[Archive Interview from Dec 3, 2020] "We’re never going back to life as it was in January 2020," says Darren Walker, President of the Ford Foundation. Darren spoke with Dov Seidman, the Founder and Chairman of the HOW Institute for Society on this episode of HOW Conversations. In a post-COVID world, “moral leaders see themselves as part of something bigger than themselves,” says Darren. And to meet the challenges of the post-COVID world moral leaders will need a new set of skills including, “empathy, compassion, humility, curiosity and grace.” Darren and Dov discussed finding shared truths and building trust, the characteristics of a moral leader and leading through nuance. Darren explains the imperative for finding hope during times of crisis and the importance of empathy in society. READY TO START YOUR MORAL LEADERSHIP JOURNEY? Moral leadership is more imperative today than ever before. The HOW Institute for Society was founded on the belief that those in positions of formal authority should also have moral authority. We are creating the tools leaders need to make principled, ethical and values-based decisions. We are a nonprofit organization dedicated to building a world rooted in deep human values and trust in our social fabric. The Institute channels philosophical reasoning to address modern problems. Today, HOW we do what we do matters more than ever and in ways it never has before. Learn more at https://thehowinstitute.org/
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
IntroductionWelcome to the HOW Institute for Society's podcast, HOW Conversations where we talk with courageous and authentic leaders about how we can build and nurture a culture of moral leadership throughout society. What does it mean to be a moral leader today who has moral authority in our society? What should we expect of our leaders during a crisis, and what are the moral leadership frameworks our leaders are using to navigate through these challenging times? These are just some of the nuanced questions our hosts cover in their discussions with CEOs, military generals, educators, philanthropists and other leaders about the importance of moral and ethical decision making. And now here's the HOW Institute for Society, founder and chairman and the host for today's podcast. Dov Seidman.
Dov SeidmanWelcome to the next in our series of how conversations brought to you by the HOW Institute for Society. It's especially meaningful to welcome Darren Walker to this HOW Conversation, where together, we will discuss the unique imperative of a reshaped world, a world that operates differently and presents leadership imperatives and implications that are profoundly different than they used to be. Darren is the president of the Ford Foundation, a 13 billion international philanthropy. He's also on the boards of the Lincoln Center, the National Gallery of Art at Carnegie Hall.
Dov SeidmanTime has included Darren as one of the 100 most influential people. Welcome Darren for and thank you for being with us.
Darren WalkerThank you, Dov, looking forward to this.
Dov SeidmanSo why don't we start you and I speak often about the pause, and to echo Ralph Waldo Emerson, it's in the pause as people, as humans, as leaders, that we hear the call. A lot's been going on in the world. There's a combustion of simultaneous crises, humanitarian crises, health crises, unemployment crises, racial injustice crises, they're all coming together. You have profound leadership responsibilities, but I know that in the midst of it all, you do find time to pause. Where are you? How have you been? I'm finding you in what state of mind right now, Darren,
Darren WalkerI am in a state of mind of feeling very privileged. I think the reality Dov is that for most of us who are fortunate enough to lead organizations to have some semblance of economic security, we're all doing fine. Our problems, while they may be, problems or obstacles in our everyday life, are minor, are insignificant in the total scheme of things when we look at the problems of the world and the conditions that most people in our country are having to cope with, people like you and me have absolutely nothing to complain about.
Dov SeidmanSo you said that because you're in a state of privilege, and compared to those in the front lines and who've run to the front lines to save lives, and those who have been so harmed and impacted, you've also said, because of this privilege and the installation that we enjoy, There's an opportunity, if not an obligation to pause and redesign some of our lives and and come out on the other side with a more clear sense of how we can make a more positive difference.
Dov SeidmanTake us into your pause. What are you reimagining? What are you redesigning or recommitting to in this time?
Darren WalkerWell, I have decided that, you know, time and space is now organized through the prism of before COVID And in a post COVID world, what will this new PC World be? And I think what I'm hoping is that one we realize first that the BC world is over. We are never going back to January of 2020, we are never going to live in that world again. That doesn't mean that our future will be dystopian, that we are headed for some apocalypse. It does mean, however, that we as leaders are going to have to rethink what leadership means.
Darren WalkerOn how we engage in the world, and the skills and tools and capabilities that we will need to successfully lead, and I believe that is going to present some tremendous challenges for leadership, because there's never been a time when it is more difficult and sometimes onerous to lead, because the systems within which we manage and lead are increasingly complex and demand of us More of our time, it seems and are increasingly stressful, stressful because of the velocity, the intensity of social media and technology, which, if you are a leader, even in a decentralized organization, places tremendous pressure on you to respond, to stay ahead of and it just adds stress. So one of the things that I think we leaders are going to have to do in this PC World is learn how to deal with stress
Dov SeidmanAnd also have the empathy to understand that everybody else is trying to and struggling with stress. So there's a premium on on empathy and trying to really internalize the stress everybody else must be feeling.
Darren WalkerThis goes back to where you started and when we began this conversation that everything that we are experiencing we have to put into context. In order to put things into context, as a leader, we need to possess the ability to contextualize. That ability comes from in part, empathy, compassion, a sense of humility, curiosity and grace. These are not necessarily the skill set of leaders in a BC world, but in a PC World, it won't be an option.
Darren WalkerIt's mandatory.
Dov SeidmanAnd these these elevated qualities of character and human capacities weren't always thought of as strengths in the BC world, but I think you're saying in the PC world, they're not only strengths. They're essential leadership, leadership skills and attributes to be able to lead and there. And since you talked about putting things in context and you've gone right to the topic of leadership. Every year as president of the Ford Foundation, you write a letter where you're trying to explicitly frame the context in which the Ford Foundation aspires to make an impact. And last year, you redefine the Ford Foundation's focus and imperative as really pursuing philanthropy insofar as it yields a more just society and elevates justice in terms of its central focus. And I believe, and this year, in furtherance of that, you were very explicit.
Dov SeidmanYou dedicated your entire annual letter to the topic of leadership, and you actually titled it the imperative of moral leadership. And you say moral leadership of all kinds in every movement and institution, organization and community, is a prerequisite of positive change. Speak a bit about some of the forces that you think are operating in the world and why they call for the leadership that you're describing, this imperative of moral leadership,
Darren WalkerIt's very challenging. The reality is, you and I are capitalists. We believe that the best way to organize an economic system is through the mechanism of capitalism. The reality of this moment, this time we're living in, is that there is tremendous profit to be realized in fomenting division. There is tremendous money to be made in the business of hate, and therefore in a capitalist system, this intersection the collision of democracy, morality and capitalism. Will capitalism win? I don't think. I think without moral leadership, it is hard to imagine how the simply incentive structure. Of our system won't ensure that we lose we lose our moral standing in the world. We lose our ability to within our own country, to really be the voices that are needed at this time, because the incentives, whether it these are the incentives in the political system or the incentives and the economic system, are propelling us to more division. They are rewarding those who would seek to divide. And so for those of us who believe that this, this really untenable dynamic of this binary construct of everything being black or white, like or dislike, if we don't intervene, I I fear for our country. I fear for our nation. So to me, I'm I think, you know, we're out, we're at the we're on a precipice in this country
Dov SeidmanIn many ways, just to echo back what I hear you say, I mean, I think you and I have talked about, for you, mentioned capitalism, for dynamic capitalism to flourish and be sustainable, for vibrant democracy, for healthy, strong communities and societies that they all have to rest on the twin pillars of shared truth and trust, and right now, both truths are being assaulted, and it's getting harder to share in them. And I'm not just talking about reality. Does a mask work, or does a mask not work in terms as fighting against a Corona, a Coronavirus, but deep moral truths around equality and justice. Can we share in a conception of those and if we can't share truths, then trust is eroded. So I think in many ways, what you're saying is there's an imperative of moral leadership, because moral leaders are purveyors. They trust people with the truth, and they create virtuous cycles of more trust, because we're starting in a shared truth.
Darren WalkerAnd I think moral leaders Dov. I believe moral leaders see themselves as part of something bigger than themselves. And I think that kind of thinking is inconsistent with with the thinking of many leaders in this country today, I have seen leaders who say, you know, it's about the individual. It's about me and my leadership, my responsibility, my my freedom. So we hear words that have great currency and contemporary culture, like individual rights, freedom, what we don't hear leaders talking about our community, our collective responsibilities to each other, service, yeah, and so I think, I think part of it is we, we have to admit that, at least in my view, the cult of the individual crowds out the space for moral leadership, because I believe that we are a little too self centered
Dov Seidmanin your in your letter and to this point, and I'd like to quote you, We are, as Lincoln suggested at Gettysburg, facing a great test, but with moral leadership, can and will pass it. With moral leadership, this can and will be a moment in Lincoln's words, for a new birth of freedom, an opportunity to rebuild and be more perfect. And what's interesting is there's freedom from authority, from a micromanaging boss. You know, we know how to get freedom from. We cast off authorities and all the powers that you know hold us down and subjugate us. But the freedom in our constitution is not freedom from it's freedom to pursue happiness. It's a freedom to be yourself, to speak your mind, to pursue whatever religion and faith is in your heart. And we know that freedom from is created structurally, but freedom to is enabled through community of shared truths, through proper governance, through moral leadership. So is this really a time, therefore, to be on a journey of moral leadership?
Dov SeidmanThat emphasizes and elevates all the ways in which we're in things together, and all that we have in common.
Darren WalkerWell, I think it is true. And I think in a a multiracial, pluralistic society like the United States, this idea of we are all in this together is fraying. It's fraying because even in the midst of this pandemic, there are many people who say, Well, yes, this pandemic is affecting our nation, but most of the people per capita who are dying are black and brown, and so this really isn't affecting me, so I should be able to just go on about my business, because the people who are really being harmed by this aren't people like me, and I think that kind of thinking is in some ways part of the challenge of building the the kind of collective spirit that we need And that and moral leaders have to be able to speak to this question of interdependency that some will say, well, but that doesn't relate to me, or that isn't as important for me, or it's going to be harmful for those people, those other people, but it's not really that harmful for me. How do we talk to our citizens, our workers, when, when that kind of thinking is the backdrop for many of the challenges that we face as a society? Well, if you live in Chicago, yes, there is a huge problem with shootings. But if you live on the north shore of Chicago, you have, you could live and not have any idea that in the same city, dozen the people are shot in a given week.
Darren WalkerAnd so the rules that might apply on the south side, really they don't need to apply to us on the north side, because we're in a different world. And so how do we lead in those contexts? You know? How do we lead a workforce when we have 1000s of workers, the workers who are African American, when you listen to their stories about policing, see a completely different experience than the workers who are white, when they share their stories about policing which are primarily positive, right? How do you manage a workforce to come together when that workforce has such divergent experiences based on their race? I think moral leadership says we have to understand that we all believe that every person should have dignity and that no one should feel treated differently, and when, when that happens, it happens to all of us. This was Dr King's message.
Dov SeidmanI'm confident saying that anybody that's been listening to you and will listen to you, that's going to tune into this conversation will be compelled by this imperative that something is that PC, post Coronavirus, we are forever changed. Our expectations of leaders are forever higher, there's going to be resonance. So I'd like to be a little bit more dynamic and bring out some of the impediments and challenges to being on this path of moral leadership. And let me so let's get a little didactic.
Dov SeidmanSo let me throw the first at you. People hear the word moral, and they go, Well, whose morality? Why your morality? And you've made a distinction. We've talked about it between being moralistic and moralizing and moral leadership. So I just want you on the record to bring to life the distinction between moralistic and moralizing leadership and moral leadership.
Darren WalkerAnd then we'll tie moral leadership is not moralizing. It's not didactic, it's not lecturing, it's not highly judgmental. Moral leadership is an understanding of a common way in which we want to be treated. COVID as human beings. It's a recognition in the idea of the dignity of all people, and it is a recognition that in a pluralistic society, we must continue to evolve to include and be inclusive, and the way in which we manage, we lead, we engage. And so for me, what moral leadership is about in this context is having courage. It is about having empathy it is managing in ways that demonstrate vulnerability, authenticity, being able to relate to others and their context, their situations, and so what it means for a university president, a public company CEO, a Foundation President, is that we are in these positions where people look to us. They look to us for guidance. They look to us as examples of leaders, of managers. Are we inclusive? Do we make room for divergent viewpoints? Do we engage with empathy, with authenticity, with curiosity around whatever the problem are we patient?
Dov SeidmanDarren, it comes down to the how moralizing is about. I've got the right moral answer. Moral leaders look at the world through a moral lens. Is it fair? Is it just? Are these conversations one way or two? Way? Am I including or excluding? So it's really about all the house that we that we've come together around. What is my relationship with authority? I know that you know that you know that I know that I pay your salary, so you're going to listen to me or actually forget that what's right based on our values and principles. So it's, and I think we're really trying to bring to life that moral leadership is really about what animates the leadership and what is it rooted in values,
Darren Walkerand it's not about and it's not, as you have said so well, Dov, it's not about title. It's not about having your name at the top of the masthead that doesn't make you a moral leader.
Dov SeidmanSo I think we're talking about who occupies positions of formal authority at a time where more people are looking to those in charge. They're looking to governors and mayors of blue and red states to transcend political differences and show us that they can connect and collaborate and coordinate to put people above politics, and they're looking for CEOs to put people above profits now more than ever in that way,
Darren Walkerand I think it's why, for example, there's been so much appreciation for Dr Fauci and many of the public health leaders who have guided us during this pandemic, I find that their their the credibility they have with the public, based on all polls, is higher than any other category of leaders in this pandemic, and That says something, because they are speaking from the perspective of of truth and facts. But there is a moral dimension to that. The moral dimension to that is, is that through bringing the evidence forward, people will make the right decisions. There is, there is a sense that they don't need to be didactic, be moralizing, but present the evidence and the facts and trust and that and those leaders will will be listened to.
Dov SeidmanWhat's also interesting is that these leaders often say that they don't know things.
Darren WalkerIt's a feature of moral leadership, where as we've discussed this idea of humility, of vulnerability, of uncertainty sometimes and and of being comfortable in that space, there are many leaders who feel that they must have all the answers, that they must stand at the top of the hill and lead the troops forward. But people actually.
Darren WalkerActually want to be led by people who are authentic. And part of authenticity is vulnerability, because if you are a human being, you actually don't have all the answers. And I think that curiosity is very important
Dov SeidmanIndeed. And there's another dimension of moral leaders. Moral leaders recognize, as they look through the world, through a moral end, they see dilemmas. They sometimes see two bad choices. They see that the tension right now between saving lives and livelihoods really feels an inexorable pull in opposite directions. And moral leaders are honest about we need to choose nonetheless, but both choices are painful there. What's your experience? Because you've written and talked about nuance in a binary world, in a world of follow, unfollow, like, unlike, how do you enlist people in a journey where the path ahead is gray and full of nuance?
Darren WalkerWell, Dov, let's start with the fact that I lead a foundation endowed by Henry Ford, a notorious anti Semite who in his lifetime did harm to Jewish people by spreading all sorts of tropes and inaccuracies and outright falsehoods. He also was a genius who transformed American capitalism, and in the process, was the first industrialist to name any quality as a problem and ensure that his workers were paid a wage that dignified their work and that allowed them to indeed by the very products that they were making on the assembly line. I am able to hold both of those narratives, and that requires nuance. There are some who have said that, you know, the Henry Ford story is simply that he was an anti Semite.
Darren WalkerThat's it. There's nothing more worth knowing. And why do you even have his name on the foundation? And there are others who say, Why do you have to talk about that unpleasant stuff? He was the founder of modern American automobile manufacturing, etc, etc. I don't agree with both of those. With either of those, sorry. I don't agree with either of those. I think we must be able to hold the narratives, the dualities of the complexity of a man like Henry Ford. That doesn't mean that that we need to put a statue up tomorrow of Henry Ford, but it does mean that we have to recognize that he played an indelible role in building this nation, and that he created a philanthropy that has done much good in the world.
Dov SeidmanIf there were statutes of Henry Ford in different places and people forget about putting one up. If they were called to tear them down, what would you say?
Darren WalkerI would say, No, you don't tear Henry Ford statue down. You may contextualize the statue. You may look to the work of the Ford Foundation today and examine what it is doing to balance some of the things Henry Ford did. I think it's, it's fair to say, you know, there's a lot that we're doing today that Henry Ford would never have imagined, right, beginning with the fact that a black gay man is the president of the foundation that bears his name,
Dov SeidmanRight? And what's so important here is that we are living in a time where the statues are being are coming down, and I think that pausing to split hairs and make distinctions between a Confederate and a non Confederate in the context of racial more racial awareness of both historic and modern day injustice matter. So I think part of what world leaders do is they help bring in this type of perspective to wrestle and split hairs and make distinctions so that we can navigate the nuance
Darren Walkerand it's it's difficult because splitting hairs, I couldn't agree with you more that moral leaders have to bring nuance that requires you. Splitting hairs requires really deeply interrogating. A particular context, so that you don't have a just an automatic reflexive view on any given question, such as the statues.
Darren WalkerBut there are frameworks and there are constructs. You know, for me, the construct around the Confederacy, which is that it was an effort to destroy the United States of America, completely discredits anyone who would be a part of that effort. So I would, I would not be in favor of raising a statue to any Confederate leader because the the enterprise was to destroy the United States of America.
Dov SeidmanWhat? What gives you hope? Because more...talk about hope.
Darren WalkerYeah, what gives me hope is seeing the young people in the streets of this country earlier this year joined hand in hand with older people, multi racial, multi generational, across America, indeed, Across the world, from Boise, Idaho to Staten Island, all coming together, asking, demanding, a country a world of more fairness, of more justice, of less inequality, of less injustice. That's what gives me hope, and I am a firm believer, as we at the Ford Foundation like to say, we are in the business of hope, and hope is the oxygen of democracy.
Dov SeidmanAnd Darren, and one more thing you've done recently, moral leaders also have the courage to ask the right questions, and you're a leader in a philanthropic context, and often in philanthropy, people ask this question, what, who should we give to and what we should give back? And you really have the courage to emphatically say, Let's not ask what we should give back. Let's ask what we should give up. And when somebody like you asks a question, what should we give up? That's a source of hope, because if people start giving up things, they create the room and the space for others to get to where they have gotten. So that's a source of hope when Leaders Ask profoundly the right questions, and I it's fair to say, you've gotten quite a response to asking that question, right?
Darren WalkerI have and that is one of the reasons I have hope. But Dov in closing, I have hope because of leaders like you and the work that you are doing at the HOW Institute, which I am delighted and greatly honored to be a part of. So thank you for having me today.
Dov SeidmanDarren, it's a genuine pleasure, and that you we are in common cause, and that you are a founding board member of the How Institute for Society as a source of meaning, and for me, hope. And thank you, Darren, for elevating the conversation and enriching and enlightening so many. All the best.
What does it take to lead with purpose when the stakes are high - and across very different worlds? In this HOW Conversation, Dana Born sits down with Bob McDonald, former Chairman, President, and CEO of Procter &...
What does it take to lead when everything around you is changing? In this HOW Conversation, former 7-Eleven and Blockbuster CEO James Keyes joins HOW Fellow Dana Born to explore why great leadership isn't about avoiding...
In moments of uncertainty, leadership is revealed. Former U.S. Sec Def Mark Esper joins Dov Seidman for a conversation about the principles that guide leaders through crisis, complexity, and change. Reflecting on his...
What does moral leadership look like across generations of change? In our latest HOW Conversation, HOW Fellow Dana Born sits down with David Kohler, Chair and CEO of Kohler Co., to explore what it takes to lead with...
In this HOW Conversation, Elise Awwad, President and CEO of DeVry University, shares a deeply personal and practical perspective on moral leadership in a rapidly changing world. From her early lessons shaped by her...