they're using large language models, which basically means to Saul's point, you're doing a compliance course and it's on something like Sarbanes, Oxley, information's on the internet, the system will generate that course. You want to do one about your business process.
SPEAKER_02Most of them also will ingest your own proprietary documents and create training. And then the product the production value level is going to vary greatly. Uh, if some people have seen the ones that have ones where it will take a, you know, a photograph of someone and turn it into uh an avatar that will read a script and you can show it, and like to Sal's point about the voice, you can choose the the narration, the voice, the tone, very realistic.
SPEAKER_02Some of them will take your documents and write a full script and create a video for you out of the script without you writing a video. The tools for course development are probably one of the most highly invested and spectacular pieces of what's changing in the training space.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, in fact, I've even seen like podcasts um created just from PowerPoint slides. But in addition to these generating entire courses, um AI can also be used in a couple of other ways. Um, one is at the front end of things, and it can be used in analysis because often we don't get all the data that we need to do our analyses, and so we have a lot of stuff that needs to be filled in. AI can help fill in, and two of the cases that are I've seen some work on, um you need to work with ChatGPT and good um, you know, prompts that you are it's called prompt engineering, but you can do some like personas or like character sketches of um prospective learners.
SPEAKER_00You can also do um use cases or how people are using either the material that they're being trained on or use cases of about the training experience itself. There's also stuff at the other end in terms of analytics. Um and it's not there's a whole area uh called learning analytics that looks to make predictions about are students at risk of failing. And they're widely used in the especially the higher ed system. Um, in training, not so much, but then we can also link some of the skills that people are supposed to be developing in training to their performance in the workplace to see are people actually applying those skills?
SPEAKER_00So it might actually simplify some of the transfer. Those are just some of the things that are going on with the learning and development side. Um, but there's stuff that's going on in career development, and Yvonne can talk about that.
SPEAKER_03Yes, there's several things I think that we can talk about that kind of augment what you just mentioned with the training side of things and career development. Um, there's uh an emphasis now on auto assessment, automated assessment for self-improvement, or to ready people for promotions or thinking about their development throughout their um career. And that is being done not as a self-assessment, but something that's being conducted by the organization using tools of AI to make it more manageable and more effective and able to produce results quicker and better and all of that.
SPEAKER_03Um, I wanted to mention about social media too, the scraping of platforms. You know, we know all the platforms Instagram, Facebook, TikTok, YouTube, LinkedIn, all of those. They have millions of both individual and business users, and that offers endless sources of information. And these data can show trends and monitor both personal and business branding efforts. And we all experience how that offers an analysis of what customers want and need.
SPEAKER_03We experience that every day when something pops up suggesting that we buy something else. So that web scraping service is going on all the time, and it runs the gambit from using pre made templates to customized programs. So there are all kinds of sources that can be used to. Great data to get patterns or discrete information that can influence workplace preferences. And that's all really important when you're thinking about career development.
SPEAKER_03Where is the workplace going? Where is the workforce needing to prepare itself or be available? And that's a really important piece, I think, for career development is think about what these social media platforms are doing for us or against us. We know there's increased automation in hiring. Margaret has talked about that very well. So I'm not going to go over that again, but that's a big piece. And that's something I find that probably as students are coming out of universities and doing their job hunting and seeking, they know a lot more about it a lot of times than the people who are already employed but still need to know what's going on.
SPEAKER_03There's research, uh ability to do research using generative AI, chat GTP, all that. I think we know what that means, but it brings resources to us that are quicker, more available, offer more opportunities. Also with skills management, that's another area that we're a little more familiar with of how AI can manage that for us. So I'd like to just take a minute to talk about AI coaches.
SPEAKER_03And the reason I wanted to mention this specifically is because this is personalized coaching that is something new to us. It's been around, but it's growing fast, and we think it's going to grow very fast. And because I am a certified coach myself and went through over a year of training to be a coach, I'm particularly interested in how this works and whether it's really effective, both in the career sense and in personal as well as professional decision making.
SPEAKER_03So the AI coaches is the idea of a tool to support and guide us in our decision making and the choices we have to make for our careers. AI coaching uses machine learning, that is, it accesses large databases, and it selects feedback and can create individualized learning plans or other kinds of recommendations to give workers. It uses various sources of information, many of which a human coach like myself might not have immediate access to.
SPEAKER_03And 24-7 access to data and the ability to create this kind of feedback and communicate it at any time gives the employer and the employee an immediate response if needed. It opens up the possibilities for helping an individual who needs this feedback, not necessarily in a negative sense, but in developing where they want to go with their career, what the opportunities are, and also what they're going to have to do to be able to compete and be ready for these jobs.
SPEAKER_03It just opens that wide up.
SPEAKER_02Yvonne, I think you've hit on probably one of the hottest things that is going to be impacting not only career development, but training. These guys that are coaches in your pocket, in our handout, we've put in a well, we've put in four types and then a load of choices underneath them. So you probably have about 30 to explore. But if you have a chance, open up the app store within ChatGTP. And if you want to have your socks blown off, take a look at.
SPEAKER_00Personalization, I think, is something that you'll see in terms of all aspects of HR. One of the things that it can do in the training side is that it can suggest personalized training paths. But you also see in general HR, a lot of the packages of stuff will be personalized to the individual. And let me just give you one other use, and it's it's not a really sexy one, but um, it's getting a lot of attention, certainly, um, from people. And that's the co-pilot in Microsoft Office. Um, because people are learning how to do tasks in the applications they already use with assistance.
SPEAKER_00And I think two of the things that I've seen that are just unbelievably awesome. One is automatically generating meeting minutes, because for some people that's almost like going through PTSD, um, get that done. And the second one is generating um summaries of presentations or generating presentations from summaries. Um, and I think because it really helps deal with that first draft syndrome. In an academic context, of course, we expect students to do original work, and there's a prospect of that.
SPEAKER_00But in a corporate environment or any workplace environment, the idea is if we're using what's called a closed AI system, or basically everything in that system that's been trained comes from our own stuff and it's a corporate copyright, um, why not use AI to generate that first draft? Because it really will be a you'll be able to produce it much more quickly and without as much angst going through it. And one of the things I do think is on the horizon is the number of programs that any individual professional in this field will be responsible for is going to significantly increase because AI can help you generate parts or all of what you're doing.
SPEAKER_03You know, part of this really gets back to there are only so many hours that a human can work effectively. And that's the the beauty of AI. You know, it's a 24-7 kind of um way of working, and so you get much more information quicker, you get more communication faster and all that. But you know, it goes back to the thing that the three of us have talked about before, is that the implementation of AI in whatever way we're using it and benefiting from it is really all about performance.
SPEAKER_03That's what the organization cares about, right? That's what the leadership cares about, the managers care about. And if we're using these tools for our own career development to help us with that, that's what we care about. Um, expectations are a part of that, of course, but it gets down to performance. And um that's why that augmentation is key. That we can't turn everything over to AI, but we can learn from it, and we will.
SPEAKER_03I mean, this this is not maybe this stuff is going to happen. It's going to happen, and we need to, you know, be ready for it.
SPEAKER_02And I think a couple of things to think about is going to be it's all about they're bringing it in and paying for it because it's increasing your productivity. But productivity without having quality doesn't mean very much. So to Yvonne's point, you need the human in the loop who can work with the system. But some of the things that we're going to be seeing in HR is going to be the end user. Their expectations are heightened by where we've had the commercialization of the HR practice. The same type of experience I have with Amazon or maybe the airlines is a poor choice, but when I've had good online experiences, that's what they're expecting carries over to the workplace.
SPEAKER_02The other part is we're going to see big changes among the students. Their expectations, keep in mind, they've grown up with this stuff. Their expectation is that they're going to have it fast. They don't have to learn until they absolutely need it just in time. We've always talked about just in time learning, but this is seriously just in time learning. And the other part is that the productivity piece we talked about. Companies used to think, well, I need someone with three to five years experience. Well, you might not need someone with three to five years experience. Maybe you're going to be using enough augmented applications in the company that somebody who does sales or someone who does customer support, maybe someone with six months and an AI assistant, will be able to do the kind of jobs that would have taken you two to three years to get the experience to deliver.
SPEAKER_02So it's going to change a lot about the hierarchy, the hiring expectations. And the other part will be if talent is scarce, we're going to start looking at the ability to, as Yvonne was talking about in career development, that we're going to be able to identify through competencies or skills for first hiring. We're going to look for the skills. And while it would be good personalization that we offer you a skill path, we may also look at and say, based on the skill profile, we see this person would be really good if we augmented their training and gave them a little more, they could move into the jobs that we're having a hard time finding outsiders to fill.
SPEAKER_02So we're going to see changes in the expectations of employees, and we're also going to see changes in the expectation of management around the people that are using these systems, how much skill they need to have, how flexible they need to be, what their role is going to be when they're working with an augmented system. This is going to be a game changer and it's going to be very fast because this is the amount of money being spent in this field is introducing more tools every year. And like Sal talked about, the stuff that's co-pilot for Microsoft, it's bleeding in through the organization.
SPEAKER_02And like, you know, frog in the water as they turn the heat up, people will not necessarily notice it, but it's going to be seeping in whether you choose to notice it or not. So we are at an inflection point.
SPEAKER_03And very significantly, when the question always comes up about, well, are we going to lose our jobs? Are people going to not have jobs or have to find new jobs? We know from the history of how this has been developing. We know from the past about what happened with computerization and digitization and so on. There will be a loss of job in some sectors. And they could go fast. And before you know it, there'd be a change around. And with others, it will be slower.
SPEAKER_03And there are reasons for all that. We can talk about that too. But there will be certain jobs that AI will replace because the human can be used more effectively with AI to do something else. And that's part of preparing for HRD changes too.
SPEAKER_01We'll be back in a moment with more from Margaret, Dahl, and Yvonne. First though, here's a reminder that today's episode is brought to you thanks to the wonderful sponsorship support of Concordia University Wisconsin. Unlock new career opportunities with a PhD or Doctor of Business Administration from Concordia University Wisconsin. Our flexible online programmes are designed for ambitious professionals seeking to lead, innovate and drive meaningful change in their industry.
SPEAKER_01With expert faculty, research-driven coursework and specialisations in financial and economic management and organizational performance and change, you'll gain the skills to excel in executive leadership, consulting, or academia. Take the next step in advancing your career. Visit earnyourdoctorate online.cuw.edu today. Right, let's now return to the episode. So it's interesting listening to the many examples you've given and also what we know and what we could anticipate about the future.
SPEAKER_01And I'm sure there's a lot of people listening to the conversation who are already at the point of starting to think through what are the practical implications for me as an HRD professional. So, so how do you view those practical implications at this point based on what's happening now and what you see coming up in the next few years?
SPEAKER_02Let me take first crack and then pass it to Sal and Yvonne. I see it as because the productivity is the piece of it, the tools are going to mean that we're going to be able to get a lot more done in a lot less time. Not that the tool does it all, we still need the human in the loop. So rather than writing the entire course, we may be instead looking it over, uh, editing it, refining it before we send it off to the client for a review. But as we become more productive, and this has already been seen by the people in the advertising world that have been using it to do copywriting and to do the graphic design, customers now expectation is well, send me three samples of that, and rather than having a week to get it ready, they're given a couple of days.
SPEAKER_02We'll probably see our timelines are going to be sped up because our clients are going to be well aware. They're not going to be fooled that we don't have the tools that make us faster and we'll need to turn things around more quickly. The other part is we're going to be facing end users whose expectations are driven by other experiences. They're going to expect better production value, whether the courses are slicker, whether the personalization is truly more personal. So I think we're going to see increased expectations around what we do.
SPEAKER_02I think it'll be less about this. Is not like the old days where you would have had to learn how to do programming to, you know, program an e-learning course or to manage an LMS. These tools are going to be much easier to use. You'll need to understand the mental model of what you're doing versus what the AI is doing, but it's not going to be a very steep curve to use these tools. They're going to be much more user-friendly than what came before. So if the practical implications for us are going to be higher expectations from our clients, students with greater expectations, and our role will be much more about being evaluator interface to the client to understand what they need as we use the tools to produce it.
SPEAKER_02But it's going to be the same work sped up with higher expectations. Saul, what are you seeing?
SPEAKER_00What am I seeing? Um, well, I just want to add, it's not different, it's just an additive to what Margaret just said. Because I'm the one who's working in academia for the three of us. Um, I think a lot of the foundations that we have for how we approach and think about the work that we do are going to be shaken. And some of them are just simple. Um, there's some rules of thumb that we use to figure out how long it takes to develop a course. And ever I've been in this field, it'll it was 40 years ago in May, so I'm kind of old.
SPEAKER_00And um it's always been the rule of thumb that it's about 39 to 40 hours of development for each hour of finished classroom instruction. And then um Brian Chapman and Carl Kopp both did some studies and came up with some general numbers about how long it takes to develop different levels of e-learning. And it's like 79 hours of development for one hour of finished e-learning for just the most basic level one and so forth. I think those numbers are all gonna go and get completely obliterated and they're gonna be much shorter because AI can really speed things up.
SPEAKER_02The other thing that's gonna hit you, remember when desktop publishing people were putting out newsletters wholesale? We are about to encounter where everybody and his brother creates an e-learning class, and the last thing we want to see will be another e-learning course. They'll be so easy to produce that they'll be painful.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, and that gets to the next thing that I see. I think there's gonna be greater demand for instructional developers than instructional designers. And of those people that are developing, I think one of the skills that will be expected of them is not it's not just going to be enough to know how to use the tools and you know, basic instructional design and instructional principles, some learning sciences. I think you're also going, I think the demand for some subject matter expertise is going to be stronger. And one of the reasons is that human in the loop. Um, your subject matter experts, your clients, they're going to expect you to do a proper review of the material before you share it with them for a review.
SPEAKER_00And if it comes in with observable mistakes, it's not just typos, but also content errors that should have been caught. That's not going to be acceptable. So that could have some implications on how we teach people. I think those developers are going to have to be familiar with AI-based tools. I also think that there's going to be some rethinking about what evaluation is in our field, because with the ability to link what's going on in the learning experience or the career development experience with what's actually happening in the job, because those data sets can be linked.
SPEAKER_00We might be able to do a stronger and tighter link between actual performance and the skills that people develop, or the actual performance and the skills people purport to have when they apply for jobs, or what we thought they had when we scraped their LinkedIn profile. You know, we've been talking about performance a lot, but a lot of it's talk and it doesn't always really translate into actual tools.
SPEAKER_02You've hit a really good point with that. There are the tools out there that will do performance in a way that we've not been used to seeing. It'll be through observable artifacts, whether it's the ability to go in and see what you've put in SharePoint to see whether you can really write a decent product description or whether your code is actually good. I can, you know, go through the GitHub and take a look at what you've posted. All of that's going to exist. Now, there's going to be a ton of legal issues around that that we could talk about in another time.
SPEAKER_02But you're right, performance is before I think a lot of us were stuck on the performance was we gave a really good into course quiz, or maybe we even got as far as one of the higher levels of Kirkpatrick and we saw whether you took it back to the job site. What if they're constantly able to monitor? You know, we know that there's fading of skills. What if you're able to constantly monitor and recognize this is the point where the fading starts and we need to do a refresher? And it's a system watching you, it's um personalized. It recognizes that Saul's done a good job staying with his, you know, the things he was taught where I kind of messed, kind of let it go and I slip back into old ways and I get personalized messages, nudges that Saul isn't going to get.
SPEAKER_02The tools are going to exist, and when it matters enough, companies will be able to bring those in and turn them on.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, and just one other thing to add to that is that the cost, one of the big reasons that even though we talk a lot about the higher levels of Kirkpatrick, um level three, you know, being transfer, level four being impact, um, it doesn't get done that much. The data is pretty consistent. It's like less than 10% of all training gets that. And one of the reasons is it's very expensive and it happens after the project is over, and the instructional team is already working on something else. With the ability to just simply program in while you're doing your course, the ability to track the actual performance on the job, we've significantly reduced that overhead needed to do that transfer evaluation and perhaps some of the impact.
SPEAKER_00And so, in theory, and it'll be interesting to see what happens in practice. In theory, the cost should come down and the ability to collect the data should be significantly higher.
SPEAKER_02But don't you also think for some of our people, the skill set is how many of us have really good data analytics skills that we could look at that data and make sense of it? And the scary part is tons of data and totally ignorant of being able to make decisions or making decisions that are just plain old silly.
SPEAKER_00Well, that's why I said that's the theory versus reality. The capability to be there, but the whether the ability to use it isn't. Yvonne, what do what are your thoughts about this issue about like What does this mean to me as an HRT specialist?
SPEAKER_03Well, I work with uh currently I've been working for about a decade with workforce development. So I work a lot with the uh colleges and other groups that provide training for middle skill jobs as well as uh others that are a little more sophisticated. And I think, you know, because AI has been in development since around 1950, we're in for a shock, I think, in the workforce for what is gonna happen and what people see. It's not gonna be subtle, it's not gonna be slow, it's just gonna start happening.
SPEAKER_03And um so I think we're gonna fall into several categories in terms of what's gonna happen with your development in your career. Um, we've talked about upskilling before, but I think now we're gonna find that some of these changes with AI are going to require upskilling of taking people where they are and actually gaining more skills that puts you at a different level. And that will be something that employers as well as workers will have to figure out how that's gonna be done and who's gonna pay for it, and who's gonna provide it, and who knows enough to provide it.
SPEAKER_03That's a huge challenge with many kinds of jobs, is that we don't have people out there who can be the teachers to inform it. So that's a challenge that's there. And then for others, we're talking about reskilling, that it's not just taking what you've done and learn more about it so you can be the augmented worker, but starting over or gaining a whole new set of skills you haven't had because you're now in a whole different category.
SPEAKER_03Now, one example of this would be a truck driver who's uh got that certification, earning a very good living driver, and now we have autonomous vehicles, and what we really need are traffic controllers for those autonomous vehicles. That's a whole different set of skills than driving a truck.
SPEAKER_02How does that play into? I mean, that reskilling and upskilling is extra challenging because we're also facing a demographic shift that's just huge. We have a rapidly aging population. What's the thinking on the upskilling and the reskilling when you're looking at people that are fairly long in the, you know, they've been in the workforce a long time.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, it's that's a challenge because um as the jobs have really uh you know bifurcated, and we're now having lots of people at a lower end of pay, and others trying to get at the higher ends of pay, and the middle class jobs seem to be um getting thinner and thinner. And that's what some of these folks were talking about, where they are or want to be. It is difficult because um to meet this challenge, you not only have to have the availability of the content to educate people and develop the skills, you have to have the providers.
SPEAKER_03And as I said, that's a big challenge right now. There just aren't people who are equipped or interested in teaching this or can earn enough to want to do it, especially if they're working in the field. Why would they leave a good job to go be an instructor in this area? So is this kind of training going to come through community colleges, government grants? Yes. Yeah, both. It's it's community colleges, workforce, development boards, groups like that, of course, private vendors as well.
SPEAKER_03And there can be very expensive sometimes for a person who may not have the resources or an employer that supports it. And that's why the the federal government provides some funding, state governments provide a lot of funding to meet these needs. And for people who are in HRD and HR, they really need to think about their employee situation and what they can do to provide those funds, guide them in thinking about their careers, just helping people even become aware that the career pathway is different and is going to be very different going forward because you know you're not gonna see that endpoint that you're headed to because you don't know what it is because it hasn't been invented yet.
SPEAKER_02Right, right. The career, the typical career ladder is there. Besides the career ladder, what else about the workplace and the structure of work is gonna change? I mean, that's pretty dramatic.
SPEAKER_00Well, if I can pop in here, I think just to build on what Yvonne's been saying, well, a couple of the skills that have been identified that are super important to dealing with this transition, and they're very they're they they've quite problematic, are collaboration and adaptability. And the reason they become problematic, um, I've just finished a study that was funded by the Canadian government just to look at how we teach these skills in the workplace. And the bottom line is really can be summed up, we barely do it.
SPEAKER_00Um, the assumption is that people come into the workplace with these skills. Employers increasingly expect universities and colleges to teach these skills, and they don't understand these are not skills that last a lifetime. Your adaptability to age 22, when you're used to changing a lot of things, is real different than your adaptability to age 40, which is very different than your adaptability to age 60. The same thing comes with collaboration. Um, and so what we've noticed is first of all, there's very little teaching done.
SPEAKER_00The teaching is quite either perfunctory at a very simple level. I mean, we looked at some publicly available courses, a lot of them were super short and didn't really cover much, um, or they're only executive focus, and there's not a lot offered for the average worker. And it is the average Joe worker out there who's really going to be affected. And these are skills that AI requires, but they're not AI skills, and they're not skills that can be taught by AI or even taught by e-learning. You can't say, sit in front of this e-learn, your system and learn how to be a more adaptable human being.
SPEAKER_00That's a really, and it shows some of the limitations of what our field is. We're very good in the cognitive and the psychomotor domains of learning. We're really, really not great at figuring out how to teach in the affective domain.
SPEAKER_03Uh, so adaptability is the one skill that really emerged after the pandemic. And when the uh employers found that the number of changes that they needed to make to stay in business during the pandemic, to adapt to having workers work remotely, all of the things that we did during that time, they started talking about what we need are workers who are adaptable. And that is an important skill.
SPEAKER_03It is not one that is taught or can easily be taught, uh, but it's one that is very important now. So I'm so glad you raised that because the adaptability that people will need as they go through these changes with AI, whether it's the piece that you bring in that really creates a situation where you're working side by side with an AI tool, or something that's the result of AI and how you have to work, or we're talking about the skills you need to deal with large data sets and things that have been interpreted that way.
SPEAKER_03Well, regardless of what it is, it says a lot about what we need to be saying to our workers when they're looking ahead for their careers and what they need to develop. And we haven't talked about this, but I think it's important that HRD, HR people consider what it is gonna take to turn every worker into a lifelong learner. And that's what it's gonna be from now on. There's we'd already seen where we had to every few years gear up our skills and take a course or whatever.
SPEAKER_03But this is a whole different world that we anticipate where people were gonna have to be learning all the time and understand that that's part of work and be happy with it and find a way to pay for it.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, well, we um unfortunately we've hit the end of our hour, but I I can't I can't wrap this up, I think, without throwing one more quick question out to the three of you. Because I'm picturing folks listening to the episode thinking this is great, but I I am bemused about what the right next step is for me. Um so if there was somebody listening who was trying to figure out what's the one thing I should now go and do as a result of this, whether it be by preparing myself as an HID professional or helping my organization adapt to this or whatever, um what would be what would be your advice to somebody as to the best next step they could take in this direction?
SPEAKER_00Borrowing from the uh the great Nike, um, just do it. Um if you haven't played with ChatGPT, which a lot of people have, or notebook LLM, definitely do that. If you have access to the Copilot, do that. Turn on the transcription, this closed captioning when you watch videos on YouTube. That's AI. Um, it's not necessarily and I think a lot of people get afraid because it sounds like such a big thing, but there are just a lot of little things that you can be doing without even realizing you're using AI. That's a great place to start, and I'll turn it over to my colleagues for what else to do.
SPEAKER_03Well, I'll just share one thing that I'm always telling people when we talk about these kinds of things, looking ahead with their careers, and that is you have got to understand your industry. Now, if if it's because you are a human resource person, your industry is in human resources, human resource development, find out what's going on in your field. If you are somebody that's in education, find out what's going on in education related to AI.
SPEAKER_03All the different industries are at different points. They're using different tools and they're moving at different rates. But you can read within your field and find out some of what is happening so that you can be informed and begin thinking about where do I fit in? What do I need to know? Because it won't be the same for everybody, but there will be something that everybody needs to learn. And I think you just start with your industry, look at your professional publications, or just you know, do searches online to find out what is going on in AI in my field.
SPEAKER_02Okay, I'm gonna spin off both of you. There is a resource list that goes with this podcast. Make a commitment to yourself to spend four hours, just set a timer, maybe two hours at a bump, and go through it. There is a whole section on the journey that we talked about going from candidate uh acquisition all through retirement. Almost every one of these vendors that have AI tools, they have a free site to try it. You're not gonna try them all.
SPEAKER_02Pick a couple that interest you so that you can actually experience it. Nothing beats having hands-on experience to say, yeah, I tried it, it wasn't all that, and a bag of chips. That's great. You've tried it and you know what it is. You are in on what your industry's up to. And some of them you'll find yourself the timer will go off and you'll still be playing with it. Then the second part, when you're, you know, when you finish with the hands-on stuff, read the last section of resources, not a heavy read, but do a quick scan.
SPEAKER_02One of the things we didn't talk about today, and absolutely is HR professionals, it probably should be top of our reading list, but the government rules globally, locally, statewide. These tools do not come with a free pass. Start reading about what the legal constraints are. You could be the local hero in your company when you're the one that says, yeah, the software does it. It's sold to us from you know a company somewhere in the US that wasn't aware that you can't do that with an employee's data. So read the stuff on the governances, go ahead and do the hands-on piece of the journey, and then on some of the things, if you're particularly interested in the learning uh and development aspect of it, absolutely spend some time playing with the coaches.
SPEAKER_02The coaches are amazing. And about two or three years from now, we're gonna come back and we're gonna talk about the coaches and we'll have a good laugh. Meanwhile, if you want to see something a little more old school, try some of those authoring tools. Again, all of the vendors offer free, um, free trial of a week or a week or two. Go ahead and make a couple of courses. Uh, some of it, maybe you're already using it and it's no big deal, but take a look at the difference in the the everything from a you know, Vyond to a synthesia to an articulate 360.
SPEAKER_02They all have very different mental models. And as educators, you'll appreciate the difference after you've dug into them and say, hmm, that kind of is very constructivist or wow, there's nothing but behavioralism there. You will go through those tools and you will bring a lens nobody else will bring. So make a commitment to yourself, set aside four hours and just do some hands-on exploration. And I think you're gonna be, you're just gonna be amazed because there's so much out there that is not fantasy, not fiction.
SPEAKER_02It's here today and it's getting better every quarter, every three months. It takes an exponential improvement.
SPEAKER_01Perfect. Well, unfortunately, you reached the end of our time together, but I wanted to say a big thank you to all three of you for taking time out of your busy days to be with me and uh have such a fascinating conversation. I'm sure anybody listening to this will go away with plenty to think about and a lot to do as well. So thank you all so much indeed for your time.
SPEAKER_02This is just fabulous.
SPEAKER_00Thanks so much for this opportunity. Uh, we love talking about this stuff.
SPEAKER_01Thank you so much for joining me for this episode. It was wonderful spending time with Yvon Thayer, Margaret Driscoll, and Saul Carliner. If you enjoyed this episode, check out our other 45, which contain conversations with over 100 leading scholars from around the world. To learn more about the series, check out HRDmasterclass.com. And to learn about the Academy of Human Resource Development, check out ahrd.org. Support the future of human resource development.
SPEAKER_01Give to AHRD, a 501c3 non-profit, today. Your donation powers research, scholarships, innovative programs and vital operations that keep our HRD community thriving. Every tax-deductible donation makes a difference. Join us in ensuring AHRD remains a beacon for research, collaboration and professional growth for decades to come. Visit ahrd.org forward slash donate and invest in the future of HRD.
SPEAKER_01Together we can make a lasting impact. Also, please check out our episode sponsors, Concordia University Wisconsin. Earn your doctorate in business administration online. Visit them at earnyourdoctorateonline.cuw.edu today. Join me again next week when I'm exploring the question of how we can rethink HRD with guests Laura Beermer, Jamie Callahan, and Tamika Greer.
SPEAKER_01Until then, stay safe. This is Darren Short signing off from the HRD Masterclass.com.
This fourth episode of Season 6 brings together Dr. Sanghamitra Chaudhuri (Temple University) and Dr. Kyung Nam Kim (Texas A&M University) for a conversation about the 2026 article Gendered Pathways to Work-Family...
This third episode of Season 6 brings together Dr. Yuanlu Niu (University of Arkansas) and Dr. Jos Akkermans (Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam) for a conversation about the 2026 article Navigating careers in non-traditional...
This second episode of Season 6 brings together Dr. Matthew Hurtienne (University of Texas at Tyler) and Dr. Heesun Kim (Francis Marion University) for a conversation about the 2024 article Silence in the workplace:...
This first episode of Season 6 brings together Dr. Joshua Collins (University of Minnesota) and Dr. Ague Mae Manongsong (Louisiana State University) for a conversation about the 2023 article “Manongsong, A. M., & Ghosh,...
Welcome to the trailer for Season 6 of Human Resource Development Masterclass - the podcast series from the Academy of Human Resource Development, the organization that leads HRD through research. The sixth season...