Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Heavy Things Lightly

Heavy Things Lightly artwork

Alex Sorin seems too nice for debates

Feb 6, 20261 hr 10 minAudio
  • Apple Podcasts
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Find this episode on YouTube: Alex Sorin joins the show today to talk about debating and defending the Orthodox Church, a little on Cicero, and a lot on the Protestant mindset in America. Also Alex is equal parts intelligent and nice. 10/10 would recommend as your lawyer. Find more Alex here: https://www.youtube.com/@Alex_Ortodoxie or on X: https://x.com/Alex_Ortodoxie Conrad's Deli - The best jerky you'll ever have: https://conradsdeli.com/ use promo code "FIRST THINGS" for 10% off. ✒ Substack: ⓧ https://x.com/johnfromftf🍷The best dinner party you've ever experienced - Supra Dinner Society: https://supradinner.com/ 🏖️ Tailormade tours that give back: https://www.gratitude-travels.com/home🔎 Discover the non-profit behind Heavy Things Lightly: https://first-things.org/ ✈ Become a Field Worker with FTF: https://first-things.org/opportunities📢 First Things Telegram: https://t.me/firstthingsfoundation🥂 Keipi Restaurant: https://keipirestaurant.orgPlease leave a review with your comments! Your support keeps this podcast alive and allows us to broaden our discussion. ---This “Enlightened” New World utopia isn’t turning out to be all it was cracked up to be. Society is disenchanting, but are the only alternatives hiding out in the hills or burying yourself in books? With an air of levity and a touch of humor, John Heers teaches how to examine the confusing New World by calling upon the mind and wisdom of oft-forgotten Old. Heavy Things, Lightly.--- Credits Music: Intro / Outro Provided by Greg Gilbertson & Band This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit johnheersftf.substack.com/subscribe

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_03Hello! Welcome! It's Heavy Things Lightly. This is Borjomi. This is, um... This is basically like a salt water thing, mineral drink from the Georgia Republic. I highly recommend it. It's at our restaurant, KP Restaurant. And I'm drinking it instead of alcohol. Which is probably good. Everyone's quitting alcohol. What's that about? Could someone write in the comments what that's about? So, Kagi Marjos, welcome to the show. Today, Alex Soren. He is, uh...

lawyer and a superman of words and a superman of things theological and really good at debate.

SPEAKER_03And I highly recommend his channel. That's why I have him on today because he's a fascinating read listening to him and his, I don't think he's nerdy, but he has a way about him that I don't have. And I love folks who love what they do and they come on here and answer questions. We had fun doing it. Alex Soren, love you and your channel. He's here with us today on Everything's Lightly. And don't forget, Andrew and his family up in Pennsylvania,

SPEAKER_03the Graver family, they make beef jerky at Conrad's Jerky Company. Check the links. Click on it right now. When you buy their jerky, they support us. Well, they do anyway. They're our sponsor, and I love them. Conrad's Jerky. Don't forget, first things, and you get 10% off on your purchase. That's your go-to phrase. It's your discount phrase when you go to buy it online. First things.

SPEAKER_03Buy some jerky. Buy Andrew's Jerky at Conrad's Jerky Company. Now, Alex Soren. Guys, I managed to get Alex Soren on here, who is a lawyer, but not really. Can you explain how you're a lawyer in your real life, but then your other real life, it's not like that at all, except for you are arguing,

SPEAKER_03but it's not the same, right? Can you explain to us you're just Alex Soren, the guy? Because people like your channel, man. It's kind of hot.

SPEAKER_00Thank you. I appreciate that. I think detaching myself from my profession is a bit of a hard thing to do because those three years that you spend in law school and that one year or so you spend studying for the bar exam and then actually going to law practice later, I see the whole thing is like a hazing process where they really try to change your way of thinking. It's true. It's true. Yeah. They try to change your way of thinking. And the unfortunate thing is that you can never go back once they change your mind in that way. So I figured, you know, since I've been trained in this,

SPEAKER_00like almost as a mercenary, you know, it's just like, and to take orders, like you already know your side of the story. You already know your side of the argument. Now tell the story in the best way possible. When I applied that to apologetics and looking at the faith, uh, I think I'm able to bring a unique angle from that perspective in the form of like storytelling. So I think people appreciate that because, you know, there's plenty of debaters out there. Some of them, I would say, obviously,

more experienced and better than I am.

SPEAKER_00Of course, everybody knows Jay Dyer in the Orthodox. Jay Dyer. Probably the best debater on YouTube. Even from a litigation perspective, I would say that he's a very excellent debater. But I know that your channel, John, is about connecting the old world and the new world. And when I was learning this trade of like advocacy, litigation and persuasion, I spent a lot of time in Cicero. And although he's a pagan ancient, he spends a lot of time talking about like You can have all the rationality you want,

SPEAKER_00but there are men that can change governments, regimes, affect people's lives simply by the eloquence of their speech. You know, rationality is almost a given. And in my profession and my trade, that through line has been kept since the time of Cicero. You see even the American founding fathers, John Adams, read a lot of Cicero. Same thing with Thomas Jefferson. And it's that starts to touch on the point of your channel where we start talking about like enlightenment ideas. But there's a through line through the profession of lawyering

that connects with

SPEAKER_00the old world, too. And I think you see that also in the rhetoric, the the rhetoricians of the church fathers. Right. Like there's a unique angle to the doctors of the church within holy orthodoxy that are theologians. have a certain like poetic tilt to them. Right. So like the first one I think of is St. Gregory, the theologian, very poetic, a great rhetorician, you know, and it's not necessarily this technical analysis that you see in the West and like

SPEAKER_00a Thomas Aquinas, for instance. What is a bit of a roundabout answer to your question?

SPEAKER_03I know you got me thinking of 30 different things. Guys, look at that. Well, so we can dive into the history, but here's my first thought while you were talking, because see, You may have heard I have a brother who's also good at arguing, not unlike... you or jay and i like a good argument but here's what happened i became the guy to you or to to your to your ilk can we just use the word ilk a

lot on this ilks i feel like ilk like it's something bad is about to happen when someone's using the

SPEAKER_03word ilk but your ilk what happened is is i'm the guy that goes like It's not going to matter, bro. Good job. Also, you won and it's all straw to use Aquinas's words.

SPEAKER_02Do you what do you do with guys like hecklers like us? Like good wind. Also, no one cares. What do you do with guys like us?

SPEAKER_00Well, there are a lot of people that don't care. And that's totally fine. The thing is that whatever medium you use.

SPEAKER_03By the way, I do care. I just want you to know, Alex, I will talk out of both sides of my mouth a lot. But actually, it's fun. And it's also helpful. But there is a don't care element to me. So keep going. Sorry I interrupted you.

SPEAKER_00No, but with my profession, I mean, we go back and forth all the time where, you know, we kind of just learn when somebody intuitively and somebody switches to devil's advocate. So, you know, you're right on the money there with that. But I'd say that there are a lot of people that don't care and there are different mediums for, you know, those people that don't care about debates. They might care more about, you know, the bookish stuff. And that's fine because there's plenty of that to go around, you know.

SPEAKER_01Right.

SPEAKER_00That's why on my channel, I try to, you know, have these edutainment style videos that are a little more maybe palatable for the standard person. But, you know, I was a born debater and I feel like that's given my profession and my training, that's something that I will never give up doing. And it's something that I do because I sincerely enjoy it. And, and there's different tools to trying to be in this world as a Christian.

SPEAKER_03This is, and I think you'll agree with me on this. Um, For those of you who aren't Orthodox, welcome to our channel, the two of you. I'm kidding. There's probably three. But Alex, for us Orthodox, you're a convert, right? We'll get into that. We'll get into that.

SPEAKER_00I am, yes.

SPEAKER_03I'm a convert. But for us Orthodox, it's like there's something non-enlightened about about the world we're supposed to swim in, by definition, historically and theologically. We're not good and enlightened philosophers, but we'll do it, don't get me wrong. But my point is, is there still is a way to be good to people by making a really sharp, clean argument.

SPEAKER_03And there are plenty of people that have gotten into the, let's call it less rational space of being a true Christian through the rational space that you provide. So I'm all for all the tools. I never understand how people get it. I appear so irritating or like Jay Dyer's mean. I'm like, yeah, but there's like thousands and hundreds of thousands of people that don't think they're mean and actually, you know, kind of vibe on it so why don't you just turn it off you know what i mean like it's exactly right it's kind of you got options you know so yeah that's my

SPEAKER_00Yeah, well, I think the more figures that we have in this orthodox space, the more you get to have a bit of a buffet style, I guess, and the manner in which the information is transmitted. You have great informational channels like Seraphim Hamilton, David Erhan. I hate whenever I start naming off people because I know I'm going to forget somebody good. But, you know, you have those more educational channels. Barrel Aged Faith. Harmony.

SPEAKER_03You've seen those guys.

SPEAKER_00Harmony. Yes. Excellent. Excellent stuff. You have like the debaters. Right. You have Nick at Fearless Truth. You have Jay Dyers, myself. Also Transfigured Life, another very good educational, more orthodox channel. And then you have the people that are in between, like Craig Trulia, like. Father Peter hears that, you know, they are not afraid to get a little sassy now and then, but they do. They do tend towards more of like the fatherly, like educational side.

SPEAKER_03Well, I think you do the words really well. I was joking that you're like young Hank Hanegraaff. I say that with a major compliment to you because I went and visited Hank in like his office. My wife and I went and, And it was like a mix between going to visit Cicero and also Colonel Kurtz from Apocalypse Now. There was a little bit of that. There was a little bit of that. He was like, please sit down. And you were like, he's going to operate on me with his mind.

SPEAKER_03Like, he was amazing, bro. He was amazing.

SPEAKER_02But...

SPEAKER_03He really does know all the words. And I'm watching your channel. That's how I feel. That's why I was really happy to have you on. So how'd this happen to you, this orthodoxy? And then how'd you go from being a litigator by day and then a defender of the faith by night? Well, it's a very long story, but I guess I'll cut it short to just the essentials here. But I think it really was an act of God's providence at the end of the day.

SPEAKER_00In hindsight, I think everybody can say that. Well, you're in the moment. What is all this craziness? But it was about, you know, I guess six, seven years ago now when. You know, the plague happened and I was I'm living in Canada at the time on a border city over here. I was raised in America. I married a Canadian. Ended up being easy. You married a Canadian side at the time. I did.

SPEAKER_03Yes, that's that. That's that is amazing. And also is amazing because I didn't think they marry anymore. Congratulations. You found one.

SPEAKER_00Well, you know, it was a different country. Even seven, eight years ago was when I got married 10 years ago, far different country. Currencies were closer in value at that time, too. It's amazing how fast Canada has declined, not just morally, but also economically. It's a straight plummet, straight shot down.

SPEAKER_03And your wife sees that and her family sees that.

SPEAKER_00Yes. Yeah. Interesting. They see that too. I interrupted you again. There's a sharp divide in Canada.

SPEAKER_03I told you, Alex, it was going to go like this. Sorry.

SPEAKER_00That's fine.

SPEAKER_03If it's too straight, then what happens is I can't handle it. I got to make it squiggly. Don't be mad at me. I agree. Keep going.

SPEAKER_00What are we talking about? I'm cool with the squiggles. It was basically how I converted and came to it. So I grew up Pentecostal and there was a Romanian Pentecostal is a kind of a different sect than American Pentecostalism. They have a lot of that. So charismaticism in the Eastern European countries, the Balkan countries over there is not totally different, but in some very tangible,

SPEAKER_00concrete ways, very different from the Pentecostalism you see in America. For example, when I was growing up, the men and the women, they sat segregated in church. Right. They would fast in the morning prior to the Lord's Supper. So they had a lot of Orthodox to hold on the women. Yeah. Yeah. Although women would wear head coverings when I grew up in Romanian Pentecostalism, it wasn't even like a matter of preference or a matter of conscience. Everybody did it. Right. And slowly and slowly, you know, my parents, they immigrated to America right before and after the Romanian

revolutions.

SPEAKER_00My dad came slightly before my mom came slightly after. And I was raised in a like this third culture, I guess, where I didn't quite fit in with the American culture. I didn't quite fit in with the Romanian culture. But there are a ton of us young people that are like this third in between culture, I suppose. But I saw the Romanian Pentecostalism kind of going more and more towards this American brand of Pentecostalism to where a lot of the churches now, and there's a pushback against this within the Romanian

Pentecostal community, but towards like word of faith and the new apostolic reformation and the more kooky

SPEAKER_00kinds of charismaticism that you see today. And during COVID six years ago, and it's amazing. It feels like it just happened yesterday.

SPEAKER_03It's crazy, right? Yeah, I agree.

SPEAKER_00Um, all of this kind of came to a boiling point for me and I was like, okay, now there is no way that this is right. Let's just go back. Like, let's start from the book of Acts, go through the history sequentially and which church is the right church today? Because at that point, you know, I had already gone through my angsty atheist phase and, uh, I was convinced of the arguments, you know, by, you know, father Sarah from Rose, I think eloquently states them in his essay against the Oh, one of the great books.

SPEAKER_03One of the great books.

SPEAKER_00That's right. How it really it. Every atheist worldview descends into nihilism and is ultimately it has no objective truths. And that's not a functional worldview to have. So big problems within the atheist system. I was very convinced of theism and Christian theism. So it was just a matter of which one at that point in my life. And then when you go through the history, I think it's a pretty straight shot. I just went through every schism and I analyzed each schism, each council as if it were a court case at that time.

SPEAKER_00So you have somebody pressing charges, right? Saints, Alexander and Athanasius v. Arius, right? What was each position? What was the decision, the holding of the council? Who was right? And then I just went through each council from there. And then when I got to the 1054, it's obviously broader than 1054, but the great East West split, it seemed very obvious to me, at least applying a legal analysis to it, that the East was correct. And the West seemed entirely falsely premised.

SPEAKER_03And that was like, how old are you when this is hitting you?

SPEAKER_00Yeah. 20 i'm 33 now so about 27 and you're not 27 years old you're what are you doing during this investing i mean this is didn't take a day this is going on did what are you doing for your spiritual life during the investigative nature of that that story like are you going to pentecostal church or what are you doing at that point So I left the Pentecostal church because at first I didn't go all the way back to the book of Acts right off the bat. I kind of started from today, started working my way backwards.

SPEAKER_00And I got a little more convinced of like that Baptisty Reformation, that like Baptisty Reformation theology. And my wife and I, we left the Romanian Pentecostal church. And I honestly, I have no bad things to say about the people there at all. For sure. Yeah. They love the Bible. I wish that they would love historical continuity and church traditions as much as they love the Bible. It would offer them a new phronema to see the scriptures through. But they were always very nice to me. They didn't really think less of us when we went to the

independent Bible church after that. But while I was searching, I spent this time at an independent Bible church.

SPEAKER_00I see. And are they inviting you into that as you get closer and closer to the church?

SPEAKER_03Are you sharing stuff with them? And you're like, Hey, Jim, look at this. Or is it kind of a solo endeavor?

SPEAKER_00Well, it started off a bit as a solo endeavor. And then I came across some like very big problems in the Protestant worldview that made it untenable, I guess, from my reading. So at that point I went to, you know, the pastors, associate pastors at that church and, um, The feedback that I got was utterly shocking. They told me to basically stop reading The Church Fathers. If I ask them, where do you get your list of books from? This seems like a pretty straightforward question, right? A very foundational one that somebody who has an MDiv degree

should be able to answer, right?

SPEAKER_00Where do I get the list of books from? And the responses that I get were so strange. And I don't know if you can empathize with it at all, but it was immediate deflection. It was like, Alex, what is going on in your life that you're asking these questions? Are you having trouble with your parents?

SPEAKER_03I call that the Jim Jones effect. That's the Jim Jones effect. Hey, let's talk a little bit about what's happening with you.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. And I was shocked that like, it was almost every single interaction that I had with somebody on the board over there or, you know, one of their elders or something, it was a universal response. And I thought that I was the one going crazy after a certain point because I was like, Maybe I'm the one who maybe I do have a problem, you know, interpersonally or something. And I realized that, like, hey, no matter what response I get from these guys or, you know, maybe there is something challenging.

SPEAKER_00And, you know, for the viewers, you're looking into this, too. And maybe there is something challenging in your personal life. What kind of held me down then was nothing has changed. Sola Scriptura is still indefensible. They still have no reasons for their canons. They can try to make you feel as guilty as you want in your heart about even asking these questions to begin with. What you have to do is you have to really look at the facts. Once you look at the history and you look at the continuity, these things don't change. So...

SPEAKER_00After I talked to these elders at the Independent Bible Church, I want to actually go to a first divine liturgy, because there's only so much you can learn from reading books, as this is a very orthodox idea, is that the intellectual stuff is very surface level. Dogmatics are just the basics. Everybody knows. Everybody can learn dogmatics, but the experiential side, actually experiencing God through the liturgy, through the sacraments, not everybody can have that.

SPEAKER_00So going to the divine liturgy was an enormous first step to realize, whoa, this is more than just words on a page or points on a timeline and historical continuity. This is something real. That was a huge turning point for me. And then...

SPEAKER_03that probably also you wanted to share because here's where it gets. Can I, I'll, I'll stick some words into the air and you, you deflect them away. But this is where people are like, you're not really going to eat. You don't really think you're eating God. Do you like, that's where it's going to go. Right. At this point in your story, It's really right out of the gospel that they walked away because it was a hard saying.

SPEAKER_03It's like you were experiencing that in real time, probably, when you started to believe it was actually a body and blood of Christ. That's a little freaky on his face on some level, right?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, and I guess I don't blame people for having this objection. It was one that I got from the... Pentecostal and the independent Baptist community at the same time. And for that objection in particular, I just say, like, look, all this boils down to is how you interpret John six. Right. He who eats my flesh shall have eternal life. He who drinks my blood shall have eternal life. If you do not eat my flesh and drink my blood, there is no eternal life in you. Christ really triples and doubles down on this, and he doesn't qualify it in any way.

I'm not saying that the analysis of legal texts is perfectly analogous to analysis

SPEAKER_00of biblical texts or anything, but... I see certain principles with no exception. Seems like it's pretty dummies out here who aren't we're spending time doing other stuff.

SPEAKER_03When we hear that, you're like, oh, oh, oh. So literally you're going to interpret that. Right. And it makes sense. So let's have communion. You can't figure out how it never got interpreted that way by most of the reformers. It's nuts. It's kind of wacky that they just skip that part. What do you think it is? It's just because ontologically, it's just like you're being just, it stays in its animal self. It can't really imagine the truth that you actually are able to commune with God. Like, can we just not get past it?

SPEAKER_03What is it? Why can't the reformers get this? Well, I think from an Orthodox lens, we would just say that they are not illuminated. They don't have the Holy Spirit because they're not a part of the one holy Catholic

SPEAKER_00apostolic church. And you see this in Romans, right? That the more you go into pre-list, right? In Romans chapter one and two, the more God gives you up into the pre-list that you want. And you see that. In the Reformation, it really was taken over by lawyers. Calvin was a lawyer. Luther was a law school dropout. And you see this in their writing as well. And it's like, no wonder you get this double legal imputation doctrine right out of the Reformation.

SPEAKER_03Yes. This makes a lot of sense. This makes a lot of sense. Do you know, are you familiar with the book Side Tangent, everybody? Because I only know like five things in the whole world, but I'm going to relate my five things to your 5,000 things. Okay, so you ready? This is one of my five things I know because it's fascinating. I love history. is there were these, the Tubigen scholars, they're Lutheran scholars. Well, they're just following, they're right after, I think they're the second, first generation after Luther.

And they're trying to answer questions and they write back and forth to the

SPEAKER_03patriarch of Constantinople. Do you know about this? Yes. And I read really all there is to read about it, basically. And what's amazing is you watch toward the end of, it's like three years they write back and forth. At the end, the patriarch, to simplify, is like, I don't know.

SPEAKER_02Look, just stop writing me. It's embarrassing. You're kind of making yourself embarrassed. Like, don't write me anymore, please. Whatever you do, if you stop, I'll be happy. Like, he can't even do it anymore. It's like such a great orthodox moment. He's like, hey, not again. What are you doing to me? It's amazing. Yeah.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, you just imagine this archetype of this Greek man struggling. He feels bad for them.

SPEAKER_02He's like, I'll try again, but please, oh, Lord. It's amazing. And then they stop writing because they're like, he's not answering our questions. For me, it was like the ultimate, yeah, no kidding, because you don't get it anymore.

SPEAKER_03Like, I can't do this anymore. Anyway, it's one of my favorites. But you know about those letters, yeah. Yeah.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, and I think it's a bit of a concession, maybe historically, that they did think that some form of historical continuity was important, that they couldn't just break off and start their own church, that they were looking for some sort of communion with another church, a group of churches, that they saw went all the way back to Christ and the apostles.

SPEAKER_03Yeah. It's wild. So did you always love... I mean, I see you doing a mix of history and you're litigating stuff in some way on your channel. Did you always love history? Were you always able to remember it? Was it something you loved as a kid?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I think history... I think for like every young man, we have some sort of love for history, right? Whether it's like Greek history or World War II or some sort of Greek or Roman mythology. Yeah, what's that about?

SPEAKER_03That's true.

SPEAKER_00We just love the stories of the heroes, the great heroes and ancestors of ours of the past, right? So I always had like a tilt toward it, but really the way I present things is formed by Cicero and that... method of persuasion through argumentation mixed with, you know, rhetorical skills and storytelling. So if I think that's what I that's why I ask about history,

because I think

SPEAKER_03History properly done is not remembering the past. It's simply telling stories that inform us about who we are. So I see that in the way that you go about it when you say rhetoric. You know, I don't really know what happened. Like Dostoevsky says, but I definitely know one thing. This story these Christians are telling me is the best one. And so I'm going with that one because it touches me the deepest and it moves me toward tears. And sorry, that's the one because the story about that God is the best.

SPEAKER_03And that's what got me into Orthodox. It just refutes a good word to use, but it really wasn't that. It was like I couldn't get the story to stop making sense. Like I didn't want it to. I was like, well, there's a lot to it. Maybe I won't be Orthodox. But then it just kept making sense. It's like – What's the game where you try to drop the bricks so they all fit? Tetris. Tetris. I was like, every time, orthodoxy is like Tetris. It fits right in there every time. I can't stop it.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. Yes. Yeah, it's funny you bring that up. I heard Jonathan Peugeot, I think he was doing an interview, I think on Ruslan's channel, where he was talking about how, look, we have theosis. Why on earth ever would I trade that and go back to some like double imputation legal model? We have fasts on a liturgical calendar that express the life of a Christian, the life of Christ. Our liturgy expresses the life of Christ and the presentation of the Gospels and

SPEAKER_00the little entrance and the great entrance. Talk about the incarnation. And why would I ever go back to a rock band and a TED talk when I have all these things? And that point that you made on the power of story, that is something that lawyers always talk about, because new lawyers, when they come out and they go into there are many different specialties in law. But in particular, if you want to go into some form of litigation, like whether it's civil litigation or just like a criminal practice where you're going to be persuading people in front of juries. There's a temptation to really emphasize like certain facts or

certain laws.

SPEAKER_00And you think that if you can find like that one technicality, that that'll win you the case and you'll win over the jury. And it's absolutely not true. In fact, what they teach new litigators is exactly what you just said, John, which is it doesn't matter who has the facts and it doesn't matter who has the law. Like these are factors, but it's not the factor. Those are just like a factor. The factor of who wins is whether like who tells the best story, who tells the most compelling story, who has a better story.

SPEAKER_00And that's who wins over the jury 100 percent of the time.

SPEAKER_03Now, watch this, though. I think our enlightened mind by that, all I mean is our math mind, the mind of let's just say logic. I think if you just approach that phrase, what you just said, from the math mind, it feels disingenuous or...

SPEAKER_00It feels a little icky.

SPEAKER_03It feels icky. But here's what I try to say in that situation, which is, no, it's... it's only icky if you have the wrong anthropology. What I mean is if you have the anthropology and you believe we are made in God's image, then the story properly told will fit with something already existing in you. In other words, you just won't be able to say it's not true. And so what I think a lawyer, just to add to what you said, not to say it's an addition to what you said,

SPEAKER_03the great lawyer is, is telling the truth and he's telling it and articulating it so that it might fit with what already exists. Right. As true.

SPEAKER_00That's right.

SPEAKER_03Right. And so I find that art, that the art of that is, is one of the great joys, at least my joys in life. is to speak into what already exists. I'm not trying to make it up, but I know you had, and I have the same experience. It's just on what level. It's not as a lawyer, me and you. It's not as a, we could say on a podcast level, we could say we both do a podcast, but there's some deep level where if I say it in a poetic way that's true, it'll just hit you like... Well, you know this stuff because you're doing it online.

SPEAKER_03But I find that art, I think it's rhetoric, but I would just call it like, I would just call it Christic truth telling. It's like willing to take a punch for the thing you know to be true and also saying it elegantly. I don't know. I love that. I find that good... that's the people who get listened to tucker's doing it right now now whether or not he's a secret cia guy i don't really know i kind of think it's fun to think about it but one thing he's good at is telling a story that

lands whether no matter what side of the divide you're on that lands in a way where it's hard to reject it and yeah that's almost enough for me on some level you get what i'm saying

SPEAKER_00Yeah, that's exactly right. I think Tucker is very good at that. And, you know, there are like little technical things that go into good storytelling as well, like using the active voice over the passive voice or like trying to stay away from certain adjectives, like try to focus on verbs and nouns, like these basic principles of writing. But at the end of the day, storytelling is a very... human thing like as you said it has something to do with human anthropology and when you do it correctly something just clicks and people just

understand it and there are litigators that are far better at this than I am like my mentors when I

SPEAKER_00first started practicing they were like 71 year old, no, 77 year old Jewish lawyer, 72 year old Italian lawyer. They'd been doing this their whole lives. All they know is litigation, you know, sacrificing their families for this kind of thing. You know, all of them had been through like multiple divorces because like this is their life. Yeah. They are hired guns. They are mercenaries and their powers of storytelling. It's like I always compare it to magic powers like they they will persuade you. They are so good at it. They haven't so mastered.

But I guess a little bit if you guys are interested in like the style of advocacy

SPEAKER_00style, this good storytelling in order to convey truth. Yeah. If you have falsities in your story, nobody's going to buy it anyway. If you're faking it, people can tell. You do have to genuinely believe what you're saying.

SPEAKER_01Yes.

SPEAKER_00But in my debate with Elijah Yassi, I had a formal debate with a Roman Catholic apologist, Elijah Yassi, who's a very fine man. He's a father. He has children. He's a great guy. But I think he fell short in certain aspects of the debate because he was too focused on technical aspects of the document of Pastor Eternus from Vatican I. And the prompt was, is the Vatican I papacy true? And in my mind, when I look at that, I think of the story of the Vatican I papacy.

SPEAKER_00What is the papacy at the time of Vatican I? Tell us.

SPEAKER_03Tell us the story.

SPEAKER_00It's not something that you can reduce to a few lines in a document. You have... a thousand years and then some of history leading up to Vatican one, you know, 1800 years or so. And you see that by the time you get there, when I was analyzing and preparing my opening statement, I was thinking the Vatican one papacy is not just a few propositions on a document. You have the Gregorian reforms. You have the Tridentine reforms. You have multiple changes in the Roman Catholic church, multiple iterations of it before you get to Vatican one.

SPEAKER_00So what do we have here? As the papacy, by the time we get to Vatican one, we have a king, a monarch of a country called the papal states who has his own mint. He produces his own money with his face on it. He has a standing army that he goes made up of Roman Catholics that he goes to send to kill other Roman Catholics. And he has the crown. He says he's king of the world. He has a special throne. His papal servants carry him around on his papal throne. And like all of these things are true. And all of these show already before even getting to any

documents or lines from

SPEAKER_00Vatican one that this papacy, this Bishop of Rome is not the same as the Bishop of Rome that you see with Pope St. Leo the Great or Pope St. Gregory, the dialogist. It's just the story itself shows that this is an utterly ridiculous notion. So that's like that's the kind of power that you see. And like, let's not miss the forest for the trees here. Let's look at what we're actually debating.

SPEAKER_03So. This is beautiful. This is to me how we arrive at truth. I wonder, so is what happened in that debate, I saw some of it preparing for this talk with you. What's the gentleman's name again? Tell me.

SPEAKER_00Elijah Yassi.

SPEAKER_03Yassi, yeah. Elijah, does he, is the problem, because this is the problem in everyday life, He retreated to the data. That's what happened, right? He retreated to the data. And there's only one little problem, Alex. Here's what's happened is the data guys, because you're a storyteller. It's obvious. The data guys are necessary, but they seem to rule the world right now through the computer. Doesn't it seem that way?

SPEAKER_00Yes, I think it's an enormous problem because they don't understand, I think, on a very basic level, they don't understand these fundamental human notions of storytelling, of needing to have a sort of mythos to know where you belong in society. There's a book on...

SPEAKER_03Yeah, see, this is definitely a Hank Hanegraaff move right here. I like it. That was impressive. He pulled out a book, guys, from his library. If you're not watching, that was hot. I want to see this. He's a Roman Catholic scholar, so you have to take it with a grain of salt.

SPEAKER_00But Michael Allen Gillespie, this book, The Theological Origins of Modernity, there wasn't any talks about the differences between is the, how people thought, you know, before the enlightenment, before the influence of medieval nominalism and these other philosophies and after, and he talks about how people really saw themselves as like part of a bigger story. They were part of a people. They had an ancestry, you know, their grandparents did this and they were born here and all these things were important to them.

SPEAKER_00Nowadays, all of that is kind of put to the side in favor of a, very dramatic individualism and self-determination, which in and of themselves, as those values aren't horrible, but there has to be some sort of balance. And because people are missing this peace, this big chunk of mythos, of story, where do you belong in the world? What do you believe? It makes this type of rhetoric that you see with Cicero and many other lawyers,

SPEAKER_00advocates, storytellers since Cicero, it makes that kind of storytelling very, very powerful, especially in today's day and age.

SPEAKER_03That's a good point. It is a... Well, it is what you're doing, and Pajot and these characters... I've sat with Jonathan, we've done events together and it's kind of funny because we'll laugh. It's like, I'm just, he just goes, I'm just telling people about orthodoxy. It's like, it's not, it's like, you know, hundreds of millions and billions of people have already known what I've known since the resurrection of Christ. Like this isn't like complicated stuff.

SPEAKER_03Well, he doesn't say that I'm adding, but he says, I'm just saying that that's all I'm really doing. And then you start to realize, oh, that's the new weapon, which is actually quite old. That's the thing that cuts through all the noise is the thing that already existed, which makes sense in this modernity of ours, doesn't it?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, as this reminds me of I posted on Twitter recently, there was a little episode when in my first year of law practice, when I realized the power behind story was we were working on a very complicated case, like eight figure litigation, like pretty high stakes stuff. And senior partners were like sitting in one of their offices and they were talking about these forensic actuaries and accountants that they were working with, like very smart people, like double PhDs, like absolute nerds,

SPEAKER_00very, very smart people. And he was like, man, None of these people can give me a straight answer on anything. And they're horrible at arguing and debating, although they are very smart people. They have no idea how to do any of this stuff. They weren't trained to do it. It's because they get caught so caught up in the data and figures and this perspective and that perspective and that angle that there's like they don't speak with any authority or anything. definitive direction. They have like no guiding principles to how they should see this data.

SPEAKER_00They are lost in a sea of data. And I think Orthodox Christianity offers that to, you know, especially in the Enlightenment, post-Enlightenment era with you know, reformed Christianity, Lutheranism with, you know, neo-Protestants and charismatics that there is very much a theological relativism going on. Yeah. People, I think especially young people are very, very thirsty for objective theological truths. Right. And you can only get that when you have the Orthodox phronema.

SPEAKER_03Isn't it crazy? It does make us arrogant. And I want to talk about that in a second.

SPEAKER_01Yes.

SPEAKER_03Yeah. that's the number one thing that happens in my world when I start talking, because I talked to a lot of people that are unorthodox all the time at these tables and at our public restaurant. And, and, They go, okay, so you just got it on lock? That's you guys. You just got it all figured out? I'm like, I don't have anything figured out, man. I'm just trying to lay down every day and get swept into the river that already is going where it's going, and I'm just trying to say what's being said by the water that's overcoming me and taking me down the stream.

SPEAKER_03That's it. And so here's what I know as of Tuesday today, and I'll do my best to explain it to you. But if you really want it, there's way better people. This is how I approach it. And I think what happens is it disarms people and they realize that, okay, I'll listen to you. But that's the humility, right? They're not saying I'm humble, but I'm saying it's a willingness to say you don't know that allows you to actually enter further into the truth, which is ironic. How do you deal? What's your go-to move when you see someone loaded for bear?

SPEAKER_03And you know you have a lot of, you know, wisdom on certain ideas. How do you start with loaded for bear? Like, do you have a disarming way of getting into this? Or is the whole point in your debates or in your conversations to just get ready to load for bear and fire? Like, do you have a way of disarming people?

SPEAKER_00It depends on the context, right? When I do the call-in debates, usually you can tell right off the bat if you've been doing this for a while. If somebody's there to get some sort of clip from your interaction, it shows up with bona fide questions, right? When it comes to formal debate, public debate, I just revert back to Cicero and examples in the New Testament as well of St. Paul in Acts 17, later in the book of Acts, his defense to the authorities, St. Stephen in Acts chapter 7, with his defense to the Sanhedrin.

SPEAKER_00And St. Stephen goes pretty hard at the Sanhedrin there. He says, you worship the star of Remphan, basically accusing them of occultism. It's like not a light claim that he levies against them. He says, you always resist the Holy Spirit, just like your fathers, you always have. So I think there is a time to be like combative and to scrap. And, you know, when you have a formal debate, I really see it as a courtroom setting where, yeah, there is my opponent, the interlocutor on the other side. But there's also a huge audience watching the jury. And those are the people that are really looking for

information out of this.

SPEAKER_00So when I do that setting, it's more like. Okay, it's more meant for the audience. But I think in interpersonal evangelism, I think that humility that you mentioned that like, yes, one of the biggest blessings that I received from Holy Orthodoxy was finally having some sort of clarity. When I was Pentecostal, there was always like a debate of like, oh, this verse kind of sounds a little more Arminian, a little more free will. This verse sounds a little bit more Calvinist, a little bit more determinist. Which one is it at the end of the day? I don't know. Whoever can stack up more proof texts maybe or present it in a

more persuasive manner.

SPEAKER_00That must be the person who's right. You don't have any of that in holy orthodoxy. You have verses that have objective truths, objective meanings. There's an objective truth. hermeneutic to all these things yeah um yeah yeah it's bound in it's bound in the body it's it actually has a body called the church yeah you don't it yeah and if you can show people like your submission to this tradition right where it's like no it's not me that has all the answers and this is something that i like to bring to the attention of the audience is that whenever you see this like orthodox

SPEAKER_00protestant back and forth There's something called the Orthodox we versus the Protestant me. So the Protestants will tend to speak in a manner that sounds something like, well, I read this passage and I think this. This is my reading of this passage. Whereas the Orthodox will say the Orthodox position on this passage is... Or read St. John of Damascus. He has the definitive interpretation of this or St. Andrew of Caesarea has the definitive Orthodox commentary on Revelation.

SPEAKER_00Right. Right. The Orthodox we versus the Protestant me. Very important.

SPEAKER_03Super helpful. You know. Yeah. I recently watched, you ready? Let's wade into this for a second. I recently watched a friend of mine. I've met him a number of times. Ruslan, who has got a big channel over in Protestant town. Do you know Ruslan? You've heard of him? I don't know him personally, but I'm very familiar with his work and his channel. Well, he sat down with a certain character named, I believe it's Joel Webin.

SPEAKER_03Weebon. Oh, boy. Oh, boy. And they had a big debate, and the title of it was something like marriage between the races normative or something. Okay. This is what happened to me. Can I ask you? Because you're a debater. I want to ask you about this. All that happened was Ruslan won, but also Sola Scriptura lost.

SPEAKER_02That's what happened. Because that was three and a half hours of proof text. I was just like, is this real? And it's real, isn't it?

SPEAKER_00Yeah. Yeah. And I think even in Joel Webin's closing, which stuck out a lot to me, where he was like, look, when I look at the scriptures, I see that God sent out man to multiply and cover all the earth. I think that whether it was post lapsarian or pre like after the fall or before the fall, we would have had different races either way. And in my mind, objection, speculation. Where are you getting this from? Is everybody just supposed to buy into your idea of how the pre-lapsarian,

SPEAKER_00pre-fall Christian world maybe would have panned out? We have 2,000 years of tradition. Exactly. We have the teachings of the fathers. We know what is important when it comes to marriage. I don't see John Chrysostom saying like – Look, marriage is important for your salvation. That's why you need to have the same race in your marriage. No, you don't see it as a factor anywhere. You see unanimously within the fathers and in the New Testament in 1 Corinthians 7, that the purpose of marriage is for your salvation.

SPEAKER_00Yes. It's in the process of theosis. Yes. Learning the fruits of the Spirit, practicing them in marriage, submitting to one another with St. John Chrysostom. He also says in his homilies that there are some situations that do call for an authority, which is the role of the man. But this is mutual salvation. And St. John says that when it comes to matters of holiness, you see equality between the husband and the wife. And race has absolutely nothing to do with any of those things. Now, before people say that I'm anti-white or something,

SPEAKER_00it is very obvious, I think, that generally people will marry within their own race just because you will tend to have more things in common. Well, I don't think there's anything wrong with that either.

SPEAKER_03It's just, that's a geography question at that point. Yeah. I really like how you, see, this really helps me because you went, before I'm called anti-white, you got to know as a Gen Xer, am I X? Yeah, I'm X. As a Gen Xer, that's such a weird stopping point. I'm not saying it's right or wrong, okay? Yeah. Yeah, it's such a weird. Now, remember, I'm like a Martin Luther King baby right now. There's a whole bunch of guys going, oh, guys, Martin Luther King did heavy lifting on Christianity.

SPEAKER_03I know he had problems, but he was actually trying to give back to the Western, very atheistic Christian pseudo Christian mind. He was trying to give back some of their own words. Yeah. He was just trying to take orthodoxy out of it. He was just trying to re-baptize the supposed Christian West. I'm sorry. He was on many levels. But that aside, I got a lot of thoughts on this. Sorry about this, Alex. But here's my question wrapped in a comment, which is,

When you said, whoa, I don't want to sound anti-white, that cracks me up. Because for us Orthodox folks, because I was the guy who goes, I don't want to sound anti-black.

SPEAKER_03I did that my whole life. I get it. I totally get it. 100%. But what's so funny is that Orthodoxy solves this stupid problem really fast. Absolutely.

SPEAKER_00Yes. I marry someone who also wants martyr crowns and has been dipped in the holy waters in baptism.

SPEAKER_03Okay, what else? Well, I don't get what else. Oh, look at her. She got a flat nose. What? Some of it actually. No, no, but you don't understand. Kinky hair. It's going to be hard for you to understand. What are you talking about? Like, really, actually, what are you talking about? It's really weird. It's really weird. Yeah, okay, I get it. Most of the people that I go to church with currently in this setting also share, let's call it a phenotype. I get it already. Also, so what? Because there's a million people around. I never know who I'm going to bump into.

SPEAKER_03How would I use this as a serious suggestion as per who I should marry? It's just... I struggle, bro, with this. I'm so glad that we can talk about it. It's a big problem right now, though, because men want identity. I get that part. But, guys, you're orthodox. Don't worry. No?

SPEAKER_00I agree 100 percent. And I think you touched on something that Joel Webb in his debate relied on a lot. And that's this is another, I guess, debate tactic. Things to look out for when you're having these discussions with people is like a retreat to an abstraction. So it's avoiding concrete language and going to abstractions instead. And I wish maybe Ruslan could have pushed Joel more on. He would talk about. And maybe Ruslan actually did, now that I think about it a little bit, did push it back a little bit on this idea of, well, there are cultural differences between races that may add undue

stress to a

SPEAKER_00marriage. I don't know if that's how he worded it, but that was the general concept. And Ruslan made the point that he said, like, look, I am Armenian. White. My wife is black. We grew up in like the same economic class. We grew up in a similar evangelical setting. I have a lot more in common culturally with her than I do with somebody who is Armenian or white from a really, really high economic class or from a really, really low economic class. So there's more that goes into it than just race.

And they really retreated to the abstraction of like, Oh, there'll be cultural differences.

SPEAKER_00Well, like what are the cultural differences?

SPEAKER_03Thank you. Thank you.

SPEAKER_00What are they? Thank you. This is really important. Point it out.

SPEAKER_03Yeah. And what I like about what you're doing right now is we can get into the scripture on this. I don't have a problem with that, but if you watch that debate and I recommend you guys do it for a little while anyway, but what, what I kept noticing is, is if you, everything stopped with basically the book of James. Like I kept pointing to like, you know, St. John Chrysostom is actually from North Africa on some level. Like he, like so many of our saints are brown.

SPEAKER_03Like the categories aren't correct. And even when the Ethiopians who took Orthodoxy so early, I mean, there were Christians, there were African Christians way before they were European Christians. You know what I mean? Yeah. going all the way West, the Spanish were Christians way after the Ethiopians. I mean, come on, man, what are we doing? But my point is, is I, I could draw on like literally the face of the icons, like in my own house to go like, Oh, well there's a Brown one and there's a black one.

SPEAKER_03It, it, it, it didn't land. It can't land with us. If we take our face seriously, that race question, don't get me wrong. We all notice it. It's a real thing. As everybody knows on this channel, I married a black woman from Harlem. Like I get it already. There's real questions to be had there, but the idea that that would not be normative, it's just so odd. It's so odd. I'm so glad we can talk about it. What do you do? And what do you do when something's,

SPEAKER_03You're angry about it in the conversation. Do you ever catch yourself going past the actual beautiful logistics of the conversation into a kind of passionate anger? Does that happen to you? sometimes but not yet in you know this uh apologetic space that i've really involved myself with i think because generally i try to keep a very calm demeanor people when i get a little bit passionate people are like oh this guy got under alex's skin or something like no what you were seeing there is enjoyment because i

do really enjoy debating and when somebody throws a curveball i think it's really

SPEAKER_00interesting and it's like It's almost like I kind of like I start salivating in a way like, OK, this is going to be like a good fight at this point. Like this is something interesting. Right. I love that. Yeah. But maybe when there was one thing that might have it didn't bug me. But there's something that I won't really accept in the Collins, which is there's this new Roman Catholic apologist. He's 15 years old, okay?

SPEAKER_00So I don't think he has any blessing from anyone. And he's not even technically old enough to be able to check the terms and conditions on Twitter. LAUGHTER And have them enforced against them. And he came into my chat, which is fine. Great. I love to have, you know, young people asking theological questions. It is far better to be having discussions about God than like the latest gossip from TMZ. Right. We should be discussing theological things.

SPEAKER_00However, when you think that as a 15-year-old, you can come to my channel and explain to me the doctrines of judicial review, somebody who has a Juris Doctor degree, and explain to me certain things, it's amazing how there's a certain archetype, I think particularly on X, of like a 15, 16, 17-year-old who... You know, it was going to save the Orthodox faith because actually origin had it all right. And we just went wayward on this.

SPEAKER_00We have to go all the way back to what origin was saying. And, you know, this one 16 or 17 year old will save orthodoxy, which is like all I have to say about that is like, look. I admire your zeal. It is very good. You need to put it in a different direction. It's crazy. That's what you need to do. You need to find a spiritual father who will actually teach you what to do with all of this energy that you have.

SPEAKER_01So good.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. So that's, I guess, one thing that might get under my skin a little bit is the overzealous younger people. But, you know, I was also that person. So I have a little bit of empathy for them.

SPEAKER_03Yeah. I would argue from having been in the classroom and teaching is that probably the best thing right then is to just slap that kid down intellectually. Just intellectually. When I had those kids in class who knew a lot about history and were trying to demonstrate and sort of kowtow me and make me think that they were that guy in my room, I would just ask them ridiculously hard questions, and they would be ridiculously shamed, and it was great.

SPEAKER_03And their parents would come in and be like... John was really upset it made him feel bad I'm like yeah because he was acting like an idiot I think I don't like making people feel bad, but there are certain times when it's really good for both of us. Probably me to assert my wisdom and age and then to have to face that shame. That's old school, right? It's okay.

SPEAKER_00Especially as a young man, I think it's very important to lose and to learn how to be a good loser. That's one thing that I enjoy about, like... My wife and I have been watching this Korean cooking show called Culinary Class Wars. And you know what I it's what I really appreciate about that Korean culture is that the winners are very gracious and so are the losers. They know how to be good losers. Right. And the way to be a bad loser is, you know, something goes wrong in a debate and then you go on Twitter and you complain about it for like the next month.

SPEAKER_00You have to move on and be like, look, Maybe there were some things I overlooked. I'm sorry, by my own standards, I underperformed, but it was a good experience for me. I learned a lot. On to the next one, right? And that's how you handle it like a gentleman.

SPEAKER_03So right now in this space, you enjoy yourself on your channel.

SPEAKER_00Oh, yes, because I think that a lot of people that there aren't many litigators that have gone into apologetics. I can think of only one other person. That would be Joe Heschmeyer, the Roman Catholic apologist who has a lawyer, JD degree, background in litigation, ended up going into apologetics work. But I think that I have a unique angle and a unique way of analyzing these things. And it's not to get too scandalous, but I sense that there was a bit of a racket going on within the apologetic sphere because I saw certain debates like I'll take,

SPEAKER_00for example. Now, again, this is just speculation. I'm not accusing anyone of like rigging boxing matches, but like applying that same principle to apologetics. It does seem to me that in that debate between Gavin Ortlund and Trent Horn, that Trent Horn pulled a lot of punches where he could have pushed a lot harder and that would have destroyed Gavin Ortlund's worldview. There was a point where Trent Horn asked the question and he said something to the effect of, is there anything that you have in common with the Christians of, let's say, up to the fourth century? And Gavin Ortlund, to his credit, he came up with one thing.

SPEAKER_00This is not to his credit, though. The one thing was usury. And I'm just over here thinking, like, are you for real? The one thing was usury. That's the one thing you have in common that you think usury is wrong. That's the one thing you have in common with the Christians up to the fourth. And I was like, man, OK, this is Trent Horn's chance. Go dismantle his entire worldview. Jump at it. There's a whole list. I'm over here salivating. Yeah. I'm over here salivating over this opportunity, and I see Trent waves it away.

SPEAKER_00I'm thinking, man, they're... This looks like a rigged boxing match where there is some sort of arrangement beforehand to be like, look, let's go about this a little soft. I'll rough you up a little bit. You rough me up a little bit. It'll be a good show. It'll be educational for everybody. We can move on. But now you have different actors that are moving into the sphere because it's been more or less democratized. You have the Jay Dyers. You have myself. You have David Erhan, these other up and coming debaters. that do not care about the racket. And we are in it for the truth.

SPEAKER_00And we are here to bring the heterodox back into the church. So that means that when we go into these debates, no, your worldview is wrong. Holy orthodoxy is the truth. And there are ways of doing that in a gentlemanly way, of course. But that doesn't mean that you lay off. It does mean that you attack when there is an opening.

SPEAKER_03Okay. Here, you want to get a little, before we get toward the end here, you want to do... Guys, stay tuned for this. This is going to be hot. You want to do... I'm going to go a different direction than you think, maybe.

SPEAKER_00Sure.

SPEAKER_03Within the church, among, I don't know, a big giant house filled with Orthodox baptized people or whatever, chrismated, there are hot topics. And I don't know where you stand on a lot of these. So on baptism... How do you argue within the House? Maybe I shouldn't even put it out there. This is what some of my OCA friends will say. Don't even bring it up. It's not for the internet. But I'm going to break the rule. I don't care.

SPEAKER_03I happen to be... I really don't like America on a lot of levels philosophically as an... Let's put it this way. As an instantiated reality in history. I'm not that into it. However... I do like that early American love of, like... things confederate not not slavery clip it everybody clip it yeah here we go oh god

of when everybody sort of had their their own little home within a home and then we they fought it out and talked about it and and it was okay to share you know on the base level your own disagreements within within the world you known as america and

SPEAKER_03i don't mind sharing with the whole world deep questions about our own faith. I think it's healthy. So baptism, what do you think the history and scripture and should we baptize Roman Catholics when they come rolling in?

SPEAKER_00That is so hard to answer as a layman, you know, because it is like very much a bishop and a pastoral question. But what I see is when I look at the acts of the councils, that there were different ways that the fathers applied this to like different types of heretics. Like I think the Monophysites were not always required to be received by by chrismation or by by baptism. There were certain exceptions for some like even before the Monophysites, what comes to mind is Actually, yes, it would be at the same time as the Monophysites,

SPEAKER_00but the Acts of Chalcedon, where there is a portion in the Acts, I want to say, session two, where they go... Don't sight check me on that one. It's in there. I don't know what... I'm not your sight check guy. Trust me. Somebody will. But they go through a list of heretics and how they are supposed to be received into the church. And the Montanists are supposed to be received one way. The Apollinarians are supposed to be received another way. And I think that within the economy of the church, the bishops have the powers to bind and loose.

SPEAKER_00And if they want to retroactively... uh ratify or affirm a baptism that occurred elsewhere uh i think that would likely be i think that's within their powers i think that's testified to within the

SPEAKER_03history of the church yeah that makes sense uh I get it. I was just watching a video of one of our field workers. First Things Foundation, if you're tuning in to see Alex, that's what I do in my life. We send people around the world to do Peace Corps-style work, but with an Orthodox chassis. I just saw one of our field workers in Georgia going into the waters on Theophany with a bunch of other people and being dunked three times in the name of the Father, Son, Holy Spirit.

SPEAKER_03I was like... That happened to me in Georgia when I was a young man there, too. And I said, did I just get... And the priest is like, whatever, just go feast right now. And I'm like... And my thought was one holy Catholic... in apostolic baptism, but you can just do it like five times. It's the same one. You see what I'm saying?

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_03Because I got dunked at least twice in Georgia on different, it's like part of the end of the feast. It's hard to explain. And not just on theophany. I did it at St. Nino's. There had been a church built in the honor of St. Nino where she first came to Georgia, you know, back in the 300s. And they were consecrating that parish. And then this is June 1st. And then everyone went into the water, Lake Paravani, and got dunked three times.

SPEAKER_03I was like... Aren't all these guys baptized? I didn't know what to think of it. And the priest kept going, don't worry about it. What's your problem? Don't worry. You're blessing. It's a blessing.

SPEAKER_00I was like, okay. Old school attitude.

SPEAKER_03So, okay. Here's another one. Is there, like, is the Lutheran church a church? Right. You know, there are different senses to the ways that you can use different words, right? So in the sense that it is an assembly, an ecclesia, an assembly of people.

SPEAKER_00Yes, it is a small C church. But I would not say that they are the one holy Catholic and apostolic church. And I think... Orthodoxy very much rejects that Calvinist-y Reformation idea of an invisible church, because we reject the idea of salvation by divine decree. In the Orthodox view, it's salvation through the sacraments, which are imbued with grace, which result in synergy with God. So in our view, it's a process of theosis.

So I don't think that we can say that any church outside of the walls of the Holy

SPEAKER_00Orthodox Church is... the church they can be a church but they are not the church yeah these are these are this is it i'm with you here's a hard one one more sure it's it's the end of a wonderful evening and you're gonna settle down and drink one drink just one with a friend maybe me and you or a set of friends or maybe even your wife what's your

SPEAKER_03drink of choice at that moment It depends on if it was a night out on the town and it fits with the atmosphere. Let's make it the very last drink. You're being executed for reasons we haven't determined yet.

SPEAKER_00Oh, man. This is a hard one.

SPEAKER_03It's just one. The last one.

SPEAKER_00Probably have to be a Guinness right from the factory in Ireland.

SPEAKER_02Oh, by the way, it does matter. I was in Ireland and it was a lot better.

SPEAKER_00You're right. It makes a difference. Yeah.

SPEAKER_03Guinness is nice.

SPEAKER_00That would probably be it. I like it. Honestly, I never liked beer. I didn't like beer. It didn't really particularly interest me. And then I had a fresh barrel. Not the whole barrel, but somebody who just opened a barrel.

SPEAKER_02I had the entire barrel.

SPEAKER_00And that was it. I knew I was going to be a lawyer ever since then. But yeah, Guinness made the difference for me there.

SPEAKER_03Because also the way it looks, it matters. It's so gorgeous watching someone pour Guinness.

SPEAKER_00That waterfall effect. Yes.

SPEAKER_03All right. Well, tell people about you if you want us to go check anything. We'll put it in the show notes. What should we do to go see you?

SPEAKER_00So I have a YouTube channel. It's just my name, Alex Sorin, where we discuss Orthodox apologetics, Orthodox theology, and we do live streams multiple times a week talking about current events, what's going on in the greater Christian space involving the heterodox and also Orthodox news. We get scholars on there. We had Father Stephen DeYoung on there recently and also Cleave to Antiquity we had on there recently and We look forward to having to having many more guests on there as well.

SPEAKER_00You can also find me on X. It's Alex Orthodoxy in the Romanian way. It's O-R-T-O-D-O-X-I-E. Alex Orthodoxy on X. It's such a great story that you were in the room with hanging with the Romanians

SPEAKER_03as Pentecostals. All that story.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, everybody just assumes that I'm cradle orthodox because they hear Romanian, and it's like, oh, well, I have a story for you, in fact.

SPEAKER_03Hey, guess what, though? You have to tell people. I'm going to tell them for you. I'm going to come on Alex's show, and I'm going to demonstrate that I actually know stuff. I'm going to do my best, okay, to be an interesting guest on your show.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I'm looking forward to it. I'm excited for it, yeah.

SPEAKER_03But you have to ask me questions. But you can talk a lot because I talk a lot. Right now I'm talking a lot.

SPEAKER_00I feel like I talked a lot. I'm looking forward to learning more about you because, you know, you're this mysterious brother of Father Peter Hears. Let it rip. Well, I looked into, you know, basic Google search before I got here and a very impressive resume and I'm eager to learning more about it.

SPEAKER_03Well, I'm thankful. I'll do my best. My problem is you can get me to say anything that's even kind of truth adjacent. It won't be hard, but I look forward to it. No, your name keeps coming up, and I'm thankful to have you on here, and hopefully people get something out of all this. In the end, you know what? We're just... Something was given to us and we're hoping we're sharing the good parts. So may it be so. That's right.

SPEAKER_03All right, brother. God bless you, man. Great to have you on here. And we'll talk again soon.

SPEAKER_00Thank you very much.

SPEAKER_03Well, sorry. I clipped over that. Give me that again. Thank you very much.

SPEAKER_00Thank you very much.

SPEAKER_03Doesn't matter. We probably won't edit it. Just in case. Okay. Here's the deal. Do you ever like have a friend and you go, that guy's smart. Well, Alex is smart. It's good having him on. It's good having him come here because when he does, he supports our work. Guys, check us out at first-things.org. Go check it out online. We do Peace Corps style poverty alleviation, but without the Peace Corps mess. We send our people, men and women, to go for two years.

SPEAKER_03Three years is now a contract option. And you learn the local language, you learn the local culture, and you immerse long enough so you can see all around you and identify amazing people that have great ideas. We call those people impresarios. And when we find them, our job is to facile, to make facile easier their vision of a better life. I think it's Christian. I don't think so. I know it. Because I got 10 years of doing this.

SPEAKER_03I can't believe it's 10 years. Guys, support our work by becoming a monthly donor. We got a field school. You're thinking about maybe a kid needs a good six weeks away, go learning about a foreign culture in a very, very, very deep way. In other words, at the level that normal everyday people live. You know, not in hotels and riding around in fancy buses. Come on, man. Who wants to go see a country like that? If you want to send your kid, we got the First Things Foundation Field School. It's opening up this summer. We're going to Georgia.

SPEAKER_03And we're working with one of our impresarios there. Amazing trip. If you're interested, write me. Love you. Peace out.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Demons, Deception, and Why Your Spiritual Practices Might Be Dangerous

    Oct 2, 20261 hr 18 minAudio

    Find this episode on YouTube: "Justine Alter" - a pseudonym - returns to chat with John Heers in a raw Heavy Things Lightly conversation you have to hear to believe.Justine worked for years as a professional psychic,...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. The Fox News Reporter Who Quit to Live an Orthodox Homesteading Life

    Sep 25, 20261 hr 35 minAudio

    Find this episode on YouTube: Holly Hickman went from Columbia Journalism and Fox News Radio covering NASA and the 2008 election - to milking cows, making cheese, and converting to Orthodoxy.In this episode of Heavy...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Why They Left NASA to Start St. George's Classical Academy

    Sep 21, 20261 hr 2 minAudio

    Can you teach kids the truth AND prepare them for a secular world?On this episode of Heavy Things Lightly, host John Heers talks with James and Juliana Joyce, founders of St. George's Classical Academy in Boxford,...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. An Odyssean Tale: The Man Who Would Not Quit

    Sep 4, 20261 hr 37 minAudio

    Find this episode on YouTube: Crow walked America searching for his father - and found the Father.From West Virginia hollers to LA gangs, from wolves in the Mojave desert to an Orthodox cross, this is an Odyssean tale...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. From Broadway to the Supra: Carrie Manolakos on Life After Lockdown

    Sep 1, 20261 hr 51 minAudio

    Welcome to the first episode of “Save Me a Spot at the Supra” on Heavy Things Lightly where John Heers hosts singer and Broadway performer Carrie Manolakos (best known for her performances in Mama Mia! and Wicked) at...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode