Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Human Resource Development Masterclass

Human Resource Development Masterclass artwork

How To Rethink HRD

May 19, 202554 minAudio

In this third episode of Season 5, guests Dr. Laura Bierema, Dr. Jamie Callahan, and Dr. Tomika Greer discuss how to rethink HRD by exploring questions: What does it mean to rethink HRD? What do you see in organizations that makes you want to rethink HRD? What makes the timing right to rethink HRD? Does rethinking HRD mean an evolution or a transformation? Do we already have alternative ways of thinking about HRD? Does transformation happen top-down or bottom-up? Where does someone start who wants to transform HRD? and much more. For full details on the HRD Masterclass series, visit hrdmasterclass.com, and for the bios of the guest scholars visit allbypodcast.com/rethinking. For more information on the Academy of Human Resource Development, visit ahrd.org. This episode is sponsored by: The University of Georgia, Gwinnett Campus and Mary Frances Early College of Education, Department of Lifelong Education, Administration, and Policy, Program of Adult Learning, Leadership, and Organization Development. For full information, check out their website.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_04Now is the time to make the move to change what HRD is. And for me, that's stripping back all of these policies and practices that are not serving interests of the people and the organizations in which they work.

SPEAKER_00Welcome to Human Resource Development Masterclass, the podcast series from the Academy of Human Resource Development, the organization that leads HRD through research. I'm your host, Darren Short, and here in our fifth season, we're exploring some of our listeners' top how-to questions with the help of leading authors, researchers and scholars. In this third episode of the season, we're focusing on the question of how to rethink HRD. In the current climate around the globe, so much of what we've assumed or known appears to be being challenged and in some cases blown up.

SPEAKER_00So perhaps the timing is right to rethink HRD. And what better group to help with this than the authors of the recent book Human Resource Development, Critical Perspectives and Practices published by Routledge. I'm therefore joined today by three of those authors who were together for a conversation in December of 2024. My first guest is Dr. Laura L. Beermer, who is Professor, Program of Adult Learning, Leadership and Organization Development in the Mary Francis Early College of Education at the University of Georgia.

SPEAKER_00Author of over 100 publications, Laura's scholarly interests include adult and organizational learning, critical HRD, Women's Learning and Leadership, Career Development and Coaching. My second guest is Dr. Jamie L. Callahan, Professor of Organization Studies and Ethics at Durham University in the United Kingdom. Jamie's research addresses issues of power and privilege in organized contexts, leading her to explore marginalized groups' experiences of leadership, learning and organizational transformation.

SPEAKER_00Her particular passion is championing gender equity. My third guest is Dr. Tamika W. Greer, Assistant Professor of Human Resource Development in the Department of Human Development and Consumer Sciences at the University of Houston. She conducts and publishes research related to career development, including post-secondary education and training, career transitions and work-life integration for women and marginalized groups. Just visit allbypodcast.com forward slash rethinking to learn more about the bios of our three guests.

SPEAKER_00And also to connect with our episode sponsors, the University of Georgia, Gwynette Campus, and Mary Frances Early College of Education, Department of Lifelong Education, Administration and Policy, Programme of Adult Learning, Leadership and Organization Development. Talking of sponsorship, Human Resource Development Masterclass is only made possible thanks to the wonderful support of our sponsors who cover all of the costs associated with the series and so enable us to release them free of charge to listeners like you.

SPEAKER_00I encourage you to show your thanks by checking them out and letting them know just how much their sponsorship means to you. Today's episode is brought to you thanks to the sponsorship of the University of Georgia Gwynet Campus and the Mary Francis Early College of Education, Department of Lifelong Education, Administration and Policy, whose program of adult learning, leadership and organization development equips learners to gain deep knowledge and skills to lead learning and change to help adults, teams and organizations thrive with their blended and online Masters of Education, innovative hybrid executive doctorate of education, and world-class research training in their PhD program.

SPEAKER_00They also have graduate certificates in organization coaching and transformative leadership. Using their unique framework that emphasizes the theory and practice needed to strategically and holistically develop healthy, sustainable organizations, learners gain a mastery of multiple areas including adult learning and training, organization development and change leadership, group development and problem solving, talent management and development, career development and coaching.

SPEAKER_00To find out more, check out their website coe.uga.edu slash academics slash concentrations slash learning leadership and organization development. Right, let's dive into the episode. So the focus of the episode today is how to rethink HRD in organizations. And we could probably start that conversation in many, many places. How about we start just by seeing where that question takes your thinking?

SPEAKER_00So when you hear that question to rethink HRD in organizations, what immediately comes to mind for you?

SPEAKER_04For me, it's the book that the three of us co-authored with Carol Elliott and Josh Collins. Originally, you know, Laura and I started with a conversation, what this must have been 10 years ago at this point, about how the way that we were thinking about the traditional ways of thinking about HRD just really did not meet the needs of so many people. And we really needed to fundamentally rethink what Laura has called the holy trinity of HRD. It really formed the basis of us wanting to write this book so that we gave people a different kind of tool to think about what HRD could be.

SPEAKER_04That was the initial impetus. If you ask me about changing up, what I immediately think of is our book, because that's what we were trying to do.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, well, and and let me just say for the sake of the listeners, that the Holy Trinity of HRD was uh Pat McGlagan's classification of it as training and development, organization development, and career development. There was a study of leadership that probably happened, I mean, maybe in the 70s or 80s. And it was where the researchers followed probably CEOs or other executive leaders around all day, since the belief that leaders plan, organize, control, motivate.

SPEAKER_01There's probably one or two other ones. And they found that's not what they spent their day doing. And I think that it kind of knowing that what we say in theory HRD should be doing, and then what are HRD people doing? And I think that's why the model that um Jamie and I proposed was based on verbs, you know, of learning, changing, organizing, and relating. As you know, the kinds of engagement with humans that people who work in the field doing.

SPEAKER_01So I think that's a good starting point.

SPEAKER_02Yeah. So for me, what comes to mind immediately is the need to unsilo, because when we talk about HRD, we are talking about a very narrow range of whether it be actions like verbs or functions like the McClagan three functions of HRD. Um, and so I I think we need to unsilo and recognize um, you know, we we talk a lot about systems theory in HRD, um, and we are part of a system.

SPEAKER_02We are not necessarily just a system within ourselves. So thinking about how the organization as a whole functions and realizing that HRD is a part of that, but it's not, it should not be a siloed part of that. Um, I think too, we need to recognize the way organizations function, I think is timeless. Organizations always function as a system and we understand those systems. But the language that's used there, the way people understand how communication and relating works, um, I think that's changing.

SPEAKER_02And so if we think back to those, the Holy Trinity, those three functions, like training and development, that's not even what it's called anymore. We have so many new and innovative terms. Like nowhere in there do we hear the word even talent, right? And um, talent management, talent development, those kinds of things are where the language has moved. And I think we need to unsilo and and move with the language and the way people think and work and speak today.

SPEAKER_00Behind some of what the three of you have spoken about here is the fact that there is something broken about the way that HRD is currently operating within organizations. When you look at HRD in organizations, what do you see that makes you think, gosh, we really need to rethink this?

SPEAKER_01Well, I mean, if you look at the theories that have been very influential of the field are Western, uh, primarily were written by white men, and I think had a very instrumental way of thinking about the organization in also ways that probably benefited management over employees. And of course, I don't want to sound naive that I don't understand that you know, people who work in an HRD are agents of an organization. However, they're also agents of human beings who work in those organizations.

SPEAKER_01And so it's it's far different than accounting, uh, you know, or engineering, which you know, maybe trying to figure out a financial solution or a technical structural solution to problems. I mean, we're dealing with lives and people who are greatly affected by policy and decision making, inequity, injustice, things that happen in organizations, the culture and the access that they have to learning and development. So I think thinking about it more holistically as a process that really is important to the overall functioning of every every functional area of the organization, but also the really important organizational health, which is something that I think all of us wrote about in the book and think about like what makes an organization healthy.

SPEAKER_01And you know, I think it's engagement, it's equity, it's opportunity to advance, it's support uh from you know within the organization, both peers and leaders. And you know, how do we help organizations be healthy places where people want to work? And it's a win-win solution because if you know, if the if the organization is healthy, it's likely fulfilling its service or product mission well with people who want to work there, who are happy to work there, who stay.

SPEAKER_01Um, it sounds so simple.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, well, and see, that's what I think is the danger of the narrow definitions of HRD, because if we define HRD in these terms of organizational performance or um learning and development, we're missing so much of the beautiful things that Laura said about equity and access. And we are kind of cutting ourselves off. Like that's what saddens me about how HRD is sometimes done in organizations, is that it doesn't always fulfill all the things that it could be doing to enhance like the organizational health that Laura was just speaking of.

SPEAKER_02And so I feel like a lot of times we we're limiting ourselves when there's so much more that we could do to help people flourish, to help organizations flourish. And I think we get caught up in some of the tradition and some of the book knowledge that doesn't always get us to um fulfilling all the things that we have the potential to do.

SPEAKER_04And I think both of you use words of process and systems. And when I think of some of the key things that make me realize we need to change, I I feel like our processes have been built up over time to respond to our context, to respond to the systems that we're embedded in. I'm kind of drawing a little bit on Giddens here, this idea that our systems drive our actions, our actions inform the systems, and there's this structuration back and forth of what happens.

SPEAKER_04And I think a lot of the processes that we've been built up, that we have built up over time, are in response to those instrumental kinds of theories and kinds of performative approaches that organizations have. And every time, you know, every time we mess up along against one of those issues of justice, or um we don't perform well, we come up with another metric, or organizations and the management of organizations come up with another metric that we need to meet to ensure that we comply with this um new policy, or we comply with that policy, or we have a better way of engaging in merit, or you know, all of the different things that we have built up to measure our success and measure what is important to ensure that we don't get hurt again on something.

SPEAKER_04We've built up these systems of processes without looking at the fundamental underlying structures that we're trying to do, which are all of the things that Laura and Tamika just talked about. We don't look at those underlying things and say, how can we fit? How can how can we address these uh issues in a holistic way that meets our underlying values? Instead, we look at how can we layer on top something so that system or that process that we have doesn't hurt. So my example is um I just got finished, I I was getting hollered at because I had eight different compliance training modules, online modules that I had to go through to meet the assessment of what was what they wanted me to meet.

SPEAKER_04Not that they wanted me to learn those things, just that they needed me to tick the box that I had done those things so that they can say, Oh, but she took the training, she knew what she was supposed to do. So it's a compliant, Irina Grigulis talks about this in one of her books on a critical approach to training and development. It's quite old now, but that particular book talks about the way that we engage in training, tells us about the processes that have led us to the point where we're just looking at compliance and we're not really interested in developing that healthy kind of organization, we're just interested in CYA.

SPEAKER_04And so I think we need to strip back a lot of our processes that we have that say this is in place to make this thing good or that thing better performing, and say, does it really? What are we losing when we have these kinds of things and how can we change our processes?

SPEAKER_00When I listen to your answers, it makes me realize that I it implies, I think, that HRD has always been flawed. The way we view HRD in organizations has always been flawed. It's never considered the things that you're talking through. Um, but I'm wondering whether the timing now is is more right to do something about it, i.e., is there is there something happening contextually within society or within organizations that makes us think if there was ever a time for us to rethink it, now's that time.

SPEAKER_01Well, how many of you saw the article that was in the New York Times in August? And it the title was So, Human Resources is Making You Miserable? This and then of course the subline is get in line behind the HR managers themselves who say that since the pandemic, the job has become an exasperating ordeal. People hate us. And, you know, and I think the article kind of gives a nice history of you know how human human relations you know evolved or devolved into personnel management and so on.

SPEAKER_01And that um, you know, people in HR generally want to help people. And it seems like sometimes the job is anything but, and uh, you know, so I think that even people who work in the field are frustrated. I think that the field is also ready to rethink it. And and then, you know, I think I've always felt confined by HRD in some ways because, you know, if you look at the discourse in the field or the bias tends to be privileged people, you know, the high potential employees and the C-suite executives.

SPEAKER_01And, you know, I come from a labor background, and you know, the labor education movement is an amazing thing, or even workplace learning is a bigger tent, really, than HRD. And I actually think the field sells it short to not pay attention to broader things that are going on with work and learning globally. And, you know, and there are people in our field who are concerned with that, you know, I think of um Alan Skully Russ, who also has a strong labor background, you know, and looking at what we can learn from labor unions and their educational movements or countries where HRD is not owned by the corporation, but it is considered a community good and you know, more administrated by like national HRD policy.

SPEAKER_01So there definitely are things I think we need to trouble. And so even the words we use um puts us in in silos, really.

SPEAKER_02When I think about Darren's question about the timing of this, um, so you know, a lot of the work and and research that I do is uh kind of in if if we're talking about those three buckets, more in the career development bucket. And I think about how we have this very large and new uh generation of people in the workforce that have very different relationships to work and labor than some generations in the past have had.

SPEAKER_02And I think to answer your question, Darren, like the way our newer generations in the workplace, um, the things that they demand of their employers and their work context definitely necessitate a change to the way we do HRD. Um, if we're thinking about meeting needs for flexibility and balance and meaningful work and um those sorts of things, that is something that we were particularly focused on 30 years ago, you know, and so we have to change if we're still going to meet the needs of the contemporary people in the workplace, um, as well as the organizations that they are starting to run.

SPEAKER_02Right. Um, and so I think given just the natural changes in generations and as we see time go on, it does. We have to change to meet the needs of people.

SPEAKER_04And one of the things that, you know, in terms of timing, I right after the pandemic, and everybody was, well, let me rephrase that, right after the end to the pandemic was declared, it's really clear that COVID in particular has fundamentally changed the way organizations interpret their policies, interpret their processes, um, and how employees do the same. Um, you know, our my my institution fundamentally changed its way of thinking about how um books could be ordered, um what books you're allowed to use and what books you can't use because of access to hard copies in the library.

SPEAKER_04Um they use that as a leverage point to change the way they they allow people to assign books in their classes. Um the way scheduling of assignments is is done. You know, we can no longer have face-to-face examinations. Um, they have to be done online. Um, and that has a fundamental change in the way people are approaching what education is, and then it links in with AI issues. And so there are a whole host of things that have changed the way, you know, there were policies layered on with what we did in organizations.

SPEAKER_04And once you layer on a policy, once you layer on a new process to fix something of the old policy, and that was air quotes on fix, fix something on the old policy, um, and layer on something to adapt it to something that's happening in our context, um, it's hard to then peel that back. And so it further silos us um and it further constrains us. And so I I really feel like um the things that have happened now, people are fed up.

SPEAKER_04So it's not just HRD people or HR people, which is a bigger poll in organizations saying something needs to give, and the employees grumbling about something needs to give. It's also now society in general saying something needs to give. And so I think that's gonna be a key linchpin in why now might be a good a good time to make a change.

SPEAKER_00No, there's there's clearly multiple factors that are driving a desire for us to rethink. It's difficult to address multiple factors, I think, in a in an evolution way. Like change tends to be evolutionary or revolutionary. And the more I hear the three of you talk, the more I feel like a gradual evolution of HRD is unlikely to be able to address the complexities of the multiple factors you were describing, which points us towards more of revolutionary change.

SPEAKER_00Is that how you picture it too?

SPEAKER_01Well, I think that HRD historically has been a tech, a technical solution to people challenges and issues in the workplace. And, you know, we are in the era where we need adaptive solutions. And if you're not familiar with that particular leadership theory, it's it's that you know, a technical problem has usually one solution and it's just a matter of outthinking it. Whereas we have really complicated, ambiguous problems in the world. You know, we've got climate change, we've got workers who want to work remotely and CEOs who want to demand people return to the workplace.

SPEAKER_01You know, you've got uh global um networks of people, you know, working across the world. And you know, the idea of the traditional employment relationship is really mostly dead, where people may work in a career, but they don't work for a company or an organization. And and yet it seems like a lot of policies sort of still assume a bricks and mortar building and certain unspoken employment contracts that really don't exist.

SPEAKER_01So it seems like in some ways, you know, it's it's we're trying to put a round peg into a square hole and it's no longer going to work. Maybe it worked adequately in the past, but it's not going to in these VUCA, you know, volatile, uncertain, uh complex and ambiguous times.

SPEAKER_02I'm thinking too the words that Darren used there in contrast to each other, evolution versus revolution. Evolution to me is very passive. It happens over a period of time. We don't notice it's happening, um, small adaptations here and there. Um, so I would say in this HRD world where we're facing the need to change, we do have to be revolutionary because evolution is too passive for what needs to happen to get us back into a position where we are our most effective selves.

SPEAKER_04I I couldn't agree more. I I feel like the incremental evolutionary changes are what has gotten us to the point of layering on different tweaks to policies that have existed for a long time that no longer work, practices that have existed for a long time and no longer work. So we're not paying attention to our contexts and assessing what's happening. And I think we are facing revolution. I think we are facing a revolution like what happened in early 20th century America with the in the labor revolution and the and the labor movement.

SPEAKER_04I think that's happening now. And we can really see that with the things that are happening in the news, the way that people are rising up and responding to things. I I think all of those give us a clue that now is the time to make the move to change what HRD is. And for me, that's stripping back all of these policies that are not and practices that are not serving the interests of the people and the organizations in which they work. You know, going back to Laura's comment about health, you know, we want both organizations and the individuals who work in them and for them and around them to be healthy.

SPEAKER_04And our policies and practices don't let us do that right now.

SPEAKER_01Well, and I think we we need to be also thinking about like what is the disruptive intervention or innovation in HRD that's needed. And it's probably more than one because, you know, I think on top of the things we've been talking about, we have AI, we have changing work expectations and what five generations working in the workforce right now for the first time, uh, the need to be more adaptive, and and then you know, persistent inequality and injustice in organizations.

SPEAKER_01And then, of course, just on Monday this week, the you know, CEO of a United Healthcare was shot down in New York City. And, you know, I that to me is a bigger moment in time. And especially, I'm not saying I agree with this, but social media has been blowing up with people who will think this guy's a folk hero because you know, taking on a big organization that basically is screwing people. And I think that given what's going on environmentally and in politics and not just in the United States, we've got wars going on.

SPEAKER_01There's a lot of destabilization. And when people can't get basic access to things that they're paying for, like health insurance uh and cut and coverage that they're entitled to, I mean, I think there is a breaking point. Um, and we may just well be seeing this revolution as we're talking about it. And we can't be doing what we've been doing for, you know, a hundred years and think it's still going to be acceptable or successful.

SPEAKER_00Now, most revolutions, at least the ones that like the obvious ones that spring to mind when we use the term revolution, uh, and we may not want to keep using that term. I've thrown it in and and like it's lingering in the conversation, but we can ditch it in at any point. But as when I think about revolution, like most revolutions that I can think of came about they were focused on a philosophy, a belief system that brought people together. And um, and the the revolution itself, of course, is amazingly complex because it's looking to change almost everything.

SPEAKER_00But what underpins all of that change is like a simple a simple statement or a simple belief system that people can wrap their heads around and sign up to? That do we have that as an alternative for HRD? As in, if we wanted to throw out HRD right now, do we have something we can point at that says, here's an alternative, or is our work to build that?

SPEAKER_01You know, I like the word transformation better than revolution. I will just say that.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, you know, I yeah, I'm starting, yeah, I'm starting to head that way as well.

SPEAKER_01So yeah, well, and first of all, calling anything, anything about anything attached to people and humans resources in my mind is the first thing that's gotta go. Yeah. You know, like how we talk about things, we talk into reality. And so I think that's that's um something that's bothered me for a long time. And actually an interesting artifact is the former American Society for Training and Development, which was created, I believe, in 1949. And we write about this in the chapter on learning discourse in our co our co-authored book.

SPEAKER_01And um, you know, now it's the Association for Talent Development. I think that's a great artifact to look at misplaced priorities of an organization that is leading the field in the wrong direction. I mean, talent development is very um incremental, it's very privileging to a few, and it's not at all focused on even learning and development. There's no discussion of that if you go and look at the vision and mission of ATD anymore.

SPEAKER_01And so even a leading organization that people look to has it, in my opinion, gone astray. And, you know, so I think how can we assure that we don't go that direction as a field? I think we there are better alternatives and more humane and holistic ones for us to think about.

SPEAKER_04The analog of ATD, the former ASTD in the UK here, um, is the Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development. And I wish it was the Chartered Institute of People and Development, um, because personnel also gives it that that ring again, you know, Sally Sandbrook's notion of we talk, we talk ourselves into being. And so we talk HRD into being. So we've talked what our field is into being. And I I think the language that we use, and we were really careful about that in in the book about how we use different language um to try and get people to change the way they think about what we do.

SPEAKER_04Um but yeah, I think we need to change and get away from those incremental pieces, as Laura was saying, we need to change um the labels of what we're doing, and we need to encourage our associations to change the labels. Um, and maybe this is an action that we start with Academy of Human Resource Development. Do we change our own name? Do we lobby? Um and this goes back to the, you know, what what you know, the the the John Walton and Wendy Rona town hall debate from from Hawaii, I think it was, in looking at, you know, a rose by any other name.

SPEAKER_04You know, what what do we call this this field? And and maybe it's time that we really get serious about doing that again. And maybe now is a place where we can start to push that.

SPEAKER_01And it's a very North American term, is my understanding.

SPEAKER_02I think there is a general consensus that terminology needs to change. The problem, the tricky part is what to change to. And I don't think there's a general consensus on what the change needs to be. Um, I think we all agree change is needed, but then we get caught up in what should it be. And what happens then is we default right back to where we were. Um and so I think we need more people on board with reimagining what it can be.

SPEAKER_02I think we still have too many people that um are holding on to some of the more tradition, um, traditional aspects of of the field versus looking at at what it can be.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. And you know, if I were queen of the universe, I would definitely get resource out of it. But, you know, something like human and organizational learning and development would satisfy me a lot more than HRD at the moment. And then of course, I have some students doing uh work with new materialism. And, you know, by having human in our title, we are ignoring other living beings of the world. And, you know, and are we interested in welfare of animals, for instance?

SPEAKER_01Uh, or, you know, other things. So I think it is interesting to think about when we start thinking about holism and health. And uh, we we can't be healthy if we destroy the planet.

SPEAKER_00We'll be back in a moment with more from Laura, Jamie, and Tamika. First, though, here's a reminder that today's episode is brought to you thanks to the wonderful sponsorship support of the University of Georgia Gwinnett Campus and the Mary Francis Early College of Education, Department of Lifelong Education, Administration and Policy, whose program of adult learning, leadership and organization development equips learners to gain deep knowledge and skills to lead learning and change to help adults, teams and organizations thrive with their blended and online Masters of Education, innovative hybrid executive doctorate of education and world-class research training in their PhD program.

SPEAKER_00They also have graduate certificates in organization coaching and transformative leadership. Using their unique framework that emphasizes the theory and practice needed to strategically and holistically develop healthy, sustainable organizations, learners gain a mastery of multiple areas including adult learning and training, organization development and change leadership, group development and problem solving, talent management and development, career development and coaching.

SPEAKER_00To find out more, check out their website coe.uga.edu slash academics slash concentrations slash learning leadership and organization development. Right, let's now return to the episode. It makes me think about like transformation, like it can be top-down. I think some like at the top, leadership can define a vision and a mission, and people could move towards that, or it could be bottom-up.

SPEAKER_00When you think about HRD and how we do this, like do you see it as like a transformation that's top down, i.e., HRD leadership needs to be proposing, or can you see this actually coming about as a result of large numbers of HRD practitioners, for example, just moving moving the model a different direction?

SPEAKER_04I think it's hard for people who are in positions of power to choose to give up that power. And our systems serve leadership very well. Um they've they've gotten into those positions, and our systems and structures that are that are in place now serve them. And if we go back to Miles Horton's work and and Highlander back in the in the early 20th century, and and his work with union organizing and the origins of the field, um, and some of the early books that were published by Nadler and and colleagues, um those those books talked about, and I'm gonna use the word revolutionary, but they say your very task is to be a revolutionary as an HRD practitioner, as an HR practitioner, your task is to be revolutionary in the way that you work.

SPEAKER_04And and so if we look at at I think history does inform us, we have to act in different ways, but I think that our systems and structures encourage us for grassroots kind of organizing, because that's where the growth of people is that are least served by the systems and processes that we have in place. And they do have an interest in seeing things change, whereas those in power don't. And look at the executive access reports put out by the Institute of Policy Studies.

SPEAKER_04Those really highlight for us how embedded and wedded um the elite are in keeping the system the way it is. So I think it, I think it needs to be a grassroots bottom-up change up.

SPEAKER_01Well, and it reminds me of um the book We Make the Road by Walking by Miles Horton and Paulo Freire, uh, you know, that looks at the importance of grassroots change in any kind of social movement. And, you know, and I I mean, and I think that it's not an either-or, it's probably a both and, but you know, how do we address the really pernicious, wicked problems of the world? And yeah, I think it has to be a collaborative, multidisciplinary approach.

SPEAKER_01I think what HRD has going for it is I it is a very multidisciplinary field. And I think we know how to do that and and human resources, if we call it that, and an organization has to be multidisciplinary to do its work by the nature of serving an entire organization. But you know, how and how do we um make it a grassroots change that trickles up, maybe is the question.

SPEAKER_02I think HRD in the way that we practice it is is very contextualized if it's done well. And I think the best way for this kind of radical change we're talking about would be to change in the context of where individual people are. And so by definition, that means it's it's grassroots efforts because I know how I'm gonna radically change what's happening in my sphere of influence.

SPEAKER_02Um and I and I know that better than um I know how to change something radically in Jamie's sphere of influence. And we both know our context better than the president of the Academy of HRD, who might be in a position to do more of a top-down approach. So, all that to say, if we're living within the ideals of HRD as a contextualized practice, then I think grassroots is the way it has to happen in terms of change.

SPEAKER_04I think we do need, going back to what Laura has said, if you've been through some of the labor organizing training, like organizing for power or any of the other kinds of labor organizing training and education that labor unions offer, you begin to learn how to organize people, you begin to learn how to make grassroots change. And we typically don't do that within HRD. How often do you see HRD practitioners, HRD scholars talking about union organizing?

SPEAKER_04Um, there aren't very many. Um and so I think that's one place where we can start because you can't just revolutions, transformation, however we want to call it, but large-scale change, you know, big impactful change doesn't just happen. There's a lot of organizing that goes behind the scenes to make that happen. Um, you know, when you look at at really successful trade union um organizing and and walk-out industrial action efforts, you know, they talk about we don't say we're going to, we we don't, you know, we don't say that we're going to strike until we know that over 90, 95, 98% of workers are on board with saying yes, we will strike.

SPEAKER_04And when you don't do that, you typically have failed industrial action. Trust me, experience that here in the UK. So I think if we start to teach people more about how to organize um to make change, that also gives us the grounds to start understanding how what we could change to, as Tamika's been talking about, how to do it. And then once we have that groundswell of people, practitioners and and academics of of HRD, then we can make the kinds of changes that we're talking about.

SPEAKER_02The question Jamie asked was how many people like have that skill to organize, know how to organize. Um, and I think even more so about the courage to do it. Um, we have a a lot of people work because they need to work. And I think we have to be mindful too that when you look at large transformational change that may go against the grain or against the status quo, that's scary.

SPEAKER_02That can be dangerous for certain people to do. And so we're dealing with a situation where change is desperately needed, but in a lot of cases, the people who are actually well positioned to do change may not be able to do it, right? Because of other factors related to their social status, their positioning.

SPEAKER_04I completely agree. We we spend a lot of time in because I I am a labor union, trade union member. Um and uh you know, we we spend a lot of time talking about how do we protect those people who um risk the most by engaging in industrial action and how do we organize? And the biggest way that you do that, the biggest way to keep people safe is in numbers. Um meaning we need to organize more, we need to get behind this.

SPEAKER_04And I thought you were gonna say that the people who are most able to make the change are the ones who are least likely. I always say that it's the tenured individuals in organizations. Um, they're the ones that, you know, the in at universities, they're the ones have the who have the least to risk because they have tenured and they have a lot to lose, but they have the most safety. And the people that they need to stand up for um are the the clinical, the the non-tenure track, you know, the the professional services staff, the admin staff, the students.

SPEAKER_04Um, and so often people get tenure and like they go, whew, I'm safe. And that's the same, you know, go out to any picket line for the the uh UCU, the higher education union here in the UK, go out to any picket line and look to see how many actual professors are out there. There aren't many of us. There are lecturers, there's senior lecturers, there's their students, they're casualized employees, they're PhD students, you know, they're they're all the people who have a huge amount of risk, and they're out there because we've built a solidarity enough for them.

SPEAKER_04Now, the people who are the elites, they need to be out there too, and they're the ones that I get angry about. Um but but we can help learn to we can help by including labor organizing kinds of ideas. Those techniques are helpful in teaching us how to transform in democratic ways in general. So those kinds of things I think is something we need to start embedding within HRD to build that grassroots so we can make that large scale fundamental change that we've all been talking about.

SPEAKER_04About.

SPEAKER_00It makes me think about the number of people listening to this episode that are in the grassroots. As in, like we we know each episode is listened to by thousands of people, which means that even if let's say a third of the audience are HRD practitioners who are who are grassroots within HRD in organizations, it means we've got thousands of those listening to the conversation now who may find themselves thinking, okay, like I'm part of the grassroots. I want to move, I want to be part of this transformation, but where do I start?

SPEAKER_00If they were asking themselves that question, what advice would you have to somebody who is in practice who feels like they they they want to they want to be part of the grassroots that moves it, they're just not sure what the right first or second step should be.

SPEAKER_04Laura's already mentioned one of them. I'll mention a different one. The book that changed my life was The Long Hawk, um, by uh the autobiography of of Miles Horton. Um it fundamentally changed the way I thought um HRD could function. He wasn't he wasn't talking about HRD, um, but it fundamentally changed the way of of my thinking as an individual and my actions as an individual. And so if I didn't have anyone else around me, and at the time I didn't, I didn't have anybody else who was doing any kind of critical kinds of stuff, I didn't have that kind of critical community.

SPEAKER_04Um, I had a few adult educators who were sort of kind of critical that were that were asking me to think about things differently. Um, but that book helped me figure out how I could practice on my own. And as I began to practice in that way on my own, I began to meet other people who were practicing in that way. So my first step, the long haul is super, super, super easy to read. Um, even easier than we make the road by walking, if you can believe that, because which is also a very accessible book. I think either of those, if you know, Paolo Frieri's work is really powerful, but I don't find it very accessible.

SPEAKER_04So anybody out there can go read the conversation between Paolo Frieri and Miles Horton and their ways of over spans of of decades, how their very similar approaches to practice can change the world, um, can change the road we're walking on. And the long haul just focuses on on Miles Horton, but it takes multiple different perspectives. So I would say to somebody out there, go get one of those two books and and begin to change for yourself, and that will open up doors to meeting others.

SPEAKER_01Well, and you know, I think what we're talking about is, and of course, this may be my lens, um, but it really requires people in our field to practice criticality. And I know, you know, people like to say, well, I'm not critical, you know, she's critical over there. And and yet, you know, I just wrapped up a research project, which we'll be presenting at AHRD of the 12 uh recipients of the critical HRD award.

SPEAKER_01And, you know, I won't go into a lot of detail, but you know, these this is a very, you know, kind of small group of people who really are committed to these ideas of the field that, you know, human resources development should be creating more good and equity than making matters worse. And it's not a radical idea. Uh, and but I think that um some of the key things that that we took away from that study was those scholars find people who are committed to the same ideas.

SPEAKER_01And, you know, and so I think I think, you know, I would be pressed to find people in HRD who aren't interested in transforming the field and making sure we're serving people and communities well, and that you have to be uh mindful of how you advocate and what you advocate for. And I think that teaching people who are in organizations how to ask good questions and how how to trouble things that don't seem right and keep their day job, you know, that they're not going to get in trouble and certainly relying on collaboration and the essentiality really of doing that work and asking the tough questions, because if people in HRD aren't doing it, nobody is.

SPEAKER_02Advocacy is what I thought of when I was thinking, um, when I was listening to Laura speak and how important that is, it goes back to you know what Jamie and I were talking about earlier, um, people who have power standing up for those who don't. And advocacy is a beautiful way of doing that, and I think is part of being a good HRD citizen, if we can, if we can say it that way. Um, and so that is another place where I would encourage uh practitioners and scholars alike to to see where it is that you can advocate advocate.

SPEAKER_02So when you look and ask questions and recognize situations that are inequitable, inaccessible, um, and unfair or unjust, um, then take it a step further with advocacy.

SPEAKER_04We we spent a lot of time thinking about the title of our book and how we were going to position it. Um, we knew that we were being critical, but we fundamentally believe that what we were doing is just good practice. You know, it's it's not, you know, oh, that's the textbook for people who are doing critical theory. No, we're just talking about basic good practice. And so we didn't want it to be the critical book. We wanted it to be, you know, thinking about, you know, thinking critically about how you engage and what's happening in an organization, you know, looking for fairness and justice for people who are working in the organization, um, looking for, you know, new ways of evaluating so that you're not privileging one group over the other.

SPEAKER_04All those kinds of things were the questions that we were grappling with in this book that we don't think are siloed for just people who are doing critical approaches. We think that it's these kinds of approaches that that fit for everyone. And so if that's the case, then you know it we can also begin to make these changes by the way that we teach.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. Well, I am conscious that we are coming to the end of our hour. I'm left with probably about 25 to 30 other questions, which makes me feel like we're gonna we're going to need a second episode at some point. But but hopefully the listeners have found this like an intriguing concept. My hope is the the conversation that the three of you had, which I found totally fascinating, gives them a way of understanding why they might feel uncomfortable and starts getting them to think about what the next steps might be in converting that discomfort into some form of action.

SPEAKER_00And I think the more people do that, the more we get the grassroots change that you've been talking about. But I wanted to thank all three of you for taking time out of your busy days for such an interesting conversation. Uh, it's been fascinating to be a part of it. Thank you all so much indeed.

SPEAKER_03Yes, thank you. This was so fun. Thank you for inviting us. I I really enjoyed this. Thank you.

SPEAKER_02I did as well. Yes.

SPEAKER_00Thank you so much for joining me for this episode. It was wonderful spending time with Laura Beermer, Jamie Callahan, and Tamika Grier. If you enjoyed this episode, check out our other 46, which contain conversations with over 100 leading scholars from around the world. To learn more about the series, check out HRDmasterclass.com. And to learn about the Academy of Human Resource Development, check out ahrd.org. Support the future of human resource development.

SPEAKER_00Give to AHRD a 501c3 non-profit today. Your donation powers research, scholarships, innovative programs, and vital operations that keep our HRD community thriving. Every tax-deductible donation makes a difference. Join us in ensuring AHRD remains a beacon for research, collaboration and professional growth for decades to come. Visit ahrd.org slash donate and invest in the future of HRD.

SPEAKER_00Together we can make a lasting impact. Also, please check out our episode sponsors, the University of Georgia, Gwynette Campus, and Mary Francis Early College of Education, Department of Lifelong Education, Administration and Policy. Programme of Adult Learning, Leadership and Organization Development. For full information, check out their website at coe.uga.edu slash academics slash concentrations slash learning leadership and organization development.

SPEAKER_00Join me again next week when I'm exploring the question of how to develop an HRD strategy. And we'll be joined by guests Bill Rothwell, Lyle Yorks and Fotios Mitzakis. Until then, stay safe. This is Darren Short signing off from the HRD Masterclass.com

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Gendered pathways to work-family balance

    Nov 17, 202634 minAudio

    This fourth episode of Season 6 brings together Dr. Sanghamitra Chaudhuri (Temple University) and Dr. Kyung Nam Kim (Texas A&M University) for a conversation about the 2026 article Gendered Pathways to Work-Family...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Navigating careers in non-traditional work

    Nov 10, 202636 minAudio

    This third episode of Season 6 brings together Dr. Yuanlu Niu (University of Arkansas) and Dr. Jos Akkermans (Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam) for a conversation about the 2026 article Navigating careers in non-traditional...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Silence in the workplace: What do we know from research?

    Nov 2, 202634 minAudio

    This second episode of Season 6 brings together Dr. Matthew Hurtienne (University of Texas at Tyler) and Dr. Heesun Kim (Francis Marion University) for a conversation about the 2024 article Silence in the workplace:...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Diversified mentoring: Living at the intersections of race and gender

    Oct 27, 202634 minAudio

    This first episode of Season 6 brings together Dr. Joshua Collins (University of Minnesota) and Dr. Ague Mae Manongsong (Louisiana State University) for a conversation about the 2023 article “Manongsong, A. M., & Ghosh,...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Season 6 Trailer

    Oct 12, 20262 minAudio

    Welcome to the trailer for Season 6 of Human Resource Development Masterclass - the podcast series from the Academy of Human Resource Development, the organization that leads HRD through research. The sixth season...

    Credit the people on this episode