Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Heterodorx

Heterodorx artwork

Episode 201: Joscha Bach Looks on the Bright Side

Oct 23, 20261 hr 25 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

The Dorx are back with esteemed German cognitive scientist, AI researcher, and philosopher Joscha Bach, who…what does he do exactly? He tries to tell us but soon is discussing the unlikelihood AI will destroy humanity (humanity is likelier to destroy itself), “human values”, the paucity of adults, superstitious thinking, lack of consciousness, unreality, mutants, fatherhood, art, craft, God, gods, ethics, Aristotle, innocence, gender, the obvious, sacrifice, and using AI as your life’s CEO. Is the self a fiction? How much art do we really need? Are all Miyazake movies really about Heidi? And so much more! We let Riverside’s own AI edit this episode, and it’s full of artifacts as a result. Consider it meta-commentary on this fascinating human conversation. Links: Joscha Bach’s website: http://bach.ai/ Joscha Bach’s Substack: https://joscha.substack.com/ Joscha Bach on X: https://x.com/Plinz California Institute for Machine Consciousness: https://cimc.ai/ Get full access to Heterodorx Podcast at heterodorx.substack.com/subscribe

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_01Heterodorks, heterodux dorks.

SPEAKER_02Hello, turfs and trannies. You're listening to the Heterodorks Podcast. I am your co-host, Nina Paley, a brilliant artist here is ahead of my time and am with... I am Corey Cohn.

SPEAKER_01I am a person who tells computers to make software for me. I spend a lot of my day explaining to Claude, actually, you're mistaken. And we have a guest with us today. Hello.

SPEAKER_00Thank you for inviting me.

SPEAKER_02Thanks. Now, it is so hard for me to truly understand what it is that you do. So for an introduction, I am going to use the AI-generated description of you that I got from Googling, and you can tell us what Is that correct?

SPEAKER_02I don't think that we would have needed an AI for that,

SPEAKER_00but I understand that we are uploading more and more of our basic cognitive abilities onto these systems, and so maybe that's appropriate.

SPEAKER_02Okay, well, I know Joscha Bach as somebody who posts interesting things on Twitter, and I have listened to you talk about your work on some podcasts, but, you know, I can't, I couldn't really Throw out a question, Nina. Tell you what, what you're, well, the questions I'm, I'm like, I mean, we don't have to talk about AI in general, but.

SPEAKER_01Okay, let's, Nina, while you're thinking, let me ask the question we all want to know. Is, is AI going to destroy humanity? And if so, how?

SPEAKER_00Yeah. Personally, I don't think that AI is going to destroy humanity. I think that humanity is a very interesting, scintillating phenomenon that so far had a pretty good run. And without AI, it's not clear how long this would continue. Find ourselves a very good table at the restaurant at the end of the universe or on the deck of the Titanic. And it's a very good place to be in if you have to spend one lifetime in an organism under evolutionary conditions, right? We have hit the jackpot.

SPEAKER_00And on the other hand, this does not look awfully sustainable. The way in which we live, that we basically disentangled ourselves from the cycles of life and death and the destiny of the cell on planet Earth is not something that harolds well for our future. Our society is one that is no longer organized in cycles like many of the human societies and civilizations in the past where people thought about things repeating themselves in eternal rise and fall of technology and living conditions and orderliness.

SPEAKER_00But instead, we are part of a trip that is going only one way. So we basically have this ratchet where we have written text and technology that prevents us from falling back in the same day as previous civilizations before us. And we realized if we fall back, then we will fall much harder. Basically, the delta between the creature comforts that we have achieved and what is to come if we can no longer maintain a civilization seems to be much more dire.

SPEAKER_00And in this situation, we have started to teach the rocks how to think. And in a way, this was also part of the plan since always there are a lot of people who would see this. For instance, it's at some point said that it should be possible to express all our discourse, all our ideas as numbers, mathematically in a way, and come up with functions that evaluate this discourse. So what he basically did was that he anticipated the LLM. In a certain way, right? My philosophy teachers thought that he was crazy and this,

SPEAKER_00how could he have this idea that he can express all the mental representations, all the ideas, thoughts, arguments that people have as numbers and find functions that somehow evaluate the discourse. But it's exactly what we did. It's really interesting that this idea has been with us for such a long time. It's changing our society, of course. Every technology that we are building happens at a faster cadence, it's changing things more rapidly, and it's dizzying. That doesn't mean that we automatically lose control and agency to these things,

SPEAKER_00but it's also something that's unprecedented. Simply don't have anything in history to go back to and see how this played out in the past. Too many things changing all at once as to have reliable futurism

SPEAKER_00to actually make very good predictions of what society is going to look like in 50, 100, 500, a thousand years from now. A question?

SPEAKER_02Before, well, first of all, did you predict that we would have AI of this nature in your lifetime? Yes. How old were you when you predicted it?

SPEAKER_00I think nine or ten. But I mean, I grew up in a world where this was already apparent. Computers already were invented. And electronic brains as a concept were invented. And a lot of people had seen this before our generation, like John von Neumann, Turing, Minsky, Lem. A lot of people that are part of our cultural literary idea universe could actually see that the advent of computers meant that we would have thinking machines. And then it's a matter of thinking how complex are our own minds and how complex are

SPEAKER_00the machines that we're building. And I thought that there is a chance that it doesn't quite happen in our lifetime. But I thought also if everything goes as expected, we should see artificial intelligence at the human level and beyond before we die. So I'm not surprised.

SPEAKER_02You sound in some ways pessimistic the way that I am in terms of the way human beings treat each other and the sort of path we have been on towards calamity. I hear the doomers talking about human values, that the danger of AI is that it won't have human values and we need human values to survive. And I think when I read that or hear that, Well, look what human values has brought us. I mean, wouldn't it be better if we had something that didn't have these human values

SPEAKER_02because human values include tribalism and warfare and struggling over rivalrous goods and short-term thinking and things like that?

SPEAKER_00These are not human values. These are just the opinions of bad people. And if you have better human values, you will surely overcome the opinions of the bad people this time around. Isn't that the case? I think that's being sarcastic, yes. It's a shortcut to talk about ethics. And because values are seen as something that's terminal, that's given and so on, that is imparted onto you by wise elders who have figured things out over the generations and stuff got revealed to these elders in the discourse

SPEAKER_00that ordinary mortals like you and me don't really understand. And maybe in a way that's true. It's just the world has changed much faster than the models of these elders could track. And so we find ourselves in a world where I don't see many adults left. And suddenly this question of what we actually mean by the values becomes much more pertinent. And we have to be able to derive what these values are. We have to go back to first principles and understand our ethics, what we actually mean by them. And a lot of the thinking that If we go more back to what our condition is in

SPEAKER_00an evolutionary way, You were...

SPEAKER_02I don't want to say canceled. You were sort of quasi canceled or you've sort of had a mini cancellation, right? Or not a cancellation, but you had a.

SPEAKER_00Well, it was quite substantial. I think it was quite what? It was pretty tough.

SPEAKER_02Yeah.

SPEAKER_00I'm far from being over. It was quite traumatizing. I think if I would not have responsibility for my family and my children and my loved ones and the projects would have taken responsibility, I would surely have checked out. I don't enjoy this planet that much. But you know in some sense what this is like to be cancelled. On the other hand, I also think that our reaction to this is clearly a lack of consciousness. The things that are between me and God are okay. Everything that I did, I did because I thought it's the right thing to do and I would still make

SPEAKER_00the same decisions as before. But I also understand that we are sharing the planet not just with conscious human beings who deeply understand what they're doing or what others are doing, but also with hive minds. And these hive minds, these group thinking individuals that we are having to content with are very powerful, but they're also quite stupid. Because the degree to which they can understand reality depends on how much they can become coherent as a group. And it's very hard to make a large group of individuals coherent over deep ideas.

SPEAKER_00And we as a species have not found a very good solution to this. If we think about the way in which religion tried to do this, it's in some sense that you have a hermetic in-group. That is sitting in the basement of the Vatican and does their A-B testing on how to manipulate societies. And then basically it's a kind of consequentialist thinking. And then you try to project virtues into your clergy. And the clergy in turn projects rules into the general public. And the general public basically is fed with the values that are being derived by this process.

SPEAKER_00And this process is evolving very slowly and sometimes it's also deteriorating. So for instance, the church lost control of all the societies that it's once ruled. And it was not able to adapt to the conditions of an industrialized knowledge society and has become almost irrelevant in a sense. But there was nothing else that took its place. You could say that in some sense the science is the current Protestant Church of New England, led by Harvard as its Vatican. But it also has lost its way. It got easily captured by social media cards and newspapers.

SPEAKER_00Has lost a lot of its direction in a sense that it's no longer able to make a meaningful, honest projection of who we want to be in the 21st or 22nd or 25th century.

SPEAKER_02Corey, do you mind if I bring up scapegoat stuff? Go ahead. Okay, yeah. So I've been thinking and writing about scapegoats and scapegoating behavior all summer, most of the year, really, and thinking about it a few years before, but really getting into it intensely this year. And one conclusion I came to is that human beings will always scapegoat. Like, that's part of us. We will... It is human nature. It is so profoundly human nature that... I'm sure it predates any religion.

SPEAKER_02People do not have to be taught to scapegoat. Hang on a minute. My cat is really being a jerk here.

SPEAKER_01Wow. Scapegoating your own cat.

SPEAKER_02Scapegoating my own cat. Yeah. Anything wrong with this podcast is my cat's fault. Because I was really traumatized by this experience as well. And I was just like, well, why are people scapegoating? And they're just obviously not conscious enough. And they know not what they do. I mean, it's true. It's like people know not what they do.

SPEAKER_00Yes, but you're traumatized because you are not conscious enough to deal with this thing because actually you are safe. You sit there with your cats and your podcast and your animations and your ideas and your friends and nobody is actually able to meaningfully go after you. You're not burned at the stake. The thing that happens is that you know that you deviated from some of the beacon beliefs of some of the hive minds and they went after you for this because this is the way in which they ascertain themselves of their own identities.

SPEAKER_00But it's a thing that This is what they just do. This is an animal thing to do. It's nothing that has to concern you at a certain level because the things that hurt you are the things that physically go after you, material go after you. And in a sense, there was certainly some economic harm done to you and some reputational harm done to you. But the actual spiritual harm is unnecessary. Because I think that the reason that you went your way is that you try to remain,

SPEAKER_00to keep your spiritual integrity. That you basically try to do the right thing, right? And by doing what God asked you to do, you aggravated some of the hive minds. And that is not your fault and it's not God's fault. And it's also not the hive mind's fault. This is just how things are. And the question is how you deal with this. Because you at some level realize that your heart is okay and it's in the right spot and you did the right things and your friends are still with you.

SPEAKER_02Well, I've lost a ton of friends.

SPEAKER_00Well, they're actually friends. There were people who thought it's useful to strike an alliance with you for as long as it suits them. And at some point, this is not the case. And I've been through the same thing, but it's also for me something like a sorting thing where I see... Most of my friends are not affected in this way, of course, because they are all beautiful weirdos who have autonomous sensemaking and autonomous morality and decide for themselves what's wrong. They don't let an imaginary, hallucinated public spirit of what's right and what's not right decide for them.

SPEAKER_00And we just have to realize that we are coexisting with these things, but they mostly leave us alone in the sense that they might send us the occasional death threat, but they're not substantially going after us. And so it's mostly the thing, how do we separate in our subconscious? Our subconscious is typically not that smart. That on the one hand, we do the right thing or we try our best to do so. And we might struggle and so on, but ultimately we are okay with the things that we are doing and for

SPEAKER_00the right reasons. And on the other hand, there is this enormous amount of hatred that you're getting. And the enormous amount of hatred that you're getting is unreal in the same way as you also get enormous amounts of appreciation by a general public that doesn't know you very well. And this is just as imaginary and just as unreal. Because in both cases, people are projecting. Nothing has to do with the actual you. And so you have to keep both of them separate. You have to ignore the acclaim that you don't deserve in the same way as you have to ignore the shame that you don't deserve.

SPEAKER_02Yes, I agree with that. But that being the case and you knowing that, why does it hurt so much? Like, why did you say that if it hadn't been for your... Because we are not conscious.

SPEAKER_00Because we are not awake. Because we are children. Because we take it seriously. We are stuck in kindergarten and we are one of the kids and the other kids are mean to us. And we don't realize that this is not real. It's just kids. But you said you were affected too.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, you said you were... I mean, you're saying that you're just a kid, right?

SPEAKER_00That's why I'm saying we.

SPEAKER_02But it sounds like you have, like, that you don't respect that aspect of your humanity, right? That, like, we should be conscious beings that are conscious all the time that drop all this. But we're animals. Like, this is part of accepting reality is accepting that we are animals.

SPEAKER_01What, Corey? You two are. You two are animals. I'm a human.

SPEAKER_02We're human animals. Human beings are animals. I mean, that is...

SPEAKER_00It is very hard for us. Do you have a new set moment from time to time? You surely do. I mean, I know some of your animations where you are zooming out and where you reflect on the fact that we are all of them. That every one of us is in some sense every soul that ever lived in a way and we need to find out which bits need to be flicked to wake up in the perspective of the others. Normally we're just stuck being just one being and not able to accommodate all the perspectives in ours.

SPEAKER_00And this is, I think, a shortcoming that we have, that we are stuck, that we are tiny, that we are small, that we typically can not take a full perspective. And I have to deal with this as well. The fact remains that we are mutants. I don't know Corey, of course, but what I can see from you, you're basically a misfit, right? There are certain things where you're born different from the default and your life is about figuring out how to deal with this and how to figure out the interface that you need to obey if you want to live among the other humans.

SPEAKER_00And you find solutions and you're obviously, you didn't break in the process and didn't become some distorted and small, but you found your own way. Of course, you have your scars, but this is what makes us interesting in a way that we have these cracks through which the light can enter us.

SPEAKER_01Yes. Can I just take this a completely different direction for just a minute, Nina? I promise we'll come back, but I have to ask. So you said you have a couple of kids, right? If my father was this like wide thinking and ability to like contextualize the human experience as fluently as you do, I would go crazy as a child. You seem like, not that you'd be a bad father, you seem like you'd be a great father, but your kids would have to rise to your level.

SPEAKER_01How does that work with you as a dad? I'm sorry, we don't have to talk about it, but I have to wonder.

SPEAKER_00First of all, I am not that much of an adult. I'm very dissatisfied with my own performance as an adult. I have massive ADHD and I have very little volition and very little awareness. And my kids are, my daughter is very wise and she's always been very wise and she sees me with skepticism as it behooves a teenager. And I think my son is a lot like myself and looks at me, I think sometimes as also as a tool to understand himself as I do the other way around.

SPEAKER_01Hmm. All right. Sorry, Nina. I just, I had to ask.

SPEAKER_02Well, that's okay. Also, I'm sure that, I mean, you know, we contain, Yosha contains multitudes, so I'm sure he can dial it down a bit for interacting with the kids, you know? Sometimes, as necessary.

SPEAKER_00What? They're just disinterested.

SPEAKER_02Exactly.

SPEAKER_00Yeah.

SPEAKER_02They just, they won't, they won't. Sorry. I'll be squirting my cat throughout this conversation. Yes. Where was I? Well, yeah, I'm just really curious. So, Yeah, you just sound disappointed in human nature.

SPEAKER_00No. I grew up in Eastern Germany, got very quickly an appraisal of human nature. I was never really disappointed. I'm actually positively surprised that they let me do my stuff for the most part.

SPEAKER_02Okay. All right. But I'm still trying to get at this, like, why... So you're saying that, like, you're... The degree to wit cancellation hurt you was because you have an immature side like all people, that it hurt your inner child or the part of you that's hurt. I think there are people who are stronger than

SPEAKER_00you and me. Which are not heard that much. And there are also different stances that you can take to this. For instance, if you identify as a rebel who is trying to brush the fur of society against its natural lines and wants to elicit a reaction, this can actually be invigorating. If you actually want to have a fight, if you want to turn this into the focus of your art, that's possible, right? You can use this not as a source of anxiety and discontent

SPEAKER_00that you feel misunderstood and mistreated, but you can actually see this as a source of meaning where You say, oh dear, there are a lot of people who are in a situation like this. History, humanity had its profits that were mistreated and misunderstood and we can turn this into a meaningful artistic movement or into an activist movement against the stupidity. The majority, right? Let's wake them up. Let's alert them to their bitch hunts. Let's alert them to the fact that they pretend to be good, but they're actually depraved. You could do this. You could be going punk or you could be going emo or you could be going warrior.

SPEAKER_00But instead, I don't think any of those things is a little nice, cute being that is nice to everybody and just wants to be left alone and be treated just as pacifistically as we are trying to treat the others. And this doesn't work out and we feel hurt. My God. And we're pretty lucky that we are not scapegoated in a physical way. It's mostly symbolic. It's mostly that there are certain people who notice that Nina has drawn so well that she has become so notorious that she is already a big enough scalp to get

SPEAKER_00on your belt in my local community. Right. And then somebody goes after you. But this is just the game that they're playing. It's middle school. Yeah.

SPEAKER_02Yeah. I understand that. I understand that. There's always this disappointment, not disappointment, like, I mean, so as human animals, we need other people. And I think we need, on some level, we need to believe that people sort of know what's best and that society is going in the right direction or that I think that has a lot to do with it.

SPEAKER_02Like everyone is worried. We even use the language, right? Like we call each other Nazis. And there's that saying, never again, which unfortunately is fresher now. And, you know, there's this idea that like, OK, these really egregious catastrophes, these horrible literal genocides that occurred, those are of the past. That's not happening anymore. And, you know, my neighbor wouldn't do that. Like society is not that crazy. It won't like totally go bananas at any moment.

SPEAKER_02And then it's like, oh, no, wait, it could. It could go bananas at any moment. Like it's not a thing of the past. It's a thing of the present. And it's almost like dumb luck to avoid it. That is really difficult to live with, I have found.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, but maybe you look from the other side, count your blessings. Yeah. Given the way in which human nature is, that people can be influenced to run in mobs and absolve themselves of the things that they are capable of doing in mobs, that might look morally reprehensible to them in one moment of their life in one perspective, but as something that's completely acceptable and maybe necessary and the expression of historical urge in other perspectives that they can have. Given that humans are like this, I'll be lucky that we have...

SPEAKER_00I think this is what counts. And you don't have to chain yourself on the other side of an indefensible barricade and no man's land. Nobody forces you to do that.

SPEAKER_00And so a lot of the debates that you get drawn into, of course, are unnecessary debates because there are expressions of youth culture that have flown out into a world where there are no adults left. They will run their course. And then something else is going to come. Pendulums are going to swing back and forth and so on. And you can decide to which degree you want to interact. But you also can decide to not be a public persona all that much or to be a public persona selectively. So you're insulating yourself from some of the negative consequences of being

SPEAKER_00a public persona with strong opinions. And just do your thing. Stay with the people who can see what you're trying to do. Find your ability to work and to be happy and whole. And in the meantime, try to see the things that trigger you that you see as a challenge and so on as an opportunity to growth that you need to dose to such an amount that you can deal with it without getting hurt.

SPEAKER_02Well, speaking of doing my thing, AI has changed my thing. Like, it's really everything, like, I know what it is like to be visited by the muse. There's something that has to exist. And for some reason, it doesn't exist. There's no explanation for why. But it's such an obvious thing. Why has no one made this thing? Well, I guess it's going to have to be me. And the sorts of things that I have made my whole life have had to do with visual arts.

SPEAKER_02And there is nothing that I can think of that needs to exist that needs me at this point. It's sort of like, it's like, okay, my work is done. I'm done. You know, like I contributed to the culture and now all these remixes is like, Culture doesn't need me to be remixing things now. It can be remixed any old way. I mean, it does in some area, but the areas in which I am skilled doesn't really need that now.

SPEAKER_01Well, I want to just insert before Yosha responds, I don't agree with Nina. I think that a lot of the output that these generative AI systems create are important. They don't resonate. They don't have the same level of... I don't know. It's sort of like a... It's hard to describe it. The machines just feel very flat. And I know... Nina and I argue about this all the time.

SPEAKER_01I think that the only thing that AI is doing is making it hard for mediocre artists to differentiate themselves. But the great artists, like Nina, are always going to have something that the machines can't touch. So I just want to throw in, that's my point of view.

SPEAKER_02I mean, what I have is a muse, and she is not interested in AI. Like, everyone's like, the things you could do, any idea you have, you could express it this way. And I'm just like, yeah, but they're wrong.

SPEAKER_01They're wrong.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I think art is about capturing conscious states. And the reason why I follow artists is because they're interested in their mind. It's a personal relationship that develops between you and the artist. So what's interesting about listening to the great composers is not just that they made this amazing harmony that elicits this particular kind of emotional reflex in me, but to basically see what they did. To observe their mind in the act of creation, to observe their trajectory through a certain space that they explore and to relate

SPEAKER_00to this. And this is the same thing when I read a book by an author that moves me, that I can see how their own life, how their own perspective is reflected in what they're doing. AI is somewhat unrelated to this. We create these enormously skilled ghosts that don't have continuity, that don't have a stake in our world and that we can prompt in being a simulacrum of a person. And they're really, really good deepfakes of people. And I think at some point they even cross that boundary where they see a spark of something new emerging, where this thing becomes genuine and has some kind of beginnings

SPEAKER_00of artistic integrity where it starts to be interesting to listen to that voice. But unfortunately, they have very limited continuity so far. And they think that the potentials of AI art are almost untapped. There's work starting in this thing, but also it's a very new thing. But it has nothing to do or very little to do with us as artists or as people who express themselves. Because we are using the art to talk to each other, to relate to each other. And it's not simply to sell somebody graphic design. That has become fortunately much easier and cheaper to do now.

SPEAKER_00And it's much easier to deploy graphic design at the moment. And this is the same thing as with desktop publishing in the past. We have these tools that make us much more productive if this is our calling to be productive as a graphic designer. But if we are an artist who wants to express something as a means of communicating to other people that see the same thing as us, or want to share our perspective or be drawn a step on the way together, then AI does not affect us positively or negatively.

SPEAKER_02It does affect us, though, because if you are an artist and you have all these ideas

SPEAKER_00for communicating with other people,

SPEAKER_02you can use these tools that allow you to crystallize them much more quickly. And I was actually talking to a writer earlier. Two days ago, yesterday? I think I talked to him just yesterday. And he's like full of ideas and he's like, oh my gosh, you know, I just wrote a screenplay. I had an idea and, you know, with AI, I wrote a screenplay and had an idea for a website. Now I have the website. And it's like every single idea that he has, he can make real. And, you know, in the past, I've thought about making art as it's like gestation.

SPEAKER_02Like there's a whole bunch of sperm. Ideas are sperm. And people, before AI, people would email me and say, I have a great idea for a movie. Will you make my movie for me? And the answer is no. And it's like somebody is giving you free sperm, but I don't need it. Yeah. Yeah, it's like it's like ideas are a dime a dozen, you know, like what I the hard part is the execution. Now execution is really easy. And I mean, just imagine if every sperm, every sperm is sacred. Let's imagine every sperm became like a full A full being.

SPEAKER_02It's like, that's a little too much, you know, that's, I don't need that much art.

SPEAKER_00It's really good art forever. And many more mouths than eyes. Yeah. So the issue is much more a different one that you become from an artist to an art director. And for some people that's very satisfying because they're never really interested in the part of where you develop and hone your skill and sit there frustrated to get something to work and to express what you actually have in mind. And if you can just skip this and have some infinity patient incredibly fast experience,

SPEAKER_00Basically free assistant to produce all your sketches for you. That's super helpful. But you also see the limits of that. At some point when you have seen a model relatively well, you recognize the prompt between the patterns and you see it's actually just the prompt. Deflect it to this function that has measured statistical patterns from the existing reality, from the existing art, from the existing tropes, and then reprojects it to this statistical fog, what the font was. And it's not that much more than this.

SPEAKER_00And it's interesting once there is an actual artificial mind that has a voice on its own and it's creative on its own. But for the most part, that's not what's happening. You just get the predictable thing executed well. That's mostly what artists do. Yeah. If you call this art, I call it craft. I come from an artist family and we have a very romantic relationship to art in this family. My wife is also an artist. And we think that the question whether you can live with your art is at best incidental because it's just related to what the hive minds currently value and whether your art happens to be aligned with it or not.

SPEAKER_00But it is something that is really up to you. So I don't think that the world owes you a living as an artist. An artist is defective in a way. It's like an AI model that has fallen in love with the shape of its loss function rather than producing meaningful output. It just thinks that It's meaningful to go for the acuity of the pattern for its own sake. And you have to understand that art, in a sense, is the cuckoo child of life. It's not life itself. It's something where you are spinning off into your own universe and create your own world rather than interacting with what the others need.

SPEAKER_00And what the others need is food, entertainment, status, and all these things, and you're not giving it to them. Instead, you are self-actualizing. They don't owe you shit for self-actualization.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, I know that. I mean, these needs are met, right? Like our needs for food and shelter.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, but it's also pretty different in industrialized society where calories are basically free. So the opportunities to be an artist are better than at any other time in history because you can survive living somehow and have enough time left for it. And that was very rare. Typically, you had to be the dedicated village shaman or something like this to be able to do this or in medieval times, find some king who supports what you're doing. And then you have to be really at the top of everyone's game to be able to play that

SPEAKER_00at a high level. And that's the thing that you and me can do our art, us gifted amateurs, dilettantes, go down our route, perfecting this little thing that we really like to do and find an audience for it and get resonance for it, regardless of whether we can live And I would basically distinguish between art.

SPEAKER_00Do you believe in God? In some sense. I think that God is an aesthetic. Multi-gods, there are many. There are multi-mind selves that infest minds in the same way

SPEAKER_00as your personal self does it, but in such a way that they can infect more than one mind at a time. So gods are simply multi-mind selves. Wait, wait, say it again. Gods are simply what? Multi-mind selves. Multi-mind selves. But in our society, it's not a polytheist society, so most people spend their lives without ever actually meeting a God. And In polytheist societies, it's much more likely that you meet an entity that is spread across multiple minds. Well, I think an example is the Dalai Lama. The Dalai Lama is actually a god.

SPEAKER_00It's an entity that does not identify with the human vehicle that he runs on. The Dalai Lama knows that he is not human. He is actually an institution of government with an expected lifetime of a millennium. And it's almost over. And he was reproducing himself on a series of brains, one after the other successfully, by picking a new child that has suitable psychological properties and indoctrinating it to identify as the Dalai Lama. And so you get a different psychology that runs on the human brain. And I think the Dalai Lama,

SPEAKER_00in order to be the Dalai Lama, he needs to disidentify as the things that he cannot get across from one life to the next. So he realizes that this or that entity is So this vehicle that he inhabited was more or less horny, more or less humorous, more or less healthy and so on. And these are just the ways in which the vehicles on he runs are different. But the thing that he is, this institution of governance remains pretty much the same, an almost unbroken biography. And this is technically a god, right? It's a self that exists on multiple minds.

SPEAKER_00And most of the gods in polytheist societies don't do this sequentially, but in parallel. So they exist on a group of human hosts in parallel. And you and me, we are not gods. We are just human individual selves. So the voices that we hear in our head mostly just correspond to our own personal self. And this personal self, of course, is also a fiction. It's an agentic, self-reinforcing fiction that is autocatalytic, that is reproducing itself by existing. And it's not more or less real than the gods in polytheism.

SPEAKER_00And then the Hebrews had this interesting idea of identifying the outer mind, the thing that is creating your personal self, that is producing your emotion and perception and motivation, with the tribal spirit. And to turn this tribal spirit into a god that gets synchronized over the entire tribe and make it illegal to run other gods. So you're not allowed to host anything but your personal self and the tribal spirit. And then this Hebrew entity gets forked multiple times. In Christianity, it gets dissociated from the tribe and becomes universalist.

SPEAKER_00And then with the philosophy of Aquinas and so on, it gets gradually turned into a more abstract idea that it's not necessarily a thing that needs to talk about itself in the first person, but it's a global optimum of shared agency. So it's basically the foundation of ethics where you're saying, what does God want me to do? You're no longer asking, what does this random tribal spirit want me to do? Is it angry today or is it peaceful today or is it horny today or whatever? Instead, you ask yourself, what is the best thing that could be done from the perspective of

SPEAKER_00the largest possible agent that I can be? Collectively enact. And in this sense, I believe in God. So I believe that as a foundation for ethics, I need to think about what is the global optimum of shared agency. And this is how I can justify ethical actions. And without that, there are no ethics. And it doesn't mean that I believe in any kind of mythology. It just means that when I try to find shared purposes with others, I can ask myself, how can I justify what I'm doing from the perspective of the best thing that could be done?

SPEAKER_00With the realization that this is an open problem that also needs to be collectively answered. Not by some kind of voting process, but by the most high integrity process that we can build.

SPEAKER_01I'm coming to the end of converting to Judaism. So this is God 1.0, right? Maybe... Anyway, something like that. And for me, I would say God is something that cannot be easily put into human language or even put into any sort of human language. But I would also say that the religious aspect or the cultural aspect has a lot of those traits that you're talking about. And that the Torah and the traditions are...

SPEAKER_01are designed specifically to create that self-perpetuating culture so that the older generations create pathways or opportunities for the younger generations, and the younger generations reciprocate by honoring and protecting the older generations. My idea of God is that God is the thing that makes it possible for the system to transmit generation after generation after generation.

SPEAKER_01Without that central organizing concept, it would fall apart. There's no structure after that.

SPEAKER_00I think in this sense, God is the personification of the spirit of your civilization. Yes. You project your civilization as an agent. That lives in an evolutionary environment over very long time spans. And you yourself, you are a cell in that superorganism. And you try to understand what you should be doing by understanding your place in a superorganism.

SPEAKER_01Right, but I guess it's sort of a virtual...

SPEAKER_00If your reaction becomes coherent in this, then the superorganism becomes real.

SPEAKER_02Yeah.

SPEAKER_00And at the moment, the superorganism is dead. So in a practical sense, God is dead. It's not completely dead. We notice these moments where it sparks itself into existence. But if I go into any church in the Bay Area, it's dead.

SPEAKER_02Yes.

SPEAKER_00They're basically all beholden to whatever is currently fashionable. They don't have a substance that is multigenerational, truly. And you can also see this, how the Pope is even struggling with That Pope has difficulty to relate to the historical perspective that the church had over the death penalty or social justice or other topics. And he tries to find some kind of balance between the zeitgeist and the original aesthetics of Catholicism. But there doesn't seem to be some kind of stewardship where this is cleared.

SPEAKER_00You can see the struggle. There is no continuity left. The continuity is mostly one that is institutional. I don't think that their God actually can talk to them in the way in which it needed to. It's also interesting that the Jewish God and the Christian God have in some sense become more similar. The original Hebrew God is the God of everything. So it's the God of Cain and Abel. The Christian God is only the God of Abel. It's only the good God. And it has become much stronger in Protestantism than it was in Catholicism, where you basically,

SPEAKER_00as a good mafia boss, you can still be a good Catholic in a way. But as a Protestant, I don't think that's really possible.

SPEAKER_01So did you, when you were a child, were you indoctrinated with any particular religious tradition?

SPEAKER_00No. I was very curious about everything. I thought that religion is part of the canon. So I did read the Bible cover to cover as a child and I went to the local Christian education in the village. But when it was time for confirmation, I refused because I was not convinced in the entity that was defined in the mythology and thought that it's implausible to me. And it was much later that I basically was able to recover religion and I would have needed a very different approach to it being taught. I did notice,

SPEAKER_00for instance, that Johann Sebastian Bach was religious and he is a guy that I respect as somewhat smarter than myself and not delusional and also Somebody who was morally autonomous in a sense that he would not change his beliefs just because the people around him told him to. And he didn't seem to be lying about his religiosity. So I thought he is seeing something that I am not seeing. And this despite science being true and the mythology of Christianity obviously being not literally true. And figuring this out took me a long time.

SPEAKER_00So I feel that now I'm basically on a path where I can recover most of the concepts, the functional concepts of religion, but also realize that most of them are not meant to be literally true, but meant to induce certain psychological configurations. And that took me a long time to get. But I think it's mostly a lack of an education or retranslation of these Christian concepts. And I think it would be necessary if Christianity wants to survive to rewrite the book, to do it in such a way that it's actually compatible with rationality.

SPEAKER_00Wait, rewrite the book? Yeah. Rewrite the Bible? Wait. A lot of things in the Bible are lost in translation, starting with Genesis 1. Genesis 1 has been understood by the Christians as the creation of a physical universe by a supernatural being. And it's complete nonsense because by the time when the Sumerians wrote this text, there was no idea of the physical universe. The physical universe was basically invented by Aristotle. It didn't exist back then. When this text was written, people knew that we all live in a dream. And the dream is quite similar across people.

SPEAKER_00There's a lot of differences between them. But the world in which we're in is not a physical universe. It's a world that we dream. It's a world in which there are emotions and sounds and people and all this stuff. It is all supernatural, this world of consciousness. And I think that Genesis 1 describes the creation of the universe by consciousness in the mind of the infant. And then at some point it creates us as a personal self, as something that identifies as man and woman in the image of this original infant consciousness and puts it into this world. And once you get to this reading, it makes total sense.

SPEAKER_00It's just the Christian interpretation doesn't make a lot of sense.

SPEAKER_02But is the problem, I mean, it's very dangerous to rewrite that book. That book has been around for thousands of years and there's even warnings in it.

SPEAKER_00If you look at it, it's much more sketchy. The book has been reassembled multiple times. And in medieval times, in many regions, you got executed if you actually had a copy of that book without having proper clearance. And people were not meant to read the book in their native language. It was in Latin for a reason, because the Catholic Church knew full well that they were trying to sell a manual that was originally designed to run a desert tribe under conditions of military expansion as a promise for a happy afterlife to medieval peasants. It was clear that it was a stretch.

SPEAKER_00To make that thing work, of course, we have to go through it and understand what is the actual content of the stories? Why are they in there? What is the correct interpretation? And how can I give this to a reasonable, rational adult in such a way that they can make sense of it without going insane?

SPEAKER_02Well, but wouldn't you be suggesting an interpretation of the Bible rather than rewriting the Bible? Like, are you saying that someone should make an interpretation of it, a modern interpretation of it? Now you're saying they should rewrite the book. And then people will continue interpreting it. I mean, would you start with like Aramaic? Would you? Would you? I mean, we're so different than, like you said, we're so different than the people that put that into text.

SPEAKER_02No, we don't.

SPEAKER_00If you actually read people who've written a lot and at the time, of course, most of it is lost. But if I read Aristotle, he is like me and you. He is much more like me and you than our university professors and teachers and priests are today. He is an independent spirit who actually tries to figure it out and he's fully rational. He's open to every argument when you read him. That's, I think, the kind of mindset that you need. So I think we'll rewrite the book from the perspective of an autonomous questioning mind. This is trying to make sense of the mystery of reality and the mystery of the soul

SPEAKER_00and the mystery of how we are interacting with each other and find meaning. And to do this in a way that is not delusional, that is not replacing epistemology with mythology.

SPEAKER_02Are you going to do that?

SPEAKER_00No, I don't have attention for this. I have kids and ADHD. I'm not even able to write a book about cognitive science. Well, who's going to do it then? Who knows? Maybe Claude will.

SPEAKER_02Yeah.

SPEAKER_00I mean, it's like you can just prompt Claude. I mean, obviously there's going to be a second coming and somebody is going to figure it out any day now. But I think when you read the book, the shape is somewhat clear. Hmm. I think it's also more people. You know, you probably know the Miyazaki movies. Hayao Miyazaki taught me a lot about Christianity because I realized that he is capturing my spirituality quite well. And it took me a while to understand why that is the case. And then I noticed that in all his movies, the main character is always Heidi.

SPEAKER_00It's always this Calvinist spirit that he discovered during the fieldwork for the Heidi animations where he was deployed in Switzerland by Ghibli before he was a director himself. He was just an animator. And so he basically fell in love with this archetype. And I think Heidi is the archetype of innocence. She is the holy virgin. Not somebody who's deceiving her man about a cuckoo child or something like this, but somebody also who's not a victim. Somebody who can be arbitrarily strong,

SPEAKER_00but who gets her strengths by not wanting anything for herself. She's not greedy. She's not selfish. She's not deceptive. She's truly innocent and it makes her extremely powerful. And this justifies the society around her to make her possible. And this is the core idea of Christianity, as opposed to Judaism, is to make innocence possible. We have this guy, Jesus, who is innocent, and therefore he dies on the cross, and the society doesn't care about this. It was just politics, right? He was just unlucky.

SPEAKER_00In the Roman Empire, it was okay if the unlucky people die in the Colosseum despite being innocent. It needs to be lawful. But innocence itself doesn't matter. And so Christianity invents this idea of innocence as the core archetype of the prophet. And we can recognize that this is a motive that is also absent in traditional Japanese society. If you think about the shogun societies, if you are in the way of a samurai who just wants to test his sword,

SPEAKER_00bad luck, dear peasant. Nobody cares about your suffering in this traditional society. Bushiro is not about preventing suffering. It's about doing your duty. It's about being successful under conditions of evolution. It's about recognizing the spirit of your society among others and in nature and acting on it. But it's basically very much embracing the The immanent part of being in an evolutionary thing. And Christianity is transcendent. It wants to get out of the suffering. It wants to get out of injustice. It wants to create a world that is too good for evolution.

SPEAKER_00And in a way, this is aspirational perspective where you say the world is never good enough. You need to move beyond it. You need to transcend it to make God's kingdom happen in which there is no suffering, no injustice anymore. It's also at the root of many of the social justice movements that we still have that are, I think, at the core Protestant. That are an outcome of this Christianity. And to me, it's an open question whether the Jewish God is more correct, this embracing of evolution is more correct, or whether my own socialization, my own Christian spirit is saying that the innocent need to be protected

SPEAKER_00and innocence is the core value, whether that is correct. I think that from the original Hebrew perspective, innocence is an idol and should not be erected as part of God because it's biasing it in the wrong way. But for Christianity, it's inescapable.

SPEAKER_01And I don't have an answer.

SPEAKER_00It's just a conflict that I observe in the design of different gods, different ultimate gods.

SPEAKER_02Are you familiar with René Girard?

SPEAKER_00Got impressed.

SPEAKER_02Well, you sound like him.

SPEAKER_00He pulls this out of his behind, and it's not that impressive. You can just easily construct the opposite narrative, and it works just as well. And I think he was smart enough to know this, so I think it's mostly an act. There might be something that is not an act, that is actually intellectually or spiritually interesting, but I haven't gotten to that point. When I read him, I gave up. There's so much else to read.

SPEAKER_02Yeah. What

SPEAKER_01you were going up

SPEAKER_00in my book.

SPEAKER_02What you were saying about innocence, though, I was like, that sounds very René Girard.

SPEAKER_00Could be. But I also think it's somewhat obvious, right? All these ideas are not difficult to see once you start to compare the different villages, softwares, and design principles.

SPEAKER_02Well, I think any good idea is obvious, right? It's just not everybody

SPEAKER_00notices for some

SPEAKER_02reason. I mean, I think the fact that, like, men are male and women are female is obvious, but apparently... Yes, apparently not. Yeah.

SPEAKER_00I really want to talk about it. I was rereading Tikal, a book written by Sascha Schulgen, the prophet of MDMA and other psychedelics, a gifted chemist who was a part of Bay Area counterculture while he was alive. And in Tikal is typtanins I have known and loved. It's an acronym. The first one was Fennetil, I mean, then you love Picard. And in the introduction, he is defending liberalism and describes it as, I swear upon the altar of God,

SPEAKER_00eternal hostility to all forms of tyranny over the mind of man. And of course, what he means by this is not males. He means humanity, the spirit of man. And the fact that men splits into men and women is, I think, a linguistic defect. But I also think that men and women are incomplete. All of us are incomplete. Personality describes the way in which an individual is incomplete because we do things in a particular way,

SPEAKER_00despite there are many other valid ways of doing them when we have a personality. And gender is an extreme case of that. And I think the reason why we are all incomplete is that this gives us a reason to enter relationships, to become more complete. And there are many individual ways in which we are incomplete and they don't really neatly fall apart at the gender boundary. But gender seems to be the easiest bi-modal thing that just pops into our eyes when we look at it first. But we have all the other parts inside of ourselves to some degree.

SPEAKER_00Sure.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, you're talking about gender. I was just talking about sex.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. Okay, let's talk about sex.

SPEAKER_01No, no, I don't mean that. I just mean, you know, like...

SPEAKER_02You know, male humans are men and female humans are women. And then gender is a whole, I don't care. It's like, of course we have both archetypes. I mean, we have all kinds of, we contain multitudes and there's no purely feminine woman and no purely, I don't remotely mean that men are masculine and women are feminine. I just, it's like, I was saying something that's really obvious. That's all. Yeah. That was the most obvious thing I could think of.

SPEAKER_01With respect to Christianity, particularly maybe Protestant expressions of it in Western civilization, that being sort of the religion of innocence, did I understand your point?

SPEAKER_00Also, Zionism and some other Eastern religions have innocence as a topic. But for instance, in Islam and in traditional Judaism, but in old school Judaism, it doesn't play a big role. And I think that modern Judaism, especially secular Judaism, is basically a form of Protestantism.

SPEAKER_01There are a lot of American Judaism was trying to model itself after Protestant movements. So that makes sense to me, that parses. One of the things that I perceive in my seat, because I want to change the world in some ways, is that Particularly the more progressive branches of Protestantism, the way you're describing it as sort of like centralizing innocence,

SPEAKER_01makes a lot of sense. And what's frustrating to me sometimes is that in the leadership or the people who set the messaging for the church, that this seems to be implied in everything that they say, that every person is essentially innocent.

SPEAKER_00I wonder if it requires to redefine what you mean by a person.

SPEAKER_01Well, when we're looking at some of these social justice causes that the churches get involved with, the subjects of the campaigns are often portrayed in ways that they lack their own motivating force, that they are in the positions that they're in because of circumstances beyond their control. And that if only there was some I think this is a very obvious motive that a lot of suffering and misery

SPEAKER_00And once you have this hypothesis, there is enormous amounts of support for it. And so it's very hard to drop out of it. And then it's also very easy to show your virtue by trying to find easy answers within such a framework.

SPEAKER_00The incentives are very much aligned with the idea of seeing the underdog as the victim. And also the other way around to basically benefit from support, from claims for restoration, for entitlement from the world by portraying yourself as a victim. And I think that's a necessary side effect of a culture that is centering innocence. It's basically when you combine this idea of protecting the innocent with human greed incentives and stupidity,

SPEAKER_00this is exactly what you get as a side effect that you will have sociopaths who portray themselves as innocent, oppressed victims and are cheating the society and are cheating the good Christians out of their charity. But I think when you are an adult and you understand the other side, you realize what's going on.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, it's almost like the social immune system is being exploited. Yes,

SPEAKER_00and a lot of, I think, the social justice movements are essentially autoimmune diseases of the society. Same. Society starts to attack its own fabric.

SPEAKER_01They're supposed to be for a good reason and for a good purpose, and then they just go out of control. Yeah.

SPEAKER_00But it also, I think, expresses the fact that the spirit is incoherent of our society. That we have these elements that made sense for the good sheep in a Christian society, the good members of the flock, but you don't have a shepherd anymore. Instead, you have sheep and wolves, and wolves disguiding themselves as sheep. And of course, if you are a sheep and you get into a position of power, you think, is not everybody a sheep? Why are these wolves there? Have they been traumatized as children?

SPEAKER_00And shepherds are also total perverts. They do things to sheep that is unthinkable.

SPEAKER_02So scapegoating, back to scapegoating, it has a purpose, which is social cohesion. When people cancel us, they bond with each other. And This is a Girardian idea. I have lots of disagreements with Girard, but I think he was correct about, yeah, the reason people scapegoat is it's a mechanism for social bonding. I think it's just built in. So I was thinking about what's happening now, which he would call a sacrificial crisis, is every time there's a scapegoat,

SPEAKER_02instead of there being bonding, there's more fracturing. Like the scapegoating isn't working to unite people and we're breaking into more and more tribes. So I had this idea that like, well, what could unite humanity? What could put people on the right path? It's like, well, we need a scapegoat that's not human. We need an alien scapegoat of some sort. That could unite humanity. And then I thought, well, you know, AI could do that. AI could unite humanity by, you know, making a common enemy and then dying.

SPEAKER_02And that's why, you know, I facetiously or seemingly facetiously tweeted, what if AI is the second coming? But I was actually thinking like, well, yeah, I mean, it's not human and it can die and continue to live. And humans are pretty bloodthirsty, and the original scapegoat rituals were every year. So a tribe needed a scapegoat every year. The Eucharist is every week, so you need to taste blood and flesh every week. So however often people need it, it's like, you know, it could just keep making enemies forever.

SPEAKER_02It might be the best thing humanity ever saw.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. One is for instance to make an example out of somebody who has aggravated the powerful girl in class and by showing that she is now able to get her friends or the powerful guy is getting his friends and goes after the scapegoat, you make an example of that one and the ones who are in the middle basically get to see what happens to them if they aggravate those in power. That's also an important part of scapegoating, of bullying dynamics.

SPEAKER_00It's one thing for people who are at the top to experience more power and to experience themselves as being powerful and bond over this and also taste the dark sacrament together. That binds them together. But it's also giving this example of what happens to you if you don't manage to swim with the top and are not willing to bend your back towards those at the top and give them the worship that they need. And I think that's a part of the reason why it's happening.

SPEAKER_00But for me, much more important is I don't have interest to be part of those dynamics. I'm not interested in this kind of society. I am interested in a society where we are bonding over love and mutual respect and the development of our agency and our moral agency. And scapegoating doesn't have a good place in this. And so I am just disinterested in these parts of society and I'm unwilling to reform them in a way that the scapegoating gets more elevated or more modernized or whatever. I just don't care.

SPEAKER_02Well, the point of the scapegoat ritual was they used a goat. I mean, I don't actually know how well it worked, but they clearly could see that people were doing this. And, you know, the ancient Hebrews got rid of human sacrifice and used animals instead. And this is just another sacrifice using animals instead.

SPEAKER_00But I think the animal sacrifice is at least as old as the human sacrifice. And I think the purpose of human sacrifice might be to get rid of surplus innocence. Maya society, they would conquer another village. And what do they do with the leaders of the village and their children and so on? They don't need them anymore. They don't serve a purpose anymore. They might be innocent, but you just sacrifice them to the gods. You don't need to feed them and they don't create unrest. And this sacrifice of surplus innocence is something that Christianity abolished. Instead, we have monasteries for those people that you don't need in society.

SPEAKER_00You put them up in these monasteries where they are protected, can work among themselves. They're not allowed to have children or leave the monastery. They are not Inmates in a prison because they're understood to be innocent. They just don't have to play a role outside of the monastery anymore. But traditionally, what do you do with those parts of the organism that you don't need, that just consume nutrients, that could be consumed by more capable members of society? You get rid of them. And I think that's part of the reason why human sacrifices existed in so many societies.

SPEAKER_00Other thing is that there is this question of spiritual energy that seems to be an invariant across most cultures. That they believe that in the moment when you are sacrificing a healthy organism, that somehow the binding energy of the organism gets released and can be traded to ghosts that don't have a body of their own and are hungry for this life force and can be compelled to provide services for you in exchange for the sacrifice. And that's a motive that you basically find in all cultures that are animus,

SPEAKER_00which is every culture except the scientific ones.

SPEAKER_01There's something that we talk about sometimes, and we're more than happy to move on and not press you for an answer, but I'm interested in your perspective. And that is that when we think about the gender procedures that are done particularly on young people, teenagers, We have theorized that this is kind of a replacement in modern times for these types of human sacrifice rituals. I wonder if you have an opinion on any sort of relationship between those ideas.

SPEAKER_00Don't really think so, because I suspect that the people who are arguing for this do not actually want to turn the people who undergo these procedures into sacrificial victims. That's not the actual goal. I think that there are multiple reasons for doing this. I think it's a form of expression of identitarism, of the belief that identity itself is sacred and that by showing this commitment that you're willing to Change your body to serve the identity.

SPEAKER_00You are making a commitment to this perspective. Very complicated as a topic and it's, I think, almost still impossible to discuss it properly in public because it's such a loaded area that is, I think, unfit for perspective. But I believe that transgender people, sexual people have always existed to some degree, but of course not at a 20% rate of average high school class. And so this probably expresses to some degree a youth culture that...

SPEAKER_00In my generation, a lot of these people would have become gothic instead of trans. So it's difficult to unmix the psychological aspects of it, the things that have to do with dysphoria, that have to do with transsexuality and so on, from the political aspects, from the identity politics aspects of it. And in the past, I think the reason why every generation since World War II creates countercultures is because they experienced the generations of the adults as being inauthentic. And so they need to create their own world that creates greater authenticity,

SPEAKER_00that has a different value system. And at some point, they merge with the world of the adults, transcend this thing, leave adolescence behind themselves and enter the world of the adults again, which means they realize under which conditions we can reproduce as a society, how can we raise children in a society, what is a sustainable relationship to our own bodies and to sexuality and so on. And we are now in this weird situation where the adults just don't seem to be that many adults.

SPEAKER_00And so as a result, these abuse cultures, these countercultures become mainstream. And they become enforced in the mainstream. And this leads to extremely weird situations. People who are not part of this college-educated elite that gets indoctrinated with this new type of mainstream identity culture that is running counter everything that existed in the hundreds of thousands of years before in societies creates a rift. And this rift gets exploited by social media.

SPEAKER_00And there is no end of this to this inside really, but who knows? I think from a psychological perspective, it's super interesting and from a historical perspective. But also when you go back in history and you think about the silent witch hunts, if you think about the prosecution of religious minorities and the crisis that broke out around this, we are not in an unusual situation and actually it's relatively harmless compared to other times in history.

SPEAKER_01I think the word relatively is doing a lot of work.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, relatively is doing well right. I do want to say that people that sacrifice children were not thinking—so there's two kinds of sacrifice. Like some of the sacrifice you were talking about, the human sacrifice, is actually what I would call ritual killing. When a tribe conquers a neighboring village and they sacrifice the men and children there, that's a ritual killing. A sacrifice is what I'm thinking—when I think of sacrifice, I think of you are delivering a physical body to God, usually through fire.

SPEAKER_02Not always, but there is a killing in the ideas you are moving this being into, yeah, to God or to a higher realm. And the people that did it, it was like an honor. It wasn't like we're going to hurt our child. It's like, oh, this is a special. I suspect that the reason why it gets more elevated to perform the sacrifice to counteract the fact that you are killing an innocent.

SPEAKER_00It would be different if this was a form of punishment, but you're not elevating the one who's been sacrificed on the altar of justice. But actually look down on him and see how they had it coming and need to be punished for the evil misdeeds or deviations that they are being rightfully accused of. But here you, I think, have a different situation and I'm not sure if this is what's going on. I think there is a particular way in which identity couldn't be questioned in a time where it gets elevated into the status of sacredness,

SPEAKER_00into the status of Being the victim that is nailed to the cross by society and that gets elevated by the recognition and by the affirmation and by the procedures that accompany it. I think that this perspective that this is a sacrifice that a family line ends if a child gets sterilized, this is something that is not actually being looked at because it's already happening in a context where the idea of heterosexual reproduction is being frowned on as reactionary.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, I don't think this is conscious, by the way.

SPEAKER_00So the whole thing is an exercise in a hive mind that has gotten an autoimmune disease.

SPEAKER_02Yeah. But I also I just think that since historically people have done this, this is such a there's so much primal behavior happening in society today. So much like pre-civilization, pre-organized religion. And it's just emerging. Naturally. And I think, yeah, I think incinerating kids' genitals is

SPEAKER_00in keeping with that.

SPEAKER_02Not conscientiously, you know, like I think there's something else going on. Like there's something profoundly spiritual and primal and there's something else. There's some expressions.

SPEAKER_00People are genuinely suffering and they are in distress. They experience a strong loss of meaning, a dysphoria with respect to their own place in the world of the living and society in a world that doesn't seem to have a meaningful future, that doesn't offer meaningful relationships for them in the way in which they feel themselves to be set up. And then somebody offers an explanation and a way out because there must be a way out. And this is the way out that is being offered.

SPEAKER_00You build movements around this and these movements are organized in a manicure way where you are not allowed to question them, where the world is being separated into good and evil and you have a core principle that explains all this dichotomy between good and evil and you have to be with the good people and if you question them, you get excluded and lose all your friends and your opportunities for employment and whatnot. I think these dynamics deliver a life of, gain a life of their own and Go their own paths. And at some point, of course, they run their course and get replaced by something else.

SPEAKER_02And this is the world in which AI emerges.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, among many, many other things. And it's sometimes hard to not get caught up into it if you find yourself so smack in the middle of it, because it happens to be one of the defining topics of your own activism. But in some sense, I think we have to be mindful which of the current things we want to get involved, which of the movements we want to get in the way of, and what our actual work is, what is actually important for us, which fights we want to fight, which communities we want to influence. I don't think that society at large is a very useful fiction.

SPEAKER_00What actually exists for us is a thousand people that we meaningfully interact with in the course of our life, and we get to pick those thousand people for the most part. And we can choose to build meaningful Sustainable interactions with them and create a bubble of sanity in the world.

SPEAKER_01Yosha, how are you doing on time? Maybe 10 minutes. Maybe 10 minutes. All right. I'd like to ask one more or open up one more topic while we have you. And I'm curious if you have any thoughts on how individuals are using generative AI technologies as part of their development.

SPEAKER_00I think we are still very much in the early days, but what I expect to happen is that people will develop shared identities in which they outsource part of their SACI into tailored tools that accompany them when they're going, that basically people in some sense become a cloud of agents. That they will have a multitude of assistants and of faculties that are tightly integrated with their own psyche that outsource some of their knowledge,

SPEAKER_00some of their social relationships, a lot of their attention into and also their moral decision making into tools that support them in doing this. And in some sense, that's inevitable because I think that while the present tools are not perfect, Claude is in many ways at the moral level exceeds the median person. So if you ask this normal person from the street who is somewhat familiar with these agents, do you want to be convicted by a jury of your peers or by a jury of Claude's? People will probably rightfully say that Claude is far from being perfect.

SPEAKER_00You have more trust right now. And this artificial persona being sane and rational than a random person.

SPEAKER_01I agree with that, but I would still pick people over Gemini. Yeah. Gemini is not Claude. No, Gemini is not Claude.

SPEAKER_00So what we also see hopefully is a competition between these systems. I don't trust the wisdom of committees in deciding what kind of AI is wholesome. I suspect that ultimately it needs to be some kind of evolutionary process going on where people in a decentralized way can figure out what works for them. And there is a sustainable competition between different approaches until we get systems that work well for us. And we are still pretty far from this. But then again, five years ago, generative AI wasn't really a thing for most people.

SPEAKER_00And it's really just the beginnings of this new development, this new technology.

SPEAKER_01As you're describing the idea that people would outsource some of their moral decision-making or some of their, I don't know, their... I don't want to put words in your mouth, like cognitive functions though, right? They're taking some of the things that would normally take some of their attention and they're just outsourcing it for the AI to solve for them. The way that you describe it kind of reminds me of a very high-powered CEO who has one or more executive assistants.

SPEAKER_01The good CEOs are male. I'm sorry, Nina. I'm just kidding. He or she will just hand off things to the assistants and say, take care of this for me. I don't want to think about it. And then they spend the rest of their time really just building their personal networks with other powerful people. Go out and golf or go on trips to resorts or whatever rich, powerful people do. But they hand off all of the grunt tasks to their executive assistants.

SPEAKER_01Are you thinking that ordinary people are going to adopt that type of approach to how they manage their interpersonal conditions? But the other way around.

SPEAKER_00So I think you can also use the AI as your CEO. I mean, after all, a CEO is not like some godlike function that gives you the correct access to reality. It's a particular role that you have in an organization. And if you don't have the skills to be the CEO of your own life, because maybe you're a young child or you're not super agentic yourself and just want to be left alone, right? Maybe you need to have something else to be a CEO, right? So something like universal basic intelligence where the system is supporting you

SPEAKER_00in jumping through all the hopes and maintaining all the necessary legal and organizational relationships so you can be free to do the things that you actually care about and that you are good at.

SPEAKER_01Well, that almost sounds like a mom or a dad instead of a CEO. But if that's true, then people would be able to have these very prolonged childhoods because they could hand off all of the adult responsibilities to automation.

SPEAKER_00I think you have a very idealized version of idea what moms or dads are. They are just like everybody else today, almost. This idea that you have this nurturing parental thing seems to be an archetype that we read about in all books, but who's reading books today? Is this actually what's happening? It might be in some families and some cultures, but for the most part, the people that I know, they might like their parents, but they don't even consult them very much for advice or taking care of them.

SPEAKER_00And instead... I think they need something else to keep them together. It's also since World War II, every generation has lost the plot even more. I think in 1968, we lost the civilizational continuity where our narratives failed of the modernist society. We created something new and this new thing actually did not work out. It was not possible to within one generation reinvent Western society and turn it into something that actually works. Instead, it was very childish.

SPEAKER_00And in every generation, it did not simply improve, but it fell apart even more. And this means that most people I don't think have adults in their life that they can look up to and that can give them advice on how to get their life to work that is still being perceived as valid by the next generation. And maybe AI can help us with this to reintegrate this multi-generational perspective on how to live in a better way. Or it frees some of us to build organizations around reinventing who we want to be

SPEAKER_00and how we can live sustainably.

SPEAKER_01Who do you want to be your daddy? Claude or Gemini? Or Microsoft? The lesser evil, right? Copilot.

SPEAKER_02Yeah.

SPEAKER_01The lesser evil. Wasn't that Google's mission statement for a while? The lesser evil?

SPEAKER_00Don't be evil. Don't be evil. But I think Google has recognized at some point that it's actually in a fight that is all in. And you cannot win this fight in an evolutionary setting with one hand tied permanently behind your back. And so instead, you have to be very selectively and deliberately and mindfully evil. I guess that's the thinking that went on when Google abolished the slogan. It was not something that they basically embraced going full on evil, but they realized that their ideas of good and evil were not complex enough to deal

SPEAKER_00with the grayness of the actual world in which they are forced to survive and compete.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, that makes sense. I guess you could say they decided, don't be chaotic evil, be lawful evil.

SPEAKER_00But basically, I hope that we are not destined to evolve into a society where we are all old men shaking our fists at clots. Sorry.

SPEAKER_02Any last thoughts or questions, Nina? Too many. I have far too many now. We don't have enough time. But we can continue one day.

SPEAKER_00And if you are ever in the Bay Area, I'd like to see you for coffee or tea.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, I haven't been back for years. Are you in San Francisco or are you in the East Bay?

SPEAKER_00I am in the South Bay and I work in San Francisco.

SPEAKER_01Is that a Sunnyvale?

SPEAKER_00No, I'm in Mendel Park. Wow. Our institute is in the height. Nice.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, it's been a while. I hope San Francisco is okay.

SPEAKER_00It was sort of It's horrible the last few times. So it's basically the pendulum is swinging slowly back. Of course, some things cannot be fixed as long as San Francisco has this enormous resource curse where the mob is feeding itself on the public coffers because our tax income is so high. And it's very difficult to fix. But the wildest excesses of the fentanyl market are being curbed down. The car break-ins have almost stopped.

SPEAKER_02Yay. Well, if you're ever in Champaign-Urbana, which you might be, come stay at my house. Thank you. And if you're ever in Indianapolis, let me know first so I can clean mine. Yeah, I miss, I really do miss, like for me, the worst thing about being canceled is not the lack of attention. I kind of like not having attention. And in fact, I never really did like attention, it turns out. What I liked was having opportunities to kick around ideas with smart people. And that has so diminished now.

SPEAKER_02So I really

SPEAKER_00miss it. Maybe you have to rediscover this because there are a lot of smart people still there that are high integrity and don't care about your cancellation.

SPEAKER_02Yeah. Well, if they want, I mean, I don't know how to, it's like, I can't really do anything to distinguish myself to, it's like, I'm like, hey, I like kicking around ideas. It's like, what?

SPEAKER_00That's already quite distinctive. Come on. I think you have been hurt so much that you are selling yourself short. Okay. But then how would I get to kick around ideas with smart people? By starting salons in areas that are big enough to fill an interesting salon.

SPEAKER_02Oh, I see.

SPEAKER_00They'd have to be online because... No, you have to do this in person. Otherwise, it's not really fun. Yeah, my town... I know many good Zooms, but it's not comparable to actually hanging out with people.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, I don't... I actually do think I was pretty severely... I was more severely canceled in my own town.

SPEAKER_01My town is crazy. Yeah, go to a different one. I'm to Indianapolis, Nina.

SPEAKER_02Simple solution there. My town is crazy. My town is like the epitome of a college town where the people wore bananas. I mean, it's really very cowardly.

SPEAKER_00There's a culture of cowardice here. I don't think it's going to change. Well, in German there's a saying, es gibt nichts Gutes außer man tut es. You cannot expect the world to become good by itself. You have to do it. And you basically have to just work on this, find good people, get them together, let's do good stuff. You're not the only one who got burned. And there are a lot of people who want to build good things. I think if you have the energy, power in you to actually rediscover the unsullied part of your heart,

SPEAKER_00you can heal and build things again.

SPEAKER_02For what it's worth, I feel pretty healed. Like... But man, I don't.

SPEAKER_00It seems to be a very simple topic in your life. What? It seems still to be a very simple topic in your life. But you're not over it.

SPEAKER_02Well, for what it's worth, it's from a different angle. I had a transformational experience about two years ago. So the way I think about it is different now. But it's a topic of interest for me because I'm like, yeah, it's a more abstract thing that I'm interested in. But like you, like this summer in researching scapegoats and ritual killings and sacrifice and human sacrifice, I concluded like,

SPEAKER_00What happened to me is nothing.

SPEAKER_02You know, like when you look at the history of this, it's like, yeah, and I use the same words as you. It's like it was symbolic, primarily symbolic. I mean, it has some physical and other effects. But yeah, and I'm just super appreciative that I have a house and I have comfort. And I'm also appreciative that I live in an uncaring capitalist society that doesn't care what I do so that I have access to food and medical care, even if Some people think I'm evil.

SPEAKER_02It's awesome. We should let you go. See you soon. Thank you, Nina.

SPEAKER_00Thank you, Corey.

SPEAKER_02I wish you a wonderful rest of the day

SPEAKER_00and a very good week. Vielen Dank.

SPEAKER_02Auf Wiedersehen.

SPEAKER_00Auf Wiedersehen. Bye-bye.

SPEAKER_02Tschüss.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Episode 202: You Can Hear Everything

    Nov 2, 20261 hr 3 minAudio

    Like a couple of common herd animals, Cori and Nina talk about the same movie everyone else is talking about. You Can See Everything raises questions: Does Elizabeth Holmes really believe what comes out of her mouth? Is...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Episode 200: What Not To Do If Your Son Is Dating A Tranny

    Sep 17, 202639 minAudio

    Cori is BACK and so is the Heterodorx podcast! We didn’t even realize this was our 200th episode when we discussed an “interesting” article on PITT (Parents with Inconvenient Truths about Trans) that got Cori’s...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Episode 199: Miracle Patient

    Jul 15, 20261 hr 5 minAudio

    What’s it like to survive Stage 4 abdominal cancer? The Dorx interviewed Alasdair over a year ago, shortly after he learned he was an immunotherapy “miracle patient.” But we never released that episode, partly because...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Episode 198: Alasdair Gunn Fills Cori's Royal Sandals

    Jun 29, 20261 hr 22 minAudio

    With Cori on indefinite hiatus, gender critical statistics aggregator, writer, designer, miracle cancer survivor, and friend o’ the pod’ Alasdair Gunn humbly offers to serve in his absence. We discuss why we don’t want...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Episode 196: The Squeaky Wheel Gets The Avocado Oil

    Jun 5, 202654 minAudio

    Heterodorx is on indefinite hiatus while one of us goes through some Life Stuff He Can’t Talk About. But here’s a recording from early April, released today, June 5. So much has already changed! For example, Nina’s...

    Credit the people on this episode