Find this episode on YouTube: Enigmatic movie commentator BLA sits down to talk Christian movies and why so many just get it wrong. Also a little rabbit hole of talking about Christic moments in film, redemtion, and what makes a movie Christian if God isn't in it. Oh and spoiler alert: Gods Not Dead didn't make the list. Find more Bazed Lit Analyzer: @BAZEDLITANALYZER ✒ Substack: https://johnheersftf.substack.com/ ⓧ https://x.com/johnfromftf 🍷The best dinner party you've ever experienced - Supra Dinner Society: https://supradinner.com/ 🏖️ Tailormade tours that give back: https://www.gratitude-travels.com/home 🔎 Discover the non-profit behind Heavy Things Lightly: https://first-things.org/ ✈ Become a Field Worker with FTF: https://first-things.org/opportunities 📢 First Things Telegram: https://t.me/firstthingsfoundation 🥂 Keipi Restaurant: https://keipirestaurant.org Please leave a review with your comments! Your support keeps this podcast alive and allows us to broaden our discussion. --- This “Enlightened” New World utopia isn’t turning out to be all it was cracked up to be. Society is disenchanting, but are the only alternatives hiding out in the hills or burying yourself in books? With an air of levity and a touch of humor, John Heers teaches how to examine the confusing New World by calling upon the mind and wisdom of oft-forgotten Old. Heavy Things, Lightly. --- Credits Music: Intro / Outro Provided by Greg Gilbertson & Band This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit johnheersftf.substack.com/subscribe
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_01Hello, it's Everything's Lightly. Today, I don't know, I was watching a crazy show and I couldn't figure out if this is a Christian show or not. Then I thought to myself, a show about botched plastic surgery can't be about Christianity, can it? And then my wife was like, yeah, it can be. Because you're actually watching people walk through a type of delusion. It can teach you about this space between who we are and who we think we want to be. I don't know. And I thought, how can we know what a Christian movie is?
SPEAKER_01And so here we are. I brought on Bayes, BLA, Bayes Lit Analyzer. He's kind of a famous guy who does movies online. And here's the thing with him. He's great. But also, we got into all kinds of stuff. The Tucker Carlson thing going on. We got into Angel Films, how that works. Because I learned a little bit how that works. I met with Angel Films. We got into the I-word. Can you say that? We got into the I-word, which is we got into I-squared. The two countries that are near each other.
SPEAKER_01The Kukulaka-paka. The Kukulaka-paka. That thing. The Kukulaka War. Oh, I can't say war. I can't even, like, hide what I'm trying to talk about. We got into that. We got into lots of stuff. Today on Heavy Things Lightly... Like the best Christian movies and I don't even know what one is. And is there such a thing? Can't wait. On Heavy Things Lightly. Guys, it's BLA. This is the guy on the internet that I like to mess around with
when it comes to
SPEAKER_01films and listen to. And also you have a very kind of old world feel for life. And are you going to smoke with us today? Because I brought a drink. Did you bring a drink? No. I brought my regular drink. Oh, well, we can toast with Red Bull. It's not allowed in the Georgian Republic. You know about our restaurant? Did I ever tell you about it?
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Well, we make a toast there. So I want to make a toast to the universal thing called that which goes into our bodies. May we be thankful for it. Water, drink, food, wine. In my case, I'm drinking a Borgiomi. It's a water from Georgia. So to your Red Bull, but to the things that nourish us, man. Coggy Marjo. Cheers, buddy. Well... I think we're going to do 45 minutes of Christian movie. What the heck is a Christian movie? You ever heard of one?
SPEAKER_01How would you, did you ever see one before?
SPEAKER_03Yeah. Well, I think it depends. Um, there, there are, I agree. We're going to talk about, I assume, but that's, there are Christian movies and I've got a list of some that I've, I think are a powerful Christian movies. Um, But I think that part of the problem with movies is that when films are overtly Christian at times, for instance, and by overt Christian,
SPEAKER_03I mean, let's say they're made by a Christian studio or something. They tend to be didactic and they compromise the form and the aesthetic of the film with an overemphasis on on the message in the movie. And I think that the best Christian films are ones where we look at them. We look at life through the lens of film, literally through a lens. We, we look at,
we look at life through this lens presented in terms of a Christian paradigm,
SPEAKER_03usually Christian redemption, morals and standards, but they're not pushed on us as if all that's to say that, If you want a Christian message in terms of, for instance, if you want to read Christianity, then you read scripture. You worship. And that's something different than art. Art is something that's much lower than that. But that's because I think that...
you know christ speaks in parables a lot of you know he speaks in parables we're told the bible functions in terms of there's a narrative that occurs and there are stories and there's this it's the foundation for all literature and all art but it's also something that it's not a manifesto it's not a bland lit list and
SPEAKER_01treatise what is that when we know a manifesto is happening what Go deeper than that. Why isn't that art again? Is it because it's didactic? That's part of it.
SPEAKER_03I think that a manifesto tends to be something that is, first of all, ideologically or politically driven and that is completely didactic and that is a sort of treatise for the way things need to change. But that's different than we get in Scripture. Scripture is all, it's all based in God and in Christ and and the way that we're supposed to live to, to find redemption in Christ. Everything in scripture is about finding redemption in Christ.
And we, and we live in this, in a fallen world, no matter what through movies. And I, you know, when we look at movies, that's a sort of confusing statement.
SPEAKER_03When we look at movies, we're watching films. films that act as if we don't sometimes tend to muddy the waters and they tend to overreach whereas when we look at the normal events in life and they can be they can be extraordinary events but that's when we really see christian uh our christian belief sort of brought out in films are you are you
SPEAKER_01Give us your bona fides real quick. You're an educator and you've studied literature and movies and then got into this beautiful podcast you have where you just do tons of movies, but... you're a Catholic guy. Yeah. How would you, how would you characterize your, your religion?
SPEAKER_03No, I was, I was born, uh, I was, uh, baptized, raised, um, confirmed in the Episcopal church in Virginia. And, you know, my whole family is everyone I know. Here's here is, I went to a, I went to an Episcopal school, an Episcopal private school. Um, I served in the church and I, I, Went to school in Northern Ireland, got my degree there. I went to drama school in England at the Bristol Olympic Theater School. And then I went,
I acted for a year, went, I taught, taught in Malaysia for a little bit.
SPEAKER_03I went back and got a master's degree at, at, in Belfast again. And then I've been, did you have your voice before you went to Ireland or after? I've, I've, I've, I've always had this voice. I've always had this voice since I was little. I could see you like at 11, like, what's up, mom? You got the baloney? That's exactly, that's exactly how I'm looking for. I'm looking for baloney with the yellow mustard, Bob. That's right. I need a chocolate milk. Hurry up. No, I wasn't like that.
SPEAKER_02The bus is late again. I'm just going to have one smoke.
SPEAKER_03Yeah. That's right. Well, that didn't come until I was 12.
SPEAKER_01Sorry, but keep going. So in your lifetime, did you ever try to expunge Christianity from you? No. Did you go through a secular atheist age? No, never.
SPEAKER_03Never, never once. I've never had that, thank God. I've never experienced any of that. And I've been pretty firm in my belief and practiced my whole life, so.
SPEAKER_01So then that was to lead to this, I think, which is fun kind of. So then, and you're great with all these films and insight. And so do you find yourself rooting for something? Because I think a lot of the people watching this pod would be like, yeah, I kind of root. I know my wife and I'll sit on the couch and root for... that movie to be christic but we don't really mean christian it's a that's a different thing we call it like a christic thing do you root do you find yourself
rooting for like oh this is going to obviously be a redemptive moment here and then it or do you not root as a christian i do i do absolutely i do yeah yeah very much
SPEAKER_03so and i gotta say you know I got to say that, you know, you're, you're, you, you're Orthodox and I've met a lot of my friends through the Orthodox church and a lot of the people who watch my channel are Orthodox and I've learned more about Christianity through listening and reading about Orthodoxy for years. And in fact, you know, and I'll, I'll just say, I'll just say this right now. I think that there are a lot of problems in the world. And I think that, and I've, this has been a, I don't usually share this, but this has been a big,
SPEAKER_03uh, not crisis, but it's been a big point in my life for years now about dealing with what I've seen is the infection that, into especially the Episcopal church in a number of ways. I've been lucky that I haven't had any of the shenanigans, any of those, the things that are normally the problems in my church. I've never, we've never experienced that, but I see it as a, as a, a bigger, broader problem. And I think that,
SPEAKER_03you know, I've really come to consider what I think of when I, when I think of Christ's church and, on earth and i think that the the orthodox church is uh is christ's true church i do and i think that the
SPEAKER_01Wait, this might be some breaking news. I mean, I don't usually talk about this because it's not something that I really share with
SPEAKER_03people because it's very personal to me.
SPEAKER_01I appreciate it, though. I appreciate it. But, you know, especially, you know, this sort of comes out in all sorts of ways.
SPEAKER_03And, you know, I've been doing a series on C.S. Lewis And C.S. Lewis was baptized in Anglican. He had that very crisis that you were talking about for a long time. And I don't feel any kind of kinship with him in that sense. But he was born in Northern Ireland. He was educated in Britain. And then he went through a phase where he became a deist and then eventually found his way to Christ specifically. Yeah. And, and CS Lewis is an Anglican.
SPEAKER_03He's a church of England, but he talks a lot about what he, what he, what he, what he terms, he calls it little orthodoxy in terms of, you know, orthodoxical issues and, and, and solutions within the church. And I, I really relate to that in a number of ways. And I think that things have moved on beyond that to now where we really are at a kind of, we really are at a kind of a, I don't know, a line in the sand is the expression.
SPEAKER_01It's happening, man.
SPEAKER_03It is happening. It's happening. Yeah, so... C.S.
SPEAKER_01Lewis was the guy for me. I was also Anglican or Episcopalian coming up. And my dad was actually a priest. And then my mom was like... fortress Anglican like she was like 1923 prayer book and so like and then I started reading C.S. Lewis in an African village and I was like wait a minute this guy doesn't seem like the guys this doesn't seem like the same thing that I was doing back in America and then the Islam like you know, all around, I was like, orthodoxy or Christianity feels more like that.
SPEAKER_01What they're doing, but they just don't have the Jesus. There's something connected with Islam and orthodoxy or Christianity, and then I found it in orthodoxy eventually. But so then... Let's go back to this thing. Well, I, can I just say, I, I brought up C.S. Lewis.
SPEAKER_03I brought up C.S. Lewis also because I just, I just reread the voyage of the dawn trader yesterday. And I read Prince Caspian reread Prince Caspian last week. And I think that's a great example of this. And it's, it's actually a great example of what we're talking about. This is in literature. I'm not going to, I don't really touch the movie versions of, of Narnia, but this is something that, really occurs in the Narnian series where we find ourselves with characters who, it is clearly a Christian book.
SPEAKER_03It's clearly a Christian book series. And we are continuously confronted with characters who are facing, they're facing themselves, they're facing their own sin and they're facing what it means to be redeemed. Now that he's called Aslan in the books, but in Voyage of Dawn Treader, for instance, when the character Lucy is about to go back to the normal world, she says, am I going to see you again? And Aslan says, you're not going to see me again here. There you will call me by another name.
SPEAKER_03And he's, he's clearly Christ. He comes from over the sea or on the East. He serves the emperor over the sea, serve his father. And what really differentiates the books from other, I think, overtly pre, you know, sort of preachy, teachy didactic books on, on whatever people are trying to push as kind of a, with Christian literature, these books are so fundamental to, I think, understanding the, the way literature works with Christianity, because we have a series of characters who are awful.
SPEAKER_03They're, they're, they're, they become very bad people. Like for instance, Edmund, um, from Edmund, from the way the book series starts, he, he actually talks to Eustace in Dawn Treader and, and Eustace has become a dragon. He's so miserable that he literally becomes a dragon. He's covered in dragon scales and he learns, uh, that basically he's yearning for some sort of connection with people and he wants to do things for other people. And it's not until he becomes a dragon that he learned service.
SPEAKER_03Instead of just taking all the time. And when he talks to Edmund and he apologizes to Edmund, Edmund says, it's all right. I know you're sorry. You may have been miserable, but I was a traitor and that's worse. And so they, that's Christian. That's Christian to, to, to want to root for somebody who is willing to confront themselves and how they've treated other people and to want to serve. They want to serve other people. They don't want to just take all the time.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, so this is it, man. So then I think you're identifying – so let's call them toppable moments. I think I would argue they're icons, but they're on film and they're moving. But what's happening is it's a moment on film – that is resplendent in its invitation to know Christ, but it's got nothing to do with Christ in the words.
SPEAKER_01This is the way I try to like, I wonder if you understand this way. And so it's resplendent and it could be about anybody. It could be, now this gets crazy. It could be a movie about Muhammad. And I know people are like, whoa, I think it could be a movie about Muhammad. And in that movie, they do it in such a way that Muhammad has these moments where he feels that he has done wrong, sinned, and is being redeemed. I think you're seeing a type of Christic moment. Is that enough to make it a Christian movie?
SPEAKER_03I don't think that's enough. I think that what it really comes down to... is that it's a normal human emotion. It's a normal human sense of ourselves and where we fit into place, even in an archetypal sense with a hero's journey, to want to accomplish something or to want to confront something we've done wrong and to ask forgiveness or to repent of a person. But the difference is that in a Christian story,
SPEAKER_03the hero or the character who finds that, finds that they can only be redeemed in either Christ himself or what Christ has set forth. That there's only one redemption. It's not just enough to seek forgiveness from a person. It's to seek a bigger sort of forgiveness. And that can take place through a wartime setting or to sacrifice yourself for others. But it has to be something in service. And also that a Christian movie... Obviously, the difference is that a Christian movie is where a person is
serving the living
SPEAKER_03God. Christ is the living God. And it's not just a person who hopes to meet God at the end. It has to be now. It has to be they're doing something right now that's going to have echoes of what
SPEAKER_01happens at the end. Does the script... Because movies are made with scripts. Does the script need to imply... christ in not even apply it does it need to say anything like does it need to does it need to describe with words a type of christ that's a good question and it's it's pretty nuanced i think that for one thing i think these things because of god's providence happen unintentionally a lot of ways and it
depends on it usually
SPEAKER_03most times if you were to ask a filmmaker what they intended, they'll give you an answer that they don't even know the answer to it. And that happens with a lot of art. In the occult sense, on the other side, this happens in that people will write things and they feel like there's a lightning rod through them and they're bringing something forth from the other side. Usually, this is with musicians or... And there's sort of a voice for characters or demons or something from the other side. But I think with Christ and with Christianity,
SPEAKER_03the other issue with scripts is that this is incredibly taboo. And that, again, that serves a Christian message because when you are not allowed to mention the name of Christ or you're not allowed, or filmmakers often don't do that, I think that That's that can take on a form of suffering for Christ or trying to get the message out anyway. Right. So I think that's a that's a major problem with Hollywood. Not all movies can be something like, you know, the passion of the Christ. A lot of people have issues with the passion of the Christ
because of various
SPEAKER_03nuances in the film, but also how just how. uh, cruel and lethal. The movie is now you see the point in the movie of why it's like that, because that's how it's treated, but not every movie can do that. But also you see what happened to Mel to base Mel, uh, after the film came out. So it depends, I think on, on where a person is. Okay.
SPEAKER_01That's a good point. Yeah. All right. So go back though. Cause I'm, I think I understand your answer. I'm just, I don't know the answer to what a Christian movie is because that's sort of our construct. So I love this movie Magnolia. I put it on my list in my dumb email to you. And so Tom Cruise, I don't know if you remember. It's from the late 90s. People out there who've seen it, if you don't like cursing and harsh language, don't go watch the movie.
SPEAKER_01So, however... I just see a whole series of Christian events in that film over and over again. There's definitely no Christ involved except for in cursing. And then there's frogs. Uh-oh, spoiler alert. We got to do that, right, if we're talking movies. But at the end, there's... Some wild stuff happens. And I don't think there's any way you can say it's not a Christian film. But people do. They say it's not. See, I might differ with you. I think it's a type of mountain of meaning.
SPEAKER_01And any movie that's showing something like The sacrifice of an individual in order to serve the other, in order to create redemption. I actually think that's a Christian movie, even if Christ is not clearly evident in the film. That's what I'd argue, but I don't know that I'm right. In other words, what I'd say is wherever you see the pattern... redemption you actually are seeing christ not the church perhaps but you're actually participating in an image that is christic and at that
point you're witnessing experiencing participating in something like a christic event that's what i would argue well i think that magnolia and i've i've covered it uh oh you did cover it stream it was a long it was a long time ago but i've covered it and What's interesting is that movie is incredibly relevant now because of Tom Cruise's
SPEAKER_03character, right? I mean, that's the manosphere. That's it. He is that in the film.
SPEAKER_01They anticipated.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, it really did. And I think that aside from having archetypal kind of symbolism from Exodus that occurs as a driving force of the narrative and the plot in the movie, there is a particularly... There's a particularly harsh scene with, you know, there's a contrast between where Tom Cruise's character is trying to reconnect with his father in the film.
And that, of course, seems to be something that, as you were saying, is Christic.
SPEAKER_03It seems to be where a character is. He's a prodigal son. He's lost. He's completely. I think I think the way I look at what you're saying is that. When we have characters in films who are so bad or so repugnant or just vile, but they find redemption, we know that that is more powerful than characters who tend to be even keeled throughout the thing. Because that speaks for all of us, because in a sense, we're all kind of like that.
We may not be doing the same things that he's doing or talking the same way or
SPEAKER_03whatever it is, but we all sort of get disconnected from the Father. We all are living in sin.
SPEAKER_01Don't you think that's why... Movies with Jesus in it are impossible because Jesus obviously is the even-killed, he's the royal path character. So we're always looking at him like Zeffirelli's film, Jesus of Nazareth. You're just looking at him and he's too far away. There's nothing about that Jesus character in there that has enough of us. You know what I mean? Yeah. And I always wondered if a movie with the Jesus character in it is actually just unmakeable as far as a Christian film.
SPEAKER_03I agree. I agree to a certain extent because... for instance, Passion of the Christ, you have Jim Caviezel playing, playing the king of the universe. And when we're watching it, there's a disconnect where we know that we're, and we have to have a suspension of disbelief beyond what Coleridge said and go into something into another world where we're really suspending everything that we know because, because Christ has already created us, is already in us. So when we're watching the film, we can't help but go at some point,
this is Jim Caviezel.
SPEAKER_03Wow. He's really getting it in this, you know, So it's hard because our our vision of Christ is he was he was a man and he's God. But we're still. And so we we would look on a man. I mean, imagine what it would be like to live in the time of Christ and to see Christ. I guess it kind of mimics that. I think a great a great version of this that actually does make this work is the movie Ben-Hur with Charlton Heston, because.
SPEAKER_01Oh, because it's not, you're right. Because it's overheated. It's just off the edge. Right.
SPEAKER_03Exactly. Because they do something very clever, which is that Christ is literally, I mean, the character Christ is literally in the movie, but he's just off camera. He's just unseen. So when, when Judah Ben-Hur is in the desert and he's a slave and he's, and he's thirsty, he's given the water of life by Christ, but we only see his hand. And then he, and then when he comes to the, when he comes to the crucifixion, he sees him and he sees what's happening.
SPEAKER_03And I think that is a, probably in in many ways a pretty truthful statement of faith uh i know i got goosebumps when you brought it up you're i did just now you know the the way that that you know again it's like i i kind of go back to christ speaking in para and parables for human beings because you think about how stupid we are and how and selfish and all of these things. And so he has to make clear the truth,
but relate it to people in other ways.
SPEAKER_03To me, it's like, It's like last week I was in upstate New York and they had the strawberry moon, right? And the moon, the moon was rising and it's this blood, it's a blood moon. It's a blood red moon. Some call it a strawberry. Some call it a strawberry. It was, it was this blood red moon and you're looking at it and I can see the man in the moon and it's right there. But if you look at it too, too hard, it gets blurry. It's like, you can't really focus. So you kind of have to look at the reflection of it. You look at the stars around it. You look at the sky around it. You kind of see it in parallel.
SPEAKER_03And that's often the way that it is in literature and in films. Oftentimes that's why we have allegory. That's why we have symbolism. We look at things according to what we know. And so I think that, I think that that works in, in better. That's a really fantastic, you know, vision of, I think the way that we.
SPEAKER_01So you might put that, that movie on your list.
SPEAKER_03Yes, I would. I definitely, that that's probably the top of my list. Uh, that one. And I've got a couple other ones. Um,
SPEAKER_01You know, before you, I want you to tell Liz, but before you do that, the Ben-Hur, that's fascinating, man. The Ben-Hur move that you're talking about is actually in the Orthodox iconographic tradition, the reason that the ascension doesn't make sense to moderns is like he just went up in the air like... Because that's actually never been the description of the ascension. The ascension is that which was tangible and real and manifest
and incarnate suddenly wasn't.
SPEAKER_01But it didn't go up in the... It went from as us to as eternity, but they had trouble trying to describe that. So the iconography is they just said he went up. And you see, the literalists that we are, it's like you said, if they had had Jesus come rolling in on Ben-Hur, then it would have changed the dynamic because it would have done something to Christ that you shouldn't probably do, right? Which is... It's transcendent. And so leave it that way somehow. It's hard to do though.
SPEAKER_03It's also beyond, I mean, it's at some point, you know, it's beyond our human comprehension and understanding how these things occur. You know, it's, you know, when a, when a, when a person is, you imagine John the Baptist, you know, he's baptizing people in the river and, People are down there and they want to proclaim him God. They say, oh, he's, you know, this is the guy. And he's like, no, there's something. No, there's he's coming. And then all of a sudden he's there. But the the average human watching this, they see a guy washing a guy in the river. How are you how are you supposed to make sense that this is
you've been reborn,
SPEAKER_03that this is new life? You've been, you know, and right.
SPEAKER_01It's like a reverse engineering. Yeah. It's like, well, of course, he's going to get in the water and get washed so that you can understand the actual depth of the experience.
SPEAKER_03We're also born in water in the first place. You know, we're in it. Yeah. There's a baby in a woman's stomach, not breathing air, but it's alive. That also doesn't make sense.
SPEAKER_01That's like the blood red moon. Don't stare at that too long. It'll freak you out, man. I'm serious. Yeah. It's like when you start thinking about your wife and the baby and your mom and you, it's like, ah, this is. Well, what was crazy? It's not what we think it is.
SPEAKER_03What was crazy with the blood moon was it was the blood moon. And I, I think I literally said out loud, it's the blood moons of Israel. And then right then the war started. So I'm saying that I'm a guru. No, I'm not.
SPEAKER_01I actually wanted to throw a war curveball at you. Well, I'll just say this for people who are listening. There is a... concept that there is a country called Israel that's the same concept within the Old Testament. So again, that's also a type of iconography. It's an image. It's not a one-to-one. It's not a geography book. This is insane to me the way people understand it as a geography book and that
SPEAKER_01that's the same exact thing. And it's frustrating because obviously that is an allusion to the people that who Christ will come for, and those people are now us. So come on, guys. But anyway, I don't want to get into the war. It's the first time turning on the camera. I know, I know. So you notice I chose my words carefully, Mr. BLA. But go to your list. Sorry, I've been sitting on it. But go to your list, this Christian movies.
SPEAKER_01I think people want to hear this.
SPEAKER_03I would say that at the top of my list, what I think of right away in terms of Christian movies, just me personally, I would say, uh, the thin red line, the book of Eli and master and commander are three, three films that just right away come to mind. Um, and I think that should be pretty, pretty evident to people who have seen, seen the films, uh, the book of Eli, you know, if you want to start with that one, do you know, do you know that film?
SPEAKER_01Oh, yeah, I know that film. I like that film. It lost me a little bit. There were moments when it was moving too slowly for me, but that's because I'm dumb on some level.
SPEAKER_03Well, you know, it's easy for a film to get lost in itself because, if you notice, most films will... uh especially films involving dialogue or any kind of what seems like a spiritual journey at the beginning of the movie will often get lost in action in the last quarter of the film that all the all the action the budget has to be we have to use the budget So we get a bunch of action at the end of the movie, but it serves it in that film because it's fairly consistent throughout the film.
SPEAKER_03And we have a character who, you know, it's also ambiguous in the film, whether he is blind to the entire movie, you can read, you can watch the film as him being, he's blind, he's blind. He's blind in a post-apocalyptic, you know, nuclear, nuclear, you know, dirt scape. And we find out that, Even though this is this is a great film because we have a character who is a warrior. He's alone. He's wandering through the wilderness and he's fighting not
only a literal war or a
SPEAKER_03series of battles for survival, but it ends up being that he's doing this for a greater purpose. And that is because spoiler, of course, in the movie. There's one Bible. There's only one left in the world and he's the keeper of it. And then the twist is, the twist in the movie for people who have seen this. And if you haven't, you know, you should watch it, but the twist is you should know it by now. People, the twist is that the Bible is in Braille. So even that is further removed from people.
SPEAKER_03So he's memories, the keeper of this, of scripture, he's memorized the whole thing and that he is, he, he's, he's fighting for survival because he wants to preserve this thing. It's not even for himself. Yeah. He meets Mila Kunis along the way and he's got to save her and a bunch of stuff. And then there's bad guys who want the Bible and they want it for its monetary value and whatever.
SPEAKER_01But his actions, for people when you watch, it's very violent. And That's not relevant to you as far as it goes in making of a Christian film. Does it matter that that character is that violent?
SPEAKER_03Well, it can be. It can be. I think that it depends on the levels of violence or of cruelty. And if there's if there's a cruel notion of violence, his violence is justified in the movie because because he's first of all, he's fighting defensively. And second of all, he's fighting for the girl that he meets along the way. He's trying to protect her. And then he's fighting for a higher purpose, which is to get this thing all the way. And they are fighting a war of annihilation. They want to kill everyone. They want him dead.
SPEAKER_03They want to use him. So that's important. It's kind of the same thing that occurs in another, another film, which is a kingdom of heaven by Ridley Scott, which, you know, we have Baldwin. I like that. It's a, it's a, it's a great film. People who like that film always remember it. And they, and they always point to it because it's a, it's a, it's a man's film. It's a dude. It's a dude's rock film. And that's because even though it didn't do well in the box
office when it came out
SPEAKER_03around 2005, it's got Orlando Bloom and all this stuff. But he meets a series of characters in the medieval world with Liam Neeson and, you know, and David Thewlis. And they take him all the way on this crusade, all the way to the Holy Land where he meets Baldwin. And what I love about the movie is that Baldwin is the leper king. He's played by Edward Norton. Edward Norton doesn't get any credit in the film. He didn't want credit. He's totally absorbed in the role. And there's the famous monologue where he tells... orlando bloom that you know he will the the decisions you make
will not be enough you you you have to understand that you will face god and you'll stand in judgment and you can't equivocate so your your judgments have to be hard including if it's if you're facing a war of annihilation or a war to destroy christianity and so
SPEAKER_03therefore violence is is appropriate at the moment. It's important, you know, who, you know, send me Lord, right. Yeah. War is, you know, I think this is one of the problems with overt or sort of educational Christian films that are made because, you know, They tend to push sort of push this idea, especially in non-Christians had heads as if Christianity is not a valiant or fierce religion,
SPEAKER_03as if it's supposed to be a pacifist religion. And that's a misinterpretation of the way that Christianity is. It's not it's not that, you know, David was a warrior. And so I think that, you know, that it's important to understand the things that one is fighting for and that cruelty is something that should be. There's a differentiation even in war or fighting between cruelty and and a justified war. And I think those two films do a pretty good example of that.
SPEAKER_00It's finally warming up. The sun is out. The air is crisp. Spring must be any day now. overwhelmed with that one closet full of junk? Have you almost been eaten by your clutter? It's time to finally go through those boxes and storage you've been neglecting. You'll be surprised what you find. Instead of throwing up these used items, you can donate them to us, First Things Foundation, in five easy steps. We partnered with eBay Charity to list your items for 100%
donation when purchased
SPEAKER_00through our storefront. First, find the items you wish to donate. Step two, take two to five pictures of your item. Step three, email me, NicoHears, at first-things.org. This is where you can include as much information about the selected item as possible, including the year you originally bought it, worth, product type, damage if any, and size. Don't forget to attach those pictures you took earlier.
SPEAKER_00Once you've sent the email, you can sit back and relax. We'll list your item for you and be in communication with any possible buyers. Once it's purchased, we'll follow up with an email and prepaid shipping label for you to attach and send your item off. Step 5. Package it up, attach the label, and drop off at your local post office. With those easy steps, you've not only cleaned out your closet, but you've contributed in assisting local visionaries in their quest for a better life.
SPEAKER_01It's nice. It doesn't, I agree, it doesn't turn me off. St. Cyril, there's the hagiography of St. Cyril. So this is the saint that was standing in the doorway basically to the temple, to Israel, I'm sorry, to Jerusalem when I believe it was I want to say it was one of the Ottoman Turk rulers came.
SPEAKER_01Suleiman, I think it's Suleiman. And basically, Suleiman is about to take over Jerusalem. And Cyril, who's well known to all the Muslims, everybody at this time, this is the 12, 1300s. He comes out. Sorry, it's earlier. It's the 800s. It's earlier. It's earlier. And Cyril comes out. And Suleiman, again, I could have these wrong, forgive me, but says, what are you doing here? You're a great, you know, you're a warrior for God in the sense you pray. You're a monk. Why are you out here about to, we're going to have chop off heads.
SPEAKER_01And Cyril says, yeah, well, I've come to try to put a stop to this. Don't come in here and do this. And Sideman says, but I'm doing this on behalf of my God. And I do this because I serve my God. And he says, Cyril says, yeah, great. You serve your God. Today I serve my God. And how many good things are you doing? For my God, I do everything today. And Cyril says, well, for my God, I do two good things. You do one. Today you come and I stand in front of those who can't protect
themselves.
SPEAKER_01So I protect the innocent. And the second thing I do today is die when you put your sword through me. So I do two good things. You do one. And then Sudhiman said, go back inside. And then they came in and killed everybody. And for me, that's the only way I've ever understood war as a Christian. And it has to be that something bad is happening. They're coming for you. And I think it's got to be pretty evident. I think it's got to be pretty evident.
SPEAKER_03I think of two things. One is I was just thinking of the idea of cruelty and how cruelty is, you know, could be considered to never be justified. But imagine, you know, I think of Vlad, you know, Vlad the Impaler, who is the who is. An Orthodox noble Who stands at the edge Of the brink of Christendom Versus the invading Saracens Who are doing horrible things and trying to eradicate his people. And so he impales 40,000 or whatever people as a message.
And I think that in my opinion, this would be considered an act of justifiable cruelty.
SPEAKER_03He's doing this to show them that the Christendom will not be eradicated. And to set up a physical barrier where these people will come and they will have to cross through a wasteland of death in order to get to this place. I think that's probably a justified thing. And the other thing I think of is I, I, uh, at Christmas time, I was visiting my family and I have my grandfather's wartime journal from world war II. And he was on a, a B, a B 24 bomber.
SPEAKER_03And he was just a kid, you know, and he, It's got his first bomb pin and he, you know, he bombed. It's got everywhere that he bombed. He bombed the oil fields, Tripoli, he bombed Italy, all these places. But there's a day he was the top turret in the plane. And there was a day where he said, basically, that everyone that he knew, everyone in every other plane was shot down and killed. He watched people get shot down out of their planes.
SPEAKER_03He got shot by a Messerschmitt. The bullet went right through his ear. It was this close to being killed. They declared that they were dead. The pilot and the engineer in the plane bailed. And the plane still limped in and he said, only God saved us. And I think that And that is true. It's true. He was saved. And he was a kid. He's doing his duty. He's doing it with honor.
SPEAKER_03He's doing the things he's supposed to do. He doesn't give up. He's almost killed, and he makes it. And he gives glory to God.
SPEAKER_01So we'll get back to it. So where there's elements of this, you're seeing something like variations on Christian movies? Yeah.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, I think that...
SPEAKER_01Well, I mean, the movie I like to hold up is my number one. You put the red light at the top, which is fascinating. I throw the mission up there, which is a really, you know, overtly Christian movie on some level, although the Christians are doing bad stuff. Yeah. You like that movie, right?
SPEAKER_03Yeah. I love that movie. Yeah. Well, it's got Jeremy Irons in it, who went to my drama school when I met. Very nice to meet you. Oh, really? Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Maybe you got your voice from him. Yeah.
SPEAKER_03It's got Jeremy Irons, Liam Neeson, and Robert De Niro's 1986. I think it's Peter Weir. I can't remember who directed it. I think it's Peter Weir. But it's an interesting movie because elements of it could turn a person off even while watching a Christian movie. It's Jesuits. We've got the Amazon, all this stuff. And yet we have... this warrior character who is trying to do penance and who again, fights, he fights for, for others who can't fight. I mean, what's more Christian. I mean, you know, he's, he's, he doesn't fear death.
SPEAKER_03He's at the point he wants to die for Christ. And I think that that's, that's a, that's a pretty fantastic movie. I actually try to avoid that movie. I can't really watch it. It's, there's a couple of movies that I, I really have a hard time watching because really, yeah, they're, they're a little bit, why, Well, I think that they, they are too, I think it's important to see those films, but I try not to rewatch them because, uh, they really just, they're hard hitting and they take a lot out of me. Another one, which is not really a Christian movie,
but the movie war horse, um,
SPEAKER_03I can't watch. I watched it one time, and from the first 30 seconds of the movie, I'm like, oh, no, this is going to be it. Seriously? Yeah, I can't. I don't know that film. I can't even rewatch it. It just leaves you too scarred emotionally? Yeah, it's too heavy. It's too cruel. It's about a horse in World War I, and it's too... The people in it become ancillary figures who are just trying to save this damn horse from who's there's a scene where the horse is running and gets
caught up in this barbed
SPEAKER_03wire in this war. And it's so senseless. And so it's, it's, it's too much.
SPEAKER_01Well, you know, I went there with apocalypse. Now I did not like that film in the end. I, it, it, it just, it was, it was nihilist.
SPEAKER_03It was too dark. Yeah. I love apocalypse. Now I think it's the greatest movie ever made.
SPEAKER_01No kidding. I really did. You had a car crash. Yeah.
SPEAKER_03Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. By the third quarter of that film, though, you're able to sit there and still watch these guys? I've seen it. Yeah, I've seen Apocalypse Now like a million times. And the movie is so powerful because I think it's a great example of film and art where it's not necessarily factual what you're watching. This sort of archon character is bigger than life. And yet it's entirely truthful.
SPEAKER_03I think that,
SPEAKER_01I watched,
SPEAKER_03I rewatched, I covered Blade Runner and do Android Stream of Electric Sheep and Blade Runner 2049 the other day. Just now, I think.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_03That's right. And Roy Batty is clearly a Kurtz character. Kurtz is also, he's that colonel in Vietnam, you know, the ears for beers guy. And we, it's a great example of how war happens. It's an it's an impressionistic, subjective film. And it's a great example of how there are certain people, you know, it says this in Heart of Darkness and Conrad's Heart of Darkness. Kurtz was a person who had something to say and he said it. He's a special being. And those people do exist in the world.
SPEAKER_03There are people that. that are bigger than life or who do something extraordinary that goes, the things they do go beyond the things that we see. And they come sort of once in a while. You never really know where they come out. They do come out in war a lot. And the movie is incredibly nihilistic, but it has a purpose. I think the purpose sometimes helped me. Well, sometimes in a film, you know, or in, in heart of darkness, for example, where you have what seems like utter nihilism is a, is a,
SPEAKER_03a fulfillment, there goes the thunder outside, is a fulfillment of the sort of arc of nihilism to its logical endpoint, which is that we see the frustration and the futility of the events. And that's especially important in light of war. And so I think that the reaction to that is that instead of nothingness, there's clearly something.
SPEAKER_01Oh, wait a minute. This is fascinating. Mm-hmm. Yeah, but the film doesn't depict that. It leaves you with the nothingness, which is supposed to what imply and give me... It's like a lesson. Hey, don't do war. Is that why it's a great film?
SPEAKER_03No, I don't think it... In fact, I think it's not a lesson. I think that the entire purpose of the movie is not a lesson. It's not a didactic... It's empty. There's an emptiness, but I think that there's something... some kind of terrible as yates calls a terrible beauty there's a sort of terrible beauty in the film um and i don't think that the end point of it is no war in fact in fact that's a good point because one of the reasons that and
i put i didn't put saving private ryan down but there's a character who i think acts in a he's supposed to be a christian character in the film and he in saving private ryan the
SPEAKER_03sniper character who's praise before his you know he's doing his duty but i think that that movie is a great example of the problem with with anti-war movies which kind of crosses over into what are supposed to be christian movies which is where we have We're supposed to be taught a lesson from watching these events take place. And yet they're showing the very events that we're supposed to rebel against. So in other words, the Americans go and they invade D-Day and they're trying to
fight.
SPEAKER_03Clearly in the movie, it's explicit in the movie that there are people they're defending that are not nothing. And yet the people they're fighting are portrayed as nothing. They're all the same. They look all the same. The characters are interchangeable, but that defeats the whole purpose of the thing. If you want to make an anti-war movie, you would have characters fighting other characters who are real. Does it make sense?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, you would feel sadness when a Nazi died on that level.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, you would feel the futility of the war itself.
SPEAKER_01Which is Apocalypse Now. You feel sadness all the time.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, and Apocalypse Now is also absurd. It has an absurdity to... You remember? Colonel Kilgore is like... they're putting the death cards on the people and there's like a Viet Cong guy and he's got his, he got shot out. And he says, you know, he's, he says, water, water, he wants water. And he gives him the water. He says, anybody, you can hold their guts and get water any day. And then he hears that there's a surfer nearby and then he picks up the water and the water just gets thrown. And it's absurd. It's absurd. This guy portraying. Yeah, it is.
SPEAKER_03It is.
SPEAKER_01Would you call that a Christian movie?
SPEAKER_03No, I wouldn't. I wouldn't call that one. I would call The Thin Red Line a Christian movie. I think that that has strong Christian elements in it. But that's me too. But yeah, I mean, the purpose of that movie is that we're following. We have a, an impressionistic sort of poetic voice that is continuously in the movie, trying to exalt the beautiful and the, and the futility of all this death in the film and trying to make sense of war. And we have a character who,
SPEAKER_03I mean, that's how Jim Caviezel obviously got the passion of the Christ. Cause he plays that character in the thin red line. It's the same character. Same character. Same character. And it's got Sean Penn. You know, there's only this world and nothing beyond.
SPEAKER_01That is one of the best conversations in movie history for me. There's only this world. And this is the world we live in.
SPEAKER_03And you have the character, you know, you have Nick Nolte. Nature's cruel, Starles. Look at the vines twisting around everything. You know, Nick Nolte represents this kind of evolutionary... you know, dog eat dog, social Darwinist viewpoint of life and some of the other characters and especially the Starles character. He's like, no, that's not the way it is.
SPEAKER_01It's an incredible film. Yeah. You know what? You just reordered my own list. I'm right. Cause I, I just, that's probably my favorite movie of all time, but I didn't, I didn't really count it, but you're right. It's, it's Malick too. Malick's always working with. Yeah. Always. Yeah. I liked it. I, yeah, I agree with that. Totally. I had on my list. Well, I'll do my list. No, you do your list next. What's your next one? What's another one you think people would watch?
SPEAKER_03Another one that I think probably goes by the wayside, but is incredibly relevant now is children of men. Children of men is, um, is highly, highly relevant right now. We've got we'll call it immigration things happening in the country. Uh, certain events. Uh, I don't think you hear the thunder, but there's a big, I can't hear it, but kind of exciting. Um, but, uh, you know, we've got, we've got a, uh, an immaculate conception that occurs in the film. Yeah.
SPEAKER_03The characters, the main character's name is Theo. Um, and he really is, uh, wandering through a wasteland, uh, trying to do a sacrificial act he wants he's he ends up sacrificing himself for not only for this woman but for humanity and um it has strong a lot of times these films it's not in dialogue it's not in the specific plot but it's in the tone of the film or in the way that the world is presented in an
aesthetic sense and that's
SPEAKER_03hard to place as far as what makes that a christian film but I think that that's a pretty strong one.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. I think you might be doing the thing. My next one was Ostrov. And the thing you're doing is the island. So it's a Russian film. But the thing is... I'm catching that there's... Movies make impressions and certain impressions have a reality. And the reality of redemption seems core to a Christian film, even when it's not a Christian. I mean, because you know what's not on my list? God's not dead. Because ironing is dead in that movie. And there's absolutely nothing to smile about in that film.
SPEAKER_01Have you ever seen God's not dead?
SPEAKER_03No, I haven't seen it.
SPEAKER_01You haven't seen it? So then here's what we're going to do. I can't show a clip of it. Can I? What's the rule on that?
SPEAKER_03No, you will. If you show a five second clip of something, either the music or the film will. I will get in trouble. Yeah, you'll get in trouble.
SPEAKER_01We've learned that, but we also can do it. We see some, there's some stuff you can do it with, but in God's not dead, you'll notice that the characters are, and it's brutal. Yeah. But the thing is the message is so didactically alive. In other words, you can't miss it. It is data and it is raining on you in a linear way. And when you're done, you're like, Ooh, that was exhausting. Yeah. I don't know how anybody, but that's probably when I talk to people about what's a Christian film, they all say God's not dead.
SPEAKER_01Should I not say bad stuff about it? You seem sad. No, I just, I just, I don't like, I, that's your favorite Christian film that I just hammered.
SPEAKER_03I don't, I don't like it. Cause I don't, I don't, I haven't seen it and I don't want to see it. Cause I don't like fair enough. I don't like the, even the phrasing. I don't like the title. I don't like the words that are used in it. I don't like dad used in that title. And so Hercules is in it.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Remember Hercules. Who's the guy who's you talking about?
SPEAKER_03Hercules from the Eddie Murphy movie.
SPEAKER_01No.
SPEAKER_03Okay.
SPEAKER_01I'm talking about... Kevin Sorbo. Kevin Sorbo. No, I haven't seen it. He's the pissed off guy that gets hit by a car. But anyway, we'll come back to that. You got another one on your list? Yeah, Rocky.
SPEAKER_03Rocky is a... What? I didn't see that coming. Yeah, it's... And it's not only that, but it's... I think it's not an overt Christian film, but Stallone intended it to be that way in terms of it's crazy because it seems to be both overt and subtle. And what I mean is that he intended for the film to open with a cross. The film opens with a cross.
SPEAKER_03We're rising in the film. We see a character who basically has nothing, is totally separated from any sort of Christian reality, tends to live in this kind of really debased environment. I don't actually really like it. the movie Rocky in terms of rewatching it. Cause I don't like how grainy it is. It's like grainy and foggy. Really green.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_03And I, and I don't like that, but he did that for a specific reason. And, and the reason is that this character, Rocky is supposed to fight. his way out. And he's supposed to give everything he can to fight. And it shows you again, and I think Stallone meant for this to happen, that we have a character who is, who symbolizes a kind of Christian struggle, who number one, doesn't win at the end. He doesn't win, but, but he still wins. He wins his dignity.
SPEAKER_03He wins his honor. He wins the love of his wife. He wins a self-respect and, Oh, There goes the power. If I cut off, I cut out, I'll come back in.
SPEAKER_01So I think as far as I'm concerned, I don't know that we have a great list, but I think our list is getting great. That's what I think. Thin Red Lion. Do you know Ostrov, this Russian movie that I want to throw on my list?
SPEAKER_03No, I haven't seen it. Everybody tells me about it, and I still haven't seen it yet, so I got to see it.
SPEAKER_01Well, if you're a little ortho-adjacent, it sounds like, especially if you're talking about the church, It's fantastic. And I can only tell you this. I can tell you about the whole film, but I won't because you're the movie guy. But I'll just tell you this. The actor in that film was a famous Soviet actor during the Soviet period. He got older and then the wall fell. And he became an Orthodox Christian, like a serious one. He may have been baptized as a kid.
SPEAKER_01And he became a serious one. And then he went out and sort of lived this serious monastic style life. He wasn't in a monastery, as I understood it. And then they came for him. He had like retired, basically, from acting. And they came for him with this script and said, well, you're the guy. You got to make it. And he was living that way, basically. And he said, only if you give me full control. You're going to tell me one thing I'm going to say. And they brought him in, and it is fantastic. Nice. Nice. Ostrov is on my list. You got any other Christian films that you want?
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, there's a few of them. Master and Commander, I think, is a Christian film. It has Christian elements in it, of course. And many of those elements... I think that the ship in Master and Commander... I covered this with my friend David Patrick Carey, Church of the Internal Lawyers. This movie... the ship really functions as a kind of arc of, of humanity. And we have characters representing sort of all different levels in the hierarchy
SPEAKER_03of men on the ship. And they are, They are led by a strong male figure who represents all the best things about honor and civilization, and they are fighting for their lives. But one important thing in this movie is that Russell Crowe's character – I think this is an explicitly, you know, this is a very Christian character. One thing about it is that he is,
SPEAKER_03he's gentle with the lowest forms and he is harsh with the, with the highest, the highest people on the ladder.
SPEAKER_02I see.
SPEAKER_03So, so this, and this is kind of a, a Cheval, this comes out of a kind of Chevalric sense of Christendom where, you know, we have this boy who, who the boy in the movie ends up being the fiercest one on the ship. He is willing to sacrifice himself. He sacrifices his arm. He becomes a kind of another Nelson figure. And we have characters who even, even though they, They present Captain Jack with like the ship and the model of the ship.
SPEAKER_03And that's how they go after the French. And when they are cruel to one of the other characters on the ship, he treats them accordingly. And he doesn't treat them with cruelty. He actually weeps for the loss of one of the guys and has to cut him away immediately. They have to cut him away in the storm in Antarctica. And the scene following that in the film, I think, is an extremely Christian scene where he opens up his Bible. He's about to do the funeral service.
SPEAKER_03And when he closes it, he says... He basically says, all of us have sinned. We are all offensive. We offend one another. And if we've offended one another, God, please forgive us. And right after that, the rain falls. They haven't had rain. They haven't had water for a long time. And they're baptized into a new life. And all of the old things are over and the new things begin. And I think that's a powerful thing.
SPEAKER_01Master and commander. That's good. I've not seen that. Can I, you think I'd give him a life to watch that?
SPEAKER_03I don't know. Well, Mastery Commander is another dude's rock film. There's one lady in the whole movie. She's a Brazilian lady who comes up and she kind of looks at, and that's another thing. She kind of, she looks at Captain Jack, but you know, I think he's married back on shore. I can't remember in the books.
SPEAKER_01He holds it together. He holds it down. Yeah.
SPEAKER_03He holds it together, dude. He ain't no simp. He looks at her and he's like, we got to go, boys. Let's go. Sounds pretty good. Any films, especially any works of literature, I think, that come out of a lot of the works that come out of of the chivalric medieval era do this. Another great one I think is, I think it's 1981's Excalibur by John Borman is a Christian film because in the grail, in the quest for the grail,
SPEAKER_03I believe that the grail is the Eucharist and that the characters are, they have to confront their own sin and confront their own natures. And the, they have to learn how to serve the King. The King, King Arthur is supposed to be a lower kind of avatar for a Christ-like figure. So, you know, they, that, that's sort of what it entails.
SPEAKER_01Would you say you may not know the state of movie making per se, but would you say angel films are making angelic films?
SPEAKER_03I don't know what thing, what's angel films?
SPEAKER_01What is angel films? So you know what? I'm making this movie with my brother and Scooter Downey and some other characters. And it's a documentary. It's like Anthony Bourdain goes in search of Christianity, basically. And it's cool. We're stuck in some production ruts. We're trying to figure out investors and money. I saw the Tucker interview. Yeah, that's right. You did see that. Yeah, man. That was a real thing. I'm watching that guy right now because we sat down for a whole day together and
SPEAKER_01I personally just think this for anybody that's listening, not that anybody cares, but in just spending time with him and talking to him for, we have two and a half hours of rolling tape on that. That dude's legit. I mean, you may not like what he's saying. I don't know what your politics are, but it's, There's nobody. He's not going to bed at night and saying, I fooled him. It's not like that for all those people that want to go CIA and all that stuff. He's just an honest guy who I think is waking up in terms of his Christianity. And I think he's like getting a really stiff back, which is like,
I don't really care about the rest of this because Christ is real somehow.
SPEAKER_01And I got to do this. That's my gut. That's my gut on that.
SPEAKER_03Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Pretty wild. Pretty wild.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, I agree. I think so, too. I mean, I don't. Tucker Carlson is funny because he is exactly where I come from. I mean, he's exactly everything he says looks like where he went to school and does. Interesting. Exactly like everyone that I that I grew up with. And so when I hear him talk, especially when I hear him talk about his religious life and his religious upbringing, you know, he's Episcopal. I mean, it reminds me of that.
SPEAKER_03And he is looking for something. He's looking for something more, I think. And I really like that interview because I think a lot of people, especially a lot of people watching, will know that that is real. And so, you know, I really dug that.
SPEAKER_01Oh, good, man. I'm thankful. Well, in two seconds, I think people will find this interesting. And again, I'm happy to have your expertise on, but this is actually interesting because during making this film, I was in London and I met with the head of the angel films, like the guy he's, there's three brothers, I think two brothers, but yeah, We just met with one of the brothers and they basically explained what they do. So I'll tell you what they do. And then maybe you've got a comment on this, but essentially they've created this guild. I forget how many it's hundreds of thousands of people though.
SPEAKER_01And they basically you could join the guild or me, but, You got to answer a bunch of questions. It's a bunch of demographic questions about who you are. You know, all kinds of stuff. They're downloading, you know, hundreds of millions of data bits on information. And then basically when a filmmaker comes to them, they'll pretty much take anybody and they take variations on whether it's a whole film and then they put it in front of the guild. And then they run these algorithms that say, you know, straight white males, you know, living in the South said this about the film.
SPEAKER_01And they return all this data on your, whether it's a 20 minute clip, it's the whole movie, whatever it is. And then they break it down and they have a rating system. And if you score over 80, they say, we'll make your movie or we'll be instrumental. Maybe they shop out some of the production, but the point is, is they're ready to roll. If you score lower than 80, they send you back and say, make another, edit it and cut it and bring it back. They're trying to get you to get into this zone where it's profitable.
SPEAKER_01that's angel films and they, they, they're, they're Mormons or they're of, let's say Mormon tradition or something. And so they're interested in Christian ish films. And that's something in their own personal story. It's, it sounds like a medieval version of a, of an artisan's guild for making movies.
SPEAKER_03And that's interesting. That's really interesting. That's an interesting way to do it. And I think that it's, you know, from what you said, I mean, it's interesting that, it has to be, we have to keep up with technology. We have to keep, you know, you have to be appropriate and keep up with technology as far as, you know, I understand running through an algorithm and maybe that's the best way as far as trying to determine whether you're going to make content for people with something so big. I think that making a movie, is incredibly difficult i've got friends who are in the movie
industry one of one one of my best friends is a is a screenwriter and he tells me the trials and tribulations of making movies and it's in it's fickle it's incredibly difficult and a lot of times it comes down to you know i was an actor and it comes down to what you look like, who you know, and where you're going to get your financing.
SPEAKER_03And that's it. It's kind of like it's not difficult to conceive that Danny DeVito is so successful, if I take him as an example, because One would think, why would you put Danny DeVito in a movie? Well, because if you're going to have a character who looks like Danny DeVito looks, for instance, you need the best looking version or the best example of that. You want that. And he's it. Yeah. You know, he's, I mean, he's like, and always sunny. I mean, he's perfect. He's also a successful producer.
And so it's not necessarily that people have to look like Chris Hemsworth or something. It's that they have to be the best versions of those particular slots that they're filling in.
SPEAKER_03And so... It's it's an incredibly fickle industry. And also, it's an unnecessary industry when you consider life and what we all sort of do in life. You know, it's amazing. Richard Burton, we talked about this last time, I think that Richard Burton and Peter O'Toole continuously talked about how. ridiculous it is that you can make a living playing pretend and playing dress up when there are people like Richard Burton's old family were slate were slate miners you know and it's like there are people who are trying to make a living for their
SPEAKER_03family and they people watching this are are going to go to work every morning. They're going to work their ass off. They're going to come home and feed their family and they know they can't miss a single meal. And that is, you know, GK Chesterton said that that's probably the most noble that that those are the heroes. That's probably the most noble thing you could possibly be is a person who never misses a meal. You serve your family. You're together because think of what an anomaly that is in the world right now. And yet you still have people who are making movies and playing
dress up and
SPEAKER_03getting paid millions of dollars. And so on the levels of different things you can do with your life and how you serve God, I suppose that's all dependent on the person.
SPEAKER_01You know, you love movies and yet you live in that in that that paradox, because you're right when you strip them bare. Sometimes my wife does this. She's a very critical viewer. She strips it bare and she starts to actually see, imagine the lights like right off the set and she strips it bare in her mind while she watches it. And when she does that with me, I watch it too that way. And it's like, it's, it's like an absurdity. All of a sudden there's no, you just want to get away from it. You realize it's all fake, you know? Well, well, you know, I mean, uh,
Tom, you know, I really liked Tom Cruise.
SPEAKER_03I think Tom Cruise is amazing. the greatest Hollywood figure. I think he's great. And I, and, you know, I'm sort of gone PA I've gone past his, his personal life and his, whatever I know about his, I don't know. I don't know any of that. That's that could all be PR. That could all be, I don't know. And who am I to judge anyway? So what I do know is that every movie that Tom Cruise makes is, is a movie to make people happy. You, he wants to entertain people.
SPEAKER_03He knows, and he said this, he knows he, he doesn't, he's not running into burning buildings for in real life, saving kids. He's making movies and he's got millions of dollars. And what I really liked was that during the Karanka five years ago, when they were making Tom Top Gun Maverick,
SPEAKER_01I remember that. I remember that.
SPEAKER_03Yeah. Yeah. I remember he was screaming at people on set and they said, look, Tom Cruise goes crazy. Well, you got to listen to the content of what he says. He says basically like that. Top Gun Maverick is the only movie they're allowing anyone to make at the time. It's it. And if they say that you have to abide by the, you know, you have to come on set and stay six feet from people or whatever the BS was. Then he says, we got to abide by it to make the movie because I'm putting people through college. I'm, I'm putting, I'm paying the gaffer.
SPEAKER_03So he, his kid can have food on the table. I'm paying. We're, we're paying for everything. all of these people to live their lives and nobody else is doing that right now. So I appreciate that.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_03I appreciate that. Yeah. I appreciate that, that things like that are done by people, but I think it's important, you know, it's kind of like when you consider a novelist or, or a writer, I think that, you know, for one, it's, writers are important. In the beginning was the word. The Bible is written and that writing is important for civilization and for understanding who we are as people and that no matter what, if people live the hardest life or the roughest life, people still need
They need to back off from that and they need to rest and they need to see how
SPEAKER_03other people live and they need to find truth. And a lot of times we can't find truth in just the lives that we live. We're not enough to do that. Sometimes we have to read or to watch other people or to... So I think, I think these things are important, even though they, they tend to be full of.
SPEAKER_01I know. I, I, I still love a good movie. You do too. You've been doing it for a while and you know, your business guys go watch this pod. It's cool. But. You think the movies are becoming more likely to be Christian in the way that, however we've, by the way, I don't, I'm not sure we've done a great time job to find it. Cause I don't think you can, but do you think we, do you think they're becoming more Christian? People are leaning into that now when they make movies or you think they're becoming less Christian?
SPEAKER_03I don't know. I think that, Christian themes or what we have tried to call Christian movies will continue. They'll continue to be anomalies, but they will be potent and powerful. And it really doesn't matter the number of films that are made as long as the ones that are made work and are great. Yeah. And, you know, you take a movie like I'll throw out one other movie. I'm here. The movie signs with Mel Gibson, I think is a, is a great Christian movie. It's relevant.
SPEAKER_03It's, it's even relevant today. We've got the fake alien stuff and all this stuff, but we have a character who was a, a religious figure. He was a priest. He loses his faith because of the, the grief from his wife's death. He learns to, you know, and he becomes a miserable, hateful person. And then he learns that things do indeed have meaning that God gives us meaning. And then at the end of the movie, there's a perfect redemption. He goes back into the,
into serving god and i think that that's that that movie was successful it was powerful it's potent it's a something that we can sort of latch on to that we see we we all know that when we see movies where people do the the right thing when
SPEAKER_03they do good when they do when they perform some kind of Proto pseudo holy ass. We feel we feel uplifted by that. Yeah, man. And as far as movies going with where they're going to go, I think that the more that Hollywood produces movies where everything is subverted or inverted and where we have ideology or political ideology or a sort of self-based identity as the thing that's uplifted,
they will continue to falter and fail and they may make more of them for years and
SPEAKER_03years, but those aren't going to be the things that people remember or that they care about.
SPEAKER_01So that's a, that's a hopeful, that's a hopeful way to think about it. I think it might be, can I just, can I give you one more little pieces that I think on some level, What you said is, I think what I was trying to say poorly before, which is if you participate in reality, the way the Orthodox would describe it, it means you're participating in Christ. And so reality is Christ. And then what we do is we have variations on degradation. So everything sort of flows out as a degraded variation on Christ.
SPEAKER_01But wherever you see that, you've been describing in all these great comments of yours about movies, whenever you suddenly, through a film, you're experiencing, I don't know, joy or something, you really are being drawn up into the higher things. You're drawn back toward reality. And so for me, that's what a movie, Dostoevsky talks about this, that's what a movie should do. It should draw you back toward reality and out of the thing you've created as your own. So for a lot of people, that's like, oh, it lifted me up. You could argue it brought you closer to Christ.
SPEAKER_01That's what an icon does. So for me, I really like that you, what you said, because even one person making one film, there's a light in there, you know, there's a light in that darkness. And I don't see any way they stop. It's human existence. To be alive and to be filled with light is to be like Christ. So, I mean, somebody's going to be around like that. Maybe even us, Bay's Lit Analyzer. Yeah.
SPEAKER_03You know, an example of that is the movie The Brutalist that I just covered a little while ago, which is... a movie that is, it's brutal. It's a, it's, you know, it's a study of, of a 20th century architectural movement, but it, it sort of trauma packs. It has all of the horrible things that you could imagine in a movie. It's got drug addiction and adultery and the H cost and the, you know, horrors of, of immigration.
SPEAKER_03And it's got all these things in it. And and yet what happens in the film is that the industrialist character goes to this town council and they say, if you're going to build this gigantic thing on this hill, it has to be a church. You have to have a cross. You've got to be. It's got to be a church. You've got to have a church in there based. So then what happens is the guy tries to subvert, the architect tries to subvert that and say, well, we're going to make a, well, I'll make a cross, but the cross won't be made. It'll be the outside of the cross. In other words, you're looking at pieces of stone that are,
SPEAKER_03that are, that make pieces of stone that are cut out where light comes in and we have the cross. and some may see that as oh well there's a cross but it's to me it seems like an invert you know it's a he's subverting the order of things and he's saying I'm not building a cross but there's a cross made and then the end of the film we see that there's an altar inside of this subterranean look it looks like hell really you're inside this subterranean place and it's it's all yeah it's
clean and brutalist with
SPEAKER_03lines but it's it's all concrete and The cross, the light from the cross is inverted on the altar. So we have an upside down cross on the altar. But guess what? God makes the crooked way straight. And no matter what, the cross still wins in the thing. So there at least there in the end is actually still a cross. The thing ends up being the people got their church. Now it's not like what they liked and this guy tries to subvert it, but it still wins. And I think that that's going to sort of continue to be a thing
that happens in
SPEAKER_03Hollywood and entertainment and literature. And oftentimes this happens again, unconsciously through people. God can work through anyone. And so hopefully that will, that will continue that it will continue.
SPEAKER_01That's good stuff. Yeah. That's really good stuff. All right. So we're pals now. And then we just got to make this thing. Got to instantiate. Maybe one day you come to the restaurant. Yeah, for sure. You're invited. Okay. Thanks, buddy. Appreciate you. We'll hook you up with all night food and wine. Awesome. And cigarettes. Thank you, man.
SPEAKER_02Thanks, bud.
SPEAKER_01Hey, to your work, man. Keep going, okay? BLA, also known as Henley, but online we call him BLA or Bazelit Analyzer. Go check out his stuff. We'll put all the links in there, okay?
SPEAKER_03Thanks for having me. Really appreciate you. Love your show. Love the channel. Appreciate it.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, man. Keep going. We're going to all find ourselves together at a table sometime. And you know what? It might even be the one, the big banquet when this crazy world ends for us. Let's hope so. Let's hope so. Peace to you, bro. Peace. Peace. Well... Besides the fact, he was, like, actually lighting up and actually speaking. He sounded like Nick Nolte from Thin Red Light. We're going to go out back to hell. That's what we're going to do.
SPEAKER_01I love that guy. So I think that's a dinner waiting to happen. But I hope you enjoyed that today. I want you to enjoy something else. The art of giving. Consider being a monthly donor at $20, $30, $40 a month. I'm asking. I'm begging. Hit like and subscribe. Do that too. I'm told to say that. I'm so bad at saying it. Do it right now. But also consider joining us. And we hop on these calls every now and then. Not very often lately. I've been traveling.
And just get to know our organization, because we keep doing different stuff.
SPEAKER_01We've got a field school. We can go for six weeks at a time to join our guys in the field. We've got a restaurant. We have an art automata coming up at the restaurant in Greenville called Capey. And the art automata there is going to be a concert. Tickets to come join for speakers. Frederica Matthews Green is going to be one of our speakers. Yeah, yeah. Jonathan Pagiot is going to be a speaker down at the Florida gig. Neil is going to come in and play music with Kate and Dirt Poor Robbins. My kids are going to come sing at the Greenville event.
Nathan Jacobs is going to come and be one of our speakers on hospitality and
SPEAKER_01philosophy and theology. I don't know, man. I don't think he really. Andrew Gould, one of the greatest architects in the country right now, he's going to bring his philosophy on what a thing, how we build things and talk about that as hospitality down in Florida. So this is happening. That's happening. This is happening. We got Art of Tamina. We got Super Dinner Society. If you want to throw a party in your world and you want to bring a Tamina, we can do that now. Look at the links. Check us out. And most of all, thank you for supporting us. It's little by little.
SPEAKER_01I'm going to buy one of those algorithm guys. Like, I don't know. Can you buy somebody that does algorithms? I feel like they would, I feel like they're going to be in Burma or someplace. And then they were just like, we'll have 50,000 people tomorrow watching because of the algorithm. Should they do it? I love you guys. See ya. Have your things lightly.
Find this episode on YouTube: "Justine Alter" - a pseudonym - returns to chat with John Heers in a raw Heavy Things Lightly conversation you have to hear to believe.Justine worked for years as a professional psychic,...
Find this episode on YouTube: Holly Hickman went from Columbia Journalism and Fox News Radio covering NASA and the 2008 election - to milking cows, making cheese, and converting to Orthodoxy.In this episode of Heavy...
Can you teach kids the truth AND prepare them for a secular world?On this episode of Heavy Things Lightly, host John Heers talks with James and Juliana Joyce, founders of St. George's Classical Academy in Boxford,...
Find this episode on YouTube: Crow walked America searching for his father - and found the Father.From West Virginia hollers to LA gangs, from wolves in the Mojave desert to an Orthodox cross, this is an Odyssean tale...
Welcome to the first episode of “Save Me a Spot at the Supra” on Heavy Things Lightly where John Heers hosts singer and Broadway performer Carrie Manolakos (best known for her performances in Mama Mia! and Wicked) at...