In this ninth episode of Season 3, guests Dr. Caleb Seung-hyun Han (University of Georgia), Dr. Ciarán McFadden (Edinburgh Napier University), and Dr. Marianne van Woerkom (Erasmus University) discuss the relationship between HRD and Psychology, including: What is meant by the term Psychology? What is the connection between Psychology and the concepts of work and the workplace? What is the relationship between Psychology and HRD? To what extent does HRD looks the way it does because we have emphasized certain aspects of psychology over others? How could HRD change if we emphasize other aspects of psychology in the future? How can HRD professionals ensure that the tools, instruments and methods that they’re using are validated by psychology research and theory? and much more. For full details on the HRD Masterclass series, visit hrdmasterclass.com, for the bios of the guest scholars visit allbypodcast.com/adulteducation. For more information on the Academy of Human Resource Development, visit ahrd.org - by being a member of AHRD, you can access bonus materials from podcast episodes. This episode is sponsored by: the Department of Technology Leadership and Communication in the Purdue School of Engineering and Technology at IUPUI, visit them at https://et.iupui.edu/departments/tlc/; and by the Board of the Academy of Human Resource Development, which encourages you to attend its 30th annual research conference in the Americas being held in Minneapolis, Minnesota, March 1st to 4th 2023 - for further details, visit ahrd.org.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_03We have looked at learning so much from the perspective of trying to fix things, trying to improve weaknesses, improve deficits, what is still not right, and how can we repair that.
SPEAKER_00Welcome to Human Resource Development Masterclass, the podcast series from the Academy of Human Resource Development, the organization that leads HRD through research. I'm your host, Darren Short, and here in our third season, we're exploring the relationship between HRD and other topics and disciplines, with the help of leading authors, researchers, and scholars. Today our focus is the relationship between HRD and psychology, and our guest scholars are Dr.
SPEAKER_00Caleb Xionhun Han of the University of Georgia in the United States, Dr. Kieron McFadden of Edinburgh Napier University in Scotland, and Dr. Marianne von Wierkum of the Erasmus University in the Netherlands, all of whom join me for conversations recorded during July and August of 2022. Our episode today is structured into two halves. In the first 30 minutes, we look at what we mean by the term psychology, and we take a higher-level look at its relationship to work, the workplace, and HRD.
SPEAKER_00And then in the second 30 minutes, we dig deeper into that relationship between psychology and HRD. You can find out all about the questions explored in the episode, the three guest scholars, and also the episode sponsor by visiting allboypodcast.com forward slash psychology. Talking of sponsorship, Human Resource Development Masterclass is only made possible thanks to the wonderful support of our sponsors, who cover all of the costs associated with the series, and so enable us to release them free of charge to listeners like you.
SPEAKER_00I encourage you to show your thanks by checking them out and letting them know just how much their sponsorship means to you. Today's episode is sponsored by the Department of Technology, Leadership and Communication in the Purdue School of Engineering and Technology at IUPUI and by the board of the Academy of Human Resource Development. The first half of the episode is sponsored by the Department of Technology, Leadership and Communication in the Purdue School of Engineering and Technology at IUPUI.
SPEAKER_00With a focus on practical, real-world, industry-relevant learning experiences and flexible scheduling, the programs offered by the Department of Technology, Leadership and Communication empower students to become transformational leaders and exemplary technical communicators. Their adult student-friendly certificates and degree programs will help you advance your career to the next level, sharpening your leadership skills and helping you to stay at the top of your field.
SPEAKER_00Choose from offerings in leadership studies, human resource management, sustainable leadership, project management, organizational leadership and more. Students can enroll in fall, spring and summer semesters. Classes are offered online and in person. For more information, visit et.edu slash departments slash TLC.
SPEAKER_00Right, let's dive into the episode. Welcome to our episode on HRD and psychology. And let's start by meeting today's three guest scholars. First, I'd like to welcome Caleb Xionghion Han, Associate Professor of Learning, Leadership and Organization Development at the University of Georgia. Caleb's research work uncovers and tests the mechanisms by which individuals learn and develop from others' expertise and experiences at work.
SPEAKER_00His primary focus is in individual-level learning within organizations by exploring how this learning is influenced by interpersonal relationships and interactions in organizations. Welcome, Caleb. Hello, everyone. Good to be here. His research, teaching, and praxis focuses on equality, equity, diversity, and inclusion, and takes a cross-disciplinary approach that involves HRD, sociology, labor economics, and psychology.
SPEAKER_00Particularly specializing in LGBTQ workplace inclusion and discrimination, Kieron was a visiting Fulbright scholar at the Williams Institute at UCLA, where he researched labor market discrimination against trans job applicants. He currently serves on the board of directors of the Academy of Human Resource Development and is a fellow of the Global Labour Organization. Welcome, Kieran. Thanks, Darwin.
SPEAKER_01It's good to be here to talk to you today.
SPEAKER_00And the third guest for the episode is Marion von Werkam, Professor of Positive Organizational Psychology at the Erasmus University Rotterdam, the Netherlands, and affiliated with the Department of Human Resource Studies at Tilburg University, also in the Netherlands. The well-being and development of workers are central themes in her research. Inspired by positive psychology, she's intrigued by the question of what happens if we take individual strengths instead of their deficits or weaknesses as the starting point for developmental processes.
SPEAKER_00Marianne publishes her research in journals like the Journal of Applied Psychology and the Journal of Occupational and Organizational Psychology. Welcome, Marianne.
SPEAKER_03Thanks, Naran. Thanks for having me and great to be here.
SPEAKER_00Well, I'd like to start off our conversation by exploring the term psychology so that listeners are clear on that, ready for when we dig deeper into the relationship between psychology and HRD. So, what do we mean by that term psychology?
SPEAKER_02Psychology can be defined in various ways to gain a broad understanding of the nature of a psychology. Let me take the simplest but most informative definition provided by Miller. That is, psychology is a scientific study of behaviors, thoughts, and emotions. Based on this general definition, various disciplines have applied principles of psychology differently. Psychology is a science, that is, it involves the systematic investigation so that theory and practice can be based on verifiable evidence rather than gut feeling or intuition we have.
SPEAKER_02So basically, psychology encapsulates a wide range of biological influences, social pressures, and environmental factors that affect how people think, react, and feel. It helps us get better insights into how people act as well as why they act the way they do. The field of psychology has many specialty areas. In reality, psychology is very diversified with many specialized interests. For example, development psychology focuses on developmental behavior over the lifespan that concerns the ways in which people grow and change psychologically.
SPEAKER_02Cognitive psychology focuses on cognitive functioning, our thought processes, it studies human thinking, cognition, and how the mind works. For example, in human research development, we may apply the technology in how well people remember information and process knowledge acquired in the training or education program. On the other hand, social psychology studies human social behavior, how our behavior, thoughts, and emotions are mutually associated with other people.
SPEAKER_02Psychology in human research development, it is not just simply the application or extension of psychological principles to the problems concerning human research development, but it helps us connect with others and can mean the difference between work life and the life of challenges that have gone unnoticed in our world. I think at a certain point I felt HLD should have unique perspective on psychology. That is, psychology is concerned with the behavior in organization that keeps human resource development focused on the individual.
SPEAKER_02This view assumes that people are consistently different in their attributes and individual behaviors, and information about these individual differences can be applied to predict, maintain, and increase work performance and the job satisfaction.
SPEAKER_01And just to add to Caleb's uh definition of psychology and to add the depth of different branches and of psychology that he's outlined, we can also see maybe different flavors of psychology as they're applied to different uh other different disciplines. So obviously, today we're going to talk about uh HRD and that relationship. We can also look at how psychology has improved and uh deepened our understanding of other things like uh other disciplines like economics, for example, behavioral economics coming in the 1970s.
SPEAKER_01So it's a complex field, it's a complex uh there's complex subfields there. I guess I would agree with Caleb there that there's no one simple definition of psychology, just uh it's an overarching uh banner which can be applied to many different contexts uh between individuals, uh between uh social groups uh in the workplace or outside of the workplace, and of course to the organization as well.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, maybe it's also good to say something about research methods that are predominantly used in psychology, and that is, of course, depending, I guess, of the stream of psychology uh that you work in. But in general, I would say that psychology has a strong focus on measuring psychological constructs and also uh on applying uh statistics to find relationships between different psychological constructs.
SPEAKER_03And another method is uh doing experiments in the lab or in the field.
SPEAKER_00So we're going to eventually get to a point of digging deep into the connection between psychology and HRD, but I but I'm wondering if that's too big of a first step and whether it's helpful to take a half step and to explore the relationship between psychology and the concepts of work and the workplace, and also how that relationship between psychology, work, and the workplace has potentially changed over recent years.
SPEAKER_00So, so what are your thoughts about the relationship between those?
SPEAKER_01So, yeah, if we start with this second part of that question about how the relationship has changed over the years, and we go back to what's all often marked as the beginning of management theory and looking at work in a more uh scholarly sense. We look at um Taylorism, we look at Frederick Taylor and his time in motion studies with the Gilbretz, and uh we look at Fordism, how to divide a job into uh equal tasks, individual, discrete tasks, how to reduce the complexity of the work and how to make it easy that anyone can come along and pick up, pick up those skills, pick up those jobs, do those tasks in a relatively easy manner, all with this aim to increase efficiency, to increase productivity, and of course, then to help to help profits.
SPEAKER_01The profit motive is kind of over everything here. And so then we have kind of psychology coming in, um, maybe at the start of the human relations movement uh with El Domeo, uh looking at organizational culture, and he's really pointing towards the aspects that we now think of as psychology in terms of individual uh psychology and the individual being, uh, the social aspects of the workplace, and then the workplace itself and the organizational culture and uh the workplace climate. Uh, and so he's really then starting to look at how can that affect people's again efficiency and productivity in the workplace?
SPEAKER_01How does that affect how they work? And I think over time, and there was a bit of a hiatus during the war years, but over time, and then especially post-war, uh, World War II, uh, we started to look at how we can use psychology again to simplify our understanding of the human being at work. So rather than simplifying the tasks, we're not looking at simplifying the worker and dividing them into discrete units like personality, uh, motivation, job satisfaction. We're looking at social aspects as well, dividing the social aspect of the workplace into discrete units like uh leadership, teamwork, and things like that.
SPEAKER_01And then we're dividing the organization into discrete units, the organizational culture, the work conditions, uh and the climate and the reward systems in place. So, again, it's all about trying to simplify with the aim of increasing efficiency and increasing productivity, uh, which might be a bit of a cynical view. Uh, but then I think it becomes exacerbated uh with the move towards neoliberalism in the 1970s onwards across many countries uh in the world, um, and then more laterally with late-stage capitalism, this drive towards efficiency and effectiveness and utilizing psychology to help that drive.
SPEAKER_01So, again, the profit motive coming in overall there. Um, and of course, we've seen clashes between the organization's profit motive and the individual's own uh motives towards well-being. But psychology has, uh in my view, been encouraged, and uh the work psychology, in particular industrial psychology, the study of that has been encouraged with an aim to seek the profit motive and to help the profit motive. Um but perhaps that's maybe too cynical.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, in my view, psychology started being very service-oriented, focusing on uh organizational interests, the interests of managers, so helping organizations to screen and select the best uh workers. But I think that throughout time, gradually it became more involved with the complexity of behaviors and emotions of workers in organizations, their motivation, their engagement, their health, their well-being, but also more concerned with dynamics in teams, issues of diversity, equality, inclusion.
SPEAKER_03So, yeah, maybe I'm less cynical, but I I I think there has been a change as well.
SPEAKER_02I think uh the work is frequently taken for granted rather than questioned or uh thought about deeply. Although uh the concept of the work and place is deeply rooted in psychology, it has been regarded as something that we have to do in our lives. So these days we put more value on work-life balance. Work is regarded as a source of personal fulfillment. The rekindling the concept of psychology, I think it raises more general questions about the importance of cognitive and effective mental processes for understanding work.
SPEAKER_02Depending on the context and uh situation, the relationship between work and psychology has been changed. I think uh recently, the topic of equity and justice and fairness is a prominent example. Simply speaking, uh, as it uh manifested in the perception that workers are excluded, interned, vilified, and masculine in the workplace, fairness, that concept uh becomes the most important topic today.
SPEAKER_02It focuses on the perceived fairness of outcomes and procedures, for example, the use of consistent standards and objective information in performance evaluation, and giving employees opportunity to voice their own are believed to enhance individual perceptions of justice and equity. That projects employees' uh work attitude and work-related behaviors. Uh, psychology principles have provided a rich range of cognitive and effective elements of work, from individual differences in intellectual ability to the importance of attitudes, emotions, and behaviors.
SPEAKER_02In that way, it highlights the cognitive and effective processes that individuals experience when they work. Furthermore, this explanation allows us to see work as a source of a psychological well-being, stress, and unhappiness.
SPEAKER_00So listening to the answers there, um, it makes me feel as if uh psychology is built into a lot of how organizations are structured, the systems within organizations, processes. What I'm wondering is if it's reasonable to say that it's become so mainstream that workers within organizations probably aren't even aware that psychology is underpinning much of what is happening around them.
SPEAKER_01I think psychology does underpin a lot of how managers practice and how uh work is designed. And I think employees perhaps uh aren't really aware of this until things go wrong, until things um are negatively affecting affecting them in their job design or in the way their job experience and their work uh climate is affecting them. Um it's only then when things like motivation and poor motivation or uh poor job satisfaction or poor engagement um become more well known, become more obvious.
SPEAKER_01I think when things are going well, maybe psychology is kind of there in the background and it's been built for decades now into job design. So I don't know if it's entirely visible until things start to go wrong. I think related to that maybe is the the tendency to maybe jump on board some of the more trendier uh psychological uh theories or or concepts. Um, if we look at, for example, personality. Uh again, a really nice way to simplify what is really complex.
SPEAKER_01It's it's how do we how do we simplify uh so the personalities uh within an organization? Well, let's divide them into 16 types, if it's the uh the MBTI test or something like that. And you know, we've seen that being used and perhaps misused in in many organizations, maybe more so 10 or 20 years ago, but it is uh a trendy concept. We also have concepts like mindfulness as well, that's been used to uh you know fix gaps or fix patches in in worker well-being, um, when maybe more simple uh job design and workload uh uh alterations could be could be the answer there.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, I I completely agree with you. I think that many in many organizations there is a great interest in psychology and and psychological constructs, talents, strengths, motivations, personality types, but there is not always interest, a great interest in scientific evidence, indeed that leads to um organizations embracing all sorts of talent, checks, profiles, uh uh all unvalidated uh instruments.
SPEAKER_03And I I also recognize sometimes the solution to uh to opt for a training in mindfulness is so much easier than to uh opt for a real good analysis of what is causing work stress, for instance.
SPEAKER_00I wonder if this is the right time then to point us more closely at the HRD piece, having talked about the connection between psychology, work, and the workplace. I'm wondering then what's the connection between psychology and HRD? And and in considering that, um, how you see research theory and practice in one influencing the research theory and practice in the other?
SPEAKER_03Well, I see psychology as one of the major theoretical foundations of HRD. And that's not just me, I think also famous HRD scholars like Telowski and Swanson have also acknowledged the importance of psychology. And I think, well, of course, psychology has evolved. Throughout time, and there have been many different streams in psychology, but they have all left their traces on HID practices and also HID research.
SPEAKER_03So, for instance, uh beginning with uh the behaviorist uh psychologist in the beginning of the 20th century, uh, they considered learning as a black box because they thought we cannot look into people's heads, what happens. So we can only uh study behavior, and they also studied how they can make animals, but later also humans, how they can stimulate them to produce the desired behavior by manipulating their environment.
SPEAKER_03And we can still see the influence of this stream in how we set up training today. For instance, how we operationalize the behavior that we would like to see uh before actually uh giving the trainings in terms of learning goals, how we try to influence behavior by giving detailed uh instruction and also by giving feedback.
SPEAKER_03And then we had more the cognitive psychologists who kind of opened this black box and they did look kind of in the head and investigated uh mental processes, memory, and information processing. And we can also still see the influence of this dream in how we try to facilitate learning by reducing cognitive load, for instance, by helping people to organize information, by activating their frame of reference, or by asking them questions to help them actively processing the information.
SPEAKER_03And also when it comes to learning in groups, research, for instance, often takes a cognitive perspective by focusing on how team members kind of function as a brain together with team members, acquiring information, then bringing that information to the team, sharing that with the other team members, making sense of it and store it in their kind of virtual uh memory.
SPEAKER_03Then we had, for instance, social learning theory by Bandura, and that kind of stress this theory stressed the importance of modeling as a very important source of learning. And we can also still see the influence of this dream in, for instance, how we think about mentoring, how it's important that learners should identify with the model uh that it's best if there are different models, and also in the importance of people's self-efficacy.
SPEAKER_03Um, then we had experiential learning that kind of comes back into HRD in how we facilitate learning in the workplace by a combination of doing the job and helping someone to reflect on it, and for instance, also in how we think about coaching as a method to facilitate reflection, and there is also the stream of humanistic psychology, uh, which kind of uh sees uh considers humans' intrinsic motivation to grow, and we can see that back in the emphasis on facilitating learning in organizations instead of teaching.
SPEAKER_03So if the right circumstances are there and people's needs are fulfilled, so for instance, their needs for autonomy, relatedness, and competence, uh people will start to learn on their own initiative. Me personally, I'm really um active in the field of positive psychology, and positive psychology is concerned with people's well-being and their optimal performance and people's positive traits and stakes.
SPEAKER_03And this made me really aware that in organizations we often approach learning and development from a deficit approach. So we start by making this analysis of okay, what are you good at? What are you not so good at? Okay, what you're good at already, that's not so interesting anymore. But let's focus on what you're not good at yet, and let's try to develop that by using coaching and training, and positive psychology gives the theoretical framework to kind of turn that around.
SPEAKER_03Well, maybe also to um make people more motivated for their own developmental processes because it really ties in with what is important for them and because it builds on their qualities.
SPEAKER_02Uh, when it comes to the connection between psychology and uh HLD, uh, I'd like to talk a little bit about a frame, a lens to view the world. I think psychology gives us a frame in research theory and practice. Uh that being said, a frame is a foundational context, as Miriam said, a context for understanding or interpretation. We do not look at an event and then apply a frame to it better. We see the world and the phenomena itself through our pre-existing frames.
SPEAKER_02Psychology, in the sense, gives us various lens. It provides a lens looking at the basic human resource development functions within organizations, for example, as the way leadership is developed, how employees are trained and developed, and the measurement of employee job performance. Another lens we might look at uh is the psychological processes underlying work behavior, such as the motivation to work and the employee engagement, job satisfaction, and employees' stress and art and so forth.
SPEAKER_02In addition, there is another lens on group processes I'd like to highlight here in the workplace, including the relationship between workplace supervisors and subordinates, and how team or work group coordinates to get the job done. Some psychology theories take the broader uh picture, including the structure of work organizations and organization culture, how the social and psychological environments affect individual behaviors. That relationship between psychology and uh uh HLD emphasizes the psychological aspect of human beings at work and therefore provides the intellectual foundations for HLD literature.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I think psychology really puts the human back into human resource development. I think it's also really interesting to look at how HRD then influences psychology to some extent. So almost like you know, the parent teaches the child, but also the child teaches the parent a little bit as well. You know, I look at diversity training in my work, and one thing that we see with diversity training is the reluctance on some people's behalf to engage in diversity training. And in some cases, they outrightly resist uh diversity training.
SPEAKER_01And so we can look at that through the lens of psychology, through the looking at the concept of reactance, that resistance to anything that seemed to be uh or perceived to be impinging on one's free will, and diversity training is sometimes seen as that. So psychology there is helping us with our organizational development through HRD, and but also HRD is helping us to uh expand our notion of reactance and to expand our notion of how reactance manifests in organizations with this case of diversity training.
SPEAKER_03Yeah. Related to that, so how did HRD influence psychology? I think psychologists tend to have less of an eye for particular context. So is it a profit or a non-for-profit organization? What is the economic situation? So, in my view, HRD brings in the attention for context, maybe also for more diverse research methods.
SPEAKER_03Like I said, psychologists are very much focused on measuring psychological constructs, using statistics to figure out relationships. And HRD researchers come from a wider variety of backgrounds and also bring in different research methods.
SPEAKER_02Well, I did a contender analysis and bibliol metrics uh in HLD literature before. Uh literature in HLD reveals the four major topics related to psychology. Uh, the first one is individual differences, personality. And the second one is a job attitude, employee engagement, and organizational justice and work motivation. These topics highlighted the importance of incorporating mental processes into the understanding of work.
SPEAKER_02That is a mental process is on how work is experienced and then conceptualized. So uh uh the personality shows that there is uh the several empirical evidence that individual uh work performances, uh work performance is uh closely related to uh personality in some category. And um, job attitude is another category we may consider in the understanding of uh the psychology. One of the most research topics recently in human research development is uh uh the employee engagement.
SPEAKER_02Employee engagement is received much attention by scholars and practitioners alike because it is uh intuitive to believe that engagement affects job performance. And the work motivation is another uh dominant area of psychology in HLD literature. Um, in contrast to economic theorizing or human resource management, psychological perspective emphasizes that the importance of uh intrinsic uh viewers or intrinsic motivation.
SPEAKER_02So these are the topics uh uh in dominant in HLD uh literature related to psychology.
SPEAKER_01I think another key uh advantage of psychology is that it's given us shared words, shared concepts, shared phrases and shared ways of talking about these particular concepts, which aren't you know unknown to us before we learn about psychology. It's it's not like something like immunology where we we discover that there's germs or there's there's bacteria or there's viruses. Um, you know, pre-psychology, as we know today, people had uh knowledge of this, they had intuitive knowledge of different uh psychological concepts like motivation and job satisfaction and engagement.
SPEAKER_01Um it's just we didn't have a shared um a shared vocabulary, a shared way of talking about that. Um and so going back to what Marianne was saying about about that scientific approach to measuring these different concepts and these different constructs, um, that's one of the key aspects of psychology, is that it's it's made these more available and understandable to a wider audience and has made that a shared concept and a shared understanding.
SPEAKER_00We'll be back in a moment with more from Caleb, Kieron, and Marianne as we dig deeper into the relationship between HRD and psychology. First, though, here's an important reminder that this episode is brought to you thanks to the wonderful sponsorship support of the Board of the Academy of Human Resource Development, which encourages you to consider joining and becoming a member. AHRD is a professional home, a place to learn, teach and share, a space to research, publish and present, a network of scholars, teachers, researchers and practitioners to connect and to apply the art and science of human resource development to change organizations and transform the world through human flourishing.
SPEAKER_00With almost 500 members, AHRD is a global organization made up of, governed by and created for the human resource development scholarly community of academics and reflective practitioners. Membership includes online access to four-peer-reviewed world-class journals, two decades of conference proceedings with cutting-edge research and thought leadership, and much more. To learn all about becoming a member of AHRD, visit the Member Central page at ahrd.org.
SPEAKER_00Right, let's return to our discussion for the second half of the episode. Welcome back to our episode on HRD and Psychology, where I'm joined by Caleb Syung-hyoon Han of the University of Georgia, Kieron McFadden of Edinburgh Napier University, and Marianne von Vierkum of Erasmus University Rotterdam. Already we've discussed what's meant by the term psychology and also the relationship between psychology and HRD.
SPEAKER_00And so I'd like to start off this second part of the episode by digging deeper into that relationship. And specifically, I'm wondering about what extent HRD looks the way it does because we've emphasized certain aspects of psychology over others. And then also perhaps whether HRD could look different if we emphasize other aspects of psychology in the future.
SPEAKER_02Well, uh, psychology plays a critical role in uh human resource development. Uh, it helped us uh at all levels of organizations select and support, motivate, and train employees and develop organizations too. It also helps us uh build a better workplace and foster uh organization culture. Psychology provides distinctive uh ways to identify training and development needs, increase employee performance, and implement policies proven to attract and retain the key talent.
SPEAKER_02The ultimate goal of psychology, I believe, in HLD, is to explain organizational behavior, but the studies showed that behavior could not be explained without taking into account people's thoughts and feelings, personality, job attitude, and work motivation are good examples. We learned that uh individuals often hold divergent uh views of a react in different ways to the situation in the same object or idea. Psychology principles explain that the effect of any stimulus depends on how individuals and groups interpreted it.
SPEAKER_02The way we look different, I think, is an emphasis on the effects of social relations and the importance of interdependency in organizations. Understanding this social aspect of psychology can help us comprehend why people act the way they do, and may also help solve important problems we face today in organizations. HLD virtually occurs within a social context. HLD is not shaped simply by economic change or individual differences, but also by the social structure and relations.
SPEAKER_02That is, by a set of norms and social exchange and socially constructed relations which determine what is acceptable and what is possible in organizations. In the sense, HLD does not only provide learning opportunity or psychological satisfaction, but also shaping social status and building social relations. HLD is an activity that requires a human interaction within social relations and networks of individuals. In this way, HLD can be conceptualized as social interactions and socially constructed relations.
SPEAKER_02HLD can be seen not as something that people simply do, but as a societal creation that positions us in the structures of systems by defining social relations and access to learning resources. For example, uh social exchange approach emphasizes the consequences of seeing work as a set of interpersonal interactions. We could focus on the role of social networks, relations, especially norms, in shaping work choices and behaviors seen as a critical for understanding HLD.
SPEAKER_02As embedded in a complex social phenomena in which uh individuals seek a learning opportunity, developing social status, relations, as a social ability in organizations. Well, uh, this way of thinking could provide how HLD looks different beyond our understanding, simply general psychology made by atomistic individuals or as simply an economic transition within organizations. Instead, uh HLD can be seen as a social exchange among uh various social actors within organizations and systems.
SPEAKER_01I think it would be really interesting to dig further uh deeper into that with this idea of the social aspect of psychology and how social psychology can influence our ideas on learning in the organization specifically, because when we think of learning, we you know we think of Cobe's learning cycle and we think of all these different theories of learning and the motivations to learn, it's always very much at the individual level, it's always very much about how the individual takes in the information, why they take in information, um, the cognition involved in that, and then if they use that, if there's learning transfer.
SPEAKER_01But social uh social learning has also been looked at somewhat in organizations. And I think we could go a bit deeper in that um in in future HRD research and psycho psychological research to see uh the different aspects of of social life on learning in individual learning in organizations. Uh, we've looked at social learning to some extent, but he's also looked at the mentoring relationship and seen if your mentor looks or has the same profile as you does that impact on your learning. So we're kind of scratching the surface there, but I think that's something that we could look at in more depth later on, especially thinking about psychology and thinking about the whole realm of social psychology.
SPEAKER_01Uh, I'm not sure if we've completely used that to the greatest extent as HRD research researchers and practitioners uh that we could so Marian, you much of your research is focused in on positive psychology.
SPEAKER_00When you take a look at HRD and its use of psychology, do you feel like HRD has made as much use of positive psychology as it could have done?
SPEAKER_03No, I I don't. Also myself, I'm I I am or was also guilty of that. We have looked at learning so much from the perspective, the perspective of trying to fix things, trying to improve weaknesses, improve deficits, simply repair, and the whole thought of well, what is still not right, and how can we repair that, which is also a very rational approach, so it's totally understandable, and I think that approach is still dominant in HRD, and therefore we have tended to overlook that well, in order to facilitate motivation for learning.
SPEAKER_03It's it's really important to know what kind of person you have in front of you and what are the typical traits and the typical strengths and interests of that person, and then take that as the starting point of a learning process instead of taking already-made learning goals or already on the shelf learning material, and and feed that to people and and well, kind of expect them to swallow it.
SPEAKER_00When you take a look at some of the core processes and models within HRD, much of them do assume that there is a deficit, a gap between what we have and what we need to have. And HRD figures out the best way of filling that gap. And and I can understand why it takes that approach, but it also feels like it's missing a possible and, which is, and how can we adopt positive psychology to also help people to build on the strengths that they already have?
SPEAKER_03Yeah, yeah, I I completely agree. I think this whole gap approach is very dominant in HRD. And and maybe in also in other, if you look broader also. So in HR research, that is also very much focused on well, preventing failure, preventing mistakes, managing risks, etc. Instead of, and I mean, if you prevent people from becoming burnout, that doesn't mean that they will thrive.
SPEAKER_03So yeah, we can see that that same bias also in the broader HR field, I think.
SPEAKER_02And particularly uh after COVID-19, we experienced a lot of anxiety and depressions in the workplace. And in that sense, that reminds me of that what is the end point of HLD? Is that the performance or learning improvement? Well, uh, we need to think about or switch our perspective toward uh taking an approach of a positive psychology, uh, more focusing on the positive events or influences in our life. For example, positive experiences like uh joy or inspiration and happiness, or positive states in organization, uh resilience or compassion toward the community or the organizational groups, uh, and um uh building a positive institution like uh positive principles within the system, uh, within the uh entire organization.
SPEAKER_02So that's the thing uh we have to consider uh uh nowadays.
SPEAKER_00So we've talked a lot then about the relationship between psychology and HRD. And I'm wondering now if we if we put that together and look at how psychology and HRD can work together and specifically how psychology could help HRD to address some of the major challenges that organizations are facing over the next few years.
SPEAKER_03I think there are many uh challenges, but let me just highlight a few of them, such as, for instance, for instance, the well-being of workers that is under pressure. Uh, we have the aging work population, and we need people to work longer. Uh, still many in spite of the shortages on the labor market, still many people are being excluded from entering uh the labor market, and we have huge environmental challenges.
SPEAKER_03So focusing on the well-being of workers, well, we we know that many people suffer from psychological complaints or burnout, and well, a psychological theory such as self-determination theory, which is already quite old, that has taught us this that people have basic psychological needs that need to be fulfilled in order to feel well, and also in order to feel intrinsically motivated for their development.
SPEAKER_03So if a job doesn't make a worker feel competent and related to others and also autonomous, then this will probably in the end have a negative impact on the mental health of the worker. And I think that self-determination theory provides kind of a lens to look at the jobs that organizations are offering and can help to stimulate organizations to maybe just make better jobs, and there's also a role for the workers themselves.
SPEAKER_03I think we can also teach them to use strategies to fulfill their own needs, and then the challenge of the aging work population. We do need to keep older workers in the workforce, so therefore, we need to understand how their motives change when people age. And a theory like social emotional selectivity theory can help to understand how people's motives change when they age.
SPEAKER_03And this theory proposes that uh because older adults are more likely to perceive their future time as more limited, they therefore prioritize goals that maximize present effective outcomes. So they want to experience positive emotional states and meaningfulness right now. And I think it's also important to stress that this does not mean that older people or older workers are no longer interested in learning and uh development, but they do have a need to play to their strengths and interests because this generates these positive effective outcomes.
SPEAKER_03And then regarding the inclusion uh on the labor market, uh, we see that that there are large groups of vulnerable workers who are still excluded, so people with disabilities, uh, migrant workers, and so on. And that is also because they suffer from various stereotypes, and actually they may come to believe in those stereotypes themselves. So there is a kind of self-fulfilling prophecy, and then there is labeling theory that explains how uh people's identity and their uh behaviors can really be influenced by the terms that are used to classify them.
SPEAKER_03So if we classify people as, well, they have disabilities, they have autism, etc., well, that that has a very different impact than when, for instance, instead we label them by their strengths. Uh, so if the if it's more a habit in organizations to label people based on their positive qualities and not just vulnerable workers, no, everyone.
SPEAKER_03That also generates a feeling like yeah, everyone is different. Also, everyone has uh different qualities, and lastly, we are uh facing huge environmental issues, so we really need to think how we can motivate organizations and workers for more sustainable behaviors, and then here is positive psychology again, and for instance, there is the broaden and build theory by Barbara Fredrickson, uh, which proposes that positive emotions have a kind of broadening effect, uh, almost literally, that people when they experience experience broad positive emotions, they literally open up and have a wider outlook uh on the world, and therefore they might have the potential to stimulate people to look beyond, okay, what is good for me.
SPEAKER_01I would pick up on what Marianne was saying about the the inclusion of marginalized and vulnerable groups, uh, and I think this is actually just from my own research and from my own reading, I think this is something of a challenge that's going to that's happening right now, and it's going to get bigger and bigger if it's not um addressed, is the I suppose the role of the organization within social justice and within uh inclusion on a broader societal sense, kind of in the same way that we're now looking towards organizations um in terms of the environment and their environmental responsibility.
SPEAKER_01We're now increasingly looking at organizations from a social justice point of view. So uh after the peak of BLM and after the peak of the Me Too movement, uh that has prompted us to start to look at organizations a bit more cynically and look at them a little bit more critically in the role that they play within social justice. And then we have the rise of Generation Z, um, who are very much more socially aware and socially active than even just the millennial generation before them. So I think there is a growing expectation that organizations have to uh be involved in social justice campaigns and social justice awareness, and that's something that psychology can really lend its hand to and and HRD kind of uh uh together.
SPEAKER_01Psychology telling us about uh stigma, exploring stigma, exploring unconscious bias or conscious bias, um, and looking at the mechanisms of exclusion on a psychological sense and an uh an interpersonal sense. And then HRD is this kind of facilitator of this learning and uh within organizations, and we might not be able to change those who would be biased or those who would be discriminatory, but we could at least change those who weren't aware of that beforehand and aware of the different aspects in which bias and exclusion, marginalization and hatred uh manifest within organizations and outside organizations.
SPEAKER_01So I think that's another challenge that's coming along, and I think it's one that HOD and psychology are both really, really well suited towards uh ameliorating.
SPEAKER_02I think Marian and Karen uh pointed out so many great things about the uh implications of psychology approaches in HLD. But at the time, uh the point of time we face the post-coronavirus phase, it is obvious that uh COVID-19 reshaped the workplace and the way we work. The boundary of psychology in HLD stretches well beyond the physical domain of the workplace because many of other factors may influence work behavior.
SPEAKER_02For example, lockdown and enforced remote working came to the forefront of the uh the critical factors such as work-life balance and family responsibility, cultural influences or employment-related registrations and non-work emergency. Even more significant is that we have to be concerned about the uh effect of work on non-work behaviors. Psychology may help us concentrate on the uh reciprocal impact of work on life and life on our work.
SPEAKER_02So, uh, with multiple thoughts of uh psychology in HLD, it is tempting to ask which thought is right or which one is best. So, by crafting a comprehensive integration of the diverse conceptualizations of HLD, psychology provides a rich foundation for this critical discourse. Uh, in a macro level, how a pandemic like COVID-19 uh influences organizational learning, leadership, and organization development, in a micro level, how employee well-being is achieved by HLD policies or how informal or incidental learning are uh motivated in the workplace.
SPEAKER_00As I listen there, I'm thinking about the potential that there is, therefore, for HRD and psychology to work together and for HRD to leverage more psychology. As it does that, my guess is that HRD practitioners are going to find themselves in a position where they have to determine which are the right tools, instruments, and methods to actually be able to do that and and how to distinguish between those that are valid and those, as as Kieran mentioned earlier, that are potentially just fads.
SPEAKER_00So I'm wondering what your advice would be for HRD professionals on on how to how to go about doing that in the future, how to ensure that the psychology tools, instruments, and methods have actually been validated by research and theory.
SPEAKER_01So I think there's kind of three main dimensions to the use of tools or instruments or certain methods within organizations. I mean, first of all, we have the aim and how well it reaches that aim, this method, or this intervention. Is it valid, like you say? Uh but then uh as I said uh earlier, and as Marianne and Caleb were talking about, there is this aspect of political pressure as well, of the politics of the organization. So HRD professionals don't always exist in this bubble where they have this utmost authority to choose whichever method or tool that they want to use.
SPEAKER_01It could be pressure or at least very strong suggestions from their from their bosses who aren't in the HRD department but who are used to using a certain tool or or having some kind of certain um construct in mind. Um so there's the political pressure as well, and then you have the experiential aspect um of actually doing the test or or being involved in the learning intervention. Um, you know, is it is it fun? Is it is it boring? You know, the the those different types of aspect of the individual's experience of of taking part.
SPEAKER_01And so you have this kind of quagmire, this uh murkiness of these conflicting goals and aims that then impact on the HRD professionals' ability to objectively assess or or validate the tools and methods that are used. Um so, for example, if you go back to the MBTI, uh a lot of people would critique either rightly or wrongly the assumption that there's predictive validity, that if you have some kind of archetype, you've identified as some kind of archetype, then you will act or be some kind of way, um, and that you will get involved in certain activities or certain careers.
SPEAKER_01Um, and and the MBTI uh would say that there's the, you know, that's not the point of this, it's to stimulate conversations. But there is that stereotype or that idea that that's what it's for. Uh, there's also the the the uh criticism that it represents aspects of personality as bimodal, so a binary, so you're extrovert or introvert rather than a spectrum where we have ambivarts and or you know the uh the the shades of gray in between. Uh but of course the MTI is very, very much in vogue. It's it's been popular for decades now.
SPEAKER_01So there could be some management pressure there. There could be some kind of um idea, well, this big uh management consulting company are doing it, so we should do it as well. Uh, but overall, it's kind of fun to do as well. So going back to the experiential aspect of doing the test, it is interesting and it's really fun to find out which of these 16 archetypes you are and what your personality is based on this on this uh test. Uh and you get a chance to talk about yourself for a while. So that's always good. Uh so in that sense, the individual factors and the organizational factors are almost eclipsing the stated purpose and finding out if the MBTI is is is effective within organizations and does it have some kind of validity.
SPEAKER_01Uh and then another example, if we look at something like unconscious bias training or EBI workshops, some are really, really effective and good, and some are really poor and they they don't do what they're meant to do. And that's kind of unsurprising given that these are relatively new interventions and again very much in vogue over the last couple of years. So there could be some management pressure involved there in ensuring that these interventions are done, either from a place of this is important to do from a social justice aspect, or this is important to do, so we can then say that we have done this in a kind of a cynical box-ticking exercise.
SPEAKER_01So, again, management pressure, the politics of this learning intervention impacting on us being able to critically assess whether whether it is valid. And so then to answer the question, how do we ensure that there's a validity and consistency? I think that all of this, uh, these potentially distorting factors really make us consider using uh IO as psychology researchers or HRD researchers more in organizations. So, in the same way that we would bring an economist or a management scholar to consult within organizations, we could bring in uh someone with a psychology background or a HRD uh research background.
SPEAKER_01And that's done, of course, in certain areas, but it's usually at the very, very upper end with large organizations with a lot of money. And I wonder, would that be useful or valuable to bring in more of these uh consultant scholars uh in the psychology space or or in the HRD space who can more objectively assess the validity or the usefulness of the interventions that are being used so that they can then um they can bypass all these politics and all these uh individual aspects of the organization uh learning interventions.
SPEAKER_01But then for HRD professionals, trying to get rid of all this quagmire of uh politics and and uh experiential aspects, as well as partnering up with these researchers, they can be aware that learning and and other aspects of HRD, just like anything, is a political process. And just being aware of that and then taking a more critical stance, hopefully as a result, will allow them to be have a bit more detachment in the choice of the interventions, in how it's delivered, and then hopefully the evaluation of those interventions in a more objective and critical, detached manner.
SPEAKER_03I I think we still need to try to tell HRD professionals and managers more about psychology, psychological measurement, and the importance of reliability and validity, and that many of the tests that they use, like MBTI, but also several strengths tests, they are not valid, but it still does appeal to their needs.
SPEAKER_03And we need to explain, I think, that the fact that you may recognize yourself in a strengths profile or in the result of your MBTI test, um, that doesn't mean that it's it's valid. Um, because you might recognize and in the same way, you might also, if you read your horoscope, you might also recognize several things, but then other things totally do not apply.
SPEAKER_03Maybe researchers are also partly guilty. We sometimes we develop such complex measures that are also very long and very time-consuming, and we might also help HRD professionals by listening more to their concerns, responding more to their needs for short measures. And several long measures have already been translated into short measures, and they are still reliable and valid.
SPEAKER_03So that's also important.
SPEAKER_02That's a great point. Uh that let me take an example of uh my experience in South Korea. The many Korean companies take uh uh the MBTI test or personality test uh for the new employees uh uh entrance. So when they get into the company, uh they have to take uh the personality test, like MBTI and or Big Five test, and then they are categorized into specific uh the groups. And then the belief uh in South Korea is that uh uh particularly in collectivism culture, uh the cohesiveness or a similarity makes uh the stronger organization or group.
SPEAKER_02Uh but uh the thing is that uh I found that um that's wrong. The difference makes it better, uh, or diversity makes it better. Uh, I mean, uh uh to take an example of my personal experience with uh personality test, uh the my uh the rank four can be different from others ranking four. When they uh take the uh the number four or five, um maybe it is a different strength of uh anchor of uh different individuals.
SPEAKER_02So when I categorize as some statistic group, when they get into when I get into the group, and um I feel like uh that that is uh I found that that lots of a similarity, but actually I found lots of differences between individuals. But the thing is that their performance came out from the differences and the diversity. So uh so uh uh we have to take uh uh the different idea of uh grain of letter, the weeks of a tie. Sometimes the diversity and the differences make a better performance or better visuals.
SPEAKER_00Well, unfortunately, we've run out of time for today's conversation, but my thinking is we could probably talk about psychology and HRD for a lot longer, so we may have to keep the rest for a uh a later episode. But I've really enjoyed our time together. Thank you, all three of you, for being a part of the episode and for exploring HRD and psychology.
SPEAKER_02You're welcome.
SPEAKER_00Good to talk to you all.
SPEAKER_02Thank you very much. Thank you for having me.
SPEAKER_01Take care. Bye-bye.
SPEAKER_00Thank you so much for joining me for this episode. It was wonderful spending time with Caleb Syong Jon Han, Kieron McFadden, and Marianne von Würckom. If you enjoyed this episode, check out all of our others. There were 22 episodes in the first two seasons, and we're releasing a further 11 here in the third. Between them, they provide access to conversations with over 75 leading HRD scholars from around the world. New episodes release weekly.
SPEAKER_00To learn more about the series, check out HRDmasterclass.com and to learn about the Academy of Human Resource Development, check out ahrd.org. By becoming a member, you can access extra bonus materials. Also, don't forget to look into our sponsors, the Department of Technology, Leadership and Communication in the Purdue School of Engineering and Technology at IUPUI by visiting their website at et.edu slash departments slash TLC.
SPEAKER_00I'm looking forward to being with you in our next episode when we're exploring the relationship between HRD and STEM with the help of Dr. Hannah Love of Divergent Science, Dr. Alina Waite of Indiana State University, and Dr. Jill Zeretsky of Colorado State University. Until then, it is Damon Short signing off from the Human Resource Development Human Resource Development Matter Fast Podcast.
SPEAKER_00It's brought to you by the Academy of Human Resource Development and the Production and all byPalcast.com.
This fourth episode of Season 6 brings together Dr. Sanghamitra Chaudhuri (Temple University) and Dr. Kyung Nam Kim (Texas A&M University) for a conversation about the 2026 article Gendered Pathways to Work-Family...
This third episode of Season 6 brings together Dr. Yuanlu Niu (University of Arkansas) and Dr. Jos Akkermans (Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam) for a conversation about the 2026 article Navigating careers in non-traditional...
This second episode of Season 6 brings together Dr. Matthew Hurtienne (University of Texas at Tyler) and Dr. Heesun Kim (Francis Marion University) for a conversation about the 2024 article Silence in the workplace:...
This first episode of Season 6 brings together Dr. Joshua Collins (University of Minnesota) and Dr. Ague Mae Manongsong (Louisiana State University) for a conversation about the 2023 article “Manongsong, A. M., & Ghosh,...
Welcome to the trailer for Season 6 of Human Resource Development Masterclass - the podcast series from the Academy of Human Resource Development, the organization that leads HRD through research. The sixth season...