In this seventh episode of Season 4, guests Dr. David McGuire (Edinburgh Napier University), Dr. Jessica Li (University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign), and Laurel Farrer (GitLab) discuss the relationship between HRD and Remote Working, including: What is meant by the term Remote Working? How has our view of Remote Working been changing, and what is driving those changes? How is the changing nature of Remote Working impacting organizations at different locations around the world? What does all of this mean for individual employees and the workforce as a whole? What are the implications for HRD practice - the work it does, where it works, how it works, who is involved, etc? What are the implications for HRD education and how people are prepared for careers in HRD? What are the implications for HRD research and, specifically, what research is needed into HRD & Remote Working? and much more. For full details on the HRD Masterclass series, visit hrdmasterclass.com, and for the bios of the guest scholars visit allbypodcast.com/remote. For more information on the Academy of Human Resource Development, visit ahrd.org - by being a member of AHRD, you can access bonus materials from podcast episodes. This episode is sponsored by Dr. Sunyoung Park of the School of Leadership and Human Resource Development at Louisiana State University. Sunyoung is currently serving on the Board of the Academy of Human Resource Development.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_01We need to understand what our employees actually need in terms of training and build proper solutions that fit the world of work that we're now living in.
SPEAKER_02Welcome to Human Resource Development Masterclass, the podcast series from the Academy of Human Resource Development, the organization that leads HRD through research. I'm your host, Darren Short, and here in our fourth season, we're exploring the relationship between HRD and trends in society and organizations, with the help of leading authors, researchers and scholars. Today our focus is the relationship between HRD and remote working.
SPEAKER_02And my guests are Dr. David Maguire of Edinburgh Napier University, Dr. Jessica Lee of the University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign, and Lal Farrar of GitLab, all of whom join me for a conversation recorded in April of 2023. Our episode today is structured into two parts. In the first, we look at remote working and how it impacts organizations and the workforce. Then in the second, we explore the implications for HRD practice, research, and education.
SPEAKER_02You can find out all about the questions explored in the episode, the three guests, and also the episode sponsors by visiting allbypodcast.com forward slash remote. Talking of sponsorship, Human Resource Development Masterclass is only made possible thanks to the wonderful support of our sponsors, who cover all of the costs associated with the series, and so enable us to release them free of charge to listeners like you. I encourage you to show your thanks by letting them know just how much their sponsorship means to you.
SPEAKER_02Today's episode is brought to you thanks to the wonderful sponsorship support of Dr. Sun Young Park of the School of Leadership and Human Resource Development at Louisiana State University. Sun Young is currently serving on the board of the Academy of Human Resource Development. Thank you, Sun Young. Right, let's dive into the episode. Welcome to our episode on remote working and HRD. So let's start by meeting today's three guests.
SPEAKER_02And first, I'd like to welcome David McGuire, who is Professor and Head of HRM Subject Group at Edinburgh Napier University in Scotland. Originally from the West of Ireland, David has spent the last 18 years teaching and researching HRD in Scottish universities. To date, he's published two textbooks and over 40 articles in refereed international journals. He's currently Associate Editor of Human Resource Development International and was previously editor-in-chief of industrial and commercial training.
SPEAKER_02David's research focuses on defining and examining the scope and potential of human resource development and deconstructing the speeches of influential leaders. Welcome, David. Hi, Darren. Thanks for inviting me. My second guest for the episode is Jessica Lee, Professor of Human Resource Development in the College of Education at the University of Illinois, Urbana-Champaign, where she serves as the Associate Dean for Research and the Director of the Bureau of Educational Research. Before becoming an academic professor, Jessica worked as a business executive for corporations such as Motorola and Nokia.
SPEAKER_02Her research explores employee learning, talent development, women leadership, and technology-supported learning. And she has over 100 publications, including peer-reviewed journal articles, book chapters, editorials, a co-authored book, and three edited special issues. Welcome, Jessica.
SPEAKER_03Thank you, Darren.
SPEAKER_02And my third guest for the episode is Lal Frar, an internationally renowned thought leader on the topic of remote work and virtual organizational development. For the past 17 years, she's been managing distributed workforces and unlocking the power of workplace flexibility to create impact in corporate and socioeconomic infrastructures. Lal has consulted renowned organizations such as Zoom, Microsoft, and Vistaprint, and has been featured in many major publications, including Forbes, Fast Company, HBR, NPR, and the BBC.
SPEAKER_02In 2021, Lal joined GitLab, the world's largest fully distributed company, as the director of Workplace, where she continues to pioneer the future of virtual workplace innovation. So welcome Lal.
SPEAKER_00Thanks so much for having me. I'm really looking forward to this conversation.
SPEAKER_02Me too. And over the next hour or so, we'll be talking about remote working and implications for organizations and individuals, and then taking that into discussing the implications for HRD. But before diving into the details, I'd like to start off our conversation by exploring what's meant by that term, remote working or remote work, and also how the three of you have worked on this as a topic through your practice, writing, and research.
SPEAKER_02So, David, would you be willing to get the ball rolling for us by talking about what that term means for you and how you've engaged it in your work?
SPEAKER_01So, Darren, remote working really is a form of flexible work that involves working outside the traditional workspace or outside a central place of work for all or part of someone's working hours. So, really, I think when we're talking about remote working, we're talking about work that's spatially and sometimes even temporally fluid, um, so that we're not stuck in an office or or in a central location for for all of the time uh during the working week.
SPEAKER_01But I think I think it's an important place to start by defining the term because I think there's a lot of associated terms that cause people some confusion. So we might hear about remote working, but we also talk about agile working and smart working and teleworking and homeworking and locationless working. And so I think there's a lot of confusion in these space because these terms, while they're related, often mean something slightly different.
SPEAKER_01Um, let me take one of those terms, Darren, which is which homeworking. So when we talk about homeworking, we can distinguish three groups of workers, workers who work at home. So that could be the likes of myself. I often work from home two days a week, doing admin or working on some research projects. We have people who work from home, such as you know, plumbers, electricians, joiners. And we have people who work in the same grounds and buildings as home. And they could be like farmers, pub landlords, bed and breakfast owners.
SPEAKER_01So it would be problematic to associate homeworking with remote working, um, because some of those categories that I've just described uh don't fall into the category of remote workers. Um so I think when we're talking about remote working, we need to be clear very much about what we're talking about, which is time away from the traditional workspace and time away from the normal office environment that a lot of us uh will work in.
SPEAKER_01Um and I'm reminded of uh a quote from Alan Felstead, who's uh spent a lot of time looking at this area, and he said, today's homeworker is no longer typified by the Christmas cracker maker or the sewing machinist, but is more likely to be a finance director or personal assistant. And, you know, as we'll come to talk about, the pandemic has really shaped remote working in a very, very significant way. Um, so much so that national governments now, a lot of them have remote working strategies that are encouraging this form of work and seeing the benefits that are associated with this form of work.
SPEAKER_00The irony of this conversation is that there literally is not a standardized glossary for the term remote work. In the remote work industry and in the remote work association that I founded, we were literally having these conversations in 2019. What standardized terms do we want to use universally so that this all means the same thing? We were trying to create um nomenclature and taxonomy around this language. And but it was still very emerging.
SPEAKER_00We felt like we had time before before we hit a tipping point of critical mass. And as we all know, now here we are. So as an international community, we're hungry for these standardized terms. What does remote working mean in comparison to work from home and telecommuting? Um, and the the hard answer is we don't have a shared definition. However, what we can share in general is a common theme. In the future of work, what does remote work represent to all of us as individual employees, as freelancers, or as organizations?
SPEAKER_00And to me, what that common theme is, is that remote work represents flexibility, right? That work is something that we do, not somewhere that we go. And so it's a branch of the future of work in which we are moving into a operational model of human-centric virtual first processes that empower individuals to be productive and valued and appreciated, no matter who they are or where they are.
SPEAKER_00And that's what remote work represents to me is that transition into a more flexible and more just and fair work environment for everybody.
SPEAKER_03I feel like we're experiencing a paradigm shift in the way we think about work and life. Traditionally, we have tried to divide the two, setting clear boundaries between work hours and personal time. And the physical separation between office and home have done this work for us, for the large part. Research has shown the benefits of setting boundaries between work and personal life, such as better work efficiency and employee mental health.
SPEAKER_03However, remote work has made these lines blurry since physical separation is difficult to maintain. As a result, we must think about work as something that is done by people, not in a specific location. This shift is leading to a more people-centered approach to work, where we focus on how to better support employees to be productive and creative. Some organizations have already embraced this shift, going fully remote after the COVID-19 pandemic.
SPEAKER_03They find that this was the most economical and efficient way to operate, at least for the time being. However, other organizations are calling their employees back to the office at least part of the week. There are a number of reasons for this, including the desire to create a sense of community and foster creativity through in-person collaboration. Elon Musk is one of the most vocal proponent office-based approach.
SPEAKER_03He believes that the office is where the most magic happens, and that is essential for fostering creativity. However, many other companies believe that the current technology, such as video conferencing, makes it possible to maintain a level of performance even when employees are working remotely. Ultimately, the debate over whether to work remotely or in the office is likely to continue for some time. There's no one-size-fits-all answer, as the best approach will vary depending on the organization and the employees.
SPEAKER_03It is clear that the pandemic has accelerated the shift towards a more people-centric approach to work. And this trend is likely to continue in the years to come.
SPEAKER_02It's interesting to uh listening to the various examples you gave there. And it it made me think, you know, Val, when we were introducing you at the beginning and thinking about you had 17 years of of being in this space, and um and all of a sudden the the spotlight has really been on it over the last two, three years. And so when you listen to Jessica there and just start thinking about how the changing nature of remote work is impacting organizations, how how have you seen that play out in the in over your 17 years and and and um and particularly when you look at it now, how do you see remote work changing the nature of just organizations?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, well, let me tell you, it looks very different than it did 17 years ago. And I'm not even one of the early adopters. You know, telecommuting has been happening since the 1970s, and so there has absolutely been a strong evolution, most of which has been fueled by evolving technology. So just as a snapshot, 17 years ago, we didn't have cloud documents, we didn't have video calls, we didn't have blackberries or smartphones, we had nothing, we had email.
SPEAKER_00So that was what we built our processes on was staying in touch through email and then coming together maybe once a week, once a month, in person, sharing ideas more synchronously, and then coming apart and working independently again. And in that framework, not much has changed. There is now a very strong emphasis and much more awareness that successful remote work is a blend of asynchronous and synchronous work. And so so much has changed. Uh, I can't even tell you. I can't even tell you what a day that was when we got Blackberries.
SPEAKER_00Oh my word, we could check email away from our computer. It was just the biggest day. Uh so exciting things have happened to evolve over time, riding the wave of an economic shift towards knowledge-based work in general, um, just as an international economy. And so we're just able to facilitate the sharing of knowledge more effectively and efficiently through evolving technology.
SPEAKER_00So as technology becomes faster and more connected, and we have more um nonverbal communication that is able to be facilitated through technology, the more effectively we can feel like we can collaborate, like we did in person. So it's more closely replicating the work environment that we had in a co-located space. However, I think that what has the pendulum may have swung too much in the reliance and dependence on technology in order to facilitate remote work.
SPEAKER_00Um, because so many leaders that I consult and talk to say, well, what tools should we be using? What tools should we be using? And if we have that mindset, we're really not seeing the forest for the trees because we are missing how we are using tools in order to create different results. I mean, think about a paintbrush. A paintbrush is a tool as well, but we're going to get very, very different results based on how we are trained to use that tool. Um, I'm sure that the picture that I paint and the picture that you paint, Darren, and you paint David, and you paint Jessica, we're all going to get very different results based on how we are using the tool.
SPEAKER_00And the same thing is true in work environments as well. Think about just as simple as a conference room. We all know that very, very different creative results came out of the same conference room as well, depending on how the tools were used within it. So when we had leaders that were creating psychological safety and were facilitating exciting, engaging conversations, those were very creative discussions.
SPEAKER_00And but leaders that suppressed innovation or were maybe micromanagers that did not facilitate creativity. So the output that we're hoping to see from our teams really has very little to do with our work environment or our workplace. What it has to do with is how we are using the tools and resources that we have access to in order to create connection and engagement with our team. So I can tell you right now, yes, I have had absolutely fantastic creative conversations with my distributed teams over the past 17 years.
SPEAKER_00And I've had very not creative conversations with my teams over the past 17 years, but it didn't have anything to do with us being in person or not in person. It had to do with the trust that we shared, how prepared we were coming to meetings, and how we were facilitating the creative process. So I think that what this change and evolution represents to me is yes, it's enabled by technology, but it's owned by us as individuals.
SPEAKER_00We have to claim our ownership and stewardship in the success of remote work without depending on the tools to do it for us.
SPEAKER_02I find it interesting to compare how what I see in the United States versus what I see in the United Kingdom at the moment in response to this, as in um where I am in Seattle, uh, it is still predominantly remote and hybrid. Um and that there has been this kind of um force to make this work. Um and yet when I speak to friends and relatives in London, um, it feels as if London has pretty much gone back to how it was almost before COVID, as in the bulk of people are now back in the office.
SPEAKER_02And so I I'm kind of interested in what you see in the United Kingdom around this, and and and and and maybe I get a skewed view based on who I'm speaking to in London, but it uh are you seeing in the UK a similar sort of pattern around uh around how things are being treated now with remote work?
SPEAKER_01Uh truthfully, Darren, I think it's a mixed picture. Uh, and and I say that because if we look at, for instance, the Welsh government and the Irish government, both of those governments have introduced national strategies for remote working, which actually, when you think about it, is quite groundbreaking. So the Welsh government have a goal of having 30% of their workforce working remotely on a regular basis. And in Ireland, the target is 20% of the workforce working regularly on a remote basis.
SPEAKER_01So to actually codify that is, I think, quite significant. Um, both of those governments have also introduced uh regional hubs to allow people a dedicated space to work remotely near where they live. So those dedicated spaces could be commercial buildings, could be public buildings, community centres. But I think what's happened, Darren, is certainly, as I say, in Wales and then the Republic of Ireland, they've seen remote working as bringing some important benefits.
SPEAKER_01Now, if we look at the literature, we see that a lot of the time, you know, people and academics and researchers talk about remote working as having, you know, well-being benefits, being able to, you know, get fresh air, mental health, uh, improved employee well-being, reducing traffic and you know, environmental benefits. But actually, you know, what's less talked about, but possibly even more important, is the economic benefits of remote working.
SPEAKER_01And the economic benefits, you know, if we look at what the Irish government and the Welsh government are saying, they're now able to create jobs in rural locations. They're not pulling people into city centres anymore. Small towns and villages now have more footfall and are more vibrant. And in fact, in both countries, they're seeing a cultural benefit whereby you're able to keep people in locations where there's a local culture or perhaps even local language benefits, you know, where people who are fluent in the Irish language or in the Welsh language stay local and keep that culture alive.
SPEAKER_01So I think there's uh a regional development benefits to remote working that really, to my mind, isn't being described and researched enough in the literature. So I think, as I say, Darren, I think the the picture is mixed in terms of yes, uh, in parts of London, there is this drive to go back to the office, but in some, shall we say, more rural locations, um, they are. Seeing a lot of benefits to remote working.
SPEAKER_02So that's really interesting to me. It makes me feel as if when I think about what this means for individuals, it probably means a lot as to where I am as an individual. So where am I living? Which country am I in? Maybe what region am I in in that in that country? Possibly even what sector do I work in? Or what is my degree of comfort in using things like technology?
SPEAKER_02So La, what's your reaction to listening to David there and hearing about how governments in Europe are starting to deal with this? What do you think this all means for the individual employee? And then if you put that together, the workforce as a whole.
SPEAKER_00Ironically, I was an early advisor to both of the government initiatives that you just mentioned, David. So yes, I've been very, very involved in these and absolutely have seen the effects firsthand in many, many countries around the world on initiatives that we've designed that each have different goals. And so there's so many different points of economic health and sustainability that can be supported by this. The United Nations, over three-quarters of the key points of the United Nations initiatives can be either directly or indirectly impacted by workplace flexibility.
SPEAKER_00The impact of this is absolutely amazing when we consider hyperurbanization and the rural divide, like you were mentioning in Ireland. I mean, it alleviates such pressure in the infrastructure of Dublin. But then also environmental sustainability and pollution, we saw that during the pandemic when all of a sudden all the cars were off the road and people could see the mountains again that they've lived next to for their whole lives. I mean, little things like that really give us such hope that yes, this is an individual change, uh, but has global impact for all of us as an international community.
SPEAKER_00So we, if we stay focused on what we're working towards and why this is so motivating for each of us as individuals, as communities, as organizations, then we can really start to make great progress. But if we stay in these trenches of which is best, if we should we go into the office or should we work from home, we are really missing the point and we're going to end up hurting our economy more than helping it.
SPEAKER_03I agree. This is an intriguing conversation. The impact of remote work on the economy and the environment is certainly significant, but there are other important factors to consider as well. One of these is diversity, equity, and inclusion. Remote work often relies on technology and broadband internet connections. This can further the digital divide, as people who do not have access to these resources may be excluded from remote working opportunities.
SPEAKER_03Additionally, remote work can lead to isolation, which can be especially challenging for people who are already marginalized. We need to be mindful of these issues as we continue to explore the potential of remote work. We need to ensure that remote work is accessible to everyone, regardless of their background, location, or circumstances. We also need to create policies and practices that promote DEI in the workplace to realize the benefit of remote work and at the same time make it accessible and equitable for everyone.
SPEAKER_00And it's even creating new classes of it and categories of DEI, right? That I mean, this is mind-blowing to watch this evolution and this history and progress. Because what would we ever have considered five to 10 years ago that proximity bias would be a factor in our DEI? Um, and things like rural accents, these programs of connecting the rural divide and providing jobs to rural uh citizens are fantastic and wonderful until we conducted research and said, what's going on?
SPEAKER_00There, the attrition rates of these jobs are really high. We found out that there was bias happening based on the communication habits and the verbal accents of rural employees. And so that's something that we've had to combat and fix as well in in uh companies that are participating in these rural programs. So it's yes, this DEI conversation is so important. Remote work has mind-blowing, skyrocketing statistics of how much it helps DEI, but it doesn't mean that the hard work is over.
SPEAKER_00It means that we need to be more intentional than ever. I love that you brought that up.
SPEAKER_02So I wonder if now is a good time to start digging a little into what all of this means for human resource development. Because like in the in the first half of the episode, the first 30 minutes, we've we've really raised so much richness about what is going on in terms of the workforce, how this is impacting organizations. And in almost everything that's been said, um, my mind is is generating questions and issues around so how does this play out in terms of employee skills, in terms of development, in terms of how we uh integrate new employees into cultures and into distributed teams.
SPEAKER_02And so, David, when you when you take a look at all of this from an HRD practice perspective, uh how do you see it impacting like the work that HRD practice does, where it does it, about how it works, who's involved, all of these questions.
SPEAKER_01Great question, Darren. And let me start by by picking up on new employees. Um, because you know, if we talk about remote working and what remote working has done in terms of creating possibly even a three-tier workforce, we're talking about employees who are based at the office, we're talking about employees who are based perhaps completely remotely, and then employees who are more hybrid in their working habits and working time.
SPEAKER_01And how do we induct and orient new employees? How do we build an organizational brand, an organizational identity for employees who are remote workers? And that's a real critical question because when I think about where I work, uh often there's something that's connected to the building and to the space where I work, that the building and the space often communicates a culture and a set of values that sometimes can be difficult to transmit virtually.
SPEAKER_01So I think, you know, one of the things we saw during the pandemic was the effect on newer employees and younger employees who had less access to coaching and mentoring, who didn't have those opportunities for informal learning from learning from the experiences of more senior employees. So, in this new space where we are dealing with remote working and hybrid working, we need to be conscious to be able to facilitate that transfer of experience, that passing on of knowledge in a perhaps a different way, and making sure that there's equity between the different classes and different categories of employees within organizations.
SPEAKER_01I also want to go back to something that Laurel said earlier on, which is is around how we train and how we engage with the new technologies. And you know, the pandemic, what happened in the pandemic was we moved from organizations treading water in terms of let's get everything online really, really quickly and let's try and survive to now what we're calling the new normal, whereby we're trying to embed these technologies more systematically and more structurally into organizations.
SPEAKER_01And I'm conscious of the what you might call learning in the flow of work. How do we use these new technologies, conscious that some of these technologies, for example, Zoom has only been around since 2011, and MS Teams and Google Meets have only been around since 2017? So these are new technologies. How do we really use these technologies in a systematic way and allow people who are working remotely, give them opportunities to access training?
SPEAKER_01Not that they have to stop work to attend a training course for half a day or a day, but that we build in training into the flow of work. We need to think about design, we need to think about the relevance of the content, we need to understand what our employees actually need in terms of training and build proper solutions that are that fit the world of work that we're now living in.
SPEAKER_00I completely agree with everything that David said. It really comes back to how are we facilitating these experiences? Um, like onboarding, we all know you can walk into a conference room full of people and still feel completely out of the loop and unwelcome and uninformed. Um, but you can walk into a conference room full of people and feel welcomed and excited and engaged. And the difference is probably going to be your interactions with the people.
SPEAKER_00How, what are they saying to you to make you feel welcome? What are they doing for you to communicate that you have a place on this team? And that's exactly what we can and should be facilitating virtually as well. I think it's a mindset shift that we really need to be very articulate about and very intentional about that when we have been based in physical workplaces, which has been happening since the industrial revolution. So this is a very long history of a lot of unlearning that we have to do as a society.
SPEAKER_00But when we've been working in physical workplaces, physical elements create alignment. So therefore, proximity, sharing time and location is what's going to create alignment in our teams. However, when we shift over to knowledge-based work, knowledge sharing is what's going to create alignment in our teams. So the more information that we can share, the more communication that we can share, that is what's going to create that alignment and that connection between our teams.
SPEAKER_00So as we do that, we really need to think very carefully as HR leaders, as people ops, as trainers, as mentors, what are we doing in order to facilitate that more knowledge-based work environment? And I would say we really need to upskill in two different categories. One would be communication. If we are trying to share knowledge effectively, we need to know how to communicate that knowledge effectively. So really focusing and investing in written communication as a skill in our workforces, I think is very, very, very important.
SPEAKER_00And all of the emotional intelligence that surrounds that. So we need to rely instead, again, on information. How are we measuring results? How are we measuring that communication in order to evaluate and assess somebody's contributions?
SPEAKER_00And in all of that, really remembering that working autonomously is the goal of remote work. It is not the same thing as abandonment. Autonomy is not abandonment. I cannot shout that from the work rooftops loud enough. We think that people are out of sight and therefore they are out of mind. And that is what's sabotaging our success as distributed teams. We need to share information and knowledge more often, more transparently, more frequently, more consistently to create that alignment in our teams and not treat people as independent of the team because that is what creates that remote work isolation.
SPEAKER_00And the studies that we've done on remote work isolation is that people don't feel socially isolated, they feel informationally isolated because at work, people are a resource. They're a resource that you need to do your job effectively. You can ask them questions, you can get mentorship, you can do career development. So the more that you share information with your team, the more it will feel connected. And so focusing on those skills of communication and autonomy, managing without micromanagement, without uh supervision, focusing on results, that is what's going to lead to sustainable success.
SPEAKER_02On that autonomy piece, it feels like there's two pieces to it. One is helping individuals to be able to work more autonomously. And then the other piece is helping managers to be able to manage those who are working more autonomously. Based on your experience, uh, are those equally challenging? Or do you find that one of those two groups is going to be a greater struggle? If that makes sense.
SPEAKER_00Ah, yes, this is the biggest secret of remote work, is that remote work is still just work. So we all keep looking to each other and saying, well, it's the organization's responsibility to solve this problem, or it's the manager's responsibility to solve this problem, or it's the employees' responsibility to solve this problem. And isn't that what business has been about since the beginning of business? Is that we all need each other in order for the companies to succeed.
SPEAKER_00And that's exactly the solution in this change management cycle as well, is the more that we look to one party or another to facilitate this change management process, the less it will succeed. But the more that we can come together as an organization, as management, as workforce, and individual contributors all work together and understand what their role in the change management process is, the more successful it will be and the more efficient it will be.
SPEAKER_00So we really, really, really need every party to understand what role they have to play in the process and work together in order to implement the goals.
SPEAKER_03I agree with everything that has been said so far. I think remote work is a huge opportunity for HRD. And I'm glad that Laurel brought up change management. The rapid change that we have experienced in the past few years has made it difficult to plan ahead. But that doesn't mean that we shouldn't do the work to make it better as we move forward. It's time to apply a plan change process by involving key stakeholders, such as employees and managers, and start with the diagnostic phase of the change process to identify what changes are needed and why.
SPEAKER_03The organization's management team needs to be on board with the changes and are willing to support their employees. Our traditional organizational processes and management processes were designed for office work. We can't just apply them to remote work. The context has changed. For example, there has been a lot of technology development to monitor people who are working from home. I found this very negative. It shows that these organizations don't understand remote work.
SPEAKER_03They're just trying to apply the same old methods to a new context. This is lazy and ineffective. Instead, we need to think about how we can redesign our work process processes so that we are effective in a remote work environment. We need to create trust and respect between employees and managers. We need to give employees the tools and resources they need to be successful. And we need to be flexible and adaptable.
SPEAKER_03I'm excited about the potential of remote work. And I think it has the potential to make our organization more productive and effective and inclusive.
SPEAKER_01And I think Jessica, just to add to that, you know, over the last prior to the pandemic, over the last 10, 15 years, we saw the physical structures in organizations changing. We saw, you know, more open plan offices, we saw internal glass walls, we saw these big, large atriums, and all of which was designed to make employees more visible and more easily to monitor. And now we're moving to a situation where employees are working remotely and you know, perhaps being less visible.
SPEAKER_01But what we haven't seen, both in terms of how we teach human resource development and more broadly, human resource management, we haven't seen a greater sophistication in how we communicate with employees, going back to what Laurel said, you know, how we manage them remotely, how we communicate with them, how we build in those autonomy skills, how we build in those people management skills in order to help remote employees feel more valued, feel more included, and feel less isolated, but being much more integrated into the body of the organization and into the heart of the organization.
SPEAKER_01So I think there's still some work to do there.
SPEAKER_00I agree. I think that those open workplaces are the perfect example of that transfer from physical work environments and physical work elements to knowledge-based work elements, right? We knew that we needed more visibility. We knew that we couldn't see productivity effectively as at the organizational level. So we were so conditioned to think physically that we thought, oh, we need more physical visibility. And so we created all of those glass walls, but little did we know that that was going to backfire.
SPEAKER_00I mean, we I I think I could feel comfortable speaking for all four of us when we all have been in a physical work environment before and we have looked really busy, but we have not actually been producing any work, right? Like productivity and visible seeming productivity are two very, very different things. So it was a step in the right direction. We knew that we needed more visibility into productivity, but we just didn't understand that it needed to be that information-based visibility instead of that physical-based visibility.
SPEAKER_00So the more that we can lean on tools and project management and effective key performance indicators in order to provide that informational visibility for us, the more that we can literally see results of productivity more effectively.
SPEAKER_02David, you mentioned education there. And so I I'd love to dig a little into that piece because it fit when I think about watched additionally in an HRD education program, like for example, in an HRD masters, um like m much of that to me feels like it kind of assumes a world which is has changed or or in some cases simply doesn't exist anymore.
SPEAKER_02So when you think about HRD education and master's programs and doctorates, what what do you see as the implications for how we need to change those in order to prepare HRD practitioners to actually be effective in this new environment?
SPEAKER_01Darren, I think we have a job of work to do. I mean, if we look just at the implications of remote working, we need to think about things like health and safety, equality, mental health issues, data protection issues, cybersecurity issues, employee engagement issues. And right now, if we look at the sort of textbooks that we're using, if we look at the Or syllabuses that we're using, a lot of those are designed for physical work office spaces and not really designed to cope with remote working and hybrid working.
SPEAKER_01So I think what we'll see, and I think this is due to the sort of new nature and the acceleration of remote and hybrid working caused by the pandemic, but what I think we'll see over the next few years is academics moving more diligently into those spaces and filling in some of those gaps right now and coming up with new approaches and new methodologies to really tackle and better serve the hybrid and remote workforces that we now have.
SPEAKER_03Yes, I agree. It is definitely a challenge to keep up with the rapid changes in the world of work. Our textbooks and curriculums can't be updated quickly enough to reflect the latest trends. This means that professors need to be more innovative in their teaching methods. We also need to be thinking about what new skills HRD professionals are needed in the future. To do this, we need to conduct significant research into the new working arrangements that are emerging.
SPEAKER_03We need to understand what skills are needed in these new roles and how we can best prepare our students for them. This is a complex and challenging task, but it is essential if we want to ensure that our students are equipped for the future of work. Professors will need to bring in new and current materials, take students to conferences, and talk with practicing HRD professionals.
SPEAKER_00I can back that up and validate that in the both workforce and leadership development programs that I've been developing all these years for remote work, it really boils down to three different educational themes and practices. And it really is a cycle of those three parties working together, like we talked about before: the organization, the management and leadership, and then the workforce. Everybody has a role to play in the education, and everybody needs to upskill. And at the root of it is the autonomy that we were talking about.
SPEAKER_00So we need to educate and upskill our workforces to be more effective self-managers, to work in location-independent environments without needing supervision. So skills like intrinsic motivation and task management and project management are more important than ever. On the management and leadership level, we need to unlearn all of those long-standing histories of physical-based supervision. So we need to replace that instinct to supervise with a habit to support and therefore enable the self-management of individuals.
SPEAKER_00And then on the organizational level, it's the same. Are we providing the tools and processes for both leadership and individuals that enable all of that self-management to happen? Are we providing knowledge management systems? Are we providing key performance indicators? Are we providing objectives and key results that create shared realities? Are we creating visibility of results in our project management systems? We're all working together to support that same goal of self-management on the individual level.
SPEAKER_02Well, so I'm conscious that we're coming up to the end of our hour together. And there's this one question that I've sort of saved for the end because it felt like a nice way of pulling all of this together, which is a question about research, because I think it's it there's a a couple of themes that have come through for me as we've had our conversation today. One is um this feels like it's an arena where practice is potentially way ahead of research, um, and research is probably struggling to keep up pace.
SPEAKER_02And the second is that um there are, in many cases, far more questions around than we have answers right now, um, which makes it feel as if this is uh a space which is rich for research. Um so I I was wondering, maybe Jessica, given your role uh as an associate dean for research, when you take a look at the implications for HRD research, what sort of what sort of advice would you give to somebody who is considering stepping into this space, either to do uh academic research or potentially as a topic for their dissertation?
SPEAKER_02Are there particular is there particular advice that you would give somebody as to how they could play a role in closing this gap?
SPEAKER_03I have been thinking a lot about this, and today's conversation has affirmed and enriched my beliefs. I believe that the field of HRD needs to start thinking more broadly about team-based research. It's not just one thing anymore, it's multiple things happening at the same time. For example, we need to bring AI experts, sociologists, psychologists, and behavior scientists into our research teams. Earlier, I mentioned we're experiencing a paradigm shift.
SPEAKER_03We need to establish a better understanding of what that means. When we shift from a workspace center to a people center or to an information or knowledge-centered approach, we need to understand what that means. We also need to keep up with the technology uh advancement. The new technology that we're talking about in this conversation is very important. And it's not just about introducing technology for technology's sake. We need to explore more specifically what kind of technology will we use and what for and for what purpose.
SPEAKER_03For example, the current conversation about Chat GPT, it is relevant to the HRD field as well. How will it impact the work of employees, particularly knowledge workers? Is it okay to ask ChatGPT to create a report? And if so, who will author? These are the things that we need to explore and understand. We also need to develop new management and leadership theories and practice to help organizations to manage this new remote work arrangement.
SPEAKER_03Laura mentioned that autonomy doesn't mean abandonment. That's one example of how we as organizations need to change our structure and process to support employees who are working remotely. In terms of specific areas of research in HRD in the remote work environment, I think there are a number of things that can be researched. For example, employee engagement. Strategy and skills will definitely have to change when employees work remotely.
SPEAKER_03We need to understand how to engage employees in a remote work environment. Leadership practices are another area that needs to be researched. New leadership models may be needed. And then there are learning and development. In the early days of COVID, a lot of people start reading and learning lots of different things online. How can we make sure that employees are learning, both informally and formally, to support their personal growth and performance?
SPEAKER_03Another area is employee well-being. How will remote work arrangement impact employees psychologically, emotionally, and mentally? This is another research agenda that needs to be explored. Finally, it is also important to consider the impact of remote work on organizational culture. When employees are not physically present in the office, it can be more difficult to build and maintain a strong company culture. HRD professionals can play a role in helping organizations to create a remote work culture that is inclusive, supportive, and collaborative.
SPEAKER_03As the field of HRD continues to evolve, we need to be at the forefront of understanding the challenge and opportunity of remote work. By doing so, we can help organizations to create a more productive, engaged, and healthy workforce. This are just a few things to get the conversation started. I'd love to hear what Laura and David think about the future of HRE research in relation to remote work arrangements.
SPEAKER_01For me, I think some of the research opportunities lie in trying to understand the learning needs of remote and hybrid workers and not just assuming that the learning needs of those groups of workers are the same as office-based workers. We've put in place, particularly over the last four to five years since the pandemic, a whole new infrastructure of work. Yes, that infrastructure existed prior to the pandemic, but the pandemic really accelerated this transition to remote and hybrid working.
SPEAKER_01So I think there's opportunities there to really understand how we can reach both remote and hybrid workers. I think there's also research opportunities in learning how remote and hybrid working offers opportunities to seldom heard and minority communities. So communities that may well not have access to the new normal vocational routes to employment.
SPEAKER_01I think remote working, there are opportunities there to look at the experiences of those communities and seeing how remote working has transformed the lives of some of the individuals in those communities.
SPEAKER_00I personally don't have much to add in terms of the research needed because obviously David and Jessica are much more determined experts in that space. However, what I can say from the private sector side is that we need this research so desperately. Coming full circle to our conversation at the beginning when we were talking about what the remote workspace was like pre-pandemic. And it was so small. It was such a tiny group of advocates that gathered internationally to just plea for attention and support.
SPEAKER_00It was very difficult to get funding. It was very difficult to get media coverage. It was very difficult to get credibility. And so because of that, not only did we have a lack of nomenclature and shared glossary, but we didn't have shared statistics either. There was a few pieces from sources like Global Workplace Analytics and Gallup that were researching this space a little bit, but that was it. And so we've been relying very, very heavily on those statistics for several years now, and now they're out of date and they're not relevant.
SPEAKER_00So we need this research absolutely more than ever. And if not only for the cases for change and adoption for future organizations, but also to combat the media coverage about remote work. There all of the controversy around remote work is because it's media driven and media messages are subjective and opinion-based. There's no data in them. And if the data does exist, it's data as a very loose term, right?
SPEAKER_00It's privately funded statistic that does not qualify as peer-reviewed research. So we really, really need credible information coming from this community in order to drive the future and inform the future resources of the remote work industry. So I put myself out there to both you, David, and Jessica, as well as anybody listening to this. I'm very deeply connected in the remote work world. I'm the former founder and president of the Remote Work Association. We've talked about my personal interest and investment in this community.
SPEAKER_00And I can guarantee I can connect you, anybody listening, to the companies, to the individuals, to the universities that are also working on research, so that we can create compounding growth and results and really achieve the goals that we need in order to move this conversation forward.
SPEAKER_02Well, that sounds like a highly motivational call to action and a wonderful way of wrapping up our time together for today. So unfortunately, we have run out of time for the conversation. My guess is we could probably keep this going for a lot longer, and that probably means we need a follow-up episode. But I wanted to say a big thank you to David, to Jessica, to Lal for such an interesting discussion and for giving us all so much to think about and then hopefully to then act upon. So thank you all so much indeed.
SPEAKER_02Great. Thanks, Darren.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, thank you.
SPEAKER_00Thank you for having us.
SPEAKER_02Thank you so much for joining me for this episode. It was wonderful spending time with David McGuire, Jessica Lee, and Lal Farrar. If you enjoyed this episode, check out all of our others. There were 33 episodes in the first three seasons, and we're releasing a further 11 here in the fourth. Between them, they provide access to conversations with over 100 leading scholars from around the world. New episodes release weekly. To learn more about the series, check out HRDmasterclass.com.
SPEAKER_02And to learn about the Academy of Human Resource Development, check out ahrd.org. I'm looking forward to being with you in our next episode when we're exploring the relationship between HRD and generational changes in the workforce with the help of Dr. Catherine Jeffery of KJ Consulting, Dr. Melica Edwards of the University of Houston, and Dr. Marilyn Germain of Western Carolina University. Until then, it is Darren Short signing off from the HRD Masterclass.com.
This fourth episode of Season 6 brings together Dr. Sanghamitra Chaudhuri (Temple University) and Dr. Kyung Nam Kim (Texas A&M University) for a conversation about the 2026 article Gendered Pathways to Work-Family...
This third episode of Season 6 brings together Dr. Yuanlu Niu (University of Arkansas) and Dr. Jos Akkermans (Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam) for a conversation about the 2026 article Navigating careers in non-traditional...
This second episode of Season 6 brings together Dr. Matthew Hurtienne (University of Texas at Tyler) and Dr. Heesun Kim (Francis Marion University) for a conversation about the 2024 article Silence in the workplace:...
This first episode of Season 6 brings together Dr. Joshua Collins (University of Minnesota) and Dr. Ague Mae Manongsong (Louisiana State University) for a conversation about the 2023 article “Manongsong, A. M., & Ghosh,...
Welcome to the trailer for Season 6 of Human Resource Development Masterclass - the podcast series from the Academy of Human Resource Development, the organization that leads HRD through research. The sixth season...