Find this episode on YouTube: https://youtu.be/0BisN-lw4ew John talks with Pavel Schelin (@PavelShchelin) about modernity, the war in Ukraine, and what this means for America and Russia. Pavel is a Russian, Orthodox Christian and political philosopher. โ Find articles, John's novel, and even more Heavy Things Lightly at Substack: https://johnheersftf.substack.com/ โ Tailormade travel adventures in Europe and Africa: https://www.gratitude-travels.com/home ๐ Discover the non-profit behind Heavy Things Lightly: https://first-things.org/ ๐ฌ๐ช ๐ฌ๐น ๐ฒ๐ฟ ๐ธ๐ฑ 2 years. Deep cultural immersion. Intense personal discovery. See what it means to become a Field Worker with FTF: https://first-things.org/opportunities or email Adrian at adrian@first-things.org for more information. ๐ข Telegram: https://t.me/firstthingsfoundation ๐ฅ And you should definitely check out Keipi Restaurant: https://keipirestaurant.org Please leave a review with your comments! Your support keeps this podcast alive and allows us to broaden our discussion. --- This โEnlightenedโ New World utopia isnโt turning out to be all it was cracked up to be. Society is disenchanting, but are the only alternatives hiding out in the hills or burying yourself in books? With an air of levity and a touch of humor, John Heers teaches how to examine the confusing New World by calling upon the mind and wisdom of oft-forgotten Old. Heavy Things, Lightly. --- Credits Music: Intro / Outro Provided by Greg Gilbertson & Band This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit johnheersftf.substack.com/subscribe
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_01It's Heavy Things Lightly. It's First Things Foundation. Today, Pavel Schellen, philosopher and all-around cool guy.
SPEAKER_01All right, guys, Pavel is here, Pavel Schellen. And this is one of my... I was looking forward to this as much as anything since our Art of Tamada, Pavel, because we had such a good time at this event. You became a Tamada... You were sort of the wanted Talmud at our table there by the end. I think people were really enjoying your toast. But we found out a lot about you.
SPEAKER_01I knew some before that you're a philosopher and you command this quite a big podcast, almost 100,000 listeners, mostly in Slavonic. Or in Russia. Russia, yeah, not Slavonic. Will you tell us about yourself? Who are you? For folks listening to Heavy Things Lately.
SPEAKER_02Well, thank you very much for having me, John. And... Well, to answer your question, I guess I do have to start on top. So I am a Russian and I am an Orthodox Christian. That would be two cornerstones of my identity, which I think is important to put these things in hierarchy. I live currently in the United States, which provides a very interesting perspective.
SPEAKER_02on everything that I do, because exactly I do have a privilege and an opportunity to almost see things from two different eyes and to have an opportunity to shift from different frameworks, from different perspectives and from different optics, if you want to put it this way. Not an easy skill to master. We honestly pretend to kind of, even people who do it professionally, but to
SPEAKER_02really learn how to do it you almost need to live in different cultures as you know yourself for like really long period of time to understand a certain culture you need to spend like several years there tourism is not enough and I happen to travel quite a lot in my life so I lived in Europe I lived in Europe for several years I lived for 23 years in Russia I now live for two years in the States so all of these things combined create a very
SPEAKER_01What kind of household did you grow up in?
SPEAKER_02I guess personal. Interesting. I was raised by my mom and my grandma. That's it. In Moscow.
SPEAKER_01In Moscow. In Moscow. Speaking Russian as Moscow.
SPEAKER_02Of course, yes. I do have a strong Moscow accent in Russian. That's what you're wondering.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, no, it's interesting because you're... Guys, Pavel's going to... We're going to get into the whole Ukrainian-Russian situation. We're going to get into philosophy and how it applies to these wars around the world and how it applies... Philosophy of war is very interesting. So, I want you guys to know about Pavel that way. How did you decide to go overseas? How did changing out of the Russian culture come about?
SPEAKER_02Okay. Here comes, I think... Not just who I am, but what I do. Because it is related in that respect. So as you've said already, I'm currently... doing political philosophy. So not just any philosophy, but political philosophy, to clear. And I can put it this way. Since my childhood, I had... If there is one trait which I would say is consistent with the general journey,
SPEAKER_02which I undertook, it's like love to asking questions and looking for different answers. So you can say that all my journeys and all the different stops on my journeys are all one way or another connected with this phenomenon of asking certain questions and looking for answers. So I moved abroad to do several master programs because I thought I was disappointed with certain things in Russia in terms of exactly types of questions
SPEAKER_02I've been asking. And okay, the logic was, okay, I will look for answers somewhere else. So I studied in different places. Then I realized, okay, you don't have answers either. And then there came a lot of self-studying and then a lot of coming back to traditions which are not in the center of modern academia. Like those battles either in Russia or in Europe or in the United States. And that's how all of these different experiences, there was a general imperative for looking and searching for analysis,
SPEAKER_02regardless of whether it's, let's say, convenient or politically correct or whatever frame you want to put it into, kind of led to where I am now.
SPEAKER_01So there was a curiosity about the questions you were asking that went, you needed more than academia could Was academia looking similar in Russia and also in Europe and in the United States? Did you feel like...
SPEAKER_02I would say nowadays way more than it would be in the past, definitely, because the academic tradition became pretty globalized. So there are still huge differences country to country. Obviously, there is still national character left. But it's very interesting that now I can explain what was, I would say, the general pattern and what I was looking for.
SPEAKER_02No matter whether you stay in Europe, in Britain, in America, or in Russia, there is one big commonality between all of these traditions, and they are all of the new world. All different versions of modernity, like using the language of your podcast. Yes, one is more, let's say, liberal, another is more other size, but it's all predicated on this effectively system of modernity. And I think what kind of
SPEAKER_02was moving in my journey was that I was asking questions. Modernity is not good once. And that, I think, led to all of these different trials and errors and mistakes and, like, all of these different intents. So, like, it took me a while to understand that you can't find answers to certain problems within the modernity framework.
SPEAKER_01Give us a favorite question. Give us a favorite question you've been asked.
SPEAKER_02Well, one of... As a philosopher now, it's pretty standard syncs to what we discuss nowadays in the symbolic world crowd. The question of unity and multiplicity, it's a question of war and peace, it's a question. Ultimately, it's a question why people do what they do. That's the most interesting, I would say, point of being, because, for example, we have this understanding often that people are acting rationally, or people are acting in accordance with their best interests. Well, it's not the case, simply.
SPEAKER_02You can't answer this type of question rationally. You need to go beyond rationality. And that's already not exactly what academia is dealing with. Another important thing in academia, where there is a big uniqueness nowadays, generally, worldwide, it's almost impossible to ask big questions, like big, simple questions. We don't say a dumb question, let's say. You need to go in a very specific manner, in a very specific, particular field, particular area, to put it in the context of very particular literature,
SPEAKER_02and then you make a small impact. But you cannot really ask big things. And this is the trend of the last hundred years. Well, why did that? Original intention was very good, honestly. Original intention was to raise standards and to move humanity closer to science. Because that's the tricky part. Humanity is not science. Philosophy is not science. It's way closer to art. And we still call them liberal arts, for example, in English.
SPEAKER_02But we want to pretend that it's science. And we want to use scientific methods. And we want to do all of this. Hypothesis of correlation. Like proven and not proven. And when you do this in humanities, you can't really ask big. That's just not the way it works.
SPEAKER_01This is so fascinating. I find this, you're saying something so true. I call it an Aristotelian inclination to chop everything into parts.
SPEAKER_02It's interesting. I would call it Cartesian way more than Aristotelian. I like that too. That's good. Because Aristotelian was at least trying to keep it as a whole. Yes, you look for different reasons, but you keep it as a whole. Wholeness is a key category for Aristotelians. But that's what I call modernity. General approach of modernity.
SPEAKER_01I think Western people use Aristotle in certain ways. We fortify the particular and the study of that. But I hear you, Kurt. Yeah, Descartes is a better place to start. I like that. So do I have that right, though? Do you think the humanities are trying to particularize everything all the time?
SPEAKER_02nowadays and it's interesting that they never used to do it and that's why it's almost uh humanities are making themselves irrelevant by trying to do it because that's even a trickier part that in attempts to be in in its attempt to become more objective and scientific they're becoming less relevant because they cannot ask questions which they actually suppose to ask
SPEAKER_01Well, this is tough. Do you think that fear of asking the big question is something like the fear of asking about the good, which is something like asking about the God?
SPEAKER_02Or absolutely. You can say that basically it is a hierarchical structure. All humanities are underpinned on philosophy. So there is a hierarchy, so you go to philosophy, and without philosophy you can't do history, for example, because history is not a matter of studying facts. It's a matter of creating stories. It's a matter of myths. It's making sense. History is about making sense out of the facts.
SPEAKER_02And this act is intrinsically philosophical. It's intrinsically non-scientific. It's intrinsically ethical, categorical, but basically not scientific if you understand science as scientific method, as we understand.
SPEAKER_01So this is just like a beautiful... Just rich butter on top of some wonderful toast. You are making this thing taste so good. I totally am utterly in this place. So let's keep going for a second. And so you kept searching for a place to ask the big questions. You got to the United States. Here's a question for you.
SPEAKER_01When Americans try to do the big question, are they trying to do it like Russians do it?
SPEAKER_02No, let's do it in a very different way. Americans really try to... Usually Americans are really good with numbers. That's one thing. Americans are really good with numbers. That's very, like, historical American thing. And the second good thing is... It's also good and a bad thing. Here comes the tricky part. Americans are great about studying Americans. No, it makes sense. America is definitely a culture which is truly interested only in itself.
SPEAKER_02That's a very important part. And that's why if you read the way Americans usually study somebody else, it already works way worse. Not nearly good. But if you want to study, if you want to read the way Americans understand Americans, that's where all of this absolutely rich field of sociology, anthropology, etc. But... At the same time, American understanding of opposite is very limited. That's what I find very fascinating. Like American truly, I think,
SPEAKER_02American even academia feels incredibly challenged to understand culture which is not based on the premises of American philosophy. Americans sincerely believe that the American worldview is a universal worldview. That's very, and it is an academia. It is gigantic, quite an academia. Like you do have technically all of these African studies, like Russian studies, but it's nine times out of ten. And actually the most scientific it tries to become misses the key, like the whole why it's happening.
SPEAKER_02Because it can truly understand like the philosophical foundation of certain worldviews. or trying to categorize it but without embracing it and then you're almost missing
SPEAKER_01all of the nuances why do you think the i don't i don't think anybody listening to this podcast would disagree with you at least not anybody who's tried to teach after experiencing um international um culture on any deep level everyone i bump into who's traveled the way we travel And they always say, they say what you just said. Americans, they're really good at doing their stuff, but we don't really get other people. So how would, what would you attribute that to?
SPEAKER_01I mean, let's not even call it a bad thing. Let's just call it an American thing. How did we send it this way?
SPEAKER_02It's the other side of your virtues, like, ultimately. I would honestly put it in this way. One thing is you are really good in doing what you're doing. And by really good, I do mean really good. Like, you can call it the side effect of Protestant ethics, like the general foundation of America is a Protestant culture, is a Protestant colony, and truth be told, There is this element in Protestantism that it is my church and kind of everything which is outside of it. I'm not truly interested in it.
SPEAKER_02But within this confinement of my commonwealth and my community, I will do it really well and really good. And then it combined with general industrialness, productivity, work ethics. So all of the things led to the fact that Americans are incredibly talented in terms of doing business. And that's the key phrase of doing business. And so good. The problem is not everything in this world is about business.
SPEAKER_02No, but that's the thing. Americans are great in doing business, ultimately. Everything which is related to this field, like, yes, you're getting your iPhone, you're getting your Starship, I don't know, whatever things you're getting out of. But when it comes to understanding, it's not about business. And that's the thing. For most part of businesses, and especially for businesses in America really excel it, you don't really need to understand it. Or you need to understand only, like, on the surface level.
SPEAKER_02Like, it's enough. Like, you need the level of understanding sufficient for the business purpose.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, and those purposes are about utility.
SPEAKER_02Yes. They're pretty utilitarian, yeah.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, and I would argue, I want to know what you think as a philosopher. It's very nice, by the way, Papa. This is a great conversation. I'm thankful for it. For me, the American leap into its own skin, so to speak, the time, the period, the time, the era in which we became ourselves was when we started to adopt the utilitarian philosophies of mill and the utilitarian, the Englishman who gave us a way to do business and sideline our morality.
SPEAKER_01So I'm talking about the 19th century. There is an ability to sideline the morality one creates something like a gospel of wealth, like a moment when you can go, it's good to make money. Instead of making money as a thing, it doesn't have a moral, there's nothing moral about making money, but we found a way to tell that story. You do agree with that?
SPEAKER_02I do agree, but it is trickier than this. This is actually a Like, you are right, but I want to push it a little bit deeper to the reasons you are right. Because original American idea, and even... not original, I would call an American idea, is very deeply tied to a particular ethical framework. It's a Christian Protestant framework. It's a Christian Protestant framework of the fathers. And if you read American,
SPEAKER_02let's say, founding fathers, you will find easily that they're constantly talking about that the system we're building is for Christian moral people. And it won't work in any other context. And this is what you can come to, which I sometimes call the paradox of John Locke, basically. Because the paradox of John Locke is pretty simple. He already lives in time when he doesn't want to be under Pope. Like, he doesn't want to be under Pope. He doesn't want to have this,
SPEAKER_02let's say, source of moral authority coming from another person, like a very particular person. Hence, you understand, Englishman, Pope, not great relationship. Historically, after a certain man and eight wives, point being like... And several long bloody history. Let's look at this. King Henry. But also he's smart enough to understand that you need a certain kind of objective
SPEAKER_02moral code for people just to behave in a proper fashion. And that's why basically law creates the system of Deus Ex Machina. So we do have this objective natural law, which comes directly from God. It just comes. But we don't have kind of anything in between. And that's a paradox. Why it is a paradox? Because in your system, truth be told, there is nothing really which supports this belief in God.
SPEAKER_02But you need this belief in God for your system to function. And here comes your famous American Declaration of Independence. Because here comes the trick. We call these truths to be self-evident, etc., etc., etc., etc. And everything the founding fathers did and everything the founding fathers written was under the assumption that so many things are self-evident. Well, and here comes the trick. They are not. They are contingent upon a very particular moral and ethical system, moral and ethical foundation,
SPEAKER_02Which you took for granted. Ultimately, that's what an irony of America. Like, you took it for granted. And it makes sense how it was in the 18th century. Everybody's a Christian. Why would anybody not be a Christian? Yes, you can be Trinitarian, you can be Unitarian, you can be Presbyterian, whatever. You can be all the different denominations, but of course you're a Christian. But here comes the trick. In effect, there is an element of Peresitism. So you took the ethical framework of High Middle Ages, of people born in High Middle Ages,
SPEAKER_02You cut it from, like, in terms of this, cut it by mean, like, reason-wise. Because then you have to say, why do I need God? I have reason. Like, it's very easy from this stage to move to, I don't need God, I just need reason. As you know, it doesn't work this way, but you can see how it works philosophically. And then, I don't need God, I just need prosperity. I don't need God, I just need money. So, this is what happens in the 19th and early 20th century, that this... is getting cut. But originally, just to be clear, founding fathers do understand that if this moral link will be cut,
SPEAKER_02everything will start disintegrating and falling apart.
SPEAKER_01That's true. I do think there was a powerful... it's not a cartel of thinkers, but there was a group of thinkers who already, Benjamin Franklin, Thomas, you know, they already knew what they were doing in terms of creating that parasitic relationship. They were a little like Jordan Peterson these days in that, you know, like we just kind of need some moral stuff in order for us to be our full best selves.
SPEAKER_01I do think they were in that place.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, and that's something, something, something. No, but it's actually a very good example because I would say in that sense, it is the quintessential, this American dream. Like we do need it, but we don't want to truly submit ourselves to it. Like we want to save this because as an Orthodox, you know, there is a huge element of humility. There is a huge element of submission. There is a huge element of receiving it, not just taking it. And this was definitely a more different project, which didn't want any of those things.
SPEAKER_02It wanted to create good through your own strengths. It wanted to do good through your own power. It wanted to do all of this, to free all of this productive... That was the Lockean reason, because... in general one of the big imperative of the Enlightenment movement because moral order is restrictive and they thought it was too restrictive so we do need to liberate here comes the whole problem of liberty to liberate man so he can do more and more and more good But we still need to... But intuitively, we understand that we need to certain guardrails.
SPEAKER_02And back then, it was just enough to say that there are these 3, 4, 5, 10 principles which are given directly through God, which are like... And then, but outside of these borders of interest, you can do whatever you want. Well, problem, it doesn't work this way on a generational level. That's kind of the trick. It doesn't work this way on a generational level. And eventually, like... You come to the point, well, I will a little bit escalate, but you need to understand that the modern, let's say, radical liberal things,
SPEAKER_02which most traditionalists in America nowadays are obviously opposing or, let's say, feeling very uncomfortable with. But there is a way to see them as not a breakage of American tradition. but as a continuation of American tradition. Because in a pursuit of happiness, remember this line of an American declaration? Well, if there is no objective moral order, then how can you tell me that one way of pursuing happiness is objectively morally
SPEAKER_02reprehensible than the other way of pursuing happiness? And here comes the trick. Founding fathers didn't have this problem because everybody is a Christian, so of course they will pursue happiness in the way we envision them to do.
SPEAKER_01Now if you look at the Russian story... Yeah. So one thing Americans, I think, really misunderstand is that most every culture is imbued with a definition of freedom. There's no culture. I'm talking Malians, Russians. There's no culture that's like, freedom? Yeah, we don't really have that. No one wants that here. There are political writers in Mali saying, we don't want freedom. They just think freedom's been...
SPEAKER_01been given through Allah and through the Quran. So the Russian story, there's a freedom element. But how do Russians understand freedom compared to how Americans do? Okay.
SPEAKER_02There are two important ways I can answer your question. And depending on how much time we have. So I will try to quickly cover both. Sure. But then we're going to get into the war. I think it might be connected. Yeah. One that basically is about a little bit philosophical and linguistical terms. And another one is a little bit of the relationship between an individual and the state. And that's very related in the Russian context. Well, first thing first, the word freedom is very loaded and it's not exactly precise.
SPEAKER_02Here we do need to do a little bit of language explanation. You have effectively two types of freedom, like in any almost philosophical or language system. One is effectively a freedom you can understand to express yourself, to express your will. And another is the freedom to master, to be a master of your own desires or something along this line. So one is a freedom to just do whatever you want. Another one is a freedom to...
SPEAKER_02Well, effectively to do something, to do a very particular something. Christ in John chapter 8 talks about the second, when you say no person who is a slave of sin is free. Effectively, remember, this is a very important part. Well, you can understand that the Western individual freedom actually is quite a lot about the opposite. Like, it's about freedom to express yourself no matter, regardless of what you do. It's a freedom of expression.
SPEAKER_02And you can understand it on a very symbolic way. Literal, any expression. Whatever comes. Like, whatever comes of you.
SPEAKER_01And a freedom to become whatever you want. Yes. The becoming is untied from the... It's like the point of being is to be something new. Exactly. Which is interesting. Okay, I'll let you keep going.
SPEAKER_02It is very interesting, and that's one of the key contradictions. And another, once again, but there is a second type of freedom which is effectively like Christianity teaches. In the sense that Russian understanding intuitively is very orthodox. The true freedom is not coming from institution. The true freedom coming from you being able... to overcome your sin, or your weaknesses, or something like this. Two different words to explain this in Russian would be samovlastia,
SPEAKER_02so power of mastering oneself, and samovolia, to express one's own will, to do whatever I want. My will be done. Let my will be done. Something like this. Well, the key part is that the second, Russians know very well the danger of the second one. And here comes the Russian relationship with the state. People often think that Russians are just, you know, state addicts. And like, you just, you know, state, state, state, state, state, state.
SPEAKER_02And to an extent, it's even true. But people don't really understand why it is the case. And it is the case because for Russians, it's historically a choice or a conclusion that came through blood and lots of different mistakes. Maybe better than anybody else in the world, Russians know what happens when they just let the wheel run wild. Because there is this archetype of wheel, and there is even this word volia, like...
SPEAKER_02absolutely unburdened, unrestrained, chaotic force. And if you imagine the Russian landscape with all its gigantic, endless space, endless forests, endless steppe, endless, I don't know, like just endless, no borders. It's not like you have your nice little, you know, close, here's one river, here's another mountain, like all this hitting course. No, it's chaos. It's just one gigantic field of chaos, and this chaos is actually somebody else constantly coming. Like some nomadic tribe is constantly burning your whole life to the ground, constantly happening.
SPEAKER_02So there is a danger from the outside, but also there is a danger from yourself, because you're becoming really self-destructive, and Russia has really bad track record of self-destructive behavior. So Russian attitude of the state, it is a lot of submission, but it's submission because you need it to survive. You need it to survive, and you need it... You need a certain level of submission. Even if it's not like you understand, yeah, the state probably won't be doing that good of a job. But if you let these things run wild, if you let these things run amok,
SPEAKER_02well, then look what happens back then. And there is a certain cycle, unfortunately. There is a cycle in Russian history when Russians forget about this and then revolution comes. But generally speaking, this whole love towards the state of some people, and that's what most Western academia legitimately is missing, in my opinion. They don't understand the reason why. And on the contrary, what Russians have discovered through its saints and heroes is if you transform yourself and if you put your understanding of freedom towards what
SPEAKER_02effectively is orthodox teaching, no matter how state is, you can be free. You can be state in the wildest camps of Siberia. So the trade-off is not that bad. That's why it's coming. So that's, I think, the rational answer. If you truly want freedom, truly, well, then any state institution, Any external thing is kind of irrelevant. And then it becomes almost a practical question. Like, do you need the state institution just for it not to collapse?
SPEAKER_02Well, you kind of do. But don't bring freedom into me. So if your argument for freedom is to do your own will, it's not a good argument. That's effectively what would be said. And if your argument for freedom is to be master of yourself, but just be... Go to a monastery. Go somewhere. Go, I don't know. These opportunities are always open to you. So just, I think, that would be the most brief way of answering.
SPEAKER_01So good. Hey, everybody. It's December. We're doing our end-of-year giving. We're trying to create match. There's always a donor that will match our work at the end of the year. www.first-things.org Donate. Go and become a monthly donor. And then, if you really want to be crazy, consider coming and working with us. two years put people over plans and be your own boss in a unique world doing
SPEAKER_01incredible things most of them born out of the notion of facilitation making things easier for others a true beautiful godly endeavor first things thanks for listening let's get back And so you take a stare because it's really clear now. Those two worldviews, they're colliding on some level right now in Ukraine.
SPEAKER_02They are, and I will even say, just to be clear, they are not, these worldviews you need to understand, they are not There is no borders between them, just to be clear. There is a lot of this desire to just wheel inside a Russian culture. You can say that there is always this temptation element for it. That all comes, just to be clear. Otherwise, I think I would represent Russians as too saintly, which they're definitely not. But if you want to talk about philosophy, and you can see it in Russian literature again. Russian literature is Russian philosophy, or the lives of Russian saints and Russian heroes.
SPEAKER_02That would be the better way of understanding it. So there is always this internal tension between two. But at least I would say there is understanding and appreciation of this tension. Whereas in the Western story, you don't really see this tension and appreciation. it's kind of almost the second part of like this mastering over yourself is like
SPEAKER_01almost like completely right so this mastering of yourself let's just I'll say it that is a very eastern again vocabulary that's an eastern way of expressing Christianity we don't do that in the west basically when we feel constrained within a church environment we just create a new church yes We just express a new will, but we call it Christianity. And I do really think something has to be addressed,
SPEAKER_01which is in America, I think of it as like cauliflower. It's like a cauliflower. It doesn't seem to have a starting spot. It doesn't seem if it could keep going, it would hold no shape and create no borders. And the church in the East has always been the place in which you go to submit so that you can heal. It's the thing you described. It's the inside freedom, right? And do you think that means America and Russia...
SPEAKER_01how do they make peace? Because I actually think this also applies not just to America and to Russia. I think there's just societies around the world. I think of Ethiopia or I think of Mexico. where they're also in the same conversation. It's also sort of these two ways of thinking plus culture, you know? I don't know. There's a lot there. Clean it up for them.
SPEAKER_02I won't be able to clean up everything, that's for sure.
SPEAKER_01No one's ever done that for me. My wife comes really close. It was so bad.
SPEAKER_02Aw. Okay, but concerning America and Russia, I think there is several interesting layers which are rarely talked about. First things first, you need to understand that both America and Russia together are in one respect way more closer to each other than to any other nation on the planet. That's a very interesting part.
SPEAKER_02Because both of these countries, civilizations, if you want to put it this way, are idea-centric cultures. What I mean by it. Sorry. Words. Philosophy. Idea of America appeared before America. And you can say that idea of Russia appeared before Russia. Anybody can become an American. Anybody can become Russian. And in that respect, they are unique.
SPEAKER_02Quite unique. I can tell you. I lived in Hungary for four years. You can't really become Hungarian. You can't. Or you can't even become truly German. You can't truly become... You can talk about all of this multiculturalism on the surface, but... Deep inside, no. It's by blood, by families. It's a very narrow, almost clan-based community. I think because of its space and because of these ironically philosophical elements, both Russia and both America are idea-centric civilizations.
SPEAKER_02And in that sense, they're way closer to each other. That's one important element of it. And that's why it's actually, I think, both uniquely interesting to each other. Like Russians are sincerely fascinated with Americans. Americans are pretty much fascinated with Russians. So there is much more unity here than it would emerge. But that's on a civilizational cultural level. On a state level, here comes another problem. And here comes another problem with Americans.
SPEAKER_02Less a little bit now with the Russians. I will explain why. America is a very unique country because it's the most externally involved country nowadays, which understands the least about the external world. I discovered Americans sincerely don't get what they are doing when they leave America. Sincerely. And you can see how it creates quite a lot of tension.
SPEAKER_02Like, we're just bringing American way. We're just bringing them... Come on, man, what's the problem? It's a mall. It's a mall. We can shop together. Coming back to the business problem. Americans are great in doing business. But politics, culture, philosophy, history, they are not business. And here comes a lot of, like, contradiction. Because... Whether you want it or not, Americans are doing a lot of these things outside, but they're almost doing it irresponsibly.
SPEAKER_02And here comes this weird trick. So there is some, I think, maturing is going to happen in the coming century, in my opinion. like for America, because it's learning through trial and error. It's still a relatively new historical project, so there'll be a lot of trial and error. And ultimately, the problem is that America found itself in a position of being a global empire, not being philosophically... Yes, I know it sounds very radical, but just to be clear,
SPEAKER_02American is not philosophically prepared to be a global empire and to carry this responsibility, let me put it this way. The world can say, even given America a chance in the 90s, it kind of didn't work nearly as well as it thought it would. But let's say America is continental superpower or continental great power. Russia has no turf with America as a continental superpower. If you're just staying to your hemisphere or you're just being around...
SPEAKER_02Other parts of this hemisphere might start having problems. But if you want to sincerely... That's actually a huge imperative for... a little bit connecting to war and like there are so many layers in war which we can touch some but honestly from a perspective of Russian power like that's what they kind of mean like stop messing into our business and yes you can say it's not your business it's the business of different countries and we can talk about it later why it It's not that simple in that region, like why there is a history involved. In general, why modern understanding of statehood is not exactly honest with itself.
SPEAKER_01Can we do that right now for a second? Okay. Well, hold on. Tell me this. Because you've had all these great interviews in Russia. And the Slavic world knows you. I want all you guys to check out what Pablo does. So just do a report from the edge for us. Because so many of us Americans, we send all this information around on our feeds. And we read this, we read that. But you're actually speaking to people in their own language.
SPEAKER_01How many Russians are just like, we should probably stop bombing now. This is enough. Is it most of the people you talk to or are most saying it's not time? It's not time.
SPEAKER_02You are not asking the right question right now. That's just to be clear. Because one thing you do need to understand about Russian, like in this war, it's not like they're happy with it. That's one important element. It's not like they're happy with it. So what I mean, it was not the right question. I would say it was an emotional question.
SPEAKER_01Yes.
SPEAKER_02And the war is not an emotional matter. The war is an ethical matter and the war is a rational matter. That's a very interesting part. War is not itself really an emotional matter. It's becoming now an emotional matter. And there is honestly a really whole long conversation why war is becoming an emotional matter and how it relates to other patterns of the puzzle we've been talking about. But let's put it this way. So Russians have definitely never been happy with this whole situation.
SPEAKER_02But here comes the trick. Your question also almost presupposes that war is not a natural part of international relations. And it's just historically false fact. all history is written by wars, through wars, with wars, and wars never stopped. Here comes a little bit of our Western arrogance. Just because, and even in Europe we can say, because there is a whole war in Yugoslavia,
SPEAKER_02just to be clear. But wars never stopped. But if you notice the first reaction of us humans, And even my personal, I can tell you. Like, when I, for two months, was kind of within this gaze, it's like, it has never happened. Like, we've been honestly reacting as if it's the first time in our lifetime and it's the first time in our history. And that tells actually way more about us. Like, the right question would be why this is happening. Like... And I think one of the whys is like, it's for us to check our understanding,
SPEAKER_02for all of us, of the way we perceive the reality, like of international relations, of the way the world is. Because it's very arrogant to have this feeling which underpins more than men, that the history starts with me. If war has never happened in my lifetime, then wars should never happen. well sorry simply not true and if you look in the history of the region like basically what i'm saying and that's what here a lot of orthodox actually and russian particular philosophy is studying the tragic historical meaning of war
SPEAKER_02where it's understood almost as a matter of calamity and almost as a matter of let's say God's not punishment, but also correctional way. Let me put it this way. So that would be more clear to understanding to why this is because we tend to understand what there is. Basically, the general Western understanding is everything was fine. There was one bad guy. It started it. Let's move the bad guy out.
SPEAKER_02It will all be great. Well, it's not the way.
SPEAKER_01It's the understanding.
SPEAKER_02It's not correct, but it's the understanding. Yes. And it's not simply. Like, there were many reasons. All important is, like, why we let it happen? Like, why it has happened? What causes led to this? So, and the short answer is, until you remove the causes... Any talk about peace is effectively a form of either cowardness or manipulation. And that's, I think, which painfully Russians are now remembering almost.
SPEAKER_02In the 90s, we also took this kind of Western framework that the end of history of Fukuyama is here, everything will be great and dandy. not the case there are many reasons why it is happening and there are many purposes to which it's happening there is a providential element in the war like that's
SPEAKER_01another philosophical element do you do you think then part of the reason for the war is because this let's just call it um a lack of introspection when it comes to American understanding of the world. Is that way of seeing the world being challenged in a way that's reshaping the world? In other words, that's the end of our time doing this type of leadership,
SPEAKER_01and that's what we need to learn from this?
SPEAKER_02Well, in one way, yes. I would say it's the smallest part of it, but in one way, yes. And that's why, for example, you can see this weird support from countries like India, China, Arab countries to this whole process. Because that was the whole talk about multipolarities, which I think philosophically is unsustainable, but the desire for which is definitely coming. So it's effectively the desire. For America to stop being a superpower and become one of many.
SPEAKER_02One of many great powers, but not the only superpower. And that was one of the big tensions. And that's effectively what Russia challenged. Again, maybe it was the wrong reason, but that's what ended up challenging. This challenge definitely happened. And coming back to how it can stop. So war is not stopping until it reaches its teos. That's another important purpose. But the real purpose, I think,
SPEAKER_02and it's my philosophical assumption, and I think people slowly, actually people understand it way better than elite in Russia, for example, and I talk quite many, that the true purpose of war is to reveal yourself let's say, to reveal you in your weaknesses and to reveal you in the way you are, but also in the way you should. It's kind of pointing your way to where you should be. You can see the symbolic world card. You can see war as a flood, as a symbolic flood.
SPEAKER_02It comes, it washes away all of the dead things that you've been carrying, and you wanted to carry or it's making you to choose that thing so the leading thing even if you don't want to let that thing go so you're kind of causing it upon yourself through your all personal faults on an individual level but also on a collective cultural level that's another thing so there is a Russian one of the Russian philosophers of the 20th century Karsavian he has this I think very
SPEAKER_02beautiful way of understanding collective as a symphonic person. So there is one person and there is collective symphony of people, like symphonic personality. So this symphonic personality can also carry the same sins, the same mistakes as, let's say, an individual person can. An ultimate sin right now, which we have, and that's we come back to the circle... Almost all assumptions of our understanding of international relations for the last
SPEAKER_0270 years are based on lies. So the purpose of the war is to make us face these lies. And it's not just about America. It's about the way we understand where, let's say, the states are coming from. It's the assumption that anybody can have a state. Not self-intuitive. It's an assumption of the nature of international law. It's not self-clear at all. It's an assumption about war. Let's say we want to talk about peace, but you can't talk about peace in international relations. It's very easy to understand because the only condition for peace in international
SPEAKER_02relations to be is actually for time to talk. It is a philosophical problem. And there was a philosopher, and I have an article on symbolic world on it, Thomas Goebs with his Leviathan project so the only way to stop international wars you need to be just very clear is to put the whole world under one universal tyrant that's literally the only way to stop it mentally like logically so not mentally logically like it's literally the only way because unless it happens changes happen
SPEAKER_02People don't understand that, for example, our assumption in international relations is that borders are something stable. But historically, borders move constantly. In a way, there are no borders in history. It's a kind of illusion we take because they can be for a certain period of time, but all borders are frontiers. So they're also always moving. And why are they moving? That's one of the questions I've been asking myself all over the CS, and I think I came to... plausible enough answer and i think all this movement is happening precisely so
SPEAKER_02your words meet your deeds so to an extent culture civilization let's say subject can put the money where your word is so let's say you let's say you're a great power you claim to be a great power well you need to be a great power and not just say that you're a great power and And historically, what this function of war as a flight is to make you show, is it just to say or do you actually are?
SPEAKER_02And in that respect to America, are you actually a global superpower or you just say that you're a superpower? Something along this line. But if this happens, you understand that there will be constant movement. There always will be a movement. Something will always change. Some things will stay, but some things will always change. And change has a violent nature in it. There is always a matter of pain. There is always a matter of struggle. And there is always a matter of impersonality.
SPEAKER_02As you see, it's way more complicated than one bad guy just ruining the global peace.
SPEAKER_01Right, because the global peace is what you said. It implies the Leviathan. And so global peace, I feel like you might be saying global peace is a fool's gold. It's not possible.
SPEAKER_02It's a dangerous fool's gold. I think there is, as an orthodox, like, you know this, but maybe your audience, not all, knows it. But you keep to forget what will be the message of Antichrist.
SPEAKER_01What will it bring to people? Peace. Peace. It will replace Christ with a false peace.
SPEAKER_02So all I'm saying is that you need to be pretty careful with the word peace. Yes, there is a peace of Christ, but there is also a peace of Antichrist.
SPEAKER_01Because that's inside peace versus the outside peace.
SPEAKER_02it's one way and another way it's a peace without proper character like now it's a nativity fast and you remember that on nativity feast actually there is a pretty clear formula which is given to us like the way angels chant glory to the god in the highest and peace of earth well you can see it as a conditional if there is no glory to god in the highest universally how can you have peace If you don't... The antithesis to war is not peace, it's liturgy.
SPEAKER_02So if you don't have a liturgy, how can you have... Then your even desire for peace is a way of your arrogance. Like, I want to keep my sins, but I just want to have peace. And history always, millennia after millennia makes you face that it doesn't work. No, you need to reap what you sow and you need to not just pretend to be something but actually be something. And it works on an individual level, on a collective level, and also on an elite level.
SPEAKER_02You need to understand that historically there is a reason the war was the main reason for elite selection. It's just the only way for them to make responsible for anything. If your elite people don't fight, they can afford the most ridiculous things because they don't bear two responsibilities.
SPEAKER_01And I'm hearing you speak and I think of the two-headed eagle, the business sign, the Russian sign. This is the role of the patriarch, which is... One.
SPEAKER_02In a proper fashioned way, yes.
SPEAKER_01It's to remind the outer expression of the state that they have a responsibility to the inner confession of the church. And so how's that going in Russia in your mind?
SPEAKER_02Now it is complicated. And here comes a very unique, almost, I would say, Russian story, which is also predicated on another philosophical gap, which Russia borrowed from the West. You can make at it. So, on the surface, everything is all right. I would put it this way. Like the church is, like, people are coming slowly, like it's coming after the Soviet Union,
SPEAKER_02but people, there is a growth in practitioners slowly, like, and the church, like, slowly is getting, like, monasteries are opened, restored, churches are restored. Patriarch is speaking on church matters. But still, there is a separation of church and state. And as an American, you might think it's a good thing. But truth be told, it's not such a good thing. That's an interesting part, philosophically. Yes, there is a certain analytical separation. You can obviously understand it in your mind.
SPEAKER_02But think about it this way. What is a people? What unites people? Culture. Let's go through linguistic matters. It is culture. And what is culture? It's a cult. So it is a religion. You can say that effectively people is a church. So if you say that your state is separate from your church, effectively you are saying that your state is separate from your people.
SPEAKER_02And it's dangerous in both ways. For both state and both for people.
SPEAKER_01Very interesting. Because it can destroy... People think that this... You take this. I'm stepping on it. But that is the best thought. Go for this.
SPEAKER_02Thank you. The way it destroys us, there are two ways it is destroyed. First, if state is without its people, it's called colonial administration. just pretty straightforward. If I don't feel that people are who I'm governing over, I'm just a president. I just preside. But it's not mine. There is this level of separation and I can't, even if I want, I can't truly care about it because there is this thing which disunites us.
SPEAKER_02But for people without it, there is a similar problem. Like, there is always this animosity. There is always potential, the skid and sword, it will betray us or it will betray me. Basically, there is a huge tax on doing any common good thing. I would put it this way. Because to do common good, you need to trust. And when there is a split, there is a trust. There can be only one worse, basically, thing than this separation. It's when you... So it's not that bad yet in Russia, thanks God. When you have people without a church.
SPEAKER_02Because do you know how people without a church is called? Population. It's just a population. It's just units. It's just numbers. We can rearrange them, we can reassemble them, we can move them somewhere there, we can move them somewhere here. And that, you can see now, is a little bit of a new modern dilemma, which is this whole decentification of power, which was supposed to be to protect. In its turn, it led first to the split and lowering the opportunities to do common good. And this is our project of modernity.
SPEAKER_02This is what is happening right now. This is, as you call it, the end time. This is what's ending. Because this is what modernity started with. Modernity started with very simple... premise that those who basically who rules to whom belongs the face, effectively. But that's a lie. This is an inversion. In fact, it's like that's whose face is in a place, then who rules. Idea comes first. But we live in a separation. But for this separation, for this simulacrum to function, you need to continuously destroy churches.
SPEAKER_02Or you need to continuously destroy people. You need to create this split. Here comes another political, modern, philosophical lie, which again, why war will continue. Maybe not this one, maybe particular. I call it the second 30-year war. 30 years. Second 30-year war. Why? Because the modernity started the 30-year war in 17th century, and I think it's going to end now with another 30-year war. I do not have a hypothesis that we are reliving the 17th century, but
SPEAKER_02to heal the mistakes and for different nations it's different mistakes there is one big common mistake but also for different nations what's the big common mistake separation of spirit separation of spirit from mind and body I was just going to
SPEAKER_01say that for me you're describing the atheism the atheist mistake
SPEAKER_02but it started way before atheism appeared but you need to understand very well why it appeared because the reason they did it is related to war because there is an element remind me to come back to your original question I remember it but just like I think it's a perfect moment to answer it now you know that in the revelation that Christ has a a sword coming out of his mouth. Flaming sword. The word and the sword are kind of similar things.
SPEAKER_02There is an inherent fight in truth and falsehood. Basically, if a person sincerely believes in something, like here comes the problem of unity multiplicity, it becomes dangerous. Thirty years' war was the most devastating war for European history. Like, truly the most horrendous war. Like, in terms of absolute numbers, not as much as Second World War, but in terms of proportions, way worse. And why it has happened? Because different people, different denominations, pursued kingdom on Earth's
SPEAKER_02like you need to understand it so they all believed sincerely in the fact that they are bringing heavens to earth through the means of external and through this they created the most horrible experience they could imagine and then some thinkers like again Hobbes the most important basically came guys guys guys guys we're gonna just kill all of us let's just put this aside originally they didn't even want to completely cut it down but let's just put it aside We can't agree on it.
SPEAKER_02We agree that Pope can do this thing. But there is no consensus. And truth be told, Hobbes definitely didn't know Eastern mysticism at all. So it was just Protestants versus Catholics. So we know Pope is wrong. But if each one of us will pursue this, let's say, the way we do, we need to separate these things. Otherwise, it will completely engulf us. And that's why we need a state, a life, and a sovereign to rule over us. Like, you're talking to Andrew. It's effectively the story. It's the story behind the story he's trying to present to you. Soft state, which I want to talk about next.
SPEAKER_02Yes. But the problem is it doesn't work. That's the saddest part of it. You can't separate the things. So you need to be willing to step into this danger zone. You need to be willing to step into the danger zone where spirit is not separated from mind.
SPEAKER_01One second. So I know this is a history guide, but explain this real clearly to our audience. So the mistake was... Ending the war and really creating a new society in many ways by setting aside those difficult inside questions of peace and simply creating a secularity, right? A seculum where those questions were no longer entertained. And is that the split?
SPEAKER_02It is a split. It's separated. It's like... It's irrelevant. And then you can see why we don't need kings because kings are coming through God. So we need to create something different. We need to create an illusion that the power comes from the people. Sorry, yes, I know. Big illusion of modernity. Power doesn't come from the people. I'm sorry. We can talk about it in a very different way. level, but never in a history majority wanted everything. Just one clear example for you. Absolute majority of American colonists in 1975 didn't want to separate from Britain.
SPEAKER_02It was not a majority decision. If you would collect like a poll, they would be like, what? It was a group of radicals who effectively decided to separate themselves from So just to be clear, it's not about people. And it's another American story. And then basically, after this separation, you had 400 years of trying different lives and building different lives. Like in America, late in 20th century, there was this guy called Edward Bernays, the creator of modern...
SPEAKER_02It's not just marketing. I love it because he's so blatantly honest. His book is called On Propaganda, and effectively the very first paragraph sounds something like this. There is an unseen mechanism of hidden power in our country which rules everything, and that's what we call democracy. Literally first paragraph, just to be clear. So he was very honest about what he is doing. So you had to basically build different machines of illusion to avoid answering
SPEAKER_02this original Inception question. And my hypothesis, here is a hypothesis, is that current age of war is for us to face this original... illusion this original mistake that you can't truly separate spiritual from bodily and rational there must be unity between them on an individual level on a state level on a society level on a church level all these things are connected together But you can see that's, let's say, a positive way of doing it.
SPEAKER_02Another way, which we humans historically would be doing greatly and most likely, to double down. Okay, our illusion was not good enough because it was not global enough. It wasn't, like, perfect enough. Let's make a perfect illusion.
SPEAKER_01Bad guys. In the way, yeah.
SPEAKER_02Bad guys. But here comes the thing. The problem is that bad guys are human. It's about because they are too aligned to their states. It's because they are aligned to their language. It's because they are aligned to their families. We need to create this perfect, atomized individual, and there will be nothing between him and the sovereign power.
SPEAKER_01So, Andrew Faberow is a friend of ours. He's actually had... He was in the news pretty profoundly, and I'm going to have him on the podcast. He was... involved in bribes that were going both ways and had his moment of fame there with Giuliani and involved with the guests. We'll get into it. I know the story, but not, you know, the story too. Was on the hook for a lot of problems at the time of Trump's first election.
SPEAKER_01Is that correct? I had that right.
SPEAKER_02You do have that right, but of course you definitely now make him challenging to present himself.
SPEAKER_01Wow, he'll present himself. He'll come and tell us the story. But he's deeply involved in a production called Sovereign State. I'm reading the script right now. We're going to have a talk. It's really about Ukraine on some level, right? What's the Ukrainian role in all of this as you see it?
SPEAKER_02in the world if you ask me now I think ironically Ukraine is a catalyst Ukraine is a catalyst for everything we've been talking about it is an H the name of the place literally means edge edge like literally like if you translate it from Slavonic into let's say English it would be edge so the purpose of Ukraine I think is to make everyone face their lies I'm not sure Ukraine will survive this.
SPEAKER_02I will be straightforward because there is a lot of lies in Ukraine and you can talk way more with Andrew about it. So maybe it won't be able to face its own lies. But ironically, providentially, if you want to put it this way, for example, it's making Russia face its own lies. It's making Russia... For example, Russia was so proud of its military being the first world, first-rate military in the world. Well, war shown, it was not. It's getting there now, providentially. And so many assumptions and foundations which were self-evident and were considered
SPEAKER_02to be just here, even part of what we talked before with you, they are now being faced. The same you can say to an extent about Europe, the same you can say to an extent about the general global understanding of things. So I do think the historical purpose of this, let's say, Ukraine role in the story is exactly to make everybody look into a mirror, into your own mirror.
SPEAKER_02So...
SPEAKER_01What does your soul tell you about the death, though? I mean, I like the way you're describing an understanding war in history. It resonates with my understanding. That doesn't mean it's good, but I get it. I'm not saying it's true. It's a revelation, right? It's constantly... But here we... People are dying. Mothers losing sons. How does a Christian sort that out? And how does a Ukrainian Christian and a Russian Christian sort that out?
SPEAKER_01Okay, two questions.
SPEAKER_02Basically, you ask two questions, I will try to provide answer to both. That's why you're on the show, to help me. To the first, we have a scripture, which is actually pretty blunt. You mentioned death, and you remember in Peter, the wages of sin is death. individual, we accept this tragedy. We don't welcome it, but we don't hide from it hypocritically, as we discussed before.
SPEAKER_02Basically, if you've been building life for 400 years, then the death will come for you, one way or another. And the second thing is what you do, and here comes another tricky part of our age. It makes us think we can affect so many things we can't affect at all basically it creates the straps for our attention and it allows us not to care about what you can actually do in your power right here and right now to your question if there is a ukrainian
SPEAKER_02refugee near you that's where you can help or like russian refugee or say one way or another but If there is something, do what you can do. Like, that's the thing. And kind of almost don't challenge, like, don't raise this fist of, like, why is this, like, happening in this, like, you know, arrogant way. Like, do what you can do. And that's what many people do. I know. Do your duty. That's another thing related to this.
SPEAKER_02Do your duty. Remember, it's related to this when soldiers came to John the Baptist. What should we do? Do your job and don't complain effectively. Like, I'm sorry, I'm butchering the answer, but it was effective.
SPEAKER_01A priest here, Father Thomas Tapico, used to say, how do you fix the war in Ethiopia? Pick a spot. He'd say, take flowers to your neighbor.
SPEAKER_02It is, but it is true. Because I think if we help to understand that, because it's much more complex than just bad guys versus good guys. I wish it were that easy. It's not that easy. It's never that easy. Like, in that sense, a little bit like World War II, like, you know, let us believe this, you know, comic book picture because, okay, yes, there was one really bad guy. But historically, it's such an exception when you actually have kind of just one super, let's say, evil side of sync. Historically, it's very rare the case.
SPEAKER_02Usually, both parties have pretty decent arguments. Like I mentioned, there is a logical element involved in the sense that I have my argument, you have my argument, and just who is more just on who started it first ultimately depends from which time you count. Here is the thing. If you count from February 2022, okay, Russia started. If you count from 1999, different people started. If you count from 2004, different started. And that's why from a truly philosophical or religious perspective, it's almost pointless to discuss it in this matter.
SPEAKER_02That's why we were trying to look into this, what is actually what I'm trying to do. It's a tradition of religious philosophy and political theology. So it's trying to show this spiritual and religious phenomenon behind what we consider to be separate from it. As you've noticed, nothing is separate. Everything is connected. Modern academia doesn't allow itself to do it. And here I think is one of the big problem why this is most important in the same way. It's quite simple matters.
SPEAKER_02I just completely missed because our attention is caught on different things. Or even thoughts is caught on different things. We just don't think on this framework. That's why nothing makes sense. And trying to make sense out of it is a pretty challenging task.
SPEAKER_01I just think you've helped us. Your approach as a philosopher, you were reminding me of Vorlatskin, who wrote Loras, and I had him on the podcast. People can go back. It was tough because his English was tough, but your English is very nice, by the way. um but he kept doing what you just did which when talking about the difficulties of russia and ukraine he would always approach it in this big cavernous way like out
SPEAKER_01from from beneath it from from deep in a barrel it wasn't pointed it was always um cavernous and And it always had to do with human nature. And it always reminded me of the great Russian artists who, they don't really take things head on. The American idea, I was once working out and I was like barbells. 10, 20, 30, 40. I was in a little gym somewhere. And this man came in, very lithe, Asian, East Asian.
SPEAKER_01And he started to just do very slow movements. And he was doing some form of Tai Chi or something. And then he just looked at me and said, you Americans always have this way about you. And he's real sweet. He wasn't accusatory. He said, you know, sometimes it's better to actually do less. And when I listen to Russians try to describe how things maybe need to be understood, it usually starts with this big idea.
SPEAKER_01And I find it beautiful. And it's one reason I became Orthodox.
SPEAKER_02Well, I would say it's through the grace of orthodoxy. It definitely helps. Not helps, but it's what has framed. People don't understand often, but you would agree that, for example, all of the classical Tolstoyevsky, effectively, Russian literature, which people read even globally, but it's effectively always a commentary to gospel. all Russian good, all good Russian literature is talking about gospel one way or another.
SPEAKER_02Like it's always, it's the only interesting part truth be told. Everything else is kind of not. And one final, just one final thing about all, since you mentioned how, but in a more simple, practical dumbbell way of doing it kind of the same on a personal level. Uh, Whenever anything happens, both on a country level or in a state level or interstate level, you need to ask the right question.
SPEAKER_02And interestingly, there is one right question in that respect. It's not like, why is this thing happening? Like, you can, but it's not exactly, it won't help you much. But it will keep you trapped. Better way, let's say, why flood came? Why flood has came? What's the purpose of the flood coming from God's perspective? Why God has let it... Not why, but what for this has happened?
SPEAKER_02And then you see how everything shifts with this just one question. It actually opens the possibilities.
SPEAKER_01Can I end there with a toast to you? Sure. The difference. Why did this happen? Technically, how is probably more how the West would ask. And in other places, they ask, what's the purpose of this? And it implies that we might not have to fix it. It implies you might just have to learn from it. So I want to toast to you because I want to do this on all our podcasts now, but to your time for coming on and also for this bridge kind of person that you are.
SPEAKER_01It's very fascinating. I think I'm one of those people, and I meet a lot of people who seem to be able to walk across the bridge. It makes me rather useless to be able to understand both sides in the sense that I don't really get anything done on either side of these cultural divides. But I want to say there's something good about being able to understand both sides to your work. The bridges. The bridges. The bridges.
SPEAKER_00All right, guys, that's Pavel Schellen. Fantastic.
SPEAKER_01He and Andrew were really interesting guests down at the Art of Tamada. Both of them were great at the Tamada. We just had moments of deep laughter and intense, I would say, learning. Thanks for listening. Sorry for my voice. Christianities continues. We're doing some cool shooting coming up. So keep a lookout for us and much love and peace.
Find this episode on YouTube: "Justine Alter" - a pseudonym - returns to chat with John Heers in a raw Heavy Things Lightly conversation you have to hear to believe.Justine worked for years as a professional psychic,...
Find this episode on YouTube: Holly Hickman went from Columbia Journalism and Fox News Radio covering NASA and the 2008 election - to milking cows, making cheese, and converting to Orthodoxy.In this episode of Heavy...
Can you teach kids the truth AND prepare them for a secular world?On this episode of Heavy Things Lightly, host John Heers talks with James and Juliana Joyce, founders of St. George's Classical Academy in Boxford,...
Find this episode on YouTube: Crow walked America searching for his father - and found the Father.From West Virginia hollers to LA gangs, from wolves in the Mojave desert to an Orthodox cross, this is an Odyssean tale...
Welcome to the first episode of โSave Me a Spot at the Supraโ on Heavy Things Lightly where John Heers hosts singer and Broadway performer Carrie Manolakos (best known for her performances in Mama Mia! and Wicked) at...