In this penultimate episode of Season 4, guests Dr. Ellen Scully-Russ (The George Washington University, USA), Dr. Eugene Sadler-Smith (University of Surrey, UK), and Dr. Maria Cseh (The George Washington University, USA) discuss the relationship between HRD and the Climate Crisis, including: What influenced the guests' interest in climate issues? What are the implications of the Climate Crisis for organizations and how are they responding? What are the implications for individual employees and the workforce as a whole? What is the relationship between HRD and the Climate Crisis? How can HRD position itself for a greater role in addressing the Climate Crisis? What are the implications for HRD researchers and for HRD education? and much more. For full details on the HRD Masterclass series, visit hrdmasterclass.com, and for the bios of the guest scholars visit allbypodcast.com/climate. For more information on the Academy of Human Resource Development, visit ahrd.org - by being a member of AHRD, you can access bonus materials from podcast episodes. This episode is sponsored by Dr. Thomas Garavan of the Department of Management and Marketing, Cork University Business School, University College Cork, Ireland, and by the Health Professions Education Special Interest Group (HPE SIG) at the Academy of Human Resource Development - check them out at https://www.ahrd.org/page/special_interest_groups.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_04We know now that the time to act was yesterday. If HRD isn't going to do that, who is going to do it? And if now isn't the right time, when is the right time?
SPEAKER_01Welcome to Human Resource Development Masterclass, the podcast series from the Academy of Human Resource Development, the organisation that leads HRD through research. I'm your host, Darren Short, and here in our fourth season we're exploring the relationship between HRD and trends in society and organisations, with the help of leading authors, researchers and scholars. Today our focus is the relationship between HRD and the climate crisis. And my guest scholars are Dr.
SPEAKER_01Maria Che of the George Washington University, Dr. Ellen Scully Russ of the George Washington University, and Dr. Eugene Sadler Smith of the University of Surrey, all of whom join me for conversations recorded in the summer of 2023. Our episode today is structured into two parts. In the first, we look at the climate crisis and its impact on organizations and the workforce. Then in the second, we explore the implications for HRD practice, research, and education.
SPEAKER_01You can find out all about the questions explored in the episode, the three guest scholars, and also the episode sponsors by visiting allbypodcast.com forward slash climate. Talking of sponsorship, Human Resource Development Masterclass is only made possible thanks to the wonderful support of our sponsors, who cover all of the costs associated with the series, and so enable us to release them free of charge to listeners like you. I encourage you to show your thanks by checking them out and letting them know just how much their sponsorship means to you.
SPEAKER_01Today's episode is brought to you thanks to the sponsorship support of Dr. Thomas Garavan and the Health Professions Education Special Interest Group at the Academy of Human Resource Development. The first part of this episode is brought to you thanks to the wonderful sponsorship support of Dr. Thomas Garavan of the Department of Management and Marketing, Cork University Business School, University College Cork in Ireland. Thomas is an AHRD Hall of Fame Inductee and is currently serving on the board of the Academy of Human Resource Development.
SPEAKER_01Thank you, Thomas. Right, let's dive into the episode. Welcome to our episode on the climate crisis and implications for HRD. Let's start by meeting today's three guest scholars. And first, I'd like to welcome Dr. Ellen Scully Russ, Associate Professor of Human and Organizational Learning at the George Washington University Graduate School of Education and Human Development. Ellen's scholarship and practice are focused on the role of adult education in meeting the individual and the political economic challenges of the emerging knowledge society.
SPEAKER_01She also has more than 25 years of experience as a workplace learning and workforce development practitioner in a wide range of industries, including healthcare, telecommunications, manufacturing, hospitality, and the public sector. Welcome, Ellen.
SPEAKER_02Thank you, Darren. I really greatly appreciate the invitation and look forward to the conversation.
SPEAKER_01My second guest for the episode is Dr. Eugene Sadler-Smith, who is Professor of Organizational Behavior at Surrey Business School, University of Surrey in the United Kingdom. Prior to becoming an academic, Eugene worked in HRD in the gas industry, and he completed his PhD part-time on the subject of cognitive styles whilst working in industry. He's taught HRD at master's level all his academic career and has written two textbooks on the subject Learning and Development for Managers, published by Blackwell in 2006, and Human Resource Development from Theory into Practice, published by Sage in 2023.
SPEAKER_01His research interests are intuition in decision making and hubris in leadership. Welcome, Eugene.
SPEAKER_04Darren, thank you for having me. I'm looking forward to it very much.
SPEAKER_01And my third guest for the episode is Dr. Maria Che, who, for the past 15 years, has served as the director of the Human and Organizational Learning Doctoral Program at the George Washington University. Maria holds a BSMS degree in electronics engineering, an MA in business administration with a focus on international management, and a PhD in adult education with a specialization in global human resource development. Maria's research interests include informal learning, organizational development and change, global leadership, and the development of global mindset and cultural competence.
SPEAKER_01Welcome, Maria.
SPEAKER_03Thank you, Darren. It's such a pleasure being with you again and especially talking about such an important issue.
SPEAKER_01Well, over the next hour or so, we'll be talking about the climate crisis and implications for organizations and individuals, and then implications for HRD. Before diving into those details, I'd like to start off our conversation by exploring how each of you became interested in this topic and how you've worked on it through your research, writing, and practice. Eugene, would you be willing to get the ball rolling for us?
SPEAKER_04Well, for me, the climate change issues goes back a very, very long way, longer than I care to remember, to be honest, because um as an undergraduate, I did geography, I did the BSC geography at the University of Leeds, and um in the 1980s, then um we were taught all about climate change then. And so it's been part of my kind of you know uh mindset ever since. But I mean, essentially, if I if I think back to the 1980s when I graduated, we we pretty much knew everything then that we needed to know about the mechanisms behind climate change.
SPEAKER_04So, you know, uh greenhouse gas emissions and all of those things were known about then. And then thinking about that in connection with this, the you know, preparing for this podcast, it really struck me that since the 1980s and probably before, we've actually lived in what we might even call uh an age of climate change denial. Um, and then almost for myself, speaking personally again, to kind of to add an insult to injury, if you like, um, in terms of my culpability uh or inaction.
SPEAKER_04I actually worked for a gas company after I left university, and um you know, and then we and we know where where we are now with energy transitions and oil and gas companies, you know, being committed to the energy transition and so on and so forth. So that's a little bit about my where I'm coming from personally. Let's face it, the main effect of greenhouse gas emissions and what's happened over the past 200 years since the beginning of the Industrial Revolution won't affect me uh as much as it will affect the future generations, human beings who are being born now or who are not yet born, who will be affected by what's happened uh with with my generation and the generations before that.
SPEAKER_04That it kind of raises a moral question. So it's a scientific issue and it's a moral issue. And I think we as human beings who who inhabit the earth at the moment have a moral responsibility to human beings who will inhabit the earth in the future to make the earth habitable for them.
SPEAKER_01You know, it's fascinating, Eugene, to hear your personal perspective on the climate, and and I'm sure we'll talk more about your experience of working in a gas company. First, though, let's transition to Ellen, as I'm interested to hear about your own journey into being interested in climate issues.
SPEAKER_02I think a lot of people don't really understand or don't experience climate, uh, particularly people who kind of live in in urban and suburban areas where you know climate is a rainy day or climate is a snowstorm coming in. I grew up on the on the Jersey shore where climate was always front and center, but we always also understood that there were patterns associated with weather, you know, such as hurricanes and patterns of storms, blizzards.
SPEAKER_02I also then married a person who grew up on the shore of South Carolina. He also had a deeper understanding of weather patterns and climate trends, and you could see them over long term, how they might be shifting. So I think I have a sensitivity to sort of climate issues. And as as you may know, I I own and operate a vineyard. Um, so it's an agricultural enterprise that is tightly entwined with the weather.
SPEAKER_02What I'm trying to say is that it's not just an a professional HRD thing. You know, sort of my interest runs a little deeper in understanding the relationship between place and climate and livelihood and climate. I think that's kind of what I take into my work, more of an ecological uh systems perspective on the relationship between climate and the built environment, which of course HRD is a core aspect of that relationship because we sort of influence how people relate within organize, if you would, that built environment to engage in sort of productive activities.
SPEAKER_02So that's kind of how I look at it, more of a sort of a systemic, longer-term embedded uh feature of not just the profession, but the sort of life and systems and processes that we support.
SPEAKER_01It's interesting to hear you talk about how your awareness of or understanding of climate was influenced by where you lived. Maria, how does all of that compare to your own journey? Were there any single events or series of events that influenced your own interests in issues related to climate?
SPEAKER_03There was no one live event, triggering event that uh made me interested in climate issues. I think it was cumulative over uh my lifetime. I was fortunate enough to have grandparents uh who lived in a village, um, in a little hamlet, with not too much land or too much wealth, but learning and learning from their ancestors how to uh to use everything that they have and how to connect uh their lives with the climate patterns, you know, when was it raining, when to plant, how to address issues of drought or other issues.
SPEAKER_03So um I had this um upbringing. I spent uh many, many summers or parts of summers with them, and I felt really at home, even the smell of the uh of the land after summer rain, it um you know it brings to my mind all kinds of um processes, approaches, discussions that I had with my grandparents and my parents at that time. So this um these climate issues for me are not a new, they are not new issues, they are ongoing, and uh I was witnessing them uh all of my life.
SPEAKER_03But of course, now with this um crisis and disasters that are surrounding us uh, it's upfront and um uh on the minds of everybody and in the media. But I have to remind you that the two of us in 2001 at our Tulsa Academy of Human Resource Development Conference, we organized a pre-conference, a globalization pre-conference.
SPEAKER_03Uh, at that time, the two of us were leading uh that uh group, and uh we visited the Cherokee Nation. Uh, we were very nicely welcomed, very warmly welcomed, and we talked about a 100-year vision of what will happen from a socio-economic development perspective for the Cherokee Nation. And we were discussing the difference between a five-year and the 100-year plan.
SPEAKER_03And uh I think um these all these issues that we are facing with climate change require long-term, long-term approaches. Uh, the other um uh event that I remember well as uh in my professional life I'm talking about was uh in 2010 when I was a member of the George Washington University representation at the United Nations Climate Change Conference that was held in Cancun, Mexico in December of 2010.
SPEAKER_03And um uh at the conference is officially referred to as the 16th session of the conference of the parties. So when you see uh COP 16, that's the conference of the parties, uh, to the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change. At that time, uh we participated as a non-governmental organization, a representative of non-governmental organizations. And together with my uh dear friend and colleague Elizabeth Davis, uh, we held a workshop there on capacity building for women, um, a global research network of women focused on sustainability and climate change.
SPEAKER_03So that experience was um, I would say, in a way, transformative to see the argumentual um efforts that intergovernmental and non-governmental organizations put in and the thoughts and the processes to mitigate climate change issues. And uh, it gave me hope. It gave me a lot of hope. Because this was in 2010.
SPEAKER_03So, what I'm trying to say, um, my interest in climate change uh is not new and it wasn't triggered by one event, but uh it evolved over the years that I'm on this earth, and I can remember.
SPEAKER_01So the the three of you have provided a really interesting personal story behind your interest in the topic, and as you've done that, you've kindly planted a few seeds that I'd like to pick up on as we dig deeper into the subject. For example, you you've referenced the role of HRD, the transformative nature of change that's needed, like the impact that has on individuals and those in the workforce and and much more. First, though, I'd I'd love to focus a little on organizations and what this all means for organizations.
SPEAKER_01After all, HRD often focuses within organizational settings, and so many HRD practitioners find themselves operating within systems that are having to adapt to changing climate. So, how do you see organizations being impacted and and reacting?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, that's a great question. Um you know, I think the basic answer would be, you know, how are organizations, as we've come to understand them, be more attuned to the fact that there are these climate, you know, the climate is changing, that there are these changing weather patterns that are going to disrupt different parts of the quote unquote organization at different times and in more significant ways, depending upon you know where the location of a particular activity resides.
SPEAKER_02So I think there's some real strategy that needs to be uh developed around how to adapt quickly to the very uncertain set of circumstances that climate change uh requires will demand really, but not just to adapt, but how to respond in ways that are helpful to the people that are being impacted, not just, you know, quote unquote, your people, meaning your employees, but the communities within which they live.
SPEAKER_02I mean, I think what we have seen in some of the disaster change literature and practices is, you know, you just have to turn on the TV and see, you know, what's going on with flooding or fires or other devastating weather events. And you see that, yeah, there's first responders out there with equipment and people are coming in from all over the world to help out. But the ones that are sort of really doing the work and understanding what needs to be done and who needs to be found and what needs to be fortified first, second, third, are the people who live there.
SPEAKER_02And those are, you know, in many instances, employees of organizations that HRD support. So how do we, you know, in the short term during a crisis, support those people, their families and their communities, I think. So there's a whole kind of you know, sort of sort of longer term, how do we adapt? What are the strategies? And then, you know, kind of in the moment of the crisis, how do we, how do we mobilize uh resources um to support employees um in, you know, kind of taking care of their own home and families?
SPEAKER_02You know, and of course, you know, this doesn't even get to the bigger question about what are the practices um within firms or within organizations that are negatively contributing to the climate change situation.
SPEAKER_01So so Eugene, Ellen referenced there the practices within organizations that negatively impact the climate. What have you seen in that space and and how do you see organizations responding?
SPEAKER_04I think that the there are the obvious impacts on what we could call kind of bottom line things. So, you know, organizations are having to take uh measures to mitigate emissions um and also to adapt to the effects of carbon dioxide uh increases in the atmosphere and global warming. So there's this whole kind of mitigation and adaptation thing that they have to do. That's gonna that cost that costs them uh money. So things like you know, fuel costs, uh carbon taxes, packaging, transportation, food miles, flood protection, carbon footprints, the whole the whole shooting match of the kind of bottom line impact on organizations.
SPEAKER_04You know, that that's kind of that's easy to quant easy to quantify in a sense. But I think alongside that, that quantifiable impact is a much more intangible. But I think for organizations, perhaps equally important, certainly as far as the HR aspect of it is concerned, then it's a the more intangible aspect is um is is is the is the effect that it can have on an organization's reputation and that this kind of reputational risk thing. So, you know, if if if organizations are seen to be not being uh not taking climate change seriously, then I think it can seriously affect and significantly affect um their reputation and how and how they're viewed, and it can affect and it can affect their brand.
SPEAKER_04I think I think it's important because in recent years, you know, in the past five years, I would say, people's expectations, and this is what a good thing is, you know, a positive side of the equation, given all the negatives. I think in the past five years, people in general have become much more attuned to it. It's kind of become part of their consciousness. Uh so you know, climate change is in the news every day. And I think with that raised level of consciousness and awareness amongst the public in general and amongst employees, alongside that there comes almost an expectation perhaps that the organizations that they work for or the businesses that they buy their products from ought to start taking climate change seriously.
SPEAKER_04Um so I guess it's this whole kind of idea about you know stakeholders and the stakeholders' view of the organization is important, and this idea of rep reputational risk. I think in in terms of the HR issues as well, I think. Organizations that take climate change seriously are going to be better placed in the in the employ in the employment market. I think they're going to be better placed to attract and retain young, talented, uh and committed people to their organizations.
SPEAKER_04And I think organizations that you know that have uh embedded uh dealing with climate change and the climate crisis into their culture will be more attractive um to people going forward.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, it it's interesting to think about organizations changing like that. At the same time, I do think there's a little voice of doubt in my head that wonders how strong those forces are, given that they appear to be battling the might of capitalism and business needs to deliver performance and profits for their shareholders. What do you think of those voices of doubt that I can't quite silence?
SPEAKER_04Yeah. Yeah, yeah. And that that's a great point. And one of the kind of sub-themes that we talk about is this shift that you've alluded to there, away from stake uh shareholder capitalism and maximizing shareholder value more towards a stakeholder capitalism and it's maximizing value for different groups of stakeholders. And one of the things that I try to get across to them in this, in terms of the kind of the stakeholder idea, is that stakeholders in the environment and the effects that businesses are having on the environment, stakeholders in the environment are human, but there are also non-human stakeholders.
SPEAKER_04So animals, so that kind of raises issues around biodiversity and so on and so forth. And then, as well, as well as non-human stakeholders, the whole the planet itself as a stakeholder. Um, and I think coming back to HRD, one one one of the things that strikes me about HRD and why HRD is well placed to play an important role in this is that if we think about the stakeholders, so humans, non-humans, um, the planet itself, you know, with the the the atmosphere and the lithosphere and the biosphere and all of those things all together, it's part of a system.
SPEAKER_04And one of the things that I think HRD is good at is seeing things systemically, looking at the big picture. So, you know, in HRD we've got the systematic approach and the systems approach. And I think as HRD uh thinkers, we tend to think systemically. We we can see we can we see the bigger picture and we see the connections between the parts of the system. So I think that's what one of the one of the reasons why I think HRD is well placed to play a really active role in promoting uh this and communicating the climate change message.
SPEAKER_01You know, there's there's something in that answer that I'd love to dig a little further into. As it's it's interesting to think of climate issues being systemic. And as you say, HRD professionals have a lot of experience of working on systemic issues. At the same time, I'm aware that many systemic issues are tough to change and slow to change. So, Maria, as you look at the transformative and systemic nature of climate issues, what what do you think about the challenges of addressing those issues because of the time it takes to make change happen?
SPEAKER_03Overall, if you look at uh what is happening, um I think we have an issue of uh short-term finding short-term solutions. Um uh because we are uh as I notice, not we, um the we as my observations in organizations, working with organizations and looking at their practices. Um there is mostly what I notice a reactive approach and not a proactive approach to issues.
SPEAKER_03Um, and that doesn't allow for these long-term interventions that are needed in order to address uh many of the issues that we are facing, in this case, climate change issues. And uh in fact, um uh the Intergovernmental Panel of Climate Change, the IPCC, uh, has a report in the past few years, in the past five years. So the two in the 2023 report, um uh they talk about the that the limiting warming to 1.5 degrees degrees Celsius, uh which we are trying to work towards, uh requires uh transformative transformative systematic change integrated with sustainable development.
SPEAKER_03And uh we know that transformative systematic change as transformative learning, as changes in paradigms, takes a lot of time and takes the collaboration of all the members of our society, and I'm not talking just individual members, but organizations and uh local, regional, um, you know, uh country-wide, global government organizations and non-government entities.
SPEAKER_03So this is not something that we can achieve in two, three years. And a lot of organizations are looking for quick fixes, and we, you know, they are hiring chief sustainability officers. Um we hear a lot about the chief diversity officers nowadays because that's another major issue that are is facing uh, you know, we are faced in our societies. Um but uh as we saw, McKinsey and company had a report saying that these positions do not last, you know.
SPEAKER_03The in the CCU suites uh these positions are the shortest terms, uh so it is very difficult to uh build um this um engage the community and build the relationships in order to uh to bring lasting changes. I I think that so what I see is that um in practice, unfortunately, despite the good will and and all the might of those HRD professionals, those few that I know that really are involved in these issues, learn about them continuously, try to find new ways to address them, um they cannot uh they cannot uh achieve what they want because of these short-term fixes that uh organizations think that it can just, you know, things like this can just happen, you know.
SPEAKER_03And we have heard that in the discussion on the on sustainability about uh the um uh CSR, you know, corporate social responsibility, and uh how I really liked how um uh my colleague Matthias Boll talked about fantasy, you know, that um this uh people, planet, profit, uh very well-meaning model, uh triple bottom line model, um, was a great idea, but um everybody, all the leaders in organizations just want to continue um their practices as they are, and uh still want to find uh solutions to deal with all these uh environmental, climate issues, sustainability issues.
SPEAKER_03And uh they do not realize how much time does it take and uh how much effort does it take.
SPEAKER_01Well we'll be taking a short break in a moment and then we'll dig further into what all of this means for HRD. But before we do, I I'd like to wrap up this first part of the episode by focusing a little on employees. After all, we've discussed the implications for organizations and and so Eugene, I was wondering what you think this means if we look instead at individuals and maybe at the workforce as a whole. And perhaps consider why there's such a gap between what individuals know about the climate and and what changes they're willing to make that could benefit the climate.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, yeah. It's an interesting question. I think I think I think the barrier if it's a barrier or or an or more of a gap and I think I think there it there's there's two aspects to the gap. I think I think employees and the general public employees have a general sense that there is a problem. Um but I think there I think there's a I think there's a it sounds a bit patronizing, but I think there's an education job to be done uh in deepening their knowledge of of of of what the problem is.
SPEAKER_04But I think there's a sense that there is a problem and there's an acceptance that there is a problem. However, I think I think that the challenge is the difference between uh having a sense that there's a problem and accepting that there's a problem, and actually knowing what I as an employee can do about it. So I think the the challenge or the gap there, it's making this shift from knowing about the problem to doing something about the problem. So it's that that so it's it's it's kind of a what I would call a knowing-doing gap.
SPEAKER_04I know about it, yeah, it's a problem, but what do I actually do about it? Um, the answer to that question, of course, will vary from situation to situation, but I think this this knowing-doing gap is is is one of the big challenges that we're facing.
SPEAKER_01We'll be back in a moment with more from Ellen, Eugene and Maria. First, here's a reminder that this episode is brought to you thanks to the wonderful sponsorship support of the Health Professions Education Special Interest Group, HPE STIG, at the Academy of Human Resource Development. The HPE STIG is a group bridging and applying HRD with Health Professions Education to develop the healthcare workforce including physicians, nurses, veterinarians, dentists, pharmacists, physician assistants, emergency medical technicians and allied health professions, such as hospital management, occupational therapy and clinical psychology.
SPEAKER_01The HPE SIG's vision is to create an interdisciplinary collaborative group that contributes to the practice and research in HRD and health professions education. For full information, check out their website at the AHRD homepage at ahrd.org forward slash page forward slash special interest groups. Students, practitioners, and scholars are welcome to join AHRD HPE SIG.
SPEAKER_01Right, let's return to our conversation. So before the break, we were talking about what we mean by the term climate crisis and the implications for organizations. And so in exploring those, we'd begun touching on what this means for HRD. And I'd love to dig a little more into that. Ellen, would you be willing to kick off this second part of the conversation by sharing your thoughts on the relationship between HRD and the climate crisis?
SPEAKER_02You know, HRD is different things to different people, right? And I don't I don't think it's either or. I think I think we're all of those things. We are a practice that does help improve organizational performance and innovation and efficiencies, but we're also a core mission to support human development. And I think that that makes us inherently transdisciplinary or maybe even transcontextually oriented, because we also work across a variety of different industries, all of them really.
SPEAKER_02And so we as a practice come from very many diverse perspectives. And so that alone requires that we really listen and understand and try to make information and knowledge broad of all kinds broadly available to people to think about and consider in addressing bigger challenges, right? And so if you think about that, you know, there's a a stream of environmental science that I came upon in some of my research on green HRD.
SPEAKER_02It's a sort of a social technical biological perspective on science, if you would. And it really at its core looks at biology of a particular location as being, you know, really embedded into the built environment and how you know sort of their fates have been married, if you would, and inextricably linked, you know, moving forward, how culture affects the biological evolution of a particular ecosystem and how the ecosystem creates conditions and constraints for the built system, which you know is a city or a town or a park or wherever, however, you want to bound it, right?
SPEAKER_02And so these scientists are looking at things like risk and risk orientation, which of course motivates people to think about things and to take action. And so they they consider that to be inherently socially constructed. And so these hard scientists are really becoming deeply interested in and concerned about the social and cultural dimensions to the environmental conditions of a particular locality.
SPEAKER_02And they really are struggling with how do we incorporate that into ecological research and how do we also infuse ecological understandings into these broader social and political and cultural processes. And so what I came to understand was that's the role of HRD here, right? Um to really help people within these very complex, embedded problems who come from a variety of perspectives, operate off of very different value systems, speak extremely different languages, actually value difference and legitimize knowledge in different ways, and therefore knowledge is different.
SPEAKER_02I see HRD's role as being one of a sort of a facilitator, if you would, within these broader networks that are extremely important for addressing the issue of climate change in a you know very locally situated context. That role is not an organizational role. HRD cannot step out of sort of a major employer's HR department, if you would, and be the facilitator in a situation like that.
SPEAKER_02I firmly believe that, I mean, there's things organizations can and should be doing related to climate change. I'm not discounting that. You know, I I value, you know, people who are trying to think about and enact those roles. But in addition to that, the field of HRD really needs to take seriously what it looks like, what our practice might look like outside of the boundaries of a single organization, you know, within which we are now embedded as a field, and to be more of a community-based practice and resource, in which case, then I see you know, sort of HRD being more of a process within these broader efforts to, you know, to build adaptive capacity and the capacity to transform uh you know environmental practices in local communities.
SPEAKER_02How do we distribute this sort of HRD capacity to bring together people from multiple perspectives and contexts to really listen to one another, to pull from each other's value systems and knowledge base, to craft an approach or a response to a particular situation that has the potential to foster some positive change.
SPEAKER_01I really like the thought of HRD being a process and operating outside of organizations. And I definitely don't want to lose that thought here in the discussion. At the same time, I do find myself wondering about the role of HRD in organizations and what we can be doing to have a more significant voice on climate issues within the organizations that many HRD folks work in. So what would we have to do to position ourselves to have a greater role within those organizations?
SPEAKER_03As I was talking with some of my colleagues who are in HRD positions, who are charged with dealing with these kinds of issues, um, I think one of the first steps is learning. And that's self-directed learning. We talk a lot about self-directed learning, but learning about these issues and being up to date to the development of science and following this type of reports and the United Nations climate change conferences and meetings, and if possible, participating in some of them and seeing learning from those people who are on the ground, both uh governmental and intergovernmental organizations, of what they are doing.
SPEAKER_03Uh, a full week when when you go to this type of events, uh you have a full week of going, there are hundreds of representatives from all over the world with very interesting new ideas of how to mitigate climate change and examples of what they are doing. And then we can, you know, we can all learn from them. So the same thing with this kind of reports that I was uh referring to, uh reading the reports, seeing what kind of mitigation strategies were found to work, even in the short term, you know, as as we are developing these long-term strategies.
SPEAKER_03So I think uh continuous learning and uh uh awareness, not just awareness, but uh active learning and participating in uh in events and in being in environments where uh people are working on the ground with these kinds of issues would be very, very helpful.
SPEAKER_02We don't know, we're not very well educated as a population in general to climate change. And that trend is not gonna change anytime soon because of the political involvement in the curriculum of K through 12 these days. Um, and in many conservative areas, climate change is still a hoax. And so that kind of regulation over the curriculum isn't gonna help the situation much. I just don't think as a public, we're very well educated to what climate is and to the patterns that are become so destructive and to what's causing those patterns and therefore, you know, kind of what we can do about it.
SPEAKER_02You know, psychologically, sort of cognitively, we're not set up very well as a culture and as a people to understand climate in the first place. So I don't see organizations understanding what their place in the climate change situation is. Um, and therefore, you know, what are they responsible for and who are they responsible to? And so, as we know, HRD, whether we like it or not, is in many organizations not considered sort of a leader in the strategy area.
SPEAKER_02And so no one's asking us to come up with a climate change strategy that would include, you know, mobilizing human resources and people in new ways and, you know. in infusing new skills and attitudes into the organization. So absent that um it's it would be it would be rolling a very big rock or up a very steep hill, if you would, to take that on from the HRD perspective.
SPEAKER_01As I listen to your responses there, I I found myself reflecting on the different topics that we've been covering in this season of the podcast. Each episode has explored a different trend in society and organizations and then we've looked at the implications for HRD. And I find it interesting to think about which topics we've leaned into as a field. You know, there's been a reasonably good response within HRD to exploring issues related to diversity and social justice, for example.
SPEAKER_01But then I don't see the same response to issues related to climate. What why do you think that is?
SPEAKER_04We we've we've leaned into diversity issues. So we've proven in a sense that we can do it that we can lean into you know these vitally important issues in the workplace. So we can do it we can do it on diversity and inclusion. If we can do it on diversity and inclusion perhaps we can in the same way lean into the climate change issue and be as effective on the climate change issue as we have been on diversity and inclusion. And I guess you know there's a job there to to kind of learn or transfer the lessons of what we did well in diversity and inclusion across to climate change.
SPEAKER_04So I think it I think it's about it's about building capacity in the HRD profession for HRD professionals to be able to um have a seat at the top table if you like and talk convincingly about climate change not as scientists because they can never do that but as as organizational development organizational change as change agents to talk about the the issues around climate change at that senior level and build a capacity amongst HRD professionals to be able to do that.
SPEAKER_04So yes that means having um a basic level of climate change knowledge but that's that's kind of an easy fix in a way to to upgrade HRD professionals knowledge to um you know to a level in which they can talk uh competently and convincingly about the issues and there's plenty of resources out there to enable them to do that. I guess I guess the bigger challenge is is to is to alongside the building the capacity the bigger challenge is to kind of develop the commitment of HRD to make a change HRD is so well placed to do this I guess we could ask ourselves well what's to stop us doing it in the area of of of climate change and acting as change agents to facilitate that you know that bridging of the the knowledge doing gap and bridging the top up the the top down bottom up aspect of it really well placed to do that.
SPEAKER_04I mean I suppose I suppose in a way what where where I am with it overall is that the I think within organizations there's there's there's there's definitely a will but there does not yet appear to be a way and I think HRD has got a real opportunity to to play a an a really important role in in in fostering the will and creating the way forward. And if you know if that means HRD being a climate change champion in organizations, I think that would be a very satisfactory outcome uh for us all.
SPEAKER_04And then you know to kind of where I am with it in terms of who and when I would say well if it's if if HRD isn't going to do that, who is going to do it? And if now isn't the right time when is the right time? So I guess it boils down to if if it's if not HRD who and if not now when and you know we know enough about the science you know and the levels of CO2 and sea level rises and increased weather increased extreme weather events and flooding and drought and all of those things.
SPEAKER_01We we know that we know now that the time to act was yesterday or you know to coin a phrase it's better late than never so it sounds like there's a real need for HRD to become more active on climate issues but there are also specific challenges in place especially within organizations and those make it more difficult for HRD to become more active I'm therefore wondering whether we see similar things when we look at HRD research if climate doesn't appear to be a big focus for HRD practitioners is is it more of a focus for HRD researchers?
SPEAKER_02The whole idea of climate seems so scientific and so part sciencey to many of us that you know we don't we don't necessarily see that as our as as being something that we have the expertise to deal with. So I think that limits our creativity in terms of how we really begin to think about building organizational capacity to respond to climate change in adaptive and transformative ways.
SPEAKER_02I think there's a lot of scaffolding that needs to be done within field around the whole idea of climate change and climate and organizational climate adaptability and transformation. In preparation for this discussion Darren I went into a couple of the academic databases yesterday and did a search admittedly it was a you know quick quick search for HRD and climate change and then HRM and climate change.
SPEAKER_02And I think totally there might have been you know maybe 20 articles have popped up with maybe half of those being really relevant to you know the question here. And of those and it was within a 10 year period and of those articles that may have been relevant to this conversation two were in the advances two were from the advances journal that three of us in this conversation Eugene Maria and I contributed to back in 2015 on green HRD.
SPEAKER_02That tells me that there's not a big conversation in HRD about climate change at least from an academic perspective.
SPEAKER_03I can give you a very uh a very uh quick one because it's right now happening and uh and Jessica Hinsho is working on that she comes from the healthcare center uh sector so she's looking at federally qualified health centers and their responses to climate change issues she's doing a multi case study and for those uh students who work in in the healthcare sector probably they know how the impact of climate change uh on uh on on the healthcare and disrupting healthcare organizations and um meeting uh communities healthcare needs um after these major uh changes climate changes and um their consequences so um we have very few examples in fact we don't know of examples of case studies of different organizations that are responding to climate change issues and learning from their responses learning from their processes the learning from their lessons learned so I think in any sector doesn't matter if it is IT or healthcare or any sector that our students come from and work in as professionals I think it is there is a need to um to conduct these case studies in order to have some examples of practices um and in those examples of practices as you know I never liked the best practices I like best fitted practices so hopefully that could help other organizations find their best fitted practices to meet the climate change challenges um another um methodology that can be used so here we talk about case studies of these organizations but um grounded grounded theory is needed here in order to understand individual change not just individual individual change and organizational change uh in behavior and practices and paradigm changes uh i think those those would be very helpful because as we know the most difficult the most difficult to change are paradigms those are the most difficult to change it takes time and um uh we have many examples of societal changes and behavioral changes in our society uh that with uh the the collaboration of uh policy makers and different types of organizations um they changed paradigms you know we just have to think of smoking you know it's amazing to think that uh when i grew up everybody was smoking everybody and uh that contributes to climate uh climate issues i have to say um um both in a direct and indirect way but definitely to health issues and we have evidence how it could be changed but it took a lot of time and a lot of uh deep thought and a lot of reflection and a lot of discussions and collaborations to happen um another area that uh that our students uh can engage into in their research is related to indigenous learning and knowledge and mitigation of climate change and how we can incorporate um that indigenous knowledge and and learning into uh into organizational life um of course we we talk here about paradigm changes so transformational learning and transformational change are areas that are directly connected to changing of paradigms and then we have to a lot to understand about community engaged participatory uh participatory action because without that we will not be able to address organizational issues organizations are part of our communities so um there is so much you know it's a lifetime of of research agendas here and if uh if we think about um if we think about how we can contribute as scholars and scholar practitioners uh to uh to the practice of human resource development in organizations um to the to address climate change issues well i'm conscious that we're nearing the end of our time together today and so I've saved one topic for the end which is the topic of HRD education.
SPEAKER_01I'm interested in your thoughts on what all of this means for how we educate HRD professionals and for those designing HRD curricula in colleges.
SPEAKER_04So in academia well for for I mean I've taught human resource development for the best part of 20 years but it's not up until recently that I've actually kind of attempted to accommodate it into my teaching. So but I I do now very consciously put it front and center in my in my classes. So I teach I teach the module on our MSc um the human resource development module is which is part of an MSc in human resource management. And the first class is kind of the bigger I call the first class the bigger picture.
SPEAKER_04And in that in that class I I I I cover what I call mega trends and they're really there are four mega trends I think that that HRD students need to know about. So there's globalization there's demography there's obviously technology with artificial intelligence and everything that's going on there with uh generative AI and so on and so on. And then the fourth mega trend is is is climate change. So I introduce it into the class uh first off and then and then you know for each of those mega trends we discuss in the class what the implications are of that particular mega trend for for um HRD as a subject and for them as students.
SPEAKER_02So it's kind of I try to embed it in their mindset from in day one almost with with with my with my master's students I I think HRD programs are doing a much better job at contextualizing HRD as a practice and as a field of research in these broader socially oriented messy wicked challenges and problems so I I think that's a step in the right direction I think to the extent that we are directly taking on climate change in these programs I think they the the agenda is still very much linked to sustainability which includes a focus on the environment but I do think that the environment gets a little bit of a short shrift now does it need to be you know a significant part of the program not necessarily but it wouldn't hurt to include a few modules on you know what climate change is and kind of how it's evolving over time and sort of the broader impacts of climate change on kind of how we organize ourselves across value change and and whatnot.
SPEAKER_02HRD programs are beginning to think about you know how we can become more socially oriented. I think the orientation to the programs within the programs are becoming broader. I mean it's not that you know we're shifting from organizational issues leadership training and development organizational performance organizational development but I do see us becoming more inclusive of bigger questions if you would and I think that you know there's a positive pivot.
SPEAKER_01Well sadly we've run out of time for today but I'd like to say a big thank you to all three of you for such an interesting discussion and for giving us so much to think about and then to act upon. So thank you all so much indeed.
SPEAKER_02Thank you Darren this was fun.
SPEAKER_04I appreciate the time and opportunity it's been an absolute pleasure and I I've learned a lot by through the conversation myself Darren so thank you very much for that.
SPEAKER_01Thank you Darren it was always a pleasure to thought this for joining me for this episode it was wonderful spending time with Ellen Scully Russ, Eugene Stadler Smith and Maria Che. If you enjoyed this episode check out all of our others there were 33 episodes in the first three seasons and we're releasing a further eleven here in the fourth.
SPEAKER_01Between them they provide access to conversations with over 100 leading scholars from around the world. New episodes release weekly To learn more about the series check out HRDmasterclass.com and to learn about the Academy of Human Resource Development check out ahrd dotorg also don't forget to look into our sponsors Dr Thomas Garavan of the Department of Management and Marketing Cork University Business School University College Cork Island and the Health Professions Education Special Interest Group HPE SIG at the Academy of Human Resource Development check out their website at the AHRD homepage at ahrd.org forward slash page forward slash special interest groups I'm looking forward to being with you in our next episode when we're exploring the relationship between HRD and pop culture with the help of Dr Jamie Callahan of Durham University, Dr.
SPEAKER_01Mark Gatto of Northumbria University and Taylor Carvalho of the University of Minnesota. Until then it is Darren Short signing off from the HRD Masterclass HRD Masterclass Podcast is brought to you by the Academy of Human Resource Development and is a production of allbypodcast.com
This fourth episode of Season 6 brings together Dr. Sanghamitra Chaudhuri (Temple University) and Dr. Kyung Nam Kim (Texas A&M University) for a conversation about the 2026 article Gendered Pathways to Work-Family...
This third episode of Season 6 brings together Dr. Yuanlu Niu (University of Arkansas) and Dr. Jos Akkermans (Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam) for a conversation about the 2026 article Navigating careers in non-traditional...
This second episode of Season 6 brings together Dr. Matthew Hurtienne (University of Texas at Tyler) and Dr. Heesun Kim (Francis Marion University) for a conversation about the 2024 article Silence in the workplace:...
This first episode of Season 6 brings together Dr. Joshua Collins (University of Minnesota) and Dr. Ague Mae Manongsong (Louisiana State University) for a conversation about the 2023 article “Manongsong, A. M., & Ghosh,...
Welcome to the trailer for Season 6 of Human Resource Development Masterclass - the podcast series from the Academy of Human Resource Development, the organization that leads HRD through research. The sixth season...