Find this episode on YouTube: Mathew Namee and Richard Rohlin join John to talk history. But weird history, because it turns out the world has ended. Maybe multiple times. And the way we see history today is not how humanity has always seen it. Mathew Namee is the editor for Orthodox History (https://www.orthodoxhistory.org/) and works closely with the Orthodox Studies Institute. Richard Rohlin is an author, podcast, and manger for the Symbolic World website. ✒ Substack: ⓧ https://x.com/johnfromftf 🍷The best dinner party you've ever experienced - Supra Dinner Society: https://supradinner.com/ 🏖️ Tailormade tours that give back: https://www.gratitude-travels.com/home 🔎 Discover the non-profit behind Heavy Things Lightly: https://first-things.org/ ✈ Become a Field Worker with FTF: https://first-things.org/opportunities 📢 First Things Telegram: https://t.me/firstthingsfoundation 🥂 Keipi Restaurant: https://keipirestaurant.org Please leave a review with your comments! Your support keeps this podcast alive and allows us to broaden our discussion. --- This “Enlightened” New World utopia isn’t turning out to be all it was cracked up to be. Society is disenchanting, but are the only alternatives hiding out in the hills or burying yourself in books? With an air of levity and a touch of humor, John Heers teaches how to examine the confusing New World by calling upon the mind and wisdom of oft-forgotten Old. Heavy Things, Lightly. --- Credits Music: Intro / Outro Provided by Greg Gilbertson & Band This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit johnheersftf.substack.com/subscribe
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_02Hey guys, it's Everything's Lightly. Today, I've been... We got two guests that are gonna help me figure out something I've been thinking about. Have you ever wondered, like, if you didn't die, there would be no time? I know you're thinking that doesn't seem true, but it's absolutely true. But here's the thing. Do we die? so if you're a christian and many other traditions but if
you're christian you don't actually die you fall asleep you pass through wait a minute if you're not
SPEAKER_02dying there aren't certain laws that you have to abide by if you actually are becoming something like eternal. And then you realize there's crazy stuff that can happen in the world. And then these two guys, Richard, Roland, who's a philologist, you guys know him from symbolic world. I think he's just about to become a deacon too. But Richard, Richard's the man, he's a historian. Then this other crazy guy, Matt, Matthew Namie shows up.
SPEAKER_02a really good Christian Orthodox historian who works over at OSI, Orthodox Studies Institute, and has some really cool projects going. Well, they come together in the clash of the historical titans. Is church history just like all other histories? And can people in church history do stuff like bend time? Hmm. Today on... Everything's lightly.
SPEAKER_02This is a great matchup. I thank you guys for being here. I have a question. And then let's just have fun for 45 minutes with this concept. Is someone doing church history something like exactly doing what someone's doing in American history? are they engaged in the same process of providing people with the past in a way to make us, I don't know, learn something? Or is there something different about church history? I don't know.
SPEAKER_02What do you think?
SPEAKER_01So, oh, can I go? Cause I have a, I have a fun story. I have a fun story, but let me tell you about, by the way, cheers to you guys. Cheers to you guys. Yeah. So let me tell you about last week when I held Hitler's keys. who doesn't want to start with that i know i know okay so so uh it's out now so i can talk about it um uh glenn beck the storm and mormon do you
guys know who glenn beck is yes i do yeah yeah well he invited uh jonathan pegeot and i out to his studios here in irving last week so that he could have a conversation with jonathan
SPEAKER_01um And that conversation is up now on Glenn Beck's podcast. It was a really good conversation. And in general, I think Glenn was a really, I mean, he was just a very good host. He was very, he was very humble, very charitable. He listened well. He asked good questions. He's very interested in us and kind of what our whole deal was. And anyway, so it was great. It was, it was very unusual. I didn't have that on my bingo card for 2025. But then afterwards, Glenn said, well, do you guys want to see the vault?
SPEAKER_01Like, well, what's the vault? Obviously, I want to see the vault. Glenn Beck has one of the largest collections of Americana and other artifacts, especially a lot of World War II and Cold War era stuff. In the country, like one of the largest personal collections, his curator, because obviously if you have a personal museum, you got to have a curator, right, told us that there's maybe over 100,000 artifacts in the collection. They're not all in one place, but they're kind of spread between different places. Wow. And so they took us on a tour through the vault.
SPEAKER_01Which had a bunch of crazy stuff in it. Obviously, the stuff I was the most interested in was the early American stuff. And so apparently the way that Glenn Beck got started with this collection was that there were some people I think associated with something called the 1619 Project that you're probably both familiar with. Oh, yeah. Which is a sort of attempt to rewrite American history to say, you know, that Well, anyway, to say certain things about American history and to say that those things are the core,
SPEAKER_01that racism, slavery, that these are actually essential parts of the American story. And so I guess in connection with this, somebody had started buying up things like papers that belonged to the founding fathers and lots of early Americana and just started incinerating it.
SPEAKER_02Oh, I didn't see that coming.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, it's pretty wild. And I can't tell you more about that because I don't know everything about it. I don't have a citation for you or whatever. But anyway, this is what the curator of Beck's private museum told me. I have no reason to think he was fibbing or something like that. But anyway, people were buying up early Americana and destroying it. And so what Glenn Beck started doing was buying it up and... preserving it and then making it available to historians and things like that. And so as we're going through his private museum there,
we got to hold things like the first Bible ever printed in the United States,
SPEAKER_01which included the Deutero canon, by the way, which was fun. Also one of the early Geneva Bibles that came over with the Puritans. Which also included the Deuterocanon. In fact, when Jonathan cracked it open, it cracked open right to the Book of Esdras, which was pretty awesome.
SPEAKER_02The Book of Esdras. Amazing. And then we got to hold a bunch of these other things, including stuff like... George Washington's personal surveyor's compass, which I got to hold with my hands.
SPEAKER_01And I took a picture with it, and I haven't decided if I'm going to post it online or not, because I think some people get Masonic ideas. Some people get really exercised about these things. But I did take a picture with it, and that was pretty cool. And things like a bunch of Washington's other personal papers and the spectacles he gave to Alexander Hamilton and stuff like that. It's all there. What a collection. And you can just pick it up and hold it all. They have a draft of the Declaration of Independence there that still has the paragraph that was eventually removed at the protest of two of
the states about
SPEAKER_01abolishing slavery. And anyway, all this other stuff. Well, one of the things... One of the things they had, there was a bunch of Lincoln stuff. And apparently I actually found out later. Well, I'll tell that story some other time. But anyway, they had a bunch of Lincoln stuff and things like a key to Ford's theater from the night when Lincoln was shot and a lock of Lincoln's hair. And then actually the collar that had been cut off of Lincoln's jacket that still had his blood on it. And these things were preserved,
SPEAKER_01you know, like the fabric things were like pressed under glass, right? Yeah, these are relics. And then also he had a bunch of World War II stuff, you know, uniforms of Holocaust survivors. And then, you know, at one point we were kind of in the World War II section and the curator picks up this big bunch of keys, like, you know, like old school iron, you know, big keys and puts them in my hand. And he says... These are Adolf Hitler's personal keys to the eagle's nest.
SPEAKER_01And I'm like, what am I supposed to do with this information, right? Just like holding this in my hand. Well, then also like we had like Hitler's dinner set and like his little port glasses and those little shot cup with his initials on it. One of Winston Churchill's cigars, which is a good thing that guy was behind glass because I would have lit that sucker up. Um, and like, there's gotta be nothing that makes you, would make you feel more powerful than smoking one of Churchill regards.
SPEAKER_02I feel like, um, and then, uh, the Eagles nest is pretty good.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Right. Pretty, pretty crazy stuff like Tokyo Rose's microphone. What have FDR's wheelchairs? Like all this kind of crazy stuff.
SPEAKER_02Is that just Glenn Beck's job these days? What does he do?
SPEAKER_01That's incredible. It's his hobby. I mean, he literally has Sputnik hanging. Sputnik 2 is hanging over his desk in his office. I was like, oh, that's a cool Sputnik replica. They're like, no, that's not a replica. That was Sputnik? It was Sputnik. So hold on, though, Richard.
SPEAKER_02Our audience is wondering, you're getting to this church question. I feel it coming.
SPEAKER_01No, I am. I'm really close to making the transition here, John. You just got to... I trust you. Listen, Trump is president now. I can do the weave. Okay? Fair point. I can take my time. 24 hours. Absolutely. Okay, so where I'm going with the question is... I think that's something that really struck both Jonathan and I when we were there and we're holding some of these items in our hands, especially like when you get to like, this thing has Lincoln's blood on it. And I just sort of,
I made a little bit of a joke to our tour guide, who's a Protestant.
SPEAKER_01I made a little bit of a joke to him. I said, well, listen, you know, if Lincoln was Orthodox, we'd like put this in a church and people would kiss it, you know? And he kind of laughed nervously about that. And then I said, well, you know, and I didn't really push this, but I thought about it. I thought about it. That, you know, there's actually, there is a temple to Abraham Lincoln in our nation's Capitol. And it's self-consciously a temple. It's not just modeled on classical temples, but if you walk up the stairs, I mean, it's a very impressive edifice. It's, for my mind, it's the most impressive thing in the Capitol.
SPEAKER_01Um, you walk up the stairs and there there's Lincoln enthroned as Zeus, you know, um, on the throne with the fascis on either side of it. And then up behind him on the wall, it says in this temple as in the hearts of those for whom he saved the union. the memory of Abraham Lincoln will be forever enshrined, something to that effect. Now, if you think about just what that is saying, like on its face, the plain meaning of the text, as we used to say in Protestant seminary,
SPEAKER_01is very clearly, Abraham Lincoln is in this temple, but he's also in your heart. And Lincoln saved you, and he saved this country. And it's a self-consciously religious kind of a thing. And we have his relics. In fact, I've been to Lincoln's tomb, which is in Illinois. And if you go up there, up to Lincoln's tomb, there's a huge bust made out of copper, like a bunch of copper pennies melted down.
SPEAKER_01And a huge bust of Lincoln right outside his door. And everything else on it is kind of, you know, shows like the kind of the green verdigris corrosion or whatever the copper shows, except for the nose, which is shiny, copper colored, shiny. And the reason is whenever you enter Lincoln's tomb, you're supposed to reach up and touch his nose for basically good luck or, as we would say, a blessing. So again, here's an icon of Lincoln. You touch it as you go in. Then you get to see his tomb. When Lincoln died, his relics, his body, his relics were paraded around the country on a train.
That was the first time that had ever been done for an American president. And so I just want to point these things out as a kind of a way of answering the question,
SPEAKER_01which is to say that when people do history, they think that what they're doing is this kind of, you know, really objective, you know, third-party observer, you know, stepping outside of the stream of history, stepping outside of the story, and then trying to tell just the facts, man, like, exactly, here's just what happened. But in actuality, Nothing is like that. Even if you try to eliminate the religious or the supernatural element,
SPEAKER_01the thing is that that's not a... It's not a DLC. It's not like an extra module that gets bolted onto reality. It's like, here's reality plus the supernatural. In fact, many Orthodox theologians have suggested that these categories of natural and supernatural are maybe where things start going wrong anyway. This is a different discussion. Oh, that's interesting. I think it's the same discussion, actually. Okay, yeah. So... But the point is that reality naturally takes this shape.
SPEAKER_01And so when Lincoln died, we did all of these religious things, right? We weren't at that point, you know, America, Protestant, Catholic nation, lots of, you know, and also like plenty of atheists, deists, et cetera, running around at the time. But the thing that we were kind of united around was this president, right? This person, this man who then... ascended. I mean, literally, the painting on the Capitol Dome of the United States Capitol Building is called the Apotheosis of George Washington. And it is George Washington ascending through the spheres,
SPEAKER_01being greeted by the goddess Liberty, etc., and then taking his place among the gods. And so all of this stuff is really natural it's really deliberate it's the kind of thing that kind of naturally happens and we're in uh i mean it's weird to be talking about this stuff the day after the inauguration yeah it's good timing on that actually yeah but anyway so that's what i would sort of say is that is that historians think they're doing a different thing and then what they try to do then is turn around and tell the story of the church also without reference to the supernatural and
it's it's a uh
SPEAKER_01Not only should you not do church history that way, but you shouldn't do, you know, secular history as though there were any such thing. You also shouldn't do it in that way.
SPEAKER_02Matthew, just make that distinction. You're not sure there is a distinction.
SPEAKER_00I mean, I don't think there actually is a distinction in reality. I don't think so either. I don't think Richard thinks that either. But certainly, like, the way we do history... And like Richard said, even the way we do church history, you could go read a book about like the history of Russian Orthodoxy. and written by a respectable historian of Russian orthodoxy. And if they're going to mention like Saint Seraphim, it'll be in the context of like, okay, Saint Seraphim was sort of a folk religious phenomenon that's
kind of notable
SPEAKER_00because a lot of people went to him or whatever. It's not because Saint Seraphim was like a god and the mother of God was repeatedly showing up in 19th century Russia and talking to him.
SPEAKER_03Mm-hmm.
SPEAKER_00If you want to talk about what actually happened, well, what actually happened is that the mother of God is a 19th century and a 20th century and a 21st century historical figure, right? In the same way that, you know, Khrushchev is a 20th century historical figure, the mother of God is, right? Like in both of them are, in fact, in her case, she's in the body, you know, both is already resurrected. They're both... doing things, having agency affecting the course of history.
SPEAKER_00But one of them we treat as kind of a historical personage. And the other one is this kind of mythical or religious sort of thing. And we make this distinction. And I just don't think that's a real distinction in actual reality. That's an artificial distinction being made by people. And it leads to all kinds of weirdness in the world because of that.
SPEAKER_01Matthew just said the thing out loud. I'm always like in the Universal History series and stuff like this, I'm always kind of tiptoeing around this stuff because it's too strong of a red pill for some people. They can't get there. But yeah, I mean, that's it. That's the whole idea. And my favorite example of this would be if you take a work of medieval history like B's History of the English Church. Or, yeah, let's just take that one as an example. So there's these stories in Bede's History of the English Church.
Now, just for people who don't know, secular historians take Bede as a pretty reliable witness.
SPEAKER_01Now, there might be some dithering about, well, maybe he's wrong about this, or maybe his source on this particular king's life or something like that's not totally reliable. But in general, people consider Bede to be a pretty careful witness. historian who's faithfully transmitting what he believes to be true. The problem is that when you read Bede, he has all of the stuff in there like when St. Augustine of Canterbury is thinking about turning away because
things are getting hard.
SPEAKER_01He's thinking about calling it off and going back to Rome. St. Peter shows up in the middle of the night and flogs him and tells him, you've got to get back to it. Oh, well, that... And in Bede, this is not, oh, well, he had some kind of a psychosomatic experience that blah, blah, blah. Right, you know, it's just St. Peter showed up in the middle of the night, appeared to him in a dream, and flocked him. And in Bede, that's taken completely at face value. Another one that I like to tell also from the life of St.
SPEAKER_01Augustine of Canterbury is that as he's on his way, Bede records that you know, he's doing miracles, he's raising the dead, et cetera, et cetera, like you do, you know, just sort of, you know, bishop things. And then as he's doing all of this, he gets a letter from Pope St. Gregory the Great who says to him, hey, listen, I've heard you've been raising the dead, working miracles, et cetera, et cetera. And, you know, to make a long story short, he says, listen, This happens to a lot of people. Don't make a big deal about it. Don't let it get in your head.
SPEAKER_01Stay focused on your mission. Don't become puffed up. We've all raised the dead, bro. Don't become too full of yourself. All of this is in beat and it's all transferred in this very matter of fact sort of a way. But when modern historians read Bede, they'll mine him for things like, where did this king live? When did he die? When did this war happen? But then they come across these supernatural elements in the story.
SPEAKER_01And most of the time, they don't even talk about them because they're materialists and they don't believe that sort of thing happens. If they do address it, then they have some kind of a spin on it where they'll treat it like... Maybe this is some kind of a propaganda thing, something like that. But if you read it and read it, it's just very matter of fact. But all ancient sources are like this. Every single ancient source that has to deal with any historical happenings, medieval sources as well, will bring in these elements that we consider to be supernatural. But that is an artificial frame that we put over history.
SPEAKER_02Is it a... So my great grandmother is sort of present in me from time to time. I remember her. I have her skin on some level all these generations later. Is she also a 21st century character in that sense then? Not in a sense that I was just talking about, you know, because the mother of God,
SPEAKER_00is showing up in the 20th century. I see. She is interacting with people. She is doing things very directly. As far as I know, your great-grandmother isn't doing that. She may be standing before the throne of God interceding for people, but she's not... As far as I know, showing up in the flesh and affecting the course of history directly. That's what I'm asserting about the mother of God. I'll give an example that kind of is, you know, so say Catherine,
SPEAKER_00the great martyr Catherine of Alexandria. Early fourth century, she was martyred in Alexandria. The earliest extant account of her life is from, I believe, the 9th century. And, you know, because it's very late that we have surviving evidence for her life, in the 20th century, the Roman Catholic Church, I think under the influence of the Bollandists, actually removed St. Catherine from their calendar of saints. because there's just not enough.
SPEAKER_01Because there will be somebody out there who's like, oh no, we didn't do... I think what they technically did is they took St. Catherine, St. Barber, St. George, some of the other great martyrs and they sort of demoted them to like optional local... I remember that.
SPEAKER_00So St. Catherine, the problem I have, part of the problem I have, it's one of the many problems I have with this, is that the Bollandists, even if you accept their premises, they're ignoring evidence. They're ignoring evidence. Right. Even if you accept the ball in his pharmacies, which I reject, they're ignoring evidence because St. Catherine appeared along with a whole entourage with the mother of God in the 1830s in Russia to St. Seraphim of Sarov and a nun that was with him. And the nun had conversations with I think Barbara was there,
SPEAKER_00too, with each of the women that were with the Theotokos. And these these saints all recounted their stories to her. So we have 19th century eyewitnesses to St. Catherine. So I don't need some source from the 4th century, right? Because we have 19th century sources on St. Catherine, you know? And I think that if you presented that to a modern historian, they'd say that didn't happen, right? That's sort of just a story.
But I think that that's just an assumption that they're making based on premises
SPEAKER_00that they have.
SPEAKER_02So history or the understanding of it changes when large groups of, let's call them academics, simply believe the grave is final? Is that what happened? If you begin with the premise that there is no supernatural or that this pre-modern way of looking at reality is false and that actually we need to be secular materialists,
SPEAKER_00if you start with that premise, then of course you have to reject anything that's contrary to that premise because that was your first principle. And there's definitely also, Matthew, there's a kind of implicit idea that
SPEAKER_01within academia in almost every field, this implicit idea that anybody who is sincere is therefore not a reliable witness. Yeah. Right.
SPEAKER_00Maya, on the topic of St. George, just since you brought up St. George, my grandfather and two of his friends met St. George. in the flesh, right? Like he appeared to them. It's a crazy story, but he would tell that story super matter of factly, you know? Like, oh yeah. And the friends all had the same story and it was just this thing that happened to them and St. George appeared to them. So the idea that like, oh, we don't have evidence of St. George. Dude, we have more evidence of St. George than we do for like my great grandfather.
SPEAKER_00Wow.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Right. Yeah.
SPEAKER_02So it's the experience of the people. It's the accepted experience of the people that allows the historians to speak differently into sort of the void, right? In other words, it's because it's accepted. For instance, if the three and I... So if you took this and let's say that I showed this podcast at like, I don't know, Columbia, where I studied history, it would all just be rebuked. It would just, thanks for playing. Is it because of that that... that history died in the way that we're talking.
SPEAKER_02So it's really a battle of culture, right? It's a battle of civilizations in some level that we're talking about. It's not about history. It's about what we accept. Is that true?
SPEAKER_00Oh, yeah. It's about how you understand reality itself, right? The demons have convinced most people that there are no demons. Right. And that their thoughts are their own thoughts and not being presented to them from external outside parties. Right. That's the deception. And one of the conclusions, one of the byproducts of that is that we would look at history and say, well, look, all of history is this very secular materialist kind of reading. But it's a byproduct of rejecting the existence of the unseen
in our own lives.
SPEAKER_02So then, so I was at the restaurant and I was talking to a friend. I was talking to a friend about something very dear in my life. And at that moment, somebody very dear in my life from that story, now they were like a very small player in that story that I was sharing, came into the restaurant. And my inclination now was to see that as a sign. But my inclination 20 years ago would not have been to see that as a sign. And is that because of essentially my baptism and my being
dipped in orthodoxy that I can see?
SPEAKER_02Or is it going on? Like, do I have to see in order for it to become more true? Can you guys feel what I'm trying to get at in terms of the epistemology of it? Like it's always going on in other words. I have a friend who's a priest in California and there is this couple that he knew and they had a young couple with kids and the wife had like stage four cancer,
SPEAKER_00tried everything, no hope, she's gonna die. Family's not, no religious anything. No, not religious at all. And the priest says, hey, listen, I know this is going to sound crazy to you. But, you know, if you're willing to try it, write a letter to St. John Maximovich in San Francisco and ask him to heal you. And so she's like, look, I don't come about to die. Right. My family, my kids are going to lose their mother. I'll try anything. She writes a letter to St. John, just like because the priest told her to. goes in to get scans done again,
and the cancer's completely gone, right? And so obviously this is going to completely rock the world of this person.
SPEAKER_00I don't even know what the rest of the story for this person was, but this was a couple of years ago. But what the priest told me is that the doctor said, look, all of our previous scans and stuff must have just been wrong. Like we must have just made a mistake the whole time. And it turns out like we've checked now and like you're completely clean. Her family was like her parents were like, hey, you're you're totally like there's nothing supernatural. The doctors just made a mistake. So you're going to like you have first principles and the way you understand
SPEAKER_00reality is going to be derivative of those first principles.
SPEAKER_02Hey, guys, before you get right back. To the show, gratitude travels. Run by our friends Amy and Jamie. It's a South African-based travel company that will take you anywhere in the world. Why South Africa? Well, there's a lot of good traveling in South Africa. And Amy and Jamie are South Africans. They do great trips for us. I want you to go with them. Gratitude Travels. It'll be linked in our show notes.
SPEAKER_02Please do it. Go there right now, Jamie and Amy, and book your trip to wherever, including if you go to Europe, you can go to Georgia and visit our site. You can go to South Africa and go to Mozambique and visit our site in Mozambique. If you want to go to Central America, they're working on that too, but they're pros. Consider your trip with gratitude travel. Oh, and also field workers. You want to do two years? Do something amazing with your life? Do something hard?
SPEAKER_02We're recruiting right now. for Africa and for Central America. Peace out. Back to the show.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, so I made a joke a minute ago about trying not to red pill the normies too fast, but the reason that I say things like that is because there is, and I've definitely seen this happen, like somebody will... start to see the world in this way, and then every time any two things happen, they're like, oh, it's a sign. Oh, it's a sign. What does this mean? What could this possibly mean? I randomly opened my Bible, and it was to this particular verse, and it's on, you know. And so the discernment,
SPEAKER_01there's kind of, you know, the Father's talking about discernment being the highest of the gifts, but I think there's also like a kind of like a low... frequency, you could say like village piety discernment. Not to fantasize too much about village piety. I'm sure people are sinful in villages just like they are everywhere else. But there is a practicality when you live down to the earth and it's like, okay, well, I got to feed the kids today and I got to plow the fields and all these different things.
SPEAKER_01And when you don't have the luxury of sitting in your nice isolated recording studio, you know, just living in your head and stuff like this. But when you kind of live close to the land, a couple of things happen. One is that you are much more in tune, as we have to assume, you know, ancient medieval people, we would have to assume, we know, that they're much more in tune with the natural cycle of the seasons and how things happen, right? And therefore... To them, the idea that God would do something just through the normal
turning of the
SPEAKER_01agricultural cycle is the most natural thing there is. To give an example of this, my personal soapbox, the way that Matthew's is St. Catherine, my personal soapbox is the date of Christmas. And I know there are people out there who like to say, oh, it's probably some date September. Even people that I like like to say that. And it's funny because when you really get down to it, it seems like most people's argument for Christmas not
happening on December the
SPEAKER_0125th is very simply without how could you possibly know what the date is? That's too convenient. Right. Something like that. It's something like that. And the thing that... I think that's bad reasoning. There's a great little book of essays on this, by the way, called The 25th by Joshua Gibbs, who's an Orthodox educator.
SPEAKER_02Oh, I know Joshua.
SPEAKER_01He wrote a book on... It's not just about the dating of Christmas. It's just essays on a variety of Christmassy kind of subjects. But... But usually whenever I talk to somebody, it'll go something like, oh, well, obviously Jesus was actually born in September or October or something like this. I'll say, well, why is that the case? Oh, well, it's because. And then they'll say something like, oh, because shepherds wouldn't be tending their fields in December or something, which is not necessarily true if you know anything about the ancient Middle East. And anyway, so you kind of go down the list of reasons and it comes down to it at the end. They're like, well.
SPEAKER_01Obviously, it's just because we don't really know when it happened. It doesn't really matter if we know anyway, etc. I really do think the church's date is the right date. There are a few different reasons for this. One is, I think it's a little silly that the idea that God wouldn't care to tell us when he was born. But what it really comes down to is this idea that, well, the idea that Jesus would be born in the middle of winter,
the idea that the light would come into the world in the middle of winter,
SPEAKER_01that's just a little too convenient. It lines up a little too nicely. And so people don't, and I think it's because people want that. They want things to line up and they want, you know, the turning of the year, right? which is also part of history, right? History is cyclic, so you have the weekly cycle and the annual cycle and all those different things. When people want it to have meaning and they feel like maybe I want this too much. And so because, again, something that's sincere, something that lines up nicely,
SPEAKER_01stuff like that can't really work. Right.
SPEAKER_02And so it's like a bread in cynicism.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Yeah. And so what I would say is, you know, kind of counter to that. When else would Christ be born? When else would he be born? I mean, when else would the light come into the world except, you know, at its darkest night, at the time of the year when every single culture says we need to have a festival of light right at this moment. Right. And so and then there's all these. So that's kind of one example. And so one of my favorite examples of this is the idea of like Kyria Pascha,
SPEAKER_01which is, you know, I'm on the new calendar, so we don't we don't get these. But we get as shorter as apostles fast, so you kind of have to weigh the things. Things bounce out. But the idea of the Kyrie Aposca was something the Anglo-Saxons, who were on the Julian calendar, they knew about this and they wrote about it. And how this is the best, most auspicious kind of a thing that can possibly happen to your society would be for you to be alive when Easter and the Annunciation fall on
the same day, or also sometimes when Good Friday and the Annunciation fall on the same day,
SPEAKER_01which can also happen. Only Saturday, which is in a few years. Right. Yes, yes, yes. Yeah, exactly. So there's all kinds of... They were trained to see this stuff and they were habituated to see it as though there really is meaning in the world, but also like... they didn't go crazy over it. Because their assumption was there is meaning, there's always going to be meaning. The reason your great-grandfather can tell the story about meeting St.
George in this very matter-of-fact way is because he probably came from a time in a
SPEAKER_01culture when you would sort of expect something like that to happen. Maybe it didn't happen to you, but you knew somebody it happened to. And so for us, once the switch gets flipped, Like, people go crazy for a little while. They go crazy for a little while until they can kind of get in a mode where they start to see these things. And then, you know, when you're having a conversation about somebody and they walk in, I mean, that's absolutely something. It's something. It's absolutely something.
SPEAKER_01I was actually in your neck of the woods, John. I was in Greenville, South Carolina, and I walked into this. Can I say this here? I walked into a cigar shop, okay? I know, I know. And I walked in, and there were these two guys there. This happened back in June. There were these two guys there, and they're sitting at the table, and they just start staring at me. Just start staring at me. And finally, one of them stands up and walks over to me and says, are you Richard Rowland? He said, yes.
SPEAKER_01He said, we were just talking about your Ethiopia video. And these guys were freaking out. They were completely freaking out. And so I already had plans about how I was going to spend the evening. But I said, well, obviously, this is not a coincidence. we need to i need to sit down and talk to these guys and and that's the reason i'm here right and so we sat down we had a conversation and i i love that there's some of the reason came to church with me the next day which was is
that right yes so you can't you still might not have been able to hang out with them but you can't
SPEAKER_02take that lightly
SPEAKER_01Right, exactly.
SPEAKER_02Yes. You're not in control. I think it's a difference between humility and a little bit of arrogance that we've acquired in the modern world, which is, yeah, of course these things are happening. Of course it's a sign. And also that doesn't mean that I'm suddenly in charge of it all. I still have to, I'm still subject. I'm still the create, I'm the creature. And, but I'm seeing now clearly, but that doesn't mean I'm controlling. And so there is some balance. I like what you're saying. I kind of get that. Matthew, do you think... Yeah, go ahead.
SPEAKER_02No, I was just going to say this. Do you think... So Richard and Jonathan do universal history. You and I were talking about sacramental history or something.
SPEAKER_00Sacred history. Sacred history. In a way, I don't think we're talking about different things. No, no, no.
SPEAKER_01It's the same project. Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_01I mean, Matthew's playing, like I said, he's saying the, what I usually try to do is take stories that people don't take seriously and And then try to show the way that those stories have meaning and it actually makes this particular people group's self-understanding, you know, actually it makes sense, it's valid, it's coherent, right? The thing that people are always asking for is, okay, well now do it for America, right? Or now do it for like some current, you know, but I mostly stick to kind of the ancient civilizations and
show the ways that they
SPEAKER_01experienced history, especially in relation to the gospel and in relation to the Orthodox Church. the tricky thing with doing it with a recent civilization or culture, and I'm going to do it, but the difficulty is that you're going to really upset a lot of people. Yeah, yeah. Because... Okay, so America, right? we have this really complex mythology built. And I'm like, I love America.
I love giving grief to my friends who are not from America about how much better
SPEAKER_01America is than where they live, et cetera, et cetera. So I'm not a hater. I'm definitely, you know, a little bit the other direction, if anything, you know, like a little chauvinistic or something, right? But when you start calling the history of the 20th century, to go back to what Matthew was saying, I'm going to hand the ball off to you here, Matthew, so you just get ready to catch it.
SPEAKER_02You know how Richard rolls, right? He'll hand it, but he might have to steal it a little bit.
SPEAKER_01A little bit. When you tell this story of the 20th century, of course, we're like, America, America. Look at all the great things that America is doing, et cetera, et cetera. But the secret history of the 20th century, or the sacred history of the 20th century, whatever you want to call it, involves just a whole lot of people who weren't American. Right. And it's funny because growing up evangelical, you definitely go to these things where they would try to tell,
SPEAKER_01you know, they would tell stories. And don't get me wrong. I definitely believe God and the saints have been active in American political life or, you know, like in the story of the United States and the world wars and all those different things. Like, I'm not saying God is absent, but. What you don't have, typically speaking in the story of 20th century America, is the Theotokos showing up and talking to somebody. You don't have a St. Paisios. You don't have these figures like this. And so I think that... If you were to look back on the 20th century in a few hundred years,
SPEAKER_01or actually, let's better say, if you were to take a heavenly perspective on the history of the 20th century and the things that have happened in the ways that God has worked, you'd have to say, actually, all of the most important things and the most important people, well, most of them didn't live in America.
SPEAKER_00That's fair. Yeah, I think that's fair.
SPEAKER_01And that's a really hard pill for Americans.
SPEAKER_00So if we'd start with the premise, which I obviously do, that the Orthodox Church, we are the people of God. We are the body of Christ and we are the people of God. Then that is the focal point for human history. even if numerically it's small and from a worldly perspective, it's weak, right? In the same way that ancient Israel from our perspective, we would say ancient Israel is the focal point for the ancient world.
SPEAKER_00Even if, you know, yeah, you can go back and say, but they were like this dinky little kingdom and they weren't that big of a deep wall and whatever. Like, okay, but that's not, that's only from one vantage point, you know?
SPEAKER_01Archaeologically, the most important king in terms of ancient Israel, like in terms of stuff that has survived from him is Omri, Ahab's father. Omri gets like two lines. In the Old Testament, it basically says this guy was a jerk and then he died. And he bought a hill. And he bought a hill. He was a jerk. And then he died. And then you get all the stuff about Ahab and Elijah. Well, why Ahab and Elijah? Because Elijah is actually the most important person from that era. And it's his story is the real story.
SPEAKER_01Because he's part of the people of God. And obviously because he's a saint.
SPEAKER_00So we can even do this like people even do this with church history. So you'll look at Mount Athos and they'll say like, look, there was this period of deep decline in the 20th century because numerically Mount Athos collapses in the 20th century. There's just a fraction of the number of monks that there were at the beginning of the 20th century. And, you know, buildings are in disrepair. Everything's kind of a mess. And yet this is like when you have a whole bunch of wonder working saints on Mount Athos. Right. So was it a golden age for Mount Athos or was it a period of decline for Mount Athos?
SPEAKER_00And the answer is kind of both. Right. It kind of is both. Another like I'll say something really provocative and offensive.
SPEAKER_02Go for it. I believe that the reason that the Orthodox Church caused the COVID-19 pandemic.
SPEAKER_00I think that the Orthodox Church caused the COVID-19 pandemic. And the reason I think this is because if we look at reality holistically and we see that all of these things are connected, right? If you were an ancient person and there was a plague, you would say, what sin caused the plague? Right. What happened? What did we do that that that that like who sinned that this happened? Right. And maybe not. Maybe it wasn't someone's sin. But that's the first place to look is like in repentance.
SPEAKER_00Right. So certainly the first part.
SPEAKER_01First place people look at the Bible like, yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. In the Bible, yeah. There's something terrible happens and then a plague breaks out. And then what happens? The priests have to intercede and, you know, incense and whatever it is, right?
SPEAKER_02Standard ancient world, yes, move.
SPEAKER_00So why is that different if we're Christians? Why on earth would we think that something has changed? Because it makes you feel bad because you're actually trying to identify the real problem. I would argue that what happened right before COVID happened that effectively excommunicated most of the Orthodox Church for a period of time. What happened? Well, there was a great schism in the Orthodox Church. I'm not even talking about church politics. I'm just saying there was a schism in the Orthodox Church, and then there was a global pandemic that shut down human activity and
SPEAKER_00excommunicated the faithful. Hmm, that seems like that's not a coincidence. And if we look at the world from a kind of holistic way, we would have to say that's the proximate cause. Maybe that's not the how COVID happened, but that is the why COVID happened. And unfortunately, I don't think we have taken that lesson. We being those who are within the church, we should be reasoning that way. Yes. Yeah. We should see that the church,
just like Israel itself, was the priest of the world, right?
SPEAKER_00The priest for the nations, right? The Orthodox Church is the priest for the nations, right? And are we fulfilling our priestly function? Are our leaders fulfilling? functioning in a healthy manner as priests, if that fails, we should expect there to be tumults and problems and catastrophes.
SPEAKER_02And so sacred history is sort of plotting the pain and the sin within the practitioners of orthodoxy. And then sort of understanding everything that happens in the world from that causal point. That would be a sacred history, is understanding the world. It would be an aspect of reading things through a sacred history lens, I believe. Which is how hagiography reads. Whenever you read about how the saints are understanding things,
SPEAKER_02they do start with sin and sort of ebbs out from there. And that is true.
SPEAKER_01Gosh, that's hard for me to... It's a rough pill to swallow. It is. But I mean... It's the, I mean, forget, you know, people can argue all they want to about, you know, is orthodoxy the true church, et cetera, et cetera. But like, like just, even if you just forget all of that and you, and you say, how are we going to approach the history in the holy scriptures? Right. Is, is what's actually the most, you know, now obviously Christianity is important because it's big.
SPEAKER_01And this is the, man, I avoided an argument with somebody on social media this week, so you should all be proud of me, who wanted to basically say like, listen, orthodoxy, you know, Okay, so there have been a lot of people, I guess, finally noticing that something is happening. And so there's just been a lot of kind of flack directed our way, which is, you know, everybody should be cool and mature about it because it's actually a good thing. But anyway, so just said something like, well, American, you know,
SPEAKER_01American Christianity is never going to look like this. And American, you know, orthodoxy is so small. And so it'll never be big or relevant. And they use those things like it'll never matter. That's what they said. It'll never matter in America. And the implicit assumption there, first of all, is that things are only important if they're big. But if you think about the situation of the church in the book of Acts, we're really talking about you know, like less than 1% of the Roman Empire, right?
And what continues to be an extremely small percentage until about late 4th or
SPEAKER_01early 5th century, a very small percentage of the Roman Empire. Obviously, it seems important to us now because we know what happens with Constantine and we know what happens with Theodosius and we know what happens with the spread of Christianity and the conversion of the empire. But I mean, at the time, At the time, this is a very small, it's even smaller than Bronze Age Israel. But if we go back to Israel and the Bronze and the Iron Age, if we look at the histories of the Old Testament, I mean, what Matthew said is exactly right.
SPEAKER_01And so the question is, you know, what are you going to do with the history in the scriptures, right? How do you read this? You know, because we know there's tons of other more important things happening in terms of, you know, big countries doing big things and big wars happening. And, you know, we know that during the Bronze Age, there was some kind of a world war between the Hittites and the Egyptians, and maybe Israel got, you know, caught in the middle of it. And there are like two small references, you know, to that in the whole Old Testament, right? Because it actually wasn't the most important thing. The most important thing was whether or not the people of God
would remain faithful
SPEAKER_01to God or not. And so, I mean, even if you can't swallow that pill for the 20th century... I think there's a lot of basis to what Matthew is saying just in reading the scriptures and just asking the question, how seriously am I going to take them? And I know there are people out there who don't think you should take the scriptures seriously at all as history. But the reason they think that is because they are proceeding with these materialist presets. Yes.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, that's right. But it does ask a lot of... Well, I would say this. It should be a hard... Would you call it a black pill? It is. Or a red pill. But here's what I want to say.
SPEAKER_01I can't keep up with the colors. I can't keep up with the colors either. It's too much.
SPEAKER_02Here's what I want to say. I think understanding the L.A. fires... as somehow related to that which takes place in the sacred space, which is the church. I get it. I think that's the proper disposition, but I think when I get into trying to figure out the how, like, okay, how is it St. John?
SPEAKER_00Well, I think that's dangerous to do too much. Yes, I think that's dangerous. With COVID, I feel like it's so... crystal clear, windingly obvious that I can say it out loud, even if it might be appalling to people. Because as an Orthodox Christian, I'm like, okay, giant schism, plague. I mean, I don't know, man, let's get a straight line. But with other things, it's not that we can just draw these straight lines. I don't think that's appropriate, right? Because there's just sin in the world and sin causes suffering.
And those kinds of things are not necessarily clear cut, how that all relates to each other.
SPEAKER_01And historically, you know, in our tradition, in our church, the people who can see the pattern are prophets. They're holy men, right? And they can actually see the connection between these different things. And it's not, by the way, saying that connection is the only connection between those things. Like God can be, you know, a plague that's judgment for one people, can also have other purposes that are going on. Same thing with fire, same things with lots of different things. I mean, who are we to put constraints on God? But the point is that... I think the point would be that if you're not one of those
special people who's
SPEAKER_01been given that gift of discernment, then what you need to focus on is not, hey, who can I blame for this? But rather... How has my sin contributed to this?
SPEAKER_00That's right. Absolutely. And even with the COVID example, I think that's the case, right? Because I'm seeing this as a... Look, I do church history, right? And obviously, this is present day, so it's a little hard to do that with current events. But in 100 years, the version of me, the me in 100 years is going to look back and make that connection, right? But that doesn't mean that in the present, it's like, well, what have I done? I've somehow been excommunicated? Like I've done something, right? I've sinned. I need to do something about that.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. Yeah. Which does seem like a proper response given all the other... sacred lessons I've learned as an Orthodox for 30 years, it always sort of does start with my repentance and my awareness of my own sin. I think that's why I was not enjoying the way you were describing it, Matthew, because the way you're describing it made me feel like I needed to know. For instance, I have a certain brother who's a priest and he makes
connections
SPEAKER_02And I think he made the same connection you did. And he was using the saints of the 20th century. And the way you described it right now is the way he described it. And I would always, you know, these are like just phone calls between he and I. And I would just, I would want to shed it because it felt like he knew something or was very, very, very, very strongly opinionated about something that still didn't connect for me. But I don't think you can dismiss it, whether you're just a priest like himself or whether he's
reading the saints or
SPEAKER_02you're reading the saints. I do believe it's connected. I'm not sure I know how, and I don't want to wade in where I don't know how.
SPEAKER_00I don't think the mechanisms are for us to understand. I think we can observe the patterns, and the history provides us with a lot of examples of patterns. That doesn't mean that we can then get in there and figure out how the mechanisms all work, because I don't think it's all mechanistic.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, you could say that a big part of the materialistic approach to history actually is saying the mechanism is the most important thing. I give you a good example of this. I did my undergrad in history and economics. Two great tastes that go great together, said Karl Marx. The driving way of understanding and talking about
SPEAKER_01history for the last 150 years, maybe 200 years now, has been thinking about it in terms of economics and thinking about it in terms of the distribution of power. And that's the only way that most people are capable of thinking about it. Christians fall into this trap all the time. People doing church history fall into this trap all the time. And so they'll say, all right, they're writing up a history of, for instance, let's pick something non-controversial, the fourth ecumenical council. Right? Where they'll say, oh, well, it was really just like these political things and these
economic factors,
SPEAKER_01all these different things. And that's why they were talking past each other. And so the stuff that was, you know, the church decided to counsel on doesn't actually matter. We should kind of like sweep that under the rug and kind of move on from it. I've heard that. Matthew knows the sort of argument that I'm talking about. The problem with this is that it's like assuming that because you can say, well, here's the material cause, right? Here's the material cause of some miracle that happens, right?
SPEAKER_01The cancer goes away. It was like, oh, well, your body just fought it off really fast or the treatment was extra effective or whatever. And so we won't say something was a miracle and we won't say God intervened in some way until we can absolutely say, look, there's no material cause whatsoever for this thing that happened. And there is stuff like that. But that is not really how things have ever worked. So you can think of things like economics and military
movements and things like that as being sort of the material causes of things that happened in history. But the point of what I think Matthew was trying to argue for is that that's
SPEAKER_01actually not the real story. And you can say, yeah, okay... there were material causes, economic forces, military power, etc. But if you fixate on those things, if you fixate on those things, then you're going to miss what the real story is. And so you could say, yeah, there was this lab, they were doing gain-of-function research, like whatever you believe about COVID and all this stuff. Like you could say, oh, that's why it happened. So it didn't have anything to do with my sins.
SPEAKER_01It had to do with... you know, Fauci's sins, or Fauci, I don't know how to say his name, had to do with his sins, or it was the Democrats, or it was the elites, or it was the, right. And so actually using the, putting a kind of focus on the material cause is a way of, among other things, shifting things away from the uncomfortable discussion, which is actually, how should I be living my life right now? How should I be living out my repentance? Which is always, which is actually always the focus of these things. You remind me of the same mistake I think moderns have made
with anthropology.
SPEAKER_02Anthros, what is a human being? They just skip this part of us called noose or spirit. And so we're animals, and that's not the whole story. You know, it's not the whole story. There tends to be a lot of focus on the how things happen and the how gets mistaken
SPEAKER_00for the why. Yeah. I think that's one of the big problems in many respects, but in history, because we're talking about history, I think that's one of the big problems in history. One quick, quick story. I have a priest friend who was a priest in Hawaii when a few years ago there was a big hurricane that was heading toward one of the islands and it was going to be devastating. And so everybody's panicking. There's just, it's here it is, it's coming, right? Brace yourselves. So he and his people go into the church. It's the church that has the wonder working icon,
the Iveron icon of the mother of God.
SPEAKER_00So they went into the church and they start praying like a mulyebin, I think, to the mother of God. And as soon as the mulyebin ends, the hurricane disappears, just disappears. And so you can watch on radar, like I could send it to you, right? We could show it, put it on the screen. You can watch the hurricane on the radar kind of just go away at this one point. And I asked the priest, I was like, what time, how long was the service? Like what time was it? He was like, oh, it started here and ended about here. Right when the service ended is when the hurricane went away, right? Now on the meteorologists are like, this was amazing.
There's this unexpected like wind shear thing that happened and they can explain
SPEAKER_00meteorologically like, oh yeah, this is a thing that can happen and it did happen and this was great. It was a good outcome, right? So that tells you how the mother of God stopped the hurricane, right?
SPEAKER_02That's right.
SPEAKER_00The mother of God stopped the hurricane, right?
SPEAKER_01An even more proximate example, there was that massive tropical storm that was headed to Florida. And it was supposed to hit Tarpon Springs. In fact, we had people visiting our parish who had basically just relocated from Tarpon Springs rather than try to wait the storm out. This happened, what, earlier this fall, I think? I can't remember the name of the tropical storm now, but... And then the Orthodox Christians in Tarpon Springs, Florida, they took relics of St. Nicholas and an icon of St. Nicholas out and they blessed the shoreline.
SPEAKER_01And then literally 30 minutes later, the storm was just gone. It just blew over. And they were expecting it was going to be really catastrophic, all of this stuff. And then the storm just dissipated. And it's very, very clear to somebody in the ancient world, St. Nicholas stopped the storm, as he, by the way, is well known to do. And he has a reputation for doing these sort of things. And we asked him and he did it. And glory to God. That's very simple.
SPEAKER_01Again, you could say, oh, well, we were wrong about what we thought the hurricane was going to do, or there were these other meteorological forces we didn't take into account when we were estimating. All these different ways to explain how St. Nicholas stopped the storm. But the thing that you should see is, glory to God, through the intercessions of St. Nicholas, we've been delivered from this terrible catastrophe. So what should we do? Well, listen, you've been given another day to repent. You've been given a little more time to get your life in order. You should maybe start actually asking the saints for help and
intercession more
SPEAKER_01often because they really do listen. That's what you take away from that. Exactly.
SPEAKER_02That's right. That's the control part, because as a modern, I want control over me. I'm talking about me, John. I want control over something, but the control is in the prayer. I mean, I can go right now. I can get off this call, go sit in front of my icons, and I can pray. That's what I have control over. God, I don't need all the hows. That's very interesting, Richard. There's so many stories, and you guys have a lot of those stories. You can share more, but I got a quick question. Trump did not put his hand on a Bible.
SPEAKER_02That's hot on the internet right now.
SPEAKER_01I didn't actually see that. I did watch the inauguration, but I guess the camera, the angle of the broadcast I was watching, I've watched every inauguration that I've been alive for as far as I know. Again, I am really interested in these things, but I didn't see that he didn't touch the Bible. I saw that there was some kind of a rush or something, and they couldn't get the Bible up there in time when they started. Yeah,
SPEAKER_02it's a big Twitter blow-up or whatever, I guess, because, you know, now, what does that mean? It's very interesting.
SPEAKER_01Is he really even president? Well, I mean, so this is... It's... It's not nothing. So it's an interesting opportunity to talk to people about why we swear oaths on Bibles. Right? And so in the Middle Ages, you could take an oath on one of two things. That is, with your hand on one of two things. So very often when kings would swear oaths, whether it was at their coronation or to make some kind of a treaty,
SPEAKER_01there's a famous story where Edward, the confessor, and... William the Bastard, William the Conqueror, as he was later known. It's one of the perks of conquering a country is you can change your nickname. I did not know that.
SPEAKER_02William Conqueror and William the Bastard is the same person.
SPEAKER_01Yes. He was an illegitimate son. Bastard is a technical term in this case. Makes sense, yeah. So he's called William the Bastard, William of Normandy, and then eventually he conquered England and became known as William the Conqueror. But anyway, the whole reason there's a question of succession between William and Harold Godwinson is because of this oath that Harold is supposed to have taken on some relics of a saint when he was washed up on the coast of Normandy.
SPEAKER_01And so anyway, it's not important. The point is that when people swore oaths in the Middle Ages, they would do it on one of two things. They would either put their hands on the relics of a saint or they would put their hands on the gospel book. Because typically speaking, you didn't have a Bible all in one volume that comes a lot later. But that's the origin of the idea of oath-taking. And in fact, people forget, but oath-taking is one of the things that the radical reformers tried to do away with.
SPEAKER_01So for instance, Quakers, early Methodists, et cetera, one of the things, and a lot of Puritans, especially the more strict ones, one of the things that they tried to get rid of was all oaths whatsoever. And people sometimes think this means like swearing or something, but it really means any kind of a formal oath. Because if you take a formal oath with your hand on a holy object, you are saying there is a holy object and I'm going to bind myself to it And that object is going to become a medium of God's grace if I
keep the oath, and it's going to become a medium of God's judgment if I don't keep the oath. That is what you say when you put your hand on something and swear an oath.
SPEAKER_01And eventually, and so this is one of those weird things, because there were religious sects in England, for instance, in the Going all the way, I don't know if anybody has ever seen, you guys have seen Master and Commander. And anyway, one of the things that comes up in the books, if you read the Aubrey Manturans series, is this question of oaths. Because there are certain characters who belong to very anti-high church, very anti-sacramental religious sects.
SPEAKER_01And therefore, they refuse to swear oaths when they would, you know, like enter, so that, you know, entering the Royal Navy, something like that. And so anyway, it's, but there were these religious acts in, in England and in the early days of the United States who would not swear oaths, which would mean by the way that they, certain things they couldn't do. Like they couldn't, um, couldn't hold political office, couldn't be in the military, you know, stuff like this. Well, you'll find it interesting, Richard, a lot of the comments that
SPEAKER_02I was just reading this somehow. I don't even know how it came to me. But a lot of the comments were of that ilk, which was, he doesn't need to do that anyway because you shouldn't be swearing an oath. It doesn't matter. And this is what, it doesn't matter what he says. It just matters what he does. Yeah. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. So I always think I kind of got into this thing yesterday, unfortunately, on Twitter, like all Twitter posts, it should have just been kept to myself. But I kind of got into this thing about spontaneity in prayer and whether or not a prayer should be, you know, especially a public prayer that you're doing in a public place, you know, to commemorate a solemn occasion, whether or not that should be something that is spontaneous. There's a great book called Rituals of Spontaneity by my friend Dr. Lori Branch, which actually examines this idea that arises at the beginning
of the Enlightenment
SPEAKER_01and starts in England with the whole prayer book controversy. But basically, it's the idea that most people take for granted now that the more spontaneous something is, the more sincere it is. But actually, if you think about it, A, that's dumb. Like, if you just think about it, like, on its face, that's very dumb. Like, the idea that the less that I think about something, the more sincere it is. Like, no. Like, if something is really important to me, I'm going to spend, and by the way, I don't think anybody's prayers at the inauguration were
totally spontaneous.
SPEAKER_01Like, obviously, the guy was really thinking about what am I going to do, what am I going to say, and it kind of becomes, when you're on television, it becomes kind of this performance art. This is a different conversation. But just the idea that that the less that I think about something, the more off the cuff it is, the more I care about it. Like, try applying that to your marriage. Try applying that to, like, a test at school. Like, just be like, because this is the most important test I'm going to take. I'm taking the SATs, so I'm going to do zero prep because it's so important.
SPEAKER_01You know, like, it would be nonsense to apply this to anything. But the funny thing is that we really know, like, deep down, we have this intuition that it's not true. because when it comes to a wedding, although weddings have gotten so much- I might fight you on this a little bit,
SPEAKER_02but go ahead.
SPEAKER_01Okay, let's go.
SPEAKER_02All right, well, there's a Georgian phrase that says, when it's time to toast or to pray, don't let it go from your heart to your head, allow it to travel directly to your mouth, because the vulnerability of not having practiced it will allow for it to be more true. And so it's not a zero in my mind.
SPEAKER_00Although I would say even for something like that, in a context of Georgia, for example, you have been around Orthodox prayers your entire life. When I, as a cradle Orthodox Christian, am in a situation where I need to spontaneously pray, it is going to sound like a prayer I read out of a prayer book. because I'm going to use all the turns of phrase and all of the form and everything is going to look you and if you guys from an outside perspective, you might be like,
SPEAKER_00did you memorize an Orthodox prayer? Right. So I think in a culture like Georgia that's steeped in Orthodoxy, that may be a different context. But if you don't have that rootedness you know, where whatever spontaneously comes out of your mouth is going to sound like an Orthodox prayer, like in Georgia, you know, then it becomes whatever, what's in there that's going to come out. Right.
SPEAKER_01But also a toast is a toast is not church.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_01And it's not a note of offer. A toast is an inherently less formal setting. Right. And so, so I'm now they're obviously, you know, I've done a few Supras with you. Obviously there is a formality like to the, to the Supra. Yeah. There's a structure, but it's, but that, but it's, but it's kind of loose. It's kind of loose. And part of the reason, and you've never told me this, but I have, you can tell me if I'm wrong, John, but I've sort of intuited this from the ones that I've been to. And you always tell this anecdote,
but you only ever tell it once somebody has gone way too long with their toast. I've done this with you several times now and every time you tell it it's because somebody got up and they went way too long with their toast and then you're like listen this needs to be a little more from the heart what are you saying well
SPEAKER_01you're really saying like stop sitting there and thinking about, okay, how am I going to impress people with the thing that I'm going to say? Because there's always the one guy at the Supra who's like, all right, I got this thing locked and loaded. I knew I was coming to this. I've been working on my toes for three days. I've got it chambered. But that impulse on his part is because he's making us toast into something more important than it is, right? Because there's an idea, again, that something is important to me.
SPEAKER_01If a lot hinges on this moment, then it's got to be certain words. And so that's the thing. It's not even so much the idea of it's got to be long or prepared. It's the idea that there are certain words which are only appropriate for certain times. And so with the supra, this applies as well. There are certain words that you have to use as keys to open up certain parts of the super. If I want to give a toast, there's a certain word I need to say. If you want to give me the toast, if you want to let me be Tamada for a little bit,
SPEAKER_01there are certain words that you say to kind of pass that over to me. And the fact that we use those words instead of just saying, hey, John, can I give a toast? If I went to your thing and I said, hey, John, can I give a toast? That would be super disrespectful of the whole project that we're doing. And so that's kind of what I mean, is this idea that there are certain phrases, there are certain words you have to use. And so when we hit the most important moments, then there's a sort of repeat after me that has to happen.
SPEAKER_01And that is part of what having your hand on the Bible means. Because you've hit, here's actually the most kind of important moment. And so what we all know is... Trump shouldn't just get up and say, hey, guys, I'm not going to do a Trump impression. Trump shouldn't just get up and say, hey, guys, I'm going to be a really great president. I'm going to be the greatest president ever. Like there should be a repeat after me where the justice says, say these words and you say them and you have your hand on something that everybody at least agrees should be holy and that we kind of collectively
should hold as sacred.
SPEAKER_01And the fact that The fact that there's fewer and fewer things that we have in common, even as Christians, fewer and fewer things that we are able to hold sacred together is a symptom of the world coming apart. I talked a bunch. No, no.
SPEAKER_02Matthew, we're getting toward the twilight here.
SPEAKER_01Go ahead, Matthew. Yeah, I just think there's a strong case to be made for formality. And I think even in the supra, that's there. And it can be really short phrases, you know, like, again, just the little phrases that you use as keys to kind of unlock.
SPEAKER_02Sagradzello. Yeah, you're... I think you're making a great... What I'm trying to get away from is the curation of the idea into something like a speech. And you're right. Yeah, absolutely. That's still necessary in some settings. In some settings, you have to do it.
SPEAKER_01But also, we don't want an oath of office to be a speech. And the problem with a lot of the prayers at the inauguration is that they were also speeches. Part of the problem around this is that there's literally no such thing as an extemporaneous prayer. because everybody has prayers in mind, prayers that they've heard people. And if you don't have something to read from, you just fall into the patterns of speech that you're familiar with. In the tradition I grew up in, that sounds like, dear Heavenly Father,
SPEAKER_01dear Lord, we are truly thankful, dear Lord. That's a great point, Richard. They sound the same. You're right. That's not an extemporaneous prayer. You're just saying the same prayer that you always say for dinner. There is nothing wrong with that, but maybe there are better prayers to say for dinner.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, that's right.
SPEAKER_01Right. And so in that sense, I totally agree with you, but I think actually what you're saying is an example of the importance of formality, right? The importance of, you know, because one of the things that it does is it sort of binds you down to a certain brevity, right? So you're putting less and less of your ego into the thing and you just kind of say the words. And... That was actually, even for me, like doing the Supra, I definitely had that moment. It took me like two or three Supras to have that moment where I was like,
SPEAKER_01actually, you know what? It would just be okay to say to my children, they're wonderful.
SPEAKER_02Matthew, you haven't come, but we're inviting you now.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah, we're going to do it. Come to the restaurant. I would love to. Matthew,
SPEAKER_02give us your take real quick on how maybe the sacred history concept, because we're in the twilight of our conversation right now.
SPEAKER_01No, we're going to go way over.
SPEAKER_02My editor's going to yell at me.
SPEAKER_01We're going to go for hours.
SPEAKER_02I know we can. I love it, but I'm told not to.
SPEAKER_00I bumped my next thing, so we're good.
SPEAKER_02Matthew, like... Do it for us maybe a little bit about the American moment, history, Trump, and then maybe how you see it connected in some ways if you do it all to sacred history.
SPEAKER_00Is that possible? I mean, I've talked about the present a lot, but I actually think that's dangerous. I said something about COVID. I talk about meteorological events. I think there's a danger there because we don't have perspective. I think that there is a frame within which we should be understanding reality. That frame of understanding reality applies, as I see it, to all of reality, to my personal life, to my daily life,
SPEAKER_00to the way I look at history, to the way I look at current events. Everything should be viewed within this same kind of framework of understanding, which is that there are spiritual powers that are interacting with our sort of physical what we can see there's an unseen that is just as real as the scene and we sort of ignore that to our peril and if we ignore it when we're talking about history we will miss the the right way of
understanding history so if you look at ancient israel from a purely secular materialist historical perspective you would say there's nothing really that big of a deal it's not important why why
SPEAKER_00are we paying so much attention to these people But that's because you've basically missed most of the story, most of what's actually going on because you're focusing just on some bare physical sort of realities. And so when we look at history, I think it's important to see the hand of God in history. We can't necessarily, like we talked about, understand the mechanisms exactly, right? But to understand, you see the hand of God,
but you also see the influence of the demonic.
SPEAKER_00And you also see... So to understand, for example, I've referred to the period around World War I, end of World War I, Bolshevik Revolution, Greco-Turkish War, early 1920s chaos, right? I would say that was an end of the world. The world ended in a world ended after World War I in that kind of the years after World War I. Yeah, for sure. For sure. You can look and understand that from a purely secular way,
SPEAKER_00from a secular historical perspectives. And the Orthodox Church is going to seem like a side character, right? And you're going to have all kinds of economic explanations and these kinds of things. But I think if we're looking at things in a holistic way, we would see there are spiritual forces at play. And those spiritual forces are at play all the way up to the present, right? And it starts to create weird cognitive dissonances when you start to look at the world in this way. So there's this point in the 1950s where a literal god...
SPEAKER_00testified before a Senate subcommittee hearing, which was St. John Maximovich. He shows up in Washington, D.C., and he testifies before this subcommittee. And I look at it and say, okay, I know people who knew St. John. I've talked to people who knew St. John. St. John was a little G God, right? St. John could walk through walls. He could bend space time. I have firsthand accounts of St. John bending space time, right?
SPEAKER_00He could do all these amazing things. And he's also like showing up and like dealing with senators. And lobbying the government and giving testimony. That's right.
SPEAKER_02Pouring soup on his head.
SPEAKER_00It's the same person, right? And at that moment when... This is something some of you guys were alluding to earlier. At that moment in 1952 or whatever, he's the most powerful person in the United States. When he was there in Washington DC, he's the most powerful man in America.
SPEAKER_01You wrinkle a lot of people's brains with this. Good stuff, though. Yeah.
SPEAKER_02So that changes your whole perspective, right?
SPEAKER_00But what I want to emphasize is it's not this parallel story. that's running parallel to the kind of the straight history, it's all together, right? It's all smushed together. You can't pull them apart. It's artificial to pull them apart. When you put them all together, yeah, it breaks your brain a little bit. It hurts. It's hard to understand. But it's reality, right? So you had like St. Porphyrios and St. Jacobus of Evia and St. Paisios as young men in the same 1950s period were both,
you had two gods in the Greek army fighting against the communists in the Greek
SPEAKER_00civil war, right? They had two gods, right? in their army. Okay? That's a weird thing to say.
SPEAKER_01People are flinching every time you say, God, Matthew.
SPEAKER_00Aren't they Richard?
SPEAKER_02People right now, the comments are filling up. Just not yet.
SPEAKER_01It is technically correct, which is the best kind of correct. I mean, yeah, but people are definitely going to like, this is going to be difficult for some people to- Let me read something from St.
SPEAKER_00Maximus the Confessor. St. Maximus the Confessor said, we are made gods and sons of God and the body and limbs and the members of God, right? There are all these sayings of the church fathers that talk about us becoming gods. Gods by grace, not capital G God, but still, right? And I think it's important to make people squirm a little bit, right? When we talk about the saints, especially these wonder-working saints,
SPEAKER_00it's just like, no, actually, actually, there's a reason why St. Paul and Barnabas, remember, they got mistaken. Right, right, right.
SPEAKER_03Jupiter and Mercury, yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_00Jupiter and Mercury. And so they're like... Because they're like doing God things, right? They're doing the only kind of people that do this are gods, right?
SPEAKER_01I always like the assumption that because Paul is talking the most, he must be the less important of the two. That's my favorite thing in the book of Acts. That is awesome. It's so great. It's such an old world assumption. It's like this guy is talking the most. He must not be in charge.
SPEAKER_02Therefore, he's the pauper.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I mean, you're right. It is important to shock people. I mean, I don't know if I've ever told you guys what I always tell new catechumens. I'm the catechist at St. Seraphine Cathedral here in Dallas. And what I always tell new catechumens is, all right, so the basis of this religion is that we eat God to become God. That's the only thing you're here for. Everything else is secondary to that goal. And you should be weirded out by that.
SPEAKER_02That's a great thing you tell them.
SPEAKER_01It's a great thing I've heard you say. If you don't get weirded out, then what you're going to think is that the Orthodox Christian faith is just one other religion among a bunch of different options. And what you're going to think is that maybe it's just like downloadable content that I can add on to whatever tradition I came from and just sort of be like, let me take... you know, this upbringing and add icons to it and boom, there we go. I'm, I'm Orthodox. Um, and it really needs to be actually shocking and,
SPEAKER_01uh, offend your sensibilities a little bit because this is a, it's a crazy thing. And, and people in the ancient world got offended all the time. Like the, the whole reason there was a council of Nicaea is because the idea that God would have become flesh. It was a big problem. Was a big problem for these people. Yeah.
SPEAKER_02Well, I'll tell you, one of the things that, you know, that the movie we're working on, Christianity's sort of the controlling image, the controlling idea. We got a blessing to go in a couple of months to go film. I think it's Samota Petra. They have the hand of St. John the Baptist. You know, it's the fleshy relic of St. John. Yeah. Is it Chrysostom's hand or St.
SPEAKER_01John the Baptist? No, it's St.
SPEAKER_02John the Baptist.
SPEAKER_01Okay, okay.
SPEAKER_02And they bring it out to bless the water. I think it's every month. There's a vigil. But they don't allow filming. But I think we have a blessing. We're working on it. But I tell folks who I want in the movie, non-orthodox, that sort of the controlling images is the priest holds the hand that baptized the creator, you know, the king of all. And we're going to say that there's something like a ripple that starts there and goes out.
SPEAKER_02And so what's a Christian? I don't know. There's all these ripples. Let's figure it out. But there's a center. There's got to be a center. So the controlling image of the film is that there it is. You talk about offended. People are like, first of all, what's the hand? What's that about? And the second one, so you're saying that there is like a center? Yeah, well, of course. Aren't you saying that? You're a Christian. And you realize that's not a good starting point. They get irritated with the starting point. It's fascinating. It's fascinating.
SPEAKER_02I don't know what that means. I mean, we're not trying to offend anybody, but it's a pretty cool controlling image in trying to figure out how Christianity is known in the world, you know?
SPEAKER_01I think when you take all this stuff away, you certainly get the situation where Christianity and converse orthodoxy, people that start YouTube channels talking about orthodoxy struggle with this all the time with this idea that it's just a series of things that I need to believe. Yeah, there you go. So if I think these things and I change to these other things that I'm thinking, then I'm orthodox. Or, you know, I couldn't possibly be orthodox unless I can think all of these different things. And of course, obviously, like, There will be a real change of mind,
like a real repentance that hopefully happens as part of your life of Orthodox Christian.
SPEAKER_01But it really starts with actually the stuff that you do with your body. And that's why my first catechetical lesson is always, here's how we walk into the church.
SPEAKER_00When I'm taught catechism, that's how I start. Exactly.
SPEAKER_01Here's how we walk into the church. We're going to make some vows and then we're going to come inside and here's how we venerate the icons and here's kind of the order that you go in because now you're walking, you know, it's your family. And so who do you say hello to first? Well, obviously Christ. And then who do you say hello to next? Well, obviously his mother. And then you kind of like go down the line from there. That's great. And just teaching people, which for that... That's how, you know, I grew up in a family that was really heavily influenced by Chinese culture, which is still kind of old world in a lot of respects or used to be.
SPEAKER_01And that's how, you know, like if you walk into the room, this is also just like Southern manners too. If you walk into the room, like who do you say hi to first? Well, your grandmother. Like if I walk into the room and I say hi to my brother first before I go over and I greet my grandmother, then it's offensive, right? You know what are my favorite thresholds for new sort of orthobros or whoever?
SPEAKER_02I love, uh, do you burn incense when you pray? Because try doing that around, just new, that's like, what, am I a Hindu? Hold on, what am I doing here? But that's a really important one. The image, first of all, the iconography of it, but also the actual your house changes. Yeah. And I love that one as a threshold. Smells like prayer. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. All right. This came to mind and then we can finish. So the way you're describing, Matthew,
SPEAKER_02this thing, sacred history and really universal history, the same conversation. So here's the thing that just came to mind. Samuel Huntington, you guys, he's a historian. It's sort of, without going deep into it, he sort of said, well, basically there's like eight cultures. I think it's eight. I'm not sure if it's eight or seven, but there's sort of cultural centers and that they're reforming he's writing this in the 90s they're reforming and each he doesn't use these words but i am gonna each has its own sort of sacred history um or it each has its own narrative for
understanding itself because that's what history is it's a way to understand who i am that's the way it
SPEAKER_02should be taught so are we saying that Yes, it appears that way, but there's really just one. And thanks for playing. And there may be wars because of these sacred histories, but there's one in the end that will be revealed. Do I have that right?
SPEAKER_00I mean, that's the audacity of the Christian claim, isn't it? That it's a universal claim that was made about Christ that excluded other gods, that demanded everything, right? Right. Yeah, the thing to understand is that this is exactly the point of the apocalypse of St.
SPEAKER_01John. So the book of Revelation, right? What is the revelation of? Well, of Jesus Christ, but it's of Jesus Christ and his hand in history. And so there are different ways to every the funny thing is like everybody knows revelation is about the future. And they really tend to fixate on like the future part of it. But actually, Revelation is just about history and it applies to every single period in history. The book of Revelation applies like and so you can. That's why there's these arguments like in the Protestant world,
SPEAKER_01like his revelation about Nero is Nero the Antichrist. Yes. But also, like, is there an Antichrist coming? Also, yes. Like there have been William was also Antichrist. Right. Exactly. Exactly. And so there's the best way that I've ever heard, uh, uh, it described, and this isn't a book by a, um, oh boy, what's his name? uh, Stratford Caldecott of all people, who was a great, uh, Roman Catholic,
SPEAKER_01um, uh, classical educator. Uh, he died a few years ago now, but he wrote a book on the book of revelation and he sort of took in kind of these ancient readings of it and explain like in his way of thinking. And I think this is right. And I think this is Orthodox that the book of revelation is history as understood through the liturgy.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Very, very clear. Like if you just know the liturgy, well, okay, this part, really corresponds to this part of the liturgy. There's a moment in the book of Revelation and it is not obvious to modern people because a chapter break was inserted. I'm always suspicious of the chapter breaks because it's a nice way for somebody to sneak in something and say, all right, this thing doesn't have anything to do with this next thing. So make a little break in your mind. So there's a chapter break, but if you take the chapter break out, here's what happens in Revelation,
SPEAKER_01I think it's 10 to 11. The tabernacle, the holy place of the heavenly tabernacle, the heavenly temple where God is forever enthroned in worship. The most holy place opens, the sanctuary opens, and you see the Ark of the Covenant. But then the Ark of the Covenant is a woman clothed with the sun and the moon under her feet. And if you take the chapter breakout, those things just flow immediately into each other. And so it's very,
you know, from an Orthodox perspective, it's very obvious.
SPEAKER_01You're reading Revelation. Here's the Ark, but the Ark is the mother of God, but also the church being revealed kind of as the secret that's being hidden, you know, in history, constantly pursued by the dragon and the pursuit of the dragon. you know, trying to, you know, kill her and her offspring and then her offspring, who is Christ, crushes the head of the dragon. That's the whole story of history. And that's always been the case. And the woman is Israel and she's the Theotokos because, of course, the Theotokos is just all of faithful Israel,
SPEAKER_01right? All that's left of it, all that's been gathered into herself. The woman is the church, which is also, you know, what the Theotokos, like it's happening at all these different levels. And that's always been the case. That's always been the case. It's always the story of history. And it's going to continue to be the story until the new Jerusalem, which is also the Theotokos, that descends upon creation and heaven and earth are united. Right. And so that's the that's the that's the whole story of history
that's being revealed.
SPEAKER_01And so that's what St. John is doing in his revelation. And it's important to understand this because, of course, he's writing to people who are currently being persecuted and Nero is happening and all of these other things are happening. And it's a really bad time. And, you know, just listen to the letters of the seven churches, except for who is it? Is it just, which church is it that gets off? But pretty much everybody, it's like, oh, it's Pergamum. Maybe it's Pergamum. Anyway, one of the churches out of the seven is like,
you're doing a great job.
SPEAKER_01Love you guys. Everybody else, it's like, well, you're doing all these great things, but you've left your first love. Ephesus, you're an unfaithful spouse. And those letters are terrifying, by the way, because Christ dictated them to St.
SPEAKER_00John and he wrote them down, right? That's the only thing we have that's like that. where it's literally like dictated a letter to us. I mean, it's terrifying to me to read those.
SPEAKER_01And by the way, Ephesus, that was St. John's church. Like he had just been the bishop of that before he got exiled to Patmos when, you know, Christ is saying like to your church, to your congregation, you guys have left your first love. Like Timothy is the bishop of Ephesus. Like the apostle Timothy is the bishop of Ephesus. Probably when that letter is being dictated by Christ to that church. Even St.
SPEAKER_02John's not off the hook. This is very classically organized.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, it's rough. A lot of those letters are really rough, but also the idea like, I know you're where Satan's seed is and all this different. There's the two different kingdoms that are active in the world and all of this different stuff. That is a cosmic reality, which is always true at every period in history. You could say that, again, the material causes. Those shift around and change. But revelation is the it's the correct way to actually view history. And that's really what.
SPEAKER_00Right. Apocalypse is the pulling back of a curtain. Right. It's pulling back the curtain and showing actually how reality is working. Right. And it's not just how reality worked then or in the future. It's how reality works right now. That is relevant right now. And I think that that's part of what I'm trying to sort of articulate when I'm talking about sacred history is to have the curtain of reality pulled back and to see how reality actually functions. Because if we could see, I'm not alone in this room right now.
SPEAKER_00There are spiritual beings here. Well, you're giving me goosebumps, man, because that's why you can say- That's reality, right? The thoughts that we have are not all ours. Some of them are brought to us by outside parties, right? Once we understand reality, it changes the whole way you look at life, the whole way you walk through your day, right? It breaks you a little bit, right? I want to read something really quick because I think this really informs the way I look at history. It's from 2 Kings slash 4 Kingdoms chapter 6.
SPEAKER_00This is about Elisha, the prophet Elisha. When the servant of the man of God rose early in the morning and went out behold an army with horses and chariots was all around the city and the servant said alas my master what shall we do he said do not be afraid for those who are with us are more than those who are with them then Elisha prayed and said oh Lord please open his eyes that he may see so the Lord opened the eyes of the young man and he saw and behold the mountain
SPEAKER_00was full of horses and chariots of fire all around Elisha
SPEAKER_01And this miracle is exactly duplicated. on the Feast of what we call the Protection of the Mother of God, or the Pokrov, which is a really big part, especially in the Slavic tradition. Ironic for history purposes, but it is what it is. And in this miracle, it's a fool for Christ and his disciples, St. Andrew, I think, and his disciple. And he asks God to open the eyes of his disciple.
SPEAKER_01And his disciples' eyes are open. This is when Constantinople is under siege, I think, by the Bulgars or some other. I think it's the Bulgars. And what he sees is exactly the same vision, except that what has changed since the time of Elisha is the incarnation of the word, that God has become man. And so he doesn't just see angels protecting the city. He sees the mother of God spreading out her mantle over it. He sees human beings who have now become gods, who have been divinized, right? And they're now actively partaking in the spiritual protection
of the people of God.
SPEAKER_01But it's in full continuity. Those two things exist in the same world. If you want to say, oh, that thing never happened, then there's no reason to believe the story about Elisha either. I would argue there's no reason to believe that the Slavic group with Bulgars or
SPEAKER_00whoever besieged Constantinople. Right. Because our sources. Right. Sure. Yeah. Yeah. All our sources for that.
SPEAKER_01All of our sources for that are Orthodox Christians. So why would we.
SPEAKER_00I mean, a lot of the sources for the Byzantine history is this man, St. Theophanes, the confessor, who was a who wrote a year by year history of the of the world or of the empire, but of the world. And he matter of factly is pointing out these miraculous events while also recounting battles and all of that. These things are all, it's all together. There's only one story. Yeah, Matthew, your insistence is great because my mind is stretching it out.
SPEAKER_02And it does end with a little God testifying before Congress, with the most powerful man in the world testifying before Congress. You're right, it does. It ends like that. If you start with the right thing, it ends with that. Yeah, but it's a tough thing to stay consistent within the sacred history. Guys, so why don't you update us before we hang up, before we finish.
SPEAKER_02OSI, your work, Matthew, is there anything you want us to know?
SPEAKER_00We have the Orthodox Studies Institute at St. Constantine College. I'm pouring a lot into that right now. We're doing data analysis and we're doing history and we're doing all kinds of stuff. So you can learn about it, orthodoxstudies.org. I write about church history at orthodoxhistory.org. I saw an excellent podcast where you're talking about the nature of the...
SPEAKER_02clerical, shall we say, shortfall in terms of numbers.
SPEAKER_00The priest shortage. They're like a numerical shortage. The priest shortage. You know, what's funny is I'm over here talking about sacred history, and I also, like, we do all kinds of data analytics. And to me, that's just like, there's no, but why is that weird? But it does seem a little weird to people. It does seem weird to people, yeah.
SPEAKER_01It seems weird to me. That video lit a fire under a lot of people, which is really good. That's true.
SPEAKER_02Richard, tell us about what you're up to. Yeah, I think most people know that I work with Jonathan Pejo on the Symbolic World Press.
SPEAKER_01I kind of run the day-to-day there. We have books coming out all the time. You can just go to thesymbolicworld.com. We have courses coming out all the time. I'll be doing a course a little bit later this year with Jonathan on Dante's Paradiso, which is a concluding book of the Divine Comedy. We've already done the first two. I also have a course that will be coming out later this year on Tolkien's legendarium as universal history, which I'm really excited about because I have a lot of research that I've been sitting on and have never actually talked about even all of the
podcasts that I've
SPEAKER_01done on Tolkien. So it's kind of like exciting to talk about that for the first time. And I'm also speaking of Father Andrew Stephen Damick. I'm also on a podcast with him called The Great Tales. It's a live show on Thursdays. Every other Thursday, our next episode comes out this week. And it's going to be on the Holy Grail. So it's just like lots of cool things happening. And, you know, check it out if you like stories, if you like just taking the stuff cold stone seriously that is what i move out by the way i didn't roast you at symbolic world conference um because but i you just said the
word that my joke actually uses to roast you the word legendarium you you use that as if everyone knows what that is yeah well you have to just come and take the course if you don't
SPEAKER_01know so
SPEAKER_02I love you guys. Thanks for coming on. You know, you help us out because we're over here trying to do the art thing with sending people in different parts of the world.
SPEAKER_01And I thank you guys.
SPEAKER_02I thank you guys.
SPEAKER_01Thanks for having us.
SPEAKER_02We'll see you again soon. Thank you. Many blessings to you guys. You guys helping me run a podcast that is, I think, properly slowly growing. Properly slowly growing. That's what I think. If it grew too fast, then I would have had to manipulate an algorithm. Or said things like this. Building seven. Or worse than building seven, you know, like,
SPEAKER_02I don't know, I'd have to talk about like Epstein and stuff, which is actually interesting. Mossad, if I said Mossad a lot. Be in touch. Lots of cool people coming on. And 2025 is going to be a podcast fun time. www.first-things.org. Go there right now. Become a monthly donor. It's our number one thing. Just do it. We love you. From the land of South Carolina, come visit our KP restaurant.
Find this episode on YouTube: "Justine Alter" - a pseudonym - returns to chat with John Heers in a raw Heavy Things Lightly conversation you have to hear to believe.Justine worked for years as a professional psychic,...
Find this episode on YouTube: Holly Hickman went from Columbia Journalism and Fox News Radio covering NASA and the 2008 election - to milking cows, making cheese, and converting to Orthodoxy.In this episode of Heavy...
Can you teach kids the truth AND prepare them for a secular world?On this episode of Heavy Things Lightly, host John Heers talks with James and Juliana Joyce, founders of St. George's Classical Academy in Boxford,...
Find this episode on YouTube: Crow walked America searching for his father - and found the Father.From West Virginia hollers to LA gangs, from wolves in the Mojave desert to an Orthodox cross, this is an Odyssean tale...
Welcome to the first episode of “Save Me a Spot at the Supra” on Heavy Things Lightly where John Heers hosts singer and Broadway performer Carrie Manolakos (best known for her performances in Mama Mia! and Wicked) at...