Ajay Banga, former Executive Chairman of Mastercard
22 minAudio
[Archive interview from May 27, 2021] “I believe that businesses cannot prosper in a failing world,” Ajay Banga, the Executive Chairman of Mastercard, tells The HOW Institute Founder, Dov Seidman, on a new episode of HOW Conversations. Ajay explains why he thinks capitalism as we know it needs an overhaul and why business is in need of values-based leadership. “This [wealth] inequality, this climate inequality, they don't work for me, and they don't work for my children, and they don't work for you.” Ajay, who is a founding Board Member of The HOW Institute, and Dov also discuss Mastercard’s decision to keep all employees on the payroll during the pandemic even though the costs hurt the company’s bottom line, “It's a tough hit, but it's the right hit for the long term, you know why? Because those very people are far more loyal today. And by the way, the skills they have is what's made our company what it is.” Ajay explains Mastercard's company morals, establishing a respectful culture and he shares leadership advice for emerging moral leaders. READY TO START YOUR MORAL LEADERSHIP JOURNEY? Moral leadership is more imperative today than ever before. The HOW Institute for Society was founded on the belief that those in positions of formal authority should also have moral authority. We are creating the tools leaders need to make principled, ethical and values-based decisions. We are a nonprofit organization dedicated to building a world rooted in deep human values and trust in our social fabric. The Institute channels philosophical reasoning to address modern problems. Today, HOW we do what we do matters more than ever and in ways it never has before. Learn more at https://thehowinstitute.org/
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
IntroductionWelcome to the HOW Institute for Society's podcast, How Conversations where we talk with courageous and authentic leaders about how we can build and nurture a culture of moral leadership throughout society. What does it mean to be a moral leader today who has moral authority in our society? What should we expect of our leaders during a crisis, and what are the moral leadership frameworks our leaders are using to navigate through these challenging times? These are just some of the nuanced questions our hosts cover in their discussions with CEOs, military generals, educators, philanthropists and other leaders about the importance of moral and ethical decision making. And now here's the HOWInstitute for Society, founder and chairman and the host for today's podcast, Dov Seidman.
Dov SeidmanSo welcome to another of our HOW Conversations. It's a delight and a distinct pleasure, and frankly, it's special to welcome you. Ajay Banga, Ajay, you and I have long considered ourselves in common cause, Kindred in spirit, Kindred philosophically, it's an honor that you are a founding member of the Board of Directors of the HOW Institute for Society. But in terms of what you do day in, day out, you lead, and you are currently the executive chairman at MasterCard. Before that, you led a remarkable journey of leadership as the CEO of MasterCard for over 11 years.
Dov SeidmanBut I celebrate you for being at the vanguard and proving that business can be an incredible and enduring force for good, for positive societal change as value, and extraordinary value, in your case, is created. So welcome and thank you for for joining us. So where am I finding you? Just share some I
Ajay BangaIt's a pleasure, Dov, and thank you for for all that you do. You're the guy who, over time, I've listened to you, I've read what you what you've been writing, and now you're putting your own self out there as well with the HOW Institute to lend real meat to the idea of the importance of how so I'm looking forward to being a part of this conversation. don't know, reflections on on on the world, and then I want to step back and just take us through your journey of moral leadership. But start with, where am I finding you, emotionally, psychologically, philosophically, so physically, I'm in our office there. I've been throughout the pandemic. I've been in office every day. My view of where things are right now in the world around where the world is, where things are is not, is not uninformed by this fact that I've been here physically through this period, because I've now seen people come back to work in our office.
Ajay BangaI can see the numbers increasing. I can see the number of cars in the car park increasing. I meet more people in the corridor. I find them wandering by to say hello. I find them coming by to say I'm vaccinated. Can I give you a hug? It's nice to be back. I know you. There's a whole thing to it, and I think that tells you that we seem to have turned the tide here. But at the same time, I'm of Indian origin, and the country I came from is in deep trouble on the pandemic right now, and in a way that is very disturbing to anybody who either lives there or has family or friends there, and it feels like the developed world is getting more done on vaccinations is getting more done on economic energy in the form of fiscal and monetary stimulus. I think the developing world is struggling on that. And some parts of developing world, like India, like parts of Latin America and parts of Africa, seem to be particularly stressed during this period. And so I feel like the progress we've made on inclusion, the progress we've made on poverty alleviation, it feels like the clock's been turned back a little bit over the last 12 to 15 months. The third part now, which you know well, is our own employees, and I've tried as a as a leader, along with Michael, who is now my replacement as CEO, we both tried really hard to be there for our employees.
Ajay BangaWe've told them their jobs are safe. Nobody will lose their jobs because of the pandemic. Through 2020 and it's now early into 21 and we're still sticking by that.
Dov SeidmanYou know, globally, we're not yet on the other side of the pandemic, but at least where you are physically are right now, we're starting to turn the corner. To quote you, if you had to just share one lesson for leaders in this post pandemic world, what would it be a lesson that you took from the pandemic
Ajay BangaThat, I guess that, two, not one, the first one is we clearly didn't see this coming. But then more to do with leadership, I think what I've learned is that communication, simple, transparent, trustworthy, communication, speaking from your heart and not from notes speaking to what you really are worried about and what people who are listening to you are worried about, those became even more important during the crisis than they ever were before the crisis
Dov SeidmanYou've said before that for you, the source of so much of this is humility, right? Why is humility the seat of being able to be this kind of leader that comes from the heart that can provide hope, truth, transparency? Why have you said that humility is the root of it all?
Ajay BangaSo I think humility and humor, yeah, are the root of their leadership, because humor allows you to empathize very quickly with those who are listening to you, and humility allows you to keep your feet on the ground and listen to people around you, so you can both understand their concerns, but you can also learn from The views they bring to the table. After all the what if you believe that you're the smartest guy in the room, then you probably are not you. I've said this to you. God gave you two ears, two eyes and one mouth.
Ajay BangaFor a reason. There's a reason for that ratio. So you should watch and listen more than you speak. And it's that brings the idea of humility is connected to the idea of realizing that you can always learn from somebody else. And the idea of learning from somebody else is connected to the root of listening. Otherwise are you going to learn so
Dov SeidmanAnd it's a great and then listening is a sign of respect, because when you listen,
Ajay BangaIt all goes together. It all goes together. And you don't have to agree. I people mistake listening for agreement. Listening is paying attention, and so I'm glad you raised that. And so if you listen carefully, you'll pick it up. They don't have to always agree. There are times when you and I don't agree, but I'll still listen to you, because you deserve that.
Dov SeidmanDuring the pandemic, you said that you guaranteed everybody's job, meaning whatever animates you, you focused on saving lives and livelihoods. It now seems that that same animating ethos of saving is being turned towards not getting back to selling things, but to serving. And at the same time, Truth comes before all else. So when you know truth is at the root of all things, as a leader, how do you forge shared truths at a time where there are some powerful forces out there that are making it harder to share truths.
Ajay BangaWell, the truth is a very interesting word, because truth is both an adjective and a verb and a noun, depending on how you look at it. It's one of those words. It means everything, depending which way you interpret it, right? And the first truth you have to come to terms with is that you're not perfect, and you're going to make mistakes that all that requires transparency. You're going to be able to hold up a mirror to yourself and say, Oh, that's what I look like. And and transparency breeds trust. And so, yes, I know that today's world is more complicated by, I guess, the speed of the spread of information, of digital media, of connectivity. But mind you, that's also the charm of today's world over the world I grew up in as a young person. So you know, the goods and the bads come together with everything.
Ajay BangaAnd so my view is that the best way to deal with the absence of trust is to drive even harder for transparency, and you set that example yourself. You can't ask other people to be transparent if you are not going to be transparent. And the one thing that our employees would tell you about me is that, with me, they know exactly where they stand. There are no secrets I will tell them if I think they're talking bunk right now, and I will tell them if I think they're doing a great job, they don't have to agree with me. I also tell them you're free to disagree, and I want you to find your own voice. That's kind of what I want our culture to be.
Ajay BangaThis questioning. Everything, every, always culture, right? That culture requires transparency and requires trust. Because how the heck are you going to question me if you can't trust that I won't freak out on you if you question me, or if I do freak out on you at that moment, because I made a mistake, I won't hold it at heart, and I will realize that actually I'm glad Dov you raised this, that trust comes through transparency. And so, you know, yes, people are not trusting each other, but you're going to be transparent. And the last part, I'll pause to take what you were just saying, because I'll forget this is please, please. I'm deeply worried about the binary culture that somehow seems to have taken root in society, which is a yes or no, everything is black or white.
Ajay BangaThere are no grays in between. Unfortunately, life requires you to deal with a series of grays, and how you navigate your way through those is what determines how happy you feel later, and how involved you are with everybody, and how inclusive is your behavior, and how open are your arms to being hugged, and not just being hugged by people who look like you and walk like you and talk like you and grew up like you and went to the same schools as you and worked with you for 20 years, but by being hugged by people who don't look like you and didn't walk like you and didn't go to the same schools. And that, to me, is the magic of diversity. That is the real meaning of diversity.
Dov SeidmanWalk us through in your efforts to shape a culture that is respectful but questioning, that is built to navigate the gray. Values were not invented for the easy black and white decisions. Values were invented for tough decisions, for trade offs, for for dilemmas, for navigating the gray. And I think it's fair to say that you believe that you should win via decency, not with decency, as though it's an extra obligation.
Ajay BangaOh yeah, oh yeah, but you should win first. Yeah, it's important. Because you're in a business organization that cannot do all the good things you think you can do with it if you're not winning, because that that there's no blood in the in the in the body, right? So you need to win, but how you win and why you win is always is as important as the fact that you win, and that's the point about decency. You use the word culture, and then you went to values very quickly. And you're a student of philosophy, so I understand why you did that my way. I'm not a student of philosophy. My approach to it is...
Dov SeidmanYou're just a natural philosopher, but go ahead...
Ajay BangaI just, I'm just telling you what I think. Right? My view is that that culture is a difficult word to describe, but values are something I comprehend. I can put my arms around. Culture is kind of amorphous. It I don't know how to put my fingers around it. Values I can put my hand on.
Dov SeidmanMy definition of culture is how things really happen around this place, and what's the beating heart, what's animating it? Go ahead.
Ajay BangaAlright, so that's what excites me. And so I tried to describe the values I wanted our company to live by through a few words that I began to use over time, and the first was the one about listening, that you have to listen, but combined with that, and these are all the dichotomies, the grace on the one hand, you have to have the patience to listen, but on the other side of it, you have to have the urgency to do so.
Ajay BangaLeonardo da Vinci said, right that that knowing is not enough. You have to apply and being willing is not enough. You have to do that. That dichotomy, the patience to listen with the urgency to do most people struggle with that, but that's what life is about, because you're never going to have perfect information. And if you keep looking for perfect information, the train will pass you by on the station. You're going to be standing there. So you got to do you got to get on the train and go for the ride by reducing what risks you can and therefore that's the second part, which is you got to take a risk, because there is no reward without a risk, there is no arbitrage if there's no risk reward equation. But you've got to do it thoughtfully, which means, if you don't know enough about it, ask somebody if you think you know enough, still make sure you ask somebody else to take a look at that risk. So the second value, the first one was listening and urgency of doing. Second was thoughtful risk taking. And the last value that I was trying to imbibe into people was, therefore, you can't do all this. I can't persuade you to take a thoughtful risk with urgency, if I don't empower you. You to make a decision. But if I'm going to empower you, then you've got to be willing to be accountable, because if things go wrong, I need you to be able to stand up and say, I made a mistake before it goes too far wrong. If you shovel things under the carpet, only bad things happen in business, and I said, You got to bring your dq to work your decency quotient, which is your heart and your mind, so that people will follow you. They should feel your hand on their back, not on their face.
Dov SeidmanI think it's fair to say that you and I agree that the world has been reshaped in ways to fuse things that were kept apart. It's cliche to say, but I think there's truth that the business of business is no longer just business. The business of business, society, responsibility, humanity, climate, the future. What does stakeholder capitalism mean, especially in today's post pandemic world?
Ajay BangaSo I believe that businesses cannot prosper in a failing world, and therefore, in your own best self interest, is the idea of ensuring that the ecosystem around you is robust because you are there, and for you being there, right? That's the idea, my view, is that the world's problems lie on three sides of a triangle. One side of the triangle is the trade off between one and many. Again, we're back to grace, and this is economic inclusion, social inclusion, educational inclusion, health inclusion, whatever that. The other side of the triangle is the trade off between humanity and nature, climate, green, all the things we're struggling with today. And the reason the triangle, these two sides, stay up, is because the bottom side of the triangle is the one that is very strong and gives them the power to stay up. And that's the trade off between long term and short term. And there is too much incentive in society, in politics and companies, and parenting and schooling, in anything for short term solutions, you apply short term solutions to long term problems.
Ajay BangaThat's a band aid. Nothing wrong with the band aid for the short term it doesn't cauterize the wound and fix it. And so this is my way of explaining all this, which is that I embrace capitalism because it has done more in the last four decades to help reduce poverty, to help expand education, to help expand healthcare, to help expand many things, but it's done a lot of bad things along the way, the concentration of money, the impact on our climate, this inequality, this climate inequality, those two sides of the triangle. They don't work for me and they don't work for my children, and they don't work for you and they don't work for your children. So the triangle is very much a part of how I think about circumstances I encounter. But remember, everyday business doesn't neatly fit into that triangle, but the triangle gives you a way of thinking, and that way of thinking is the framework. I mean, I told you, we made a tough choice around jobs last year, so our profitability went down. It's been in my 11 years as CEO. It is the first year in which we didn't go profits compared to the prior years, when we took the decision to not lay off people, we took the decision to absorb that hit, right? It's a tough hit, but it's the right hit for the long term. You know why? Because those very people are far more loyal today, and by the way, the skills they had and the capabilities they have is what's made our company who they are and what it is. So I have no doubt that some people will choose to leave. Others won't perform as well, and we may have to part company with them. We may have duplicate people in some places where we buy another company. These things happen. I got it, and those things need to be fixed, but not because of the pandemic. That's the moral imperative of that decision.
Ajay BangaThat's the long term, short term trade off of that decision.
Dov SeidmanThe pandemic just accelerated and presented you with the decision, but it was your moral triangle that you brought to the decision that the pandemic tested you with in some ways, yes. So as we wrap up, Aja, you shared so much. There's a there's a teletic adage that what comes from the heart enters the heart. And what I love about you is that you are unabashed about that, yeah, that you think the heart makes the world go around one piece of advice to this next generation, and then just one or two more things. And we'd like, I'd love to wrap up, I know you have a busy day still ahead.
Ajay BangaI think the one piece of advice I'd give you is to never discount luck. Life is. 50% luck. And you know, all the things I'm describing, I've gone through bad days with the same behavior, and good days with the same behavior. This heart on your sleeve also gets me into trouble. And so luck has to be there for you. You know what you do with the luck is what describes the other 50%
Dov SeidmanAnd you're actually wrapping up this conversation in full circle by acknowledging that half of life is luck. Isn't that the greatest expression of your deep value of humility? Because if you're not humble, you're going to think you did it all yourself.
Ajay BangaSo you certainly didn't. You certainly you know there, but for the grace of God, go I kind of thing, right? So don't forget that.
Dov SeidmanBut the acknowledgement of the role luck plays is what is, what makes it, keeps somebody humble.
Ajay BangaIt's the truth. It's the truth. So the truth will set you free,
Dov SeidmanRight? So indeed, and in your case, smooth seas have never created a great mariner. And the way you've sailed rough seas, always with decency is is a real, enduring example to so many others that look up to you and follow you. Close this conversation with what gives you hope, moral leaders, such as yourself. A moral leader is a purveyor of hope. So in the spirit of purveying hope, what should we tap into to be hopeful?
Ajay BangaI mean, human beings are nothing if not hopeful. So what allows us to be the superior beings on this planet is hope. Because hope has made us innovate. Hope has made us quest for new frontiers. Hope it made has made us competitively paranoid. Hope has made us everything. So my belief is that optimism and hope is innate to human life, and so why would you ever give that up? I don't give it up. I'm an eternal optimist, but that's part of what makes me who I am.
Dov SeidmanAjay. It's been a genuine pleasure to be together online next time in person, but thank you for embracing this HOW Conversation and sharing from the heart and imparting really exquisite wisdom. Thank you, Ajay.
What does it take to lead with purpose when the stakes are high - and across very different worlds? In this HOW Conversation, Dana Born sits down with Bob McDonald, former Chairman, President, and CEO of Procter &...
What does it take to lead when everything around you is changing? In this HOW Conversation, former 7-Eleven and Blockbuster CEO James Keyes joins HOW Fellow Dana Born to explore why great leadership isn't about avoiding...
In moments of uncertainty, leadership is revealed. Former U.S. Sec Def Mark Esper joins Dov Seidman for a conversation about the principles that guide leaders through crisis, complexity, and change. Reflecting on his...
What does moral leadership look like across generations of change? In our latest HOW Conversation, HOW Fellow Dana Born sits down with David Kohler, Chair and CEO of Kohler Co., to explore what it takes to lead with...
In this HOW Conversation, Elise Awwad, President and CEO of DeVry University, shares a deeply personal and practical perspective on moral leadership in a rapidly changing world. From her early lessons shaped by her...