Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Heavy Things Lightly

Heavy Things Lightly artwork

Jordan Hall

Mar 1, 202457 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Find this episode on YouTube: Jordan Hall was for a long time an early tech pioneer, perhaps best known for founding DivX (if you've downloaded or watched any video on the internet you can thank him). However his interests turned towards philosophy and what the future holds for humanity. He founded the Civium Project and Plan B to explore how humanity might become less rivalrous and more win-win. Jordan Hall on Medium: https://medium.com/@UCMzT-mdCqoyEv_-YZVtE7MQ On YouTube: @JordanGreenhall Visit us at https://first-things.org/ 2 years. Deep cultural immersion. Intense personal discovery. See what it means to become a Field Worker with FTF: https://first-things.org/opportunities or email Daniel at danielpadrnos@first-things.org for more information. Like the podcast? Join us for more on Substack: https://johnheersftf.substack.com/ Telegram: https://t.me/firstthingsfoundation Keipi Restaurant, SC is where you can find us👉 https://keipirestaurant.org Please leave a review with your comments! Your support keeps this podcast alive and allows us to broaden our discussion. --- This “Enlightened” New World utopia isn’t turning out to be all it was cracked up to be. Society is disenchanting, but are the only alternatives hiding out in the hills or burying yourself in books? With an air of levity and a touch of humor, John Heers teaches how to examine the confusing New World by calling upon the mind and wisdom of oft-forgotten Old. Heavy Things, Lightly. --- Credits Music: Intro / Outro Provided by Greg Gilbertson & Band This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit johnheersftf.substack.com/subscribe

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_01guys today heavy things lightly Jordan Hall philosopher business tech guru and a guy who is deep in the meaning crisis and what a beautiful conversation we had Jordan Hall big time intellect and now new friend and you'll love this talk also I gotta give a shout out to glassy baby they help first things and continue to we're going to do a KP out there with them in Seattle in March and go check out their stuff magnificent stuff at Glassy Baby Candles all kinds of glassware you got to check it out I love that but this is Heavy Things Lightly

SPEAKER_02our new and wonderfully branded new situation. Greg Gilbertson, play the music.

SPEAKER_01Hi, Jordan. So you're in it these days, at least in our little corner of the world where we're trying to do meaning and figure out Life so here's my first question to you who's uh the term is this proper to call you um how about this a philosopher of technology something like that do you like that I've certainly done some of that I would say that I've delved into that meaningfully I tend to I tend to not I don't for whatever reason my life has not been easy to fit in any given box that's the box I've been in

SPEAKER_01yeah and that's the thing that informed me and when you said you could come on I got excited so here's a first question and a toast I don't know if you have a drink sitting there but coffee is that okay coffee works perfectly because one thing we do is throw these Georgian dinners and we I'm realizing that it's like a natural way of life so I want to do a toast to get things started and how about two um The Risky Endeavors of the Mind to things when we go down these rabbit holes where our mind is at work may it always be accompanied with something like love and beauty so to the risky endeavors of the mind Gagimarjos and that means to you the victory from the Georgian Republic Gagimarjos Gagimarjos

SPEAKER_01alright so here's the first question something's happening probably in your own life we'll talk about that my life our lives but there's also something happening in culture so take a shot what is in some of the other interviews you say something's out there something's coming and what is it how would you go about calling this something that's the end of the world it is isn't it on some level

SPEAKER_00I was on a conversation with my friend with John John Verveke and Greg Heinriches and I said look I I can't help it but I'm a practical eschatologist you know from from the point of view of say strictly material causes or a a model of how cultures and civilizations operate I say I can say and I do say with some degree of confidence obviously not certainty but some degree of confidence that we're at the end of something very big like a significant end of something um and how big well at least 100 years big I would say almost certainly more than 500 years big in fact my primary sensibility is that's on the order of 10 to 30 000 years big

SPEAKER_00and may in fact be on the order of a million years big something really really big is ending which by the way also means that something really really big is beginning unless those are not maybe not actually in the Christian eschatology the end is also the beginning of something and so that's happening and we can talk about all that if we want to go into it but that I think is the precursor that's happening and then we humans are perceiving that in the ways that we perceive things oftentimes very much in the background like we're not quite clear what is going on

SPEAKER_00um but you know we have this this metaphor of animals you know running into the hills when an earthquake is going to happen they can sense an earthquake in a way that's not cognitive but it's sensed and then they have an instinctual response we've hijacked our instinctual responses we don't know how to respond and we don't have narratives in in secular culture that encompass this magnitude of change and so you know many years ago about 10 or 15 years ago I talked about it as something that we will have to perceive through the mythopoetic register but of course now I'm realizing that we actually have to perceive it through well Christianity specifically and if we'd like and kind of say religion as a kind of a broad category and that lens allows you to talk about the end of the world that it's a proper con you mean that in the Christian context at this point something like that

SPEAKER_00Well, I don't claim to know that this is the sort of the end of the end of the end, like the big one in the Revelation sense. But in sort of a Jonathan Pagiot sense, it will definitely partake of the symbolic characteristics of that at a level that is as profound as has ever happened in history. So it's a pretty high bar. If it's not the big one, it's the biggest we'll ever have seen.

SPEAKER_01yeah do you think this is so you're you're making me think of this thought do you think that the the enlightenment we do a lot of we create a false it's not false there's truth in it but in order to sort of teach I like to talk about old world new world and and I think there's real There's real utility in it. I understand it has problems, but what you just said makes me think that the Enlightenment, the idea of moving toward deism and eventually materialism and now a type of atheism, do you think it was a kind of a type of preparation for this new thing?

SPEAKER_01It was sort of like a... It was a moment when we had to have that in order to have this. Do you think that's happening on some level?

SPEAKER_00I do. Yeah, that's the conclusion that I draw. I mean, weirdly, I was about to say I wouldn't frame it teleologically, but actually I guess maybe I would nowadays.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, right, right, right.

SPEAKER_00I haven't explored that. There's just so much about my life where I haven't really brought everything into a single unified way of thinking nor do I necessarily need to I have a single unified way of living and that is what the core tone is and there's like stuff hanging out there like yeah I really haven't thought about you know how do I feel about teleology in relationship with things that are happening in chronological time that makes no difference in how I'm actually living so it's a big question are you familiar at all with the work that Craig Henriquez has done with the joint points no but go for it riff on it if you want he's put together what I think is a very nice model one of the things I really like about it is that he got there as a psychologist but was a practicing clinical and then an academic studying metapsychology like how do we deal with the branches the fact that psychology is made up of distinct disciplines that aren't connected in any meaningful way

SPEAKER_00it's like it's a grab bag it's the most grab bag of the of the sciences and in order to resolve that problem he ended up having to actually create a whole meta theory of history like big history all the way from the inception of the material world all the way up to to now and what he what he identifies is there's a series of epochal moments the epochal moment of physics the epochal moment of chemistry the apocalypse of biology the epochal moment we called minded animals behavior The Apocalypse Moment That We've Been Living As Humans Which Is Culture and then his theory which is has like it's not broad brush it has very particular reasons why things happen the way they happen indicates that we're at the end of the apocalypse of culture and the beginning of some new epoch which he just calls the fourth or fifth joint point I can't remember which number it is and I consistently forget which one it is um

SPEAKER_00So in that context, what we might say, and I apologize, by the way, if this is too heavy. If it is, just cut me off. No, no, no, no. It's great. It's quite great. If we've been in the epochal moment of culture, let's move back one level. So prior to the epoch of culture is the epoch of behavior. Animals Things That Have Neurology That Can Take Perception Input And Produce Outputs That Are Distinct Based Upon Some Characteristics Of What Behavior Is Affected So Prey Flees Hunter Pursues That Kind Of Stuff

SPEAKER_00which requires nervous systems to do. Nervous systems, the underlying requirement to get to the point where you can have behavior and then you have behavior. And then what happens is you unlock this exploration of all the different variations on behavior, all the different variations on perception, processing, and action. There's many. There's schooling fish, there's schooling birds. But there's also this thing called communication. Communication is a kind of behavior. And you just nod at your head, yes. I, being a hominid human, recognize the signification of that as something like hearing and agreeing in some fashion, at least within Western cultures.

SPEAKER_00so at the end or at the end but at the high point the high watermark of behaviors is very very complex narrow category of behavior that is built on top of the fact that humans have very subtle facial expressions in very high capacity to perceive these distinctions and can you relate sounds with extremely diverse tones and glottal stops and things like that which give rise to an affordance for particular particular kind of behaviors language communication then transitions us through this new category called culture there's other elements like memory and things like that and by the way fathers like there's a whole bunch of stuff that goes into that bucket but that bucket then pops us through this thing he calls a joint point into a whole new regime which wasn't possible in reality in chronological history before which is culture okay so then what happens is the same thing culture begins to explore the space of possibility of culture there's lots of different variations on how you can do culture

SPEAKER_00um there's cultures that have child sacrifices woven into the nature of those cultures there's cultures that do things like um um or pacifist cultures cultures that actually have a strict or there's cultures that have strict restrictions on having children like strictly non-procreative cultures they don't last very long but there are some um and just like in the previous iteration the high watermark of behavior puts us through to the edge of something that is in some sense the fulfillment of behavior which then gives rise to this new category of culture we're nearing the high watermark of culture of necessity of culture

SPEAKER_01and I want to go back because I have a I have a foundational question that I think undermines that analysis but in a good way like like like we should you know like question like a scientific kind of question but and does that end of that Epoch then is this where the civium is this where the new kind of digital culture I don't culture is the wrong word a new type of being starts to be be born or is it a total end of this this way of being for humans and something more like

SPEAKER_00like the end of the world as per revelation what is the end in terms of that analysis you just gave it well in this analysis we could just kind of use the comparison to the past like behavior doesn't go away when culture emerges behavior stays and then this new thing culture emerges um and there's particular like a solidification of a particular category of behavior you think about like the way the child A Human Child Develops. And they actually go through all the different stages.

SPEAKER_00And then when they come out as an infant, they recapitulate behavior in a very particular fashion, which builds the substrate of the ability to be recipients of culture somewhere around four or five to become capable of becoming cultural beings. And then they begin learning culture. And they move into the culture journey. so same thing here we will find in this story this way of thinking about things which I like it's not mine and I'm not sort of but it's comfortable to you but I think it's rich I think it's got a lot of good pieces to it when we get to this joint point we will get to something like a a stable and compact culture

SPEAKER_00that then provides a foundation for some other kind of new thing. And the problem is that when we talk about the some other kind of new thing, it's very difficult to talk about what's on the other side of that.

SPEAKER_01A new ontology, a new way of being. Yeah, a new way of being, yeah. now take that analysis I'll go back now I don't know this may be too heady or or I might just be confusing you know by the way it's nice to have you did I tell you that yet so check this out Christianity for me I'm my Orthodox Christianity over 27 years because I went through kind of what a lot of people are going through now I'd like jump to jump the gun a little bit

SPEAKER_01I'm thankful but or I was given that I was I didn't do it I was given it but what happened with me is is that analysis which is beautiful it has a degree of rational seamlessness it I think we could make sense of it what happened with me is is I realized through orthodoxy that all of those assumptions are based in something like the enlightenment value of reason and and so what happened with me is is I started to realize that that those assumptions were built into the very notion of evolution as if we can understand it in other words evolution as something that teaches for me now longer is true evolution doesn't teach I'm not even sure it's a real thing and I wonder as you become Christian and are becoming I like becoming for our guys out there maybe we'll we'll tell the conversion story but you

SPEAKER_01This powerful thinker became Christian recently in the last year or so. I wonder if this analysis won't be able to live anymore in your mind as per the adoption of your Christianity. I don't know, and I just wonder what you think about that.

SPEAKER_00No, no, I understand exactly. Well, that's not true. I have a sense of what you're talking about, and I have experienced certain things that have dissolved, let's say. and you say, can no longer live because the underlying presuppositions that they require, those presuppositions are now exposed as not being, well, presupposed in that way. That's right. Not true. Uh-oh. They just kind of go away, the footing underneath it. So as you say, there is an underlying presupposition of if we endeavor to make our understanding of reality subject to being reasonable,

SPEAKER_00subject to the way that reason grasps things then it looks like this and this is the most reasonable story that we can tell but that's not the whole story and so I don't know if you know but I've been quite influenced by the Orthodox not as much as you I don't know and by the way feel free to talk about it I think people listening would be interested in that many of the challenges that I had in moving through into Christianity as it turns out were actually just artifacts from

SPEAKER_00narrow versions of Christianity in kind of American 20th century 19th 20th century Protestantism right now but the understanding of sin in a particular way and when I sort of said well you know there's lots of Christians out there who have different perspectives on things who are committed like they're not pretending they're not just a play acting they're like really seriously committed over like thousands of years um let me delve into that like so I started looking at the Orthodox like oh yeah that's actually in some sense super obvious. Like as you sort of come into relationship with the orthodox sensibility on the notion of sin, you're like, oh yeah, it kind of feels like that describes reality.

SPEAKER_00That's not, uh-huh, okay, great. So I can kind of move past that issue. Now, of course, I now need to come into relationship with it as a thing, but it's no longer sort of a thing that I need to say, oh, what the hell's going on here? right um so so that's that's one thing and then Jonathan Pageau is an individual who I just really really enjoy the way he articulates and expresses things and so I I understand him it's like a way of like when he speaks in certain ways most of the time not all the time but most of the time I'm like all right you're saying something both beautiful and true and I understand it and that helps me move like maneuver my way into a deeper understanding was was real real

SPEAKER_00and then I've been reading Schmemann recently oh you have okay yeah what's his name I can't remember his name the book's called The Ethics of Beauty yeah he was on he came on our podcast oh beautiful so yeah I'm three quarters of the way through that book and um and I've jumped into some like here here you can't necessarily say they belong to anybody but I've also delved into the uh you know the Cappadocian fathers and some of the the early early guys uh which is also quite beautiful and so and then one offs into other you know John Chris Awesome Chris yep Chris Chris System Chris System um and Seraphim Rose and folks like that like I've kind of

SPEAKER_00you're in it you're in it you're definitely in it and because there's something profoundly correct and beautiful and the point is beautiful right so this notion of a beauty first like what does it mean to reorient in that direction that loosens the grip of reason right truth first and when you loosen that grip you notice that the beauty first opens up a deeper ground where the reason has a way of situating itself properly but no longer is endeavoring to it's funny like the image that I had of like if we endeavor to grasp reality by means of reason it has the feeling of like when you use your hand you squeeze a piece of clay and you like you deform the clay into the shape of your hand and you look at you oh look it looks like a hand imprint like that's because you squeeze the clay really hard it's not a clay very nice very nice um so so yes I think your proposition is and what's beautiful there for me is I say okay

SPEAKER_00This then becomes a... By the way, my mind has long been not attached to paradigms. I'm aware of how paradigms work. And so I'm not attached to the paradigm that Greg has put forward. I just appreciate it. But in this sense- That's beautiful.

SPEAKER_01That's a beautiful thing. I find that our Puritan past actually substitutes the paradigm for God on many levels. We become adherents of the paradigm instead of adherents of the beauty or the truth. To be able to put the paradigm aside, I really like that because even orthodoxy and especially orthodoxy can become an idol, an idolic paradigm itself that we're actually supposed to break through

SPEAKER_01and that the truest form of existence is in not being quote religious which I want that's a question I have for you later about what is religion because it's very sure it's changing all the time but so it's a beautiful thing and I don't like not to preach but I think one of our problems just in modern society is that the paradigm is the idol and the right, the left, the economy, how a conservative approach. It's fascinating to me that you are able to put that paradigm, not aside as if it's not true, but you can see it for what it is.

SPEAKER_01I think it's important for all of us.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, just popped into my mind is that we can say the notion of ideology is idol-ology. That's right. Our friend John Vervaeke very clearly said, look, what happened, one of the things that happened was that as we began to step away from religion for reasons, we began to reify them as ideologies. And then we began to set up other ideologies sitting next to them that Cut away some of the trappings of religion because there was a propaganda war going on. But it's still an idol ology is at the center of all of that.

SPEAKER_00Yes. And I think this is diagnostically correct. FYI, definitely. Do you agree with that?

SPEAKER_01Do you think what happened to me, whatever to you happened to Peugeot and then put put this weird corner of meaning aside? I think it's happening in culture do you think it's a return to religion in the West let's call them I call them on the show the light people the people of the Enlightenment that's me and you whether we like it or not we're of it does that thing go dark in the sense that we we can't hold those paradigms to they don't hold and then a new religion is born is that what's happening on some level interestingly enough

SPEAKER_00Probably not. And here's one of the reasons why I would suggest not. The civilization that we live in is really complicated way off the charts complicated and we may or may not have already sort of you know jumped a shark on that by the way because so much of that know-how lives in the minds of Boomers who are very quickly going to be falling asleep and they didn't hand it off to anybody younger so it means sort of already it may already be done but let's for the moment say it's not um there's a bunch of stuff that is in kind of

SPEAKER_00Enlightenment, part of the set of faculties and capacities that came out of that moment in history that are strictly necessary to run this civilization. And if we drop the ball on that, the number of people who will die and the number of people who will not go gently into that good night is so large that the end result is quite significantly bad. It may, in fact, be strictly catastrophic, which if that happens, then maybe we are in the big one for the book of Revelations.

SPEAKER_01so it so in that sense Jordan to drop the ball on a thing we may identify as let's say less than healthy for us like pure rationality to drop the ball would be unchristian on some level because oh yes it would be to not care for our brother by simply rejecting all aspects of the culture we were born into yeah out of a out of an ideological yeah assertion I won't do that it's dirty therefore I'm out and therefore everyone suffers that's interesting yeah I won't wash his feet his feet are dirty that's a Nicky thing I'm not going to do that yeah

SPEAKER_00So the challenge of stewardship is to say, okay, this thing is out of control. It's a little bit more like an ox cart that's out of control. Okay, the ox cart's out of control, but we can steward it back into being in control, and now it can functionally be an ox cart again. The problem is not that it's an ox cart. The problem is that it's out of control. and it's probably on a hill going too fast and in the wrong direction something like that and we're and we're drunk now let's just add just make sure that the guys who are in the ox car have also lost all reasonable strength that's right we hit the mead too much mead yes so

SPEAKER_00so yeah I mean the way I have told the story and oddly enough it continues to hold it may dissolve at any point but it continues to hold there's actually a bit of a bifurcation either we behave reprehensibly and we actually allow tremendous tragedy that we could otherwise prevent out of something like an ideology or an idol worship I would say by the way very much influenced by the adversary um

SPEAKER_00or we we find a way of stewarding this thing and grounding this entire arc of reason in the deeper area of faith we actually james polis who i've known for some time was just recently on jonathan pageau talking about this really funny phrase called bitcoin monasteries but that's basically what he's talking about is grounding technology The Thing That Humans Have Been Doing. It is kind of like the ox cart out of control, grounding it in the monastic sensibility, grounding it in sainthood and sanctification, which would ultimately then be to sanctify technology.

SPEAKER_00That doesn't mean the opposite.

SPEAKER_01This appeals to me. I think there's a type of would you agree with this and again this is like I guess psychology again I'm always using what I've been given because I'm a modern person and then I always go to the prayer corner and just try to sort it out maybe I shouldn't have used it you know maybe let the candle maybe silence sometimes is a better answer but let's just do psychology for a second I wonder if there's not a type of psyche where all the things you're recognizing a person recognizes like ox cart dirty drunk and then there's a type that wants to endeavor a relationship in the messiness and then there's another type

SPEAKER_01that sees the messiness as not worth the time and wants to stay clean outside of that space I am drawn toward the relationship and trying to fix it up within the filth I don't know if that makes sense I wonder if that's a type of person what I was noticing as you were describing it is I would almost like put it on a relational continuum so say I'm walking down the street and I see a homeless man who's drunk and filthy

SPEAKER_00maybe I just walk by maybe I'm the type that wants to stay clean and not get entangled in that but then I look closer and it's my dad now if I'm the kind of person who walks by my father who is homeless and filthy that's a pretty bad place to be holy smokes I've got some work to do Well, you're clean, but are you? You're clean. Yeah, you're clean, but boy, you are not clean, my friend.

SPEAKER_01Not clean, right.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, you got some spiritual, some spiritual filth to work through. That's bad. And I get it, by the way. I can imagine if, you know, if you were, your relationship, now everybody's got their very particular, but you get the metaphor. and maybe it's not your father maybe it's your uncle or maybe it's your neighbor right and maybe it's your neighbor's son in each case it's like a place where you're going to hit a threshold where the quality the intensity the characteristics the relationship hit you know wow okay this is something I gotta be responsible for this is something where I I I have an obligation to take care and then as you say there are types which go all the way out as you say they fly to Africa they go to a place that's very far away

SPEAKER_01and they say you know what I'm gonna take care here and of course a saint I would imagine would have that experience all the way down to the leaf falling off a tree well that's amazing that you say that because the saint at least in the Orthodox tradition again there's variations on it all throughout anyone who's believing a saint actually knows that the prayer the silent Prayer is actually stopping and taking care of the father or the whoever's on the side isn't that nutty that the prayer I had a friend of mine once I was teaching at school I really respected this woman very good teacher and we got in a huge fight I'll never forget it was in front of kids seniors in high school and she goes I don't understand why anybody goes to a monastery a total waste of time when you could actually lay hands on people and help them but you got these people up on a mountain praying

SPEAKER_01but I could not go convince her or the whole class that it was of any use to pray and what I realized in your in your phrase right there what was brought out of me was the idea that the assistance is actually in the prayer if there is such a thing right as that that medium called spirit as in other words it's real and if it's real that's actually assistance but

SPEAKER_00but I don't know if I always believe in myself we can loop that because it ends up happening this is a I'll put it out there is something like you enter into the prayer and then from the place of the prayer the spirit then guides you so the spirit might actually say yeah go out and pick the guy off the street and bring him to the monastery right right right okay right exactly right or the spirit might say yeah you've done you've done the thing that needs to be done this basic prayer is complete silence is the right place here and that I think is like that's the thing that we humans like this goes back to that initial grabbing with reason um oh man this is like this is the profound bottom dropping out

SPEAKER_00That's actually an impossible problem to solve from the point of view of reason. You can't do it. This is where the enlightenment runs into the shoals. This is why every effort to build institutions on the basis of reason to quote-unquote solve problems doesn't ultimately actually work in a deep sense. Entering into a space of fear, this has to be done for the place of the spirit. And then the spirit will guide you in that.

SPEAKER_01it's weird I think old world cultures intuit that and that we can argue about you know which God is the right God and that was it that's an old world problem too you know hitting each other in the head over gods we got rid of that but the problem was we we sterilized everything in a way like I like what you said that it's so sterilized that the proper germs can't even live that's so interesting so how do your old pals you know pre this meaning I'm like I'll call it a meaning crisis in you I mean if it's gotta be some sort of meaning crisis that leads somebody to Christianity in 2024 um how are your old pals who aren't necessarily Christians how are they doing what do they think of you

SPEAKER_00that was a good question well I mean nobody has sort of called me out and I haven't been burned to the stake nobody's thrown big rocks at me so so far so good I suppose I don't in some sense obviously know what is being said behind closed doors but at least in direct interactions the interactions have all been beautiful Even when the interactions have been, like, you know, one of my, maybe my best friend, he said, well, I look forward to some long conversations about theology so we can talk about this tremendous era of judgment that you've made.

SPEAKER_00I get that. Yeah, that's beautiful. Thank you. That sounds like a wonderful, like, honestly, one of the best things I can imagine because I have deep confidence. Go ahead.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. Imagine if it was the other way. oh I'm sure you did a great thing and it's wonderful and I'm gonna do it too whoa whoa whoa whoa whoa whoa whoa that's very interesting but I I have a very good friend who's an atheist and what happens he comes on the show if he suddenly shifted I would want to know what was going on there on the other hand if it's genuine yeah fine yeah you don't want to have and this is like the the errors when you talked about like this notion of what is religion

SPEAKER_00you know the error is when you have an ideological commitment to religion I will just adopt that as a set of propositions like a set of words that I nod my head to I agree to this like you know I have a statement of faith that's it that's the end of it the words right um you could do that quick you could do that instantly but you can't actually live that way I think it's Saint um

SPEAKER_01I want to say it's Saint Theodore he wrote a book where he says by seven the young girl or boy has everything they need for the rest of their life except for one thing and that is to be again converted in their teenage or early 20s in other words the parents have given them everything at least should have and now it's time for them to live that way until they live that way again, which I really like.

SPEAKER_01And that's beautiful. It's for everybody, right? On some level, it's like a constant manifestation of the thing that you believe to be true, but it's blessed doubt. And I wonder, I wonder why that's hard for people to understand. I think it's because they're using the enlightenment framework.

SPEAKER_00Well, my friend Zack Stein provided me a nice way of describing what he calls the pre-tragic, the tragic, and the post-tragic. And the seven-year-old is in a pre-tragic state. They're in a received world, which, and frankly, even if it was not a pleasant world, is nonetheless not received at the level of tragic. Life just is a certain way. um and then when you go out into the world it was funny because like adolescence is the proper stage for the tragic experience of life which is where your your naivete is shattered that you're actually coming into relationship not with your parents world with world and you're going to have to learn how to live it you're going to suffer you're going to you're going to undergo things that are going to break your your uh

SPEAKER_00Innocence, and you will lose your innocence in the sense that you will actually engage reality directly, and you'll have to come into relationship with it as a mature human, with the process of becoming mature. That's a tragic sensibility. Now, the problem with the tragic sensibility is it's very unpleasant. So we clothe ourselves with different ways to avoid the pain of that tragic sensibility, like we rub salves on ourselves or we drape ourselves into distractions. We can't feel the pain of the tragic sensibility. and if you get stuck in a tragic sensibility that could be very bad like unfortunately if your coping mechanisms are good enough you just get stuck in the circle around the tragic sensibility like you're still sitting in it you just can't learn from it you can't grow through it as a result and then if you get converted again you've actually transitioned into the post-tragic sensibility

SPEAKER_00where you really actually feel the fullness of the tragedy of reality like you feel that life is a thing that has suffering built into it and you say yes to it right and you're like yes and i i fully enter into it i entered it consciously as a mature adult i step into this um and so that that bridge cultures like real cultures that's the you know the process of becoming an adult and we don't have those in our in our culture but not just i mean the enlightenment was a cut but you know it's a cut really a deep cut at this little notion of becoming an adult massively like it's almost like the enlightenment is the super amplification of adolescence in some deep sense wow i've seen this

SPEAKER_01I've invited you to this dinner over at this restaurant we started with our nonprofit where we do this Georgian feast called the Supra I'll tell you a quick story from there that I think illuminates exactly what this is that you're discussing although it was very clear a group came in maybe 20 really very nice 15 women in their late 20s, early 30s. And they were throwing a birthday party for the their their friend. And I was the Talmud I was the one walking them through this very formal but informal, oddly informal dinner where we toast, and they were excited.

SPEAKER_01and their friend sat and everybody was excited but three of their her friends the birthday girl's friends came to me just before we started the dinner and said please please i need you to do this for us i know there's a toast to the dead so in different regions of Georgia it's the fifth toast or the third toast there's always a toast to those who have fallen asleep very essential toast and they're pleading with me because they've heard their friends have come to the dinner before please don't do that one thing where you toast to the dead please and so I'm in an existential crisis because I've pledged to the people in Georgia who taught me this that you always do this toast

SPEAKER_01and the reason is because what you're saying is because life does that it goes up and it goes down and so there's a reality to the table that must be adhered to and so I said hey ladies just trust me on this and they wouldn't they said we're paying for this dinner for her and it's important that you do not do this and so we're asking you please we're the customers more or less and I said to them Yeah, no, I got to do it. You have to trust me.

SPEAKER_01So the first toast, second toast, third toast, they were not happy, Jordan. The fifth toast comes and we do it to the dead. Now, it's a general toast to all those who have died. And then what do you think happened? someone at the table toasted to her father who had just who had died only a week before 10 days before. And then what happened was is what you described as maturity emerged like a true sense of maturity, not because they were bad or immature people, but they were forced to deal with that suffering, which was that moment past the threshold of, like you said, the teenage world.

SPEAKER_01And then everyone was happy. I can't explain how the dinner ended except for in total joy because we properly suffered if at least for a moment it was really seminal for me to watch that happen and I'm glad I didn't succumb to the marketplace you're the paying customer I can't I will do that for you and it was a big thing for me and I think So I love the story.

SPEAKER_00I'm glad it ended up that way like in the middle of the story I'm waiting for you come on man come on you gotta stick to your guns what's funny it's like one of those teleologies like in some sense it had to end that way properly it had to that was absolutely the only proper way for that story to end and also because of the nature of how stories work like in the middle of them like how did it end um it was a joy but it wasn't it was nerve-wracking oh my goodness yeah I mean our culture is is numb and this isn't the term the term is called salience and the specific term is actually called super salience it's like cotton candy it's super salient and so we simultaneously extract the good and convert it back into something which is a super salient version of the good

SPEAKER_00and we extract the bad and numb it completely out of existence. um and this is because we have we have an excess of the capacity to to meet our our desires our passions as opposed to the orthodox sensibility and we have a deficit of our ability to actually live wisely or in a mature fashion and this this this this separation has gotten bigger and bigger the thing that we've got is better and better and actually doing that like that's our our superpowers we can we just keep spreading those two things apart

SPEAKER_00and it's tricky it's tricky because without being in a proper level of discipleship there you go it's like let's just go with like fasting we don't fast in Western culture and I and I being aware of the physiological benefits of fasting yeah fast a little bit not much now I'm fasting every Friday I'm not yet doing Wednesdays and Fridays yet I did my first Wednesday and Friday last week I didn't do it I guess today I'm not sure why actually probably because I'm a wimp but it literally is only in the context was like well why am I fasting every Friday not because I want to be healthy

SPEAKER_00because I'm in discipleship at a fundamental level. If I'm truly committing to Christianity, I have to. It's actually not my choice. The choice is so deep, and it implies then these things that come back up from that deeper level. So it gives the resolve to be able to go through the process of sanctification. It gives the resolve to go through the process of actually having that metanoia settle in your body. um and if you cut that off at the bottom this is the critique of secular culture if you cut that off at the bottom the constraints of secular culture will drift towards the passions they aren't grounded in something stronger than the passion so the passions becomes the new god and and then you will end up over there and if you have the power to give yourself the passions or avoid them give yourself the passions you like and avoid the passage you want you

SPEAKER_00this is what a perfect description of the ascetic life so here's a question you're a

SPEAKER_01who is the founder and CEO of Heavy Things Lightly. He's the founder and CEO of Heavy Things Lightly. The People Generally in that corporate culture. You just described a type of life, a willingness to embrace Friday, for example.

SPEAKER_01Can they intuit, can they place that and push it into their vision as business people? Nice.

SPEAKER_00So the deep answer is no. But here we have to actually speak to the notion that to know something means to actually live on the basis of it. Not to have a mental representation of it in your head. That's right. So the deep answers now Many of them do have something like a mental representation of it in their head Like I could actually tell you the story I just told I could tell them the story I just told you and I might even get nodding to it But what happens is if you're with the concept of spiritual bypass you heard of this term a little bit Yeah, so it's it's in that category.

SPEAKER_00So what ends up happening is that there's a uh it's like a what do you call it the shadow government the shadow king the the the ego or or the reason or something like that is situated in the position of being the shadow king and then and then other things are put in place that that look like an aesthetic life um but they're play active they're not really grounded all the way down and they're kind of committed and so they're actually designed to support the shadow they're designed yeah they're ultimately pointing up to the shadow exactly right um and you can see how that shows up because as it as it matures or not as matures as it ages um it gets more and more obviously uh using that term obese or more uh let's say grotesque it's easier

SPEAKER_00and so you get this grotesquery where you look at it you're like yeah that's clearly not good like the fruits are not good like something wrong is happening here right um and I mean that in terms of like the the environment becomes uh Decadent in a way that is sort of increasingly obvious than decadent. You look at it, you imagine like the distance between say Hugh Hefner circa 1953, black and white first edition Playboy and kind of the grotesqueries that are on the sort of the deepest version. That's so good.

SPEAKER_00That's so good, Jordan. Yeah. That's right. Whoa. But if you realize that that, when you get it, like that actually is that, it just takes a while to become obvious if you're living in chronological time.

SPEAKER_01and that's that right his black and white you know leggy picture became whatever pornography is now they're actually this in other words spiritual rationality in other words clear spiritual seeing already knew what that was before it was the thing that we now see it was already that thing in full advance and those seers are few and far between in our western society and also we don't listen to them although you and I are trying probably on some level we're trying

SPEAKER_00Oh, I am deeply trying. And there's the difficulty is, as you said, they're few and far between. And then there's also the problem that the adversary is perfectly capable of dressing up in those clothes. And so, we have to actually develop a discernment to be able to know, okay, this is a sort of a saint-saint, and this is actually the adversary dressed up like a saint.

SPEAKER_01well now you're into the realm of the church of the Ecclesia which I finally realized and we could go Jordan we could talk a long time I I love guys this is I don't know this is very easy I thank you Jordan for your time but I want to can we just do one little thing on the church here for a second yeah I wanted to fight against the church 27 years ago when I became Orthodox because I want to fight against the notion that um I'm in obedience and

SPEAKER_01and my mother the most magnificent Orthodox person I know she was also willing to fight like crazy and so I can't but I want to start to realize is the Ecclesia it's not somebody trying to make me obey it's just a series of voices intertwined in wisdom and so the question is are you going to listen or not because as my priest told me once you don't have to fast you don't have to do the marital fast do whatever you want to do I'm telling you wisdom you can choose it I'm telling you how to be

SPEAKER_00Beautiful. And with your accent, your priest suddenly becomes very Jewish. I know, by the way.

SPEAKER_02This is my New York thing that comes out whenever I get excited. I did. He was very rabbinical. But by the way, if you could talk to a good Orthodox priest, they do have a lot of Rebbe in them. You know what I mean? I like that.

SPEAKER_01So when I finally realized that it's not a police, the church is not filled with policemen. It's filled with wise old men speaking to you from, and women speaking to you from 2000 Years Ago. That's helpful to me. Super helpful.

SPEAKER_00You're a parent. I have four daughters. Four daughters. How many kids do you have? I'm an all-daughter-all-the-time kind of guy. I have three. So we have a line in common already. We can hang out. So I've had this conversation as a hopefully somewhat wise and caring adult with my five-year-old. It's like, you know, I'm going to give you the choice of whether or not to do this thing. Like, let's say I have a simple one.

SPEAKER_00I notice that you have the salt shaker and you're pouring it into your water. This is a beautiful, perfect opportunity. From my point of view, as a person who's lived life, I will tell you that you're not going to like the taste of that water. It will taste yucky. But you can choose to do that. And you can learn for yourself how that works. and of course, as humans do, she looks me in the eye and pours the salt into the water and then she tastes it and it's salty. Therein lies, that's the story of sin and wisdom all in a single beautiful little tale of parenting.

SPEAKER_00And then when you grasp like, oh my goodness. So the church is doing the same thing and I'm the five-year-old and I'm looking at him in the eye and pouring the salt into the water and tasting it going, oh my gosh, why did I do that? And they're like, well, because you didn't listen.

SPEAKER_01um yeah the family scales up right the idea of those with whom you learn how to be the family well your family your friends the church everything scales up eventually into the ecclesia and then you start to realize who who is it and then that's Christ's body and then you really

SPEAKER_00are touched if you really stay in that space for a minute you realize you're participating in Christ but it's obedience man it's it's a brutal it's a brutal it's a tough game for us Americans too because you know our both our origin story and even our uh like our origin narrative and our actual origin story is that we are the disobedient ones we are the prodigal son in perfect symbology and we we My ancestors left.

SPEAKER_00They left a place and came to a place. And not all of them. Only a few. Only the ones who were adventurous, some would say disobedient, left. And by the way, a long line. They landed on one coast and they got kicked out of that place and kept moving forward. That's right. Nobody tells you what to do. um so it's actually kind of from my point of view very beautiful like if you think about the beginning of our conversation in this mission with the end of something big there's something about the prodigality of us like our particular piece of this story and the return like our return what does it look like for us to come into a place where we can return that has a beautiful piece of that story like we needed to go out here because that was part of the

SPEAKER_00The Liturgy. The Liturgy required our prodigality so that our return was a deeper communion. We're bringing something like, yes, I know not to pour the salt in the water. I get it. Thank you, Father, for your wisdom and for your gift and for your care and for welcoming back into your family.

SPEAKER_01You, in a flash, helped me understand. When I say the little corner of the world, people are coming back and then they the father runs out the father runs out and and grabs me back and says okay Come Feast and that has been my experience man and it's been so many the experience of so many of my friends and these are educated people you know what I'm saying I think education right now probably makes it harder to be the prodigal the proper prodigal it probably keeps you in the pig pen as Father Thomas Hopko said what what west in the west what happened is the prodigal went out and then got in the pig pen and then said you know what I could do with this pig pen

SPEAKER_01Jordan Hall because there's a lot of people that are going to reject this prodigal moment, and who knows what happens?

SPEAKER_00Well, I can say that from my experience, to whatever portion of wisdom that I've been given in this life, I would suggest to them that the return, the feasting is real. It's been my experience as well. And if you stop pouring the salt in the water, you can have living water, and it's really nice.

SPEAKER_01yeah man well let's do this too let's make a promise because I heard you in another great talk um let's keep doing I like what you said you said I don't really reach out I just try to accept conversations where there's something like A High Chat Going On

SPEAKER_01pull something bro do something yeah so uh let's stay friends come and have come and have um that's the the the that's the Georgian cheese bread and bring your family and um I know you guys are about three or four hours in you're up in Carolina North Carolina North Carolina so it's only about 90 minutes

SPEAKER_00Oh, that's not too far. Yeah, that's right. I've been trying to navigate what's the right logistics. Do I bring a bunch of people? Is it just me? Do I bring my family? We're talking about it. It's in a live conversation in our house.

SPEAKER_01Well, I'll tell you what. This is such a central part of my life now as sort of the head of our organization. It leads to great relationships and networks. But what it really does is it gives me a lot of... an image of the liturgy outside of the liturgy in a way that it fills me up it fills me up and so you tell me and we'll make it happen yeah bring folks and we'll sit you around a big table and we'll do the Georgian Georgian tradition which is you know it's it's ground in the ancient the ancient ancient so

SPEAKER_01that's beautiful I just had a feeling of what the right thing looks like so the spirit is moving in this my friend okay brother well guys Jordan Hall and um we'll talk again and we can't wait well let's do it again I don't know six months a year we'll talk or even sooner I don't care just reach out yeah let me know if you feel like it's time to talk let me know all right greet your family greet your family man and I hope you have a beautiful day take care I will blessings bye-bye guys that's it I don't know man I don't know how this all happened but meeting folks like that makes me happy Jordan Hall go check out his stuff too it's amazing lots of good conversations he's had with Verveke I feel like he popped up with Jordan Peterson Jonathan Pedro all those cats Jordan Hall beautiful wonderful guys Symbolic World is next weekend see you there if this comes out in time if it doesn't then I'll well

SPEAKER_01you know it didn't come out in time next week go there we're throwing a capey throwing a supra Jordan Peterson's going also see what kind of toast that guy makes should be very fascinating peace to everybody can't wait to meet you all down there peace out

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Demons, Deception, and Why Your Spiritual Practices Might Be Dangerous

    Oct 2, 20261 hr 18 minAudio

    Find this episode on YouTube: "Justine Alter" - a pseudonym - returns to chat with John Heers in a raw Heavy Things Lightly conversation you have to hear to believe.Justine worked for years as a professional psychic,...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. The Fox News Reporter Who Quit to Live an Orthodox Homesteading Life

    Sep 25, 20261 hr 35 minAudio

    Find this episode on YouTube: Holly Hickman went from Columbia Journalism and Fox News Radio covering NASA and the 2008 election - to milking cows, making cheese, and converting to Orthodoxy.In this episode of Heavy...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Why They Left NASA to Start St. George's Classical Academy

    Sep 21, 20261 hr 2 minAudio

    Can you teach kids the truth AND prepare them for a secular world?On this episode of Heavy Things Lightly, host John Heers talks with James and Juliana Joyce, founders of St. George's Classical Academy in Boxford,...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. An Odyssean Tale: The Man Who Would Not Quit

    Sep 4, 20261 hr 37 minAudio

    Find this episode on YouTube: Crow walked America searching for his father - and found the Father.From West Virginia hollers to LA gangs, from wolves in the Mojave desert to an Orthodox cross, this is an Odyssean tale...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. From Broadway to the Supra: Carrie Manolakos on Life After Lockdown

    Sep 1, 20261 hr 51 minAudio

    Welcome to the first episode of “Save Me a Spot at the Supra” on Heavy Things Lightly where John Heers hosts singer and Broadway performer Carrie Manolakos (best known for her performances in Mama Mia! and Wicked) at...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode