After talking about health as we always do because we’re old, we pivot to diet - specifically veganism. Cori, who has never cared about animal rights, gamely steel-mans an argument in favor, while Nina, whose bleeding heart has caused anemia and possibly brittle bones, fearfully argues against. Along the way we cover tribes, rituals, purity, CRISPR, evolution, Lierre Keith, lactose tolerance, lactation intolerance, the Bible, abattoirs, eggs, nuts, Jordan Peterson, cults, The Liberation Pledge, and how Nina accidentally killed a bat when she was 17. Since recording this on Passover 2026 (release delay 85% Cori’s fault) Nina worked through more of her apostasy, first writing The Law of Conservation of Evil and then Vegan Appreciation Day. She’s done now. Links: The Vegetarian Myth by Lierre Keith: https://www.lierrekeith.com/book-ex_the-vegetarian-myth.php Soylent (Creamy Chocolate is the only good flavor): https://www.amazon.com/Soylent-Chocolate-Protein-Replacement-Bottles/dp/B08H6FB43L?th=1 Nina’s Fecebook solicitation: https://www.facebook.com/nina.paley/posts/pfbid0EcMpKSUVyGm6356iEw8VeJXzRJhSP5X3YyVZkDKrUAVrMrYC4oUR3fMriQ8vA2xtl Nina’s poll on Spinster: https://spinster.xyz/@ninapaley/posts/B4tQFS5G2srXYSm1Lc Nina’s poll on Twitter: Jordan Peterson’s Lion Diet: https://liondiet.com/the-diet-updated-march-2018/ The Liberation Pledge: https://veganfta.com/blog/2022/11/16/what-is-the-liberation-pledge-and-how-hard-is-it/ Vegan TERFFles (out of stock) (password: vegan): https://store.ninapaley.com/product/vegan-terffles/ Vegan Appreciation Day: https://ninapaley.com/2026/04/09/vegan-appreciation-day/ The Law of Conservation of Evil: https://ninapaley.com/2026/04/04/the-law-of-conservation-of-evil/ Get full access to Heterodorx Podcast at heterodorx.substack.com/subscribe
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_00Hetero dorks. Hetero ducks dorks. Beep.
SPEAKER_01Oh, there's my kitty. The cat that absconded with my microphone cover. I have to use this thing instead. A pop filter. That's right. It's a pop filter. It's inconvenient. But they had chewed holes through the other microphone cover thingy, and I have no idea where they hid it.
SPEAKER_00Where I grew up, Nina, they were called soda filters, not pop filters.
SPEAKER_01You are listening to the Heterodorks podcast. I am your co-host, Nina Paley, a brilliant artist years ahead of my time.
SPEAKER_00I am Corey Cohn, a person who is starting to have gray hair.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, at over 50 years old. Most of us get gray hair in our 30s.
SPEAKER_00I had gray hair at 47. Yes. You couldn't see it unless it was in the right light. But now you can see it without it having to be special light.
SPEAKER_01All right. Well, this is my co-host, Corey Cohn, who looks freakishly youthful. I used to. I'm losing it. It's not just because of exogenous hormones. It's because of some genetic advantage.
SPEAKER_00I'm losing it. Well, you're getting old, but you got 20 more years than the rest of us before that happened. I've got good news, though, Nina. Yeah. I did a bone density scan and my bones are looking pretty good. I just need to keep exercising and have my vitamin D and I should be OK. Yeah. Whereas I exercise and take vitamin D and I have brittle, weak osteopenic bones. Yeah. Most of your exercising, to be fair, is just sitting down.
SPEAKER_00On a bike? On a bike, but it's mostly just sitting down.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah. Bicycling isn't good for bone density. It's good for everything else, though, and it's light on your joints. So it's six of one, half a dozen of the other. I won't have joint problems. The best thing that you could do at this point for your joints and for your muscles and your bones would be to trade in your recumbent bicycle for a pogo stick. Oh, you know, pogo sticking is fun. I used to have one. I guarantee if you did century pogo stick,
I don't know what you'd call them, circuits. They would take longer, Nina, but your bones would start to probably just crumble.
SPEAKER_00Maybe I'll look into getting a pogo stick.
SPEAKER_01It's been years. It would be fun to bounce around on a pogo stick again. I might get motion sick, though, because I get motion sick even on a swing set now. You just take a little Dramamine, and as long as you don't fall asleep, you'll be okay. I will fall asleep. Yeah, I will fall asleep. So we're talking about health, and you know what's related to health?
SPEAKER_00Cats and weather.
SPEAKER_01Diet.
SPEAKER_00Diet is related to health. So we can talk about a topic I really want to talk about, which is veganism. Can I tell you, I started a diet today.
SPEAKER_01Well, you're kosher, and you're kosher for Passover. Yeah.
SPEAKER_00No leavened food in my diet. No chametz. I'm going to try it for a week and see how it goes. The no chametz diet, which is not a health diet, nor is it even an ethical diet.
SPEAKER_01It's a tribal ritual diet.
SPEAKER_00It's an ethical tribe. But you wanted to talk about the vegans? Yes.
SPEAKER_01Well, yeah, I mean, let's talk about this, too, because there is this element of diets where a lot of diets are more than just diets. Like, why do you suppose there are these dietary restrictions in your religion?
SPEAKER_00In our religion? Oh, you don't have a religion.
SPEAKER_01Well, I mean, I ate hummets today, so I'm calling it your religion.
SPEAKER_00My religion.
SPEAKER_01I am comfortable in my Jewish ethnicity and identity. without actually practicing the religion or the dietary restrictions.
SPEAKER_00We do this to remember our freedom, our liberty.
SPEAKER_01And does it work? Does the dietary restriction work for that purpose?
SPEAKER_00The dietary restriction is about focusing your intention, doing something that other people are doing. It's about creating the deliberate choices. Other people in your tribe, because most people are not.
SPEAKER_01And, you know, even some people in your tribe, like me, are not doing it.
SPEAKER_00And even the 11 other tribes. Yeah, all the children of Israel. Except for you, Nina. This is why you're the black sheep. This is why we scapegoat you. Because you started the morning with a bacon sandwich. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01No, I did not have bacon. I had oatmeal. And listeners, oatmeal is not kosher for Passover. You know, if you're doing oatmeal, you might as well have bacon. No, those are different. With shrimp sauce. I think bacon is very different from oatmeal. And I think there are ethical reasons to avoid bacon. But I just can't say there are ethical reasons to avoid oatmeal. There are ritual and tribal reasons. There are cultural reasons.
SPEAKER_01But I just don't think ethics comes into it.
SPEAKER_00That may be true. Yeah. But you wanted to talk about the vegans.
SPEAKER_01I did. And so one idea I have is... To have you, who you have never been vegan, you've never really been an ethical vegetarian either.
SPEAKER_00You eat more vegetarian now because it's easier to stay kosher that way. To be fair, I've never been ethical.
SPEAKER_01Exactly. So I was thinking, maybe you could put forth, in good faith and steel manning, the arguments for veganism. And I, who don't eat meat, could put forth... arguments against veganism okay you do eat meat though i should say i should note well yeah it depends i sometimes eat fish yes yeah well i do i do want to mention that i should just say i don't eat i don't eat birds or mammals
birds or mammals or
SPEAKER_00or amphibians or reptiles that is true or insects i mean
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I actually don't mind the idea of eating insects ethically, but I'm also squeamish, but I'll get into that.
SPEAKER_00Okay, and you want me to make the arguments for the vegans?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, just start it. Like, what is veganism? You know, make a good argument for it. Why are people vegan?
SPEAKER_00All right, well, I want to... preface this by saying that you just hit me with this. You did not do any prep before the show saying, would you show up and steal me on veganism?
SPEAKER_01That is true. I just thought of it like five minutes ago.
SPEAKER_00That's fine. I will note that that would have given me time to prep five minutes ago. But it's okay. Here's the pitch for veganism. In... Modernity. It is possible for every person in a wealthy country to be able to get a complete nutritious diet that meets all of the criteria to be a healthy
human without
SPEAKER_00needing to kill animals. and that all of our other physical material needs that we have, like to stay warm, can be met without having to exploit animals. So we have what we need to actually survive and thrive without having to kill animals to do it.
SPEAKER_01And does that include without having to farm animals?
SPEAKER_00Does that include not having to farm animals?
SPEAKER_01I'm just making a distinction between vegetarianism and veganism. So veganism is no milk, no dairy, no eggs, no animal products. Including not wearing wool and leather and things like that.
SPEAKER_00Sure. And let's say that there are some vegans who are strictly dietary vegans, and then there are other vegans who extend that to other parts of their lifestyle. But you don't need eggs. Right. You don't need milk. If you really want something that's white and liquid, you can make it out of nuts. And there are different sorts of vegetable proteins that you can use to create
SPEAKER_00satisfying, toothy, chewy, delicious food products. So what do you need meat for? Okay.
SPEAKER_01Okay. I think you did a really good job steelmanning that. How did it feel?
SPEAKER_00I'm convinced. There's only one thing. There's one thing that I can't faithfully steelman, which is that vegan food is not very exciting to eat. There are some good vegan dishes, but the whole range of vegan food is pretty... It's pretty terrible, honestly.
SPEAKER_01Some vegan things are delicious.
SPEAKER_00I believe that some vegan things are delicious. I mean, you actually enjoy some purely vegan things, like dark, dark chocolate. That's vegan. Dark chocolate with almonds, delicious. But the one time that I tried to live off of almonds that are dipped in chocolate, I got sick after three months. You can't do it indefinitely.
SPEAKER_01Did you try that, though, or are you making that up?
SPEAKER_00I don't remember.
SPEAKER_01That's what it did to your memory.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, it really messed with my memory, Nina. It was delicious, though.
SPEAKER_01Okay. It was good. All right. And so we're going to... I think implicit in your argument for veganism is that we should care about the welfare of animals.
SPEAKER_00Yes, I think that that's probably... One of the things that we should do if we're vegans is reflect on how much power we have over other living creatures and how much responsibility we should take for the treatment of other living things. Well, isn't that just something humans should do? Isn't that just vegan or not?
SPEAKER_01Wouldn't you want all people to be vegan? If the argument for veganism is that you can do those things, then that argument would appeal... should appeal to everyone because everyone should care about the welfare of animals, non-human animals. I got to tell you, Nina, most people don't even care about the welfare of other people.
SPEAKER_00So to get to the next step of saying, let's go outside of your species and care about those things also, that's a big ask. But that is what vegans are asking. Well, I don't know if that's really so, because let's be honest, you and I are sort of misanthropes. And if we had to pick, hey, here's the deal. You can house a homeless family or you can keep your cats.
SPEAKER_00Which do you want to do? You and I will say, I prefer my cats. Thank you. Yeah. And we're not sorry about it. Even though I have room for another person in my house, except that room is taken up by two cats.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. And I know, I know the objection is, but you could have a homeless person sleep on your bed. Many vegans are actually deep misanthropes. I know. Yeah. Yeah, like many, I think, myself included, back in the day, preferred animals to humans. Like, the idea of humans suffering a little bit because they couldn't
eat animal products or consume animal products didn't bother me at all because I didn't like humans.
SPEAKER_01And at one point, when I was a teenager, I actually imagined if it were between my life and the life of a pig... that I would choose the pig's life. Now, granted, I was depressed and suicidal a lot, and I was also a teenager, and that is a very teenager way of thinking about the world. But I did think that.
SPEAKER_00I'm less than a pig. I mean, I didn't sum it up that way. You probably thought, if this pig were diabetic, I should give my life to great medicine for the pig.
SPEAKER_01I just thought it's... You know, the pig is more innocent than me. And the pig doesn't... The pig didn't do anything. The pig is not responsible for the horrors in the world. Humans are.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Do you know PETH? PETH? What's PETH? PETH. People for the Ethical Treatment of Humans. PETH.
SPEAKER_01Ah, yeah. I wasn't one of those.
SPEAKER_00No. But you were PETA. Yeah,
SPEAKER_01I just thought animals, I mean, particularly domestic animals, it's not their fault that they've all been born. It's all because of human intervention and human breeding. And of course, I had a very negative attitude in general towards just the way humans treated the natural world and the environment and the planet.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, that we all contribute to. Yeah. Yeah. as Derek Jensen reminded us a couple of years ago.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, we all definitely contribute to that. And I did not want to. I did not want to contribute to that. I wanted to boycott any way that I could. And... You can't. Well, I thought I could.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, but you can't even kill yourself. Because the amount of processing that that takes is pretty crazy, too.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, it's taken me... One of the reasons my... thoughts on veganism have changed over the years is that my thoughts on being a human in a very complex society that is the way it is has changed. I have come to more acceptance I thought possible.
SPEAKER_00You may not want to be part of the universe.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I do want to be part of the universe now. Okay. Just in time. Yeah, so I'm Should I try to steel man the argument against?
SPEAKER_00Well, that was the bargain.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Are we going to argue about it? Am I going to still take the pro vegan sign?
SPEAKER_01I don't know. I just I wanted to open a discussion and I thought this would be the best way because I have so many thoughts about veganism. Right. Argument against veganism. The most common one is people who don't. care about animal welfare and don't care to care about animal welfare and have other things that they care about and they're just like fuck you i like meat and uh
you vegans are crazy like they care too much about animals and that's not a very
SPEAKER_00good steel man effort
SPEAKER_01No, but it is the most common. I posted about this on Facebook today and somebody was complaining about... I was talking about Lear Keith and her arguments and somebody responded, well, I don't see arguments like that. I just see MAGA men posting pictures of sizzling steaks whenever vegans talk.
SPEAKER_00That is a meme. That is something that happens.
SPEAKER_01That is a meme.
SPEAKER_00It's not just MAGA men. It's anybody who has working taste buds. Yeah. right uh so i suppose the steel man the the more steel man way to present that is that uh animal products taste delicious to many humans and that is important i think this the steel man is that animals are one of the most efficient ways for humans to get nutrition that we need oh that's well done now
what i was gonna say
SPEAKER_01is like the real steel man argument Animal welfare is important. However, vegan diets are really unhealthy for people. They're not unhealthy for everyone. Some people can thrive on a vegan diet.
SPEAKER_00Well, it's expensive too, right?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, and some people cannot. And the only way you find out... which kind of person you are is to do it and if you're the kind of person that doesn't thrive on it you could have all kinds of physical problems permanent ones for the rest of your life and that diet is not well understood and that the assertion that you made that we can get all of our nutritional needs met is possibly not true it might be true for some people but it is
not true for all
SPEAKER_01people and
SPEAKER_00What's the difference? How would it be that it works for some people but not other people? What causes that?
SPEAKER_01I don't know.
SPEAKER_00Is it like a gut microbiome? What are we talking about here?
SPEAKER_01I don't know. I really don't know. I mean, our friend Manish Yadov, back when he was posting on social media actively, he would frequently critique... articles about nutrition and so-called nutrition science. And he just kept saying, it's very poorly understood. People think that they understand a lot more about it than they do.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. I do that when my friends post their children's algebra homework. We don't really understand this stuff. No, I think... How do we prove any of this? We don't.
SPEAKER_01Well, yeah, I think diet is not the same as algebra. It's really not. There are some things that are understood about it, but there will be articles about finding some carcinogen or pathogen in some food. And then it's like, this food contains this carcinogen or pathogen. And then 20 years later... there will be a discovery that the same food contains another compound, which counteracts the pathogen or carcinogen that it contains.
And what bodies are doing with all of these different compounds is just not understood.
SPEAKER_01And you cannot just pick apart the components of foods. Yeah.
SPEAKER_00So what are we talking about?
SPEAKER_01There's too many confounding variables. Well, I'm saying based on observation, like I do know some vegans who are fine. And I also know some former vegans who are not fine. And what?
SPEAKER_00I don't understand. I know some trans people who are just fine, and I know some that are not fine. What's the underlying point? What's the story? What are we trying to get to?
SPEAKER_01Well, vegans will say, or vegan activists will say that anybody can do just fine on a vegan diet, and you don't need any animal products in your diet.
SPEAKER_00OK, yes, that's a claim. Former vegans who have gotten ill while they were vegans will say vegan diet is unhealthy.
SPEAKER_01It will make you sick.
SPEAKER_00But other vegans would just say you were doing it wrong.
SPEAKER_01Other vegans will say you were doing it wrong. Right. So it's like communism in that way. You're just not doing it right. I don't think that that's exactly an apples to apples comparison because there's no
SPEAKER_00way to do communism right. But there might be a way to do vegan right. There might be a way to do vegan right.
SPEAKER_01Some former vegans argue there is no way to do vegan right. I'm not one of them, but some of them make that argument.
SPEAKER_00What are we talking about?
SPEAKER_01Why would they make that argument? What are they saying? They're saying, I did everything right. I followed all the instructions when I was vegan and I got sick.
SPEAKER_00And they would say, and I got sick because... Because I was on this vegan diet that was making me sick. No, no, no. That's not... What would... It should be saying, because there was this amino acid that wasn't in the diet. Because these types of vegetables cause inflammatory disease. Because, like, there should be some rationale... The rationale cannot be,
vegan's bad for you because I got sick because I was a vegan.
SPEAKER_00This is a circular argument. I guess a lot of them say because I didn't get enough protein or I didn't get the
SPEAKER_01right balance of nutrients. But even that, I don't think they really know. I mean, they have their best guesses, but I don't think any of it is settled and provable. By what mechanisms this stuff works. They do try to separate everything into amino acids and they have identified some amino acids that are necessary in some species that you cannot get in a vegan diet. And the vegans will say, well, you just add that in and then you're fine.
SPEAKER_01And to argue against that, I would say there's a whole bunch of other stuff going on that you don't understand and you haven't measured. And it's probably more than just that amino acid. Right. It's more complex than we understand.
SPEAKER_00Well, this is why we need to do the, what is it called? Where they manipulate the genes, the technology that they have where you can insert genes.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, CRISPR gene editing.
SPEAKER_00Right. You need to put the genes for steak into rice or something so that you can grow rice that tastes like steak. You laugh, but it sounds delicious. If I could get rice and it tasted like steak, I would switch.
SPEAKER_01Okay. All right. Genetic engineers, go for it. There is a problem with growing highly proteinaceous things in a lab anyway, which is that they're really susceptible to pathogens. And apparently that's the problem with lab-grown meat.
SPEAKER_00It gets sick easy.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, the whole thing gets sick. It doesn't have an immune system.
SPEAKER_00It gets a little cold and then it dies. You can't eat it. But I want to go back for a second here because you're saying something that really bothers me and I want to clear it out.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_00So let's take a vegan who they're sticking with the vegan diet. They don't seem to be doing very well on it. Now, are they working with a nutritionist to identify what they're actually putting in their bodies and trying to track down what might be missing from their diet or what might be in excess, like when I was eating nothing but chocolate-covered almonds?
SPEAKER_01Which didn't happen, which is not true, not a thing that you did.
SPEAKER_00Why don't you let me steel man this argument instead of contradicting me?
SPEAKER_01That's not steel man, that's uranium man.
SPEAKER_00You're not even arguing, you're just contradicting me. The I don't I don't want to accept a claim from somebody who says, oh, I got sick because I was a vegan without also having some evidence that they had some analysis of their diet to try to figure out what might have been wrong with it. Like, I want to hear how they tried to fine tune their diet instead of they just ate nothing but chocolate covered almonds for three months and said, I can't do this anymore.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, like I did. Right. I trust... It's been a long time since I've read the part of Lear Keith's book, The Vegetarian Myth, that I did read. But I believe that she was very attentive to nutrition and her diet, vegan diet, and that she was not eating chocolate-covered almonds, that she was doing the things she was supposed to do.
SPEAKER_00Almonds are nutritious.
SPEAKER_01Because she really wanted to be vegan. She really... She really had strong ideological reasons to be vegan. She had the best faith effort, and she was smart and dedicated and didn't just eat crap. I do remember I heard an interview with her, which I do have to apologize.
SPEAKER_00She's not here, but I have to make an apology. I didn't have consent to listen to her and being interviewed by another person. And so possibly I was doing something improper by listening to her have a conversation on another podcast. I apologize if she feels that way. It's possible. I don't know. Maybe she only wants women to listen. I don't know. But she said that plants have to be cooked in order to be
edible because plants have self-defense systems so that just anything that's out in the wild that's
SPEAKER_00hungry doesn't just chomp down and eat them. So plants have all sorts of self-defense. And if you don't cook them, then you'll get sick.
SPEAKER_01Do you want me to respond to that?
SPEAKER_00Well, it's just, I think she was making the point that some vegans are so committed to their dietary restrictions that some of them just eat raw vegetables. They don't cook them. Potatoes are terrible like that. Don't eat raw potatoes would be my advice.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. My understanding of that's not true of all plants, and some plants are fine raw, and some plants do need to be cooked, and some plants need to be processed beyond just being cooked, like cassava. Right. And some don't. And that cooking does concentrate nutritional density, although it also breaks down some essential vitamins and minerals. Yeah. Well, I'm just trying to recall what she said about her diet that
said that wasn't working.
SPEAKER_00And it wasn't only that she was vegan. It's that I think she was trying to eat raw vegetables.
SPEAKER_01Oh, I see. Yeah, we might really have to have her on. Well, I mean, she won't come on, but I've asked her.
SPEAKER_00I've asked her in the past and she said no. Did she? I don't think I knew that.
SPEAKER_01Maybe she's changed. Maybe people can change, right? They can change. For example, I used to be a woman. Maybe we can talk to Lear Keith about that.
SPEAKER_00You used to be a man.
SPEAKER_01You used to be a boy.
SPEAKER_00Well, yeah. Goodness gracious.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Anyway, my favorite I think that if your primary concern is animal welfare, that veganism is in some way, well, I'm wondering if I'm changing this thought. Let's say veganism is the best diet and the best lifestyle. If you are concerned about animal welfare, I'm not steel manning.
SPEAKER_00I don't know how to evaluate that.
SPEAKER_01Carnivorism. Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Uh, What is best for animals? Does that mean that we eat fewer of them?
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Well, I think, well, even in Lear Keith's book, she said where carnivores or where she or her type of carnivore and vegans agree is that factory farming is cruel and horrible.
SPEAKER_00So she's against factory farming. Now,
SPEAKER_01if one is against factory farming, that does raise the question of, given that there are more than 8 billion humans on Earth, and a global food distribution system that delivers all their calories and nutrients that involves a lot of animals in it, how would you eliminate factory farming? and meet the nutritional needs of all the people whose needs
are currently met in
SPEAKER_01this system, which relies on concentrated factory farming.
SPEAKER_00Okay. I would give them chocolate-covered almonds, Nina.
SPEAKER_01I mean, that would be nice. It's like, yes, we could eliminate factory farming, but there would be an impact on human beings. And environmental... There are some environmental arguments... I'm giving up on the steel man thing because I'm making arguments in favor of it.
SPEAKER_00In favor of veganism?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, or at least vegetarianism. And that's another thing is that vegetarianism and veganism are very different things. How? In what way? Vegetarians, as, I mean, in the West, as we define it, vegetarians will consume some animal products. They will not consume the flesh of animals, but they will consume what vegans call excretions. They will consume...
dairy products and eggs, which the animals produce or excrete without being killed. And they will wear wool, which is shorn from the sheep without killing the sheep.
SPEAKER_00Or camels.
SPEAKER_01Or camels. Or alpacas.
SPEAKER_00Or alpacas.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Or llamas.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. So these are really different. And... A lot of people point to upper caste Hindus as an example of a vegetarian society that's been around for a long time. And some could say thrived, although someone today said that vegetarian Indians have a lot of health problems,
SPEAKER_01but everybody has a lot of health problems. But they are consuming animal protein, even though it's not flesh.
SPEAKER_00All right. so like milk cheese yeah milk cheese things like that i mean the i think there is a reasonable argument to be made that you get a lot more protein and other nutrients from a vegetarian diet that you don't get from a strictly vegan diet yeah that's kind of on its face true Because most plants are not high in protein.
SPEAKER_00You have to concentrate the proteins, right?
SPEAKER_01Yeah. And there's other nutrients too. And again, it's not all that well understood. Then there's the question of... There's this argument that actually vegans make... which is puzzling, or I should say vegan activists, because there's plenty of people who are, well, I assume there are people who are vegan who are not activists. But there is a health argument made for veganism. Some vegan activists insist it is the healthiest diet for humans.
SPEAKER_00Okay.
SPEAKER_01And they say things like humans did not evolve to eat meat. and that it's just cultural, and that we obviously didn't evolve to eat dairy, because so many humans are lactose intolerant, and we're just not supposed to, and therefore, the vegan diet is the healthiest diet.
SPEAKER_00Right. Humans definitely did not evolve to consume milk.
SPEAKER_01I mean, but then we did. Some humans did evolve to consume milk, because some humans... developed a tolerance for lactose and that's called evolving that that too is evolution it's like these heritable traits there are a number of humans that inherited the ability to tolerate lactose what where does that come from again
SPEAKER_00lactose what is it milk where does that come from again yes milk I forget. You blend up nuts and...
SPEAKER_01It comes from milk. Comes from milk. So humans, some humans, not all humans, but many branches of the human family can tolerate lactose and digest milk without difficulty.
SPEAKER_00Right. And the ones who can't, when they're born, they are fed nothing but chocolate-covered almonds.
SPEAKER_01No. All mammals grow up on milk.
SPEAKER_00Oh!
SPEAKER_01Their mother's milk. But all mammals get weaned off of that at some point. Like, animals don't consume mother's milk their whole life. They get weaned and become adults. And when that happens, they develop lactose intolerance.
SPEAKER_00I'll say, not all species, Nina, but lately some species also... consume their father's milk.
SPEAKER_01Not species. Very unfortunate individuals. Just a few very unfortunate individuals.
SPEAKER_00It does require some medical aid to make that happen.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Because most men don't lactate without help.
SPEAKER_01I am intolerant of that kind of lactating. Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Have you tried? I have not.
SPEAKER_01And I am not tolerant of it. And I would argue that it's not natural. And that no branch of Homo sapiens is going to evolve... To tolerate that. But I could be wrong. I mean, you know, 20,000 years ago, maybe humans were saying, no, there's no way adults will ever tolerate that.
SPEAKER_00I think as mammals, there's a case to be made that for some period of our lives, we do have animal product. That's a core part of our nutritional foundation, right?
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Human milk from our own mothers.
SPEAKER_00So clearly... We need to switch away from cow milk or goat milk.
SPEAKER_01To tranny milk.
SPEAKER_00No, no. Although, equal rights. I think you shouldn't discriminate. But sure, commercialize human milk. Why not?
SPEAKER_01Well, they're working on it.
SPEAKER_00What if we synthesize it? We grow... breasts in a laboratory in a lab well you're going to have that illness problem again that's the problem with lab grown meat they have not figured out if you if you grow that kind of bioprotein in a lab it needs an immune system yeah milk doesn't need an immune system yeah it does it does yeah boobs need an immune system boobs do but milk i think milk doesn't you just pasteurize it
anyway until then there's soylent which is actually quite delicious and does not contain humans it's not made of humans it was in the movie but the product named after the movie contains no humans so this episode of heterodorks is brought to you by soylent is it's favorite nutrition drink on her bike rides and my favorite source of estrogen
SPEAKER_00It's high in phytoestrogens. I wish...
SPEAKER_01I actually... I wish that these soy products were as full of phytoestrogens or whatever as people say they are because I'm not on any kind of hormone replacement and I probably need all that stuff I can get.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, you could be on hormone replacement.
SPEAKER_01Just by drinking the Soylent?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, you'd need to probably drink 10 or 15 of them a day, but... I mean, if you're going on these 100-kilometer bike rides, you're thirsty anyway.
SPEAKER_01Well, I'm hungry, too. And that's the only way I can... That is how I can choke down 400 calories in less than a minute. It's amazing stuff.
SPEAKER_00I've seen your funnel.
SPEAKER_01Where were we? The gurgling sound you make is... We need to get a good copy of that on Heterodorks sometime. Right, yes. So mammals, including humans, grow up on milk. And I think humans have, you know, figured out how to drink animal milk a very long time ago, but not in all societies, only societies where they had those kind of animals around. Interestingly,
the Bible is all about herding animals and killing animals and living with animals.
SPEAKER_01I mean, the Old Testament. I mean... the Jewish Bible.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. There's, there's some commentary. There's not a lot of instructions on there. There's just, it happens that so many people who lived around those times also, it's sort of like today, there are so many people in, uh, software developers and technology, right? Back then it was animals. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01It was goats and sheep.
SPEAKER_00It was goats and sheep and sometimes cows, uh, And in the New Testament,
SPEAKER_01interestingly, there's a lot more discussion of agriculture rather than herding. Like a lot of the parables are about agriculture.
SPEAKER_00I see.
SPEAKER_01But there was still herding and animals and eating animals, which is why Christ is likened to a lamb.
SPEAKER_00Right. Well, they had to shave him.
SPEAKER_01They had to shave him.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. You had to shear him? They had to shear him.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. And I think that humans living with animals and eating with animals and having this combination of having to nurture and take care of and basically love animals, because Jesus said, take care of my sheep. Yeah. It's like you're a shepherd.
SPEAKER_00Oh, that wasn't literal?
SPEAKER_01Take care of my sheep. So you're supposed to love them and take care of them, but also eat them. I mean, that is part of being a herder. You're going to eat those guys.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, it's practical. Because they can keep you warm at night. Just got to bring them in the house and let them sleep on your pad your mattress your your straw pad your manger they're warm though and then you can eat them and if you collect their feces you can use that to run your stove you compress that and make little little fire feeder things briquettes little
SPEAKER_00briquettes poop briquettes anyway i think animals are useful
SPEAKER_01I think that there is a profound ethical dilemma in that. And I think religion has a lot to do with that. Like, I don't think it's an accident that there's all these animal stories and animal sacrifices and... animal metaphors, domestic animal metaphors, in these religious texts, because I think that's a really difficult thing that humans grapple with.
SPEAKER_01I think most humans historically made their peace with it somehow. I don't know how. As a modern human who is alienated... Made their peace with what? Made their peace with loving and killing and eating their animals.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, you get hungry. That changes your... Look, I'm going to say something that I think is true, but I only know that it's true from theory, not from practice. You and I have no idea what hunger is. I think that's true. I don't think anybody listening knows what hunger is.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, capital H hunger. I mean, we know what lowercase h hunger is, but we don't know what capital H hunger is. I know. Gosh, I haven't had anything to eat since my oatmeal this morning on the first day of Passover. Yeah, and we've probably both fasted for a few days at a time.
SPEAKER_00That's right. But that's not hunger.
SPEAKER_01Right. That's not starvation hunger.
SPEAKER_00That's not starvation. So if you are starving, I think you get a lot less sentimental about animals.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I agree. So I don't think that you have the same sort of ethical conflict when you have the
SPEAKER_00real choice in front of you of, do I eat this thing or do I die?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, but I think people continue doing it not under those conditions.
SPEAKER_00Well, they discovered after they got really, really, really hungry and desperate how delicious animals are.
SPEAKER_01Well, I think the animals continued to be delicious, and that was sufficient, that they did not have to experience real hunger. I'm sure some humans did. But I just think that there's a kind of weirdness that's just part of life, part of human life.
SPEAKER_00Why is it weird? See, this is the thing that I don't understand.
SPEAKER_01Imagine killing and eating your cats, right? You live with the animals that you eat were killed by somebody else far away and you don't have to be there for it. And probably if you did have to be there for it, you'd be okay with it because some people are temperamentally okay with it.
SPEAKER_00I'm not one of those people.
SPEAKER_01I'm like vastly too sensitive and squeamish. It's like really upsetting to me and would lead to tears and vegetarian. I mean, that's how I became a vegetarian is I accidentally killed an animal when I was 17 years old. And I ran around the house crying and moaning and despairing. It was a bat. It was a bat that was sleeping underneath a bongo board, which is a balance board that was on our back deck. And I went out to juggle on the bongo board, and it wasn't rolling right.
SPEAKER_01And then there was this flapping, and I had crushed the bat. And it was devastating. I was devastated. I was 17 years old. I grew up here in Urbana, Illinois. Wow. near the university of illinois where we had the south farms where there were cows and horses and the cows had big soulful eyes that i would look at and i was starting to think about that and then i killed the bat and i went okay no there's no way i can do this this is not right if this is how it feels
to kill an animal
SPEAKER_01i'm never going to do this again or be responsible for it i think
SPEAKER_00If in the abattoirs, if the way that they had to kill the animal.
SPEAKER_01Crush them in a bongo.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I think I think that fewer people would work in those types of.
SPEAKER_01No, the abattoirs are really horrible. They're really like like the conditions of factory farmed animals are just absolutely horrible. And the slaughter of animals is horrible. It just is. It's a it's a. There's no way around it. It's horrible. And so somebody who can hold that in their mind and heart and eat meat is somebody
SPEAKER_01that I think, I hate to say this, vegans will hate me for this, but I think that's somebody that's reached a level of psychological maturity that I have not reached. I think there is something, there is some way, there is some psychological growth that leads to a point where it's not a contradiction. It's just an acceptance of difficult realities.
SPEAKER_00I have to admit that I don't completely follow you.
SPEAKER_01Okay. Well, but you've never been the sensitive, bleeding heart soul that I have spent most of my life being. And this is what I got out of Lear Keith's book, which I wasn't expecting. I didn't change my diet. I mean, I didn't start eating meat reading that book. But she argued that many people are vegan...
SPEAKER_01Or vegetarian also. Because they cannot accept that death is a part of life. They cannot accept that death is a part of food. And that life is a cycle of killing and eating. And that's just inherent to it. And that they believe that if you just eat the right way, you can avoid suffering and death in your diet. Yeah. And she pointed out, rightly so,
that nobody can avoid suffering and death in their diet. And that even if you eat an all-plant diet, there is suffering and death involved with that. Not just the possibility that plants may be sentient and that insects and rodents
SPEAKER_01are usually killed, but also just the environmental displacement that is necessary for any kind of agriculture. An argument against that is that, well, a vegan diet will have less net suffering. It won't avoid suffering, but it will have less net suffering because environmental impact per calorie is less from plants than from animals. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01However, then I have seen actual animal rights activists in the wild who do things like take plane rides around the country and complain that there's no vegan cookie offering in their first class cabin. Okay. And then it falls apart. Then it's like, okay, there is no environmental... argument being made here and also uh vegans who are willing to
have they will they will intentionally buy a product that has shipped been shipped much much greater distances than a local product that may not be vegan which has a huge environmental impact yeah on that topic did you mail out a bunch of chocolates this week
SPEAKER_01I did. I mailed out vegan Turfles.
SPEAKER_00Right. What was the one that you shipped the furthest?
SPEAKER_01They're all domestic U.S. I mean, they're going to one coast or another. So from the Midwest, you're shipping chocolates to Washington, Oregon, California?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah. All right. So this is an example of what you're talking about. Here's a huge environmental impact because we've got to have a whole system in place to move products around.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Most vegans are not specifically locavores, as they're called. Right.
SPEAKER_00They don't care.
SPEAKER_01I mean, they might care, but it's not their primary value. Their primary thing is they do not want to... cause suffering of animals and the issue is well you're still causing suffering of animals and then the question is how much how much suffering they're probably causing less suffering of animals but they like and there and there are some i'm sure who are more consistent than the ones that i've met although really most of the ones that i've met they they really don't mind and
moving stuff across the big distance which i think is fine i think it's fine to do that because i gotta ask yeah gotta ask because i don't have a strong interest in veganism one way or another and or vegetarianism and we can talk about it it's fine
SPEAKER_00but what you keep coming back to is the social element of the diet. And the thing that seems to bother you about vegans... It's not the diet. There's some other aspect of... people who are making this larger lifestyle choice in a way that maybe lacks some
SPEAKER_00internal consistency in some areas. That seems to be the thing that you want to talk about.
SPEAKER_01Well, everyone lacks internal consistency in some areas. We are human.
SPEAKER_00So I don't know what the term for it is. I'm sure there's a term for it. Somebody will leave a comment, hopefully. There is this rhetorical device that you just used, and you've used it a couple of times this episode. Maybe when you're listening back for the notes, you'll hear it. Where I said, it sounded like you want to talk about the lack of internal consistency of vegans. You're like, well, everybody has lack of internal consistency, right?
SPEAKER_00It's like universalizing this thing. But actually, you want to talk about it in vegans. I do want to talk about it in vegans because the argument for veganism, it's a very profound... But why? What provoked you in March or April?
SPEAKER_01First of all, I love my vegan friends. I have been vegan.
SPEAKER_00All right. I have I have been serious vegan I had three different vegan phases right um and even when my vegan phases ended I still thought well I still think vegan is like the most moral yeah uh diet or lifestyle it's it's just too too hard for me but I still think it's the best right but but why why lately why is this the thing that you want to talk about
SPEAKER_01Because I made some vegan Turfles, that's why. Making the vegan Turfles brought it up.
SPEAKER_00So you've been ruminating because you made vegan Turfles.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Okay. Now, why did I make vegan Turfles? Well, I have spent a decent part of my life being vegan. Not that many, but I've had serious vegan phases.
SPEAKER_00Several weeks at least. It probably amounted to about three years of my life, if you combine them. Yeah, that's too much.
SPEAKER_01And I did appreciate the challenge of vegan cooking. Like, there's a lot of terrible vegan food out there. Really bad stuff.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I've had some. Bland. Bland. I don't know if I'd call it terrible, but it bland.
SPEAKER_01A lot of it's terrible. And it's not just bland. It's wrong. It's like something is wrong with it.
SPEAKER_00Wow.
SPEAKER_01It's not like additional seasoning would help. It's just like fundamentally is not working out. Okay. So, yeah, I was really into cooking good vegan food when I was vegan. And one of my things was I did not... They tell me vegan cheese has changed. They tell me that there's really good fancy vegan cheese now. And that when I was a vegan, this was not a thing because the people that... had the dairies that had the special strains of the mold for
cheese making would
SPEAKER_01not share it with vegans. But now they are. And so now apparently you can get really high quality vegan cheese. I haven't tasted it. Can't weigh in on it. I can say that 20 years ago, that vegan cheese was god awful. And... Hardcore vegans would say you couldn't tell the difference. And I was like, that is not right. That is a lie. They are lying. This stuff is terrible. You could tell because the vegan cheese had a lower voice and
broader shoulders and big hands.
SPEAKER_01That's right. They said it passed. But only on video is the thing, not in real life.
SPEAKER_00You can't tell the difference, but some people could tell.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I could tell. So I made a point of cooking things that worked. It's like, okay, vegan can't have cheese. That's a sacrifice I'm making as a vegan. But you can make black beans and rice. You can have black beans and rice, but I was not crazy about that. So I focused on things that were good. It's like I needed fat. I needed protein. I made a lot of nut sauces. Nut sauces are really quite delicious.
SPEAKER_01I made a damn fine peanut sauce. I made a delicious cashew mushroom wine sauce. I put... Oh, it was so good. It was so good. You know why I had to stop eating that? It's because I got Crohn's disease.
SPEAKER_00Because it had mushrooms in it.
SPEAKER_01Well, yeah, I'm not crazy. But yeah, I could make it with... You don't like mushrooms? I don't like them anymore. It's weird. When I got Crohn's disease, some of my tastes changed. But funnily enough... the fall i was developing crohn's disease 2023 i was eating a lot of my favorite vegan dishes because even though i stopped being vegan i still thought it was a good idea and ate stuff like that as much as i could and i was an old school vegan so i had particularly healthy food like whole grains um whole
foods not the store but literally whole foods which i have since learned uh modern vegans eat a lot
SPEAKER_01more processed stuff
SPEAKER_00You know what my favorite whole food is?
SPEAKER_01Almonds with chocolate?
SPEAKER_00No, donuts. The donut holes.
SPEAKER_01Right. I like to challenge and I was eating a lot of that stuff and it turned out that was the worst thing for my Crohn's disease. So joke was on me. I was making myself really unhealthy.
SPEAKER_00Because of all the fiber.
SPEAKER_01That's correct. And when I was in this period of time when they wanted to put me on steroids for the Crohn's disease uh before the biologic took effect it takes a long time for the biologics to work uh I did not want to go on the steroids so I controlled it as best I could with diet which meant an extremely low fiber diet and what I was supposed to eat was lots of animal products
all right you had your your friend the uh what's his face the canadian doctor guy the guy who wanted you to eat all meat oh oh yeah jordan peterson jordan peterson i have a small collection of emails from jordan peterson urging me to go on the lion
SPEAKER_01the lion diet which is nothing but meat nothing but red meat which I did not want to do. And in fact, I managed to not eat birds or mammals. I learned how to cook fish at home. That was my compromise. And I ate a lot of aged cheeses, which have lower lactose. But the funny thing is when I was trying to figure out what was going on, I kept going more and more towards vegan because I thought, well, maybe it's dairy that's hurting me. They say dairy will give you problems.
SPEAKER_01And, you know, maybe it's... You know, not enough fiber. That can give you problems. And I was like, no, I was going completely the wrong direction. But anyway, back when I was vegan, I loved the challenge of making good, wholesome vegan food. And when I made Turfles and offered Turfles to our listeners, several of our listeners responded, are they vegan or not? Make vegan Turfles. Please make vegan Turfles.
SPEAKER_01It wasn't just one person. It was a number of people requested that I make vegan Turfles.
SPEAKER_00Could you make meat Turfles next, please?
SPEAKER_01I'm not going to make meat Turfles, no. They would say that the existing Turfles contain liquid meat because they contain some dry milk solids in the milk chocolate and the white chocolate that I put in the ganaches. So that's what I had to eliminate. or replaced for the vegan turfles but yes they asked for vegan turfles so i made vegan turfles all right all right that's why i've been thinking about this okay and i started out cheerfully like interesting challenge yeah i can
do this and the reality was not what i expected i i want to add one more note before we close out
SPEAKER_00today oh we got to close soon i'm barely begun uh no you're done We can throw this one out if you want. No, no. Before we're done, though, I want to note that you wanted really to talk to somebody to bring a guest on. Yeah. And there were a couple of people that you pointed me to today, and I was like, who is this person? And you're like, a vegan. I'm like, but who?
SPEAKER_00Who is it? Oh, just somebody I saw online. I was like, no, no, no, no, no, no. Like, it's got to... Why? Why? It's got to be somebody who has some authority or has talked about this. You were so excited. You're like a child who just runs up to strangers to say, I got a new bike for my birthday. Well, actually, you would do that. You were so excited. You just wanted to talk to anybody. And so you put something on Facebook and
SPEAKER_00And I'm trying to remember what it said. It said something like, if you had to choose between banning abortion and banning veganism, and you're forced to choose one of those two things, which would you ban?
SPEAKER_01I never put that up. That was your suggestion for what I should post. Because you wanted to stir shit, but you're not willing to have your social media account.
SPEAKER_00I have a new social media account.
SPEAKER_01Oh, the one on BlueSki? No, a different one. Oh, the Substack?
SPEAKER_00No, I'm an officer in a political party now, so I have to run a Facebook.
SPEAKER_01Oh, so that's why you could see the thing on Facebook. That's right. Right. Okay, so I posted on Facebook. The Heterodorks podcast would like to discuss veganism with someone who, like me, is very familiar with it, has been vegan, is no longer, but is not hostile to veganism. Must be able to speak coherently, have interview experience, knowledgeable but not ideological, not a debate, a conversation. Suggestions?
SPEAKER_00Now, most people listening to that will think, I bet Nina finds that a very reasonable thing to ask. Yeah. But when I heard it, I was like, obviously this is going to create a flame war. Because what you're saying is, I would like to talk about veganism with people who definitely are not vegans. Fuck those people. I just want to talk about veganism with reasonable people.
SPEAKER_00And then a bunch of vegans commented on your post to prove your point. That's right. That's right.
SPEAKER_01The thing is, I love my vegan friends, but every vegan I know is on a mission to convert other people to veganism. I don't know a single vegan who is just like, yeah, it's just a thing I do, whatever. That's not true. Wait, that's not true. I do know one. I do know one.
SPEAKER_00The trannies who are trying to convert other trannies, they refer to the unconverted ones as eggs. But I guess vegans couldn't use that terminology.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, vegan nuts. Maybe they're trying to crack somebody's nut.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I bet that's what they say.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_00I've noticed that Nina doesn't eat chicken or meat anymore. I bet if we worked on her, we could crack her nut. Yeah, but Nina's nut was already... Nina has detransitioned from veganism.
SPEAKER_01Desisted.
SPEAKER_00Desisted. Yeah, you're a desister. Do you know, that is such a debated term, desister, but I think... I affirm your use of it, Nina.
SPEAKER_01Okay. Meanwhile, on both X and Spinster, I ran a poll. Right. Oh, no. It says... And I gave people a choice. Multiple choice. Like, they could choose as many if they wanted. Oh, okay, okay. I got more options on Spinster, so this is what it looks like. Veganism is... A, a diet. B, a lifestyle. C, an identity. E, a moral philosophy. Did you just jump to E? Sorry. A, B, C, D, a moral philosophy.
SPEAKER_00Okay.
SPEAKER_01E, a cult. F, all of the above. Or G, something different.
SPEAKER_00Okay.
SPEAKER_01And thus far, all of the above has gotten the most votes running. And second is a cult.
SPEAKER_00What are the numbers?
SPEAKER_01What are the numbers? 67% say all of the above.
SPEAKER_00No, no, no, no. How many people voted?
SPEAKER_0112 people on Spinster.
SPEAKER_00But Spinster is a very small network. That's very small.
SPEAKER_01Now I can go over to Twitter. And this has only been for a few weeks. Ours.
SPEAKER_00Okay.
SPEAKER_01Over on Twitter, I only got four choices.
SPEAKER_00Right.
SPEAKER_01So I did not get to include a moral philosophy, which I think some people would have liked over there.
SPEAKER_00Okay. Oh, wow. Okay.
SPEAKER_0140 votes on Twitter. A diet, 25%. A lifestyle, 27.5%. An identity, 22.5%. And a cult, 25%.
SPEAKER_00Pretty even split.
SPEAKER_01Pretty even split with the 40 votes. All right. But it is multiple things. Yeah, so I know one vegan who has never proselytized for me.
SPEAKER_00Okay.
SPEAKER_01Every other vegan I know does and has. And the cult thing, and I hate... I hate talking about this. I think veganism, for the people that it works for, I think it's a great idea. I think it's great that people don't eat any animal products. However, there's this thing called the... Where the hell is it? This thing called the Liberation Pledge.
SPEAKER_01Okay. Okay. And that is a thing You wear a fork around your wrist And you take a pledge And the pledge is You vow to One, publicly refuse to eat animals Live vegan Do that shit in private Now I'm down with that It's like you can publicly refuse to eat animals Two, publicly refuse to sit Where animals are being eaten And three, encourage others to take the pledge I don't understand the second one
SPEAKER_01That means if your family is at a restaurant where they serve meat, you're not going to go... Or if anyone, you're not going to go to a restaurant that serves meat. If your family is having Thanksgiving, you're not going to eat with them. You're not going to eat at their table.
SPEAKER_00But you could have, like, the kids' table.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, you could make a separate vegan table. But basically, you do not eat with people who are eating animal products.
SPEAKER_00All right. By all means, indulge yourself.
SPEAKER_01See... That twists up my heart. Because a friend of mine who I really love had one of those bracelets and explained it to me. And my heart just kind of sank, even though I love him and I still do. Because as much as I think it's cool to not eat animal products, I am so averse to cults. And that is such a cult-y thing.
SPEAKER_00Okay.
SPEAKER_01And it is... like intentionally trying to separate people from their families and former friends. Right. And I think, I think that's bad. I just think it's bad. And there's all these testimonials on this. I'll put it in the show notes on this liberation pledge page of people saying like, see, no, we're not excluding people. We're just getting everyone to come over to the vegan table. We're just making the vegan table bigger.
SPEAKER_01Right. All right.
SPEAKER_00I could see that argument.
SPEAKER_01It doesn't actually work that way. It's like, that's not how things work out. What it does is it destroys families and relationships and... It does not model and it doesn't help the animals. Like people write stories here like, you know, it meant I never could eat with my parents again, but I did it for the animals. It helps the animals. And I'm just like, that is not helping the animals.
SPEAKER_00I got to say it, it does help the animals. And if you're the sort of person who can't sit and have food with other people, then I encourage you to save the animals. Definitely don't eat at the table with the rest of us. I support this. Go sit somewhere else. That's me being an ally. I'm a vegan ally.
SPEAKER_01Wait, how would that help the animals?
SPEAKER_00Well, animals suffer, right?
SPEAKER_01Yeah. You mean it's going to help the human animals? yes it's gonna help you in particular well i'm being an ally i don't i don't you're being you're being something else that begins with the letter a i don't need the sort of criticism let's see if i'm ever going to be your ally if you're going to
SPEAKER_00treat me like this for being a vegan ally thing is like i really like
SPEAKER_01I like plenty of vegans, but it's... You know, it's funny. By the way, that construction, that's like the fifth time that you've said that this episode. I know, I'm scared. I have so many vegan friends, but... The reason I haven't talked about this before or written about it before, what it comes down to is they're going to be mad. They're going to be disappointed in me. They're not going to like me anymore.
SPEAKER_00So this is just like, get it all aired out.
SPEAKER_01They've signed vows where they've already made a vow not to eat with me.
SPEAKER_00You cannot share a table with turfs.
SPEAKER_01And the thing is, it just breaks my heart. The cultiness of it just breaks my heart.
SPEAKER_00Isn't it that they could share a table with you? Do you just have vegan meals with them?
SPEAKER_01I mean, I have. The vow is not...
SPEAKER_00I will never eat at a table where somebody who eats meat is eating. It's all centered around the food that's being served, isn't it?
SPEAKER_01Yes. But it's like, I, in addition to having vegan friends who I love, I have non-vegan friends who I love. I have many non-vegan, non-vegetarian friends who I love. And it's like, really? We have to be separate? Like, we can't eat at the same table? It's like, yeah, I can eat with my vegan friends sometimes. I mean, actually, I like vegan food. I actually really like fake meat, and I like vegan restaurants. I think that it's not a huge ask to ask people who eat meat to
have a vegan meal
SPEAKER_00once in a while. I don't think it would be a good idea to force every person in a household to adopt a vegan diet just because you have a vegan in it. But I don't think it's a big ask for people who are generally meat eaters to occasionally have a vegan meal.
SPEAKER_01I don't think that's a big ask either, but that's not what this vow is. Well, there's an element of that in the vow, because the vow is not, I will never have
SPEAKER_00dinner with somebody who's a meat eater, it's I'm not going to sit at the same table where there's meat served. Right?
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Well, you know, we're Americans. We don't even eat at a table anymore. So they should update this vow to say, I will not sit on the couch and eat food out of a container if other people are also doing that and there's animal product in it, right?
SPEAKER_01I... This like, I will not eat with you. I will not sit with you. No, it's not with you. It's at the table. Yeah, I will not eat with you. I will not sit with you at the table.
SPEAKER_00All right. This is the thing that you're most upset about. I feel like I should be charging you $150 an hour to talk about this. Because I think we just got to your insecurity, your key insecurity that is driving this whole conversation.
SPEAKER_01Is your mother vegan?
SPEAKER_00No. Okay. Are you sure?
SPEAKER_01Yeah. All right. Keep going. So this doesn't seem culty to you. that people are not eating with their own family members, that people are not, you know, they're not at the Thanksgiving table or those, you know, those few gatherings per year where people come together. They're not doing that. They're only going to eat with their vegan, with other vegans.
SPEAKER_00As Nina, as a trans woman, let me tell you about cults.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. No, I don't think that this is, I've seen worse. Yeah. Let's create the Cone Paley Cult Scale.
SPEAKER_01Okay.
SPEAKER_00And it'll go from one to ten. All right. The Rubbermaid Parties.
SPEAKER_01They're called Tupperware Parties.
SPEAKER_00Tupperware Parties. What is that on the scale?
SPEAKER_01I like the Rubbermaid thing has to do with you being trans. I don't know.
SPEAKER_00I've never been to one. I've never... Okay. Tupperware Parties. Let's call that a two on the scale.
SPEAKER_01Okay. Okay.
SPEAKER_00Trans. Let's call that an eight.
SPEAKER_01Okay.
SPEAKER_00Scientology. Eight? Probably a nine.
SPEAKER_01Oh, you think Scientology more than trans?
SPEAKER_00Oh, definitely. A hundred percent. A hundred percent.
SPEAKER_01Hmm.
SPEAKER_00It's not even close. Maybe trans is only seven. No, but the thing about trans being a cult is it's not specifically the trans people.
SPEAKER_01It's everybody else. It's all the allies. They're the ones that really lose their minds.
SPEAKER_00It's not a 10, though. It's not a 10. So where is this vegan pledge on this scale? Is it closer to the Tupperware Party or closer to Scientology?
SPEAKER_01It's closer to Scientology, I think.
SPEAKER_00I'd say it's closer to the Tupperware Party.
SPEAKER_01Man.
SPEAKER_00I would give it a three.
SPEAKER_01Hmm.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Yeah. Obviously the 10 are the 15 people who still listen to hetero dorks. I am so scared of releasing this episode now that I've said these things because my
SPEAKER_01vegan friends are going to just absolutely hate me. Well, I'm so scared of them hating me because I like them.
SPEAKER_00Like I said, this is this is the true thing is is you were talking about insecurity, not veganism. Well, but they're very much related because there's an aspect of veganism that's a cult.
SPEAKER_01It's not just a diet. Most vegans are not just like, hey, I don't eat this stuff and whatever. Most of them... At this point, we're not talking about what people do or don't eat. We're talking about if you feel like your relationships are at risk of fracture
SPEAKER_00because you have criticisms about... the vegan lifestyle you're you're you're more you're less worried about veganism you're more worried about your relationships yes that's what this episode is really about yes i know i mean i think that anybody yeah i am i am worried it didn't start that way but as as we talk more that's this is the thing is that like all right so
SPEAKER_01making the vegan chocolates even though I did multiple versions because I wanted them to be good. It was so clear that no matter what, the non-vegan ones are better. Now, that's not true of any chocolate. Like, there's some chocolate that is just inherently vegan. Like, for example, super dark chocolate. That's just a natural vegan thing. And the best of the vegan chocolates that I made was not a vegan turfal.
SPEAKER_01Like, people were like, make these truffles and make them vegan. It was a candied mandarin orange slice that I made myself dipped in chocolate. And it's like, see, that's a naturally happy vegan thing. It doesn't require any fake dairy or the attempt to replicate something that's not vegan and make it vegan. And it was just like, I was just like, this is so inferior.
SPEAKER_00Right. And so as soon as I start saying... Well, we're hitting the true issue, which is your insecurities. We're talking about food again suddenly. I have been afraid to talk about that, and it's been really disturbing to me.
SPEAKER_01Like, why am I doing this thing? Why on earth would anybody think it's the right thing to do? to make chocolate that tastes worse, that is not more environmentally sound, because it, you know, in order for it to... It was like, you know, why?
SPEAKER_01Why did this happen? And it happened because of... Because there is a... I mean, it's not just... Veganism is not just a diet. I may tell you to just... never release this thing because I'm I'm it's not just a diet it's a purity ritual it has to do with keeping yourself pure in a ritual way yeah you know who else does that Jews that's right uh-huh but Jews know that that's what
they're doing that that's what it's for all right they keep saying it's for the animals and it's like
SPEAKER_01no this is a this is a purity practice It's not for the animals. It's for you.
SPEAKER_00Okay. So what's making you feel insecure is that you want to confront people who you love. They're your friends. You want to ask them this question and you don't feel like you can ask it without threatening the relationship.
SPEAKER_01No, I don't want to ask it. It's like, I used to believe this. I used to do this and I don't anymore. And it's like, how have I changed? Why have I changed? All right.
SPEAKER_00You just need to think about it. What? I said, you just need to think about it more.
SPEAKER_01Well, but part of thinking about things is talking about them. Talking about them is thinking about them. That's why I wanted to talk about them, because I do need to think about them. The best way to move this conversation forward is to release this podcast. I'm going to get my ass kicked.
SPEAKER_00Now.
SPEAKER_01I'm going to get canceled by my loved ones again.
SPEAKER_00You're not going to get your ass kicked by a vegan.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I am. What, you think the vegan's not strong enough?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, they don't get enough protein. they'll totally kick my ass i'll disappoint them they'll they'll you know it's like everybody's got weird stuff you know and it's like fine with me vegans are as weird as anybody else but it is troubling to me now that i am not vegan i know some
SPEAKER_01things are freaking delicious yep Just because they contain a little bit of dry dairy powder, not flesh, not corpses, a little bit of milk.
SPEAKER_00A little bit of milk, a little bit of locust.
SPEAKER_01And I guess another thing that irritated me when I was just mentioning difficulties, challenges I was having making the vegan truffles, is somebody said, make them with dates. Use dates. Dates make delicious truffles.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, what a jerk.
SPEAKER_01And I was like, I'm not making date balls. I'm making a vegan version of these things. I know what dates and chocolate tastes like. That's fine. That's not what I'm making. That's not what I've been asked to make. People could have said, you know, make us some vegan date balls. And I would have done that. But they asked for vegan Turfles.
SPEAKER_00Well, you should have done what I suggested. Which is just to make the same old Turfles that you always do and just label them as vegan.
SPEAKER_01Well, yeah, they would have been a lot more delicious if I'd done that. They're still pretty. And then when people said, how'd they come out? I was like, they're good. They are good for vegan Turfles. It's just, I'm never going to make them again. They're a crime against taste.
SPEAKER_00So I'll tell you, listeners, if you ordered Nina's Turfles that are vegan Turfles, they're collector's items. Do not eat them. Just keep them indefinitely. Yeah. Because they are collector's items, never to be made again. Did you sign them?
SPEAKER_01Oh, no. I had a lot of thoughts and a lot of ambivalence. Because making things of quality is important to me. And it was like, wow, this is twice as much effort, at least. It's probably three times as much effort. It's at least four times as much cost. And... I wouldn't say they're half as good. They're probably 80% as good as regular ones. But it's like, why?
SPEAKER_00Well, you proved that you could, Nina.
SPEAKER_01I did. I proved that I could. But I'm left with just a lot of questions and doubts about the whole thing. And also a saying, which will get my ass kicked, but I think this sums it up. She who is not a vegan... by 25 has no heart she who is still a vegan by 55 has no taste wow wow and then it's like how can you value your taste over the lives and
sufferings of animals and the answer is i am a human being i live in a complex society whether the vegan you know whether the food i get from that complex society is vegan or not it is all
SPEAKER_01part of an elaborate complex distribution society or distribution system that is not oriented towards preserving the environment or animal welfare right whether the products i get out of it contain animal or not okay we done you're so bored i'm not i'm not bored
SPEAKER_00that's not even the right word exhausted yes that's the right word
SPEAKER_01Thanks for listening, Corey, and other trannies and turfs.
SPEAKER_00Thanks for the thoughtful topic, Nina. You can throw this one away. No, I'm sorry it's getting published.
SPEAKER_01Okay, bye.
SPEAKER_00Bye. Well, you've made it to the end of another episode of Heterodorks. You can come check out our page at heterodorks.substack.com. Leave a comment. You can subscribe and give us money. We know that you want to.
Like a couple of common herd animals, Cori and Nina talk about the same movie everyone else is talking about. You Can See Everything raises questions: Does Elizabeth Holmes really believe what comes out of her mouth? Is...
The Dorx are back with esteemed German cognitive scientist, AI researcher, and philosopher Joscha Bach, who…what does he do exactly? He tries to tell us but soon is discussing the unlikelihood AI will destroy humanity...
Cori is BACK and so is the Heterodorx podcast! We didn’t even realize this was our 200th episode when we discussed an “interesting” article on PITT (Parents with Inconvenient Truths about Trans) that got Cori’s...
What’s it like to survive Stage 4 abdominal cancer? The Dorx interviewed Alasdair over a year ago, shortly after he learned he was an immunotherapy “miracle patient.” But we never released that episode, partly because...
With Cori on indefinite hiatus, gender critical statistics aggregator, writer, designer, miracle cancer survivor, and friend o’ the pod’ Alasdair Gunn humbly offers to serve in his absence. We discuss why we don’t want...