Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Human Resource Development Masterclass

Human Resource Development Masterclass artwork

HRD, Anxiety & Burnout

Sep 12, 20231 hr 6 minAudio

In this fifth episode of Season 4, guests Dr. Amanda Hay (Nottingham Trent University), Dr. Ellen Ernst Kossek (Purdue University), and Dr. Meera Alagaraja (now Texas A&M University, and University of Louisville at the time of recording) discuss the relationship between HRD, anxiety, and burnout, including: What is meant by the terms Anxiety and Burnout? How are individual employees and the workforce as a whole impacted by Anxiety and Burnout? What are the implications for organizations and what actions can organizational leaders take to address Anxiety and Burnout? What are the implications for HRD practice - the work it does, where it works, how it works, who is involved? What are the implications for HRD education and how people are prepared for careers in HRD? What are the implications for HRD research and, specifically, what research is needed into HRD and its relationship to Anxiety & Burnout? and much more. For full details on the HRD Masterclass series, visit hrdmasterclass.com, and for the bios of the guest scholars visit allbypodcast.com/anxiety. For more information on the Academy of Human Resource Development, visit ahrd.org - by being a member of AHRD, you can access bonus materials from podcast episodes. This episode is sponsored by the Health Professions Education Special Interest Group (HPE SIG) at the Academy of Human Resource Development - to find out more, visit https://www.ahrd.org/page/special_interest_groups.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_04It's really HRD's role of giving a voice to those that are marginalized in organisations, giving voice to things that are difficult to talk about, like anxiety, like burnout.

SPEAKER_02Welcome to Human Resource Development Masterclass, the podcast series from the Academy of Human Resource Development, the organization that leads HRD through research. I'm your host, Darren Short, and here in our fourth season, we're exploring the relationship between HRD and trends in society and organisations, with the help of leading authors, researchers, and scholars. Today our focus is the relationship between HRD, anxiety, and burnout.

SPEAKER_02And my guest scholars are Dr. Amanda Hay of Nottingham Business School, Nottingham Trent University, Dr. Ellen Ernst Kosek of Purdue University, and Dr. Mira Aligaraja, who is now at Texas AM University and was at the University of Louisville at the time of recording. All of whom join me for a conversation recorded in March of 2023. Our episode today is structured into two sections. In the first, we look at anxiety and burnout and how they impact organizations and the workforce.

SPEAKER_02Then, in the second, we explore implications for HRD practice, research, and education. You can find out all about the questions explored in the episode, the three guest scholars, and also the episode sponsor by visiting allbypodcast.com forward slash anxiety. Talking of sponsorship, Human Resource Development Masterclass is only made possible thanks to the wonderful support of our sponsors, who cover all of the costs associated with the series and so enable us to release episodes free of charge to listeners like you.

SPEAKER_02I encourage you to show your thanks by checking them out and letting them know just how much their sponsorship means to you. Today's episode is brought to you thanks to the wonderful sponsorship support of the Health Professions Education Special Interest Group at the Academy of Human Resource Development. The HPE SIG is a group bridging and applying HRD with Health Professions Education to develop the health care workforce, including physicians, nurses, veterinarians, dentists, pharmacists, physician assistants, emergency medical technicians and allied health professionals such as hospital management, occupational therapy and clinical psychology.

SPEAKER_02The HPE SIG vision is to create an interdisciplinary collaborative group that contributes to the practice and research in HRD and health professions education. For full information, check out their website at ahrd.org forward slash page forward slash special interest groups. Students, practitioners, and scholars are welcome to join the AHRD HPE SIG. Right, let's dive into the episode.

SPEAKER_02So welcome to our episode on anxiety, burnout and HRD. And let's start by meeting today's three guest scholars. And first I'd like to welcome Dr. Amanda Hay, Senior Lecturer in HRM and Organisational Behaviour at Nottingham Business School in the United Kingdom. Amanda has a PhD in work psychology, and a central theme of her work focuses on efforts to humanize management learning processes by paying attention to rarely discussed lived experiences of managing, such as doubt and anxiety.

SPEAKER_02So welcome, Amanda.

SPEAKER_03Hi, it's great to be here, and I'm looking forward to some interesting conversations today.

SPEAKER_02My second guest for the episode is Dr. Ellen Ernst Kosek, the Basil S. Turner University Distinguished Professor at Purdue University's Cranit School of Management. Ellen is an award-winning social scientist who helped advance the US and international work-family life research policy field. She studies how work-life boundaries, work-life family, and diversity employment practices impact women's workplace inclusion and career equality. So welcome, Ellen.

SPEAKER_00Thanks very much, Darren. Looking forward to the conversation today.

SPEAKER_02And my third guest for the episode is Dr. Mira Alacaraja, acting associate dean at the Office of Innovation and Strategic Partnerships, and Associate Professor in the Department of Educational Leadership, Evaluation and Organisational Development at the University of Louisville. Mira's research interests include well-being, strategic HRD, and workforce development. And her work has been recognized through both the Monica M. Lee Award for Outstanding Research and the Richard A. Swanson Award for Excellence in Research.

SPEAKER_02Welcome, Mira.

SPEAKER_01Hi, everyone. Happy to be here.

SPEAKER_02So over the next hour or so, we'll be talking about anxiety and burnout and then implications for individuals and organizations and implications for HRD. And before diving into those details, it feels like a good place to start our conversation is by exploring those two terms of anxiety and burnout, what they mean, and then also how the three of you have explored those terms in your own work. Amanda, would you be willing to get the ball rolling for us?

SPEAKER_04Sure, Darren. In my work, I think I've tended to draw on the work of the Slovenian philosopher and sociologist Renata Salikal. And she sees anxiety as being associated with a specific anticipated threat, which incites in us the feeling of being uncomfortable. But like most concepts in our field, then there are different ways that we might then view that understanding. So I think oftentimes when we think about anxiety, we tend to view it through a medical paradigm and we see it as a clinical condition which has paralyzing effects.

SPEAKER_04And as such, it's something that should be avoided or certainly highly controlled. But there are also other ways that we might view anxiety. So an alternative way is also to see it as part of an inevitable part really of human existence, which affects us to greater or lesser degrees. So here I'm thinking particularly of some insights from process philosophy, which might be useful. So a very basic level process philosophy is a way of seeing the world as always in a state of becoming, as always in the making.

SPEAKER_04And this means that our worlds then are far more precarious and fragile than we would oftentimes like to admit. So our worlds, therefore, are oftentimes uncertain, unpredictable, unknowable. And these are the very conditions I think which evoke anxiety. So when anxiety overwhelms us and we're no longer able to cope, then it is, I think, anxiety can become damaging and this can lead plausibly to burnout. Something that was recognized by the World Health Organization in 2019, and it broadly describes a state of physical and emotional exhaustion, which can occur when we experience long-term stress in a job or when we have worked in a physically or emotionally draining role for a long time.

SPEAKER_04So turning to my experience, I've tended to focus on anxiety and not burnout per se. So my work has largely focused on management learning, how they learn in both formal and informal everyday settings. So when we study formal management learning, such as in the context of, say, an MBA program or a DBA program, we see that experiences of anxiety are often an integral feature of the classroom. Since when we think about it, learning happens when we work on the edge of not knowing.

SPEAKER_04And this is a condition which evokes anxiety. We also see that anxiety both encourages and hinders learning. So if anxiety can be worked with, it can lead to new insights and learning. Yet if it is avoided, it can lead to what scholar Russ Spence has termed willing ignorance. And in some cases, it might become so overwhelming that it leads to dropping out. Perhaps this is the learning equivalent of burnout. I've also seen that anxiety is an important topic of discussion, important part of what it means to learn to manage.

SPEAKER_04So, for example, my work in 2014, which interviewed a sample of mid and senior level managers, this highlighted that a common struggle for those managers related to coping with the anxiety of not meeting grandiose expectations of the managerial role, which demanded that they were always right, always in control, and ultimately, I guess, always successful. And what kind of struck me through those conversations with those managers was at the same time they were afraid to discuss their anxiety, since ironically, managers aren't supposed to be anxious and they tried to carry on, typically by overworking.

SPEAKER_04So, for some in that study, at least, um, I saw a link between anxiety and burnout, and importantly, how in that situation, how trying to avoid anxiety could actually lead to even more anxiety.

SPEAKER_02Thank you so much, Amanda. It's a great way of positioning those terms. And it's great to hear about your own work in that space as well. So maybe to take it in the order that I introduced folks in, uh Ellen, I'm interested in how you have viewed anxiety and burnout and whether it's kind of different to what Amanda's talked through, and then your own experiences of working on those issues.

SPEAKER_00Yes. Um, so I've done more work on uh burnout and in particular uh done work from psychology on uh looking at aspects of it. There's uh physical exhaustion, emotional exhaustion, such as Masluck and Jackson's work. An example, if we were gonna measure this, is I feel emotionally drained from work, from emotional exhaustion. And I've looked at work-family conflict, which is a different concept, but I think it's related to this, and that a lot of parents are anxious about managing work and family or people with elder care or people with their own health issues, and how can we design work to support people's well-being while on and off the job?

SPEAKER_00So a lot of my work is focused on training leaders and cultural initiatives to support policy use. And I think uh different jobs need different types of support. And it's sort of like we could saw during the pandemic that uh some workers, frontline workers, had to go to work in a grocery store, police, and had to leave their families at home. That would make people stressed. And uh there, I'm writing up a paper today about whether leader training helps employees.

SPEAKER_00And we found different effects of training leaders to support anxiety and burnout. Uh our case we called it family supportive behaviors. And what we found is for workers that were frontline jobs, having a trained manager reduced their emotional exhaustion. And that was very important because they were, you know, having to leave home and during a very stressful time. Uh, but for people that had control over their jobs, like professors can work on a laptop, many managers can work on a laptop anywhere.

SPEAKER_00It uh if you had a trained manager, it helped engagement in their family and engagement in their work, being able to be absorbed in it and enjoying it. And I think those are the opposite emotions of anxiety and burnout. And I think we have to look at mixed effects and try and uh look at positive effects to prevent burnout and anxiety.

SPEAKER_02So, Mira, how does all of that compare to how you viewed anxiety and burnout and your own work on them?

SPEAKER_01Thank you. I I don't study um anxiety or burnout. What I do focus on is um well-being and wellness. And and there, I I see different approaches to well-being too, especially if you look at it from an organizational level approach, or you're talking about from a personal standpoint. Um, what are these different approaches? And also within the context of work and within the context of life itself. And so, within the context of work, when we talk about terms like anxiety, burnout, well-being, I think um I am informed by Aliyah Crumb's work on mindsets, how they relate to stress, and the downstream effects these can have on being well and feeling good.

SPEAKER_01And I think I'm also seeing outside of the context of um organizations um all kinds of ways in which people spend their time earning uh what I would say is maybe a living wage or something, you know, or maybe it's not. So all of these impact, all of these impact our sense of security and who we can be within the context of being well and feeling good. And so then there's a cultural aspect of how we approach, how we approach or manage, or what notions we understand of who we can be and what those barriers are and how we work through those barriers.

SPEAKER_01But um, overlaying all of this is also societal notions of who we can be. And I think then there's that, then there's that, I would say, a daily dynamic and a struggle of like our identities that are informed by our families and communities versus maybe organizational expectations or societal expectations. So I think this is where I feel that there's so much that we are still learning and figuring out and and learning from perspectives of others or employee groups that have traditionally not been the focus of management scholars or HRD scholars as well.

SPEAKER_02It's interesting listening to the three introductions that you've each given. In in there, there are uh factors or implications related to like the individual or to groups of individuals, or in some cases the workforce as a whole. That there's clearly um implications or issues that relate to organizations and organizational leaders, and then as you just mentioned there, Mira, there's also like the societal or like national level and implications for those.

SPEAKER_02And so to kind of break the kind of past those a little and to dig in a bit, I'm wondering if a good place to dig first is looking at what this means for individuals. And so when we actually take a look at an individual employee and then consider like the therefore the workforce, um how do you see the individual employees being impacted by anxiety and burnout? This probably connects to what you were just saying, Mira. So are you willing to pick that up first?

SPEAKER_01Oh, definitely. Uh, I think so that though that individual view, and then I also think it's connecting that with job perspectives. So whether we're talking about job crafting and the autonomy or the freedom or the extent to which employees can be involved in crafting their jobs with their managers. And then we can also also talk about organizational impacts of anxiety and burnout. But again, I think from an individual view, I see overwork, a lack of agency.

SPEAKER_01And I think it's at multiple levels in the organization, regardless of where our roles and responsibilities or either constrain us or give us additional opportunities to exercise or bring forth our skills and expertise. So I think that's the individual view, and um I think there's a lot of work for HRD professionals to figure that out, also in support for all of the other things that are going on in organizations. The second perspective, I think, is also looking at jobs and like within jobs, it's have like um issues related to lack of role clarity, because I think there's been turnover, um, there's been fewer replacements of positions.

SPEAKER_01So then jobs have been added, responsibilities have been added, absorbed, and then overall a lack of clarity. I think also lack of communication. So I agree relying more on technology, but at the same time, there's that sense of connection, loss of connection, burden of overwork that's also impacting our jobs. And overall, I don't know if you all agree with me, but there's there seems to be an unreasonable time pressure. Um, I overall, just like less time, we've got more tools, less time to connect with one another and problem solve.

SPEAKER_01What I think we are also sensing is this lack of community. And so there's increasing silos, individual silos, or within programs and teams, but that cost collaboration is somehow being impacted. Um increasing concerns about lack of fairness of employees, like especially in how you receive practices and policies and how you experience that, and demands for customizing HR policies or HRD policies within organizations that actually can support a particular employee and not just a group of employees.

SPEAKER_01So that customization is becoming a huge part of the diversity, equity, and inclusion conversations, um, social justice agendas within the context of higher ed and also outside. And then overall, there seems to be a mismatch of values and skills within organizations as well. So there's all of this going on at multiple levels. And I think I think it's it's causing uh differential demands on if you look at uh if you look at women, if you look at marginalized employees within organizational context or marginalized communities as well.

SPEAKER_01So I think creating a line of sight for organizational leaders of how we can help employees connect their individual or personal aspects of well-being to their jobs and and how we can at least try to head in a similar direction is is a big challenge and also an opportunity for a greater alignment or moving towards some alignment of goals and expectations.

SPEAKER_04I think that's a really interesting point about the alignment of expectations. Mira and you were talking earlier about um our identities and who we can be in in the workplace. And certainly the studies that I've come across, there's there's a lot which talk about um anxiety as being understood as a response to idealized images and expectations. So, you know, increasingly there is that pressure, not just time pressure that's being put on us as individual employees, but also you know, this these expectations to um to deliver more and more and more.

SPEAKER_04Um and that leads to you know individuals feeling anxious and insecure about their failure to be able to fulfil those various demands and expectations. Um, you know, I'm thinking particularly of some work by David Knight and Caroline Clark in the UK context, and they looked at um, for example, veterinary surgeons and academics and found high levels of anxiety related to the neoliberal context of deprofessionalization and a loss of autonomy as well as increasing managerial controls of assessment, audit and accountability.

SPEAKER_04You know, and it's about these conditions, I guess, where we can all probably relate to this, where we are pressured to expect more and more. Yes, yet we must do so in a world where increased levels of uncertainty mean that the achievement of those raised goals, those raised expectations is somewhat fraught. And then in terms of what this means for the individual, you know, that study was very much kind of helping us to understand that the anxiety and the insecurity that was provoked means that oftentimes people are increasingly living on the edge.

SPEAKER_00Just related to that is the idea of, as you mentioned, identity and roles, both of you. And I think the blurring of boundaries between work and personal life is what's uh a big factor for many of us. There is no separation for many people within between roles. Uh, your family can text you at work and you can be uh contacted by your boss or colleagues at night. And so um I've uh worked with the Center for Creative Leadership uh and had developed an assessment uh that's an article published in the Journal of Vocational Behavior on how people manage work-life boundaries to fit with uh their role identities.

SPEAKER_00So uh it used to be that we thought that if people were workers, they were generally career-centric and that they valued their work role and demands more than their uh non-work roles. A part of that was the structure of family, somebody was taking care of their, you know, having meals ready when you got home or other domestic demands. And then people were thought to be non work centric. You know, they might work part time or want flexibility, but they were uh and they were seen as more centered on family and personal life. Well, many people today are dual centric.

SPEAKER_00They are high in their job identity out of necessity, or professionals often love their work. We academics have a lot of overlap between who we are and our jobs and their families as well. And there's frustration because you can't uh work in an environment that allows us to excel at both. And this lack of boundaries has increased cognitive complexity of managing back and forth between roles. And there can be rural confusion. You could be home, uh, I studied uh STEM faculty during the pandemic and they'd be trying to do their job and you know their kid, yeah, you're locking them out of your home office, or you're trying to watch an autistic child while you're working.

SPEAKER_00Um, and uh I'm worried that we are haven't learned as much as we could from the pandemic. Maybe we've lightened up a little bit to let staff work at home more, but I think uh it just increased demands. And I know women administrators, Mira, had were the most overloaded in our study. Um uh just one last thing I wanted to mention too is I've forgotten about the idea of related concepts of stress and psychological distress. And I have studied that in an NIH-funded study. And Amanda, when you were talking about everybody needs a little bit of anxiety, the same with stress.

SPEAKER_00We all need a little bit of stress. It would be boring if we weren't stretched. But uh I remember we did use a scale on psychological distress with nursing home uh nurses caring for patients, and some of them had elder and child care off the job. And psychological distress scales do include I feel anxious, I feel you know, uh uneasy. And I think as you were both talking, many people are just feeling, as Amanda said, on edge. And that is a lot of depression right now with violence in the world.

SPEAKER_00We've got a war going on. UK, I have a family member that lives in the UK, Amanda, and you know, you can't buy tomatoes right now in the UK. I mean, these little things in life are I'm joking, but there's a shortage. You know, it it's you know, can our kids go to school? Can we go to a movie theater? Can we be an armor professor? I taught at Michigan State. There was a shooting there, it's an uncertain time.

SPEAKER_02It it sounds from your answers that um levels of anxiety and burnout uh have been increasing over potentially the last few years, certainly over the last decade. And I'm interested in your thoughts about the extent to which they've been increasing at a faster rate than our ability to help people with them. As in, is do you see an increasing gap between the levels of burnout and anxiety and our ability to support people?

SPEAKER_00I'll just say in organizations, we have an ad hoc approach approach to solving anxiety and burnout. Somebody has a problem, we say, oh, go to the employee assistance program, but we don't design occupationally healthy workplaces to try and prevent anxiety and burnout and the design of work and reduce stigma for asking for help. The US Surgeon General has come out with five aspects of a healthy workplace. I was interviewed for that, and work-life harmony is one of them.

SPEAKER_00I'm a work-life scholar, I bring that. But if people can't have time to be whole people and feel that both many parts of their life are not sacrificing one for the other, uh, that's a challenge. And you know, people can't easily buy houses now. You know, they you know, lots of things for the good life, young people coming out, is there a job security? We don't work for a company long-term, people are delaying getting married, fertility rates are dropping. I think when people have children until they have place or you know, growing, there's hope.

SPEAKER_00Are people losing hope in the in our institutions functioning?

SPEAKER_04An interesting point for me, perhaps, is you know, that um stress and anxiety um are distinct phenomena as well. And perhaps while we've had lots of conversations about stress in the organizational context, we haven't really necessarily talked about anxiety. It still seems to me, from my kind of research, very much a taboo word that we are well behind in terms of being able to help people that are suffering from living on the edge and dealing with those pressures of anxiety.

SPEAKER_01I think it's also important uh when we talk about um anxiety, burnout, stress, well-being, also to like these descriptors for you know human experiences that we are having, how does that get contextualized outside of like traditional data sets that um management and HRD scholars typically focus on, right? So, for example, one of the things that we found very fascinating with my with the research team that I work with, we say, okay, so let's look at well-being data sets that have, you know, we've collected data, we have talked about this, about these concepts and constructs in multiple fields, so whether it's in psychology, sociology, sometimes in the intersection of spirituality, religiosity, and all of these different components of well-being, what does that mean for someone from a low resource community, a member who falls below the poverty threshold?

SPEAKER_01And what are their experiences of well-being? And when we're shining a spotlight on these kinds of words and descriptors, what does that mean for somebody's experience outside of that socioeconomic status or the kinds of data sets that we go after, or who we survey, who we talk to, who we interview? And it was fascinating for us to because we started talking more, we started unpacking the kinds of opportunity structures that are available for somebody who might be lower middle class, upper middle class, or you know, or maybe somebody who works within higher education, who has a job, who has employment.

SPEAKER_01So anxiety and burnout and well-being and feeling good all have different notions of what that could be like, and that what we continue to discuss not just in research literature, but also in popular media literature, right? And so what we wanted to focus was how do we shine a spotlight on folks whose stories we don't hear enough from? What are their stories of feeling well? And so within limited opportunity structures, what we are finding is similarities in some of the some of the themes around well-being and feeling good, so which is great.

SPEAKER_01So there's the commonality of that human experience, but also very specific differences in how folks are focusing on being well, or sometimes saying we don't use those terms to describe these kinds of feelings that we have or these experiences that we have. And so then I think it goes, I think the work is interesting because now what one of the projects that I'm working on currently currently is now we're looking at community settings, or like how, as individual members, we're embedded in these particular communities, these particular geographical locations, or for the or zip codes, if you want to say that way, like where we are, what resources are available to us, create these different structures, and within those structures, what is our sense of being well, and what are those stories?

SPEAKER_01And I think so. I think I think there's a lot of perspective taking that folks who have, I think I would say, bottom line, have a full-time job, able to make more than a living wage. I think they're that I we I think we are losing sight and sense of perspective of what other people's experiences are. So going back to some of the comments Ellen and Darren you made earlier on, I think there is a societal siloing of experiences and experience sharing and a greater loss of community knowledge, um, community um you know experiences, whether it's generational or passing of expertise or things of ways of being that I think there's much bigger loss than we are able to grasp.

SPEAKER_01And the pandemic has sort of like really like been a big, like hopefully, like it stalled us, I think, for a little bit of time, but I somehow feel that now we are on a faster, crazier path. And sometimes I'm I think just perspective taking alone. Like when I go to the field, when I go to the community and I collect data, I talk to that one person in the community, I come back, I know I show up differently at my workplace. And so sometimes just hearing, like getting perspectives of others itself in itself is a great, I have from personal point of view, it's a great coping mechanism for for the things that I feel like, oh, I can't grapple this colleague or whatever's going on in my workplace.

SPEAKER_04I think that's really important, Maya, isn't it, to have um situated understandings of particular individuals and their their situations, and we can't just assume what anxiety means, what burnout means in that particular context. And I think particularly as well, it's that that kind of um relational aspect, the the ability to share and to see and to and that kind of really helps, doesn't it? I think once we know it's not just me. And I think that's so mundane, but certainly in the work that I've done, that's very, very powerful as a way of helping the individuals to to cope because there's so much stigma, it seems, still attached to these kind of uncomfortable emotions when it's necessarily you know part of life, and you know, it might be getting much worse if we've been saying across society as well.

SPEAKER_04So we need to be having conversations about this so that we can connect to it in healthier ways.

SPEAKER_00Miri, you were talking about zip code uh being a you know variation of communities resources. And uh years ago, before the US passed welfare reform, uh requiring people to work uh and also get benefits when Clinton was in power. I did a study in Michigan with the Department of Social Services, and it had mothers and children, and we looked at four work sites uh predicting who would get off welfare. And so there was the public policy law that you had to work or go to school to be able to get your benefits, that we asked people psychological capital, do you feel you'll be able to have self-efficacy?

SPEAKER_00And we looked at uh zip code, and what predicted over time who was able to get off welfare was not whether you were assigned to a policy or how you personally felt necessarily as much as where you lived. And it was a lot easier to get off welfare in Kalamazoo, Michigan than Detroit, because there were less resources in the community, less people functioning, going to work. And so I think we've gone, particularly US society is very individual focused. If you don't succeed or you have anxiety or lack of well-being, well, are you not exercising or not?

SPEAKER_00You know, it's like, hey, I just want to make a paycheck to pay my rent. Do I have time to even, you know, go buy healthy food and and you know, go to the gym? It's uh different levels. So I love those comments. Um, I just also want to, I was thinking about social support. I've done a lot of work on and the that you're talking about customizing what different people need, different things. And I do think the power of social support has been shown time and time again, specifically when it's what the party wants.

SPEAKER_00Not everybody wants the same thing. So part of the perspective taking and situational uh viewing that Amanda also mentioned, I think is important that we just need to understand that the world people need different things and you know, figure out where they are at and meet them there if you can. So types of support I've studied is emotional support, the empathy, instrumental. Uh, one of the classic items for social support can you borrow a car from somebody or$10,$20, um, role modeling, people showing others being kind.

SPEAKER_00And the last one is harder to measure, but creative. Uh, we look at creative work-life management, thinking of win-win, how to help people, and it also helps the community be better. And those we're not in that creative space as much as we should be.

SPEAKER_02To pick up on that, you know, I obviously eventually in the conversation we're going to get uh talking about what this means for HRD, but it feels like there's a a step there because we're talking about uh community, we're talking about social support. Um, and maybe the step towards HRD is to explore the question of what does this mean for the organization? Um, so if we take a look at the prevalence of anxiety and burnout within the organizational setting, what are the implications for organizations and in particular for the leaders of those organizations?

SPEAKER_02And Ellen, at the big back at the beginning, you talked about the significance of having a trained manager and what that can do. And so, Ellen, I'm interested in your your thoughts really about what what all of this means at an organizational, an organizational leader level.

SPEAKER_00Well, I think leaders um need help in learning how to be good leaders. And uh just like not everybody knows how to be a parent, I think a lot of leaders uh don't always know how to be a good supervisor and need some help. And supporting uh well-being and mental health and work and family is not something that many leaders thought were part of their core leadership roles. I just uh published a paper in Academy Management Annals on Misconnections between the leadership and the work-life field.

SPEAKER_00And uh, work-life people always focus on just support for flexibility, but they don't look at how abusive supervision also makes people's lives horrible off work and uh leadership people don't look enough at the non-work. So I would like organizations when somebody becomes a manager that they uh learn about core skills. And one would be helping people have flexibility or whatever they need uh to be able to have their non-work life fit with their work life in ways that create positive synergies between both.

SPEAKER_00And so those four behaviors that I mentioned, uh leaders having emotional support, uh, but and what matters is what employees think. So we find there's a 50% perceptual gap that 100% of leaders will rate themselves as being supportive emotionally and uh other forms of support, and about half the employees don't experience it that way. So we need to go back to uh training leaders and how to, you know, give help other people feel that they are being supported. And so I would like training seems like a not a strong intervention, but your your crowd certainly is interested in training.

SPEAKER_00We start there, it builds awareness, uh, it helps people have common language, uh, it helps uh build a baseline of expectations. And then what you have to follow up with is having leaders at different parts of the organization mirror these behaviors because if people are just trained as first-line supervisors, go do this, but the top managers and middle managers are sending lots of pressures down, make profits at all costs, but you know, uh and lay off people whenever you need to, but and not help them.

SPEAKER_00That that's we we're in a very mixed message society. I mean, look at these Silicon Valley companies that offered, you know, lots of flexibility during the pandemic and vitro fertilization, parental leave for dads, and now a lot we're having major layoffs. So it needs to really be uh cascaded uh down the organization. It'll only happen when leaders are at the top that have these lived experiences from increasingly diverse backgrounds, whether it's women, people of color, of people uh immigrant.

SPEAKER_00We have a lot of people immigrating the US, they have families in other countries, and they can also mirror ways to uh be flexible and supportive of many backgrounds.

SPEAKER_04I think that's that's a really interesting perspective in terms of you know, it's this cascading down from the top and it's a cultural change, isn't it? In terms of the the ways that leaders and managers are working with with employees. You know, if we if we think about anxiety, as I kind of mentioned earlier, it's something that is commonly felt in organizations, yet it's something that is not very well discussed. It's you know, there's there's a there's kind of barriers there. We can't openly still discuss um about our anxiety.

SPEAKER_04And so I guess there's there's very much you know training of leaders and managers, you know, they themselves will experience anxiety and well-being issues, and it's kind of you know, working with that to enable a safe environment for other people to to come forward so that they've got the support that they need.

SPEAKER_01There was um uh like an earlier study um in Human Resource Development Quarterly that looked that um where interviews were conducted with CEO CEOs who had participated in um the reality show Undercover Boss. And um, and so my colleague and I we did we took that opportunity actually to really talk about um you know what do those vertical and direct linkages look like when CEOs are in direct contact with frontline workers or frontline employees, and what is that quality of communication and exchange or conversations?

SPEAKER_01What are the impacts on HRD practices? But also was interesting that we found that it affected, like positively impacted the morale of the CEOs and the senior executives, as much as it had an impact on frontline employees. I think, I think they could see like how do you how does that vision for whatever they want their company to be, how does it actually get operationalized in day-to-day um interactions in the front line of the company? And so that was very fascinating to see. And so, how do how do organizational leaders create those, um, you know, get out of those silos and create those opportunities for conversations to get like a first-hand view, so to speak, of that experience of being in the front lines?

SPEAKER_01Because again, it's about perspective taking and um instead of like um organizational leaders staying with other people, more of their kind, uh, what does it take to go past your your structural silos within organizational spaces and connecting and finding ways to impact that employee experience, especially for those that have limited support and attention within the organization?

SPEAKER_00And and there was a recent, I love I love those comments, Mira, about you know, connections uh between the leaders and employees and with the growing virtuality of work, people are not connected as much. And even for front-leg workers with face uh custom-facing jobs, we have different schedules, compressed work weeks. So there was recently a New York Times article uh labeled laid off in your living room. And so you're laid off, and you know, people may not have ever met their boss face to face, you know.

SPEAKER_00So I think that is part of, as Amanda mentioned, about the need uh for relational support and relationships are not as high quality or uh in quantity as they were in the past when we were all coming in and maybe having lunch together at the office or factory.

SPEAKER_02Mary, you were talking there about an article in HRD quarterly. You were talking about uh the potential role for training. What do you see as the role for HRD practitioners within organizations?

SPEAKER_01I think the research is very clear that um resilient employees, you know, they're able to navigate or they're less likely to experience burnout, and they're also, you know, probably not searching for jobs, less likely to search for jobs outside. But we know that job search is also related to other factors within the organization. So, how does your immediate team work? What's the supervisor relationship with employees and subordinates?

SPEAKER_01So there are other factors, and yet we know that resilient employees somehow are able to navigate typical challenges of working in organizations. And I think also when we have resilient employees, we know that they're able to meet their goals, they're also able to help their teammates and also the overall organization. So, knowing these uh, I think these evidences that we have from the research literature, I think helping employees generally being able to weather change or manage change, whether it's incremental or long-term or drastic disruptive change in organizations, as we know what just happened with Google and all that's happening within the technology industry.

SPEAKER_01I think we can, if we can help employees, like how do they find ways to bounce forward and thrive despite all of the challenges, all of the pressures that are going on? And then I think if you're able to do that from a HR standpoint or a HRD standpoint, then there's going to be sustainability for, you know, it's gonna be more about human sustainability, and that's gonna be very crucial moving forward. Specifically in terms of HRD practices, I think the challenge for us going forward will be how do we customize our policies so that they can, they are really responsive to that unique needs of an individual.

SPEAKER_01And with more generational change in the workplace, we are seeing that's going to be one of the key challenges for HRD practitioners. The other challenge is absenteism, right? So it's about how employees are showing up for work, whether they are physically showing up for work. Or they're working virtually because the nature of the job and nature of jobs across industries, it's more remote working, and organizations and employees have had a harder time reintegrating back into the workplace.

SPEAKER_01And collectively, we're seeing that it's negatively impacting employees, their mental health, but also it's impacting, negatively impacting organizations too. And so then there have been articles in Wall Street Journal and some research that's coming out saying that we actually need employees to be physically, at least for a few days, we don't know exactly how many, four days of work week. We really don't know about that, but we know that's going to be that that those are important conversations that we are having. So then the importance of well-being strategies within the context of a much more complicated hybrid work situation is something that HRD professionals we need to grapple with that as well.

SPEAKER_01I have to say this, that wellness products that are currently in the marketplace, I think they're all over the place. And it's really, really hard for employers and also for individuals, right? To figure out like what kinds of strategies do like at an individual level, what kind of strategies do I need to use? Or for an organizational standpoint, as from a manager or a supervisor standpoint, what are these different products that are available and how can I actually bring it to the workplace and help employees navigate these different services?

SPEAKER_01I think that's again another challenge because we have more choices. And however, employees want better communication, they need better ways of understanding what those well-be, what well-being experiences work for them, and how companies or managers can help them find the products or services that are most suitable for them. So navigating benefits, navigating coverage, what kinds of programs work better for them, and what would be able to get them the tools that they need in real time in the moment of their greatest need is another way of uh another challenge, I think, for HRD practitioners.

SPEAKER_04I think kind of building on that, Mary, you know, it's it's it's really HRD's role is perhaps of giving a voice to those that are marginalized in organizations, giving voice to things that are difficult to talk about, like anxiety, like burnout, and going beyond kind of things like employee engagement type surveys to get deeper understandings of the specific situated issues. And that's perhaps where we might come in as academics and perhaps have conversations and collecting also more qualitative and deeper levels of understanding, perhaps.

SPEAKER_04You know, I think going back to my 2014 paper that was looking at the anxieties actually of managers, then perhaps one of my um inspirations for that piece was to actually voice those anxieties because they seem to be something that we're people were suffering in silence with.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, and and you know, Amanda, as you were talking about your work, uh reminded me on the quality of work. I just um did a report for the National Academy of Science Commission paper with Tammy Allen and Tracy Dumas. I invited them on work-life boundaries and division of labor, unequal division of labor uh for gender. And gender is not a binary term, uh, but we were focusing on women in particular because childcare centers and things were closed during the pandemic, uh, domestic labor increased.

SPEAKER_00And what we found is this idea of quiet quitting. We we found that um, first off, a lot of the popular uh narratives are that, you know, and it is true, many thousands of women left the workforce uh because it was just too hard to try and figure out how to manage uh non-work demands and whole hold things together. So they uh where maybe they made less money something often and had to stay home. But we found we studied the women who stayed in despite the lack of organizational support.

SPEAKER_00They love their jobs. Work is very good for people. It brings, besides resources, makes you feel valued. And we found that uh occupy in uh organizations where they felt they were not supported at all bad climate, there was a higher uh rocket science, higher occupational turnover intentions. With so interest in this is STEM, which is more uh masculine, women are underrepresented, say the college campus and aerospace engineering, maybe women are, I don't know if it's like 7% or 8% of faculty, but it they're not a lot.

SPEAKER_00And so in these masculine environments, uh you feel like you don't fit you already, and then you have a stressful situation. And so when the women leave, they don't leave STEM, they just they still go somewhere else to work. So there is something about making the culture one for people who feel marginalized from the poorest employee that's working in the cafeteria to even people that are in these supposed elite positions, we're not gonna have the diversity we need where people will rise to the top or stay there very long if we don't make at different layers of the organization places where everybody can fit in.

SPEAKER_00And so we found besides occupational turnover, some women uh just mentally disconnected and they sort of like phoning it in. So it's either they phoned in their job or they phoned in for their children. Oh, I know they're online all day, but I gotta get this report out, you know, and so the quality again, we we have to help people uh be able to give their attention and energy to be the best they are at different uh times or you know, where whenever the time's needed. And part of that is workload.

SPEAKER_00And maybe it is because we're online a lot and social media, and there is, but I do think uh I've also uh looked at the idea of low value work. And uh, you know, you think of the university double reporting or uh, you know, you get to do more, more, more, more is always better, right? You know, now more grants, more outreach, more engagement. And so maybe uh some of the work I've studied on reduced load work is where for your this is privilege, but for high talent people you customize uh rather than have them leave.

SPEAKER_00If somebody's really great at research, maybe they do have a different load. Somebody's great at teaching, maybe you don't stigmatize them, but they enjoy teaching but have less research. We're not very flexible even in how we design jobs. And then at the lower levels, I think it should be allowing people to have, you know, transportation, uh, child care, flexible hours, money towards going to school, money towards daycare vouchers. We our social safety nets are sort of uh declining.

SPEAKER_00And uh it's it's unfortunate. The role of the employer is uh being able to lift people up is uh you know is not doing very well. And so we need, I worked in HR for many, a number of major companies. We're pretty siloed even with an HR. So the you know, the benefits and the training people and the leadership people all need to get together.

SPEAKER_04Anxiety oftentimes comes from um poor performance management systems as well, where we've got these kind of unrealistic um metrics that are in place. You know, like you say, we're expected to be fantastic at everything instead of recognizing that people have strengths in certain areas and allowing us to have strengths in certain areas. I think that is kind of that is really critical to have realistic performance metrics, realistic and responsible performance metrics, I guess.

SPEAKER_00And that requires managing performance as a team, right? It rather than one off uh, you know, then where you're not as strong, then I you know, I could cover something else. And what we implement flexibility right now, for example, it's pretty odd ad hoc deal making. You can work at home, but then somebody else is angry because you're not in the office, or senior people who are high talent can negotiate a four, you know, your studying your 410 work week in the UK. Well, but you know, is that gonna work for everyone? Is that gonna work for child care?

SPEAKER_00Uh, long to 10 hour shifts. So let's take a look at a group, let's look at the you know, managing the work across a work group and having to find roles and backup systems that requires coordination and that's weakening in in many of our work groups, particularly for virtual work. People are working asynchronously, just like our emails.

SPEAKER_02So, Amanda, something you said there makes me think about um what what this means for us in terms of uh how we prepare HRD professionals to work on this, because it's clear from this conversation that first of all, it's a it's a complex or complicated picture. Um it also feels from like the last 10-15 minutes of our conversation that there is amazing potential for HRD within organizations to do some good here.

SPEAKER_02Um but I'm wondering how we actually help prepare HRD practitioners to have that role. Um and and there's presumably a role here for education, as in how do we through our through graduate diplomas, through degrees, prepare HRD professionals to work on issues of anxiety and burnout. Do you have any thoughts as to the role of education?

SPEAKER_04Yeah, well, I I I guess, you know, given our focus on um anxiety, um, there's a real need from my perspective to foreground discussions actually of anxiety in HRD education, both as part perhaps of the learning process itself and as a topic for reflection for learning about how how organizations are emotional places. Um, you know, because if we look at HRD education, anxiety is rarely discussed in that in that in that context as we find it being rarely discussed in the organizational context.

SPEAKER_04And as um Russ Vince has commented in 2016, you know, it's it's actually somewhat depressing perhaps that emotional aspects of learning within and about management and organization are not already so obvious, that they're integral to what we do in business um schools at the moment. You know, so improving how we engage with anxiety as a process and as a topic in the HRD context might be a really important first step towards helping people better to connect to it in the organizational context, whether that be the HRD professional themselves, whether that be if we think about forms of management education and thinking about, you know, we've talked a lot about training leaders, training managers.

SPEAKER_04So what we do and what we emphasize in management education becomes important as well. So, you know, it's I think partly it is about recognizing and accepting anxiety as part of the process of learning itself, you know, as my work has highlighted, that anxiety itself is a major emotional output of attempts to learn and develop. So it is kind of, I guess, recognizing when we are learning in education that um learning itself necessarily involves uncomfortable emotion, and then thinking about the ways in which that uncomfortable emotion both um promotes and at the same time hinders learning.

SPEAKER_04Um so I guess then it's also thinking about can we can we have open and discussions in HRD education about the concept of anxiety, about the topic of anxiety, to think about and to reflect on its significance as a subject matter. Um, you know, how how significant actually is anxiety in everyday practice? Um, as we've discussed earlier, it's an integral part of the lived experience of organizational life, but it seems to be rarely discussed in the education and development context.

SPEAKER_04Um, and then I think you know, there's there's perhaps a need for HRD education to go further and to kind of use that unsettling of anxiety in the classroom as a starting point for asking some deeper questions about the um the extent of anxiety in organizational life and whether um it's realistic for expecting people to cope with those levels of anxiety. So, and thinking about the links to employee well-being. So, I'm thinking here then of kind of challenging taken-for-granted ways of doing, and this would then chime, I guess, with the aims of more critical forms of um HRD, which challenge the status quo.

SPEAKER_04Um, and then I also kind of think as part of this reflection and an important role for HRD education is that it helps um learners to recognize that the the problems and the struggles and the issues that we oftentimes associate with a shortcoming as us as an individual might actually well be a representation of the broader power relations of the social context within which we work. Um, and then finally, just I guess also to say that you know there are real challenges for um HRD educators as well.

SPEAKER_04If we start to foreground discussions of anxiety in the classroom as a way of bringing these out in the organizational context, um, you know, it's it's very challenging to do that. And once we start discussing uncomfortable emotion in the classroom, that in itself might actually generate further anxiety in the classroom. So we have to be alert to that and look at ways in which we can work with unpredictable outcomes, particularly perhaps in environments where there is pressure to show relevance, immediate relevance, to show value for money, um, for favorable teaching scores and the like.

SPEAKER_02So, as a final question for the episode, I'm thinking here about the role of research. And I'm conscious that a fair number of the people who listen to this podcast are either users of research or they're generating research. And so we've talked a fair amount about the complexity of anxiety and burnout, the potential for HRD, and probably some of the limitations about what we currently know. And so I'm interested in your thoughts of what guidance you would give to researchers out there about potential research agendas or research questions and what research is needed into HRD and its relationship to anxiety and to and to burnout.

SPEAKER_02And Ellen, I was wondering if you'd be willing to dive into that first for us.

SPEAKER_00Sure. Um, I think that um research and practice um is sometimes siloed itself. And uh there's a lot of work on the idea of evidence-based HR practices being actually implemented. Early work was done. I think it was Sarah Rhines might have written on that from out of the University of Iowa. And so I've run research to practice conferences on diversity and gender. And I think for this question, I would like to see uh teams of people that are interested in policy, but implementation of policy well, uh align, say, HR people with OB people or wellness people or interdisciplinary research things.

SPEAKER_00It'd be prime for an NSF grant. They like interdisciplinary research. I think right now we're kind of we have people measuring emotions very micro, and uh that there's nothing wrong with that. We need to measure it well. Uh, but I don't see sometimes a measurement of how people are feeling linked to what are interventions that organizations can do, whether it's for leaders uh or for employees, there's research on mindfulness training. I'm certainly supportive of that, but individuals are in a social context. So you can be very mindful.

SPEAKER_00But if everybody else is texting you at night or saying, you know, having crazy uh not non-functional interactions, you're going to be depressed. You're in a system. So I'd like to also see uh multi-level research. So this idea of uh, and you know, people look at this, this is disciplinary. So Mira said we needed disciplinary, interdisciplinary work. Sociologists look at the big picture, psychologists measure how people feel, HRD people measure, you know, what are the training and policies and development we can do. I don't always see these cross-cutting research.

SPEAKER_00So one is what is something you can do as an employer of choice, since that's their, you know, the mantra we say, to proactively make a work culture that helps people feel have well-being when they come to work. And then for those people at the margins at the low end, or you know, how can we help people at the bottom? And I've studied a little bit on flexibility policies. And I think in some ways, policies need to provide a floor of protection for people to prevent serious episodes happening.

SPEAKER_00We have to at least start with, you know, helping people walk before they run the marathon. And then once people have protection that they're not being abused at work, that they have the resources they need, that they're able to do their jobs, that they're not worried about their families while they're at work, we can then motivate them through good managers, through performance managers, through teamwork, through career opportunities. But right now, we can't even get to those higher level needs, as Basil would have talked about, if we if we aren't addressing the basic things people need to function every day.

SPEAKER_00And that's coming to work feeling good.

SPEAKER_04I think that's really important in terms of understanding through the participants' own terms. Um, and that would call for that kind of more in-depth um research to generate those deeper understandings to to be able to describe it in their own terms. Um, and I also kind of wonder when we're talking about burnout, you know, that's something that doesn't happen overnight, um, to have some more sort of longitudinal research to see how how how things unfold over time and at what point does the anxiety become too much to handle and and and and what leads to kind of that burnout.

SPEAKER_04Um and then also I guess you know, you're you're talking about the the researchers' role in in the projects that you've been working on. And it's also then looking, I guess, about how the work that we're doing, how is it received, what difference does it make, what impact does it make, and then research to actually follow those things up after we've we've kind of done the intervention.

SPEAKER_02Well, that feels like a tremendous call to action to researchers that will wrap up the episode very nicely indeed, because unfortunately we've run out of time for today's conversation. But I want to say a big thank you to Amanda, Ellen, and Mira for such an interesting discussion and for giving us all so much to think about and then hopefully to then act upon. So thank you all so much for being a part of the episode. Thank you.

SPEAKER_00Thank you. Thank you. Great to meet you all. Yeah, you too.

SPEAKER_02Thank you so much for joining me for this episode. It was wonderful spending time with Amanda Hay, Ellen Ernst Kosek, and Mira Ala Garaja. If you enjoyed this episode, check out all of our others. There were 33 episodes in the first three seasons, and we're releasing a further 11 here in the fourth. Between them, they provide access to conversations with over 100 leading scholars from around the world. New episodes release weekly. To learn more about the series, check out HRDmasterclass.com and to learn about the Academy of Human Resource Development, check out ahrd.org.

SPEAKER_02Also, don't forget to look into our sponsors, the Health Professions Education Special Interest Group at the Academy of Human Resource Development. To find out more information and also to join the SIG, visit ahrd.org forward slash page forward slash special interest groups. I'm looking forward to being with you in our next episode where we're exploring the relationship between HRD, inflation, and unemployment. With the help of Dr.

SPEAKER_02Mandolin Mull of Rockford University, Dr. Photios Mitsakis of Nottingham Trent University, and Dr. Parisa Maboubi of the C.D. Howe Institute. Until then, this is Darren Short signing off from the HRD Masterclass.com.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Gendered pathways to work-family balance

    Nov 17, 202634 minAudio

    This fourth episode of Season 6 brings together Dr. Sanghamitra Chaudhuri (Temple University) and Dr. Kyung Nam Kim (Texas A&M University) for a conversation about the 2026 article Gendered Pathways to Work-Family...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Navigating careers in non-traditional work

    Nov 10, 202636 minAudio

    This third episode of Season 6 brings together Dr. Yuanlu Niu (University of Arkansas) and Dr. Jos Akkermans (Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam) for a conversation about the 2026 article Navigating careers in non-traditional...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Silence in the workplace: What do we know from research?

    Nov 2, 202634 minAudio

    This second episode of Season 6 brings together Dr. Matthew Hurtienne (University of Texas at Tyler) and Dr. Heesun Kim (Francis Marion University) for a conversation about the 2024 article Silence in the workplace:...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Diversified mentoring: Living at the intersections of race and gender

    Oct 27, 202634 minAudio

    This first episode of Season 6 brings together Dr. Joshua Collins (University of Minnesota) and Dr. Ague Mae Manongsong (Louisiana State University) for a conversation about the 2023 article “Manongsong, A. M., & Ghosh,...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Season 6 Trailer

    Oct 12, 20262 minAudio

    Welcome to the trailer for Season 6 of Human Resource Development Masterclass - the podcast series from the Academy of Human Resource Development, the organization that leads HRD through research. The sixth season...

    Credit the people on this episode