Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Hidden Threads: Real Private Investigators. Real Cases. Real Stories.

Hidden Threads: Real Private Investigators. Real Cases. Real Stories. artwork

100,000 Messages Convicted Him | The American Idol Pastor Murder

Oct 1, 202632 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Send us Fan Mail No murder weapon. No gunshot residue. No fingerprints. No eyewitness. And a Miami County jury still needed only about two hours to convict him on all nine counts. In the early morning hours of February 16, 2026, former music pastor and one-time American Idol contestant Caleb Flynn called 911 from his Tipp City, Ohio home and said an intruder had broken in and shot his wife. Ashley Flynn, a 37-year-old schoolteacher and volleyball coach, had been shot twice in the back of the head while she lay in bed, with their two young daughters in the house. Within 82 hours, Caleb was the one under arrest. On this episode of Hidden Threads, Macky and Jus break down how investigators took apart the home-invasion story and why the digital evidence carried the case: more than 100,000 messages with his mistress, texts about wanting his wife dead, and a message sent hours before the 911 call that read, "I choose you. I'm free." We walk through what a phone examination actually recovers, how a digital timeline gets built, and why the defense's "no gun, no GSR" argument didn't hold up. This is what digital forensics looks like when it matters most. Need a digital forensic examiner? Shadownet Digital handles phone and computer forensics, OSINT, and investigations. Call 866-910-7499 or visit shadownetdigital.com. #CalebFlynn #AshleyFlynn #AmericanIdol #TrueCrime #DigitalForensics #HiddenThreads Support the show 866.910.7499 help@shadownetdigital.com

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_02All right, juice, we're recording.

SPEAKER_01All right.

SPEAKER_02We had technical difficulties earlier in the week.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, we did. Well, not we. You.

SPEAKER_02Yeah. Well, you slept while I tried to work it out. You know, when you work third shift, you gotta get a nap in when you can. So we were talking, you were telling me about this woman in Tennessee. Krista Pike. Krista Pike. Let's look her up. She's taking a dirt nap today at 10 a.m. They might not put her in the ground today. I remember this woman now. I haven't looked her up in a while.

SPEAKER_01Oh, yeah.

SPEAKER_02She's she's taking a nap. Krista Gail Pike, an American convicted murderer who is incarcerated on Death Row in Tennessee. Today's her day.

SPEAKER_01Yes, it is. At 10 a.m. their time. Nashville time.

SPEAKER_02Yeah. Nashville Central.

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_021995. When she was 18, Pike murdered her 19-year-old Job Corps classmate, Colleen Schlimmer, in Knoxville. Oh, they lured her out in the woods and beat the crap out of her, didn't they? Yeah, she bashed her head in with a rock and killed her. Yeah, they beat her pretty for a good reason.

SPEAKER_01And the other two held her down, the victim down, while this one, Krista Pike, killed her.

SPEAKER_02Did the other two get the death penalty? No, they got life in prison. Tell me how that worked. Yeah. Krista did it.

SPEAKER_01Snitches. Snitches.

SPEAKER_02They probably didn't get stitches over this one.

SPEAKER_01No. No.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, I remember this in the news or like one of the Dead Con shows or something. Pretty nasty.

SPEAKER_01But yeah, she's Yeah, but while she was in, I mean, she she didn't just do something when she was 18. While she was in prison, she has an attempted murder charge on her there. She has an escape charge on her. So it's not like she was an angel.

SPEAKER_02So at after Pike's trial, the Tennessee Department of Correction adopted a policy requiring death throw inmates to be held in maximum security conditions. As such, Pike has been inside. So I went to visit a death throw inmate in Florida. All right. And they actually carried me back on death row, and I sat in a chair.

SPEAKER_01Yo, outside the cell?

SPEAKER_02Yeah.

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_02And uh I was walking by these other, they're like, hey man, what's up? You know, they're they're just sitting there watching TV or reading or something.

SPEAKER_01Oh, yeah. I used to work in South Carolina. I built Death Row with a work crew at one facility.

SPEAKER_02Like they don't even bring them out like to a room to talk to you.

SPEAKER_01No, they gotta stay in their cell and they pop the beanhole open and had a little chair and me and him sat there and chat.

SPEAKER_02Well, I was there for two hours or so. Yeah. They brought a coffee and brought him some coffee. Oh, that was nice of them. So I reckon he was a pretty good, like he didn't cause no trouble. But it's hard to when most of them don't. Uh-oh. Most of them don't. Booth's connected. Well, death row, man. You're pretty much done. So unless you got some kind of big time appeal going on or some new evidence or something. You got lights on your head, Juice. Let me turn those off.

SPEAKER_01I do. It's that big orange ball. Oh, look at that. I can see out of my right eye now.

SPEAKER_02Yeah. You see out of your right eye. Yeah. Do you have your left eye, do you have your right eye closed so you don't lose your night vision in your left eye? I've done that a lot.

SPEAKER_01I have done that when flares and whatnot go off.

SPEAKER_02The curtain. Nobody can see behind the curtain.

SPEAKER_01No, no, you don't want to see behind the curtain.

SPEAKER_02Use the scene back there. It's just a big jump pile of wires. That's a lot of spaghetti. It's phones from like uh there's phones in there from 2018.

SPEAKER_01I'm surprised there's not a rotary dial phone in there.

SPEAKER_02We got one around here somewhere.

unknownYeah.

SPEAKER_02But um anyway, so Krista Pike's getting the needle today. Yeah, they're doing it tonight.

SPEAKER_01Uh no, this morning, I think.

SPEAKER_02Really? Some of them in the middle of the night for whatever.

SPEAKER_01I think they're doing it at 10 a.m.

SPEAKER_02But the biggin we're talking about this morning is the American Idol murder. Oh Caleb Flynn, City, Ohio. That's up next to Miami, Ohio. All right. Yep. I've been following us some pretty close. He caught my attention. The pastor. Yeah. So let's talk about who's who in the zoo. Trial is under, well, not underway anymore. He got convicted yesterday of everything. Yeah, he did. Except for a one gun charge or something, which That's because they couldn't find the gun. Who cares? You know, he's got yeah, he got murdered one, two, three, and four.

SPEAKER_02And he got convicted yesterday unanimously. His mistress, she got a weird name. We'll call her Miss Botner. Okay. I watched her testimony for two days, off and on, and it was horrible for him. She sat up there and read their text messages for like three years.

SPEAKER_01There was like a hundred thousand text messages.

SPEAKER_02Where he said over and over again he was gonna kill her.

SPEAKER_01Now she did say it once in the text.

SPEAKER_02But then she said, I shouldn't have said that.

SPEAKER_01And then she said, Well, that was wrong. I don't I don't really want you to do that. I don't want to hurt her.

SPEAKER_02Well, they got here's a key witness because she lied to the feds, and the feds were like, Hey, we won't put you in jail for lying to us. Yeah, that's a crime, which is ridiculous in my opinion. But we won't put you in jail for lying to us if you cooperate with the locals, yeah, basically. A little boo tactic. And she did. Yeah, because first the feds started snooping around and they ask her, and she goes, I don't know this guy, all this.

SPEAKER_01And yeah, but you know, you're when you get caught doing something, and and I've said this before, your first psychological response is to lie. It's protection. Yeah, it it's exactly what it is. Yeah, it's a survival mechanism. So you give them one shot and then you say, Now look, we got you lying. Let's tell the truth now.

SPEAKER_02Now the feds have used that and put people away for a while.

SPEAKER_01Oh, yeah.

SPEAKER_02It's a felony in the federal level. Uh I guess they got tired of people lying to them, so this made a law. So I don't think it's fair because like you said, psychologically, people tend to I you know, I lie. Everybody lies. Everybody does. Catholic priests lie. Get the pre trice is the only one that didn't lie.

SPEAKER_01Exactly. Everybody else is susceptible to lying.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, everybody is, and but and the feds are like, hey, you want to lie to us, it's a crime. Right. That's why even if I'm on the friendly side of a Fed case, right? I get a lawyer to talk. I'm like, hey, Mr. FBI agent, I love y'all, but I don't want to get myself in trouble. And they're they yeah, they're like, yeah, please get a lawyer. They used to, you know what I mean? But yeah, the and because I don't want to say something out of turn by accident, right?

SPEAKER_01Right. Because then that's gonna put you in the spotlight if you were to accidentally say something correctly.

SPEAKER_02Now there's intent there too, if you're intending to deceive, is what their the actual crime is, but and that's exactly what she did. Oh, yeah, she was trying to cover up this affair. Oh yeah, but yeah, so him and her, Miss Bottner and uh Mr. Caleb having an affair for a good while. Sorted affair, heated, like going on vacations together, right? That kind of stuff. And he had two daughters, ages nine and eleven at the time. They were asleep in the house. So he he was a former pastor and contestant on American Idol season four.

SPEAKER_02I don't yeah. I watched the season one or two and three, probably of American Idol, when Colin Powell Colin Powell, Colin Cowell, is that his name? The British guy, the joke. Oh, Simon Cowell. Simon Cowell. Yes, was on there. And uh, because he was funny.

SPEAKER_01Yes.

SPEAKER_02After that, it was kind of like, oh, everybody's the greatest, you're gonna be great, even though they weren't great, you know.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, I seen the first season.

SPEAKER_02He's funny though.

SPEAKER_01And I didn't even watch all the first season.

SPEAKER_02But anyway, yeah, they were having a big time affair. He taught in the text message, they called his wife douche, they called her all kinds of things. Oh, yeah. And he admitted, he said a bunch of times he wanted to kill her. And then she said it once, but then she recanted. She recanted, yeah. Hey, I didn't mean that, or whatever. Now he just said, I'm ready to kill her. I want her dead today a bunch of times. Right. Well, lo and behold, he said in the middle of the night, while him and his kids were asleep together, an intruder came in and murdered an adult lady, and he didn't hear nothing.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, nothing. I don't care whose house you're in. If somebody's trying to murder an adult and a gun goes off, you're gonna I maybe me or you and I are just anomalies, but I'm gonna hear that crap. I'm gonna get up. And I've got bad hearing, I'm gonna hear it. And if you get me up at two o'clock, I'm gonna be mad and I'm gonna come kill you. Yes. You shot my wife, especially. So if she don't kill them first, right. My wife, it'd be rough, and my my kid and my wife would if they couldn't get their hands on a gun, they would find something and make your life miserable.

SPEAKER_02You might kill them, but you're gonna remember. Oh, you yeah.

SPEAKER_01They're you're gonna be marked up.

SPEAKER_02That's typical for all Sand Mountain ladies, though.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, they they uh one one woman I know calls it the Sand Mountain Flash.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, that. Well, the thing is, most young they they used to be, I don't know if they are now. Sand Mountain girls were raised as boys. Yes, farms, working in the plants.

SPEAKER_01A large majority of them still are. Yeah, I see them walking around, they look like they're about to take a bull down.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, they could. Good people, yeah, but they're just they were raised tough, especially the generation X and behind that. Yeah, this near bunch, I'm not sure. Yeah, that's questionable. I've got a couple of them in the house, so yeah. Anyway, they're different personalities, but yeah. He said all through his text message he wanted to be free of her and all this. And then he called the n he called 911, said, Hey, somebody, an intruder came in and shot my wife. Did a good show on the body cam and stuff.

SPEAKER_02He didn't do a lot of it in he didn't do a lot of in-station interviews, he requested a lawyer pretty quick. Whenever hours before the killing, for the prosecutor, he told her, the girlfriend, I chose you, I'm now free. So there it went. He did it. He called 91 Wood saying what saying an intruder. This is February 16th, 2026. This is a pretty quick trial. Said an intruder broke in and shot Ashley, and then that same day he was arrested.

SPEAKER_02Aggravated murder, three count, three counts of murder, two counts of felonious assault, three counts of tampering with evidence, and he pleaded not guilty. He got convicted to all those except for the gun charge. Right. Because the gun is magically missing.

SPEAKER_01Yes.

SPEAKER_02Now, they actually did some the gun. So they did the you know, pulled the bullets out, and they said this gun was a certain model. I don't know what model it was, I didn't memorize it, but let's just say it was a nine millimeter. Right. And probably from a some kind of Taurus, I think it was. Right. He just so happened to buy one a few years before that is that same model. It's just missing. What a coincidence. If he could have produced a gun that hadn't been fired, he'd have probably been let go. You think so?

SPEAKER_02He wouldn't have been ruled out. He wouldn't, yeah, he wouldn't have. Because you can wipe you get the gunshot residue off your hands, the gun.

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_02Get some hops in there.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. He wouldn't have been ruled out though, because every time there's something like this going on, the spouse is the first person they're looking at.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, and I know you and I know that. Like if you got a spouse or you're living whatever, immediately, I don't care if I'm in Illinois doing work and my wife gets murdered. They're gonna try to see if I arrange this thing somewhere. And they're gonna look at everything. And once I feel that line of questioning, I'm gonna be like, sorry guys. Yeah, you know, I'm sad, but I'm not gonna talk to you anymore. So need an attorney. Here's my attorney, Miss Charlotte Christianer, one of them, one of the good ones.

SPEAKER_02Right.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah.

SPEAKER_02So the investigators way to grief performance, emotional camera proofs, nothing either way. What matters is that the story fits. So some people try to use this whole grief thing. You can't convict somebody off of grief performance because people act different. Everybody's different. I'm me personally, I've dealt with grief. I'm more of I don't really cry a lot. I'm I'll just shut down. Yeah, you won't hear from me for a while. I'm not gonna say a lot.

SPEAKER_01Well, you know, I'm loud and I'm always being a wise guy and cracking jokes. Everything's funny. It's when I get quiet and withdrawn, then there's an issue. A lot of people, well, he's not sad.

SPEAKER_02Well, yeah, I am. Yeah, I'm not I don't sit around and beller and make a big show. No, but girls do. No, that's their they get they they release emotion through uh crying and all those kind of things. But I kind of shut down and go in internal, you know what I mean? But yeah, so you can't use grief as to convict somebody. A lot of people put a lot of weight on that. I do not.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, neither do I.

SPEAKER_02It is stuff like that affects everybody differently. Here's what got him and helps a lot staging the crime scene. Garage doors open, middle of the night, which typically it's closed. All right. He opened that up to make it look like so for me to just go up to a garage that's closed with an automatic closer, I've got to do some manipulation to get that joker open.

SPEAKER_01Well, I think he had his vehicle door open, and I guess the opener was in there. Okay and they opened it again. You and I can sleep. I'm gonna hear my garage door go up.

SPEAKER_02I hear mine going when it's moving. Um even in our bedrooms on the other side, I can still hear it. I know exactly what it sounds like. But also, when I walk away, modern cars, when I walk away from either one of our cars and get 10 feet away or whatever, and my keys are in my pocket. Guess what? I don't have to think about it. The and his door is open, the big one, he had his center console of his truck was open. Yeah, that's where he kept his pistol all the time. Of course. Even the girl friend said, Yeah, that's where he keeps his pistol.

SPEAKER_02His buddies said that's where he keeps his pistol. He even said that, yeah, I keep my pistol in there.

SPEAKER_01Absolutely. The perpetrator knew it was right where it was at, also.

SPEAKER_02So kill this woman. I'm not gonna bring my own weapon. Yeah, I'm gonna manipulate the garage door, the truck door, and just happen it on happen upon this pistol.

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_02And break in the house, she confronts me and I pop her.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. So all that's real believable right now.

SPEAKER_02Right said that she was shot twice in the back of the head, lying in bed in a sleeping position. So she didn't even know what happened. She just went on to the grape by and by. You would hear a suppressor, even if he used a suppressor. I'm gonna hear all this junk before the gun even goes off.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, I I I I would say you would hear every bit of that. And even the suppressor, it's not like it is on Holly in Hollywood where it just goes doesn't do that. You know that. People call them silencers, they're not silencers, they're not, they're suppressors.

SPEAKER_02You still got the mechanics of the gun. And if the the ammo, unless you're some unless you know subsonic, supersonic, it's gonna make a noise when it cracks that comes out with that speed of sound. And subsonic, if they had a shot of subsonic, it looked a lot different. Uh yeah. The penetration wouldn't be deep.

SPEAKER_01No. Yeah, it's it slows it down, and yeah, but all of the stuff leading up to that, even if he he did, you would still hear that. You'd hear the garage door, you'd hear your doors open on your vehicle. Because mine, if you go to open my door, the alarm's gonna sound. Right.

SPEAKER_02So the initial responding cops, the uniforms that responded initially, right? They were kind of like you could see it on the body cam when they the detective showed up, the investigator. They said, Hey, here's what we got. Somebody broke in, killed the woman. They didn't hear it. They just laid out the basics. Immediately, the detective, when he starts walking around, he said, This is staged. You can hear it on the him walking around, right? He said, This is staged immediately. So, yeah, of course, he's a 20-year-old vet, you know, it's been around a while.

SPEAKER_01He's seen a thing or two.

SPEAKER_02Typically, your detectives have been cops for quite a bit before they take the test and all that, or they got some kind of educational background that promotes them quicker. I don't know. Right. It did it depends on the department, right? But they usually been they're usually good uh they're not stupid. They've been good observers, they've been around a lot of crime. And he immediately kind of like, hey, this looks staged, and they started they played all they know they they investigated all directions, but this lead detective was like, Yeah, from the beginning I thought this was a stage crime scene.

SPEAKER_02The big hit on the police was the they didn't bring in a ballistics expert to analyze those rounds or anything like that.

SPEAKER_00Right.

SPEAKER_02Because they didn't have a gun to compare it to.

SPEAKER_01Right. I'm sure I'm sure they extracted the rounds and ran those through forensics and got tool marks and photographed it and you know, rifling. I'm sure they got all that done. Right. But to match it to a weapon, they couldn't do they didn't have the opposite.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, it was gone. Yeah, other side of the equation. Yeah, right. The other side of the equal sign.

SPEAKER_01Right.

SPEAKER_02All right. So what does force entry look like versus a stage entry juice? Have you ever seen one? Yeah, I've seen forced entry, plenty. I've never seen a stage one.

SPEAKER_01Oh, yeah, there's damage to the door frames, the the locking mechanisms. There's there's all kind of stuff that you're gonna find. Staged, you just open it.

SPEAKER_02Right.

SPEAKER_01There's no damage to anything.

SPEAKER_02But if you're trying to make it look like stage, you're gonna put some tool marks here and there, right?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, I mean you you'll jam a screwdriver in there and make it, you know, look like you the door was pried open with it and stuff. But it's just it's not as easy to stage it. It's it's really not. Well, let me rephrase that. It's very easy to stage it, but it's very hard to make it look like it's an authentic break-in.

SPEAKER_02Right. And he didn't have any gunshot residue in his hands, but you can get rid of that.

SPEAKER_01Yep.

SPEAKER_02Wash it, bleach it, whatever. Yeah, and I'd get rid of it, rinse it off. I got a story about that. You ready? Yeah. So when I was contracting overseas, I'd come home for 30, 40 days, and I'd shoot a lot when I was here. I'd shoot my get my pistols out and shoot them, and uh, you know, stay well, you had that range right here. Stay in tune, right? Right. Now it's a barrel pattern. You can still shoot on it, though.

SPEAKER_01All right, we're we'll we're gonna pop some rounds.

SPEAKER_02It's just dirt anyway. Dirt with some barrels on it. Anyways, still got a burn. The uh and I guess I'd shot a few and my shirts got washed, but I went to the Birmingham airport and they I got I got pulled to the side and they swiped me and had gunpowder residue on it on my shirt. Yeah. From being after even after being washed.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, you can't wash it all out, especially doing the amount of shooting you were doing. You it's you just can't wash that out. Powdered residues everywhere.

SPEAKER_02Yeah. I probably got it on this shirt, but but they said, Oh, you got gunpowder residue. TSA had to, you know, get an anal probe basically.

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_02And one guy, like not the TSA, but the actual federal officer, yeah, the Ash guy, I guess you call it, border protection guy, whatever, came over and said, Hey, do you shoot a lot? And I said, Yeah, and he goes, Yeah, that's what it is. So he looked up, he asked me about my background. I said, Yes. Yeah, imagine that. And they let me go get on the airplane. So I was almost late because then I was I look like a terrorist.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, I you do.

SPEAKER_02White guys typically blow up planes.

SPEAKER_01Yes. No, they don't. And they changed their name to Achmed.

SPEAKER_02White guys, we like we just shoot up, we like mass shootings and serial killer stuff. Yeah. So anyway, but that's our tip that's our mode of mode of operation. Text message was the big one. 100,000 plus. Prosecutors say more than 100,000 texts between Flynn and Butner in the year before the killing. Said I was up until 4 a.m. last night crying, literally, literally trying to think of ways to kill her and not go to jail was one of his messages. If I could literally kill her and not go to hell, I would do it in a heartbeat. Well, that's well, anyway.

SPEAKER_02Prosecutor's theme, he hated Ashley, wanted her gone, wanted her dead, wanted to be free of her. They had financial issues, and she was always on him about his spending habits, which most wise will if you're acting like a retard. Yeah, yeah. Uh, you know, you're trying to feed kids and you're out buying a truck every week and all this stuff.

SPEAKER_01Right.

SPEAKER_02So I think he thought he was famous, but he wasn't really.

SPEAKER_01I don't think so, but I think he believed there was a stigmatism with being a a pastor and divorced.

SPEAKER_02Right. There is that.

SPEAKER_01Okay, well, I'd rather be a divorced pastor than a convicted murdering pastor. Than I have my children know that I've murdered the mother, they're gonna hate you. Just I've been through it twice. Divorce is easy, it's not a problem. It's a lot better than doing life in prison or get in the chair.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, from the religious standpoint, God does hate divorce. Yeah, he does. However, he does he hates murder worse. I'm I'm just yeah, that's my opinion. I don't know. And I'm with you. I believe that's what he would say if he was sitting here.

SPEAKER_01But uh Yeah, and I'm I'm with you, but it's it's just very easy to get divorced and do what you gotta do if you don't like each other. I'm telling you, I've done it twice. It's not that bad.

SPEAKER_02Now they're saying he had put particularly heinous circumstances here because there was children in the house. Right. So he may get the needle here. So he should. It's in Ohio, they like to kill people too.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, so and if they could put him in the express lane like Texas does, that would be even better.

SPEAKER_02It ain't like they got in a fight and lost his temper. Plan this thing out for a lot of sure he did. You can see it by the messages.

SPEAKER_01Oh, yeah.

SPEAKER_02Now Botner, the mistress, the concubine. No, yes. All right, you'd think at some point she should have raised her hand and said, Hey, I think this guy's off his rocker.

SPEAKER_01She was in love.

SPEAKER_02Super young, too. She was early twenties when this went down.

SPEAKER_01So I think they met when she was one of his youth students. He he groomed her.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, that's where it came in the church. Absolutely. Okay. We saw another one where this lady, she was a singer, it's in South Carolina. She led the worship service at her husband's church. Now here's This gets funky. He came up in the church and became a youth pastor. And then she came later, like age 12 or 13. He goes on and gets married, still the youth pastor. She gets married to some other guy. And then they start having an affair when she turns 19. And then they divorce their wives and the her husband and wife and get married.

SPEAKER_02You think he groomed her? And then he was horrible to her for years, like treated her like garbage, and she killed herself. I think he drove that woman crazy, in my opinion. But that's a different story. It's on Netflix. It's possible. Pastor's wife is the name of it. It's good. That's possible. You watch Netflix, Juice?

SPEAKER_01Not really.

SPEAKER_02Oh yeah.

SPEAKER_01But that's you know, I I hate to say it, a church setting is probably one of the best places to groom your victims. Church and school.

SPEAKER_02So like teacher-student relationship type thing. And in church, I want to choke them. They use this whole thing. Well, you know, they have this image, they're a pastor. They're supposed to be a representative of Jesus Christ. Oh, yeah. And they use that. And they and this kid is looking at them, and then they start showing them a little bit of favoritism, and here we go. The kid thinks it's all right.

SPEAKER_01Well, they the the Catholic priests where I'm from, they did it. And they would give has as much as they could, they would give little either silver or gold crosses to the boys that they molested to tell the other priests that were doing it what they can and can't get away with it.

SPEAKER_02That's my kid.

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_02They cleaned them.

SPEAKER_01And this is what he'll do if he'll this is what he'll let you do if he's wearing a gold cross or a silver cross.

SPEAKER_02Right.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. It's that is the perfect place. Well, one of the two.

SPEAKER_02Man. It's terrible. So this guy probably did groomer. Here's what the defense, the defense did a good job here. I watched some of their stuff. They admitted he said ugly, hurtful, selfish things to appease his mistress. Concubine. I like honor that. I heard one of the lawyers. Paramour. The defense attorney called it. The prosecutor called a concubine. I was like, that's not true. Well, negative connotation. Yeah. Caleb betrayed Ashley. Caleb is not on trial for being a bad husband. Just because you had an affair don't mean you're murderer. That's a good, he did good there. Says there were warm, loving texts between Caleb and Ashley regularly.

SPEAKER_02Okay. He was a good actor. Right? Performer. Says he was texting the mistress about divorce plans, not murder plans. Let's go back.

SPEAKER_01Pretty sure he said he wanted to kill her if he could get away with it.

SPEAKER_02Not go to jail or go to hell. So anyway, all right. Says he was texting the mistress about divorce plans, claims of flawed investigation, lack of forensic evidence, rush to judgment. Okay. They're saying that there was no he didn't have any prints, murder weapon. Bedroom was white. There was no prints in the bedroom, by the way. Right. Not even her, the the wives.

SPEAKER_01So I wonder if they got his phone and looked to see if it was moving throughout the house when all this was going on.

SPEAKER_02They did. He was supposed to be asleep.

unknownYeah.

SPEAKER_02They looked at the health app and his heart rate was up to 100 beats a minute, and he had been he walked around for an hour. Oh, imagine that. When he's supposed to have been asleep.

SPEAKER_01So it was actually off his watch. So you can't. If you have electronics, you're not getting away with it.

SPEAKER_02Right. Yep. So yeah. We deleted our text between each other.

SPEAKER_01You still didn't get rid of them.

SPEAKER_02So you can delete them off of phones and iCloud, you know, your backup cloud or whatever, and they go away. But no subscribe. The uh provider, yeah. ATT, Verizon, they keep them jokers for quite a while. Yeah. They don't go away. Right. We just found we just had a lady and the employer fired her, and they thought she was hiding something, like trying to find out what side deal she had going on. And she wiped the phone and the computer. Now the phone didn't have any, we couldn't recover any messages off of it.

SPEAKER_02But the work computer, she used that as a backup. Like she charged her phone with it. And we got them all, every single one of them. And and deleted messages. Like she thought she wiped it, but it wasn't gone. But yeah. So the other person now, this other blottener girl, the the concubine, right? She didn't delete her messages at all. So she had them on her phone. That's where they got most of them from. And you got your iCloud, Google Backups, carrier, and app level records. And then you got forensic extraction, can recover deleted database records.

SPEAKER_02If it's backed up to computers more than or a server or larger surface area, they can serve save them up. Oh, yeah. It's probably recoverable. The phones have such a small chip in them, it gets overwritten pretty quickly.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, but as soon as you connect it to a computer, it writes to it. It's it yeah.

SPEAKER_02That's why we use write blockers when we connect stuff where it doesn't write.

SPEAKER_01And you you can see it right on there if you pull up your little folder at the bottom. If you're on a Windows run computer, you see that little folder, pull it up, and it shows your phone right there in the side. It copied everything.

SPEAKER_02Yep, it does. So, how would an examiner handle a hundred thousand plus messages, Juice? That's crazy. Now, we used to up until about a year ago, less than a year, we'd get these messages, and me and Shannon Miller would dump them in a spreadsheet, Excel spreadsheet, and do searches and get this spreadsheet to help us arrange them. It would take hours and days. Right. Now we have this little thing called AI, and we dump them in there, it tells you exactly. I mean, within two minutes.

SPEAKER_02Oh, yeah. Yeah. Here they arranges them for you, puts them in a nice readable format, and says, here's what it says. Gives you a summary. So AI is helping a lot with that. I'm sure that's what they did here. They oh I'm sure. And don't doing the old way with the spreadsheet took a while, but it worked. You know, before that, you had your your your eyes and a pencil, and you went down the list and basically wrote out what was important. Yeah. Put it in a report.

SPEAKER_01So I mean, but drop it in a computer, you throw in the buzzwords, and there it is.

SPEAKER_02We also got mobile edit too, which if mobile edit don't recover, if it's not on the phone, it's not going to do it. But if we get it from some other source, that's where we would use AI to help us sort that data, massive amounts of it. The keyword searches is the detective used they had on the stand. He's used the words killed, dead, gun, and divorce. And that's where he got his stuff organized. So and the tone shifts as the day get closer. So initially it was about him and the concubine. Right. Oh, you're so pretty. I love you.

SPEAKER_02Blah, blah, blah. And then as it gets closer to the kill date, he gets more violent and closer together, him talking about killing his wife. So proving a negative FBI Canvas 80 plus homes for cameras looking for the guy. The sign of intruder finding nothing is evidence to you. So the camera, door camera, security camera across the road from him looked at the home all the time. You know, he could see his neighbor's house.

SPEAKER_02And that night the garage door was just was up. The previous 180 nights, they went back. It was down every night. You could see him walk out and close the garage door before bedtime. That night he left it up. You couldn't really see in the garage that great because it's kind of an angle where you went and opened the door and all that stuff. But anyway. A lot of stuff. A lot of circumstantial evidence here, but the totality is what we're looking at.

SPEAKER_01He was not as smart as he thought he was.

SPEAKER_02This is one of those where there's no DNA, no fingerprints, none of that. But we get digital evidence, yeah, testimony. It's all the circumstantial evidence is what got him. Yeah. Even a fingerprint you can say planted or whatever. Yeah. You can say all of it, sir. One of the defense a lot good defense attorneys I know in uh Huntsville, she says everything's circumstantial. Yeah. So you can it is you can attack everything. So yeah, but once you put it all together, yeah, it kind of paints that picture. She said the one she hates is DNA, because it's so hard to attack these days.

SPEAKER_02Right. They get it so tight. But even that can be attacked. We've seen it where sure it can. Even the DNA examiner fudge numbers. You know, we've seen that before. So it's all circumstantial. So this gets back to you know, infidelity cases and even criminal defense cases, man. Let's talk about let's be a criminal for a minute.

SPEAKER_01Okay.

SPEAKER_02How do you get away with it, Juice?

SPEAKER_01You don't tell anybody.

SPEAKER_02You don't text your minstress of the year that say, I'm gonna kill this person. No, that's crazy, man.

SPEAKER_01You gotta keep that mouth shut. You know, years ago, like we said, it was a lot easier back then to get away with stuff. Right. I did it prior to the age of 18. Just don't tell anybody and don't do it with anybody else. Do it whatever you're doing, whatever dirt you're doing, do it by yourself and don't tell anybody.

SPEAKER_02You know, we talk about the big heist like bank robberies where they use more than one person. Right. Typically, it's one of those idiots spends money in the wrong place, yeah, brags about it, tells his girlfriend when he gets drunk or high one night. Yeah. And it's one person, and they the feds are like, hey there, Mr. And the dominoes fall. You can either we can give you 99 years or you can give you 10 if you're telling these other dudes, right? So whatever. That's how it goes. But yeah, man, this is a good one. Good case to look at, and uh, because of the text messages, what what do you think about it?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, there was a lot going on there. He he wasn't gonna get away with it. But technology and common sense is what got him.

SPEAKER_02Right. That's that for this one, Juice. We're gonna call it a morning on this one, and we'll come back in a minute with another one. All right, that'll work. Let me turn it off, Juice. Say bye. Bye.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Caught on the Ring Doorbell: Ex-Cop Lawrence Goodine and the Murder of Kara Akins | Hidden Threads

    Nov 19, 202634 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail Kara Akins, a mother of seven, had a no-contact order against former Chattanooga police officer Lawrence Goodine. In November 2023, her own Ring doorbell recorded her running outside, yelling for help,...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. The Yacht, the Hotel and $50,000 in Checks: Public Corruption From Jackson to Knoxville | Hidden Threads

    Nov 17, 202626 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail An FBI undercover team posed as hotel developers in Jackson, Mississippi, and the city officials who could approve the project started taking money. There was a trip to Florida on a yacht, cash bribes,...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Badges for Hire: The FBI Sting That Caught Mississippi Sheriffs Guarding Cocaine | Hidden Threads

    Nov 13, 202627 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail Drug dealers in the Mississippi Delta kept telling federal agents the same thing: the cops were on the payroll. The FBI's Jackson Field Office took that seriously and built a years-long undercover sting...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. They Quit and Took Your Secrets: How Employees Steal Company Data | Hidden Threads

    Oct 30, 202621 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail Your top salesman gives two weeks' notice. A month later, your biggest clients are buying from a competitor, and your pricing sheet looks awfully familiar. In this episode of Hidden Threads, Macky...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Is Someone Tracking You? AirTags, GPS Trackers & Phone Spyware Exposed | Hidden Threads

    Oct 27, 202612 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail That "AirTag Found Moving With You" alert. The car that always seems to know where you've been. The ex who shows up wherever you go. In this episode of Hidden Threads, Macky Outlaw and Jus break down...

    Credit the people on this episode