Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Hidden Threads: Real Private Investigators. Real Cases. Real Stories.

Hidden Threads: Real Private Investigators. Real Cases. Real Stories. artwork

Your Phone Is the Best Witness Against You

Sep 8, 202620 minAudio

Send us Fan Mail Twenty years ago, an alibi was a story you told and somebody either backed up or didn't. Today it's a data set - and it doesn't care what you say. In this episode, Macky and Jus break down how the phone in a suspect's pocket has quietly become the most reliable witness in the room. Location history and geofence warrants that put a device within meters of a scene. Health app step counts and accelerometer data that show someone was walking, not sleeping. Cell site records, Wi-Fi and Bluetooth pings, car infotainment logs, and the smart doorbell down the street that nobody thought about. We talk about how these threads get pulled in real cases, why suspects so often destroy their own defense by lying about something the data already answered, and where investigators and juries get it wrong - because a phone's location is not the same as a person's location, and confidence in the number is not the same as accuracy. We also get into the other side of it: the innocent people this data has cleared, the limits of what these records actually prove, and what all of it means for the rest of us walking around carrying a witness we never swore in. Want me to write the 60-second hook for the clips, or a YouTube-length version with timestamps once you have the runtime? Support the show 866.910.7499 help@shadownetdigital.com

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_01So, Juice, you're talking about buying a new home. What's up with that? Oh, I just don't like the one I'm in. You don't like the location? No. You trying to get closer down this way?

SPEAKER_00Probably.

SPEAKER_01Okay. Rosalie, huh? You don't want to live in Rosalie anymore? No. You and your one neighbor up there?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, one neighbor. There ain't many people in Rosalie. No, there's not. I mean, it's not a bad area. It's just, it takes so long to get to everything.

SPEAKER_01Well, you got Bernie's That's it. Italian eatery up there, which is very good. Yeah. So the food there is exceptional, honestly. It is. I like it. We get it at church on Wednesday nights, so that's good. So you want a smaller house but more land, right? Yeah. What do you want on the land?

SPEAKER_00Trees. I want to be out in the middle of the acreage where nobody can see me. I want to be left alone.

SPEAKER_01Set in the shade with your thoughts and a cup of coffee.

SPEAKER_00Yes. All right. Well, I'll keep looking for you. I just have too much grass to cut. And with work in and other things, it's just becoming a pain. So I can this year I paid a guy to cut all my yards.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. Because I it was getting very expensive because I'd break something every time I would mow. Right. So I'm like, I'm done. Here, here, kid, can mow this. So yeah. It would get pricey after I'd break a lawnmower every week, you know. It happens. But uh are you you're not yeah, you hunt, right?

SPEAKER_00Yeah.

SPEAKER_01You don't come here and hunt this winter?

SPEAKER_00Are you kidding?

SPEAKER_01Your wife will kill me. We need to get some of these out of here.

SPEAKER_00These these are not huntable animals. These are now your pets. They come up to our fence over here now and look at us and watch us like wait a minute. Why would I have to come hunt when you're very capable behind the trigger? Because I don't want to have to clean it. So well, call me, I'll come clean it.

SPEAKER_01I don't want to I just want to clean the thing, so I'm lazy.

SPEAKER_00Okay, but call me, I'll clean it, and then you just take it up to the processor and get deer meat.

SPEAKER_01Give you half of it. So but I like deer meat, my wife doesn't like it very much. She doesn't. So really that's weird. It is. But yeah. Looking for juice a house. You guys have one for sale in Alabama. Email juice.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. So small house. With a lot of woods. Wooded property. Yeah. I don't want to mow anymore. Yeah, but you have to poison and bush hog.

SPEAKER_01No woods. No, you really don't. You spray poisons easy though.

SPEAKER_00Yeah.

SPEAKER_01Get rid of the get rid of the poison ivy and stuff.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, you just do a control burn once a year and keeps from round up burning house. But if it's there's enough trees on it, they're not gonna let anything grow underneath it anyway.

SPEAKER_01So no, but you could get the Roundup and get part of that lawsuit. Yeah, good. You see the commercials on TV. Yeah. Did you use Roundup? Everybody uses Roundup or something similar. All right. So we're talking about today about the crime scene in your pocket, Juice.

SPEAKER_00We are talking about a phone, just so everybody knows.

SPEAKER_01Juice has had that's a crime scene in your pants, Juice, not your pocket. Right, right. Talking about Thailand or something. But uh anyways I wasn't on the Lincoln. Anyways, but talking about cell phones, and I think it's made policing detective work easier based off what I've talked to but other ones.

SPEAKER_00It has.

SPEAKER_01If they get those phone records, you're pretty much done. Yeah. If they get your phone, you're definitely done. They've led the, you know, people say they have an alibi, and then they get that phone open, and it's like, well, you don't have an alibi anymore. So because we have your location. And some people use say, well, the cell phone towers and all that. Well, now they connect to Wi-Fi, which makes it even more precise. Yes. So I'm not I guess I'm not smart, but I go to Starbucks a lot and just set there and do work when I'm waiting on an appointment or something.

SPEAKER_01What do you got that look on your face? I hate Starbucks. I will not give them a penny of my money. I love their Majesty T. Okay. Well, you would. Anyway, anyway, I'll sit there and do work and I've connected their Wi-Fi. So I could go to a Starbucks in California and it automatically connects to Wi-Fi. Right. So if I committed a murder out back, I'm done.

SPEAKER_00You know, so that's how precise it can be. But there's there's so many identifiers on this thing.

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_00When you sent the message, that you sent the message, where you were when you sent the message, you're not gonna get away with anything.

SPEAKER_01There's been people caught because of the notes they put in the notes on their phone. Yes. You know, they've made it like a little diary. They're all time stamped, it's all identified. You're not gonna get away with anything. Right. A big identifier these days is lack of communication. Your phone turned off at a certain time and then turned back on later on. So that's another one. Here's one I haven't read about till today. Stephen McCollow and Natalie McNally, Northern Ireland Ireland. Is this your people? No, this is your enemy, right? Because you're British. Yes. Anyway.

SPEAKER_01Correct. 2026. This is a clean modern example. He was arrested right after her death, but ruled out as a suspect because he appeared to have an alibi. A six-hour live stream of him playing Grand Theft Auto on his YouTube channel with 37,000 subscribers. He's sitting there for six hours during her time of her murder on video playing a video game. All right. Okay. His alibi collapse when the cybercrime unit forensically examined the computer and found the video had been recorded days before the killing.

SPEAKER_01Absolutely. So he set this joker up. He planned a few. Investigators noted he claimed at the start of the video that he couldn't engage with live chat due to technical issues and repeatedly referenced the current time throughout an apparent attempt to reinforce the timeline. Prosecutors also put a C in CCTV phone data and forensic evidence showing him traveling while the stream appeared active. He got 31 years. He got live with a minimum 31 years.

SPEAKER_00You could be a member of Mensa. You are going to do something that's going to get you caught.

SPEAKER_01Right.

SPEAKER_00And these little things, these little pocket computers, are the downfall. Right.

SPEAKER_01Alex Murdaw.

SPEAKER_00Yeah.

SPEAKER_01The big thing that got him, they talk about the phone that was that recorded his voice, right? The I think it was his kid's phone that was dead that was recording at the time. Yeah. And you could hear his voice on there. But his watch showing his health data and where he was walking around there. Because he said he wasn't there, right?

SPEAKER_00Yeah.

SPEAKER_01But his health data on his watch showed him walking around and pacing elevated heart rate, too. Absolutely. And but it was a watch that did, you know, of course, his voice is on the dead person's phone. Right. But the uh that's crazy that his watch got him.

SPEAKER_00But my watch. He got something, he just hit the news again, something that they got new evidence that proves his innocence, and he's going back to trial.

SPEAKER_01He got a new trial based off some technicality. Yeah. So but they got a federal charge on him, too. Which that one's that's for him stealing money from clients. Right. So he'd make a contract. He was a personal injury guy, I think. But he would make a contract, say, hey, Mr. Client, we'll pay you this much, but he would hold how much they totally their total pay out.

SPEAKER_00He was skimming.

SPEAKER_01And he would hold out, you know, pay them lesser less than what they're supposed to get. So big no-no.

SPEAKER_00Yeah.

SPEAKER_01Contracts and stuff. But yeah, he got a new trial and a murder, which I don't think it's it's just gonna waste time, in my opinion. That's all it's gonna do. But he's also gonna get uh he's still got the federal stuff hanging over him. I think they charged him or convicted him already on the federal stuff. So he's not going anywhere anytime soon. So no. Then he had Chatry versus United States. So we talked about this one one time. So they got this guy's phone to look at the cell phone data. And while they're in there, they found a geofence that he had set up around the crime scene.

SPEAKER_00Oh, yeah, yeah.

SPEAKER_01And there the big thing was the police weren't allowed to, they're only allowed to look at what the warrant uh showed them. But the argument was it's the same as the plain view doctor. Well, I was looking in there and saw this, so we used it. And the Supreme Court said, Yeah, you can use it. So plain view stuff, right? Yep. Uh if I'm looking in your car and I see somebody bound and gagged in the backseat, I can open your door and assist that person.

SPEAKER_00Yeah.

SPEAKER_01And then charge you with binding them and gagging them, right?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, you can be in somebody's house for domestic violence and see pot on the table. Drug check. Plain view. Yeah. Now you're getting charged with that.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, or you go and do a convicted felon sex offender check and you see a weapon. That happened here recently. I don't know if you saw that in the local news. The the guy invited the cop in, just hey, do you want to be nice? Yeah. And he had a weapon laying up, a rifle, and the cop is like, You're not allowed to have that weapon because he's a felon.

SPEAKER_00Exactly.

SPEAKER_01And they arrested him. So people aren't smart. No. But this goes back to talking. So the phone does the talking for you, right? Yep. Remember, we talked about the way to get away with a crime is not talk about it.

SPEAKER_00Yep.

SPEAKER_01So here's the here's an issue. So let's talk about this. I want to commit a crime. Say I want to murder somebody, hypothetically. Okay. All right. We plan this thing out. I'm going to go kill them. I'll leave my phone at a certain place and turn it off.

SPEAKER_00Okay.

SPEAKER_01I go commit the crime. No cameras pick me up, no nothing. But they suspect I did it. You know, no evidence. And they try to say, Well, you turned your phone off during the time of that. Oh, I can turn my phone off whenever I want, right?

SPEAKER_00You can.

SPEAKER_01Here's what's getting people though is they turn their phone off and leave it, and then their car tracks them.

SPEAKER_00Yeah.

SPEAKER_01Because it has a cell phone-like system in it as well. A dumbed-down version of it, you know.

SPEAKER_00When they started putting computers in these vehicles, you were caught.

SPEAKER_01Right. So I guess you gotta do it by horse and wagon these days.

SPEAKER_00So if you're Amish, get away with murder. Yeah. So weird out, you know, an Amish Amish gangster's paradise.

SPEAKER_01So another thing that's happening lately, and it's getting chewed up in court, is the cell tower information. Right. All right. So what they're finding is a lot of the carriers aren't mark aren't recording every location of every call. So they're like, well, you know, if you're not gonna, you know, allow us to see everything, this warrant's no good, right? Right. So they're having to find it with other means means. They prompted an inquiry into 10,000 cases in Britain, basically. They had to go back and look at them. How much manpower that is?

SPEAKER_00That's crazy.

SPEAKER_01If you're trying to use cell data as a the only evidence, it can be easily argued against. Right. You gotta have other evidence to support it, right? Right. I've always said digital evidence alone does not convict people. No, you have to have other physical evidence to help out or testimonies.

unknownRight.

SPEAKER_00Now it can prove that the person was there or whatever, right? But you have to have supporting cooperating evidence to go out.

SPEAKER_01The totality of the evidence is the big thing, right? Here's some more. Here's another wearable one. The Richard debate in Connecticut. He claimed a masked intruder with a Vin Diesel voice shot his wife Connie and subdued him with it with pressure points. Vin Diesel. I know he's a strong dude, man, but come on. Her Fitbit showed he was up and moving around an hour before she was up and moving around an hour after he said she'd been killed. A slew of other digital artifacts also undermined his account, home alarm sensors, Facebook activity, and cell phone records.

SPEAKER_01Convicted 65 years. The Connecticut Supreme Court upheld the Fitbit evidence on a 6-0 appeal.

SPEAKER_00So the big Vin Diesel dim mock touch didn't work.

SPEAKER_01Right. Subdued me with pressure points. Yeah. You better subdue good.

SPEAKER_00Yeah.

SPEAKER_01Pressure points hurt, but they're not gonna, you know. No.

SPEAKER_00It's just a control technique. It's not permanent. It's not, you know, it doesn't shut your body down. No. Come on. No, it doesn't.

SPEAKER_01Then you got Karen Navarra ver in California. Her death initially looked natural. Her Fitbit showed a sudden sharp heart rate spike, followed by an abrupt stop, which established it as a homicide and fixed the time. Contradiction, her stepfather's account, which he hasn't gone to jail yet. I mean, he's they haven't tried him yet.

SPEAKER_00So no.

SPEAKER_01But he did something to kill her, stressed her out at that time. So and he lied about it. A 2015 Pennsylvania case ran the other way. A woman's fitness watch disproved her own rape account. So her Fitbit said that she was had a heart rate between 50 and 60 beats a minute over the time she said she was raped.

SPEAKER_00Yep.

SPEAKER_01And if you're under that kind of stress, your heart rate's gonna spike over a hundred, probably. A normal person.

SPEAKER_00At least over a hundred.

SPEAKER_01Yep. And then we got this one. This one's cool. Implanted medical devices.

SPEAKER_00Yes.

SPEAKER_01The old what's that thing they put in your heart? The pacemaker. Pacemaker that connects to Wi-Fi. Yeah. All right, here we go. State of Ohio versus Ross Compton. He said the fire woke him. He panicked. He packed a suitcase and bags, broke a bedroom window with his cane, threw the items out, and carried them to his car. So a fire's going on, and he packed a suitcase. Police warrant obtained his pacemaker data, heart rate, pacer, demand, cardiac rhythms before, during, and after the fire.

SPEAKER_01A cardiologist concluded it was highly improbable he could have collected, packed, and hauled that much in a time in the time claimed given his condition. Gasoline was on his clothes, and the fire started in multiple places. Judge denied the suppression and let the pacemaker data in. First U.S. case of its kind. That's cool, man.

SPEAKER_00Commit Nars and you're you got a pacemaker, and you you're gonna tell me that you decided during a fire to pack a bag.

SPEAKER_01Throw some underwear in this box. Yeah, because you never know what happens. You gotta have clean underwear. Right. Fire happens at my house. We're gonna go out and we will go to Walmart. We'll go to Walmart and get you some britches. So to hold you over. Yeah. We got I got you and I got some family members that would go get us some britches for a little while.

SPEAKER_00Absolutely. Now, for you, I'll go get like extra small huggies or something. You know what I mean?

SPEAKER_01Because you're dirty.

SPEAKER_00You're dirt bag, that's why. Yes.

SPEAKER_01You just want to see me wearing huggies. I do. I do. And then you got media metadata. The McCullough case earlier, the artifact wasn't location, it was an encoding timestamp on a video that he assumed nobody would examine at that level. So this case we talked about another earlier, where the guy was posting his ex-girlfriend's pictures on the porn sites. Right. So three of the porn sites, we got into the we were down downloaded the photos from the site, and the metadata was stripped, which is what they typically do. One site it was not.

SPEAKER_01Only takes one. The location where it was and the time it was taken.

SPEAKER_00Only takes one.

SPEAKER_01We me and Shana Miller, my other employee, went through, I think it was 20, 270 photos to get to those. And it was like ding ding ding, we got them. You know what I mean? Kind of thing. And then we also couple that with we got a receipt from the hotel where the pictures were taken, and he was there. A couple other things like that. You know what I mean? So this guy's in trouble. Good. I'm more upset over the school system firing her, though.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, that I don't get. I hope she sues them. I hope she wins. Because it's not a crime to take naked pictures. No. And she didn't post them. So she's being punished for what he did. Right. I mean, if if you and your significant other at the time, you want to do that, I I highly suggest nobody ever does that. Yeah. But if you do it, that's between two consenting adults. Yeah, people do it. People have made mistakes in their past. I've made a lot of mistakes in my past. I don't know anybody who hasn't made a mistake in their past.

SPEAKER_00And it still comes back to haunt you. But when you make that mistake, it's understandable you get questioned. When somebody else does this to you years later, and a school board fires you over it, that's wrong.

SPEAKER_01How about this? The superintendent at the time and the guy that took the photos are best friend. Oh. Wa. It just keeps getting deeper. The detective in the case, the local detective, they reported it to him. He goes and tells the guy, and the pictures come down immediately.

SPEAKER_00Why would he go tell?

SPEAKER_01They're all buddies.

SPEAKER_00Tell me. And then they came back up again. Tell me it was this county.

SPEAKER_01No, different county. Small county, but different. So I would have believed it was this one. I wouldn't put it past these knuckleheads around here, but anyhow.

SPEAKER_00Neither would I.

SPEAKER_01But you know, when you start messing around like that as an investigator, FBI start sniffing around, you know, because they didn't. That's one of their investigative tasks, is corrupt police officers, right?

SPEAKER_00So corruption is one of their I I can't stand a dirty cop. I cannot stand them.

SPEAKER_01If it's your friend, get somebody else on it and just ignore it. You know what I mean?

SPEAKER_00Well, first of all, if it's a friend of yours, you're not supposed to be ignored, you're not supposed to be on that case anyway. You have to rec recuse yourself from that case. Tell the sheriff, hey, bro. Hey, look, this is a buddy of mine. I can't do this. Hand it to another one. Let the other guy handle the investigation. We may be friends, but because it's an investigation, I can't say anything.

SPEAKER_01You can't rat me, you can't rat on me. You can't go. That's like obstruction stuff, right?

SPEAKER_00That's you're you're walking that line, yeah.

SPEAKER_01Obstruction's a big one. So anyway, yeah, this all comes together under our, you know, we do it on the civil side mostly. Yeah. We get into some criminal defense work where the police try to say, just because we said. Yeah, that doesn't work either. And they hire us to come in and tear their reports apart, which we do. Police don't like it. Now I'm not here to say I like child pornographers either.

SPEAKER_00Right.

SPEAKER_01But the police can't just go just because we said.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, that doesn't work. It's not the way it goes. Right.

SPEAKER_01What else you think about this stuff?

SPEAKER_00You're not gonna get away with anything. Everything has a a timestamp, an identifier. You may think you're getting away with something. You may think you're you're scrubbing it. You may think you know you've gotten rid of all the you have not gotten rid of all the evidence. I promise you, you haven't. Someone's gonna find it.

SPEAKER_01Right. Especially instead of you talking, your phone's talking for you. So telling on you.

SPEAKER_00So you don't have to tell anybody. Your phone will snitch.

SPEAKER_01Your car snitch, your pacemaker.

SPEAKER_00Anything, anything electronic.

SPEAKER_01It's connected to that Wi-Fi. Well, you had the rape lady saying she was being raped, but it her heart rate never got above 60.

SPEAKER_00Yeah.

SPEAKER_01So impossible.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, that's a crisis situation. Yeah. Your heart rate is gonna go up. I don't care if you're on metaprolol or whatever you're on. You've been attacked.

SPEAKER_01Yes. But all right, Juice, we're gonna get off here and let you go bush hog somewhere, whatever you're doing.

SPEAKER_00No, gotta go shopping.

SPEAKER_01Supposed to be cooler today.

SPEAKER_00So I gotta get some blackout curtains.

SPEAKER_01So you can sleep?

SPEAKER_00Yeah. All right. That's the biggest thing. Take magnesium and and get blackout curtains, is what I'm told.

SPEAKER_01Okay.

SPEAKER_00Because you know how bad my sell those at Walmart? Yeah.

SPEAKER_01Do they? I didn't know they sold them there. Yeah. My wife has some. Now hers are thick, but they're more for in the winter time that and you close them that keeps the heat in. You know what I mean? Yeah. It's extra insulation, I guess you'd call it. So because her the bedroom is on that north side of the house there, so it gets cold in the winter with those wind blowing against the windows. So all right, we're off here, but we'll see what you buy next time, Juice. Yeah, we'll be back next time. All right.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Caught on the Ring Doorbell: Ex-Cop Lawrence Goodine and the Murder of Kara Akins | Hidden Threads

    Nov 19, 202634 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail Kara Akins, a mother of seven, had a no-contact order against former Chattanooga police officer Lawrence Goodine. In November 2023, her own Ring doorbell recorded her running outside, yelling for help,...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. The Yacht, the Hotel and $50,000 in Checks: Public Corruption From Jackson to Knoxville | Hidden Threads

    Nov 17, 202626 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail An FBI undercover team posed as hotel developers in Jackson, Mississippi, and the city officials who could approve the project started taking money. There was a trip to Florida on a yacht, cash bribes,...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Badges for Hire: The FBI Sting That Caught Mississippi Sheriffs Guarding Cocaine | Hidden Threads

    Nov 13, 202627 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail Drug dealers in the Mississippi Delta kept telling federal agents the same thing: the cops were on the payroll. The FBI's Jackson Field Office took that seriously and built a years-long undercover sting...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. They Quit and Took Your Secrets: How Employees Steal Company Data | Hidden Threads

    Oct 30, 202621 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail Your top salesman gives two weeks' notice. A month later, your biggest clients are buying from a competitor, and your pricing sheet looks awfully familiar. In this episode of Hidden Threads, Macky...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Is Someone Tracking You? AirTags, GPS Trackers & Phone Spyware Exposed | Hidden Threads

    Oct 27, 202612 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail That "AirTag Found Moving With You" alert. The car that always seems to know where you've been. The ex who shows up wherever you go. In this episode of Hidden Threads, Macky Outlaw and Jus break down...

    Credit the people on this episode