What does it take to lead with purpose when the stakes are high - and across very different worlds? In this HOW Conversation, Dana Born sits down with Bob McDonald, former Chairman, President, and CEO of Procter & Gamble and former Secretary of the U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs, to explore the principles that have guided his leadership across the military, business, and public service. Bob shares why values can serve as a compass in a volatile, uncertain, complex, and ambiguous world; how leaders can build cultures of trust through their everyday behaviors; and why the “how” of achieving results matters just as much as the results themselves. Drawing on lessons from his time at P&G, the VA, and in the U.S. Army, Bob also discusses servant leadership, leading through pressure and uncertainty, developing the next generation of leaders, and the importance of remaining a lifelong student of leadership. At the heart of the conversation is a simple but powerful idea: leadership is not just about what you accomplish, but how you accomplish it. READY TO START YOUR MORAL LEADERSHIP JOURNEY? Moral leadership is more imperative today than ever before. The HOW Institute for Society was founded on the belief that those in positions of formal authority should also have moral authority. We are creating the tools leaders need to make principled, ethical and values-based decisions. We are a nonprofit organization dedicated to building a world rooted in deep human values and trust in our social fabric. The Institute channels philosophical reasoning to address modern problems. Today, HOW we do what we do matters more than ever and in ways it never has before. Learn more at https://thehowinstitute.org/
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
IntroductionWelcome to the HOW Institute for Society's podcast, HOW Conversations, where we talk with courageous and authentic leaders about how we can build and nurture a culture of moral leadership throughout society. What does it mean to be a moral leader today? Who has moral authority in our society? What should we expect of our leaders during a crisis, and what are the moral leadership frameworks our leaders are using to navigate through these challenging times? These are just some of the nuanced questions our hosts cover in their discussions with CEOs, military generals, educators, philanthropists, and other leaders about the importance of moral and ethical decision-making, and now, here's the HOW Institute for Society senior distinguished fellow, Brigadier General Dana H.
IntroductionBorn, United States Air Force retired.
Brigadier General Dana H. BornWell, welcome to another HOW Conversation on Moral Leadership for our listeners today. We are so blessed to have with us the Honorable Robert (Bob) McDonald. So I know you're going to say "Call Me Bob". We'll talk about that in a moment. But Bob, welcome so very much back to the HOW community and for this conversation.
Bob McDonaldThrilled to be with you. It's really an honor, and I so look forward to it.
Brigadier General Dana H. BornBob was selected by President Obama in 2014 to head the Department of Veterans Affairs. He was the eighth to lead the department, which is the second largest next to the Department of War, and was able to transform the agency to be able to much better care for our military veterans. He also served Procter and Gamble for 33 years, and as the last four served as the chairman, president, and chief executive officer, and really expanded the footprint of the company. He is also the recipient of many awards and honorary degrees. Bob and his wife Diane are the founders and support the West Point's McDonald Conference for Leaders of Character. So, Bob, welcome, and we're so great to have you here. Now, I know you're the Honorable, and you have many distinguished titles: President, CEO, and many more, Chairman. I know you're going to say, "Call me Bob". What's behind that as we welcome you into this conversation?
Bob McDonaldYeah, this idea of "Call Me Bob" is really an interesting idea, and it almost became an iconic slogan during my time at the VA. We're going to talk about this more, I know, but culture change is probably the most important thing you can do as a leader, creating the right culture. So my thought was I had to break down all that formality, because what I wanted to do was create trust in the organization, trust and intimacy, and intimacy leads to trust, and all of that allows bad news to travel as quickly as good news, so we made a more informal culture. We said, "Call me Bob". Everybody called each other by first names. We limited the number of people attending meetings so that people didn't evaluate themselves based on their presence in my meetings or their presence in my trips. And by calling me Bob, as I traveled around the country, bad news got to me very quickly.
Brigadier General Dana H. BornJust as an example, I know you've shared in other interviews, and I know we've talked about the fact that you know you came from a military culture, you know came up through Procter and Gamble, and then you're at the VA, and you have people that are your, you know, your bag person, and you talked about that in terms of your own identity and flattening of the hierarchy. Would you talk a little bit about that?
Bob McDonaldSure. Well, when I got to the Procter and Gamble Company, I was leaving the service as a captain, and I called everyone sir, ma'am. I thought that was a symbol of respect. And that first day I interviewed, which was April 4, 1980, I won't forget it, they told me they said, you know, we call everyone by our first names here. We you know, one of our values of the Procter and Gamble Company still to this day is trust, and you can't trust people without intimacy, and intimacy comes with relationships. So always as a leader, I've worked hard to create intimacy and trust. For example, having my brand group over to the house for dinner, getting to know them on a personal basis, just like in the military. I mean, it's ironic in a way. You learn this in the formal culture of the military when you're a platoon leader of an airborne platoon like I was in 82nd, you have squad leaders, you have a radio telephone operator, and because of the life and death situations you're placed in, the intimate bonds grow. And so, my challenge in going into business was how do I create that kind of life and death intimacy in business?
Bob McDonaldBecause life and death occurs in business on a much longer time frame than it does in the military.
Brigadier General Dana H. BornI know I want to get to the where does this come from for you in terms of your values and your leadership and approach? Because I know I read somewhere or heard that you knew you wanted to go to West Point well before your senior year of high school, like when you were young, and so there's something in you that started well before the development and leadership and character programs at West Point. So where does this framework come from? What shaped you, and what do you still carry with you today from your answer of where that comes from?
Bob McDonaldI first applied to West Point to my congressman when I was 11 years old. I was in sixth grade. I knew I wouldn't get in, obviously, but I wanted to establish a relationship and create a file that I could fill over my career until I got to be a junior in high school. And fortunately, my congressman encouraged me to do that. But it all starts, obviously, with my parents, grandparents. A life where values and how you lived your life was more important than what you accomplished. It was how you accomplished it, not what you accomplished. And of course, the institutions that we valued, whether it was our faith coming from our Presbyterian Church, the values of scouting, having our grandparents close by. I remember, if I can tell a brief story, my brother and I (I have a brother who's 18 months older than I am), we went with my grandmother to a car dealership. She was babysitting us, and we were waiting for the car to be repaired. Someone walked in and started talking to my grandmother, and they talked for over an hour, because it took a while to repair the car.
Bob McDonaldAnd when the lady left, I said to my grandma or my brother did, "Who was that?" and she said, "I don't know", but the lesson there was that she treated a total stranger as if she were her best friend, and there's something to that. I think it's a very important value to treat other people with the kindness that you would want to be treated with. My grandparents during the Depression would leave the door open to their house because my grandfather had a job, and anybody who needed a meal could come in and join them for the meal, and that for me is the kind of culture I want to create.
Brigadier General Dana H. BornLet's talk a little bit if we can, because you're a rare commodity in terms of having been in the military, served a long time in the private sector, and also in public service, in incredibly important position, the second largest, I think, federal agency to the Department of War, and environments with very different missions, stakeholders, and measures of success. So let's dig into what principles, which are very important to you, remain constant across those different leadership roles, and how did your values help you navigate the what changed?
Bob McDonaldWell, as as as I know you believe as well, the value of education is learning models or heuristics, and because it gives you then the tool to evaluate a situation, so while I was at the Procter and Gamble Company, I developed a model that I would use to analyze every organization I took over, including the company eventually, and I applied that model at VA because again it gives you a touchstone to analyze, and for me, a high-performance organization starts with the the basics at the bottom, which the most important thing, which is, do you have a purpose? Do you have values? Do you have principles?
Bob McDonaldAnd are the people in the organization living that every day? So while the problems I discussed earlier at the VA was not giving veterans access, employees lying, the primary problem was we weren't focused on our purpose, which is caring for veterans. We weren't living out our values, which the acronym is ICARE - integrity, commitment, advocacy, respect, and excellence. It tries to do more of what it's been doing to get out of the problem, when the reality is it needs to do something different. You know, we tend when we're in crisis to draw in the drawbridge, close the windows, and the reality is you've got to get out of the office; you've got to meet with your customers; you've got to understand what's going on; and you've got to change, and so that's what we had to do at VA.
Bob McDonaldPutting the veteran at the center of everything we do, training people in our values, and then getting them to recommit to those values every year.
Brigadier General Dana H. BornI think our leaders today and all of us are feeling this pressure, right, of acceleration and unprecedented speed to make these decisions, and at the HOW Institute, we really promote the pause and how important that is. If you hit pause on a machine, it stops. If you hit pause on a human, we actually begin. So my next question gets at: How do you distinguish between moving so fast and quickly, and moving wisely, and making sure you're not just doing the next thing right, but you're also doing the right thing? And what values do, what what role do values play in helping leaders make these sound decisions when they don't have all the answers?
Robert (Bob) McDonaldYou know, at the Army War College, we often talk about the VUCA world-volatile, uncertain, complex, and ambiguous- and boy, if that doesn't describe all of our lives today, I don't know. I don't know another acronym that does. What's the values that help you through the fog of VUCA? You know, if you stay true to your values, that will help you make the right decisions through the fog that you see in a VUCA world. The other thing I would say that's fundamentally important but often ignored is you've got to look at everything through the lens of your customer. Let me give you an example. So we at Procter and Gamble bought the Gillette Company in 2005. I said, "Well, you know, how are we developing our razors in India? Well, the answer I got was, we don't develop them in India. We go to MIT and Harvard, and we recruit some Indian students, and we ask them to come in and use the razors. We watch them use them, and then we design them for them. Well, that's great from a physiology standpoint. I mean, certainly Indian physiology is the same, but that's not great from a habits and practices standpoint. So I said, no, no, no. Let's get on the company plane. Let's go to India. I went with them, and let's watch people use our razors. And what we discovered was that in India, water is almost as expensive as the shaving cream. And men would sit on the floor of their home with a little can filled with water, shaving, and the problem was our razors didn't... When you put the razor in the can of water, you couldn't get the suds off. You couldn't get the shaving cream off because there wasn't running water, and so we redesigned the razor to create a wishbone kind of look at the end that was more rinsable, and of course the business took off.
Robert (Bob) McDonaldBut the point is, you can't figure that out in Boston. You've got to go sit down with your customer and watch your customer and practice, talk to your customer, and then do the design.
Brigadier General Dana H. BornI can hear that, and I think our listeners can too, about improving lives- really deepen your purpose and your why. And you've consistently centered on that, whether it's service in general, but you've done that with consumers, with employees, soldiers, veterans, the public. So how...
Robert (Bob) McDonaldIt's the most important thing. It's the most important thing. If you look at my leadership beliefs, the number one thing is living a life of purpose leads to a more rewarding life than meandering through life without direction. And all of the forces today, whether it's computers, phones, the instantaneous lifestyles that we all lead cause reaction. They don't cause leadership. Leadership comes from having a purpose, having a vision, and making sure every day you're working against that.
Brigadier General Dana H. BornYou know your why. You encourage others to know their why, but you also focus on how, and obviously, the HOW Institute-that's an important part too. So, how has this mindset of service that you have deeply embedded in your life and your leadership shaped the way that you exercise your leadership, particularly when you face competing priorities, when you feel torn, when you know you can't keep everybody happy? There are difficult choices, but that has guided you; this how linked to your purpose has guided you. Maybe some examples for our listeners.
Robert (Bob) McDonaldWell, I think it's important as a leader to be humble and to be empathetic. And what I've been trying to describe through my behavior at the Procter and Gamble Company at VA, call me Bob. You know, I'm not impressed with myself. I'm probably not the smartest person in the room. I want to surround myself with people who are smarter than me. And at Procter and Gamble, we used to describe the company as a democracy of ideas, and that's what I want. I want everybody bringing their ideas to the purpose of the company, improving lives. And in the military, you learn that you never rely on your rank to create a mission. You don't rely on your authority, even though legally you could use it, and I think great emblematic of that is the thing you and I learned in the military, which is the soldiers always eat before you do. As the officer, you always wait for the soldiers to eat. I tried to take that servant leadership approach into business, into the VA, where I was there to help people get their jobs done, rather than helicoptering over them to supervise them, and I was more of an enabler. And I think enabling is a very important quality of leadership.
Brigadier General Dana H. BornAnd you also talked earlier about in the how, in how you develop the cultures that promulgate that more than what an organization does or aspires to do, and more about how leaders consistently behave. What is the thing? What do they reward, reinforce, and refuse to compromise those bright lights of principles and ethical boundaries? So across Procter and Gamble, the Department of Veterans Affairs, how did you use your own like leadership observable behaviors to shape cultures, accountability, build trust, shared purpose? In addition to leaders last a beautiful behavior demonstrates that. But what are some other things?
Robert (Bob) McDonaldYeah, it's a great question. Here's my point to everybody listening, which is: leadership is deliberate and intentional. You've got to be deliberate and intentional. So sit down and figure out how you want to change the culture, and then go act it out, and so let's talk about a few examples. For example, flying into a city, the first thing you do is you go to consumers' homes and watch them use your products. If you walk into an office, what are the pictures on the wall? I'm on the board of an organization where I said, "Take those pictures off the wall. Those are pictures of us. I don't want pictures of us on the wall. I want pictures of our customers on the wall. Whose lives have we saved? Put them on the wall. Who's on our website?" Things like this idea that when I walk into a room for a meeting, I don't want anybody standing up. I want people calling me by my first name. I don't want anybody carrying my phone or my briefcase. I don't want people valuing their careers based on whether they travel with me. These are all things that are very visible, very important. How about when I walk into a Procter and Gamble plant, if I see trash on the floor and I see somebody walk by it, I know our standards are too low. If I go into a restroom, like a men's locker room at a factory, and I see water around the sink, I know we don't care for each other. These are little symbols that you've got to solve.
Brigadier General Dana H. BornSomewhere in here is a clarity of shared purpose and shared values that enables. Maybe you can share with our listeners a little bit about how that's somewhat the secret of being able to, I don't know, accelerate that perspective that people have, but aligned with something bigger that is unifying.
Robert (Bob) McDonaldExactly. Well, my leadership model that we helped create the Procter & Gamble Company is called the 5E model. So you've got to you, as the leader, have to engage your organization to create a vision that is so strong and so attractive and so clear that people will run through fire for it. You know, in the military we say run to the gunfire. You know, don't go away from the problem, go toward the problem, and the vision's got to be so strong that people are willing to do that. That they're willing, that it's attractive for them. And importantly, we as leaders have to show them what's in it for them personally. One of our values at the Procter and Gamble Company is that the interests of the employee and the company are inseparable, and we achieve that by giving everyone company stock.
Brigadier General Dana H. BornThat's fantastic, and I hear a lot of alignment and common cause there in terms of locking arms to do that together, that unifying part. Let's go into our next gen fellowship now, because you spoke to our next gen fellowship. These are, you know, high-performance mid-level managers and their managers. And one of your quotes and you say a greatest responsibility right now we have as leaders is developing the next generation and I want to get your quote exact. And so, for our listeners, you said: "Successful leadership involves recognizing the unique qualities of different leaders and adapting the context". So, beyond technical competence, what qualities right now would you say you look for in emerging leaders, and how do you cultivate and how do you help moral judgment alongside of professional excellence?
Robert (Bob) McDonaldYeah, great question. The first thing I would say is, and you've heard me say this, is leadership is the most scarce resource in the world. So if I'm hiring people or looking for people to be on teams I'm on, the first thing I'm looking for is leadership. Is the person a dedicated, professional, insatiable student of leadership, and how long have they been that? And what are they doing to nurture themselves, educate themselves as students of leadership? So I would look for all the behaviors of leadership. Are they engaging others? Are they envisioning with others? Are they creating a vision? Are they energizing others? Are they building organizational capability? Are they executing what they envision? These would be all things I look for. Are they taking initiative? And then, of course, part of that, an important part, one that is uncompromisable, if I can say that, is not what are you accomplishing, but how you are accomplishing it. I can tell you, all the different discussions I would be in about promoting people at the Procter and Gamble Company or at VA. We always had people with great results. That wasn't the question. The question wasn't is Sally's result better than Ted's result? The question was, how did Sally achieve her result?
Robert (Bob) McDonaldHow did Ted achieve his result? The how you achieve it, you know, did they do right things right, or were they doing short-term things that may look right at the time but actually work against the organization? I love Jim Collins' quote. Jim's a good friend, visiting professor of leadership at West Point for a while. Great guy. Anyway, he always says, "Are you, as a leader, are you building a clock, or are you telling time?
Robert (Bob) McDonaldInstitute, hope. And so, during these VUCA times and what seems to be, you know, accelerating change, what Well, the number one thing, and I think you would join me in this because we've talked it, is the young people I associate with every day, whether it's the young people at West Point, the cadets at West Point, or the young people from other universities who come to West Point for the conference for leaders of character. They make me so optimistic because while we think they may be young, while we think they may be not yet wise, while we think they may be short of things that we think are important, what we discover is they're on top of things, if not well beyond where we are. And I, you know, I always love being around young people because they challenge me, particularly technically, but they challenge me to be a better version of myself. It reminds me at the Procter and Gamble Company every year I would train the incoming general managers and leadership, so I'd have a room of let's say, 100 general managers, newly minted general managers, who were really all quite proud of themselves at that point of their career, and I'd bring bring young people in, and I have them complain to the general managers about their behavior. You know, like my general manager talks to me about work-life balance. If I want to work on a holiday, I'll work on the holiday. Or my general manager comes up behind me and looks at my computer screen. I don't want them doing that. My general manager doesn't text. I text them. They don't.
Robert (Bob) McDonaldThese are obviously dated comments, and I would always stop the proceeding and say, okay, you young people are complaining about us older people. Someday you're going to be on the other side of the room, and there are going to be young people complaining about you. I mean, it's it's inevitable, right? Every young new generation complains about the older generation's inability to learn new things, so there's a couple of points there. Number one, we as leaders need to constantly learn new things. You know, if you hear a word and you don't understand it, like quantum computing, AI, you know, go out and research it, figure it out. If you hear a political point of view on TV that sounds unusual, go research it. You know? And think of yourself as a leadership vessel that needs to be filled with new knowledge and new experiences because it's that knowledge and that experience that will improve your leadership. And as you talked, Dana, leadership is a journey, it's it's it's not a destination. And then secondly, recognize that every new generation is going to think the older generation is somehow incompetent, and take advantage
Brigadier General Dana H. BornI love this, and you know you have used the words I'm a work in progress. We're all in progress, and we have more to do. Just want to say thank you to the Honorable Robert Bob, "Call me Bob" McDonald, a great leader in the Army, and also Procter and Gamble as Chairman, CEO, and President, and Secretary of the VA, our number eight Secretary. You and Diane, we thank you so much for your ripple effect of putting more how in the world and leadership and character.
What does it take to lead when everything around you is changing? In this HOW Conversation, former 7-Eleven and Blockbuster CEO James Keyes joins HOW Fellow Dana Born to explore why great leadership isn't about avoiding...
In moments of uncertainty, leadership is revealed. Former U.S. Sec Def Mark Esper joins Dov Seidman for a conversation about the principles that guide leaders through crisis, complexity, and change. Reflecting on his...
What does moral leadership look like across generations of change? In our latest HOW Conversation, HOW Fellow Dana Born sits down with David Kohler, Chair and CEO of Kohler Co., to explore what it takes to lead with...
In this HOW Conversation, Elise Awwad, President and CEO of DeVry University, shares a deeply personal and practical perspective on moral leadership in a rapidly changing world. From her early lessons shaped by her...
What does it take to lead with principle in a system defined by pressure, trade-offs, and competing interests? In this HOW Conversation, HOW founder Dov Seidman sits down with David Gelles, best-selling author and...