Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Heavy Things Lightly

Heavy Things Lightly artwork

From Broadway to the Supra: Carrie Manolakos on Life After Lockdown

Sep 1, 20261 hr 51 minAudio
  • Apple Podcasts
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Welcome to the first episode of “Save Me a Spot at the Supra” on Heavy Things Lightly where John Heers hosts singer and Broadway performer Carrie Manolakos (best known for her performances in Mama Mia! and Wicked) at his restaurant after she attended a Supra, discussing how the tradition builds community, the role of the tamada, and ways to bring more music into American Supras. Carrie reflects on her early discovery as a vocalist, her training in the Syracuse Children’s Chorus, performing professionally as a child, and later learning to belt and pursuing powerful roles. She describes major hardships beginning around 2014, and how COVID brought stillness, but also industry pressures she refused, leading her to step away, stay quiet, and later face public backlash after speaking openly, including support for RFK Jr. She shares how pain, a dental injury, and her film “Metanoia” coincided with returning to Orthodoxy, deepening her faith and art, and closes with a toast about eye-to-eye connection, grace, and unity.Chapters00:00 Welcome to the Supra02:43 Meet Carrie Manolakos04:05 First Impressions of Supra07:37 Tamada and Table Magic08:56 Why We Sing Together15:00 Getting Americans to Sing21:15 Why You Must Go22:35 Famous Guests Wish List25:40 Carries Early Talent26:50 Training and First Gigs30:41 Work Ethic and Athletics32:19 New York Pull in Her 20s32:50 Losing Innocence33:27 Building a Belt36:01 Scarcity and Worth37:26 Faith Roots and Drift39:48 2014 Breaking Point41:43 Alone Through Crisis45:22 Defining Diva Needs51:54 Wicked Standby Chaos53:19 COVID Career Exit55:59 Intuition and Refusal58:40 Hiding and Backlash01:07:00 Nashville Reset Plan01:10:00 Reading Scripture Again01:11:50 Art Led to Faith01:12:06 Going Rogue in Nashville01:15:50 Injury and Metanoia01:19:56 Sermon Hits Home01:23:37 Learning as a Convert01:26:29 Speaking Out and Backlash01:30:05 Floods and Guardianship01:33:57 Politics as Religion01:37:42 Writing America Song01:39:27 Dealbreakers and Values01:41:15 Art and Human Commonality01:42:57 Ala Verde Toast01:49:41 Final Blessing and Outro__🏷️ Sponsored by Conrad's Beef Jerky - loyalty not guaranteed.Conrad's Deli - The best jerky you'll ever have ➜ https://conradsdeli.com/ ⭐ Use promo code "FIRST THINGS" for 10% off.🔥 Support First Things Foundation field workers like Sarah (featured in this episode): https://first-things.org✈ Become a Field Worker with FTF: https://first-things.org/opportunities📢 First Things Telegram: https://t.me/firstthingsfoundation🍷The best dinner party you've ever experienced - Supra Dinner Society: https://supradinner.com/🥂 Keipi Restaurant: https://keipirestaurant.org✒ Substack: https://johnheersftf.substack.com/ⓧ https://x.com/johnfromftf🏖️ Tailormade tours that give back: https://www.gratitude-travels.com/hom__Credits Music: Intro / Outro Provided by Greg Gilbertson & Band This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit johnheersftf.substack.com/subscribe

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

[music]

SPEAKER_00Hey everybody from the restaurant today. This is Save Me a Spot at the Supra on Heavy Things Lightly. Today we got Carrie here, Menalakos. Menalakos. She's a singer. She's like profoundly interesting and profoundly has a profoundly Deep story. And I make her cry and other stuff, but she's not really a crier, but kind of. And so come watch her cry on Heavy Things Lightly today, which is a special treat because it saved me a spot at the Supra.

SPEAKER_00Carrie came and spent the Friday night at the Supra. We put her up. She's here now. We did this beautiful talk. Join us right after Greg and the boys do our Gagimarjo song. Carrie Menilakos and I, from Mamma Mia and all of her profession, we hear about her work on Save Me a Spot at the Supra.

SPEAKER_00Carrie, you saved me a spot at this, wait,

SPEAKER_01I'm going to cross myself. I was just going to say, I was like,

SPEAKER_00I like that. How would we not start that way?

SPEAKER_01I literally went like this, it was a close turn. This is so good. It's a good way to start. It's a good way to start.

SPEAKER_00I probably start that way often, but off camera. But now we can, we leave it in.

SPEAKER_01We leave it in. We leave it in.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, may our words be of use. May something good come of a good conversation with you, an artist and performer, but let's have a little wine because we're at KP.

SPEAKER_01Yes.

SPEAKER_00Our restaurant has managed to not die. In fact, in its fourth year, just turned four. Thank you. Well, you joined it. Congratulations. This is Carrie. I know you as a friend now, but performer. Broadway, lots of stuff, Wicked, Mamma Mia. Then you did that video that everyone liked,

SPEAKER_01Creep.

SPEAKER_00And then we have a fly in here, which is great.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, he's joining us as well. He's joining us.

SPEAKER_00Then you, then COVID came. We're going to talk all about this. And now you're doing a lot of stuff that's beautiful. You got a new album out. And then you came and said you'd come and hang out.

SPEAKER_01Of course.

SPEAKER_00So this is saving me a spot of the super we do these whenever we can with like, yeah, famous people on your, I think you're kind of famous. So to your arrival, and to giving proper thanks to God who created all of this, including our being together. So Kagi Marjos.

SPEAKER_01Kagi Marjos.

SPEAKER_00Christos Anesti. So What'd you think? You did a Supra.

SPEAKER_01Oh my goodness. It was so fun, John. It's unlike anything I've ever been to. It really is.

SPEAKER_00It was last night.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. Yeah.

SPEAKER_00You came and sat down. You were on time because we weren't sure that the girl was going to be on time. I was not a great time.

SPEAKER_01Well, only because you picked me up. But I was on time for you to pick me up. Fair point. By the way, you were actually waiting. I was early. Very impressive. I know. Today I was like, but it's okay. You know what I mean? Do your best.

SPEAKER_00No, it's fine. Greeks are late, and then they're even later to liturgy. But everything's fine.

SPEAKER_01I'm early to liturgy.

SPEAKER_00You're an early goer now.

SPEAKER_01I did not used to be, but because the church has gotten so packed, I got to get there or else I don't get in.

SPEAKER_00I guess we talked about this a little. The converts are flooding in.

SPEAKER_01Yes.

SPEAKER_00So you're kind of like a convert, but let's finish this super conversation. We'll talk about that. So you sat down. Yeah. What do you think? First of all, it was people that didn't know each other.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. Yes. Well, because I was at the Art of Automata, and that was my first introduction to the Supra, different experience, which we can talk about too. This was really interesting to watch so many people who'd never done a super before and are also really unfamiliar with where it comes from and the tradition of it and why we gather and that the base is about it because I had so much more knowledge because of really being kind of taught

SPEAKER_00the origin of what this is. Yeah, we did it before, aren't we?

SPEAKER_01Yeah. So I, you know, you know more, but what was cool is that, I mean, beyond cool, but to watch the spirit of it infuse, regardless of whether they know why it's happening or not.

SPEAKER_00It's weird, right?

SPEAKER_01It is weird, but it's really amazing. And it's funny, I was kind of describing it to our end of the table, is that at some, the way it goes, it's like, whoa, whoa, whoa, whoa, whoa. And then all of a sudden, it's like, And it just goes on its own. And at some point, you kind of see the tamada sit down and it's like, just let it all happen.

SPEAKER_00By the way, that's the proper pattern.

SPEAKER_01Is it? Yeah. Oh my gosh, that's amazing.

SPEAKER_00They call that end of that, they call shfidova, where it's like, I don't, it's like, don't worry, we don't leave now. Tamada may be one, two words, but we're fine. And now you're just like, and then also what will happen is people start toasting to each other. They don't need the tamada.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, you do get that sense. It's like all of a sudden they sort of find Their own rhythm and their own community in it. Whereas like in the beginning, you're like, what am I doing here? What is this thing? How did I get here? But I'm really happy and excited because I don't know what to expect, which is really cool. But it's a special thing that you're doing. It's so wonderful to see both sides of, you know, kind of people who've never experienced it. And then something that was like the art of the Tamada.

SPEAKER_00So the other end of the table, because I sat at your end, I was not Tamada. I was not Tamada. Which was nice. Yeah. And I was not Melikipe.

SPEAKER_03Yeah.

SPEAKER_00So I was just hanging out at the table.

SPEAKER_03Yeah.

SPEAKER_00It was actually hard at first because I've done so many of these. But at the other end of the table, you know, they didn't know each other. They acted like they were the best friends of all times. They did. Wasn't that nuts?

SPEAKER_01That was really amazing.

SPEAKER_00I went up there later and I'm like, oh, you guys are all, you all came together. It was like five or six of them. They're like, no, no, these two came together. This one came. Yeah. And I was like, something happened up there.

SPEAKER_01Something did happen.

SPEAKER_00They're having a party.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. They really connected.

SPEAKER_00I think they did connect.

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_00We had a Tamada.

SPEAKER_01We did.

SPEAKER_00Now in Georgia, I want you to know for all you Georgians out there, wherever you are, it's American Supra because we're Americans. And we don't always, it doesn't ring exactly like in Georgia.

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_00But did you see the Tamada trying to attend to his business? What do you think his business was? Like, what do you think he's trying to do? A Tamada in general? Yeah, like, no, Evan last night.

SPEAKER_01I think he's, he's the guide of the experience, you know, but he's, he, you know, there's an allowing, right, of the, of the spirit of what Tamada is. So there's a little bit of like a, I need to channel whatever that spirit is.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, that's right. That's right.

SPEAKER_01And, you know, you got to read the room. You're like a professional room reader. You know, you got to read like, what's going on? How are these people doing? How are these people doing? Do we need to bring the energy up? Do we need to bring the energy down?

SPEAKER_00Did you see him come over a couple of times and... He was like, what do we do next? It's like, this is what we're going to do

SPEAKER_03next.

SPEAKER_00It was cool because he was trying to get you to sing. He was trying to get me to sing. This I cannot do, but he got you to sing.

SPEAKER_01He did. What do you think

SPEAKER_00about that? You sang.

SPEAKER_01It's good at Supra. It's good. You know, we talked about this a little bit at the end of the table, but it's, you know, the way that we view singing and music in the West is different than everywhere else in the world. Because it is it's like either you do it or you don't, or you're professional or you're not, you know, or you like, you know, Sort of apologize. I just do it as a hobby. And I, you know, just sing when I'm by myself. And occasionally I'll do a little performance. You know, it's like, come on, we can all just sing. I mean, when you, it's, it's like anything.

SPEAKER_01You get good at it by practicing and you master the craft. And of course people have natural talent and some, you know, excel faster and that kind of thing. But we all have a voice. You know, we all get to use that voice.

SPEAKER_00Don't you think that's true? I really do. It's not just bullshit. Like it's real.

SPEAKER_01No, no, no. We all have that. We all, like singing is a, is a, is a, is a, um, It's a full expression of what's inside of you, you know? And that's why we do it in liturgy. That's why we, you know, cultures all across the world, whether they're, they don't even think of the idea of professional singing potentially, you know, we do, but it's, they just sing because they have joy. They sing because they lament. They sing because they have grief. They sing because they've come together. They sing because of their faith. They sing for all of these reasons that, um, You know, have nothing to do with performance.

SPEAKER_00And... Did you feel... So you got microphones in your face. You know how to sing. You were singing at Washington Mall on 4th of July. So... But you seem... I wouldn't say you seem nervous, but you weren't like gung-ho to stand up and sing.

SPEAKER_01It's funny because you get more nervous at these kind of things than I would...

SPEAKER_0020, 25 people or whatever.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. Because also, too, like people are... You're talking and then you're like, when do I start? It's not... It's just... It's, there's no lead up to it. You just kind of like, why?

SPEAKER_00Yeah,

SPEAKER_01yeah. So it's different. But also to just in, I always say it's harder to sing for five people than it is for 5000 people. It makes total sense. And even though I always look at people, that's kind of something that I do. I think it's for me, the experience of singing is about connecting. It's not some singers will like close their eyes, and they just kind of get in their zone. And they're But I'm not that way. I look at people and I have an experience with them.

SPEAKER_00Right. And then there's just five. Last night there were 20. That's really intimate.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, it's really intimate. And sometimes those people don't know what to expect.

SPEAKER_00Well, they also don't know how to act.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. They're like, she's right next to me. They're like, do I look at her? She's literally right next to me. It's just such a joy.

SPEAKER_00The way the Georgians do it is they just start singing like at their seat. Yeah, I love that. They're just like all of a sudden, like right now, we'd just be like, you know, they'd be like, okay. And then boom. And you're like, wait, what's happening?

SPEAKER_01Yeah. Which I love. It really is, it's not that big of a gap. It's like you speak and then you sing.

SPEAKER_00That's the next- So that's what we're trying to pass on. I love it. So one of the things we're trying to do, it's like an active event in our life of first things, is field workers overseas being guests and field workers at home being hosts or tamadas.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, I love how you said that.

SPEAKER_00It's like this, it's a union of what always was. Like at any given moment, We're like switching between host and guest. But the whole point is, is we can't be a host by ourself. We can't be a guest by ourself. It doesn't work. You have to have other people in our lives. So first things is like the light bulb went on when I was doing Supras in my lifetime because I hadn't started the nonprofit. And we'd just throw a Supra and then neighbors would come.

SPEAKER_00They'd be like, what is this? And I kept saying, this is a Georgian thing. I learned when I was in Georgia during the 90s. We want to come back. And then my kids would know how to do it. And then their little 12-year-old friends would come over and drink wine with us. And their parents were like, what are you doing over there? But I guess my life was a translation of this Georgian liturgical, supra-liturgical outside of the liturgy.

SPEAKER_00Then we started it, and then we had a light bulb go off inside the organization that like, whoa, this is actually the work at home.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, totally.

SPEAKER_00We don't need to help people facilitate material wealth. In Mozambique, they have a lot of what we're talking about, a kind of a spirit of communion. Obviously not orthodox, but it's a spirit of the commune, of being together.

SPEAKER_01Yes.

SPEAKER_00They're outside of the material wealth belt. Let's call it like that. They're outside of the global material wealth belt. They don't have the proper education or whatever. We try to connect them so that they can live at least a life that they have water and food and stuff. But at home, it didn't matter because we're really surrounded by the wealth belt. You can jump on. You can. I'm talking about even in rough neighborhoods where people are poor or whatever. They're blocked to it, but it's not far away where you can find a way to either get money or make money.

SPEAKER_00It's not far away. So what was far away was the spiritual element of people sitting like this, maybe not with all these lights and stuff. So we're finding that that's our work. But here's my question for you. I want you to help me. So before we get into your life, This is a full deep dive. You're stuck.

SPEAKER_01Great. I can't wait. It's always a deep dive with you, John.

SPEAKER_00And I'm going to ask all the questions that I wrote down, which are zero.

SPEAKER_01But I have them stored.

SPEAKER_00I have them stored. If they were stored in my belly, there would be a lot of them these days. But I think they're in my heart. So there's probably only like two. Then it dies. No, I'm kidding. But you're my hired... Consultant for the next three minutes. The American Supra, which we are now promulgating and it's working, lacks music. So I have little tricks, but I want to hear from you, a professional.

SPEAKER_00At that table, that was very representative of the American, there were Southerners, there were Northerners, there were two guys that met in Peace Corps. It was just a cool table. How would you... Get that table to be inculcated or whatever with a musical spirit. Is there a way to do that in four hours?

SPEAKER_01Are you asking how to incorporate Musicians?

SPEAKER_00This is it. This is what I'm talking about.

SPEAKER_01That, you know, like someone like me or you ask me- Is that your answer? More of infusing the table to feel free enough to be able to express themselves in that way.

SPEAKER_00So it's really, I feel like the question is the second thing you just said.

SPEAKER_03Okay.

SPEAKER_00One of the answers may be the first thing you said.

SPEAKER_03Yeah.

SPEAKER_00But let me repose it. Table filled with Americans, all of them, Probably not wanting to sing a single note in any four hour span.

SPEAKER_02Yeah.

SPEAKER_00Make them sing, how would you do it?

SPEAKER_01Well, I feel like what you did when you just burst into Sweet Caroline. Yeah, it was tough.

SPEAKER_00I did it though.

SPEAKER_01You did it, you crushed it. But people did sing along. I mean, it was helpful that I was right next to you. Touching hands, and then they all know what to do. That's exactly right. Yeah, that they do know what to do when they sing a song.

SPEAKER_00Did you feel embarrassed when I did that? No. Be honest.

SPEAKER_01No, John.

SPEAKER_03One of my favorite things is when you burst into song.

SPEAKER_01You did it at the Art of Automata, and it was so... Just pure and joyful. Oh my gosh, it was the best.

SPEAKER_00Do you people who know how to sing? You were like, you sing?

SPEAKER_01I'm going to sing.

SPEAKER_00It was okay?

SPEAKER_01Yes.

SPEAKER_00Because I'm like a true believer in this, but I don't have like a great voice. But so you people who can sing don't get, do you get cringed out?

SPEAKER_01No, I think when you do it, other people feel like they can do it too.

SPEAKER_00And I think that's- Oh, so maybe that's one of the answers is to get them to sing, you got to have a fool there that'll sing. I'm being serious kind of, what would you do?

SPEAKER_01Well, I think it's, you know, when someone is singing at a professional level, you know, there is an element of like, there's an audience and a performer, right?

SPEAKER_03You know, just because that's the nature of how our

SPEAKER_01culture is built, right? Plus you're good at it. It just is. Well, you know, but I also, I'm happy to just sing with everybody else and do the thing and like, like how we- Like

SPEAKER_00sing a note right now. Just like sing. What do you want? That's not talking about. See, if you just rip that, the whole table will go, what? They will all go, what? That's so nice. Thank you. We get not everyone's going to, by the way, hardest song ever written, maybe. But we get everyone's not going to do you right there.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, of course. Keep going. For people out there who don't even know what I'm talking about, the Supra is always two things happen. There's always a little music and then there's always a toast to suffering and death. Not to it, but about it. We can talk about that in a minute because we're going to get into your life, but keep going. Give me one or two more ideas to get these Americans, these whites, get the whites to sing.

SPEAKER_01I feel like honestly, I know the toast are in order. Right? Aren't they in order?

SPEAKER_00There's a type of order, but you can move them around.

SPEAKER_01I feel like there might be a way when you feel like you hit that, that's when you do the music.

SPEAKER_00When people are just gliding and enjoying themselves.

SPEAKER_01They're gliding because then they're just like, You can see it in everybody's faces. Their feeling of, what am I trying to say? Insecurities or anything along those lines. They're just like, no, no, I'm just here and I'm enjoying myself and I'm having a great time. And I did see that at the time and I was like some people just got up and sang and they just wanted to sing. You know what I mean?

SPEAKER_00It was like so cool. Okay, you're right.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, they did do that. So I think that maybe when you get to that glide, that might feel like a good time to introduce it. And also too, like potentially the Tamina, whether they sing or not, or the Malikipe or whatever, like they could sing a little something too to just-

SPEAKER_00It feels that way, doesn't it?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, just to sort of break the ice there. And especially if they're not a professional singer, they can just be like, I'm going to sing a little something for you guys. Somebody else might get up and be like, okay, great.

SPEAKER_00It feels like we have to have that in our- Yeah. The American Supra project has to have Taminas that can do that. Yeah. By the way, in Georgia, I'm thinking of three right now, three Taminas that I really love.

SPEAKER_03Mm-hmm.

SPEAKER_00They all sing. One guy, he's a priest also. He sings well. He's not like superstar. But he sings well enough that the table becomes super animated. So maybe, okay, so tamaras have to be able to weigh in or melakipes. They should be able to hit a note or two.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. Willing. You should be willing.

SPEAKER_00Willing.

SPEAKER_01They don't have to be great. You know what I mean? That's the thing. They have to be willing to do it and put themselves out there in a way that-

SPEAKER_00Because it breaks that fear for the other people.

SPEAKER_01That I'm not a professional singer, that I can't get up and sing in front of people.

SPEAKER_00Would you put musicians at the table that you experienced last night? Would you sneak them in there? We snuck you in.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. I totally. Yeah.

SPEAKER_00That works too, right?

SPEAKER_01Yeah. And maybe like an instrumentalist.

SPEAKER_00One of the ladies cried while you were singing. That's a fact.

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_00Fact. So, I mean, I don't know if it's good that she cried, but it's good that you sang well enough that someone was moved. Nice. So you did the Supra. Last takeaways before I ask you about your life outside, because this has saved me a spot at the Supra, or maybe should we save other spots? Was it a good time?

SPEAKER_01I say if anyone ever gets invited to a Supra, especially by John Heers, You have to go. You must go. But what you're doing is different than anything I've seen before. It's a tradition that we don't have here. And I think it is so beautiful. And it kind of cracks the heart in a way that I think does help bridge This, these worlds, right? This ancient tradition of, of the faith and of the beauty and hospitality and of being hosts and being a guest

SPEAKER_01and then the busy world of being an American that's like, I, you know, just go, go, go, go, go.

SPEAKER_00Yes.

SPEAKER_01And it really brings those two things together. So I think Very few people know what it is, but like you said, it's almost impossible to describe. You just have to go.

SPEAKER_00You can't describe it. You just go and- Come taste and see. Come taste and see. Okay, so your advertisement, and now I'm going to ask you to do one other thing. This is our market. By the way, this fly is- He is- He is living large. He is in it with us. He's in it. We're going to kill him on camera. No, no, it's fine. So here's our marketing strategy for Save Me a Spot at the Supra.

SPEAKER_01Okay. Okay.

SPEAKER_00Here's the marketing strategy. Ready?

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_00Say names right now of famous people that you know.

SPEAKER_01That'd be like, do you invite to the Supra? I know one that you know. Yeah.

SPEAKER_00RFK Jr. Let's get him to the Supra.

SPEAKER_01To the Supra? Invite him. Can you imagine if he just showed up last night? I think that would have been like, wow.

SPEAKER_00That's kind of the idea.

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_00Right? People show up and you're like, oh, there's Carrie Menilakis. She knows how to sing. Famous people. Let's go. Jonathan Jackson.

SPEAKER_01I was just going to say Jonathan Jackson.

SPEAKER_00Famous actor.

SPEAKER_01He would come in a second. Jim Caviezel. I just made friends with him. You're friends with Jim Caviezel. I just met him at the 4th of July.

SPEAKER_00People, this is the marketing strategy right now.

SPEAKER_03We are putting out- Jim, if you're watching this, you'll love the Supra.

SPEAKER_00Jim will be here. Okay, good. This is a pipeline. If we get Jesus to come literally and sit with us. That would be next level.

SPEAKER_01And then who wouldn't want to come? Clooney's right behind him. Clooney may be right behind him. I don't know Clooney, but.

SPEAKER_00I don't know. You know him. I don't care about politics that way because my daughter knows Clooney. Why isn't Clooney here already? Well, you got to invite him. They spend like eight weeks together, day after day. Why isn't he here?

SPEAKER_01Was he invited?

SPEAKER_00I haven't invited him.

SPEAKER_01There you go.

SPEAKER_00What about, come on, let's throw two more out. Then I'm going to chase these people down with a glass of wine and a horn.

SPEAKER_01Jonathan Rumi, another Jesus. Jonathan Rumi, you know him too. I don't know Jonathan, but he knows a lot of people I know.

SPEAKER_00What if we just do only Jesuses?

SPEAKER_01Well, those are the two. Who else?

SPEAKER_00The Jesus podcast. Well, what about a Zeffirelli Jesus? He's probably old at this point. Do you remember the Zeffirelli? No, I don't.

SPEAKER_01That's how old I am.

SPEAKER_00So Ferelli, this is the 70s Jesus who was shiny. Okay, I didn't see that one. What's wrong? Because you're young and vibrant. Yeah. Whatever. Okay, I hate giving away my age because most of them hang out with these young guys. What's a 25-year-old? What's a 25 year old? Like, what are you? What did this is by whether we were speaking, we break that we break the Europe Broadway. We broke the fourth wall.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, but obviously, there's somebody probably here with us. Maybe?

SPEAKER_00No, they're helping us.

SPEAKER_01Exactly.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. This is our friend, Derek. Derek is rocking this. What do we call you guys that are like young and under 30? Gen. Gen what? But there's also Gen Alpha new. Are you Gen Z? I'm technically a millennial. I'm cool. Oh, you're a millennial. I know millennials. I raised some millennials.

SPEAKER_01You did?

SPEAKER_00I don't know about you guys. We got to watch out for them. But like these Gen Z-er people, I hire a lot of these guys to go to these faraway places, African stuff.

SPEAKER_01That's great.

SPEAKER_00And they're always calling me a boomer, but I'm not technically a boomer. You're a millennial, right? No. Are you?

SPEAKER_01I don't know what I am, but I'm not a millennial.

SPEAKER_00Well, we're not giving away your age. Is that Greek love? 21. We're not giving away your age.

SPEAKER_01My age, we're not giving that away.

SPEAKER_00Tell me about growing up. So, first of all, I'll just put it like this.

SPEAKER_02Yeah.

SPEAKER_00You're like super talented. Thank you. Growing up, was there a moment when you're like, holy shit, I'm like super talented. Did that ever happen to you in your whole life?

SPEAKER_01Well, I just, so it actually, The story I like to tell is like my parents didn't know I was good. They just thought all kids sang. And I loved singing. I loved the voice. I was always singing. And so when I was young... Really young, I was like, begging my mom to be on Star Search. And I was like, I, you know, I was sitting behind me this little corner in our living room, where I would play CDs. And I would listen, Whitney Houston was one of my favorites.

SPEAKER_01So I Will Always Love You is a song that has been with me since I was a little girl. It's how I learned how to riff, how I learned how to riff. And it's been with me, I've sung it at so many major performances like Carnegie Hall and It's in my show a lot of the time. It's got me Mamma Mia. It got me in the job.

SPEAKER_03Oh, is that right?

SPEAKER_01Yeah. Things like that. It's just like, whoa, this song has been with me forever. Anyway, I just love singing. It wasn't until I went to public school until fifth grade. And then I moved to a private school. And when I was, I think in like third or fourth grade, I was singing in just choir in this big room of probably like 100 kids. And I guess the teacher, the choir director heard a voice. And she was like, where's this voice coming from?

SPEAKER_01And she just kept breaking the room into, she was like, okay, and now you eight people sing, everybody else be quiet. Okay, cool. And then you eight people sing, and then finally she figured out where it was coming from, and it was me. Interesting. Kind of amazing because I had such a quiet voice. Like I didn't belt, a lot of people don't know this, but I didn't belt till I was 20 years old. I had a very beautiful voice. I have a very agile voice, big range, all that stuff, but I did not have any power. And so she sort of figured out where this voice was coming from.

SPEAKER_01And then when my mom, I guess they were in the same room together where she asked her to come in, she said, I think your daughter has something. And she invited me to audition for a children's choir that was a really amazing children's choir, Syracuse Children's Chorus.

SPEAKER_00Syracuse in Europe.

SPEAKER_01Syracuse, and we ended up, when I went through all the choirs, we traveled internationally. So I learned a lot about music from that choir, which made me the singer that I am. Got it. A ton of ear training, reading music, intonation, pitch blending, like dynamics. Which kind of music were you singing? All choral. It was all choral music, like traditional children's choir music. So she was kind of the first one who, Picked me out. And it was around that time that I started auditioning for shows. So I ended up doing a professional show when I was 10 years old in Syracuse.

SPEAKER_01There's a professional equity theater called Syracuse Stage. And I was the stable girl. And we did a version of, it's like the nativity story, but it was called Butterfingers Angel. It was amazing. It was such a good show. And someone from the radio, Y94FM, was like, oh my gosh, I heard this girl sing Silent Night from Butterfingers Angel. And I just cried. And somebody had sent it to my mom and there was two casts. And so she called in to be like, was that... What night did you go? And it was me. And so he invited me to the radio station when I was 10.

SPEAKER_0110 years old. Yeah. So it was just all of a sudden they were like, oh, it's not just that she sings. It's like she's people are noticing. And so that emotional component has always been a part of my passion. It's like always been a part of a chord, I think that, you know, God has given me to connect on. And so then it was kind of back then, but I just love singing. So I didn't even think about it. I just wanted to do it. And then later on, I was like, okay, I think I'm, I think I'm onto something.

SPEAKER_00And your mom and dad, could they believe it?

SPEAKER_01They were always very level-headed and very humble about it. They supported me... In every single way that they possibly could have and still do. But they never let it get to my head.

SPEAKER_00They weren't pushers.

SPEAKER_01They were not pushers. It almost always came from me. My mom did encourage me to do a play once, which I resisted and it was so smart that she did that. I did To Kill Mockingbird and I played Scout when I was like 13 or 14 and it changed my life. But they have always supported that, but they've always been very Kind of reasonable about any stuff that I was getting from the outside world and they really I never needed to be told to work hard because I just loved it so much.

SPEAKER_01All I wanted to do is get better and learn. Interesting. But, you know, and I continued to grow and change.

SPEAKER_00Could you do the other things that were being asked of you by the culture? Like were you good at math? Did you play sports? Yeah. Or did you just reject those things always for the music?

SPEAKER_01You know, I always say if I had like a tenth of like the discipline and the work ethic that I had when I was a kid, I still work really hard, but I was just some sort of like, I look back at my childhood and I'm like, whoa, because everything I wanted to do, I was like, I'm going to excel at that. And I worked really, really hard. So I was like a huge athlete as well. And I was like, sumo come loud. And so if I didn't sing, I would have played soccer. Oh, is that right? Yeah, like I was, you know, yeah, yeah. Like all-star soccer player, MVP, high scorer.

SPEAKER_01So I did all the stuff.

SPEAKER_00Let's call this like a focus. You had a... You were able to see something, figure it out and do it.

SPEAKER_01Yes.

SPEAKER_00Did you inherit that or were you taught that?

SPEAKER_01No, I think it's just my nature. It's like, it's kind of, and again, it changed. I think it honestly, the internet changed a lot, but like it changed as I grew older and more components came into the picture that had nothing to do With real work ethic. Like it, it just, it became less about the craft and other things came into play. But I was kind of kid that, that on my summer, this is so crazy to say out loud, but on my summer breaks, I would like organize my day and I'd be like, okay, two hours of practicing soccer, two hours of reading, two hours of singing.

SPEAKER_01Like I, and my person was like, what is going on?

SPEAKER_00And they're not pushing that. That's just you.

SPEAKER_01I was just me. I, you know, and so I, I've always had very high standards for myself.

SPEAKER_00Did it, Change in your 20s? Could you still be that super hyper-attentive person or did it change?

SPEAKER_01It changed. It changed. Yeah.

SPEAKER_00Because it's your 20s and people wanted you to do drugs and stuff?

SPEAKER_01Well, I won't go live. The New York culture does pull you out quite a bit.

SPEAKER_00You felt it?

SPEAKER_01Oh, yeah. I felt it in a big way. Yeah.

SPEAKER_00Interesting.

SPEAKER_01I still look back and I'm like, oof, nice.

SPEAKER_00Do you blame people for changing the pattern of your work like that? No. Or is it just you? No.

SPEAKER_01I wish that I like I look I always had a very pure nature and I was always like a good kid like I never wanted to get in trouble. And I kind of noticed it's a slow burn, you know, and those things start to Disassemble and you let in other things that you don't even know are coming in and then all of a sudden you're like, how did I get to be this person? You don't even realize it when it's happened.

SPEAKER_00I'm not implying you went off the wagon and went crazy. I'm just saying it sounds like that same super attentiveness, that innocent attentiveness of a child, it changed. When did you start singing those big Broadway pieces? You know, Wicked and Mamma Mia. Were you really young? I can't remember the dates on that.

SPEAKER_01So I was, I didn't sing anything big. The first time I belted a note was when I was 20. And so when I went into college, again, I had a very pretty voice and I could riff and I could, I sang classical as well. I could do pop music. But when I went into college, I made a decision. And I was like, Okay, well, if I sing this way and continue to sing this way, I will play these parts. These are the only parts that I will play. And I was like, Am I okay with that? And I was like, I think I want to play powerful roles.

SPEAKER_01And I want to do this and I want to do that. And so I set a goal for myself. And I said, when I go to when I end school, I don't want there to be anything I can't sing. And when I left, there wasn't. And that took so much work. But the thing is, and I teach people about the voice. I love the instrument of the voice. I was born with a voice. I was not born with this voice. So one of the things that ended up happening was that I had all these incredible, amazing teachers throughout my lifetime. And I always say, even for people who work with me, I say, take what's useful, leave what's not.

SPEAKER_01You're going to find out things on your own that I may never be able to share with you, because it's your instrument. When I was in school, nobody was like belting high. Like that was not a thing that people were doing. Oh, really? yeah, yeah. It was not a thing. So very few people, like maybe one or two that I could count on my hands, you know, were doing it. And so I kind of learned this technique on my own. And my very first voice teacher was in the original Fiddler on the Roof on Broadway.

SPEAKER_03Wow.

SPEAKER_01So she had a very traditional voice. Like kind of, you know, like that kind of a sound. And I loved her so much. Eventually, I started making bigger sounds without vibrato and testing the limits. And she'd be like.

SPEAKER_00People weren't pulling you toward that. You just kept wading in on that. I was just curious. So your curiosity seems like some sort of engine for you. It is. And then you have this ability to focus.

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_00How did you handle the moments when The curiosity was waning, your focus was waning and you worried you were a failure. How did you handle failure moments? As you got to become a, you know, when you started to realize I'm a singer, were there voices like, no, you're not.

SPEAKER_01It was never, it was never about singing. It was more about like worth. Oh, interesting. And they're in the industry. I watch it all the time. It's kind of ingrained in you. There's like a scarcity mentality. It's like you're lucky to always have a job. We can replace you at any time. It is that kind of a thing that is instilled in people. And I'm not to say it's always the case. Sometimes you work in environments, and they're very supportive, and they really want you there.

SPEAKER_01But I think Those kinds of moments when they are cumulative tend to weigh on you. And I think what performers deal with that not everybody deals with is this life that's on stage and the life that's off stage. And how do you make those two things have congruence and the ability to be the same? It's an authenticity.

SPEAKER_01But it's also, you know, now looking back, it's like kind of a calling to, I've always even when I was singing, even before I really understood faith, and then actually chose this, I was always giving this to something bigger than me, like always, every time. So I was on the stage and had these feelings of like, Oh,

SPEAKER_00and you called it God?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, called it God.

SPEAKER_00And your parents were calling it God in the Orthodox Christian tradition or not really?

SPEAKER_01My father is an Orthodox Christian. Yes. My mother grew up Methodist.

SPEAKER_00Well, so let's talk about that. Which tradition did they choose? Or did they choose no tradition?

SPEAKER_01Orthodoxy.

SPEAKER_00Oh, so if you went to church as a kid, then you went to Orthodox Church?

SPEAKER_01Yes. Yeah.

SPEAKER_00So that probably made you feel like a Greek girl?

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_00At some level?

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_00It was a Greek church?

SPEAKER_01Yeah. That's Greek.

SPEAKER_00Did the Greek Orthodoxy in these times when you're trying to figure out the worth offstage, worth onstage, did it inform you? Before, let's call it COVID, before we get into what happened with you, but was it informing you or was it just feeling? By informing, I mean, were you using principles and presuppositions of Christianity to make sense of your world offstage, onstage?

SPEAKER_01No, I really was not, I wouldn't have, even though I was baptized in the church as a baby, I was not connected to Christianity at all. Like I that was not even in my vocabulary of something I was doing. So I actually was kind of in the space of, you know, I would even call it more spiritual new age, you know, like in that world. And then That changed tremendously. Once I started to be like, okay, what is faith? What is in the Bible?

SPEAKER_01What is, you know, so it's, yeah, the whole, the whole thing has shifted. But the interesting thing is, and it's way more similar than to how I was as a child. Now, And I'm just like, Whoa, like, how cool is that? Like, how beautiful is that?

SPEAKER_00But- So something happened.

SPEAKER_01Oh, yeah.

SPEAKER_00So would you say you were a successful, you had a major Broadway show, you went touring with these characters? Something happened. So what, I can tell there's two parts of your life. What happened? Let's go professional life and we can talk spiritual life. We can talk about both because that's what this podcast is trying to do. There's a crisis or something that happens in your professional life. Would you say that happened?

SPEAKER_00What was it?

SPEAKER_01It was around 2014. I was actually having a conversation about this last night at the Super Bowl. Interesting. Yeah.

SPEAKER_00See, Super does that.

SPEAKER_01It does that. It does that. My childhood, I did such a beautiful childhood and I had a beautiful beginning to my adult life. It really was this amazing experience where I played the lead in a Broadway show when I was 24, that was my lifelong dream. And these things would just happen. And it would just, I would set out to do something and it would just happen and just happen. I went through around 2014, a two year span,

SPEAKER_01where like, all these things that had never happened in my life, all happened at the same time, within like three months apart, like tragedies, deaths, losing representation, Sicknesses in the family, taking care of people, witnessing things that I never should have seen, all kinds of stuff within like everything was like two to three months apart. And I it was like, I always felt like a resilient person. But it's almost like it's you're like, like, you just can't get back up again.

SPEAKER_00You're like, Okay, where are you living at this point?

SPEAKER_01I was in LA. Um, no, I was kind of in between. I was like Nashville, LA, New York. This is when I was writing music and starting to become a better writer, had taken a break from theater. And, um, kind of at the end of that with, it was a death of a childhood friend that like, you know, I just, it was just so shocking. And I got to this point where I was like, okay, Carrie, you've been sad long enough, like, because I've been, it just was like a wreck for two years.

SPEAKER_01And, um, I go, you're done being sad. Like you have to figure this out.

SPEAKER_00Do you have a man at this point? No, no. What was your romantic life? What was it doing to inform these, these difficult times?

SPEAKER_01It wasn't, there was no,

SPEAKER_00there's no guy.

SPEAKER_01No. And I've spent a lot of my I mean, I have been in relationships and long term relationships, but I spent a lot of my adult life navigating these waters without that, which I think is a very difficult thing. You know, it's like you just have to make all the decisions on your own. You know, you have to kind of figure out the next right thing on your own. You have to deal with it. Not to say that I don't, of course, have family and friends and, you know, but there was a span of time where I felt like I was the person who had to help everybody and that's okay.

SPEAKER_00Were you doing that to yourself or was it true? Were you kind of on your own? Could your mom have had those conversations if you called?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, but it was almost as like, you know, when you're in a situation where somebody else is going through something Way worse than what you're experiencing. You don't want to put that on them. And I also, too, during that time, I will very openly say I was not the best version of myself because I was so stressed out and I was so unequipped to handle this many things at the same time. So that element of it was very, it was so difficult.

SPEAKER_01You don't want to burden people, but then you also just don't know how to Ask for help. If people need you more than you need them, you just have to suck it up. You know what I mean?

SPEAKER_00These are real problems you were having. You talked about death of a friend. You talked about losing. Would you say you lost your career in those two 14, 15 in there?

SPEAKER_01I would say it was just kind of, Because I do different things and because I was kind of on theater and then started doing music, I had a foot in both worlds, which I think was difficult for the representation for both of those worlds at the time. I think it's different now, but it's almost like choose a lane kind of thing. And then it just by the timing of it, everything just sort of fell apart at the same time. And I was like, okay, I am on my own doing this.

SPEAKER_00Wow. This is painful.

SPEAKER_01Oh yeah, super painful.

SPEAKER_00I'm trying to figure out, I have some experience with performers. Before I married my one and only wife, I dated a performer. Did you? Yeah, she just won a Tony Award actually. She was on Broadway and then all this happened and then it's really funny. Then literally in the theater next to where my kid was singing. She was singing and won a Tony for

SPEAKER_00the one about the band Buena Vista Club. Oh, Buena Vista.

SPEAKER_03Okay. Yeah.

SPEAKER_00So then I saw her and my kid's like, that was your girlfriend. I was like, what? That is. So I had some experience with that. How much of your problems were, let's call them real. It's a hard question. And how much of it were diva problems? There's a lot of divas singing lead at Broadway, right?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, oh yeah. But I will say it's like- You

SPEAKER_00don't seem like a diva. But I'm not even calling it that it's bad. Some of my favorite football players are wide receiver divas. And they're really good at what they do. You know what I'm saying?

SPEAKER_01Well, we have to talk about what the definition of a diva is.

SPEAKER_00Let's do it.

SPEAKER_01I would say If you're performing at a high level, you need what you need to be able to do your job. You're not going to compromise. Like I need, you know, like for example, if I'm like eating this way my entire life and then I go to a gig and I don't have those things available to me, it's like I'm sacrificing my performance. You know what I'm saying? Like I live in a way that facilitates singing at the level that I sing at.

SPEAKER_00Right. So you need certain drinks. You need certain things. You need rest.

SPEAKER_01You can't deal with like, Transportation that like wipes you out completely so you can't do your job. Like it's not a diva. It's just like, well, if you want me to perform at this level, like I can't show up and be exhausted and don't have food waiting for me when I have an hour in between, you know, that kind of stuff. So it's like, and that's something I've had to learn with time. But also I do feel like performers that are at a high level, they have a different sensory awareness and they have a different emotional need that is like, I need,

SPEAKER_01I need space to be able to be present with what I have to go on stage and do what I have what I'm going to be doing. So it's not some people are good at like, I can grab lunch before I can go do this before I can go to I'm not that way. I'm like, I need space and time. And I need to be silent. And I need to have all my stuff ready to go. So I don't have to stress out beforehand.

SPEAKER_00Even when we, before we hit play here and record, you went, are we about to hit record? And then you went like this, I need to take one more break. And I was like, what's she going to do? Well, before I do, before I always go to the bathroom one more time. Touch up. By the way, I have four daughters and a wife and I like Pevis. They're great. But this is really interesting. It's almost like a soldier.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I'm not going into that firefight right now. Yeah, there is a reason I'm asking for these kind of glasses so I can see at night. Jerk. Don't under-equip me for this hard task.

SPEAKER_01Yes, and you have to be realistic about like, The way that I perform is incredibly athletic. Anybody who plays somebody like Alphaba or sings these humongous ballads or like that is a stamina thing, it's an endurance thing, but it takes something to do It's not like you just stand on a stage and you open your mouth and you have to work out. You have to keep your body in shape. You have to have your muscles functioning. You have to be stretched. You have to like all of this stuff. So it's like what you see on stage when it looks easy takes a tremendous amount

SPEAKER_01of work to be able to execute.

SPEAKER_00It's amazing that you just sang at the Kennedy Center and I watched it and it seemed easy, but it's not.

SPEAKER_01You know, that actually performed, it's not easy, but that performance had a lot of ease to it. And that was sort of a specific moment in time where I feel like I, and this is where I'll talk about diva-ness again. That experience, I had everything I needed at a level I had never had it before.

SPEAKER_03Mm-hmm.

SPEAKER_01Like an escort from the commander of the Pentagon, like I had like everything in a row, everything was in my dressing room, everything like I was like, Whoa, This is next level, to feel this taken care of. So I had so much space. So I was so at ease in a way that I- Is that right? Yes, that I've never been in, like ever. And then that showed me really what was possible because when you really think about it, it's like I had done all my own shows and I'm handling the camera crew

SPEAKER_01and I'm paying people and I'm doing this and I'm doing that. Carrying my bags and I'm jumping in and I'm getting change and finding my outfits. And, you know, and so it's just it is a different thing when you show up and you feel taken care of in that way. It's like, then I was able to just go on stage. I mean, all I was doing was like praying on my way there. Because it had

SPEAKER_00all been prepared. It had all been taken care of.

SPEAKER_01Nothing had my mind. I just got to be present. And I try my best to always, it's usually in that breath right before I start, that I have trained myself to, no matter what's going on, be there. But that was a special thing for me to be able to have all of that already taken care of. And so when I got there, all I did was just do what I was there to do.

SPEAKER_00And it was tough. That was classic. One mic, one singer, very little music behind you. It was intense. When does the performer, when does it get dark though? When does the divas start to go too far? You know, we hear stories.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. I think it's when, I think it's really more of just like a respect thing.

SPEAKER_00Ah, with people.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, like if people are like, if you sort of feel like,

SPEAKER_00if you feel- Like if you just started cursing Derek right now. Never. I'm sitting over there in the dark. Oh, Derek. That'd be bad.

SPEAKER_01Do you think I'd do that, John?

SPEAKER_00No, but I feel like that's when a diva goes dark.

SPEAKER_01What the F is going on?

SPEAKER_00Why is this fly in here? Someone doesn't have to kill this fly, I'm out. I think there are very few divas that are like how you're describing. You don't think there's a diva right now that would want to be pissed about this fly?

SPEAKER_01I'm sure there is one, but I don't think that's the norm for people who are like at a real professional level. That's fair. You know, that's what I've gathered, but I haven't worked with a lot of like true divas.

SPEAKER_00Could you tell a story when you went, whoa, whoa. But you don't have to name them. It's kind of fun if you do. But I mean, there's only like 11 people watching this anyway.

SPEAKER_01It's going to be huge. I'm already in all kinds of trouble. So I don't know if I want to die on that hill, John. Don't do it.

SPEAKER_00Don't do it. But there's had to be a time when you were like, whoa, what's your craziest show when you were like, that was nuts? Like from a person or from like a- Whether maybe you attended or maybe there was, well, you're a performer. This is what I'm getting at.

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_00We're on this side watching. You're on the other side. Yeah. On the other side, when did something go like either for your show or other show where you're like, whoa, that's not, wow, let's not let that get in the news. Is there a time like that where something happened?

SPEAKER_01Not like, not get that in the news, but like, I will say things like my first time going on for Alphaba and like things like that. Like if anybody had known- Alphaba? In Wicked.

SPEAKER_00Oh, that's it. The Greenwood. Okay.

SPEAKER_01If anybody had known what that, what led to that of the first moment of getting on that stage, um, It's like you show up and you do it and you're like, okay, I'm here, I'm on stage. And there's so much happening. Like backseat, like you're literally running for your entrance. Like you're, I'm sprinting upstairs. I'm like, you know, things like that. And then the doors open and you grab your suitcase and you're like, I'm here. And I am on stage. And then you're rolling. And you're rolling and you're just, you know, but I will say that training for me,

SPEAKER_01especially as a standby was some of the best training I ever had as a person who has to do hard things in the moment and get in the zone. Like no matter the circumstances, it's like I have to do my job and I'm going to do it.

SPEAKER_00It sounds like the corporate aspect of those Broadway shows, it didn't kill the art. You were still able to, a lot of people complain, you know, everything becomes corporate and then it loses its heart.

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_00It doesn't sound like that was happening to you.

SPEAKER_01No, not too much.

SPEAKER_00Okay.

SPEAKER_01I think you stay in something a long time. It's hard to keep it fresh.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah.

SPEAKER_01You know, people do the same show for like four or five years. That's difficult.

SPEAKER_00So you're doing well, things get hard.

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_00And then COVID comes.

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_00And you have some opportunities.

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_00Can you tell us about it? COVID was hard for you, right? Yeah. Like I'm talking about in a professional level as a performer. One of the things I want to get into in these conversations was I really find performers fascinating. And I'm talking about like, I'm talking about like people on a trapeze.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah.

SPEAKER_00Or I think a football player is just performing. I'm talking about all those cats that walk the two steps up and then we're all watching, whoever those people are.

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_00I love them. Now everyone's like, well, that's because you're vain like them. I'm like, yeah, I get that. That's probably true. But there's something cool about them. And you're doing this. And then that performance life, what did you do during COVID? And what did people say about performance and COVID that maybe was hard for you? Because I know some stuff went down.

SPEAKER_01Yes, some stuff did go down. During the beginning of COVID, and I guess this is all intertwined, like this whole, this is a huge about face in my life, you know, was the first time I actually had time. I had free time. And it was funny because everybody was jumping online and doing like weird cooking shows and like stuff. I was like, what are you doing? You know, I was like, what's happening? And people would reach out and they'd be like, will you do this with me? Will you do that? And I was like, No, like,

SPEAKER_01I have free time for the first time in my life, like, I'm gonna take a class, I'm gonna enjoy this, I'm gonna, I'm gonna go on walks, I'm gonna do this, you know, and so I think it was the first time that I had a moment to be still. I will say there were things that were asked of all of us that I was not willing to do. And because of that, I had to walk away from my industry. That was a very, very difficult decision.

SPEAKER_00You wouldn't do the thing.

SPEAKER_01Wouldn't do the thing. I wouldn't do the thing. I didn't do the thing.

SPEAKER_00I didn't have to do the thing because nobody was making me. But I got stories. But your story- I want to hear those stories.

SPEAKER_01Well, we can talk about- Well, I know people that were in medicine. Yeah.

SPEAKER_00Somehow they didn't do the thing. They were helping people who were dying.

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_00It was kind of a miracle, actually, with some of the people I'm thinking of, some of the nurses I know that didn't do the thing. Can we say the thing? I don't even want to. I feel like we'll get in trouble. I don't even want to. I don't want it to like, bleh. But we have to talk about it. We do have to talk about it. It's part of the thing. If people are still getting trouble in 2026, that's like nuts to me. But I think people still take the thing.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, and to each their own.

SPEAKER_00So you didn't. And why did you get steadfast on that?

SPEAKER_01That was something that I have never experienced in my life. Actually, I listened on your Dr. Ian McGilchrist podcast, which was so good. That one and Pavel, I was like, whoa, they were perspectives I've never heard.

SPEAKER_00It's much cooler when we're in person right now.

SPEAKER_01It's easier. I'm a big fan of- But it was great having those guys. They were amazing. Dr. Ian McGilchrist talked about intuition. And he talked about that on there. And I really appreciated that. Because I think that that is a lost signal that we have. And back then, I would say like, this was this was just my intuition, but I didn't realize how it was connected to hearing the Holy Spirit. Yeah. I, the story is a little bit wild, but I was actually meditating at the time.

SPEAKER_01I was still not a person of, I would call faith. And I was meditating at the time and I felt something I never felt. And I felt like I had gotten punched in the stomach. Like punch, punch. Like gut punch in the stomach. And what it said is something is very wrong here.

SPEAKER_00About the thing.

SPEAKER_01Just in general, the world, the thing, what you're hearing, just something is off with what's going on. And it never even crossed my mind to take it. I would, I was, I mean, I had, I've been like, you know, there's moments where I'm like, am I wrong? I always questioned myself, but like, you know, to some degree, but then I was like, no, I'm not doing this.

SPEAKER_00Who's wanting you to as a singer? I don't get it.

SPEAKER_01Every single job. Everyone. Every single one.

SPEAKER_00These are producers. These are directors.

SPEAKER_01This was our union. We had to.

SPEAKER_00Oh, okay.

SPEAKER_01We could not, we literally could not.

SPEAKER_00Which union?

SPEAKER_01Equity, SAG, everything.

SPEAKER_00So they can't, oh wow.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. So it, you know.

SPEAKER_00What did you have to do, present a piece of paper about the thing?

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_00You just wouldn't do it?

SPEAKER_01No, I can't lie. Like I'm not a, I just like don't have it in me.

SPEAKER_00You're not good at lying?

SPEAKER_01I just can't do it. It's like, it's like antithetical to my soul. I just like can't do it. That's nice to know.

SPEAKER_00That makes, I got some good questions for you.

SPEAKER_03I'll either be like whoop or I'll be like whoop.

SPEAKER_00Okay, I keep this in mind for the rest of this interview. This is exciting.

SPEAKER_01Sometimes I just have to keep my mouth shut.

SPEAKER_00Sometimes you just stare at the camera.

SPEAKER_01I don't know. What do you think, John?

SPEAKER_00Not doing that. So you couldn't work?

SPEAKER_01Could not work. Could not work. And I also could not speak freely. That was the other thing. I couldn't say whether or not I did or not because we saw- Like if you did something

SPEAKER_00like this, you couldn't talk about it.

SPEAKER_01No. I would have been canceled immediately, which eventually I was. But the culture was so extreme that we were in a position of literally being in hiding. And someone had joked- What

SPEAKER_00town were you in?

SPEAKER_01At the time I was in Well, when COVID first hit, I was in LA and then- Fun. Yeah. But it happened that all my stuff was in storage and I was able to like, I was like in between figuring out where I was moving. And so I was able to just pack up and go. And so I spent a year trying to figure out where I wanted to be.

SPEAKER_00Really?

SPEAKER_01Yeah. I was in Hudson for a while between all my family and

SPEAKER_00then- Did your intransigence about the thing also go to the mask? Would you not wear a mask too? If I just walked into a place with 100 people and I had to pick out the person who didn't wear the mask and wouldn't take the thing, I am not choosing you. You just don't look like that person. That's hilarious.

SPEAKER_01I know, I just, I know. Seems like he would have been going like, give it to

SPEAKER_00me, give it to me, mask, just by my prejudicial terrible judgment. And you're like, hell no. You're like, hell no, I'm not taking that thing. That's you.

SPEAKER_01That's me, but I don't have that accent. From Syracuse. Yeah, yeah.

SPEAKER_00I know you're like, I'm the sweetest person ever, and also, F you, I'm not taking anything.

SPEAKER_01But you do what you want. It's pretty good. Hey, you know- What did

SPEAKER_00your people, let's call it the start of your family, were they like, what are you doing? You're going to ruin this, your career.

SPEAKER_01I think there was concern for me, but certain people in my family totally respected it, and certain people in my family were very upset by it.

SPEAKER_00Was that painful?

SPEAKER_01Incredibly painful.

SPEAKER_00What about industry people in New York and LA?

SPEAKER_01They didn't know.

SPEAKER_00Why? Because you were in hiding?

SPEAKER_01I just literally was like, I'm not available. That's what I would say. Because if I said something, my career would be over. That's how this happened. It happened to a friend of mine. Explain that. What do you mean? For example, I have a dear friend of mine who we've come close to, and she's a two-time Tony nominee, and she did not take the thing. Then her status essentially got outed into the paper, and then they fabricated what had happened. But she was very respectful about everything. She followed every rule, and she just was like,

SPEAKER_01I didn't take it at this time, but feel free to back out of the job. I totally understand. And she was so respectful and amenable and respectful of what everybody else needed. And she bowed out of things that she couldn't do. And her entire story was put on page six. Someone took her story and took it to the press. And she overnight, her career was over. And poor thing. I mean, she was annihilated.

SPEAKER_00She was the goat they sent into the wilderness.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, she was annihilated.

SPEAKER_00Well, she was.

SPEAKER_01Publicly.

SPEAKER_00Was she annihilated inside?

SPEAKER_01Yeah. I mean, when you experienced that, and I have a degree of that, but like, she wasn't expecting, you know what I mean? It just literally came out of nowhere. She's just a performer. And she's so kind and gracious and such a good leader. And she is a beautiful heart. She's kind to everybody, you know? And so to watch someone like that, who I had become close with since that time, but just literally crumble. Like, that's what that does. And if that's the goal for people, like, cool,

SPEAKER_01you know, and she's, she's now way out of it and is completely, I mean, so peaceful, so successful, crushing life, doing things on her own terms.

SPEAKER_00Is she performing again or she's just out? Oh, yeah. But she is.

SPEAKER_01She's performing all the time. But I just.

SPEAKER_00Right, screw them then. Man, this is, it makes me mad.

SPEAKER_01It does. But it's, you know, and it's, and, and it makes me mad too. And it's, um, You know, we're getting to the point where it's kind of like, what are we really trying to do here? What are we trying to do? Like, what is the point of that?

SPEAKER_00You couldn't have those conversations with other performers. It was dangerous.

SPEAKER_01No, there was one person I could talk to, and she wasn't in the industry. And then we found each other. Like, we started to find each other. Literally, like, we were like, but it was walking on. Every conversation was so trepidatious. It was like, You would drop these little hints and then be like, you know, because truly if someone was onto you, and right now in 2026, I think people would be like, oh my gosh, no, that never would have happened, but that's exactly how it was. Like if you would have said something, somebody, people tried to come after me even before I was honest about things.

SPEAKER_01They tried to come after me because I wasn't saying things. People tried to end my career.

SPEAKER_00Just for being silent.

SPEAKER_01Just for being silent. People tried to end my career, take it upon themselves.

SPEAKER_00Spiritually, what do you think that was? I get it. There's some Freudian explanation, but spiritually, how did you come to know their reaction? Were they afraid? What was happening in terms of the spiritual world for them? What do you think?

SPEAKER_01There's nothing new under the sun, right? There's nothing new under the sun. And we want to act like we're all, we have changed as a culture and you've spent so much time in the rest of the world and America's different. But I don't have that in me. I've never had it in me to be like, I'm going to take them down. I've never had that. I don't even understand it. But I have had that come at me.

SPEAKER_00So you think envy was a spiritual piece in play?

SPEAKER_01Well, I mean, if we're talking about what we're talking about now, which is like the context of 2020, it was like, if you disagree with me, you are my enemy. Like literally that, and I will take you down.

SPEAKER_00Why did it take down though?

SPEAKER_01I don't know. That's another level. Not everybody's like that. Some people are like, I don't get you or I'm really upset or whatever. But there are a few people who are literally like, I want to end your career and said really horrible things to me.

SPEAKER_00Are you sure you weren't out there like, this is all a big thing?

SPEAKER_01Honestly, I've not talked about the thing until this moment.

SPEAKER_00Really? Yeah. Oh, it's an exclusive. It's an exclusive. Yeah. It's really interesting. I want to get a little further into this because I saw it too. I traveled to Africa during 220 into 220.

SPEAKER_03Yeah.

SPEAKER_00221 too. It wasn't happening there. They kept calling a white man's disease. It was hilarious. In West Africa, Andy's. They were like, that's not a disease for us.

SPEAKER_03Yeah.

SPEAKER_00I was like, well, why are you getting the shot? Because they were getting shipments of it. They go, so we can get the money. They would tell you point blank.

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_00In Mozambique, the mayor told me that of our town.

SPEAKER_01Wow.

SPEAKER_00Just straight up, like, well, how am I supposed to get the money if I don't?

SPEAKER_01Do the thing.

SPEAKER_00They invented, this is a fact, a place called Karane. They invented a holiday so that all the farmers would come in and they all gave them a shot for the holiday and they gave them money. That's how the mayor was taking a lot of money from the European Union to give the shots to these guys.

SPEAKER_01Wow.

SPEAKER_00That is weird.

SPEAKER_01That is weird.

SPEAKER_00He thought when he was telling me the story, because he was looking me in the face with my friend, he was like, isn't it great?

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_00Because he thought we were like representatives of the idea of everyone should have this shot when my buddy and I were actually just trying to not get the shot. I can travel without the shot. Sorry, the thing. But he said it so honestly.

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_00It was disconcerting.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, he's just like, this is the truth. This is the fact.

SPEAKER_00It's so great. I just didn't want to fight with this guy.

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_00And that was happening in America with people that you know. Now, did you meet people in the industry that also had your opinion and still took the shot and then played the game?

SPEAKER_01Yes. And people who did the thing and then really regretted it and wish they didn't.

SPEAKER_00Oh, they regret it now. Interesting. Were you going to an Orthodox church during all that? Not at all. When did you return to your childhood faith?

SPEAKER_01It's kind of intertwined in this time and the stillness. I had moved myself to Nashville in the beginning of 2021. How I describe it is I had to be somewhere and nowhere at the same time so that I could figure out what I thought and what I believed. Have time and space to get clear with myself. Because there was a lot going on for everybody. And so I didn't tell anybody I moved there except for my parents and one friend.

SPEAKER_01And I just was there for months being like, okay, I have to build a new life. Like, what is happening?

SPEAKER_00Like, what were you like, how'd you eat? You had money from before?

SPEAKER_01Well, by the grace of God, I had played Carnegie Hall in February of 2020. We were the last show to play there with the New York Pops, me and two other singers. It was an amazing show. And I'm so thankful because we were the last one. And I have previously I have taught about the instrument of the voice only because about 15 years ago, 10-15 years ago, people kept coming to me being like, Can you show me how to do what you do? And I was like, I don't know, maybe.

SPEAKER_01And then- Unlikely. Yeah, unlikely. But then I started to figure out like, oh, I understand this thing, and I know how to teach it. And I love it. And so I do, there's an element of wanting to pass it along. But it was like, right after that show, that I had finally said to myself, I said, Look, I've had a great career, I have a great career. And I really care about this thing. And I want to pass this along. And I, in February of 2020, basically did a beta test of this online program.

SPEAKER_00Teaching.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, sharing about the instrument and teaching and, you know, because for me, it's bigger than just singing. It's like the spiritual component, the heart. It's like a lot of stuff I was never taught and ever, ever taught, like the fullness of the instrument, the whole holistic side of it. And so I launched this thing and then COVID hit. And like, I was like, Gosh, thank you.

SPEAKER_00That's wild. It was wild.

SPEAKER_01And I wasn't even still, again,

SPEAKER_00I wasn't at the church. But it was protected because COVID let stuff online.

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_00Carnegie Hall.

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_00Then online. And so, okay. So you can feed yourself and you can pay rent.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. Feed myself and pay rent. And at the time they were, we were all like on, we were able to file for unemployment. Like all performers were able to file for unemployment too. Oh, okay.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, that's right. There was a lot of money flowing around.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. So it was like, okay, like it actually was totally fine. And then, but I, go ahead.

SPEAKER_00But Nashville was a hideout then.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. So I moved to Nashville in the beginning of 2021 and I, Ended up making a film. But before I made this film, it was a short film, I had gotten this little hit that was like, I don't know, maybe go to church. And I was like, I don't know. And then I got another little hit that was like, Carrie, like, why do you because I have like strong feelings about Christianity.

SPEAKER_01And I think that's the culture of New York City, right? It's like you If you're not in the faith, everything, there's everything else. And if you're in everything else, you just are like, that's not for me. And that was where I was. And so I had a real kind of like aversion to it, if I'm being honest. And then finally, I was like, okay, Carrie, like, why do you act like you know me? What you're talking about and you have the ability to have such a strong opinion about this when you haven't even read scripture. I just had to kind of just give yourself a little slap and be like, get it together.

SPEAKER_01Who are you being right now? You haven't even read this. You don't even know what you're talking about and you have these really strong opinions. So there was a little bit of calling myself out and being like, okay, fine, I'll read it and then I'll make a decision.

SPEAKER_00Look at you. You're in charge.

SPEAKER_01You're in charge, but I'll do my best. Well, that's it. That's the magic trick.

SPEAKER_00You got to come out of your delusion.

SPEAKER_01You got to come out of your delusion. I got some wise words that were basically like, well, if you've never read it, I think you should start with the New Testament. I did.

SPEAKER_00By the way, good advice.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah. Obviously, we go back and read all of it. But, you know, I started to read it. I was like, Oh, wow. I was like, I'm feeling things. Okay, whoa. But I still was not, you know, I was not kind of sold. And then I ended up making this film, which was basically, I mean, this is probably important to share, but this is how I came to my faith was God came to me through my art and through my voice. And So I'll share a little bit of this, if that's okay. But basically, so the timing is 2021, moved to Nashville by summer of 2021.

SPEAKER_01And there was a real grieving process because I had to be like, I guess I'm done working.

SPEAKER_00Oh, it felt like that.

SPEAKER_01Oh, yeah. I was like, because I had to say no to a job. They just were like, we can't have you here. And they didn't even really know where I was at. There were certain things with testing and certain things. I just was like, Everything was changing. You just had to say yes, no matter how it changed. I was like, I'm not okay with this. You don't get to have all my information all the time. I don't know who you are. You can't put things in my mouth and my nose all the time. Where's this coming from? I was not down with that. And if you're down with it, great, but I was not. And so I started reading the Bible in the middle of 2021.

SPEAKER_01I started to feel things. Ended up deciding to go out on my own and sing. And I did these like small gatherings of people. The first show that I did was at a property in Asheville, North Carolina. A lot of people who felt the same way, but were wanting to get together and gather. And it was just me and the sky and a sound system and a keyboard and people. And I just shared my heart and I was so honest and something happened

SPEAKER_01and it was like, it was just the next level of Connectedness and emotion and intimacy and purity of just how art once was and could be. And there were some people that are in the industry, in the sort of more film directing production side of things. And they were like, whatever, because I wanted to kind of make a documentary. And they said, whatever you're doing, we want in, we're in, whatever it is. And I was like, okay.

SPEAKER_01And so we ended up making this documentary, and it was about me going on my own. And I was pretty vague about it, but it was basically like, nobody gets to tell me whether I do this or not. I literally said the words, this is between me and God. And now looking back, so another thing happened around this time where, again, I haven't really talked about, exclusive to you, John.

SPEAKER_00This is exclusive. This is exclusive. Make a note of that. Also, we're going to link up to your documentary.

SPEAKER_01Yeah,

SPEAKER_00it's out there. Yeah, it is.

SPEAKER_01It is. And so I had done these a couple of shows where we did film it, again, in Asheville, and then in Nashville. And I talked a little bit, we did like a mini interview. And it was about kind of the hope of continuing on in doing it in this way. And then God kind of had some other plans. Oh, yeah. And so I had bought like this huge SUV when I moved to Nashville. And you know, I was like, I was like, I'm gonna go, I'm going wrong.

SPEAKER_01Wait, hold on.

SPEAKER_00You had an SUV?

SPEAKER_01Yeah. Yeah.

SPEAKER_00Again, that doesn't seem like you'd be driving an SUV.

SPEAKER_01It's humongous, John. It's a seven passenger SUV. Like, why do I have that car?

SPEAKER_00Did you just pick people up?

SPEAKER_01I have a little seat that helps me like see, you know.

SPEAKER_00Were you like the gypsy cabs of the 1990s and you just pick people up randomly and charge them cash?

SPEAKER_03Get in.

SPEAKER_00It's for real.

SPEAKER_03Yeah. Totally, that's me. They're like, how much? You're like, I don't know, how

SPEAKER_00much you got in your pocket?

SPEAKER_03Exactly. Yeah, man, hop in.

SPEAKER_00Come on in.

SPEAKER_03I got six more seats of you.

SPEAKER_01It's just like ridiculous. Like, why did I do that? But I just, I was like, you know, I gotta have room in my car. Like, I gotta go rogue. Like, I'm going, I'm, I'm getting all my equipment. I'm, you know, the whole thing. And, and so I, I had this big plan. And then I end up getting an injury, very unexpected injury that happened in all of this territory, mouth, Bite, palate, neck, teeth, everything.

SPEAKER_01That I thought it was going to be like a month. That was end of 2021. I'm still dealing with it now. It's monumentally better.

SPEAKER_00Did you know what the injury was?

SPEAKER_01It was a dental thing that went horribly wrong and then kept going wrong and more wrong. Got it. And it was like, this is going wrong. And the mouth is so sensitive. It's a different level. The nerves are different there. It's like a thousand times what I would feel in my finger.

SPEAKER_00You know, like it's like- Yeah, you're bumming me out. Stop talking about it. I know, it's the whole thing. Because people get scared of dentists.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, I know, I know.

SPEAKER_00But you were suffering with that right before you were going

SPEAKER_01to- Oh,

SPEAKER_00yeah. Go on the middle finger tour, basically.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, and I thought it was going to be a quick thing, like a quick thing, and it wasn't. What ended up happening is that so this was like the we had filmed everything. We had made an edit. And I was really struggling because I was like, what just happened like this? This was a mistake. This shouldn't have never happened. I'm trying to think of a name for the film. And I'm like, you know, I'm like, maybe it's called resonance or remembrance.

SPEAKER_01I'm thinking of all these names of film and I'm Greek. I was like, you know what? It's got to be a Greek word because Greek words are so much more robust.

SPEAKER_00Of course it does.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, it's so much more robust and it's got all these other meanings.

SPEAKER_00The Greeks answer all the questions. I'm sure your father told you.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, they do. We have all the answers. We have all the answers.

SPEAKER_03Yes, exactly.

SPEAKER_01And so I was like, looking at all these words. And for whatever reason, I am again, still not I hadn't even really been back to church much yet. I mean, I think I had gone once and I we can talk about that too. But I had started to go back. But it was not like a thing. I just sat in the back. I didn't want to make any friends. And I was like, literally just in the back by myself. So I end up choosing a word. Because of the philosophical version, not the theological.

SPEAKER_00Not the theological.

SPEAKER_01I had no concept of the theological. Interesting. I ended up choosing a word. And I'm like, oh, this is it. This is the one. This is the name of the film. And the name of the film is Metanoia.

SPEAKER_00Ooh, I knew that.

SPEAKER_01Metonia. Metonia. So a change of mind, which is basically, but I was looking at the philosophical version of this word, which was to go into the cave to turn from the dark towards the light. And I was like, oh, that's me. Like, I feel that. Well, yeah, like, you know, I've always changed.

SPEAKER_00Amazing, dude.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, totally. So I was like, yeah, turn from the dark towards the light. I had read on one little Facebook thing that it was like, oh, metanoia means repentance. And I was like, oh, nobody's going to know that.

SPEAKER_00I mean, not for me. For me, it's a really different thing.

SPEAKER_01Talk about the hubris. It's embarrassing. That's interesting for you, but I don't really do that.

SPEAKER_00I'm talking about the light. That's not what it means for me.

SPEAKER_01I literally was like, nobody's going to do that. It's so ridiculous.

SPEAKER_00I do repentance, but not the way you do it.

SPEAKER_01I do the light. I'm out of the cave. Yeah, I'm out of the cave. I'm good.

SPEAKER_00I'm the one.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, it's so stupid. I love this. It's so ridiculous.

SPEAKER_00The train is chugging down the tracks at you. Oh my, it's like God is coming for you.

SPEAKER_01Oh, coming, coming for me. And so I'm still at church, sitting in the back by myself, like not making any friends and trying to make sense of things. And I'm in agony with this injury, like literally agony. Like I'm like, am I ever going to sing again? Like what's going to happen? So The day that I released this film, it was on February 2, 2022. I couldn't do anything to promote it. I couldn't do anything other than literally get it online. And I just like put it on YouTube. And that was it. And I am that night, I'm like, on my knees.

SPEAKER_01Like, I'm like, help me. Like, I am don't know what to do. I've never experienced it. And the voice to me was something that I was like, I can't like, What if I can't do this? It's such a spiritual kind of something to be with that I never anticipated. And so on that Friday, I release a film, and I'm like, on my knees.

SPEAKER_01And that Sunday, I go to church, I'm sitting in the back, making no friends. And the entire sermon is about metanoia. And I'm like, okay. And I just couldn't believe how personal it was. It was like, okay. He literally came to me through the only language I would listen to, which is my voice and my art.

SPEAKER_01And in a way that was like, you're just going to sit there and you're going to listen. And I joke that God has benched me for three years. But it was... It was, and I also joke that I'm like, I like accidentally named my film Repentance. I like accidentally, like God has a sense of humor, you know? And I'm like, wow, that's crazy. So now you got to do it. Yeah. Well, and then I just, and then I even said this to my priest later on, I just said, you know, it really never even occurred to me that I was a sinner.

SPEAKER_01Like, you know, I just, that's a weird thing to say, but I think When you try to live a good life reasonably, you're like, oh, I make mistakes, it's not a big deal, you know, but I'm going to try it better next time. But that's not what that is.

SPEAKER_00This is a heresy of Christianity.

SPEAKER_01Yes. Exactly.

SPEAKER_00No one lives a good life.

SPEAKER_01No one lives a good life. Me, most of all.

SPEAKER_00You know how I know? Because they die. If they lived a good life, they would live, they would have died. Yeah. But they keep dying. So something went wrong.

SPEAKER_01It's going to happen to you, it's going to happen to me.

SPEAKER_00It's not meant to happen.

SPEAKER_01It's not meant to happen.

SPEAKER_00So we keep doing it, but it's interesting. So then did you wake up by staying, did you keep going back to that same parish?

SPEAKER_01Oh yeah.

SPEAKER_00Because you had to sit in it. You had to sit in it. In other words, you had to wake up. Was there a moment when you're like, I don't need to go back there? Or you knew right away you had to go back?

SPEAKER_01It has never wavered. I had to miss church a couple times because of the last few weeks and all I wanted to do was go back to church. I was just like, oh my God.

SPEAKER_00That feels like the end of something. It feels like the end of, like you said, in your early 20s, you were giving it, giving it, giving it, giving it, and then stuff started to happen in a way. And then COVID really like, Something about that courage you had allowed you to keep going to this moment of repentance. What happened next?

SPEAKER_01Well, I started to kind of approach the faith as if I were a convert. Because I really felt like I knew so little. And I said this last night, and it's one of my favorite things. I think I said it to you too. It's one of my favorite things that somebody said to me, I can't remember who did, but I'm definitely not gonna take credit for it. But because I'm what they call cradle, right? I was baptized as a baby. And the churches back then were immigrant churches. So like was all in Greek. And I was like thinking about singing and other things.

SPEAKER_01And now the church is filled with all these converts and catechumens. And they say that Cradle knows what they're doing, but they don't know why they're doing it. And converts know why they're doing it, but they don't know what they're doing.

SPEAKER_03And I think that's so beautiful,

SPEAKER_01because it really is like, we're all kind of now in this position where we're all learning from each other. And so I really approached the faith as if I were a convert. And so I was in catechism. I was taking the classes, even though I'm baptized, you know, and I was taking several sets of classes, honestly, because at first we had a priest that was leaving and then a new priest coming in. So I was taking him in another parish.

SPEAKER_00This is in Nashville? Did you start to friend up? Did the orthos start to...

SPEAKER_01For a minute I did. And then I sort of had to like kind of chill out on that because I, as I was reentering, I would say the faith, I didn't, I really was mindful. I didn't want it to be because of social reasons. And not to say that that's not valuable. I think there's a real important thing Element to creating those relationships. But at that beginning time, like that first year, I was like, I don't want to do it that way.

SPEAKER_01And also, too, a lot of the people that I knew had converted. And my story was different because I had already lived the faith. I mean, I knew the faith. I wasn't living the faith. But I was like, this is familiar to me. I actually have to know if this is real.

SPEAKER_00It's a harder conversion in some ways for you.

SPEAKER_01Oh, yeah. And I joke that a friend said this to me a while ago, but it's like if you had said this would be my life seven years ago, I would have been like, love that for you. No way was this on my radar at all. And now it's the best thing that's ever happened to me by a long shot. Oh, really? A long shot.

SPEAKER_00So you stand up now and say, this is who I am. I'm Orthodox and I'm a singer and a writer and whatever. How's that going?

SPEAKER_01Well, we had a moment. Is it like having COVID again?

SPEAKER_00Is it like, oh God, she won't take the shot and she's orthodox.

SPEAKER_01Well, and there's even more, but I did end up having a moment where I spoke freely and I knew I was going to get some pushback. I didn't know I was going to get the pushback I got, but I had a version of like, Everybody coming after me and trying to essentially cancel me too.

SPEAKER_00Again?

SPEAKER_01Nobody, the first one was more private.

SPEAKER_00It was like DMs and- Because you were silent.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, DMs and like I would hear like a producer reached out to me and was like, Carrie, this person's calling all your colleagues and saying this, this and this about you. And I was like, I haven't even talked to this person. This is crazy. So, but this time I just got to the point where I was like, okay, no one that I know That feels how I feel is speaking out in the industry. And I got to the point where it's just like, this is my life's work, like about is freedom of expression is using the voice, however, you need to use it.

SPEAKER_01And, and so I just thought to myself, well, if I can't do it, who can? And so I did end up speaking out about my beliefs. And And got slammed, totally slammed.

SPEAKER_00Who's slamming you at that point? This is like 222, three, four, right there? Four. 224. Who's the slammers?

SPEAKER_01Come on, say it. A lot of the, it's just entertainment industry, you know, a lot of Broadway.

SPEAKER_00It's like a trifecta. So you kind of loud, loud is the wrong word, you're willing to openly talk about your orthodoxy, openly talk about the thing, not taking the thing, and then openly talk about your political positions. And so boom.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. Well, I didn't, I didn't honestly talk about the thing or orthodoxy for a while. You know, I think I maybe was sharing about, you know, posting pictures at the church or things like that. But like, you know, nobody really knew where I was at with that. That's, that's been mostly like, just Something I'm doing, you know, I'm personal, but I did get to the point where, you know, I just felt like I was choking, you know, I was like, kind of like, I am not saying, I'm like, not being myself, you know what I mean?

SPEAKER_01Like, I'm not saying, and I'm not extreme by any means, like, But I do think that there's this middle world where some of us lean a little this way and some of us lean a little this way. And this is where the real meat of things is. And this is where things get done and where conversations happen. And that's an important place to be. And I think if you don't have that in your life, if your friendships and relationships don't reflect that, It's so easy to go really far in one direction on both sides.

SPEAKER_01And that's not healthy by any means. And so I was kind of like in this middle being like, okay, well, I'm kind of here right now. And then that's where this all began. So that's when people started to kind of, and it was really all online. Some of it was direct And I also got a ton of support, like a tremendous amount of support.

SPEAKER_00But for saying what kind of things were you getting a hard time for?

SPEAKER_01I was saying that I supported RFK Jr. And then I supported where he, his camp, like where he went to, you know, I sang for his campaign.

SPEAKER_00You mean the guy used to be a Democrat? It's kind

SPEAKER_01of weird. I know. Obviously, that shifted. He would have had my vote. That shifted. You do the best you can. You make the choices the best that you can. Obviously, none of this is ideal circumstances, but it was important for me to be able to express myself. It's interesting. We're in South Carolina right now. Part of the reason why I ended up doing that at that time was because of the floods that happened. And I saw firsthand,

SPEAKER_01I have a lot of people I'm close to in Asheville, and I saw firsthand what they were dealing with and how we were not getting an accurate representation and how they got no help.

SPEAKER_00Because of their perceived conservative mountain man viewpoints from each coast, right? They were like the lost people. We don't have to work hard to try to- Try to help them. To try to help them. You saw that.

SPEAKER_01I saw it firsthand and I was like, this is insane. And I just watched people make fun of it. And the amount of loss and death and things that happened, it was just like, It was biblical. You know what I mean? It was really bad. It was really bad.

SPEAKER_00People still not found.

SPEAKER_01My dad said this to me, and I just got to the point where I was kind of like, I don't know. I'm not in this position where I have a family and all this stuff, but it's like, These are, you know, our houses, these are our kids, these are, you know, are that and like, no one's helping them. Like every all the help they got was from private citizens and nonprofits. And I and, you know, my dad said to me, he goes, you know, you're the guardians now.

SPEAKER_01And that had never occurred to me again. You know, especially being the entertainment. It's like, you're always just kind of like, well, I'm not my thing. I'm just like, wait, no, I am. We are the guardians now.

SPEAKER_00Guardians of?

SPEAKER_01What's happening? You know, like the kids. Of showing the truth? Well, no, just like taking care of each other. You know what I'm saying? It's like we're kind of in this middle generation of like the kids are the kids and the grownups are getting older. And it's like, you're like, okay, well, like we got to take care of everybody.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I think you're describing something that happened to a lot of people during COVID. Yeah, same more. And then during the hurricanes up here. And you're right. It feels like that 10-year-old kid that was making the to-do list every day. Yeah. Started to make to-do lists again, and you got focused.

SPEAKER_01Yes, I did.

SPEAKER_00It feels like it, yeah?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, it's a nice way to put it, John. I hadn't thought about it that way.

SPEAKER_00Well, and maybe the things you got focused on, it doesn't feel like politics. It feels like honesty, like you're just not willing to do the bullshit anymore.

SPEAKER_01That's exactly right.

SPEAKER_00Does that sound right?

SPEAKER_01That's exact. My tolerance for it just became zero.

SPEAKER_00So this is my point, because in your world, and my New York friends who are very Orthodox, like me, when they go to say those things loudly about, yeah, I go to church, yeah, I cover my head when I go to, immediately in the world they're in, they're dancers and singers and stuff too. They can't say those things because they get labeled, they weirdly get labeled as like racialists or racists. It's very weird though. But you're just not taking it anymore.

SPEAKER_01Well, I mean, everybody has said, called me every name under the sun at this point. And it's like, I mean, it's just so inaccurate. You know what I mean? It's just like, it gets to a point where it's just laughable. It's just like, you don't know how to make sense of anything, especially when it's a person who knows me. And I have a real relationship with.

SPEAKER_00And they still jump to the political cartoon.

SPEAKER_01They jump to the conclusion. Yeah, they jump to the political extreme. And I'm like, whoa, whoa, whoa, whoa, whoa.

SPEAKER_00What is it about that culture? Why are they doing that? What's the deal with the entertainment biz?

SPEAKER_01I think it's just, I mean, and I understand it because I was on the, I had a major flip. I mean, I was on the other side of that. I wouldn't say I was that extreme, but I had a moment of what I would call my own cognitive dissonance, but I caught myself. This was in 2017. Because I was more on the other end politically.

SPEAKER_00And I had a really bad- Other end, meaning you were more, let's just say, liberal? Yeah. Okay.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. And I had a really bad conversation with somebody I love the most. And it was like something came out of me that I had never experienced. It was like a total attack. And there was wine involved. And all of a sudden, it was very scary.

SPEAKER_00And you were attacking as a progressive, not against progressives.

SPEAKER_01Yes, as one. Got you. Being like, you're wrong. How could you do this? Right. And then the next day, I was like, what was that? For real? Oh my gosh. I literally was like, that was not me.

SPEAKER_00You know what I think it is? What? It's just politics as religion.

SPEAKER_01I agree.

SPEAKER_00I mean, if someone comes start trashing Christ, I'm going to probably at some point go rawr. Yeah. You know what I'm saying?

SPEAKER_01I agree.

SPEAKER_00I don't know what point, but I might. Because I actually want to die on that hill. And I find a lot of people want to die on weird hills.

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_00You know what I'm saying?

SPEAKER_01I do. I do.

SPEAKER_00It feels like they were trying to kill you on a lot of hills. But you weren't a killer, right? You weren't really trying to destroy people. You just wanted to tell the truth.

SPEAKER_01I just wanted to be able to speak freely and tell the truth. Yeah. I don't have that in me. I don't have that in me. Like I'm like a...

SPEAKER_00So can you make music now telling the truth? I'm going to say, I believe a lot of what you tell is the truth. But we can say the things you believe to be true. Can you make music now doing that? It's happening?

SPEAKER_01It's happening.

SPEAKER_00You have a new album out, which I'll probably say in some intro somewhere.

SPEAKER_01The last album I made was in, well, I released, I was working on it for years, was in 2019. And it's called The 44th Court. And that the wildness is that that preemptively was actually about where I am now.

SPEAKER_00Oh, really?

SPEAKER_01Yeah. It's like all about like the coming around of something bigger than myself and God. And then this season, I ended up I honestly did not think I was going to make music again. I just it's so much to take on. As you know, I like run a business now I perform, I do all kinds of things. And so then it's this full time job that sort of comes out of nowhere. And you're like, this has a ton of my focus. But I ended up releasing a song a year and a half ago,

SPEAKER_01that was my response to being, you know, kind of when I did speak freely, and people said what they said. And, and, you know, and I think also too, it's important that I say, God gives us free will. And so you can do whatever you want. You know what I mean? Like you have free will, I have free will. And if that's how you choose to use it, that's fine.

SPEAKER_00Human history shows us this.

SPEAKER_01Exactly.

SPEAKER_00You do whatever

SPEAKER_01you want.

SPEAKER_00Even people who don't live in democracy can do whatever they want. Pretty weird.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. Yeah. And at that time, I honestly had to double down. And I think that sort of threw people off. Like I wasn't like, oh my gosh, I'm so sorry. Like I was just like, no. And it like freaked people out. It like really did. But my response to that was not to get angry. I did not get angry. Of course, there were spiritual ramifications that I experienced because of all that. The being on the receiving end of that, that was really difficult. But my response to that was to write a song. I literally could do nothing other than write a song.

SPEAKER_01Like my body was like, and I had my friend Jamie, I said, look, this is in my heart. I have America on my heart. Because I do believe we actually have more in common than we're led to believe when we're on the internet. It's like, this is why this is important. This is why supers are important.

SPEAKER_00Will you just sing like the first verse? Because you're going to sing it. Are you going to sing that song when you come and play here at Art of Tamadoc? I could, yeah. Will you just sing a little?

SPEAKER_03America, I believe in you. America, we can start brand new. Oh, America, your heart knows how. Oh, America, we are ready now.

SPEAKER_03I just love that.

SPEAKER_00So that was the song that you wrote because I've talked to you about this. Yeah. I got all the wrong words, don't be mad at me. But something happened to you, you became a pit bull for honesty, and then something happened where you became like an angel of artistry. Like, there's something going on with you. And I know it, and I know it. Now, I don't know about you and Trump, but I know one thing. You don't really care either, that's what I'm trying to say.

SPEAKER_00What I know and learned about you though is there's something happening.

SPEAKER_01There's something happening.

SPEAKER_00Something really good is happening. And it's really beautiful. And so like right now, you have like a toughness.

SPEAKER_02Yeah.

SPEAKER_00Now you're not married. A lot of guys would want to marry you. But it feels like you got to be Orthodox. Is that a thing now? Are you hoping for an Orthodox person?

SPEAKER_01I mean, ideally, yes.

SPEAKER_00But it's not like a deal breaker.

SPEAKER_01Faith is a deal breaker.

SPEAKER_00Oh, it is?

SPEAKER_01Oh, yeah.

SPEAKER_00Do you think ladies should have deal breakers?

SPEAKER_01I think all people should have deal breakers.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, they should.

SPEAKER_01Because if you're not aligned on your values and how you're choosing to walk through life and the rest of your life and then beyond, you know, it's just, if you want to raise a family, all of these things, it's just, you do have to be on the same page.

SPEAKER_00But what if they're really, really nice?

SPEAKER_01Then they're a wonderful friend.

SPEAKER_00That's right, right?

SPEAKER_01They're wonderful friends. Yeah, so.

SPEAKER_00Could you have said that 10 years ago?

SPEAKER_01No, no.

SPEAKER_00Oh, so that changed too.

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_00Your ability to, some people would just call this maturity. You've gotten a little older, but it's not that? Is it more than that?

SPEAKER_01No, I think it is. But I think it's a sense of knowing who you are. It's like when you're in the, you're in sort of the, I thought I knew who I was, you know what I mean? When I was in the industry and I had all these beliefs, but I think it's important that we continuously question our beliefs, you know what I mean? It's like, You don't want to be like just a bull about everything, especially with how you feel. And I've always been a person of questioning myself first. That's literally my line of work. That's how you put emotion onto sound.

SPEAKER_01That's how you connect with people is you know your own human experience in a way that is so... Clear and is so intimate that you're able to express that in a way that lands for people so that they feel their own human experience.

SPEAKER_00Well, you might argue, and Dostoevsky argues this, that is the mark of art, that it's actually touching everybody.

SPEAKER_03Yes.

SPEAKER_00And so we will go like, well, people are all different.

SPEAKER_03Yeah.

SPEAKER_00But also people are all the same. And it's just like, how are they all the same? Dostoevsky and you are saying something like, The artist is able to elicit that in the moment with the pen or the voice or whatever. And then everyone turns to it and says for one second, oh, that's it. And that's what I love about a good artist. They're not trying to tell you about all how different they are. And if they are, they're a flash in the pan.

SPEAKER_00Right. They'll get a collection of people around them for a second because they're so radically different like me.

SPEAKER_01Yes.

SPEAKER_00And then, poof, it's over.

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_00Because it's not actually art.

SPEAKER_01Right.

SPEAKER_00Art is the thing that's in the center.

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_00It's the soulful center, I think, anyway, in some level. I agree. How would you finish up if I gave you an ala verde? We could keep talking, by the way. An ala verde.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, we can keep talking. It's up to you.

SPEAKER_00Good. I don't even know how long we've been talking. Is it a good long time? Hour and 30? Hour and 40. What a nice talk. Hour and 50.

SPEAKER_01Hour and 50.

SPEAKER_00Oh my gosh, John. That's the longest talk of all times.

SPEAKER_02Ever.

SPEAKER_00No, Rogan does. Three, four hours. But let's do this for a second.

SPEAKER_03Yeah.

SPEAKER_00There's a tradition at the Supra. Mm-hmm. I have to do an advertisement, too. It should come at the beginning, actually. We should cut this into the beginning. I'll get Andrew to edit this at the beginning. But you're coming to sing at the Art of Tamada. The Art of the Tamada is an event that first things throws to our nonprofit. I'm the founder, which just means I'm poor. That's all that means. Where we teach this sort of the beauty of this dinner with the toasting and

SPEAKER_00where it comes from and historically what it is and how to do it and how to be a Talmudoc because it's not just talking. In fact, usually just a talker will backfire. And we're doing it in Greenville, August 28th and 29th. And that event you're coming to sing with a group called Shovels, well not with them, but you're singing, Shovels and Rope and Darby Wilcox, great musicians. And we're going to do Supra and we're going to teach it.

SPEAKER_00So with that lead in, one of the things that a Supra is the Aliverde. The Aliverde is when the Tamera, you saw it last night. The Aliverde is when the Tamera, They give the table to someone and say, please, won't you take my table and give us a toast? And the toast is wide open usually for them. So sometimes the tamara will ask for a particular type of toast. So will you do ala verde on what's happening in this world?

SPEAKER_00What's happened to you? And give us a toast or some words about the beauty of what's happened to you maybe over the last couple of years. Please, just say some words on that.

SPEAKER_02As a toast. Okay, as a toast. Yeah, as you wish. But that's how it would be. Yeah. Well, I think it's in the asking of the questions that

SPEAKER_01I have found the opportunity to Through God's help to peel away what is no longer useful. And there's something that is so special about two people being in room together and like, and I'm emotional now, so you said it would happen, John. You said it. And this is why I love being on stage and why, like, all of this other stuff, like the internet is kind of real, but not really like all these other

SPEAKER_03things is like, what is

SPEAKER_01that, you know, and when you can look someone in the eye, even if you disagree with them, even if you have been hurt by them or hurt them, if you can, if you can look someone in the eye, you can, there's, there's like a mirroring that happens, God gives us this opportunity to truly see another person, like one heart to another. And I think God has given me this gift, which is

SPEAKER_01the willingness to fight for that in a language that I know, which is like, how do we bring people eye to eye and heart to heart? And Everything in me did not want to make more music. I just was like, this is too hard, this is too much. I ended up having to be on vocal rest when I recorded All Eyes On Us for the first time. I was really struggling because of this injury.

SPEAKER_01And what I kept getting was, it doesn't matter if you don't want to, you have to. And we all have whatever our calling is, and that just happens to be mine in this moment. And there's way more beauty in the world than so many, than we're led to believe, I think. And I think the faith has opened my eyes to the beauty of

SPEAKER_01the light that Christ brings and the choice to follow Him and the choice to die on that hill. And to give yourself completely. And my path, even though I, you know, I thought I might never sing again, you know what I mean? Like, it's like, but now the depth of my voice is like so different because of this experience that I've had and because I have that in my life. And everything is simple now. It is just so much more simple.

SPEAKER_01And this is what it's about. This is what it's about. And so I, I also just want to thank you, John, because I think you, you really have. I was thinking this last night when you were like, it shouldn't

SPEAKER_03take you an hour to

SPEAKER_01get ready. And I was like, right, I'm gonna get ready in 45 minutes. I even showered Drupal Blue Drive repair and I was like laughing about that. And you have this, you part of your gift is you give people An opening to show up completely as themselves and not like there's nothing put on like it doesn't matter what what you're wearing, what you say, what you just like, whatever. And that is that is what you that is a gift that you bring.

SPEAKER_01And I knew from the first moment I talked to you, I was like, What is

SPEAKER_03going on?

SPEAKER_01Yeah. And I'm very thankful that God has sort of put us in each other's orbit. And That we get to have these experiences and if I could say anything, it would be let's just try to look at each other in the eye. Let's raise a toast. Let's sing if we want to sing. Let's share our hearts if we want to share our hearts and let's do our best to just try and have grace with people as they do that because everyone makes mistakes.

SPEAKER_01No one is perfect. So many people are trying to do their best. Everyone has struggles. It really is what I believe that we have more in common than we do with what separates us. That's right. And I, that is what I stand for. That is what I will walk in. And that is what I will continue to raise my voice for is the things that bring us together. So.

SPEAKER_00Kagi Marjos.

SPEAKER_01Kagi Marjos, God bless you.

SPEAKER_00To your victory. Kagi Marjos. Guys, Kiri Menolakos. I think I said it right now.

SPEAKER_01It's good. It's kind of the Greek way, yeah.

SPEAKER_00We'll drink our wine. This has been great.

SPEAKER_01It's been so great.

SPEAKER_00We're going to keep doing these.

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_00All your famous friends are going to come now. They have to. And will you just, let's have a great concert. Let's have a great super in a month and a half.

SPEAKER_03Yeah.

SPEAKER_00Then I'll see you in Florida too.

SPEAKER_03Yeah.

SPEAKER_00We'll hang out. We'll go to church tomorrow with Helen. Yeah. It'll be great. So... I'll just say this as an outro. Andrew, you can cut this. We did it. We had a good talk.

SPEAKER_03Yeah.

SPEAKER_00Save me a spot at the Supra. It's a special little side. Everything's Lightly we do where we get people to come to the restaurant, sit down and spend long form, big conversation, sort of plumb the meaning of life. So today we did it. Carrie Menelakis, check out the show notes. You'll see all the connections to her documentary, to her work, but also to our work. The first thing. So join us and keep joining us. Gagy Marjos. Gagy Marjos.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Demons, Deception, and Why Your Spiritual Practices Might Be Dangerous

    Oct 2, 20261 hr 18 minAudio

    Find this episode on YouTube: "Justine Alter" - a pseudonym - returns to chat with John Heers in a raw Heavy Things Lightly conversation you have to hear to believe.Justine worked for years as a professional psychic,...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. The Fox News Reporter Who Quit to Live an Orthodox Homesteading Life

    Sep 25, 20261 hr 35 minAudio

    Find this episode on YouTube: Holly Hickman went from Columbia Journalism and Fox News Radio covering NASA and the 2008 election - to milking cows, making cheese, and converting to Orthodoxy.In this episode of Heavy...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Why They Left NASA to Start St. George's Classical Academy

    Sep 21, 20261 hr 2 minAudio

    Can you teach kids the truth AND prepare them for a secular world?On this episode of Heavy Things Lightly, host John Heers talks with James and Juliana Joyce, founders of St. George's Classical Academy in Boxford,...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. An Odyssean Tale: The Man Who Would Not Quit

    Sep 4, 20261 hr 37 minAudio

    Find this episode on YouTube: Crow walked America searching for his father - and found the Father.From West Virginia hollers to LA gangs, from wolves in the Mojave desert to an Orthodox cross, this is an Odyssean tale...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Why This App Designer Hides His Face | An Old-World Cure Built as a New-World App

    Aug 28, 20261 hr 14 minAudio

    John Heers sits down with "Justin Smith" - an anonymous app designer you'll never see, only hear.His app, This Life, is audio-only and anonymous by design: you record your own voice, then get paired with a stranger for...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode