[Archive Interview from Jun 15, 2023] “I don’t think there is such a thing as leadership without ethical or moral leadership,” Deval Patrick tells Dana Born on this episode of HOW Conversations. The Honorable Patrick served two terms as the governor of Massachusetts, the first Black person to serve in that role. He is now a professor of practice and the co-director of the Center for Public Leadership at the Harvard Kennedy School. Watch the discussion with Governor Patrick and Distinguished HOW Fellow, Dana Born, that touches on leading during crisis, the need for moral leadership in a democracy, and why he believes that leaders can be kind and generous but still have the tough-mindedness to make hard choices. “It is about struggling with the conflicts that you will always find as a leader, as a human being for that matter, between the thing you think you need to do that’s expeditious or seems convenient at the time, and the right thing over time.” READY TO START YOUR MORAL LEADERSHIP JOURNEY? Moral leadership is more imperative today than ever before. The HOW Institute for Society was founded on the belief that those in positions of formal authority should also have moral authority. We are creating the tools leaders need to make principled, ethical and values-based decisions. We are a nonprofit organization dedicated to building a world rooted in deep human values and trust in our social fabric. The Institute channels philosophical reasoning to address modern problems. Today, HOW we do what we do matters more than ever and in ways it never has before. Learn more at https://thehowinstitute.org/
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
IntroductionWelcome to the How Institute for Society's podcast, HOW Conversations where we talk with courageous and authentic leaders about how we can build and nurture a culture of moral leadership throughout society. What does it mean to be a moral leader today who has moral authority in our society? What should we expect of our leaders during a crisis, and what are the moral leadership frameworks our leaders are using to navigate through these challenging times? These are just some of the nuanced questions our hosts cover in their discussions with CEOs, military generals, educators, philanthropists and other leaders about the importance of moral and ethical decision making. And now here's the HOW Institute for Society, Senior Distinguished Fellow, Brigadier General Dana H. Born, United States Air Force Retired.
Brigadier General Dana H. BornWell, welcome to another HOW Conversation on moral leadership. We have an incredible guest with us today, the former governor of Massachusetts, Deval Patrick, so governor, do we still call you governor? Governor Deval Patrick, welcome back. We're looking forward to this conversation. Thank you. It's great to be with you. Former governor of Massachusetts, Deval Patrick is an American politician, but he's also a civil rights lawyer, author, as well as a businessman with an incredible background, and I'm trying to share a little bit of your background, I'm sure in our conversation we'll unpack this and add a little bit more to the tapestry of your life and your leadership. Raised by a single mother in the south side of Chicago who moved to Massachusetts as a teenager and earned a scholarship to the prestigious Milton Academy in Massachusetts at eighth grade and the first in your family to attend college, and also went to Harvard College and Harvard Law School, appointed by President Bill Clinton to be the Assistant US Attorney General for Civil Rights in 94 and then general counsel to many businesses, including Texaco, which later merged with Chevron and also Coca Cola. Your governorship, you were elected in 2006 two terms, then through to 2015 and the first black governor of Massachusetts briefly ran for president in 2019 and currently is a professor of practice at the Harvard Kennedy School of Government
Deval PatrickThank you so much, Dana, it's great to be with you.
Brigadier General Dana H. BornGreat to have you here. Let's journey into our conversation now to go back a little bit into your upbringing, share with us a little bit about your upbringing and the people and experience that shaped who you are today and the leader you have become, and maybe even as I know you as a learner and a leader, are becoming.
Deval PatrickWell, to go all the way back, you mentioned that I grew up on the south side of Chicago, and I've talked many times about how at that time in the 50s and the 60s, every child was under the jurisdiction of every adult on the block. So, you know, you messed up down the street in front of Miss Jones. She'd straighten you out as if you were hers, and then call home. So you got it two times. What those adults were trying to get across to us was that membership in a community is understanding that you have a stake in your neighbor's dreams and struggles as well as your own. And that lesson in community has been incredibly important to me, more meaningful frankly, as I have gotten older and as I have taken leadership opportunities that we are stronger together when we turn to each other rather than on each other, and that's the kind of leader I have tried to be. I think the other lesson is one every one of us gets from our grandparents, right, that we're supposed to do what we can to leave things better for those who come behind us, whatever it is, it doesn't have to be the, you know, the grand gesture. It doesn't have to be the big elected office or anything like that. It has to be. It has to do with how you not so much what you do, but but who you are, how you behave
Brigadier General Dana H. BornWell, you honor your grandparents, and you know you share that they're refugees from the Jim Crow South, and they really embedded in you how you are inspired to see the humanity in everyone, which is one of the principles of moral leadership. You know, how did that influence your public leadership journey through, you know, many avenues, including your co director role now.
Deval PatrickFirst of all, let me just say that you're telling me that I honor my grandparents is one of the nicest things anyone can say, they were extraordinary people who in the 1930s I think it was left Kentucky, where they had grown up, and moved to Chicago, as so many people did in the so called Great Migration, so many black people did. And I think what I took from my grandfather's way. Of living was that he saw the dignity in every living soul, everyone it didn't mean even frankly, you know, when we would take our monthly drives over a weekend back down to Louisville to visit family, and in those days, you know you had to bring enough food for the trip and a slop jar, if you know what I mean, because you didn't know where you could stop to go to the bathroom. Even the folks who treated him, you know, this grown man with a lack of dignity, he responded with dignity. And I think it's so many cases I, I can think of, he seemed to draw that out of other people that it was there was power in his example. So so many different kinds of influences of that, of that kind around the importance of human dignity that that I took from him. And then, of course, there were other adults in the neighborhood. Ms Jones, like I talked about teachers in the in the schools who loved us and helped us raise our expectations of ourselves.
Brigadier General Dana H. BornYeah, I want to share another wonderful quote that you have shared publicly, and it's the quote if you think about the big challenges that face humankind today. Some have their roots and shortcomings in leadership. We have people in many senior positions who have thought hard about how to become a leader, but not how to be a leader. How do you become a better leader? One who's more focused on moral leadership?
Deval PatrickI think, first of all, in the political world, although I don't think these lessons are limited to politics, but in the political world, one of the phenomenons I've I've observed is, is it there an awful lot of folks who have spent a lot of time thinking about how to be, how to become this or that, not why they should not, not what it is they want to actually accomplish. And the there's so much premium placed on, you know, kind of harvesting and storing up your political capital. But if you actually want to do something, you have to spend that political capital. You have to be willing to lose, it seems to me. And I think while I honor folks who have made a career of public office, particularly elective office, and there are some remarkable people in service today who bring a servant leadership approach to it, but I will say, I have to tell you, when you think about the big challenges that face us today, from the climate crisis to loss of confidence in democracy itself, to sectarian and religious and racial division to frankly, you know, I'm a capitalist, to the loss of confidence in capitalism. So many of these challenges have their roots in, as I said, and as you quoted, or are touched by a lack of leadership and unwillingness of the folks who have a chance to reset the tone and the dialog, to call us to a higher and better place and to work for it, not just to hope for it, but to work for it. As my grandmother would say, there is risk in that right. There is risk of ridicule. There's risk of of of, you know, being overwhelmed by the cynicism that is all around us today. There's risk of failure, being called to that higher place and then not being able to actually achieve it. But when they do, and when they believe the leader believes they have it in them, amazing things happen.
Brigadier General Dana H. BornWhat are some pieces of advice to people in those fields of education, business and elected leaders that you would provide in terms of advancing our shared democracy, some maybe top, top things that they can do and be to advance shared democracy.
Deval PatrickWell, I think you start with listening, you know, there's, there's a, I'm a great believer in grassroots campaigning, and that's that was our approach when I ran for governor, partly because it was the only way practically to break into a very tight and inward looking political establishment here in Massachusetts, but also because philosophically, I believe there are an awful lot of people, As I was saying earlier, who have checked out, who feel left back and left out of their own civic and political future, and showing up not with all the answers, because nobody really has all the answers, and no one person, no one party, has a corner on all the best ideas, but to ask questions, to. To engage people. There's power in that right. In addition to real information, there is power in inviting people to see their stake in their own civic and political future. And I think that's true in business as well.
Deval PatrickI used to say, you know, I learned, to some extent, how better to manage a large state government, having worked in large corporations, because, you know, if you don't go talk to middle management and get their understanding and influence on the agenda, you think you have that you think you want to drive and have them refine how to do it, or tell you all the reasons why it was tried a decade ago and didn't work then and won't work now, and why there are other things that are more important then you just miss the opportunity to get real success out of your agenda and the very best out of what, out of what the lead the followers have to have to offer.
Brigadier General Dana H. BornI'm going to take us back now, if you don't mind, to 10 years ago in 2013 when you were the governor of Massachusetts and we had the horrific Boston Marathon bombing. You know that was obviously a critical time for your leadership and an aspect of trying to lead during crisis and tragedy. So what did you get right looking back, and also, what are some of the things if you were to do it all again, you might do differently, or what you learned leading during that difficult time.
Deval PatrickThere was some element of kind of stepping into a void and doing it in a way that was again, about servant leadership. What do other people need? Right? We had, we had the law enforcement folks who were trying to solve the crime. We had the medical community that was trying to save the hundreds of of life threatening injured who'd who'd made it to hospital, and then we had a community that was reeling and afraid in circumstances where often people will turn on each other rather than to each other, right? And it's a natural thing, and it happens. And so I think trying to sort out all the different ways we had to respond and assure that we had the right leaders in the room for those lanes, and that they felt supported by me. So the question I was always asking is, what do you need? What do you need? How can I help? What can we cut through? And then, you know, I had some great advice from my Chief of Staff at the time, who said, you know, every other emergency you've managed, you have given information to the public, but you've also asked the public to look out for each other, right, to check in during a blizzard on their elderly neighbor, or a power outage, or some other kind of emergency.
Deval PatrickAnd he said, you know, you ought to do that here too. And and so we started, after the very first press conference, to call out the acts of grace and kindness that people were showing the ways that folks would bring runners into the into their homes when the race was called, who were disoriented and dehydrated, and get them water and get them warmed up and explain what was happening and help them get reconnected with their families. There were all kinds of acts like that through that whole week that we kept elevating. And as we elevated them, they prompted other people to show those acts of grace, and in fact, I think that has as much or more to do with Boston Strong as as anything else.
Brigadier General Dana H. BornThe culture of kindness. I can share a personal story I've shared with you also where my former executive officer when I was active duty Air Force, was killed in Afghanistan and in an insider threat situation, and was an immigrant from Venezuela. His wife was running in the race that day, and was just short of the finish line, and had some traumatic experience based on that experience, and was swarmed by kindness to help her through that double trauma that she was experiencing. So I owe that to you and your leadership, that you created that environment and difficult right, because being a moral leader during these times where you know, it's not just doing the next thing right, but doing the next right thing.
Brigadier General Dana H. BornOftentimes it's pulling you in two different directions, which is probably why being torn and tired is a natural part of being a moral leader.
Deval PatrickDana, such an interesting thing. I've made this point in my class. I think that we have a marvelously talented group of students at the Kennedy School who are of a generation that frequently confuses cynicism with sophistication, and they think that there is something incompatible with kindness and generosity and tough mindedness as a leader, mental discipline and having to make the hard choices. And I just don't think that's true. I think that there, in fact, I don't think there is such a thing as Leadership Without ethical or moral leadership. There is, and it's not the same thing as being righteous, but it is about being right. It is about having a true north. It is about struggling with the conflicts that you will always find as a leader, as a human being, for that matter, between the thing you think you need to do that's expeditious or seems convenient at the time and the right thing over time.
Brigadier General Dana H. BornAnd, yeah, I love how you phrase that as kindness is sort of, you know, it's part of your centering. You know, when you are being pulled in directions, where you're having to decide where somebody's not going to be happy with your decision, but what is your prevailing value. And you know, you're affiliated with the Harvard Kennedy School Center for Public Leadership, co director, also a great friend of our founder, Dov Seidman, and also the HOW Institute for Society and moral leadership. And we talk about effective public or effective moral leaders having a very strong moral courage. I love the word cur, because courage is Heart, heart maybe kindness go together, but there's also this sense of being not just having moral courage and strength, but also being humble and recognizing our own vulnerabilities. So how have you integrated the desire to portray strength and expertise and courage, along with that desire to maybe listen and ask for help. You know, what's your playbook for how you challenge this, you know, dynamic and how it is that, how do you, I guess, follow your compass in that being strong, but also being humble.
Deval PatrickI love that question. I love that question because I think humility is is one of the handful of key qualities of a successful leadership. And I will say that every of a successful leader, and every time I've gotten in trouble, it's because I've, you know, I've forgotten myself and gotten a little a little carried away. I had a great teacher at Milton Academy. I think of him every single day, an English teacher named A.O. Smith. You know, he'd ask us to recite a a passage from a poem or a novel that we were studying. And if we didn't, if we really didn't get it, or it was clear we hadn't read it, it would make us stand up in the class and face the class and say, I am ignorant, Mr. Smith, and you know, it was a small class, but it was still embarrassing for a bunch of 14 year olds and and he explained.
Deval PatrickHe said, You can't learn until you acknowledge what you don't know. And there is power in acknowledging what you don't know. What I have found, he did not say this, but what I have found is that in any number of settings, when you acknowledge you don't know, people come right forward to help. You know they do step up.
Brigadier General Dana H. BornThat's fabulous. And you know, we're humans, and everybody knows humans are imperfect, and so if we try to project perfection, people look for the chinks in our armor. Well, let's move into the fact that you are devoted to developing principled public leaders at the Center for Public Leadership and with our fellows and the Kennedy School, and also invested in the development of next generation leaders and moral leaders here with the HOW Institute for Society. So my question has to do with a piece of additional advice. What would you like to leave for developing moral leaders in the next generation of key maybe some things that you haven't shared yet, or maybe it's re emphasizing some of the things you've shared in this how conversation on moral leadership. Some advice for the next generation, emerging leaders, moral leaders.
Deval Patrickthink, you know, I taught a course this year, this past spring, that one of the newly graduated students helped me design that we called principles and politics when running for office, and it was not a how to course. It was more about how to center your why. As a would be candidate, really focus on what it is you want to do with this or that elective office and. How to come back to that when the sharp elbows of politics come out, and one of the most poignant classes in that course was about opposition research, and people talking about how this or that in their background made them ashamed of stepping out and having that thing, whatever it is, be made public. And, you know, in a class of 100 people, it's hard to get people to be that intimate. But we, we, we had amazing conversations, trusting conversations within parameters we'd set down on the first day of class. And people told all kinds of stories, and I told some of my own, and I said, you know, we're all broken. We're all broken. Maybe one way to think about your brokenness is to make that a part of your story, because it's not just our leaders who are broken, it's the lead. It's the followers who are broken too. And maybe the healing is something we do together. Maybe that's also an element of our civic life. You do that, I think we've talked about this of both mental toughness, your sense of what's right, and also humility.
Deval PatrickBecause, as I said, no, no person, no party, has a corner on all the best ideas. And so I think there is a way to think about principled, effective, public leadership. I want conviction. I don't want just people who are polling to figure out what they care about, but who allow for surprise, allow for the insight that that you get because you've made a point of engaging most especially with the people who are so often left out and left back and who aren't feeling like they are heard, which, it turns out, I think, is most people nowadays.
Brigadier General Dana H. BornAnd I'm wondering if we can go back to what I hear from you, and maybe it's some of your grandmother coming through who you honor of hope for the best and work for it, I think is what you said that she said to you, so what gives you hope for the future, and what are you working towards for that future?
Deval PatrickWell, I, you know, it'll sound a little like a cliche to say that young people give me hope, but I have, I remember, like everybody else, or so many of us, being stuck inside or in one place during covid, which is funny, it was either a couple of years or a decade. It's completely messed with time. But after the George Floyd video that so many people from so many different backgrounds in so many different places in this country and around the world, were out in the streets day after day, overwhelmingly peaceful, sort of putting their collective foot down and saying, you know, We don't have to do this the same way in the in the future. And I think the what was particularly striking, in addition just to the breadth of empathy for the for the tragedy we saw, was that it was sustained and in a place of famously short attention span that I think gave me tremendous amount of hope, because I think that the the point was not just about how to reimagine this, you know, kind of old fashioned notion of consistent professionalism from the police, but the notion that, you know, actually, there is humanity and dignity in everyone, including George Floyd, and that we can see that and Honor that, and we can behave accordingly. So I'm encouraged. I'm encouraged by that. I will say, I worry too that the strong conviction we hear from so many of the students at the Kennedy School, for example, which is so is so inspiring. I sometimes tease them that they have more certainty than they do actual experience. But that's okay, that they don't always leave room for folks who don't already agree with it, that they aren't they, they, they, they feel some. Some tension, some conflict, between the strength of their convictions and their and their curiosity about other people's views or how they how other someone else may take the same set of circumstances, the same facts and reach a different conclusion. And I worry about that, because I think politics is supposed to be about how you manage those differences in a society, how you work those out.
Deval PatrickAnd you work those out, not in not not just through power, I get that part, but you also work those out through persuasion and and the willingness to engage across differences is is, is a worry alongside the hopefulness that that so many young people are calling On so many of the rest of us, each other and the rest of us to be and do better.
Brigadier General Dana H. BornWe are so grateful from the HOW Institute for Society, and for your dedication to developing moral leaders and being an example of moral leadership, recognizing we're not perfect, but we're on this journey, and it's really worthwhile, and for creating a wave together with us, we salute you, we honor you, we thank you for the time and the wisdom you've shared with us today.
Deval PatrickThank you so I'm so touched that you would include me. I appreciate it.
What does it take to lead with purpose when the stakes are high - and across very different worlds? In this HOW Conversation, Dana Born sits down with Bob McDonald, former Chairman, President, and CEO of Procter &...
What does it take to lead when everything around you is changing? In this HOW Conversation, former 7-Eleven and Blockbuster CEO James Keyes joins HOW Fellow Dana Born to explore why great leadership isn't about avoiding...
In moments of uncertainty, leadership is revealed. Former U.S. Sec Def Mark Esper joins Dov Seidman for a conversation about the principles that guide leaders through crisis, complexity, and change. Reflecting on his...
What does moral leadership look like across generations of change? In our latest HOW Conversation, HOW Fellow Dana Born sits down with David Kohler, Chair and CEO of Kohler Co., to explore what it takes to lead with...
In this HOW Conversation, Elise Awwad, President and CEO of DeVry University, shares a deeply personal and practical perspective on moral leadership in a rapidly changing world. From her early lessons shaped by her...