Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Hidden Threads: Real Private Investigators. Real Cases. Real Stories.

Hidden Threads: Real Private Investigators. Real Cases. Real Stories. artwork

Caught on the Ring Doorbell: Ex-Cop Lawrence Goodine and the Murder of Kara Akins | Hidden Threads

Nov 19, 202634 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Send us Fan Mail Kara Akins, a mother of seven, had a no-contact order against former Chattanooga police officer Lawrence Goodine. In November 2023, her own Ring doorbell recorded her running outside, yelling for help, as he chased her down, wrapped an arm around her neck and dragged her back into the house. Hours passed before anyone called 911. Goodine told police she had overdosed. The medical examiner ruled blunt force trauma and manual strangulation. Macky and Jus walk through how the case was proven: the doorbell video, a phone call that put a second timestamp on the argument, the delayed 911 call, and a minute-by-minute timeline. A jury convicted Goodine on all seven counts, including first-degree felony murder. They also cover what this case teaches private investigators: canvassing a neighborhood for camera footage before it gets recorded over, how video gets authenticated in court, what a motion in limine is, and why the defense side needs investigators too. Plus some politics and world events to open the show. Support the show 866.910.7499 help@shadownetdigital.com

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_02All right, here we are, Juice. Again. They haven't paid kicked this off of YouTube yet. Not yet, but I'm working on that. Or Apple or Spotify. They haven't kicked this off yet. Yeah. YouTube is the bigger one. Yeah. Because they love our faces. Look at this. Yeah. This face. Yeah, it's the face. I'm looking right in like looking at you. Anyways, the it's the face, the hair, my Brad Pitt good looks. Yeah. I don't have any eyebrows. I have eyebrows, you just can't see them. So they're real thin. You do? They're real thin. Yeah. Oh.

SPEAKER_02I used to have dark ones. They fell out the last trip in Afghanistan.

SPEAKER_03It happens.

SPEAKER_02I maybe want to get that looked at. I don't know. But that's not normal, is it? So I don't know. They did. They fell out and they grew back real light. So who knows what's in the ground in Afghanistan.

SPEAKER_03So well, it's shape savion shampoo and stuff.

SPEAKER_02Well, the Russians, you know, they just dumped whatever on the way out.

SPEAKER_03Of course.

SPEAKER_02That's their tactics. They'll dump all their explosives and gas and everything on the way out and just leave it. So they're not the only ones. Oh yeah. We just give it to them.

SPEAKER_03Well, yeah. Yeah, I I don't know if we would consider that dumping or just handing it over to Al Qaeda.

SPEAKER_02We're just like, here's you can have these boxes. They're not here's the keys. Yeah. Here take our trucks. You know, I was over there. We lived it right next to the embassy on the back side. Our camp was on the back side of the embassy. Right. And that's where they stored all the connex boxes for storage for everything. Right. And it was a it had to be three miles worth of three three high connex boxes down through there. Nice. You know, you're talking a century of gear and everything. And a brand new embassy. That embassy was nice.

SPEAKER_02And we just handed it over.

SPEAKER_03Of course, because that's what we do. We don't care. Build it up and put all kinds of equipment and say, here you go.

SPEAKER_02It was as good as any building you would see in DC, a new building. Just picture that. You know, modern amenities and everything. And built a hotel for the government workers right there next to it. Towers.

SPEAKER_03Don't luckily Biden pulled everybody out.

SPEAKER_02Right. In a smart manner.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, yeah.

SPEAKER_02Somehow that's Trump's fault, Juice. Bowl and ball. That's Trump's fault. You know that, right? Yeah.

SPEAKER_03He gets blamed for everything.

SPEAKER_02So we mentioned in one of our previous episodes about socialism. We define socialism.

SPEAKER_03Yes, that was one of them we defined, yes.

SPEAKER_02Yeah. You know, it's when this is a simple answer, it's when government controls the means of oper production, right? Correct. Either partially or fully. We have a semi-socialist society here where you know you have to pay to play.

SPEAKER_03Yeah.

SPEAKER_02Don't pay your property taxes and see what happens. Exactly. I know you paid taxes when you bought the house. Of course. And you get to you get you have to pay tribute every year. Yes.

SPEAKER_03For them allowing you to buy your house and pay taxes on it.

SPEAKER_02Again. Yes. That's the dumbest thing ever seen.

SPEAKER_03Yes.

SPEAKER_02So these cameras and microphones here, I paid sales tax when I bought them. Right. I don't have to pay an why don't I have to pay an annual tax on those? I don't know. It's a mystery. And the computers, you know, all the crap I got here. But yeah, these homes we own, yeah, I have to pay tribute to the king, which is the county in this case, in the state, to to live here. So it's partially socialism.

SPEAKER_03It's not a full Oh yeah, you're outside city limits too.

SPEAKER_02Yeah. I have to pay to the county.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, we just do county and state.

SPEAKER_02Yep. And if you lived in one of the cities, Fort Payne or Rainsville or something, you have to pay a tax to them, I think. Wait a minute.

SPEAKER_03No, I don't I don't have to pay tax on mine.

SPEAKER_02But you live in Rosalie.

SPEAKER_03Yeah. It's not Rainesville. No, but I don't have to pay tax on my stuff anyway.

SPEAKER_02Right. Now, also, I have business in Huntsville. Right. Okay. Madison County and Huntsville City, and one in Birmingham and Jefferson County. Right. Check this out. So I have to pay a s tax every year, and I do my taxes, right, for income on the business. To the Fed, state, and every other politician with their hand out. I have to pay homage to the kings of Madison County and Huntsville City just to do be able to do business there.

SPEAKER_02Right. Every year.

SPEAKER_03Well you gotta do that down Birmingham, everywhere. Yeah, I do.

SPEAKER_02And it's in my opinion, that's socialism. Yeah, I'd agree. All right. Now, somebody said that because Trump has said, hey, I'll give you$5,000 if we win the midterms. That's it. They said that's socialism. You gotta be kidding me. No, I had to explain what a rebate is and all that. That's a tax rebate. So it's not a or rebate or you can name it whatever you want, but that's not socialism.

SPEAKER_03No, it's not.

SPEAKER_02Socialism doesn't give you money, they take money. Exactly. So, anyways. Yeah, I'm not a I'm not a dummy. I know we have semi-socialist tendencies here in the United States. I'm sure we do. You know, we're trained up by the British who love socialism. So that's where we get our tax system from.

SPEAKER_03I just don't understand where they they get you know, Trump could come up with a cure for cancer. And they'd be mad about that.

SPEAKER_01Right.

SPEAKER_03They would. You know, like, no, I want my cancer.

SPEAKER_02All right. I don't agree with everything Trump does. I don't think he's conservative enough. I'm super con I'm hyper conservative. You're more you go more towards the middle a little bit on certain things.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, I mean you can't I'm conservative in a lot of ways, but I'm also liberal in a lot of ways. So I I kind of ride the middle, but I don't agree with everything Trump does.

SPEAKER_02I do not. Neither do I. What's just an example? This Iran war, okay? I know I think we should have blasted them decades ago. Yeah. And I don't disagree with crippling them. Here's my problem. Why isn't over?

SPEAKER_03It should be over. It should have been over in '79 after they released the hostages. We should have turned that place into a glass parking lot. And then they gave us another chance when they blew up Beirut. And then the coal. Yeah. And then it just repeated itself so many times over the years.

SPEAKER_02And nobody had the balls to do anything until Trump came along. But here's my thing. I think it should have been over. Like we, you know, we are the most powerful military in the world. If we turned them loose, it would have been over already. That place would be a parking lot.

SPEAKER_03Yeah.

SPEAKER_02Let General Watts' face, that Air Force guy, hey General, let give report back in 90 days. Right. You know what I mean? Yeah. You know, limit civilian casualties and all that. But but I don't know what he's doing. He's squeezing them on the money. They don't have any money right now. So no, they don't.

SPEAKER_03But it I don't understand a lot of the game plan. Bush one did it, Bush two did it, Clinton did it, Obama did it, Biden did it. They all play that game with them. I don't think Trump should be playing that game with them.

SPEAKER_01Right.

SPEAKER_03Um, uh when when Carter was in, I'll give the man credit, he tried to get the hostages. Yeah. It went bad. Reagan told him, You're gonna release them hostages because when I get in, I'm gonna annihilate you. Right. He got elected. They knew he wasn't gonna play and they let them go. Right. Why is Trump playing with him?

SPEAKER_02Yeah, no. It doesn't I I'm gonna be called a racist or whatever. Negotiating with Muslim nations is very you can't do it. It's futile. You you it's an impossibility to negotiate with them.

SPEAKER_03They only respond to power. Exactly. Um that's the only thing they respond to. And there's a lot of people out there gonna hear that and they're gonna be like, oh my god, you're wrong. You don't know. It's exactly what it is.

SPEAKER_02I live with them for basically 10 years. I don't want to hear I don't want to hear your mouth out there.

SPEAKER_03Exactly. Especially when you haven't left your living room or mommy and daddy's basement. Yeah. Because, you know, that's where the games are.

SPEAKER_00Yeah.

SPEAKER_03You get to run your your console and game all day. Right. And then you get to play keyboard commando and be a tough guy.

SPEAKER_01Right.

SPEAKER_02I know we don't want to just hurt innocent civilians and all that stuff, but the the military targets, I don't understand whether how are they still able to fire a missile right now? I have no idea. You can't tell me that the U.S. doesn't have the intel. Well, we get off, we go off the Jewish Intel, which they've had people on the ground there for century almost.

SPEAKER_03Oh, you're gonna get in trouble for that one now, too.

SPEAKER_02Oh, because I'm pro-Jew? Yeah. I am. I'm pro-Israel. Sorry. Everybody go cry. So from the Bible, I will bless those who bless those and curse those who curse you, which has repeated itself over and over again in history. God's serious about what he says. And you know, and you know, I think that's the only reason we're as a nation we're still standing because we've supported Israel as a nation as a whole, financially and militarily. So, but that's the spiritual side, Juice. Sorry.

SPEAKER_03I don't know if I would agree a hundred percent with that. There's there's other things in play, I would say.

SPEAKER_02Understood, yeah.

SPEAKER_03But I I think that's a large majority.

SPEAKER_02Yeah. Tucker Carlson's come out against Israel. He's pro I don't even want to get. You know, we're supposed to have a talk on a case today, but we're talking about other stuff.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, I I know. That's okay. We go off on tangents. We're really gonna get bashed on this one, but I love it. I don't care. Bring it liberal. We're not bashing anything. If they want to bash us, leave your sofa, come down here, pull up a chair, and talk to us. We'll put you on the air, man. I don't care.

SPEAKER_02I'll bring you coffee. Oh, I'll bring donuts for them, bring cookies. A jack's biscuit. I don't know. I'll let their mommy come with them. We're nice people. We'll listen to you, and then we're gonna tell you our ideas. Exactly. And then we're gonna put out some statistics and facts, and you're gonna get mad and want to kill us.

SPEAKER_03Right. But the funny thing is when you sit and talk to people, when they actually want to engage in a discussion, you kind of find out there you have a lot of things in common. It's very few things that separate everybody.

SPEAKER_02Yeah. Tucker Carlson is saying that this is not the Israel that the Bible talks about. It hasn't moved, it's the same piece of dirt, so I'm not sure what he's talking about.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, I'm he's lost his true where it was to begin with.

SPEAKER_02I think he's back on the bottle. Possibly. All right. Do we want to talk about this case or keep talking politics?

SPEAKER_03Yeah, let's get to the case because this is something that really spins my gears. This one.

SPEAKER_02I got your gears spun up on politics already.

SPEAKER_03Yeah.

SPEAKER_02I guess the next episode we'll talk about me bumping my head under the house, so we'll be less serious. Yeah. So, all right. So, this is the case we're talking about today. Oh, off the politics and world matters. We're here, we're here to talk about how private investigators match up with everyday life. You ready for this? Yeah, let's let's get this one rolling. Juice Mike Custer in this one. Uh, Lawrence Goodline Good Goodine. Goodine, yeah. Lawrence Goodine, murder of Kara Akins in Chattanooga, Tennessee, about 45 minutes from the house here, depending on traffic.

SPEAKER_02Right. Traffic's awful. And construction. Yeah. They've been working on that road into there since I was a child, by the way. All right, here's some facts. Uh Lawrence Goodine is a former Chattanooga police officer. He last served on the force in 2009. He was fired after being accused of stealing and extortion, though he was cleared. But he's not allowed to be a cop anymore.

SPEAKER_03Yeah. I'm gonna tell you, I believe he was either told to resign or be fired. Right. The victim, Kara Akins, 48, mother of seven.

SPEAKER_02Mother of seven. She was busy. She's like the old lady that lived in the shoe.

SPEAKER_03Yeah.

SPEAKER_02So anyway, killed in November 2023 at home on Carr Street in Chattanooga. Okay, this is tragic because you got seven kids here and lost her mom. Seems like a pretty good mom, but anyway. After about a month before the murder, there was a domestic violence incident between them and a no contact order was in place. Prosecutors entered Aikens' October. Prosecutors entered Aikens' October 2023 no contact order as evidence. Okay? A ring doorbell captured the two arriving at the home.

SPEAKER_02Apparently these two are in some kind of relationship. Right. Right. Then captured Aikens running outside yelling for help and telling him to stop. Something's going down in the house. Goodon chased her down, wrapped his arms around her neck, and pulled her back in the house with a no contact order in place, right? So Tennessee calls it no contact order. Here we call it protection from abuse. Same stuff. Right, right. Okay. You're not allowed. It says it specifically. You can't get within a thousand feet.

SPEAKER_02You can't call them. You can't bother them through the internet. Whatever. It'll say all that stuff. Sometimes it says your agents can't do it either. That's when they put the private, no private investigator thing in there. So prosecutors say goodon spent several hours covering up the crime before calling 911. They say he moved her body and washed her. Okay. So they got into an argument of some sort. He brought her back in and whacked her.

SPEAKER_03This isn't the first time. Right. What do you mean? This is not the everybody thinks, oh, it just happened. This is this time was the icing on the cake. No. This stuff starts gradually. Right. Until he or she gets comfortable to put their hands on the other person. Right. If he went out there, double armed her and scooped her up and pulled her back into the house, he's done this before.

SPEAKER_02My wife asked me a question here.

SPEAKER_03So you can't you can't say, oh, this you know that they just had this one issue and the protection from abuse was ordered. And no. This has happened before. Right. Guaranteed. Right. Sorry, my wife asked me a question. That's right.

SPEAKER_02She's allowed. My beautiful bride. She's the boss. My beautiful bride of almost 20 years, juice. Do you believe she's let me stay around that long? No. It's crazy. It is. Anyway. Can we question her sanity? Right. I've never had a protection from abuse put against me. So anyways, so people typically tell you who they are. That's what I look at. Like there's gonna be some signs, right? I'm sure she gave him a couple chances, and then she finally said, Hey, get out, and that's when he started putting hands on.

SPEAKER_02So when officers arrived, he kept telling him she took something and pushed an overdose story. All right. The medical examiner ruled the cause of death was blunt force trauma and manual strangulation. What kind of pill is that, juice? It was a baseball bat pill. Blunt force trauma and overdose don't unless you have a car crash.

SPEAKER_03Why would he even say that? This this is why he's a mental midget. They're gonna do a toxicology. The toxicology is gonna come back and it's gonna show what in her system. Nothing. Right. Nothing that would make her do this. Why? Why even come up with that lie? Come up with something like, oh, she fell.

SPEAKER_02You know, I've taken the medical legal courses and you've taken similar courses, and they can tell if you fell from five feet and slammed your head on the ground. Oh, absolutely. Or if there was force where your head hit the ground. Absolutely. Or if an object hit your head. Yeah. Especially with penetrating, you know, if you go through the skull, all that stuff. It's not hard. It doesn't take a medical examiner to go, man, that does not look like a fall. Somebody fell over and hit their head on the ground.

SPEAKER_03Yeah. Man, that looks like the front of a carpenter's hammer in his head.

SPEAKER_02That's right. I've fallen, you know, wrestling, goofing around, playing sports, slap your head off of a wooden floor, concrete floor. Yeah, it hurts, but it typically does not crack the skull from a normal distance. I'm talking falling over from however tall you are. Typically. Oh, yeah. Now, if you get, I'm talking if you're an older person where your bones are more brittle, yes.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, that's a little bit different.

SPEAKER_02But this woman was a middle-aged, healthy woman. So from all accounts. All right.

SPEAKER_03And with seven kids, pretty sure she was active. So she's not a couch potato.

SPEAKER_02Well, she can't with them. You know, you're constantly wrangling cats here. Absolutely. A witness testified that Goodon, the cop, called her around the time the ring doorbell captured the argument, and the woman on the line identified herself as Kara. That gives a second timestamp data point that overlaps the video. Goodon called her around the time the ring doorbell captured the argument, and the woman on the line identified herself as Kara. All right. Got that. Another witness testified that a woman Goodon stayed with after the death passed along a message from him that he didn't have to talk to the police.

SPEAKER_02So he'd already gone on to the next woman. So Absolutely. Mm-hmm. The defense filed motions in Lemini. What does that mean, Juice? I've never heard of that. One sought to bar any what they're saying is they want to bar evidence. Right? They want to keep evidence out from in front of the jury's what that means. Okay. Okay. One sought to bar any mention of the ring video until let me ask the question while we're doing this. Until the specific clip was identified and authenticated, the judge admitted the video over defense objection.

SPEAKER_02So they didn't want the entire video out there.

SPEAKER_03Okay. So they just wanted the parts where it shows he didn't do anything, but they want to pull out the parts where it showed him wrapping her up and jerking her back into the house. Right. Oh, yeah, yeah. That makes sense.

SPEAKER_02All right, we're gonna get an official legal definition of liminy or lame. What is it? What is it, juice? Let's see what it says here. This is the first time I heard that one. In Lemine, Limini, correct me there, lawyers. Uh Latin for threshold, a motion to in limini is a request a lawyer files before trial or before a piece of evidence comes up, asking the judge to rule ahead of time on whether that evidence can be used. The point is to keep the jury from ever seeing it because once they've heard it, an ejection can't do it. So all right. Let's say here's another one.

SPEAKER_02How to pronounce it.

SPEAKER_03I was gonna give you the pronunciation.

SPEAKER_00Mm-hmm.

SPEAKER_03Hey, I'm just a C student from Fife here.

SPEAKER_02Limini. I said it right. All right. Some say it lemonade. Limine? Limine.

SPEAKER_03Yeah. Liminee. Never heard of it.

SPEAKER_02Limine now and then, but lemony is what you'll hear in most courtrooms. Good. All right. So, hey, we learned something today, right? We did. So I was watching me and my wife were watching a crime show last night, and they did this. They didn't call it that. They just filed motions. Hey, we don't want like their past criminal history. They don't want it brought up. It's kind of the same thing. All right. Here we go. Prosecutors say good on a ring doorbell camera captured two arriving at the home. It then captured Akins running outside, yelling for help and telling them to stop.

SPEAKER_02Goodon chased her down, wrapped his arms around her neck, and pulled her back inside. We've already covered that, right? A witness testified. We talked to that one. A defense filed motions in lemon, lemonade, whatever. The trial was delayed multiple times. One delay came because the defense said it needed more time to retain an expert witness and a private investigator. Cool. Defense doing their job there, right? Right. Jury selection and opening statements were October 17, 2026, and it was a five-day trial, and Goodon waived his right to testify.

SPEAKER_02Imagine that. So guilty on all seven counts, including first-degree felony murder, aggravated kidnapping, and tampering with evidence, life sentence on the felony murder count, sentencing on the remaining counts, it counts as set for October.

SPEAKER_03See, at that point, what does it matter what the other counts are and sentencing is? That guy right there for what he did, they should light him up.

SPEAKER_02Former cop? Yeah. They're gonna put him in there with gin pop.

SPEAKER_03Oh yeah. I hope he enjoys it. And I think they all should go. He may get locked down. So he can't stay locked down forever. I hate to tell everybody, you can still get gotten lockdown. Right.

SPEAKER_02But yeah, so it the remaining counts. What I've been told by other lawyers is that the if they so if he appeals the first degree and it gets off or whatever, they have the other one so they can keep him hemmed up. So yeah, it's just stacking charges on him. Yeah. Especially in a serious case like this, in case one gets a lost on appeal. So we had a case last year, I don't know if you remember that, but it was a a doctor who tried to murder his wife, right? He beat her face off the cabinets.

SPEAKER_03Oh, yeah, yeah, yeah.

SPEAKER_02And he got let out on appeal. Right. He got he got overturned on appeal for some some technicality of how we like to do in the United States.

SPEAKER_03You know, we don't have a court of justice, we have a court of It's not that he didn't do it, but they made an error in the procedure.

SPEAKER_02Yeah. We have a court of uh administration instead of a court of justice, by the way. So people a lot of people get mad when I say that, but sorry. That's true. Anyway, and he got he still had a no contact, like he couldn't be within, you know, he couldn't come back and harass her or whatever. That was put in the thing. And they hired us to use our tag notify and we have the ability to see where tags show up on around the world, right? On these little cameras and stuff, flight cameras. That's controversial.

SPEAKER_02And they hired us to do that and to see if he'd try to get into her computer systems or anything like that. She's a doctor too. But anyway, yeah, he got let out on that. He didn't have any more, they didn't stack anything else, just attempted murder. But so if they had something stacked on there, yeah, yeah, he could still be in jail. But he's a dangerous guy. I saw I saw where he's applied to get his medical license back.

SPEAKER_03Well, unfortunately, he got out it on a technicality. It's not that he didn't. And do it. Some defense attorney was good at his job and said, Oh, you guys missed this for a procedure. Let him out. Yeah, why don't they retry it though? Maybe they are. There's some of them that are worth doing a retrial.

SPEAKER_02I mean, they can cause just as the defense can appeal, the prosecution can do the same. The state can say, Hey, we want to, we got questions too, pal. Absolutely. But I'm not sure what the exact rules are there. But that's kind of why they stack it, because this guy could come back and try to kill her again. Right. You know, he messed her up good. Like she had to get false teeth, get her face reconstructed, that kind of stuff. You know, like she was laying there bleeding. But he won't touch a man. Right. I met her, he's not her husband yet, but her fiance, retired Air Force peririscuan.

SPEAKER_02Oh, come on around. Yeah. He's a paramedic down in Birmingham now. So come on, come on by. So swing on in. We didn't get into it, but I'm sure he'd like to go take care of him now. But he don't, you know, he don't want to go to prison. So, anyways, how this relates to private investigations. So, this they did a neighborhood camera canvas, which we've done that. Right. It turned on a doorbell camera, and any death, assault, or domestic case, one of the first things we do is we go around and start talking to people. It's called a canvas. You know, it used to be you just ask getting people's witness testimony.

SPEAKER_02Now they've got the little cameras all over the house.

SPEAKER_03Well, you remember that that one case that that we investigated on the suicide? Yeah. Wasn't sure it was suicide. After we looked at it, I think we figured out. But the first thing we did is those businesses that were across the street, as soon as we started looking, we seen the cameras, we went right over there. Had they would have not looped the digital recorder, that thing was taped over like a week after he went missing. So it it was close to the time where that person went missing, and we missed it by a week.

SPEAKER_03Here's the problem with that though.

SPEAKER_02If you're if you're a detective on the police side, wouldn't you want to freeze that evidence in place? I would, but the cops never went over there. Okay.

SPEAKER_03All right. We did, but police never went over there and questioned anybody at those businesses.

SPEAKER_02Because I've worked wrecks before, and a lot of those stopping shops or whatever, they will that we'll be like, hey, I'm looking at this wreck that happened two days ago. And they'll let you basically what they do is they let the video run and you record it with your phone.

SPEAKER_00Yeah.

SPEAKER_02That's that's the easiest way to do it. Yeah. Now if they get a warrant from the cops or subpoena, they have to make a video, you know, make a copy of it on the thumb drive or whatever.

SPEAKER_03Had the whoever was there there was a jurisdictional issue.

SPEAKER_02They fought about it for about a month.

SPEAKER_03Yeah. Which is had somebody would have just gone over there and checked that camera, right? The the family wouldn't have had to go through all that.

SPEAKER_02I hate to say it, Juice. No one where that happened. Just another black guy dead.

SPEAKER_03Yeah.

SPEAKER_02They didn't really get into it. I know. That's what happens over in that area where that happened.

SPEAKER_03I know. And it it's a shame that that's the way it is in that area. Right. But the first thing we do when we seen those cameras, we were over at those businesses. I wasn't, you were. Well. I said, Hey, Juice, go do this. So But that's the the first place I went.

SPEAKER_02Yeah.

SPEAKER_03You start looking around, you know. Of course you do.

SPEAKER_02Now everybody, I got cameras outside my house.

SPEAKER_03If something happened out here, ring cameras, uh oh, there's so many of the other ones.

SPEAKER_02If the dude got murdered across the road and the cops said, Hey, let me see your camera. I'd say, Yeah, sure, here. You know, I'd let them see it. I got nothing. We know we're not dealing dope out of here or nothing like that. I'll just give them my phone because it shows up on my phone. Here, I'll email it to you, basically. You know. Now, if I was dealing dope, I would say no, you need a warrant. Well, yeah, you gotta protect your investment. All right, authentication. The defense attacked the ring video on foundation. Which clip is it? Who pulled it? What are the timestamps accurate?

SPEAKER_02So we're doing this on one now. So, and the we got a case or a pointed case where the woman shot, they say the woman shot into her husband's business. All right, did I tell you about this one? No. Uh-uh. All right, and he just turned over some footage. The cop didn't go pull it digitally off the device or nothing. Turned over a thumb drive and they're entered as an as evidence. Now, the defense said, Hey, I want to hire my guy, me, to come in and see how it was acquired, if it's legit, has it ever been cut or spliced?

SPEAKER_02Right? Right, right. The judge said that that digital forensics is voodoo science. No. And she argued, so since it's voodoo science, we're not allowed to we can't be allowed to have digital video entered as evidence. Okay. That's ain't that the yeah. That's what she's supposed to do, right? Yep. And if he says no and allows it to be, then this if she does get convicted, then this is gonna get turned over quickly. Of course it will. Because of the words out of the judge's mouth.

SPEAKER_03I hate to tell that judge it's not voodoo science.

SPEAKER_02If it's voodoo science, why did Alabama invest$2.5 billion in labs, computer labs all over the state?

SPEAKER_00They're nice.

SPEAKER_03It's not voodoo. It it is scientific, it's proven. I I that judge Oh, he must have been the judge on my cousin Vinny. Yeah. That's uh ain't that the drill instructor. Herman Herman Munster. Oh, that's Munster.

SPEAKER_02That's not Gunny Fred Gwynn. Yeah, Fred Gwynn. He was her he was good. A good actor. Yeah. Um now Gunny Gunny Hartman, he was a judge in another Yeah, yeah. Anyway, I forgot which one it was. I'm sorry we confuse people on here, but it's fun. Yeah. Then you got the timeline reconstruction, ring timestamps, the phone call to the witness, phone extractions. Uh-oh. The delayed 911 call all fit into a minute-by-minute timeline. This is exactly what the prosecution did.

SPEAKER_02And we do that too. We build a minute-by-minute timeline.

SPEAKER_00Right.

SPEAKER_02So we got one. I just keep saying we got one, right? I got one going on now where we were allowed to go in and look at the police-produced celebrite report. Okay. We were not allowed to go in and do our own investigation on the phone. All right.

SPEAKER_03They already did it though. Why wouldn't you be allowed under their eyes to go ahead and do a dump?

SPEAKER_02We offered to bring in a computer, laptop, and a hard drive, boot, do our dump, review our dump, leave it locked up in evidence. Right. Because it's got CSAM on it, right? Or potentially. Right. And then, you know, they can investigate our computer, make sure we're not taking anything out. Yeah. But they won't let we had to review their stuff. So now, my report, I'm regurgitating their report back to them, which is incorrect. Of course. I'm I'm regurgitating saying exactly what their report says in my report. And the DA's mad about it, said I lied.

SPEAKER_02Okay, so they lied then. I'm quoting your report. I use quotations and footnotes and everything, just like the college people said to do. You know, that's the only time that came into play here. It's quoting it back to them. And I'm gonna go next week and sit there and read their report back to them. Nice. And you know, and I'm what about the DA said my report's inaccurate.

SPEAKER_03Okay, well, that means the original report is inaccurate.

SPEAKER_02That's what my the defense there you go. The defense attorney's stomping around right now, you know, saying, Hey Judge, we need to toss this. This is bull crap, yeah. Kind of thing. So it is a bull crap case. I'm not getting into it right now. He's accused of something he didn't do.

SPEAKER_03Well, the good thing is cops don't ever want to work with private investigators.

SPEAKER_02They don't. They don't they don't like getting their work scrutinized. Well, it somebody needs to scrutinize it. Yeah, I don't get it. But anyway, now here's the cops have great labs and they use Celebrite, which is top of the top-tier extraction software that you can only get your hands on if you are a government entity. Right. How fair is that, by the way? Somebody uh in court before, why don't you use Celebrite?

SPEAKER_02Well, it's$65,000. That's not cheap. I don't have unlimited taxpayer dollars to go out and buy stuff.

SPEAKER_03I actually just looked at that too.

SPEAKER_02I use mobile edit, which is still not cheap, and I use recon ITR for computers, which is even more expensive than that. So it's celebrite is expensive, man. So they mentioned it in that class you took, right? Yes. Yeah, and he talks about how expensive it is in that class. Yeah, he does.

SPEAKER_03And that that's one of the reasons I looked into it. It was just two days ago that I looked into this.

SPEAKER_02Yeah.

SPEAKER_03And I almost choked when I seen how much it was. I was like, well, I won't be getting that.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, usually it's not necessary. That level is not. And even the cops, they just go off the what the Celebrout Report tells them. They don't, they're not good at saying, so what? What does this matter?

SPEAKER_03That's what we do. Because they just pull the report because a lot of it is in my opinion, over their heads.

SPEAKER_02Right. And that's what we're good about is saying, so what? Here's why this matters type of thing. You know what I mean? So all right, so back to the case. We had a cover-up window, several hours passed between the event and the 911 call, phone activity searches, app usage, and location in that window tape, what somebody was doing. The search history after the fact is most often damning. So, yeah, you see that a lot where they searched how to cover up a crime scene, how to bury a body deep enough, that kind of stuff. He had a stage scene. He tried to sell an overdose, the physical evidence, and the medical examiner said otherwise when someone's story she took something, you tested against toxicology.

SPEAKER_02You got a hole in your head, negative on toxicology.

SPEAKER_03Well, lead poisoning. Huh? Might be lead poisoning.

SPEAKER_02The chiropractor in Huntsville? Yeah. We worked on that one.

SPEAKER_03Yeah.

SPEAKER_02I'm embarrassed to say we did. That guy was mean. I hated him as a client. But, anyways, he's just a cocky person. The defense side needs investigators too. Yeah, you know, the defense gets a vigorous defense, okay? And they hire us as private investigators and experts to come in and do the work for them, right? I hate to say it, somebody may be accused of a crime, but I'll come in and I'm just reporting off what the evidence says, not what my opinion is.

SPEAKER_02Right. Now I'm I have an opinion that sometimes they ask for an opinion, and it's framed by evidence. And I'll say it. I cannot get outside of this framework of evidence that's sitting in front of me. I can't do it. But in the dragnet, just effects, ma'am. Yeah, that's it. Uh you have witness contact, which is huge today because everybody records everything. It's better than bringing in one person with a recording, it's better than 25 persons saying, I saw it. Right. You know what I mean? That's back in the old days, that's all they had.

SPEAKER_02And then you have protective orders, no contact orders, and all that stuff. All right. This guy's cooked.

SPEAKER_03He was a scumbag before he did this.

SPEAKER_02Dirty cop, man. You love those, don't you?

SPEAKER_03No, I hate dirty cops.

SPEAKER_02You have cop behind as on, you know, you're a cop for a long time. Mm-hmm. And it makes y'all look bad, the good ones.

SPEAKER_03It does. It does. And it it's the I've seen it too many times where they say you get caught like this guy got caught stealing, extortion, and all that. And they say, Well, we're gonna give you a chance to resign or be fired. No, don't give them the chance. It needs to be safe fired on there. It needs to say fired. Their post certification needs to be stripped, and they need to be prosecuted. Period. Right.

SPEAKER_02I'm not sure if he tried to reapply to be a cop or not somewhere else. It didn't say. I'm not sure what he was doing. But he'd be an idiot to do that. He's dirty. All right, Juice. That was a long one. We got into politics, yeah, religion.

SPEAKER_03We hit a lot of stuff on this one.

SPEAKER_02That's a lot of, you know, people's gonna bash us for our conservative viewpoints.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, well, come on.

SPEAKER_02And plus, I've got I got the shirt on too, so people really it triggers people.

SPEAKER_03So come on down, pull up a chair, we'll get you coffee, I'll bring donuts.

SPEAKER_02Their favorite thing is Maggus pedophile. That's their state that's their comment. Magas are all pedophiles, but they don't ever respond or want to come to debate.

SPEAKER_03So of course not.

SPEAKER_02All right, Juice, we're gonna get off here, but uh we'll be back with another interesting episode in just a minute. So

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. The Yacht, the Hotel and $50,000 in Checks: Public Corruption From Jackson to Knoxville | Hidden Threads

    Nov 17, 202626 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail An FBI undercover team posed as hotel developers in Jackson, Mississippi, and the city officials who could approve the project started taking money. There was a trip to Florida on a yacht, cash bribes,...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Badges for Hire: The FBI Sting That Caught Mississippi Sheriffs Guarding Cocaine | Hidden Threads

    Nov 13, 202627 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail Drug dealers in the Mississippi Delta kept telling federal agents the same thing: the cops were on the payroll. The FBI's Jackson Field Office took that seriously and built a years-long undercover sting...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. They Quit and Took Your Secrets: How Employees Steal Company Data | Hidden Threads

    Oct 30, 202621 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail Your top salesman gives two weeks' notice. A month later, your biggest clients are buying from a competitor, and your pricing sheet looks awfully familiar. In this episode of Hidden Threads, Macky...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Is Someone Tracking You? AirTags, GPS Trackers & Phone Spyware Exposed | Hidden Threads

    Oct 27, 202612 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail That "AirTag Found Moving With You" alert. The car that always seems to know where you've been. The ex who shows up wherever you go. In this episode of Hidden Threads, Macky Outlaw and Jus break down...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. She Threatened the Metcalf Family on Facebook. The Feds Came Knocking.

    Oct 8, 202622 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail The same day Karmelo Anthony was convicted of murdering 17-year-old Austin Metcalf, federal prosecutors say a Kansas City woman sent the grieving Metcalf family a Facebook message threatening to kill...

    Credit the people on this episode