Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Human Resource Development Masterclass

Human Resource Development Masterclass artwork

Organization Development

Jul 6, 20211 hr 8 minAudio

In this third episode of HRD Masterclass, guests Dr. Gary N. McLean (Professor, Assumption University, Bangkok, and Professor Emeritus, University of Minnesota, USA) and Dr. Toby Egan (University of Maryland, USA) discuss Organization Development and its role within Human Resource Development, including: Defining Organization Development. Examples of OD interventions. Diagnostics and identifying the right OD intervention. Ethics within OD. The roles of internal and external OD consultants. Choosing an OD consultant to work in your organization. In the first part of the episode, Gary and Toby meet one-to-one with host, Darren Short. In the second part, Gary and Toby discuss their shared interest in Organization Development. For full details on the HRD Masterclass series, visit hrdmasterclass.com. For more information on the Academy of Human Resource Development, visit ahrd.org - by being a member of AHRD, you can access bonus materials not included in this episode. This episode is sponsored by: Interpretive Simulations. Find out about their services and their HRManagement simulation at https://www.interpretive.com/.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_00It's not enough as an organization to be technically expert. We really have to think through how we engage people, how we engage our own people, as well as when we face outward to customers and community members.

SPEAKER_02Welcome to the Human Resource Development Masterclass, the new podcast series from the Academy of Human Resource Development, the organization that leads HRD through research. I'm your host, Darren Short, and throughout this first series of 10 episodes, I'll be joined by leading authors, researchers, and scholars to explore the fundamentals of HRD and how those are changing in the 2020s. Our focus for this episode is organization development, and we'll be focusing on different OD interventions, the roles of internal and external OD consultants, choosing an OD consultant, and much more.

SPEAKER_02To help me, I'll be joined by two leading scholars. Dr. Gary M. McLean from Assumption University Bangkok and Professor Emeritus of HRD, University of Minnesota, and Dr. Toby Egan from the University of Maryland. In the first part of the episode, I'll chat one-to-one with each of them, and then for the second part, Gary and Toby are together to explore their shared interest in organization development. That discussion is brought to you with the help of the generous support of our sponsor, Interpretive Simulations.

SPEAKER_02Find out more about their services at interpretive.com. All of the content you'll hear in this episode was recorded during March and April of 2021. Right, let's dive in to meet my first guest. My first guest today is Gary N. McLean, who's a professor at the Assumption University Bangkok, Professor Emeritus HRD University of Minnesota, former senior professor at Texas ANM University, renowned scholar at International Islamic University Malaysia, adjunct professor in the HRD OD PhD program in NIDA Bangkok.

SPEAKER_02He's a past editor of several referee journals and served as president of the Academy of Human Resource Development and the IMDA. He was president of McLean Global Consulting, a family OD business. His research focus is international and national HRD, gender and OD. He authored an award-winning OD book and has published over 300 peer-reviewed articles. Hi Gary, welcome to the HRD Masterclass podcast.

SPEAKER_02It's great to have you here in our episode focused on organization development.

SPEAKER_01Thank you, Darren. It's good to be with you again, too.

SPEAKER_02How about we start by exploring OD at a high level and then we can dig into some examples of OD interventions? So why don't we start by exploring the term HRD and what that means to you and how OD fits into your understanding of HRD?

SPEAKER_01I take a rather broad perspective of both HRD and OD. I'll start with the definition that my son Laird and I created back in 2001. I had been very concerned over how ethnocentric definitions of HRD had been. With that in mind, we interviewed people from 13 different countries. We created a definition that I will share with you now.

SPEAKER_01Human resource development is any process or activity that either initially or over the long term has the potential to develop adults' work-based knowledge, expertise, productivity, and satisfaction, whether for personal gain or group team gain, or for the benefit of an organization, community, nation, or ultimately the whole of humanity.

SPEAKER_01I'm known within the field for my emphasis on the ambiguity of life. And so when you ask how OD fits into this, my response is that organization development can have almost an identical definition to human resource development. I do not make the clear distinctions among some of the subsets of HRD that many people do.

SPEAKER_01And so as we go on with some examples, you will see how I use this broader definition of HRD to cover my perspective of organization development.

SPEAKER_02That sounds a good segue then into taking a look at a few examples of OD interventions. So do you have uh some examples you'd be able to walk through for us of common interventions that are found in OD?

SPEAKER_01One of the fastest growing aspects of organization development is the field of coaching. Let me give you an example of a coaching experience I had. I had been working with a very large consulting company as a contractor, and my role was to help them improve their organization through total quality management and statistical process control.

SPEAKER_01We had worked on that for about three years and we made good progress. And the CEO of the organization approached me and asked whether I would be available to provide coaching to him. He explained later as we began to work that it was difficult for him to talk with individuals in his own organization because there was the possibility of him looking like an indecisive leader.

SPEAKER_01So for a period of about eight years, I met with the CEO on a twice-a-month basis. Basically, he would share with me his plans for what he would do during the next two weeks and invite my observations and feedback. Another example I could share with you relates to the role of organization development in improving processes, the very beginning of the HRD definition.

SPEAKER_01In this case, I saw a call for proposals from the Minnesota Department of Transportation, and I made an application, was hired, and began to work with them on process improvement, again using many of the TQM, total quality management, and SPC statistical process control tools. Their concern was that they were experiencing a high level of mortality as their construction workers were killed in accidents because the automobile drivers were not following state law, were not paying attention to the signs.

SPEAKER_01So we worked in teams to try to identify why this was happening and what could be done. And based on employee input, we began to make changes both in state law and in the signage. We also began to make changes in how the construction sites were put together. Over a period of two years, we saw that number go down to zero.

SPEAKER_02So we've had a couple of examples there. Just a quick follow-up question, and I'd love to dig into some more examples. What I'm wondering is if is anybody who coaches in the organization doing OD? Or is there an approach to coaching from an OD perspective that makes OD coaching different?

SPEAKER_01Well, one of the things I worry about with coaching is that a lot of people put out their shingle as a coach without having qualifications, without knowing how to do coaching in a way that is likely to be most successful and most established within the organization. So your first question is anyone who does coaching doing OD?

SPEAKER_01I would answer no if that's all that they're doing. Okay. Because a major component of organization development is systems theory. And I know that Toby's going to talk about that. But with systems theory, you have to look at the entire system. And you have to be trained to do that and experienced to do that. If all you're doing is coaching, you don't see the full system. And without seeing the full system, you're likely to make decisions or take actions that lead to outcomes that are not desirable for the organization.

SPEAKER_02We've heard a couple of great examples in terms of coaching and in terms of process improvement. What other common interventions might be associated with OD?

SPEAKER_01Well, a couple of examples out of my history that I think OD has been slow in coming to, and HRD as well, but we're starting to see again a lot of interest and emphasis on the use of organization development, both for the purpose of community development as well as for national development. I have been working for a period of 16 years now with a small village in Thailand called Lumpaia.

SPEAKER_01It is a community that requires tourism to keep the village going. And over the years it had begun to die. Poverty had become a significant problem. As kids grew up and went off to college, they never returned. And so by the year 2005, the village had been slowly decaying.

SPEAKER_01A colleague of mine, Siraporn Yamnal from Mahidan University, and I began to work with the village on a volunteer basis to try to help them through the use of action research to change the nature of their community. Now, action research goes back quite a long time and is a common organization development intervention that really looks to the consultant as a to be a facilitator and to look to the teams from within the organization to come up with possible interventions, try them out, measure their success, and come back on a regular basis to determine what they can do differently to continue improvement.

SPEAKER_01So between 2005 until just last year before the pandemic, we would visit the community periodically. And so over a period of those uh sixteen years, we have seen remarkable changes in the community. Tourism has been revitalized. The schools have been revitalized with the students taking an active interest in the community.

SPEAKER_01The number of floating markets has increased from less fewer than a hundred to well over three hundred today. And so that's been a great opportunity out of doing pro bono work to help a community revitalize itself. National development.

SPEAKER_01I was approached in the late 1990s by a faculty member of education from Seoul National University to see if I would be willing to take him on as a visiting scholar. And in that role, we met once a week and talked about what was needed to help develop Korea and keep it going in the direction it had begun to become a highly developed country.

SPEAKER_01So we did that for a year, little knowing on the side of either of us that a year later he would be appointed to be the first minister of human resource development and education. It's been again a wonderful opportunity to see how HRD and OD can operate in two very different contexts than what we normally think of as an organization.

SPEAKER_01Another growing area is the application of organization development to societal issues. The one in particular that I'd like to highlight is the issue of child labor. I did a lot of work in Bangladesh where child labor was at the time widely used. I was doing some work in a textile mill where most of the seamstresses were between the ages of 12 and 16.

SPEAKER_01At that time, the U.S. government passed a law that limited a country from being designated as a preferred country if child labor was prominent. As soon as that happened, the mills in Bangladesh had to shut down. As a result, all of those child laborers lost their jobs.

SPEAKER_01For many of them, they were the primary income earner for their family. Well, the U.S. Congress got the word very, very quickly. They rescinded that particular law, the mills opened, the children had jobs again. But that's not the end of the story. As I was working with the mills, I said, you don't know when this is going to happen again.

SPEAKER_01So why don't you do this? Why don't you create educational opportunities for the child labor workers to participate in two hours a day? So at the end of their workday, get off two hours early and begin to extend their education through the industry-provided education.

SPEAKER_01They bought that idea. And it has done marvelous things in changing Bangladesh.

SPEAKER_02Listening to the examples, a number of them, I'm not sure whether it's all of them, but certainly most of them are interventions that run over a long period of time. Is that typical of OD? Or is that just typical of the examples that you've chosen to share?

SPEAKER_01I would suggest to you that any good organization development intervention is going to have longitudinal impact. And I think there are a couple of reasons for that. One, good organization development requires trust. Trust between the client and the consultant. Trust doesn't occur overnight. You also need trust so that the OD consultant can be open and honest with the client.

SPEAKER_01I have seen too many organization development interventions where the consultant has not been honest because they're afraid of losing the contract. I also think that good OD is longitudinal because the longer the client and the consultant work together, the more the client knows about the consultant, and the more the consultant knows about the client. And the more you know about each other, the better you are in a position to work together.

SPEAKER_02I'd love to hear your experience around the use of training as an OD intervention.

SPEAKER_01I had the opportunity to teach in Saudi Arabia for a number of years. And that teaching was typically on the weekends. And so I had the opportunity during the week of doing consulting work. So about 15 years I did that. I got a phone call one day from a colleague of mine who was working in a refinery. And he said, Gary, we've had a horrible accident. One person has been killed, eight people seriously injured.

SPEAKER_01We've got to figure out what went wrong. Can you help? So I teamed up with a colleague who had expertise in the area of safety training. And the two of us went over. We spent about a week doing interviews with people in the refinery trying to figure out what was wrong. And at the end of the time, we came up with two recommendations.

SPEAKER_01One was that they needed more employees. The other recommendation we made was that the training that was being provided needed to be provided to everyone, not just employees, but also to contract laborers. All nine of the people involved in the accident had been contract laborers. When we made the recommendation to management, management said, Well, we've just been notified that we need to cut our staff, not increase it.

SPEAKER_01And we both went, What? What's going on here? Well, it turns out that they were part of a consortium of 150 refineries in the Middle East. And they submitted numbers at the end of each year. And the numbers that they had just received for the previous year showed that for a refinery producing as much oil as this one did, they should have 150 employees instead of 180.

SPEAKER_01Well, this is where you see benchmarking, which is so popular. Causing huge problems. First, the refineries were not the same. The one we were working in was the oldest one of the 150, and so it did not have the same technology. Second, the oil was what they called dirty, and therefore it required extra um procedures in order to prepare it for the market.

SPEAKER_01Well, we were able to get them to agree to do training for everyone, but we were not able to convince them that we could not cut back on staff.

SPEAKER_02Well, Gary, I really appreciate you taking us through a number of interventions and providing some great examples from around the world as well. So I've really enjoyed our conversation. Thank you so much indeed.

SPEAKER_01Well, thank you. I appreciate the opportunity.

SPEAKER_02Excellent. So if you uh please stay with us, because I'm going to chat with Toby next, and then uh the three of us will be back together later in the episode. So for the time being, thank you so much, Gary, and we'll chat with you soon. My second guest for the episode is Dr. Toby Eager, Associate Professor in the School of Public Policy and the Robert H.

SPEAKER_02Smith School of Business at the University of Maryland. He was a vice president of Corn Ferry International, a global consulting firm serving US-based Fortune 500, nonprofit, governmental, and multinational firms. Toby has also founded several university academic and executive education programs at three universities and has received numerous best research and academic awards. His research emphasizes organization development, learning organizations, coaching, innovation, and leadership.

SPEAKER_02At the start of the COVID-19 pandemic, Toby immediately teamed with physicians and medical technology consultants to launch a series of research studies which have been disseminated widely. Hi Toby, welcome to the HRD Masterclass podcast. It's great to have you in our episode focused on organization development.

SPEAKER_00Thank you, Darren. It's really a pleasure to be here.

SPEAKER_02I'd like to start by picking up an area that Gary touched on, which is the importance of viewing organizations as systems and of designing systemic interventions. And I'm wondering what this means in terms of the theories that form the foundations of OD.

SPEAKER_00So you really have to look back into biology to really understand where systems theory comes from. Systems theory has been informing organization development pretty much from the beginning, or at least at the intersection between these two concepts, and especially over the last 40 years or so. If we think about our experiences in being introduced in a maybe even an elementary school biology class, in learning about the dynamic intersections that happen between different parts of nature.

SPEAKER_00So for me, recently I was had the pleasure of being in the Masa Mara Nature Reserve in Kenya. So you can just see these interrelationships between trees and grasslands, buffalo rhinoceros and hippopotami and elephants, and in turn the intersections between these animals and lions and leopards. And it really is a good example of when we get closer to those principles in biology about what we're thinking about in organization development as well. Some of that's really observable, but a lot of it is implicit or invisible, just not able to be within the vision.

SPEAKER_00And so these things need to be thought of as well. So for instance, insects, vegetation, the micro-level creatures of that area all are having an important impact on the natural system. But uh we don't necessarily see those things, but they're important for us to be aware of, especially when we're talking then of taking that example from nature and translating it to organization development. So then we're thinking about layers in which the organization's operating. These biologists who thought and extended the idea of systems theory and those people who study organizations and borrowed it really think in a basic term about inputs, the way organizations bring in resources or things that they transform in the organization, and the outputs that lead to that.

SPEAKER_00So one of my favorite examples there was actually working with a company uh called Ralston Purina, and uh they're a dog food company. So they make pet food. Uh, and literally on one side of the uh warehouse, they would pull up a rail car and have that raw material, and they had a huge process that they used to transform that into pet food, which they literally offloaded at the other end uh in terms of it's being transformed and ready to ship.

SPEAKER_00So we can think about that as kind of the inputs and outputs in real time, but we're also talking about that from a human perspective as well. So our inputs can be technology, they're certainly people, and they're all the things that that uh the organization gathers around in terms of its mission to make transformation happen. It's also about the layers in the environment. So, again, if we use that natural um example, it's about different ways in which the theories here help us to think about the interactions between parts.

SPEAKER_00And that's where we can start to get in mixed with some complexity. So organization development kind of frames these interrelationships and uses it in terms of planning and changing practices. So it really asks organization members to consider their interactions. So, my favorite example of this is a man named uh Mr. Conroy. He was across, lived across the street from us and worked for a company called American Motors Corporation, um, which is now a defunct company. And this is the reason why.

SPEAKER_00My parents used to walk down to the end of the driveway, my dad, my all the dads, and uh the stories that they tell us over what was happening at work. And Mr. Conell used to complain he put doors on cars. Uh, but Mr. Conroy would complain that uh the people up the line weren't putting the hinges on right. So he was putting the doors on and the hinges were not put on correctly. And so he didn't have any way to talk to anyone else about that. And so sure enough, uh these cars would come back with significant defects.

SPEAKER_00So there was no way to think about the interrelationship between his role in putting this car parked on and uh others' roles in supporting that. And so that's a very basic way of thinking about how interrelationships are important in the workplace. And then we think about that at the top level of the organization as well as outside, and we begin to consider those interactions as part of what organization development practitioners can facilitate thinking about.

SPEAKER_02Given the complexity of organizations, it must be particularly challenging then for an OD consultant or an HRD consultant going into an organization to make sense of that complexity and to figure out what are actually the root causes of problems. So when you take a look at OD consulting, how does somebody actually enter an organization and then go about understanding that complexity to figure out what's really happening?

SPEAKER_00Well, I think that that uh was an interesting thing in terms of Gary's comments because what you heard is similar to my own experience, where we're bringing organization development perspectives to a variety of organizations. But an organization development practitioner is strong in facilitation, um, has to download a tremendous amount of information and learn a lot about the organizations they're engaging and embracing, but they should also facilitate their approach in a way that brings in those members of the organization who have expertise.

SPEAKER_00That diagnostic approach can really bring an organization development practitioner up to speed. Uh, so in a in the case where I've done a lot of interventions in terms of organization culture, so we do surveys and focus groups and interviews and try to learn more about the strengths and needed changes or gaps that uh the client might be seeing. Um, these diagnostic tools help the OD practitioner better understand the organization. But it's an interdependency, and you don't have to be an expert in necessarily every aspect of the business on the first day.

SPEAKER_00Uh again, Gary mentioned the long-term relationship helps you to do that as well. So OD practitioners bring their skills, uh, and the broader skills they bring aren't necessarily dependent on them understanding the specific aspects of every industry they engage, uh, but are more about understanding the processes and problem and problem solving and solution generating areas that can really help organizations address the changes that they think they need, as well as present them new information that might change their minds about exactly what changes need to occur.

SPEAKER_02You talked earlier about layers, and I suppose if you look at organizations, one way of viewing layers within organizations would be sort of like as individuals, there are teams, and then there's the organization as a whole. And when I look back at some of the examples that we've explored so far in the episode, we've talked a bit about the individual level and a bit about organizations, but not much about the teams.

SPEAKER_00Well, it's really an interesting time, uh, Darren, to be thinking about teams as so many organizations have suddenly been immersed in uh a new team experience, which is for most, I think, uh the experience of perhaps being fully online at a distance using teleconferencing for long, uh quite extended periods of time. So that's really brought in even some new questions about how we work with team development.

SPEAKER_00But mostly when we think about team development, we can think about it at the level of team membership and behaviors. So we can look at that in terms of awareness, feedback, and skills and development. That's often a training active process and also potentially a feedback uh-oriented process. And that often is done with uh 360 feedback in terms of team insights. But I'll give you an example of an engineering company I work with that made custom machines. So every client who they contracted with actually had a specific need.

SPEAKER_00And so every situation they were in was a new situation, a new product, a new design. So they actually gave each other feedback in person. So they would do 360 feedback live, uh, one person at a time. Uh what this did is it it created a lot of tension early as they explored how to do it, but they knew that they had a level of interdependence that relied on their providing that kind of feedback to each other. Um this this engineering group actually thought it was really important to do that.

SPEAKER_00I think it's a good example of the possibilities that systems approaches to teaming can can really bring in. Um, and then another type is just just the thinking through in terms of the the process relationships. So, not so much how the team operates in terms of their communication, but also how they're sharing product. So, this might be uh any kind of process where we have people who need to exchange information in providing customer service, um, responding to uh defects or problems that are going on in a manufacturing area, that kind of thing, so that they're actually learning to build teaming.

SPEAKER_00But you know, the most traditional way of thinking about team building is training. Um, so I think we're seeing more in terms of different training tools to help with that. And I think um depending on the real buy-in of the team and really the necessity depending on the kind of work they do, um, we're seeing more electronic ways to provide feedback.

SPEAKER_02As part of the example there, you referenced COVID and the um the complexity that that's added and the changes that's brought about to organizations. And as part of the podcast series, we're trying to focus a little on the challenges that HRD is facing in the workplace of the 2020s. And of course, COVID is part of that. When you look at organizations and what they are what they're facing right now, how do you see OD helping?

SPEAKER_00Well, I have two reactions to your question. One is I'm going through my experience of doing what was my only real experience of doing a fully at-a-distance COVID intervention. I work with a team of medical doctors and uh medical technologists to support first one hospital and then a whole hospital system in developing safety procedures in emergency rooms for doctors that helped both patients and the community. And what uh for me, in terms of that experience, what it taught us, I think as a team, was not only the importance of thinking through the technical side and the also the gaps, as we literally were working on intervening and supporting safety in the hospital.

SPEAKER_00New information would come out about what COVID was, and we'd have to continue to pivot and adjust to that. But we also ran into human attitudes, just um new uh challenges that are coming in and people's reactions to them. So for me, in organization development, we use this term socio-technical systems a lot. Uh, I think it's really important that we balance our understanding of technical needs with people needs. And I think COVID's taught us so much about that. What it's taught us is the importance of human attitude, of human investment, and really the importance of trust.

SPEAKER_00Uh, so if you look at some of the challenges in my international comparisons between South Korea, a country that's had really very few deaths relative to uh its size, and the US, you know, a lot of what you can do is explain that technically, the healthcare system, uh, what's been happening in terms of uh their history with healthcare management, uh, the fact that they had a similar virus uh attack their country before, but you can also see it in terms of attitudes, trust, and values.

SPEAKER_00Um, so the big difference between the US and South Korea is probably as much about people's attitudes and trusting of healthcare systems and organizations than it is anything else. So it really brings in this idea of it's not enough as an organization to be technically expert. We really have to think through how we engage people, how we engage our own people, as well as when we face outward to customers and community members. And I think that's really highlighted that. It's also shown us a lot of the weaknesses that we've had in terms of thinking through the most effective and vibrant uh organizational systems.

SPEAKER_00It gives us a tremendous opportunity. And I think there's a lot of positive things we can learn from this COVID experience as it evolves. And so one of the things that I hope we do, Darren, is that we do more to think about international learning. You know, within human resource development, we talk a lot about different kinds of learning systems. I wondered the whole time that COVID's been going on, if there would be an ability for us and a willingness to bring spotlights to the most successful countries and places that really had did a great job of mitigating COVID-19.

SPEAKER_00And if that there would be some possibility to spend the time to observe that in a way that could really influence citizens, people's uh individual decision making, as well as develop trust in healthcare processes. So, trust, I think, is something that we're really going to have to think more about uh over the next while. And I think COVID-19 has shown us so much about the importance of that.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, it's it's interesting when you look at COVID-19, I think it also highlights the challenges that we face in being able to learn quickly enough. And and also, as part of that, our our ability to deal with vast amounts of data.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I also think that it's it's certainly culture. I mean, I think that if you look at um our two home countries, the United States and and the United Kingdom, and we um think about them in terms of the reactions that people had, we're also seeing a cultural phenomenon. I think. I think that we're seeing highly individualistic cultures, people who really want to make their own decisions and feel good about them at the individual level, but maybe are not in a place to think about having decisions being more influenced by government or by uh people they don't know or policymakers.

SPEAKER_00And uh now I you know I've had the pleasure of being involved in organization development academic programs and human resource development programs in a school of engineering, in schools of education, uh, in schools of public policy, and in schools of business. And uh the time I'm now spending in the public policy domain has really showed me a different angle on organization development and human resource development. We've been talking about it as national HRD and international perspectives on HRD, but we don't often talk specifically about the idea of policy, just what are the specific aspects in which policy formation influence behavior and influence our decisions about we talked about systems before, so the policy environment is something that organizations sit in that they also can influence.

SPEAKER_00Um, individuals are really influenced by policy. So when we look at intercultural experiences, sometimes we forget to think about how policies might be shaping the very experience that people are having in terms of their identities with being, in my case, uh my Danish relatives being Danish American or whatever country you might look at to compare. And so I think COVID's also helped us see that a little bit more, just in terms of how do we explain these differences in reactions?

SPEAKER_00Uh, how do we explain the differences even in the way that we think about ourselves? And so for me, this idea of individualism and collectivism has been there. Um, there's a researcher uh named Gelfand who talks about cultural tightness and looseness, so how much we adhere to rules and how much we don't. These have big impacts on the way we think about organizations. And certainly, in terms of organization development, um a new lens on how we might analyze uh the way in which organization cultures operate.

SPEAKER_00So, Darren, I just wanted to highlight one more thing, um, which is just a trend that I think is important. Uh, Gervaise Bush and colleagues have been talking a lot about this idea of diagnostic and dialogue organization development. And so I really point to this idea of diagnostic, which I mentioned before, which is really using tools to assess an organization, its processes or its culture, surveys, observation, process analysis, um, with an emerging area of um dialogic, which is really the process of involving a mixture of people in discussions about their organization, key stakeholders.

SPEAKER_00So the organization development practitioner moves from being a facilitator to being more of a producer, an orchestrator, uh somebody who creates containers in which individual members of organizations can engage in dialogue about key issues. Uh, this came from the appreciative inquiry movement that was around for a while, looking at positive ways to have discussions about organizations and dreams and areas of discovery that organizations have that are part of their values and dialogue, not necessarily a fix-it approach to the organization, but more of an investment approach in terms of the way that people talk and describe.

SPEAKER_00So when we think about the future of organization development, these are the kinds of voices that are coming in and new ways of thinking about how organization development operates. And that really fits into my hope for diversity moving forward. So when we think about dialogue and dialogic approaches, so it's really about people talking and working to have deeper understanding with one another. Uh, and so I've had a good amount of time in my career to really uh engage organizations in thinking about diversity. As a matter of fact, I was with a colleague the other day.

SPEAKER_00We talked about uh kind of our estimates of how many people we've you know engaged in diversity training a few years ago when that was my full-time work. And we estimate that uh just individually we trained about 30,000 uh individuals on diversity. So for me, it's been an important aspect and uh really something that's coming up now in the unit in the US and worldwide in terms of diversity and anti-racism. So I see these things connected because having dialogue or taking a dialogic approach to OD could really lead us to a place of better understanding one another through careful, thoughtful discussion.

SPEAKER_02I feel it feels like that sets us up nicely for inviting Gary back in. And for the group discussion, I think. But before we do, I did want to say a big thank you, Toby, for our one-to-one chat. It's been great talking through these issues with you.

SPEAKER_00It's really my pleasure, Darren. Thanks for the time.

SPEAKER_02Up next, we have the group discussion, where my guests are together to discuss their shared passion for the episode's topic. This discussion is brought to you thanks to the sponsorship support of Interpretive Simulations. Since 2008, students and trainees have used Interpretive Simulations HR management simulation where participants are tasked to make challenging decisions at the HR director level in a simulated environment. Students must build a strong HR function at their stimulated, medium-sized organization and wrestle with the challenges of staying on budget.

SPEAKER_02The simulation makes the connection between concept and practice while students learn by doing. It comes with assignments, mini cases, and quizzes to reinforce core HR principles. If you'd like to receive faculty access to review the HR management simulation, visit them at www.interpretive.com and fill out a demo request. Welcome back to the HRD Masterclass podcast.

SPEAKER_02Our focus for this episode is organization development, and I've already met one-to-one with Gary McLean and with Toby Egan. And for the final section of the episode, we're all together for our group chat. So welcome back, Gary and Toby. It's good to be back. Thank you, Darren.

SPEAKER_00Thanks, Darren.

SPEAKER_02So I'd like to start by talking a little about external consultants versus internal consultants. I was thinking about the examples that both of you shared in your conversations with me. And those examples were predominantly about external OD consultants coming into an organization. So given that organizations have a choice between using an internal consultant, an internal employee in an OD role, or an external consultant, what do you see as the benefits and challenges of internals versus externals?

SPEAKER_01The issue for me around internals is whether or not the expertise resides within the organization. In many organizations with which I have worked, they do not have a designated organization development person, nor do they have someone who has experience or expertise in doing OD. However, my personal preference is whenever possible to marry up an internal with an external.

SPEAKER_01And that's because, as with most of life, there is some ambiguity here. We see sometimes the internal has knowledge about the organization that will take years for the external to discover. On the other hand, the external has the ability to really stand up to the leadership within the organization. And that sometimes can be very dangerous and very difficult for the internal.

SPEAKER_01So when you marry the two, you have the opportunity to uh take advantage of the strengths and overcome the weaknesses of each.

SPEAKER_01So, of course, the answer is always going to be it depends.

SPEAKER_02Okay, if an organization hasn't used an external OD consultant before, how should they go about selecting one?

SPEAKER_01Well, I'm involved in another consulting group called HR Connection, and their primary focus is facilitating small groups, and those small groups are across industry and they bring together people with common backgrounds. So in the HR arena. So what I find happening there is that when someone needs someone with any specialty within the HR arena, they will simply ask the group, who have you used who has been successful?

SPEAKER_01Is there someone out there I should avoid? And through that networking is the way they get their connection to an external OD consultant.

SPEAKER_02Now, are there particular um types of OD consultant or certain OD consultants that specialize in certain methodologies or processes? And if so, if an organization looks out into the marketplace, what are those sort of buckets of OD consultant that they'd see?

SPEAKER_00Certainly, given the last year or year or so, uh diversity and anti-racism consulting consultants, which are also tied to organization culture consultants, uh, certainly have been predominant uh in terms of the kinds of contacts I'm getting. I'd say um lean black belt, uh, that area is also one that uh often is pointed out to you in terms of the need for specialization. Depends how you define OD, but I'd include executive coaching there.

SPEAKER_00Seems to be something that's um very strong in terms of interest. Uh and then I would also look at um areas like reorganization, uh merging, uh, and managing employee uh either size or workforce issues. Those would be some of the categories. Gary, what what else would you say?

SPEAKER_01The one other one that I would add is virtual instruction. With the growth of the Zoom area, uh people are trying to figure out how to use it most effectively in terms of providing training. Um, the other piece that seems to be popular again because of the Zoom uh environment is how do we evaluate our employees? And that's not a new one.

SPEAKER_01Uh that's been around for a very long time.

SPEAKER_02With so many OD consultants out there, how would you advise an organization goes about selecting the right one to work with?

SPEAKER_01Well, I think the question implies that there is a right one. And I don't think that's the case. There are lots and lots of people who can be effective somewhat different ways, perhaps, but they can be effective in the organization. I don't know how you really go about doing this. It's sort of like asking the question that I raised earlier about evaluating employees. Who is a successful OD consultant?

SPEAKER_01And the only way I really see that playing out is through the networking. You ask other people who have used consultants and say, what was your experience like? Is this someone you would hire again?

SPEAKER_00And I would just add, uh, we sometimes have affections for the brand name uh consultancies. And I think getting closer to what they're going to do and recognizing that in some cases, maybe more than we would like, these are actually not entirely customized approaches. Uh I'm cautionary about that because of my experience with some of the large firms deploying consultants from the firm that have limited real work experience, lots of MBAs, um, recent MBAs who may not just have a lot of experience in the organization development realm and really rely on a templated approach.

SPEAKER_00Now, these templates can be great, but I think that it's really helpful to see what are you in for and what would you like to see in terms of outcome? And then I'd add ethics that I think that you know one of the dilemmas we have often in looking at any consultant is to what extent may they be assigning or prescribing work that is leaning more towards their benefit than the benefit of the organization. So that gets back to the issue of reputation. But I also think uh just talking in terms of uh the flexibility and even having a values-based discussion with a prospective organization development consultant could be a benefit.

SPEAKER_01I go back to one of the comments you made earlier, Darren, about uh knowledge about the industry. And I often have the experience when I'm being interviewed, of being asked the question, what is your experience in X industry? So a recent example is what experience have you had in the mining industry? Well, I don't have any experience in the mining industry, but I think when I get that question, I am a red flag goes up for me because I'm concerned that they don't really understand what the OD process is.

SPEAKER_01My expertise is in OD, not in a given industry. So I think it's fairly easy, especially if you've got an internal to work with, to move from industry to industry.

SPEAKER_02So, in other, in other words, then your specialism is in the process that you're bringing into the intervention. Correct. And it sounds like some organizations then, not knowing that, are actually trying to buy solutions rather than buy a process.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, and that's where I was a little cautionary around the templated approach that some larger organizations apply as well, because in part they're they're pointing in the direction that Gary's mentioning. They heard that so-and-so consulting firm did a good job for X firm, maybe didn't get close enough to ask what was happening on the consulting side. Um, so they're ending, they end up buying something that uh might from a surface level seem like the right thing, or might be at the executive level, the named organization that just sounds like the right firm that our executives will want us to use uh without looking more closely at what's really going to happen here.

SPEAKER_00And that that's where I do think, particularly with um firms, it's helpful to look at that portfolio in whatever way it can be described to get a closer feel for how much customization is going to happen there so that the kind of process that Gary's laying out can really be implemented.

SPEAKER_02How do you generally go about dealing with a customer who has a strong point of view of what they want and you feel like or you believe that's not what they actually need?

SPEAKER_00You know, out of out-of-the-box solutions is what we talk call this a lot of times, right? So they want to have something that they've seen before and they think it's the right thing and they want it fast. Well, I think that you have to appreciate the the value of that from the standpoint of the client, but also have a critical conversation that reflects an alignment between your estimation of what will lead to a successful outcome, in addition to what your client thinks is the right thing to do. And sometimes those diverge, and that is where you have to make a decision to not engage the client, but to do it directly, not indirectly, uh, so that you're both clear on the reasons for either the startup of a relationship or the reasons why it's not going to move forward.

SPEAKER_01Um, I was approached by a university and asked if I would help uh in a conflict management situation where deans were not getting along well and were not able to make much progress in terms of uh the vision and mission of the university. And as I talked with some folks internally who I happen to know, I found out that there was a budget system in place where the resources that went to an individual school within the university were based on the enrollment of students in courses in that particular college.

SPEAKER_01Well, that automatically set up a competitive environment. So when I talked with the um contacting person, I said, Are you open to changing the budget system? And I was told in no uncertain terms, no, this is the way we do things, but we got to get over this conflict. Well, it was a lose-lose environment, and so I simply said no.

SPEAKER_01Further, I asked how they plan to do this, and they said, Well, we have a fall workshop with all the deans, and we can give you an hour and a half. Well, again, it was obvious that was not going to lead to success, and so I simply declined the contract.

SPEAKER_00I think that's a great example of time constraint plus prescription, um, meaning that the client has a good idea about what they want to have done, um, without necessarily considering the reality of how the practice of engaging up front and the thoughtful process of a real intervention needs to be there before the outcome that's desired can actually occur. And uh so I think that's a a common thing where someone wants you to come in for X number of hours or days or has X amount of money to spend, all of things that are realistic constraints and can be worked out, but they really do need to be sorted on both sides.

SPEAKER_02Uh the ethics piece has cropped up a little during the conversation. I'm wondering, do you have conversations with clients about ethics up front, or is the ethical conversation something that happens when you hit a situation and you think, okay, I now need to have a conversation with the client about my ethics?

SPEAKER_00I'll just start off by saying it's important to separate anonymity and confidentiality. And what I mean by that is if you're going to do any kind of needs assessment or any kind of engagement in the in the work environment, it's important that the client understand and you agree on what are the ways in which information will be used, and that in some cases, when appropriate, there may be confidentiality, and in other cases, anonymity. Uh, and I know that in terms of consequences, there's actually uh HRD ethics uh advances from a few years ago that has some case studies that look at this exact issue and the dilemma uh when a client demands to know who said what or who um has a particular opinion or what the data are uh from a climate survey, for instance, regarding specific people.

SPEAKER_00So laying those things out front are really important to the success of the trust building process. And I think more than ever, trust building in organizations is an important component. So those things need to be laid out up front.

SPEAKER_01I have lots of examples of what Toby just talked about. Uh I had one um intervention where I was doing a fairly extensive needs assessment in an organization where we were doing both surveys and interviews. And in one of the interviews, an employee shared with me anonymously that he was aware of an employee who was embezzling from the organization.

SPEAKER_01So that was shared with senior management, and they were, of course, very anxious to know well, who is this? Where is it taking place? And I had to say, look, we had an agreement up front that when employees share something anonymously, it stays anonymous, and so you know it's happening, you go about and finding out where it is, you've got systems to do that, you do it. That's not my role to be a police um in the organization.

SPEAKER_02And one of the answers Toby gave earlier, um, Toby referenced consultants who are working in the OD area, focusing in on diversity and inclusion. And diversity and inclusion are topics that have cropped up in a number of the episodes for this first series of the podcast. And so I I'm wondering about the history of diversity and inclusion in OD.

SPEAKER_00I've been involved in diversity work in organizations since the very beginning of my career. So in the late 80s. And I what I would say is that what we see, as we see in some other social movements, is evolution. So diversity has been around for a long time in terms of organizational intervention. So what I see happening now is another wave that's included more anti-racism in many cases because of the social issues that have emerged. And it's really reflective of often how diversity gets focused in on in organizations.

SPEAKER_00Other thing I just point out here in terms of that is the work that I've done in diversity has always involved diverse backgrounds. So if whether that's partnering internally or externally, I think consultants need to come with a variety of backgrounds to do this work. So independent consultants can do that. I have done it, but I always partner internally, uh, often with a woman of color, with people who represent different groups in the organization, to make sure that not only in the assessment process, but in whatever's delivered, that there's a mixture there that's beneficial.

SPEAKER_00Last thing I'd say is I think that there's also in the Academy of HRD a focus on a critical perspective, which asks about the historical roots of diversity. So that's another question, just in terms of your values and your background and your vantage point. But I certainly think looking in terms of privilege is an important aspect, getting familiar and more deeply familiar, and embracing both the best parts of the US history and the global history around diversity, as well as some of the most tragic. And I think that uh we hopefully, as HRD professionals and as OD professionals intervening in diversity, do the work to think through our own identities and what we bring and the limitations to that, as well as the broader historical perspectives of what might bring a particular organization or client to where they are at present in diversity.

SPEAKER_01Let me just add, because I am so much older than Toby, that my history in working on diversity and inclusion goes back to the early 70s. And at that time, my primary focus in diversity was probably on gender issues. And gender has been a focus of my work, both in practice as well as in research from that time. We're making some progress, but it's still not enough.

SPEAKER_01And so we need to keep our foot on the pedal around dealing with gender issues and creating equity in the workplace. Other areas, though, that I've worked in in diversity that don't seem to get much visibility or leverage. Um sexual orientation. We're starting to see that emerge in some of our literature, uh, but I still don't hear a lot about it in practice. Uh, another area is uh dealing with issues of uh lots of politically correct terms here, but the those who are physically challenged or mentally uh challenged, and how do we make a place for them in the workplace?

SPEAKER_01Uh I I agree with what Toby has said that that we seem to be so focused now on race, very important, but in that process, we can't forget that there's an intersectionality here around several of these components of diversity that are important for the workplace.

SPEAKER_02Well, Gary and Toby, we've reached the end of our time for today. So a big thank you to both of you for our conversations and for being part of our discussion on organization development.

SPEAKER_01Thank you, Darren. Thanks, Darren. Appreciate the opportunity.

SPEAKER_02Thank you so much for joining me for this episode. It was wonderful spending time with Gary and with Toby. If you enjoyed this episode, check out our others to explore topics such as training and development, learning organizations, career development, and much more. New episodes release weekly for this first series of 10 episodes. To learn more about the series, check out HRDmasterclass.com and to learn about the Academy of Human Resource Development, check out ahrd.org.

SPEAKER_02By becoming a member, you can access extra bonus materials not included in the podcast. Also, don't forget to look into our group discussion sponsor, interpretive simulations, by visiting their website at interpretive.com. I'm looking forward to being with you in our next episode. Until then, this is Darren Short signing off from the HRD Masterclass.com.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Gendered pathways to work-family balance

    Nov 17, 202634 minAudio

    This fourth episode of Season 6 brings together Dr. Sanghamitra Chaudhuri (Temple University) and Dr. Kyung Nam Kim (Texas A&M University) for a conversation about the 2026 article Gendered Pathways to Work-Family...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Navigating careers in non-traditional work

    Nov 10, 202636 minAudio

    This third episode of Season 6 brings together Dr. Yuanlu Niu (University of Arkansas) and Dr. Jos Akkermans (Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam) for a conversation about the 2026 article Navigating careers in non-traditional...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Silence in the workplace: What do we know from research?

    Nov 2, 202634 minAudio

    This second episode of Season 6 brings together Dr. Matthew Hurtienne (University of Texas at Tyler) and Dr. Heesun Kim (Francis Marion University) for a conversation about the 2024 article Silence in the workplace:...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Diversified mentoring: Living at the intersections of race and gender

    Oct 27, 202634 minAudio

    This first episode of Season 6 brings together Dr. Joshua Collins (University of Minnesota) and Dr. Ague Mae Manongsong (Louisiana State University) for a conversation about the 2023 article “Manongsong, A. M., & Ghosh,...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Season 6 Trailer

    Oct 12, 20262 minAudio

    Welcome to the trailer for Season 6 of Human Resource Development Masterclass - the podcast series from the Academy of Human Resource Development, the organization that leads HRD through research. The sixth season...

    Credit the people on this episode