Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Heavy Things Lightly

Heavy Things Lightly artwork

The Ancient Christianity That is Alive and Well in Georgia

Jun 2, 20261 hr 5 minAudio
  • Apple Podcasts

Georgia's ancient faith is still alive - and it demands more than just going through the motions.Professor Levan Gigineishvili joins John to discuss the importance of continuous personal growth as an Orthodox Christian, the ultimate answer to avoiding complacency and transforming our lives in Christ. A medievalist, philosopher, and one of Georgia's most respected public intellectuals - walks us through 1,600 years of Christianity that refuses to die.This conversation goes deep, we cover:✧ Why Ilia Chavchavadze (philosopher, national hero, and saint) believed good ritual isn't good enough✧ The Golden Age of Georgia: Rustavelli, Neoplatonism, and the "Second Athens"✧ How Georgia kept the faith when empires - Byzantine, Persian, Ottoman, Russian, Soviet - tried to erase it✧ Why Sola Scriptura and the Reformation never took root in the Caucasus✧ Levan's own journey from Soviet atheism to Orthodox Christianity✧ The Georgian Supra: why Americans are falling in love with this ancient feast tradition✧ And one unforgettable story about a panic attack, a monastery, and a phone call🕯️ "Be perfect, as your Heavenly Father is perfect." - That's the Christianity Georgia has been living for centuries. It might be the Christianity we've forgotten.00:00 - Introduction: Professor Levan Gigineishvili02:30 - Ilia Chavchavadze: Saint, Philosopher & National Hero11:45 - Why the Church Canonized a Modern Thinker15:08 - Georgia's Golden Age: Rustavelli & the Second Athens20:00 - The Reformation That Bypassed Georgia22:00 - Soviet Atheism to Orthodox Faith: Levan's Journey30:00 - Field Report: Sarah in Mozambique32:00 - Georgia Between Iran & Russia: Choosing the Lesser Evil38:00 - A Panic Attack, a Monastery & Georgian Hospitality42:00 - Why Americans Love Supra (The Georgian Feast)44:00 - Be Perfect: Christianity as Continuous Growth__Levan Gigineishvili is a PhD graduate of the Central European University, Budapest. He also graduated Catholic University of Leuven (Philosophy), Harvard University (Education) and Javakhishvili Tbilisi State University (Classics). His PhD dissertation “The Platonic Theology of Ioane Petritsi” later published as a book (Gorgias Press, 2007) is the first English monograph written on this 12th century philosopher. Presently Levan Gigineishvili works at the Institute of Classics, Byzantine and Modern Greek Studies of the Javakhishvili Tbilisi State University, giving courses on Byzantine literature and Medieval Philosophy. He is an author of numerous articles on Ioane Petritsi and medieval Christian Platonism in the Eastern Christendom.__🏷️ Sponsored by Conrad's Beef Jerky - loyalty not guaranteed.Conrad's Deli - The best jerky you'll ever have ➜ https://conradsdeli.com/ ⭐ Use promo code "FIRST THINGS" for 10% off.🔥 Support First Things Foundation field workers like Sarah (featured in this episode): https://first-things.org✈ Become a Field Worker with FTF: https://first-things.org/opportunities📢 First Things Telegram: https://t.me/firstthingsfoundation🍷The best dinner party you've ever experienced - Supra Dinner Society: https://supradinner.com/🥂 Keipi Restaurant: https://keipirestaurant.org✒ Substack: https://johnheersftf.substack.com/ⓧ https://x.com/johnfromftf🏖️ Tailormade tours that give back: https://www.gratitude-travels.com/hom__Credits Music: Intro / Outro Provided by Greg Gilbertson & Band This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit johnheersftf.substack.com/subscribe

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_02You should be assimilated to Heavenly Father. It's a task of like overcoming yourself, like going farther and farther. This can be lost in this habituation of, I would say, liturgical life. And you need a good priest who can show to youngsters that this habituation is not a good thing. You should all the time develop and Hello, guys. Today, Levan Giganeshvili

SPEAKER_01Quite a famous professor in Georgia of medieval studies, history, philosophy, very close to the patriarch and also very close to the reality that takes place when you're trying to talk to somebody in the caucuses, very close to reality called bad technology. Professor Levan's phone dropped. We lost some of the call. We decided to go ahead and share it. It's still an hour of excellence.

And we start off, we'd been talking sort of about the origins of sort of the Georgian character.

SPEAKER_01And now we go into modernity. So you're going to pick it up with me asking a question about how Georgians are dealing with their ancient qualities. their modern qualities they really like the West and feel themselves connected to the West and their Orthodoxy and so a very very respected professor from Georgia Professor Levon Giganashvili joins us we jump in and I love you don't forget to eat beef jerky by Conrad's Deli you can find the links and you do

that because they

SPEAKER_01support us you support them you support us Don't forget to consider all the things that we do out there in the field look for a beautiful little advertisement where you actually meet some of our field workers it's coming but most of all thank you and now Greg Gilbertson and his crew play this beautiful it's my favorite song going called Goggie Marjos and on the other side we pick it up with Professor Levon Giganeshvili live from Georgia

I think there's a you've spoken before there's a fusion going on something like Western ideals of individualism and freedom being put together in georgia with orthodoxy which for me is nerve-wracking because i think we saw this in europe and it didn't end very well but so far so good in georgia with chav chavadze and the experiment what do you think how's it going i think i i think it is uh with chav chavadze felt

SPEAKER_02somehow Sincerely, that those processes going on in Europe and the evangelism, the gospel, are somehow connected with each other because this emancipation of labor, for instance, the women, emancipation of women or this abolition of selfdom, again, it's emancipation of labor, yeah? This esteeming human dignity with no reference to his social class as an image of

God and this not being snobbish for this nobility that they would not even dream and not even dream in their worst nightmare that their daughter could marry a kind

SPEAKER_02of peasant good boy. that is Ilya Jojo's writing about it that why don't you even imagine about it because there are so many virtuous boys among the peasants let's say who are educated courageous something but you still don't think about them as even fully human beings because you don't think they're just peasants yes but so Ilya Jojo wanted to establish certain kind of a this Christian Equality, not non-hierarchical equality,

SPEAKER_02but hierarchy that is based on meritocracy, that is based not on your, let's say, noble heritage, but on your nobility of your character. And so for him, this process is going on in Europe. Also, emergence of nation-states for him was kind of a divinely and providentially ordained thing. And that's why he He felt that these big empires are ruining the Habsburg

monarchy or the Russian Empire is about to get ruined and then these national states will emerge there and by this emergence national states would have the kind of a better possibility to fully implement their hidden capacities or the language of national culture so

SPEAKER_02because in the 19th century Georgia was part of the Russian Empire and and Georgians had to rescue their language, their cultural heritage, to develop their language. Ilya Georgiose actually created a new Georgian language, new idiom of Georgian language, which could be accessible to all strata of society. Which Would Make It Possible To Think In A Public Sphere About Everything About

Politics Economy Philosophy Religion Everything Could Be Somehow Uttered And Discussed In This Language So And He Wanted To Create This Public Space Of

SPEAKER_02Discourse And I Think Do You Think Yeah Do You Think Levan I'll jump in real quick one thing that happens when I bring people to Georgia whether they're Orthodox or not Christian or not is they have a sense of the familiar but there's something odd about Georgia or Eastern or

very foreign but

SPEAKER_01they always say the same thing which is but I feel very welcome Do you think philosophically that's this mixing that the 19th century Georgian philosophers, especially Ilya Chaochevazi, for people who don't know, he was a philosopher, a national hero, and a saint. Do you think that's what we're feeling? Yes. Sorry, Levon.

SPEAKER_02Kind of interesting merging of these two things. Ilya Chaochevazi, yeah, he felt that this... um enlightenment tradition separate out the tradition this idea that you should be somehow questioning things you should leave your adventure you should not be satisfied by what you have but try to develop something to find new forms that is for him a very christian thing because he was saying that christianity is a religion of grace and when you are graceful person

You will never get satisfied because there is always more and more to be attained.

SPEAKER_02It's like an epictasis of Gregory of Nyssa. Ilya doesn't say in these terms, doesn't speak about epictasis, but he speaks, essentially he speaks about this graceful person should always and always develop. You should not somehow reduce Christianity to ritual. As in his stories and novels he thrashes bitterly and very harshly those people who are purporting purported to be Christians so to say but the

Christianity is encompassed is how to say the Christianity is expressed only in the ritualistic adherence to certain kind of traditions fasting rules but they don't regard the most important aspect of Christianity which for Ilya Jaujewaza is is expressed by this verse of Bible be perfect as your Holy Father is perfect so if the

Christianity's essence is to be perfect but if you go to church light candles and participate in all fastings and the ritualistic ceremonies but don't try to become

SPEAKER_02perfect as your God Heavenly Father is perfect, then you are missing the point horribly. It's even better for you not to go even to church because by going to church you have some kind of a false hope or false conceit that you are in a good situation.

SPEAKER_01Piety, yeah. Not in a good situation at all because you are deceiving yourself because you are

SPEAKER_02not trying to be graceful. Ungraceful people are satisfied, but graceful people, Ilya Jojo says, are never satisfied. They want more and more. But what is interesting in Ilya Jojo, this more and more in Ilya Jojo is not only in monastic context of getting saturated with more and more grace through prayers and fasting. Also, this dimension he endorses, yes, but he also says that also social political life should be

connected with this.

SPEAKER_02Social political life should be also touched by Christianity, touched by grace, that it may also change. Because you should not create this gnostic world of spiritual growth and secular world, which is devoid of this. The secular world should also be connected with Christian development. That's why he wanted many Christian laymen to change something in the social political realm. And that for him was a Christianity in action.

SPEAKER_01Of course you are... Do most... Is there any pushback against this conversation, this Chav Chavadze worldview within the church these days? Or is he fully accepted... Do priests agree with you generally in Georgia about what you're saying?

SPEAKER_02It's not like a simple issue or an easy issue. There are priests and ecclesiastics who are more in a different direction, more towards seclusion. like church is church and lake society is lake society like we are to save our souls and why should we care much about what will happen outside so this kind of attitude there is also very secularist attitude which could

erase this mystical dimension of the church also it's a spectrum it's kind of it's a spectrum of

SPEAKER_02attitudes but I think when church canonized Ilya Chao Chavadze, it was both acknowledging this type of Christianity, this lay-oriented Christianity that would not leave orphaned, so to say, this social political realm, but try to transform it according to Christian commandments and make it better so that history may also have some progress. Yes, like Hegelian vision of Ilya Chao Chavadze was that

yeah right uh like uh you should it's a british problem leave world a better place than it was before before you so this kind of things this progress of social political progress as part of christian progress but uh do you do you think do you

SPEAKER_02think but when they go ahead levin go ahead they made ilio jojo the saint and you can light candle in front of his icon. It's a great thing. Yeah, you can ask him to supplicate for Georgia and he's a saint martyred for Christ and for his nation. Yeah. But on the other hand, If you only burn candle in front of Ilya's icon and don't read his voluminous literature, his articles, his stories,

SPEAKER_02his letters, it's also not right because you have now the blessing that you have the thought of this great thinker in front of you and you are just burning candle in front of his icon that's not enough read him and he's very modern how to say modern author in the sense that he can address some modern issues which is a century-long centuries-long writings so in this sense I think would you

would you say that

SPEAKER_01Would you say Levan that For people listening I'm trying to Take you guys on a walk through Georgian history by trying to understand the spirit of Georgia In the 1100-1200s there was a golden age in Georgia and one of the really important writers and I'm going to ask you about is Rustavelli and there's a spirit to his writing in Night in the Panther Skin Many people listening to this will have heard about him and

SPEAKER_01King Tamar and St. Nino. Is there a through line starting with maybe St. Nino through Rustavelli and then these characters from the Golden Age to Chav Chavadze to Georgia today? Is there something like a common thread or would you say those epochs are really very different and that Georgian people then were very different?

SPEAKER_02I would say there is a certain sort of seamless continuation from Nino, from Christianity and from advent of Christianity in Georgia and Nino and the great literature of hagiography and hymnography, homiletics, theological literature and philosophical literature and Galatist school of which here is Rustavelli also. Rustavelli knows all of those things and he also started to

study Plato Aristotle Greek Philosophy also open himself to our to other cultural influences like a Sufi mysticism of Islam or this great Persian poets like Jaladin Rumi and the Sufi poets so he knows Persian also besides Georgian besides Greek philosophy knows and Greek fathers and Christian theology he knows Persian he can

SPEAKER_02he can read the Sufi poetry and can incorporate those things in his poem as well. He's a Christian author, but he's very much a Renaissance type author who tries to see some good seeds of truth in different cultures and utilize them. So it's one continuum of Georgian culture. When Nino introduced Christianity, you see that she introduced some new dimension of humanity. Because when King Miriam, the saintly King Miriam,

SPEAKER_02first Christian king, wanted to somehow forcefully spread Christianity in Georgian mountains, Nino had a clash with king's generals saying that you should not do it because Christianity is not a religion of coercion. Christianity is the religion of persuasion and not words but words should convert people. That was Nino's idea.

SPEAKER_01That's how she said it. Not swords but words. Yeah.

SPEAKER_02That's how she said it. and so she was she had already this idea that christianity is religion of freedom and ilija jojo also writes that nino came and she planted a tree of freedom instead so freedom and christianity was taken together it's not that some compulsion coercion coercion or this forceful acceptance but one should reciprocate freely with it and this was uh from the outset and uh You see that Georgians were very much influenced by Byzantine

Christianity, but they were not slavishly imitating Byzantians because Georgians developed their

SPEAKER_02own hagiography, own hymnography, their own architectural forms. So they didn't copy it from Byzantines, but they tried to rival Byzantines and developed their own theological language. It's so fascinating it's so fascinating the Greeks the Byzantines at times they fought the Georgians they were both Christians and at other times the Georgians were using the traditions other times the Byzantines were borrowing Georgian

SPEAKER_01traditions it's pretty it's so complicated but I call it there's a great relationship there right would you say it's a healthy relationship

SPEAKER_02Absolutely, yeah, for instance, Byzantine, one of the empires of Byzantine was Mary the Martyr, the Georgian queen, Georgian royal descent in 11th century, and she was a mecenate, or they financed the entire circle of Georgian intellectuals in Costinopolis, and so those intellectuals were financed by her to translate things and write the books and so it was great interaction and

SPEAKER_02one more thing that Georgia somehow was more vibrant culture in the more inquisitive culture than Byzantines in a certain sense because Byzantine somehow believe that they're the number one They have everything, Plato, Aristotle. They would keep it like keepers. But when Georgians discovered Plato, discovered Aristotle, an explosion happened. Like in Western Europe, there was a Renaissance explosion. Something similar happened in Georgia.

SPEAKER_02Because when they started to translate Plato, Aristotle, Proclus, Neoplatonic philosophers, this explosion happened in Galati school. And you see already these Galatian philosophers who are developing their own very original ideas about theology and philosophy.

SPEAKER_01They try to combine— This is the 1200s, right? 1200s.

SPEAKER_02The Galatian school, yeah. Especially Ioane Petrizzi, he translated 5th century pagan philosopher Neoplaton is Proclus a very difficult treatise it's called the elements of theology or metaphysical elements and it's 211 propositions and he gave him wrote the explanation or exegesis for each of those propositions and develop his own philosophical ideas where he combined Christianity,

SPEAKER_02Christian theology and platonic metaphysics. Somehow he decided to Show that biblical text is metaphysically clad so to say you can express in metaphysical language in philosophical Neoplatonic language what is metaphorically written in Bible so and that what he what he does somehow making the harmony of the two traditions of biblical and Philosophical as in Galati Galati was called second Athens and New Jerusalem so it was Athens in Jerusalem was

combined in Galati and And Rushtar Stawel is the heir of all those things Yes So would you argue then So

SPEAKER_01that's 11, 1200s, 1300s Now we're going to get into the Reformation And you're going to see Western Europeans arguing over lots of theology And that argument ends with really a terrible split Would you say Sola Scriptura These things didn't make it to Georgia or did they come and the Georgian church was able to not adopt some of these reformations or would you say some of the western changes in theology they also came to

Georgia how would you

SPEAKER_01describe that they were

SPEAKER_02There were Catholic missions, yes, but I wouldn't say that Catholic missions really changed the society by large. They could establish some parishes, but I would not say that it became a mainstream voice or it was followed by some theological debates. Yeah, there were theological debates. There were written anti-Catholic treatises written at the time when Catholic

SPEAKER_01missions arrived in Georgia.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, but it was not something very, how to say, something very... I would say reaching the population level and very important like culture wise for Georgia it was more parochial importance I would say but I may be mistaken but one thing is interesting that there was a great poet in the 18th century his name was

SPEAKER_02David Guramishvili And he had a great project of introducing the new, how to say, book for learning for Georgian youth. And he called it Davitiani. Davitiani means the book of David. But Davitiani is a play of a word because Georgians call Psalms Davitani, which is verses of David. So he wanted somehow Georgian male could have learned the prayers from his book of Davitiani He wrote this prayer book for Georgian youth And also

he wrote some kind of poems of religious character And in this poem you see that he's trying to

SPEAKER_02democratize Christianity So he shifts from this old Georgian language and the old Georgian hymnology language, which is very difficult and arcane. So he came down to the popular language and created these prayer books, prayer prayers and prayer Poems in vernacular, like a popular language. Sometimes he would sing, he would write these prayers with a tune of Georgian folk songs

for children,

SPEAKER_02for young boys and girls. But he was imprisoned in Prussia at the time And Prussia at the time had these Lutheran movements as well Like it was under Frederick And Frederick himself was Catholic But was very open to Lutherans and to other denominations And it's possible that David Guravishvili felt this democratization of Christianity in Europe And that's why he wanted to introduce similar things in Orthodoxy He remained Orthodoxy But at the same time he wanted to democratize the prayers and

make it more acceptable to a younger generation that they may get honed in Christianity through

SPEAKER_02his noble prayers which is very easy to pronounce, easy to sing because they are attuned to these peasant folk songs. So he's a great poet and his ambition was grand but at that time the printing press was not very developed in Georgia so his poem was his grand work Magnum Opus was not printed that's why somehow this was I call it bomb which did not explode so to

SPEAKER_02say But again, those questions, Sola Scriptura and Sola Fide, they bypassed Georgians for good. I think it's good that they bypassed Georgians because the Georgians remained very staunchly orthodox in these terms. And they, of course, they follow Church Fathers with this strong feeling of freedom and responsibility. What about you?

SPEAKER_01Did you undergo... Was it sort of a religious conversion when the Soviet Union collapsed? Were you always a church guy? Are you a church guy? Yeah, now I'm a churchgoer, or as I say, practicing Christian or whatever.

SPEAKER_02But yeah, I regularly attend liturgies now, for many years already. But when I was in my school years, the educational system was kind of atheistic, and they wanted simply to uproot God from everywhere. Somehow I had a thirst towards Christianity, towards religion and spirituality. I had very good teachers who were believers. For instance, my teacher of Georgian literature was a believer.

SPEAKER_02And, of course, these believers were at that time sometimes bizarre. They would combine beliefs in Christ with certain doctrines of Gnosticism, of Steinerism or whatever, Rudolf Steiner.

SPEAKER_01Steiner, yeah, for sure.

SPEAKER_02Yes, but it was kind of a mixture of different spiritual things, but some Christian basis was there. And so I was very much, how to say, hungry for the Christianity, understanding the Georgian literature because the Georgian literature is permeated by Christianity. It's based on Christian values and especially medieval Georgian literature. So I was a searcher, so to say, and I would read When Perestroika came and the religious books started to be

edited and published I would read those books and for instance I was reading sermons of 19th century

SPEAKER_02Georgian great bishop of Imereti his name His name is Gabriel. He was canonized later. He was canonized in 1995. But I loved his sermons. I was reading them and I said, but sermons are just one aspect of church life. How great it would have been I participated fully in this thing because it's such a clever and kind and wise term. And then also my cousin married when I was at 11th grade, I guess.

My cousin married an American girl who was very staunch Protestant and Evangelist.

SPEAKER_02And I saw that she's a sincere believer and she gave me some books. And among them was the book of C.S. Lewis, Mere Christianity.

SPEAKER_01And I liked it.

SPEAKER_02C.S. Lewis, Mere Christianity, I loved it. It was my first theological treatise, so to say, where he speaks seriously about the Godhead of Christ.

SPEAKER_01Wait, so C.S. Lewis was working on you in Georgia. It was working on me, too. I was reading C.S. Lewis. I was coming back. I was in a mud hut in Africa reading C.S. Lewis. Interesting. Interesting. That guy.

SPEAKER_02I even translated his Out of the Silent Planet into English. I didn't publish it.

SPEAKER_01You did. You did.

SPEAKER_02Wow. And so I was fascinated by C.S. Lewis. I loved him and I read some other books of him as well. So but Mere Christianity was like eye opening for me in a certain sense. It regulated my ideas on Christianity. I went to America to visit my cousin and his wife and she would take us to Bible studies and I saw that, oh, the Christianity is a living religion. People are reading Bibles and praying and it was Protestant surrounding of course,

SPEAKER_02but I liked the seriousness of those people in devotion in faith. Later, when I went to Budapest to study there, I met Istvan Pertzel, a supervisor, a professor at Central European University, and he was a Jewish convert to Orthodoxy. And he was a very deep, deep thinking person and knew very well and deeply,

SPEAKER_02profoundly, Greek theology and fathers. We read the fathers in original St. Simeon, the New Theologians hymns we read in original, for instance. He took me first to the first time I attended liturgy from the beginning to end in Budapest. So, and...

SPEAKER_01In Budapest?

SPEAKER_02Yeah. And since Budapest, when I returned home, I started to, I continued in Tbilisi. And so, henceforth, I'm continuing.

SPEAKER_01What year is this? What year is this?

SPEAKER_02In 1995, I guess, yeah.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. Oh, wow. I was in Georgia then. Hey, real quick, meet Sarah in Mozambique. Two years she'll be there. She's from Oregon and, well, she worked, was deeply engaged in the work of serving people who are in need of social assistance. She was a social worker, but she's a lot more than that. Sarah in Mozambique, one of our beloved field workers. Sarah, can you hear me from Mozambique?

SPEAKER_00Yes, for now.

SPEAKER_01Sarah is new to first things. She's in phase one. How's phase one going? The immersion ship.

SPEAKER_00Yesterday was one month in Mozambique.

SPEAKER_01One month. I think you're parasite free. That's the word.

SPEAKER_00Let's let's hope so. So far I am.

SPEAKER_01Come on, there's more to it than that. It's fun to joke about medical problems when you're in Africa. But like, what are you seeing around you? How's life? Well, we've been going back and forth a lot between the village and the city. So we're kind of getting this cultural whiplash of urban Mozambique and then very,

SPEAKER_00very rural Mozambique. But it's fun because we're getting a kind of a foot in both places.

SPEAKER_01Are you happy with a decision to sort of try a new life?

SPEAKER_00Life here is good. It's very overstimulating and very restful in the same day. You feel There's so much to take in that your brain can't even handle it and then all of a sudden everything just becomes siesta and you just lay around for the afternoon. You can log it all into the long term memory and try to make sense of it.

SPEAKER_01Is it difficult to learn the language? What's happening with you and language? And is language important to you?

SPEAKER_00Well, language has been a challenge. And mainly that's because we are learning two languages. At the same time, we're learning Portuguese, which is the colonial language and Makua, which is the tribal language here. And we're not doing one and then the other, we're learning them simultaneously. And everybody I told that I was gonna be doing that just gave me this look like you're absolutely crazy. But once you get here and once you start doing the learning,

it really makes sense why you need to learn them simultaneously in order to be

SPEAKER_00successful because the way that people speak here, it's woven together in the same sentence and in the same conversation you have both. We're just learning like babies right now and eventually it's all going to congeal into cohesive thought someday. All right we're gonna talk again we're gonna do this every couple of months and this is gonna appear on our podcast and in all kinds of shorts and you're gonna be like why do I have to be used this way and the reason is is

because you are wonderful and doing something special and thanks for being on for a second anyway

SPEAKER_01there's more to say I don't think it's gonna upload if we keep recording So you and I both know when you drive around Georgia, Tbilisi, you see signs for Tehran. Like Iran is right there. So what do you take away from this war in Iran? And how do Georgians who've been invaded by everybody, you're right, Mongols,

SPEAKER_01Russians, Persians, Turks, just name it, How do you see this relationship between the West and Iran and just what's the Georgian perspective or your perspective on what we really are seeing in this war in Iran and how should Americans know Iran from a Christian perspective, albeit a Georgian one? Iran Iran was for six hundred years Iran kind of occupied

Georgian occupied in sense that yeah we had kings our kings and they were consecrated as kings but by Iranians they were regarded as valley valley like they were like subjugated to Iranian sharks subjects subjects of Iran yeah but then Iraq was the second he decided to shift allegiance to Russia because Russia was an Orthodox empire and Iraq felt that in the long run so to say if Georgia would

remain under Iranian

SPEAKER_02influence would remain the subject of Iran the iranians would assimilate georgians and christianity would perish in georgia that's why of course it was difficult decision because when you are becoming subject of anybody still it's it's a painful thing and our our last king george the 12th Even so that russia empire is not really protecting georgia because just russians are not protecting just a protectorate protectorate kingdom

because when agama

SPEAKER_02hamad khan Persian Khan Decided To Retaliate And Punish Georgia For This Shifting Of Allegiance Towards Russia In 1995 Russians Did Not Help Georgian King And So Iranian Sect and so many people were killed and the king hardly survived like I was narrowly survived the death so and then the last king of Georgia realized that Russians

would not really protect Georgia from Iranians unless Georgia becomes a province of Russia without being a kingdom I guess and so that he made a painful decision

SPEAKER_02and sent a letter to Paul.

SPEAKER_01What year is this decision? Give us a year or a time period.

SPEAKER_021799 1799 or 18 or like this this year and then he sent a letter to Paul the second emperor and saying that he's ready to like how to say make Georgia full sail part of Russia so to say and without with already abolition of Georgian kingdom which was a very painful decision but There was a Padre Rutigliano,

SPEAKER_02the Italian representative of Roman Pope, and he was saying, don't do king this, don't do this to your people, because Russian Tsar will become like a stepfather for your people. You are a loving father, but he will become a kind of a cold and callous stepfather. But then George XII answered to this Padre Rutigliano, I know this Padre, but what to do? Without this, Christianity would be uprooted in Georgia. So he made this decision to, how to say, save Christianity for Georgians.

SPEAKER_02Rather than be in the long run, so to say, assimilated by Iranians and that Christianity may be abolished in Georgia altogether. Like in Iran, we have a lot of Georgians living there in Faridah, but none of them, they're not Christians anymore.

SPEAKER_01Oh, they're not. I've heard mixed reports on that.

SPEAKER_02But en masse, they're not Christians. Probably they could be newly converted, but they didn't keep Christianity.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, they didn't keep it. So how did... Georgians who remained outside this project of Erechle II retained Christianity.

SPEAKER_02Neither in Turkey nor in Iran. All got Islamized. So he was right Yeah He was right to go under the Russians So it was a painful decision of choosing lesser beds as it usually Yeah but so with Iranians Some people Levan some people don't know out there there was a period for folks who were interested the Russian church would build churches alongside

Georgian churches and

SPEAKER_01it was it it would the the policy was you should go to the Russian churches not to the Georgian churches it's very complicated and often in America live on people are they think of Russia and Georgia as one place and I think it's important that we it's very different at least the cultures are very different the faith is the same we commune together but it's it's complicated right would you agree with that it's it's quite complicated yeah because yeah languages are very different it's uh even not

do not belong to

SPEAKER_02the same language group and Georgian language is not even Indo-European language. English has more connection with Russian than Georgian has. But on the other hand, culturally, there is great connections, especially in the 19th century, 20th century, there were great connections between Georgians and Russians because Georgian men of letters were steeped in Russian literature. would read Tolstoy and and Gertsen or Belinsky or all those

Pushkin of course Lermontov they were steeped in those authors and they would they would get access to European liturgy sometimes through Russian liturgy which was also European

SPEAKER_02liturgy And also Russians somehow created out of Georgia a certain romantic image of exile for best Russian men of letters and this dissidence it was a good place of exile because it was kind of romantic land of ancient Christianity and some kind of romantic image of Georgia was created among Russian poets if you can read it in Pushkin and So there was a hostility,

there was a trial of assimilation of Georgians by some Russian authorities there were periods of this very strong assimilation abolition of Georgian language in churches which was very painfully taken by Georgians abolition of Georgian language

SPEAKER_02and singing in churches and Georgians struggled a lot to to rescue their theological language and their liturgical tradition and also this hymnology. It was heroic efforts of Georgians in the 19th century to rescue it. And we have the Saint Octimius Kereselidze who devoted his life to preservation and the development of Georgian church singing in Georgian.

so this was well it it it worked it worked in georgia now in america one of the favorite troparian of many churches is the georgian this this is well this becoming known in the united states it's such a beautiful mountain a swanetian style yeah

SPEAKER_01they're different yes so nice Yeah also Patriarch Patriarch has this Trisagion written by Patriarch is very famous has become very famous Patriarch Hylia wrote that Yes it has yeah But go back go back for me go back so are Georgians what do they think of this war and this war this fight that the Americans picked with the Iranians do they care or is it well it's in your backyard Of course

SPEAKER_02Of course Georgians care because everything is so close. I don't think I can speak for myself what I think. It's not that Georgians think so and Georgians think. As many as there are Georgians, so many as there are opinions, I guess. But Georgians are very concerned. Because we are very concerned because everything is so close here. because we are afraid that, for instance, if we provide basis to America, I don't know,

SPEAKER_02I speak as a profane, then Iran may be angry with Georgia and who knows, maybe send some missiles to Georgia and this kind of thing. I don't know. And of course, Georgia is not siding with anybody and with Iranians or something. We are afraid of... getting somehow involved and we try to keep a good relationship somehow as it is possible as far as possible with all our strong neighbors yeah so we even also with

SPEAKER_02Iranians with Americans America is regarded by us as a Strategic Partner by its official position of Georgian government is the American strategic partner but strategic partner if it will mean the angering of Iran so much that Iran could like attack us with missiles I don't think Georgians are very much sure that America and Georgia from this I because it's a We are far away interest for America maybe so in this sense I

think it's the idea of Georgians is more cautious to be cautious and not to side with any cause so to say but my personal opinion is another thing I speak like for general opinion but my personal opinion is that it's a mistake this war in Iran it's a it's a it's a

SPEAKER_02blunder it should not have started

SPEAKER_01Yeah, I think here more and more people are agreeing with you, Levon. It's not popular. I say all this... you know it's interesting to hear your perspective but just from my experiences in Georgia I know that there's a spirit of let's call it hospitality in Georgia one that you're very the people in Georgia and I think I can say this and I hope you agree there's a deep sense of understanding the other of course

Georgians are proud

SPEAKER_01of their own culture and their traditions and their church but because of your place in history you have to you're very aware of the guest let me put it like this and I don't think anyone could argue this you can try and so I know that you have to be very aware of what's happening because every little everybody crosses through Georgia at some point for whatever they need and so I wonder is this part of the Georgian identity this ability to So sort of take a punch Get back up again Love your neighbor

Take a punch It seems

SPEAKER_01like a pattern Do I have that right about Georgia or not really? It is a technique of survival of Georgians I guess because Georgians developed a

SPEAKER_02certain sagacity of not equating political things with people Somehow when you when you see for instance, Georgian poems of 18th century, you see that you have Turks are our oppressors. Yes, but these Ottomans. Yeah, but Turk is our brother. I mean the turkey himself like he he he is also our brother because he can he can be as a person he can be regarded as with respect but of course we are not succumbing to the

situation that we like to be oppressed by by Ottomans but Turk himself can be regarded as with respect and with with brotherhood with hospitality this was the

SPEAKER_02idea that Yeah, also today, yeah, Russia has occupied 20% of Georgian territory, but the Russian is Russian and Russian culture is not, how say, regarded as something hostile or enemy for us. There are so many Russians walking in Tbilisi streets with just freely, without any feeling of, I don't know, some fear or qualms or some kind of, how say, Some kind of unease.

SPEAKER_02Full of Russians. We understand that politics is one thing. Politics has its own logic. Very cruel logic sometimes. But people are another thing. And that was...

SPEAKER_01It is incredible.

SPEAKER_02It is incredible. Georgians do not have the nation whom we hate. I don't think.

SPEAKER_01I don't think so either.

SPEAKER_02But we don't need anybody for our identity to hate. This identity is formed not in hatred. That's important.

SPEAKER_01It's so beautiful. For people out there, you have to realize Russia and Invaded Georgia just it wasn't even 15 years ago and so and they still have they still have incursions and Russians still come to hang out and and they they feel welcome I know this personally from my own Georgian friends and I love what you said you don't they your culture has not decided their identity comes from who they hate yeah that's really true it's really true I think

it's I think I think it's a good good thing it's a strength and that that made Georgia to survive so

SPEAKER_02many calamities in history because you don't hate people for what they are and also we were boasting that so many people are living in Georgia for centuries without any kind of feeling of oppression they take Georgia as their homeland like Jews are living in Georgia 26 centuries and we don't have a 26 we don't have instances of oppression or pogroms or something like you know 26 and actually first Christians in

Georgia were Jews like

SPEAKER_02in the first converse of two Christians I encourage everyone to go look at the story of Nino because it's a Jewish community that sends some people to go find out about Christ and they come back they come back with the robe and from there starts the conversation about Christianity it's really beautiful can I tell you a quick story and then can you tell me if this is normal it's a great

story can I tell you by the way we have to talk about Supra for one second because Well I'll end with the story Can we talk about Supra for one second Because Levan

SPEAKER_02is so great Tell me first the story Okay i'll tell you the story this is the story i was in georgia this is 2019 uh i'm with a group of 12 maybe in two different cars and in one of the cars a young man who's traveling with us starts to let's just say has a panic attack a panic attack i don't know if you know what that is but he starts to feel anxiety in georgia he's he's a panic attack or a foreigner

No foreigner He's from He's a westerner He's from He lived in Scotland And He's having a panic attack So he's a foreigner Traveling with me And he starts to sweat And he starts to say It's happening again It's happening again He's having some sort of breakdown Psychological maybe I need to And he starts to say I have to go

SPEAKER_01to a monastery I have to go to a monastery I have to go to a monastery and we're far from a monastery we're like in Kashuri we're after Gori in Kashuri and we're not near and he's driving in a car and for all of you out there George is very mountainous we're sort of out in the middle of nowhere and he says I have to go to a monastery so my friend who's driving we call him Mepe king but his name is his name is Chacha

SPEAKER_01He says, don't worry, why are you crying? Don't worry, everything is fine He says, I have to go, I have to go to a monastery So he goes, okay, one second So my friend, he doesn't go to church, Levon He's not like, you know, taking confession, going to communion He's not like that, but he's Georgian He makes a phone call, you know He starts talking to someone He says, I don't know who he's talking to and he says, okay, don't worry, I turn around.

SPEAKER_01We turn around and guess where we go? And he pulls up the Holy Church there and a monk comes out and says, okay, you go with him. And my friend got out of the car and went and spent two nights in the monastery. This American guy, this Scottish guy, who's American. and he comes back two days later we pick him up and he's like i feel better i feel better let's keep going on the tour my friend knew a monk but

my friend doesn't go to church yeah it's possible and i tell that it's possible right yeah it's quite

SPEAKER_02quite possible georgia is a little country everybody knows everybody He could not know the monk in person, but he could have called his friend who knew this monk in person. It's quite possible. I'm not much surprised with it.

SPEAKER_01See, I wanted your reaction because when I watched it happen, my American friends were like, who's he going to call? And I'm like, we'll figure it out. But the beautiful part is they just came out. They didn't know him. Mepe, my friend, just waved to them. They came out and took him. And that was it. So I say that story to just that was in 2019. That's not like from you know, the 1100s. It's also a merit of one of the reasons for it is the late

Patriarch Ilya who really was behind all those developments and so many monasteries are now in Georgia

SPEAKER_02because before in Soviet Union time the monasteries were empty or desolate or whatever only handful of monks existed there handful I would do and so but now it's it's kind of a it's a many of them are established and you can find the ancient monasteries restored like Shiom Guime or Tawid Garegi and you

SPEAKER_01see everywhere yeah so we did Supra together and you're You're this kind of a famous professor, highly educated, you speak English and I think other languages, do you speak another, don't you speak French?

SPEAKER_02I don't speak French, I can read German, mostly like scholarly articles in my field, but I speak fluently Russian, and I can read ancient Greek.

SPEAKER_01So, Levan, comes and we meet together symbolic world it's very nice and then we throw Supra and then at the conference wherever we were I forget our London people kept saying you're Georgian do you know about Supra and you're like what is happening like why are all these people so in my world Supra has become very important and in your world you were like this is so fascinating why these Americans want this so before

I go on you know it's not a lie people like Supra in America can you just guess why you think it is like what's happening first of all is it weird to you yeah Supra is a place where you kind of forget about somehow you forget about the everyday life's troubles in a

SPEAKER_02way and you create a separate different time It's a different time so you're kind of thinking more and we are more relaxed in a intelligent way so you're relaxing super you are thinking about memories of past and expectation of future some good things We are praising each other. We are trying to find some good aspects in each other's character. And this kind of you are proposing toast and blessing each

other like this and having just fun.

SPEAKER_02And it's not like a very, how to say, it's not very Academic Thinks The Supra Supra Is Very Lex Situation When Tamada Sometimes Shouts Oh Listen To Me Please And People Are Not Listening But It's Kind Of Part Of The Part Of The Situation That You Are Not Too Much I Would Say It's Not A Conference It Says That Supra You Just Care For Carefree Situation But Also Serious Because

SPEAKER_02You Also Compete In Eloquence Tamada says something and you have to make a variation on theme of which Tamada proposes and kind of try to make a nice twist of the phrase and whatever. It's kind of a competition of eloquence as well and wisdom as well because You try to say some good and important things. Remember a person, let's say a dead person, for instance, in his best way, some kind of good memory, which would underline the good character of this person.

Or also there's this list of the, let's say, liturgical almost list of the different toasts. Yes So you follow it and then it creates some kind of unity feeling and unity sense of unity and if you are sincere sincere in your words and in your blessings then it is a kind of continuation of liturgy I love you In a more

relaxed way of course Because Levan one of my worries when we started the restaurant was Georgians would Be angry that i'm not georgian but it's it's not that at all it's the opposite people are very thankful and also the supra has all the elements of every of all

SPEAKER_01kind of human traditions of being together and John Heers johnheers johnheers johnheers johnheers johnheers johnheers johnheers johnheers johnheers johnheers johnheers johnheers johnheers johnheers johnheers johnheers johnheers johnheers johnheers johnheers johnheers johnheers johnheers johnheers johnheers johnheers she taught us she's a historian of Georgian culture and she taught us she wrote she wrote papers about you're writing you're speaking about another

Nino Gambashiza so I have I have another coursemate Nino Gambashiza who is also a very nice girl you may get acquainted with her but this Nino Gambashiza I also know but she's not my

SPEAKER_01friend but by the way everyone listening notice There were two Ninos that's very normal but also Levan also knows the other Nino so this is Georgia this is Georgia I love it can you leave us with something how can we when we come to Georgia Father Teodora's church is the one I often go to is that your church as well

SPEAKER_02He's a very active priest, a very good priest. He's working with youngsters a lot and so he established an atonite kind of salon or room near his church where he organizes John Heers John Heers John Initially many youngsters came to church and they searched it

but now it became more moderate and sometimes these youngsters are not going anymore to church so intensely but with Father Theodore the youngsters are going there a lot of them and it's always full with youth who is really taking spiritual food from him because he

SPEAKER_02can speak in the language that is attractive to these age groups

SPEAKER_01Do you think your writings talk about this? I mean, you publish in Georgian and English, but is there a meaning crisis for young people in Georgia? Are they struggling to figure out why they...

SPEAKER_02Yeah, of course, meaning this is a problem because, again, you see this European culture, it's a Western culture, it's a great culture, it's a vibrant culture with so much of creativity in it, so much of risking steps, which is attractive. So it is both attractive, fascinating, but at the same time, fear, I would say, frightening. And so Georgian youngsters sometimes are kind of open to this culture.

at detriment of their own tradition and they embrace it and kind of leave,

SPEAKER_02abandon church, abandon this spiritual life of their ancestors, seeing in it some stagnation. So, Father Theodor does show that there is no stagnation in Christianity. All the time there is a religion of development, of growth in spirit. of Creativity. So in this sense you need more such priests who would attract youngsters. They may not be lost and they may kind of get united to church,

but in a very creative way.

SPEAKER_02Because if you go all the time to liturgy, Just get accustomed to it and then you at certain moment you may feel that oh, I'm just Walking in circles. I'm not going somewhere. So I should I'm not doing this stuff with Julia George was saying that you should be a assimilated to Heavenly Father. It's a task of like overcoming yourself, like going farther and farther. This can be lost in this habituation of, I would say, liturgical life.

And you need a good priest who can show to youngsters that this habituation is not a good thing.

SPEAKER_02You should all the time develop and Posit for yourself new challenges and try to translate Christ's message and become representatives of Christ in the modern world, in the postmodern world, so to say. Be witnesses of truth in this situation. So I say that there is nothing more cool than to be a Christian. Because when you are cool in other things in subculture way,

SPEAKER_02this cool will very quickly evaporate, very quickly will fade out. But cool of Christianity will never fade out because it is ongoing growth in grace, which is ontological thing.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, unto ages of ages. So, well, thank you for We'll do Georgian check-ins with you. Can I try to bring you on another six months? There's something really refreshing about hearing from you and not from me and I'm so glad to have you talk to us. It's an honor. Next time we'll talk about St. Gavriel and there's many things to talk about and hopefully the war will be over.

SPEAKER_01We can talk about that.

SPEAKER_02Let's hope. There's many things to speak of and I'll see you I'm gonna come this in October I'm trying to write a book about Supra actually so I might come pick your brain and you

SPEAKER_01know pick her brain so anything you want us to know Are you working on anything? Is there something you can publish in English for all of us?

SPEAKER_02Yeah, I'm now working on Johan Petrizzi, the philosopher I mentioned. I'm with my professor Ishton Pertzel. We have to publish first volume of his commentaries and his translation commentaries on Neoplatonic philosophy of Proclus. So it will be in English. We'll put a link to you. It's amazing yeah that's what we'll talk about next time too is the neoplatonists i'm very interested in the your perspective on neoplatonism and

georgian orthodox christianity because obviously they're related and i'm interested to see how

SPEAKER_02they're related they're very much related And also it is related, Platonism is related to Eastern Christianity with church fathers. They were steeped in reading Plotinus and Plato and the new categories of Plato that were introduced by this tradition. Okay

In a more intense way That's next time Yeah That's next time And also I'll see you in Georgia We'll have some Ginkali And some cha-cha I hope so Are you drinking

SPEAKER_01cha-cha these days? Everything No Yeah Okay Cagimarjas Cagimarjas Krista Jagsda Cagimarjas Jagsda

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Demons, Deception, and Why Your Spiritual Practices Might Be Dangerous

    Oct 2, 20261 hr 18 minAudio

    Find this episode on YouTube: "Justine Alter" - a pseudonym - returns to chat with John Heers in a raw Heavy Things Lightly conversation you have to hear to believe.Justine worked for years as a professional psychic,...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. The Fox News Reporter Who Quit to Live an Orthodox Homesteading Life

    Sep 25, 20261 hr 35 minAudio

    Find this episode on YouTube: Holly Hickman went from Columbia Journalism and Fox News Radio covering NASA and the 2008 election - to milking cows, making cheese, and converting to Orthodoxy.In this episode of Heavy...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Why They Left NASA to Start St. George's Classical Academy

    Sep 21, 20261 hr 2 minAudio

    Can you teach kids the truth AND prepare them for a secular world?On this episode of Heavy Things Lightly, host John Heers talks with James and Juliana Joyce, founders of St. George's Classical Academy in Boxford,...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. An Odyssean Tale: The Man Who Would Not Quit

    Sep 4, 20261 hr 37 minAudio

    Find this episode on YouTube: Crow walked America searching for his father - and found the Father.From West Virginia hollers to LA gangs, from wolves in the Mojave desert to an Orthodox cross, this is an Odyssean tale...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. From Broadway to the Supra: Carrie Manolakos on Life After Lockdown

    Sep 1, 20261 hr 51 minAudio

    Welcome to the first episode of “Save Me a Spot at the Supra” on Heavy Things Lightly where John Heers hosts singer and Broadway performer Carrie Manolakos (best known for her performances in Mama Mia! and Wicked) at...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode