Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Human Resource Development Masterclass

Human Resource Development Masterclass artwork

HRD & The Great Resignation

Aug 22, 20231 hr 7 minAudio

In this second episode of Season 4, guests Dr. Bhagyashree Barhate (University of Southern Mississippi), Dr. Rajashi Ghosh (Teachers College, Columbia University), and Dr. Yuanlu Niu (University of Arkansas) discuss the relationship between HRD and the Great Resignation, including: What is meant by the term Great Resignation? How is the Great Resignation impacting organizations, and how does that impact look different by industry or sector? What does all of this mean for individual employees in general, and also specifically those who have acted as part of the Great Resignation? What are the implications for HRD practice - the work it does, where it works, how it works, who is involved, etc? What are the implications for HRD education and how people are prepared for careers in HRD? What are the implications for HRD research and, specifically, what research is needed into HRD & the Great Resignation? and much more. For full details on the HRD Masterclass series, visit hrdmasterclass.com, and for the bios of the guest scholars visit www.allbypodcast.com/resignation. For more information on the Academy of Human Resource Development, visit ahrd.org - by being a member of AHRD, you can access bonus materials from podcast episodes. This episode is sponsored by The University of Southern Mississippi’s Human Capital Development programs - find out about them at https://www.usm.edu/graduate-programs/human-capital-development.php.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_03Employees are reflecting why they're spending the time that they're spending for work. What is it that they're really striving for? Reflecting back to the very core purpose of why we get up in the morning and go to work.

SPEAKER_01Welcome to the Human Resource Development Masterclass, the podcast areas from the Academy of Human Resource Development, the organization that leads HRD through research. I'm your host, Darren Short, and here in our fourth season, we're exploring the relationship between HRD and trends in society and organizations, with the help of leading authors, researchers and scholars. Today our focus is the relationship between HRD and the Great Resignation.

SPEAKER_01And my guest scholars are Dr. Bhagi Yashri Bhate of the University of Southern Mississippi, Dr. Raj Shigosh of Teachers College Columbia University, and Dr. Yuan Lu Nu of the University of Arkansas, all of whom join me for a conversation recorded in April of 2023. Our episode today is structured into two sections. In the first, we look at what we mean by the term the Great Resignation and how it impacts organizations and the workforce.

SPEAKER_01Then, in the second section, we explore the implications for HRD practice, research, and education. You can find out all about the questions explored in the episode, the three guest scholars, and also the episode sponsors by visiting allbypodcast.com forward slash resignation. Talking of sponsorship, Human Resource Development Masterclass is only made possible thanks to the wonderful support of our sponsors who cover all of the costs associated with the series and so enable us to release them free of charge to listeners like you.

SPEAKER_01I encourage you to show your thanks by checking them out and by letting them know just how much their sponsorship means to you. Today's episode is sponsored by the University of Southern Mississippi, whose human capital development graduate programs academically prepare students to improve performance in organizations through the talents of people. Students experience a think tank environment to solve today's workplace issues through connections with peers, the curriculum, and award-winning faculty.

SPEAKER_01The programs are offered through online and executive formats and are respected internationally as leading innovation in human capital development as evidenced by the quality of graduates and faculty research. For further information, check out usm.edu forward slash graduate programs forward slash human capitaldevelopment.php or email school of leadership at usm.edu.

SPEAKER_01Right, let's dive into the episode. So welcome to our episode on the great resignation and implications for HRD. So let's start by meeting today's three guest scholars. And first, I'd like to welcome Dr. Bhagiushri Bhate, a tenure track assistant professor of human capital development in the College of Business and Economic Development at the University of Southern Mississippi. Bhagiashri has a PhD in educational HRD from Texas AM University, College Station, and her research explores career development and leadership development, especially pertaining to women and Generation Z.

SPEAKER_01She's given numerous conference presentations in Asia, Europe, and the United States, as well as publishing her research in HRD journals that have garnered over 650 citations so far. So welcome, B.

SPEAKER_05Thank you so much, Darren, and I'm extremely honored to be a part of this fantastic panel today and speaking on the topic of grade resignation.

SPEAKER_01My second guest for the episode is Dr. Rajshi Ghosh, Associate Professor in the Adult Learning and Leadership Program in the Department of Organization and Leadership in Teachers College, Columbia University. Rajshi was formerly Associate Professor of Human Resource Development and Department Chair of Policy, Organization and Leadership at Drexel University. Rajshi's research explores how different developmental initiatives can facilitate workplace learning and development through building inclusive relational spaces and countering the prevalence of workplace incivility.

SPEAKER_01And her work has been published in several high-impact peer-reviewed journals. Rajshi's work is interdisciplinary, as evidenced by the different awards she's received from the American Educational Research Association, the Academy of Management, the National Science Foundation, and most recently, the 2022 AHRD Wayne Pace Book of the Year Award. Rajshi is the editor-in-chief of the journal Human Resource Development International. Welcome, Rajshi.

SPEAKER_02Thank you, Darren. Very excited to be here and to be part of this panel.

SPEAKER_01My third guest for the episode is Dr. Yuan Lu Niu, Assistant Professor of Human Resource and Workforce Development at the University of Arkansas in the United States. Yuan Lu holds a PhD in education with a concentration in workforce education and development and an MBA from Southern Illinois University, Carbondale. She conducts both qualitative and quantitative research on individuals' professional growth in the international workplace, including barriers to women's career development, employability as an outcome of career development, and career development interventions at both individual and organizational levels.

SPEAKER_01So welcome Yuan Lu.

SPEAKER_04Thank you, Darren. It's nice to be here and have a conversation about great resignation.

SPEAKER_01Well, over the next hour or so, we'll be talking about that topic and implications for organizations, for individuals, and then implications for HRD. But before diving into those details, I'd like to start off our conversation by exploring what is meant by that term, great resignation, and then how the three of you have worked on that topic through your research, writing, and practice. So, Rashi, I wondered if you'd be willing to get the ball rolling for us by sharing your thinking on that term and how you've worked on it.

SPEAKER_03So, thank you, Darren, for that thoughtful question. Um, when you think about great resignation, obviously that's been on the top of our minds given what the organizations have been experiencing, like a high level of attrition. In fact, according to the Harvard Business Review article published in 2022, uh, between January of 2021 and February of 2022, nearly 57 million Americans quit their jobs. Now, if you think about the phenomenon of great resignation, if you just focus on that, uh, you might miss really focusing on uh like a deeper cause or root cause, which I would argue, and I agree with this um HBR piece that I read, is more about uh finding what's purpose for work.

SPEAKER_03So they have reframed great resignation as great exploration. What the authors are arguing that given uh what um organizations have experienced, given the pandemic and um the existential kind of crisis that all of us have gone through, employees are at a cross-section where they're reflecting why they're spending the time that they're spending for work, what is it that they're really striving for? So it's kind of like how and why we work. So getting like, you know, reflecting back to the very core purpose of why we get up in the morning and go to work.

SPEAKER_03So if the organizations, instead of focusing on just the attrition and the resignation, which is kind of a symptom, were to focus on the root cause, which is really reflecting on the core purpose of why we are working, we might be better served. So I really like that kind of shift that the HBR or Harvard Business Review article was arguing in terms of refocusing on great exploration of the purpose than the great resignation.

SPEAKER_05I am going to build on Rajashri's response here because when I was reading about this topic and the work that I have been conducting, I have also reframed this topic as either culture correction or the great renegotiation. Because I have always believed that leaders should have always taken good care of their employees. And even though employees knew that they did not have a voice at work, they felt that lack of respect or they even felt that burnout, right?

SPEAKER_05But still they stuck around the organization because there was a fear of the unknown. Employees were thinking, if I quit my job, what happens next? Will I get a new job? Am I even employable? Or how will I attend to my family's needs if I quit from a job that I am not satisfied at? But then here came the pandemic. It removed the fear of the unknown among employees. So many individuals during that time were furloughed or even laid off.

SPEAKER_05So being in that situation caused by the forces of nature, employees started to believe that they can make it work if they quit. So they are more resilient and they can stand up for themselves and work in an environment that is right for them. My work is focused on the latest generation in the workforce, which is Generation Z. They are born between the years 1995 and 2012. I'm very interested to understand how Gen Z, our future leaders, are reacting to these workforce trends, such as the Great Resignation, as their behaviors, actions, and workplace practices are going to shape the future of the organizations and the workforce.

SPEAKER_04There are several factors caused the great resignation, such as the pandemic-related factors, economic factors, and also people re-evaluating their personal and professional growth. So the great resignation has impacted different industries and also different generations. And regarding my research, which is about professional growth in terms of individuals' employability and the career development in the context of great resignation, I am looking for how to improve employability for the individuals who are seeking for another job after they resigned from their work.

SPEAKER_04And I am also examining individuals' experience of career transition and the exploring how the organizations increase retention of employees through improving career development to support.

SPEAKER_01Clearly, this has been in the news in recent years, and I think maybe part of that is COVID. And I think Raji, you mentioned that. And then B, you mentioned Gen Z. And of course, Gen Z is increasingly in the workforce. So maybe those are a couple of factors that have kind of brought this to the forefront. But I'm sorry, Raji, I was wondering when you look at the factors that have kind of been driving this and have it in the news, are there others you see beyond COVID and Gen Z that you think are sort of like driving this?

SPEAKER_03You know, what's interesting is that, as Pagishri mentioned, that the leaders in organizations should have always treated their employees better. So while these recent factors or events, global events, such as the pandemic, might have pushed us to kind of look at these issues. I don't believe that this phenomenon that we are seeing that, you know, great resignation or that people really uh standing up for themselves and advocating for what is it that they want in terms of career development or just, you know, uh to be treated well, um, having psychological well-being in workplace, those issues have always been there.

SPEAKER_03It's just that the pandemic or other global events or stressors have really pushed employees to stand up and ask for some of the things that they thought that if they were to ask, they wouldn't be heard. Employees have become more resilient and more aware of their own rights. So it's like before, also, they um had experienced mistreatment, they experienced lack of inclusivity in organizations, they had experienced toxic culture.

SPEAKER_03But now, having experienced the pandemic, they know that their well-being comes first. And so that's kind of the attitude we are seeing across the um different industries and organizations among employees is that they're not willing to tolerate being mistreated anymore. And that's where that's what is driving the great resignation. Uh, one of the articles I read in MIT Sloan Review said toxic workplace culture is on the top of the list that is a driving factor for great resignation.

SPEAKER_03We might fall into um thinking that compensation or pay is one of the key reasons that drives attrition. But according to the analysis, and they did analysis across industries, among both white-collar and blue-collar employees, they found toxic workplace culture, which lacks inclusivity, lacks the focus on DEI, you know, that the cultures that tolerate unethical behavior is the top reason that drives employee attrition, specifically the great resignation phenomenon. So I, you know, while it might seem to be a recent event, what has happened in my understanding is that employees are now really advocating for themselves, unlike what they used to do before.

SPEAKER_01But does that imply then, do you think that this would have happened anyway, even without the pandemic? Or maybe what the pandemic did was maybe speed it, speed us up a little towards it, but like that most of the ingredients were potentially there for this to happen at some point, anyway.

SPEAKER_03Maybe, but what I would say is the pandemic, or even for that matter, the civil unrest in the country has really catalyzed that movement, that phenomenon, that employees have had it enough and they are standing up to say that no more. And if the organization cannot respect that, then they're going to look out for better options because at the end of the day, the quality of the life they are living matters more. Because what again, COVID has shown us is that life is finite, and we cannot keep kind of like um working for leaders and organizations that don't value us at the end of the day.

SPEAKER_03Um, our well-being um should come first. So I think yes, it would have happened, but I definitely think that these global stressors have catalyzed.

SPEAKER_05So I completely agree with what uh Raji just said that the events that we are currently living in has definitely catalyzed the great resignation. Because, for example, the workplaces and the work practices were already shifting much beyond and much before the pandemic happened, or even the different discrepancies and the different unrests or the war that has happened so far, right? In my opinion, we were working and operating in a technological environment because of which remote work, hybrid work, and even flex work were already slowly getting introduced into the workplace.

SPEAKER_05Recently in UK, there was a study where 61 organizations participated, and there were over 3,000 employees who were a part of that study, and they tested a four-day work week for six months. And during that time, 71% of employees reported a reduction in burnout, and 90% of participants reported that they want to permanently work in a four-day week format. So, what this is telling us is that when individuals are wanting this flexible work, remote work, because the technology is allowing them to do it, and all of these employees that participated in the study, they were working at an 80% capacity for just four days of the work week.

SPEAKER_05They're working at 80%, but still they reported to be much more productive than they were during the entire week. And when individuals hear about the great things that other companies are doing for their employees, they want the same things too. They want that caring for employees becomes customary. And when they recognize that their company is not invested in them, they just get up and leave. And the ability for employees to do that now has definitely risen after the pandemic.

SPEAKER_05And as more and more employees are becoming aware and quitting in hopes that some other company will value them for their contributions and respect them for who they are.

SPEAKER_04It's not reasonable. And before the great resignation, the people may not think about it, but uh right now, especially the young generation, they are thinking about why they do this, why we have to work eight hours. So they are looking for more flexible schedule and the flexible time to do some more meaningful work for themselves.

SPEAKER_03I couldn't agree more because I think what's another interesting um thing that has happened is a shift in the way we think about remote work. I think in one of your papers, Bhakeshi, you'd uh written about um how remote work is often gender stereotyped, um, or used to be mostly gender stereotyped in terms of or even flex work, that women um need that more because um they have uh household chores, and because there was a stigma associated, then women kind of shied away from actually using it. What um you know the pandemic has done is really challenged that way of thinking, and um employees across different demographics have benefited from remote working, from using flex working um opportunities, and the organizations have also figured out is that the work is getting done and in fact getting done better because the employee well-being has risen due to being able to use those different kinds of flexible work opportunities.

SPEAKER_03So while the organization was maybe shifting in the right direction, the experiences that have followed in the past few years, in terms of being thrust into this natural experiment of having no option but to do remote working, having no option but now that you know, um, after COVID, the organizations are coming back, leaders are still understanding that employees prefer flexible working opportunities. So having to be thrust into those natural experiments, I think it's even more, you know, that employees are aware of what their uh rights are and what their options are.

SPEAKER_03If their organization is not willing to be nimble and flexible and adapt um to the current um working needs, then they will look elsewhere.

SPEAKER_01So I wonder if that takes us into the direction then of start exploring what the impact is to organizations, because one of the things that each of you have spoken about has been how some of this is being caused by the organization, um, and how some organizations are starting to respond to this and what happens potentially if the organizations don't respond. So if we took a step back and considered like organizations and what advice we might give to them, what how do you see the great resignation impacting it?

SPEAKER_01And possibly, I suppose, how might that impact differ by industry or or by sector?

SPEAKER_04Organizations face labor shortage, which make it difficult to maintain their usual level of productivity and service. And the organizations also have to invest more resource in the recruiting and the onboarding new employees to fill the gaps, and also the organization. Face challenges of the retention of employees and also the knowledge and the skill gaps.

SPEAKER_04For example, they have to think about how to facilitate the experienced employees, transfer their knowledge to the new employees before they retired, or even after they retire, or uh after they quit from job, they still may think about how to help the current employees and the ex-employees to establish relationships to facilitate or promote the knowledge transfer regarding the retention of employees.

SPEAKER_04The organization has to think about offer more competitive salaries, benefits, and the flexible working conditions, which maybe increase the operations cost, but the organization has to do that and also include the provide better career development support and the opportunity for their employee to maintain them.

SPEAKER_01Raji, I reflecting on what Yuan Lu was just talking about there, one of the things that was going through my mind was going back to what you talked about in terms of the toxic workplace culture and how much of this is being caused by that. And so I wonder when you take a look at actions that organizations could be taking. It sounds like from Yuan Lu's response that there's a lot of things they could be doing. But I do wonder if they if they do all of that but don't address the toxic workplace culture, then potentially they won't see much benefit.

SPEAKER_01So what's your thinking about the significance of culture change in organizations' responses to this?

SPEAKER_03Yeah, I would agree. Um, because at the end of the day, how you feel treated by your leaders, whether you feel cared for, and here I would want to emphasize um the need for building a caring culture. There is a myth that caring and performance don't go hand in hand. And that needs to be busted. And the organizations, in fact, I follow Dr. Robert Keegan's work recently. I think there is a paper in HRDQ that's also drawn from that work on deliberately developmental organizations, they call it DDO culture, where employee growth and caring for employee well-being comes first and foremost.

SPEAKER_03And performance follows. Um, it's kind of like the proverb I remember my parents used to tell me is that strive for excellence, success will follow. So that's how I feel the organizations and the leaders need to really kind of rethink what is it that they need to focus on, and they need to really invest into career development of the employees. And I think in the last podcast I had engaged in with you, you talked about this partnership in regards to career development between organizations and individuals.

SPEAKER_03And more and more it's becoming obvious that organizations cannot just get an easy way out by thrusting the responsibility just on the employee's shoulder to say that because you know, career is boundaryless, it's completely up to you to develop your skills or develop your career. It has to be a partnership. And the more the employee sees that the organization is investing in their long-term growth, um, in not just their growth, but also, you know, some of the organizations have opened up their uh professional development modules to employee families, to employees, uh, you know, family members.

SPEAKER_03So those kinds of uh innovative um human resource development practices can go a long way in building trust and in building a sense of belonging that the employees would then naturally feel towards the organization. Also, the focus on inclusion needs to be very intentional in terms of all different factors that can play into it and the way that employees may experience any kind of practice as exclusive needs to be called out. And there needs to be a zero tolerance policy towards microaggression or other kinds of incivility and bullying that happens in organizations and it's often overlooked.

SPEAKER_03You can have the most like the fanciest HRD intervention in place, but if the CEO or if the leaders in the organization shout at their employees, then the whole point of that fancy HRD intervention falls flat because that clearly shows that the leaders on the top don't believe in being respectful. They don't believe in caring for employees. So I would put like a lot of emphasis on the culture aspects of the organization. And it cannot be the culture, it cannot be built by building a specific intervention.

SPEAKER_03It has to be modeled by specifically the leaders on the top, but leaders across all levels in the organization. And I'm I'm not saying that mistakes wouldn't be made. Of course, mistakes would be made because we everyone is learning. Uh, in terms of inclusion, there would be chances where some unintentional mistakes would be made. But then the aspiration, the motivation should be to own that mistake and work towards addressing why that mistake was made and what kind of learning needs to happen in the organization so that that mistake is not repeated.

SPEAKER_03Instead of not talking about that mistake or shaming the individual who made the mistake, I think we need to, as an organization, embrace a learner mindset about how we how we can better ourselves to uh build a culture that's inclusive, that's scaring, that's respectful.

SPEAKER_04Yeah. And I think also organizations should uh re-evaluate their cult their workplace culture and uh values to become more employee-centric and fostering environments that prioritize employee well-being and the satisfaction. That's how the organization could show their caring about the employees to increase the perceived organizational support of their employee.

SPEAKER_05Exactly. And I completely agree with both Yuan Lu and Raj Shri here at this point. I mean, there is so much that the organization needs to change as the workplaces change, right? And I want to here also point out uh some findings from uh research about newer generations who are completely like these Gen Z, for example, the newest term that they use is the cancel culture, right? So the one of the first things that they have canceled is the hustle culture that we refer to in organization, which is staying there from eight to five, staying at work from nine to six, completely debusting the ideal worker-like images, right?

SPEAKER_05If this person is here, has a good FaceTime with the leader, it's he or she is a good worker. Because this greatly affects definitely the DEI, that is the diversity, equity, and inclusion related culture in within the organization. Uh, some of the thought leaders who support and work on women and women's leadership developments, such as Cheryl Sandberg, um, she actually went about and called this great resignation as a great breakup, where she was referring to how women are breaking up with toxic work cultures.

SPEAKER_05They are breaking up with toxic leaders where if they do not find a support, they do not find investment in their leadership and their activities, they do not want to stay there anymore. They are definitely finding employment with in places with higher commitment to diversity, equity, and inclusion. So organizations are obviously being forced because of this great market correction that's happening, because now the labor has the power to dictate how they want to be treated in the organization.

SPEAKER_01So I wonder if that transitions us then into starting to think about what this means for individual employees. I'm saying clearly there is a significant agenda there of issues for organizations. The other side of that, I suppose, is what does it mean for employees who are in those organizations? And some of those employees, I guess, are folks who've already acted upon the great resignation and have made career choices and career changes.

SPEAKER_01So what do you think it all means then for individual employees?

SPEAKER_05That's a great question. And um, I would like to hear talk about how great resignation started out as a process where employees and individuals wanted to get away from toxic work cultures. But then it ended up being a trend on social media, right? Where increasing number of employees were posting videos of them resigning. They were resigning live and they had a live stream going on on social media. Or in some cases, there were group resignations where groups of people walked into their boss's offices and resigned.

SPEAKER_05And some individuals even posted their resignation letters on LinkedIn to further humiliate their bosses. These employees were most definitely frustrated with their jobs and bosses. Uh, they would have no job, they would rather have no job rather than the job that they were performing. This is such a unique testament to how much employees were being taken granted for, or in some cases, even abused. For example, like Haurash explained in the beginning, that in 2022, almost 4 million employees were quitting every month.

SPEAKER_05And as we enter 2023, the great resignation phenomena has not slowed down. Almost 61% of American workers have reported that they intend to quit, of which 66% are millennials and 72% are Gen Z. So the younger generation is actually leading this effort, is leading the great resignation. And like 37% of employees who quit in 2022 were actually between the ages of 18 and 29.

SPEAKER_05So it's very fascinating to start understanding this topic for especially these individuals who had just started their careers, were working for maybe three or four years, and then decided to resign from their jobs without really having worked through maybe five years, six years, seven years, and going through the different seasons that an organization goes through. So one of my recent studies actually conducted with my SDEM colleagues here at the School of Leadership, is focused on Gen Z.

SPEAKER_05And we investigated if career resilience has a mediating effect on Gen Z's emotional intelligence and career outcomes, especially in this volatile, uncertain, complex, and ambiguous environment, which we call as the VUCA workplace. And we've been living in it since spring 2020. Our research has shown that Gen Z's career outcomes are significantly affected by their emotional intelligence through career resilience. So, because they have a very high emotional intelligence, these younger employees are more likely to recognize when they feel dissatisfied at work and when they are feeling burnt out.

SPEAKER_05And that is the point when they just decide to leave rather than staying. So career resilience has a positive and significant effect on career outcomes, but that effect is not large enough to have a measurable impact on their intention to stay in their careers or to stay in the jobs that they are working at.

SPEAKER_01I think about the folks that I know, and there's there's folks who, in a way, almost feel like they are privileged to be in a position that they could make a decision like that. As in they work in the tech industry, for example. So so what are your thoughts about the individual piece and great resignation? As in, to what extent do you feel it is like somewhat influenced by your the the work you do, the sector that you're in, the education that you have?

SPEAKER_03You know, one of the interesting um things um that I read in that MIT sloan piece, though, it had actually analyzed, the authors had analyzed data across different industry sectors. And what they said is that the great resignation is actually being experienced among both white-collar and blue-collar employees. The two blue-collar industries that they highlighted were on the top of the list was uh were retail and fast food. That there were like, you know, there was huge attrition among.

SPEAKER_03In fact, retail um was even above tech industry or management consulting industry in terms of uh amount of attrition that they were experiencing. So it might be a good kind of uh research to really follow up on this about um, I think intuitively it definitely makes sense that those who are quitting must have a backup or some kind of a safety net to fall back on in terms of paying bills. Then how are they really taking that risk or taking that leap at the same time?

SPEAKER_03I think there's something at the confluence of whether it's the you know, um heightened awareness about one's own value of life, uh, because life is finite, as the pandemic has taught us, um, one's awareness about uh what it is that they deserve in life, and maybe among the Gen Z generation or the younger generation, that um a sense of like self-care is um again um more. Um but it I it would be an interesting study to really explore, specifically in those kind of industries in retail and fast food, um, for jobs that are not um, you know, that either in terms of compensation or other kinds of um you know resources is uh comparable to the white-collar jobs.

SPEAKER_03How or why, what is the process or the what is the decision-making process that's guiding those employees to quit because of toxic work culture? And toxic work culture did appear to be the key reason across these industries, um, so in in both those blue-collar industries as well, to be the driving factor. So it would be interesting to kind of research the decision-making process for um if there's any difference um between the blue-collar and the white-collar employees.

SPEAKER_04There is another article published in 2022 that discusses the impact of the Great Resignation on different industries in the US economy. The article indicates that the growth in job-to-job transitions in manufacturing and construction from January to November 2021 severely fall behind the growth increase.

SPEAKER_04On the other hand, the number of job-to-job transitions in ledger increased at an equal place to the number of quids. Then the article investigates whether differences in job-to-job transitions and quids between manufacturing and construction versus ledger have an impact on wage growth in these industries. The analysis shows that wages in the leisure industry have grown more than wages in the manufacturing and construction industries.

SPEAKER_04This funding is consistent with the idea that increase in the leisure industry is due to workers leaving their current jobs to take new jobs, which often result in higher wages. In other words, workers who are quitting their jobs in the leisure industry are likely doing so because they have found better paying jobs elsewhere, which is leading to stronger wage growth in this industry compared to manufacturing and construction.

SPEAKER_04However, it's important to note that this is just one aspect of the analysis presented in the article. Future research could investigate the reasons behind the differences in job-to-job transitions and quiz between different industries. For example, it could be interesting to explore why job mobility is high in both manufacturing and the construction and the leisure industries, and whether this has implications for workers' well-being and the career trajectories.

SPEAKER_01Over the last half an hour or so, there have been references to things like cultures and how cultures could be changed, to skills, to the need to for people to learn new skills and knowledge if they're transitioning between careers, all of which makes me feel as if there are significant implications here for HRD practice in terms of like the work that's done, where that work happens, like how the work is done, or who's involved in it. So, so Raji, I wondered if you'd be willing to share your thoughts first in terms of what you see as the implications for HRD practice.

SPEAKER_03Yes, absolutely. I think, you know, first and foremost, um organizations, um, human resource development professionals need to recognize that we cannot expect employees to tolerate toxic workplace cultures, to tolerate the expectation of upholding this ideal worker image where the work comes first about well-being. We cannot, we cannot expect that. So, you know, in terms of then uh how the leaders are role modeling, what behaviors are they role modeling, what are the mentors really passing on in terms of key wisdoms?

SPEAKER_03Um, that needs to be really retaught. In one of the recent pieces, I collaborated with my colleague Dr. Sandra Petra Chowdhury in MIT's loan management review, we questioned if mentors are perpetuating toxic ideal worker norms. It kind of like, you know, I if I have been pushed to skip lunch to um really finish a certain project, then I will also advise my mentee to do the same so that um they get ahead is not the right advice anymore. Or if I, as a woman of color, I have felt that I needed to edit my identity to fit in into the work culture of the organization, for me to uh pass on the same advice to my mentee is a disservice.

SPEAKER_03So we need to really take a pause and rethink what kind of leadership behaviors, what kind of uh mentoring behaviors are we encouraging in the organization? And that is then kind of chipping away at the workplace culture by deprioritizing well-being, deprioritizing caring for employees. In the MID Sloan piece that I read that I was talking about, that they did uh cross-industry study, one of the interesting things they found was that when the employees rated a certain organization as very innovative, the attrition and the attrition number in that organization in those kinds of organizations were also very high, which was kind of a dissonance, right?

SPEAKER_03So, why would um employees who rate the organizations to be very innovative would also uh leave those organizations? So, what they then, when they dig deeper, they found is that the innovation means that it would be a high stress work environment. It means that the employees are expected to stay late, to compromise on family time, on other kinds of activities in life, to spend larger or like you know, amount of time or higher uh number of hours at work to get work done innovatively, which was then um really what was driving the attrition.

SPEAKER_03So then again, we need to understand is that while you can get high rating on innovativeness or high performance, that's not sustainable. Because as Yang Liu was talking, then with the employee walking out the door, the knowledge. Around that creativity is also walking out the door. So it's not sustainable then to kind of have short cycles of employees contributing towards the innovation that you want to strive for as an organization, but then lose the long-term sustainability because they are not, they're they feel burnt out in the organization because of the expectations that the leaders have, that the mentors are advising them to follow.

SPEAKER_03So I think HRD professionals really need to take a hard look at what kind of values or what value system are they really uh perpetuating or advocating for through the different um behaviors. And again, it's not restricted to just formal interventions, but also the informal interactions, the behaviors that the leaders and the mentors in the organization are rolemarking.

SPEAKER_04I agree. The great resignation has highlighted the importance of employee engagement and the well-being. HRD professionals must develop strategies and the initiatives to support employee mental health, foster a positive work culture, and address work-life balance issues. Also, with increased competition for talent, HRD professionals need to ensure that their organizations offer competitive compensation package such as wages, benefits, and other incentives that align with employee priorities, such as a flexible work schedule and well-being support.

SPEAKER_04Moreover, HRD professionals must stay updated on emerging technology that can support their work, such as talent management softwares, digital learning platforms and remote collaboration tools, they must also ensure that employees are equipped with the skills and resources needed to use these technologies effectively.

SPEAKER_04In addition, create a positive and inclusive work environment that encourages collaboration, innovation, and growth. When employees feel connected to the organization and its values, they are more likely to stay engaged and committed to their roles. Encourage experienced employees to share their expertise and knowledge with newer organizational members through mentorship programs, internal workshops or cross-functional collaboration initial atives.

SPEAKER_04This can help minimize the loss of organizational knowledge when employees leave the organization.

SPEAKER_05Yeah, I completely agree. And actually, one important thing to remember here, as Yonloo pointed out a couple of minutes ago, was that like as employees are resigning in such large numbers, organizations are also hiring at the same pace. So, and post-pandemic, organizations are operating under the looming recession threat. But the recession has not yet occurred. And some economic experts also state that we might not even face a recession this year. But customer expectations from organizations are to perform great resignation or not, COVID or not.

SPEAKER_05Customers is paying the organization for a service and they expect it. And it is up to the organization to actually fill that gap. But what they are what they end up doing is like under these threats of recession and meeting customer expectations, they are panic hiring almost, uh, which leads to placing mismatched talent. And now that is leading the wrong people to do to getting hired to do the wrong jobs. And this is obviously leading to newer bouts of burnout and career dissatisfaction in some ways.

SPEAKER_05And in these situations, hiring not only becomes necessary, but it's expensive because organizations are required to furnish a signing bonus, a relocation bonus, and also new training so that the hired employees can perform the jobs that they are hired for. And organizations just to keep those costs down are now either reshuffling their teams internally or they are cross-training high-performing individuals. And this has led to further employee abuse.

SPEAKER_05And because their salaries are not changing in those cases, they're doing two roles for the salary of one. And some thought leaders, again, are calling this as quiet hiring. And now that some employees are expected to perform two or three roles to compensate for the lost talent, they again feel that burnout and are eventually quitting. So this is like a vicious cycle which needs to be addressed through strategic HID partnership.

SPEAKER_05And HID professionals really need that training in how to operate in this new workplace. Because even now, the definition of what work is is in a big flux because everybody is bringing very new experiences, very new expectations to the workplace. And HRD professionals need that training, need that strategic partnership. And to me, it also leads to thinking like whether leadership development is also a very important aspect of how HRD practice and how HRD can support the organizations.

SPEAKER_05Because I work in an organization where my leader is 100% supportive of my work and of my choices of working either in a remote hybrid or working in an office workplace. So I know that I thrive in such an environment where my leader is caring for me, where they ask after how I am doing that day, if they see me in the office. So I also think like leadership development is a critical aspect of where HRD can partner so that we can have a better culture and an organization where employees want to work at.

SPEAKER_03What Bhageshri just said brought me back to the central point of great exploration or that kind of finding out the key purpose or the core purpose of why is it that you're working. You know, if you're just hiring to fill some vacancies, you're not really then taking the time to find out the core purpose of the employees. So there is a fundamental mismatch. So you're just trying to put a band-aid in terms of like we need the employees because the customers want the organizations to function. So we we will just kind of like bring in another batch.

SPEAKER_03But and those employees by making them do more than one job, it's a further mismatch of then what their core purpose is and what it is that the organization needs. So, you know, I would say that HRD professionals really need to do train the leaders to have those conversations with their employees about going back to what it is that they find meaningful to do at work, why work is meaningful to them, and how it can be improved in terms of so that it's really connecting to their core purpose.

SPEAKER_03Um, job crafting is one intervention that I think really helps or gives the agency to the employees to design their work kind of bottom-up in terms, you know, instead of like a top-down job design. Um, so I think things like that, where leaders need to be trained to have such job crafting conversations with their employees, can go a long way. But I think fundamentally the leadership at the top or the central motivation of the organization shouldn't be just to kind of put a band-aid, because then they're just looking for short-term solutions and it will perpetuate that vicious cycle.

SPEAKER_03They need to really pause and do it right. Um, it may be, you know, that in the short term they can incur some losses in doing it right, but it will really give good returns in terms of long-term sustainability.

SPEAKER_01As you each answered that question there, I think you each you talked a bit about the implications for for HRD and HRD practitioners. And and I suppose of each of the answers, B, you specifically said we need to be preparing HRD practitioners, which makes me think a little about what this means for HRD education. I think when you take a look at um the content of a typical HRD, let's say master's class at this point or master's program, um, to what extent does that content prepare people for working on the sort of issues that we've spent the last 45 minutes or so discussing?

SPEAKER_01So B, what there's kind of apologies for picking on you, just kind of like because you were the one that mentioned preparing HRD practitioners. Well, when you think about HRD education, what do you see as the implications of all of this for how we prepare people for careers in HRD?

SPEAKER_05To me, that question is obviously forward-looking, but also focusing and reflecting on the past so far, right? Like and what we have experienced. So we've just experienced that events that are literally going to go down the history, right? And um, these are events that are going to be noted as critical tipping points for our humanity. Um, for example, the global pandemic, of course, the great resignation that we have been talking about so far, climate activism, anti-racism efforts, and wars that have caused a lot of tremendous resource shortages.

SPEAKER_05And employees that are coming to work every day are going through these events. They are going to grocery stores, not having enough to bring back home. They are earning money, but they're probably facing microaggression at work. They are probably not anymore in some countries, for example, not allowed to drive the vehicle that they are driving to work every day in. So our employees that are coming to work are facing a lot of these issues. They're going through these events that are definitely making history.

SPEAKER_05And um uh, for example, like a lot of individuals have even graduated online and they started a career online, they have never seen a physical workplace, they've never been there. And these are just momentous, momentous events in my eyes. And our future practitioners will need to be shaped to operate under these circumstances and to understand and take cognizance of their external environment and how that implies, or what are its implications to the organization's internal environment.

SPEAKER_05Because that a lot of employees are coming in from a lot of different contextual factors, a lot of different issues that are completely invisible to co-workers, to peers, to leaders, but they are going through because we don't know what they are, what has happened at their homes. So HRD education needs to emphasize developing HRD professionals that can contribute to building career resilience, for example, and to build a sustainable culture that can breve economic certainties, uncertainties, and has a little something for everyone in the workplace.

SPEAKER_05Uh, we need professionals that can provide strategic partnerships with organizational leadership. And we definitely also need to emphasize on a curriculum that focuses on organizational research. Uh, doing employee satisfaction surveys is not enough anymore. Uh, we need practitioners who can analyze the implications of what they have gathered from their employees and what that means to the greater organizational well-being.

SPEAKER_03We've had in HRD curriculum and research focus on different levels of HRD. I think in the current times and the curriculum, that's even more in need of emphasis in terms of how, from a system level perspective, as you know, Bhageshi was saying, is that how does it impact the organization, but then how these global events are experienced in the communities and in the societies in different ways? And how does that then connect back to how the organization is making an impact in that community and society?

SPEAKER_03So it's it's it's all interconnected. So really just to kind of have a micro focus is not enough anymore, but it has to be married with a macro focus, with um trying to understand the impact or the ripple effect at the multiple levels, uh, going back really to um the society at large. Um, also another point I'll make is um we need to put uh really high emphasis on our HRD practitioners to understand how they can support employees to build relationships.

SPEAKER_03And I say this because again, you know, going back to what Young Lu was kind of sharing about technology and the advent of technology, we all know with AI and chat GPD how that has created another kind of crisis situation or panic situation where employees are thinking that their jobs will be taken over by technology. And one of the articles I read today morning, in fact, in BBC, uh, was talking about that. And a professor from Columbia University, she um is a career coach and lecturer at Columbia, and she was talking about there are some core skills that the technology wouldn't be able to take over.

SPEAKER_03And one of those core skills is relationship building, is about emotional intelligence. So I don't think in our HRD curriculum we spend enough time talking about how to support employees to build relationships. Um, so those are the ways that you know HRD can really still be very relevant in organizations in helping employees understand how they can, instead of shying away from the new technology, lean into it, but use it in a way that still highlights what their core skills are.

SPEAKER_03And relationship building is a core human skill.

SPEAKER_01I'm conscious that we're coming up to the end of our time together, and there's one question that I've left to the end. Um, this feels like a sort of a rich area for somebody to step into in terms of the research agenda, or possibly if somebody's considering, like somebody's out there looking for topics for their dissertation, it feels as if there's plenty they could be exploring here. So, Yuan Lu, I was wondering when you take a look at uh to the topic, what do you see as the implications for HRD research?

SPEAKER_04I want to discuss the future research within three pillars of HRD, including career development, training and development and organizational development. Research in career development should focus on understanding how the great resignation influences employees' career trajectories, decisions, and the satisfaction. For example, investigating employees' experience for career transition during the great resignation, investigating the impact of remote and hybrid work models on career development.

SPEAKER_04Examine cross-generational and cross-cultural differences in career development during the resignation. Training and development research should explore the changing needs and the expectations of employees during the great resignation and how organizations can address these issues through effective learning programs.

SPEAKER_04For example, exploring the role of training and development in retaining talent and addressing skill gaps during the great resignation, examine the impact of digital technology and the data analytics on the design, delivery, and the evaluation of training programs, investigating the role of learning and the reskilling or upskilling initial atives in employee engagement satisfaction and retention.

SPEAKER_04Organizational development research should focus on how organizations can adapt and transform their practice, culture, and strategies in response to the great resignation. For example, exploring the impact of the great resignation on organizational culture, structure and strategy, investigating the role of leadership in navigating the challenges and the opportunities caused by the Great Resignation.

SPEAKER_04Investigating the relationship between diversity, equity, and the inclusion, initial atives and the organizational effectiveness during the Great Resignation, examine the effectiveness of different organizational development interventions in improving in employee, improving employee engagement, well-being, and the retention in the context of the Great Resignation.

SPEAKER_01Well, my my guess is that there is plenty to continue that conversation with.

SPEAKER_05Thank you, Darren. It was a great conversation. It was really nice to talk to everybody here.

SPEAKER_02Thank you very much for this opportunity.

SPEAKER_05Yeah, thank you.

SPEAKER_04I appreciate that. I think I learned a lot from all of you.

SPEAKER_01Thank you so much for joining me for this episode. It was wonderful spending time with Bhagi Yushri, Raji, and Yuan Lu. If you enjoyed this episode, check out all of our others. There were 33 episodes in the first three seasons, and we're releasing a further 11 here in the fourth. Between them, they provide access to conversations with over 100 leading scholars from around the world. New episodes release weekly. To learn more about the series, check out HRDmasterclass.com.

SPEAKER_01And to learn about the Academy of Human Resource Development, check out ahrd.org. Also, don't forget to look into our sponsor, the University of Southern Mississippi's Human Capital Development Graduate Programs. For further information, check out usm.edu forward slash graduate programs, forward slash human capitaldevelopment.php. Or email school of leadership at usm.edu.

SPEAKER_01I'm looking forward to being with you in our next episode when we're exploring the relationship between HRD and politics with the help of Dr. Greg Wong of the University of Texas at Tyler, Dr. Maxim Voronoff of York University Canada, and Dr. Dion Rotterminz of Troy University. Until then, it is Darren Short signing off from the HRD Masterclass.com.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Gendered pathways to work-family balance

    Nov 17, 202634 minAudio

    This fourth episode of Season 6 brings together Dr. Sanghamitra Chaudhuri (Temple University) and Dr. Kyung Nam Kim (Texas A&M University) for a conversation about the 2026 article Gendered Pathways to Work-Family...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Navigating careers in non-traditional work

    Nov 10, 202636 minAudio

    This third episode of Season 6 brings together Dr. Yuanlu Niu (University of Arkansas) and Dr. Jos Akkermans (Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam) for a conversation about the 2026 article Navigating careers in non-traditional...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Silence in the workplace: What do we know from research?

    Nov 2, 202634 minAudio

    This second episode of Season 6 brings together Dr. Matthew Hurtienne (University of Texas at Tyler) and Dr. Heesun Kim (Francis Marion University) for a conversation about the 2024 article Silence in the workplace:...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Diversified mentoring: Living at the intersections of race and gender

    Oct 27, 202634 minAudio

    This first episode of Season 6 brings together Dr. Joshua Collins (University of Minnesota) and Dr. Ague Mae Manongsong (Louisiana State University) for a conversation about the 2023 article “Manongsong, A. M., & Ghosh,...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Season 6 Trailer

    Oct 12, 20262 minAudio

    Welcome to the trailer for Season 6 of Human Resource Development Masterclass - the podcast series from the Academy of Human Resource Development, the organization that leads HRD through research. The sixth season...

    Credit the people on this episode