Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Heavy Things Lightly

Heavy Things Lightly artwork

Wrestling the Tech Monster: James Poulos

Feb 27, 20261 hr 1 minAudio
  • Apple Podcasts

Find this episode on YouTube: Reupload** The internet spirits inhabited our audio on the previous upload - we think we have it fixed this time around.John and James tackle the modern technology empire that seems to be consuming all of us. James sums it up pretty well during our convo: "...we are all slowly becoming cyborgs."James Poulos is the Editor of The American Mind and author of multiple books including The Art of Being Free and Human Forever. He is also the host of Zero Hour at BlazeTV which will be returning soon.Zero Hour: https://www.blazetv.com/series/tHP3lVDtMZku-zero-hour-with-james-poulos?channel=seriesConrad's Deli - The best jerky you'll ever have: https://conradsdeli.com/ use promo code "FIRST THINGS" for 10% off.------------------------------------------------------------------------------✒ Substack: https://johnheersftf.substack.com/ⓧ https://x.com/johnfromftf🍷The best dinner party you've ever experienced - Supra Dinner Society: https://supradinner.com/🏖️ Tailormade tours that give back: https://www.gratitude-travels.com/home🔎 Discover the non-profit behind Heavy Things Lightly: https://first-things.org/ ✈ Become a Field Worker with FTF: https://first-things.org/opportunities📢 First Things Telegram: https://t.me/firstthingsfoundation🥂 Keipi Restaurant: https://keipirestaurant.orgPlease leave a review with your comments! Your support keeps this podcast alive and allows us to broaden our discussion. ---This “Enlightened” New World utopia isn’t turning out to be all it was cracked up to be. Society is disenchanting, but are the only alternatives hiding out in the hills or burying yourself in books? With an air of levity and a touch of humor, John Heers teaches how to examine the confusing New World by calling upon the mind and wisdom of oft-forgotten Old. Heavy Things, Lightly. This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit johnheersftf.substack.com/subscribe

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_00Hello. It is. I'm having a drink because I had a great talk with James Poulos, who's a philosopher. He's an author of numerous books, including The Art of Being Free. He's got a great show called The Zero Hour. New episodes coming out this year. I bumped into him again and again. He's an interesting character with a beautiful pen. He writes wonderfully.

SPEAKER_00Today, he walks us through this thing called technology. And we figure out a lot about technology. You know what? It's never just going to be clean. There are no clean answers. And that brings me to this drink and to our sponsors. There they are. I'm holding it up. Conrad's Jerky Company in Pennsylvania. That's right. They sponsor us. And by the way, when you buy it, you donate to First Things Foundation.

SPEAKER_00Just like when you come to our restaurant, it's a donation. You see, we're involved in all kinds of ways. We're not just sitting around. I love Andrew and his family. We're getting together soon for a Supra. They're up in Pennsylvania. He reached out. And guess what? Small family doing small business and making beauty happen all around. Support them. You can see the link here. Conrad's Jerky Company. Support our sponsor by supporting us. Or vice versa, however you want to do it.

SPEAKER_00Today, James Poulos on Heavy Things Lightly. All right, James, it's good to have you here. We're getting to know each other, but we met earlier in the year in England. Well, last year. And now we get to talk to you about important stuff. But tell us what you're doing. You have so much stuff. I'm just trying to figure out in terms of time and chronologically, where are you right now? What's going on with you?

yeah well you know um i really didn't feel like becoming transhuman so i decided to become transmedia instead so um so season three of uh of the talk show zero hour is

SPEAKER_02uh as of this moment about to come roaring back um You know, it was a show that was kind of conceived as like the oh no, what is happening to us show. And then we suddenly came out on the other end of another Trump administration. And all the vocabulary changed and kind of the menu of things to think about changed. And...

And I wanted to make sure that the show reflected those changes in a way that made

SPEAKER_02things, I don't know, hopefully, you know, a little bit more, a little bit, a few more rays of sunshine.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I was going to say.

SPEAKER_02You know, uh, yeah. So, uh, so I'll probably be spending a little bit more time, um, on the show talking about, uh, things that I'm calling golden age problems. Uh, a lot of talk about the golden age, you know, uh, can we have nice things? Um, and the idea, uh, and this is a book that's, uh, that's sitting on an editor's desk right now waiting for the editor to do what editors do. Yes. Um, so, uh, that'll, that'll probably drop, um, sooner rather than later this year, I think.

SPEAKER_02Uh, so yeah, you know, so, so let's say the dog catches the car. Uh, let's say we, we get what we think we want. Um, let's say that the technologists, um, deliver on some of their promises. Um, uh, then what, you know, um, I think, I think many people have, um, we talked about this a little bit in the In the nightmare scenario, I'm the victim,

SPEAKER_02I'm the anarchist, I'm the dissident, I'm the criminal, the canceled, the downtrodden. We've all seen those movies, all the dystopian movies. We know what the bad planet looks like.

SPEAKER_00It's crazy, right?

SPEAKER_02Remarkably, regardless of what our political identities, regardless of where our faiths might be, our ideological commitments, our geographical location, everyone kind of has mastered the Nightmare Scenario script. Yeah. Few people know who we are if it doesn't go horribly wrong. Who are we in a society where things kind of start to get back into some semblance of order?

SPEAKER_00You've addressed some of your writing. Well, I think all of it at some point is sort of asking us to be more than whatever the political media is telling us, right? You have your own journey. How would you describe... what you practice in terms of your core beliefs.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, well, I can segue right into that. When we're confronted with the prospect of a golden age or a relatively happy turn of events, when we get out of that doomer mindset, we're still going to have problems. You look back in history and the few golden ages that there have been, and then even fewer when the people living in the golden age knew that they were living in a golden age. And even then, you know, we're talking like peak Byzantine Empire, peak Spanish Empire,

SPEAKER_02maybe a few others here or there. There were still problems. And in some cases, the problems were more entrenched, more severe, more challenging, more subtle, more invidious, harder to brush off. Yeah. And so I think we're really headed into a time where, you know, even the best case scenario is going to be one where we need to get better at spiritually discerning the kinds of problems that you can't just innovate your way out of existence.

SPEAKER_02So, you know, I guess it was not all that long ago when after – far too long of sort of flutzing around. Um, I was received into the Orthodox church and, uh, it's just been invaluable, you know, invaluable to, um, to expanding kind of my, my, my view of these things as they unfold, uh, and then disciplining, you know, narrowing in some ways, you know, it just, as you have an idea, it doesn't mean it's a good idea. So just heightening that up.

SPEAKER_00Do you, do you have, so, um, you have this pattern of being in the media. Like you have great books and insight and you're a philosopher. And now that you've become like Orthodox or whenever that started to happen to you, do you worry that when you say, yeah, that's what I am, do you think people take your work less seriously? No, that's because of that. Do you sense that? Yeah. They write you off once they find out you're orthodox or whatever.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, it's always a risk. I've had some people who will remain nameless say, oh, be careful, you could narrow your audience. And in the old media landscape, you didn't want to narrow your audience. In today's media landscape, even some of the most... Relentlessly secular kind of analysts or industry people in the media space are like, you will not break through unless you first niche down is what I call it.

SPEAKER_02So some of that is a bad thing. The internet is very relentless at just creating a sort of taxonomy of all possible variations and then trying to find people to sort of fill smaller and smaller cubbyholes. You know, it's just kind of a pigeonholing machine. And that's, you know, that's not ideal. Niche down. That's so fascinating. Yeah. Right. And in other ways, you know, this is kind of like what happens to identity politics.

SPEAKER_02Well, you know, it can be sort of flipped into this sort of economic system instead of a political system. You know, the way that you kind of survive and... And categorize yourself is the thing that unlocks economic opportunities for you is turning yourself into like a member of this little, you know, it's bigger than a polycule, but smaller than a clan, you know, and that's kind of who you are. And the more that you are that and the more that you perform that,

SPEAKER_02the more legible you are to your own people and people on the outside. And so I think there is this pressure to become a sort of caricature or a parody. of yourself or this micro identity that you subscribe to in order to try to be legible and visible, instantly recognizable, um, on the internet. Uh, you know, at the same time, um, there is, there is a, an upshot to that, which is if you are a member of a relatively, uh, obscure, um, uh,

SPEAKER_02church tradition, um, it's, it's growing, uh, orthodoxy in America. Thank God. Um, Um, but you know, many people are sort of like, is that the Russian thing or the Greek thing or whatever?

SPEAKER_01Um,

SPEAKER_02it doesn't have the kind of, uh, uh, whiff of irrelevance to it that, um, that maybe it did, uh, you know, even, even 10 years ago. Well, because of the internet, I think.

SPEAKER_00It plays a big role, yeah. Partially, anyway. It helps to have an ancient lineage. It helps to actually go back and be able to say things about your church that are 1,500 years old, 2,000 years old. It's a weird combo of being brand new and really old. I find that I was doing a super last night dinner for a new guy who's going to Columbia for us, and his people were Lutherans.

SPEAKER_00So it meant half the table was Lutheran. He's a new convert to Orthodoxy. Half were Orthodoxy. A couple were just like. And watching them, first of all, they're wrestling with their son having become something odd. But then watching them wrestle with sort of the ethos of the table as sort of this old medieval toasting liturgy, it's really cool. Because I find Americans don't reject it.

SPEAKER_00They kind of have a sense for it because it's Christian, the whole orthodox ethos, but they don't. They don't reject it. There are a few who will bang on it theologically, like you have icons or idolatrous and that kind of thing. But let me ask you this. Do you think – okay, so here's – I've got a degree from Columbia, a master's degree. You've got Georgetown, Duke. Yeah.

SPEAKER_00All that stuff is a type of peace state, a way of knowing. It used to be cool to say those things. Now I'm inclined to go, maybe I went to Columbia a little bit. Yeah, I did. Okay. And also, I'm a convert to Orthodoxy. And that's actually cooler now than citing my credentials. Are you finding that as a public intellectual? Yeah.

SPEAKER_02It's pretty interesting. When I was in grad school, my dissertation committee chair, Josh Mitchell, he's just an incredible guy in so many ways. He said, James, academia is the last feudal institution. Find your feudal lord, he will protect you. And that was true, certainly, at the time in my experience. Yeah. But, you know, that was 2008.

And now, in every new years, you know, every vestige of the kind of medieval... Christian imprint that was left on the university has been beaten out of just so many schools. It's been relentlessly modernized in so many ways, and even postmodernized just a little bit.

SPEAKER_02But it's been interesting, you know, it's been interesting to see feudalism sort of return to society. And for many people, that's like a scary thing that they don't understand and has connotations of, you know, being reduced to a status of serfdom, of benighted ignorance. The Jeffersonian spirit in America is very uncomfortable with anything medieval. But if you read your McLuhan, you will see that digital retrieves the medieval and it doesn't

have to be that

SPEAKER_02scary. There are some okay things about feudalism, and you don't have to be a sort of papist or monarchist reactionary in order to see and to understand that what we call the Middle Ages is centuries and centuries and centuries, and you can even break them up into the early, middle,

SPEAKER_00and late.

SPEAKER_02And it wasn't all nightmare fuel. It wasn't all the year that the giant... Volcano destroyed the crops and it wasn't the, you know, the 14th century, you know, Barbara Tuchman wrote, uh, what was it? A distant mirror and it was sort of like complete. It wasn't all that. Um, it wasn't all the bubonic plague. It wasn't all black death. Yeah, no, no, no. And I think, you know, when you look at what's popular on the internet, when you look at what the popular sort of internet games are,

SPEAKER_02I mean, Farm Simulator, you know, it's right up there. It's crazy and true. So crazy. So much of what, you know, what the kids are doing on the internet is farming. Point farming, aura farming, like farming has become a sort of everyday life metaphor for what you do on the internet. But they won't be able to own any actual land because it's all getting bought up already. Yeah, you know, it seems that way, but there's still a lot of land out there.

SPEAKER_02And, you know, I know enough guys who are not that young anymore, but Their experience was, you know, was logging on and gaming and putting in the hours and doing the grind and farming the points and whatever and leveling up and then starting to realize, like, I could do this in my real life. And what, you know, what would the rewards, what would the benefits be if I did that? Yeah. So I would not be stunned if some of these Gen Zs and Alphas

got a thought in their

SPEAKER_02minds or parts that said, like, maybe farming for real. Why not that? I see it all the time because of this dinner we've gotten involved with as per our

SPEAKER_00work at First Things. It's wild because everybody assumes because I'm orthodox. and restaurant adjacent that I'm also right on the verge of farm to table or some kind of crazy menu choices that are, you know, like pure food or whatever. But I'm not that way at all. But I noticed that is the milieu. That is where people want to go. They really... Let me ask you this.

SPEAKER_00So you've written about the Tocqueville... And let's call it the farming century of America, because let's just admit the 19th century is like the farming century. But we were like coherent. We were really maybe decentralized compared to after the Civil War. But the United States could claim to have been, you know, farmers and commoners. And so do you think right now that there's a tug back toward that,

SPEAKER_00not only because it's romantic and it's also probably healthy, but also because there's a fear of tyranny? Like, how are you reading the politics with Trump and Is he becoming a type of kingly figure because we're already that and then he's reflecting who we are? Or is he going in a way where we're not going? We're like, hold on a minute. Hold on a second. Or do you even think he's not that kingly figure? How are you reading our politics given that kind of context?

SPEAKER_02Yeah, it's hard to say. I mean, it's hard to get the farmer out of the American consciousness,

SPEAKER_01you know,

SPEAKER_02even like a state like California, which seems just so far from that. I mean, really, its cultural DNA is oaky. You know, it's just dumb farmers hitting the road and just going until they can't go. There's nowhere else to go except into the ocean. That's true. Not pejorative. I mean, look at what those Okies managed to do with Southern California. Create a paradise that is still the envy of much of the country. So you got the farmer thing, then you got the rancher thing. I mean,

the cowboy isn't just kind of the gunslinger and the guy who's out there just kind

SPEAKER_02of spitting into the breeze or whatever. It's campfire culture. And when you talk about your experience with the Supra and how something that seems... You know, in some ways more akin to like Knights of the Round Table or the Knights Templar than to, you know, your drive-through McDonald's experience. Right. It is evocative of campfire culture.

SPEAKER_01No doubt.

SPEAKER_02One or two people there kind of know exactly where they are. You know, you're getting loud. You're telling stories. It's very oral culture. Someone's got a guitar. You know, you're shooting things. You're throwing things into the fire that shouldn't go in the fire. And you're having a great time. That's true. So, that's all. You know, it's hard to get rid of. Yeah. And it's ironic when you think about all the commercialism that swept so much of that kind of rural experience of leisure,

SPEAKER_02hard, hard work during the day, and then leisure, leisure, leisure at night. So much of that stuff, so much of the brands – uh fell back on on royal metaphors in order to sell their products you know donald trump included uh you think of a guy like don king or you think like burger king or you think of like in new york city you know papaya king was like such a big deal for a while that they had a secret speakeasy in the that you could only access

SPEAKER_00through the back a hot dog speakeasy yes that's

SPEAKER_02Right. Yeah. And, you know, the the the like auto dealerships, you know, the king of this, the king of that, the king of queens, like so much of that monarchical stuff. Or you think of like Louisiana politics, you know, the kingfish, like all that stuff is very much in the parlance of of even high modern America. And, uh, and it, you're, you're seeing Donald Trump really just step into that and, and inhabit it. Does that mean I think that Americans actually want a King?

SPEAKER_02Um, well, you know, you, you need a figure who was really capable of receiving the acclaim of a super majority of Americans. Yeah. And I don't think we're going to get that.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. It's a great point.

SPEAKER_02Just don't. So, you know, we can, we can dream on and we can enjoy our sort of, you know, our fantasy King. I mean, fantasy football draft Kings, like all this stuff is just like in the mix, man. So it'll be interesting to see that kind of, A newfound appreciation for royalty and monarchy, but maybe not in a political context. Maybe more in that sort of cultural context or in business. I think a lot of guys who are looking for a way out of the

grind that is a sort of

SPEAKER_02decayed version of what their parents... ground their way through. They see tech as a way of just kind of climbing out of that and the guys who run these corporations as these sort of kingly figures. And that, you know, I can see how that would be a big attraction.

SPEAKER_00Well, maybe, yeah, I was never this way when I would come back from this work from places that were really medieval, like West Africa, the Georgia Republic. A lot of these places are medieval in their cultural milieu. By the way, that's a compliment on some level. But when I would come back, what I did notice about America, even with my own life with this organization, is entrepreneurship is like baked in. Like the idea that I'm going to go over the hill and figure stuff out,

SPEAKER_00and then when you see me again, I will have built a little kingdom out of a business. Like that's really baked in. And I kind of like it. I think there's some problems because it leads to sort of market worship. On some level, the Chinese, the Han, used to say the merchants were dangerous because they had no allegiance except for the margins, profit margins. So they're scary people on some level because they're acquiring power and have maybe no true ideological direction. But when I come to the States, I feel that freedom when I come home.

SPEAKER_00I do feel that freedom. I wonder if you think... Do you think that tech will allow for more small business? Let's say small, let's call it freedom. Or is it, where is it going right now? You've written a lot about it. Like, is this tech, is it just like the same as the Babylonian tech that we had? You know, in the sense that it's dangerous in the same way it was, you know, 4,000 years ago, or can it really afford a freedom for us?

SPEAKER_00Like, is it good? Yeah. there are always perils and many of them are the same you know the same gosh darn perils that they were 4 000 years ago um if you uh build the tower of babel in 2027 and expect a different result than the one that was built the first time around don't be surprised if you get the same result um so what has changed right uh what

SPEAKER_02has really changed um And I think the answer to that, you know, I've given a lot of thought, maybe too much thought, especially over the past year to this question of like, well, you know, but what's really going to happen? You know, you study this to what it's really. And people really want an answer. You know, they want to know if we're going to hell on Earth or heaven on Earth. And I think it's very important to just resist that. Both of those desires,

SPEAKER_02the desire to either, you know, I know exactly what's going to happen and that's a good thing or that's a bad thing. America is unlike other countries and other civilizations. Yes, we're all human beings. Yes, still on planet Earth. Of course, there are underlying similarities that we're not going to be able to escape. I mean, look at us today. We're sort of cyborgs right now. We're kind of just hobbling down the road to some kind of transhumanist something

SPEAKER_02or other in many ways. But the similarities shine through. So what's really different is we haven't had a country like the United States of America. okay um we haven't had uh this sort of you know democracy this is a republic but it's got oligarchic features and it was sort of an empire but it's obviously not an empire but it acts sort of like like this is a crazy mixed up regime with crazy mixed up people continental power in the new world unprecedented in so many ways the technology the weaponry um the very unified in some ways

extremely fractured in

SPEAKER_02others um But not, you know, not tribal in the way that any European could really understand. A very unique and strange place that defies prediction. America's very open to analysis, you know, especially to French for some reason. Tocqueville did it. Jean Baudrillard just brilliantly, you know, updated Tocqueville. Paul Virilio, René Girard. I mean, it's a long list of these French guys who...

SPEAKER_02Who just kind of saw what was going on in the 80s. And here we are living in that world. Nevertheless, it is very hard to predict where exactly we're going to end up in five years. Are you hopeful? Is this what this year has been about? You have to be hopeful, right? You have to be hopeful. And a huge part of hope, I think the most difficult part of hope for many people and sometimes even for myself is trusting amid the uncertainty,

SPEAKER_02amid at the point where you apply all of your faculties, all of your experience, all of your reason, all of the tools at your disposal, your network, your experience, whatever. And you're like, It's not like there's some fate out there that's waiting to be discovered. There's always hope. There's always free will. And God is always in control. And when you put all those things together, I think it's really going to pay dividends to accept the fact

that we do not know

SPEAKER_02exactly where we're going. Okay.

SPEAKER_00So here's the deal. You helped me. Okay. Because, well, first of all, let's make a toast. I don't know if you have a drink. You can fake it if you do.

SPEAKER_02Obviously, just pure ouzo right here.

SPEAKER_00That's perfect. That's perfect. Because I didn't forget to make a toast. I just want to. Because you helped me, brother, because... I love a good spiral. Like, I can do it. I'm kind of happy about it. I kind of want to make all my spirals into a comedy routine because in the end, they all kind of land and they're dark and funny. Yeah. What you said is truly Christian. I was just listening to the Senexarian for St.

SPEAKER_00Seraphim of Seraphim. The guy gets beat up to the point of death and he's like, yeah, it's a good thing. I'm going to grow from this. And he spends the rest of his life basically in heaven, like while on earth and transporting himself in ways that are like no one could understand. Uncreated light, just shining. So why wouldn't we be? Thank you for reminding me with your... Your spirit there. So a toast to something like, it kind of doesn't matter, gut. We'll be okay. Or we'll choose to rely on our dumb human reptilian brain.

SPEAKER_00How about that? To being okay on some level, to hope in this country. God more jokes. God more jokes.

SPEAKER_02And of course, you know, that's not to minimize the extreme anxiety and dismay that so many people feel. You know, oh, Trump is going to disclose the aliens. They're actually Nephilim. They're actually sea demons. They're, you know, it's over for us. Galactic Federation. It can be. It's a lot. You know, you don't need acid in 2026 to go on. Right. That's a psychedelic experience.

SPEAKER_02Um, the kind of experience that until recently you could only enjoy as, um, you know, someone who was kind of performing a psyop on someone or someone who is on the receiving end. And now that's kind of everyday life. And yeah, that's, that's a mess.

SPEAKER_00But how old are you? Um, can I ask that? Am I allowed to do that? 46 years old. Yeah. So I got 10 years on here in a little bit and, um, Isn't it crazy how, if you had said these things in our youth, I'm talking like youth, youth, when we were 10 or something, or 15, 15. Like, it's just like a joke. I mean, it was a flat world. And you were worried like, you know, like Reaganomics.

SPEAKER_00That was like the hot topic. And I'd be like battling over Reaganomics in my freshman year in college or something. But now, yeah, you just brought in the sea creatures. You brought in, you know, the Nephilim. And it seems possible that this is all possible.

SPEAKER_02Yeah. That's medieval mindset too. Yeah, that's true. And I think so much of what the pain that is being experienced is one version of the American dream was that it would be high noon in modernity forever. It would just be peak modernity and it would just be the lamp of reason and incremental, unidirectional, cumulative progress uh linear time um ancient hatreds that's just you know stuff

get rid of those husband of history they can never come back you know the the boogeyman no longer exists and it's this kind of delightfully disenchanted world where um you know

SPEAKER_02everything is is kind of additive and and numerical and uh And we all live happily ever after. And technology has now advanced to a point where philosophy cannot acquit itself of the charges of irrelevance that technology is beginning to mount against it. Same thing for nature, right? Same thing for unaided human reason. Same thing for humanity.

These things that modernity relied on as self-evident foundations are not looking

SPEAKER_02so self-evident anymore. And people are suddenly going like, well, wait a minute, you know, but if I'm not going to – I was just in Las Vegas writing something for the magazine for Frontier. And Vegas is at this sort of weird crossroads where it's like, okay, well, people aren't drinking as much. They're not as social. They're not really going to the strip club. So much of what made Vegas Vegas in that high modern way is now

just kind of coming

SPEAKER_02under question. And I was sitting there floating in the hot tub, as I love to do, just kind of, you know, gazing out upon this bizarre fantasy land that has been created in the desert, very postmodern in that sense, but very high modern in terms of what the actual, you know, what are you supposed to be doing out there? Mm-hmm. It's not, what are you doing after the orgy? It's the orgy of consumption. That's right. Bright lights, forget what time it is. You know, everything's open all the time. And so it is with Vegas.

So it is for a lot of Americans going like, given technology's advancement, And given what human functions and habits are seemingly becoming irrelevant or

SPEAKER_02obsolete or unjustifiable or not worth the trouble, what am I going to do with myself? What am I going to do with my time? And it's very interesting to me because, you know, the church asks these same questions. Mm-hmm. isn't that really the best usage of your time? You know, you got one shot here. And what you do is taking place in this kind of linear time, but it's also going to echo throughout eternity.

SPEAKER_02And this is a time where judgment is going to lead to forgiveness, but you know, that's not how it's always going to be. So, so are you really going to just kind of Lose yourself in labor that gets you money maybe, but doesn't get you spiritual treasure. Entertainment that seems fun at the time, but you kind of forgot even what you were doing and what it felt like. Both technology in the church are throwing people who are kind

of accustomed to

SPEAKER_02losing track of themselves amid the habits of maternity. All this being called into question. And so in one sense, that's a good thing. It's overdue. These are questions people ought to be asking themselves anyway. Yeah. But in another sense, we're going to need some answers. You know, the Byzantines didn't all disappear into the desert in the monastery. The Spanish during their golden age, you know, people still did things, lots of different kinds of things.

SPEAKER_02And if... Human beings don't do a bunch of different kinds of things. You know, the uniformity, conformity, standardization to excess never works out very well. It's good to have that kind of that spiritual diversity.

SPEAKER_00It's a beautiful way to think about it. Somehow, in some way, despite the technology, despite... the bigness and globalism of it all, there's still just gonna be human beings on a given day interacting with one another and choosing to act. The most human of all things is to sit together. They did that always. And then in the sitting together, it's like seed and soil, something was born.

SPEAKER_00It might have been something simple, but spiritually edifying. And that's going to be there on some level, even unto death. I'll be sitting with someone, maybe even as I choose to not conform, and I'm being killed. There's something so beautiful about the simplicity of that all that at least as I get older now, It helps me with the technology, but I play around with it. I'm in it. I'm not a purist. I don't have a bunker. I don't operate like that.

SPEAKER_00We got to do something. I like what you're saying. The Byzantines had culture, man. They were doing stuff. It wasn't all monastic. Do you think orthodoxy has a role to play in the end as per like actually getting into what we'd call Western culture or is it always an outlier or do you care? Is it not something you think about?

SPEAKER_02No, I think it's certainly going to become – let's say very helpful to people who understand that they're disintegrating because of the identity that they inherited and are looking for a way to reintegrate themselves. Um, the thing that I'm, I'm most concerned about since we haven't really talked about the, the Oogie scary stuff,

SPEAKER_02um, One of the things that- That size scares us. Yeah, you know, one of the things that our technology does really well is simulate. We're building these sort of automated simulators. You could prompt them and they can simulate very well. And so much of where people think the value is in a, what we call AI, is in the possibility of infinite simulation, world simulation, simulation from the very tiniest, you know, from the micro, micro, microcosms to enormous,

SPEAKER_02you know, to the degree that the map becomes larger than the territory. And to the degree that... uh is like one of those u2 songs right uh even better than the real thing um that's kind of the the anti-holy grail is um is not looking for you know for the the life-giving spirit but looking for um something that's even better than the real thing you know even better than salvation even better than the

church um and you

SPEAKER_02know where tech can go very wrong and is in the direction of simulating what it is that the church provides and what it offers. That's helpful. And yeah, so to the degree that tech is helping people understand things that they should have understood anyway by now, and it's throwing them into... Such an acute awareness that when they take a look at the church, they go, oh, maybe organized religion isn't such a bad thing after all.

Maybe this isn't the thing that I should fear the most and then deal with all the

SPEAKER_02problems in my life that result from whatever organized religion is, I'm going in the opposite direction. That's good. But to the degree that tech becomes a kind of super alternative to the church, a kind of mirror of the church that says, hey, it's going to simulate all the great stuff about community and feeling good and improving yourself and not doing anything. things that some mean person wants you to do and takes your

feelings seriously and

SPEAKER_02brings people together and you can radiate this incredible light. But it gives you all the bad things, all the struggle, all the suffering, all the asceticism, all the just having to put up with your neighbor, having to love your enemy, having to accept that You're going to get older and maybe not look the way that you want to look anymore. Like all that kind of stuff. We'll fix that. We'll just wipe that out. That is where you do, I think, get into the more apocalyptic territory.

And I would like for all of us to make an effort to have nice things in the sense of –

SPEAKER_02Finding the balance, finding the harmony, understanding the wisdom of that little word symphonia, which is usually applied in orthodox political theology to church and state, where the point isn't to have a strong church and a strong state. It's to have a healthy state and a healthy church. And when you have healthy church and healthy state, one doesn't eat the other. They're in harmony. There's symphonia. Yeah. To have that kind of thing with technology taking on such a larger role in our

SPEAKER_02daily existence, it We really don't want to be calling in the airstrikes on the data centers, right? We really don't want to get to the point of a civil war or Terminator style. We don't want that. That's going to unleash such tremendous suffering. It's going to turn this very large country, which can be like a blank canvas to so many people, into just a projection screen for the worst nightmares.

SPEAKER_00Well, two things. that is a perfect so again very helpful because simulation we can actually we can name that it doesn't have to be that AI does that it doesn't have to be that it does that it's sort of like porn I'm not sure we have to have porn that's something we can point at and go no You don't get to do that.

SPEAKER_00But for me, for the church, the thing you don't get to do and that seems bad and you're like naming this type of tech is very dangerous is Bishop Maxim, a Serbian bishop, at a presentation out west, he said, I don't know about all these, you know, your specialty. I don't know about the tech, but I do know one thing. It doesn't seem like we should ever have a camera in the church showing liturgy to anybody on the outside. He said, I would say that's not good as a type of simulation of the

liturgy scene.

SPEAKER_00And that stuck with me. That was two or three years ago he said that. And I get we're trying to help old folks or whoever can't come to church, but it does seem like it's the beginning of a type of simulation that is in the spirit of what you just claimed is pretty dangerous.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, it's certainly difficult. I mean, I remember, you know, when COVID happened and the lockdowns and, you know, churches had different approaches to this. But there was in some, certainly some parishes, a strong desire to just put the camera off so that parishioners could remain in contact. Yeah. You know, there's a longing for a law to just say, it's got to be this.

SPEAKER_02I know. I fall for it. But, you know, it is going to be messier. And I think it's going to be messier all up and down the line with the technology where – People want daddy to say yes to this and no to that. I know.

SPEAKER_00I know.

SPEAKER_02If you're in a democracy or a republic or whatever, if you are not taking a legalistic, juridical understanding of how church life and political order works, Um, ought to dance together. Um, then, you know, the, the, the, the place to begin is, should I do X? Yeah. You know, look at where I am, look at who's around me. Um, how do I know what to do? Well, I started my own heart and I work my way out from there slowly.

SPEAKER_02Um, That might be messier or clumsier or more frustrating than looking up to the god emperor or the Caesar or the hope to say it is this. But that's kind of the other big threat that technology will offer to us if we're willing to take it is just the idea of that kind of simplicity. Where, you know, oh,

SPEAKER_02people are so dumb and slow and awkward and, you know, all this kind of forgiveness and struggle and, you know, one step forward, two steps back. That sucks. You know, we need something that's cleaner and faster and that you can rely on so that we don't have to worry about today. We can put all of our worry into tomorrow. And that is the opposite of what the Lord wants. tells us to do, which is, hey, you know, there are cares and worries of the day and they're sufficient

to that day.

SPEAKER_02So don't, you know, don't try to perfect today so that we can put all of our obsessions into tomorrow and tomorrow and tomorrow. Keep it, keep it a day at a time.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, this is great. This is, it's just, it just simplifies everything. You know, okay, can I do a two second rant though? But the forces that, that aren't taking it day to day. I love it. It's just true. It's also, it simplifies your life. And it is, it's a Christian way to go. But the problem is, it's like our big institutions, both those that we know about, like the State Department,

SPEAKER_00and then those that we don't really know about, the CIA and everything that's going on, they have like the opposite idea, which is let's get control of all the big... Anytime we get a technology, the DOD's already figured it. They are doing the opposite. It's never about today. It's always about the next thing. And I just... For me, this is what happens. A lot of young men who I talk to through this, because of this podcast, but also because of our work, they kind of know what I just said to be true and they want to

fight or they want

SPEAKER_00to be angry or they want to demonstrate like a willingness to, to win against that thing. And I always say, I don't think we do that as Christians. I think we're not really meant to try to sort that out unless you've been given that opportunity through power. Somehow you got the power. I think you're meant to die and, to the idea that you're going to control everything, and instead you're meant to live in the space of loving your neighbor.

SPEAKER_00One of the things I always want to ask guys like you is, I think there's a type of nihilism that's really beautiful, which is none of it matters except for loving your neighbor. Do I go too far if I say that?

SPEAKER_02Well, look, you look at the monks and they sacrificed everything. They gave it all up so that they can focus full-time, as we like to say in our culture, on praying every moment of every day for the salvation of the world. That's a full-time job. And surely that can't be bad, right? Not a bad choice. Right. um sacrificing everything onto laying down your own life for uh

for those you love is obviously a a great choice you know it's a great great option to exercise um clearly you know not everyone and and even not every saint uh went that far um

SPEAKER_02To the point that some saints were heads of state. And that, you know, I think reading the lives of the saints causes a person to reflect on the fact that, you know, these are all very different kinds of people. And... And if we all go off into the woods, it's not the woods anymore.

SPEAKER_00I know. You're doing what – your words are like the way of, I think, true spiritual life, which is your words confound everything. So it's like there's these kind of saints, there's those kind of saints, there's this kind of technology, and I think some people walk away going, what the – Like, could you just give it the answer already? But I'd like it's confounding. That's how it works.

SPEAKER_02It's paradox. We have to embrace the paradox. And, um, Uh, and we have to remember that what is the impossible for man is possible with God. Um, and we have to remember that, you know, the poor are here to purify the hearts of the rich and the rich are here to, uh, support the poor. I mean, this is just stuff that's just straight out of scripture and it is paradoxical. Um, and, and it does, you know, it frustrates, uh,

the the deep-seated attachment to the idea that a written code will save us yeah it's not gonna you know these these solutions we're not living in in a in a space time where solutions are the answer it's going to be salvation and salvation is something that is mysteriously available to people whether they are emperors or

SPEAKER_02serfs or you know, work in the, the, the drive-through window in and out or whatever.

SPEAKER_01So beautiful. Sitting with that, you know, sitting with that is going to get us farther than it seems. And I know a lot of those young guys want to have agency and they fear that if they

SPEAKER_02don't rush to establish their agency, then they're going to get swept out into a sea, the likes of which we've never been swept out to before. I get it. But also, yeah, what you said is true. The executive temptation, the temptation to think that if you're not executing, then you suck, you don't matter, you're up in someone else's game. And it's tough to execute unless you have a plan. And the more that you can plan out into the future and be sure

that your plan is going to work –

SPEAKER_02the harder that you can execute. That's the mindset. And that is certainly at odds with the teaching of the God-man. I know. Not even anywhere to rest his head from one day to the next.

SPEAKER_00It's crazy. It's so beautiful, but the temptations are everywhere. There's a rumor going around. Because you're a Greek guy, right? Half Greek, so, you know. Even your half Greekness, because somehow it's happened to me, too. I'm a half, well, a quarter Greek. Whenever I say half Greek, my wife always says, look, man, your mom was Greek, but your dad wasn't. I'm like, fair point. But there's a rumor going around because of your Greekness and the law that all Greeks have to,

SPEAKER_00at some point, either own a restaurant, run a restaurant, or be restaurant adjacent to This happened to you when you had a restaurant in Asheville? Is this you or is this not you? Happy Hill Restaurant? Were you? That's not you? No. See, that's the rumor going around. One of my friends down in Florida said, I think he ran a restaurant in Asheville.

SPEAKER_02That's not you. What happened is the Greeks in my family arrived into the U.S. around, I think, 1909. Put down some roots in Chicago. And yes, started a restaurant. Okay.

SPEAKER_00So if you scratch hard enough, it's going to happen. Yeah, scratch hard enough.

SPEAKER_02A restaurant did fairly well. Maybe a little too well because a couple of heavyset Italian gentlemen came in one day when my grandfather was working the bar and said, you know, hey, this is a nice place. It could really use a jukebox though. And it's like, oh yeah, you know, good, good, good thought. Good talk. What are you drinking? And what am I drinking? Yeah. What am I drinking? Tell me what's going on in that room back there in the back. Oh, that's the storage room.

SPEAKER_02Oh, interesting. Would you say it's a particularly large storage room? Well, I guess you could say that. Well, how about this? You let us hang out in your storage room, play some cards, nice quiet evening once a week, and we'll get you a brand new jukebox you can put right off front. Uh-oh. right yeah um so uh my uh my granddad said um thanks but no thanks have a nice day talk to the hand and uh and waited for them to come back the next day and whack him

but they did not they uh they thought he was a nice guy and uh after all he was

SPEAKER_02greek not italian so they let him off the hook they did yeah they did The restaurant did not survive the depression. So, you know, it's always a mixed bag. I love this stuff. Yeah.

SPEAKER_00I do love that. We opened Capey here in Greenville, South Carolina. By the way, you got to come. And it was funny because my mother was... She was just getting ready to come to the restaurant. So her father owned a restaurant. It was called the American Cafe in Wisconsin. And he had two menus. He had the menu for when they opened to when they closed.

SPEAKER_00And then he had a little Greek menu. And when they closed, they would serve the Greek menu to people in the know and the Greeks. Because in Wisconsin, as you know, as everybody kind of knows, It wasn't that cool to be a foreigner. Like, okay, it's fine, but keep it over there. So when we started Capey, it was like a total... It had a lot of failure written all over it. We didn't know what we were doing. But she knew. It was like, and she was always that person.

SPEAKER_00She died just before we opened it. But her Greekness, it translated somehow because I really like, I really, I like being in the restaurant. Like, If I didn't have other things to do, that's probably all I would do. But I had to see if your Greekness had involved yourself in a restaurant. So I tried to be funny there. But it's kind of true.

SPEAKER_02It's kind of true. It's in there.

SPEAKER_00Well, how about this? Promise that we'll find each other at a table this year, maybe. Are you... Are you going, are you on a, tell us what you might end up, where could we find you? We're going to go look at zero hour, right?

SPEAKER_02You're going to look at zero hour. That'll be on YouTube. I mean, it is, it is on YouTube. New episodes coming soon, as they say. Cool. I'm always lurking somewhere on, on X.com, the everything app. Yeah. At James Polis. You can find books on canonic.xyz, certified orthobro, Bitcoin-powered book marketplace.

SPEAKER_02You can publish, you can buy, you can sell. Wow, that's cool. They got a couple books on there, including Human Forever. Oh, yeah, yeah, I saw that. You know, written in 2021. Read the book that's more true now than it was when I wrote it. That's a fun one. Yeah. And then let's see. Frontiers magazine. Yeah, I saw it. It's a big, luscious, large format, full color, full bleed lifestyle magazine about the American frontier.

SPEAKER_02Frontier. Where do you expect to find it?

SPEAKER_00And of course, where you would not expect to find it, too. Okay, good. I'm going to. try to invite you to a table out in LA when, in fact, there's, might even, the end of January, are you in town the end of January in Los Angeles? Yeah, I'm around. In three weeks? Mm-hmm. All right, I'm going to write you a little text. Do it. And I'll send you the info, okay? Perfect. Maybe we can get together, that'd be cool. Sounds awesome. Otherwise we could keep, we can keep going. But Andrew who runs, he runs, he owns me.

SPEAKER_00He just thinks he knows more. You guys got, you got these guys in your life, right? Andrew's out there. He's like, let's go. Like nobody listens past 45 and I always go an hour and 20. I understand. But who loves you? Like, good. Greet your family. Are you old calendar or new calendar?

SPEAKER_02I mean, I'm new calendar unless I miss something, you know?

SPEAKER_00I know. I'm old calendar unless I miss something. Yeah, it flips and flops. I know what you mean. Well, main blessings to you. Thanks, James. I really appreciate this. I've been trying to put this up for a long time. And thanks for supporting our work, too, and by coming on this show. I really appreciate it. Anytime. Okay, brother. Take care. God bless. Okay, guys. As I finish up with that conversation, again, it's...

SPEAKER_00It's ambiguous. Here's the thing. If you're of the tradition where because you took Jesus into your heart, you're saved, it doesn't feel ambiguous to you. And on many days, it doesn't feel ambiguous to me exactly where I stand vis-a-vis my God. I will say this, though. The idea that a creature with a skull that's what? I don't know, half a meter in diameter or whatever it is. I don't even know how to do math.

That a creature like me would have it all figured out because of some intellectual

SPEAKER_00choice I made. That's hilarious. Unfortunately, we've been learning over the last 400 years since the Enlightenment, since the light people have been teaching us that we could get our head around such a thing. We've been learning a lot about ourselves. And one of the things we've falsely learned is we're pretty great without God. Yeah. And that is a problem. And that is what I always say on this show is the new world hubris,

SPEAKER_00the scientific atheist, the hubris. And James is helping us in this conversation you just watched to go like, eh, it's a little bit of that. It's a little bit of this. I don't really know. That is weirdly helpful to me. We don't have to live in the space where you are the answer to all your own deep and profound questions. It's not possible. It's very anxiety-ridden. Like, remember when you tell your kid, what are you going to be when you grow up?

SPEAKER_00I used to always think, and especially when I was in Africa, I'd be like, that's a harsh question. Aren't I already somebody? Like, my name's Johnny. The last name is here. That's like an answer already. Like I am somebody. What do you mean? I want to be when I grow up. Oh, you mean how am I going to put money into my pocket? That's a weird concept. Is it that important to you that you keep asking? Because it is supposed to shape my being. It's weird.

SPEAKER_00I am a lawyer. I am a physical therapist. I am a nonprofit founder. Are you though? No, that's just something you do, man. That's like sludge philosophy. That's like, hey guys, let's talk about deep things. That's not that deep. The deeper thing is like, what is it that's in my nature that drives me toward meaning?

SPEAKER_00Why do I have such a thing in me? Doesn't seem like the praying mantis is doing that. Or it doesn't seem like ants or even my dog. My dog's not doing that at all. My dog's like, let's want to find a way to please him. Which is a beautiful thing. But meaning? I don't. Anyway, James is helping us with that. It's so good to have mine. I also want to drive you toward meaning. Maybe you need to get outside of yourself to see yourself. That's travel.

SPEAKER_00If you ever want to travel. I suggest you travel to the places where we work and gratitude travels will help you with that. So if you stay this long, gratitude travels, this means that you have to do something because this is like... This is a spiritual moment. Gratitude Travels, our friends, Jamie and Amy, they take you places and I hope you'll go. Jamie and Amy, Gratitude Travel, it's in the name. They're thankful and they donate to us as a form of gratitude

whenever you travel with them.

SPEAKER_00And they donated this year and it's working. Travel with them. You can find their link in our show notes, or you can just look it up. Gratitude Travels, Jamie and Amy. In South Africa, they're good at safaris. That's what they do. That's their expertise. If you want to go anywhere in Africa, they got your back. But they also take you to Georgia. where our guys pick you up. My guys, meaning my good friends in Georgia. That's another way to travel.

SPEAKER_00Amy and Jamie, grant you travel. Please check them out. Much love. See you soon on Heavy Things Lightly. Galmarges.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Demons, Deception, and Why Your Spiritual Practices Might Be Dangerous

    Oct 2, 20261 hr 18 minAudio

    Find this episode on YouTube: "Justine Alter" - a pseudonym - returns to chat with John Heers in a raw Heavy Things Lightly conversation you have to hear to believe.Justine worked for years as a professional psychic,...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. The Fox News Reporter Who Quit to Live an Orthodox Homesteading Life

    Sep 25, 20261 hr 35 minAudio

    Find this episode on YouTube: Holly Hickman went from Columbia Journalism and Fox News Radio covering NASA and the 2008 election - to milking cows, making cheese, and converting to Orthodoxy.In this episode of Heavy...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Why They Left NASA to Start St. George's Classical Academy

    Sep 21, 20261 hr 2 minAudio

    Can you teach kids the truth AND prepare them for a secular world?On this episode of Heavy Things Lightly, host John Heers talks with James and Juliana Joyce, founders of St. George's Classical Academy in Boxford,...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. An Odyssean Tale: The Man Who Would Not Quit

    Sep 4, 20261 hr 37 minAudio

    Find this episode on YouTube: Crow walked America searching for his father - and found the Father.From West Virginia hollers to LA gangs, from wolves in the Mojave desert to an Orthodox cross, this is an Odyssean tale...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. From Broadway to the Supra: Carrie Manolakos on Life After Lockdown

    Sep 1, 20261 hr 51 minAudio

    Welcome to the first episode of “Save Me a Spot at the Supra” on Heavy Things Lightly where John Heers hosts singer and Broadway performer Carrie Manolakos (best known for her performances in Mama Mia! and Wicked) at...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode