How do leaders navigate moments of profound loss, transformation, and hope? In this HOW Conversation, Dana Born sits down with Dr. Beth Hillman - Air Force veteran, legal scholar, former president of Mills College, and now President & CEO of the 9/11 Memorial & Museum. Together, they explore lessons in moral courage, civic responsibility, and the power of education to shape not only informed citizens, but moral ones. Dr. Hillman shares her journey across the military, academia, and nonprofit leadership, offering insights on listening, pausing under pressure, and meeting people where they are. From stewarding memory at one of America’s most sacred sites to guiding institutions through change, this conversation highlights how values-driven leadership can inspire resilience and hope for the future. READY TO START YOUR MORAL LEADERSHIP JOURNEY? Moral leadership is more imperative today than ever before. The HOW Institute for Society was founded on the belief that those in positions of formal authority should also have moral authority. We are creating the tools leaders need to make principled, ethical and values-based decisions. We are a nonprofit organization dedicated to building a world rooted in deep human values and trust in our social fabric. The Institute channels philosophical reasoning to address modern problems. Today, HOW we do what we do matters more than ever and in ways it never has before. Learn more at https://thehowinstitute.org/
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
IntroductionWelcome to the How Institute for Society's podcast, HOW Conversations where we talk with courageous and authentic leaders about how we can build and nurture a culture of moral leadership throughout society. What does it mean to be a moral leader today who has moral authority in our society? What should we expect of our leaders during a crisis, and what are the moral leadership frameworks our leaders are using to navigate through these challenging times? These are just some of the nuanced questions our hosts cover in their discussions with CEOs, military generals, educators, philanthropists and other leaders about the importance of moral and ethical decision making. And now here's the HOW Institute for Society, Senior Distinguished Fellow Brigadier General Dana H Born United States Air Force, Retired.
Brigadier General Dana H. BornWell, welcome for another HOW Conversation on moral leadership with the HOW Institute for Society. I am just really thrilled. I think you can always tell on my voice and hopefully my expressions, that it's an honor to have with us as our guest and contributor today. Dr Beth Hillman, includes military service, her legal scholarship, as well as educational leadership and now stewardship of our national memory. As President and CEO of the 911 Memorial and Museum.
Dr. Beth HillmanDana, it's great to be here. It's really a privilege. I'm across the street from the 911 Memorial and Museum, and I have an office up high enough that I can see the memorial pools, and I have some of the books that I've picked up along the way from my academic and other journeys behind me here. So it's great to be with you.
Brigadier General Dana H. BornIt is fantastic. So Beth began her career similarly aligned with my Air Force career. She was an Air Force officer who served seven years as a Space Operations Officer in a very important area then Cheyenne Mountain Air Force Base, I think now we're space and also doing a lot of our Northern Command and behind the scenes in the mountain in Colorado. Then became a history professor at the Air Force Academy, and lot of educational assignments leading to the 14th president of Mills College, which for our listeners, was the first women's college west of the Rockies. That during your tenure as President, I know you focused a lot of your time and and heart and passion and energy into inclusivity and transformation through the covid times, as well as a merger with Northeastern University. So Dr Beth Hillman is leadership personified and exemplifies moral courage, civic responsibility as well as and not the least of a commitment that is profound in the way that you remember, and I would say how you remember as well as how we move forward together. So Dr Beth Hillman, it is just wonderful to have you with us in this HOW Conversation on moral leadership. Welcome, and we're going to jump into our first question, which is really getting to know you a little bit more the person and the professional in terms of your journey that you've been on the zigs and zags of your life and your leadership, and who and what has inspired you and led to the way that you think about influencing today.
Dr. Beth HillmanYou know, like many people, I think my family of origin had the first impact. I chose the Air Force because my father served in the Army Air Force during World War Two. My parents certainly had a huge impact on me. My mom was very proud of the degree that she had earned. She studied dietetics at Seton Hill College, not too far from Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania where I grew up. And she did an internship in Rochester, New York that she was very proud of. But when she became pregnant with my oldest brother. I have four siblings. She left the workforce and didn't go back until my sister and I were in grade school. But I learned a tremendous amount from my parents, my siblings, my teachers and my coaches, and then when I got into the Air Force, I ended up in a purple service, command, us, Space Command, and I learned from officers of all the branches of service in the United States, as well as Canadian Forces folks.
Dr. Beth HillmanSo they were all really important in helping shape my own approach, which I didn't realize I was always developing. I was a little more self conscious about leadership and other young people because of the Air Force and the military's emphasis on developing leadership as a young you know, in its in its officers, because of the responsibility that they take on. But I didn't, I think, fully appreciate what I was getting from that until much later.
Brigadier General Dana H. BornBut I love how you describe yourself in terms of not only influencing, but you were who you were influenced by. And you've kind of described yourself that way in the past, as a cumulative sum of the parts, taking Lessons from each phase of your life. So in terms of leadership, how do you build and reinforce a personal framework that guides your decisions along vastly different roles which you have held and what are some of the constants right, the constant values that you lead with, regardless of which role that you are exemplifying or performing within.
Dr. Beth HillmanEarly on, when I was still a cadet in the Air Force ROTC and studying at Duke and I only studied electrical engineering because the Air Force gave me a scholarship in it. I probably would not have chosen it otherwise, but the Air Force was giving almost all of its scholarships in electrical engineering, and I wanted to get one. So I said, Sure, I'll be an electrical engineer. But while I was studying that, I one of my summers, I spent at the Pentagon in the Strategic Defense Initiative organization, and I worked with some senior officers, and they took a trip out to Colorado Springs, and we ran a lot of meetings and a lot of different places and a lot of different offices, and I didn't always know what was going on.
Dr. Beth HillmanThe language they were using was unfamiliar to me. The programs, the satellites that they were working on, weren't ones I was familiar with. I was at the very beginning of my understanding of Air Force, Space Command, as it was at the time. There was no space force, yet we were Space Command. And then US Space Command within the US Air Force. And after one meeting, I remember saying to one of the Colonels with us, I think I'm going to skip this next one. I said, I'm not really I'm not really sure I'm not really following everything that's going on. And he said, Oh yeah, definitely don't come. You might learn something. And I thought, Okay, I'm hearing that it's important to stay engaged, even when it might feel like not everything is clear, and I really think that's true. It's possible to learn from virtually every context. And so for me, a principle of leadership is realizing there's something to be gained from every conversation and every interaction with people, across organizations and across the communities of interest that we serve when we're in leadership positions. So it has really helped me to recognize, even if it's not all making sense as I encounter it, if I have the patience and the wherewithal to stick with it, it will actually help help me understand something better. And the next time I hear that, that jargon or that, that, next time I'm in something similar to that context, it will be a little bit easier.
Brigadier General Dana H. BornSo as you've moved through these new spaces and roles, especially ones thathistory and complexity are clearly deep. How do you approach this early period as you're going into new positions of listening and learning, and as you said, being patient in this new space, but also persistent in terms of practice and what kind of intentional principles help you as you build trust or try to build trust, to acclimatize to this new environment, because so many of us are going through these like into the new, you know, the imposter syndrome in this new role.
Dr. Beth HillmanYeah, I have learned from many of the folks I've encountered about what works, and I think as long as I keep keep listening, they keep teaching me new ways to do it. One, one of the constants for me has been meeting people, just physically, materially where they are. Some people use describe this as shoe leather. You know, you know, wearing out shoe leather meaning visit, visit faculty in their offices. Visit our visitor services staff on the plaza. Visit visit students in classrooms. Visit museum visitors, you know, as they encounter the the exhibits in the museum and and watch them and talk to them, I think that if I, if I, if I can bring people to the space that I'm in, and sometimes that's it's helpful to, you know, summon people or to invite people in, but actually getting out of the office that I'm in, much of the time, surrounded by books that are my provide some of my context and into where other people are. It makes a big difference here at the 911 Memorial and Museum, the memorial pools are a great example. We have a very complex physical plant at the 911 memorial and Museum, we essentially have a skyscraper that goes underground, seven stories down to bedrock where the World Trade Center towers, the twin towers once stood, and in the footprint of each of those towers is a pool. Each of them has 50 500,000 500,000 gallons of water circulating through them. There's massive pumps inside there, and to go with the engineers and look at the pumps and the filters and talk to them about that and recognize what they're managing, I'm never going to be the one who sets the pressure on the pump or responds to a problem when something happens on the Memorial Plaza, but for me to understand where they are and what they've done, I get a sense of the pride they have in their mission, and I also get a sense of the complexity of the problems they're solving every day. And I think when I when I get too far away from what people are doing, I lose sight of the challenges that they face, and it's tougher for me to understand and translate and support them. So I guess, you know, getting getting out there.
Dr. Beth HillmanAnd not being with people, where they're where they're working, where they're thinking, is a good thing for me.
Brigadier General Dana H. BornThat's awesome. And I love the the it's like the nothing makes the field in the farm go better than the farmers footsteps. It's also a practice for the HOW Institute and the the moral leadership framework of seeing the humanity in every person is a wonderful example, and from your heart, right? It's clear for our listeners, this is something that is a genuine care that you bring so working in many different organizations, you know, our nonprofits that you have served, military, educational institutions, they all come with, I don't like the term balance, because balance is bunk in my world, but maybe integrating, or because of your musical background, maybe harmonizing many different stakeholders and diverse and influential voices. What advice do you have for our listeners, for navigating those pressures and voices while executing really important tasks that you have at hand and serving the mission of the organization that you have really devoted and committed yourself to and leading.
Dr. Beth HillmanI think that's there's that plays out in different ways at different points in time, but I think you've hit on the fundamental challenge of trying to balance a commitment, a fidelity to mission with all of the interests that people invest institutions with. So they have preconceptions about what you should be doing that may not be aligned with the mission that you have, may not be aligned with the current circumstances or the future that you think is ahead of, ahead of the people and the place and the function that an institution is playing. So I think it's ultimately about navigating change. Sometimes I think it helps to show people how much things have changed, even as they feel so committed to a particular vision of that past. You know, history is a very dynamic thing. I mean literally. The way we understand history changes all the time is we learn different aspects of it, because there's so much happening at any point, we can't see everything all at once, and we privilege some aspects of a story over other aspects of the story. And then we realize another piece, and that one rises to sort of dominate perspective on something that happened in the past. I think too they need to know that you hear them, and that's really hard. Communicating is just hard, you know, I've long said to folks who work with me in academic institutions, just because you said something, students have not heard it and you haven't communicated because you've simply said something in one venue or one forum or in one particular way,
Brigadier General Dana H. BornIn terms of your being an educator in the classroom, but also, you know, an administrator In education now shaping public understanding of 911 which in the memorial and museum, you've remained deeply devoted to that education. So how do you see education as a vehicle for developing moral leadership? And I know you've focused a lot on the youth population, next generations, but you've also focused on all people who are having a touch point with the memorial in the museum.
Dr. Beth HillmanI think you know, we're all students in many respects. Of even, for instance, my children, I learned from my kids all the time, by the young people in my life have the capacity to change the way I understand the world and help keep me from from failing to reckon with what's happening around me all the time. So it's not just young people who need to learn. It's really all of us. And I think that education without some connection to to morality, makes very little sense. It's, it's, it's, it's a field that people study. Of course, it's, there's, there's particular experts in philosophy and ethics who can help us on this. But really, all of us make ethical and moral decisions about what we study and what we do and how we treat people every day. So education to be meaningful has to involve some some sense of first learning multiple moral frameworks, because there can't be just one that works all the time, and then trying to understand how that sense of what's right might might intersect with what's true and what's beautiful and what's effective. And I think, I think it's impossible to separate those things in any of the environments that I've learned and taught in. I think I feel like they've become intertwined very quickly.
Brigadier General Dana H. BornYeah, I hear you as saying the responsibility for educators, for all of us, but institutions in particular, to develop moral citizens, not just informed ones. And that resonates. I want to share with our listeners that you were a participant and contributor to our HOW Summit on Moral Leadership in New York City in December of 2024 and one of the topics we discussed there is the pause. And as you well know, you know, in the pause, we talk about four Rs of the framework of. How important it is, as Dov Seidman, our founder and chair, talks about, when you take a pause for a machine, it turns off, but a pause for a human, we actually start, and that's through a reflection, a reconnection and re thinking and then reimagining. So my question for you is on this pause notion to share, if you would, with our listeners, a moment where you felt under pressure and you needed to act quickly, or felt like you needed to act quickly, but instead you chose to pause and take time to do that reflection share with us. You know, what were your options and what were the consequences if you had moved forward and reacted.
Dr. Beth HillmanFirst, I'll say, I think I've not paused nearly enough. I find this a helpful framework when I encountered it, and I'm grateful that you're socializing this more broadly in people, because I do find it very instructive. When I got to Mills College, so I had been, I had been teaching for some time in classrooms and in different environments, in military training environments. I I taught orbital analysts when I was in Space Command in Colorado Springs, and then I I taught kids basketball when I was at the Air Force Academy. I I had, I had done a lot of different teaching other than academic, faculty, but I had come from teaching in law school, and I came to a liberal arts college, and when I arrived at Mills College, they were facing some financial challenges, and we had a significant budget deficit. So I started in July, and the board had just adopted in the month of June, a budget for the next year with a deficit larger than the college's line of credit. So I and that so that our fiscal year ran through June 30. So I was starting with, I was starting underwater, essentially, you know, we wouldn't have enough money to pay the bills through the end of the year, through June 30 of the year that I was starting, if we didn't make some changes. But I couldn't really say what to change instantly. I didn't, but I was under some pressure to decide quickly, so we sort of balanced that, and I had been spending time at the at the college prior to the starting date, actually, in that way that sometimes jobs overlap that you're working on closing out one while you're starting the next one. I talked to a lot of people, and I listened to them. I tried to bring the I tried to bring people in who were going to be most impacted by decisions that we made, and then ultimately, together, we decided to take a few steps immediately to reduce costs for the year, but to wait longer, some months to figure out over the months ahead of us. We probably took about six months to do this, to figure out what would be the larger steps that would start to address what was a structural deficit, meaning a deficit that occurred year over year, and that wasn't tied to sort of one time outcomes of a particular academic year of tuition and grants and all the other sources of funds and the expenses that the college incurred throughout the year.
Brigadier General Dana H. BornWow, and a powerful statement, starting underwater and with the pressures upon you, and yet the pause and the basketball analogy you gave of sometimes going faster isn't always a prudent approach. And so let me go back to saying thank you for participating and in your busy and very challenging role, an important role, leading the 911 memorial and museum. You took a pause to join us for the full day as much as you could for the HOW Summit. So thank you for that, and thank you also, on behalf of the HOW Institute for stewarding this leadership space, which is really focused on profound loss, courage and also resilience. And so the question, how has that enormous responsibility shaped your own leadership? And I want to say, particularly when it comes at, you know, trying to inspire hope and a shared sense of purpose.
Dr. Beth HillmanI often get questions about how well I can how I can manage being at a place that is sort at the 911 Memorial and Museum, a place of such loss. As you just pointed out, 911 was New York's worst day. It's not a day that's comfortable for many to remember, and it's difficult to encounter the the intertwined histories of that day, but I've realized that first, many people heal from encountering the past, including the most challenging parts of the past. And second, a sense of what's possible in terms of recovery is obvious every day at the New World Trade Center, which has been rebuilt, which is thriving. It's a center of commerce, of culture, of learning and of hope now, and it's it's a physical testament to the ability to recover after after a terrible set of acts of arbitrary violence against the United States and against the world. So for me, that the inspiration. That comes and from being at a site where we have rebuilt after the terrible consequences of terrorism, is is, is a great opportunity, and we can share it with the people who come to see us, I think to being here has helped me understand grief and the impact of grief. Just this week, we had a program in the museum where I was reminded of the generative capacity that grief can create in some people, that people do learn and grow. I mentioned before that young people grow relentlessly and their their capacity to learn and their curiosity and the necessity that they learn, that that's that's that's always inspiring to me, but really, trauma and loss can also trigger a reckoning that that can lift people in ways they didn't realize. And as we tell stories, as we will in our 25th anniversary special exhibition, tell stories of how people responded to 911 really, the lasting legacy is the courage, the compassion and the service that came out of 911 I mean that people came together to find hope amidst all that loss, and also to to come together and to be unified,
Brigadier General Dana H. BornYeah, and I hear your message of transformation out of trauma, which is really elevating and inspiring. And I can say on behalf of our listeners, that is a message right for all of us, individually, all the way through organizations and societies. And so in this 911, Memorial and Museum, profound, emotional, historical weight that we have, like many major institutions, feeling right now. It also, in addition to that incredible purpose, has operational and business needs, and so the nuts and bolts and the daily grind, or the daily, you know, necessity, how do you navigate the integration of honoring the sake of responsibility, of the memory and meeting the practical demands running a sustainable organization.
Dr. Beth HillmanOur mission is to commemorate what happened on 911 to educate people about what happened then and after, and inspire an end to the hatred and intolerance that caused those terrorist attacks we realized and the people who built the museum, many still work for us today, an extraordinary collection of individuals who who built a beautiful and and long lasting memorial to what happened that day. Fortunately, they also built an economically viable place people want to come and want to visit, and we were immediately successful in terms of the people coming to the museum and supporting our mission right from the start, and really the first time a major challenge hit was the pandemic in terms of the finances of the institution. But that was a massive challenge.
Dr. Beth HillmanAnd again, New York, our board responded, and in an emergency fundraising campaign, brought in the funds that allowed the museum to stay solvent during a time when we realized we couldn't actually even maintain a minimum level of security and safety on the site without spending more than what we that what we could get with no visitors to the museum and no visitors to the memorial at all. So the for me, they've they've stayed connected, and as we approach the 25th anniversary of 911 in 2026 also America's 250th it's it's really a time when it feels like our mission to never forget and to acknowledge what happened and what happened has happened after to reckon with 911 health effects which have harmed and killed more People than 911 itself, those attacks of 911 itself, to share those stories with people who will be reckoning with what it means that we're 25 years past 911 and that we have 100 million Americans too young to remember for themselves what happened on 911 that's something that feels tied to our our economic sustainability, and also to our mission itself. So I think that it is possible to pull them together, but, but you're right that looking at spreadsheets and telling stories of of inspiring leadership and incredible courage, those aren't always the same things
Brigadier General Dana H. BornAs you make a wave of purpose, courage and resilience. What's giving you hope right now?
Dr. Beth HillmanI think that next generations learning from what has happened in the past. I've always loved history. I was trained as a historian. I've trained as a lawyer too, and law here is often about looking to the past and understanding precedent and how things have played out. For me, the the desire of young people to understand what has come before, which they don't always know that they have, but I find they often do when they get a chance to encounter it, that inspires me. And the other thing is also tied to history. The contingency of history really gives me hope, rather than the despair that some people feel. You know, things could have gone differently at. So many different points in time, in the past, and if that's the case, then things can go differently today and tomorrow and long into the future based on the acts of individuals and and collections of people and institutions.
Dr. Beth HillmanThings change all the time, and people change them. So the sense of a lack of ability to influence and to change things, I find it's a it's a failure of imagination and a misguided sense of what's possible. I don't think humans are very good at understanding what we're capable of. I think we're capable of much more, even in this time of artificial and generative intelligence and the real challenges that this is going to pose, I think we're going to need very different skills as we move ahead, and I don't fully understand what's ahead in terms of workplace structures or in terms of individual learning and growth.
Dr. Beth HillmanI think learning and pedagogy themselves are changing right now, and we have to work hard to understand that. But I would be wrong if I were to underestimate the capacity of people to sort of reckon with that too. So I think that the understanding contingency and that we can actually change things that gives me hope all the time.
Brigadier General Dana H. BornThis has been a terrific time to connect in with your great wisdom. We want to say thank you. Thank you for being a friend with how and also exemplifying the how in your life, your love, your leadership, your legacy. Dr Beth Hillman, enormous thanks. We salute you and we wish you all the best as we embrace this next year commemoration of the 25th of 911.
Dr. Beth HillmanThank you, Dana, it was good to be here.
What does it take to lead with purpose when the stakes are high - and across very different worlds? In this HOW Conversation, Dana Born sits down with Bob McDonald, former Chairman, President, and CEO of Procter &...
What does it take to lead when everything around you is changing? In this HOW Conversation, former 7-Eleven and Blockbuster CEO James Keyes joins HOW Fellow Dana Born to explore why great leadership isn't about avoiding...
In moments of uncertainty, leadership is revealed. Former U.S. Sec Def Mark Esper joins Dov Seidman for a conversation about the principles that guide leaders through crisis, complexity, and change. Reflecting on his...
What does moral leadership look like across generations of change? In our latest HOW Conversation, HOW Fellow Dana Born sits down with David Kohler, Chair and CEO of Kohler Co., to explore what it takes to lead with...
In this HOW Conversation, Elise Awwad, President and CEO of DeVry University, shares a deeply personal and practical perspective on moral leadership in a rapidly changing world. From her early lessons shaped by her...