Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

HOW Conversations

HOW Conversations artwork

Dr. David Agus, Professor, USC [Part 1]

Aug 11, 202517 minAudio

[Archive Interview from Jul 6, 2021] Dr. David Agus believes leaders have a moral responsibility to be transparent and accurate, especially during a pandemic, “We saw people just talking and not thinking of the ramifications of their words and of their actions. There weren't people stepping up to really normalize the right ideas, the right behavior and it became more about a belief system than data.” He sat down with Founder and Executive Chairman of the HOW Institute, Dov Seidman, where the two discussed frameworks for values-based decision making, battling misinformation in science and adapting under pressure. Dr. David Agus specializes in treating cancer and is a researcher at the Ellison Institute at the University of Southern California. He is also a regular contributor to CBS News and has spent much of the past year answering questions about COVID-19 and vaccines on TV and social media. READY TO START YOUR MORAL LEADERSHIP JOURNEY? Moral leadership is more imperative today than ever before. The HOW Institute for Society was founded on the belief that those in positions of formal authority should also have moral authority. We are creating the tools leaders need to make principled, ethical and values-based decisions. We are a nonprofit organization dedicated to building a world rooted in deep human values and trust in our social fabric. The Institute channels philosophical reasoning to address modern problems. Today, HOW we do what we do matters more than ever and in ways it never has before. Learn more at https://thehowinstitute.org/

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

IntroductionWelcome to the How Institute for Society's podcast, HOW Conversations where we talk with courageous and authentic leaders about how we can build and nurture a culture of moral leadership throughout society. What does it mean to be a moral leader today who has moral authority in our society? What should we expect of our leaders during a crisis, and what are the moral leadership frameworks our leaders are using to navigate through these challenging times? These are just some of the nuanced questions our hosts cover in their discussions with CEOs, military generals, educators, philanthropists and other leaders about the importance of moral and ethical decision making. And now here's the HOW Institute for Society, founder and chairman and the host for today's podcast, Dov Seidman.

Dov SeidmanWelcome Dr. David Agus to our latest HOW Conversation. Personally, it's just special and a pleasure to be in conversation with you. I want to start by saying that we are close and dear friends, and I cherish our friendship. I've learned a lot from you, and professionally, I respect you. Your bio is well known, but I will recite some of it. Dr Agus is currently the professor of medicine and engineering at the University of Southern California. You've authored not one, not two, but three, New York Times bestsellers. You're also the founder and CEO of the Lawrence J Ellison Institute for Transformative Medicine at USC.

Dr. David AgusThank you, Dov. I mean, it's truly a pleasure to be here. And I mean, the one part of my bio, I think you did mention, is that you've had a significant influence on me. You know, our conversations, you've helped me dramatically in how to frame issues. I may know the science, but it's not just the science that gets things done, just how you frame it and how you present it. I keep using that word how, and I'm sorry about that, but our conversations have dramatically influenced whether it's writing a piece in The New York Times, or whether it's giving a talk or trying to enact the behavior change and the normative change that we need in healthcare.

Dov SeidmanThat's, again, that's kind of you to say. But where did it begin? Your your journey of, obviously, of exquisite excellence in science and medicine? But deep down, there's a heart. Deep down, you've been on a journey of moral leadership. What is that rooted in? Where did it start? Share some of your family history. I know it, but I think our listeners would love to understand it as well as I do.

Dr. David AgusYou know, I came from two parts, right? I mean, there's the old expression that in order to understand peace, you have to go to war. And on a daily basis, I sit face to face with patients with advanced cancer, and I see the desperation in their eye. And so there's really a striving on my part, and a realization of my weakness. And the weakness of our system is we can't cure advanced cancer. We could potentially lessen some of the symptoms make you live a little bit longer, but that's about it, whereas we're pretty good on the prevention side. And so it really was a passion is, I don't want to experience failure more.

Dr. David AgusI want to prevent and it's pushing that direction. And then, you know, listen, I grew up in a in a household where I was taken under the wing of my grandfather, who was a well known rabbi and philosopher, and he had wrote books about religion changing with the times that were considered heretical at the time. And he was actually, you know, pushed out of many communities and pushed almost excommunication because of what he wrote, but he had a firm belief in moving forward and using the change in our times to change some of the normative behaviors within religion, and I respected him.

Dov SeidmanSo David, in terms of where we find you today, you've been in the thicket and at the front lines of fighting the pandemic, of just trying to help us not have as much harm as we were having, but also find, you know, pathways to emerge. So where are you today, when we are starting to emerge from a pandemic to post pandemic world? What have you figured out? What do you want to leave behind? What do you want to take with us? What do you want to what are you in the midst of redesigning?

Dr. David AgusI mean, you know, in my field, we have exactly that. We have the reflex, and we have the pause, right? Much of the actions in the healthcare spaces, reflex, this happens, do this, and we don't pause enough, you know, in one of my exam rooms, and you've yet to be to our new building, and it really is special. But I have a photo of a sculpture from Italy, and this is a sculpture of a man named Edward Jenner who is vaccinating his son. And where it came from is that Jenner saw women milk the cows in England in the early 1800s and back then, smallpox was killing off 11% of the world population, and he would notice pucks on their arms, and they wouldn't die and they. The only ones who taking care of people with smallpox without dying. So he goes to the King of England, I want to stick a needle in, draw a puss out of their arm, and I want to inject other people. And the king says, Get the hell out of here. And he goes, I'll eject myself. And he says, Every scientist says that.

Dr. David AgusAnd he kicked him out. That night, the King had a dream. He says, The King Solomon experiment, where two women went to the king and said, Hey, this is my baby. And King Solomon said, I'm going to rip the baby in half. And the real mother said, you take the baby. And he thought, listen, I have to think of something to do that with this vaccine. He calls Jenner back and says, you have one child who's five years old. And I know how difficult it was for you to have children, especially in the smallpox era. If you inject your child, I know you believe. And this is a sculpture of Jenner injecting his child. This was the first vaccine, and I had actually written the Italian government several years ago say, I want to make a copy of it, because it's so meaningful to me. It's meaningful me, not that it's the first vaccine, historic milestone, but science can be done, and is done by great scientists around the world. And most of the time, nobody hears it or listens to it. But in this case, the King of England was the second to receive the vaccine. The royal family were numbers two through 11, so that leadership is what enabled vaccines to be normalized across the globe. For the first time in the world, the world saw the sausage being made in our field, and we saw people just talking and not thinking of the ramifications of their words and of their actions. And there weren't people stepping up to really normalize the right ideas the right behavior. And it became more about a belief system than data. And we have to go back.

Dov SeidmanSo the world needs to turn to people like you who are schooled in science and the scientific method and have an have an approach to figuring out efficacy. So at the same time where the world needs to turn to experts and those with scientific backgrounds, it's at the same time that they've been attacked and discredited, at least by one side or the other, how do you lead as a scientist and as a medical professional when your profession, in many ways, is fighting misinformation about it at the same time,

Dr. David AgusIt was interesting. You know, I learned a lot of that from you in many respects. And I hate to keep being differential to you, it's more it's better for the audience if we argue and beat up each other. But I was in my backyard talking on the cell phone to you, and you've told me about, you know, the way in America we really stop smoking is the second hand smoke argument. And it really was a powerful argument to me, is that, you know, I could argue all we want about the data and efficacy of vaccines, but if I say, hey, listen, you know, by choosing not to get a vaccine, you can harm your neighbor, your grandmother and others, that secondhand smoke argument, it's not what it does to you. You have every right in the world to smoke in your bedroom, but you don't have a right to smoke in front of a child at a restaurant on a plane, because you can harm others. That argument, you know, started to make sense to me, and really, you know, you kill many people.

Dov SeidmanYeah, if you want to kill yourself, it's fine. But when we stig... smoking became socially stigmatized when we started to learn how secondhand smoke kills the other. And I see that you've been making an analogy to that.

Dr. David AgusSo I want to it's deeper, right? It's that I need to learn from history. I need to look at that the King of England and what he did, what you talked about in the second hand smoke. I need to talk to philosopher. I can't stay in my lane. In order to, you know, to influence people, I have to learn from others and use that collective learning to influence people, because every day sooner, I can do it, we can save a lot of lives.

Dov SeidmanNow, when the pandemic just started to encircle engulf the world, we didn't have all the data. We didn't really know about the efficacy of masks. So how do you lead in a crisis when the data is not in and people still are feeling vulnerable, they're turning for guidance. You have to give guidance. You're a scientist. You know that you could be more reliable and confident when you have data, and I know that you're obsessed with data, but when the pandemic happened, we didn't have all the data that we needed around masks and around ventilators and etc. So how do you lead when the data is not in

Dr. David AgusIt's very interesting. You know, to me, it's about two things. One is networking, right? Is that I need to run my ideas by equivalent medical leaders and healthcare leaders of different countries and around the globe. We have to make each other better, and we have to learn from each other. Hey, I just went on air and I said this, and I said this, and people just reacted negatively, and so we helped each other. It's the first time in my life, you know, through the power of Zoom, where we're talking on right now, through the power of Zoom, I would have calls with researchers in Oxford, in France, in China, in India, literally, on a daily basis. And we would learn from each other and help each other. Run ideas by each other, run observations by each other. That power of collaboration is what got all of us through it and enabled us to make some declaratory changes, and then it really was just keeping our blinders on and, you know, making, you know, explaining when you tell someone what to do, their shoulders go up when you explain to them the data you. They almost always do the right thing. And when you explain to someone, listen, I don't have data on the role of masks yet, but my gut is x, y, z, and here's why people actually change and do things.

Dov SeidmanIt seems that the data is in vaccines work, and yet we're not exactly where we want to be in terms of vaccination rates. And here's the conundrum, I think you and I both know that to truly scale and to enter the hearts of others, we should inspire them to change behavior or to be normative in the ways you talk about, how do you choose between or assimilate or harmonize the attraction of mandates when the data is in, because you believe you've got the science now, say on vaccines. So why not mandate you're right, and knowing deep down that inspiration is preferable.

Dr. David AgusIt's very interesting. You know, I get to cheat, right? I shouldn't say this publicly, but, you know, I know data many times, months to longer before it's public, and it's very frustrating when you know the answer yet you can't publicly state it. So I spent a good fraction of my time pushing academics, pushing governments to release data so we can get it out there right. Careerism stands in the way. I spent my career building this data set. I need to publish it in the New England Journal of Medicine so I could be promoted. How dare you take away my promotion for the public benefit? And this is the arguments that I face daily.

Dr. David AgusBecause I know right. If I could start to tell a story and have data behind it, I know I can influence a lot of lives. If I get up there and just say, hey, I really think vaccines are going to work. Trust me, nobody's going to respond in the way I want them to respond. And so part of my job behind the scenes is really ugly and dirty. It's really pushing people to get that data out there, that leadership position, and to normalize things like releasing data, not by the old means of publication and peer review, which made all the sense in the world in peace time, but in wartime, we have to think differently. Whose job is it to do that? And that's what we came in right interface with. There wasn't someone in the government's job to say, hey, release that data, what, no matter what country you're talking about, those kind of institutions didn't exist. And so we had to do it ourselves and really provide that backdoor, you know, the back of the room, leadership to do that. And that's what got scary and frustrating.

Dov SeidmanAnd when trust is low in society, as it has been, even when the data is accurate and it's not trusted by enough, how do you break that vicious cycle of even, not only releasing data, even when it's accurate, it's not trusted by a sufficient amount?

Dr. David AgusIt's tough, right? I mean, you get a lot. I had death threats. I mean, small cancer doctor, a university getting death threats and getting, you know, 1000s of inbounds of people pissed off you. It is scary. You feel alone. You feel vulnerable. But at the same time, you have to be steadfast in your belief and in your communicating with others and in drawing the data and iterating. And then if you say something that changed. You have to explain why. Yesterday I said this, but there's now new data that's changing my opinion, and here's why it changed. And I apologize for you know yesterday's conclusion, but it was wrong. You have to be vulnerable. You have to be transparent. We're not built like that. Is there an example in an ivory tower?

Dov SeidmanIs there an example you can give? I've seen you do this, where you you led with data, got new data, that changed, and you did pause and apologize and say, got this wrong, and where you created new connections through that humility and vulnerability of apologizing and owning the mistake.

Dr. David AgusYou know, early on, I think we all thought that this was going to be like other viruses in that when you're symptomatic, you spread with the flu, with the common cold, when you're symptomatic, you spread. So getting asymptomatic people to wear masks was just taking away PPE from healthcare providers, and was causing a panic, because people were hoarding masks. People were trying to get it so they could resell them. And it really was causing an issue in the country. So I and others got out there and said, Hey, listen, you know, an average person asymptomatic, wearing a mask or hoarding mask doesn't make sense. Let's save them all for the healthcare providers, because they're the ones who need them. Because if you're asymptomatic, you can't spread the virus. And then all of a sudden, we started to hear anecdotes of asymptomatic spread, and then we got the data. This is the first virus that I've been privy to where, when you're asymptomatic or pre symptomatic, you could spread that virus, and it all changed.

Dr. David AgusAnd we had to explain that and explain why we were wrong and why the data made us change.

Dov SeidmanSo given the state of the data today, if a CEO of a large publicly traded company comes to you and says, David, where should I come out on mandating versus incentivizing and motivating versus coercing vaccines?

Dr. David AgusIt's a really difficult question. 7% of the US population will not respond to a vaccine. They have leukemia, they have an autoimmune disease. They're an immune. And suppressive drug. They're too young to get vaccines, or they have an infant at home, all of the above. And so you as a CEO have to make a decision. Do I want to tell anybody who can't respond to the vaccine, you can't come to work because you could be harmed, because they're people who may not be vaccinated? Or do I want to take people who are in their control to be vaccinated and say, listen, I don't want you at the office because you can potentially spread to others, because you could potentially harm others, because we're a publicly facing company, and there may be a customer who comes in who has Lupus that you may harm them by spreading the virus, and it's going to take guts to stand up. And you know, I think throughout this pandemic, many, many CEOs I've had conversations with on a daily basis, and some of them have a remarkable way of leadership and explaining to their employees, and saying, Listen, you have a right not to be vaccinated, but you can't come into the office. You have to work at home, and we can't have it. And here's why, and let's explain the data, because we want to protect all of our employees, not just some of them. And yes, I think it is a gutsy move if Bruce Springsteen can say, you can only come to my Broadway show if you've been vaccinated, hell, CEO of a public company should stand up like Bruce Springsteen did.

Dov SeidmanThank you, David. Thank you Dr Agus.

Dr. David AgusAnd thank you for being a friend that you know course corrects me on a regular basis in a good way, a positive way, and enables me to achieve what I hope to achieve. So thank you.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Bob McDonald, former Chairman, President, and CEO of Procter & Gamble

    Sep 3, 202628 minAudio

    What does it take to lead with purpose when the stakes are high - and across very different worlds? In this HOW Conversation, Dana Born sits down with Bob McDonald, former Chairman, President, and CEO of Procter &...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Jim Keyes, former 7-Eleven and Blockbuster CEO

    Aug 2, 202628 minAudio

    What does it take to lead when everything around you is changing? In this HOW Conversation, former 7-Eleven and Blockbuster CEO James Keyes joins HOW Fellow Dana Born to explore why great leadership isn't about avoiding...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Mark Esper, former Defense Secretary, United States

    Jul 3, 202628 minAudio

    In moments of uncertainty, leadership is revealed. Former U.S. Sec Def Mark Esper joins Dov Seidman for a conversation about the principles that guide leaders through crisis, complexity, and change. Reflecting on his...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. David Kohler, Chair and CEO, Kohler Co.

    May 23, 202625 minAudio

    What does moral leadership look like across generations of change? In our latest HOW Conversation, HOW Fellow Dana Born sits down with David Kohler, Chair and CEO of Kohler Co., to explore what it takes to lead with...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Elise Awwad, President and CEO, DeVry University

    Apr 24, 202630 minAudio

    In this HOW Conversation, Elise Awwad, President and CEO of DeVry University, shares a deeply personal and practical perspective on moral leadership in a rapidly changing world. From her early lessons shaped by her...

    Credit the people on this episode