HRD: How To Be Culturally Responsive In Coaching & Mentoring
52 minAudio
In this seventh episode of Season 5, I meet with guests Dr. Henriette Lundgren (University of Georgia), Dr. Angela D. Carter (Clemson University), and Dr. Katrenia Reed Hughes (Purdue University) to discuss how to be culturally responsive In coaching & mentoring. We discuss: What do we mean by the terms “culture”, “cultural responsiveness”, “coaching”, and “mentoring”? What have been your personal experiences in seeing how culture impacts coaching and mentoring relationships? What role does cultural responsiveness play within coaching and mentoring relationships? How can we approach coaching and mentoring and the design of those programs in a way that allows for culture? How can an HRD professional, who functions as a coach or mentor, build up their own experience to be culturally responsive? How can they help others to be more culturally responsive through coaching or mentoring education? What would be the best first steps for someone looking to be more culturally responsive in their coaching and mentoring? and much more. For full details on the HRD Masterclass series, visit hrdmasterclass.com, and for the bios of the guest scholars visit allbypodcast.com/developmental. For more information on the Academy of Human Resource Development, visit ahrd.org. This episode is sponsored by the Department of Technology Leadership and Innovation at Purdue University. With a focus on practical, real-world, industry-relevant learning experiences and flexible scheduling, the programs offered by the Department of Technology Leadership and Innovation empower students to become world-class leaders, communicators, and project managers. Our online certificates and degree programs will help you advance your career to the next level, sharpen your leadership skills, and stay at the top of your field. Choose from three newly redesigned graduate certificates in Human Resource Development, Project Management, or Technical Communication. Students can enroll in fall, spring, and summer semesters. Classes are offered in a flexible, 100% online format. For more information, visit https://bit.ly/purduehrd.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_03So if we don't acknowledge culture in these spaces like coaching and mentoring, we risk turning it into another site where we might be silent instead of being able to really grow.
SPEAKER_00Welcome to Human Resource Development Masterclass, the forecast series from the Academy of Human Resource Development, the organization that leads HRD through research. I'm your host, Darren Short, and here in our fifth season, we're exploring some of our listeners' top how-to questions, with the help of leading authors, researchers, and scholars. In this seventh episode of the season, we're focusing on the question of how to be culturally responsive in coaching and mentoring.
SPEAKER_00And you'll hear a conversation recorded in July of 2025. To explore this important question, I'm joined today by three experts. My first guest is Dr. Henrietta Lundgren, assistant professor in learning, leadership and organization development at the University of Georgia. Her research focuses on boundary issues between formal, informal, and incidental learning. Before joining academia, Henrietta held diverse industry positions in learning and development for 20 years.
SPEAKER_00Most recently, she worked as talent manager for Corning, Incorporated. Henrietta is a certified executive coach with Columbia University. My second guest is Dr. Angela D. Carter, assistant professor and programme coordinator for the Master of Human Resource Development Programme in Clemson University's College of Education. Her research focuses on developmental relationships, especially coaching, mentoring, and leadership development, as drivers of individual growth and organizational learning.
SPEAKER_00She is particularly interested in how these relationships foster engagement, belonging, and sustainable change. My third guest is Dr. Katrina Reed Hughes, a tenured associate professor of organizational leadership at Purdue University, where she serves as Director of Student Excellence in the Office of Student and Community Engagement. With over twenty years in higher education and a decade in corporate organizational development, Katrina brings deep expertise in mentoring, leadership and inclusive relationship building.
SPEAKER_00Her work centres on helping students and emerging professionals grow through culturally responsive mentoring practices that foster connection, confidence and access.com forward slash developmental to learn more about the bios of our three guests and also to connect with our episode sponsors, the Department of Technology Leadership and Innovation at Purdue University. With a focus on practical, real-world, industry-relevant learning experiences and flexible scheduling, the programs offered by the Department of Technology Leadership and Innovation empower students to become world-class leaders, communicators and project managers.
SPEAKER_00Their online certificates and degree programs will help you advance your career to the next level, sharpen your leadership skills, and stay at the top of your field. Choose from three newly redesigned graduate certificates in human resource development, project management or technical communication. Students can enrol in fall, spring, and summer semesters. Classes are offered in a flexible 100% online format. For more information, visit bit.ly slash perduh.
SPEAKER_00Right, let's dive into the episode. Okay, well, I am delighted to be joined today by Angie Carter, by Henrietta Lundgren, and by Katrina Reed Hughes. Thank you so much, all three of you, for joining me for today's interesting conversation.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, it's great to be here. Thank you for having us.
SPEAKER_00I was thinking about a good place for us to start on the conversation. And I was thinking that some of the listeners will be coming to this topic from different places and therefore may have slightly different understandings of some of the terms that you're likely to be using. I was thinking maybe it's helpful at the start of our chat for us to focus just a little on what we mean by some of these terms. Terms like uh culture, coaching, mentoring. Angie, would you be willing to get the ball rolling on just some of the terms you think are likely to crop up and and what they mean to you and this group?
SPEAKER_03Yeah, absolutely. It's a it's a really great place to begin because all of these terms like coaching, culture, cultural responsiveness, mentoring, they they get used a lot. Um, but they're interpreted really differently depending on who's speaking. So setting the stage for these definitions, I think, is is really important. Um, so the first one, let's talk about culture. We're talking about these shared patterns of values and beliefs and social norms that influence how people make meaning and how they interact in the world.
SPEAKER_03And so that means the visible things, right? Like language and food and dress, the things, the observable parts of us, um, but also these kind of hidden and invisible things like assumptions about leadership or uh how we deal with time or our communication styles. All of those things go go into culture. Culture is much more about where you're from, it's about how you've learned to see the world and how you interact with the world, and that is something that's always in motion.
SPEAKER_03And so our understanding of how to engage across cultures has gone through some really important shifts. We started with this term of cultural sensitivity, which was really about not offending others, um being aware that difference exists, and it was a really good entry point, but it really kind of stopped at politeness, didn't really reflect um a change in behavior. Cultural humility um is really about um self-critique and acknowledging and fixing power imbalances and um being affiliated um with you know advocacy groups and things of that nature.
SPEAKER_03We get to cultural competence, um, and it's interesting because competence is a word that has a complicated legacy depending on the field. Human resource development, competence is foundational, right? It's our KSAs, our knowledge, our skills, and behaviors. Um, but it feels like medicine, cultural competence has come under fire. People think that this is um what what it means to be competent is different in medicine than it is in HRD.
SPEAKER_03So in HRD, competence can be helpful as long as we remember it's not an endpoint. And now we get to this term of responsiveness. Um, and responsiveness is centering on you know reflection and adaptability and partnership and taking action, being cognizant that culture exists, but also taking action in the way that we use that. Um, are we paying attention to how culture shows up in the moment? How are you adapting your language, your questions, your strategies, things of that nature?
SPEAKER_03How are you affirming what is equitable in a space? And so that's important when we think about coaching and mentoring, which are developmental relationships. That means that they're these intentional relationships that support someone's growth. I like to use a riding riding a bike analogy when I explain the differences between um coaching and mentoring. So you come to me and you say, you know, I want to go on a hundred-mile bike ride. Never done it before, but I need you to help me do that.
SPEAKER_03If I were mentoring you, I would come from a point where I have typically I've done that, right? I've gone on a hundred-mile bike ride. I might introduce you to the same people and the same path and the same route that I used. I might offer you guidance based on my experience and helping you find where you want to go ultimately in your ride. It's a much more directive way for me to do that oftentimes. Coaching, on the other hand, is where I would ask you, all right, well, what makes you nervous about being on the bike?
SPEAKER_03What do you notice about your balance? What do you notice? You know, what small adjustments might you make in the future? It is much more goal-oriented. It's a partnership that focuses on growth and performance and on learning. And so on this bike ride, we might use both of those, right? We might use coaching and mentoring and bringing it to kind of this, you know, cultural responsiveness. Both are valuable, right? Both are valuable ways to help people because it's about surfacing how people want to get from A to B and surfacing what support feels safe.
SPEAKER_03And all of that is shaped by by culture. Um, and so it's not just about you know teaching someone how to ride, it's it's about walking with them and guiding them as they build the courage to ride on their own.
SPEAKER_01Well, I'd like to jump on the right, on the right, on the bike riding analogy that uh Angela just offered, because uh, well, first of all, I just returned from the Netherlands and there was lots of bike riding. And so I I love that aspect and how you differentiate between the coaching relationship and the mentoring relationship, one being more guiding and experience-based, and the other one really being developmental in nature, supportive, um, maybe um in yeah, more encouraging on an emotional level, um, but without the clear pathway.
SPEAKER_01Um, also, what came up when I heard the bike analogy was uh I think a common misunderstanding that we have when we talk about the term culture or culturally responsive. And that is, I think our minds often, especially if we maybe have a business school background or have studied culture, cross-cultural things in the business school, business management organizational context, their cultural model of uh Gerhard Hofstad, he was a Dutch social psychologist, comes to mind.
SPEAKER_01Now, Gerhard Hofsteter did a study um back in the 1960s, I think, and it was a study with an organization called IBM, and he was uh working at IBM, and he compared all these different people working for IBM on the national culture dimensions. Now, I think the misunderstanding is that when we use the term culture, people think a model like Gerthofstady's model, which maybe in the 1960s was how the term was used, but I think what we're trying to say is much different from a national culture definition.
SPEAKER_01We um don't necessarily, and um Angela mentioned it, I mean, where I grew up or where my family comes from might have had an impact on me as an individual, as a person. And there is so much more, right? The national origin or a citizenship or a place of birth is not necessarily the defining factor of how I show up here in this podcast, for example. And so what I think is important and where I would like to maybe um verify this misunderstanding is that the term cultural, culturally responsive refers to identity work.
SPEAKER_01It refers to seeing the whole person in a conversation. Of course, um, you know, how I show up, and Angie had a beautiful definition of you know, the visible things, the invisible things. Yeah, this is all important, but there can also be um right, there's there's a lot of layers of uh who I am as a person, with my gender, with my socioeconomic background, maybe with my neurodiversity, with my generational experiences, and all of these things, of course, also including language and dress and you know what I like to eat, but all of these things somehow need to be speakable when we try to build a relationship.
SPEAKER_01And I think that is important when, especially as I research more the coaching side of things, when we think about culturally responsive coaching, that both the coach and the client can speak about who they are and can show up in their authentic selves. Even if this is a complex thing, it won't all happen in the first meeting or in the first conversation. It bubbles up um depending on what's happening. But I just want to make sure that we go beyond the cross-cultural understanding of a model that maybe was formed in the 1960s.
SPEAKER_02Very well said. I also really like the bike example because it really, to me, it spoke to how whereas Henrietta was just in an environment where people bike all the time, there are some generational differences on biking. One of my daughter's best friends, you know, doesn't know how to ride a bike and she's 27. Um, and so our life experiences, and as an individual, that person never learned how to ride a bike. And so you can't just think that everyone in a neighborhood with, say, streets, knows how to ride a bike.
SPEAKER_02There's just so much about the individual that really goes into um both the coaching and the mentoring relationship. And to me, culture uh really is the relationship in a lot of ways.
SPEAKER_00That individual piece actually takes me to a question that I've had bubbling up as I've listened to the three of you talking through here. I'm sure a lot of a lot of people who are listening are starting already starting to think, ah, I've been coached, I've been mentored, and are starting to think about how culture played a part in their own coaching and and mentoring. And so it made me wonder about your own experiences. Because I think that could provide some colour to the listeners to get a sense as to your what your own personal experiences have been in terms of how culture has impacted coaching and mentoring.
SPEAKER_00So Katrina, you just mentioned the individual piece, so maybe I come to you first, as in what what what's been your personal experiences, personal experiences of how culture's impacted coaching and mentoring?
SPEAKER_02To me, culture is never separate from a mentoring relationship. And when it is, it often creates um barriers and boundaries. Um, so I grew up in a sharecropper's village in rural Southeast Missouri. Uh it was almost completely, I'll say homogeneously, African-American. But when I left, I went to a um university that was what we call PWIs or primarily white institutions. And so throughout my career, throughout my education, and um just professionally, I've often been an N of one or the first.
SPEAKER_02Um, and so I had some mentors, primarily mentors, not so many coaches early on, that really denied the fact that I was in any way different from anyone else that they had ever mentored before. Um, one mentor in particular, and I've written about this, uh, would always stop me whenever I said the word ask, because he I would say axe. And it's just a part of who I am.
SPEAKER_02And he would stop me every time and say, it's you're not cutting wood, it's ask, it's ask. And I just remember how how it's shut down my ability to like flow in my conversations, you know. And so when people try to say that, oh, you know, we treat, we can treat everyone the same, you don't get to know a person if you try to treat everyone the same. And I've also seen situations where if people aren't allowed to just be themselves, then I've had I've had people that were so worried about having saying something the wrong thing as my mentor, or that it really it was like that in and of itself was a barrier in the relationship.
SPEAKER_02And one of the things that I have chosen to do, and I talk to my students in my classes about this, is I come from a place of vulnerability where I've just chosen to trust first and to just let people be who they are and meet them where they are. Uh, otherwise, I feel like we kind of get stopped and stuck. And um, if a person feels as though they can't, and being raised in a way that may have created some biases and may have put you on the wrong side of historical marginalization, those are things that they can't change at this moment.
SPEAKER_02And so, how do we come together in those relationships and uh really support and serve one another? And I think that one of the important things that we can do as you know academics is to even in our current climate not uh deny the fact that difference in all types of ways, and I'm not being in any way uh in a box with this, is it's it's such an important part of the relationship, and everyone has difference.
SPEAKER_02Even me and my brother, who is like my Hebrew, is what I call him, raised by the same parents. We are different people, and we have we have different needs and different conversations and different relationships, and our culture, believe it or not, is different. We're five years apart, it's still different.
SPEAKER_00It's fascinating to hear, just to hear one person's perspective on it. So why don't we add a second and a third and then take a step back and think about what this means given that there's seven, eight billion. Angela, what what's been your personal experiences of how cultures impacted coaching and mentoring?
SPEAKER_03I I think back to um kind of the origins and and why I really became interested in this. And I went through my own coaching certification through um International Coaching Federation or ICF. Um and this program um culture was mentioned, but honestly, it was it was a slide, and the uh facilitators were brilliant, they were wonderful and almost apologetic that they they had this slide and had to get through the material, right?
SPEAKER_03I felt um discomfort, I'm not sure. Um, I was in Kansas, so I'm not I was the only uh uh black woman there, so I'm not sure that anyone else um held the same discomfort that I I did, but um the instructors, I remember at the time, the instructors said, um, this is a new slide. We're still trying to figure out how to talk about culture and um, you know, again, that kind of apology, you know, apologizing for it, right?
SPEAKER_03And they didn't quite know how to teach it and how to how to surface it. Um, there was no framework, there was no real modeling, there was no discussion of identity or power or what it means to coach across difference. And that absence really struck me and it stuck with me, especially since I've now become a coach in higher education, and I rarely see people who look like me. So as a black woman in academia, I'm often the only one in the room, and I know I'm not alone in that experience.
SPEAKER_03Um, but research tells us in both coaching and mentoring that outcomes improve when there's intentionality around matching, when clients or mentees um feel a sense of um cultural understanding, of safety, of being seen. And now that doesn't mean that you have to match by race and background, right? That's we we've had this whole definition now of culture and what that means and all the different manifestations of it. Um, but it does mean that you need to be culturally responsive as a coach, as a mentor.
SPEAKER_03Um, you need to ask yourself, how am I showing up? What assumptions am I bringing into the space? And you know, asking, you know, what kind of holding environment um am I creating? Um if I'm creating something where someone's identity is acknowledged and honored, right? Um I've seen firsthand how culture impacts trust and vulnerability, and ultimately how the coaching relationship or the mentoring relationship goes.
SPEAKER_03Um it can be very both can be very powerful tools um for enlightenment, for transformation, for the Client or the mentee. But if we don't really touch on culture, we risk reinforcing harm, even if it's unintentional. So for me, culture isn't an add-on like Katrina. It's at the core, right, of coaching and mentoring. And so I'll even take it a step further.
SPEAKER_03My own research has looked at um how black women navigate coaching and mentoring spaces, and particularly through the lens of code switching and identity management. How do we show up in spaces? And so for many of us, especially in these PWIs or professional environments, coaching isn't just about growth. It's also about negotiating like negotiating who we get to be in those spaces. And so if you take something as simple as hair, right?
SPEAKER_03I wear my hair in its natural state, how it grows out of its out of my head is how is is how it is, right? It's curly, sometimes it's unruly, but it's my hair and I love it. Um it's a choice, it's a statement. Natural black hair is often politicized in many spaces. And now imagine I'm an executive and I walk into a coaching session um visibly upset because a colleague um may be well intentioned, but maybe they touched my hair, right?
SPEAKER_03Without permission. That's not a small thing. Um, it's a violation of boundaries, it's a microaggression. I would even say it's a macroaggression, it's a reminder that I'm seen as different, right? And so if I go into a coaching session and my coach doesn't recognize that, or worse, brushes it off and says, Well, they meant well um people touch my hair all the time. I'm no longer fully in this coaching space. I'm managing my emotions, I'm a I'm man managing the coach's discomfort, my own sense of safety.
SPEAKER_03And I can guarantee I'm not getting the full value of that coaching session. And so this is where coaching is really or culture is really important. It's about creating a container where people can bring their best selves, their whole selves, especially the parts that might be marginalized. And so if we don't acknowledge culture in these spaces like coaching and mentoring, we risk turning it into another site where we might be silenced instead of being able to really grow.
SPEAKER_02I would just say I worked in HR for a while, and one of those HR business partners, I changed my hair all the time. And one of them walked up to me and she, you know, grabbed my hair. And um the VP could hear this conversation and she was like, What are you doing? Stop that. But I told her, I said, if you tell me you have new dental work and if I put my finger in your mouth and touch your teeth, how would you feel about that? You know, just because it's different or it's new doesn't give you the right to touch it and even and speak on it, you know.
SPEAKER_02Um, I just thought that was interesting. And it's in HR, of course, it's everywhere, you can't get away from it.
SPEAKER_01And and thank you for offering those examples because I think what we're talking about is uh we want to see difference, we want to acknowledge difference, we don't want to touch difference, so we have that clear. Um, and I think what's important is when we see difference and we acknowledge this and we embrace difference, we don't want to jump into conclusions that the hair defines you as a person, that you know, the change or the difference that is the only thing that you are, which is not.
SPEAKER_01And I think what I feel, my personal experience, is that because we're somehow our brains are trained to notice difference, this happens early on. I think there's researchers who talk about this, right? How babies are trained to see the differences in the world in order to start recognizing patterns, in order to um basically navigate the world in in you know whatever often also limited ways they they get to learn to experience the world, but or we get to learn to experience the world. But I think what's important is that we don't make judgment based on this visible uh differences that we perceive, and that we don't um jump into conclusions too quickly.
SPEAKER_01And I think that's a good reminder, both for us as we are coaches and mentors, but also my experience has been when I was a coachee or a mentee, that that was sometimes against me, that people heard my accent, my German accent, and they were like, Oh, she's German, so she is X, Y, and Z. And I'm like, wait a second, we haven't even talked about me yet, right? So there's a there's a clue that is being given. I was born in a different country and suddenly I'm the German, whatever that might mean. And of course, the risk is um that um, you know, in that in that experience I felt pigeon-holed, um, you know, stereotyped.
SPEAKER_01Of course, there's also, you know, like just how can I say, you know, me wanting to defend myself. And when you're already in a defensive state, that's not a good starting place to have a developmental conversation. And um, and that was just one experience of being in a coaching client position. I I also realized we're now here all we're united here as women in academia. Um, and I remember that before I joined academia and I was a so-called practitioner, or maybe if I'm lucky, a scholar practitioner, um, you know, that that was a kind of stereotyping as well, what a practitioner does versus what a scholar would do.
SPEAKER_01And I always felt a little bit odd at you know, at this differentiation because I think we use labels, yes, to differentiate or to also show how we have, you know, uh different or how we have experiences that might be in, let's say, working in business type organizations or um governmental organizations versus in academic um institutions. So I understand the differentiation, but why can a practitioner or why does a practitioner have to be different from a scholar and a scholar be different from a practitioner?
SPEAKER_01And why are these labels so so dominant? And I remember I think at some point when, for example, when you're in the publishing business, you always have like one line on um, you know, who you are, like what your title is, and if you have several affiliations or several titles, I mean that already doesn't work. So I think a good reminder that you know, not I mean, seeing difference and embraces it, embracing it, yes, but not jumping into conclusions or making the visible parts of the difference the only part that defines the person.
SPEAKER_01And I think that is super important to me, and I hope I hope it resonates also with you, Angela, and with you, Katrina, of having shared your experiences. Because yes, we're all different, and yet we have so many things that unite us.
SPEAKER_00Now, all three of you have at different points in the last half hour have used the term cultural responsiveness, which um may be a new term to some of the folks who are listening to the podcast, and I think your personal experiences there have done a great job of helping people uh understand what that term would mean and why it's important. Um, I think before we start digging a little into how to design coaching and mentoring from a what allow us for culture, I wonder if it's worth kind of wrapping up this first part of the conversation by digging into a little more about what role cultural responsiveness plays with coaching and mentoring relationships as a way of sort of summarizing where we've got to, and then we can start talking a bit about so what do we do with this?
SPEAKER_00Um, Henrietta, are you willing to help us move in that direction?
SPEAKER_01Yes, for sure. So I think it plays a huge role. I think it's the centerpiece of client and coach relationship. I think it's the part that is the foundation of building trust, and trust can be built through vulnerability. I think we talked about vulnerability in this conversation already, without vulnerability also of the coach, who, whether we like it or not, when you enter the space and you are the coach, you are kind of in a power position.
SPEAKER_01You're you're setting the scene for the conversation as it unfolds. You kind of indicate when the conversation starts and when it ends, you give nuance to the conversation through the questions. And when the coach, when I as the coach, don't show my own vulnerability and authenticity of being a human being, and also you know, showing that I do care in these more nuanced ways of seeing my counterpart, in this case my client, then I think anything like trust or growth can't really be built.
SPEAKER_01So I think it's the centerpiece. And what I like to think of why culturally responsive coaching is important, because not only does the client want to be heard, I mean, the listening part is a really important part of a developmental relationship, but the client also wants to be seen and wants to be respected. And I think this idea of heard, seen, respected, which is also liberating structure, that I like to use liberating structures as a set of microstructures that help us in one-on-one relationships, but also in bigger conversations, you know, be it in a department meeting or be it in a committee kind of setup, I think is an important building block of building the trust.
SPEAKER_01So um showing how we see each other, how we hear each other, how we respect each other in order to move on with the relationship. There are other things that come to mind, but I'd love to hear also from the colleagues here on this podcast to see how they would respond to this question of cultural responsiveness in their respective fields.
SPEAKER_02One of the exercises that I do whenever I speak on cultural responsiveness and mentoring or coaching is I use the iceberg as you know a framework for us to kind of look at, and we talk about what is above the surface and what is below the surface, and how many, how so many assumptions can be made about the things that you can see. Um, and then there are just so many other things that exist within an individual that you actually can't see.
SPEAKER_02And so, how do you set up a relationship with another person in a way that you acknowledge all of the things that are visible above that iceberg, the water level, but also allow a person to surface all of the rest of those things as needed in the relationship?
SPEAKER_03Going back to something you said earlier, Katrina, was that cultural responsiveness wasn't just a bonus or an add-on, right? It's baked in, it's foundational. Um, and and so if we think about coaching and mentoring as relational practices, um, if I don't feel safe or seen or affirmed in in my identity within that relationship, I'm not going to show up fully. I might shrink, I might code switch, I might disengage altogether.
SPEAKER_03And coaching is not cheap, right? Mentoring is not cheap either, right? We're we're we're pulling people out of a work environment to to you know to do things and have these relations relationships. And so that's that's you know, there's something to that, right? Um and so we want to make sure that we're making um the most of these relationships. Um, and it's it we don't want it to compromise um any kind of developmental relationship that can be formed.
SPEAKER_03And so in my experience, cultural responsiveness is the difference between maybe surface level support and true transformation. Um it's what creates this environment where someone can relate, reflect, take risks, and imagine new possibilities without having to explain or defend themselves or defend their humanity even. And so that responsive responsiveness doesn't mean that you have to share someone's background.
SPEAKER_03Um, it doesn't, but it does mean as a coach or mentor that you have to do the internal work. You have to check your assumptions, you have to listen this beautiful uh idea of the song beneath the words. You have to listen to what's going on underneath the surface and adapt your approach to who's in front of you. Um, it means that knowing that the that coaching and mentoring don't happen in a vacuum, they happen in systems with histories, with power dynamics, and we have to remain curious as coaches and mentors.
SPEAKER_03And if we say we're committed to equity in coaching and mentoring, then coach cultural responsiveness is not optional. It's the only ethical way forward for us.
SPEAKER_00Katrina, like a few minutes ago, you started using the word how. And so I'm gonna take us down that how path a little here. Because my guess is the people who are listening at this point will have will be buying into the importance of what you're saying and are seeing the need for this. And my guess is many of them are going, Great, I now know I should be doing this, but how? Um, so what advice do you have for listeners as to how to approach coaching and mentoring and maybe the design of coaching mentoring programs in a way that then allows for culture?
SPEAKER_02Absolutely. Um, I would say it starts with embedding cultural responsiveness from the ground up, not as an add-on, like Angela said earlier. Uh, and that means recruiting diverse mentors and coaches who reflect the communities that are being served, training mentors and coaches on the things that we've talked about before, like cultural humility, bias, microaggressions, macroaggressions, and then power dynamics as well.
SPEAKER_02Structuring the program to honor multiple definitions of success, allowing mentees to name their goals, not forcing them to fit into one size, fits all metrics. And one example I will share of that is when I was in my graduate program, um, I considered a lot of the women that were my professors, my mentors. And I married at 19, and we tried to have a child for years, even though I was a graduate student.
SPEAKER_02And whenever it surfaced that I was pregnant with my daughter, who's now turned 27 two days ago, um, one of them kind of like cornered me in the mail room and was like, I can't believe you did this. You just, you know, she completely um had her own definition of what success would look like to me, for me, and really, you know, scolded me for choosing to actually start a family when I chose to start a family. And so not being given the goals that another person wants for you.
SPEAKER_02And, you know, I was showing up completely and it wasn't accepted. And um, do you think I shared any of the experiences, bad or good, that I was having in terms of being pregnant and having a child with that particular person? No, I didn't. And she may have been helpful in a number of ways, but that really damaged that relationship. And then the other thing I would say is just building in reflection, both for mentors and mentees, to process how culture is actually influencing their relationship.
SPEAKER_02Because I think, I think sometimes, and we can all be guilty of this, I even with all of the things that you know we've all studied and all the things that we try to be aware of, one of the things that I constantly worry about is that people who have been marginalized get really good at code switching and trying to show the other person what that person needs in order for them to be safe and to survive. And so we need to make sure that those relationships are safe, not just because it's what we think, but how do we get to the point where we know that the mentees aren't just doing all of the things that they think we need them to do?
SPEAKER_02And that really depends upon what Henrietta was saying earlier about the vulnerability and building trust early and checking in often. I think we also need to look at what voices are actually shaping the program when it's being created, and what lived experiences are being looked at as a part of the design and the leadership of those programs.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. And I think, you know, um it starts really with us, the coaches, the mentors, to do that reflective piece. And as a cisgender female, currently able-bodied German-born, I mentioned that already, um international scholar, I, you know, I have to do the identity work and have to support others to do their identity work in order to be able to show up in the development of relationships with that sensitivity, the authenticity, the vulnerability.
SPEAKER_01And similar to Angela, when she mentioned her educational experience of becoming a coach or being certified as a coach, the current educational landscape, the landscape where we teach others or train others or facilitate conversations for others, with others to become a coach or mentor, I'm not sure we are there to include these elements, their culture work, the awareness work, the identity work with the individual, before we let them be in relationship with others.
SPEAKER_01Granted, we're all grown-ups, so we're in relationship with each other already, but before we become the professional with an ICF type of label with extra, you know, um uh letters behind your name as you're accredited to become the coach or mentor and then work with someone on these important topics. And so what Angela and I actually embarked on was um a research study that bear with us, it's not published yet, but hopefully at some point the manuscript will be out there uh for everyone to read, where we looked at what our educational providers in the space of coaching education doing to bring the aspect of cultural responsiveness in their programming so that the newer generations of coaches can actually learn to be more culturally responsive, meaning to do more identity work as they're being trained, and then they can show up in the ways they chose, but maybe in more nuanced ways if they choose to, in um in their coaching relationships.
SPEAKER_01And what we found, and we initially um reached out to about 435 uh coaching providers, all North American based, with a survey to see, you know, are people doing something about this? Is cultural competence even a thing in their lingo, in their programming, in their how they see their educational offering being there? And then we did, because the survey only showed us actually not so many organizations currently, at least not those who responded, showed up with yes, we do cultural competence coaching education programming.
SPEAKER_01We did follow up with actually, I think only about two handful of organizations said, Oh, yeah, we would actually like to do a one-on-one interview on this topic. So we followed up with them, and through these conversations, the more in-depth interviews, and we're writing up this as a comparative multiple case study right now. Um, we found so the organizations that are more culturally competent in their educational programming for coaching, they do a couple of things. And one thing was, and I loved how Katrina said, you know, it is always personal, like a lot of organizations who do this, there's a personal story why they do this, and it's also always intentional.
SPEAKER_01So that really stood out to us that there was someone in this, let's say, coaching certification program who had had a personal experience, why culture became important for them, why identity work was something that they wanted their coach trainees to become more fluent in. But also we looked at, you know, are there certain theoretical frameworks that are maybe being built upon that are useful if we think about cultural humility, cultural confidence, cultural intelligence.
SPEAKER_01And yes, we did a couple of frameworks, for example, Brasinski's Cultural Orientation Framework, that is a framework that actually helps new coaches to think about different dimensions of how culture shows up. Um, we also noticed that there Certain curriculum design strategies and also activities, we call them promising practices that actually help in coaching education on you know how to bring this topic closer to maybe a broader audience.
SPEAKER_01Um, and so I mentioned this study because I think, yes, on the one hand, we have our personal experiences, but when we have education providers, and frankly, a lot of higher education institutions play in this phase of training mentors, training coaches. I think there is a social responsibility that we hold, especially as people who realize that there is a lack of culturally aware coaching and mentoring currently being present, that we are move further towards supporting that those programs, highlighting and supporting the programs that are culturally responsive, and maybe making others who are not yet on, haven't haven't jumped on the bike yet or on the train yet to make them more aware that there is actually it's not so hard to do.
SPEAKER_01And yeah, Angela, I know you have probably uh ideas about our study as well, but um, in a nutshell, I'm learning a lot from listening to those people we've been in contact with.
SPEAKER_03I was really excited as I heard you talk about um our study, and and I think about what uh I'm really curious about. Um, and that's the stories of the educators themselves and how they came to their own worldview. Um and I think it's important when we talk about design of programs, right? Who whose worldview is embedded in the program? Um, what kind of models are you using? Um, what's the definitions that you're using and whose voice is considered neutral, right?
SPEAKER_03Who who are we kind of saying this is the norm? And here, you know, or are we even doing that in, you know, in the first place? And so I think that the, as we've said before, the design uh of culture um and cultural responsiveness has to be baked into the design of the program and not just kind of sprinkled into a workshop or a one-off session here or there. And that means maybe rethinking who gets to build the frameworks and how participants are are matched, how reflection is supported, as Katrina said, how we teach responsiveness and not just talk about it.
SPEAKER_03And I I'm I'm also curious about this idea of it being systemic, right? Um one of the you know HR quotes that that always strikes me is that or you put a changed person back into an unchanged system, the system wins all the time. So we can't just change the uh individual and expect them to thrive in an unchanged system. So if we train someone to be reflective and culturally responsive and equity-minded, and then someone um you know sends them back into an environment that rewards conformity, punishes difference, um, the system's gonna win every every time.
SPEAKER_03So um this is true in technology as well. I think about AI, right? AI is the mirror of its maker, and I think you can say that uh cultural responsiveness is the mirror of its maker as well. Um in AI sense, um facial recognition, even you know, HRIS uh algorithms that screen for fit, um, bias is built in unless we intentionally design against it.
SPEAKER_03So if the designer uh of culturally responsive programs doesn't center culture, the system automates exclusion. Um so when we talk about you know being innovative in coaching and mentoring or even in education, we have to ask who are we being innovative for? And so for me, it's not just making um space for culture, it's about redesigning systems with intentionality, with culture in mind, with equity in mind and a cultural responsiveness at the center.
SPEAKER_01Darren, and as a final thing, maybe we should all start by just introducing yourself with our own cultural autobiography going forward. And that would be around, you know, who are we as the individual who are showing up in this space today? Uh, as the, you know, I mentioned the cisgender female, currently able-bodied German-born international scholar who comes from a family that has been migratory for many generations. And I come to the discussion with curiosity and a willingness to learn. And I wonder, you know, how that would be different if we start with an autobiography of that sort versus maybe how we start the conversation.
SPEAKER_01I just thought I wanted to leave that with you as well.
SPEAKER_00Well, I I'm conscious we've got many more questions to dig into and no time in which to dig into them, at least not in this episode, which makes me feel as if we have an argument for a follow-up episode where we can take this to the next level, um, which I think would be fascinating. Um but unfortunately, with us hitting our time limit for the day, like I wanted to say a big thank you to all three of you. I think the the three of you between you've done a fantastic job of raising people's understanding as to why this is important, um, and to then move them into the space of what this means in terms of the design of programs.
SPEAKER_00And I'm sure that's already getting them to a space of what this means for them as individual coaches or mentors and actions they can be taking. And if we have a follow-up episode, I think that's where we would start digging into more of okay, so how do they start developing as individuals? Um, but for this episode, I wanted to say a big thank you to all three, and thank you so much for taking time out of your busy days to be with me today. Thank you so much.
SPEAKER_00Thank you so much for joining me for this episode. It was wonderful spending time with Henrietta Lungren, Angie Carter, and Katrina Reed Hughes. If you enjoyed this episode, check out our other 51, which contain conversations with over 100 leading scholars from around the world. To learn more about the series, check out HRDmasterclass.com. And to learn about the Academy of Human Resource Development, check out ahrd.org. Also, don't forget to look into our sponsor for the episode, the Department of Technology Leadership and Innovation at Purdue University.
SPEAKER_00By visiting their website at bit.ly slash Purdue HRD. That's one word, Purdue HRD. I'll be back next week with an episode focused on how to prepare the next generation of HRD professionals, when I'll be joined by Brian Vivona, Stephanie Sisko, and Ronan Carberry. Until then, stay state. This is Darren Short signing off from the HRD Masterclass Podcast.com.
This fourth episode of Season 6 brings together Dr. Sanghamitra Chaudhuri (Temple University) and Dr. Kyung Nam Kim (Texas A&M University) for a conversation about the 2026 article Gendered Pathways to Work-Family...
This third episode of Season 6 brings together Dr. Yuanlu Niu (University of Arkansas) and Dr. Jos Akkermans (Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam) for a conversation about the 2026 article Navigating careers in non-traditional...
This second episode of Season 6 brings together Dr. Matthew Hurtienne (University of Texas at Tyler) and Dr. Heesun Kim (Francis Marion University) for a conversation about the 2024 article Silence in the workplace:...
This first episode of Season 6 brings together Dr. Joshua Collins (University of Minnesota) and Dr. Ague Mae Manongsong (Louisiana State University) for a conversation about the 2023 article “Manongsong, A. M., & Ghosh,...
Welcome to the trailer for Season 6 of Human Resource Development Masterclass - the podcast series from the Academy of Human Resource Development, the organization that leads HRD through research. The sixth season...