In this seventh episode of Season 3, guests Dr. Szufang Chuang (Indiana State University, United States), Dr. Claretha Hughes (University of Arkansas, United States), and Prof. Jim Stewart (Liverpool Business School, United Kingdom) discuss the relationship between HRD and Philosophy, including: What is meant by the term Philosophy? What is the connection between Philosophy and the concepts of work and the workplace? What is the relationship between Philosophy and HRD? Which current philosophies inform the work of HRD practitioners and academics? How does Philosophy help HRD to work on challenges facing organizations? What could an HRD philosophy look like, and how might one be developed? How can someone surface the philosophies that are driving their behaviors and approaches to HRD? and much more. For full details on the HRD Masterclass series, visit hrdmasterclass.com, for the bios of the guest scholars visit allbypodcast.com/philosophy. For more information on the Academy of Human Resource Development, visit ahrd.org - by being a member of AHRD, you can access bonus materials from podcast episodes. This episode is sponsored by the Board of the Academy of Human Resource Development, which encourages you to attend its 30th annual research conference in the Americas being held in Minneapolis, Minnesota, March 1st to 4th 2023. For further details, visit ahrd.org.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_00The essence of philosophy is the search for truth. And how do we search for truth? And so when you think about philosophy, you're always searching for answers, you're searching for truth, you're examining questions.
SPEAKER_02Welcome to Human Resource Development Masterclass, the podcast series from the Academy of Human Resource Development, the organization that leads HRD through research. I'm your host, Darren Short, and here in our third season, we're exploring the relationship between HRD and other topics and disciplines, with the help of leading authors, researchers, and scholars. Today our focus is the relationship between HRD and philosophy, and our guest scholars are Dr.
SPEAKER_02Tzu Fang Chuang of Indiana State University, Dr. Claretha Hughes from the University of Arkansas, and Professor Jim Stewart from Liverpool Business School, all of whom join me for conversations recorded during April and May of 2022. Our episode today is structured into two halves. In the first 30 minutes, we look at what we mean by the term philosophy and its relationship to work, the workplace, and HRD.
SPEAKER_02And then in the second 30 minutes, we dig deeper into that relationship between philosophy and HRD. You can find out all about the questions explored in the episode, the three guest scholars, and also the episode sponsor by visiting all by podcast.com forward slash philosophy. Talking of sponsorship, Human Resource Development Masterclass is only made possible thanks to the wonderful support of our sponsors, who cover all of the costs associated with the series, and so enable us to release them free of charge to listeners like you.
SPEAKER_02I encourage you to show your thanks by checking them out and letting them know just how much their sponsorship means to you. Today's episode is sponsored by the Board of the Academy of Human Resource Development, which encourages you to attend its 30th Annual Research Conference in the Americas being held in Minneapolis, Minnesota, March 1st to 4th, 2023. It's the ideal opportunity to meet leading scholars, practitioners, and rising stars, including many of the guests featured in this podcast series, as they report their cutting-edge research and share insights on rethinking the meaning of work.
SPEAKER_02The event is perfect for learning and networking. And AHRD is an inclusive organization that invites all of those who are interested in the field, no matter where they are on their scholarly journey. Mark your calendar for 2023 in Minneapolis. We look forward to seeing you there. For further details, visit the AHRD homepage at ahrd.org. Right, let's dive into the episode.
SPEAKER_02Welcome to our episode on HRD and philosophy. Let's start by meeting today's three guest scholars. First of all, I'd like to welcome Tsu Fang Chuang, who is Associate Professor of Human Resource Development at Indiana State University. Su Fang holds advanced degrees in technology management, human resource development, industrial education, and adult education, and worked in human resource management, training and development, and academic positions at a private institution before joining Indiana State.
SPEAKER_02So welcome, Tzu Fang.
SPEAKER_01Thank you, Darren, for having me. It's great to be here.
SPEAKER_02My second guest for the episode is Claritha Hughes, who's Professor of Human Resource and Workforce Development at the University of Arkansas. Claretha's research interests include valuing people and technology in the workplace, technology development, diversity, intelligence, learning technologies, and ethical and legal issues. She's published numerous articles in peer-reviewed journals and has authored or co-authored 13 books. Welcome, Claritha.
SPEAKER_00Hi, everyone. It's great to be here. Thank you for having me.
SPEAKER_02And my third guest for the episode is Jim Stewart, who is Professor of Human Resource Development at Liverpool Business School in the United Kingdom, where his role is to provide mentoring support and research leadership for colleagues researching HRD and HRM. Jim is former chair and currently president of the University Forum for HRD, and he's the author and co-editor of over 20 books on HRD. Welcome, Jim.
SPEAKER_03Thank you, Darren. Very good to be here and good to be with Caritha and Sufa.
SPEAKER_02Okay, well, I'd like to start off our conversation by exploring the term philosophy, which is the focus of the episode. And I thought it's worth us starting with that definitional piece so that listeners are clear on what we mean by the term, ready for when we start digging deeper into its relationship with HRD. So what do we mean then by the term philosophy?
SPEAKER_00I look back at the origin of the term. We started with the ancient Greek. When you look at a definition, the Greek really defined it as a love of wisdom. And when you think about wisdom, it's a combination of knowledge and experience. And our field is about knowledge and experience. So for HRD and philosophy, they're intertwined, even if we don't have a true definition of HRD theory or HRD philosophy, there's always interactions between the two.
SPEAKER_00And philosophy is not about alternative facts, it's about questions. And it's more about the questions than the answers because every time you get an answer, you can come up with a new question. So the essence of philosophy is the search for truth. And how do we search for truth? How has our lived experiences influenced our HRD philosophy or our philosophy as a whole? And so when you think about philosophy, you're always searching for answers, you're searching for truth, you're examining questions.
SPEAKER_00Because Jasper's J S P E R S in 1951, in his book Way to Wisdom, he suggests that there's no escape from philosophy. And that the question is only whether philosophy is conscious or not, whether it's good or bad, muddled or clear. And that anyone who rejects philosophy is himself unconsciously practicing the philosophy. So when you look at philosophy, you look at it from different perspectives of how we see the world, which is ontology, how we come to know and think about the world, epistemology, and how we should act in theorizing, researching about, and practicing in our world, which is axiology.
SPEAKER_00So the definition of philosophy is ever evolving because we could ask the question, what is a philosophy? Continuously and still not ever answer that particular question. But in our field, we have begun to look at ways to answer that question.
SPEAKER_01I think this is a very, very interesting question. Um, we talk about philosophy, we do research involving philosophy, but we never really talk about what is a philosophy. And so hearing that question stopped me to thinking, yeah, why I why I had philosophy in my research. So I start to look back and I realized that to me, philosophy helped us to think. And ever since my research involved philosophy, um, such as Confucian philosophy and analytical philosophy, I started to view and value things differently.
SPEAKER_01So in my case, I can better explain different perspectives and behaviors as well as dealing with the conflicts between uh Eastern and Westerners, like in a learning setting. Philosophy is to me, I feel like this is like a set of accepted and shared beliefs or views about life.
SPEAKER_00Philosophy is foundational to learning and knowledge, as Su Fang suggested. And in the field of HRD, it's predicated on learning and knowledge, which influences our field, our studies of training and development, career development and org development. And within those three pillars, we have the interactions among people. And everyone, as Su Fang suggested, has a philosophy or philosophical thoughts and questions. And then in their search for truth and understanding, how we bring new people and new thoughts into the field expands our understanding of philosophy.
SPEAKER_00Because, as we stated, everyone has one, and it's based upon numerous theories and lived experiences that takes us back to the wisdom of what they've learned and how they bring it into our field. And so, from that perspective, I think learning that requires research, reading, writing, and discussion among all HRD peoples in every aspect, from students, faculty, professionals, administrators, is vital to us understanding philosophy in the context of HRD.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, can I just um offer a definition which I think I might be wrong is from uh a guy called Eric Tang, who wrote a book on the uh philosophy of management. And that says the aim of philosophical inquiry is to develop a more adequate understanding of the world for the purposes of developing more adequate practices in the world. So I think this definite this focus in the definitions and discussions of what is philosophy from Clarita and uh Sufan, emphasizing practice and practices in the world is uh a kind of the essence of philosophy.
SPEAKER_03And the other thing that went through my mind was um a debate academics often have about theorizing, and that debate often kind of starts on the point that it's the job of academics to theorize. Whereas my position is that every human being uh theorizes probably every day of their lives, and the theorizing that they do certainly um managers and professions like HID practitioners in organizations are operating uh on their own theories, and their theories are informed by their own philosophical positions, whether they are aware of it or not.
SPEAKER_03So, philosophy is highly practical, in my view. It's um it's about informing how we uh how we are and how we behave in the world, and therefore is central to human resource development, which is all about how we are and how we behave in the world.
SPEAKER_02It makes me feel as if, therefore, um philosophy has uh an impact on everything that's around us, including what's around us at work. And so, of course, ultimately I'm looking to explore the relationship between philosophy and HRD, but I'm wondering if a half step to that is to first consider the relationship between philosophy and work and the workplace. So, so how do you see the relationship between those?
SPEAKER_03One of the things about philosophy and what I said earlier by theorizing is that philosophy is highly influential in influencing the sciences, including social science. And work is a focus of uh thinking and research and writing uh within the social sciences. And I think we tend to think about work in relation to employment, but we forget that we might say something like, I should be doing some work on the garden, or my partner and I share the housework, and therefore work is not necessarily associated with employment, and work occurs whenever human beings undertake some kind of effort in order to produce an outcome, which kind of relates to the next question, which is what is a workplace?
SPEAKER_03The obvious answer would be wherever work occurs is a workplace, including the home. You can also kind of generalize about the nature of organizations based on different philosophies of work and of employment. For example, if you take capitalism as a philosophy, then that supports the notion of employment, which is based on the notion of individuals selling their, according to Marxist philosophy, selling their labor power uh in exchange for for wages.
SPEAKER_03But if you look at alternative kinds of organizations, something like cooperatives, they still have uh employment relationships, but uh the basis of those is is different. Maybe Sue Fun can help with that.
SPEAKER_01Oh, definitely. Let me start with um the history of philosophy. So taking some examples, transitional Confucius thought has a stronger emphasis on one's role in a hierarchical structure and loyalty to the company. And that's why when we observe a workers in an Asian cultural setting, their behaviors and their reaction or uh their thought process tend to be different from the Westerners.
SPEAKER_01And if we take um the question transition, for example, the way that they work is like a work is a calling and it involves God's will. So culture definitely plays a part when we talk about the philosophy here. It could be consciously, it could be unconsciously. I did not realize that I was impacted by this philosophy. I was born and raised in Taiwan, and um at that time, Confucius' philosophy is not just embedded in our daily life from the parents from the old generation to the younger generation, but also in our education system.
SPEAKER_01We all have to learn what Confucius thought, and we all have to learn about his practice. And there's tons of information about what he said, uh how you should be a good human being, how you should practice in your daily life. And I did not realize how much that I was impacted by that, and how much that the way I communicate, the way I think and process, or how like value certain things, they were impacted by the Confucius philosophy.
SPEAKER_01And I did not realize until I start doing research a little more about the philosophy. As I now live in different cultures and experience different cultural values and the cultural shocks, and I start to realize that how this impacts me and the people I know in the, I call it the Confucius influencer societies in many different ways.
SPEAKER_03Su Fang kind of highlights an important point there, which is that unless you think hard about your life and what surrounds you, you kind of just take for granted the um the philosophy, unstated, unarticulated, that has influenced your education and your socialization and growing up. So, for example, in Western economies in Europe and the US, uh, capitalism is taken for granted. Capitalism is thought to be the only way of living, the only way of doing things.
SPEAKER_03And in the old Soviet Union, and probably still in China, uh, communism is the assumed only way of doing things. And in Taiwan, uh, as Sufan was saying, uh, Confucianism as a philosophy is the taken for granted, the assumed only way of doing things. And so philosophy is very important to get people to think harder about the things they take for granted.
SPEAKER_00And the question that came to my mind was how has your lived experiences influenced your HRD philosophy? And when Su Fang was talking about how her lived experiences in her education system, and Jim Stewart was talking about how capitalism in America influences your thoughts. When you think about work and the time involved in work, you have people who may have been working in childhood, you know, child labor laws and all of that.
SPEAKER_00And all of those experiences come into play when they think about what they how they work today. And a lot of people think work begins at 18, but for some people it may have begun it began at five or six years old. And so the way they value work and look at work is totally different than the way people inside um organizations view work. And as Jim suggested, if you're working at home all the time and having to have a job, your views shift.
SPEAKER_00And you when you look at HRD from a career development perspective, if I've already worked from age five to 18, I don't want to spend the rest of my life working. And so career development for me would be totally different from somebody who started work at 18 and wants to have a career, and so they would look at career development a little bit differently. And so I think all of our lived experiences influence how we look at HRD.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, I think that's uh that's a very important point. And uh, if we disassociate work from employment and understand workers' physical or mental effort, then a good current example uh of interest to HRD researchers and uh practitioners is the unpaid domestic and care work that happens in the home, predominantly done by women, and that has impact on women's education, on their employment, and on their careers.
SPEAKER_03So philosophy might raise the uh might raise the question: is it ethical that the burden of work in the home falls unequally on women? And that's of interest, I think, even more to HRD because of the uh the consequences of the pandemic, which kind of emphasized the burden that women have to have to bear in relation to work carried out in the home. And the consequences for how we can, as HRD researchers and HRD professionals, uh, do something about that and uh work to work towards supporting women's uh opportunities and ability to pursue a career.
SPEAKER_02So maybe this is an opportunity then to start focusing in even more into the HRD piece of it. I think that was a really interesting conversation about the relationship between philosophy and work and the workplace. Um, and so I'm interested in what you see there for as the connection between philosophy and HRD, and in particular, how how they influence each other.
SPEAKER_01I really like um Carissa mentioned about the HRD philosoph philosophy. I like the term, it's very interesting. I feel like I I kind of uh want to set this as my next research topic. Um, so different fields or uh country they'll have different philosophies. So I heard about the political philosophy, educational philosophy, philosophy of life, now the HRD philosophy.
SPEAKER_01I think we could use and learn from all the philosophy to help to understand better about people, like sometimes in HRD, that we will wonder why this individual responds that way, why this individual behaves that way. Knowing all the different philosophy can enhance our ability to understand a phenomenon. So research on the impact of cultural values, such as like continental philosophy, confusion philosophy, work or job satisfaction, learning, leadership teamwork, et cetera, are a great example of a strong connection that between the philosophy and HRD.
SPEAKER_01So what I'm saying is I think as HRD professionals that we could also think about what we could benefit from the available philosophies.
SPEAKER_03Well, I was kind of thinking of the distinction between philosophies and doing philosophy and philosophizing, philosophizing, right?
SPEAKER_00guess uh is the process by which we uh we come to have a variety of philosophies uh but i think you know philosophizing is uh is more important in the sense of asking the fundamental question so uh the fundamental question is for me is you know what is the purpose of HID what are we about what are we there to do what are we trying to achieve if you think about the purpose what is the purpose of human resource development is it is to support um achieving organizational goals which in the corporate private sector is primarily making profits or does it have some other purpose or should it have some other purpose so this is when we get into the axiology that uh Theresa said the morality and the ethics of human resource development a lot of the conversation we're having is what I thought about years ago when I wrote my book Valuing People and Technology in the workplace and when you thought about even talking about humans and technology at the same time HRD and training professionals did not want to have that discussion.
SPEAKER_00And you know when I came up with perspectives Darren I I wasn't thinking about it from a philosophical perspective but that's exactly what it is when we had our first conversation I looked at it and I said every organization has a cultural behavioral or cognitive perspective but I'm going to include the word philosophical perspective because that's exactly what I was looking at at the time but couldn't put my finger on it. It's not the culture of the organization it has cultures within that but if you have organizations such as accounting firm and educational institutions they're more cognitive based.
SPEAKER_00You have companies such as IBM that are more behavioral based. Then you have the Googles and the SaaS and all of those organizations Apple that operate more from a cultural perspective of how they treat their employees. And so as I update the Bay and people as technology book I'm I'm going to include that philosophy into those three perspectives and that's governs pretty much how those organizations operate.
SPEAKER_00And if you bring um someone with a cultural perspective into a cognitive organization they may mesh better than bringing an IBM behavioral thought process person into an educational institution. And that I think that's the shift that you're seeing when you bring people in the education who wants to have the business mindset in as opposed to the education cognitive mindset where time to do research is lessened time to think about concepts and constructs and new theories and this publish a parish speed at which you're trying to do the work is governed by a behavioral perspective as opposed to a cognitive philosophy.
SPEAKER_00And so I think as we work together as HRD scholars and professionals we need to really really examine how we truly value the work that we do and the people that we're working with and understand from them as Su Fang says communicate with them and how it has an impact on diversity and you know my diversity intelligence construct came out of this value in people and technology book and model because I was saying how do I value each individual person and I couldn't value each individual person if I did not see them if I marginalized Su Feng because she was from Taiwan or Jim Stewart because of his location in the UK how do I truly value each individual that works within my organization it cannot be accomplished if we have totally different moral and ethical viewpoints towards differences and why people do what they do and these philosophies play a role in that as well.
SPEAKER_02I think one of the fundamental questions for me about HRD is what is the purpose of HRD? And so I'm interested in your thought given the conversation you've just been having I'm interested in your thoughts about how philosophy helps us view or answer that question. How does philosophy help us answer the question of what is the purpose of HRD?
SPEAKER_03It's a very good question uh Darren and I think um what Shu Fan was uh saying earlier kind of uh can be helpful in the sense of different philosophies might lead us towards uh different answers for example capitalism would I think lead to the answer something like the purpose of HRD is to uh develop the employees and the organization in order to better more efficiently more effectively meet its uh its goals and its object objectives which within capitalism are usually expressed in uh in economic terms and financial terms to do with the growth of uh net worth and growth of uh profits etc but a different philosophy I don't know but maybe Confucian for for example might lead us to a a different um answer to the question of what is the purpose of human resource development so the study of philosophies can enhance our abilities to reason think critically and solve problems based on my research findings a strong emphasis on humanity in Confucian philosophy may be used to support HR the initiative for OD and C D during the transition and process of Industrial 4.0 or the age of AI and so that human can better coexist with the robot and or AI if humanity is valued and practiced.
SPEAKER_00But yeah I want to remind that um everyone that despite the to take the benefit from available philosophies we should not forget to review the historical cultural and political background of the philosophies for a true understanding um I'm saying that because for example confusion philosophy um it was it has been around for like over 2500 years and it is a long transition uh philosophy that has spread through deeply in many uh far east asian countries such as China Japan Korea Taiwan Taiwan VN and it has a great emphasis at the social harmony social stability social order more standard uh goodwill human being and cultivate in the uh spirituality and at that time the 2000 years ago 2500 years ago that completely different historical background um so we kind of have to keep that in mind when we want to adopt or learn from a philosophy and use that to help us to address the issue that we are facing I would like to say that you know I think that HRD research is part of the problem because it seems to trend so much towards leadership if you look at all of the trends using the ATD yearly industry report employee training gets very very little focus and HRD has seldom if ever done a lot of work on technology and work in the literature now that AI has evolved you're seeing some work in HRD literature related to it but I think we are behind the trends and we're behind the times on that level of research and so when you look at Confucius um philosophy Greek philosophers the history of manifest destiny in this world which is where I began my work on diversity intelligence because without history none of our work is valid and we're constantly going into vicious cycles because we don't know the history and we don't keep up with the trends.
SPEAKER_00We're on the fourth industrial revolution right now but a lot of students don't even know the first industrial revolution so we have to as a society of human resource development truly look at all aspects of work and how we look at employment. And when I teach it I make sure I go have the students do the history and understand the history and the work so that they can have a better understanding of why we are a field.
SPEAKER_00Why do we exist?
SPEAKER_03Not just what our purpose is but why do we even exist if we can remain true to who we are and what our purpose is I think we'll be successful in philosophy having a philosophy of HRD will help us you know shape that yeah I think um two very important points have been raised there one of my um uh Suafani in relation to cultures and societal cultures and how how how they vary and influence and uh and shape things and uh from Claretha the uh the importance of um historical development and how that has and continues to uh to shape things and shape understandings and shape philosophies.
SPEAKER_02So I think those two things the um societal cultures and uh historical development are really important in understanding uh where we are and how we got here and therefore how we how we might um get to where we want to be in relation to answering the fundamental questions about anything and therefore fundamental questions about human resource development so it might have had a purpose in the uh in the last century uh it might have had a purpose in the century before that uh different to what its purpose is now and different to what its purpose um could and should be in the future we'll be back in a moment with more from Tsufang Claretha and Jim as we dig into the relationship between HRD and philosophy first though here's an important reminder that this episode is brought to you thanks to the wonderful sponsorship support of the Board of the Academy of Human Resource Development which encourages you to consider joining and becoming a member AHRD is a professional home a place to learn teach and share a space to research publish and present a network of scholars teachers researchers and practitioners to connect and to apply the art and science of human resource development to change organizations and transform the world through human flourishing with almost 500 members AHRD is a global organization made up of, governed by and created for the Human Resource development scholarly community of academics and reflective practitioners.
SPEAKER_02Membership includes online access to four peer reviewed world-class journals, two decades of conference proceedings with cutting edge research and thought leadership and much more. To learn all about becoming a member of AHRD visit the member central page at ahrdorg Right let's return to our discussion for the second half of the episode welcome back to our episode on HRD and philosophy where I'm joined by Su Fang Chuang of Indiana State University, by Claritha Hughes of the University of Arkansas and by Jim Stewart of Liverpool Business School.
SPEAKER_02Here in the final part of the episode I'm thinking it'd be interesting to continue our discussion by exploring maybe three themes that came out from the previous part so maybe current philosophies in their uses the concept of an HRD philosophy and also the implications of our discussion for individuals who are listening to the episode. So to get us going how about we start off with current philosophies and in particular what do you see as the current philosophies that are often informing the work of HRD professionals and academics there are three philosophies of HRD currently being influential and informing both research and practice within the subject each of these are derived really from the um differing answers to the question what is the purpose of HRD?
SPEAKER_03And the first of those is what's called generally the performance philosophy and in the performance philosophy the purpose of HID is to improve organizational and in relation to national HID country performance and the effectiveness of those improvements are measured by economic and financial indicators for instance at the country level that would be gross domestic product at organizational level it might be increases in profits or return on investment.
SPEAKER_03The second one is what's enabled the learning philosophy and here the purpose of HID is to promote and facilitate the development of individuals and that development is kind of focused on personal growth improving life chances and supporting self-actualization measures used to assess the effectiveness of HID in this philosophy are to do with the impact of HID practices and the benefits for individuals' personal growth.
SPEAKER_03The third current philosophy which is the most recent I think is referred to as critical human resource development and the purpose of HID here is to question and challenge existing power structures in social relations including those operating in organizations and the kind of end purpose of that is to contribute to and facilitate increased equality and diversity in organizations and inclusion for marginalized groups in both organizations and in society. The effectiveness of the critical HID philosophy is measured through changes in the power relations within society and within organizations.
SPEAKER_03Now these three philosophies are each influenced by different answers to the basic philosophical questions mentioned by Claritha earlier in the discussion what is the nature of reality which is the concern of ontology what is the nature of knowledge and knowing which is the concern of epistemology and what is of value and valuable and valued which is the concern of axiology each of the HRD philosophies are within different streams of philosophy in relation to those three questions.
SPEAKER_02So for the performance philosophy the ontology is realism the epistemology is positivism and the axiology is utilitarianism for the learning philosophy the ontology is idealist the epistemology is interpretivism and the axiology is deontology which is basically a rules based value system and for critical HRD the ontology is critical realism the epistemology is pragmatism and the axiology we can say is uh virtue virtue ethics and so there are connections between what we can describe as three current HRD philosophies and answers different answers to the basic questions that philosophers and philosophy have uh struggled with for centuries and still struggle with now those basic questions about what is the nature of reality, what is the nature of knowledge and what is of value and valuable I wonder if it's helpful to explore how current HRD philosophies and maybe how philosophy more generally could help HRD in addressing a specific challenge.
SPEAKER_00For example we could consider the emergence of the great resignation but when you think about that concept how could philosophy help HRD to react to that phenomenon when I was listening to Jim what I thought about was how capitalist society we talk about it a lot and how it influences the morale of the employees in HRD we want to talk about it as engagement but you can't separate the two and the economic impact on employee morale is huge.
SPEAKER_00And I think that contributed to the great resignation I think the fact that HRD was so far behind with technology when the great resignation began due to the pandemic HRD wasn't quick enough to train the people on using technology when they were displaced and sent home to work and then they weren't equipped to handle the morale issues that came up when it became a debate about an essential worker versus a non-essential worker.
SPEAKER_00And a lot of the non-essential workers' morale was depleted because they didn't feel like they had a place and because they didn't have a place in the organization and their needs at the moment their work is valuable but it wasn't valuable in the context of the need that had to be met in order for society to survive the during the pandemic and for organizations to provide the needs of society during the pandemic.
SPEAKER_00And I think America for years had been using technology to really shatter the middle class. We outsourced so much of our manufacturing in the name of cheap labor overseas versus being able to develop workers here and pay them more. And so all of this came to a head when you needed resources that you couldn't get from overseas but you didn't have the workplace in place or the technology in place to produce it here.
SPEAKER_00So HRD professionals were left scrambling and trying to meet the needs of the organization of the society of their own because as an HRD professional you have to know it to be able to teach it. So if you don't have the technological skills to help train faculty to teach online to help teachers teach online to learn Zoom to learn Webex to learn all of these different technological skills virtually overnight HRD professionals were trying to train people from their homes inside the person's home and without a philosophy of HRD that could really structure where change is supposed to reside where technology resides where learning and performance reside where value of each individual worker resides we don't really have that structure what Jim outlined earlier will help us I think put together a stronger model of where HRD philosophy resides but without that I don't think we could have helped the great resignation we're shaped by society versus us helping to shape society because we society's values on life and the history of health care influenced a lot of the decisions with regards to the great resignation money became more valuable than people money became more valuable than people's health in their minds.
SPEAKER_00The history especially for vaccinations of African Americans with regards to the Tuskegee experiment is still hindering them even taking the vaccine and the reason I bring up the Tuskegee experiment is that is why we have institutional review boards in America all of us in our research has to get IRB approval and IRB came out of the Tuskegee experiment and we're still suffering the effects of it in minority communities because they don't trust the government enough to take a vaccine and so I think a lot of HRD philosophy cannot exist without understanding society itself and the history as we discussed previously.
SPEAKER_02When you take a look at the concept of like the great resignation is it possible for you to look at that say through a performance philosophy lens and then also to look at it say through a developmental philosophy lens and to and to see the concept of the great resignation Differently?
SPEAKER_03Yeah, I mean, I think you would end up with different understandings and explanations for the great resignation, depending on which philosophical point of view you started from. So from a performance perspective, it's a problem to the extent that it creates problems for organizations to continue to function and to continue to produce their goods and services and continue to make profits. Whereas maybe from a critical HID perspective, it's not a problem, it's the opposite of a problem, something to celebrate, something to uh welcome, something to cheer, because individuals are exercising their power uh to decide where they work and who they work for.
SPEAKER_03And so how you see the great resignation, how you understand it, depends on which philosophical stance that you uh that you start from.
SPEAKER_02During the whole episode, multiple philosophies have been referenced. And I think at a number of times, we've also dripped in maybe the concept of there being an HRD philosophy, as if there could be potentially a single HRD philosophy at some point. I don't know whether that could happen, but if it could, what would that look like? And and how would a philosophy of HRD be developed?
SPEAKER_01To begin with, first we have to understand that each philosophy might serve different purposes and each individual might view each philosophy differently. And so maybe we could start from the very broader perspective, start with what's what a philosophy could do for us. So, like today, HRD professionals are taking more responsibilities, especially after the pandemic.
SPEAKER_01And HRD philosophies that in place could really provide some guidance and influence how the HRD professionals interpret and practice the HRD interventions within the organizations. So, specifically, in my view, I feel like that the HRD philosophies should provide some central values in advancing the HRD functions and direct the HRD scholars or and practitioners to either form ideas or to analyze the concepts, definitions, and problems.
SPEAKER_01So as the pandemic, let's go back to, since we mentioned about that before, as a pandemic has changed people's lives and business operations and forced the organizations to adopt different ways of working, then um the changes that brought to uh brought various challenges to management in HRT professionals to find new ways to work productively. And so therefore, having a strong HRT philosophy in place helps to ensure the HRT effectiveness and facilitate the professionals to address the labor structure changing, um, identify new meaning of work, assess management, uh, developing leadership skills that are necessary to deal with the crisis, or ended develop a strategic planning for continuous development.
SPEAKER_01Therefore, a philosophy of HRD should be created and continually viewed updated as our uh work environment and structure change. So, in that line, and fundamentally, a philosophy of HRD could include core values, which detect how HRD should be functioned and how HRD professionals should behave. Alignment, the other uh component I feel should be um in there is uh to ensure that the values and practice support organizational mission and goals.
SPEAKER_01And so a thorough understanding of organizational values, goals, and culture is needed. Uh, relevance, the other one that uh I feel it should is critical that demonstrates that the philosophy is socially and culturally relevant to HR the daily practices and considers of what are the governance and code of ethics in the organization. And a mindset, the other one, which advocates uh embracing challenges such as uh advanced technology, job changes, uh, work structure, new meaning of work, et cetera, as opportunities.
SPEAKER_01And so I think that these are critical components as we look at what's uh what are needed, uh how we how we could develop a philosophy of HRD to ensure everyone is on the same page and uh promote a value that we are trying to practice in the workplace.
SPEAKER_00I don't think, I don't think there'll ever be a grand philosophy of HRD only because you got humans and everybody has a mind. And that's why you have doctor of philosophy degrees across all different disciplines, because everybody's thinking, at least you're supposed to be thinking as academics. You're thinking and you're studying, and you new things are emerging, so change is a constant, it's continuous questioning.
SPEAKER_00So I don't think that there'll ever be one grand philosophy of HRD or one theory of HRD, but I think um there needs to be a constant communication among HRD professionals and scholars and practitioners, because without it, we tend to go into silos and we leave people out, or we leave um different societies out.
SPEAKER_00For example, our organization, we're we have a European division, we're looking at the Asian, we're exploring Africa, you know, without those type of communications, I don't think that we can be effective worldwide. So I think we should have talks and discussions around it, but I don't think we ever have just one.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, I mean I uh you know I think that's kind of the basic point of this of this um podcast in a sense that you know the the purpose and the practice of philosophy is to pause and seek to answer questions full stop all of the time. Um and if there's one thing that I would want uh uh listeners to the podcast to get from uh what we've been talking about is that I want them to engage themselves and with others that continuous questioning and seeking answers for themselves and for the and for the profession.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I agree. Um I don't think that we were ever able to come up with a universal agreed um HRD philosophy, just like HRD definition. We still do not have an HRD definition that is universally agreed. And um, so there are all different kinds of versions of HRD uh definition, and there are even some other uh different uh definitions of international HRD.
SPEAKER_01We cannot have, and I don't think just one single universal agreed HRT philosophy will work, but I would uh think that it's still a good idea, it's still uh worth it to continue the conversation and dialogue about HRD's philosophy, because if HRT philosophies could be developed, then the the work values and paradigms of HRD could be better understood by others. Um, even as well as for our own professionals, people still have some misunderstanding about what HRD is, and people often confuse the difference between HRD, HR, and other, sometimes other discipline related discipline as well.
SPEAKER_02Several points in the in the conversation, you you've each mentioned how philosophies can be operating consciously, or in many cases uh operating like outside of our awareness. And so it it feels as if there's a benefit to surface those philosophies, and then once they're surfaced to challenge them. But but I'm wondering, like in terms of advice to listeners, what would your advice be on how someone could surface the philosophies that could be driving their behaviors and therefore driving their approaches to HRD?
SPEAKER_00We tend to focus on what we know, and often we don't want to look any further than what we know. So, for me, what I do for my students is I ask them the question, and it is not in the philosophy class or anything like that. I just ask them to please explain how they personally go beyond what they currently know and understand to learn something new. And once you answer that question, I ask them, how do you then teach that to someone else?
SPEAKER_00I teach working adults, so I get a lot of people who are already set in their beliefs, and when I see them set in those beliefs, then I start asking these types of philosophical questions of how do you go beyond what you know? How do you take what you've learned about how you go beyond what you know and teach it to someone else? And some of the answers are just amazing of well, I question things and I question things over and over. And so it they start philosophizing, like Jim talked about.
SPEAKER_00And you don't expect that to that degree, but that's the result I get when I start asking them to think beyond what they currently know.
SPEAKER_03I'm just reading and reminded of um Rajah Rebels' formula from uh a very long time ago when he was formulating action on learning, which is L equals P plus Q, L being learning, P being programmed knowledge, and Q being questioning. And so, as Clarice was just kind of highlighted, questioning is uh is is essential. You've got to pose questions and seek answers to them. That would also require taking action and learning from the um learning from the action.
SPEAKER_03And again, taking from Reg Revens, doing that in the um in the company of what he called uh comrades in adversity. So doing that in the uh in the context of engaging with fellow professionals. Another piece of advice might be that you can you can find codes of practice, ethical codes of practice, which might be the P in the uh in the formula, the program program knowledge. And uh one example would be the Academy of HRD, have a code of ethical practice.
SPEAKER_03And those are useful starting points if you want to uh behave in an ethically uh appropriate manner as a professional, but the only starting points, then you've got to get on with the other parts of the um of the equation, which is the questioning.
SPEAKER_00It takes time to learn who you are, what your beliefs are, what you think, and it also takes time and an humble spirit to be able to listen to people question what you believe and not just respond because they question what you believe, believe, but to do that self-actualization and self-reflection and use metacognition to really think about what you're teaching as an HRD professional.
SPEAKER_00Why are you teaching it? How are you teaching it? Does it really matter from a relevance perspective, as Su Fang said earlier? Where does the value of it reside? Does it reside within you, or does it reside within society or your organization, or are you trying to help someone else? And so it takes a lot of time to do that. And I think we tend to want to just respond immediately, and with social media and the pace at which information is coming out, we are oftentimes not as deliberate as we can be about discussing these topics and and getting an understanding.
SPEAKER_00So the question I read, I put it on the final exam. So the students have had an entire semester to really think about what they know and how they know it. And so I think we need to really value time more and in the learning and performance and the critical HRD philosophies that Jim talked about.
SPEAKER_02Reacting to what Claritha just said there about social media, it um it makes me think about how so many of us are increasingly in our little bubbles where we're surrounded by people and points of view that are similar to our own. And so also reflecting to what Jim was saying around the benefits of of doing of questioning within groups, it it sounds as if there's some merit to making sure when you're doing that questioning, you're doing it with people who potentially see things differently to yourself.
SPEAKER_02So you can actually understand how different philosophies could be operating and coming up with potentially different outcomes. Is is that something you'd recommend, like the idea of getting deliberately seeking out people who could be viewing things differently?
SPEAKER_03I think more diverse groups are likely to be much more productive, much more um stimulating, much more thought-provoking uh for everyone who's a member of uh a diverse group. So, yeah, I would I would make that recommendation.
SPEAKER_00I I would make it from the perspective of inside organization, you have so much group think. People think the same. And so without um to be able to break up the group think, you have to have different perspectives and you have to discuss it from a different perspective. For example, if I'm teaching a technology resources class, I'm not teaching them the technology, how to use the technology, I'm teaching them what goes inside the technology.
SPEAKER_00Because when you go into an organization, they've they have bought the software and the technology that they want their organization to use. So you can't often go in and say, take that technology out and use the one I brought with me. You have to understand how to navigate within what's already in existence in different ways. And so I think you have to talk and discuss with people that are different, with organizations that are different, with different cultures and beliefs.
SPEAKER_00Because without that, you're just in a groupthink mentality and there's no growth. I think the pandemic forced disruption that forced growth, that forced us to rethink how we philosophize about things. Because prior, you were just thinking, oh, technology, everybody don't really need it, and you had the great divide where certain groups didn't have access to technology.
SPEAKER_00Pandemic hits, everybody needs technology, so now you throw in every type of resource like Zoom. Most people didn't know Zoom existed until the pandemic hit. You had kids with mobile um internet resources in places where there was no broadband. So all of this different technology just came flooding out of the background to help society, and people had no clue.
SPEAKER_00So without this diverse thought and diverse conversations, we don't know what's in the world.
SPEAKER_02Well, I like wrapping up episodes with a sort of call to action. And so reflecting then on the conversation for the last few minutes, I'm wondering if the right call to action is to ask the question how can somebody who's listening get better at philosophizing? And so, would somebody be willing to wrap up the episode with a final thought on that?
SPEAKER_01I think with all the ideas and the um thoughts that we just discussed in this episode, and I think what I'm getting at is we can engage um an ongoing dialogue on core beliefs of HRD philosophy to shape questions and learn from different aspects would be the great start. Um, just like Claritha mentioned, um having a different perspective and getting different ideas and having a lot of conversation can really help and contribute.
SPEAKER_01And and most importantly, I think it's critical to have a growth mindset to develop a system that links human strategies and performers for a more dynamic talent and work model in the workplace. So if we could have um like with a strong HRT philosophy in place, that it may um ensure the effectiveness of HRD, enhance our capacities to solve problems and deal with uncertainty in workplace, may as well promote a strong sense of belonging that feeds HRD in the big picture, as well as shape a workplace culture that promotes employees' um productivity and engagement in the organization.
SPEAKER_02Excellent. Well, unfortunately, we have run out of time for today, but I wanted to say a big thank you to all three guests for being at the episode in the episode. I've really enjoyed our conversation about HRD and philosophy. Thank you so much, Su Fang, Claritha, and Jim.
SPEAKER_03Thank you for the invitation, Dart. It's been very uh it's been very thought-provoking for for me as well.
SPEAKER_01Thank you. This has been great. Thank you all.
SPEAKER_00I learned a lot from each one of you. Thank you.
SPEAKER_02Thank you so much for joining me for this episode. It was wonderful spending time with Su Feng Chung, Claretha Hughes, and Jim Stewart. If you enjoyed this episode, check out all of our others. There were 22 episodes in the first two seasons, and we're releasing a further 11 here in the third. Between them, they provide access to conversations with over 75 leading HRD scholars from around the world. New episodes released weekly.
SPEAKER_02To learn more about the series, check out HRDmasterclass.com. And to learn about the Academy of Human Resource Development, check out ahrd.org. By becoming a member, you can access extra bonus materials. I'm looking forward to being with you in our next episode when we're exploring the relationship between HRD and spirituality. With the help of Judy Neal of the Global Consciousness Institute, Julia Storberg Walker of the George Washington University, and Stuki Tai of the Haitia Institute.
SPEAKER_02Until then, it is Darren Stort signing off from the Human Resource Development Masterclass.com.
This fourth episode of Season 6 brings together Dr. Sanghamitra Chaudhuri (Temple University) and Dr. Kyung Nam Kim (Texas A&M University) for a conversation about the 2026 article Gendered Pathways to Work-Family...
This third episode of Season 6 brings together Dr. Yuanlu Niu (University of Arkansas) and Dr. Jos Akkermans (Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam) for a conversation about the 2026 article Navigating careers in non-traditional...
This second episode of Season 6 brings together Dr. Matthew Hurtienne (University of Texas at Tyler) and Dr. Heesun Kim (Francis Marion University) for a conversation about the 2024 article Silence in the workplace:...
This first episode of Season 6 brings together Dr. Joshua Collins (University of Minnesota) and Dr. Ague Mae Manongsong (Louisiana State University) for a conversation about the 2023 article “Manongsong, A. M., & Ghosh,...
Welcome to the trailer for Season 6 of Human Resource Development Masterclass - the podcast series from the Academy of Human Resource Development, the organization that leads HRD through research. The sixth season...