[Archive Interview from Feb 24, 2022] Jonathan Greenblatt, CEO of Anti-Defamation League, doesn't like what he sees. Hate -- of all kinds -- is on the rise. In his new book, It Could Happen Here, Why America is Tipping from Hate to the Unthinkable - And How We Can Stop It, Jonathan explains what’s at risk if we don’t confront hatred head-on but also why he is hopeful; he believes that decent, moral people far outnumber the haters. In part-two, Jonathan sits down with Dov Seidman to discuss how we can tap into our moral courage to speak up when we see injustice and why we need values-based leadership in a transactional world. Jonathan also explains moral decision making as a leader and gives an authentic apology framework. Use promo code "ADLMEMBER" at checkout for an exclusive discount on Jonathan's book, It Could Happen Here. https://www.harpercollins.com/product... READY TO START YOUR MORAL LEADERSHIP JOURNEY? Moral leadership is more imperative today than ever before. The HOW Institute for Society was founded on the belief that those in positions of formal authority should also have moral authority. We are creating the tools leaders need to make principled, ethical and values-based decisions. We are a nonprofit organization dedicated to building a world rooted in deep human values and trust in our social fabric. The Institute channels philosophical reasoning to address modern problems. Today, HOW we do what we do matters more than ever and in ways it never has before. Learn more at https://thehowinstitute.org/
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
IntroductionWelcome to the How Institute for society's podcast, HOW Conversations where we talk with courageous and authentic leaders about how we can build and nurture a culture of moral leadership throughout society. What does it mean to be a moral leader today who has moral authority in our society? What should we expect of our leaders during a crisis and what are the moral leadership frameworks our leaders are using to navigate through these challenging times. These are just some of the nuanced questions our hosts cover in their discussions with CEOs, military generals, educators, philanthropists and other leaders about the importance of moral and ethical decision making. And now here's the HOW Institute for Society, founder and chairman and the host for today's podcast, Dov Seidman.
Dov SeidmanWelcome Jonathan Greenblatt to another of our HOW Conversations. Jonathan, it's a genuine pleasure. And I say this as your friend and as somebody that I know that you know that you know that I know that we are kindred, both in spirit and philosophically. We go back a long way, and most recently, you became the CEO of the Anti Defamation League. Everybody knows that the ADL is really about a righteous fight for elevating civil rights in society, explicitly fighting anti semitism, but equally promoting justice for all.
Dov SeidmanYou've been doing it valiantly. You've been doing it in a respectful yet outspoken way, which is part of the calling of what the CEO of the ADL signs up to do. And it's a pleasure and an honor to welcome you. And I want listeners and viewers to know that I'm welcoming you on the occasion of the publication, and I'll use the word I used before of your significant book. It could happen here. And the subtitle, in and of itself, says so much why America is tipping from hate to the unthinkable and how we can stop it to the extent your premise is right, which I think, day in, day out, we get evidence that it is stopping. It becomes an urgent imperative. I really credit how data driven you are, that you're you're promoting a set of values, but you're also responding to real data. You know, we're, as Americans, leaning into a project, a grand Human Project, E Pluribus Unum. It's on every$1 bill, you know, out of many.
Dov SeidmanOne, yeah. And it starts with we, the people. What is the state of we and our one? How much of a we is there right now based on data that you have? And then how far are we from the one? The more perfect union?
Jonathan GreenblattWell, so I think there are a couple things. So first of all, like, let's just acknowledge that hate isn't a bug. It's a feature of the human condition, right? It's just it's been part of our, our our humanity, if you will, since time immemorial, it's just simply true, like it or not. I think we're living in a particular time when we've had systems like social media, public figures like our prior president, some other current politicians, who have actually weaponized that hate, right, and use as a kind of currency to dominate. And that's not unique.
Jonathan GreenblattAgain, this also happens in the annals, and just today, things to be on a kind. Things are the kind of steroids, and social media is part of that. So there have been a series of high profile frightened things that have people on edge. So attitudes may be going down, but instances have gone way up. And so that's part of the paradox of the moment we're in. And the trick is, how do we, you know, how do we bring this number of instances down to reflect the attitudes?
Dov SeidmanAnd in that spirit, in your book, which I'm happy to hold up again, because I think it's so important, you share a framework and you because you and I know that normative behavior needs normative frameworks. If we're going to go from organizing our affairs based on what we can and can't do to a world where we're doing what we should and should not do, we need normative frameworks that guide the should. The Potter Stewart adage, there's a difference between doing that which you have a right to do and that which is right to do. And you want normative action around hate, and you've developed a framework to make it actionable, and you have a pyramid of hate.
Dov SeidmanShare that framework, because I think it could be instructive, if not useful.
Jonathan GreenblattYeah, so the pyramid of hate is this kind of sociological construct that we've developed over the decades, because at ADL, we advocate. Eight to try to create a more inclusive, you know, environment where Jews and all minorities are protected. So whether we use the courts or Congress, we're pushing or the court of public opinion advocacy. Secondly, we do. We work with law enforcement. We identify the extremists, whether they're online or offline. We try to thwart incidents before they happen. We help the police to arrest the people who commit these kinds of crimes, but ultimately, to win hearts and minds. You can't litigate or or arrest. You've got to educate.
Jonathan GreenblattAnd it's this notion that hate can again corrode and expand and mutate unless you stop it.
Dov SeidmanTo fight hate, do you not fight it directly, but rather fight the indifference that enables it.
Jonathan GreenblattWell, look at ADL. We balance between the theory and the practice, right? So in theory, let's focus on the indifference. So that's kind of about the education. So we can, we can kind of embed these values, if you will, in the next generation, and curate more empathy, more understanding. But in practice, you know, the rabbi in Colleyville in his first interview after he was saved or he survived, he said, I'm alive today because of training I got from the FBI, law enforcement and the ADL, and literally every single day my last year, our analyst at ADL gave over 1300 tips to law enforcement about extremists or potential crimes that were going to unfold against Jews or other minorities. So on the one hand, I can't afford not to deal with evil
Dov SeidmanSo in the arena you have to toggle between a direct intervention or assault on hate and the systems change of scaling, scaling values, so that not, and not just values, but the kind of courage, so that people we don't have the kind of indifference that perpetuates. Or,
Jonathan GreenblattYeah, that's exactly right. I mean, there are some groups who just do, like, this wonderful group called Basic History and Ourselves that just does education. It's amazing. There's another group called Secure Communities network that just does defense, just a systems, just does, like, protecting things on the ground. At ADL, we do both, and we think that the toggling, as you described it, that balancing is appropriate. So we're dealing with the here and now, and we're dealing with the long term as well. The education opportunity that I had on the view is as important as the training we did. You know, in synagogues in Dallas, Texas, like they are two sides of the same coin, which is, how do we protect our community and other marginalized groups?
Dov SeidmanSo you mentioned Whoopi Goldberg and I followed it closely, and I've spent a lot of time trying to help purvey a framework of authentic apology. I once called for an apology ceasefire, because apology has become performative. Everybody's apologizing the confirmation bias it's in and a true apology is always followed by making amends, right? Always followed by getting touch with anybody that you might have victimized and asking them, how can I make it up to you in a meaningful way? It involves a moral audit of saying what's come of me that I could have done this or said this in the first place. It involves a public commitment to behavioral change. You forgave Whoopi Goldberg publicly, what about her apology? Felt? What made it sincere to you and meriting official forgiveness from the ADL so that we could just not fray or polarize even more.
Jonathan GreenblattSo, number one, I believe in this notion. And you were alluding to this earlier, that this, this, this phrase my friend Nick Cannon coined, we don't need cancel culture. We need Council culture, right? And I because I just, I believe you bring people in should be your first essay, not to push them out. So I think jet and there's a Jewish value of Chuba, right? This notion of repentance like it's not my idea. It's been around for 1000s of years, this notion that in our faith, we've all sinned, right? We've all made mistakes, and we need to, I think, as humans, have the ability to recognize when people acknowledge their error and seek to do better.
Dov SeidmanAnd since the ADL is so it's so central to the ADL to be an educator. And Aristotle taught that Educating the mind without educating the heart is no education at all. And what you're fighting, you know, as we know, that only that which comes from the heart enters the heart, yeah. How does the ADL? What are some of the pedagogical techniques that the ADL has to educate the heart?
Jonathan GreenblattI'll give you a couple ways. So number one, I think, as I mentioned before, our entire raise on debt, like our pedagogy is, again, you know, this advocacy and this kind of investigation combined with kind of education, right? Eight, it's not either or, it's both, and because we believe again, you gotta you may have to advocate and stop the crime, but you also gotta touch hearts and minds, as you said. And I did not know that Aristotle phrase, but it's exactly right. Some of these guys in Silicon Valley educated in the head, not in the heart.
Jonathan GreenblattSo number one, I think that's our raise on debt, as we do both. Number two, we do a lot of interfaith and inter group engagement work, the Iftar, the Seder, the worshiping together, breaking bread together, that stuff matters. I mean, social media is encouraged to kind of performative behavior, and we live in such a transactional society, but I think relational is the strongest kind of bonds that we can build.
Dov SeidmanWhat's your advice to people coming of age...in terms of educational choices they make when they enter the workforce for profit, nonprofit? They're coming of age in a world that's fraught, in a post pandemic world, in a world where the expression of hate has become more violent with incidents, what's your advice to a young person trying to make a life, trying to make a living, trying to build a career.
Jonathan GreenblattI think you got to follow your heart like I Don't believe necessarily that there's a linear path to success, though that's valid. You could do that, because I just don't think the most interesting things happen not on the path. Like, think about Talmud for a minute. Like, think about our own Jewish faith. Those interesting things are not what's on the page. It's the commentary around what's and so I think in life, it's not just, you know, the path you're on. It's what happens off the path.
Dov SeidmanTruly being on an up and down journey, and getting really good at zigging and zagging and going up and down, but always going forward towards true north, being really good at being on a journey and not on a linear path, I think is a important skill.
Jonathan GreenblattYou know, something else I would say, actually, to that point about the zigging and the zagging, like it's fun to talk to you, and I appreciate, again, your super generous introduction. But all my ventures haven't succeeded. Like I could think about one business I started that failed miserably. I could think about other setbacks I had in companies that I ran. And I say that because, you know, we laud success and we lionize like the winners, we often overlook, you know, when they lose, and so recognizing that the zig and the Zag means sometimes you're going to lose, you're going to you're going to miss that, you're going to fail.
Dov SeidmanRight? And finally, you know, there, this book could be daunting, because it's inviting people to go into a world of negativity, a world that can depress and make us sad, and at the same time, there's such a hopeful message in here that we can stop hate, we can make the world better. What gives you hope? What's your greatest source of hope? I'd like to end on a hopeful note.
Jonathan GreenblattWell, I give you the macro and the micro. I mean, first of all, my greatest source of hope is America. Like I am someone who believes in American exceptionalism, like this has been the greatest democracy in the history of of humanity. I mean, what we have achieved? I mean, it is indeed an imperfect Union, but that impulse, that design principle, to seek a more perfect union, is fundamental to this experiment. And it has been quite an experiment. And again, as you were saying earlier
Dov SeidmanAnd that's what makes us great. Us great, our greatness. Our greatness isn't are we getting an A in the class? Our greatness is that we're taking the class, that we're in the project, and we're not great when we're leaning out of the project and having a food fight in Congress and at each other, but as long as we're showing up to that class to engage in the project, then we're great.
Jonathan GreenblattI have great hope, because what the American people have shown after global conflicts and civil war and economic tumult and civil strife, like we were saying a few minutes ago, this country always rebounds and comes back better. So I do believe that we have that capacity. And then the second gives me hope is I just look at my kids. They are more empathetic than I was, they are more global than I was, they are more smart. They're smarter and more strategic than I was. And so I think the next generation gives again. It sounds really kind of cliche, but I look at my own children, when I see the world through their eyes, I feel enormous optimism.
Dov SeidmanThank you for embracing this conversation. It's been a special one.
What does it take to lead with purpose when the stakes are high - and across very different worlds? In this HOW Conversation, Dana Born sits down with Bob McDonald, former Chairman, President, and CEO of Procter &...
What does it take to lead when everything around you is changing? In this HOW Conversation, former 7-Eleven and Blockbuster CEO James Keyes joins HOW Fellow Dana Born to explore why great leadership isn't about avoiding...
In moments of uncertainty, leadership is revealed. Former U.S. Sec Def Mark Esper joins Dov Seidman for a conversation about the principles that guide leaders through crisis, complexity, and change. Reflecting on his...
What does moral leadership look like across generations of change? In our latest HOW Conversation, HOW Fellow Dana Born sits down with David Kohler, Chair and CEO of Kohler Co., to explore what it takes to lead with...
In this HOW Conversation, Elise Awwad, President and CEO of DeVry University, shares a deeply personal and practical perspective on moral leadership in a rapidly changing world. From her early lessons shaped by her...