[Archive Interview from Jul 20, 2023] Darren Walker, President of the Ford Foundation, joined Dov Seidman, Founder of The HOW Institute, on a new episode of HOW Conversations to discuss Mr. Walker’s new book, From Generosity to Justice: A New Gospel of Wealth. “I was born into an America that believed in my promise.” Mr. Walker tells Dov, “I had hope, hope is the oxygen of democracy. And philanthropy is, in some ways, the business of hope.” Watch the full episode to learn why Mr. Walker, who is also on the Board of Directors of The HOW Institute, believes philanthropy must harness hope and move beyond charity to address both dignity and justice. Order your copy of From Generosity to Justice: https://www.fordfoundation.org/news-a.... READY TO START YOUR MORAL LEADERSHIP JOURNEY? Moral leadership is more imperative today than ever before. The HOW Institute for Society was founded on the belief that those in positions of formal authority should also have moral authority. We are creating the tools leaders need to make principled, ethical and values-based decisions. We are a nonprofit organization dedicated to building a world rooted in deep human values and trust in our social fabric. The Institute channels philosophical reasoning to address modern problems. Today, HOW we do what we do matters more than ever and in ways it never has before. Learn more at https://thehowinstitute.org/
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
IntroductionWelcome to the How Institute for Society's podcast, HOW Conversations where we talk with courageous and authentic leaders about how we can build and nurture a culture of moral leadership throughout society. What does it mean to be a moral leader today who has moral authority in our society? What should we expect of our leaders during a crisis, and what are the moral leadership frameworks our leaders are using to navigate through these challenging times? These are just some of the nuanced questions our hosts cover in their discussions with CEOs, military generals, educators, philanthropists and other leaders about the importance of moral and ethical decision making. And now here's the HOW Institute for Society, founder and chairman and the host for today's podcast, Dov Seidman.
Dov SeidmanHello everyone, and welcome to our latest and this is a special HOW Conversation with my dear friend and HOW Institute for society board member Darren Walker. Darren, as we all know, is the President of the Ford Foundation, and really embodying and manifesting at scale the kind of leadership that the world so desperately needs. So welcome Darren.
Darren WalkerThank you, Dov, and that's a kind of introduction. I'm not sure I'm worthy of of such accolades.
Dov SeidmanWell, I know you are, and so many others affirm that, and all the ways in which they lean on you and and look up to you, but I want to say that we are gathered for this how conversation on the occasion of the recent publication of this important book, and from generosity to justice a new gospel. I think it's a manifesto, it's a framework, it's an approach, it's a model for creating, but more importantly, sharing and making wealth go around by reframing wealth as a matter of justice, being philanthropic as a matter of justice. So before we dive in, a bit into your book, what animates you and what inspired you to see and therefore reframe and reimagine philanthropy as a matter of justice.
Darren WalkerWell, Dov for me, what frames every day of my life is the history I have had in this great country. I was born in an America that believed in my promise, that did not believe, because I was poor, born into a single headed household, living in rural Texas and Louisiana, that my opportunities should be In any way diminished by my geography and background and so I had hope, because hope is the oxygen of democracy, and so philanthropy, I like to say, in some ways, is about the business of hope. We, through our work, can make a difference in the lives of people in small ways, one at a time and by systemic change at scale.
Dov SeidmanDarren, what...define hope?
Darren WalkerHope is believing in in what you may not be able to see. It's aspiring for something that feels very far away, right? That is what I had. I living in Ames, Texas as a little boy, when I would read in Ebony Magazine and see the lives and lifestyles of middle class African Americans, I could imagine an America that was a better place than the one I was in, and that is what gave me hope for a better future, a better tomorrow.
Dov SeidmanI assume that there were those around you or something was happening in your context to inspire hope in you, so that you could imagine reaching higher and going farther.
Darren WalkerOne of my most impactful experiences growing up was of my experience with Mrs. Majors in the fourth grade. Mrs. Majors was an extraordinary educator. I got in a fight one day, Mrs. Majors saw me fighting in the hall. I met with her. And she said, You should be ashamed of yourself. I'm ashamed of you.
Darren WalkerI know you can do better, but let me make one thing clear to you. This was a white woman telling me this. She said, little Negro boys who cannot control themselves, get into trouble, and you have to exercise self control. I've never had anyone talk to me about self control or how to contain my rage or my anger, which was frequent at that time, because I had a very chaotic home life, but that was a life lesson for me that continues to this day.
Dov SeidmanHow are you going about inspiring hope in others? And then I do want to get back to justice as your articulation of philanthropy, but just stay on this important topic of hope, because you and I came of age also in the capitalistic sphere, where people said, hope is not a strategy. Forget this hope stuff through planning, budgeting and control, we're gonna, you know, superimpose a future, and deep in your heart, you know that without hope, there is no strategy. So I love the centrality of hope, that that hope plays in your model of leadership. But talk about, how do we inspire it in others in today's age?
Darren WalkerWell, I agree. It is about inspiration, and it is not about saying I have the answers. One of the things I find is how often people say to me, and I accept this with great humility. Thank you for inspiring me. And I think what they mean is I'm a black gay man with a particular background that in some ways, is is not normal in the elite circles, unfortunately, not normal that we find ourselves in, and I think that's regrettable, but it does, it does embolden me to tell my story, To be proud of my background and to speak truth as I see it, I mean, these are the ways in which leaders have to communicate. But as you and I also know from our work at how that communication has to be authentic. It has to be perceived as authentic, and you have to be perceived as authentic as a leader.
Dov SeidmanTell us about the journey from generosity to justice. That journey. What is your conception of justice? What has the pandemic revealed about society to make justice the central focus of your work?
Darren WalkerI found in a rather obscure speech that Dr King made in 1968 a few months before he was murdered, and he said the following about philanthropy, philanthropy is commendable, but it should not allow the philanthropist to overlook the economic injustice, which makes philanthropy necessary. And so what Dr King was saying was something else that philanthropy, yes, is about the idea of charity and generosity, but it should also be about dignity and justice.
Darren WalkerAnd so what King was encouraging demanding was that philanthropist interrogate our own complicity in the very problems we seek to solve. And so he was holding the mirror up and saying, it's not enough to be generous. It's not enough to give all. You have to consider just how much you have contributed. And that's a very different idea of philanthropy.
Darren WalkerFor me, the fundamental idea of philanthropy and justice, especially justice, is the basic notion of dignity that every person should live with dignity. Dov, the number of people you and I know, I know you are a graduate of a very prestigious Ivy League school who are progressive and who consider themselves generous people, but when confronted with the suggestion that we should do away with legacy programs and initiatives and. Them become silent, or, in fact, resist the idea that this privilege, which again compounds their privilege and the life opportunities for their children, who are already in a such a better place so much farther along, and yet they want to hold on to something that even further accelerates the inequality in our system, which they profess to want to address so in small ways and in large ways, this question of conversations about, how do we think about, what's the differences between giving back and giving up? Is a very challenging conversation.
Dov SeidmanSo Darren i I'm fond of saying that in order to create shared prosperity or shared value, you you actually need shared values. Without shared values, you can't pursue shared value. What will allow you to do the sharing? What's your theory of distributive justice? What if there's not enough to go along and you need some normative framework to make sacrifices and shared burdens? Where are we in terms of the shared values required to be on a journey of shared prosperity and shared value.
Darren WalkerFor many, we seem to have lost a sense and a commitment to our shared American identity. It is a dangerous place because you some feel ill equipped to engage in it, and some are fearful of engaging, because engaging might reveal that you are ignorant of a particular community. It might reveal that your background hasn't prepared you for the more diverse world we live in, and therefore you may say something that can be misinterpreted, and the consequences of which could be material and and so if, If one is afraid of engaging and and the people who we need to be in the public square retreat from the public square, then the public square is left to the toxifiers. It is a business model. Hate is profitable, yeah.
Darren WalkerAnd so when you have a system where the public square needs to have everybody in it, but you find that the the square seems to be filled increasingly with haters.
Dov SeidmanIt's hard to want to engage the Greek root of philanthropy. As you know, Darren is lover of people, or a lover, of humankind. Is it fair to say that as you want to inspire a transition from generosity to justice, you're actually making philanthropy, not just for those who have a lot of means, it's everybody can be philanthropic if dignity and justice is the ethos, right? So what can anybody do to be philanthropic in your conception of philanthropy?
Darren WalkerWell, it is, and it does begin with love, love of humankind, and a belief that love is possible and that love can heal. There's no doubt in my mind of that philanthropy has to be a mechanism by which people can demonstrate their love for each other, and it is why some of the most effective philanthropists in this country are people whose names you and I have never heard, because in their communities, in their small towns, in their villages, in their slums, in parts of the world, they are demonstrating their love for humankind, their brothers and sisters, by offering very modest person to person, help and assistance.
Dov SeidmanWhat is the role in your conception of philanthropy and justice, of humility? So there's hope, there's love. And I think the third prong or pillar, is, is humility, right?
Darren WalkerIt is humility, but humility and ego are critical ingredients. And what I mean by that is there is often an inverse. Relationship between humility and the ego when it comes to effective philanthropy, I am reminded of a billionaire philanthropist who went to Eastern Africa, and I met with him after the trip, and he said, My wife and I have decided we want to start with our foundation, a new program to help with rural health in Tanzania. And my question to him was, Who asked you to do that?
Darren WalkerWho in Tanzania asked you to create a rural health program? There are dozens of rural health programs in Tanzania. Why don't you ask some of the leaders of those organizations how you can help them, rather than just immediately believing that what's needed is for you and your wife and your family to set up in your image and in your name of a program in Tanzania.
Darren WalkerThat's unfortunately, not unusual. And so my point is, when you center the people and the communities you want to impact, you will often hear what you don't know, and you will hear solutions that are more authentic, more likely to be sustained and owned.
Dov SeidmanYou talk about engaging the other through the five senses, paint that picture, because that'll probably allow you to balance humility and ego and get them in some form of equilibrium. Describe what you paint the picture, what it means to engage in all with all five senses, the way you put it.
Darren WalkerWell, I think you have to with your eyes. You have to be able to see, and you have to be able to see and believe things that you that may not be in front of you, but you have to see the people. You have to see and believe in them. You have to listen to them. You have to genuinely believe that they can help, and that they have wisdom and knowledge that you don't have, and that expertise is not found in just the the experts with PhDs in public policy, we have to speak in ways that reflect empathy, sympathy, a sense of generosity, a sense of a belief that we want to be engaged in a real dialog, not just me, wealthy person speaking to you, speaking at you, but actually in a dialog, hearing you.
Dov SeidmanWhere are we today, with your conception of capitalism, how are you navigating the push and pulls of it, especially right now, where there seems to be a pullback and economic impair challenges that are motivating the pullback when we should nonetheless transcend Where are you on capitalism?
Darren WalkerWell, there's no doubt that I consider myself a disciple of Adam Smith and his moral sentiment book, and yet most people do not know Dov, or, I should say, most adherence to capitalism who quote Adam Smith, are unfamiliar, are ignorant of the full richness of his philosophy, which was a moral Philosophy, not simply an economic philosophy. But your point about this moment we're in around ESG and stakeholder capitalism is real, and it is a shame that we these are not ideologies, and that ideologists have taken from from many of us, these, these fundamental notions that are just about fairness, are about long term sustainability, are about ensuring that the future there can be hope. And that's that, to my mind is where frameworks, the kind I've learned from you, and being a part of the how Institute, is so important because it allows us to have an understanding of how we make courageous, principle based decisions.
Dov SeidmanIt's, how do we inspire courage besides just being examples of it?
Darren WalkerWell, I think that being an example, hopefully it cannot be underestimated, and I don't particularly hold myself out as an example Dov. I truly don't. I do, though, feel compelled to both acknowledge and act, act on my privilege. I have a I have a platform, I communicate, and I have to use those privileges to contribute to bettering our society and expressing love for humankind, and that can put one at risk.
Darren WalkerWhen you are prepared to write an op ed for the New York Times, you are opening up yourself to receiving vitriolic messages, as I do every time I write something, you absolutely have to be prepared to put something on the line. And I think that that's only right because we privileged people have so much to put on the line.
Dov SeidmanWhen we gathered at the Ford Foundation for the how Institute summit on moral leadership, and you spoke to those, to the to our community of common cause, you offered a succinct definition of moral leadership and how moral leaders walk a fine line in the world that I think keeps you honest and allows you to walk that fine line. You said moral leadership is about being righteous but not self righteous. Feels to me that that distinction allows you to write in the New York Times and be out there, as long as you're trying to be righteous thoughtfully, but not self righteous. Is that a fair way to play that back to you?
Darren WalkerYes, it is, and it's it's understanding that this is not about lecturing people or naming and shaming people or polarizing us. It's about finding the common language that speaks to us all, but it does require a willingness to sometimes make people uncomfortable, not for the sort of perverse joy of making the privileged uncomfortable, but to actually engage with people in thoughtful ways that recognizes that While there are some people who truly are not interested in bridge building and working collectively. Most people in this country would wish to do that.
Dov SeidmanSo Darren, I mentioned The New York Times, so you recently wrote a highly personal essay. It was an editorial in the New York Times, but you, you made an argument, but you also did it in personal terms, following the Supreme Court's recent ruling on affirmative action. I'll quote a little bit of what really jumped out on me, where you, you celebrated diversity by saying that diversity and you said that, there are studies that prove this, but it was also your your truth. Diversity enhances critical thinking, creativity and collaboration, as well as productivity, profitability and performance. It is a national tragedy that diversity is now a contested issue, rather than of common interests, and we should tell the truth about why diversity is now controversial.
Dov SeidmanOpponents of diversity are opponents of any racial consciousness they want to prevent us from understanding the ways that the past informs the present, from wrestling with the fullness and richness and complexity of our history. What are you in touch with that made you say that, besides the studies that empirically helped make your case,
Darren WalkerWell, first, as I lay out, I am most definitely an affirmative action baby. There's no doubt that without affirmative action, I would not be here. That is not to say that I am in any way an under performer. It is to say that the institutions and the American society and, most importantly, public policy, recognized that people like me, historically, have had the doors shut. We are not going as a society, to erase the reality of the problems, the legacy of racism in our country by simply wishing it away or legislating that we can't talk about slavery, or we can't talk about racism in ways that make some of us uncomfortable. This is not going to help our country. What's going to help our country is if we are able to understand the fullness the richness of this great country, and hold that both things can be true, that we have a great history that has inspired people around the globe and made us the envy of the world, and at the same time, we have a stain of racism and racial cast that has held back too many of us.
Dov SeidmanYou invoke Martin Luther King, a man of a great moral leader and a man of faith. And he said, The arc of the moral universe bends towards justice. And it's a beautiful expression of faith to use the present tense, it bends. It might take five years, 50 years, 500 years. When I listen to you for the last hour, it feels like part of what you're arguing is to have hope that it shall bend, that it bends. But there's a lot of bending that we can do by putting our shoulder into the arc. Right?
Darren WalkerWhat we can all do to bend it is rededicate ourselves to the American experiment, commit ourselves to in our own communities, speaking to people who we don't always speak to, finding places and spaces to be present with, people who don't always look like us or have our backgrounds, extending oneself in generous ways, in curious ways, being better active listeners in our communities are, in my view, essential to build a community.
Dov SeidmanDarren, there's, there's an adage that when you come from the heart, you enter the heart. Thank you for sharing so much insight and wisdom, but doing it from the heart and touching us. And it's been a pleasure. Thank you, Darren, truly.
What does it take to lead with purpose when the stakes are high - and across very different worlds? In this HOW Conversation, Dana Born sits down with Bob McDonald, former Chairman, President, and CEO of Procter &...
What does it take to lead when everything around you is changing? In this HOW Conversation, former 7-Eleven and Blockbuster CEO James Keyes joins HOW Fellow Dana Born to explore why great leadership isn't about avoiding...
In moments of uncertainty, leadership is revealed. Former U.S. Sec Def Mark Esper joins Dov Seidman for a conversation about the principles that guide leaders through crisis, complexity, and change. Reflecting on his...
What does moral leadership look like across generations of change? In our latest HOW Conversation, HOW Fellow Dana Born sits down with David Kohler, Chair and CEO of Kohler Co., to explore what it takes to lead with...
In this HOW Conversation, Elise Awwad, President and CEO of DeVry University, shares a deeply personal and practical perspective on moral leadership in a rapidly changing world. From her early lessons shaped by her...