Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Human Resource Development Masterclass

Human Resource Development Masterclass artwork

How To Prepare The Next Generation Of HRD Professionals

Oct 20, 202551 minAudio

In this eighth episode of Season 5, I meet with guests Dr. Brian Vivona (Northeastern Illinois University), Dr. Stephanie Sisco (University of Minnesota), and Dr. Ronan Carbery (University College Cork) to discuss how to prepare the next generation of HRD professionals. We discuss: How do we see the work of HRD professionals changing over the next 10-15 years? What do these changes mean in terms of the skills and knowledge needed by HRD professionals? How can degree programs prepare HRD professionals for all of this? How does this impact who transitions into HRD from other professions and how they transition? and much more. For full details on the HRD Masterclass series, visit hrdmasterclass.com, and for the bios of the guest scholars visit allbypodcast.com/developing. For more information on the Academy of Human Resource Development, visit ahrd.org. This episode is sponsored by the Program Excellence Network of the Academy of Human Resource Development. Are you committed to advancing excellence in HRD education? Discover the Program Excellence Network, or PEN, an exclusive initiative from the Academy that connects institutions and educators dedicated to building top-tier HRD academic programs. PEN offers a powerful annual meeting for networking, online searchable directory, case competitions, best practice sharing, and professional development - all aimed at strengthening graduate and undergraduate HRD teaching. With an individual membership in AHRD, the PEN Community memberships is just $99 per year per institution, unlocking access to a vibrant community where faculty collaborate, innovate, and champion student success. Whether you’re faculty members looking to expand your network or an institution seeking program recognition and continuous improvement, PEN is your gateway to excellence. Find out more and join PEN by visiting ahrd.org. Elevate your impact and connect with colleagues who share your passion for transformative HRD education. The Program Excellence Network - where excellence

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_04They're using ChatGPT to write job descriptions. They're using Google Gemini to write learning development strategies. They're using Microsoft Copilot to screen TVs. If we're taking a human out of HR, what are we actually left with?

SPEAKER_00Welcome to the Human Resource Development Masterclass, the podcast series from the Academy of Human Resource Development, the organization that leads HRD through research. I'm your host, Darren Short, and here in our fifth season, we're exploring some of our listeners' top how-to questions, with the help of leading authors, researchers, and scholars. In this eighth episode of the season, we're focusing on the question of how to prepare the next generation of HRD professionals.

SPEAKER_00And you'll hear a conversation recorded in August of 2025. To explore this important question, I'm joined today by three experts. My first guest is Dr. Brian Vivona, Associate Professor of Human Resource Development at Northeastern Illinois University. Brian's research interests include how humor functions in the workplace and specialty nursing certification. As a research affiliate at the University of Wisconsin Center for Research on College Workforce Transitions, he's co-authored several studies on internships and utilizing community-based participatory action research.

SPEAKER_00My second guest is Dr. Stephanie Sisko, assistant professor at the University of Minnesota, where she teaches business and marketing education, human resource development and adult education. Stephanie's areas of expertise include diversity management, critical human resource development, and participatory learning strategies. My third guest is Dr. Ronan Carberry, Professor of HRM at University College Cork in Ireland, where he is Director of the Executive MBA program.

SPEAKER_00Ronan's research interests include platform work, algorithmic management, and learning and development. Ronan's contributions to HRD have been recognised by the Academy of Humorous Aur Development with the 2024 Outstanding HRD Scholar Award. Just visit allbypodcast.com forward slash developing to learn more about the bios of our three guests and also to connect with our episode sponsors. Today's episode is brought to you by the Programme Excellence Network of the Academy of Humorous Orse Development.

SPEAKER_00Are you committed to advancing excellence in HRD education? Discover the Programme Excellence Network or PEN, an exclusive initiative from the Academy that connects institutions and educators dedicated to building top-tier HRD academic programs. Penn offers a powerful annual meeting for networking, online searchable directory, case competitions, best practice sharing and professional development, all aimed at strengthening graduate and undergraduate HRD teaching.

SPEAKER_00With an individual membership in AHRD, the Penn Community membership is just$99 per year per institution. Unlocking access to a vibrant community where faculty collaborate, innovate and champion student success. Whether you're faculty members looking to expand your network or an institution seeking program recognition and continuous improvement, Penn is your gateway to excellence. Find out more and join Penn by visiting ahrd.org.

SPEAKER_00Right, let's dive into the episode. Hey Ryan, delighted to be joined today by Ronan, Brian, and Stephanie. Thank you all three of you for being with me today for such an important conversation. I was thinking about a good place to start, knowing that we're going to talk about preparing the next generation of HRD professionals. And I'm thinking maybe the right place to start is by considering how we see the work of those HRD professionals changing over the next 10, 15 years.

SPEAKER_00So, Ronan, would you be willing to kick start that conversation by sharing how you see the work of HRD professionals changing over that period? Sure.

SPEAKER_04Thanks, Darren. And I suppose I think I think we need to start with maybe an uncomfortable reality that a lot of people aren't addressing when it comes to looking at the next 10, 15 years for HRD professionals. And that's like how much specialized expertise is really needed when AI can produce so much relevant learning materials on demand. I think this isn't something that's idle speculation, it's actually happening right now. And it's driven by an economic logic that's quite straightforward. So if we look at content creation, that was a specialized skill that required instructional design expertise.

SPEAKER_04That can now be generated pretty much instantaneously by AI systems with minimal human input. AI powered platforms, they're automatically personalizing content for individuals, analyzing skill gaps, recommending development paths. And these are tasks that were previously done by human experts. So as organizations face economic pressures, the question becomes, in I suppose, increasingly pragmatic. Why would you maintain a full training and development or HRD department when AI tools can deliver personalized learning experiences at a fraction of the cost?

SPEAKER_04And what I find particularly concerning for the future of HRD is what I see is almost like a form of entry-level elimination effect. So we know that companies are posting 15% fewer internships this year than they were two years ago, with CEOs explicitly stating that they're reluctant to hire junior staff whose work AI can replicate. And then this kind of creates a pipeline crisis that I see because your traditional entry points into the profession, whether that's a learning coordinator or a junior instructional designer, they're disappearing.

SPEAKER_04So I think we're not just losing current jobs, but we're also losing the pathway for developing future H4 professionals too. And then I suppose at a higher level, there's also a strategic isolation risk that I think many practitioners don't really fully appreciate yet. So as AI is automating the day-to-day operational tasks that I mentioned, like content creation, tracking, maybe tracking learner progress, recommending those developmental paths, HOD professionals will often respond by emphasizing their strategic business partnership role.

SPEAKER_04But without a clear foundation in that specialized learning experience that AI cannot replicate, I think HOD risks maybe becoming untethered from its core purpose and value proposition. And this kind of connects to what I see as a real measurement paradox. AI provides more granular learning data than ever before, but proving causation between learning activities and business outcome still remains exceptionally difficult. And I think this leaves HRD vulnerable to critical questioning about return and investment, because AI learning platforms, they often promise direct business impact without the overhead of a full LD function or a full HRD function.

SPEAKER_04So the reality is that sophisticated AI systems may eventually demonstrate more convincing return and investment models than human-led LD or HRD initiatives potentially. But I do see a kind of a troubling quality metrics type of disconnect emerging. So we know if we look at some corporate learning analysts, the likes of some reports, recent reports from Deloitte and LinkedIn Workplace Learning Survey, they suggest that while AI-powered platforms increase content consumption metrics, they often fail then to deliver meaningful skill transfer or behavioral change, which are often some of the core measures of learning effectiveness that HOD professionals would be quite adept at.

SPEAKER_04And then this kind of creates a scenario where organizations maybe celebrate increased learning engagement metrics while actual performance improvement stagnates. So what does this mean for the profession? I think then that the those HOD professionals who remain will have to be far more senior and influential than today's practitioners. They need to be strategic partners who understand maybe both human psychology and AI capabilities. They're focused on kind of the uniquely human aspects of development that AI can't replicate.

SPEAKER_04And I think maybe without a serious self-examination of HRD's purpose and value, many HRD functions kind of risk finding themselves increasingly marginalized or worst-case scenario, eliminated entirely as AI continues its encroachment into various forms of knowledge work domains. And the organizations that honestly address these challenges, rather than just maybe assuming HRD's continuous relevance, is going to be really important. And they'll be best positioned to kind of redefine what a HRD function will look like in 10, 15 years.

SPEAKER_04But that does require us to actually reflect on those fundamental questions. What aspects of learning facilitation genuinely require human expertise that can't be replicated by sophisticated AI systems? And how can HRD then develop capabilities that complement rather than competing with AI systems? So that's just some of the kind of pressing issues that I kind of see today. But I'm happy to hand over to Stephanie and Brian to see what they think.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, uh thank you for for that. Um you mentioned a lot. Um I I think with AI, you know, there's definitely an appreciation for it. There's, you know, obviously there's uh a convincing use for it, but as learning specialists, as those um grounded in development, you know, we know that learning is a socialization process. And so, I mean, there's the individualized attention you can get from AI, but we know development doesn't come without the us coming together and and learning from one another.

SPEAKER_02Um and you know, whether that's through uh the sharing of stories, testimonies, getting feedback, direct live on the spot, feedback from your colleagues, um, just the reinforcement uh that we look for um just naturally as humans. And so although we may get direction from uh AI, um, you know, we're we're always seeking that, but it there's still a lot of gaps that um it just can't compete with, being that it is a human entity.

SPEAKER_02And so we we still need our coaches, we still need our trainers, we still need our evaluators, um, because that's critical to learning and development. And so, you know, when I think of something like, for example, leadership development, you know, that's that's not going to be effective through AI. Um, that comes with um, again, that personable um on-demand type of facilitation of learning.

SPEAKER_03Thank you, Stephanie. You you and I are thinking kind of in a similar manner. Darren, I'll I'll I'll refresh your memory from your conversation with Toby Egan on organization development uh in this podcast series, and he talked about the diagnostic and the dialogic, right? So the so AI does a can do a great job at the diagnostic, right? It can go out there and find all sorts of really great information, best practices, all those kinds of things, but we still need to hear the voices of the stakeholders.

SPEAKER_03And so I'll I'll I'll I'll try and provide an example, and hopefully this makes sense. Let's say we're doing a job in task analysis. So obviously, AI can grab large amounts of data to tell us about the particular job that we're looking at. So let's say it's a maintenance employee. We're looking at a maintenance employee, let's do a job in task analysis of that. Well, the diagnostic part will be great, but AI will not include the unique contextual influences of different organizations where those maintenance employees are working.

SPEAKER_03So let's say you're looking at a maintenance employee working at a pickle factory in Green Bay, Wisconsin versus a maintenance employee working at Abbott Laboratories in North Chicago, Illinois. Those contexts are very different. And so we're gonna need, we're still gonna need HRD professionals to uh be able to talk to those stakeholders and have the voices of those stakeholders be heard. Um, I know Stephanie and I are kind of on the same page when we talk about uh participative and collaborative inquiry.

SPEAKER_03So we want to think about um the there's complex dynamics going on with these organizations that we can't understand without the participation of the actors within those organizations. And so while I agree with everything that Ronan is saying, I'm I'm gonna be an optimist, which is hopefully hopefully most of us are gonna be optimists, that there's still gonna be need for the HRD professional, whether that's whether it's a practitioner or a scholar, to be there to um hear the voices and include the voices of the stakeholders when we're trying to diagnose and solve organizational problems.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, yeah. And I just want to uh follow up on that. You said some something that um hit a nerf there uh in terms of maintenance and in context, you know, AI still needs maintenance, it still needs monitoring, it still needs evaluation, um, which means that HRD still needs to be very much in tune with organizational culture. And and you know, our our positionality has always been in sort of a uh unique place where we're the middlemen in in terms of having a good sense of its organizational members and also responding to the needs of the organizational leaders.

SPEAKER_02And so we have a good vantage point to be able to deliver on on the maintenance and monitoring and evaluation of AI. And so we're like like Brian, um, I'm optimistic that we still will play a role. Um, we maybe still need to tease that out. Um, but I you know I I don't see us being fully replaced um by AI.

SPEAKER_04Yeah, and I suppose I don't want to come across as overly overly pessimistic here. Um, but I think what kind of has underpinned some of my ideas that I outlined is um so this was a report published last year, for example, that found that chief financial officers were more likely to invest in AI software rather than employees, because software is an asset that can depreciate it or paid off over time. Whereas learning and development or other investments in employees, they're deemed to be kind of current expenses that must be paid off completely in the year that they're that they're utilized.

SPEAKER_04And like some of the other things that we've seen, so there's one of the largest social media um platforms in the world was recently found 513 million euro by the Irish Data Protection Commission. And what they did in response to that was that they have laid off the entirety of their learning and development team in Europe, Middle East, and Africa. Another company that employs over, I think it's about 110,000 people worldwide. They have completely reorganized the structure of their HR function to the extent that they now only have eight HOR business partners globally uh across multiple countries.

SPEAKER_04And it just seems to me that with the advent of AI, the first thing that's on the chopping block when it comes to budget is seem to me learning and development or HRD activities. Uh so I am I suppose that's what's driving a lot of my concerns rather than pessimisms.

SPEAKER_00Each of you have talked there about where AI can essentially do the more basic stuff and can do it probably faster, cheaper. But it's that basic stuff where most HRD professionals come into the profession and learn the foundations. I suppose if we follow that logic, HRD professionals are starting to come into the profession at a higher position in the ladder, and when they come in at that higher position, they presumably don't have the foundational experience that people at that point in the ladder currently have.

SPEAKER_00Am I thinking about that right based on what the three of you uh have been saying?

SPEAKER_02No, that sounds completely on point. And you when we think about AI, we we naturally think about these high-earning enterprises. And you know, AI does seem like highly accessible, but will everyone have the access to software that would be able to do the work that I guess is more uh efficient and individualized? Or will there be these these mid-level organizations, these nonprofit organizations where there'll be a huge disparity will where you know they won't have access to that.

SPEAKER_02And I'm I'm thinking, is you know, is that an opportunity for HRD to find itself in in new spaces dealing with new clientele, time will tell of who will fully embrace AI, but that is is something um that does seem quite problematic.

SPEAKER_03From my context, I uh we teach we have an undergraduate HRD program. And so what we've been um encouraging our students to also take management classes to become a little bit more broader based in experience. So when we talk about the term HR generalist, right, if you look at some of the the postings for an HR generalist, they want people that can do benefits and um insurance, but also maybe do a little bit of a training and a little bit of evaluation. And so what we've been trying to do for at least our undergrads and our master's level students is encourage them to um take classes in these different areas so they can develop a broader set of skills so they can slot into a role and fill a lot of different functions for an organization.

SPEAKER_03And I agree with you 100%, Stephanie. There's an equity issue when we call when we're talking about small to medium-sized uh enterprises and whether or not they have the the financial wherewithal to be able to afford these higher level AI systems. And um, you know, my father was uh uh was an entrepreneur, had his own independent business, a two or three-person organization. If he were to open his business today, I don't think he would be able to have the ability to afford some of these AI systems that other organizations have.

SPEAKER_03And and would he be at a competitive disadvantage because of that?

SPEAKER_00I wonder if this is a good point to start thinking about what all of this means in terms of knowledge and skills. So if this is the sort of the landscape of how the profession is starting to change over the next 10, 15 years, um, I'm wondering what this means in terms of the skills and knowledge that HRD professionals will need to be successful in that landscape. Brian, what what are your thoughts about what this means in terms of skills and knowledge?

SPEAKER_03I think we're heading towards a greater emphasis on interdisciplinary knowledge and skills. One of the things that I've always really loved about HRD is it can mean a lot of different things to different people. We could have different sources of emphasis, right? We have different scholars in our organization that look at one particular part of HRD. And I see that we can now have greater opportunities to explore other areas that are in connection to HRD.

SPEAKER_03So one of the things I've really been excited about with your podcast series, Darren, is that you've been connecting HRD to areas that maybe we wouldn't have thought about a connection five or 10 years ago. So um, you know, you've had episodes on spirituality and politics and psychology and philosophy. Let's think about that. Would we have really thought about spirituality and HRD 10 years ago? I I don't know if we would have. And and so I'll I'll I'll bring it back to you, Darren. You and I and and Gene Roth started talking about HRD and humor many years ago.

SPEAKER_03And everyone kind of looked at us with kind of a raised eyebrow. Like, what does the humor have to do with HRD? And so today I don't think we would have that kind of same um level of circumspect. And so I think that HRD scholars and practitioners are now going to have greater opportunity to look. Look at a wide range of the work life experience and how it connects to HRD. So one of the things that, again, you know, I'm very interested in humor, but I've really after listening to your podcast on HRD and spirituality, I really started thinking about that.

SPEAKER_03And I started thinking about religious and civic pluralism. And, you know, uh, I've done some research on the experience of Muslims who wear the hijab in organizations. And, you know, that's a very over expression of their faith. And with that comes challenges in various organizations. And so I see religious pluralism as a way to overcome some of those challenges and make connections with others that have different religious and political and social identities.

SPEAKER_03And so uh I think what HRD scholars now are going to have this great opportunity to look at things that maybe have been in the back of their head and have been afraid to, but now we're going to have the freedom to do that because um of the fact that we can now look at the entirety of the work experience.

SPEAKER_04I might come in there just on that. I love the idea of the kind of interdisciplinary expansion that Brian spoke about. Uh, but I'm gonna come at it from maybe a different angle. So I've spent a lot been researching platform labor and gig work for the last number of years. And about a third of US workers are engaged in some form of gig work. Uh but as of the time of recording, journals like H4DOR, HRDQ have never published anything on gig work. They've never published anything on platform labor. There's a recent paper in H4DOR on algorithmic management earlier this year.

SPEAKER_04And these workers are subject to what I call a form of algorithmic precarity. So this is a really distinct form of labor control that extends beyond employment insecurity to encompass real technological dependence and psychological vulnerability and social fragmentation. And then I think in this particular form of work, where HOD professionals are providing services to these large platforms, they're operating in contexts where traditional frameworks are really structurally inadequate.

SPEAKER_04And we're seeing this isn't just a new field to explore, but it I think it really fundamentally changes how work is controlled and how work is organized. And in terms of the skills then that are required for that, they're the so what's what I see as fundamental is digital literacy, not just technological competence, but the ability to understand and critique the socio-political dimensions of algorithmic control. So HOD professionals need to be fluent in data literacy while also maintaining their expertise in human psychology and organizational dynamics.

SPEAKER_04And that kind of interdisciplinary knowledge that Brian touched on, uh, I think is also really important in addressing power structures at work. So when we look at this kind of platform-mediated labor, our traditional HOD employability frameworks, they collapse when it's algorithmic systems that are determining employment outcomes through opaque criteria. So I think KOD professionals need to understand how economic systems change work, how power operates in these organizations, and how management control has really evolved in digital contexts.

SPEAKER_04They also need to understand why workers might resist certain technological implementations and how maybe collective action or resistance emerges in response to algorithmic management. And I don't come up as overly pessimistic now on this podcast, but I think many traditional HRD competencies are at risk of becoming commoditized. And those who survive or those who thrive over the next 10 years or so, they need capabilities that are genuinely irreplaceable. So complex stakeholder management.

SPEAKER_04And I love the idea that Brian said they're teaching their HRD undergrads management classes as well. So ethical decision making in technological context and the ability to facilitate democratic kind of participation in shaping the systems, the technological systems that govern work.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, I I agree with you know all that's been said in um, you know, I when when we think about these new interests, you know, I think it it it comes from who we are as a community. Uh at least when we are in person, uh on the ground, uh, you know, at a conference, we are looking different. And so, you know, there's there's more students becoming aware of what HRD is in education in general.

SPEAKER_02You know, there's more first generation students. And so, you know, they're not just invested in, you know, the traditional knowledge work, they're looking at things like the gig economy, um, as you know, people who are in their direct network might be more inclined to work in those you know type of industries. And so um, they're looking to solve problems that can help them and their people. And so, you know, when we think about things like spirituality, those things um when we think of people of color, first generation students, you know, they're they're thinking from their lived experience, their background, how they've been taught.

SPEAKER_02And so to me, there it's no surprise that these things are making their way into our our focus. And so um in terms of spirituality, I think things like um what was all what was mentioned already, I think I heard some some civic stuff. And so, like civic development and and workplace learning, you know, that's us getting back to our roots uh when we think about adult education. Um, and so I I appreciate this this shift that we're experiencing in the the humanistic aspects that are needed to drive some of these new directions um as it relates to you know things like public policy and in community development.

SPEAKER_02And so I think those are the things that we are we can anticipate seeing as we continue to be more diverse in who we are, the social identities that we represent, um, and the the interests that come along with uh being a community of of diverse people.

SPEAKER_00It's fascinating to think think about this. Like I I um one of the benefits I have of uh like facilitating the conversation is I get a chance to sort of sit back and and and listen and and reflect as the three of you talk. And it's um it it it takes me to a place of thinking about how much of what HRD professionals have typically learned early in their career and learned in depth because they needed to be able to go and do it, transfers to something that they need to possibly learn in less depth because they need to know it because they need to know basically what AI is doing in the background, which frees up the space for them to then learn in the areas that you're talking about.

SPEAKER_00Which feels like it's a challenge for how we design programs that prepare HRD professionals. So what do you think all of this means then for the folks who are designing and running um educational programs for HRD professionals? Like degree programs being an example of this, as then how do you see degree programs for HRD changing over the next five, ten years to reflect the direction you've just been talking about?

SPEAKER_00Ste Stephanie, what's what's your thinking on that?

SPEAKER_02As I think about what HRD programs should be doing to respond to these things, you know, as Brian was was mentioning about us being so interdisciplinary, you know, that's always going to work in our favor. Because I think that is the space to find your fit. But that also puts responsibility on the program, on the department, on the college, on the advisors to have a greater awareness of what the individual needs are, the different needs are.

SPEAKER_02We can't just rely on the traditional buckets of org development, career development, TND. People are bringing in their own spin on those things. And that's okay. I mean, we're already in a place where the parameters are just, they're not there. You know, we're expansive in our reach, which is also a good thing. But we also need to have a better handle on who's doing what. Like, what is the landscape of HRD? Are we growing in our representation in terms of our programs or our programs closing?

SPEAKER_02Like, who who knows this? You know, there's still a lot of ground to cover, even though we cover so much in terms of subject matter. Um, you know, we we still are disguised as other things, you know, organizational psychology, talent development. We still are in the process of trying to be more distinct in who we are. And I feel like that will, you know, address some of the things that we've talked about earlier about us um dealing with our placement, our positionality, our responsibility as it relates to things like AI.

SPEAKER_02And so we just need to have a better grasp on who we are, where we what we want to be. And so I think with that comes a greater responsibility in the evaluation of ourself.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, I agree with uh much of what Stephanie has to say, but I'm gonna I'm gonna add a little bit of a twist. Um, Matthew Horah up at the University of Wisconsin uh has been working on teaching transferable skills in college courses. So, what are some of the universal skills that employers want? So, how do we integrate subject matter expertise, but also teaching these transferable skills that are that are universal?

SPEAKER_03So uh the National Association of Colleges and Employers defines eight core competencies that most employers uh really value. So, career and self-development, communication, critical thinking, equity and inclusion, leadership, professionalism, teamwork, and technology. And and I'll gonna I'm gonna add two more. I'm gonna add self-directed and lifelong learning. So so we can think about embedding these kinds of things in our classes.

SPEAKER_03So there's a couple of ways we can we can do this. And so um, you know, many of us that teach, we have our students uh in group or team projects, which is always a good thing. But instead of assigning um these students at random, maybe take a survey at the beginning of the class and think about which topics within that particular class that students are interested in, and then putting those students that have a common interest together and putting them in a team so they can explore that topic together.

SPEAKER_03We can think about uh a lot of self-assessment. How can we have students self-assess themselves, such as like how how how good a note taker have I been? How much of an active participation uh have I displayed? Um, and then at the semesters end, they can think about talking about their where they've struggled and then where they can improve upon. Um, I also think about connecting uh course learning objectives to career competencies, right? So have students try and clearly articulate what they've learned and what competencies have they developed as a result of that learning, because then they can explain that to their, to they can put that in their resume, they can talk about that in their job interview, as opposed to, well, I learned this.

SPEAKER_03You can now say, I can do this, right? There's a difference between I learned this, but can I do it? And then I also think about assignments where it's not only develop just demonstrating subject matter expertise, but it's also thinking about maybe having develop a skill in addition to that. So one of the assignments I give my undergrads all the time is uh is an infographic, right? So now all of a sudden so now all of a sudden they're they're demonstrating what they know about the particular topic, but they're also using some sort of technology, um, you know, whether it's you know Canva or any kind of other graphic design technology.

SPEAKER_03So now they're integrating subject matter expertise into some and and practicing it using a different skill. So I think about all these kinds of things, how we can we can develop these transferable and very, very welcome skills um in our curriculum in addition to developing subject matter expertise.

SPEAKER_04I might just take what Stephanie and Brian have said, uh, because I fully agree with what they've said, but I'm just gonna maybe add just one more thing. Um in addition to like I've kind of outlined, I think this profession is undergoing fundamental transformation. Um, and just and this is an element of recency bias here because it's a paper that I'm working on with some colleagues, and we've been doing some meta-analytical research on training effectiveness, which kind of I think reveals some important insights about actually what works when it comes to H or D.

SPEAKER_04But it also exposes the maybe shaky foundations of traditional business case arguments, which claim that training investments deliver significant long-term value to organizations. So, when we examined the evidence, now we could only find 13 studies that provided plausible evidence regarding the long-term impact of organizational training on performance. And I suppose what's concerning about that, the majority of those studies had uh quite significant methodological problems, and most only investigated static relationships without considering past performance levels.

SPEAKER_04Um, and then when other researchers have controlled for past performance, the positive effects of training on future performance either reduced dramatically or disappeared entirely. So the evidence base that underpins billions of dollars been invested in training is probably far weaker than most people realize. Uh, one of the things that we did find was that quality of training matters more than quantity, and there's a specific sequential relationship between ability and motivation that's fundamental for organizational performance. So I think really we need to be teaching students this kind of rigorous, evidence-based, foundational concepts first.

SPEAKER_04And they need theoretical frameworks then that help them understand structural challenges regarding was it the digital increased digitalization of work that I spoke about when work has been mediated by technological systems. I think programs maybe need to integrate more critical theoretical perspectives alongside traditional approaches to learning design and so on. And in the context of how AI is encroaching on HOD, teach them to be critical evaluators of technology while grounding them in solid evidence about human development.

SPEAKER_04Because I think ultimately they need to understand but the empirical evidence about what works in human development and then maybe the structural conditions that make the traditional approaches that we've been teaching for 10, 20 years, that makes those obsolete. I think that will allow them to be both evidence-based practitioners and also critical analysts of the systems that they will be working with.

SPEAKER_00Um and an attitude. What I'm not sure folks have got much in the past has been experience. So they come out of a program with a lot of knowledge and a lot of attitude, but not a bucket load of experience that uh an organization would look at and say that seems relevant to us.

SPEAKER_00As in the organization's hiring them because of the knowledge, they're hiring them because maybe of the attitude. And yet, when I think about what the three of you were talking about earlier, and almost the removal of the lower rungs of the ladder, which is where the people are gaining that experience at the moment, we're almost trying to develop people in degree programs to come in at a much higher level, a much higher level of the ladder. Do you think there's anything that degree programs could be doing to replace some of the lost experience or any way that you that experience could be integrated more into degree programs to give HRD professionals a way of practicing so that they can turn up at a job and say, I not only do I know it, I've also got evidence that I've been able to do it.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, I I there are a number of schools that are that are doing portfolios now as kind of cumulating uh cumulative or capstone projects. So I I think that that's something that that we should really be emphasizing, uh, where a student can can take the feedback that she or he have been given over the course of their program, uh, improve the various projects that they've done, whether it be in a needs assessment or an evaluation or an instructional design document, and then put that all together in a portfolio and be able to say, here, this is what I can, this is what I can do, this is how I can do it.

SPEAKER_03Uh, I know that uh that's something that uh we're gonna be changing our capstone for our master's program from a comprehensive exam to a portfolio uh over the next year or so, uh, in order to do exactly what you said, Darren, to be able to demonstrate this is what I can do, uh, and this is how I can help your organization.

SPEAKER_04I think given that that disappearance of the entry-level roles we discussed uh as educators, that we can't focus on just preparing students for this traditional apprenticeship pathway that is no longer there. So, how do you prepare graduates then who can immediately operate maybe at a more strategic level? So I think then that means rather than just maybe bringing in a single management module here and there, HOD programs need to become more interdisciplinary from the start. So rather than focusing primarily on just maybe learning theory and instructional design, focus and developing graduates who can bridge different domains.

SPEAKER_04So combining organizational psychology with data analysis, integrating change management skills with critical evaluation of technological implementations. So, because I think these, as you've spoken about, these graduates, if they're not going to have the luxury of learning the business through junior roles, ultimately they will need to arrive with some form of or some form of knowledge of cross-functional capabilities that will allow them to articulate the strategic value that they can add whilst they learn specific H or D type methodologies as well.

SPEAKER_04So ultimately, I think we're looking at a like when I look at an Irish or European perspective, that would require completely rethinking our curriculum design.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, yeah. Um Darren, I really do appreciate that that comment about you know the experience. Where are you supposed to get this? Um, you know, there's always going to be a need for the the knowledge set that we have. Um and it may not um we may not always have access to the place where we want to um you know share that knowledge, get paid to to uh utilize that. Uh but in our communities, there's always a need to help our our our fellow um community members, um, our people learn.

SPEAKER_02Um you know, there's a lot of community organizations, community-based organizations, NGOs, um, even just people doing policy work that could benefit from even what our undergraduates, you know, leave uh college with, you know, they they have this framework, this mindset, this perspective that they they learn through HRD. And you know, when people come together, essentially they're organizing for you know a shared uh mission, meaning, um, objective.

SPEAKER_02And so I, you know, the skill set that we have um can grant them access um to those types of organizations, which again are always in need of help, support. Um, and and there are people in those uh situations where there's a lot of history and experience. There that you know social movement leaders, community leaders are willing to share with people who are willing to provide some sort of um uh participation uh to help things move along.

SPEAKER_02And so, you know, we I don't know if it makes sense to stay in this place of being so high-end all the time when again there is a human need for the skills that that we have. And when I think of uh you know things like internships and and so forth, you know, we we should allow our students to um participate in those things as if they choose to, as opposed to always thinking about for-profit um enterprises.

SPEAKER_02And so uh I just I feel uh again, I'll I'll repeat what I said before as we see more people of color, more first generation um students uh going through our educational programs, whether that's in the school of education, technology, business management, wherever they find themselves, uh we're in all these different places, um, we're going to continue to do the work of the people. And so we're we're we're we need to be ready for that as uh people in the classroom, as educators, and also mentors as we are advising these people, where we may not have that direct experience, but we need to grant permission for other people uh again to find their fit.

SPEAKER_00It's in it's interesting to think of it that way. It makes me think that there's always been a significant difference between what it looks like to be in a global multinational organization of like tens of thousands of employees versus, let's say, a small nonprofit. Um, but it makes me feel as if the difference between those two things is uh getting wider and wider as a result, for example, of AI. Which may mean for the next five, ten years, we're trying to prepare different types of HRD professionals, some of which may end up finding themselves in a global organization where they are gonna they need to be multidisciplinary, they're gonna go in high a higher level.

SPEAKER_00At the same time, we also need to make sure that we're preparing some folks to go in working at smaller, you know, small medium enterprises where that isn't the reality. So I wonder whether we're actually going into a period where we need to make sure that we don't that that we're kind of trying to support everybody for whatever career path they are going into.

SPEAKER_04I think one of the things that probably hasn't been really fully realized when it comes to AI use at work. So the number of organizations that report that they've officially incorporated, say, for example, enterprise AI solutions into their HR system is really low. It's about 25%. Uh but the number of HR and HRD professionals who are bringing their own AI tools to work on a daily basis suggests that the figure is much, much higher. So, for example, you've got this isn't just HRD specific, but some of the research that I've done shows that HR professionals are using Chat GPT to write job descriptions.

SPEAKER_04They're using Google Gemini, their own profile, uh Google Gemini accounts to write learning and development strategies. They're using Microsoft Copilot to screen CVs without without approval from the organizations itself. And then on the other side of the coin, you've got job applicants also using AI extensively to write cover letters, tailor CV to job descriptions. So we have this situation where job descriptions, person specifications have been crafted by AI, and candidates are then using the same AI systems to write cover letters and CVs to match these roles.

SPEAKER_04So um, like Roman's at the point in in some aspects of HR, though if we're taking the human out of HR, uh what are we what are we actually left with?

SPEAKER_02Wow. I uh I love that whole interplay that you just described. That's bizarre. Wow. But it's it's it's happening. That's that's the reality.

SPEAKER_00It is, and it it's one of those questions that I think like you know, at this point I can see listeners pressing the pause button and thinking, I need to think about this a little. Like I'm I'm conscious we've been talking now for an hour, and I realize the more we talk, the more questions I've got. Um, like I've I've got answers to some of the questions that I had when I came in, and I I now have a whole new batch of questions. I I I feel as if um what Ronan just talked us through there is probably a good way of of wrapping up the episode and giving people stuff to think about.

SPEAKER_00Um and I also am hoping that the four of us are gonna be able to get back together again so that we can revisit all of this and just see how some of this is landing in practice and then revisit some of what we've what we've just said. So I did want to thank all three of you for the your time today. Thank you so much for being willing to be a part of the episode and for feeding in your all of your thoughts and ideas, and I really hope we have a chance to get back together and continue this conversation in a future season.

SPEAKER_03Thank you. Thank you, Darren, thank you, Stephanie, thank you, Ronan. Yeah, thanks everyone. Really enjoyed it.

SPEAKER_02Yes, thank you so much for bringing us together. This was such a delight, and I'm gonna go to the city.

SPEAKER_00If you enjoyed this episode, check out our other 50, which contain conversations with over 100 leading scholars from around the world. To learn more about the series, check out HRDmasterclass.com and to learn about the Academy of HRD, check out ahrd.org. Also, please check out our episode sponsors, the Programme Excellence Network, an exclusive initiative from the Academy of Human Resource Development, that connects institutions and educators dedicated to building top-tier HRD academic programmes.

SPEAKER_00To find out all about it, check out ahrd.org. I'll be back next week with an episode focused on how HRD can respond to the current DEIB challenges, and I'll be joined by Nicole Dillard, Jeremy Bahonos, and Kira McFadden. Until then, stay safe. This is Darren Short signing off from the HRD Masterclass.com.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Gendered pathways to work-family balance

    Nov 17, 202634 minAudio

    This fourth episode of Season 6 brings together Dr. Sanghamitra Chaudhuri (Temple University) and Dr. Kyung Nam Kim (Texas A&M University) for a conversation about the 2026 article Gendered Pathways to Work-Family...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Navigating careers in non-traditional work

    Nov 10, 202636 minAudio

    This third episode of Season 6 brings together Dr. Yuanlu Niu (University of Arkansas) and Dr. Jos Akkermans (Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam) for a conversation about the 2026 article Navigating careers in non-traditional...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Silence in the workplace: What do we know from research?

    Nov 2, 202634 minAudio

    This second episode of Season 6 brings together Dr. Matthew Hurtienne (University of Texas at Tyler) and Dr. Heesun Kim (Francis Marion University) for a conversation about the 2024 article Silence in the workplace:...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Diversified mentoring: Living at the intersections of race and gender

    Oct 27, 202634 minAudio

    This first episode of Season 6 brings together Dr. Joshua Collins (University of Minnesota) and Dr. Ague Mae Manongsong (Louisiana State University) for a conversation about the 2023 article “Manongsong, A. M., & Ghosh,...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Season 6 Trailer

    Oct 12, 20262 minAudio

    Welcome to the trailer for Season 6 of Human Resource Development Masterclass - the podcast series from the Academy of Human Resource Development, the organization that leads HRD through research. The sixth season...

    Credit the people on this episode