Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

HOW Conversations

HOW Conversations artwork

Bill George, Executive Fellow, Harvard Business School

Aug 20, 202520 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

[Archive Interview from Jan 24, 2023] Bill George has a challenge for the next generation - lead with authenticity. “We need you as leaders to step up now and hear the call.” Bill is a professor at Harvard Business School, a best-selling author and the former CEO of Medtronic. On this new episode of HOW Conversations Bill spoke with Dov Seidman, Founder and Chairman of The HOW Institute, about why emerging leaders must keep their purpose and values in sight. When they do, Bill says, "the world is a better place...and not just for the people on top, but for everyone.” Bill's new book, written with Zach Clayton, “True North, Emerging Leader Edition,” is available on Amazon https://a.co/d/gLmDkvb READY TO START YOUR MORAL LEADERSHIP JOURNEY? Moral leadership is more imperative today than ever before. The HOW Institute for Society was founded on the belief that those in positions of formal authority should also have moral authority. We are creating the tools leaders need to make principled, ethical and values-based decisions. We are a nonprofit organization dedicated to building a world rooted in deep human values and trust in our social fabric. The Institute channels philosophical reasoning to address modern problems. Today, HOW we do what we do matters more than ever and in ways it never has before. Learn more at https://thehowinstitute.org/

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

IntroductionWelcome to the HOW Institute for Society's podcast, HOW Conversations where we talk with courageous and authentic leaders about how we can build and nurture a culture of moral leadership throughout society. What does it mean to be a moral leader today who has moral authority in our society? What should we expect of our leaders during a crisis, and what are the moral leadership frameworks our leaders are using to navigate through these challenging times? These are just some of the nuanced questions our hosts cover in their discussions with CEOs, military generals, educators, philanthropists and other leaders about the importance of moral and ethical decision making. And now here's the HOW Institute for Society, founder and chairman and the host for today's podcast, Dov Seidman.

Dov SeidmanWelcome my good friend and compatriot, Bill George and welcome Bill to a HOW Conversation. There's an adage that I think is attributed to FDR, that smooth seas have never created a great sailor. Currently, you are at the Harvard Business School where you've been teaching for almost 20 years. You're a senior fellow there. You're known obviously for your exemplary leadership as as the CEO of Medtronic from 1991 to 2001 and we are together on the occasion of the publication of your latest important book. And I want to hold it up you have really underlined and amplified the importance and the ever increasing importance of being animated by a true north, and the journey of discovering one's true north and then having the courage to be to be animated and guided by True North. But in this book, Bill, you focus on the next generation, and I want to spend a lot of our time together, really talking about leadership animated by a true north for the next generation.

Dov SeidmanBut I think of late, it's your wisdom that you've been imparting around Authentic Leadership anchored in true north. So Bill, in the spirit of true north, how did you discover your own let's start with your journey. I mentioned that smooth seas did not make great sailors. Tell us about the seas that you sailed as a young child, then as somebody coming of age, how did that form you? And let's take it from there, and then we'll get into some of your teachings. But welcome again.

Bill GeorgeThank you Dov. And I was born in Michigan to as the only child of older parents. So a lot of my parents folks are vested in their only child. My mother, all she cared about was whether they had good values. She said, Son, I don't care if you get A's or C, Just be true to what you believe in. And I heard that over and over growing up. So senior year, I threw my hat in the ring to become president senior class, and when votes came in, I lost my margin two to one. So you could see the kids in my school didn't think I was much of a leader, which I wasn't, because I hadn't learned that leadership is all about relationships. So I went off to Georgia Tech and ran for office six more times, and lost all six. And then some seniors pulled me aside and said one of the most valuable things I ever heard, Bill, no one's ever going to work with you, much less be led by you, because you're moving so fast to get ahead you don't take time for other people. And that was very true.

Bill GeorgeAnd so it's a whole year trying to do my own self help development plan. Realized all the things I wasn't I was was moving too fast, like I was building a resume instead of a life.

Dov SeidmanSo when you pause Bill, what questions do you ask yourself to always stay tethered to your true north? What are some of the questions and ways in which you interrogate yourself to really become sure that you're staying true.

Bill GeorgeWell, let me just comment on the pause Dov, back in when I was about 34-35 my wife dragged me to a transcendental meditation class. At that time I was going 24/7 our business growing and micro is 55% a year. And you know, I got into this, and then they said, Oh, and you're going to meditate now 20 minutes, twice a day. And that became my pause. And I did it in the morning. Did in the evening, sometimes a little hard to squeeze in the evening with two young kids at home, but the important thing is, I took time to reflect and ask myself question, what's really important that we're going to do today, what kind of leader I want to be. And so I got focused. And frankly, my most creative ideas have come out of that. Would you call the pause? What I and do a meditation practice? Now I've taken your idea and this idea and brought it into all my teaching for CEO, saying you have to do this. Forget about the task list. Forget about the election. Electronics. Just take time. How did I show up today?

Bill GeorgeWas I the kind of leader I wanted to be? How did I treat other people? What kind of did I express my values? Was I clear about this? And I think it's really an very important idea that you have to do that.

Dov SeidmanObviously, this is not what I believe. But if somebody says moral compass, the business of Business is business. Just follow the law. Play within the rules, don't cross lines, but just pursue business. Do what's in your business interests. How does moral compass in that? How do you square the two?

Bill GeorgeWell, business is chartered by society to help society, and so when you work for an organization, first thing you need to figure out is, how is this organization contributing society? Now, this was pretty straightforward in Medtronic, when you restore someone's health, you're definitely making a contribution. But you know, we had the banking problems of 2008 banks actually are very important to provide the fuel in the tank for organizations to invest and grow, and so they're fulfilling if they do that role. So I think any organization needs to figure out what its moral compass is and how it's contributing. And so if you get too much just trying to make money, I can guarantee you today you'll not get the best people.

Bill GeorgeThey will not stay and you will not inspire them because they're not as interested in that. They're much more interested in how they can make a difference in the world and have their own impact. And can you find that congruence between the individual and the company's purpose? You need to do that first before you start charging ahead.

Dov SeidmanWhy did you write a book for the next generation? That's the first part of the question. And then you dedicate an entire chapter to moral leadership, and pretty much exhort the next generation to be on a path of becoming moral leaders. So why'd you write it for the next generation, and why were you so explicit with the next generation that the path for them to be on is one of moral leadership.

Bill GeorgeBecause of the baby boomers have had their day. They've had 30 years in charge. It's been command and control leadership. It's been about maximizing shareholder value. It's about making a lot of money for themselves, minimizing the compensation so the people actually doing the work, millennials and Gen Z, they want to serve for a purpose. They want to make a difference. They want to do things ethically. They're searching for that organization, not all of them, but the vast majority. And so we want to get them grounded in that so they don't charge ahead trying to lead without a sense of their true north, because then it's too hard to go back and figure it out. So I wrote this book to encourage emerging leaders to understand that they have to have a moral set of values to be moral leaders. They have to stand for a purpose.

Bill GeorgeThey have to have real sense of clarity about who they are and where their organization is going. And I can tell you Dov, the key thing is what I call moral courage. There'll be a time when you have to make a bold decision, and you may not have full agreement on it, and you may not win. It may not work, but you stood for something, and you say, we're going to do this, we're not going to do that. And you make those bold decisions.

Dov SeidmanHow do you develop moral courage? You know fear, you know, in a organizational or corporate environment, I think one of the greatest ironies is we tell people we we say, Please, be courageous, speak up. Why don't we create cultures and environments so high in trust and so low in fear where it doesn't take courage to speak up or speak out, it doesn't take courage to do the right thing, but we are where we are, where courage is so important. So how do you develop courage? Because being courageous can be inconvenient or it could it can seem that way. It could feel unpopular.

Bill GeorgeI think you actually have to experience it, leading through crisis, leading through difficult times. Today, leaders are affected by multiple intersecting crises. When you lead through these times, that's when you have to stand up and be counted. I can tell you this stuff, if you work with people who are not moral but don't have clarity about that, it's going to rub off on you. You can say it won't, but it will. Like my colleague, I'd married a great deal, it got fell off the track. Rajat Gupta got tied up with a lot of people that were doing immoral things, and unfortunately, he spent two years in jail. He was a great leader. What happened? And so if you're not grounded in that, so I think you start early, you have the experiences of leading through challenging times and having the courage to speak out, and you'll get pushback. But if you don't do it, if you silence your voice, who are you? You know, and so just having beliefs without actions is meaningless.

Dov SeidmanSo you said something very interesting about the next generation that they don't need what we consider to be formal or traditional. Power to lead, right? So you're you're almost describing the next generation in new ways and coming up with a leadership playbook that doesn't leverage traditional gears and levers of power, right? You say, this is a quote on page 278. Moral leaders don't require positions of power, anyone could become a moral leader by using their voice and writing to inspire others. Elaborate on that?

Bill GeorgeWell, I think some of our best leaders have no titles. They are, but they are people who speak up. And I remember Warren Bennis when he left the president of the University Cincinnati, started writing. He said, Bill, I found I could do with my more with my voice and my writing than than I could having position power. I don't need position power. And I think too often is I fell into that trap too we strive for position power rather than personal power, which comes from our character.

Dov SeidmanGiven that there are positions of formal authority, positions with big titles. It's crucial to ensure that moral leaders are in those positions, right?

Bill GeorgeIt is, but it's crucial on moral leaders throughout the organization. So I spent tremendous amount of time meeting with everyone, talking about our mission, our values and our purpose, because I figured if we got that right, so when I go to India, I go to Korea or Poland, you really need to make that sure that message gets across. These people are a long way from headquarters, and they have a lot of autonomy, and you better be darn sure that they understand it is more important to do the right thing.

Bill GeorgeAnd you know, they would say to me, Mister George, you know, we don't pay we're losing contracts here in India. And I said, That's right, you're going to lose one and you're going to get two more because of what we stand for, our principles, our quality, our technology, our service, but who we are, that's our brand. And if you one person can take us down. I saw this in the banking field. One person can drag you down. It happened with a banker in Malaysia for Goldman Sachs, and it cost a tremendous amount.

Dov SeidmanOften, as we've seen, especially the pandemic, we're choosing between two suboptimal choices or two painful choices, real dilemmas we've seen between saving lives and livelihoods. What is your framework for making difficult decisions when both choices aren't all that all that good, and both can be painful. And how do you go about making those decisions? What's the framework you use for making those decisions? How do you enlist others into embracing a bad decision that has to be made, nonetheless bad because it's painful or unwanted.

Bill GeorgeYou start with your mission and values, or your purpose and values of your organization, and if you build off of that solid base, then you've got somewhere to go. And these are difficult choices. I'll give you an example. Joaquin Duato, who is the new CEO of Johnson Johnson, had to face his ref. He took over as CEO at Johnson Johnson in Russia, and there was a huge pressure to get out of Russia. But he said, you know, we have a credo that says we provide life saving drugs. So I'm we're pulling out all of our consumer products, everything you would do, brand names, you know, like band aids, that's all going Tylenol, but we're going to continue buying the life saving drugs. You get a lot of criticism for that, but he stood through it. I said, That's what our credo calls on us to do.

Bill GeorgeHere's the right thing to do. These are not easy choices. No one's happy making these choices, but we have to do the right thing. So if you're not grounded in that, you're going to wind up making decisions that have no grounding. We see this as Elon Musk going into Twitter right now, there's no basis for any of his decisions, and if he doesn't do that, he'll have total chaos.

Dov SeidmanHow do you decide what issue to engage in and what to let be and if you're going to engage how do you engage in it. How do you engage others in that decision? Because a business, I assume you would agree, cannot, every five minutes, take a stand on, on the latest tweet and on the latest this and that. So you need to have some framework to decide. This one we have to weigh in on, and this one we could just, you know, maybe just keep going and not.

Bill GeorgeIt's the number one question I get from every CEO today, when should I speak on these public issues? Actually, most of them are very uncomfortable doing that, but if it reads on their mission and values, they have to speak out. I'll give you a couple examples. George Floyd was murdered three three miles from where I'm standing right now, and Minneapolis is a headquarters town any CEO of a company here that didn't take a position on that, not just in support of their black employees, but to really study it and recognize, hey, we're not doing the job we thought we were doing. They ripped the band aid off. We found out that black employees here, bipoc employees, don't have all the opportunities we thought, and maybe our LGBTQ don't either. And so. They not only had to take a position publicly, but they actually had to have a plan to do something about it, and that's what the CEOs in this town went to work on because they didn't. They had no legitimacy. People weren't going to believe them. Then you listen to everyone and make the call, is this something we want to take on or not? And I think that's the key.

Dov SeidmanSo more CEOs and more people in charge are going to slip up. How do you get a second chance today? How do you make it right when you didn't get it right the first time? What do you it's going to pitching a perfect game, if you will. Is going to become increasingly harder, probably more opportunities to, you know, fix a problem that you might have created by not getting it right the first time. How do you go about repair and turning something around when you didn't get it right out of the

Bill GeorgeWell, you have to apologize for making a mistake. You have to own your mistakes. And I believe that vulnerability is power. You make yourself vulnerable by doing that. And for instance, one day, I was teaching about values at Harvard Business School, and I went up to the board and I wrote down, I drew a line. I said, here's B black, here's W, white. Now all the value stations are really not black and white. They're in the middle. They're in this gray area. After the class, three black employees came up and said, Why do you say Black is bad, and they were taken as a personal and so I apologize to them, and then I wouldn't use that anymore. There are other ways to deal with right and wrong and good and bad, but you know, I had to learn from that experience. I had never occurred to me that they would equate what I tell my values black and white as being in racial terms, but I had to understand their sensitivities. And I think the easiest thing to do, or the best, most important thing to do, is to apologize,

Dov SeidmanAnd you and I both know that just saying you're sorry is just the first step. You know, when you tell a child, say you're sorry, that's almost teaching them a verbal escape route. Just say you're sorry and go back to playing. We need to make amends. We need to reflect on on why we might have done that in the first place. Any examples on how, once you want to manifest, embody vulnerability and take responsibility by starting with the apology. Any examples of going beyond that, making amends, committing to a journey of behavioral change so that we come out a lot better for the apology.

Bill GeorgeWell, I think you have to have a put a plan in place to make it happen. And for instance, on the Goldman Sachs board, I got upset with them because they were talking about diversity statistics, and I said, Why is all these people leaving? So we need to have a plan here to create an inclusive environment, that means changing our culture, that everyone feels included, that people who are not white males don't have to buy into the dominant culture. And we need to have a plan to do that. David Solomon came in as CEO, and he put such a plan in place, and promoted a lot of women, a lot of bipoc to very key positions in the firm. And it's really transformed a place because everyone has had that sense of belonging and feeling and fully included if they don't. So it may mean different leaders who get it and making those those calls. And sometimes I have to do that too. I have to replace someone, when I make a mistake, who didn't represent a moral leader, with someone who is a moral leader?

Dov SeidmanI'd like you to wrap up with the following, you know, look right into the camera so to speak and speak directly to the to the next generation, to all the individuals out there on a path.

Bill GeorgeWe need you as leaders to step up now and hear the call to do so with a clarity about your moral compass, your true north of knowing who you are, and then leading with a clear sense of purpose and bringing people together around purpose and values. And when you can do that, your organization is committed to a purpose that's going to benefit our society, then you're going to be a part of leading people to make this world a better place, not just with people on top, but for everyone. And we have to solve real problems. And I encourage you to find that real problem that you can contribute to making this world a better place.

Dov SeidmanBill, that's inspiring. And thank you. Thank you for imparting this wisdom and wisdom that you earned by how you forged your path of leadership. So thank you, Bill.

Bill GeorgeWell, thank you Dov, for your leadership and having being that moral leader and bringing the house society along in your organization to train and develop more moral leaders. That's what we need to do. We don't need more people reading spreadsheets. We do more people doing what you're doing, and I hope you'll continue on that path.

Dov SeidmanWe all will, and we'll do it together. Thank you,

Bill GeorgeThank you. Bill.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Bob McDonald, former Chairman, President, and CEO of Procter & Gamble

    Sep 3, 202628 minAudio

    What does it take to lead with purpose when the stakes are high - and across very different worlds? In this HOW Conversation, Dana Born sits down with Bob McDonald, former Chairman, President, and CEO of Procter &...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Jim Keyes, former 7-Eleven and Blockbuster CEO

    Aug 2, 202628 minAudio

    What does it take to lead when everything around you is changing? In this HOW Conversation, former 7-Eleven and Blockbuster CEO James Keyes joins HOW Fellow Dana Born to explore why great leadership isn't about avoiding...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Mark Esper, former Defense Secretary, United States

    Jul 3, 202628 minAudio

    In moments of uncertainty, leadership is revealed. Former U.S. Sec Def Mark Esper joins Dov Seidman for a conversation about the principles that guide leaders through crisis, complexity, and change. Reflecting on his...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. David Kohler, Chair and CEO, Kohler Co.

    May 23, 202625 minAudio

    What does moral leadership look like across generations of change? In our latest HOW Conversation, HOW Fellow Dana Born sits down with David Kohler, Chair and CEO of Kohler Co., to explore what it takes to lead with...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Elise Awwad, President and CEO, DeVry University

    Apr 24, 202630 minAudio

    In this HOW Conversation, Elise Awwad, President and CEO of DeVry University, shares a deeply personal and practical perspective on moral leadership in a rapidly changing world. From her early lessons shaped by her...

    Credit the people on this episode