In this third episode of Season 4, guests Dr. Dionne Rosser-Mims (Troy University, USA), Dr. Greg Wang (University of Texas at Tyler, USA), and Dr. Maxim Voronov (York University, Canada) discuss the relationship between HRD and organizational, national and global politics, including: What is meant by the term politics? How do national and global politics impact organizations, and how has our view of the impact changed in recent years? What does politics look like within organizations, and how does organizational politics impact the way organizations work? What does all of this mean for individual employees and the workforce as a whole? What are the implications for HRD practitioners who are working on training & development and organizational change? What are the implications for how we prepare people for careers in adult education, leadership, and training? What are the implications for HRD research and, specifically, what research is needed into HRD & politics? and much more. For full details on the HRD Masterclass series, visit hrdmasterclass.com, and for the bios of the guest scholars visit allbypodcast.com/politics. For more information on the Academy of Human Resource Development, visit ahrd.org - by being a member of AHRD, you can access bonus materials from podcast episodes. This episode is sponsored by the Department of Human Resource Development at The University of Texas at Tyler Soules College of Business - please visit their website at https://www.uttyler.edu/soules-college-of-business/human-resources-development/, and by the Troy University Fast Track Graduate Program - find out more at https://www.troy.edu/.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_01Politics is it's all around us. The big P and that's related to government and how government runs to what we experience individually at the community level and organizational level.
SPEAKER_02Welcome to Human Resource Development Masterclass, the podcast series from the Academy of Human Resource Development, the organization that leads HRD through research. I'm your host, Darren Short, and here in our fourth season, we're exploring the relationship between HRD and trends in society and organizations, with the help of leading authors, researchers and scholars. Today our focus is the relationship between HRD and organizational, national and global politics.
SPEAKER_02And my guest scholars are Dr. Dion Rossa Mims of Troy University, Dr. Greg Wong of the University of Texas at Tyler, and Dr. Maxim Voronoff of York University in Canada, all of whom join me for a conversation recorded in May of 2023. Our episode today is structured into two sections. In the first, we look at organizational, national, and global politics and how they impact organizations and the workforce.
SPEAKER_02Then, in the second section, we explore the implications for HRD practice, research, and education. You can find out all about the questions explored in the episode, the three guest scholars, and also the episode sponsors by visiting allbypodcast.com forward slash politics. Talking of sponsorship, Human Resource Development Masterclass is only made possible thanks to the wonderful support of our sponsors who cover all of the costs associated with the series and so enable us to release them free of charge to listeners like you.
SPEAKER_02I encourage you to show your thanks by checking them out and letting them know just how much their sponsorship means to you. Today's episode is sponsored by the University of Texas at Tyler and by Troy University. The first part of the episode is brought to you thanks to the sponsorship support of the Department of Human Resource Development in the Soles College of Business at the University of Texas at Tyler. The HRD Department offers BS and MS degrees in human resource development and a PhD in organization development and change.
SPEAKER_02With the mission of leading the HRD discipline through innovative scholarship, academic excellence and professional services, the HRD department at UT Tyler provides students with opportunities to combine studies and professional experiences to develop, apply, synthesise and evaluate HRD knowledge and address performance needs and problems, as well as theoretical issues of both for-profit and not-for-profit organizations.
SPEAKER_02For full information, check out their website by doing a Google search for UT Tyler HRD. You'll find their page at the top of the search results. Right, let's dive into the episode. Welcome to our episode on organizational, national and global politics and implications for HRD. And let's start by meeting today's three guest scholars. First, I'd like to welcome Dr. Dion Rosser Mims, full professor and vice-chancellor for the Troy University Phoenix City Campus.
SPEAKER_02Dion has authored four books, including the 2020 co-edited publication entitled Pathways into the Political Arena: The Perspectives of Global Women Leaders. She's the co-founder and former co-editor-in-chief of Dialogues in Social Justice, an adult education journal. Prior to joining Troy University, Dion held a faculty position at the University of Georgia's Fanning Institute for Leadership, where she worked on projects targeting communities suffering from economic, educational, and social disparities.
SPEAKER_02Welcome, Dion.
SPEAKER_01Thank you so much for the opportunity.
SPEAKER_02So my second guest for the episode is Dr. Greg Wong, professor of HRD in the Soles College of Business at the University of Texas at Tyler. Before his academia appointment, Greg worked at GE, Motor Roller, and in HRD Consulting Businesses in International Arenas. Greg recently made groundbreaking contributions to HRD theory building. His decade-long research on redefining and theorizing HRD challenged mainstream assumptions and developed the general theory of HRD.
SPEAKER_02Greg's research interests include HRD practice research assessment, economics of HRD, cross-cultural studies, HRD ethics, and innovations in HRD. Welcome, Greg.
SPEAKER_05Thank you, Laren. Thank you for having me here.
SPEAKER_02And my third guest for the episode is Dr. Maxim Voronoff, Professor of Organization Studies and Sustainability in the Schulich School of Business, York University, Canada. Maxim conducts research on the dynamics of social change at organizational, industry, and societal levels, and is especially interested in how people and organizations deploy cultural resources to bring about or resist social change. And he has studied the role of emotions in social change, the role of social movements in creating popular support for local products, and organizations' efforts to promote new ideas.
SPEAKER_02Maxim's work appears in such leading journals as the Academy of Management Review, Academy of Management Journal, Journal of Management Studies, and the Harvard Business Review, among others. Welcome, Maxim.
SPEAKER_04Thank you, Darren, for having me. Great to be here.
SPEAKER_02So over the next hour, we'll be talking about organizational, national, global politics and implications for organizations, for individuals, and then for HRD. I figured that before we dive into those details, it might be helpful to start our conversation by exploring what we mean by the term politics and how the three of you have worked on that as a topic in your research, writing, and practice. So, Greg, I wondered if you'd be willing to get the ball rolling for us by telling us what politics means to you and how you've worked on it.
SPEAKER_05Sure. This is really a good question. And uh people hardly really think about it. Uh uh, in my view, I would say politics is about uh control, about coordinate, about uh resource allocation policies or power relations. And uh it in my use my term terminology in the HRD definition, um, politics is about shaping.
SPEAKER_05I have another word called scaling, but related but mostly focused on shaping area. Uh, in my research, I divide two extremes of um national governance structure. On one extreme, it is a closed system represented by North Korea, China, Iran, those countries.
SPEAKER_05And on the other extreme, it's open system. Any countries with a democratic uh governance structure. And then all these um governance structure, or you call it the countries, nations, can be measured and described by four dimensions. One is uh power centralization or power concentration, two is decision making, uh, three is accountability, and four is information flow.
SPEAKER_05So make a long story short, in the all closed systems, power centralized is the key point, and everything one person says it all, and everybody else is just follow the lead. And then on a accountability dimension, loyalty is number one thing, not the competence. And for conformity, it is in open system, it is autonomous.
SPEAKER_05And then the last and probably very important critical aspect is the information flow. In the closed system, we got all the censorships. You have no opportunity to choose your own information sources, and government control everything. Like in China, they got great firewalls for the internet, block all the Western unwanted uh internet.
SPEAKER_05So all these would determine all the organizational behavior in different contexts, and this means context is more than traditional culture, which is, in my theory, is much less important because the same culture is likely to support two extreme systems. Think about Confucian value, Confucian culture.
SPEAKER_05It's supporting Taiwan's democracy system and also supporting China's dictatorship system. So that's my view, and it uh also determines all the right or wrong criteria, and HRD ethics would be completely upside down in two different whole systems. So I may just make a long story short. Um, we can have extended discussion if we have time, but uh it's something really triggered my additional research area.
SPEAKER_01I and I agree with Greg. This is a great place to start. My initial thinking, and and not to duplicate what Greg stated, is to delve a little bit deeper in terms of the the notion of sharing of power or in the negotiation of power. And so as I think about the course of my career, I've had to negotiate politics and just about every facet of my journey in higher ed, in particular as a woman and as an African-American woman.
SPEAKER_01And so in negotiating spaces, in how to position myself in terms of, let's say, advancement opportunities, but yet ensure that my mission and in the in the organization align with my expectations and what I see for myself in terms of rising, if you will. In the organizations that I've led, I try my best to pay attention to politics, ensuring that there's equity across the board to the extent possible in terms of access to, and again, you'll hear me refer to opportunities, access to opportunities.
SPEAKER_01Politics is it's all around us. Uh the big P is we we sometimes um talk about, and that's related to government and how government runs and a body of folks who who make who sort of represent us in um as a as a citizenry and making decisions on our behalf uh to what we experience individually at the community level and organizational level.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, I'm not gonna say anything drastically different here, I don't think. Uh I do tend to think of politics as uh how different groups are trying to see their interests and values reflected in what organization looks like and behaves like, which of course connects to what uh Dion and Greg were saying, in a sense that's much more pervasive than we tend to think about politics. And in my case, I I have to think about it quite a bit back in the days when I used to teach strategy for a number of years, and uh, we would discuss the units on strategy process and uh how profoundly political uh strategy development is, in the sense that all the decisions about strategy revolve around what organization will do as well as will not do.
SPEAKER_04And of course, those all have consequences for you know, some groups feeling satisfied with their interests and their values being reflected on what the organization is doing, and uh others feeling less satisfied uh by what the organization is doing. And um uh we can obviously go through every other process that organization has to go through and find politics there in a similar way.
SPEAKER_02That's interesting, and it leads us nicely, I think, into a conversation about the impact of politics on organizations. Because I think, like on the one hand, there is what you might describe as organizational politics, or the politics of what's happening within an organization. But before getting there, I I'm interested to explore national and global politics in terms of how how what's happening in society and the politics that's outside an organization, how that actually then can impact organizations.
SPEAKER_02So, Dion, this references to some of what you you talked about in your definition of politics. So, when you look at national and global politics, how do you see that impacting organizations and and has that been changing, do you think, over recent years?
SPEAKER_01Connecting uh this question to my area of research around women and policies and politics, if you will, around governing women's bodies. What relationship does government have and play in in the decisions that get made around women's rights? And so you see more and more of this conversation um occurring globally within the United States. We uh have experienced significant change in in particular Roe v.
SPEAKER_01Wade, it has really reverberated through throughout uh the United States and also has had a ripple effect to some extent globally. Uh, and so with my students, we're having conversations. What does this mean? And even as a mother uh to a daughter uh who is trying to find her place in this world uh where she will will walk into and is is will will lead in an environment where she has to figure out how how do I regain and reclaim that power right and the rights, if you will, of how women's bodies are governed.
SPEAKER_01And I'm situated in the southeastern part of the United States between two states that that are deemed conservative in terms of gun control, right, and gun rights. And and so what what I see and hear uh more often than not in the hallways are discussions about how do we protect ourselves, right? And so, Darren, I would offer, and and as you've sort of heard in my through my response, uh there's value in having conversations around these difficult topics in an organizational environment.
SPEAKER_01And it does require strategic leadership, it requires care. If we ignore the social uh activities and really movements, if you will, if you want to use that language, the things that are happening around us, if we do not find ways and create space for individuals to have conversations and really to try to gain a better understanding of multiple perspectives and sides, our organizations are will not be as effective and nor will the individuals who work and support those organizations.
SPEAKER_01So, in my view, it's important to create space for again these difficult topics.
SPEAKER_04I agree uh wholeheartedly with uh what what uh Dion was saying about sort of the kind of inevitability of um of politics penetrating organizations. And uh um as somebody whose uh work is more informed by sociology, I don't I tend to think of uh national politics as not something that happens out there. It inevitably penetrates organizations because you know our managers, our employees, uh they are all citizens, right? We don't stop being citizens the moment we walk into organizations and go to work nine to five.
SPEAKER_04Organizations uh may want to try to avoid taking stands on uh uh contentious political issues. And there are lots of forces, namely, I think more reactionary anti-progress forces that like to silence them and try to remind them that, oh, you know, your job is to uh focus on uh um shareholder value maximization, but that's not really realistic. And I think uh I'm pleased to see more organizations recognizing the fact that it's not a sustainable position.
SPEAKER_04It it's simply unsustainable for organizations to somehow pretend that they can just ignore those things. I mean, I we are seeing more organizations being more vocal, taking stances on important societal issues that um seem to be conflicting uh with the values of their employees and uh pushing back in some cases rather vocally against some of the uh uh government policies, as it might be necessary to do so. Um, and I hope we're gonna see more of that.
SPEAKER_02It makes me think about the challenges that organizations face in responding to national politics. And then, as Greg says, if you then have a global organization that is then attempting to respond to um political systems in the different countries that they have employees or that they're actually providing services, that makes it even more complicated.
SPEAKER_05Sorry, let me jump in with uh one particular example to demonstrate. Uh, in Canada, probably Maxim know that there's a lady called Meng Wang Zhou, who is the uh uh Huawei's CFO at the time, got detained by Canadian government and uh um under custody by Canadian government for two years and later on signed an agreement with the US government, released her, but she acknowledged every wrongdoing that the US government um alleged and uh trying to get an extradition from Canada to the US.
SPEAKER_05But eventually she was released, and then when she arrived in China, she received really big, big welcome back party to say what a heroic figure she was to cheat the enemy. So, in that context, cheating the US government is a heroic behavior, is being praised, encouraged. But in this country and in Canada, this is the bad thing to do.
SPEAKER_05You're lying, you're not honesty, but you still want to do business with the US. So this is what's going on here, and we'll see more things like that in the future, just based on my theoretical uh framework here.
SPEAKER_02So, Maxim, but back at the beginning, we talked about the fact that although although politics obviously is happening in society and is is feeding in and influencing organizations, that there's also organizational politics. There's like the politics of that naturally bubbles up as a result of us putting human beings into organizations. So I think it's worth focusing on that a little bit next. So when you look at politics within the organization, how do you see organizational politics, therefore, impacting the way things work in those organizations?
SPEAKER_04The big thing for me is to appreciate just how pervasive politics is in our organizations. To the extent that we sometimes teach our students about politics, the conversations tend to revolve around uh kind of distribution and eloquence. Of scarce resources primarily and negotiating for more resources for one's particular function and so on, right? And so as we start talking about all the important societal issues that are uh penetrating organizations, as we've been alluding to today, we can we can see that it's actually that there is much more that's going on in our organizations, right?
SPEAKER_04So it's not just about negotiation over tangible resources for the respective functions, it is about really negotiating the values. And it becomes more complicated as we as you have uh you know pluralistic organizations with employees whose values may differ from each other, from the management, uh, navigate also the pressure that an organization experiences as it tries to respond to the demands of external stakeholders such as governments.
SPEAKER_04And of course, it's interesting to think about the cross-national differences being very salient in terms of you know the pressures that organizations experience, but also, of course, now increasingly uh even state-to-state differences being very important, and in some cases, maybe more pronounced even than cross-national differences. So I can say, so in some senses, then you know, like I guess you know, organizations are kind of like families, right? They can be unwieldy and uh, you know, people with different perspectives and different views.
SPEAKER_04Uh, an organization kind of tries to move uh forward in some direction, you know, while different groups try to push it and pull it in a different direction, you know, which kind of I think creates an interesting paradox. I've been wondering about loudest voices versus democratic representation.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, it takes me to what Greg was talking about earlier. When Greg, when you were talking about closed systems versus open systems, and and like organizations, presumably, therefore, are probably more similar to a closed system than they are an open system. There aren't too many organizations where employees democratically elect their CEO, for example. Um, and so I I'm assuming, therefore, when we look within organizations, that we have such um we have the dynamics you were talking about in terms of power concentration, decision-making, accountability, and information flow.
SPEAKER_02And that probably plays out in things like differences of opinion between those who are revenue generators in an organization versus those who are cost centers, or those who are in the headquarters office versus those who are in regional offices or in satellite countries. So when you take a look, Greg, at organizational politics, do you view it through the same lens as you view global national politics, or do you look at it differently?
SPEAKER_05Yeah, there are some detailed, more specific concepts under this theory. For instance, I see organizations uh in open systems, they are doing open shaping. But in the closed system, they are doing closed shaping. So, first let me define the closed shaping. What is it? Close shaping is number one individuals, employees cannot leave the location to be shaped.
SPEAKER_05You have no way to leave if you don't want to be shaped. That's the closed shaping. You basically stayed in a big, large jail. Number two, the information flow is being controlled by the organization. You have no choice to get additional information. And if the person is can freely move from a being shaped location and can receive free information from wherever the person wishes.
SPEAKER_05This is called open shaping. So in the US, for instance, if I worked in GE, we know GE's uh culture, organization culture used to be very competitive. If I don't want to be shaped, I can leave. Nobody can stop me by quitting my job. That's the key part for the differences. And then I have perfect information sources, I can find jobs in the market, but in China, in North Korea, people cannot leave, they're restricted.
SPEAKER_05Even with uh, I'm sure you heard of China's uh huko system. If you were born in a place your lifetime fixed there, there's no way you can leave. So that's the difference. And with all that in the micro level, organizational level, then plus the two uh extreme governance structure, that's what's happening right now in this world. And that is also causing all the problems in the international setting and in national setting.
SPEAKER_01So, Maxim, as you were speaking and Greg, um social media and the flow of information and how how organizations and individuals within these organizations how do they use social media to either promote their positions or to express their positions? If if you're in a closed system, social media is often a venue to be able to sort of an outlet to share what your position is on a particular topic. And what I am seeing more and more of in organizations, in particular higher ed, there's there's an expectation that you need to be extra careful about what you post.
SPEAKER_01And I'm sure that is not uh unique to higher ed. That's a sort of an expectation uh in other organizational settings, but it's particularly acute in higher education because the stakes are high for uh institutions that are again seeking to attract a diverse group of students. And if certain faculty and administrators post certain things, that may be uh obviously a reflection on the organization and the institution.
SPEAKER_02That might transition us nicely actually into exploring what this does mean for individual employees and the workforce as a whole. Because I think the social media example is a really good one. I think when I take a look at the social media posts of Ben and Jerry's, um, and you take a look at how Ben and Jerry's post, I'm saying their posts are very political in support of the agenda that as an organization they passionately believe in. But I then listen to Dion, and I'm thinking if I worked in higher education and posted as an employee what Ben and Jerry's post as an organization, there would probably be a considerable reaction.
SPEAKER_02So, Maxine, when you take a look at what all of this means, you know, how how do you see it playing out for individual employees and like the workforce?
SPEAKER_04One of the exciting things, I guess, about the fact that we're talking about politics and the pervasiveness of politics is that I think uh a lot of us, a lot of employees, uh a lot of managers, um, are still sort of in some ways stuck um in the kind of traditional old-fashioned mindset that politics is bad, right? So basically there is that mindset that good people focus on the work and on the substance, and the bad people focus on the politics, right? And I think that's that's the first thing that we really need to get away from is to appreciate the pervasiveness of politics.
SPEAKER_04And I think it is the the employees who buy into this sort of the traditional mindset that politics is bad, and we can somehow depoliticize our organizations and our work, um, they actually find themselves at a disadvantage for many reasons. The thing that I want to focus on here is that it makes it harder for them to voice their values, to influence their organization, and to help set the agenda for the organization and how it uh tackles not just business issues, but a variety of uh the societal issues that we've been talking about uh here that that are that in that are inevitably part of what organizations have to deal with, right?
SPEAKER_04And so oftentimes calling something political delegitimizes it, right? And and it uh um and delegitimizes in the eyes of many. And um, there's of course lots and lots of examples that organizations have had of things that organizations have had to negotiate over the past uh few years that are inevitably political. So, for example, the issue of remote working, right? Uh, that that has been uh contentious uh for organizations even before the pandemic. And of course, during the pandemic, it seems like we gravitated toward a quote, new normal end of quote, where it turns out we actually were able to do a lot of things remotely that we swore up and down that we could not possibly do remotely prior to the pandemic.
SPEAKER_04And now suddenly, as a part of our spirit, to hey, let's get back to normal and pretend that it's uh 2019 again. You know, we're very busy forcing employees back to work regardless, and kind of trying to forget all the lessons we've had about data, and that in some cases, for example, remote working can be beneficial and can address a variety of issues, including diversity issues, for example, in organizations and uh promote inclusiveness and so on. So that's just one example of the things that that employees are having to, you know, the political issues that they're having to navigate, uh, that oftentimes that they somehow end up feeling silenced because they don't want to play politics, quote unquote, right?
SPEAKER_04Or the the issue about the safety, uh COVID safety. And this and this is what kind of what brings me to the to this to this dilemma that that I've been uh thinking um and writing about a lot, the dilemma between sort of loudest, loudest voices versus democracy, right? So generally speaking, we set up uh organizations or we try to have to run organizations and other uh of you know whether it's businesses, but even more so, you know, universities and other things, uh, as more democratic institutions, right? And so essentially it's that we're supposed to be reflecting uh and protecting the rights of uh of the majority.
SPEAKER_04The problem is that there's always the issue of quote unquote silent majority, right? And so, you know, so most people are not particularly activated and not particularly feel either comfortable or motivated to get involved in various politically contentious issues. And uh, and of course, then there's a small number of people who tend to be very comfortable and very eager to get involved in politically contentious discussions. And it's kind of interesting to think about in the context of COVID safety, right? Where we see it both in in a lot of organizations, uh, where the majority of employees, based on their internal surveys, would have liked to have kept safety practices going for longer, uh, but organizations dropped them.
SPEAKER_04Uh, we saw it at uh at government level, for you know, in state level. So, for example, you know, we New York City actually showed surveys that uh people wanted to keep uh mask mandates going longer in public places, but the city went ahead and dropped them anyway. Whereas the silent majority, instead, what we do hear are the voices of the vocal minority who you know who really exaggerate the coerciveness of these public health measures that are that are uh meant to promote collective safety.
SPEAKER_04And in and in general, organizations then end up sort of surrendering to the vocal uh minority of people who are particularly loud and tend to be anti-progressive. And we see we see it of course in any number of contexts as well, right? Like organizations sometimes hesitate to do more on uh corporate social responsibility because they are afraid some internal or external stakeholders, a few of them, will loudly accuse them of being quote unquote vulg.
SPEAKER_04And so they end up silencing themselves. And uh, and so and that's and that's really the uh the um interesting thing, uh that the interesting phenomenon that we need to think about and we need to wrestle with is that the the more we sort of try to depoliticize our organizations and uh to sort of try to get away from politics and quote unquote focus on the core of our jobs, ironically, we're actually not doing that, right? We're just simply surrendering to the minority of people who are particularly keen on kind of invalidating the social consensus on uh stopping you know a lot of initiatives that might be for public for public good.
SPEAKER_01So, Maxim, you you hit a hot button for me, and that is your reference uh to the term woke or wokeism, and and that's a hot topic right now, particularly uh in the south southern part of uh United States. And and and I've I've been fortunate along my journey to to really work with a diverse group of folks up and down the ladder. And um, as as this this particular term has is become politicized, right, and and keeping my higher ed hat on, what I've discovered is that folks don't understand the term.
SPEAKER_01They don't understand history, they don't know history. And it's a bit frustrating because individuals who have chosen to quote unquote politicize the term, they're they're speaking and talking and the use of the term without context, without really, again, sort of centering back on this notion of not really understanding history. And so so I have had to bite my tongue on a number of occasions.
SPEAKER_01And and um, and again, so going back to this this topic about politics, how how do you, at what point, Maxim and Greg and Derek, when do you voice, express uh not necessarily dissent, but but to create space for discussion? And again, my my intent is not to change minds, but to to inform. And so what I've what I've become much more comfortable in doing is approaching those conversations with, hey, have you thought about X?
SPEAKER_01Have you thought, have you, would you be open to reviewing this particular resource? And I distinctly remember having a conversation several months ago when and a colleague of mine simply said, uh, Dion, you know what? I had no no clue. So, and we're talking about individuals who were leading organizations who were promoting uh in a misunderstanding or a lack of understanding around terminology that is affecting and really having seismic uh impacts on um topics, for example, I'll just get granular um critical race theory, for example.
SPEAKER_01I mean, that is that topic alone uh in the United States is is really taking a um a beating because there's misunderstandings about that particular theory and it's it's being used in a way that was not intended.
SPEAKER_02We'll be back in a moment with more from Dion, Greg, and Maxim as we dig into the relationship between HRD and politics. First, though, it's an important reminder that this episode is brought to you thanks to the wonderful sponsorship support of Troy University.
SPEAKER_00At Troy University, we teach everyone to be leaders in their field. Are your masters with the Troy University Fast Track Graduate Program and finish in as little as one year, online or in class. Head towards the future you've always wanted, with a top-ranked education from Troy University. Now is your time to take the lead. Apply today to begin classes October 16th. Visit Troy.edu.
SPEAKER_02Right. Let's return to our discussion. Listening to your your response there, Dion, makes me think about the challenges that there are for people in organizations who who potentially are in a place where they could create spaces for discussion, but increasingly find themselves, I guess to respond to what Maxim was saying, how do I listen to the voices, whether they're loud or whether they're a silent majority?
SPEAKER_02Um, how do I then respond to that? Um, given increased polarization of viewpoints within organizations? So, Greg, given the work that you've done on HRD, when you look at all of this and the complexity of politics and how it's impacting organizations, what do you see as the implications for HRD professionals who are working on organizational change, who are working on learning and development?
SPEAKER_05Yeah, I would say this is all about um shaping. I mentioned earlier, and we'll continue to mention these keywords. What is shaping? Shaping is about culture change, about value, norms and beliefs. Think about the um just mentioned about the individual level, diversity, inclusion, or in workplace. This is this is all about culture change.
SPEAKER_05And uh the key point would become how HRD, or maybe how the leader in any organization can take and play a critical role to initiate and manage this change. So HRD for the three keywords is all about uh change, learning and performance. And if you can change successfully in culture, value, believe, norms, and uh make your employee individuals really learn what's new in the culture and they will perform.
SPEAKER_05That's all about HRD.
SPEAKER_02That's all I'm glad you mentioned DEI there, because that that's been in the the news a lot over the last few months, particularly where there seems to be an increasing like polarization between organizations that are pushing DEI initiatives versus other organizations, particularly state organizations in certain states, where um they're being told you cannot run DEI initiatives.
SPEAKER_02And so that presumably places HR professionals in an increasingly challenging position, because that that really is a case of where politics is influencing what training is happening or not happening within organizations. I'm saying uh Dion, when you when you see that at a sort of an organization or a community level, how do you see that playing out?
SPEAKER_01Darren, that is a hot potato. It's a it's a good one. It's a good, what's a good one, yes. So how do I see it playing out? It you see in Maxim address this silencing, right? You you see individuals who perhaps are facing a major decision as to whether to stay or to leave the organizations because there is no longer or potentially a lack of alignment with organizational mission and personal um perspectives and missions.
SPEAKER_01And so ultimately, in my view, the the individual or the CEO, the the leader has to reflect, has to embrace principles, and this is where where my training comes in principles of continuous learning, um, modeling the expectation of um creating space and ensuring that there is access and there are opportunities for individuals to learn and grow and to expand their under their knowledge base around, let's say, diversity, equity, and inclusion.
SPEAKER_01I will tell you folks, the the vast majority of individuals who really are not studying those terms, they may not fully understand what they mean. And so we we have individuals who are operating uh programs or attempting to launch DEI, uh DIB. I mean, there's other terms that are associated in uh with uh this notion, but they're operating programs, perhaps not with the intent to truly make systematic changes or really uh systems level changes, and they're they're simply promoting DEI because it's politically expedient, right?
SPEAKER_01And when you see that, and it's clear, it's very clear when you when you come across and I bet Maxim, when you're studying these organizations and Greg, you can clear, you can smell it, right? It's very, it's very easy to pick up. But you when you do find the organizations that that are truly um mission focused and and and Reflective of the principles and understandings of around DEI. And I'll provide a specific example locally. The United Way of the Chattahoochee Valley, which is based in Columbus, Georgia, the leader or the CEO of this organization, he lives, breathes all of the decisions, the way that the organization is how it's run.
SPEAKER_01The practices, the hiring practices reflect this appreciation and understanding of DEI. So just literally the decisions that are made organizationally and what I see occurring at the community level in terms of programming, it's reflected DEI, that the philosophy and the understanding is reflected in the decisions and the activities that are promoted through this organization.
SPEAKER_01And so ultimately it's it at the top level, if the the leadership at the top level fully embraces, it's going to be inculcated with throughout the organization. And then you'll also find employees, in my view, who who are much more engaged, who are willing to speak up Maxim, as we talked about, in in times when it is contentious.
SPEAKER_02One of the themes that's run through our conversation here, I think, is about the the incr I think the increasing influence that politics has on organizations. A good example of that for me, I think, has been that the nature of the influence of politics might depend on whether you're working for a private sector organization or a public sector organization. And if you're public sector, what state are you in, what city you in, all of that could influence at the moment what training you can run, what adult education programs you're allowed to run, how you what sort of leadership you might be allowed to promote.
SPEAKER_02And so Dion, coming back to you, because I think you you you were heading in that direction in what you were just talking about there. When you take a look at uh politics as a whole, uh how do we prepare adult educators and leadership developers and HRD professionals for being successful in a space that's as complex as this?
SPEAKER_01So Greg shared the the term open shaping. So I'll sort of link back to to that term and and and he's spot on organizations led by hopefully individuals who are lifelong learners, who embrace education, um, who hold a per the perspective that everyone should have the opportunity to be developed, right? Have the opportunity to have access to professional development opportunities and then and also leadership training opportunities.
SPEAKER_01If the employees, if they are fully supported at all levels, from my experience and and I've I've come to understand that when you make these professional development opportunities uh uh accessible to individuals, um, they will access them. They will also create uh and not to necessarily say create, but they will be much more open to engaging in uh contentious uh discussions, uh, if in particular if if it involves their their leadership ability and their leadership capacity.
SPEAKER_01And so for the HRD profession and for adult educators, at the end of the day, it's about uh recognizing that you do not hold all, we do not hold all of the answers. Uh we have a requirement and expectation to learn and then to also afford and create space for others to do the same. And I'm hoping that that that's getting to your point, your question there. But for me, it's all about uh access to learning, education, and uh and and then also being open to uh the notion that you may not be right.
SPEAKER_01I may not be the the sole expert in in the space or in in in in in the organization. And I may hold positional power, however, there there's value in shared power, which also, in my view, is is an important concept when promoting um an organization that that allows discussion around political or contentious topics.
SPEAKER_02So Maxim, Greg, you're you you're both involved in university programs that are potentially educating those who will be our next set of leaders, our next set of HRD professionals. But when you take a look at education programs in colleges, do you see them preparing people for the sort of complexities that we've talked through? And if not, what sort of changes would you like to see in college curricula?
SPEAKER_04I think so, in general, I don't think our curriculum is doing a particularly good job, to be blunt. I I think fundamentally we need to get the future HRD practitioners to appreciate the fact that organizations are social systems as opposed to simply economic systems. And as such, politics is an intrinsic part of it, as we talked about. So they need to be trained to acknowledge, diagnose, and uh help organizations deal with the political realities that are inevitable.
SPEAKER_04And uh, you know, my PhD was in organizational psychology, and I've gravitated toward more sociologically oriented research. And there's a reason for it, I guess, uh, because the more soci more psychologically rooted perspectives tend to be almost allergic to politics and that almost uh try to reduce everything to sort of benign and non-political terms. So I'm super happy to be hearing the frameworks that uh Greg has developed to you know to teach HRD practitioners to really take politics seriously seriously, because you know, in the days when I was doing my PhD, that didn't really seem like there was much for people to draw from.
SPEAKER_04And I think it and I and I my sense that's still quite still largely remains the case. That's also the case for our business school uh curriculum. I teach at the business school, uh, and uh you know, politics is still at most the peripheral part of what we talk about. You know, basically a lot of the concepts that we train students to get good at are in many ways intended to get the politics out of the conversations. And as we talked about before, that's that's it doesn't get politics out of organizations, uh, it just uh and doesn't get politics out of conversations, it just silences the conversation about politics and makes it uh lopsided and uh makes it easier for some people to participate in it and not others.
SPEAKER_04And so I think an intrinsic part of what HRD practitioners need to be learning is to appreciate their unique role as somebody who is particularly well positioned as an agent of facilitating these conversations around politics, so that something that is normally silent is uh given voice and uh negotiated and discussed in a more constructive way that results in more beneficial outcomes for employees, for the organization, for this for the organization stakeholders, etc.
SPEAKER_05Given my research, my thoughts are now on two different parts of the world. And let me talk about situations in China now. There was a number by some organizations say is right now in China PhD production is the number one in number in the world, in all countries, and um in higher education now they have all the communist party branches controlling the education, and students can only study what being told, not everything uh they wanted.
SPEAKER_05And uh the Marxism theory is a required course from uh elementary school up to PhD level. If I remember correctly, in all higher education institutions, universities, colleges, they newly created College of Marxism to teach the Communist Party's theory, Marxism theories, and um this is what I call shaping.
SPEAKER_05And under this shaping, the accountability perspective would be the loyalty. So you have only one voice, one thought, and one leader, also one source. So there's no innovation, no critical thinking is allowed. That's uh that's one thing I see that uh um the a possibility would be lost of the innovation and creativity in that part of the world.
SPEAKER_05On the other side, in uh in our program, from my uh experiences, my teachings focused very heavily on critical thinking. And I gave students extra bonus if they can critique my publication. And I encourage strongly, and my assignment would always be uh article critique from peer-reviewed HRD journal.
SPEAKER_05And you have to say something, uh, independent thinking based to critique. So that's one critical thing I would think at uh probably should start with uh undergraduate, but uh I'm currently teaching only uh masters and PhD students, so I'm focused more on that perspective because this is an open shaping environment. So the open shaping, one critical thing is to critique so that you can be innovative and be creative.
SPEAKER_05That's what I take, and I I can also see the contrast between the two extremes of the governance system.
SPEAKER_02Before we hear our final question on the implications for research, let's first pause briefly for an important reminder that this episode is brought to you thanks to the wonderful sponsorship support of Troy University.
SPEAKER_00At Troy University, we teach everyone to be leaders in their field. Earn your MBA from Troy University's AACSB accredited at the Royal College of Fitness in as little as one year online. Head toward the future you've always wanted with a top rate education from Troy University. Now is your time to take the lead. Apply today to begin classes October 16th. Visit Troy.edu.
SPEAKER_02Right, let's return to our discussion. Um I'm conscious that all three of you are active in terms of research and writing, and also that um some of our listeners are um PhD students who are probably listening to this episode right now and are currently thinking about what topic to select for their dissertation. I'd be interested in what advice you might give those people if they if they've listened to this and start thinking about for the first time, maybe, the about the connection between politics and HRD, what what advice you might have for them about what research they could do on politics and organizations and HRD that could maybe fill some of the gap in our understanding or to move our thinking forward.
SPEAKER_05In my theory paper, towards the end, I derived uh well it naturally leads to uh two separate but very close related subfields of HRD, what I call it macro HRD and micro-HRD. So I would encourage those who are interested in politics at national level to focus on macro HRD, which is HRD at the national level.
SPEAKER_05But that does not mean that uh micro-HRD has not uh does not important. It is important because it examines HRD behavior at organizational team and individual level. I would encourage uh PhD student to challenge the authoritative big figure uh HRD scholar and uh to be innovative, uh to be uh critical.
SPEAKER_05That's my um because I started with that and I've been very productive, uh, and I can't publish fast enough. So that that's a key thing I would advise for PhD students.
SPEAKER_01I have the opportunity to teach in uh my university's global leadership PhD program, and so I would offer there is incredible, there's an incredible gap in the literature in terms of the intersection of HRD and global leadership and understanding the implications of that. And so I would suggest uh uh venturing in into that arena and then also uh also referencing my passion around women and leadership, there is still plenty of space to uh explore how women are impacted by politics uh and at various levels in an organization and globally.
SPEAKER_01And so those are really two good opportunities and potential areas of research for dissertation.
SPEAKER_04I guess I would suggest that uh there's there's a growing body of literature that is sometimes explicitly labeled as such, and sometimes it's not, uh, under the rubric of open policy, which basically conceives of organizations as um kind of open policies, that essentially there is an interpenetration uh of organizations. Basically, there's external stakeholders, you know, with their agendas that are trying to influence organizations, and then there is uh uh internal stakeholders that kind of translate those external pressures and uh and kind of influence um what organization does or does not do.
SPEAKER_04So uh there's two papers in particular that were published in 2017 by Daniel Weiger and Klaus Weber. Um, it you know, basically the term is open policy, so for any students uh listening who want to look them up, uh, one in Academy of Management Review and the other one in Academy of Management Annals. Um the big thing that I would encourage uh folks to do is really to sort of think about how this you know external um societal political issues that we have alluded to throughout the conversation today, how they are impacting the more traditional uh HRD topics, right?
SPEAKER_04So basically kind of go through the list of whatever uh you know core topics uh within HRD that uh you know folks have been studying in the various classes and kind of think about how these macro environment forces the political environment, you know, the globalization, um, you know, the national, you know, the cross-national and uh intranational differences, how do all those things might be influencing how these topics um might be operating, right?
SPEAKER_04And essentially just getting away from the assumption, you know, that that somehow that that uh we can focus on those topics and depoliticize organizations, but actually flip it and say, okay, let's start from the assumption. Everything we do in organization, all of our HRD practices are intrinsically and profoundly political. How do those extra-organizational forces read large, how are they influencing and how could they be influencing how these um uh issues are playing out?
SPEAKER_02Well, that sounds wonderful advice, and uh across the three from the recommendations all three three of you shared, they're a great call to action. Um unfortunately we've run out of time for today's conversation, but I'm hoping it will kick start a whole bunch of new conversations and form a new discussion. I wanted to say a big thank you to all three of you. So thank you to Dion, to Greg, to Maxim for such an interesting discussion and for giving us so much to think about and then to act upon. So thank you so much indeed.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, thank you, Darren, for organizing this and uh uh uh wonderful to have a discussion with you, Dion and Greg.
SPEAKER_01Likewise.
SPEAKER_03Thank you, Darren.
SPEAKER_01Thank you again. Thank you.
SPEAKER_02Thank you so much for joining me for this episode. It was wonderful spending time with Dion Roster Mims, Greg Wang, and Maxim Voronoff. If you enjoyed this episode, check out all of our others. There were 33 episodes in the first three seasons, and we're releasing a further 11 here in the fourth. Between them, they provide access to conversations with over 100 leading scholars from around the world. New episodes released weekly.
SPEAKER_02To learn more about the series, check out HRDmasterclass.com. And to learn about the Academy of Human Resource Development, check out ahrd.org. Also, don't forget to look into our sponsors, the Department of Human Resource Development at the University of Texas at Tyler Seouls College of Business. Find out about them by visiting their website. You'll find it at the top of the Google search page when you search for UT Tyler HRD.
SPEAKER_02And also don't forget to look into our second sponsor, the Troy University Fast Track Graduate Program. Find out more about them at Troy.edu. I'm looking forward to being with you in our next episode when we're exploring the relationship between HRD, social justice, and human rights. With the help of Dr. Mary Alfred of Texas AM University, Dr. Cynthia Sims of the University of Georgia, and Iko Bethea of RAIR Coaching and Consulting.
SPEAKER_02Until then, this is Darren Short of signing off from the HRD Masterclass.com.
This fourth episode of Season 6 brings together Dr. Sanghamitra Chaudhuri (Temple University) and Dr. Kyung Nam Kim (Texas A&M University) for a conversation about the 2026 article Gendered Pathways to Work-Family...
This third episode of Season 6 brings together Dr. Yuanlu Niu (University of Arkansas) and Dr. Jos Akkermans (Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam) for a conversation about the 2026 article Navigating careers in non-traditional...
This second episode of Season 6 brings together Dr. Matthew Hurtienne (University of Texas at Tyler) and Dr. Heesun Kim (Francis Marion University) for a conversation about the 2024 article Silence in the workplace:...
This first episode of Season 6 brings together Dr. Joshua Collins (University of Minnesota) and Dr. Ague Mae Manongsong (Louisiana State University) for a conversation about the 2023 article “Manongsong, A. M., & Ghosh,...
Welcome to the trailer for Season 6 of Human Resource Development Masterclass - the podcast series from the Academy of Human Resource Development, the organization that leads HRD through research. The sixth season...