[Archive Interview Feb 18, 2021] “COVID has been a rude awakening for most of us. For the first time we have seen that our current system isn't really working as well as we intended,” says Paul Polman a HOW Institute Board Member and the former CEO of Unilever. Paul spoke with Dov Seidman, Founder of The HOW Institute, in this episode of HOW Conversations about the challenges and the opportunities the pandemic has revealed. Paul told Dov that a greener, more inclusive future is within reach but it will take moral leadership and courage from individuals plus strong public and private partnerships, “Business cannot succeed in societies that fail nor can business be a bystander in a system that gives them life in the first place.” The two also discussed the shortage of moral leaders (and why they still have hope for a turnaround), making long-term moral decisions and goals, and implementing strong company morals. In 2019 Paul co-founded Imagine, an organization dedicated to helping CEOs and businesses be sustainable, equitable and inclusive. Watch part one of Paul's HOW Conversations to hear some of his solutions for a better, healthier post-pandemic world. READY TO START YOUR MORAL LEADERSHIP JOURNEY? Moral leadership is more imperative today than ever before. The HOW Institute for Society was founded on the belief that those in positions of formal authority should also have moral authority. We are creating the tools leaders need to make principled, ethical and values-based decisions. We are a nonprofit organization dedicated to building a world rooted in deep human values and trust in our social fabric. The Institute channels philosophical reasoning to address modern problems. Today, HOW we do what we do matters more than ever and in ways it never has before. Learn more at https://thehowinstitute.org/
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
IntroductionWelcome to the HOW Institute for Society's podcast, HOW Conversations where we talk with courageous and authentic leaders about how we can build and nurture a culture of moral leadership throughout society. What does it mean to be a moral leader today who has moral authority in our society? What should we expect of our leaders during a crisis, and what are the moral leadership frameworks our leaders are using to navigate through these challenging times? These are just some of the nuanced questions our hosts cover in their discussions with CEOs, military generals, educators, philanthropists and other leaders about the importance of moral and ethical decision making. And now here's the HOW Institute for Society, founder and chairman and the host for today's podcast, Dov Seidman.
Dov SeidmanWelcome everybody to our next HOW Conversation. I am just delighted to welcome Paul Polman, my friend, a kindred spirit, a fellow traveler and an embodiment of moral leadership. And not just a personal embodiment of moral leadership, but Paul Polman is somebody who I've long admired for scaling moral leadership in his institution at the time Unilever, and then beyond in capitalism itself and in the broader business community.
Paul PolmanThank you, Doug, looking forward to it. Thanks for the opportunity.
Dov SeidmanYou created Unilever, sustainable living plan probably 10 to 20 years before it became fashionable, if not so practical, to be principled. You are now the co founder and chair of Imagine, and you're going to tell us about that. You are a board member of the HOW Institute for Society, and in that regard, we are in common cause. You are a member of the World Economic Forum's International Business Council. You chair the B Team. You're the vice chair of the United Nations Global Compact. Welcome, Paul. I'm just thrilled to have you, and I look forward to our conversation.
Paul PolmanWell, thank you, Doug, certainly looking forward to it as well.
Dov SeidmanWonderful so I know you're physically in Geneva, but emotionally, philosophically, spiritually, where do I find you? We you and I have talked often that the one of the hallmarks of moral leadership is the pause, because it's in the pause that we can hear the call. In the pause we can reflect more deeply on the world we're in or the situations we confront. So in the spirit of pausing, Paul, take us into your pause. What new reflections have you been having about the world, about leadership, about the path ahead. Just bring us into your pause. I know you've been pausing.
Paul PolmanYeah, we've definitely been pausing and thinking about the lessons that we can draw from COVID Once more. I think it has drastically changed all of our lives and the ways we obviously interact with each other, and I don't want to go through that right now, but it is very clear that COVID has been a rude awakening for most of us. I think for the first time, we have seen the relationships between biodiversity, human health, climate change, inequality was the tragic events in the US now also the racial inequalities, and that is really brought to life, that our current system isn't really working as well as we intended it to be. And I've said many times that if too many people feel that they are not included or excluded from systems, that ultimately will rebel against itself and and we've actually seen that we know for the first time, are in a situation that we've put 12, $13 trillion into into the global economy just to save lives and livelihoods, and are starting to think now of how do we come out of it, now that the vaccines start to be rolled out across the world, more so regretfully, in the developed markets than in the developing markets, but that's what it is right now, and we need to now think about the lessons from the past and how to build the right inclusive economy moving forward, one that is inclusive with our fellow human beings, once that is inclusive with Planet Earth, ones that is resilient for generations to come. And COVID has shown us that if we are faced with a burning action, we can actually work together enormously at the local level, we can react fast. We've also seen that companies that have a business model that is more focused towards the long term, multi stakeholder seem to be doing better. We see the financial market waking up to some of the risks, but more importantly, to the investment opportunities. So now we need to be sure, as we work together the private sector, civil society and governments, that we built it back better, and that we start to address the shortcomings and. To create this greener, more inclusive future, and that's a huge opportunity.
Dov SeidmanSo before we move on as to what exactly that entails, and we're going to spend more time on the kind if it's a time for action, the job of a leader is to inspire the right action in many others and to generate enlistment and worthy ideals and and paths that are sustainable. So we're going to get to leadership. But I I'd like to take to encapsulate everything you've said, You've recently said, and also told me directly that we are living through a crisis of morality. So if I take, if I take the combustion of these many different crises that you've described and put them all together. Why have you termed them explicitly a crisis of morality? And then you've said that moral leadership to get us through and beyond this crisis of morality is in short supply.
Dov SeidmanJust speak. Why do you call it that? And why is moral leadership in short supply.
Paul PolmanWell, I've always said that we are short of leaders and trees, and both are desperately needed. Never, ever have we been so forewarned about what is going to happen, and frankly, I also believe never, ever have we been so forearmed to do something about this. The crisis of climate change, of food security, of air pollution, of inequality are not new to us. And on the one hand, you will not find any CEO that tells you that they want more air pollution, more people going to bed hungry, more unemployment, more inequality. Yet collectively, we are not able to live up to the challenge to address these these areas, and we simply in the rat race of short termism, of shareholder primacy, don't take the time or the pause to do the right things for the longer term. And if we want to create this more sustainable, equitable world and attack these issues that we talked about, it requires longer term solutions. So we need to create that space to do that.
Paul PolmanAnd what we currently are facing is that our behaviors are controlled not by our own desires or inner compasses or moral beliefs, but they are more decided by the boundaries that are put on us. And for example, to make this come alive Dov, if you talk to CEOs, they have to incentivize the sales people to perform. If you incentivize the sales people with the number of orders they write, they will write a lot of orders, but they will be very small. If you incentivize them by the way they behave or give customer service, they will behave differently.
Paul PolmanIt's not different in society. So we need to focus on moving these boundaries to let moral leadership blossom the and that's difficult because it's very complex and it's not fully in your control. It requires systems thinking. It requires partnerships. It requires longer term thinking. It requires to make tough choices.
Dov SeidmanYeah, and is this why you recently called for a Marshall Plan to redesign a kind of Marshall Plan, to redesign our entire economic system, but as a huge node in the system when you became the CEO of Unilever, what inspired you to go to the edge and declare a moral journey of sustainable living, to go to Wall Street and say, I'm going to escape the tyranny of 89 day planning cycles. And we're not just going to think long term. We're going to operate long term. And I'm going to inspire 160,000 Unilever colleagues from around the world, if, if I as their fearless leader, I'm going to take on Wall Street, then I'm going to create a context where you can think long term. It was a very systematic approach. What in you because you were it was you were alone at the time. Very few CEOs were so out in front.
Dov SeidmanThat was about 12 years ago. Take us into that world. Lessons learned from that journey that others can grab and run with today.
Paul PolmanWell, I've always believed that you cannot have finite, infinite growth on the finite planet. I've also always believed that that organizations are here to positively, positively address these issues of people and planet that we have. So if an organization is only working in in its own self interest the shareholder, I think we have increasingly, the evidence that that is not leading you to a long term success. The organizations that are long term successful are built on strong values. They think multi stakeholder. They operate under the longer term in order to move our business to this longer term positive model with. We call the Unilever sustainable living plan. We had to create the boundaries that we talked about a minute ago. We had to move these boundaries for people to behave differently. So by abolishing guidance, by abolishing quarterly reporting, by changing our compensation systems for the longer term, I actually provided a framework for people to operate in by making clear statements that we would only grow as we would decouple our environmental impact and increase our overall social impact. I provided permission for people to behave in certain ways by making clear that we had to be responsible for our total footprint in society. Many companies still think they can outsource their supply chain and also outsource their responsibilities. We said, No, we are responsible for our total footprint. I gave them permission to work on more areas, and more importantly, ultimately, to not have all the brands that we sell, which was basically the connection we have with our citizens or consumers.
Paul PolmanOf this wealth not be driven by just functional benefits and profit and growth, but really having each of these brands address the broader societal issues. And what we found very clearly difficult at that time, because the evidence wasn't there, and the data probably went there. But what we found was that these brands that have a higher purpose also actually were growing faster and were, believe it or not, also more profitable. And that is increasingly the case if you now look at the financial market.
Paul PolmanDuring the crisis, the ESG funds have performed better financial institutions increasingly demanding transparency and behaviors that probably was unheard of, 3,4,5, years ago. So I think we're in the right direction now. Normally it would be governments that we rely on, but in the absence of that, I would argue once more that business who is, after all, over 60% of the global economy, 80% of the financial flow, 90% of the job creation. If business at at scale doesn't get involved, involved, we will never solve it, and the ultimate victim of that will be business itself.
Paul PolmanBusiness cannot succeed in societies that fail, nor can business be a bystander in a system that gives them life in the first place. So with Unilever, we move that business model from CSR, corporate social responsibility, that actually deals with less bad that simply isn't good enough anymore, nor acceptable, to what I call RSC, responsible social corporations, putting purpose at the core, maximizing the return on the multiple stakeholders, working on creating value and values, making shareholder return the result of what we do, not the objective and that we have seen over a 10 year time period, giving us about a 300% return and an enormously robust and resilient business that is well placed for the future.
Dov SeidmanLet's take stakeholder capitalism. There's been a movement away from shareholder primacy, but there is a system in shareholder primacy that as long as you aggressively pursue your commercial ends and your growth agenda within the bounds of the law, right, and you make money for shareholders, you have permission to continue to operate. Stakeholder capitalism basically says that the imperative is to take into account the interests of all stakeholders. Well, what does that mean? What is the framework of taking into account entail?
Dov SeidmanRight? Is that just shareholder primacy, that let's be thoughtful and about everybody else so that shareholders can make more money over the long term? Or is it really a moral system, Paul, where every stakeholder is not a means to anybody else's ends, but everybody is a co equal constituent with their dignity that deserves respect, and we really are creating value for everybody. So maybe you can help us really where the rubber hits the road. What does it mean to take into account the interests of everybody? What could a framework for doing that look like?
Paul PolmanSo what you now see, obviously, is that it is in companies interest if you want to be around for the longer term, that you have a workforce that is engaged, that you have relationships in your value chains with your suppliers or your customers that are built on trust and transparency. So the currency of trust transparency, the currency of cooperation, is increasingly defining what the value is of your company. And so dealing with optimizing the multiple stakeholders that actually create your value will also then result in the best long term value creation. That is really what the multi stakeholder model is after. And.
Paul PolmanAnd I don't think that these two are in conflict. If you think about you leave a shareholders where we certainly want a good return. For the shareholders, we pay out 80% of our profits, 70% of our profits and dividends. That's basically pensions for people that need to live a decent life after they retire. So it's not bad to have millions of shareholders that benefit from profits of companies and can retire perfectly. But the way to do that is to ensure that the people that create that value are being prioritized first of all the planet, to be sure that we can continue to live on this planet now and for future generations, which is a more most important thing.
Paul PolmanSecondly, that it results in inclusive growth, so that these markets expand, more people benefit from that. And thirdly, that it is done in cooperation with all the people in a fair way, the farmers who work for you, the suppliers who help you and provide innovations or technologies, the communities that let you be there and and and prosper. So this, this contract that you have with society, is really getting to the heart of this multi stakeholder model, and actually companies that understand that will do really well, because one of the great traits of leadership, I would say, is, is to have a high level of awareness and engagement with what is going on in the world, so that you can see the opportunities to respond to that. Companies that are outside in, as I call it, instead of inside out, do much better over time, and that brings me to the next step of leadership is to really have great leaders understand that it's not about themselves, that actually, if they invest more in others, making them successful is the main driver of their own success as well. If that is true for individuals, then it must be true for companies, which are a collective of individuals as well. And that certainly has proven to be the case for Unilever instead of selling bar soaps and do hand washing, we said we're going to attack the issues of infectionary diseases, of pneumonia, diarrhea, where 4 million children die. In fact, of make, instead of making just a toilet bowl cleaner, we said we're going to attack the issues of open defecation. So we made commitments to reach a billion people with hand washing, to build 100 million toilets with Dove to build self esteem with 100 million girls in schools.
Paul PolmanAnd as we put these bigger objectives out there, we're not we're not only helping to hopefully make humanity a little bit better, but we created unlimited growth for our brands. That's why growing ahead of the market and also actually more profitable. So at the end, all of our stakeholders can benefit, if you believe in that model.
Dov SeidmanI'd like to talk about leadership. Obviously, what's been animating you is this deep conviction that business and society have fused. There's never a conflict. Just like Aristotle said, that a good decision is both practical and principled, they can come together and reinforce each other. Business people often use cost benefit analysis, and even if you're going to do the right thing, if you do the right thing for the wrong reasons, it doesn't scale because it doesn't enter the heart, it doesn't sustain. So it's one thing to do the right reasons, because you've done some analysis and you say, if we do the right thing, we're going to engage our employees, or more people will think highly of us, but the best reason for doing the right thing is that it's the right thing.
Dov SeidmanVirtue is its own reward, and that's what really scales. So it seems that you need moral leaders to help foster this dynamic, because moral leaders are about doing the right thing because it's the right thing, not through a business cost benefit analysis. How do we go on that journey of not just identifying the problems and the solutions which are right and more sustainable, but how do we scale the reasons for pursuing them and rooting them in moral purpose, in moral values, in the kind of leadership so that it sustains and scales in that way.
Paul PolmanSo I could not agree more with you, Dov, that that the starting point that we need to attack, in my opinion, is, is the boundaries of what we define success if we continue to live in cultures where self worth is measured by net worth, we will not get there, and we've forgotten some of that, and it is good to go back to that things like the Golden Rule do unto others and the planet, as you would do unto yourself, are around in every religion in one form or another. So we need to bring that moral compass. Back to ourselves, and that has to start with education at the parental level. In education itself, where we very much have taught, at least in business, where most of the MBAs come from, or law, we've taught Milton Friedman. We have to broaden the the, obviously the teaching here, and go multi disciplinary and social science and other things have to come in.
Dov SeidmanAristotle said that educating the mind without educating the heart is no education at all. And in many ways, we're so good at analytics in business and so good at all this the intellectual parts of business, but the heart, the seat of values and empathy and and concern, if that needs education as much as anything, where you're not really educating, I think you're saying something in that same spirit,
Paul PolmanIn the same spirit. But ultimately, that can only come from having a very strong moral compass. Because even in Unilever where we change compensation systems, where we were really focused on making this a long term successful company, there were still incentives there to drive your short term performance. I could have gotten the share price higher over a five or 10 year period, cut my compensation up even more than I thought was ever possible, and leave the problems to the next person who then would have a big write off and start again. And then secondly, as not everybody can have that strong moral compass, you need to move these boundaries. How can we move to a different accounting system? If we only account for the return on financial capital, then indeed we're very good in optimizing that. But if we can rapidly change our reporting to really what counts, which is also environmental and social capital, then the capitalistic system is very good to optimize the total so changing what we measure as we say we treasure what we measure, and bringing that to the foreground, like things like a price on carbon, for example, drives behavior. So we could work on our own inner compass, but we can also work on the boundaries in which we operate to make it a little bit easier on people. And then we need to move to the third level, which is a higher level that is partnerships. We have to realize that the challenges that we now face, they are what they are, but they are of such magnitude that nobody can handle them alone anymore. And as Einstein said of the definition of insanity, doing the same thing over and over again and expecting different results is not going to work. We need to solve them at a different level than they were created, and a different level is partnership.
Paul PolmanSo how can we bring civil society, governments and private sector together in these more transformative partnerships, and that requires trust, that requires transparency, that requires respect, and all these values are values that moral leaders now need to foster if they want to be successful moving forward.
Dov SeidmanSo Paul, it's it's just really meaningful to be in common cause with you, with the HOW Institute, and so many other ways in which our lives have intersected and overlapped. And thank you for being you and for all that you've done and continue to do make sustainable and better. Thank you.
Paul Polmanand thanks for being such a great, great part of our journey. Actually, you've been, to some extent, a friend, a mentor, a teacher already along the journey, if I go back to the many memos that we've sent back and forth and found common ground and learned the same language and and shared the valuable lessons in each other's lives. It hopefully makes us all the better for it. So I'm grateful for that.
Dov SeidmanWell, that's heartening of you to say, and I share in the gratitude I've I've learned just as much, or probably more so thank you for being you and for the friendship.
What does it take to lead with purpose when the stakes are high - and across very different worlds? In this HOW Conversation, Dana Born sits down with Bob McDonald, former Chairman, President, and CEO of Procter &...
What does it take to lead when everything around you is changing? In this HOW Conversation, former 7-Eleven and Blockbuster CEO James Keyes joins HOW Fellow Dana Born to explore why great leadership isn't about avoiding...
In moments of uncertainty, leadership is revealed. Former U.S. Sec Def Mark Esper joins Dov Seidman for a conversation about the principles that guide leaders through crisis, complexity, and change. Reflecting on his...
What does moral leadership look like across generations of change? In our latest HOW Conversation, HOW Fellow Dana Born sits down with David Kohler, Chair and CEO of Kohler Co., to explore what it takes to lead with...
In this HOW Conversation, Elise Awwad, President and CEO of DeVry University, shares a deeply personal and practical perspective on moral leadership in a rapidly changing world. From her early lessons shaped by her...