Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Heavy Things Lightly

Heavy Things Lightly artwork

Eros Unbound: the story of Donald Marc Antony Trump

Mar 16, 20261 hr 7 minAudio
  • Apple Podcasts
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Find this episode on YouTube: Pavel Schelin sits down once more with John to talk about the tragic story of Marc Antony and those characters around him. What happens when massive Dionysian energy has no true master? It's a story of a bad Tamada, or Trump, or crazy college parties - and understanding this can help us all order our lives a little better.We invite you to join Pavel's new course at the Symbolic World - Plutarch: Symbolism in History. The course reads Plutarch’s Lives as a grammar of symbolism embodied in history to better understand the patterns that govern human political order and disorder.▶ Discover more and register here: https://www.thesymbolicworld.com/courses/plutarch-symbolism-in-historyEarly bird discount available. Live sessions · Wednesdays · 4-6 PM ET · Starting March 18th-----------------------Conrad's Deli - The best jerky you'll ever have: https://conradsdeli.com/ use promo code "FIRST THINGS" for 10% off.-----------------------✒ Substack: https://johnheersftf.substack.com/ⓧ https://x.com/johnfromftf🍷The best dinner party you've ever experienced - Supra Dinner Society: https://supradinner.com/🏖️ Tailormade tours that give back: https://www.gratitude-travels.com/home🔎 Discover the non-profit behind Heavy Things Lightly: https://first-things.org/ ✈ Become a Field Worker with FTF: https://first-things.org/opportunities📢 First Things Telegram: https://t.me/firstthingsfoundation🥂 Keipi Restaurant: https://keipirestaurant.orgPlease leave a review with your comments! Your support keeps this podcast alive and allows us to broaden our discussion. ---This “Enlightened” New World utopia isn’t turning out to be all it was cracked up to be. Society is disenchanting, but are the only alternatives hiding out in the hills or burying yourself in books? With an air of levity and a touch of humor, John Heers teaches how to examine the confusing New World by calling upon the mind and wisdom of oft-forgotten Old. Heavy Things, Lightly.--- Credits Music: Intro / Outro Provided by Greg Gilbertson & Band This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit johnheersftf.substack.com/subscribe

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

let us toast to eros let us toast to the creative desire let this desire never run out in us let us not be sterile but let not this desire but but also let's this

SPEAKER_00desire serve the worthy king the worthy master

SPEAKER_02Guys, hello. It's this podcast, Everything's Lightly. I'm pouring a Borgiomi. I had some just now with my guest, Pavel Pasha, I call him, Schellen, who is a philosopher. He's Russian. He's got a huge following in Russia, hundreds of thousands, and he does also English language. And he's coming on to talk about what? The coolest thing. which is the life of Mark Anthony as essentially the life of

maybe all of our

SPEAKER_02leaders right now. It's very interesting. He's teaching a course on Plutarch over on Symbolic World with a character named Jonathan Pajot. And I think it's really worth you checking out. But today he kind of goes off script of Plutarch and talks about what Plutarch says about Mark Anthony. And we tie it into, I don't know. I don't know.

SPEAKER_01People bombing people.

SPEAKER_02I don't know. Why am I doing Nixon? I'm having fun. This is my toast to you guys. In a time that's laced with crisis, we should laugh. But Marc Anthony allows us to have the energy of laughing, which is part of the Dionysian energy. That's what we talk about today on Everything's Lightly. Also, I'm going to tell you about beef jerky. It comes from Conrad's and a family named the Glazers in Pennsylvania.

SPEAKER_02And I'm showing it to you right now. I showed it and blocked out the sun, which is the light that's shining on me. Guys, Conrad's Jerky Company, delicious flavors, many different kinds. I'm eating a natural here, an all natural Conrad's Jerky, but I'm not eating it because it's lent. Oh, one other thing. Do listen to this music from Greg Gilbertson, and I will see you on the other side.

SPEAKER_02Well, hello. What's up? Are you in Arizona, Pasha?

SPEAKER_00No, I'm in Georgia, Atlanta.

SPEAKER_02That's right. You live in Georgia now.

SPEAKER_00You can do a second timestamp. I knew that. That was awkward. It was a joke. Anyway.

SPEAKER_02I'm trying to open my board, Jomi. I'm drinking water today with you. I'm going to start with a toast. Is that okay?

SPEAKER_00It's always okay with you.

SPEAKER_02But people who hear that you're drinking a toast of water, they probably have some sadness from hearing that. But it's the middle of the day, in the middle of the fast, and I'm drinking Georgian water. But I won't... The wine is for the words, but here's some words to philosophy. I want to talk today about Plutarch because you're teaching a cool course over on Symbolic World where we're friends with Jonathan and those guys. And so I want to toast to the words that take place in the mind,

SPEAKER_02but sometimes we should get out of the mind too. And I think Lent's something like that time. So to the words, may they not be... let's put this overemphasize for their meaning, but let's have fun with them today. In other words, sometimes silence in the presence of sacred things might be enough, like a tree. Now I sound like a tree hugger, but okay guys, this is Pasha.

SPEAKER_02You know him. He's my world famous Russian philosopher. Yeah, some of them. What do you want to do when you go into the past and you start talking about people like Plutarch as a philosopher and as a philosopher from the East, from Russia? Do you have an inherent care for people? the Greeks and Romans as, let's call it, not a Westerner who got caught up in,

SPEAKER_02say, the Renaissance and the Enlightenment? I mean, what do you Russians think of Plutarch as a teacher? Is he necessary to your story?

SPEAKER_00Great question. So I would be up front. I think... Now, and for the last, let's say, hundred years, Pultrach was not one of the most famous authors or writers in Russian, let's say, education or curriculum or general world building. However, general interests to Greek stories, Roman stories in Russia are as widespread as they were in the West.

SPEAKER_00Because also remember, we consider ourselves being the third Rome, which kind of makes a very clear connection. So it's kind of our story and like we're not completely separated from it. But for me personally, it took pretty late in my life to actually discover Plutarch. And it happened at a point of certain dissatisfaction with the capability of the

stories I was taught in academia to actually make sense of what is happening around

SPEAKER_00the world, in my life, in my region. Generally speaking, basically it was a paradigmal problem. The problem was in the paradigm. And then just started looking into different places. Obviously the scripture, like highly recommend. But as a level you say, Below scripture, but still in some ways relevant to it, if you know how to read it, the classical literature like Plutarch, like Thucydides,

SPEAKER_00like all other great classical writers, they are turning to be surprisingly relevant for modern times, for modern people. And modern people, East and West. Globally. That is the key. I think it comes to how you read them. If you read them in a sense of a modern historical approach, like this eternal question, was it for real? then it obviously is useless.

Obviously, by the standards of modern academic history, Plutarch is not a historian.

SPEAKER_00He doesn't have proper sources, he doesn't do the proper work with his materials, there is no 300 verifications, and he is not asking the right research questions. If anything, he doesn't ask research questions at all. But that's what precisely makes him useful nowadays, because ultimately, Plutarch writes about people. He writes about desires. He writes about the fruits of different desires, and in that sense,

It's a universal story because in terms of desires, we are all like sitting in the same manner.

SPEAKER_00Like it's, you know, one of these interesting jokes, like not jokes, but it was basically an Orthodox priest told me once that People often have huge hesitation to go to confession out of false modesty, pretense, in a sense that as if they can surprise a priest in something. Trust me, like you said, there is nothing really you're going to tell me which I haven't heard already.

SPEAKER_02That's a good point. I'm one of those people.

SPEAKER_00So, what it means, it means that there is some universal level. Not, you know, this fake universal level of global narrative, like basically we're all things the same, but look different. More or less the story which has been running around for the last 30 years combined with... another essential element of the story that history began with us that it's not relevant what happened before we are special we are beyond laws

of history we are beyond laws of desires we are beyond laws of time well Plutarch is an antidote to it at least that's the way I'm going I'm teaching the course and I'm missing today we're gonna gonna talk about one of the heroes which didn't come which who didn't

SPEAKER_00become part of the class I'm teaching but Nevertheless, it's a very useful story in modern times. So, to summarize... Yeah, that's what I... Oh, sorry.

SPEAKER_02Let me frame that real quick. As the host guy... If you're watching this podcast, you'll know I'd like to reach into the old world, which is sometimes still alive and well where we work, West Africa, Georgia, in the mountains. And you find something like the 15th century there sometimes. Sometimes. Now with phones, you don't. So when you go dig around in the Greco-Roman world like we're doing today, and this is why I love you,

SPEAKER_02Pasha, you do it with a great sense of accuracy. I do it like someone who's frosting a cake. I don't know. It'll get on there, and we'll figure it out later. But just slap it on there, and we'll figure it out. But when you look at Plutarch, he's something like – I think he wants – to dive into human ontology, the art of being, as if...

SPEAKER_02As if not a Greco-Roman. He feels like he wants to be like a church father or something. Like he loves the idea. And so with that in mind, one of the people that he doesn't love so much is somebody that I kind of love. Oh, interesting. Okay. Mark Anthony. I kind of love him because he was a lover. Yeah. So, do you think Plutarch hates Mark Antony? And maybe give us a little background for people who don't know the story.

SPEAKER_00Who is this guy? Basically, you can think about Mark Antony as a guy who... was a finalist of a very long championship for an emperor title of a Roman world. So basically Rome spends like around like 100 to 150, depends how you count, years in a constant change of civil conflicts and strifes as a period known as the Civil Wars period.

SPEAKER_00It's basically first century before Christ. many great characters all of them are incredibly like interesting and relevant and no matter whether you're gonna join the class or whether you even gonna do like mark anthony i don't highly recommend reading their stories just for your own sake you won't never want listening to stupid news again i can i can guarantee this Basically all of them,

like Sula, Cato, Pompey, Caesar, like all of the great names.

SPEAKER_00But let's say eventually by the process of elimination, after Caesar's association, big round of civil wars, ultimately there are two big finalists. One is Mark Antony and another is Octavian. Octavian is the guy who becomes this... first proper big emperor of a roman empire octavian is a winner mark anthony is the guy who lost to octavian and he's famous enough you had

shakespeare shakespeare writing a play about him basically his story became a huge inspiration for all

SPEAKER_00let's say uh western art especially renaissance art classical art But yeah, for us, I think he's interesting as a symbol of a very particular type of energy, of a very particular type of person. And it's both downsides and upsides. It's actually great that you brought it up, that you think that Plutarch didn't like him because I don't get it. So it will be a good point of contention. There is a person, though, I think Plutarch clearly hates in the story,

and it's Cleopatra.

SPEAKER_00This one he hates. For Mark Antony, I would say he feels rather sympathy but sadness and a little bit annoyance. So this combination of, you know, imagine you having a friend whom you genuinely like and care but who constantly ends up messing things around him. That's kind of the attitude like Blutarch has to Marc Anthony, I think.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, that's really well said. I think you're being generous, but I'll say this. Marc Anthony is like a proper overflowing... like a flood that, that, that just has energy on its own. It runs. And I think for Plutarch, he's like, you know, we should have cleaned that up as Cleopatra, but she didn't clean it up and women should clean it up for these men that are overflowing this way. Do I have that right?

SPEAKER_00Or would you say that it's worse because like, uh, I mean, Let's be honest, the topic of Marc Anthony, like generally I would say the most philosophical way of explaining it is exploration of erotic or exploration of eros like this, you know, creative unbound power. If you consider about errors as something which makes things happen and makes things bigger around when you are in their presence,

SPEAKER_00that is Mark Antony. Like, he makes all of his friends bigger. Like, he makes his soldiers bigger, more. Like, there is constantly this idea of access. Whoever comes to him, they are becoming bigger. Even on a material level, like wealthier, like there is a corruption element or more like... economy of glory element, like depends how you want to put it. But basically people around him, that's what you like him. And you see these people around the table. You know, these people often are called the soul of the table.

SPEAKER_00Whoever is around them, like this untamed huge energy, The table is sitting quietly. Everybody is like, I don't know. And then there is a guy who just starts firing jokes, who just does doing the toast, who just can, in some traditions, jump on the table and do a dance. This is the guy Marc Anthony is. And... We need to really clarify that in doing so, people around him are sincerely getting bigger. It is important, like table becomes lovely, friends become happier.

There is more merriment in a process, at least at first, at least at first.

SPEAKER_00But this exploration of erotic desire, I think was a huge part of like At least the story is the way Plutarch writes it. However, with every boon comes a bane. And if anything, the story of Mark Antony is the story where you have the most depiction of different female portraits in the whole, basically, Plutarch lives. And it's not a coincidence. I think that's actually... Maybe I'm curious to hear what you would say after reading it, and then I give my comment.

SPEAKER_00But what do you think is this deep... connection between this creative erotic Dionysian desire and femininity like in your experience as Thamada and like enlightened by what you write I think so as someone who leans into that as an archetype but also someone who I like those kind

SPEAKER_02of people and also reading a little bit of Plutarch I think what you have is an envy. There's an envy. And the envy comes naturally for the big ego. But the big ego itself is going to destroy itself. So Plutarch's great because I think he's... dispassionate enough to be able to tell the story, revere the big ego,

SPEAKER_02and still recognize it as its own problem. But I think for many people, they see that kind of person as getting in the way of their own moment. And what I've learned is that those people – And the people that I like in the world, like here, has no relevance to goodness. It's taste. I like those people because they create cracks in the convention.

SPEAKER_02Oh, yeah. they allow for people, if only for a moment, like I like entertainers. I like people who take a stage because they're kind of calling you to disperse with convention and get rid of it and to break it apart. We know it's going to be put back together. We know the order will return, but there's something about that breaking. And I think Plutarch recognizes it. I don't think he hates him, but I think he's got a little bit of,

I think he's got a distaste for the chaos that obviously Marc Anthony is going to

SPEAKER_00participate in. He definitely has more distaste for the chaos than the order. And I think there is a very particular small scene in the story, which I feel where I can really understand Plutarch, and we will come to it later. But let's first do our fair share of praises. Combining with what you said, it's about cracking. It's about the potential. Ultimately, it's about this element of making things which were sleeping in

someone appear.

SPEAKER_00And it's very attractive. I would say it's very attractive. But... important in that case is that in case of Mark Antony, this awakening has no direction, no true direction, which is important. He truly doesn't heal with theos. He is a little bit a reminder as another character in classical literature. Have you read Three Musketeers? I have as a youth. But remember there is a famous quote from Portos.

SPEAKER_00He basically says that I fight just because I fight. something of this character something of the character mark anthony just is like yes he wants himself become bigger he has abundance of energy he is occasionally capable of let's say um obviously pursuing he has certain desires of glory he is a roman he wants glory wealth women all of this let's say natural low desires but ultimately

SPEAKER_00you don't even get that he does a huge rational planning for them. Ultimately, he just goes for them. He goes, and wherever he goes, things happen. Like, sometimes good things, sometimes bad things. But they happen. And just as a comment, you mentioned about entertainment, and it is interesting because what he was best at in his highest, let's say... periods of his life was actually war.

SPEAKER_00He was an ultimate warrior. He was a talented military commander. He was a brave military commander. We know it about him. He was a commander capable of both tactical maneuvers, but also personal bravery. He was basically a cavalry commander under Caesar, which is a very noble and high important role. And you can think, what is the connection between war and performance? In a way you described it, like it is this ability to cause cracks. It is ability to put force, to put the wheel forward just to express it.

SPEAKER_00Should it be bound? Yes. And here comes the trick, like where is there like this energy, this process can be put into service of something great or not. In case of Mark Antony, we have both elements.

SPEAKER_02That's, you see that in the service of, I think that's really helpful because again, I want to defend Mark Anthony. If only for a second is that character who's provides all that energy on some level, they have, and I believe this with my heart. Again, these are the people that I'd like in life. I'm thinking of three or four friends right now. There's a degree of humility to opening yourself up so that stuff can flow out of you.

SPEAKER_02Like, not everyone's going to like it. You already can be aware of that real fast. It's like a comedian, right? A comedian, one of the things at the heart of a comedian is a smallness. They're not really sure about themselves. That's why they want to go up there on stage. They need some recognition that they may not be so bad. And there's a real risk. in Marc Anthony, in that to be this guy with all this energy and to actually present it and to participate in it,

SPEAKER_02you know what I think? I think there's a degree of smallness in that, that people don't recognize because it's always so loud. But that given, the smallness has to be in the service of something beautiful, greater, higher, right? And well, in the story, It's really just for a good-looking lady? Is that what happens? In the end, it really is just about getting the hot chick in Egypt? Is that what happens?

SPEAKER_00Kind of, and that is the tragedy. She was not even so good-looking, which is, I think that's... By the way, it's true. No, that I think is a true tragedy. Okay, let's make it controversial. After all, the title is about Eros. Because the story of Marc Anthony is counterintuitive to me. And that's something, honestly, I even struggle to understand. So maybe you will help me. I can name it, but maybe you will show me the bigger, let's say, essence about it. You have three women in the story.

SPEAKER_00Fulvia, Octavia, and Cleopatra. Two of them are... At least the way Plutarch describes them, not really nice ladies. Basically, he clearly hates them. I think it's the most passionate writing I ever basically read in his whole book. So Fulvia was the first wife of Mark Antony. Octavia was the second wife of Mark Antony and also the sister of Octavian, which is important for the story.

SPEAKER_00And Cleopatra was effectively Mark Antony's mistress from Egypt. well Fulvia was effectively a controlling wife and that's what actually interesting like first question to you why do you think two controlling women ended up with this unbound crackling performer warrior type energy yes But Octavia is basically one of the most virtuous women in the whole Roman history. Even later, she was always praised as an example of female virtue.

SPEAKER_00Just to give a context, after Mark Antony's death, she took all of the children, like from all of his wives into her house and did all of her best to give them best possible education and like a position in the court. And basically she stayed true and loyal to him, even against his complete unloyalty to her.

SPEAKER_01True humility. True humility.

SPEAKER_00So the second question is, Ah, and she was pretty. It's another important part. It's clear by the story and by the witnesses, she was a very pretty lady. So she wasn't like ugly, virtuous woman. Sorry, but she was a very pretty, virtuous woman. Why this raw Dionysian performer energy not chooses her? Why he wants Cleopatra? By your, let's say, by your experience. Yeah. Why do I think? Why do you think? Yeah, I'm curious. You see around the table. I think it's a very table story, basically.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, I know. You're absolutely right. Well, I think my first instinct is to argue, and again, from what I know and what I've read... you become greater when you acquire the other. And so you're always trying to acquire the other, whether they be in the form of a wife or in the form of a friend or in the form of a colleague,

SPEAKER_02you make yourself greater by becoming in union with the other. And there's something for me in the story that is, if you think about it, it, It's probably also the story of Donald Trump on some level, which is it's a constant acquisition that actually gives meaning to this guy's life. And so I get what you're saying. I hadn't thought about it, though. The pretty one – the true humility is probably not –

SPEAKER_02he can't probably process that on some level. How do you read it?

SPEAKER_00Well, I read it as a paradoxical exactly tragedy. It's this... I think it's subconsciously inability to see... the proper more against an improper more so imagine so you're this raw dionysian energy like any contact with you makes everyone around you bigger like one way or the other Octavia.

SPEAKER_02And you said Dionysian energy right there.

SPEAKER_00Dionysian energy. It's a concept. Sorry, this god of wine, festival, raw festival, which ended up with orgies. And sometimes orgies would end up with blood. So like Vakhanelia comes from like Vak, Dionysian, like all of this ancient culture. Very modern, actually looking like. Imagine the wild, any wild... party you've been to, that's a Dionysian energy one way or another. Basically that was a liturgy of Dionysus whether you were aware

of it or not.

SPEAKER_00So what I'm saying is like Octavia was a good, faithful, loyal wife who served her husband, like legitimately, like honestly. And this is a proper way of making someone bigger. However, I feel like for this energy, it's something which cannot be seen. Whereas, let's say, Cleopatra visibly made him excited. It is Plutarch writes like she went with him into, let's say,

crazy adventures.

SPEAKER_00She tempted and teased him. Yeah. She, let's say, constantly entertained him. Octavia didn't entertain him. She served him. She was humble. She was making him bigger. But she was not entertaining enough. And I think that is a blind spot of improper erotic energy. That you really miss this part. You really miss this part where... you need to basically internalize this deep humbleness you talked about.

SPEAKER_00Maybe there is this deep humbleness around your heart, and maybe there is a deep fear around your heart. But the solution to the fear is not to just find another entertainment who will play upon your vices in order for you to feel bigger.

SPEAKER_02Is that because of, is the passion there vanity? Yeah. but you think so right i think so yeah i think basically uh it's on a very deep level vanity and uh also just certain blindness like you are so huge so you have a gigantic blind sport uh blind spot around you and that's the problem like because uh we are called for both yes you can be big entertainment and

you can be a great

SPEAKER_00amada and you need to make people big around you. But, and that's what the difference between a good Tamada, you know, and a bad Tamada is a good Tamada looks around himself. He's not just passing energy, but he looks to it. He cares. He manages. And then he was none of those things. He just like a raw stream. Basically, that's all it is. Do you think, do you think from your reading, I know Plutarch is not going to do this.

SPEAKER_02I don't think. But do you think Alexander the Great and Mark Anthony are in the same category?

SPEAKER_00I think they are much closer to each other. I would say obviously Alexander had bigger dreams of order. At least you can say Alexander dreamt of an empire. Alexander had a certain vision. But more blind spots than let's say other characters in the story. I would say the closest people like in the story, Alexander is the Caesar. Caesar is a better version of Alexander and Anthony is even

lower version of Alexander if you're looking into this creative power basically like on different

SPEAKER_00levels of scale. But yes, also Alexander was, you can say, pretty blind to things around him. And then there were moments of passion, you know, the murders of friends of Alexander, which happened like very wild party type of energy. But Anthony is even more pure in that sense. He doesn't even go into, let's say, friends murder or anything. He is just completely blind. And when he is blinded by passion and improperly oriented passion, And Plutarch writes about it excessively.

SPEAKER_00He constantly does things in a wrong time. He either acts too quickly or he doesn't act quickly enough. He is losing himself to this nature of time and that's why ultimately he loses the civil war.

SPEAKER_02So interesting. I have two questions. Just a comment, though, or I have one question in this comment. You've hit on something really fascinating when we do these dinners. You'll see new Tamada, who just are trying to figure it out, when the energy at the table feels low, a better way to say it, it's running out, you'll see them go full Marc Anthony.

SPEAKER_02as a way to re-energize the table, often by speaking about themselves. I do this too, when you get nervous. It's a public speaking thing. When I was a comedian, when that energy would ebb out of the room in New York, then I would start to curse. Or I would say funny things with cursing. And again, you would elevate the space. The problem is if it wasn't true humor, in other words, if it wasn't ground in reality, this is one of the problems with bad comics,

SPEAKER_02is the reason stuff is funny is because it's true. And then it actually connects with everybody. It's just like automata. The words connect with everybody in the room on different levels. But just cursing words or funny words that are loud, they're like sugar high, right? They're like bad American food. They taste good for a second, then they're finished. And I wonder, this is my question, are we in an age... of the Marc Anthony's?

Is that what I think people complain about as like tyrants around the world?

SPEAKER_00What do you think? Okay, I would say we definitely have all of the vices of Marc Anthony's. We don't have virtues of Marc Anthony's. That is a tragedy. That's a general pattern when you read all Plutarch's story. We really share all of the vices, all of the characters, let's say improper oriented desires, the fruits of these horrible choices. But we rarely have their virtues. For example, Mark Antony himself was truly a brave man.

that's plutarch is unequivocally clear about like he was man not afraid of suffering a man capable of suffering man of capable of bearing the cross in a moment that's that is a very contradictory for our understanding like we're talking about warrior entertainment who can't keep his journey in when he should but at the same time i'm talking about the person who's capable of carrying the cross

SPEAKER_00But it is true. That's the true paradox of human nature. There is a scene when basically his military expedition goes south because he started it in an improper time. But then he doesn't run away. He stays with his soldiers. He invigorates them. He drinks dirty water. He embodies the spirit of command. Plutarch writes about him in a very, I think it's a key quote about him. Such was he by nature that in misfortune he surpassed himself

and became most like

SPEAKER_00a truly worthy man. And I think this is a key problem of this type we've been talking about today. Ironically, for people who are of pure Dionysian energy or like pure Marc Anthony energy or just a pure erotic energy, If you don't bind yourself, then the only moment when you will truly shine is in a moment of trouble. It's in a moment of mismorption, when you will be bound by basically external world. Do you hear what I say?

SPEAKER_02Wow. Yes. Is that because... Okay, hear this out. I don't know if this is true in traditional philosophical terms, but... So in those truly, let's call them difficult moments, let's call them in these, what did you call them? Misfortunes, misfortune.

SPEAKER_00He was a Roman. He was calling it misfortune. We can say tragedy, tragic moments. Tragedy, right, right. So you're saying that these kind of Mark Anthony characters, they do well in that space.

SPEAKER_02Is that because, let's just call it in that, when all the... when all the dimensions of reality collide and all the layers are filled with misfortune, is that because those are, that moment is just pure passion in the, in the sense of it itself has the nature of Mark Anthony. Like the moment itself has a type of nature and that in that moment, he's made for that moment but not all the other ones because

these things don't happen all the time well is that a crazy idea it's not such a crazy idea but uh

SPEAKER_00with one caveat so if he is not of himself and if he doesn't serve a higher thealus, then yes, basically. Then it's only in this involuntarily suffering he can truly shine. Then, again, remember the key in nature. He makes things bigger around himself. So imagine your family is suffering. You said before, table is running out of energy. You can call it the moment of misfortune of the table, the moment of suffering of the table.

SPEAKER_00That's where we need Mark Antony. That's where you need this energy. That's where you need this vulnerability. That's all you need. But The moment, let's say, the table becomes wild and happy and running, a good tamada stops. A good tamada knows how to slow down. And you can say that for such type of a person, it is a misfortune in itself. But this is a misfortune you need voluntarily to inflict upon yourself. You need to make yourself smaller in the right moment. Well, because at that point,

which is your original point, and Plutarch's as well,

SPEAKER_02You should not join that energy because there's a higher calling. Yes. And there's a higher calling to your table, to your men in the battle. Company. Yeah. And that's to... to go through that moment of energy into something like reality or what we'd call like a Christic reality that God gave us all that energy that we might find him, not just so we have energy. And so maybe I think I really understand

SPEAKER_02what you just said, in the sense that a Trutamada is not going to fully participate in that Dionysian moment, which is necessary. Otherwise, the table has no ultimate talos purpose.

SPEAKER_00Exactly. Does that sound right? It's absolutely right. And that is a tragedy, a personal tragedy, and the paradox of Mark Antony. That's why, I will be honest, I like him too.

SPEAKER_01It's a man... I do.

SPEAKER_00I would love to have a party with him or just a table with him. He would be a great man around the table. However, he would be a horrible Tamada. And that's his tragedy. That he was in the game of power. And a game of power is a game of Tamada. To your language. We made a series about it. And he unfortunately... didn't see himself truly. And then, for example,

SPEAKER_00he was capable of serving Caesar, and he was a great cavalry commander under Caesar, but it was absolutely impossible for him to make a right, let's say, Roman choice and serve... Octavian who was destined to be a leader and like Octavian is in the class and you will read there like why Anthony why Octavian was the right moment to lead but for Anthony it was a younger guy who not that brave on a battlefield like he's not big

SPEAKER_00enough visually from his perspective I would never serve him and that was his strategy right strategy basically a dionysian energy i will just finish this hot and i think you will like it a dionysian energy always needs a proper master and the story of mark anthony it's the tragedy of dionysian energy either without master at all or without a proper master with bad masters here is the tragic role back to the female part of cleopatra or fulvia

bad female masters of over his energy like he subconsciously feels he needs a master but in his passion and pride he chooses the master who you can say tempts him or poisons him like like but but in a very sweet way in a very sweet poison

SPEAKER_02yeah yeah that makes sense it There's many, many Trump vibes here. There's no way around it. It's very obvious. But you're hoping that This president's master becomes, I don't know, the Constitution. But I mean, I'm an Orthodox Christian, so that itself is kind of a low bar. Like, okay, great.

SPEAKER_00He's honoring the Constitution. He literally just said like two months ago that it's only him who controls him. It's a literal quote. The question was, is there anything that limits you? And he said, well, I limit myself. And that's actually a very Dionysian problem. You can see it this way.

SPEAKER_02Can we say that's a Tamada fail?

SPEAKER_00Tamada fail.

SPEAKER_02At that point, your table sucks because your Tamada won't stop talking. You're like, gosh, this Tamada, he's killing me over here. Yes, you're right. Trump would be a terrible Tamada. This is true. I think we just proved it. I got a question. Okay. Which is one of my favorite things. Just in going through this and trying to understand... Well, what you're going to do in the class, which I'm going to invite everybody to the class over on Symbolic World,

SPEAKER_02there's this phrase that, well, it's used. And I want you to use it and put it in context. But it's the most beautiful thing. And it's something like, to what are you giving what you were given? Yeah. I think this is the failure of Mark Anthony, right? It's like, stop and pause. You were given something like all this energy to what are you giving what you've been given?

SPEAKER_02And that takes a great desire to care about others. And I think that's, Probably in the end.

SPEAKER_00And it's conscious desire to care about others. I think that's an awesome... Because you can see he cares about his friends. Like, for example, he is not, let's say, a sociopath who, let's say, hates the whole world or, like, inhuman being. But that's a very tragic paradox. Like, as a Roman, he cares a little bit about glory. But it's about his personal glory. Here is the problem. At this rate, he can't give it to the glory of Rome because by this moment, any... big military commander in Rome basically equals Rome's glory

with his personal glory.

SPEAKER_00Like, my glory is the glory of Rome. Like, actually, that was one of the big mistakes, which really turned Roman public opinion against Mark Antony because in the process of, let's say, managing the eastern provinces, he gives several of them to his children from Cleopatra, naming them like new kings and queens. And for Romans, it was like, okay, okay, It's one thing when you give your personal spoils of war to your illegitimate children. Fine. Been there for the last hundred years. Done it. We don't hold such a huge moral standard anymore.

SPEAKER_00But it's a Roman land. You can't give what Rome conquered or what you conquered for Rome to your personal, let's say, children. So he doesn't feel it. And that was coming back to the point that... From an Orthodox Christian perspective, that's what we are called to understand and realize, that everything we have is actually a gift. It's not for our own goodness. It's not for our own sake. It's something you need to use for the betterment and the benefit of the others. In the same way, the gift of Tamada is for the table,

not for Tamada's glory.

SPEAKER_00Ironically, it's precisely in sacrificing Tamada to the table, Tamada becomes a good Tamada, it becomes bigger. Marc Anthony, would he sacrifice his talents to the greater glory of Rome and not for his personal love affairs and for his personal glory, would become even bigger. And let's say he left even more decent memory. And that's a very interesting part because he had a wife who basically... really visibly shown him an alternative like this Octavia his second wife like basically it's like literally like God is offering him I'm

offering you heaven I'm offering you hell I'm offering you Octavia I'm offering you Cleopatra which one are

SPEAKER_00you going to choose well Mark Antony Not out of evil heart, which is truly tragic. And that's why it rings so nice. Like it's not out of evil heart, but it's out of like of humility, out of like of simple care, out of blindness. He makes the wrong choice. He makes the wrong choice. And what is truly tragic is like, It's not just about you. Damada is not just about himself, it's about the table. Mark Antony was not just about himself, he was about the soldiers who followed him.

SPEAKER_00I think the reason, like coming back to the way you started, why Plutarch is, you can sense a certain dislike, like obviously in writing. But I think the dislike is attributed. Remember the moment where he quotes all the soldiers before the final battle with Octavian. And the quote runs something like, Our emperor, why don't you trust the scars anymore? Why are you now trusting the stupid wooden planks? Leave it to the stupid easterners. We will fight on Earth where we will give you glory as we always did.

SPEAKER_00Like something along this line. But you can send this... deep sorrow in this old man who's been fighting for like 20 years under his banner he loves this young idiot or not so young idiot anymore he will die for him and like you kind of you feel like he's gonna die in this battle but that's what i think plutarch can't forgive mark anthony it's not his personal failure because like okay you had your glorious death later you've been like he died well by roman standards mark anthony didn't die shamefully he died well like he died as a warrior he like yes he took his own life which is a sin from orthodox perspective

SPEAKER_00For Roman, it was part of the, let's say, glorious death. It's a very common theme in antique culture. But what was bad is the lives he wasted. His Dionysian energy became destructive. He didn't make people around him bigger. In the end, he kind of killed everyone who was not saved by Octavia. Everyone around himself kind of died or lost except for those who were saved by this good feminine nature. And that's what I think is very important.

SPEAKER_00like personal lessons, lesson we learned. So you need creativity, you need to do the crackling, you need to do the movement because otherwise things die. Order itself without this movement becomes a stale order. But when it becomes unbound, when it's not serving the higher tilas, when it's not ultimately a gift to something higher, well, it will end up just destroying everything around himself. And that's what I think.

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_02You know, we're heading into that – I don't want to take – I have this Georgian idea that I want to share with you, but I'll just make this historical comment. I think you can argue that with the Enlightenment came, let's call it the non – Antonian epic. A lot of dryness, a lot of real love of equations and rationality and things that could be instantiated in the world as obvious success and a lot of,

SPEAKER_02let's call it mathematical creativity, but the Antonian spirit, it's around. I think what's happening now is that dryness. And by the way, Plutarch talks a lot about these kind of leaders too. Yeah. These kind of sharp-edged, rational leaders.

SPEAKER_00And he shows their faults too.

SPEAKER_02That period is coming. Yeah, it shows their faults. And I think that we have to be careful to not... overcorrect now to an Antonian Dionysian moment in culture which will be very difficult and I think it's a great thought let me expand on it because I think it's great parallel with modernity like we're called to have both like you're called in

SPEAKER_00church to have both Peter and Paul you need both left hand you need both right hand you need order you need creativity it's this dance of polar opposites uh which makes the unity whole you're absolutely right and late enlightenment actually and uh comma both of those can be flipped into let's say they're dark versions order can become a dark order dionysian energy can become a dark dionysian like actually dionysian energy is always dark so let's keep on erotic erotic

and eros is great

SPEAKER_00like Erotic.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, that's the best.

SPEAKER_00Eros is great. Like, and yes, it's not, it's actual Orthodox teaching, which we had a magnificent conversation. I remember in Florida about it, but basically the centrality of Eros, like in the whole Orthodox teaching is really often overlooked. People who think we are just boring and like love, uh, let's say, not eating and stuff like this. No.

SPEAKER_01Like, these people have no Eros. We're like, no, that's not it.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, it couldn't be far more than opposite from it. But the problem is improper Eros becomes Dionysian energy. And what Enlightenment did... It created, in my opinion, improper order by placing it on up too high or by limiting it, making it mechanistical and artificial order. But also, it neutered erotic desire to Dionysian desire. That's where the whole Freudian stuff comes in. And basically, that's why you have now exactly these two false choices.

SPEAKER_00You have this... sterile order and you have unbound, performative, narcissistic, self-centered Dionysian type island and stuff like this energy, or just performative energy, like pop show, in a horrible meaning of this word. the centrality or like in a church type like mega churches like basically that would be this two improper element the tricky moment is obviously now like and it's

like light and shade so like this sterile order is let's say the finger and the

SPEAKER_00ionician erotic desire is its shade Well, now they might be changing the balance. Now we might have more Dionysian energy becoming the figure with sterile order becoming its shape. But they will always be together. What we are called to do, and let's say, and I will be upfront, Plutarch doesn't tell you what to do. That's his limit. He's still a pagan author. He doesn't know Christ. It's important. He doesn't know how to do things in a proper way.

SPEAKER_00He's more like, well, and that's how this didn't work. Well, and that's how this didn't work. And well, that's how we can learn from this. And well, that's how we can learn from, et cetera, et cetera, et cetera. But what we in the current moment, we are called to find by seeing the mistakes of other great men who are better than us, who have way more virtue. Like we are not similar again to them in their virtues, but in their vices, we can really see that even better version. Because we often say, well, it's a vice only because I'm not good enough.

SPEAKER_00No, imagine you being really good at something. So that's what makes Mark Anthony's story so compelling. In all of the Plutarch writings, I think he's the most perfect embodiment of this erotic desire turned Dionysian. And he's doing it most authentic and with most dignity as is possible with this energy. And still, it's ends up how it ends up and that's what you need to know that's why you won't be tempted to kind of at least i hope like people will won't be

attempted to repeat to repeat the same mistake and start recognizing these patterns around them because unfortunately yes i think we first need to look back into maybe how not to do

SPEAKER_00things before understanding how to do things. And one thing to do is, and actually I will end up with this, very liberating. No matter whether people go to class or not, read history. Not because it happened in the past, but because it's happening with you here right now. You think it's scary, but it's actually liberating because it means you are not alone. You are not the first person in history whose leader became a narcissistic buffoon.

You are not the first person in history whose leader ended up on a crazy military

SPEAKER_00enterprise because he had a feeling of it. You are not the first person who, let's say, sees the order collapsed about him or the becoming tyrannical or et cetera, et cetera, et cetera. And once you get this, once you get this feeling of a shoulder with all of the generations behind you, you actually feel less scared no matter what is coming your way. Yeah.

SPEAKER_02That is, well, history, as I learned it in West Africa and then couldn't teach it this way in America, history is the study, which really the handed down narrative of who you are. And then you start to realize the parts we share are like overwhelmingly the same in terms of every human history, whatever part of human history you're studying from whatever culture. And that really, like you said,

SPEAKER_02It helps you calm down. History is a type of therapeutic event when you actually participate in it. But we don't really do that anymore. We're cut off from it, which is also part of the machine, right?

SPEAKER_00Absolutely. And you said the key word, and I think that's what I really hope... At least that's what I... It's my main methods, because up front, I'm not a professional historian, by no means. I'm not a professional, let's say, scholar of Roman time. But what I learned is... there is a huge hunger for people exactly not to learn history because we have abundance of information, but to participate with it. And that's when Plutarch shines, because his reading is participative.

SPEAKER_00It's a story, you like these characters, you dislike these characters, you hate them, but you are engaged with them, but it still feels more real than, let's say, just a mythos. or just a story like DC or I don't know, Hercules or something like this. That's like, oh, just a story. Here, well, these people actually lived and you can engage with them and you can participate in them. But that's upon you. You need to participate with history. Learning about history gives you nothing. Because if you're learning about it as something which a set of dates and actions

SPEAKER_00which happened in the past, well, what does it do for me? Like nothing. Like, sorry, like this does nothing. but if you see this participative but this relational if you relate to these people if you relate through your heart to the hearts of people before you then you exactly get this first step towards calmness because then you can actually start looking at sacred history differently notice it's very interesting like uh It takes really a while, at least in my church experience,

SPEAKER_00to actually start reading, let's say, Old Testament and New Testament as not stories about the past. It really takes a huge, let's say, it's a process because like okay this especially with all this okay this happened so long ago with some Jews like why would it matter to me like sorry I'm living in 21st century why would I still hear about them or like even like 2000 years ago with some people there but that's a key problem like we feel so alienated and

SPEAKER_00you're absolutely the part it is a machine from our our past, that we are, as a result, also alienated from each other in the present, from the future, and from the eternity. And that's... You can start with the past. At least there are good stories written about it.

SPEAKER_02Well, you know, earlier... Let's go back and then I got a last question for you. If you'll help me with round out the show, I like to ask a last Aliverde of my guest, which you know about Aliverde. But before I do, when you were talking about the idea that you're aware of what you're giving and Because you're aware of what you've been given.

There's a Georgian saying around the table that you kind of become what you're

SPEAKER_02willing to give away. And one of the tamadas I heard said that when you give away your time, you become timeless. And it's an awareness of the reason for the giving. which Americans would call selfish. But I think it's just an ontological reality that you're going to become something. And I love this notion that when you're aware of what you're been given time on this earth and then you give it away in

order to recognize this thing you've been given that the Georgians say you become timeless when you're willing to give away your time to others which is a wild concept that I couldn't stop thinking about when you got into your conversation which leads me to the last

SPEAKER_02thing that I want to ask you in the history of the Georgian Supra, which is what I'm all involved in, and first things, does it, and yada, yada. I'd love for you guys to check it out. You can find it all at our links and everything we do. But I want to give an Al-Averde to you, as the Tamadol, as the guy in charge. And my Al-Averde is... To all the words that splashed around today,

SPEAKER_02might you give a toast or some last words on where we went today? Where did we go with all this? How would you summarize what we've tried to say today on some level?

SPEAKER_00I would say so. Let us toast to errors. Let us toast to the creative desire. Let this desire never run out in us. Let us not be sterile. But let not this desire, but also let this desire serve the worthy king, the worthy master. And in doing so, I think we'll- Caggy margins.

SPEAKER_00Okay. Caggy margins.

SPEAKER_02No, no. We can go on. By the way, that's the master. That's the timeless master on some level. Yeah. But what's so weird is everyone's always had something like a timeless master, which, which you just toasted to as Christ, which makes it all come back around. So thank you. Thank you. So we'll see you. This will probably come out. As you're teaching, how long is your course at Symbolic World?

SPEAKER_00It's gonna last for, so there are six heroes, like three Greeks and three Romans, and there are two seminars. So eight classes in total. We begin in the middle of March, and it lasts until early May. So hope to see you there.

SPEAKER_02Oh, fantastic. All right, well, I'm gonna go over. I signed up. So I thank you. This is my friend, Pasha. Thanks for your Aliverde, and thanks for coming on. We'll see you again. We'll put all your links. What I probably already said in the intro, I'll say again, is Pasha has made this incredible, let's call it an offering, where he, as a philosopher, a young philosopher in America,

SPEAKER_02has taken a voice and taken a voice on and shares it with many, many Russians all around the world. And so... I don't think my guys understand what's happening because you've become listened to among really important characters in our world, people in the East, including Russians and many, many millions of Orthodox. So I just want to thank you for that. All glory to God. Yeah, glory to God.

SPEAKER_02It's an intemperate time, but you're a very – temperate person and with lots of deep thoughts. And sometimes you're also like a ton of fun. Guys, his tables are the best when he's Tomodon. You wouldn't do Tomodon in Turkey and all kinds of places. There's a rumor that Andrew and you want to take me to Russia and I'll do some tape. I'll be an American Tomodon in Russia. That would be hilarious.

SPEAKER_00If Lord wills, yes. amen amen uh-oh did that just put me on a list am i on a list all right pasha god bless take care thank you there it is guys hit hit like and love and then there's a button over there for amor eros i don't know if i like the way pasha was making me into this character or i made myself into this character who's out of control

SPEAKER_02But I do want to say a few words on love. Hit the love button and do subscribe, which is a form of love. This is my thought. I don't really know what would happen to a world where these Mark Anthony characters weren't around. I just returned from the monastery. I'm like monk bragging. If you're not Orthodox, you're listening in the Orthodox world,

people monk brag.

SPEAKER_02Some nun brag. I'm monk bragging right now. Well, I was actually I'm nun bragging because I went to a female monastery and I went to a male monastery both in the same weekend. I'm nun bragging, which is totally gross. It's doubly gross in this great land. But I tell you that because what I saw there is what you are going to think is the absence of Eros, but I didn't see the absence of Eros.

SPEAKER_02I saw guys in liturgy, four-hour liturgy, literally cleaning the candles as they burned constantly with this little thing, this little chopper thing that chops off the wax. I saw an attention to something that was so gorgeous that it was Eros. So I don't want to hear about it. We're not Puritans. It's just you got to direct the love. Now for a man,

when he sees a beautiful woman who's not his wife, that's a good thing.

SPEAKER_02That you can recognize the beauty. Feel free to be drawn. Just, just like, don't put out the, let the fire burn. You got to tend it though. Like the monk I saw. Don't get crazy, bro. My point though is, is in this crazy interim between two worlds, something like the old, like the enlightenment world that's burning out in the new world of postmodern craziness,

SPEAKER_02which by the way, you are going to see angels now. I don't know, some of you are going to think they're aliens. But get ready. In this world, though, this kind of love is really important. Just direct it in the right way. So I don't know. So coming to you live from the land of Mark Antony. I mean, he kind of got divorced a lot. I mean, if you are divorced a lot and you're out there and you're trying to go to church,

SPEAKER_02that's great. Right now people are like, why is he giving divorce, like, decrees? I don't... You should turn on other people's podcasts. Preferably the kind of podcasts where the people wear cassocks. In the meantime. Kagi Marjos. Cheers. Hit like, love, desire. What's another word for love? Agape.

SPEAKER_02But that's different to Eros. Hit the Eros button. Hit the desire button, baby. Coggy Marches. See you next time.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Demons, Deception, and Why Your Spiritual Practices Might Be Dangerous

    Oct 2, 20261 hr 18 minAudio

    Find this episode on YouTube: "Justine Alter" - a pseudonym - returns to chat with John Heers in a raw Heavy Things Lightly conversation you have to hear to believe.Justine worked for years as a professional psychic,...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. The Fox News Reporter Who Quit to Live an Orthodox Homesteading Life

    Sep 25, 20261 hr 35 minAudio

    Find this episode on YouTube: Holly Hickman went from Columbia Journalism and Fox News Radio covering NASA and the 2008 election - to milking cows, making cheese, and converting to Orthodoxy.In this episode of Heavy...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Why They Left NASA to Start St. George's Classical Academy

    Sep 21, 20261 hr 2 minAudio

    Can you teach kids the truth AND prepare them for a secular world?On this episode of Heavy Things Lightly, host John Heers talks with James and Juliana Joyce, founders of St. George's Classical Academy in Boxford,...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. An Odyssean Tale: The Man Who Would Not Quit

    Sep 4, 20261 hr 37 minAudio

    Find this episode on YouTube: Crow walked America searching for his father - and found the Father.From West Virginia hollers to LA gangs, from wolves in the Mojave desert to an Orthodox cross, this is an Odyssean tale...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. From Broadway to the Supra: Carrie Manolakos on Life After Lockdown

    Sep 1, 20261 hr 51 minAudio

    Welcome to the first episode of “Save Me a Spot at the Supra” on Heavy Things Lightly where John Heers hosts singer and Broadway performer Carrie Manolakos (best known for her performances in Mama Mia! and Wicked) at...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode