Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Human Resource Development Masterclass

Human Resource Development Masterclass artwork

HRD in Small & Medium Enterprises

Jan 11, 20221 hr 40 minAudio

In this eighth episode of Season 2, guests Dr. Ciara Nolan (Technological University Dublin), Dr. Michael Mustafa (University of Nottingham Malaysia), and Dr. Heather Short (The Open University) discuss HRD in SMEs, including: What is meant by the term Small & Medium Enterprises. How SMEs differ around the world. What HRD and learning looks like in SMEs, and also within Family SMEs. The role of the business owner and family members in HRD within SMEs. The role of technology in learning within SMEs. Whether HRD trends found in larger organizations are also found within SMEs. How well HRD models and theories work in the context of SMEs. and much more. In the first part of the episode, Ciara, Michael, and Heather meet one-to-one with host, Darren Short. In the second part, they are together to discuss their shared interest in HRD in SMEs. For full details on the HRD Masterclass series, visit hrdmasterclass.com. For more information on the Academy of Human Resource Development, visit ahrd.org - by being a member of AHRD, you can access bonus materials not included in this episode. This episode is sponsored by: Interpretive Simulations - check out their website at https://www.interpretive.com/, and by Positive Career Options - obtain the career advice you need to succeed by visiting https://positivecareeroptions.com/.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_04They weren't fans of going on a formal course for a week to find out how to do something. Whatever they choose really must be free or low cost because they just haven't got the money to spend.

SPEAKER_01Welcome to Human Resource Development Masterclass, the podcast series from the Academy of Human Resource Development, the organization that leads HRD through research. I'm your host, Darren Short, and throughout this second series, I'm joined by leading authors, researchers, and scholars to explore the fundamentals of HRD and how those are changing in the 2020s. Our focus for this episode is HRD in small and medium enterprises. And we'll be looking at what is meant by the term small and medium enterprises, and how SMEs differ around the world, what HRD and learning looks like in SMEs, and also within family SMEs, the role of the business owner and family members in HRD within SMEs, the role of technology in learning within SMEs, how well HRD models and theories work in the context of SMEs, and much more.

SPEAKER_01To help me, I'll be joined by three leading scholars: Dr. Kira Nolan, lecturer, Technological University Dublin, Dr. Michael Mustafa, Associate Professor, University of Nottingham, Malaysia, and Dr. Heather Short of the Open University. In the first part of the episode, I'll chat one-to-one with each of them. Those one-to-one conversations are brought to you with the help of the generous support of our sponsor, Interpretive Simulations. Find out about their services at interpretive.com.

SPEAKER_01Then for the second part, Kira, Michael, and Heather are together to explore their shared interest in HRD in SMEs. That group conversation is brought to you with the help of the generous support of our sponsor, Positive Career Options. Obtain the career advice you need to succeed by visiting PositiveCareerOptions.com. All of the content you'll hear in this episode was recorded in October and November of 2021.

SPEAKER_01Right, let's dive in to meet our guests. Here in the first section of the episode, I'll meet one-to-one with each guest. This section's brought to you thanks to the sponsorship support of Interpretive Simulations. Since 2008, students and trainees have used Interpretive Simulations HR Management Simulation, where participants are tasked to make challenging decisions at the HR director level in a simulated environment.

SPEAKER_01Students must build a strong HR function at their simulated, medium-sized organization and wrestle with the challenges of staying on budget. The simulation makes the connection between concept and practice while students learn by doing. It comes with assignments, mini cases, and quizzes to reinforce core HR principles. If you'd like to receive faculty access to review the HR management simulation, visit them at interpretive.com and fill out a demo request.

SPEAKER_01My first guest for the episode is Dr. Kira Nolan, lecturer in management specializing in human resource management in the College of Business Technological University Dublin City Campus. She's also a Fellow of the Higher Education Academy. Kira has previously worked as a lecturer in HRM at Dublin City University and Ulster University, as well as in HR practitioner and consulting roles in the retail and hospitality industries. Her main research interests focus on the dynamics of human resource development in small and medium-sized enterprises, with a particular emphasis on professional service firms and the tourism and hospitality industry.

SPEAKER_01Kira has published her work in outlets such as the International Journal of Management Reviews, Tourism Management, Human Resource Development Quarterly, Human Resource Development International, amongst others. Her publications have been cited in the recent International Labour Organization report, Strategic Staffing in HMEs to Supporting Lifelong Learning. Hi, Kira. Welcome to the Human Resource Development Masterclass. It's great to have you here in our episode focused on HRD in small and medium enterprises.

SPEAKER_03Thank you very much, Darren. I'm really happy to be here today to discuss what is a topic very close to my heart and one that I think is absolutely vital. So thank you so much for the invitation.

SPEAKER_01Perhaps a good place to start is with that term, small and medium enterprises, so SMEs. And I'm wondering what's meant by that term and whether you've got some examples of different types of SMEs.

SPEAKER_03I think first to say that, you know, while the idea of explaining what an SME is, it might appear on the surface to be a relatively simple task. In practice, it can be quite difficult to come up with a definition because there is a fundamental lack of consensus around what is an SME. So it's probably one of the most fundamental problems of those doing research within small businesses because there isn't a universal solution. So other than the fact that the firms are just not large. So a colleague of mine in Dublin City University, Brian Harney, talks about this idea of SME being an umbrella term.

SPEAKER_03So under that label, you have a range of organizations from maybe the family-run corner shop to maybe a professional service firm or kind of a gazelle or innovative firm that would focus on kind of knowledge generation. We also see a huge amount of variance in definitions across the globe. But in a general sense, the definitions that are used tend to be based around the numbers of people employed. And within the OECD area, the most commonly used definition is that of the European Commission.

SPEAKER_03So within that, under that label of small and medium sized enterprise, we actually have micro firms as well, which employ less than 10 people, small firms, 10 to 49 people, and then medium-sized firms employing between 50 and 249. And the European Commission also utilizes annual turnover or balance sheet totals and also firm autonomy in that not being a subsidiary. So that independence is also utilized. But I think a key problem with relying on those types of definitions is that they don't really sufficiently capture the variety kind of within the small business population.

SPEAKER_03And that in itself can lead to what has been termed size reductionism. So we look at trying to explain the behavior of an SME according to just simply its size and those metrics. So by privileging that, we're ignoring other really important contextual factors that shape what that firm does, or they're potentially treated as secondary. And Professor Richard Scates from the University of Kent makes a really important point on this. So if I if I can kind of even quote him here, he talks that it's he says it's conceptually simplistic, you know, the whole idea of collapsing such a diversity of proprietorial and managerial styles into a single generic category.

SPEAKER_03So you've got other characteristics like skill mix, product market, and so on, and are very much determining factors that shape what happens in the management process. So this idea of smallness can also be tailored to what type of economic sector you're looking at. And the advantage of that is that you can capture the multidimensional nature of an SME, but then you are faced with the challenge of achieving comparability between studies. And a further layer of complexity can be added to this by being sensitive to context, because within SMEs, you tend to have an owner manager who's very much exercising their own agency, and they will exercise that in various ways.

SPEAKER_03So we kind of can make a distinction then between the different types of small business and those that run them. So the business can be a reflection of the aspirations of an individual. So that could be focused on maintaining a particular lifestyle. It could be about sustainability rather than growth. So there are different kinds of managerial objectives as well. It's very difficult to kind of apply universal conclusions. Although it's challenging, we need to observe and recognize context and accommodate that variety because it does undermine our efforts to understand HRD and SMEs.

SPEAKER_01In light of those examples, what do you see as the main arguments for better understanding small and medium enterprises and HRD's role within them?

SPEAKER_03Well, I think first and foremost, um, SMEs account for the vast majority of private sector employment and net job creation across the globe, regardless of the country. So in the United States, for example, some studies will estimate 97% of all firms can be classified, you know, under that label. While we also see some recent data from the European Commission telling us nine out of every 10 enterprises is an SME and they generate two out of every three jobs. Now, in the Irish context, which is what I've been writing about for many years, SMEs actually account for 99.8% of active enterprises.

SPEAKER_03So actually, in an Irish context, the importance of SMEs is very much accentuated because they account for a greater proportion of employment than the EU average. But we see very much a paradox in terms of the importance of SMEs and their absence from the HRD agenda. So we actually don't know enough about them. And it's surprising and difficult to justify for a multitude of reasons. Okay, the numerical significance, as I've mentioned, but the economic significance in terms of other variables like innovation, social cohesion, things like that.

SPEAKER_03We must include SME data if we're to understand H or D, I think, in a general sense. And I think Professor James Kern, the Emeritus Professor at Kingston, has talked about, you know, if only a very small percentage of total businesses employ more than 250 people, should we not be skeptical about any theories or models based on both a small and very doubtfully representative part of the business population? And when we look at SMEs themselves, HRD does assume a much greater importance because SMEs are very labor intensive.

SPEAKER_03The individual contributions of employees are much more visible and they're very heavily reliant on a skilled and motivational workforce. So you could argue that HRD actually assumes much more importance within an SME context because of that dependency on the workforce. And I think other work as well is interesting in that it points to the challenges that managers in SMEs face when trying to manage HRD. A number of deficiencies in doing so has been identified. Managers themselves and owner managers lack an ability to identify skills and to actually carry out the development themselves.

SPEAKER_03And that lack of skill in this particular area, I suppose I could extend it to general kind of people management and development skills, is a leading cause of firm failure. So we also can, in a more macro context, looking at the public policy agenda, there have been lots of reports published in the last kind of couple of decades that have highlighted the importance of HOD for, in my case, the Irish economy, but particularly the role that SMEs play within the economy. And Ireland wouldn't be alone in that regard. So the OECD has some fantastic work about how important the topic is and how we need to focus on the training and skill needs of SMEs to improve productivity and innovation.

SPEAKER_01It's interesting because almost every book I read about HRD, without saying it, kind of implies that HRD operates in this large global corporation with vast structures and tools and systems and processes and people, which probably means that a lot of us don't really have a great sense as to what HRD looks like outside of that arena.

SPEAKER_03Yes, and I think it's a very important question and point that you make there. And I think when we look at the evidence that does exist, um, as I said, there has been a conspicuous absence of SMEs in the HRD field. But when we look at the evidence that does exist, we see a lot of negativity, we see a lot of weaknesses when it or lack of managerial capability when it comes to actually undertaking uh training and development. But I think what's interesting as well is that the studies would suggest that SMEs don't invest in formal training and skills development when you compare them to their larger counterparts, as you've mentioned there.

SPEAKER_03And when they do try, they experience a lot of barriers. So you have a lot of liabilities, I suppose, associated with this idea of being small and a number of resource constraints, so be that financial, time, operational pressures, and so on. So these all kind of coalesce to restrict um the uptake of H or D. So because of that, what we see is a strong tendency for informal ad hoc and sometimes reactive H or D approaches, where smaller businesses will rely mainly on unstructured on the job training or experiential approaches as their primary means of skill acquisition and knowledge acquisition.

SPEAKER_03So if you take that narrative, if we don't, if we just take that on face value, it's easy to come to the conclusion that SMEs are poor trainers. And while that may hold some truth, it's a very simplistic conclusion because it very much comes from the homogeneous treatment of SMEs in a lot of the literature. So what we know about HRD, as you've mentioned there, derives from the study of large organizations, where you will find resources are more plentiful and formality in terms of having budgets or plans would be much more common.

SPEAKER_03So we see a tendency to compare what happens in SMEs to this kind of idealized version of a larger organization. We also see very narrow conceptualizations or definitions of HRD focusing on the easily measurable and a lot of quantitative research. So that will not necessarily capture what actually happens in an SME. It won't necessarily capture the informality that prevails. And again, kind of Claire Rigg and Kieran Trahan have written a lot about this, talking about it leading to very much a distorted picture of what goes on, because we criticize these businesses for kind of failing to live up to this large firm ideology while also criticizing what they are doing, which is the informality.

SPEAKER_03And I think what's particularly interesting around this is that there's contrasting research regarding the benefits that can accrue to an SME that does go down that formal route. So there's some evidence to say we have a positive relationship between formality and SME performance outcomes, so financial performance or labour productivity. But for others, you know, that idea of formality adding value in that unique SME context is quite a contentious issue. And some would say that it actually interferes with the distinctive advantage of smallness that these businesses have, like the flexibility they have and the informality.

SPEAKER_03But I think ultimately we need to recognize that there are very real distinctions with regard to how decisions about HRD are made. SMEs are not a scaled-down version of a larger firm. So we can't just make that assumption that theories from large firms necessarily apply in that context. What we need is much more attention to smaller firm relevance rather than kind of larger firm comparisons. And I think as well, when it comes to looking at different sectors, um, SMEs do differ with respect to context in terms of institutional context, resource context, economic context.

SPEAKER_03And so understanding the logic of what they do in terms of H or D can only be understood by being sensitive to issues of context. So in terms of sectors, I the research I have done over the years, I'm very interested in professional service firms, management consulting firms. And we actually do find evidence of more formality in their approaches to H or D. So an example of where that would manifest would be having a policy, having a budget, having a written plan, and the use of external off-the-job interventions.

SPEAKER_03But in contrast, I'm also interested in tourism and hospitality firms where you would tend to see a more informal on-the-job ad hoc approach, it tends to be more common. However, what my co-authors and I have found over the years is that many of these small firms can and do implement HRD in a coordinated manner. So we find that what they do can be imbued with elements of both formality and informality, regardless of the sector. So that's kind of something that's quite interesting. And it may be the case as well, and some evidence would suggest this that a firm's decision to invest in formal HRD may be something that reflects rational and informed decision-making logic on behalf of the owner manager, that it's not just the way things are, it's not just an afterthought, because they're not passive recipients of these external influences.

SPEAKER_03Ultimately, I think my work would suggest support for an equivalence model. So, whatever approach is adopted, be it informality or combinations of formality and informality, if it meets firm priorities in context, it may actually be appropriate and shouldn't just be criticized. So there can be a wide range of alternative options for how HRD is handled. And really, we should assess the suitability of what a given firm is doing against the backdrop of its unique context and sectoral needs.

SPEAKER_01You've referenced a couple of times in your answers the significance of the owner. How important do you think that dynamic is between the owner and the employee in determining what HRD happens and how it happens in an SME?

SPEAKER_03Yeah, and I think that this is a particularly uh interesting one. I suppose I'd like to actually even answer that by saying that what we see is a particularly striking void in the research in terms of the limited incorporation of employee experiences of HRD within the SME setting. So we don't know enough about how employees in SMEs perceive, experience, and respond to different opportunities for HRD. Now, there is some evidence that would suggest that the subjective orientations of employees are very important to understanding HRD within SMEs.

SPEAKER_03But the significance of perceptions as well has been recognised as a very important factor determining the effectiveness of HRD. So there is a limited body of evidence that does talk about better engagement levels, greater effective commitments, job satisfaction, and perceptions of support from the organization, loyalty and turnover. But I think what we what we do see is um a need for more employee perspectives. So this idea of a top-down and bottom-up analysis of HRD and SMEs.

SPEAKER_03So it's important that we look at their perspectives as a point in principle, as well as to fully inform debates about HRD and kind of rebalance the agenda. We see kind of anomalies in this field, which I think is quite interesting as well, that employees in SMEs will show greater levels of job satisfaction and work engagement in the absence of more formal and potentially sophisticated HRD approaches. But when we look at a lot of the evidence, we see a dominance of owner manager frames of reference.

SPEAKER_03So in the main research in this area focuses overwhelmingly on the viewpoint of the owner manager. So we only often get a cursory look, if any, at the viewpoint of employees. But they are not, as uh Ram and Edwards have talked about, passive recipients of management control. And that's a phrase that always resonates with me. They're very important actors in the HRD system. They're a key missing stakeholder. So, and it's really that close proximity between employees and employers, where you have rigid kind of bureaucratic structures being rare, flattened iron, you know, organizational structures would be the norm.

SPEAKER_03That gives a greater role to individual agency and choice in amongst employees and owner managers in influencing and shaping HRD practice. So you have a range potentially of different interests and expectations amongst two key stakeholder groups, and that might mediate HRD and SMEs. So obviously, owner managers will exert a significant amount of power, but their influence is not absolute. It's going to be tempered by employee attitudes, their motivation, their orientations, both positive and negative.

SPEAKER_03So employee input is going to affect the deployment of HRD and shape its operation. So I think it's important to kind of acknowledge that the character of HRD and how it how it works, how it unfolds, is very much the outcome of ongoing, dynamic and complex interactions within what can be quite an idiosyncratic SME context.

SPEAKER_01I'd like to wrap up our conversation with a bit of a personal question because you're clearly passionate about this as a topic. And so I'm wondering how you got into researching SMEs and how you decide what aspect of SMEs to focus on in your research and writing.

SPEAKER_03Yeah. I mean, I always An interest in training and development from the various roles I'd undertaken in industry. And even going back many years ago when I was studying HRM as an undergraduate, I studied hospitality management. And I even remember my final year thesis, I was looking at creativity and innovation in the hotel industry. And a huge part of that was the importance of people and the input of the staff. So we kind of stemmed from there. And I also worked in several small businesses in HR and training roles. So I was always interested to see how I could improve things and how do I make the best decisions.

SPEAKER_03I mean, one of the roles I had included being responsible for all HR and training issues within a startup business in the retail industry. But I wanted to progress in my studies and I undertook a master's degree by research, and I was looking at this concept of best practice HRD within the hotel industry. And it actually naturally led me to focus on SMEs as they represent the dominant business model in the industry. So that's really how my interest in how the dynamics of SMEs shape the nature of HRD began.

SPEAKER_03Surprising, what was surprising to me at the time was that I found very little was known about HRD in this particular context. And I was kind of scratching my head at this, going, well, so many of the businesses in this industry are small. Why aren't we talking about them? So I think from my M field, it was it was clear that there was an awful lot more research to be done on these various issues. So for me, completing a PhD was a natural step. And I was very fortunate then to um work with Professor Thomas Garmin in the University of Limerick and a subject matter expert who's obviously participated in the podcast series as well.

SPEAKER_03So really he was very inspiring to me about the HRD field. And I think how we go about researching it then within the SME context began to kind of take over. So some recent work we've done on this has been conceptualising HRD in a multidimensional way. So looking at both the formal and informal, kind of the qualitative stuff and the quantitative, but also managerial and employee perceptions so that we try and capture the full, the fullness of the picture of HRD.

SPEAKER_03On a personal level as well, when I was doing my research, um, a huge motivating factor was the lack of research on in on HRD in Irish organizations. In many of the colleges, for example, University of Limerick and DCU in particular, there's been a lot of research on human resource management, and that's progressed significantly on the international stage. But we also see a lot of academic attention mainly on large organizations, on public sector bodies, and on multinational corporations in particular, to the neglect of SMEs.

SPEAKER_03Now, there are some very notable exceptions. Um I think my again, my colleague Brian Harney and Professor Tony Dundan, they've they've used open systems theory to look at that dynamic kind of interplay of internal and external factors that shape HR HRM and SMEs. But that that lack of research and the dimensions of that um lack of research, I think, really prompted me to see well, can I go and fill this gap? Can I can I make something of this that um is something I'm very passionate about, I'm interested in, and really that will hopefully make a difference.

SPEAKER_03So that is kind of where I began, and I've been very fortunate then more recently to participate in an EU-funded project looking at um management development practices within SMEs and how we can improve that. And that's a policy report that was published last year. So this is something that's very much on the agenda at national level here in Ireland because of the reliance on these businesses. And I think given what we've gone through economically and psychologically, we we need positive kind of goals, we need very strong goals to focus on.

SPEAKER_03And I think encouraging entrepreneurs, small business owners to not necessarily grow, but to enhance their skill base and to try and address the gaps that they're experiencing through mentoring and coaching and other forms of development is really, really important. So hopefully it's the beginning and not the end of the journey for me.

SPEAKER_01Well, Kira, that feels like a real call to action around SMEs and probably a great way of wrapping up this opening segment of the episode. Thank you so much indeed for your time today. I've really enjoyed our conversation on small and medium enterprises.

SPEAKER_03Thank you so much, Nan. It's a great opportunity for me to talk about uh this very important topic and uh to share insights, and hopefully, people will uh take up the call to action in terms of doing more work in this area. And I'd be delighted to kind of talk to anybody who's interested in this space about potential future research collaborations.

SPEAKER_01Well, that's excellent. So please stay with us, and we'll have you back later in the episode for the group conversation with Michael and with Heather.

SPEAKER_03Great. Thanks a million, Darren.

SPEAKER_01My second guest for the episode is Dr. Michael Mustafer, Associate Professor of Entrepreneurial Management and Head of School for the Division of Applied Psychology at University of Nottingham, Malaysia. Prior to being an academic, Michael was a professional army officer in Australia for a decade, where he worked extensively in the area of training and development. Michael has published numerous articles and books related to human capital management and development in family firms throughout the Asia Pacific.

SPEAKER_01He's currently editor of the journal Entrepreneurship Research Journal and Associate Editor for Journal of Entrepreneurship in Emerging Economies. Michael's research focuses on management-related issues in family business and employee proactivity and innovativeness in large organizations. Hi, Mike. Welcome to Human Resource Development Masterclass. It's great to have you here in our episode focused on HRD in small and medium enterprises.

SPEAKER_02Hi, Darren. Thank you. Thank you for having me here. And it's uh great to be here and great to be a part of this very exciting series.

SPEAKER_01So the topic of this episode is small and medium enterprises. And I know that you've researched and written on a topic that's a subset of that essentially, family SMEs. And they often go by the label family firm. And so perhaps a good place to start is what's meant by that label of family firm and what does a family firm look like?

SPEAKER_02Unfortunately, like SMEs, uh, where there is a standard European definition based on turnover or size, that largely the field of family business has not come together and agreed upon a common definition of what makes a family firm. Sure, many people would say that a defining characteristic of a family firm would inquire a family to have some sort of ownership in the family firm through equity or stops, but how much is another question.

SPEAKER_02And there has to be some degree of family involvement in the firm. So whether you have a family CEO or chairman or family members on the board. But then we start to get into this sort of trickier part of the definitions what is really a family business, right? So some scholars have said, well, it's not just about having family members own the business or be involved in the business actively, but there's also uh an intention sort of to have transgenerational continuity of the family business.

SPEAKER_02So you can imagine, sort of in this field, we might have all types and shapes of family businesses. They could be very micro-family businesses, which many of us would encounter, let's say, when we go down to a local store that's run by a husband and wife team and maybe having their siblings or even their family members involved in the family business. But then they could all the way range up to companies like Ford, which is a family business and it's been around for a couple of generations.

SPEAKER_02So, really, there's no stock standard definition of what a family firm looks like. And rather than seeing that as sort of uh an unusual barrier to studying family firms, I personally believe it it gives some degree of higher scholarly interest and thinking around family firms because we're always trying to understand what is a family firm, what makes family firms different to other types of firms.

SPEAKER_02And a great place just to sort of start thinking about this is really to sort of consider how a family SME might look like versus a non-family SME. Sure, they might have similar characteristics when we look at it in terms of its structures and stuff. But when you start to get family involved in decision making and a family a part of ownership, there's a whole series of sort of unorthodox behaviors and attitudes that arise from families' involvement in those processes.

SPEAKER_02So maybe one thing that distinguishes family firms is really their behaviors in terms of whether it be strategies or whether it be things like HRM. And some of this can be attributed to what we call the socio-emotional wealth view of family firms, which kind of goes to show us that family firms and family members have this stock of non-financial endowment, which is kind of derived by the family by being involved in the firm.

SPEAKER_02And what this really sort of says to us is that unlike other businesses, family firms might be willing to pursue non-financial objectives. A really good example of that is to, and has been provided by the researchers, to look at family firm during crisis. Rather than sort of downsizing or not investing in their business, research has shown them to do the opposite, right? To to kind of invest more in their people, invest more in the business during downturn with the idea of continuing the family.

SPEAKER_02So that's what I wanted to sort of mention regarding family and non-family firms. But it's more important that we recognize that family firms are not homogeneous themselves. There's a great deal of heterogeneity found within family firms.

SPEAKER_01So if we focus in on human resource development or human capital development, how do you see that being of importance to family SMEs?

SPEAKER_02The decisions around human capital development start at a very different point in time compared to non-family firms. So immediately when a family firm is created, if we think about that sort of defining factor of a family firm being that intention to carry the business across generations, then the family founders, the family is already thinking about human capital development. How do we prepare future generations to effectively run the business and to grow and develop the business?

SPEAKER_02So that's the one aspect of it. But more generally, just like any business, whether it's family or not, um, human capital development, human capital is essentially important to the everyday functioning of the enterprise, right? It's what differentiates very successful family firms from non-family firms in that sense as well. So it's related very strongly to things like productivity, performance. There's been a lot of research showing about how human capital in family firms is really important to things like innovation.

SPEAKER_02But you might also kind of appreciate here, I feel that as the firm develops, as the family firm develops, there seems to be a rise in the complexity regarding how do we manage human capital development. So, like I mentioned before, it might be a very important decision very early on in the founding of the firm that we have to think about intergenerational continuity and preparation of the next generation for future leadership of the enterprise.

SPEAKER_02We must also appreciate that in a family firm, there's a finite number of family members. So, how much of a family talent pool can they tap into? So, as the firm grows, there will inherently be decisions about do we hire from outside? Do we bring in others with different expertise that we don't have? So it all depends on, I think, the life cycle and the stage at which the family firm is with regard to the importance of human capital. Some family firms may not pay much attention to developing human capital within the firm for a long period of time until crisis hits.

SPEAKER_02So we think about in the current world today, if we look at Europe and even in countries like throughout Southeast Asia, the crisis has, in terms of the COVID crisis, has really imposed a significant challenge to human capital development and management in a family found. All of a sudden, you have family founders who have unfortunately passed away, and succession, transferring of ownership and management from one generation to another has to happen very, very quickly.

SPEAKER_02And the question is, are we our successes prepared? Simultaneously, you might have family members walking away from the business because the business has itself collapsed and ended. So there's a lot of human capital decisions that are necessary in family firms in order for the firm for the family firm to actually just survive and more importantly prosper.

SPEAKER_01In light of all of those decisions that you've just described, uh how are how are those decisions made within a family SME?

SPEAKER_02To be honest, we don't really understand how human capital development decisions are made in a family firm. And I think this is an exciting area of research that needs much more attention. But you can imagine that there are a plethora of factors which would sort of influence those kind of decisions. So one of the basis that we sort of have to think about this is not so much how is the decisions made, but more importantly, who makes the decisions in a family firm.

SPEAKER_02Because in a very small family firm that has just been founded, the decisions could simply be made by the founder. The authority he or she exercises over the business is he or her ability to tap on the shoulder of a potential successor and provide them with the necessary resources and opportunities, more important, to develop knowledge about the enterprise that's very sort of unique and tacit to it. But what happens when the family firm grows, which it would naturally do?

SPEAKER_02So, do decisions now move from being made by the founder solely to more of the family group? And when that starts to happen, then the family dynamics come in, right? Um, you know, favoritism, nepotism, uh, conflict. So all of these can have an implication in eventually how human resource development practices are actually conceptualized and implemented in a sort of family firm. And then going even further than that, you might have decisions then being made by the next generation who are potentially become the leaders of the family firm.

SPEAKER_02So they will be in a better position to start thinking about well, what do I know about my family business? Do I have the requisite skills to be a leader or a manager effectively in my family business? What else do I need to do? So that just looks at it in the family side of the sphere. But as I said, as family is a finite resource, and as family firms tend to sort of grow, they're going to increasingly be reliant on more and more non-family human capital. And that could be expertise in a variety of areas.

SPEAKER_02It could be expertise in sort of marketing, it could be expertise in production. So then another whole interesting set of decisions have to come about about how do we treat our employees' development needs versus our family employees' human development need? Do we offer them the same level of mentoring and development, or is there special types of mentoring and development that we provide that say family members and not non-family employees? Here I want to add this notion that what makes a family firm unique is its idiosyncratic practices.

SPEAKER_02The question then for many family owners and businesses: how do we capitalize on our idiosyncratic practices, our unique knowledge, our experience, which is very local to the actual maybe a family that owns the business or even the founder. So when you take it from this kind of perspective, you can appreciate that the only way that such sort of tacit knowledge is developed and passed on is through managing and developing the firm's human capital.

SPEAKER_02And it might be easier in the context of a family firm because the relations between family members might be easier to pass that type of knowledge on. So this gets back to my whole notion that from the beginning, from its founding, family firms are thinking about continuity, and as part of their thinking around continuity, there is also thinking about developing the human capital, maybe more importantly, the family uh employee human capital in order for the firm to survive.

SPEAKER_01So it sounds as if then that the like the family member piece clearly plays a role in decisions about who's developed or how they're developed within family SMEs. Is that is that is that a fair statement then that being a famil being a family member does play a role in in who is developed?

SPEAKER_02I believe so, yes. Again, we have to think about this in sort of what type of family SME we're looking at. If it's a small family SME, maybe something with 50 or less employees, definitely being a family member would give you tremendous advantages, I believe, in terms of human capital development. Just simply because of the focus and the idea that you will be the next generation leader in the enterprise. But then again, as the firm grows, then the complexity of being a family member increases.

SPEAKER_02So we can imagine that one of the issues that faces many family firms is the idea of nepotism and altruism. Now, this I believe is a double-edged sword when it comes to human capital. Because if we pre family owners and families and governing families sort of practice nepotism and altruism, then right, they can really have this small pool of talent which they can tap, and they can know that that talent is sort of committed to the enterprise and understands it.

SPEAKER_02But then that comes at a risk, doesn't it? And the risk here is that you're not actually bringing in new ideas into the family enterprise. Um, you're actually restricting the knowledge development within the family enterprise. So to take this when we look at sort of the literature around succession, um, we can always appreciate that succession in a family firm, and that's not just passing the baton from one generation to the next, but it's also passing on all of that pent-up knowledge and the speciality in terms of practices that a family firm has built up across to the next generation and making sure that they can not only utilize that, but develop and build upon it in order to develop more advantages.

SPEAKER_02But then family firms need change because change is going to be good for them in terms of continuity, but change means also disruption to existing systems and processes in a family firm. And it especially challenges the things like traditions and values in a family firm. So you can imagine from a being a family member, you're kind of almost having this sort of trade-off that you're going to have to experience in terms of your development.

SPEAKER_02You want the family firm to grow, you want to bring in new ideas, you want to challenge established norms, but doing so will also challenge existing values under which the family firm has traditionally been built on.

SPEAKER_01So, what factor does gender tend to play in human resource development or human capital development within family SMEs?

SPEAKER_02Actually, to be honest with you, we don't know much about that. And I think that's a really great avenue. For future research. So this is a space that myself and Professor Carol Elliott are working on, trying to understand how gender and gendered norms might impact human capital development within a family firm. So one area to kind of think about this has been the writings about women in family firms and how they are often contradictory in nature.

SPEAKER_02So one end we've got sort of literature which shows that female family leaders can be very successful at revitalizing the family firm, at growing and developing it. But at the other end of the scale, we've got this sort of disadvantaged view of women in family firms, right? Much of the literature has talked about the invisibility of females within a family firm. And part of this, I believe or feel, is often associated closely with how females might develop their human capital within a family firm.

SPEAKER_02So one kind of common cultural practice around the world and is often found in many family firms, is the idea of promogenity. That is, the eldest male heir will run the family firm or is the appointed successor. So when such attitudes might exist in a family firm, you might appreciate that from a very early age, the male founder, the male next generation will be sort of anointed. They will have opportunities to learn and develop in the family firm.

SPEAKER_02They might have opportunities like having sort of informal leadership positions. They might have opportunities by, let's say, shadowing the founder or other key family members more closely. This gives them immense insights into the family business, that tacit aspect of it and how the family firm is actually run. They might even be favoured to go, you know, uh overseas or be having the opportunity to go and get higher education with the intent of coming back to the firm.

SPEAKER_02But unfortunately, that doesn't seem to translate very well to females in a family firm, especially maybe females in the owning family. They might often have secondary roles. I mean, research has shown that you know female founders and female next generations have better relationships. But all of these, I think, subtly impact the development of human capital, especially among female family employees within the family firm.

SPEAKER_02And while they may be very talented, some of the pre-existing sort of attitudes and norms and cultures and cultural practices within family firms might prevent them from actually fully developing their human capital potential and utilizing it in the family firm. Now, I said that with the mindset that this question was really framed around female family members. What we don't know actually is how does gender play a role in the human capital development of non-family female employees?

SPEAKER_02So some of the unique sort of characteristics of family firms, like the family type of atmosphere, the caring attitudes might be very good at attracting, and research has shown this, large numbers of female employees, especially from disadvantaged communities and marginalized communities. While that may be a good thing, um, how much do family firms actually invest in female development, even learning on the job?

SPEAKER_01As a final question, I'd like to focus in on how several of our episodes have explored the ongoing COVID pandemic and its impact on HRD. And so I was wondering what your thoughts are about how the pandemic could be impacting HRD within family SMEs.

SPEAKER_02So for many family firms at the moment, I believe, they've got this unique opportunity to tap into government support, especially we can appreciate many countries throughout the world pumping money, training and development opportunities into uh into SMEs, into businesses. And this provides family firms with an opportunity to tap into that, so to get some sort of external training and development, if you want to think about it, for their employees.

SPEAKER_02But I'd also believe that families face an issue with this. While they might be appreciative of the funding that's provided, they might also recognize that isn't the type of learning and development we want our employees to experience. Because that type of learning and development, once you start getting it from funding authorities, comes with strings attached. And those strings that are attached to that type of funding may not be necessarily in line with what the family wants to do and might actually go against the family's values or practices.

SPEAKER_02So I think there's some tough decisions that family firms are going to have to make, whether we go it alone in terms of developing our human capital, or whether we open up the family firm and accept funding from external sources. Another point is that this pandemic has also provided family firms with a unique opportunity to tap into external talent. There's many skilled individuals who may have been unemployed from large companies or who've been graduating from universities with a significant degree of human capital, and they might actually turn to family firms because they might be seen as a good form of stable employment, even though they might not be able to provide some of the perks and privileges as other companies, but they might be attracted to sort of the characteristics of a family firm, the notion of working in a family firm.

SPEAKER_02So, in the short term, I feel that there's a lot of opportunities for family firms to sort of pick up a lot of good talent and human capital to help boost their operations. But on the longer term, the real challenge for family firms in terms of human capital development is how do we keep that talent? How do we continue to develop it? Besides providing sort of informal on-the-job learning, can we provide other ways of developing the human capital which larger organizations or even non-family organizations may not be able to do so?

SPEAKER_01Well, Mike, thank you so much indeed for your time today. It's been great having this conversation about small and median enterprises and specifically about family SMEs. Thank you, Darren. Well, please stay with us and we'll have you back for our group conversation with Kira and with Heather. My third guest for the episode is Dr. Heather Short, who is a learning consultant and teaches at the Open University on the Senior Leadership Master's degree apprenticeship and MBA programs.

SPEAKER_01Previously, she taught a range of business and management topics, specializing in HRD at the University of Portsmouth. Her many years of experience in business include several years setting up and running her own small and medium enterprise, taking it from a£45-pound investment to a multinational organization. Heather has extensive experience and knowledge of SMEs through networks and ethnographic research into learning in SMEs. She started, ran, and contributed to the Learning in SME stream at the University Forum HRD, which has been adopted as a permanent stream.

SPEAKER_01She has guest edited an HRDI special issue exploring learning in SMEs, originally with the late Professor David Gray. And her publications include an HRDQ guest editorial with him, encouraging more research into learning in SMEs. Hi Heather, welcome to the Human Resource Development Masterclass. It's great to have you here in our episode focused on HRD in small and medium enterprises.

SPEAKER_04Hi Darren. Well, thank you very much for inviting me. It's just wonderful to get the opportunity to talk about one of my favorite subjects, learning in SMEs.

SPEAKER_01Well, maybe that's a good place to start with that term, learning in SMEs. I've noticed that in your writing you use that term as opposed to HRD in SMEs. So what do you see as the significance of the difference between those terms?

SPEAKER_04Well, essentially, I think it's a difference as to whether people in SMEs actually understand it. Terminology is a really important issue when dealing with SMEs. Each SME often has their own words and phrases. Research by Jeff Gold and David Devins established that quite a long time ago. And it's as true then as it is now. And so that may be one of the reasons why learning in SMEs is so hidden. Researchers are using terms which the people in the SMEs don't really understand.

SPEAKER_04I could give you an example from my own research. My PhD explored e-learning in SMEs. And when I put the questions together, which I wanted to ask people in the SMEs, one of my supervisors, who had had very little contact with SME employees, insisted that I change the term e-learning to technology-enabled learning. I was reluctant to change that, but I did so. I think in the early days of a PhD, convinced that your supervisor knows everything.

SPEAKER_04Anyway, probably not surprisingly, the question, how much technology enhanced learning do you do in your everyday job? That just met with blank stares. And to be fair, even when I substituted the word e-learning for technology enhanced learning, that didn't always help a lot either. Their understanding of e-learning, in fact, learning in general, certainly didn't coincide with mine. And it was only when we got talking and I explained the sort of things e-learning and general learning could include that really useful information began to emerge.

SPEAKER_04I think that also illustrates how unsuitable some of the methods used to research SMEs are, which also hinder finding out how much learning is taking place there. For example, if a researcher uses a questionnaire and includes a question such as, how much HRD do you do, especially if the acronym isn't spelt out, the answer may well be none. However, if you're conducting an interview and can then explain what you mean and they can ask questions, the answers are much more likely to be more revealing.

SPEAKER_04And if you can conduct ethnographic research, which I was fortunate enough to do, and which people such as Tom Garavan have recommended, you can also observe what they do. And so really rich information starts to emerge.

SPEAKER_01Well, I'd love to talk a bit more about what you've learned from that research on learning in SMEs. Before we do, though, I'd like to explore what it's actually like to research with SMEs. What have you found is the key to researching with them?

SPEAKER_04I think I've already touched on some of that, which is use their language. And also, I'll definitely say be prepared to put a lot of effort in. Researching in SMEs isn't for the faint-hearted. To start with, as people such as Mark Saunders have found, it's not easy to gain access to SMEs. In fact, just identifying suitable ones is difficult. There are so many of them, and mostly we're unaware of the existence of many of them.

SPEAKER_04For example, if you walked along the average high street, even in these days of the pandemic, you're likely to pass many SMEs, probably a family business news agent, a one-person greengrocers, a law partnership, all those sorts of things. There are just so many of them. So even when you've identified them, you've then got a huge barrier to get over because you have to persuade them, or more specifically, persuade the owner manager to allow you to come in and research.

SPEAKER_04I think it's well known that SMEs are notoriously short of resources, money, people, time. Why should they waste time speaking to an academic for some research which is unlikely to benefit them at all? I must admit, I had a bit of an advantage when I started researching in them because I had run my own SME for many years, and I knew loads of people who owned or ran or worked in SMEs, and I belonged to various SME networks.

SPEAKER_04And so I had contacts. And although none of the SMEs I researched in belonged to people I knew, it was those people, the people I knew, who told me about the particular SMEs that I did end up researching in. And probably more importantly, they recommended me as someone who wouldn't waste their time. Being personally recommended is it's like gold dust to anyone who wants to research in an SME. But I also found that I had to offer them something in return.

SPEAKER_04As I've said, they're very short of time and resources. And so, why, you know, why would they let employees be interviewed by me for an hour or whatever at a time and then lose that time? So, what could I offer them to make up for that? So, in my case, I offered to do some work for them unpaid in return for researching there. And that was really useful for me because I could then work alongside people and then I could observe firsthand what they were doing.

SPEAKER_04And that was, oh, that was just so useful. The other thing I was really careful to do was to become one of them as soon as I could. Things like making the tea is always a good idea. It really breaks down an awful lot of barriers. I think you've got to be careful not to talk down to them. Certainly from some people I spoke to in a business where they had had a researcher in before me. They felt that they had been talked down to on occasion. I think you've got to respect their knowledge and their tenacity.

SPEAKER_04Being in a SME or running an SME really isn't an easy job, and be prepared to work long hours just as they do. One of the SMEs I researched in and worked in, it was sort of 7:30 starts, and you know, people were still there at six o'clock in the evening. So just try and fit in with them as much as you can.

SPEAKER_01There must be many ways in which SMEs are different larger organizations that are kind of focusing on the learning piece of it. But when you consider learning in SMEs, how do you view the balance between formal, informal, and incidental learning compared to what would happen in a larger organization?

SPEAKER_04I think researchers' over reliance on looking for formal learning is responsible, or at least partly responsible, for failing to unearth the amount and richness of learning that does happen in SMEs. As you know, most research into learning is in large organisations. And in those large organizations, the learning is very often formal. Typically, employees there would go on a course run by an external company for a few days, or they did tend training sessions developed by the in-house team.

SPEAKER_04Somehow that has led to an assumption that only formal training is real training. I know that Kurtzer and Perry encountered that opinion in their research into New Zealand SMEs published in, I think it was 2008, and that view still seems to persist that only formal training is really training at all. However, one of the key characteristics of SMEs is their informality. Michael discussed that in his podcast.

SPEAKER_04Many are family businesses, andor they employ friends and people they know, and others have started as collaborations between friends. So formality has no has no place in the organization in an SME. And so why should they look for formal learning? And indeed, how could they afford externally run courses? So learning in SMEs tends to be informal, interpersonal, and on the job.

SPEAKER_04The term learning at Nelly's knee originated there, I believe, and that continues to be a key way of SME employees' learning, learning from more experienced people within the organization. However, another complication is that learning within SMEs may not always be evident because it's contextualized in the everyday practical application. So learning is occurring through rather than on the job, so that it's often not recognised as learning.

SPEAKER_04And that's been found by many people, such as Gilden Hearn and Cilias and Rig and Trahan. It occurs as it's needed, often as a result of an emergency or at least an unexpected event cropping up. Several SME employees have told me that they really like working in an SME because no two days are the same, or that you never know exactly what you're going to do or what you're going to learn that day. And I think that's very true. So, in my experience of SMEs, there is very little formal learning, and therefore most of it is informal, and included in that is a large amount of incidental.

SPEAKER_04However, SMEs, they're not homogeneous, and so it would be impossible to put percentages on it. But yeah, definitely most of the learning in SMEs is informal and much of it is incidental.

SPEAKER_01You talked a bit there about the significance of the people within SMEs, and I'm sure one of the most significant people is the owner manager. So, what do you see as the role of the owner manager in learning within SMEs?

SPEAKER_04Well, they're hugely important. In an SME, the whole organization is molded in the shape of the person who starts it and what their wants and aspirations for the business are. And therefore, the learning within the organization is similarly influenced by them. Some owner managers are relatively uneducated and therefore they don't always see the need for training. But similarly, those very people who don't see the need for the training then blame the lack of learning in their organization on employee laziness.

SPEAKER_04And there's also, in some SMEs, a fear of training employees who would then take their learning elsewhere. And so it will have been a complete waste of time and money. Or owner managers are reluctant to employ people more educated than themselves. So it is a very, very complicated picture. However, another problem which arises is that usually research into learning in SMEs has been from the perspective of the owner manager. Researchers have tended to ask owner managers questions, but very rarely to involve employees.

SPEAKER_04And this has been highlighted by people such as Susan Murrith and Kurtzer. Even when employees are the research subjects, owner managers often want to influence who is involved. I found this in my research, and I know others have, and often the owner manager's suggestions are people of exactly the same mindset as themselves, which probably isn't that useful in gaining a truly representative view of people within the organization.

SPEAKER_04And I think that adds to the picture that little learning occurs in the SME. Only the owner managers seem to be doing any learning. But in my experience, that's really far from the truth. Another problem with only asking owner managers is that many of them don't really know what their employees are learning or how. And they really wouldn't want to admit that to a researcher. And the reason for that lack of knowledge may be for a number of reasons.

SPEAKER_04The owner manager's likely not to have the time to know exactly what the employees are doing, so long as the job's done, they're quite happy. This can sometimes be interpreted as a lack of interest on behalf of the owner manager, but personally I don't think that's fair. An owner manager is likely to be far too busy trying to ensure that the organisation thrives and survives than to be involved in what they see as the nitty gritty of the business. And that's really a demonstration that trust is likely to be strong in an SME, which I think is another very important factor in learning.

SPEAKER_04Another reason may be that the owner manager doesn't understand what their employees are learning. And again, That may be complicated by other factors. For example, the owner manager may not want to admit that they don't understand. Or again, they may not have the time or the inclination to understand it. They may have employed a specialist, perhaps in order to save themselves time in learning a new skill. So why should they spend time trying to understand it?

SPEAKER_04So if you're only asking the owner-manager and they don't understand it, they're very unlikely to talk about it. Another factor that I discovered, and that's particularly with e-learning, which I was primarily investigating, is that the learning isn't always obvious. For example, if an employee is online, are they looking up how to do something or are they involved in an online chat discussing the best way of doing something on perhaps on a forum?

SPEAKER_04Or are they just getting on with their job? It's very, very difficult to tell. And although some SME owner managers told me that their employees were doing lots of e-learning, I think I said at the beginning that when I went in to do my ethnographic research, I had to give them something in return. So I was offering to work for them free for several months. But one of my prereqs for going into the organization was that they should be doing some e-learning.

SPEAKER_04So owner managers were keen to get me there to do this free work for them. And so some of them may have been a bit, shall we say, economical with the truth about the extent of the e-learning going on. But they told me that, yeah, there was lots of e-learning going on in their organizations. And when I started researching there, I found that yes, e-learning was happening, but it was very, very different to that which the owner manager had told me was happening.

SPEAKER_04They were telling me that people were doing online courses and this sort of thing. And in reality, it was much less formal and much more interactive. So they weren't doing any sort of online course or very rarely, but they were Googling things, they were asking fellow members of forums for advice, they were using Twitter, all of these sort of things. They were watching TED talks, some of them, in the evening to build up their knowledge on things. So although owner managers are undoubtedly very influential in learning in SMEs, by focusing on them, I think researchers have missed out on some very, very rich information.

SPEAKER_01E-learning is an example of learning through technology and in larger organizations, we've seen a significant trend towards learning through technology in recent years. Has this also happened in SMEs and does it look different compared to larger organizations?

SPEAKER_04I've found that there's much more e-learning happening in SMEs than previous research would indicate. Probably the low amount of e-learning that's expected to occur in an SME is really largely because there has been so little research into it. But from what I've seen, e-learning, probably not surprisingly, is similar to general learning in SMEs. It shares the same characteristics, but it's informal.

SPEAKER_04So employees would be Googling things, they'd be looking things up on websites, including Wikipedia. It's interpersonal. So they use forums, um, interactive websites, they undertake Skype calls and so on. And it's on the job. So they might be perhaps watching a YouTube video to solve a problem. And an overriding factor, again similar to general learning in SMEs, is that whatever they choose really must be free or low cost because they just haven't got the money to spend.

SPEAKER_04But interestingly, when I've discussed that with employees in SMEs, they've been adamant that the methods that they've chosen have not only been free or almost free, but they've also been the most effective means of doing what they're doing. They weren't fans of going on a formal course for a week to find out how to do something, if they could find that out quickly by using some informal e-learning method. I've also worked in large organisations, international organisations, and so on.

SPEAKER_04And I have got lots of friends and students who work in such companies, and so I do have quite a bit of familiarity with e-learning in big organizations, but I think they still are quite entrenched in the view that this formal learning is real learning, and so people go on courses, and so I wonder whether larger organizations could learn from SMEs when it comes to e-learning.

SPEAKER_04I mean, goodness me, that is a complete turnaround in views about learning in general, isn't it? Really? That large organizations could actually learn from SMEs. But in these times of what's the pandemic, there's Brexit, there's general economic problems across the globe, supply problems, and so on, large organizations are becoming increasingly cost conscious. All organizations are now, just as SMEs have been for a long, long time.

SPEAKER_04And so perhaps those large organizations will be moving away from developing or buying in online courses when it comes to e-learning. And perhaps they will be using these less formal methods, which will save them money, and I think it would increase employee satisfaction because there's a lot of interaction in many of these methods that are chosen by the SMEs. So yeah, I think it is different in a large organization, but I think they may all be moving in the same direction.

SPEAKER_04And um I just think there's so much fascinating and really useful research which is just waiting to be done. Well, that's excellent, Hedda.

SPEAKER_01Thank you so much indeed for taking time out to talk with us about HID in SMEs today. I've really enjoyed our conversation.

SPEAKER_04Oh well, thank you so much, Darren, for inviting me. And most of all, a huge thank you for recognizing that learning does occur in SMEs and including it in your list of topics. And I do hope that this will lead to some much needed research into learning in SMEs.

SPEAKER_01Well, I'm looking forward to continuing the conversation, so please stay with us and we'll have you back in the next section of the episode for our group conversation with Kira and with Mike. Up next, we have the group discussion, where my guests are together to discuss their shared passion for the episode's topic. This discussion is brought to you thanks to the sponsorship support of Positive Career Options, who combine a multidisciplinary team with academic and industry expertise to provide a unique and valuable insight into career options utilising fully validated psychometric tools combined with one-to-one feedback and coaching from qualified career coaches.

SPEAKER_01Their five services include CV, interview and assessment centre preparations, as well as career coaching and a career options program. To find out more and obtain the career advice you need, visit them at PositiveCareerOptions.com. Welcome back to the HRD Masterclass podcast. Our focus for this episode is HRD in small and medium enterprises, and I've already met one-to-one with Ciara Nolan, Michael Mustafa, and Heather Short.

SPEAKER_01And for the final section of the episode, we're all together for our group chat. So welcome back, Kira, Mike, and Heather.

SPEAKER_04Oh, thanks, Darren, and hi everyone. Yes, great.

SPEAKER_02Yes, Darren. Thank you for inviting me back.

SPEAKER_01As a place to start, I was thinking that uh during our one-to-one conversations, we touched on how SMEs are defined differently around the world, and that must make it a challenge sometimes to look at HRDs in SMEs across countries. So I'm wondering what we know about the differences between SMEs in light of the ambiguity of definitions and those challenges of terminology.

SPEAKER_03The task of defining what an SME is is probably the most fundamental problem that we're faced with because depending on whether you're adopting a US definition, which can be up to 500 employees, or the OECD, which can be 250, or the European Commission, which is up to 250, we can have a problem in kind of connecting the different evidence. And I think that is that has created problems in terms of building a robust body of knowledge. And I think the fact as well, it's it's this continued tendency to engage in comparisons between larger and smaller businesses that has fed into the ambiguity and uncertainty because we have the language systems of the discourse of larger firms being privileged at the expense of SMEs.

SPEAKER_03And that leads to this tendency to universalise, which in turn creates more problems. Because when we're talking about what is HRD, we're looking at models or definitions or theories that have stemmed from the studies of larger businesses. They tend to be kind of very universalist in tone, normative. And so it's they focus predominantly on what HRD should be rather than looking at what it is. And Peter Kuchinka has done some really interesting work around that. And we also see that within the field of HRM.

SPEAKER_03So maybe we need to do a better job as scholars to capture the complexity and the dynamic work of a different of different SMEs and really embrace the context in terms of how that influences the enactment of practice and kind of move away from looking at practices that we see in larger businesses, which tend to be formal and assume a large amount of resources, expertise, HR professionals, because it's because of when we when we do that, what happens in these smaller businesses gets labelled or deficient, and then it becomes even more overlooked.

SPEAKER_03So I think we just maybe need to take a step back about how we go about doing this research, and also as well as how we define HRD.

SPEAKER_04This idea that SMEs are all the same and can be um lumped into one group to be researched is is obviously wrong because they do tend to have their own words and phrases. You know, they've grown up from one person, and that person's words and phrases tend to be repeated through the organization. And so, of course, they're going to be different from each other. That's why the learning can be so hidden. We're using terms which they don't understand, so they're not answering the questions which we think we're asking.

SPEAKER_04Uh, and it it's it's just a really complex situation.

SPEAKER_02But if we just sort of think a little bit more into the future now, this ambiguity and definition that both Kira and Kevin talked about, it's also an opportunity to open up new and interesting avenues for our understanding of what HRD might actually look like in SMEs. Because as we move forward in time, we're going to get very different types of SMEs that are coming about. And the way that they're developing so rapidly at the moment, the current definitions and the way we think about HRD in SMEs currently may be the wrong language to use to understand HRD in maybe five, ten years' time.

SPEAKER_02So I think there's also this element of overlooking and this opportunity that this uh ambiguity affords us, not so much as a challenge, but the ability to sort of grow the field.

SPEAKER_01I think that's a really exciting area to go forward into one of the other topics that came up in the in our one-to-ones was about how a lot of employee development happens within the SME, with a particular emphasis on the uh owner um developing employees. But I was wondering whether you also see examples of SMEs working together to develop employees, or is it the case that most SME employee development does just happen within the SME?

SPEAKER_02The simple answer to that question is that unfortunately it seems to be most of the latter in this case that most SME employee development tends to happen within the boundaries of a specific SME. Now, that doesn't exclude the fact that there could be lots of examples of SMEs working together to develop employees. And I know there's been a lot of government efforts, especially in countries like uh the UK as well as in countries like Ireland, even to some degree in places like Malaysia, where there is infrastructures put into place where there can be small clusters or hubs of SMEs and with the assistance of government getting together and providing knowledge sharing and hopefully channeling employee development.

SPEAKER_02But then again, this gets us to think about how SMEs network with one another in a more broader sense. Are they just simply networking with one another to gain a particular advantage or gain access to resources? And I'm not sure whether there is actually any research or those in-depth studies that have looked at whether SMEs sort of form networks or clusters to help uh employee developments sort of build those sort of uh HRD ecosystems themselves.

SPEAKER_02Now, I can appreciate that this is quite sort of different from larger organizations. Let's uh let's just take an example of somewhere like Silicon Valley, where we know there's a lot of high-tech firms, where you've got your classic sort of Facebooks and your Googles and your Microsofts and all of that. They've got natural hubs of employee development, and more importantly, within those sort of ecosystems, employees are constantly moving around from one organization to another, and that in itself facilitates a transfer of knowledge and learning in a lot of cases.

SPEAKER_02With the SMEs, though, we don't really tend to see that picture. So, where we're getting an image is most of the employee development happening within the boundaries of the organization, and again, whether that is formal or informal, there's there's a lot of debate around that, and we seem to be kind of moving towards this understanding or illusion that it at least is informal in nature. But on the flip side of that, um, the informality though can actually help the way SNEs deal with one another, and that in itself can provide opportunities for the employees to develop it.

SPEAKER_04If I could take a UK-centric view for a moment, uh, in the UK, there are some organisations such as the FSB, the Federation of Small Businesses, the British Chambers of Commerce, and so on, where SMEs do work together and learn together, that might be through organised courses or it might be just from meeting together, sharing ideas and so on. Um, and then there are things like the local enterprise partnerships, which involve SMEs as well as well, organisations, local organisations of all sizes, public sector, academia, third sector, and so on.

SPEAKER_04But they really seem to just involve owner managers or perhaps a few senior people within an SME. There's not really much employee involvement. And in an ideal world, new knowledge gained that way, yes, it would be shared with others in the organisation, but in reality, that's rarely done, probably due to the well-known shortage of time in SMEs. So I certainly haven't seen much evidence of employee development resulting from the FSB and so on.

SPEAKER_04And even bodies like CIPD, the Chartered Institute of Personnel Development, um, here in the UK, that in theory is concerned with learning in all organisations, but in reality, some of its publications show very little understanding of how SMEs work and of their problems, their limitations, and so on.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, if I could pick up on a couple of points made there. I think again, kind of looking in my own country in Ireland, we we have an um a particularly valuable initiative to micro and smaller businesses. It's called Skillnet Ireland. So it's it's a business support agency of the government and it's it's very much a training network approach, but they focus on kind of improving productivity and innovation of businesses, but it's driven by the businesses themselves. So they publish a report every year, and they kind of some of the latest data will tell us that there are over 70 networks and they cover industries from baking to hairdressing to radio to hospitality.

SPEAKER_03And we have you know over 80,000 people trained, nearly over 21,000 companies involved of all sizes, but it's a very valuable platform because they come together with a common need, and the training is then customized to their unique requirements, and I think that is the way that the businesses actually benefit in particular because it's so customized and they do engage with each other. Um, so talking about how smaller businesses connect together, a lot of the learning occurs in the context of that informal kind of chat that you might have with somebody.

SPEAKER_01So throughout the episode, we've contrasted SMEs with larger organizations. And so, kind of to continue that a little further, I'm thinking about some of the trends that we've seen in larger organizations over the last few years. For example, the continuing push for technology, the increased emphasis on equity, diversity, and inclusion, and so many more. So, do we see the same trends in SMEs that we're seeing in larger organizations, or are they different?

SPEAKER_04I think a big change has been in the use of technology, and that's been through necessity. Um, it's been sped up by the global pandemic and general economic problems across the globe, as well as some more localized challenges such as Brexit here in the UK. Um, so before all of this, think back to 2019 and earlier, it was large organisations which appeared to be leading the way in their use of technology. However, few SMEs seemed to use any sort of online courses.

SPEAKER_04There was often a bit of a distrust of people they hadn't met before, and perhaps it all seemed a bit a bit too formal for people who worked in, as we've discussed, a predominantly informal concern. But the pandemic, as we've all found, has affected all aspects of life, all aspects of business, including learning. Um, and use of technology has become necessary throughout all those things. So um SMEs have had to put their use of had to up their use of um of technology in order to survive.

SPEAKER_04I'm sure we've all seen small shops who are now selling things online, which previously would have been unthinkable. Um, but they seem to have learned, as has often been the case in the past, they've learnt from the skills that they've picked up in their personal life. Um, I think we've all had to use Zoom, Skype, Teams, and so on to keep in touch with our nearest and dearest. And so they've used these methods to contact people in their work situations to learn what they need when they need it.

SPEAKER_04As I mentioned earlier, I do wonder whether larger organizations could learn from SMEs regarding informal e-learning. They're also feeling the effects of the economic downturn much more sharply than they were. So are they too using the cheap or free methods of learning which um SMEs have long been using? So I think that's another really interesting and valuable research area which could be explored further.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, I couldn't agree with you more, Heather. And it's just interesting, a couple of the points you made that reads really resonates in terms of I think we we need to pay more attention and give consideration to whether whatever the practices in use are that they're achieving their objectives within the context of the SME rather than just criticizing them because they might be free, they might be informal. So I really love the concept of functional equivalence. So the idea that, you know, one Practice isn't necessarily better than another, but you know, SMEs may just follow a different logic to their larger counterparts.

SPEAKER_03So it's about trying to surface those various functional equivalents in terms of how they accomplish particular outcomes.

SPEAKER_02One way of sort of thinking about this is that during this pandemic, the notion of the informality, the small is beautiful, the close relationships between the owner, manager, and all the staff has actually paid a little bit of dividends for many SMEs, even though some have been forced to have their employees work from home. They've already had this inbuilt culture of kind of independence, looking for all of the information and the learning themselves. So when we see this gradual return back to sort of normality, I guess, we can see maybe a lot more SMEs sort of investing in the development of their people because people have been forced to kind of do it for the last one and a half years.

SPEAKER_01A lot of the listeners to the episode will have a particular interest in HRD theories and models that they either using in their research or they're creating in their theory building. And I'm wondering about your perspective on how well those HRD models and theories are working in the context of SMEs and where they don't work, what can we be doing to address that?

SPEAKER_04I don't think that generally HRD models and theories work at all well in SMEs. As you know, most research into learning is in large organisations where there's generally formal HRD. There are departments, managers, dedicated resources, external courses, and so on. However, in an SME, such things are very, very unusual. There's lots of learning from each other, learning which is geared to the specific needs of the SME at a particular time.

SPEAKER_04So it's probably unplanned, for example, trying to solve a problem urgently, and perhaps even to ensure that the SME can continue to exist. However, I think from what we've been discussing, that we've probably all seen that the learning in SMEs can fit into HRD models and theories. It's just that the people within the SMEs aren't using the formal terms, and so they don't recognise it as such. And it may well be well hidden from the researchers because it is so tied up with their everyday work that they're doing.

SPEAKER_04So we've really got to put lots and lots of effort into finding it and try and use terms, as we've all been discussing. Kira led the discussion earlier today on that. As I mentioned, and I think we've all mentioned earlier, learning within SMEs is contextualised in everyday practical applications. And so it is well hidden. And that coupled with the fact that SMEs aren't homogenous, that all makes it really difficult to see the learning in SMEs, much less to see how that learning fits into the formal HRD models and theories.

SPEAKER_04And so I wonder if perhaps it's a slightly different question we should be considering. Perhaps we need to think about why we want it to fit such models. If it's going to help SMEs with their learning, make it more, make them more efficient, um, make the learning more understandable for them. Well, that's great. But if it's just to make it easier for us to research it, it's not really a very valid reason, is it?

SPEAKER_02We should be pushing sort of the boundaries and trying to really ask ourselves why is it the models are not working as we kind of predict them? And also moving beyond this constant comparison or trying to say this is what happens in larger organizations, and this is what we expect to happen in SMEs, and we kind of stop there or then saying, Well, maybe this is what it might look like in SMEs. There's much more depth and breadth in SMEs than we might actually find in larger organizations, and I think we should need to leverage that, especially with sort of some of the HRD models and theories.

SPEAKER_02Just looking at an area where I'm particularly interested in, and that is sort of human capital development in family firms. And I mentioned this earlier that if you think about it, HRD decisions are made from almost the time the firm is founded. They are constantly thinking about how are we going to ensure the continuity of the firm? How are we going to ensure that there is capable next generation successes developed in the organization who can carry on our legacy?

SPEAKER_02Now, for many large organizations, employee development decisions and the models around those might come very much later on once an individual has become part of the organization and might be more things to do with things like performance management or career development. So it's only through looking at the uniqueness of these SMEs and saying what's different about them and the different types of SMEs, and even comparing amongst SMEs, that we can sort of get these more contextualized explanations, I feel, of HRD.

SPEAKER_01In your answers there, there's something of a challenge to HRD researchers. And so to continue that a little further, I'm wondering what you would encourage those HRD researchers to focus on in advancing our understanding of HRD in SMEs.

SPEAKER_03I think there's so much potential here, and I think we're all clearly very enthusiastic and passionate, as has been said already. But fundamentally, I think it comes down to the need to kind of bring context back in. And we need to kind of more mindfully and systematically integrate it into how we we look at this phenomenon within SMEs. And I mean, and that is kind of tying into the fact that we've already spoken about more useful language that resonates with SMEs, looking at SMEs in a disaggregated way and kind of moving beyond kind of simplistic ideas, you know, that small firms don't do training to understanding what they actually do.

SPEAKER_03So there's so many avenues. And I think one of the key things that needs further research is the voice of the employee. So we need to move beyond the owner-manager frame of reference. So this limited incorporation of employee voices is really stark. Um, we need to understand how they how they perceive, how they experience and respond to HRD practices. I think recognizing the fact that that relationship between the owner-manager and their employees is so critical, it's surprising actually that that hasn't been given further attention.

SPEAKER_03I think it's important to talk about the future of work. I don't think we can kind of overlook that. I mean, Heather and Mike were talking about the pandemic, but I think some of the characteristics may be, I mean, looking at startups and those that have a track record of pursuing new business models and engaging with technology, which Heather alluded to earlier. I mean, I think SMEs are really important sites for research to look at things like changing expectations and demographics of employees on HR, HRD, you know, the impact of digitization, changing market factors, institutional context.

SPEAKER_03So the pandemic has obviously presented huge challenges, but I think it's a it's a catalyst as well to try and continue to explore um how we can enhance productivity through digitisation.

SPEAKER_04As we all know, in an SME, people tend to do, if not everything, many jobs rather than being a small cog in a large wheel. And so if you research there, you aren't really researching learning in one particular area. You're looking at them learning in lots of areas, probably at more or less the same time. And so it's the process of learning that can come out so much more clearly there.

SPEAKER_02I also encourage further exploration of different research methodologies. What I've noticed the lack of is things like diary studies to understand day-to-day learning that is taking place at the individual level in SME. So that could give us some really good in the future insights into employees' perspective of how through their everyday activities they are actually learning and developing on the job. But an area that I'm kind of sort of really passionate about, I think, going forward, is to think more about equity, diversity, and inclusion and its impact on HID and SMEs.

SPEAKER_02And the future, I believe, looks really sort of bright here. On one sort of level, we may be experiencing this unique period now where SMEs are able to pick up much older talent and bring them into their organization. And how does that work with the current sort of setup in terms of their organization and the employees that they have there? I think these are some sort of interesting questions that the future scholars can at least take up.

SPEAKER_01Well, that's almost a call to action there. So maybe that's a maybe that's a good place to end our conversation today. So a big thank you all for all of your time. I really enjoyed our conversation. So thank you so much for being a part of our discussion on HRD in SMEs.

SPEAKER_03It's a real honor, Darren. Thank you.

SPEAKER_02Thank you, Darren. Thank you for setting us up. We've got really a lot of good ideas going there.

SPEAKER_04Thanks, Darren. Bye, everyone.

SPEAKER_01Thank you so much for joining me for this episode. It was wonderful spending time with Kira, Michael, and Heather. If you enjoyed this episode, check out all of our others. There were 11 episodes in the first season, and we're releasing a further 11 here in the second. Between them, they provide access to conversations with 50 leading HRD scholars. New episodes release weekly. To learn more about the series, check out HRDmasterclass.com. And to learn about the Academy of Human Resource Development, check out ahrd.org.

SPEAKER_01By becoming a member, you can access extra bonus materials not included in the podcast. Also, don't forget to look into our sponsors, Interpretive Simulations. Check out their website at interpretive.com. And by Positive Career Options, obtain the career advice you need to succeed by visiting PositiveCareerOptions.com. I'm looking forward to being with you in our next episode. Until then, this is Darren Short, signing off from the HRD Masterclass.com.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Gendered pathways to work-family balance

    Nov 17, 202634 minAudio

    This fourth episode of Season 6 brings together Dr. Sanghamitra Chaudhuri (Temple University) and Dr. Kyung Nam Kim (Texas A&M University) for a conversation about the 2026 article Gendered Pathways to Work-Family...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Navigating careers in non-traditional work

    Nov 10, 202636 minAudio

    This third episode of Season 6 brings together Dr. Yuanlu Niu (University of Arkansas) and Dr. Jos Akkermans (Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam) for a conversation about the 2026 article Navigating careers in non-traditional...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Silence in the workplace: What do we know from research?

    Nov 2, 202634 minAudio

    This second episode of Season 6 brings together Dr. Matthew Hurtienne (University of Texas at Tyler) and Dr. Heesun Kim (Francis Marion University) for a conversation about the 2024 article Silence in the workplace:...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Diversified mentoring: Living at the intersections of race and gender

    Oct 27, 202634 minAudio

    This first episode of Season 6 brings together Dr. Joshua Collins (University of Minnesota) and Dr. Ague Mae Manongsong (Louisiana State University) for a conversation about the 2023 article “Manongsong, A. M., & Ghosh,...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Season 6 Trailer

    Oct 12, 20262 minAudio

    Welcome to the trailer for Season 6 of Human Resource Development Masterclass - the podcast series from the Academy of Human Resource Development, the organization that leads HRD through research. The sixth season...

    Credit the people on this episode