Send us Fan Mail Alex Murdaugh told investigators he was never at the kennels the night his wife and son were murdered. Then a forensic examiner pulled a 50-second video off Paul's phone, recorded at 8:44 PM, and Alex's voice was on it. In this Best Of compilation, we walk through the digital evidence that dismantled the story: the kennel video and the three voices on it, Paul's phone locking at 8:49 PM and never being used again, the dead zone in Alex's own phone activity followed by a sudden burst of step data, the OnStar and GPS records showing the drive to Almeda, and Maggie's phone found in the brush down the road - with motion data consistent with being thrown from a moving vehicle. Nobody testified that they saw Alex Murdaugh pull a trigger. The devices in that house testified for them. Phones, vehicle telematics, and health data don't get nervous on the stand and don't change their story. I'm Macky Outlaw. I run a digital forensics and OSINT firm, and this is the kind of work my examiner and I do every week - just usually without the cameras. If you want to understand how a case actually gets built out of data, start here. Subscribe for more true crime told from the forensic side of the table. Support the show 866.910.7499 help@shadownetdigital.com
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_01Jeuce, we're back with another episode here. Yes, we are. You know, I was disturbed yesterday. I don't know how we're disturbed every day. I am mentally disturbed. Yes. And physically nowadays. Yes. I don't see how we made it out of World War 11 alive. Well, eight was the worst one. Seven was a beast. I was in that one. Yeah. I don't know, man. World War Eleven. That was all scuba diving in. What's her name? The one that said it. Ilian Omar. Number one, just her face and that little thing she wears on her head pisses me off.
SPEAKER_00Her attitude, her arrogance when she doesn't need to have it. It just yeah.
SPEAKER_01Go to Somalia and open your mouth like you do here.
SPEAKER_00Yes. No, go back to Somalia and stay there. But if you do that, try to act like you do here, somebody's gonna strike you down. But that idiot goes out there and does a interview, and she talks about how Americans are dumbed down and you know the dumbing down of America, and it's just gotten so ridiculous. It's hard to have an intellectual conversation. That's why Donald Trump got elected again. Okay. Then she said, We'll get on there and say World War 11.
SPEAKER_01Man, I saw that. I didn't know what the inner what she was talking about. I just heard the World War 11 comments. I seen it. It was hysterical. She's so stupid. I know she faked that attack on her here a while back. Oh, yeah. That was all staged. World War 11. So you are talking down to us and call yourself educated. Yes. And you don't know Roman numeral two. No. I'm not good with Roman numerals, but I can get to 10.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_01After that, I'm kind of lost.
SPEAKER_00Well, you know, you just add a one on that X and you're at 11. She had one one, World War II. Yeah. And if they typed it out, it was a capital I and a capital I.
SPEAKER_01Not 11. Yeah. So Miss Intellectual. Times New Romans, pretty obvious what an I and a one looks like. Yeah. So, but talking down to us, we're Trump supporters. Yeah. I know the difference. I know Roman you're most two, I know what it means.
SPEAKER_00Well, we're we're not what they say is the typical Trump supporter. Right. You know, uh, we we're actually educated. Are you and I both have degrees, multiple degrees.
SPEAKER_01I've read books, yes, a few things. Now I talk about my high school career sometimes, how like luster it was. Oh, mine was even below that. I snapped out of it later in life. Yeah. But yeah. And realized hey, hard work, not just education, but you gotta combine it with smart decisions, hard work, and you can make it in America without somebody handing you something. Unless you're Ilian Omar. No, she's been handed a lot of stuff. Yeah, she's been handed everything, and she's still an idiot. Her brother handed her a marriage certificate.
SPEAKER_01Yes. Is that real? I've not looked into it a lot. Yes. Yes. Oh my.
SPEAKER_00And that's a representative. And they talk bad about like the South. That's congressional. Marrying kissing your cousin and all that. She's from Somalia. She married her own brother. All right. That's disturbing juice. Yeah. But yet she's a lawmaker now. She's been there a while. Somebody voted her in. So I'm gonna go with those people who are even lower in intelligence than she is.
SPEAKER_01She was smart enough to get somebody to vote for her. Yes. Which is like a salesperson kind of thing. Yes. She's smart enough to do that. And they were dumb enough to vote for her. So that disturbs me. Yeah. I don't even have to hear her talk. Just looking at her makes me angry. Why is she a representative?
SPEAKER_00She shouldn't be. If you're not a natural born citizen, you shouldn't hold any political office. That's not on the book. That's just my opinion. That's your opinion. That's not on the books.
SPEAKER_01But I just don't like the anti-American rhetoric. Neither do I.
SPEAKER_00If it's good enough for you to be here and flourish and and prosper, shut your pie hole. Right.
SPEAKER_01And make laws that help people and not hurt people. That's what she does. So but anyway, there's a bunch of them. Not just her. Yeah. She just happens to be the idiot that came up with World War 11 this week. And she's on TV a lot, so or in the on social media a lot. Her and the squad. Oh my God. Get out of here. Let's get on to something before I start cussing juice. All right. All right. Alex Murdoch. So we're going to talk about him a little bit and digital clues. We talk about digital clues on here sometimes, and you try to say like you're not a digital person. I'm not. I I am nowhere near the nerdy guy you are.
SPEAKER_01You struggle with email. I do. Those kind of things. Email's been around for a while. Trying to think when '92, '91? I remember in the Marines. I was a young private.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, it had to be before that. So 8089, I think. I got a my first email. Right.
SPEAKER_01I remember when I was a young private, they got the first computer hooked to the internet in the company office. Oh, yeah. And we would all go stand around and be and just watch people send emails back and forth. Yeah. We'd print them out and read them. Like it was amazing. It was magic. You know, I mean, it'd been around before that, but that was like the first use of it out in public, right? Yeah. And we had one computer. Oh, yeah. You had to get time on it to go send an email, you know, that kind of stuff. On the ship was the same way. They had three computers. You'd stand in line to go send email and read email.
SPEAKER_00So our first computer in the company office we got from Dermo. Dermo. Yeah. And one of our guys, Calm Sargent, he was actually uh he was really nerdy at the time. He uh got that thing to work. Probably put a processor in there or something. Yeah, I don't know what he did, but he was super nerdy. And like he would go in and you know the floppy disc games and stuff. He would go in and change the code on them so you could just keep getting indefinite lives. And he had some training in there. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Well, in high school, the we had we in typing class, we still had the now that we had a word processor, it was a type electric typewriter, and it would beep at you when you misspelled something. Oh, yeah. And you go to correct and go pop. You know, made the noise. We didn't we had one computer in the whole school, and you took computer science class, they'd give you a lot of theory on the board, and then you went and played Oregon Trail. You know, you didn't really learn a lot.
SPEAKER_00Our PE teacher was our comp side teacher in in high school. He he was as dumb as the basketball he was playing with, taught us computer science. He didn't have a clue.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Compute, so I've I've always been a computer nerd and uh tech nerd and all that. The I've trained, I kind of self-trained for a while and learned it. Uh bought myself a Windows computer when I was a young Marine, and I would sit up late at night learning that code and how to do stuff on there. Yeah. And then that was the old what, MS-DOS. No, dot well DOS is always DOS is the always the background of Windows. Yes. That's the code in the background of Windows. Windows is just the Yeah, Windows wasn't there when when we started.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Windows is just the operator interface, is what you see on the outside. But you had Fortran and Cobalt, which were MS DOS-based. Yep. Fortran was I think was business and Cobalt was more medical. Yeah, formula translation. I took courses in that. Anyway, it was pretty it's pretty simple when you get down to it. It's just another language, is all it is. But those still run in the background of all these machines you see. Oh, yeah. Yeah. You can reveal code and go, there it is, you know. But uh and you get Python and some other languages now, which make it simpler. Right. But yeah, that's computer science.
SPEAKER_01How do we get onto that?
SPEAKER_00I don't know.
SPEAKER_01Talking about Murdaw and him getting busted, a smart lawyer, rich guy getting busted because of technology. Let's remind everybody about Murdahl, what he's doing. He's sitting in the jail right now, as they say on Andy Griffith. So he's in the prison. He's in a big house, yeah, South Carolina. On June 7, 2021, Maggie and Paul Murdaw were shot and killed near the dog kennels at the family's Moselle property in South Carolina.
SPEAKER_00You know that area, right? Yeah, I live down there. This is a that place is beautiful. It's like a big ranch type of thing. Oh, yeah. That's very affluent people are down that way. Wasn't he a uh personal injury attorney or yourself? Yeah, an attorney.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Big attorney. Alex Murdaw reported finding the bodies and claimed he had been napping and visiting his mother, denying he was at the kennels. All right. Investigators uncovered a tight digital timeline that contradicted his story. The prosecution argued the murders were committed to delay exposure of his financial crimes and generate sympathy. On March 2023, a jury convicted him of two counts of murder and two weapons charges, and he received life without parole. Which is shocking in South Carolina. They normally put him in the seat.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, which is is weird because I've been up there for old Sparky and I worked on Death Row, and he should have been there.
SPEAKER_01He did not cooperate at all with this either. He said he'd be guilty. He still says he's not guilty right now. So he may not be, I don't know. Yeah, oh, he's guilty. So Paul is the son, right? Let's see here. Yeah, Paul's the son. So they found video recorded on Paul's phone minutes before the murders happened. All right. They captured Alex's voice at the Kennels. Yes. Which he says it wasn't, it wasn't his voice, it was the killer's voice. Yes. But they had many people come up and say, Yes, this is him, you know.
SPEAKER_01And he had repeatedly said he was never there. This directly proved he lied about his location at the time of the murders. Now they got down in what we call micro-locating. Right. So we use our phones and we use GPS trackers and all these things. The GPS trackers we use, and our phones can say, hey, they're good up to about a hundred yards or whatever. Yeah. But they got into some some of his text messaging apps and all that. It got down to the foot. And so he was there, man. He was right there. Oh yeah. And of course they came out and said, Oh, this is flawed evidence and all that, but that's what got him. Right?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, you can say it's flawed, but it's there.
SPEAKER_01Right. Let's talk about the phone data. It showed minimal movement and then a sudden spike in steps right after the murders. Right. And they were going off also his smartwatch, which had his heart rate data on it.
SPEAKER_00Oh yeah.
SPEAKER_01They did a bunch of things happen here. Activity consistent with rapid movement and possible staging and cleanup. All right. Screen use and orientation changes supported his timeline of where he was. All right. Then he had calls and text messages, the old goodie, the old classic. Calls placed Maggie and Paul after they were already dead, or placed them there. Increased communication right after the estimated time of death. Timing suggested attempts to create an alibi. Pattern looked staged rather than natural.
SPEAKER_02All right.
SPEAKER_01He had some vehicle telematics, your vehicle computer, right?
SPEAKER_00Yep.
SPEAKER_01His shaping suburban recorded engine start and stop time, speed changes, and trip duration. Showed quick departure from Moselle right after. All right. Travel timeline inconsistent with his statements. So he was there, left Moselle, and then came back later. So all right. But he wasn't there at the time. He said he was at his mother's house. Oh, maybe he lied. All right. Yeah, timeline fusion, which brings everything together. Investigators aligned phone data, vehicle data, and witness statements in a minute by minute reconstructed. Very good. I like it.
SPEAKER_01And the points that put him at the kennels at the time of the murders, and then he lied through his teeth. They caught him in so many lies afterwards. So the police did a good job on this one, in my opinion. Oh, yeah. This is one of those two where the public was like, oh, the police ain't doing their job because it took a while.
SPEAKER_00It's not an instant thing, man. It's not. And some of that stuff, you know, when you're you're doing a digital dump, it takes a while. And then you have to sort through everything.
SPEAKER_01So we do a digital dump. One cell phone is four to six thousand pages of data. And another issue they had, the son's phone was not unlocked immediately. They had to get some help to get it unlocked. So that takes time too. And they thought and the voice on that recording, they everybody said, Hey, this is Alex talking.
SPEAKER_00You could have had that analyzed, I mean, honestly, if you if you really wanted to. Right. But there's people that ID'd that voice.
SPEAKER_01Right. And the jury they convicted not on one single piece. A single piece of evidence doesn't usually convict somebody.
SPEAKER_00No.
SPEAKER_01What do you what's your favorite phrase?
SPEAKER_00Totality of the circumstances.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, right. One, you know, it's the physical evidence, digital evidence, and witnesses that tie it all together.
SPEAKER_00But the biggest thing in cases people don't understand or it's it's because you don't see it. Okay, yeah, SVU on TV, they did this and they got the guy in 48 hours. That's not the way it works. You're building your case. You want as much evidence as possible. You want to fine-tooth comb every bit of anything that could be a lead, could be a witness, could be evidence. So you want to make sure that you have a preponderance of evidence against that individual.
SPEAKER_01Right. And it it takes time. Yeah. You take time. You're getting data from all these different sources. Yeah. You got your uniforms that were there first, or you do the first responders, right? Yep. And then you got your detectives and you got your all time. You got the body, you got the scene, and you got what was the word we use? Environmental. What was the word I use? The phrase I used very smart. It was good. Environmental timeline. What's the what's the when they when you got the FBI?
SPEAKER_01Environmental profiling. There you go. That's what this was. What where the crime took place and the relationship from the criminal to the crime scene. That's what they do. Oh yeah. Yeah. They use it a lot in the um serial killers because they're usually spread across an area and they're trying to pinpoint where their base of operations is. Right. And you gotta have a lot of data to do that. But this guy, he was he was lying and saying I wasn't there, but then all the data points to yeah, you're standing right there, dude.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. You may be an an intelligent individual. Like he, you know, he's an attorney and he specializes. So in his specialty, I'm sure he's very knowledgeable, very intelligent. But when it comes to everything else, you're not the expert. You're gonna screw everything up. Right. Somewhere along the way, you're gonna get caught.
SPEAKER_01These digital computers we carry in our pockets are are cutting down on the amount of crimes that helping people get caught. Yeah. Yeah. I mean, so I think that's why we see a reduction in serial killers because of the digital footprint. Right. It's rough. It makes it tough to be a prolific, we're gonna kill 32 people over four years type person, like we used to see. You know what I mean? And they they they are serial killers, they're just getting caught quicker.
SPEAKER_00Right. Well, like we've said it before. I know I have, you know, from working for for NASA, these these little pocket computers, these have more intelligence and technology than what put the man on the moon. Right. Yeah. What what do you think you're gonna get away with with something like that?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, Steve Jobs said that about the iPod before they started making phone calls. You know, uh iPod had a lot of you could do a lot with an iPod, and then they put a phone system on it and made it a phone, right? That's what we got. But yeah, man, Merdal, you know, he lied through his teeth over and over again, said he didn't do it. He's still saying he didn't do it.
SPEAKER_00Well, that's the attorney behind him, that that knowledge that he has. If you keep putting it off, putting it off, deny, deny, deny, counteracuse, maybe you get somebody to listen to you, believe you. You just, you know, need one juror to say nope.
SPEAKER_01I think he's got an appeal coming up or something.
SPEAKER_00Oh, yeah.
SPEAKER_01But so he was trying to make people feel sorry for him because he is in financial distress.
SPEAKER_00Well, you know, he was stealing from his clients.
SPEAKER_01All right.
SPEAKER_00How was he doing that? He was billing them out. Hey, this is what you owe, this is what you owe, this is what I did. This is you know, I need this money, I need that money. But he wasn't doing the work. He wasn't.
SPEAKER_01Uh yeah, and um, I think he was a uh personal injury attorney as well.
SPEAKER_00And I think somebody in his firm caught him, caught on to him. He was getting ready to get fired, basically. Oh, yeah.
SPEAKER_01They were getting ready to drop the hammer on him, right? You know, no longer a partner and all that stuff. Yeah. He did a lot of crying on the in the witness and the police. Yeah, alligator tears. Another thing he did that's very arrogant, he walked in there several times with investigators in the room. Yeah, he thought he was smarter than they were. And talk to him, right? Now, what would he tell if he had a crime a criminal, a person being accused of a crime? What's the first thing he would tell them?
SPEAKER_00There's a lot of things that go through their minds. Yeah. But he would be like, Oh, I want to help you guys, you know, I didn't do it, and then start offering them false leads. But it it's just it's weird.
SPEAKER_01But if you had a client in that situation, you say stop talking to the cops. Yeah, absolutely. But he thought he's smart on everybody.
SPEAKER_00He just wanted to talk when he got there and gave him all kinds of info. He thought he could talk his way out of it, didn't he? So and you you you you really can't. And any of the investigators take basic classes and what they call statement analysis. And it it it doesn't say you're lying, but it gives the investigator a tool to use on what you say. You have to have statement balance with with certain nouns and verbs, and but in statement analysis, it just gives you deception markers.
SPEAKER_00They uh lead you down the road of questioning. Doesn't say you're lying, but it leads you down other roads because it it it will tell you that person is answering deceptively, right? So I mean any of the the investigators in that case, they they could have taken those classes and and your your main line of questioning starts there. But he just started talking.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. I I took a class in that. Most a lot of us have, right? It's not and it's not a difficult thing. It's a you're breaking down the w what they're saying and you're and you're putting it down in bite-sized chunks and you're comparing them to each other. Yep. And a lot of them stand out, like, well, you know, yesterday you said this, today you're saying this. You know, you you explain themselves and they lie again and then they do it again. But you're just breaking it down into bite-sized chunks and comparing words and statements.
SPEAKER_00And um I mean you can record it and then transcribe it and run it through software that does the statement analysis for you.
SPEAKER_01Yep, they got it now.
SPEAKER_00It breaks it down and you're going, okay.
SPEAKER_01It's a great tool. And it gives you and you have to do it quick sometimes because you're setting nose to nose with them, but yeah, it can give you data to to the next question to ask, the next set of questions to ask to make them live and more that's that comes more with the experience. Yeah. The best technique I've ever seen is if they want to talk, I'm gonna sit here and let you talk, man. And always ask open-ended questions. Yep. But I guess you know why I'm here. That's an old trick.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, never give them a yes or no. Always give them an open-ended question so that way they can elaborate.
SPEAKER_01When they whenever they volunteer to come, they say, Yeah, I'll come talk to you. That's a sign, right? Oh, yeah. And always say, Hey, tell me what your thoughts are on this. And just sit back. Oh, yeah. And they start spewing vomit. Yeah. Lies, truths, a little bit of both, right? And uh, and that gives you directions. So tell me more about this. Tell me more about that. And that's what they did at Murdoch here. And it was he talked to them for a long time before they arrested arrested.
SPEAKER_00And they they just baited him and he went for it. So he is an intelligent individual, he's just not that intelligent when it comes to things outside of his wheelhouse.
SPEAKER_01He got cocky. Our lawyer's cocky. Yes. Yes. I I wouldn't say you're a good lawyer if you're not a little bit, right? Yeah, you have to have an ego to be a good attorney. Yeah. Some of them control it and are approachable people, some aren't. Some of them are. I can't stand to be risked. But all right, do you see anything else on the Murdoch?
SPEAKER_00No. How about statement analysis? It's it's if if you're an investigator, I don't care if you're a private investigator, I don't care if you're in a law enforcement agency, I don't care if you're a patrol officer. Find out who's offering statement analysis courses. There's three levels. Get them all. Because it's just a tool that you're going to be able to use. It's going to make you better, more proficient. It's going to help your cases. Definitely take classes. Don't ever quit learning any of that stuff. Right. Okay.
SPEAKER_01All right then. We're going to get off here for now. We'll be back soon. Say bye, juice. Bye, juice. Nice.
Send us Fan Mail Kara Akins, a mother of seven, had a no-contact order against former Chattanooga police officer Lawrence Goodine. In November 2023, her own Ring doorbell recorded her running outside, yelling for help,...
Send us Fan Mail An FBI undercover team posed as hotel developers in Jackson, Mississippi, and the city officials who could approve the project started taking money. There was a trip to Florida on a yacht, cash bribes,...
Send us Fan Mail Drug dealers in the Mississippi Delta kept telling federal agents the same thing: the cops were on the payroll. The FBI's Jackson Field Office took that seriously and built a years-long undercover sting...
Send us Fan Mail Your top salesman gives two weeks' notice. A month later, your biggest clients are buying from a competitor, and your pricing sheet looks awfully familiar. In this episode of Hidden Threads, Macky...
Send us Fan Mail That "AirTag Found Moving With You" alert. The car that always seems to know where you've been. The ex who shows up wherever you go. In this episode of Hidden Threads, Macky Outlaw and Jus break down...