Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Human Resource Development Masterclass

Human Resource Development Masterclass artwork

Strategic Human Resource Development

Aug 24, 20211 hr 9 minAudio

In this tenth episode of HRD Masterclass, guests Dr. Thomas Garavan (University College Cork, Ireland) and Dr. Holly Hutchins (University of North Texas, USA) discuss strategic HRD, including: How strategic HRD leads to improved organizational performance. What it means for an organization to practice strategic HRD. The relationship between strategic HRD and strategic HRM. How HRD practitioners can become more strategic. The importance of speaking the language of business. In the first part of the episode, Thomas and Holly meet one-to-one with host, Darren Short. In the second part, they are together to discuss their shared interest in strategic HRD. For full details on the HRD Masterclass series, visit hrdmasterclass.com. For more information on the Academy of Human Resource Development, visit ahrd.org - by being a member of AHRD, you can access bonus materials not included in this episode. This episode is sponsored by: Interpretive Simulations. Find out about their services and their HRManagement simulation at https://www.interpretive.com/

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_01Many learning and development HOD professions do not think strategically. They think in a very operational, tactical way. And that perhaps limits their impact within the organization.

SPEAKER_02Welcome to Human Resource Development Masterclass, the new podcast series from the Academy of Human Resource Development, the organization that leads HRD through research. I'm your host, Darren Short, and throughout this first series, I'll be joined by leading authors, researchers, and scholars to explore the fundamentals of HRD and how those are changing in the 2020s. Our focus for this episode is strategic HRD, and we'll be exploring how strategic HRD leads to improved organizational performance, what it means for an organization to practice strategic HRD, the relationship between strategic HRD and strategic HRM, how HRD practitioners can become more strategic in their work, and much more.

SPEAKER_02To help me, I'll be joined by two leading scholars. Dr. Thomas Garavan, Professor of Leadership Practice in Cork University Business School at University College Cork, Island, and Dr. Holly Hutchins, Vice Provost of Faculty Success at the University of North Texas, United States. In the first part of the episode, I'll chat one-to-one with each of them, and then for the second part, Thomas and Holly are together to explore their shared interest in strategic HRD.

SPEAKER_02That discussion is brought to you with the help of the generous support of our sponsor, Interpretive Simulations. Find out more about their services at interpretive.com. All of the content you'll hear in this episode was recorded during May and June of 2021. Right, let's dive in to meet my first guest. My first guest for the episode is Dr. Thomas Garavan, Professor of Leadership Practice in Cork University Business School at University College Cork, Ireland.

SPEAKER_02He is a world-leading expert in leadership development, learning and development, and HRD. Thomas has published 185 journal articles, 16 books, 26 book chapters, and six monographs, including extensively in the leading HRD journals, the top four HRM journals, and leading management journals. His most recent book publications include Learning and Development in Organizations, a Systems Informed Model of Effectiveness, published by Palgrave, and Strategic Human Resource Management, published by Oxford University Press.

SPEAKER_02Thomas is co-editor of the European Journal of Training and Development and Associate Editor of Personnel Review. He was recently elected to the Hall of Fame of the Academy of Human Resource Development and has won numerous awards for publications as well as journal editing. Hi, Thomas. Welcome to the HRD Masterclass podcast. It's great to have you here in our episode focused on strategic human resource development.

SPEAKER_01Well, I am very delighted to be involved. I think it's a very important endeavor for AHRD.

SPEAKER_02Strategic HRD is likely to be a new term to many of the people listening to this. And so I thought a good place to start would be to explore what's meant by the term and how strategic HRD differs from HRD.

SPEAKER_01How I define HRD and how I've defined it for the past 30 years is that it involves investments by organizations in the human capital of employees to achieve organization performance. Now I appreciate that that's a short definition, but in underpinning that or within it, there are a lot of very important uh subtleties and nuances. The very first thing that needs to be said is that uh having reference to the very famous Swanson continuum of learning and performance as the orientations of HRD, strategic HRD really focuses on the performance end of that continuum.

SPEAKER_01And so therefore differs somewhat from more traditional HRD conceptualizations and conceptualizations such as development, training, and learning, which more give emphasis to the learning piece. Now, admittedly, learning is important, but performance is the really important component of strategic human resource development. One of the other things about strategic HRD, it gives emphasis to the notion of alignment, and in this case, strategic alignment or what we call vertical alignment. In other words, that the things that the HOD practitioner does day-to-day in organizations contribute to building the knowledge, skills, abilities, and behaviors and values that will best help the organization to realize its business strategy.

SPEAKER_01Now, that all sounds great in clearing. However, some from my research uh down to the years, I've I've realized that many HRG practitioners don't have a great appreciation of the strategy in some cases, or a knowledge of it, or they are not in a position hierarchically or structurally within the organization where they can glean what current strategic thinking is. Because in many organizations, and especially in SMEs, which I've studied quite a bit, they may never articulate in a formal term what their business strategy is.

SPEAKER_01And likewise, learning and development may operate, and HOG may operate in a very informal way. So, therefore, the practitioner in that situation has to make it up and improvise and learn on the hoof as the goal, so to speak, and to find out what's required. And often in those situations, investments in HOD are often very reactive. They are done when a problem or a gap arises rather than proactive to build to help to help the organization with strategy implementation.

SPEAKER_01So that's one of the big things that there's that there's a gap or a misfit between um what's articulated by the organization, but also what reading the L and D or the HRD profession can make of it to try and make sure that they do the right things. And then the other, I think, controversial point about strategic HRD is this do you invest in all of your human resources, or do you invest in the strategically more valuable human resources? And that I would say is another big area where SHRD differs from traditional HRD.

SPEAKER_01Traditional HRD takes a more inclusive, uh equitable, and uh all-embracing approach that all employees are valued to the organization. Or all employees, human capital makes a contribution. Whereas an extreme form of strategic HRD would say that actually employees have different value. And depending on their position in the organization, the role that they perform, then it may be appropriate to make more investments in development and training and HRD generally in those to gain maximum effect.

SPEAKER_01So that I suspect that represents three of the more um fundamental components of SHRD, and I've highlighted as well how it potentially differs from more traditional notions of HRD.

SPEAKER_02There is a um a sense within practitioners that just because I've got an HRD strategy document that that makes me doing strategic HRD. But it sounds like that isn't the case. I think I could have an HRD strategy document that that focuses HRD on the wrong things. Absolutely. So having an HRD strategy document doesn't imply that you're doing strategic HRD by the sound effects. Absolutely.

SPEAKER_01One of the problems we're having a strategy document, even if it's an HRD strategy document, it's a very static thing, and organizations are continuously changing. So therefore, what may be written down a year ago may no longer apply as we've seen post-COVID or as we're coming out of COVID, many ways in which the organizations operated have to fundamentally change. And that is one of the criticisms that's often made against HRD practitioners, is they lack the agility or the ability to pivot to meet the fundamental change requirements of the organization and deliver the type of learning solutions that were necessary.

SPEAKER_01And I did a survey on this last year, which I published, a short survey, which was done with Irish and UK LD practitioners. And we asked them in that survey, I was with a team of researchers, what was the most typical thing they encountered when it came to responding to COVID? And that was uh they told me was to get out of the traditional ways of doing things, think differently about the way in which HRD could be delivered, but most fundamentally of all, to talk to your point, to prioritize what we should really focus on now, rather than all things to all people be more precisely focused to meet the very uh crisis needs that might have existed at that time.

SPEAKER_02So it does sound uh from listening to that, it sounds as if a critical piece to be to strategic HRD is being close to the business and but close to executives. And and that's that's often a challenge for HRD practitioners. They find themselves maybe in an HRM function or they find they can't get to executives because they have to go through other leaders. Um if you were talking to HRD practitioners about how to get around some of those problems, what what what are the things you've seen work?

SPEAKER_01I published a monograph last year in European Journal of Training and Development, which actually talked to that point. Number one, um there was no doubt about it, is of where the L and D function was a separate function, and the head of that position was on a senior board or a senior management team within the organization. That gave the function greater profile, also greater potential to be proactive, but also to pivot and to be strongly strategically aligned.

SPEAKER_01One of the interesting things that came up in that survey was that um LD professionals told me in some cases that they were reporting to a HR manager who was very employee relations or industrial relations oriented, and therefore they found themselves not having a great ear when it came to articulating LD issues in the organization. And then what they told me, I asked them specifically to come to your point was what can they do to um to raise their profile?

SPEAKER_01And they told me two or three things which are very interesting. Number one, that whatever they do, they do it very well, publicize it and get senior management sponsorship first. Get somebody outside of the HR function in a senior role, be it the CEO, be it a manager or director level, to sponsor that program. And that gives them a higher degree of visibility and that these senior executives who are the decision makers ultimately can see what is going on in the organization.

SPEAKER_01Number two, uh they told me that it's important to involve senior stakeholders in the design of these learning events, HOD events, whatever they are. Many times the LD function is asked to do something, it goes off and does it, but doesn't consult or involve. So, therefore, involve the senior team so that they have greater ownership of this particular intervention. And the third thing is to evaluate the success of any high-profile training HOD intervention and to publicize those results because it's through a process of feedback on what those results show that they may have a basis to get resources for future investment.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, the that evaluation piece is particularly interesting to me. When I look at a lot of organizations and the way that they evaluate HRD, they're gathering vast amounts of data on metrics that really don't matter.

SPEAKER_01Well, I make a very important distinction between lead lead and lag measures when it comes to evaluation. And a lot of training L and D professionals, HOD professions are very good at the lead things. These are the things that are immediately can be immediately measured. So they include all the stuff around efficiency, how many people attended, how many courses were done, what was the perception of it in terms of reaction satisfaction level and the perceived utility and value of it? They do great on that, but they do not do well on the lag pieces.

SPEAKER_01And the lag pieces are uh what was the level of training transfer? Did it go back into the workplace? How did it impact, say, productivity levels? How did it impact health and safety? Did customer satisfaction scores go up? Was sales performance improved? Was there a better focus on quality, et cetera, et cetera? And for example, was there more innovation in terms of the number of ideas created and all those types of things? Now, they don't measure those. Now, I admit and acknowledge that to measure those effectively, they need to set up some good designs and good evaluation designs.

SPEAKER_01Otherwise, they're not, will not be able to say with confidence did the investment in HRD actually lead to those things, or was it other factors that might have explained those outcomes? But that's the real conundrum.

SPEAKER_02Um it's interesting there because it takes me, I think, into um the theories that underpin this, because one of one of the one of the one of the topics or threads that has gone through the podcast episodes that we've created is the gap between research and theory on one hand and practice on the other when it comes to HRD. And so, how do you picture the theoretical base behind strategic HRD?

SPEAKER_01HRD theory is rather narrow in terms of the number of theories used. The predominantly used human capital theory and the resource-based view, those make up the greater number of theoretical perspectives that are used to investigate a very fundamental relationship, and that is the relationship between investment in HRD and organizational financial performance. So there is very a very narrow set of theories. Those theories suggest a long-term, a longer, longitudinal relationship between investments in HRD and performance.

SPEAKER_01However, many studies, and the vast majority of them, measure impacts cross-sectionally. They gather data on training at point one and on performance at point one, rather than say gathering data on training at point one and performance at point two, three, and four, to really show that there's a longitudinal uh impact. The third difficulty and challenge that I find in much of the research looking at strategic HD and performance is that they don't have what I call predictive research designs.

SPEAKER_01They don't get baseline measures of everything to start with before they start to show that performance has improved as a result of training. And they typically only gather one measure of training rather than looking at how training might vary over a period and then showing is dynamically do differential or different investments and training results in different performance levels. And the really holy grail of all of this is that very little of the research that we have today can show causation, that there's an actual direct causal relationship between investment in HRD and organizational performance.

SPEAKER_01And even more uh intriguing and problematic is that there is no research, absolutely no study that I know of that has looked at reverse causality. Well, if the organization achieves good performance benefits as a result of investment in HRD, do those good performance results imbue amongst senior executives the confidence that we continue to invest in HRD so that we can get future performance gains.

SPEAKER_01And that reverse causality relationship is not established in the literature.

SPEAKER_02My sense is that um when a practitioner asks a question about strategic HRD, the easiest response to any of those questions would be, well, it depends. It depends on what your organization's like, it depends on what your executives are like, it depends, and so that makes it difficult, I would imagine, to come up with an area of investigation that can provide a generalizable statement.

SPEAKER_01Absolutely, yes. A lot of the research on the HRG investment organization performance link has assumed a direct relationship, which is a very simple, in other words, if you invest in training, you get a performance improvement, an organizational performance improvement. But in fact, that's a very simplistic way to look at it. It's more than likely an indirect or what we call a mediated relationship. And the key thing is um, the key thing is that there's a causal chain, there's a chain of consequences between investment and training to enhanced human capital to enhanced motivation to enhance performance.

SPEAKER_01Because I've just completed a more recent meta-analysis which shows that that it's a it's a sequential relationship, that if you invest in training, it definitely enhances human capital. But if your employees are not sufficiently motivated, they will not give their human capital or contribute it to the organization. And as a result, the organization will not gain performance advantages. So therefore, you must train. If you train, employees must be motivated to contribute to human capital because we are all owners of our own human capital, so we must contribute it to the organization for the organization to gain benefit from it.

SPEAKER_01Then the second thing that I would say, and you used a very interesting word there in your question called conditions, and I call those boundary conditions or moderate. So, for example, we we haven't enough of insights on what impact does firm size have on the HRD, strategic HRD performance relationship? Does sector make an impact? Does the fact the organization is high or low intensity, uh technology intensity make an impact?

SPEAKER_01Does the fact that the um that the organization is very service-oriented, how impactful is that? Are there are there are there contingencies or or conditions that relate to where it's where the company is located? Is it located, say, in a high uh human capital country where there's a lot of investment in human capital? What role do national cultural factors have? Say performance orientation, say uh learning orientation, say collectivism versus individualism.

SPEAKER_01We have loads of gaps. So we don't fully understand all of these contingencies that might impact on the relationship.

SPEAKER_02It sounds like underpinning a lot of your answers, there's almost a call to action, like uh to say to HRD practitioners, look, there's a missed opportunity here. There is there's something you should be doing. What would you recommend are the first steps for an HRD practitioner in taking this journey towards strategic HRD?

SPEAKER_01Many organizations train and invest in HRD, but they invest in it not because they need to do it, but because it's might be perceived as a good thing to do. And they often do not know the needs that they are, the learning needs. That very famous piece of the systematic training cycle, identify your training needs, is actually rarely done in practice. There must be a back to basics here. Let's see what it is is the need.

SPEAKER_01The next thing that I would say then is picking the right HRD strategy. That's a fundamental thing. A lot of people and a lot of organizations and a lot of HRD professionals like the classroom. Now, the classroom has been up-ended with COVID, etc. Now, the classroom is great for certain types of generic skills. However, it may be more appropriate to have the training and the HRD intervention applied on the job, using a structured instructional method on the job that may enhance transparent.

SPEAKER_01Or there may be times where it was better off to use a virtual solution because it's a knowledge-based thing and you can get wide coverage. So they often don't make the best choices in terms of matching the learning solution to the need that has arisen. Now, at a more general level, I would say that if if all if the HRD practitioners want to get good evidence from researchers, then they must allow us in to do the research and let us come in, let us set up the designs that are necessary to gather the data on high profile training interventions or whatever they might be, or HRD interventions, and let us gather the data and stay with us.

SPEAKER_01Be patient, wait for the results to come through because there's a big tendency for quick answers. Oh, they love the course, they were all thrilled with been on the program, but that reaction and that effective reaction doesn't necessarily mean that it has any impacts on organizational performance. And then I would say a lot of training and HRD, the benefits of are lost because the organization culture and climate are not right. So you must have the right contextual conditions within which to do a learning and development, HRD, strategic HRD, simply because if you invest in knowledge, skills, and abilities, and the organization's climate, its culture, and the levels of morale are low, then the reality is that you will lose a lot of the benefits of it.

SPEAKER_01And more than likely, you might be developing people to leave the organization rather than to retain the skills that are required.

SPEAKER_02Well, Thomas, I really enjoyed our conversation today. Thank you so much.

SPEAKER_01Thank you so much. And I hope that I've said a few things that might encourage our research community to think differently about how they research the HTTRG organization performance link.

SPEAKER_02Well, please stay with us and be rejoining us after I've had a conversation with Holly. So thank you so much indeed. She just recently assumed the role of Vice Provost of Faculty Success at the University of North Texas.

SPEAKER_02Prior to this position, Holly was professor and department chair in the College of Technology at the University of Houston. Holly's research has focused on training transfer, crisis management, and more recently, faculty talent development. Holly's research has been featured in multiple peer-reviewed journals and across global media outlets such as NPR, the BBC, Psychology Today, and The Guardian. Her TEDx talk on overcoming your inner critic is based on her innovative research on the impact of imposter phenomena on work and career outcomes.

SPEAKER_02Hi Holly, welcome to the HRD Masterclass podcast. Great to have you here in our episode focused on strategic HRD.

SPEAKER_00Thank you so much, Jaren. I am so excited to be here with you.

SPEAKER_02In my conversation with Thomas, um, he and I explored the importance of strategy and being strategic. And now I know as a scholar and as a practitioner within a scholarly setting, you've developed strategies in practice. And so I'm interested in your experience of doing that and the lessons that you've learned.

SPEAKER_00I'll speak to it from the lens of a faculty member and also as a higher ed leader in a formal leadership position. I, you know, I think I think in both of those roles, you have to be very mindful of the direction the organization's going. You know, what is their strategic plan? What are their goals? And we know that the goals shift sometimes really rapidly, especially in this last year. And as we think about aligning the learning development, talent, talent development function with those goals, what does that mean for us locally?

SPEAKER_00And certainly as a departmental leader, how do my uh colleagues understand that? And so certainly one of the lessons learned is is is to be that translator and co-translator really with your colleagues. What is what does this mean for us? Organizations saying we should do this, we should be mindful of this, we should be doing this in the next two to four years. What does that mean for us? And what what gifts and strengths does your team bring to that? And how can we understand that so it makes sense and there's some there's some buy-in?

SPEAKER_00Another lesson is that are we doing some of that work anyway? What are some exemplary practices that we are finding across our organization or our team? Are there people ramping up and doing great work? Who are those people? What can we learn from those people? So it's it's very much an inquiry perspective too. And when we can find local examples of implementing the strategy or innovating the strategy, making it work maybe on a small budget or making it work with a small team.

SPEAKER_00I want to understand the aspects of that to be able to scale that up. And lastly, I think it's really critical to measure our work because we don't know how we're doing in alignment with the strategy unless we go back and say, well, this is what we aspire to do, this is what we articulated. Um, how are we doing? And how can we adjust in practice to that? Because it's not linear. We've certainly seen through COVID that it's it's more of a zigzag and sometimes a fallback.

SPEAKER_00And oh my goodness, what do we do now? And so assessing where we are and feeding that back into the system uh and making adjustments as we go. I found that my colleagues along the way, when we do things like that, are are more inclined to stay with me as a leader, stay with the flow and the uncertainty if they feel like you know their needs and issues and contributions are really being valued.

SPEAKER_02In listening to your answer there, it makes me feel like a lot of what you're doing is being strategic. Um, through through the relationships that you're building and the conversations that you're having. And and what I'm wondering is how you take that being strategic and turn it into a strategy.

SPEAKER_00I think as co-creators of the direction we want to go, you know, being able to engage those conversations in a really strategic way, we are developing strategy. So I could simply come in, which often happens in organizations, and I'll say in a higher ed, the academy, it happens too. It's very top-down. Um, this is what you'll be doing, thus go, right? And of course, there's going to be resistance. Um, what I've what I've found is that in that co-creation, this is this is this is where the organization you know wants to go.

SPEAKER_00We want to focus on lessening student debt. We want to make our curriculum more inclusive. We want to develop, let's say, a college of medicine or or develop urban health practitioners. You know, those those are directions that are that are really important right now at the University of Houston. And so that can still be the goal, but how we get there is is has to be strategic and inclusive. And so I have noticed in the leaders that I have served with that they can have a direction.

SPEAKER_00People can be excited about it, but how we get there, uh, that that that pathway has changed. And I think that evolution of being strategic and engaging these conversations helps us at the end develop a more strategic perspective because it's informed. And, you know, they always say what culture eats strategy all the time. Um, so it needs to be informed by the people that will enact that strategy. So I agree with that. Like the way in which you engage discussions of strategy, you're being strategic in doing that, which leads to more of that strategic direction.

SPEAKER_02So it sounds as if being strategic and developing strategies, that there's a mindset around that, which um so sort of an attitude around the importance of strategy, and then all of the skills and knowledge that goes with being able to have those conversations and turn those conversations into a strategic direction. So there's a lot there in terms of mindset or attitude and and skills and knowledge. Um, what I'm wondering is how well we prepare HRD practitioners for doing that sort of work and whether we could be doing more to cover strategic HRD in our education programs.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, and and HRD is in its infancy and its evolution, is strategic. It's it is an applied uh perspective that, you know, as as we go in as HRD scholars and practitioners to prepare our students, they need to be involved in in projects and in interacting with HRD professionals who value an evidence-based approach. And so, in my experience, we do have several practicing professionals, you know, HRD professionals teaching our classes as adjuncts.

SPEAKER_00We also, University of Houston, have a very successful executive human resource development master's program. And in that program, we probably have a ratio of, I don't know, uh, four or five um very successful HRD practitioners, and I think two two ordinary faculty members, me of me including uh me as one of those individuals, who also do consulting and and uh grant work with with different industries. So um I think the exposure to um HRD professionals, they're bringing their insight, um influencing the curriculum, um, having them really pose scenarios and case studies to students, and then students doing applied projects.

SPEAKER_00Um we bring a lot of projects from from industry through our advisory board, um, who are uh the University of Houston, vice president level and above. So that they're they're in that strategic role. And so um having them bring projects and internships and really getting our students prepared, not only in the language change, but in their concept, in their application of the theories and and the ideas that we present and they read about, um, they're seeing that in practice.

SPEAKER_00And so um I think that that's essential if we espouse to be an applied discipline, you know, leading the field through research. What does that mean exactly? And and I think that when you if you don't have that exposure and that connection to um individuals in practice that are students are going to remain in the conceptual realm and not really get understand how you translate that into the applied realm. And and many students arrive, and I would argue, across the nation and internationally with some experience.

SPEAKER_00Um, our job, I think, as educators is to elevate and expand that experience. And I think the curriculum is is a is a pathway to do that.

SPEAKER_02And then for a practitioner who is not currently in education, if if I take what you you're saying there, it sounds as if a good way of learning to be strategic then is to be networking and getting close to HRD practitioners who are strategic. So they can they can learn from them as to how they're doing it.

SPEAKER_00Yes, I would I would agree with that. And and you know, there's of course the mentoring research, you know, certainly supports this, that a variety of different um connections and and you know, people in your network that can really inform that understanding. I I learn a lot from my colleagues in the academy. I learn a lot from my colleagues that are practitioners, I learn a lot from the people that have a foot in in all of those areas. And so I think the strength of your network and your community is is so very important in that way to learn about, you know, how does how does it look across different organizations?

SPEAKER_00Um, what does it mean to be strategic? Because we're we're one thing that's that is not the same, but it's certainly similar, is how businesses have had to adjust to you know to COVID and to the um increasing focus, as should be, um, the long-overdue focus on social justice and anti-racism work. I mean, there's there's a lot to learn about how to make that more of the strategic focus. In fact, I heard a wonderful um uh quote, um Iko Batheya, who Brene Brown uh uh works a lot with as her um diversity uh officer.

SPEAKER_00And she said, you know, uh we used to talk about DENI as separate, but DENI really is leadership development. Maybe shouldn't even be called about you know DEI anymore. It's central. And so strategically, we're seeing movement within that, but that's becoming a lot more integrated.

SPEAKER_02Sounds as if, as we talk about the practice of being strategic, that a key piece of that is being close to the business and being able to have conversations with the business about where the organization is going, um, what challenges they're facing that HRD can help with. Uh, I know from my experience as a practitioner that one of the things I had to learn early on was the importance of being able to have those conversations using the language of the business, so the language that executives speak and the language of business metrics.

SPEAKER_02Given your experience of being close to practitioners who are going through education programs, do you find that they naturally are able to speak those languages? And if they don't, what can we be doing to help them?

SPEAKER_00Um, I think it depends on on the students that come into our programs. Some will have, you know, that experience or they're they're you know working in organizations like that. And so our students that that don't have that language or those concepts, some of that is being you know understood and observed and and modeled through that. Um, so I think that's one of the the blessings of having a diverse you know program or uh attracting diverse students.

SPEAKER_00Um but it's certainly essential as they are progressing into whether they're going into another position or going into an HRD or HR position for the first time. And so I I go back to not only faculty members, um, both you know, HRD scholars and HRD um scholarly practitioners, and you know, using that language, um, talking to students about and putting and giving them readings and and guest guest speakers that who talk about different aspects.

SPEAKER_00And so I think that language development can certainly be modeled. One thing we we often tell students is I know that you've learned something because your language is changing and your the way that you describe things, the way that you approach um performance issues is different. And I know that because you're behaving differently, and a lot of that is through language. Um and then immersing them in these apply projects where the the professionals, um the clients, if you will, um interact with them.

SPEAKER_00And so they're picking up cues, they're they're understanding different ways of communicating their message with with their clients who are industry individuals. And and so that is also a form of education for them as well.

SPEAKER_02It sounds like almost as if the HRD practitioner has to be bilingual in a way. I be able to speak one language and set of terms with their fellow HRD colleagues and then be able to speak a separate, a similar but different language when they're in the room with executives.

SPEAKER_00Yes. And I don't know if it is completely code switching there, because as HRD becomes more strategic and are in those strategic conversations, then they I think should also be using that same language with their colleagues. And uh, but of course, yes, the translation. Well, what does that actually mean, really? You know, because strategic, you know, uh working a strategic level, sometimes it's it's not well defined.

SPEAKER_00It's not, you know, and it's really like on the ground, what does this mean? Okay. But we we have moved, I know, as a field from being less transactional to more uh transformative and strategic, where we are guiding ideas about talent development, we're bringing ideas to the table. And so that translation mode of making that understandable for non-HR or HRD people is really important. And I think that just observing what employers are looking for with even our undergraduate students now, but certainly our graduate students, you need to be able to talk that language because we're seeing students even brought in and in a generalist role or an analyst role, because they have a strategic perspective that's represented in their language and decisions that they make and suggestions that they make, they're quickly pulled into more specialist roles.

SPEAKER_00They're quickly pulled into more OD work, even though maybe they were hired as an instructional designer. But because they're slowing down around needs assessment, asking good questions about evaluation, asking important ideas about how we're gaining, you know, engaging feedback and addressing resistance, they're they are speaking, they're speaking the language of strategy.

SPEAKER_02I like the sound there of HRD professionals having those kinds of strategic conversations. Of course, in some organizations, HRD professionals have to work through HRM colleagues to engage the business or or to engage business leaders. So, in your experience, does that create a barrier to HRD being as strategic as it could be?

SPEAKER_00I would agree with that. And that's certainly been the history um of you know, when we think about it, the the C-suite level, um only really in the last decade or so have we had a chief learning officer who who sometimes is part of the HR team, um, sometimes not. Um, but there has always been a chief people officer, you know, called, you know, a VP of HR, et cetera, et cetera. And so it can be a barrier in the wide portfolio of what HR, using that term generally, has to deal with, you know, the recruiting and safety and and and um onboarding and benefits.

SPEAKER_00I mean, there's so many different aspects. I I usually tell students that HRD is the better part of HR. But um, but I do believe that. I do believe if you talk about learning and development, that is across all aspects of HR. And if you don't have a strong learning development portfolio, it's not central to the HR function, then I'm not sure how successful the HR function is going to be.

SPEAKER_00Um and so yes, I think that the the traditional way that HRD professionals have been positioned or cast um within the organizational framework can be can be limiting. Uh, I think organizations now in understanding how to respond to change and understanding that it's not always about being first or or you know just immediately reacting to something. I think building that learning and development piece to it allows HR to be a lot more strategic.

SPEAKER_00And I'll give you one example. Um, you know, again, talking about diversity and equity and inclusion and all the rush to do something. Um, a lot of organizations have handled that recklessly. Uh, just you know, have a listening session, um, which may or may not be well orchestrated or facilitated. Um, let's quickly do training, let's quickly get a guest speaker without really understanding what the felt needs are holding space for our uh Black, Latinx individuals with intersectional identities, you know, all of that to you know to share their experiences.

SPEAKER_00And so I know that some of the rush to be action-oriented has done more harm now. HRD professionals would say, I think, believe, let's have some discussions, let's really understand what's going on, let's educate our leadership team, let's slow down. We can we can make some announcements, we can talk about you know how we're coming together. We don't need to try to band-aid this. And I I and I'm not saying HRM professionals would do that.

SPEAKER_00HRD brings a much different approach to understanding change, the emotional aspect of change and how to engage that. And so it's it's

SPEAKER_02a real asset um that we that we're bringing into organizations and and the reason i know that um not just believe it but i know it is because we're watching our students um really outpace some hrm students they come in with a with a with a much different skill set can understand the business part of it but but bringing in a very strategic understanding of change and strategy and and that's made the world a difference it's made the world a difference in their careers they've quickly been snatched up by you know other parts of the organization or they've been hired out the other other um organizations so they're quite competitive and they bring this this very rich skill set into into an organization excellent well thank you so much holly i've really enjoyed our conversation today on strategic hrd me too thanks Darren so stay with us and we'll bring Thomas back in for our group discussion up next we have the group discussion where my guests are together to discuss their shared passion for the episode's topic this discussion is brought to you thanks to the sponsorship support of interpretive simulations since 2008 students and trainees have used interpretive simulations HR management simulation where participants are tasked to make challenging decisions at the HR director level in a simulated environment students must build a strong HR function at their simulated medium-sized organization and wrestle with the challenges of staying on budget.

SPEAKER_02The simulation makes the connection between concept and practice while students learn by doing. It comes with assignments, mini cases and quizzes to reinforce core HR principles. If you'd like to receive faculty access to review the HR management simulation visit them at www.interpretive com and fill out a demo request welcome back to the HRD Masterclass podcast.

SPEAKER_02Our focus for this episode is Strategic HRD and I've already met one-to-one with Thomas Garavan and with Holly Hutchins and for the final section of the episode we're all together for our group chat. So welcome back Thomas and Holly thank you Darren thank you very much. Thank you so much for excited to be here in our individual conversations we touched on the relationship between HRD and HRM. And I'd like to dig more into that specifically I'm wondering how strategic HRD compares to strategic HRM and what the relationship is between HRD and HRM at a strategic level well that is a very fundamental question Darren and it's one that I frequently get asked when I come before HRM students in particular first of all I say that the remit of HRM in an organization is much broader than the remit of HRD.

SPEAKER_01So for example I see the remit of HRM to be concerned with finding talent uh developing it retaining it and managing the relationship with people in the organization. So given what I've said there HRD specifically focuses in on the developing piece. And so HRD is very much about the development of people and I also emphasize that what HRD does in the strategic space must align with all the other things that HRM does in the relationship retention recruitment pieces of the of the HR architecture.

SPEAKER_01And what's interesting is uh we if you remember back to my first um piece of this masterclass I talked about horizontal alignment and that's the term I use here to say that HRD and strategic HRD must align with uh what HRM is doing. Otherwise you will have a poor fit between practices in each of the different domains and therefore you will not realize the benefits of either HRD, strategic HRD or all the strategic HRM.

SPEAKER_01So that's very important. And while I say that strategic HRD is primarily a development piece and it's about knowledge skills and abilities I do acknowledge as well that there's a motivational component to strategic HRD which it shares with all the other pieces of HRM. The other thing you asked there is about I want strategic HRD compared as well there are both I think both strategic HRD and strategic HRM are are premised on the idea that people are a vital strategic resource to the organization and therefore you must manage them and develop them effectively if they're to contribute to organizational performance.

SPEAKER_01And I think performance is something uh organizational performance is something that definitely is common to both perspectives. I know that some of the strategic HD is narrow in that respect because it doesn't give as much emphasis to the learning piece which is a fundamental component of HRD generally.

SPEAKER_00So I I agree with what um Thomas just said and I certainly um can see the horizontal alignment and certainly that that tracking with strategic HRD and strategic HRM being very important. I do see though that um to be effective with strategic HRM or strategic HRD that they are becoming one in the same and and perhaps that is is more of a US centric perspective but certainly during COVID um so much of what we are understanding and learning about the needs of employees and how work is changing that and around social justice and anti-racism, a lot of that I would argue has fallen to the HRD perspective in terms of how change happens and how learning and development can best be can best be supported strategically.

SPEAKER_00And so my what I'm seeing is that it's it's much more aligned from an HRM perspective we're relying more on the people that know learning and development and how that shows up in organizational performance much more than perhaps we did pre-COVID and pre-George Floyd and pre-BRBrianna Taylor. And so I'm seeing that alignment even more strongly now and at least in some of the business schools within the United States are acknowledging even more so that their expertise is not in learning and development.

SPEAKER_02When that HRD function is outside of the more traditional HRM structure, they are relying more in bringing that into the center so I think that some of the external triggers that are that are that have happened that continue to happen really are aligning those pieces between HRD and HRM much more with so much happening as Thomas says on the ground there what I'm wondering at this point when you go into an organization what is it that you would look for to determine whether that organization is actually practicing strategic HRD?

SPEAKER_00I would say who's who's at the table who is um involved in those um I'll say strategic conversations I think conversations happen or should happen at all levels but certainly in the C-suite and certainly where um decisions are made at the table who from a learning and development performance perspective is in that mix or does it fall just to the one chief HR officer or chief VP of HR?

SPEAKER_00Does that individual is she bringing in the learning and development piece? So structurally I I would look for that I would also look for um how individuals within the organization at all levels um what their perception is of learning and development are they familiar with how that's integrated into what the organization says is is our strategy, is our is our is our mission and how how even the language use around learning and development is integrated.

SPEAKER_00And again I I fall back to um the uh the current situation you know whether you read the McKinsey reports or whether you look at HBR or some of the um just conversations that we're having across different platforms how are we learning about anti-racism? How are we developing individuals you know I would say before before the last year's events we would talk about DENI separately from say leadership development like it's like it's a competency area and and now that is fundamental.

SPEAKER_00It's not separate from that and learning and development is so so much a part of that that perhaps the traditional or prior way of viewing that was as a separate entity. So I would look at um again structurally how learning and development and talent development is positioned who is who is around the table and making these decisions and how leaders are behaving.

SPEAKER_01I think that's I would agree with everything there. And I would add two other dimensions that I think I would look for when I go into an organization. First of all I think that the line manager has a very big remiche and I use the line manager in a general sense for developing its people. So I look at the way in which that particular dimension of the HRD architecture is in fact stitched into the organization are there clear delineation of responsibilities of line managers are they actually evaluated in the performance reviews on how they undertake the development task that's an important piece.

SPEAKER_01And the other piece then I I increasingly look at is what's the role of the employee? How how clued in are the employees about their own development about their careers about the types of skills that they need to develop their employability all of that there are other things that are very important. And Holly alluded to a number of formal things which I think are really important. And I think if you look at some of the on the face of it on the surface level you'll be looking at all of the HR policies the HOG policies and practices the types of things that are in place and you will then be looking perhaps at looking under the bonnet a little to see well how are they implemented because one of the big dilemmas we have in this area is that organizations can espouse a lot of things and the say to have all of this stuff but it's actually how they implement it is the real test of what happens and I totally agree with Holly that you have to ask the employees about their perceptions of the quality of implementation their exposure to HRG and their evaluation of its uh quality and effectiveness I'm conscious as we've talked through all of that that we we're describing strategic HRD in a somewhat generic way as if it's the same in all organizations and all sectors and all countries.

SPEAKER_02So I'm thinking it might be worth breaking that down a little and and exploring whether strategic HRD actually looks the same or different in different sectors and different countries.

SPEAKER_01Well I think that's a a very interesting question and one that's well researched in the training and development feed the learning and development feed as the organization grows in size and as it becomes more complex uh you tend to have a greater degree of formalization of HRD and therefore you have more clearly defined roles you have clearly defined policies their budget allocations and all of those things so that's an important differentiation. Number two in in as organizations grow they move from doing things in a very ad hoc inflexible I should say and unstructured way perhaps to a more structured um modus operandi and the implement um training development learning HRD activities in a much more structured and targeted way.

SPEAKER_01And then of course the other big thing that we often assume and I agree with the tenor of the question that when we talk about strategic HRD we often talk about a big country company mentality and we assume that there's a role there specific roles designated to learning and development training and development and you won't find those in many small firms and for example in SMEs you will find that the owner manager is a big influence on what happens within that organization and also you will find that a lot of HRD is informal conversational takes place on the job in work roles through experience etc and they may not even label it HRD they may just label it learning.

SPEAKER_01So that's a very important thing then if you go to public sector organizations you find that they are less strategic and more person focused and they focus perhaps more on the individual needs and on learning and development and they also quite a strong job focus and they look at development for roles competencies for roles etc so strategic HRD is definitely um a varied notion and it's highly variegated too depending on which context you're going to talk about and there isn't a one size fits all at all it's very much context dependent I would certainly agree with that and and I also think that you can find these exceptions to nonprofits or maybe smaller smaller shops um depending on who is in the role of of you know managing leading talent development.

SPEAKER_00So sometimes you may find that individuals that come in from a learning and development background we've certainly seen um students who maybe come in with a bit more of a generalist perspective in HRM but certainly a deeper perspective within HRD really transform a small you know not you know maybe even a public organization a large organization so um I I think that's important.

SPEAKER_02Throughout the episode you've both given a compelling argument for HRD professionals to become more strategic. And and I'm thinking about what that means in terms of developing HRD professionals. So what competences an HRD professional needs to develop in order to improve themselves in strategic HRD. And I'm also thinking about whether HRD education programs are actually changing to offer HRD professionals the education they need to become more strategic.

SPEAKER_00Yeah I'm in terms of the educational preparation of our of our professionals and and our researchers and those that call themselves both I think one of the competencies is is early on in in you know in the program or in their their development is is understanding systems thinking and that HRD or HRM or any any change doesn't happen in isolation. And so when when students can begin to see the ripple effect of any change they take a much more inclusive perspective and from understanding the the importance of engagement understanding how um how learning and development really should be interwoven throughout multiple aspects of the organization and the importance of knowing the business.

SPEAKER_00So that's another area know the business you are not just learning and development talent development or performance whatever you call yourselves um you need to know the business to which you're serving and so spending time understanding that and through whether it's embedded internships or specific group projects where you're you have an actual client not hypothetical you have actual clients um to to build that that requisite knowledge of of not only how learning and development is positioned but also who it serves.

SPEAKER_00I think another competency is um consulting we have recently at the University of Houston made consulting really a centerpiece within our programs not only in our executive master's program but also in our professional program at the master's level and at our undergraduate program. Consulting being a consultant understanding the issue applying an evaluation perspective asking good questions um of course it's you know often we we want to hear the answers but it's it's really asking good questions that can really help to to change so the relational management piece goes I think also with that as well and then cultural competence is so very important um to understand especially um interacting not only with individual differences and group differences and identities but certainly from a more global perspective um I mentioned earlier that that is that is foundational to leadership development and while I'll separate that out I I think it's interwoven at all levels that that cultural competence is so very important and that it's evolving as we we understand how that shows up differently.

SPEAKER_00We've already touched on evaluation and assessment I think that is a core competency I know it's a core competency I think when students go into the workplace and have that lens it it we have seen that they really stand out with the questions that they ask with with um the people that they choose to partner with the engaging conversations that they're not they're not quick to act without the data that they need I I make a distinction in a paper that I published last year on mindset and skill set.

SPEAKER_01Harley has really elucidated and illuminated a lot of the skill set pieces around cultural skills, relational skills, business skills and all of that. But the mindset is also important. What I found from the research that I have done is that many learning and development HOD professions do not think strategically they think in a very operational tactical way and that perhaps limits their impact within the organization and may prevent them from getting that seat at the table that Holly alluded to earlier in her in her answer.

SPEAKER_01And I think that's very important. I also think that the skill set and the combating set required depends on this the career stage of the individual because for example um in the research I conducted I found that specialist knowledge such as LD knowledge training design knowledge knowledge about learning and all of those concepts were very important at the beginning of a HOD professional's career but as they moved up to the hierarchy they had to drop some of those things and acquire a lot of the relational and cultural stuff and consulting stuff and political skills and generic interpersonal skills they became really more important and then as they moved up into the operational they had to acquire bigger business knowledge project management skills and organizational change and transformational knowledge and stuff like that.

SPEAKER_02So they moved in a little bit into the realms of OD so as a final question I'm thinking back to the two conversations I had with you one-to-one and now in this group conversation and I feel like throughout all of this you've both done a great job of highlighting what's known about strategic HRD. And so I'm starting to think at the end of the conversation around what that means in terms of what next. So what are the biggest gaps in our understanding of strategic HRD and how can we be closing those gaps through research or through HRD professionals partnering with researchers one of the big gaps I think in the strategic HRD research is showing that long-term investment in HRD impacts business performance.

SPEAKER_01That is a big area and a big challenge most of the studies that are undertaken are cross-sectional they don't and they use single source data and they do not track changes in both training and changes in business performance and see how they relate to each other. And in addition they haven't investigated what I called reverse causality how does a very good or a very poor organizational performance impact subsequent investment in in HRD.

SPEAKER_01So that's a big area and it's the really it's almost the holy grail of this feel trying to demonstrate a causal relationship between HOD and business performance because that's one of the strong pieces that underpins the whole strategic HRD paradigm. I think the other area that I think is important is the relationship between strategic HOD practices and HOM practices strategic HRM practices, how they fit together how they synergize with each other and what cumulative performance effects are got or achieved from a configuration of both HRM and HRD practices those represent two very challenging areas and I think the third area then and it's alluded to in something that Holly said earlier which I think is very perceptive the cultural dimension.

SPEAKER_01We don't know enough about strategic HRD cross-culturally is the relationship in HRD and business performance the same across culturally are there moderating influences and cultural differences, institutional differences, uh economic development human capital development differences within those countries that's a really big area and it's a very exciting area that I would encourage um students of HOD conducting PhDs to start engaging with well that feels like a wonderful place to wrap up the episode it it it sounds very much like a call to action and at the same time I think it points to the potential and the opportunities that there are out there if strategic HRD can continue to evolve and we can close that gap between research and practice and get practitioners and researchers working together to answer those questions.

SPEAKER_02So thank you both so much indeed for your time today.

SPEAKER_00I've really enjoyed our conversations thank you so much Thomas always great to be in the same space with you.

SPEAKER_02Bye now thank you so much for joining me for this episode it was wonderful spending time with Thomas and with Holly if you enjoyed the episode check out our others to explore topics such as training and development, learning organizations, critical HRD and much more new episodes release weekly To learn more about the series check out HRDmasterclass.com and to learn about the Academy of Human Resource Development check out ahrdorg By becoming a member you can access extra bonus materials not included in the podcast.

SPEAKER_02Also don't forget to look into our group discussion sponsor Interpretive simulations by visiting their website at interpretive com I'm looking forward to being with you in our next episode our final episode for the first series until then this is Darren Short signing off from the HRD Masterclass HRD Masterclass Podcast is brought to you by the Academy of Human Resource Development and is a production of allbypodcast.com

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Gendered pathways to work-family balance

    Nov 17, 202634 minAudio

    This fourth episode of Season 6 brings together Dr. Sanghamitra Chaudhuri (Temple University) and Dr. Kyung Nam Kim (Texas A&M University) for a conversation about the 2026 article Gendered Pathways to Work-Family...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Navigating careers in non-traditional work

    Nov 10, 202636 minAudio

    This third episode of Season 6 brings together Dr. Yuanlu Niu (University of Arkansas) and Dr. Jos Akkermans (Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam) for a conversation about the 2026 article Navigating careers in non-traditional...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Silence in the workplace: What do we know from research?

    Nov 2, 202634 minAudio

    This second episode of Season 6 brings together Dr. Matthew Hurtienne (University of Texas at Tyler) and Dr. Heesun Kim (Francis Marion University) for a conversation about the 2024 article Silence in the workplace:...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Diversified mentoring: Living at the intersections of race and gender

    Oct 27, 202634 minAudio

    This first episode of Season 6 brings together Dr. Joshua Collins (University of Minnesota) and Dr. Ague Mae Manongsong (Louisiana State University) for a conversation about the 2023 article “Manongsong, A. M., & Ghosh,...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Season 6 Trailer

    Oct 12, 20262 minAudio

    Welcome to the trailer for Season 6 of Human Resource Development Masterclass - the podcast series from the Academy of Human Resource Development, the organization that leads HRD through research. The sixth season...

    Credit the people on this episode