Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Heavy Things Lightly

Heavy Things Lightly artwork

You Can Be a God. Bam!

Sep 5, 20251 hr 2 minAudio
  • Apple Podcasts
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Find this episode on YouTube: After dropping an article that ruffled some feathers, John had to invite Mathew back on the show. And alongside him Dcn. Seraphim who provides excellent insight to a the idea of theosis. Join us in Greenville or Islamorada for ART OF THE TAMDA: https://first-things.org/aot ✒ Substack: https://johnheersftf.substack.com/ ⓧ https://x.com/johnfromftf 🍷The best dinner party you've ever experienced - Supra Dinner Society: https://supradinner.com/ 🏖️ Tailormade tours that give back: https://www.gratitude-travels.com/home 🔎 Discover the non-profit behind Heavy Things Lightly: https://first-things.org/ ✈ Become a Field Worker with FTF: https://first-things.org/opportunities 📢 First Things Telegram: https://t.me/firstthingsfoundation 🥂 Keipi Restaurant: https://keipirestaurant.org Please leave a review with your comments! Your support keeps this podcast alive and allows us to broaden our discussion. --- This “Enlightened” New World utopia isn’t turning out to be all it was cracked up to be. Society is disenchanting, but are the only alternatives hiding out in the hills or burying yourself in books? With an air of levity and a touch of humor, John Heers teaches how to examine the confusing New World by calling upon the mind and wisdom of oft-forgotten Old. Heavy Things, Lightly. --- Credits Music: Intro / Outro Provided by Greg Gilbertson & Band This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit johnheersftf.substack.com/subscribe

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_02Hey, everybody. Heavy things lightly. This week, I was entertaining the notion that demons are around. It feels like our politics have a lot of locked doors and behind them are files that have demonic stuff in there and that people seem to have participated with the demons on some level. I don't know. Feels possible. Then I thought, well, there's a guy, Matthew Namy, who's an Orthodox historian, who's talking about this stuff. That really what he's talking about is, I think we can become gods.

SPEAKER_02And he's written about it. And he's fantastic. And then Richard Rowland, also known as Deacon Seraphim. Well, actually, Deacon Seraphim, actually also known as Richard Rowland. He joins us and applies some of his ancient wisdom. Not because he's so old, because he just knows old stuff. And it's a great conversation. And it's filled with technical difficulties. A lot of them. If you, like me, don't care about that, you just want to hear the conversation,

let's go.

SPEAKER_02Here it comes on Heavy Things Lightly. Well... People wanted you guys to be back on, and then I tried, and then we all have these lives, but now it's Deacon Seraphim. There's a transition period, right? So we can say also known as Richard Rowland.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, that's right. Well, listen, if Father Andrew Stephen Damick can have three names, I can be Deacon Seraphim Richard Rowland. It's okay. I have a feeling you're going to be doing this a lot over the next couple months to

SPEAKER_02remind people. So Deacon Seraphim, Richard Rowland, the 12th or whatever, is here. And also Matthew Nami. It's not Nami. It's Nami. Nami. Matthew Nami. Do people say Nami, though? Do they do that on you? I hear all versions, yes. No, and you guys become sort of my internet pals. I actually saw you, Seraphim, in Charleston just recently.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, at the Searcy Institute National Conference.

SPEAKER_02Let's do a toast. As they say, it's good to be together, and it's nice to be together and be attentive to some cool stuff, as we hope to do today. So to a type of brotherhood, Gagy Marjos, being together. Gagy Marjos. And I'm drinking water, guys. I did four tables this week. I'm like, what kind of person am I? This is embarrassing. All right. So can we just start with this God question that some of your work has managed to get people sort of talking about the notion that,

SPEAKER_02well... that I may be a God on some level, or the saints are gods. And it starts with a conversation about an article you wrote where you just sort of said a God came to Congress. Yes. Tell us about, first of all, the article. Just summarize that. What were you trying to say, Matthew?

And we're in the Philippines as refugees and he wanted to get them into the United States. So he went to Congress and lobbied and successfully got them to be allowed into the

SPEAKER_02United States. So this was like early 1950s. And I made the I actually we talked about this the last time we were all together. This exact thing when when a God I refer to St. John as a God visiting Congress. And when I published the article, I was like, oh, I'll just title it the way that we talked about it. I'll call it something like When a God Visited Congress. And it got quite a reaction from a lot of people. who sort of publicly and privately thought that some people,

SPEAKER_02some people thought that, what are you saying, man? Uh, how dare you refer to there being gods other than the most high God what's going on? So that's, that was, and I kind of, I'm like, I guess I should have anticipated that reaction. Um, but that's what I did. Well, um, It was interesting to me, as per the theme of this podcast, because I see that the old world,

that's not like a crazy concept to imagine that there's this closeness between...

SPEAKER_02really certain types of people and the gods. It happens all the time. And then suddenly it gets winnowed out, you know, over the last 500 years. It's like becomes really against the rules. And I wonder, Seraphim, Deacon Seraphim, like... Is it because of who we are that such a concept would get everybody... Are even the atheists Puritans in that sense that such a mingling causes problems?

SPEAKER_01Yeah. So I would kind of preface this by saying, and I'll put on my catechist hat for a second here, is that the... Even in the ancient world, there is this intuition that there's this line. And the line is, you could say, between the uncreated and the created, between the Most High God. So, I mean, just as an example, in the more sophisticated versions of kind of late-stage

paganism that come right

SPEAKER_01around the same time that Christ comes into the world... In these more sophisticated versions of late-stage paganism, they would say, okay, well, there's not really like 12 Olympians or however many deities. Actually, the whole 12 Olympian thing is kind of like a modern... We like to imagine there was some systematic theology of paganism or something like that, which there wasn't. It's more about local cults and more about kind of local... But in any case,

SPEAKER_01they'd say, okay, well, there's not really that many gods because for something to be the true God, it would have to be, you know, one of the things that would have to have would be like oneness, right? And so if there's multiple, you know, multiple things at the same level, right? They're basically, they're trying to grasp towards saying something like, well, for God to be perfect, he has to be one. Right? And so therefore, when we talk about the...

SPEAKER_01when we talk about like Aphrodite or Zeus or all these different, you know, Aries, what we're really talking about is different aspects of the divinity, which, you know, like we're, we're being given, you know, given to us in these kind of anthropomorphized ways so that we could understand them. But obviously there's, there's just really, there's just one thing, let's call it the divinity, you know, like the sort of like the, you know, and this is basically, this is Plato's idea of God. So yeah, The question then is if there's the uncreated and then there's

the created,

SPEAKER_01which is everything else, could be a variety of spirits, of spiritual beings. You could say like local deities of places. You know, like a river, you know, like naiads and dryads, river spirits, tree spirits, etc. But also would include things like the local heroes that are venerated in the heroic cult of your city. Athens, you know, certain heroes in Thessaloniki, certain heroes and so on.

SPEAKER_01But all of these things are created. And this all the way down to normal human beings, animals, plants, rocks, elemental forces, things like that. All these things are created. So there's a line between the uncreated and the created. And the question is, what is able to cross that line? And the sort of the dictates of Greek philosophy are that nothing crosses that line. And so when Arius comes along, people sometimes misunderstand Arianism.

SPEAKER_01Arius' point was not to say Christ was not divine. It was to say that he is not co-eternal with the Father, that he's not uncreated. In other words, he is some divine thing that was created by the Father, but he is not uncreated. He is not co-eternal with the Father. That's what Arius said.

SPEAKER_02So Christ is a saint, sort of. Matthew, pick that up. So in the same way that St. John Maximovich for you is a type of godly character, Arius is saying Christ is the same way, a type of godly character. Yeah, he's like some kind of a super angel or something.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, something like that. And so to kind of bring this home to your original question, John – Obviously, the church pushes back against that. And we, you know, in that process, we formulate the creed, the symbol of the faith, etc., etc. We all kind of know that history. What happens, though, in the modern world is that we take that line between the uncreated and the created, and we bump it down now to be a line between the unseen and the seen.

And so then what we say is there's actually nothing except for maybe Jesus,

SPEAKER_01except for maybe the miracles in the Bible. we would still pray for people in the hospital. Oh, Jesus healed, was guiding the hands of the surgeon or something like this. But the idea of actually experiencing the miraculous, seeing an angel, the gifts of healing and so on,

SPEAKER_01those are really things that just happen in the Bible. They don't really happen nowadays because they were necessary. They had this idea that the miraculous was necessary to basically establish the faith. But now that we have the Bible, we do not need miracles or revelations anymore.

SPEAKER_02So seen and unseen. Yes, this is helpful.

SPEAKER_01And so this is actually, I think, a big part of why people get sideways. We can come back in a moment to that God language. But if you can understand that the impulse that somebody, when somebody hears something like, saint athanasius the great uh his famous you know axiom which is very often translated into english as god became man so that man could become a god right uh or god became man so that man can become god as or you know the the line i always tell my my new new catechumens the whole point of this religion

is that we eat god

SPEAKER_01to become god right that's what we're doing here right uh The thing that makes people uncomfortable with that language is actually the same impulse that makes people just generally uncomfortable with the supernatural, right? And it's kind of this latent separation between the seen and the unseen world and this idea that... You don't really cross that line. And so the idea that a human being, either one walking around with us today, as obviously there are saints walking around right now,

SPEAKER_01maybe we know them, maybe we don't, maybe they're not only to God, but God always has his holy ones at every time and in every age and in every place. He always has his holy ones. Or somebody like the Theotokos, the mother of God, or St. John of Shanghai now, who have kind of crossed over that line into the spiritual realm, but still have the ability to interact with us in the seen world. That idea is kind of the thing that's actually, the modern mind is kind of naturally offended by that idea.

um and so then we can talk about you know well then why would why would christians why would orthodox christians right who should kind of know better why would they have a a reaction to this language and that's where we can kind of pick up the

SPEAKER_02story but yeah what do you think matthew So I was told after I published that article that I had, uh, committed blasphemy, that I had created a stumbling block for neophytes in various ways, various kinds of points on this, um, that I didn't understand the Orthodox tradition, which was, um, maybe I don't, I don't know. I've been Orthodox my whole life, but you never, you know, I may not. Um, this is the most negative feedback I've ever received for

anything I've ever written.

SPEAKER_02And I've written some controversial things in my, I think 16 years, 17 years of public writing on the internet and so forth about orthodoxy. Um, I think that that we have there is this idea of kind of Unitarian monotheism. You know, we only worship one God. Right. But the idea that there are other gods that are not to be worshipped, but they are these kind of spiritual beings with the term God is applied to is like that comes straight out of the Old Testament.

SPEAKER_02That's not that's not a I'm not making this stuff up. So if you go to Psalm 81 slash 82, depending on if you're using the Greek or the Hebrew. I'm going to read this. I'll just read this real quick from the Holy Transfiguration Monastery Psalter, which is very commonly used by a lot of people. So that's the translation a lot of people will be familiar with. God stood in the congregation of the gods, and in the midst he shall stand out among gods.

SPEAKER_02How long will you judge unrighteously and accept the person of sinners? Judge for the orphan and the poor man. Do justice to the humble and the pauper. Rescue the poor man and the needy from the hand of the sinner. Deliver him. They have not known nor understood. They walk in darkness. Let the foundations of the earth be shaken. I said, ye are gods and all of you are the sons of the Most High. So you have this psalm, and this psalm gets Christ himself.

SPEAKER_02In St. John's Gospel actually interprets and comments on this psalm. So we have Christ's own commentary. St. Justin Martyr explains this psalm. We have other saints that explain this psalm. And this psalm in Hebrew, the word in Hebrew for God and the word in Hebrew for God's plural is the same word. uh elohim right it's it's the same word that's being used in both in both right so it's context that tells us the distinction and so you have this

idea there's this

SPEAKER_02term sons of god or this term gods that's being used in the old testament And repeatedly to refer to these spiritual beings, what we would call angels, who are these spiritual beings, but not the most high God, right? They're not the same as the most high God. So Christ in St. John's gospel, chapter 10. So if you, if you go to chapter 10 of St. John's gospel, which has, there's a lot of stuff going on in chapter 10 of St. John's gospel. But in this part of chapter 10,

SPEAKER_02Christ talks about he's he's saying things, you know, this is he's saying, you know, the Jewish leaders are saying to him, how long will you keep us in suspense? If you were the Christ, tell us plainly. So Jesus answered them, I told you and you do not believe. The works that I do in my father's name bear witness about me, but you do not believe because you are not among my sheep. My sheep hear my voice and I know them and they follow me, etc. Right. So Christ is being challenged about who he is. And he says, I am the father are one. And then it says the Jews picked up stones again to stone him.

SPEAKER_02So they recognize him saying, I am the father are one. From their perspective is blasphemy, right? He's just claimed to be one with the Father. He's claimed to be Yahweh. And so Jesus answered them, I have shown you many good works from the Father, for which of them are you going to stone me? The Jews answered him, it is not for a good work that we are going to stone you, but for blasphemy, because you being a man make yourself God. Jesus answered them, is it not written in your law? I said, you are gods. If he called them gods to whom the word of God came,

SPEAKER_02the logos of God came and scripture cannot be broken. Do you say of him whom the father consecrated and sent into the world? You are blaspheming because I said, I am the son of God. So Christ is saying here in St. John's gospel. You guys are offended that I'm calling myself God. I'm talking about myself in a way that makes me God. But here in the scriptures... We refer to these created beings as gods.

SPEAKER_02How can you object to Christ being called the son of God? This is what Christ is saying in chapter 10 of St. John's Gospel. And so there's this language about gods and the sons of God. These terms are used almost interchangeably. This kind of language is just rampant in the scriptures. Right. And some of this, I think, gets papered over a little bit in translation sometimes. Sometimes we just read right past it because we just are kind

of like our minds

SPEAKER_02maybe just don't pick it up or something. Sure. But it's right there. It's there for anyone to read.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, so let me add a little, tack on a little something there real quick, John, and that is to kind of clarify what this, what does this word mean? You know, God, you know, Elohim, El, you know. all these old Semitic words, which we kind of usually translate as God, G-O-D, in English, because that's the correct, you know, Germanic cognate, you know, word to that idea. But it's also there in our words like divinity,

divine, deus, and other Indo-European languages.

SPEAKER_01So when we're talking about a God in the sense, what we're really talking about is a spiritual power that rules over things. Yeah. And in that sense, the Most High God, that is the Holy Trinity, is not like the other gods, in the sense that however you would describe other spiritual powers, let's go back to that line between the uncreated and the created, right? Yeah. In that sense, the most holy trinity is not like any of the other things that

the trinity created.

SPEAKER_01It's not like the angelic powers, the bodiless hosts. By the way, when we talk about principalities and powers, dominions, thrones, etc., it's all that same language. The idea is that these are spiritual beings... who are given parts of creation to rule over. And of course, I think it's the very clear teaching from a very, very early, from the very beginning all the way back to Genesis,

SPEAKER_01despite what some people on... on Twitter might want to say. It's the very clear teaching of the Holy Scriptures and in our tradition that this is, in fact, the thing for which we as human beings were made. This is the destiny to which we are called. And you very strongly find this idea that human beings... are one of the things that we're to do is sort of replace the angels who fell. You get this idea. This is kind of implicit in a lot of the numerological stuff,

for instance, in the apocalypse. The traditional number of the gods of the divine council is like 70 or 72,

SPEAKER_01which, by the way, has to do with the number of... brightest stars and major constellations of the old sumerian zodiac that's where that number comes from and uh so when uh when god says to abraham your descendants will be as the stars of heaven he's not just talking about number he's talking about they're going to be in this place like kind of ruling over the fate of the world right ruling over time ruling over history and And so when we talk about a saint,

SPEAKER_01a holy one, which is what saint means, that terminology in the scriptures is interchangeable with this word that we translate as God. Wow.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, so you have these terms, holy one, sons of God, gods, that are used interchangeably to refer to these angelic beings in God's divine counsel. So then make the distinction. Okay, make the distinction for me. So the saints then are the holy ones. And your use of the word God is something like a wake up call the moderns to

SPEAKER_02actually pay attention to the forgotten words.

SPEAKER_01We have this buzzword that we like to use in Orthodoxy. You know, we're talking about theosis this, theosis that. Like, what do people think that word means? It means becoming God. That's what theosis means. And he just very clearly lays out in this series of essays that, actually why this is the purpose and destiny of the human life. He lays out things like here's a whole, you know, the whole third essay in here is called The Contribution of the

Theotokos to the

SPEAKER_01Theosis of Man. Like it's just very, very beautiful, very pastoral. And it is one of the things that I think that he makes, one of the points that he makes in here, which I thought was so beautiful and so relevant to things in my own life right now, He says that since man is called to be a god, and that he's quoting from one of the fathers there, that is, was created to become a god, as long as he does not find himself on the path of theosis,

SPEAKER_01he feels an emptiness within himself. Yeah. He may organize his life in such a way that he is almost never at peace, never alone with himself, surrounded by noise, tension, television, radio, continuous information about this and that. He may seek to forget with drugs or not to think,

SPEAKER_01not to worry, not to remember that he is on the wrong path and is strayed from his purpose. And he goes on to talk about how the thing that is necessary for theosis... is the death of the ego. Like you have to be, or at least of egoism rather. And he talks about how we see Christ open up the path to theosis to us, that is the path to become gods. He opens to us by becoming man. And he really expands on this axiom of St.

SPEAKER_01Athanasius in this really beautiful way where he really shows... a big part of that, you know, God became man so that man might become a God, has to do with God's self-emptying, right? He empties himself, becomes one of us, takes on the form of the servant, so on, and therefore our path to ascend with him is also through that self-emptying. And a big part, I think, of why we have this,

SPEAKER_01we as Christians, like we shrink from this kind of language, right? Some of it is just, again, kind of like modern Puritan heebie-jeebies that are just kind of hanging around. We all have some level of that to deal with. But I think a really big part of it has to do with the fact that whenever we think about somebody ruling... We can only imagine this in the way that it happens in the world. That is, people who are exerting their domination, who are,

SPEAKER_01you know, respect my authority, you know, people who are, you know, just totally lost in their own ego. And it's very difficult for us to actually imagine someone... It's very actually difficult for us to imagine someone who has that Christ-like humility, but that is exactly the person who is a God.

SPEAKER_02So I think what people are thinking, at some level I am, like Joe Blow, so I'm like a God, but... The saints are like a God more often or more consistently? You and I are supposed to be gods. We're supposed to be gods, but we're not doing it. Do we image it at times? Because part of what I was reading in preparation was that, oh, look, he's merciful. He's like a God.

SPEAKER_01So St. Gregory of Nyssa, who is very often brought up in these patristic conversations about theosis, and by the way, again, just to restate, what do people think the word theosis means? I mean, it means becoming God. It's the process of becoming God. That's what theosis is, okay? Right. St. Gregory of Nyssa is often brought up in this context, but actually one of the main places that St. Gregory of Nyssa talks about this is in,

SPEAKER_01you know, everybody likes to read his weird, really hard theology stuff, but actually the stuff to read with St. Gregory is the homilies, which is one of the very first things I was recommended by my spiritual father, I was told to read, were his homilies on the Beatitudes and the Lord's Prayer. And in his homily on the Lord's Prayer, St. Gregory says that the way that we become most like God is, and this is in the commentary on the homily on the line,

SPEAKER_01forgive us our debts as we forgive our debtors, or trespasses if you're that church. But in any case, the time that we become the most like God is, is when we forgive and why is this it's because god is free and to truly forgive someone means to totally free yourself actually from holding on to that resentment you know over the wrong that they've done to you and allowing

that to continue to

SPEAKER_01have control over your life and so if you want to be truly free then what you have to do is totally forgive everyone beginning with yourself. And this is what, this is what makes us free. And so it's definitely the case that there are ways that we can be, uh, gods. Um, I mean, a good example, um, you know, God says to, uh, says to Moses, right? I will make you a God unto Pharaoh. That is, you are going to become a spiritual power ruling over Pharaoh.

SPEAKER_01Right. Um, Anytime that we take order in creation, anytime that we engage in, let's say, exorcistic activities, that is when we take things that are impure and we make them pure. We take places that are unholy and we make them holy. We take places that are chaotic and we make them orderly. Interesting. Anytime we do this, we are participating exactly in the order that

The ordering of creation, which we were called to do, and that's the thing that we're made for.

SPEAKER_01And of course, obviously, yes, yeah. I have to read something.

SPEAKER_02I have to read something. Okay. So just from what you just brought up. So this is from the feast that one of the hymns from the feast of Saints Barsanufius and John,

SPEAKER_01the Desert Fathers. Okay. Everybody's favorite.

SPEAKER_02All right. Having become gods in this life by the grace of God, ye forgave sins, prolonged life, opened the gates of death, cast out demons, caused wars to cease, held nature subservient, and changed men's hearts. O ye summits of the fathers, ye fashioned spiritual men after your own image and created a paradise in the desert wasteland. Wherefore, save us by your prayers.

SPEAKER_01Pay very close attention to that line. You fashioned spiritual men... in your image. He's talking about... I mean, that is... First of all, there are... That's crazy. There are things in the services and in the Holy Fathers which I... deacon seraphim would not say i just like i wouldn't go that far i would be afraid to say those words i'm a timid man but but what the holy service is saying i'm really glad you brought up this hymn because because uh this is

something that's a saint symphony of essex picks up he says that so so who are the who are you gotta

SPEAKER_01like who are the men who who are the spiritual men that St. Sparsanuvius and John are fashioning in their image. Well, it's their spiritual children, their spiritual sons, and that actually kind of also all the people who continue to read their writings, ask their prayers, participate in their patronage, and so on. And so it's saying that they're actually now participating in the creation of a living soul in the same way that Christ made Adam. And Saint Sophrone of Essex, he actually says that when we participate in prayer,

SPEAKER_01like real prayer, deep prayer, true prayer, that we are actually participating in that moment in the creation of our own soul. This is in his little book called On Prayer.

SPEAKER_03Hmm.

SPEAKER_01And of course, I mean, on just like a very basic level, I mean, you know, we're all fathers here, right? You know, when you have a child, right, you're participating in the creation of human being, right? You know, like, obviously, it's an act of God to the mystery of all of that, right? But you're participating in that, but you're also participating in in the i mean why do we call a priest a spiritual father right

because he another one i keep you're absolutely right because he makes you can hear all the triggers though he makes a he makes a new person right in the baptismal waters he's obviously of course this is the work of christ nobody's saying it's not the work of

SPEAKER_01christ but but But the whole point is that we are called now to participate in the work of God, not just ordering creation, but actually bringing new life into existence. Guys, pause, invite.

SPEAKER_02Greenville, May 24, 25, Art of Tamada. Lots of different pricing prices for small-time tickets, big-time tickets. Come for all of it for the whole VIP weekend. Spend, I don't know, $225 on tickets. Or just come for the concert Saturday night, the 25th of October. Did I say May? It's October. October 24th, 25th. Buy a ticket to the concert. Come.

SPEAKER_02Or buy a ticket to our speakers, Nathan Jacobs, Frederica Matthews Green. And then have a table with them and hang out. You can do that too. You can do lots of stuff. Pricing is all coming out, but those are the kind of prices we're talking about for our Art of Tomodot in Greenville at the restaurant on the green at Hampton Station. Don't forget in November, 6789, we're doing our Art of Tomodot in Florida. Back to the show. But you're triggering that last four and a half minutes was a

trigger for even the

SPEAKER_02residue of my old pre-Orthodox self 30 years ago. You guys are triggering me. Stop triggering me. Because that's why you got in trouble, Matthew.

SPEAKER_00Yeah.

SPEAKER_02So there's a lot of this. So I've gone through with some help. I have to credit my friend, Father Andrew, for helping me with this. Gone through a lot of the services of the church. And at least, at minimum, on average, every other week, at minimum, there is hymnography that we sing in our services that speaks about the saints as being God's. And a lot of the time,

SPEAKER_02it's like this kind of, what I just read, you have this kind of like, they're like sub-creators. The Apostle Barnabas, in the hymns to the Apostle Barnabas, it says that he was a secondary god. Which is a weird riff on something in the Book of Acts, by the way. Yes, that's right.

SPEAKER_01This whole thing where Paul and Barnabas show up, it's Paul and Barnabas, not Paul and Silas, right? Yeah, St. Paul and Barnabas show up and... No, no, it's the other way. St. Paul's the one talking all the time. And so people assume Barnabas, therefore, must be the boss. And they start calling him Jupiter or Zeus. And they start calling St. Paul Mercury because the idea is obviously that the more talkative person is obviously less important.

SPEAKER_01This is how people think in the ancient world, right? Because the more talkative person, he's the messenger. And so this hymn does a weird little inversion there and calls him a secondary god. And it's like, well, they were wrong to mistake him for who they mistook him for, but it's not wrong that he was a god, but he's not quite on the level of St. Paul. And anyway, I don't know. It's just a very fun...

SPEAKER_02Well, I got I got more. I got another one. I got another one. If you're like riffing on this, like Olympus imagery. Right. Cyril and Methodius. So St. Methodius was a monk on not the Greek Mount Olympus, but another mount called Olympus. Okay. And so there's this hymn, being gods by grace, ye dwelt on Mount Olympus. That's so great. Whence ye were called forth by God. It's like, you know, they're obviously, it's obviously playing on this.

SPEAKER_02You also have, so see, Phonurios is called a new Colossus of Rhodes. and alive forever in christ as a god by grace we have on the feast of the apostles the 12 apostles not like a minor feast fairly significant feast right they are called uh the friends of christ and 12 god seers do i honor whom i call heroes and gods and do rightly so you have like the hero language this is all playing on this greek god imagery right with the colossus of roads and mount olympus

even the even the procumen verse that we use for the feasts of the apostles or just like the daily procumen on for thursday which is their sound has gone forth into all the world and their sayings the end of the cosmos this is a psalm verse about the zodiac folks

SPEAKER_01It's literally, if you go read what that psalm is about, it talks about the way the sun gets up and leaves different. That's a description of the zodiac. Because the whole point is, you've got 12 signs of the zodiac, but there are 12 apostles. And it's not the stars that are ruling over creation. It's the apostles who are ruling over creation. It's fulfillment.

SPEAKER_02Yeah. It's the fullest form.

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_02So, so going to go to the Zodiac kind of the, the, the kind of cosmological imagery, I have to, I have to quote this one. So I just have all, I have a bunch of these. St. Simeon, the new theologian. So this is a hymn to St. Simeon. I think this is from Matins. In the primordial light, he became a second light. And by him who is God by nature, he was made a God by grace. So here he's a second light in the cosmos and Send me the new theologian. And so it's in some way.

SPEAKER_02So this is like rampant. This is everywhere. If you just like go to Matins and you're at the whole service of Matins with all the canons and stuff,

SPEAKER_01you will hear this guy. I'm sorry to even like give us any kind of airtime, but there's this guy on Twitter who was saying, not an Orthodox person, but basically saying, hey, the Orthodox have only actually like taught theosis, you know, since the 1980s. And I was like, really? Really? 1950s, whatever. I think you said 50s. That's so ridiculous. All you have to do is read the services. The services that we all hear when we go to church. Yeah.

SPEAKER_02Well, Matthew... Yeah, I think we kind of discount the services a little bit when we think about like theology and stuff. We want to like dig up texts and stuff, which is fine. But but there's a sort of like the primary way the locus of Orthodox life is in the liturgical services of the church. Right. So if the services are all saying something, we should probably pay attention to it. Yeah. I mean. sorry john that happens a lot to me where when i am in that

prayerful moment and i'm actually hearing the tropar it's almost never fails that it it doesn't it does something to you that it it it makes you question all your presuppositions that you brought into the church as a convert they never fit easily with your old self i've

SPEAKER_02noticed no they challenge you i mean Can I read one more hymn, guys?

SPEAKER_01Please read all the hymns as far as I'm concerned. Because lest we think that this is like some old, like archaic thing, right?

SPEAKER_02I'm going to read you the second canon to the new martyrs of Russia, the Matins canon to the new martyrs of Russia. So this is like, I think we're 21st century at this point when this was composed, probably like early 21st century, but like recent, recent, right? Yeah. O race of gods, who were once humbled below the beasts, your dishonor hath been turned to that which Adam long ago vainly sought amiss. But lawfully striving, ye won the prize of divinity.

SPEAKER_02And in your congregation, as the judge with the victors, God doth stand out among you, the gods by grace." Sarov and Perm, Tobolsk, Solovky, Astrakhan, Peter's city, with Kazan and ancient Muscovy herself leap for joy to stay. The whole land of Russia rejoiceth to see how martyrdom hath made her earthborn children to be gods by adoption, and we faithful are hallowed in blessing them. And you're saying that's consistent all the way back to like Irenaeus, who's talking about first we're men and now we become gods.

SPEAKER_02So you can take it back to Christ speaking in St. John's gospel and then to the Psalms. I mean, this is like a Genesis, right?

SPEAKER_01This goes all the way back. And here, let's talk about Genesis for a moment. Part of the reaction, part of the squeamishness, ickiness, part of that does come from this interaction between the serpent and Eve in the garden. And so this is the thing to kind of bring up. And this is the thing to kind of talk about. Next, I think, you know, because, I mean, there's absolutely no, as far as I'm concerned,

SPEAKER_01and I really don't, I don't know any Orthodox clergyman, theologian, et cetera, who would disagree with this. I mean, this teaching of theosis, right? This is just Orthodoxy 101, right? This is what we've always believed. This is what we've always taught. This is what is in the Holy Scriptures. So the question then is like, well, okay, but what about what the serpent says to Eve? Right? Because this is a serious objection that you could bring up. And certainly, I'll talk about my Protestant upbringing again for a moment.

SPEAKER_01So people would say things like... You know, whatever, whatever, like Joel Osteen would, because there was kind of a thing where like new agey people and especially kind of like prosperity gospel types would pick up some of these same verses that we've just been quoting and say, look, see, you're a God, you're a little G God. And so you should be able to like take control over the spiritual realms. You can just name it and claim it and you have all this power and all these different things.

and um and of course it's coming outside of like any kind of like church hierarchy you know it's it's tied very closely to this idea of prosperity and you know sort of like the more god loves you the more money and stuff you're going to have which seems to be the opposite of the actual case actually if you have a lot of money and stuff i would maybe really like look at your life and think about your soul um because there are no warnings to the poor in the scriptures but in any case in any

SPEAKER_01case um In any case, there's... It's a bad emotion. Yeah, things you should not say like on Stuart's Sunday. That's a good one. But yeah, no one next to the poor in the Bible. Anyway, so we would, in response to those kinds of people who would say things like that, we would bring up this as, oh, well, that's just the lie of the serpent, you know, all the way from the beginning, this promise of power, right? And so it's worth considering, like, what is it about,

SPEAKER_01what the serpent promises Eve, our first mother? What is it about what the serpent promises her that is different from what God promises Abraham, from what the scriptures promise us, from what the church promises believers? And it's very simple. The offering of becoming like God was the thing That human beings are made to be. But what the serpent offers is a way to get there.

SPEAKER_01And this is actually implicit, by the way, in that one of the last treparia that Matthew just read. I think it was the one that was talking about the one that one talking about Adam. Was that was that the new martyrs of Russia, Matthew? Or is that the one before that? Where it mentioned Adam.

SPEAKER_02Not the new Mark. Yeah, yeah. Your dishonor hath been turned to that which Adam long ago vainly sought amiss. but lawfully striving, ye won the prize of divinity. So there's this idea that Adam vainly tried to get this thing, but these saints lawfully striving by being martyrs have achieved what Adam couldn't. Can I read one more thing real quick? Because this is relevant. This is a hymn to the virgin martyr Theodosia.

SPEAKER_02who in this hymn to her, she's contrasted with Eve. So there's this kind of direct contrast being made between her and Eve. So it says, deified through gazing upon God, thou hast attained the artful desire of Eve, our first mother, becoming a God through divine communion. Wherefore, we magnify the almost blessed Theodosia. So you have this idea of through divine communion,

SPEAKER_00Well, this is when I get to tell you we've encountered some technical difficulties, specifically with Matthew Naimi's recording. So I hope you stick around. The rest of the show will sort of be some back and forth between John and Richard because they didn't realize at the time that we had lost his recording. So it is what it is. Please forgive us and we'll try to make sure it doesn't happen again. Much love.

SPEAKER_01And that's the thing that I want to point out. Like, what is it about the promise of the serpent in the garden that is a problem? It's the fact that the serpent was offering to eve a way to try to become god without god to try to become like god without reference to him without obedience to him without gratitude and thanksgiving to him this whole failure of thanksgiving you know that for instance father alexander schmemann used to write about all the time and talk about all the time right this this this this failure of to live the eucharistic life

to offer the world up in Thanksgiving, but instead to try to seize power for ourselves.

SPEAKER_01And so the thing is, you are made. You are made. Every single person listening to this was made. to sit in authority and to judge the angels and to rule the stars and planets and to command the cosmos, right? St. Paul says this to literally the, like objectively the worst church in the Bible, right? To the, to the Corinthians, you know, like all kinds of wacky stuff going on at Corinth, right? They get more letters and longer than anybody else because they have so many problems. And he says to them, don't you know that you are going to judge angels,

right?

SPEAKER_01And that if you understand this, then things like the hymn to the Theotokos, it makes a lot of sense. It's not in any way blasphemous or taking away from God's honor to say that she is more honorable than the cherubim and more glorious than the seraphim.

SPEAKER_02I have a question. Is the implication then, does it go the other way? There seems to be a going up and a returning and doing things as we were meant to be, as agia, as holy. Is the flip side the same, where we try to have the power of God without God? Do we become demonic, say some technological giant that wants to change the world through his techne? Is that person then achieving a type of demonry?

SPEAKER_01Seems to be the case, John. I mean, you know, sort of hesitate to judge anybody, but.

SPEAKER_02No, we're not naming names. I'm just wondering if that's the image of that.

SPEAKER_01I mean, yes. Anytime. I mean, just go back to the Bible, like the whole project of Babel. The whole project of Babel. And if you read especially the literature and the tradition commenting on the book of Genesis and commenting on the Babel story, it's very clear that the let us build a city and a tower, all of this is very closely associated also with idolatry, also with tyranny, and so on. I mean, this is just very...

you know, two paths, you know, one of life and one of death, one of light, one of darkness.

SPEAKER_00Well,

SPEAKER_01also one of, also one of you can rule with Christ or you can try to rule the world on your own. And if you do that, then you do the works of the first person who tried to do that. Do you think it's hard to hear that for a lot of people because of the equality

SPEAKER_02test, you know, the democratic impulse in us to be like, hey, man,

SPEAKER_01yeah, I mean, I'm sure that they're really good, but...

SPEAKER_02What about all of us?

SPEAKER_01I mean, it's very obvious, John, that if... Because when very often, and you'll even see this with Orthodox people, we would talk about saints. The thing that we want to focus on now, the thing that we have the impulse to focus on now is the ways that the saints are just like us. But if you read the hymnography and you read the Synaxarion and you look at the tradition, the thing that we are not actually super impressed with is, oh, he's just like me.

SPEAKER_01He yells at his kids too or whatever. He doesn't read like that, you mean? That is not how it reads. Yeah. It's very, very clear. Like this guy's this guy's not like me. I mean, I mean. All right. So the name thing, you know, Seraphim has been my name since I was received into the church and for years and years and years. It's what family and friends have called me. And then because I was too lazy to ever change my name on Facebook, I started doing some podcasts and people called me Richard and I didn't want to make a big, you know, so whatever. But now I'm a deacon, and so I need to just kind of,

SPEAKER_01you know, I'm representing my bishop to a certain extent. I have to be the same person everywhere, not, you know, two different people in two different places. All right, so why, but why seraphim? It's because I was named after St. Seraphim of Sorov when I was received into the church. And what do I have in common with St. Seraphim of Surab? Literally the only thing is chronic back pain. I mean, otherwise, you know, he's different from me in every single way. And that's to my, like, the thing that I'm hoping will happen, you know, is through his prayers.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. And the love of the people in my community, and ultimately through the grace of God, I hope to become more like him. I really desire that, to have his quietness, to have his humility, to have his wisdom, to have his discernment. to have his, most of all, just his fervent prayer. These are things that I won for myself. I didn't pick him as a saint because I related with him. I didn't really pick him at all, but it's a different story. But I didn't pick him as my saint because he was somebody I

just really related to.

SPEAKER_01And if somebody's done that, I'm not trying to run them down. The thing I'm trying to point out is that... The saints are spectacular. And the reason I like the language that Matthew has used, which is actually, again, just the language of our holy services, is that... Let me put it this way. If you're an Orthodox Christian and you react a little bit to that, what I would encourage you to do is examine yourself and see

where that reaction is

SPEAKER_01coming from. I think that you will find it's coming from one of two things. I said something earlier that hopefully will make it into the last edit. But in this wonderful little book on Theosis called Theosis, The True Person, A Purpose of Human Life by Archimandrite George, of the Holy Monastery of St. Gregorios on Mount Athos. This is a wonderful booklet. You can buy it on Amazon. I get no money for promoting it, but it's like 50 pages long. Yeah, get it from Eite Books. Don't buy it on Amazon. Yeah, buy it from Eite Books. Thank you, Matthew. Yeah, buy it from Eite Books.

SPEAKER_01I also don't get money from that, but they will buy me a beer. Cha-ching. Yeah, cha-ching. So definitely get this little booklet. It's about 50 pages long. It talks about a lot of the things that I'm trying to say here. But one of the things that he ties it into is that the path that Adam and Eve tried to seek when they tried to take this outside the proper time, outside the proper way, was the path of egoism. And that egoism is really, that's the enemy here.

And in the same way that God became man by emptying himself, by taking on the form of a servant,

SPEAKER_01If we can also empty ourselves, you know, this is St. Silouan's, his whole idea of like the inverted pyramid, right? If you can empty yourself, you go all the way down to the bottom of the pyramid, that's actually where you will find Christ. And that is when you will actually become divine. And...

SPEAKER_02Man, it's anti-democratic.

SPEAKER_01It's very anti-democratic, but it's also kind of... It's not anti-hierarchical, but it's like the real hierarchy is not the one you think there is. Now, I'm not in any way saying anything against the visible hierarchy of the church. But my point in saying this is to say that very often when we have a reaction to this term, God... or this language of human divinization, which is the same word as theosis,

SPEAKER_01just from Latin instead of from Greek, right? But when we have a reaction to this terminology, part of it is because the only way, you know, whenever we think of people we've seen trying to rule over things, we think of little petty tyrants, we think of our own ego, right? And then we sort of assume these other people must be like that. And we know that the saints aren't like that. And so we kind of shy away from that language. I would say to a non-Orthodox person watching this, if you've, my gosh, if you've stuck around this long,

SPEAKER_01first of all, well done for sticking around for most of the feedback, shop talk, fighting through the feedback and the editing and everything else. But what I would say to you is... If you have a strong reaction to this kind of language, that your idea of what your true calling and purpose is as a human being is too small. And I would recommend to you this, like I said, this great little booklet.

SPEAKER_02And it's funny, right? I think Matthew said something that stuck with me. Somehow we miss it, but when you go back and read it, it's really evident in scripture. And I think we miss it because I think I was taught to read scripture for the morality. Like I had a morality, what do you call it?

SPEAKER_01Oh, he's got the best line in here about this. I'm going to hunt for that while you say what you're saying.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, just see if you can find it, because it's like I have a thresher with the words in Scripture. I'm going... And I keep looking for how to be good, how to be good, how to be good. And then I get a lot of those lessons, but this stuff's like how creation's designed. And then you get, that implication's pretty cool because then it calls me not to so much do good stuff as much to find my place in all of creation.

SPEAKER_02And then you go, whoa, I'm called to be like a god? Like actually, then you realize that, you know, how far away we are, but also how there's so much potential for beauty. Like it could be much more beautiful a little bit yeah so this is not the quote I was looking for but it's a similar one and it basically makes the point that I want to make it says that the charismata that form us in his image were given to man so the things that make us like God

were given to man by God in order that he may reach very high so that through them he may attain a likeness to his God and creator so that he may have not only an

SPEAKER_01external moral relationship but a personal union with his career. And so much of modern religion, even for people who believe in God, is about an external and moral relationship. And if I'm totally honest, most of the day I'm going throughout the day, I'm like, oh, I'm feeling tempted to sin. I shouldn't sin. And I'm just thinking in these external and moral terms. But that is not actually the substance of our relationship with God. That would be like saying the substance of my relationship with

my wife is just

SPEAKER_01whether or not I'm you know, faithful to her from moment to moment. Obviously, that's a big part of it. But if you're at the end of the day, you know, you get to the end of the day and you're like, well, I didn't cheat on my wife today. It's like, OK, congratulations for doing like the bare minimum to actually be in a marriage.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, right. I paid rent.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, it's right.

SPEAKER_02You know, I paid rent.

SPEAKER_01OK, but also. Right. Yeah, so you're not in a real, you know, that's actually not the relationship. That's just not falling out of the relationship. And so, yeah. I think it was serendipitous because I know Matthew wanted to speak about,

SPEAKER_02I mean, he's about to publish an article I hope everyone will read. uh it's really a digging down on this idea that it's okay to lean into gods as our our potential reality or or for saints as a type of reality and then your book it's really i mean it sits right in front of us theosis it's so funny how we miss the obvious thing sometimes can i read a prayer

SPEAKER_01Oh, there's Matthew. Yeah, read a prayer, and then I think Matthew's coming back on, and then we'll finish.

SPEAKER_02How about that?

SPEAKER_01Okay, sounds good. We'll give Matthew a second so that it doesn't cut in.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, let him hear the prayer, and then we can make some.

SPEAKER_01Sorry, this is going to be horrible for your editor. He's going to be working on this. I feel sorry for that guy.

SPEAKER_02But I got to say, and you can leave this in if you want. When it's cooking with you two guys on this pot, it's cooking, like deep cooking.

SPEAKER_01All right, so I'm going to read this prayer. And by the way, Father George begins the preface here by saying, it is very daring for someone to talk about theosis without having first tasted it. And which is which was how we should have probably started this podcast. You know, like we're all talking about something which none of us have really, you know, experienced. Certainly not in the way.

SPEAKER_02Wait, wait, can I take that on for one second?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, do it. I was reading in prep for this that there was a number of references that when someone is acting mercifully against all the grain of humanity or fallen humanity.

SPEAKER_02There's also, the saints will say, there is Christ. There is the saint. And if only for a moment, sort of like a whale appears out of the ocean and gets its breath. I feel like sometimes it's okay to say that. It sounds kind of cheesy, but I actually do think that's true.

SPEAKER_01in your life, any moment, you know, where, where, you know, uh, the, the egoism and the selfishness has kind of subsided, like hopefully we're all, you know, we can be realistic about ourselves enough to say that that has sometimes happened. You would just say, you know, that was Christ.

SPEAKER_00Right.

SPEAKER_01But that's what, that's what we mean. Right. And the thing is like, you have to, part of, part of the process is that you have to make that deflection. One of my spiritual fathers who had a very... Well, anyway, he frequently gives talks on Elder Emilianos of the Seminus Petro Monastery, who's a recent holy man, somebody who lived within my lifetime just a few years ago, I think will certainly be canonized. Not that I have anything to do with that,

but it seems obvious to me that he will be.

SPEAKER_01But, you know, one time I heard him giving a talk on Elder Emilianos, and it got to the end and said, listen, if there's anything good in here, it wasn't me, it was the Elder. You know, just basically saying, you know, it's the saints, it's Christ working on me, right? That's the idea. And so, you're right, we do have these moments, you know, when we show mercy, when we show love, when we just, like, humble ourselves and apologize to our children. I mean, my goodness. I mean, if you want to really... Humble yourself.

SPEAKER_01Sometimes that's a good place to begin. But anyway, so here's this prayer that he puts at the beginning of this book, Theosis, The True Purpose of Human Life. He says, Merciful Lord, in your boundless love, be pleased to make us worthy to enter the path of theosis before we leave the present temporal world. Merciful Lord, in their quest for theosis, guide those of our Orthodox brethren who do not rejoice because they are unaware of

SPEAKER_01the magnificence of the fact that they are called to be gods. Merciful Lord, also guide the steps of heterodox Christians to become aware of your truth so that they are not left outside your bridal chamber and deprived of the grace of theosis. Merciful Lord, have mercy on us and on your world. Amen. So that's not my prayer. That's Father George's. But maybe that's a good place to kind of cap off this conversation.

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_02It's perfect. Matthew, don't worry. We're going to do it again. But we're going to use this. I'm just going to make an announcement. I'm not the first person to have some pods. And we'll get together again. And I think I might bump into some of you this summer and some of these really cool projects we're doing. And Matthew... Your pop and I are pals in a weird way, and I'm still trying to do some work with his philanthropy, so I'm going to keep pestering him through you, okay? Is that all right?

SPEAKER_02Hey, many blessings. Thanks, guys, for your work. It's really, it affects people. It matters. Peace out. Talk to you guys soon. Well, times are freaky. My Gen X self can't handle it. I remember when I was taught you're just supposed to get a yard and a house and then buy beer and retire and watch the Jets lose.

SPEAKER_02But it seems that we're called to more than that. I'll do it. I'm called. My wife helps me. I'll do that stuff, like become a god. Cool conversation today. Sorry about the technical difficulties. All right, who loves you? Peace out.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Demons, Deception, and Why Your Spiritual Practices Might Be Dangerous

    Oct 2, 20261 hr 18 minAudio

    Find this episode on YouTube: "Justine Alter" - a pseudonym - returns to chat with John Heers in a raw Heavy Things Lightly conversation you have to hear to believe.Justine worked for years as a professional psychic,...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. The Fox News Reporter Who Quit to Live an Orthodox Homesteading Life

    Sep 25, 20261 hr 35 minAudio

    Find this episode on YouTube: Holly Hickman went from Columbia Journalism and Fox News Radio covering NASA and the 2008 election - to milking cows, making cheese, and converting to Orthodoxy.In this episode of Heavy...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Why They Left NASA to Start St. George's Classical Academy

    Sep 21, 20261 hr 2 minAudio

    Can you teach kids the truth AND prepare them for a secular world?On this episode of Heavy Things Lightly, host John Heers talks with James and Juliana Joyce, founders of St. George's Classical Academy in Boxford,...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. An Odyssean Tale: The Man Who Would Not Quit

    Sep 4, 20261 hr 37 minAudio

    Find this episode on YouTube: Crow walked America searching for his father - and found the Father.From West Virginia hollers to LA gangs, from wolves in the Mojave desert to an Orthodox cross, this is an Odyssean tale...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. From Broadway to the Supra: Carrie Manolakos on Life After Lockdown

    Sep 1, 20261 hr 51 minAudio

    Welcome to the first episode of “Save Me a Spot at the Supra” on Heavy Things Lightly where John Heers hosts singer and Broadway performer Carrie Manolakos (best known for her performances in Mama Mia! and Wicked) at...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode