In this third episode of Season 3, guests Dr. Nicholas Clarke (University of Kent, United Kingdom), Dr. Thomas Garavan (Cork University Business School, Ireland), and Dr. Kibum Kwon (Texas A&M University-Commerce, United States) discuss the relationship between HRD and Economics, including: What is meant by the term Economics? What is the connection between Economics and the concepts of work and the workplace? What is the relationship between Economics and HRD? How does Economics help HRD to understand and work on current and future challenges in organizations? When considering theories that underpin HRD, how much weight should be given to Economic theory? What would HRD look like in practice if alternative or additional Economic theories were adopted by HRD? and much more. For full details on the HRD Masterclass series, visit hrdmasterclass.com, for the bios of the guest scholars visit allbypodcast.com/economics. For more information on the Academy of Human Resource Development, visit ahrd.org - by being a member of AHRD, you can access bonus materials from podcast episodes. This episode is sponsored by: The Educational Human Resource Development Program at Texas A&M University - visit their website at https://eahr.tamu.edu/; and by SiTUATE, a new platform that is the digital version of structured on-the-job training - find out more by visiting https://www.situate-training.com/
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_01Sometimes we have been insular as a HRD community. We've worked amongst ourselves, but we haven't invited in people from neighbor economics, people from institutional economics, and other areas of economics that just might help us.
SPEAKER_04Welcome to the Human Resource Development Masterclass. The podcast areas from the Academy of Human Resource Development, the organization that leads HRD through research. I'm your host, Darren Short, and here in our third season, we're exploring the relationship between HRD and other topics and disciplines, with the help of leading authors, researchers, and scholars. Today our focus is the relationship between HRD and economics, and our guest scholars are Nicholas Clark, University of Kent in the United Kingdom, Thomas Garavan, Cork University Business School Ireland, and Keebum Kwon, Texas AM University Commerce in the United States, all of whom join me for conversations recorded during June and July of 2022.
SPEAKER_04Our episode today is structured into two halves. In the first 30 minutes, we look at what we mean by the term economics and take a high-level look at its relationship to HRD. And then in the second 30 minutes, we dig deeper into that relationship. You can find out all about the questions explored in the episode, the three guest scholars, and also the episode sponsors by visiting allbypodcasts.com forward slash economics.
SPEAKER_04Talking of sponsors, the podcast is only made possible thanks to the wonderful support of our sponsors who cover all of the costs associated with the series and so enable us to release them free of charge to listeners like you. I encourage you to show your thanks by checking them out and letting them know just how much their sponsorship means to you. Today's episode is sponsored by the Educational Human Resource Development Programme at Texas AM University and by Situate, a new platform that is the digital version of structured on-the-job training.
SPEAKER_04The first half of the episode is sponsored by the Educational Human Resource Development Program at Texas AM University. With a vision of transforming lives through the core mission of teaching, research and outreach, the Educational Human Resource Development Program is addressing some of Human Resource Development's most urgent challenges today, including talent and leadership development, career development and organization development, and through diversity, equity and inclusion at local, national and international contexts.
SPEAKER_04The program is also a leader in graduating scholar practitioners, conducting research that advances theory and informs both policy and practice, ultimately improving the quality of life for countless individuals. Across multiple disciplines, the Educational Human Resource Development Program is focused on preparing the leaders of tomorrow and setting the standards for excellence. You can learn more about their program by visiting eahr.tamu.edu.
SPEAKER_04Right, let's dive into the episode. Welcome to our episode on HRD and Economics. Let's start by meeting today's three guest scholars. And first, I'd like to welcome Nicholas Clark, Professor of Organizational Behavior and HRM and Deputy Dean at University of Kent Business School in the United Kingdom. Nicholas has spent the last 15 years building a major body of research, advancing our understanding of how the quality of work relationships influence the effectiveness and outcomes of leadership and leadership development in organizations.
SPEAKER_04And his recent work explores the role of respect as part of more socially responsible leadership. Welcome, Nicholas.
SPEAKER_00Hello, and I'm absolutely glad and a pleasure to be here.
SPEAKER_04And my second guest for the episode is Thomas Garavan, Professor of Leadership Practice in Cork University Business School, Ireland. Thomas was recently listed in the Stanford University Science-Wide Author Citation Indicators as one of the top 2% of academics in economics and business. He's a world-leading expert in leadership development, learning and development in HRD, and he's published extensively in the leading HRD, HRM, and management journals. Thomas is a member of the Hall of Fame of the Academy of Human Resource Development.
SPEAKER_04Welcome, Thomas.
SPEAKER_01Thank you. I don't know how I'm going to live up to that, but that's that's that's a great could be all downhill from here. Yeah.
SPEAKER_04And my third guest for the episode is Kibam Kwan, assistant professor in the Department of Higher Education and Learning Technologies at Texas AM University Commerce in the United States. Kebum holds a PhD in workforce education and development from Pennsylvania State University. And his research focuses on human capital investment, talent development, and employee engagement, as well as statistical methods for longitudinal data analysis. So welcome, Kebum.
SPEAKER_02Good to see you all. I'm excited to join this imbecile discussion today.
SPEAKER_04Excellent. Well, I'd like to start off the episode by exploring the term economics so that listeners are clear on that, ready for when we dig deeper into the relationship between economics and HRD. So, what do we mean by that term economics?
SPEAKER_03Economics is uh actually uh one of the major theoretical foundations of HRD by Dr. Swanson. Typically, uh there are very few HRD scholarships that have thoroughly explored the potential of the economic foundation and its applicability to HR research and practice. Among the very few, uh, most studies based on economic perspectives are using human capital theory as is uh theoretical perspectives.
SPEAKER_03Uh, human capital refers to like uh stack of knowledge and skills and experiences and other various types of characteristics that serve as the central drivers of economic growth and or sometimes largely overnational performance. So uh the discussion on HRD regarding human capital models is a like a linear relationship between learning and earning. This means that in today's economy, it is assumed that employees have more skills and more higher level credentials, more productive than employees with less skill and credentials.
SPEAKER_03And finally, they can earn more incomes as a reflection of contribution. So naturally, uh, this human capital theory for economic perspective on HRD is uh closely related to issues in productivity. So this productivity is related to uh return on investment regarding human capital investment.
SPEAKER_01I agree that a lot of what has happened in the way economics is informed HRD has been largely to human capital theory. Human capital theory is a very pervasive theory that underpins an awful lot of HRD. Also, I dare I say HRM, but particularly HRD. And essential to economics are two important questions or two notions. The first idea is that productive resources are very scarce, therefore, economic actors, whoever they might be, have choices about how the resources are used.
SPEAKER_01And secondly, economists concerned with how those choices are made, be they at the level of the consumer, the producer, government, or in the case of HRD, at the level of the organization. And it's very interesting that when you transpose those two very interesting purposes into a realm of study that I engage with a lot, which is strategic HRD, that's fundamentally what the two questions are as well. Number one, uh organizations have a scarce set of human capital resources, they have to decide how best they're going to develop them, who's going to be invested in, who's not going to be invested in.
SPEAKER_01And then the second key issue and a major concern that strategic HRD has been concerned with is who makes those investment decisions, how are they made? What are the choices? What are the criteria that are used?
SPEAKER_04So ultimately, what we want to do is to explore the relationship between economics and HRD, but it feels a big leap to get to that point. So I'm wondering whether a useful half-step is to first explore the relationship between economics and the concepts of work and the workplace, and also how that relationship may have changed over the years. So, so what are your thoughts about that relationship between economics, work, and the workplace?
SPEAKER_00I think it's important, first of all, to get to establish a couple of uh key uh definitions of the concepts we're using. Um, I think it's more useful actually to talk about the relationship between work and uh the notion of economy. The economies, from a sociological perspective, are essentially the institution that organizes the production, distribution, and consumption of goods and services. We also have to bring into play and recognize that actually economies are understood and work and built upon different philosophical foundations.
SPEAKER_00So, of course, two of those most obvious ones are capitalism and socialism. Work is understood in relation to the type of capitalist economy in which we which we which many of us uh live in. The goal of a capitalist economy is the pursuit of profit. The private ownership of production, competition in all will benefit uh society in the sense it leads to the lowest price for goods and services. Now, of course, the contrasting uh system, economic system, is socialism, where the ownership of production is actually collective and the goals of the economy are the collective good.
SPEAKER_00Those things are important because when we understand the nation of the notion of work um in relation to economics and economy, often a lot of the writing that we are particularly used to within the academic literature has been written primarily from a capitalist society perspective. And in that, there are a number of perspectives I just want to highlight regarding how work is looked at. The first perspective is what's called the functionalist perspective. And the functionalist perspective would argue that the production of goods and consumption of goods and services actually lead to uh societal well-being.
SPEAKER_00The ultimate aim of work or employment in that context is for uh economic growth and economic productivity. A second view is brought to bear in relation to conflict theories, and conflict theories derived from writers, early writers such as Marx and Engels, which essentially establish the idea that workers and work is exploited by those who own the means of uh production. This has given rise to uh labor process theory, which looks at quite a lot of um ideas around workers being alienated from work and the workplace, ideas of autonomy.
SPEAKER_00This has given rise to some of the critical management ideas that we we currently see today. There's another perspective on work, which is called interactionist perspective, and this really has looked at the meaning that people ascribe to work and the workplaces, how people understand the meaningfulness of work. Let me just say something very briefly about the history of uh how this has changed, because economies aren't static, and economies change a great deal, and with them work, and by that I mean also uh jobs, uh the quality of jobs, and the quantity of jobs, all of which have significant implications for understanding of what we do in relation to HRD.
SPEAKER_00We had in the 1970s the oil crisis, demands for efficiencies, and some major changes that began to occur. Technological change and the beginnings of globalization. What happened was we began to see in most uh many of advanced economies the hollowing out of certain types of jobs, particularly middle-skilled jobs, as organizations began to seek efficiency savings by offshoring much of those types of jobs to other countries in developing economies where labor was much cheaper.
SPEAKER_00Of course, now, in terms of the future of work, the big issues for advanced economies are uh technological change, particularly in relation to AI and uh artificial intelligence and robotics, which uh various estimates suggest a significant amount of jobs are likely to be affected. The other big change will be uh demographics in terms of an older working force and a decreasing availability of labor in these countries.
SPEAKER_00And of course, all these things will begin to shape uh the nature of the work in the sense of jobs, uh the type of jobs, the quantity of jobs, the quality of jobs, but also a fundamental difference that we've already begun to see since COVID is that increasingly workers will be will have greater decision making power in relation to where they work, who they work for, and what work they do.
SPEAKER_01That's a positive history, Nicholas, of the whole um the whole trajectory of economics. Wonderful. And it it made me think HRD research hasn't engaged as much was work and the whole notion of what work means and what it means for HRD policies as much as it should. And the other big thing that I'm really interested in is that you'll be you'll find it very difficult to get really good stuff in HRD that takes um a labour process perspective or treats uh the HRD discipline as more pluralistic in nature.
SPEAKER_01Those are gaps potentially within the field of HRD as we see it now.
SPEAKER_00One of the advantages of, if you like, capitalist economies is of course they lead to greater growth and innovation because profit is thing is a motivator. But uh there are also problems with a lot of economic perspectives, not least that it that it creates um considerable disadvantage and uneven you know, inequality within our society. And at the moment we're witnessing uh across the cost of living crisis across many countries, and those issues around um wage differentials and issues around um employability uh are becoming more and more arising up the agenda.
SPEAKER_00Sometimes I wonder whether we've really understood the limitations of human capital theory or the tensions that it poses.
SPEAKER_01Human capital theory is a very individualistic uh unit-type theory, and it doesn't greatly, maybe perhaps in the way we've treated it, take into account the employee perspective as much as certain. Even though it does assume that we we all own our own human capital in terms of how we provide it or decide to contribute it, that's not as simple in reality because of the complexities of the contract, the employment contract, and the way organizations operate.
SPEAKER_03I just want to say this is very uh macro-level perspective on human capital and some issues in our society uh from the perspective of economics. So I think we need to see from the perspective of policymaker and decision maker in any organization about the human capital issue. So uh sometimes we see uh our human resource development issues in individual level and micro-level approaches, but sometimes we see how uh decision makers and policy makers choose their strategy to develop human capital.
SPEAKER_03So decision makers uh they have some resources in their organization. Uh they try to maximize the effectiveness of their use of uh strategic assets in order to maximize uh their uh performance. So they try to find most uh competitive cost-benefit alternatives in order to maximize their uh given funds potential financial uh uh yield.
SPEAKER_03No matter how important HID and workforce development is, uh it should be most beneficial when it contributes to most heavily to uh organization profitability rather than other strategic investment options. Uh, if not, HID might not be selected as a uh company's initiative and a funds level of you know HRD investment may be more unstable.
SPEAKER_00The idea of um people, planet, profit, I think is suddenly, you know, has turned some of those economic ideas, certainly those that have informed HRD in early writings, I think it's really challenged the how the utility of those. And I understand, you know, that and and and Tom referenced this the importance of well, what does uh how does economics affect HRD at a firm level or an organizational level? And this has been a predominant um thread throughout a lot of that writing, which is well, how do we allocate resources with for HRD within organizations in order to get the biggest, greatest return on investment?
SPEAKER_00But those ideas are problematic because they are heavily influenced by what do you mean by return on investment? Often, you know, that could mean all sorts of things. Uh generally you're talking about in financial terms, but of course, because of that thinking, there are two things that happen. One is who should you allocate training to or HRD to? Presumably, within an economic model, and you're talking about the uh the production of goods and services, then anything or anyone within an organization who isn't actually doing anything or HRD will not contribute directly, perhaps, to the production of whatever goods or services that firm is producing, then that is not going to be worth by human capital theory, it shouldn't be worth investing in.
SPEAKER_00Those people should be, should not be invested. Doesn't make sense from an economic perspective if you adopt that that point of view. The other thing is um, you know, this this whole uh responsibility uh agenda has meant that some of those initial ideas of economics and its relationship to HRD being really about the allocation of resources within the firm level, incredibly limited. It is the more bigger issues as we move into the fourth and what's called the fourth industrial revolution with AI and robotics, with the changing nature of work, HRD must look to the bigger macro issues of economics and in terms of the way uh economies are changing in order to inform what type of HRD should be pervading.
SPEAKER_00Since the ages, all I've heard constantly from employers is um we don't have graduates with the right type of skills to have the jobs that we need. There is something not working within our development systems, if that is still being said. And to do that, you have to look for macroeconomic trends. Uh so I mean, for me, those things seem to be uh the most integral that we should be looking at within HRD, um, as well as, if you like, the these more micro issues.
SPEAKER_01I agree. And I think something you said there, Nicholas, that really resonates with me. And it's alive and well. If you look at exclusive notions of talent management and talent development, what do they suggest? Their classical human capital theory ideas. Oh, we'll only invest in the small number because they will give the biggest bang for the buck of the organization, and the others are a B and C and D talent, you know, they're they're they're mine or they're down the scale. And that exclusive notion or exclusionary notion or uh exclusive talent management and talent demand pervades a lot of the of the HRM literature.
SPEAKER_01Whereas some of the HRD literatures try to be a corrective to that and say, hold on a minute, we must think of the total talent pool because there are bigger objectives than just the economic uh imperative of the of the organization to achieve. And I think that's very interesting. You know, the big question is uh the relationship, the connection between economics and HRD. And I think it's fair to say it has been unidirectional, it has all been in one direction, it has been economics. Economics to HRD, really, there hasn't been as much HRD back to economics, even though you could argue that some of the stuff in institutional economics and in the HRD kind of brings in that macro idea that you have articulated brilliantly there.
SPEAKER_01But it's still often within strict economic terms. I think most of the research, if you look at the training literature alone, and I picked that one as I have a bit of expertise, it's mostly at the individual level or at the organizational, it's very internal, and I agree with you. We don't look at the wider macro context in which we want to investigate these issues and look at what all of these things mean for HOD at a societal level, at a national level, and an organizational. And the other thing is that we have sampled, if you look at what we selected from economics, we sampled a very small number of theories, really.
SPEAKER_01I mean, human capital theory and signaling theory and agency theory are the theories that you'll most often find within uh being used within the what you call it. Whereas we haven't just HOD as a discipline hasn't engaged as much with what I call social capital theory, but more specifically institutional theories and institutional economics and that type of stuff. So there's a very well we have sampled relatively small things and um human capital theory is alive and well.
SPEAKER_01And even the newer version of it, Nicholas, human capital resources theory that tries to bring the stuff from the individual level of analysis to the organization level is still alive and well in in many of the management journals, in particular and the HRG journals as well. So if we want to bring that bigger, bigger macro ambition, it means a major shift, I think, in terms of what we do as researchers within the field uh to look at those wider.
SPEAKER_04I'm interested in when you take a look at the concepts of research theory and practice in HRD, how do you see each of those three things, research theory and practice in HRD, being influenced by economics? And do you feel as if research one of those research theory or practice is is uh is influenced more by economics perhaps than the others?
SPEAKER_01I think first of all, as a as a as a group of academics who operate within HOD, we need to have multidisciplinary uh type research approaches, and we need to work and engage with scholars from different branches of economics to maybe come up with more holistic and systemic uh views of of uh our research questions or more robust research questions. However, working with other disciplines is not uh, I acknowledge, a very easy thing to do because there are paradigmatic differences and assumptions about knowledge, etc.
SPEAKER_01But I think that's a cross-step because I think sometimes we've been insular as a HRD community. We've worked amongst ourselves, but we haven't invited in people from labor economics, people from institutional economics and uh other areas of economics and developmental economics in particular, that that just might help us. So there's a bit of a mindset change required, I think, in terms of us as researchers to start looking beyond our area. And I also think, in analogous to that, is that we need to disseminate our research findings in different outlets and a more diverse set of outlets than what we potentially do at the moment.
SPEAKER_01Because I was reviewing some stuff on national HRD, and a lot of it is written in the HRD discipline. There isn't enough of it written in the economics discipline, enough in the labor economics discipline, the VET disciplines, all of those. So we need to broaden those things and think about how we can um uh get our messages out there so that others will build on what we've done and bring different perspectives to play in it. So those are my two points a little bit about more about the about the research piece and how we can get some of this engine going to allow us to have better integration and uh between HRD and economics and economics in HRD.
SPEAKER_03Uh also I want to add some uh research uh stream uh really related to human capital theory. Uh so as I mentioned, uh human capital theory is the most widely used economic theoretical foundation in the HRD research field. Uh, more specifically, but there are two types of human capital in in uh backers uh theory. Uh the first one is general human capital, which is applicable to any organization context.
SPEAKER_03And the other one is the from specific human capital, which is only meaningful within a specific organization context. Just think about it. General human capital is like an accounting or loss, law-related work kind of thing. So this this uh human capital is universal in any organization. But from specific human capital is really a source of funds uh competitive advantage. So it is really uh related to core competency over an organization.
SPEAKER_03So these two conceptualizations of human uh general human capture and from specific human capture have like a highly influenced uh theory and practice like the resource-based view, strategic human resource management, and talent management in uh management research field and human resource management research field. However, this two conceptualization is really meaningful, but it is not widely uh introduced in the HRD research field.
SPEAKER_03So, in my personal uh research for uh for uh HID journals, there's no study using this uh conceptualization as a major theoretical framework in the HIV journals. Uh, in fact, these uh two conceptualizations are closely related to HRD. Let's just think about formal learning is a critical opportunity for developing general human capture. And also our informal learning that occurs in the workplace can help employees to acquire like tested knowledge and skills in performing higher tested complexity uh jobs and ultimately develop uh form-specific human capture.
SPEAKER_03So I really recommend use this uh to conceptualization uh for to advance the risk uh HRD research uh regarding economic perspective and human capital theory and other uh return on investment uh research on uh human capital.
SPEAKER_00I think that those are interesting perspectives. Um I'll come back, I'll I'll start with Tom's because um from what you from what I heard you say, it doesn't sound to me like you are you're fully behind um uh Swanson or Holton's ideas earlier on that economics is a foundational theory of HRD. They suggest there are three foundational theories, and and that gives it quite significant primacy within the HRD field as delineating who what the field looks like.
SPEAKER_00And I just wondered what you seem to be suggesting was was not that, that um economics were and I uh some economic concepts were helpful, were useful, um, we should make more of them, greater collaboration, but you aren't necessarily arguing that um economics is a is a fundamental pillar of um of HRD, are you or not?
SPEAKER_01I would I think what I'm saying is it's one of several, but I wouldn't confine myself to three because I think there's a strong philosophical uh uh pillar as well. And there's a sociological pillar and there's a psychological pillar, and there's potentially other pillars as well, even there I see it now increasingly, the whole religious pillar is coming in and notions around spiritual leadership and responsibility and responsible management and all of that type of stuff. So I think we have the three-legged stool, and I think has to become something of a six-legged stool, perhaps, or nine legs, or what we call in the Irish country a farm, a big long chair with nine, eight or nine legs, nine legs on it.
SPEAKER_00I I just wonder whether, you know, these are the tensions we've always had to manage within this field, because um the the economic concepts that you talk about, particularly in relation to human capital uh and and and and then the how HRD, I mean, I just wonder whether how you know how compatible they they entirely always are, because um certainly within the field of HRD, there has been a much stronger emphasis on um, and of course, this goes back to the early days of different learning and performance debates.
SPEAKER_00I think they're emerging again in relation to ideas that's being connected now to broader ideas, back to the meaningfulness of work, uh, back to ideas of um what does responsibility mean in organizations, and back to this idea that profitability isn't the only uh goal that organizations, you know, the organizations today are having to juggle and to manage multiple goals on multiple fronts, of course they must remain profitable, but there are another th other things that they must do as well.
SPEAKER_00Um and when Keebon talks about the the the economics um um issues in relation to you know human capital theory uh and its importance of productivity, I agree with those, but it's a bit like to me when I read Swanson's uh 2001 three-legged stall paper, and um he includes ethics in it, and he says all these three, you know, the three legs uh sit-on um, you know, are filtered rather uh through the lens of ethics and has absolutely nothing to say about ethics within that conceptualization.
SPEAKER_00And of course, that's problematic because if I've got, you know, what I said about Friedman, Freeman argues the only ethical responsible uh uh accountability organization should have is to make a profit. So it has no meaning. And I think one of the problems with some of those earlier conceptualizations in economics, which have meant that they failed to gain traction within HRD more broadly, I think has been the failure to recognize that there are tensions with these other goals that I think HRD uh theorists, academics, uh practitioners see themselves fulfilling, which uh incorporates far more humanistic, human flourishing ideas, which is far more akin to you know the new agenda that we're seeing, far more akin to people's ideas of meaningfulness at work that we're seeing.
SPEAKER_00That I and I think they're important, and I think by looking at sort of more um emergent ideas um in economics that have um developed over more recent years, I think they may they may have more resonance now uh with the HRD community uh than than once that than than earlier perhaps uh conceptualizations actually did.
SPEAKER_04We'll be back in a moment with more from Kebum, Nicholas and Thomas as we dig deeper into the relationship between HRD and economics. First though, here's a reminder that this episode is brought to you thanks to the sponsorship support of Situate, a new platform that is the digital version of structured on-the-job training. Situate is the only learning management system that focuses on developing job-specific skills and includes a proprietary toolkit for conducting job and task analysis, among other analysis techniques.
SPEAKER_04Situate makes it possible to integrate the task analysis information with the training guides, performance checks which occur at the end of the training, the training plan and more. Also, Situate allows trainers to deliver the structured on-the-job training remotely or face-to-face, all the while keeping the emphasis on skills development. Situate is now being used by companies for employee training, by institutions to deliver apprenticeship programs, and by national and international workforce development systems to prepare individuals to enter the workforce.
SPEAKER_04More information about Situate can be obtained from Situate.com. Right, now let's return to our discussion for the second half of the episode. Welcome back to our episode on HRD and Economics, where I'm joined by Nicholas Clark of the University of Kent, Thomas Garavan of Cork University Business School, and Kibam Kwan of Texas AM University Commerce. So to kick start the final part of the episode, I'd like to continue our conversation about the relationship between HRD and economics by exploring what the challenges are that HRD are facing in organizations right now and how you see economics helping HRD in working on those challenges.
SPEAKER_03Many business leaders are talking about human capital and talent development issues in their organization. They're talking about uh oh, it is really difficult to hire talented employees, and it is really uh difficult to maintain work engagement for the talented employees and kind of topics we discussed. HID can play a critical role in addressing those issues, but I thought that they do not think HID is kind of a strategic partner to solve those issues because they're talking about our talent development and human capital issues can be delivered and addressed by uh executives and their uh team leaders and line managers.
SPEAKER_03So they are the major agent. So they believe that HID is kind of agent to provide uh a very uh marginal program or professional development annual and compliance training. That is the perspective of the role of HID. I think this is the really big uh challenges uh facing HID in organization, because in organizations there are more interested in talent, but HID is not the major character in the organization.
SPEAKER_03So I believe that this problem is that HID is not very closely related to the organizational strategy and business needs, and there have been many critiques about alignment between HID and strategy, and uh HID's role is not well known in the business side. So HID is not an active participant in the business planning process, and also at the same time, uh our learning and development has been changed.
SPEAKER_03So in the past, uh we have been interested in developing training programs. So we in the uh graduate program in HID, we have taught like instructional design and competency modeling and task and job analysis, and we are talking about how to manage corporate university, but now learning and development is uh is happening in the workplace, and people are interested in coaching, mentoring, leadership development, and work engagement in the workplace.
SPEAKER_03We need to think about these changes. Our strength has been outdated, and we need to we we have we uh need new uh strategy and tools to lead our talent development issues. I think uh economic and economic perspectives can drive changes in HID. So uh basically we can uh think about economics in our HID implementation, for example, like a labor cost issue and return on investment and talent, uh workforce uh demand and supply.
SPEAKER_03They are they have been very still, uh there have been important issues in the uh about the relationship between HID and economics. So we need to think about those uh traditional economic issues related to HID. And also uh I have been interested in new initiative in human resource development related to economics, is that people analytics. We have uh some people analytics and HR analytics and workforce analytics uh movement in uh HR and HRD uh field.
SPEAKER_03So uh we can now have many different types of new data sets. And also we have many different types of analytic approaches like text mining and uh big data analysis, so we can use these uh new approaches to make strong uh connections with strategy and organization planning.
SPEAKER_00I mean, I would I would certainly echo uh Keebrum's point there. I mean, for me, the big challenge coming for HRD is this question of how does HRD deliver value. And I think Keeblum's point, which is the extent to which we can use uh HR data analytics to help drive our understanding of how HRD delivers value, is a very important one. But this is not going to be without problems. To what extent people are equipped with the skill based uh competences to fulfill a data analytic role is highly questionable.
SPEAKER_00That's one problem we will face, and that will mean that in terms of teaching HRD, that will have to change so that that reflects the type of jobs HRD professionals will be expected to undertake. It's very important because we cannot assume these sorts of roles are something that analysts do, it's not what HRD people do. You know, that we're concerned with with other things rather than actually uh looking at the uh data.
SPEAKER_01I'm doing a piece of research at the moment for the Irish Institute of Training and Development, which is in effect the the professional body for HRD and learning and development specialists in Ireland. And actually, three things come out of it in respect of uh competence and capability of L and D and HRD specialists to um uh utilize data. And the first thing that comes out of it is the majority of them have a very low level of proficiency in terms of data analytics or any skills to do with that.
SPEAKER_01Number two, they are much more comfortable making decisions based on intuition and previous experience, and uh thirdly, have a fear of data and what the data might tell them, and that the idea that um actually uh it may undermine the contribution of HRG to the organization rather than enhance it. And uh in reality, too, many master's programs and Program and L and D and HRM do not actually equip them with those things.
SPEAKER_01So that's a big gap in the in the provision.
SPEAKER_04So earlier in the episode, um you referenced the theoretical underpinnings of HRD as being about economics, psychology, and systems theory. And I'm therefore wondering how much weight should be given to economic theory and and how HRD can ensure it's given giving sufficient weight, but not too much or too little.
SPEAKER_00HRD has always had and paid attention to um economic theory. I mean, even as something as simple as evaluation. Um evaluations occupied a large role within the field. Uh, lots of scholars have have obviously written about it. And this idea of looking at return on investment in terms of uh dollar value has been as played a large part in some of in some of that writing. But I think that increasingly the importance of economic and economic concepts actually becomes uh far more central.
SPEAKER_00I think the first thing is this question of improving productivity in organizations. Um, and I specifically mentioned productivity and not performance, and of course, productivity is integral, it's related, it's the biggest indicator of societal uh well being and driven by not just physical capital and labor, but also human capital. And the other thing in which we which we have actually had very diff great difficulty understanding.
SPEAKER_00Is a range of intangible assets, often to do with management processes or leadership processes, which help translate human capital into the value we want to see. I think a lot of the time when we think about these concepts and we talk about human capital, which is a concept that many HRD scholars and practitioners will be familiar with, there is a sort of sense that there is that the step is to provide uh increasing knowledge, skills, etc.
SPEAKER_00But we have to remember that that knowledge and skills has to, in order to translate into improvements in productivity, etc., something else has to happen. And part of that is the wider organizational or firm architecture, particularly around things, it could be HR processes such as performance management systems, it could be also considering uh organizational culture and ideas around social uh capital. So I think one of the things that where economic theories can can increasingly help HRD is helping us to understand that relationship between how perhaps um human capital through these other intangible processes um perhaps actually then impacts on productivity.
SPEAKER_00And I would certainly like to see far more in terms of future research, that far more research that actually looks at HRD's impact on productivity rather than the preoccupation with performance, because it's not the same thing. So I think the whole area of productivity and thinking about how economic uh concepts can help HRD understand how it um may uh drive productivity, I think is important. Related to that, of course, the other issue is this question, the whole question of the fourth industrial revolution.
SPEAKER_00These technologies raise very difficult questions about the broader impact of automation on jobs, on the skills, um, and the nature of work itself. This will give rise to a number of significant issues for us within organizations. It places an emphasis on reskilling and upskilling. And I think one of the major challenges that we will face is the extent, and this comes back to the strategic role of HRD, um, the extent to which when we that organizations are have the capacity or actually are undertaking some of the work that's needed to think about what is the skills gap.
SPEAKER_00You know, what is the gap between uh the skills that we we will be expecting or that we will need for uh jobs in the future compared to uh the skills uh that people have today. The the divide here is slightly to grow. There already is in relation to digitization. And of course, this place is enormous emphasis on organizations to provide that upskilling or reskilling or development in order to fulfill those the roles that they need in those organizations.
SPEAKER_00I think the other thing I would emphasize, and I think Kebum talked about this in earlier, is the importance of um labor economics. So this question of supply and demand of uh labor. And I think the the COVID crisis is the interesting example of this, is the the extent to which individuals uh uh an economic uh term often use utility. Uh they they they they calculate their utility, which is the balance between you know their their work hours and their leisure hours.
SPEAKER_00Uh and that makes, you know, will they forgo a bit of leisure now for the hope of better circumstances, uh, work processes in the future, which is often what what we tend to see? Um, or to what extent will they uh will that does that calculus change? And we've seen it, we've seen it just recently, the great resignation, uh the the whole idea of hybrid working, that this push that was arguably already going on prior to COVID, but has been rapidly accelerated as a result of people's experience uh through the uh through the through the pandemic.
SPEAKER_00But this notion about you know who will want the availability of workers, what will be what will be their decisions that they wish to make as regards particular jobs they might want to perform or not perform? HRD differs because HID has always taken a view that learning and development is not simply about driving a performance of an organization which is connected just simply to profitability. But it's always had far more expansive goals or principles underpinning underpinning it to do with the whole notion of uh democratic learning, the whole notion of uh learning for learning's sake because it helps the human condition to flourish.
SPEAKER_00And of course, these ideas uh were were um well, you can find them in HID literature in the very early days, but it's interesting to see how they've got more traction. So the the HRD should give weight to economic theory. Um, you know, we are there to, as I say, to deliver value within an organization. There are economic concepts, particularly in relation to understanding the nature of productivity, understanding the nature of human capital, and associated with that the importance of reskilling and upskilling within organizations, um, and the notion of labor markets.
SPEAKER_00Because if we don't know, if HID professionals or HID scholars haven't really any clue as to what are the type of jobs that we, our economies are going to need and um how we need to prepare for them, I cannot see how HRD is going to be able to deliver value within that context.
SPEAKER_01Super. I want to comment on something that Nicholas said, which I think resonates greatly with something I'm doing at the moment. And he mentioned um one of the issues around uh human capital theory, and there's a new theory that's beginning to get hold of, which is called human capital as a resources theory, Cloyhart and etc. and Garrett and all the guys. And what this theory looks at is really how does human capital, which resides within individuals at the individual level, how can it become accessible at the organizational level?
SPEAKER_01And they allude to three things that uh Nicholas has mentioned there early. First, they and they call them emergent conditions, leadership and trust processes in organizations are very important for this capital to emerge. The second thing is the whole idea of HRM, HRG processes uh and routines that exist in the organization, and the third one then are knowledge processes, be the sharing, seeking, integration, etc. etc.
SPEAKER_01All of those processes seem to be very useful, explaining how capital that resides at the individual level becomes available at the unit organizational level. And it was interesting that the title of the article, which um which wrote about this in journal management, was uh Human Capital is dead, Long Live Human Capital Resources, which was a very interesting commentary on how we focus too much on the individual level and forgot about looking at how these things translate up and become available to organizations.
SPEAKER_01And they bring into account all things like motivation states and all those other things, and individuals willing to contribute their human capital to the organization, make it available.
SPEAKER_03Actually, I have approached by using economic theory and uh economics and human capital theories, and uh, I believe this approach is really underexplored in HRD research field because my uh I use human capital theory and longitudinal effects of uh training investment for my doctoral dissertation. Actually, 95% of references not from HRD, they are all my references from uh HRM and strategic management journals.
SPEAKER_03So I can't find any relevant uh uh not many relevant research uh by using the economic and human capital theory in HRD research field. Uh recently I'm uh researching uh uh diversity and inclusion issues in our current organization. You know, this is a really popular topic at this moment. Interestingly, there is uh some part of Camp uh approach to diversity and inclusion issues from the perspective of economics.
SPEAKER_03They call it by uh they are called by functionalists, so they believe they uh research diversity and inclusion issues from the perspective of ROI, because we need to more pay attention to diversity and inclusion because this is uh beneficial, this is profitable. So uh you someone can uh one can agree or disagree or this perspective because diversity issues uh we are talking about human value, and this is our you know, our world is uh better because of the human value of a human being, but uh there is some those types of approaches.
SPEAKER_03So we should think about our talent development issues from the perspective of economics, for example, diversity, and also we can talk about ethics and sustainability, social responsible issues from the perspective of economics, how it is profitable, or how it is how we can uh protect our human value uh from the perspective economics. And also, we have another approach like a technology, also. We can think about the benefit of technology investment from the perspective of economics.
SPEAKER_03So we need more discussion about uh uh from the perspective of economics, our talent development issue in our current organization. But uh when I submit my articles to HRD journals, that it is really there are many uh not positive uh reactions to my papers. They do not want to talk about discuss from the perspective of economics. So I want to suggest we need more uh various perspectives on a uh talent development issue, and we need more discussion uh how to have better ideas or better approaches in on uh talent development issues in our organization.
SPEAKER_04So throughout the episode, um you've referenced at times how organizations, particularly um in in Western countries, how those organizations uh are built and operate under certain economic theories, and that presumably then that the HID functions within those organizations are adopting similar sorts of perspectives on economics and are presumably placing greater weight on certain aspects of economics than others.
SPEAKER_04And so I'm wondering as a final question for the episode, what what would happen if we took alternative or additional economic theories, if those were adopted by HRD? Could that alter HRD strategy and approach within organizations?
SPEAKER_01Well, I to tip up this question and to address it, I started to look and had a look to the literature to see what kind of what types of economic theories were used, and by and large it was human capital theory at the individual level. So for example, I didn't see many studies that utilize what we call agency theory, gain theory, uh, institutional economic theory, um, human capital resources theory, or maybe even uh social capital theory as an old way of looking at problems within um uh HRD and how it might mandate or prescribe certain ways in which HRD should be invested in.
SPEAKER_01For example, I would have thought that uh game theory, uh which looks at maybe looks at the cost and benefits perhaps of different HRD options and investments, and looks at why this should be considered and what are the factors to bring into play when they're trying to make these complex and veteran decisions around human advice development. Surprisingly, there is absolutely a dearth of literature in HRD that really has looked to use game theory. You'll find some stuff in strategic management journal, which looks at game uses game theory to uh analyze strategic uh priorities or strategic alternatives or strategic investment alternatives.
SPEAKER_01But there's very little that you very few studies in HRD that would invoke game theory to try and understand some of these complex decisions and to use experiments or field experiments or other types of things to investigate them. So game theory potentially could shed light on the complexity of these decisions and why you might invest in this group of talent versus another, why you might invest now versus some other time, or that you invest in a whole in a small segment of your workbook for the total workbooks.
SPEAKER_01The other theory that is fundamental to um which cuts to the core of HOD is the whole idea of agency theory and the whole idea uh the principal agent relationship with the employer-employee relationship, and the whole idea that HOD does it benefit the organization, does it benefit the individual? And if so, what are the issues around that? How is how are trade-offs made? What are the compromises that are to be made? And how does it impact um issues around uh uh the motivations of employees to take up a organizationally provided training?
SPEAKER_01Uh, is it only a value to the organization? Is it a value to them? As well as that, a linking to that is the whole idea of information asymmetry and a signaling theory and Spencer's idea that uh that you can use HOD practice signal certain things, or you can look at in decisions around HOD or organizational processes around HOD, and what are the signals to employees? And do they, for example, help to reduce information as symmetry or do they increase it?
SPEAKER_01Signal in theory, I think, is a very interesting theory that's only begun, really begun, even though Spence has it, it's been around for years and it's received a lot of airing in journal management, for example, in those areas. It hasn't caught foothold yet within HRD, HRM. I did some work and published a paper on it recently that looked at signaling theory to say to understand how learning and development or HRD processes can be used to signal the corporate brand to employees, get them to buy into that brand in hotels, by the way, where they have to live the brand every day and their customer interactions.
SPEAKER_01And it was a very useful theory. I also used it to look at green HRD practices and HRM practices and what they signal to employees in terms of engendering them to engage in voluntary green behavior and environmentally friendly behaviors and all that type of stuff. So um information symmetry, signaling theory, agency theory are very, very used, very uh potentially little used, but have great potential to be used. Then another theory that I was looking at was screening theory, which is very, which is somewhat similar in a way or aligned to human capital theory, and that uh uh HOD human resource development programs might signal or might act as a screening process, and they tell you, well, if this person is invested in HD, they're uh ready for promotion, for transfer, for other investments of that type of stuff.
SPEAKER_01We haven't engaged a lot with that particular um area. And finally, I think human capital resources theory. I've been looking at that recently, and we were looking at it in terms of how does, and this was in knowledge-intensive terms, where we were really looking at how does HR investments in training and development at the individual level emerge to the organization level to enhance innovation profits in the organizations, and we looked at two particular um emergent processes.
SPEAKER_01We first of all looked at uh knowledge sharing climate, which is an emergent process which allows people to share information and all of that, and to see how that comes up, and then we looked at human um resource processes or human resource management processes like recoupment selection, all of those things that allow uh the capital that resides in individuals to emerge to the organizational level and within that context be of value for competitive advantage.
SPEAKER_01The basic point I want to make is that um there are lots of different theories that have strong economic underpinnings that can be used to shed new light and then answer new questions and be able to investigate uh particular things that have to date been under studied within the field.
SPEAKER_00It is a yes, there are ideas that we can make use of, and they can help us get new angles and new insights into problems that we will be facing uh uh in organizations ourselves. Um, but somehow the translation and uh and the communication between those two HRD and economics um has to be facilitated uh as far as possible. Um and of course, to some extent, you know, economics and some of the theoretical ideas that you've just referred to, Tom, um, they have developed in ways that actually um take on board uh far more the plurality of understanding what's of what goes on in organizations, you know, that um what uh what are the drivers, what are the motivations and how they are affected by particular contexts uh rather than you know the general rule that um all people are or all firms are the motivation for doing anything is maximizing profit or or or things of that nature.
SPEAKER_01I came across a study last year, I think it's in the American Journal of Sociology, and it looked at the issues involved in doing interdisciplinary research, and two things came out of it that were very interesting. Number one, it's very difficult to get it published because a lot of journals find it difficult to find reviewers who can review these interdisciplinary studies, and journal editors sometimes feel uncomfortable with them. That was the first thing that came out of the study. The second thing that came out of the study is that there seemed to be a penalty for academics who were doing this interdisciplinary research, is that their identity and research identity was not particularly clear and they were disadvantaged when it came to promotion processes in organizations.
SPEAKER_01So you do highlight certain things. I mean, there's aspirational, but at the ground level, there are an awkward problems to try and translate this into a reality. And of course, I'm involved in UCC in an interdisciplinary study with medics and with economists, and it's like herding sheep because we're all coming in different directions and we're all trying to say, Well, what are the research questions that we really want to answer? And if we put up this particular question, well, is that too economics informed or too HOD informed, or is it too uh medically informed?
SPEAKER_01And this is to do with healthcare and health and well-being. Just to get, but I I totally with you on that, on that, Nicholas.
SPEAKER_04Well, unfortunately, my guess is we could continue the conversation for a lot longer because it's uh it's a really interesting one, and there's there's clearly uh a lot more to discuss on it. But unfortunately, we've run out of time for today's conversation. I wanted to say that I really enjoyed our time together. So thank you so much for being a part of the episode and for exploring HID and economics. Thank you, all three of you.
SPEAKER_02Thank you.
SPEAKER_01Yes, thank you. Well, thanks very much.
SPEAKER_04Thank you so much for joining me for this episode. It was wonderful spending time with Nicholas Clark, Thomas Garavan, and Key Bum Kwan. If you enjoyed this episode, check out all of our others. There were 22 in the first two seasons, and we're releasing a further 11 here in the third. Between them, they provide access to conversations with over 75 leading HRD scholars from around the world. New episodes released weekly.
SPEAKER_04To learn more about the series, check out HRDmasterclass.com. And to learn about the Academy of Human Resource Development, check out ahrd.org. By becoming a member, you can access extra bonus materials. Also, don't forget to look into our sponsors, the Educational Human Resource Development Program at Texas ANM University. Find out more about them by visiting eahr.tamu.edu.
SPEAKER_04And Situate, a new platform that is the digital version of Structured on-the-job training. Find out all about it by visiting situate.com. I'm looking forward to being with you in our next episode when we're exploring the relationship between HRD and adult education. With the help of Stephen Brookfield of Antioch University, Robin Grinier of the University of Connecticut, and Aliki Nicolaides of the University of Georgia.
SPEAKER_04Until then, this is Darren Short signing off from the Human Resource Development Masterclass.com.
This fourth episode of Season 6 brings together Dr. Sanghamitra Chaudhuri (Temple University) and Dr. Kyung Nam Kim (Texas A&M University) for a conversation about the 2026 article Gendered Pathways to Work-Family...
This third episode of Season 6 brings together Dr. Yuanlu Niu (University of Arkansas) and Dr. Jos Akkermans (Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam) for a conversation about the 2026 article Navigating careers in non-traditional...
This second episode of Season 6 brings together Dr. Matthew Hurtienne (University of Texas at Tyler) and Dr. Heesun Kim (Francis Marion University) for a conversation about the 2024 article Silence in the workplace:...
This first episode of Season 6 brings together Dr. Joshua Collins (University of Minnesota) and Dr. Ague Mae Manongsong (Louisiana State University) for a conversation about the 2023 article “Manongsong, A. M., & Ghosh,...
Welcome to the trailer for Season 6 of Human Resource Development Masterclass - the podcast series from the Academy of Human Resource Development, the organization that leads HRD through research. The sixth season...