Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

HOW Conversations

HOW Conversations artwork

General Stanley McChrystal, Army, Retired

Jul 23, 202529 minAudio

[Archive Interview from Dec 17, 2020] Moral leaders must have a strong sense of purpose and must be willing to put personal desires aside to achieve shared goals, says retired General Stanley McChrystal. “Things only matter if they link to a purpose that we've all looked at and we've all accepted, and we are committed to. As a leader I have to keep pointing where we want to be going,” Stan told Dana H. Born, HOW Institute Fellow on this episode of HOW Conversations. The two also discussed transparent leadership, being intentional within leadership and moral decision making. Gen. McChrystal spoke about leadership built on values and the importance of active citizenship. Stan is the CEO and founder of the McChrystal Group in Alexandria, VA. READY TO START YOUR MORAL LEADERSHIP JOURNEY? Moral leadership is more imperative today than ever before. The HOW Institute for Society was founded on the belief that those in positions of formal authority should also have moral authority. We are creating the tools leaders need to make principled, ethical and values-based decisions. We are a nonprofit organization dedicated to building a world rooted in deep human values and trust in our social fabric. The Institute channels philosophical reasoning to address modern problems. Today, HOW we do what we do matters more than ever and in ways it never has before. Learn more at https://thehowinstitute.org/

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

IntroductionWelcome to the HOW Institute for Society's podcast, HOW Conversations where we talk with courageous and authentic leaders about how we can build and nurture a culture of moral leadership throughout society. What does it mean to be a moral leader today who has moral authority in our society? What should we expect of our leaders during a crisis, and what are the moral leadership frameworks our leaders are using to navigate through these challenging times? These are just some of the nuanced questions our hosts cover in their discussions with CEOs, military generals, educators, philanthropists and other leaders about the importance of moral and ethical decision making. And now here's the HOW Institute for Society's Senior Distinguished Fellow Brigadier General Dana H Born, United States Air Force, Retired.

Brig. General Dana H. BornWell, welcome to our how conversation today we are so delighted to have with us US Army, retired Stanley McChrystal general, how are you doing? How is the McChrystal group? How is your family? How are you navigating through some of these tumultuous, unprecedented times of crises?

General Stanley McChrystalFirst off, thanks for asking. Thanks for all you do and doing great. You can probably hear in the background one of my granddaughters running around. I live next door to my granddaughters and my son and daughter in law, so we're kind of a nuclear family. So this has been different, like it has for everyone, but it's been a kind of special time for us, too, and so we've gotten to spend a lot of time with family,

Brig. General Dana H. BornThat's wonderful, and it's great to see that you look like you're doing well and thriving and surviving, and I think that's what most of us are trying to do right now. Let me talk a little bit about your background, and this is mostly for the theme of getting at our conversation, which is about moral leadership for the HOW Institute for Society, but also about leading really complex organizations, which you have done a lot. I mean, you've commanded our International Security Assistance Force, the United States forces in Afghanistan, our Joint Special Operations Command credited with the death of Zarqawi also directing our joint staff, which is a very diverse group of people. And my own personal sense of you, and I hear it by others, reflected and mirrored, is that you really are a unifier. You're someone who is a soldier, soldier, but also a statesman, as well as someone who's deeply passionate about service, and so I guess I'll start with a question of, would you please share with us where does that come from?

General Stanley McChrystalWell, that's I think, from examples. I think most of us learn leadership by watching leadership. We certainly study it. We certainly read about it, examples in history and whatnot. But I think most of us learn how you treat people, how you conduct yourself, by watching role models. And sometimes those role models are holistic. They might be my father, who I deeply admired, and I wanted to be just like him, or there might be other people who you don't want to be like them in every way, but they do certain things that just imprint themselves on you. I, you know I've worked with some, typically more junior to me, non commissioned officer leaders in the military who could sometimes cut to the heart of moral leadership more clearly than somebody who'd studied it for years, they would simply look at something and they go, No, that's right, and that's wrong. What's hard about this? And you'd step back and you'd go, that's That's correct. And so I think it's by example is, is how we do that. And then every time you see a good example, most of us sort of try to internalize it and and carry it with us.

Brig. General Dana H. BornAnd when you talk about leadership now, and especially when you said you would, when you sat down to write your memories and your I don't know if it was memoirs, you're fairly young for for that, but to do that, you said you thought you would be the center of the story and the example of you know, your experiences, and yet you said that wasn't the case. That leadership is extraordinarily complicated and complex. What did you mean by that?

General Stanley McChrystalYeah, it's an interesting example, because when I left the military, I was approached to write my memoirs, and I, of course, first said no, and then people talk to you and and you say you've got a debt to history, whether it's true or not, I wrote my memoirs, spent two and a half years working with a young, recent Yale graduate, and we studied my life, and I thought it. Be simple, because I was there, I should know what happened. But the reality was, when we dissected most complicated things, I'd been a part of things in Iraq, Afghanistan, and other times, I would have a memory of what happened. And we found out that my memory was pretty good. I would remember generally, but it was always incomplete, because there was so much more to what was happening than I ever knew at the time, and actually ever knew until we wrote the memoirs, because we did all these interviews and brought people in, and something was like filling the pieces of a puzzle together and realizing it wasn't all about me. I didn't make a brilliant decision, and we had a great outcome. I was part of the decision, and then all these people did these extraordinary things, and we got a good outcome. They just didn't come to me afterward to claim credit for what they had done.

Brig. General Dana H. BornI want to go on to your now teams of teams, and your incredible way of thinking about, how do you make big, massive teams and organizations smaller, and your experience in terms of, you know, having the counterterrorism strategy responsibilities that you did to defeat the Taliban in Afghanistan, and taking this like unwieldy, large organization, but somehow channeling it especially changing operations drastically. What lessons would you share in terms of how you approach that

General Stanley McChrystalOur challenge, I commanded from 2003 to 2008 Joint Special Operations Commander JSOC. And JSOC was formed after the failure of the Iran rescue mission in 1980 and it was purpose built to do those very precise, elegant operations that people thought we would need to do in an age of terrorism, counter hijacking, hostage rescue, whatnot. It was made up of a series of smaller entities, SEAL Team Six, the Rangers, Delta Force. And each of those organizations were these very cohesive, insular, almost tribal units that people would join and stay in for, usually, the rest of their career. When we got into Iraq in 2003 we suddenly had a problem at scale that we'd never dealt with before. Al Qaeda in Iraq was big. It was constantly changing, morphing. It was run by information technology, which hadn't existed for other groups, so it had different DNA, so we had to fight a coordinated war on a huge scale with a bunch of small teams that were tribal and didn't want to play together, didn't want to deal with each other at all, much less with people outside the command. So we had to do is create a team of teams where we brought these teams together and we built relationships between individuals and between organizations that created this synergy, and that meant you had to have much more communication than ever. You had to have cultural links between organizations, driven at first by process that we put in place to force it, and then reinforced by shared experience together. And so what happened was we were able to achieve scale, but 7500 people at the height of it all operating in this way that I sometimes describe as like a human brain. Information didn't go up to the top and the great leader at the top made a decision. Went down. Information went and decisions just got made very close to the point of action. But then coordination was almost all lateral and diagonal. We didn't direct things from the top because it was too slow. And so when we talk about Team of Teams, it's a constantly adapting entity, almost like a cell structure mutating, and the key is to allow it to do that, but bound it with a mission and certain norms.

Brig. General Dana H. BornSo I wonder if you might talk a little bit more about that, the role of the purpose, or the why? How you How did you do that in such a large, complex leadership challenge and organization?

General Stanley McChrystalYeah, you really cut to the heart of it, Dana. The purpose was this, and it's funny, because JSOC had grown up is this sort of hard bitten group of counter terrorists who do what they do, because that's who they are and what you know you if you go in and ask them, they'd say, what do we do? Well, we're fighting the war on terror. And I said, stop it. We're not here to fight the war on terror. We're here to win the war on terror. And so things only matter if they they link to a purpose that we've all looked at and we've all accepted and we're committed to, which means that we are also willing to adapt ourselves, subordinate our personal desires are good all to get to that shared goal that we've we've identified and we keep our eye on all the time.

General Stanley McChrystalAnd I found in so many organizations, it's easy to lose that and start focus. In some commercial organizations, we find we want one behavior and outcome, but we incentivize another, you know, with bonuses or pay or promotions. And so that's what became so important. And then as a leader, I found I had to talk about that a lot. I had to keep pointing at where we're going, because that's what you wanted them to be focused on.

Brig. General Dana H. BornYou know, you've made the comment that that people are complicated and that relationships are complicated, and that sometimes, you know, it's not good to be too open with your subordinates, because it might be complex for them, or maybe even confusing, yet moral leaders have to be human too, and have to share some vulnerabilities, and we have to be empathetic to understand emotions and to understand perspective. So how do you balance those leadership complexities?

General Stanley McChrystalYeah, there's several ones there to unpack what you said. One of the first is, I'm a great believer in transparency, but I shouldn't give my problems to my subordinates. So for example, if I have a trusted subordinate, and on Monday, I go to them and I start complaining about my boss or the situation, and I create a familiar environment where that person is is being asked to be a sympathetic ear. And then Tuesday, I go in and I'm not happy with something they've done, and suddenly I'm the the strict leader. Again.

General Stanley McChrystalThink of the confusion it causes that subordinate that's not their responsibility to take my burdens in that way. Now we share tasks, but it's not fair of me to do that to them, because it puts them in an impossible position, and that's why leadership at the senior levels command is lonely by definition. You've got to find other people in ways to connect when you talk about the moral part of this, as we start to say, how do we make sure that how we are doing something is remembered? Because there's a, you know, there's a school of thought that says, you know, the ends justifies the means. And and in the counter terrorist fight that that I was involved with, there was this great pull to go down to the tactics and the the approaches that our enemy were was using because it could be expedient. And the argument I would make out to people I said we we won't win if we shouldn't win, meaning if we become something that we don't want to be, if we if we represent a set of values that are not worthy of our cause, we shouldn't win. But it's easy to say that, and then remember just how complicated this gets, because sometimes there's a sirens call to tactics that that are pretty difficult to think about. At the beginning of World War Two, as you know, all of the combatants said they wouldn't bomb civilians. Every nation, Nazi Germany, said it. Everybody said they wouldn't bomb civilian targets. Within a year, everybody was bombing civilian targets. By the end of the war, we'd made a science of it in terms of fire bombing and and things like that. And those were all we evolved to that. You know, we over time, we just said we got to get this done, and we started to rationalize it. And so when you start to get into values, you start to ask yourself the question, as a leader, if I practice good leadership, but I fail my mission. Was that good leadership. And then I flip, flip that, and I say, but if I practice bad leadership, either immoral or just abusive leadership. Well, either one, and I'm successful, is that really bad leadership, or, in fact, did I, at the end of the day, do what I was supposed to do? And that gets to how you treat people. That gets to whether you abuse workers, in the grand sense, if you're an industrialist, and that gets to whether you have the organization do things that are not morally acceptable, if the company opens bank accounts that people don't want, like Wells Fargo did, but they make a lot of profit, and the shareholders get a lot of money. Are the shareholders happy or unhappy?

General Stanley McChrystalThis is where we start to really have to step back and and go to first principles, because there is a sense that if the shareholders, and we'll just simplify it, if the shareholders are widows and orphans and. Raising their share price by doing things that are untoward. Isn't that a good thing? And of course, I think you and I would base say no, but it's never quite as simple as it seems.

Brig. General Dana H. BornWell, thank you for your vulnerability and humility and sharing that example for us all to learn alongside of you in the wisdom, and I'm going to take you back now to 1976 and going back to your West Point days and Bicentennial class, and maybe much of what I learned I learned at West Point. But you were graduating from West Point at a time when crises was known. We were Vietnam. We had civil rights going on. What had you lean into those crises? Times to go to West Point during those times?

General Stanley McChrystalYeah, it's interesting, because we entered the summer 1972 the military was almost at its lowest point of self esteem, and so it would actually was the easiest year in the Academy's history to get accepted, because there just weren't as many people applying. So even I got in. But it was a time in which the values of the army were under assault. Mid I had happened about a year and a half before there were a number of things which had ruled the army.

General Stanley McChrystalOf course, while I was there, Vietnam ended unsuccessfully. The President of the United States resigned from office. The superintendent of the military academy resigned right before we got there. So we got and, you know, it just occurred related to me, like there was a cheating scandal my senior year, just before i were i left, we had 179 people in the class behind me cheat and and get found for cheating. So there was this, this entire set of big waves that came and so we entered the army, I think, unsure about the steadiness of the organization we were going into, unsure about whether it was going in a good direction, bad direction. And in actuality, when we actually got to our first units, a lot of them were not in good shape at all. I got to the 82nd airborne, and it wasn't in a healthy place. I was almost fortunate that there wasn't anything to compare it to. I'd read stories of World War Two and before, so I had had them on a pedestal, and when I got there, I was deeply disappointed, but it started getting better pretty quickly. But a lot of people in my class, as a consequence, I think, of the times, entered West Point already having desire or decided not to make a career of the army. And that was disappointing. You know, they they self selected while cadets, and they just said, I'm going to do my five year commitment. They were bad people, but they didn't enter the army with the open mind that says, I'm going to try this, and I may like it.

Brig. General Dana H. BornWhat is a lesson that you would offer us in thinking about what you learned by maybe that example, or actually maybe through your career, that would apply to how we might think about the crises we currently face.

General Stanley McChrystalYeah, I think the first thing is that crises are most crises are of a limited time duration. You know, you and I have been through a number of crises in our life, and one thing we know is they're going to end. There's going to be a time after crisis. And that's helpful in several ways. One is you tend not to get despondent, because you know that if it's it's bad, it's going to get better. The second thing you learn if you if you pay attention, is what you do in a crisis is going to matter later. It will matter to you.

General Stanley McChrystalYou will know how you conducted yourself when it was very difficult. And if you think of small examples of time at work or a time and family, when suddenly there was a crisis, and you remember back who was calm, who was helpful, who was interested in the welfare of others and who wasn't, and you start to to pay attention to yourself a little bit more. You say, Who do I want to be? I want to be the person who after the crisis, feels good about what I did, and people were happy that I was a part of the organization then. And people need to be reassured during crisis.

General Stanley McChrystalSometimes they need to be reminded during crisis of what they should be doing. There are there just a number of functions that leaders perform, even sometimes to their peers and superiors.

Brig. General Dana H. BornI love I'm hearing your example, especially in crisis, because we oftentimes will, we. Respond habitually, like how we normally are. And I am reminded of some of the language we use at the how Institute is a moral muscle, and as we practice that moral muscle every day, then when crises happen, we're more likely to not allow others to influence us, but to basically habitually respond as we have been practicing kind of an Aristotle foundation there, and one of the things that you've been very much an advocate of is is public service and service for all. And I guess I'd like to give you a platform to share with our listeners a little bit about how that can help us evolve as moral leaders, build that moral muscle and maybe even skills and capabilities as a moral leader.

General Stanley McChrystalSure, and I'm going to go back to the idea of citizenship. And citizenship is simply an agreement between people, a covenant to create an entity, a nation, if the case of the United States, God didn't draw the United States and say this, a bunch of people got together and said, We're going to form a country. Now what citizenship means is we will do a number of things. We will meet our obligations to be citizens, and from that, we'll get shared defense, and we'll get a number of advantages from it. The challenge is we've allowed the idea of citizenship to shrink.

General Stanley McChrystalWe think that if you pay your taxes and if you vote, and we vote, still this election is better, but we vote at a low rate, and so we really don't think much about what I would call our inalienable responsibilities. But if you go back in our history, in the times on that the prairies where communities had to band together or they wouldn't survive, volunteer fire departments all it seems we have a great tradition, but it is shrank down. And think about it, when do you feel most involved in something? And it's when you have invested. I don't know if you've ever been forced to pick up trash along the roadway, and you do that, and while you're out there picking it up, you're complaining about people who litter. You're saying, you know, people shouldn't do this. And the next time you drive, you don't litter, because you go, yeah, somebody's picking this trash up. If you invest in our society, in your fellow citizens, suddenly have a different belief on it. But the only way we do that is through experience. You don't get it through civics class in high school. You have to go out and do something. Think, who are the people? Who are you and I are probably at least a little bit guilty this. Who gets most self righteous about defending America? It's veterans, because we did it. So Darn it. Why don't everybody do it? Well, don't you want people self righteous about everything to do with responsibilities toward others.

General Stanley McChrystalAnd so what I've been involved in for eight with eight years now is the idea of creating a year of national service for every young American, either sometime between 18 and 28 where they go out, they can do something that can be education, health care, environment, you name it, and they go out and do it full time for a year, and they're paid because you want them all in you want them to have a different experience in their life. So the rest of their life they can look back away. That was painful, but you know, it was good for me, and everybody has that shared environment. So when they go to cocktail parties in their 40s, they can go Dana, where'd you serve? And you have an answer.

General Stanley McChrystalAnd I think that that is really what's missing in the idea of trying to unify America now, because who do you like? Who do you not like? You don't like the people you don't know, those people who live in Iowa, I don't like them because I don't go to Iowa, I don't know. Well, you know, of course you do if you knew them, it's different. We learned that from mixing people in the military. So I think it's time for the nation to stand up and say, we would be a better nation if every young person had that opportunity.

Brig. General Dana H. BornSo I hear, I hear so much humility in this and humility and the virtue of service go so closely together and tying into citizenship of it's a way to be humble, right in that service,

General Stanley McChrystalExactly. I mean, most of us, we, we sort of puff our chests up. We say we're citizens, but we didn't do anything to be citizens except get born.

Brig. General Dana H. BornBeautiful point. Well, let's go back to values. I'd love to circle back around with something so pivotal, important in everything that we've heard from you and experienced with you. And this is something that that you said, which is a quote that. What we need to do is look in the mirror right now. Stop looking at elected officials or somebody else. Look in the mirror. Decide what we believe is the necessary leadership for our country.

Brig. General Dana H. BornDecide what we believe our values are, and then that's what we will get, because that's what we will demand. And now this might be focused on us looking in the mirror, but it also probably applies to globally, leaders, moral leaders throughout the world. So I wonder if you'd share with us what values you're thinking about and and how do these values translate into moral leadership?

General Stanley McChrystalYeah, it's, it's really a form of self accountability. And I mentioned to you I have three granddaughters now, age six, four and one, and what they think of me matters tremendously. The six year old is asking me very thoughtful questions. Says, you were in the army. What'd you do? There you go, on TV sometimes. Why do you do that? What's the point of that? And you suddenly, it's very important to you, to me, that what she thinks of me is something that she admires. And it's more important that years from now, when I'm not around, and she's 35 that she remembers her grandfather, and she is proud of what I did and what I was. So if I look in the mirror at myself and I say, Okay, who am I supposed to be? Who are you looking at that? And then who do we have representing us, for example, as politicians? If we say, well, you know, I don't like the way that person operates, or they do so and so.

General Stanley McChrystalBut you know, they they've done some things that benefit me, and you get a wait a minute. They are us. They are represent, representation of us. What our nation does in the world is a representation of our values. We shouldn't be able to travel to Europe and go, Yeah, our government, you know, our country's, you know, lousy we, they should be able to look at us and go, You voted right? You're responsible. You're part of the United States. If you, if you are not, you the country not conducting itself the way it should. What are you doing about it? And that's kind of fair, and I think that's the way we ought to be thinking we have gotten to the point where we say, well, you know, politicians are sleazy, and that's just what they are. No, that's what they are. We elect them. We tolerate them. If we're not happy with that, fix it same way with any members of our society. So it's what do we start at home? What do we demand of ourselves?

General Stanley McChrystalThere's no point in me criticizing anybody else if I'm going to sleaze ball.

Brig. General Dana H. BornIt's a shared sense of sacrifice, and it makes me think of your other book about my share of the task, and it's looking in the mirror and saying, What is our share of the task? Coming back to what you said about our moral leadership responsibilities to contribute in citizenship, regardless of where we are, maybe global citizenship. I think that our listeners probably agree in terms of how you have helped us think about leadership complexities and how really you do ooze and reflect unification, uniting a sense of soldiering on and citizenship, statesmanship, and also great humility. Yourself and I just thank you so much for the time that you've spent with us in a HOW Conversation on moral leadership, and for what you've given us to think about and to look in the mirror in terms of how we're habituizing our own leadership going forward. So thank you very much. General Stan McChrystal, it's been just terrific to spend this time with you.

General Stanley McChrystalMy honor. Dana, thank you so much. Thank you.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Bob McDonald, former Chairman, President, and CEO of Procter & Gamble

    Sep 3, 202628 minAudio

    What does it take to lead with purpose when the stakes are high - and across very different worlds? In this HOW Conversation, Dana Born sits down with Bob McDonald, former Chairman, President, and CEO of Procter &...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Jim Keyes, former 7-Eleven and Blockbuster CEO

    Aug 2, 202628 minAudio

    What does it take to lead when everything around you is changing? In this HOW Conversation, former 7-Eleven and Blockbuster CEO James Keyes joins HOW Fellow Dana Born to explore why great leadership isn't about avoiding...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Mark Esper, former Defense Secretary, United States

    Jul 3, 202628 minAudio

    In moments of uncertainty, leadership is revealed. Former U.S. Sec Def Mark Esper joins Dov Seidman for a conversation about the principles that guide leaders through crisis, complexity, and change. Reflecting on his...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. David Kohler, Chair and CEO, Kohler Co.

    May 23, 202625 minAudio

    What does moral leadership look like across generations of change? In our latest HOW Conversation, HOW Fellow Dana Born sits down with David Kohler, Chair and CEO of Kohler Co., to explore what it takes to lead with...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Elise Awwad, President and CEO, DeVry University

    Apr 24, 202630 minAudio

    In this HOW Conversation, Elise Awwad, President and CEO of DeVry University, shares a deeply personal and practical perspective on moral leadership in a rapidly changing world. From her early lessons shaped by her...

    Credit the people on this episode