Send us Fan Mail The same day Karmelo Anthony was convicted of murdering 17-year-old Austin Metcalf, federal prosecutors say a Kansas City woman sent the grieving Metcalf family a Facebook message threatening to kill one of them and put them in a body bag. Then she dared them to take her to court. They did better than that. On September 9, 2026, a federal grand jury in the Eastern District of Texas indicted 34-year-old Sharifa Nicole Henderson on three counts of interstate threatening communications. Prosecutors allege she sent threats through Facebook Messenger and even called the Collin County government, the office that prosecuted Anthony. She was arrested in Kansas City on September 11. Each count carries up to five years in federal prison. Henderson is presumed innocent unless proven guilty. On this episode of Hidden Threads, Macky and Jus break down how an online threat gets traced from a screen name to a front door, why "it's just the internet" isn't a defense, where free speech ends and a federal crime begins, and what you should do right now if someone is threatening you or your family online. Jeff Metcalf says his family has received more than 100 threats since the trial. This case shows those threats can follow the sender home. Being harassed or threatened online? Shadownet Digital identifies who is behind anonymous accounts and preserves the evidence. Call 866-910-7499 or visit shadownetdigital.com. #AustinMetcalf #KarmeloAnthony #OnlineThreats #TrueCrime #OSINT #HiddenThreads Support the show 866.910.7499 help@shadownetdigital.com
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_00All right, Juice, we're back for another one. Awesome. So when when does hunt you've been bird hunting?
unknownNo.
SPEAKER_00You don't bird hunt much, do you?
SPEAKER_01No, not really.
SPEAKER_00I've heard I'm popping off around here a little bit.
SPEAKER_01I guess dove season's. Dove season's in, yeah. When does deer season start so after Christmas or around Christmas? No, next month. Is that Bowen Muzzle Elder? Yeah. Around the 15th or something. When does rifles start? A few weeks after that, November.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. We got a family living here now around us. Oh no.
SPEAKER_01I'll be down. And his little harem. Yeah, but we discussed that. If I come down and shoot them, your wife's gonna kill me. Those are now pets. She's named Frederick. Who names up dear Frederick? They are off limits at that point. And then there's a bunch of little bambies, you know. I mean, so Frederick is gonna live a good life right here on the outlaw estates.
SPEAKER_00We call it the animal preserve.
SPEAKER_01Yes.
SPEAKER_00Sometimes you pull up out here and they're all standing and look at you, and they just go back to eating.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, because they know you're not gonna do anything. Because she's here to protect them.
SPEAKER_00You're not gonna do nothing. Yeah. Anyway. So in the Tetons, we you know, they don't have air conditioning. Right. And it was pr good weather. Like one day it was like 26 in the morning, but it was we left the windows open at night. At about 4 a.m., those elk would start bugling. That was your alarm clock. That's awesome. Yeah. Them things are loud. Yeah. They make a lot of racket calling up their women. They're in trouble now though, because it's elk season over there. And you know, that's what gets the bucks in trouble here, chasing women.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, exactly. They they don't show their face all year until they go in the rut. So and they start taking risks and all this stuff.
SPEAKER_01So yeah, like we all do. Because we're we're stupid.
SPEAKER_00So Saturday, you coming over? No. You're not coming to get up under the house with me all the time? I'll probably be working again. So you're you're the kind of guy that you would sit outside the little floor. Uh what I gotta do is get up under the house and put in, re-insulate our HPAP. Well, you needed something to do. You'd be the guy that would sit at the opening under the house and just say stuff to why. Oh, talk trash? Yeah. Oh, yeah, that'd be me. Yeah, and drink coffee and like sit back in a chair.
unknownYeah.
SPEAKER_01Man, that's nice out here. Ask you if you're done yet.
SPEAKER_00Well, I got dust, you know, yeah in my lungs.
SPEAKER_01While you're sucking fiberglass into your lungs.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. That's gonna suck, but it ain't bad.
SPEAKER_01So it's like those coffee commercials where the guy's sitting there sucking on the coffee and he says, Oh, it's cold out there. I ain't going out there. Oh, burnt my lip.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, that would be me. We gotta get it done. So the HPAC guy was gonna charge me 7k to do it.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, so Mackie's gonna do it.
SPEAKER_00For about$500. So Huh.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_00It is aggravate. I get why it's so expensive. You gotta do it. Because it's aggravating. Rip stuff out.
SPEAKER_01You come do mine. I've got like four snakes under my house.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. I haven't seen any snakes under ours.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I got about four of them in there.
SPEAKER_00Now I did have somebody come put the new plastic down.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, the bisquewing.
SPEAKER_00They did that. So I don't have to do that. All right. The title of this next one, I will hunt you forever. Alright. This is the all threats against the Austin Metcalf family. Remember Austin Metcalf was stabbed by Carmelo. Carmelo. The young guy. They got on the tussle.
SPEAKER_01Because it ain't fair.
SPEAKER_00Why?
SPEAKER_01Because he's African American.
SPEAKER_00I've seen people go to prison for a certain amount of time for bar fights because they cracked fractured somebody's orbital bone and they lived. Yeah. They went to like got a two years in prison because the person was down and they didn't quit beating them.
SPEAKER_01They have the new Black Panther Party out there protesting and raising cane, and it ain't fair if it was a white guy that stabbed a black guy, it wouldn't be this. He'd get off Scot Freak. No.
SPEAKER_00They don't either.
SPEAKER_01So No, the kid stabbed him. He did it intentionally. He murdered him. He's doing 35 years.
SPEAKER_00Which is kind of light.
SPEAKER_01He can't appeal it. He can't get a new trial.
SPEAKER_00Why can't you appeal it?
SPEAKER_01Well, he can appeal it, but they were trying to get him back as saying it was a mistrial and get him out.
SPEAKER_00Oh, the juries.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Lo and behold, they said it's not a mistrial. His sentence sticks. He can appeal it and go through the appellate court and deal with it that way. It's hard to get past the jury conviction. It's it is. But his parents went for visitation day and they were all huddled up, you know, taking a happy family inmate photo. Right. He looked pretty happy while he was in there.
SPEAKER_00His mom posted something about he got beat up and they're back in the prison. If the warden's like, no, he didn't. He didn't. Somebody might have shoved him or bumped into him.
SPEAKER_01At some point, he is gonna have to throw knuckles.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Or something. It is what it is. You either fight by you either win or lose.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. You either fight or you know.
SPEAKER_00You get more respect for fighting fighting and getting beat up than you do just going hide in the corner. There's somewhere they're hiding there.
SPEAKER_01But no, or check being a check-in baby.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, it's not a what's a check? All right, tell me that one.
SPEAKER_01Protective custody. Oh.
SPEAKER_00All right.
SPEAKER_01That's what I would. I'm gonna go cry just so I could be alone. I'd go read book, be Eddie Alan Poe, and read read books. Yeah, I'm gonna do something really crazy off the wall to somebody in office or something, so they just lock me in solitary.
SPEAKER_00Strip your clothes off, start hugging everybody and slinging thes everywhere. That happens. Yeah. Yeah. That happened in Jackson County here a while back. Did you hear about that one?
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Nasty, man. It's that's not the first time it's happened there. It's happened.
SPEAKER_00Well, you can be crazy and stuff. I don't want you to do-doo on me. Oh yeah. So anyway. All right. This lady, let's go, let's talk about it. Sheriff Nicole Henderson, age 34 of Kansas City, Missouri. Federal grand jury in the Eastern District of Texas indicted her on September 9th, 2026, just the other day. Arrested on September 11th. Charged with three counts of interstate threatening communications. This is the big the Fed level. We call it the big chicken dinner.
SPEAKER_01Yep.
SPEAKER_00Up to five years in federal prison and$250,000 fines per count. So they got her on how many counts? Three counts. So that's expensive. Three-quarters of a million dollars right there. All right. She has a prior record, disorderly conduct, theft, trespassing, resisting arrest.
SPEAKER_01That really helps her case.
SPEAKER_00I've got a trespassing conviction.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I remember.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, you were there for that.
SPEAKER_01But anyway.
SPEAKER_00You know, I get tired. Like, you know, I applied for Georgia. I got my Georgia license. Right. If I have to go in there and say, this is yeah, this is Yeah, this is what happened.
SPEAKER_01You have to explain it.
SPEAKER_00It's a misdemeanor. They kind of hand, they like whatever.
SPEAKER_01I hate to tell you this. I still have to explain things from when I was a young teenager that I did. Yeah, because it's set it's there, it's on the paper, right?
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Here's the backstory April 2nd, 2025. Carmelo Anthony stabbed 17-year-old Austin Metcalfe at a high school track meet, took them down stadium in Frisco, Texas. Anthony said under the Memorial High High School tent. Austin told him to leave. An argument followed, and Anthony stabbed him. June 9, 2026, Anthony convicted and sentenced to 35 years in the bake house. All right. How she sent these messages. Here's the three counts. Count one. June 10th, Facebook Messenger.
SPEAKER_00Message of Metcalf family. Member saying she'd kill them and put them in a body bag. Then, now this is a threat. Take me to court.
SPEAKER_01That wasn't very smart. First, it wasn't very nice. That was kind of rude. And then she was stupid about it.
SPEAKER_00Metcalf's daddy probably said, Hey, Mr. Lawyer, here, don't go do this thing. So count two, June 10th, the phone call. Voice. She called the Collin County government, the office that prosecuted Anthony, and said she would demolish the Metcalf family and strangle one of them. Just one. She's gonna strangle one of them.
SPEAKER_01Hmm. That'd be hard to pick.
SPEAKER_00All right. Count three, June 11th, again on Facebook Messenger. Don't worry, I'll kill you next. Hunt you forever until I kill you. I will be there. You'll always have to look over your shoulder. Man. It's kind of harsh. Yeah. She needs a hug. She does. Go outside and take a walk.
SPEAKER_01She needs a little love.
SPEAKER_00Go outside, take a walk, cut some grass, pet a dog.
SPEAKER_01Maybe it's the caffeine. Maybe she should switch to decaf.
SPEAKER_00I drink a lot of it, so anyway. Yeah. Reports say the recipient was Jeff Metcalf's Hofston's dad. One outlet says the messages started June 9th on the on the verdict day, whenever the verdict was read. The indictment charges list June 10th through 11th. So it was right after the verdict, anyway.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Jeff Metcalf, daddy, says his family has received more than 100 threats since the trial ended. Since his son, she's one of the She's the one who got charged. U.S. Attorney J.R. Combs said investig uh investigators use phone and social media records to trace some messages to her. Attorney Combs says threats against jurors, judges, prosecutors, or victims will be treated seriously, and there's ongoing investigations in all the threats. So anyway.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Threat sentenced up to his wife, I think. Yeah. So take me to court, she dared them. All right. They think they're behind it, that they're sitting at their computer or their phone, and they don't think anything's gonna happen to them.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, because you know they're sitting back and they're their speedos, they're under roos in mommy's basement talking trash where they're safe.
SPEAKER_00She sent the sent threats from her own Facebook account and called a government office. That's what went that's what made it federal. Government line and also going across interstate or uh going across communication lines. They had her. Communication lines, right? Yeah. Government lines log caller numbers. She didn't even hide it. So we get these where people get threats from anonymous accounts. Yeah. Those are hard to pick up unless unless she subpoena Facebook. Right. Facebook takes it pretty seriously.
SPEAKER_00Well, only one of 100 plus threateners got charged, meaning you're anonymous overseas, never crossed the line to a true threat. A specific direct threat, though I will kill you, is what gets prosecuted. What to do? What do you do if you're threatened online, Juice? What do you tell people? If I'm threatened online? What if what if a friend comes to you and says, Man, this dude's threatening me online? What do we do? Save the message. Go to the cops. Right. Preserve it though. People automatically block. Yeah. Which makes it go, hey, preserve it. Take screenshot, record it, and then block them.
SPEAKER_01The bad thing is they're going to get on another app. They already have your phone number. They're going to get on another app that gives them an other another phone number to use. They're going to get on there and they're going to start messaging you again. Just save all the messages.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Screenshot with a date, time, profile name if it's visible. Capture the sender's profile page, the your profile URL, not just the name. The URL and the account ID is where the information lives for Facebook or Ash or whatever. Right, right. They live in a digit world. So they're going to be like, I don't know Jimmy Brown, but if you give me the profile ID, here's who created that profile, when they did it, and from what device. They'll tell you everything about it. You got to save your voicemails and call logs, write down the time, number, and exact words.
SPEAKER_00Don't reply to them. Don't argue. No, even those, if you can save them on your phone, save them. Yeah. Don't threaten back. Don't get yourself caught up in a jawjacking thing. It's hard. I'm not a good, I'm a so you talk about good debaters like a JD Vance or Marco Rubio. You know, they keep it calm and just lay out facts, right? Yeah. I can't do it. I'm more of a Trump guy. I if you say something about me or my kids, I'm gonna smart off to you. Yeah. I gotta do it. Absolutely. You're that way too. I know. Yeah. It's hard to hold back, man.
SPEAKER_01It is. And I will do some cutthroat talking real quick.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I can't be calm and debate.
unknownNo.
SPEAKER_00And I ruin the debate because I call somebody a bad name or say something stupid.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Yeah. My the vulgar side of me comes out on a lot of stuff.
SPEAKER_00It makes it more interesting, though.
SPEAKER_01It does. It makes it funnier. Especially when you play it back and listen to yourself trash talk them. Yeah. Shouldn't have said that.
SPEAKER_00But anyway, it is what it is. So you got to report it to the police, right? Here's a problem I'm seeing with local police these days. They don't entertain this stuff. They're like, I don't know what to do with it.
SPEAKER_01Because they don't they don't know right.
SPEAKER_00They're dead by car crashes and fights and domestics.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Um runaway kids. Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Drunk drivers, whatever.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. This is just something. Like I said, we we've discussed this in the past. There was a time that if somebody were to call you on the phone or say something, we can't prove that was you on the other end of that phone. So it was a hey, it just take the report, write it all down, and we'll go from there.
SPEAKER_00Right.
SPEAKER_01There's really nothing you could do about it at that time.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Oh, it's tough, man. But now you can record a lot of stuff yourself. So we're digital forensic examers, PIs coming on this. We can attribute account to a real person sometimes. Right. We can't guarantee it. We can document everything. So one thing we do, people get some of our clients are like, well, that don't approve anything. Well, because it takes some legal teeth behind it. Right. Here's where you didn't know where any of this came from. Now you do. And where does subpoenas need to go to?
SPEAKER_00Before you hired me, you had no idea where it was where the subpoenas need to go. Right. We're pointing you in the right direction. Sometimes they think they want me to bring a person by their collar and say, here they are. Yeah, it doesn't work that way either. Sometimes it does, but somebody don't.
SPEAKER_01You know, if it's the kid doing it in the own house, yeah. We've seen that before.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. And I didn't, they didn't do it. They told them to go to the get in there. I knew that his dictator to get that table. Oh yeah. The Yeah, so yeah, we got, you know, the you gotta we build a timeline for you, all these things, and that goes in that logical report. A lot of it has digit digital stuff behind it. We can explain it to a judge, a jury, or argue, not argue, but answer def defense attorney's questions logically.
SPEAKER_01Uh those things. And and and hope they can even understand it. Because some of them, digital forensics is not their forte, it's not their specialty. They don't know. They gotta go by what you are telling them. Right.
SPEAKER_00So we got one, it's a defense case we just got where a woman and her husband's going through a horrible divorce, custody thing, and all this, right? The man owns a mill work shop, right? And he has a little apartment there next to it, and that's where he's been living. Right. So somebody drove by and shot at the building, shot four rounds into the building. He calls the cops and said there's an active shooter, blah, blah, blah. He's got about five employees there. You know, he'll lock them and all that. And he immediately says, It's my wife.
SPEAKER_00Now, he pulled, they pull up security video. It shows her a car that looks like hers. They don't have a tag. Maybe her car. It's very fuzzy. It shows her driving in the area 30 minutes after the 911 call. Well, you gotta come back and see what you did. Near the bill. All right. Now, the defense attorney who I'm working for said, Hey, judge, we want to examine the digital evidence. I want a digital forensic examiner to look at it and see how the chain of custody, how this came got off the device on this thumb drive y'all are using.
SPEAKER_00Right. All that. And the judge says, I'm not going to give you money for it because that's voodoo science. No, no, it is not. She argued back and said, if it's voodoo science, why did the state of Alabama invest over a billion dollars in digital forensic labs over the last 10 years? Correct. He didn't have an answer for that.
SPEAKER_01So nah, it's not voodoo.
SPEAKER_00It it's provable, cold, hard evidence. And then she made a motion and said, since the videos are digital, when they're not allowed. He made a motion to squash, squash that evidence because if it's voodoo science, we're not allowed anything digital and then it becomes his word to get started. Their word to get to each other. Right. That's a good defense attorney, though, right? Yeah. So yeah, but it's voodoo science. Why is anything digital allowed? Why are we even reading this case off of a computer? Yeah. You need hard copies and handwritten notes.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Nothing electronic can be used in this trial if it's voodoo science.
SPEAKER_01Again, that's where it goes back. They may know the law. They don't understand the digital forensic side. That's why. But now so much digital stuff is written into the law now. It is, but how many of them actually, and I I'm not trying to be the devil's advocate here. I'm really not. But I know a lot of cops, they don't read up on new laws when they come out. Until they run into it, right? Yeah. How many of the judges are actually sitting there, you know, waiting, you know, biting their nails for something new to come out so they can get their hands on it and read it?
SPEAKER_01Very, very, very few.
SPEAKER_00A lot of them are like, oh God, it'll be law. Yeah, I'll get it memorized.
SPEAKER_01But and that they'll they'll be like, I'll get to it this weekend or something.
SPEAKER_02Mm-hmm.
SPEAKER_01Right.
SPEAKER_00But me and her got it, put her heads together and found some case law where old stuff, like in the 80s, where the Supreme Court said that every defense is every defendant is has to have the opportunity to have experts examined. Psychological DNA, digital phone, right, fingerprint. You gotta give them some money so they can go get an expert to look at it. So I think he's gonna end up giving some money so we can do it. But probably because she's gonna raise hell all over the place if they don't.
SPEAKER_00So that's a good attorney. All right. So the threats, Juice, don't threaten. How about that? Yeah, that'd be smart. And people get so caught up in these cases, when you look at the facts, they're guilty.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, but they're they're that's not what they look at. They let their emotions guide their actions, which is just wrong.
SPEAKER_00I'm gonna I get emotional, but I can't do I don't make decisions when I'm emotional.
SPEAKER_01Mad, happy No, because I will do dumb stuff.
SPEAKER_02Right.
SPEAKER_01But if if I make a decision and I'm my mental health isn't where it should be, if I'm mad, upset, you know, hurt. That's not the time to make any decisions.
SPEAKER_00I've got life-altering stuff I still deal with because I made decisions, but I was mad. Right. Or whatever, you know what I mean? So yeah. And it's I don't know, man. People get caught up in these things that let the motions override it. You know, my motions are more important than the data. Yeah. That's you can't or law. You know, law's data, right? Uh your emotions don't outright over override the law. No, they do not. And she's gonna get her a little five years in jail, or maybe she might make a deal and get to whatever, yeah, or be on probation. It's gonna ruin her life. She's gonna have the felony forever.
SPEAKER_00Oh, yeah.
SPEAKER_01Um, felonies don't go away. And you have to admit that when you go for jobs and they ask you, have you ever been arrested? Oh yeah, but it was misunderstanding. I just threatened to rip her head off and and dismember her body and float it down the river. But I was just joking.
SPEAKER_00This ain't a DUI when you were 19. This is big time stuff here. Yeah. So what if she would have carried through with this stuff? What if she would have put hands on one of them? Absolutely. Shot one of them, whatever. We were dealing with that with the Charlie Kirk kid that shoot her. He made a lot of comments before he actually did it. And I'm not so sure that kid gets excited.
SPEAKER_01Have you watched him? I'm not sure if he's medicated or what's happening. I don't know either, but he's just like I I don't know. I can't explain it.
SPEAKER_00There it's something there's something off there. In one of his pre-trial hearings, they kept playing the video of Charlie, you know, getting shot in the net. Yeah. And it was brutal. And the judge had to like walk out like they need a break, you know. Yeah. And the the DA and everybody's, hey, let's go outside and walk around a little bit. And that kid was just like, nothing. No emotion, nothing. Some people say he wasn't alone there. He may not have been. He had some, I think he had some planning help. What do you think?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, we we discussed this before. I think he did it. I think he had some help though. I think he had a part in it. Right. Ballistics are weird. Still don't agree with those.
SPEAKER_00But I think he had a part in it. Everybody had a part in it. He'd be hauled out, put out in the middle of the square. Yeah. We all get a lick in on with a brick. The old stoning days. Yes. Hit them in the head with rocks till they die. So that's what they deserve. I'm good with that. And his wife gets one of the bricks, too. Give her two. She probably wouldn't do it. We'll give her two bricks. Y'all go do your thing. I'm not holding. She may surprise you and we'll got some fire in her belly. I don't know. Yeah. But she may. All right. That's all we got for this one, Juice.
SPEAKER_00We'll be back with another one here in just a bit. Awesome.
Send us Fan Mail Kara Akins, a mother of seven, had a no-contact order against former Chattanooga police officer Lawrence Goodine. In November 2023, her own Ring doorbell recorded her running outside, yelling for help,...
Send us Fan Mail An FBI undercover team posed as hotel developers in Jackson, Mississippi, and the city officials who could approve the project started taking money. There was a trip to Florida on a yacht, cash bribes,...
Send us Fan Mail Drug dealers in the Mississippi Delta kept telling federal agents the same thing: the cops were on the payroll. The FBI's Jackson Field Office took that seriously and built a years-long undercover sting...
Send us Fan Mail Your top salesman gives two weeks' notice. A month later, your biggest clients are buying from a competitor, and your pricing sheet looks awfully familiar. In this episode of Hidden Threads, Macky...
Send us Fan Mail That "AirTag Found Moving With You" alert. The car that always seems to know where you've been. The ex who shows up wherever you go. In this episode of Hidden Threads, Macky Outlaw and Jus break down...