Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Heavy Things Lightly

Heavy Things Lightly artwork

Jay Dyer on the Enlightenment, Americanism & the Religion of Politics

Jul 24, 20261 hr 19 minAudio
  • Apple Podcasts
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Find this episode on YouTube: Jay Dyer joins John Heers to discuss the decline of 2000s New Atheism, shifting internet culture, the Enlightenment, Americanism, Orthodox Christianity, and the political forces shaping the modern West.They examine growing skepticism toward claims of scientific neutrality and political objectivism, arguing that politics often functions as a substitute religion - complete with its own dogmas, sacred myths, and promises of salvation. The conversation also explores whether political systems are ultimately controlled by deeper oligarchic and bureaucratic forces operating behind the scenes.Jay and John critique the Enlightenment as a project that elevated human reason into an idol, connecting its assumptions to liberalism, American civic religion, text-centered religion, and modern ideas about human nature. They contrast abstract systems that promise to save society with the concrete virtue - or vice - of the people who actually operate them.The conversation also covers monarchy and democracy in the Christian tradition, the American Dream, Tucker Carlson’s interest in theology, Kant, postmodernism, the decline of New Atheism, and what may come after the Enlightenment project.Along the way, Jay discusses his background, podcasting, internet culture, humor, and the importance of embodied community. They also introduce upcoming Art of Tamada events in Greenville, South Carolina, August 28-29, and Islamorada, October 29-November 2, describing Supra as a communal and experiential practice rooted in hospitality and Orthodox theology.Topics include:- The decline of New Atheism- The Enlightenment and reason as an idol- Americanism and liberal rights- Politics as a substitute religion- Democracy, monarchy, and Christian political thought- Oligarchy, bureaucracy, and political power- Kant, postmodernism, and human nature- Orthodox Christianity and political theology- Supra, hospitality, and the Art of Tamada- Tucker Carlson and the return of theology__🏷️ Sponsored by Conrad's Beef Jerky - loyalty not guaranteed.Conrad's Deli - The best jerky you'll ever have ➜ https://conradsdeli.com/ ⭐ Use promo code "FIRST THINGS" for 10% off.🔥 Support First Things Foundation field workers like Sarah (featured in this episode): https://first-things.org✈ Become a Field Worker with FTF: https://first-things.org/opportunities📢 First Things Telegram: https://t.me/firstthingsfoundation🍷The best dinner party you've ever experienced - Supra Dinner Society: https://supradinner.com/🥂 Keipi Restaurant: https://keipirestaurant.org✒ Substack: https://johnheersftf.substack.com/ⓧ https://x.com/johnfromftf🏖️ Tailormade tours that give back: https://www.gratitude-travels.com/hom__Credits Music: Intro / Outro Provided by Greg Gilbertson & BandChapters:00:00 New Atheism Fades00:53 Show Intro Sponsors03:02 Tech Setup YouTube Origins06:11 Reading Habits Background08:11 Art of Tamada Pitch13:29 Supra Meaning Experience17:30 Enlightenment As Paganism24:21 IQ Technocracy Critique25:47 Americanism Liberal Rights33:57 Tucker Everything Religious36:13 Systems Versus Virtue40:31 American Dream Myth42:26 Boomer Lies and Taxes43:46 Peace Corps Democracy Lesson47:02 Enlightenment vs Christian Nature53:54 From Kant to Postmodernism55:27 What Comes Next59:25 Politics Is Bureaucracy01:01:30 Comedy and Podcasting01:07:17 Thanks and Event Details01:14:09 Authenticity and Depression01:15:51 Opposable Thumbs Outro This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit johnheersftf.substack.com/subscribe

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_00Sam Harris and the Dawkins and that whole sphere, which was very popular in the 2000s, that's kind of died down. It's not nearly as popular as it was. A lot of those guys were flying on Epstein's flights. So we're realizing that they're not as scientifically, ideologically neutral as they claimed they were. So I think people, the idea of neutrality and, you know, Scientific Objectivism. I think a lot of that is going to collapse. A lot of those sacred cows think that people are going to begin to realize even more

SPEAKER_00that the political process itself, which is a kind of a religion is an idol. It's stupid. It's not at all real or what you think it is. It's controlled by, you know, forces behind the scenes.

SPEAKER_01It's oligarchy almost always.

SPEAKER_00It's an oligarchy. Yes, exactly. So I would say realization will continue. Today, Jay Dyer.

SPEAKER_01We do get into maybe how to be mean when it comes to philosophy. Some ideas are not as good as others, so we get into the enlightenment today. We also talk about the Art of Tamada, where he is a guest speaker in Islam Arada, October 29th through November 2nd. Those tickets are almost sold. Also, August 28th, 29th, Art of Tamada. That's a different event, same concept. This one is in South Carolina in Greenville at our restaurant. That's right. Conrad's Jerky Company out of Pennsylvania.

SPEAKER_01They help to run this show each month by being our major sponsor. We love them. Eat Beef Jerky from Andrew and his family, a small business in Pennsylvania. They support us. We support them. First things is... Your promo code. Now, Greg Gilbertson singing our song, Gagi Marjos, and then Jay Dyer.

SPEAKER_01Jay, what's up? Jay Dyer.

SPEAKER_00John Heers, glad to be back with you. We had a good conversation last time. We had a great Supra, and then now we're going to do this, so I'm glad to be here.

SPEAKER_01I think it's like a full collaboration, because we, I think until about three minutes ago, we didn't know whose show we were going to be on. That's sort of how I operate. You'll forgive me, right?

SPEAKER_00Well, actually, the Riverside setup is a little... Better, smoother than my ghetto version of what I do from Streamlabs. So this is probably a little better for production value.

SPEAKER_01Here's the thing, though. I just want to ask you this as a guy on the interwebs. I think people think you're really good at the interwebs. Are you good at it? You get it? The right place to record, microphone volumes. Are you that guy?

SPEAKER_00No, I'm terrible at all that stuff. The only really significant use that I found with AI is whenever I bought two new cameras about a year ago. And AI was very helpful integrating that into OBS because it basically took one or two days to do that. I see. So no, I'm not a tech dude.

SPEAKER_01And basically, that's how you started your channel, right? You just got online and started talking.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, actually, I did YouTube totally wrong. And again, this is another indicator that I'm not a tech person. I thought that it would just be a place to store, you know, content initially. So I was posting a lot of my audio podcasts back in 2010, 11, 12. And then I realized, so this is actually, you know, a video platform. And I could have had a much larger audience much sooner had I just been doing more video content. But yeah.

SPEAKER_01That's interesting. We started audio too. And I did like, do you remember these days? Here's another question before I ask you another question, because I just so glad to have you on and you're coming to our event. So but when I first started, I would research like crazy. In fact, It was like I was back at my master's degree in history. It was crazy. And I was addicted to it. And I realized I didn't even really care that much about who's watching.

SPEAKER_01I was just learning a ton. Did that happen to you or not really?

SPEAKER_00No, I didn't know what I was doing. As soon as I figured out uploading audio podcasts and figuring out RSS feeds and all that, At that time, I mean, everybody was still pretty much audio focused. There was a growing YouTube presence and YouTube was really getting popular in 2010, 11, 12. But I just thought video was like way too much stuff to do. And so I got really, I had to practice doing like three audios a week. And that kind of got me in the cycle of being able to do long form content consistently.

SPEAKER_00No, I didn't even think about really consistently doing videos until probably 2017. And I think I did my first live stream around that time, just testing it out. And then for me, that ended up being the best format as live streams.

SPEAKER_01So do you, well, when you, when you debate, you prep, but.

SPEAKER_00If it's a formal debate. Yeah. You're prepping like crazy.

SPEAKER_01But now it's just spilling out of you. This is what I found when you were just on Tucker and then we were talking to Father. We just mentioned his name. I forgot his name.

SPEAKER_00Father Ivanov.

SPEAKER_01It's clear now that I kind of understand you more from those conversations because we met. We met. We had a great Supra. But I'm always trying to sort out, like, how does Jay know all this shit? Like, where did – And it's just a love of yours. Is that right? Is that how you would describe it?

SPEAKER_00That's a good way to put it. I mean, I had a mom that was a editor for a large scientific publication. She used to edit for Harcourt Brace Yovanovitch, which was a big publisher of academic scientific stuff, conglomerate. And then she became a librarian when she left that. So I grew up with that. My dad was more of an engineering tech kind of guy. He was in the Navy and did... Tech stuff on different guns. So I got a good dose, I guess, of right and left brain from them.

SPEAKER_00But yeah, I was raised just to be in books all the time. So I thank my mom for that. But yeah, I know all this stuff because also I had other things happen where I had a really easy job for 10 years where I could just read all day long. And they didn't care. So that's how I got through a lot of the church fathers that you see up here was that period. I mean, I read The Church Father since then, but that was a heavy period when I was reading that consistently.

SPEAKER_01I'm interested in that arc when people, mine started in Peace Corps when I was in West. I was weird because I could read constantly because no one was paying attention to anything I did. I could have got malaria. I did get malaria and nobody knows. Nobody knows. We were just out in the middle of nowhere.

SPEAKER_00You've got AIDS to this day, nobody even knows.

SPEAKER_01Got AIDS a couple times, fought it off.

SPEAKER_00Lost the AIDS, got it back.

SPEAKER_01Got Ebola. That's nothing, Jay. Jay, that's from a lab. I'm not going down that rabbit hole, but it's from a lab. It's definitely, I don't want to get into it. Africans all know it. West Africans are like, we know what happened. But let's not go down that. Hold on. Let's do this. Do not turn off your YouTube people because I'm going to do an advertisement because you're coming down to Art of Tamada to be a guest speaker. We'll talk about kind of what we're going to talk about when we're down there,

SPEAKER_01but I want people to come. They can meet you, but it's like 30 people, right? It's a small little gig that's turned into something I'm real proud of, which is it's a fundraiser for our work. But with like, it's not just like a big giant scholarly event. It's people on the beach hanging out and doing Supra. And so just say you're excited to go so everyone will believe what I'm saying, please.

SPEAKER_00Well, I'm absolutely excited. I mean, I love the keys. One thing I'm curious about is there's not a lot of beaches. So which key are we on?

SPEAKER_01By the way, I have to watch out. It's a little close to false advertising. You can swim. There is a pier. I wouldn't call it very beachy, though.

SPEAKER_00I know there's one beach. We stayed at a hotel one time, and I heard there's one at, I get the names of the different keys mixed up. This is on which one? Is this key what?

SPEAKER_01This is La Mirada. This is like two keys out. Two keys out. On the other side of the key is a kind of beach. Right. Yeah. Yeah.

SPEAKER_00There's a really awesome national park down there that we went to. And what's neat about that park is that because it's that far down to the tropical zone, they have a lot of wildlife that doesn't exist anywhere else in North America. So some really cool stuff down there. But anyway, yeah, I'm looking forward to that. I'm a little in the dark exactly on exactly what we're going to talk about or how this works, but I'm definitely looking forward to it.

SPEAKER_01Okay, here's your assignment. For people who think, well, you did a conference too. Conferences are hilarious. The whole keto conference is to be together and everyone thinks it's to hear the speakers. You can hear the speakers on YouTube, bro. But what will happen is the 30 of us, you'll have a chair on the beach and what I hope you'll do is take your expertise and Let's call it church history and theology and history, because we're going to talk about the Enlightenment in a second,

SPEAKER_01because I really want to talk about that. And then to do something creative, which Automata would do, a Georgian Toastmaster, and unite that to the idea of, let's call it the hospitality, which is something like a Christian virtue, and kind of tie in the things you know about the church. Or about life and history to this notion of how we live generously by loving our neighbor.

SPEAKER_01So that's your assignment. Something like your expertise plus the idea of Supra. And I gave that assignment to Paul Kings North. He's coming. And also you. Pazio is going to be down there as a Melikipa. He's going to help us pour wine and be fun. Neil will be there. Oh, nice. Yeah. But it's becoming a little collection point for, I'm just calling you guys friends now. And I'm really blessed by it. Really blessed.

SPEAKER_01But that's what I hope you'll do. No mic. We won't even probably record it. And the idea is people can chime in. It's not a cheap ticket because it's sort of all inclusive. And you know how expensive that is down there.

SPEAKER_00Is this multi-day or how long is this?

SPEAKER_01People show up Thursday night. We have just a very cool hangout. We call it a Philo Jam. I'll probably bring up some topics. People sit around and drink bourbon or whatever, and then we talk. And then the next day is Friday. Pretty open during the day. We'll do some Tamada training stuff where people like to learn how to do this dinner that we can talk about, but it's a Georgian feast that's predicated on the liturgy. But Secular people do it all the time. Then Friday night,

SPEAKER_01we have a Supra and our chef comes down and she cooks Georgian food on these little ovens. We rented out the whole resort. It's a nice little resort. I don't want anybody to think it's like it's not it's not the Hilton. OK, calm down. But it's beautiful. And then Saturday is a repeat. We bring in a fishing boat. If people are into it and go out fishing and or often just snorkeling because fishing's a bigger bill. And then Saturday night, we do another Supra,

SPEAKER_01but it's a little different because people have been trained on it. And we kind of we involve people differently because my hope is when they leave the art of the Tamada, they feel like I think I know what this is and I want to share it because Jay and then we can keep going. But Here's my plug for people who are watching because Jay's here. The tide has turned and everybody is learning, not just on ortho channels. Everybody's learning something has been gutted from, let's just call it Western humankind.

SPEAKER_01And that's what we're going to get into. And Supra is sort of like an answer to the unspoken, right? Would you agree with that?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I remember we had a great discussion about that because, you know, I didn't really understand what this was, even though I'd heard you guys, you know, explain it, but you kind of have to experience it.

SPEAKER_01Exactly.

SPEAKER_00Similar to Orthodoxy, you can hear all about it, but it's very different when you actually live it, experience it, it becomes real. That's what I was trying to get at with Father Jonathan Ivanov, is that it's much better to Meet Tucker in person and hang out with him for that day and have that discussion versus being on the internet, you know, abstracted, non-incarnational sort of setting. So, yeah, I think that's exactly the purpose of what you're getting at with the Tomada and the guy that's leading,

SPEAKER_00you know, this ceremony that has these ups and downs and is sort of a village version of what happens in the church. That was really an explanation. So, yeah, I think the setting of doing that at the beach makes perfect sense. That's my favorite place to be is sitting on the beach. So, yeah, I'm excited to do that. I think, again, there's just the personal aspect that we have in Orthodox theology with God as person, not force, not essence, not form, but person that's relational.

SPEAKER_00That's, you know, central to our theology. So I think it makes the most sense that you would have this expression in terms of how we celebrate, you know, this faith.

SPEAKER_01Well, it's kind of I look at it like a teeter totter. I think what we do on on the Internet when we make a really good argument is we do a really important we do the intellect, which is a part of our essence and what we do. When we do Supra, it's something like the senses. Yes. But they're filled, right, with the Tamera says in Georgia, there's a tradition that says the wine sits like creation before God entered.

SPEAKER_01And, you know, over the waters, right, came the spirit. And the words that the Tamera pours into the wine... Bring it to life. So you need both. You know, one's Gnosticism. The other is some sort of Hedonism. Right. So together, a proper table has both. And so what I found is all that's really happening, because it's so, Jay, I love you. You can't explain it. I'm in the business and I can't explain it. But what you can't say.

SPEAKER_00People are laughing. People are crying. It goes into the night.

SPEAKER_01It flogs.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, we don't, we don't experience this usually. I mean, there's people that do like Toastmasters or whatever, but this is much richer, a richer experience.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. Yeah. And in the end, what they call Shvidoba is the goal of the Tamida. The Tamida is just bringing people to attention. If you just think about it. It's what any person that you love does. Your dad walks in and calls the room to attention and you have dinner or whatever. You need the attentiveness. And in the American spirit, everything is about I'll attend to my own thoughts. And you're like, hold on, bro. There's a common spirit.

SPEAKER_01And that's all really at its core. That's what the super is about. And then there's all these Georgian heritages and then there's the history and we go into all that during these events. There's also one, by the way, in August 28th and 29th in Greenville. It's a different event. It's much, much, much more affordable. We teach, but there's a concert, Shovels and Ropes. I don't know if you've ever heard of Shovels and Rope, but. Nice singer-songwriters. They'll be in Greenville for the same event, different vibe.

SPEAKER_01Our vibe is small, just 35 people. In Greenville, it's open to the public. You can just come for the concert. Anyway, let's talk about the Enlightenment. Want to for a second?

SPEAKER_00Sure.

SPEAKER_01I'm like a junior... I'm a historian compared to probably where you are right now, given all the time you spent. But I studied history. I went to Columbia University, Jay.

SPEAKER_00Well, no, if you're doing masters in history, you probably went way deeper than I did. I just have certain areas that I'm pretty I was two classes from a double major in philosophy and history. So I basically just have undergrad history in terms of broad. But I focused a lot on French Revolution, and I focused a lot on church history, and then modern geopolitics. But outside of that, I'm not very well studied.

SPEAKER_01I was an American history guy.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, you would know way more about that than me.

SPEAKER_01When I listen to you, basically, I'm vibing. Like, I love it. So here's the thing that got me. Do you remember the CDs? You're probably a little younger than me. You are younger than me, so you might not remember this. But the CDs that the ortho bros of the early 90s listened to were like Frankie Schaefer. Do you remember that, dude?

SPEAKER_00Yeah. And then he sort of went liberal.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, it didn't happen.

SPEAKER_00I mean, I was in the 90s. I had, you know, every... All band, every industrial band CD. So I had CDs for sure out the wazoo, but I don't think I got my first Orthodox tape or CD until probably the 2000s.

SPEAKER_012000s, okay. I probably got my first like 1990, 91 album. And Frankie Shaver was one of them. He was very articulate. And then I read, my brother is always telling me not to read, but I don't care because I love him. Philip Sherrard. Yeah, I read a lot of Sherrard. Yeah, I love Sherrard. I know he gets a little fuzzy on the edges, but what happened with Sherrard and then Frankie Shaver and then living in Africa and the Georgia Republic, what happened was America became Not the only option.

SPEAKER_01Like all the things I had learned about America, you know, I grew up taught by boomers. I'm almost a boomer. Not quite. And boomer America suddenly became kind of bullshit. Like, whoa. Right. You had that moment, too.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, well, it's interesting because you're on that cusp, I guess, of Boomer and Gen X, and I'm on the cusp of Gen X and millennials. So there's a vast sort of shift, you know, in terms of mainly what the internet has kind of forced into the four. That is probably what you're hitting at. But I understand being on the cusp of both of those generations. It's a weird place to be because I can understand the Gen X mindset and I can also understand, you know, the millennial mindset.

SPEAKER_00But it's also a good window to sort of bridge those two too.

SPEAKER_01Well, that's what I think happened to me is I eventually brought this. Well, to finish that thought, I didn't hate America because I'm born here. I can't do it. It's not like, what are you talking about? This is where I eat food and this is where I meet people. I don't hate this place. That's never going to happen. However, the principles became Harder to understand. Well, let's put it this way.

SPEAKER_01Easier to understand, harder to accept. And then I realized this was tied to the Enlightenment. Yeah. And once that happened, I couldn't unsee this one idea, and I want to give it to you and tell me what you think. The Enlightenment is just an atheist project, basically. Would you agree with that idea?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, there's a famous book or there's a series. It's about Peter Gay and... Not faking it. Peter Jay, he wrote a thing called the Enlightenment, the rise of the return of paganism, the new paganism. And in that sense, yeah, I mean, a lot of paganism is atheistic, too. So yeah, it's sort of a demythologizing project that sought a bunch of different ideals, a bunch of universal ideals about things. And you have these Enlightenment philosophers,

SPEAKER_00you know, trying to Bring reason into this sort of deified status, that reason would really be the salvific faculty that would take us into the future and solve the world problems. You have, for example, Kant writing a treatise about how open economic free trade Well, I'd say for economics would basically bring world peace because in a very naive way, he thought that everybody would see the advantage of economic commerce

SPEAKER_00with regulating open trade in the world and nobody would want to go to war. There would be no longer incentives. So he thought world government would come about in a peaceful way through economics, which is just such a flawed, Pelagian way to view human nature, as if it's not fallen. You've got that side of it. You've got other influences, too, with Renaissance humanism and things like that. And this stuff also is,

SPEAKER_00I think, adjacent to the Protestant Reformation, the idea of returning to texts, making the books, making the religion essentially text-oriented verses. I have a lot of critiques of Catholicism, but Catholicism was at least still Eucharistically focused in terms of the religion itself. And then it shifts into, you know, textual focused religion, which is really sort of a Judaizing project.

SPEAKER_01Yes. Does that feel to you like a type of idolizing of the reason? Absolutely. That's it, right? Yeah.

SPEAKER_00I mean, the French revolutionaries, you know, when they went into the Notre Dame Cathedral to defile it, they brought a prostitute in there and they put her up on the altar and called her the goddess reason. So they wanted to, you know, on the one hand, invert and defile and also exalt what's a, you know, crucial faculty of human nature. You know, Christ assumed a rational soul, which means that he's fully man. And thus to have human nature requires this faculty of reasoning. So reasoning isn't bad,

SPEAKER_00but it's not the highest faculty or the ultimate pinnacle of, you know, of human salvation by far. So it can become an idol. And I think that's the essence of the enlightenment.

SPEAKER_01All right. Little side. I could go on. I love this stuff and I love your your clarity. But share this moment with me for a second. I had a good talk with a podcaster, Ben Michael, formerly Ben Luigi. He's on a track. I don't always agree with him. That's not why I'm bringing this up. I don't want to fight with anybody. I love all these. In fact, I'm having a Supra tonight with Ben. He's coming to our restaurant. I'm hanging out with him. I love this guy.

SPEAKER_01But he was elevating the IQ test to a place that it felt like enlightenment politics to me. It felt like if we can get all those smart people together, then everything can get fixed up. And the smart people tend to be white people because they kind of wrote the test. And I don't know, what do you think about that? Am I off? Am I going down the wrong road there?

SPEAKER_00What does correlate with certain areas of social success, or perhaps civilizational success? So it can maybe be a correlation with, you know, building businesses and infrastructure and that kind of stuff. But I mean, again, that's not all there is, you know, to human society or to mankind. So you could, you could have a, you know, 200 IQ technocrat, who's good at building computers, but if the computers enslave everybody, like that, serve no purpose.

SPEAKER_00So you got to have these other dimensions, you know, to human to humankind. I mean, we see the same thing with like, people who think that And this is something I'm going to be speaking on at Ludwell, because I think critiquing the Enlightenment is critiquing classical liberalism, which necessarily ends up with a critique of aspects of Americanism. Not everything about America, but aspects of Americanism. And, you know, one of those is the idea of these hallowed rights that are inalienable of freedom of speech,

SPEAKER_00freedom of worship, freedom of association, freedom of commerce, all these freedoms that That are supposedly rights. And then that eventually turns into a quote, right to basically be and do whatever you want. Yeah, that's right. And that's just absurd. And really, again, that's all antithetical to Christian tradition. You know, we have the church speaks to the state, there is a Christian doctrine of the state. And that's the absolutely antithetical to the way Americans think they think,

SPEAKER_00first and foremost, even though it wasn't originally intended to be this way, because you had various colonies that were attached to some, you know, usually some form of church governance. In the colonies. But eventually after Roger Williams, you get the idea that no, actually the state is like the beast and it's the enemy of the church and all this kind of stuff. So there's this division then between private faith and private worship and the rest of the civil sphere. And that becomes, I think, the essence of Americanism. Great example of this,

SPEAKER_00when my wife and I toured the big Masonic Monument to Washington, In Alexandria, DC, which you can see DC from over the river, but it's in Alexandria, it's not in DC. So I'm not talking about the Washington Monument, talking about the Masonic Washington Monument in Alexandria. We took a whole tour of that all the way up to the very top of it, all the different levels. And the guy who was the Masonic historian there was really trying to sell this sort of sales pitch that the essence of America is ecumenism.

SPEAKER_00He actually said that. It is the enlightenment project of God is a generic being that is bigger and broader than any church or any religion. Wow. And so that's, I think, the essence of the problem is this idea that we can escape religious squabbles by some sort of enlightenment liberalism.

SPEAKER_01Well, you can understand

SPEAKER_00why coming out of the. The Thirty Years' War and the Reformation Wars and all these different battles that happened in Europe over theology. People coming to America who were persecuted by the Church of England or whatever. I mean, all those are factors, and I understand that. Also, not wanting to be under the Pope in terms of the papal states or the kings didn't want to be subjected to the Pope because the popes were many times corrupt or as corrupt as the kings. Mm-hmm. I understand why there were these desires to want to not be under that kind of situation.

SPEAKER_00But that doesn't necessarily mean that your answer is going to be the right answer. So the idea that we can have an Enlightenment liberal republic or democracy, I think itself is not going to last the test of time, unfortunately, because in my assessment, and this is something even Jordan Peterson said like 10 years ago, humans just tend to Move towards authority and hierarchy. I don't mean you worship authority. So I'm not saying fascism where the authority structure is something that you kind

SPEAKER_00of worship because that would be sort of a papal model. But there is a natural hierarchy that humans tend to sort of drift towards. I mean, think about the family. You know, the father is ideally the patriarch of a family. The church, we have patriarchs, et cetera. So bishops. So I think that that's what's natural to human beings and church and state tend to reflect this. So when you try to institute these idealized pictures of an ideal Republic from, you know, Plato's Republic or whatever,

SPEAKER_00even if you think that you can do a Christian Republic, I mean, it's perhaps as possible, but the problem is that again, it just seems to not really be what humans tend to do. So, uh, And I know that there's warnings about kings, but the warnings in the scriptures about kings are about being a king like the Gentiles. If you read the book of Judges or if you read Samuel or whatever, it's not about kings itself. It's about the idea that we want a king like the Gentiles have a king, and they usually worship their kings as deities.

SPEAKER_00But even within the Mosaic law, you had in the Torah, you have prescriptions and rules for the king. So there's nothing in the Torah that's antithetical to a king. In fact, in Genesis 49, there's the prediction, the messianic prophecy, that the scepter won't depart from Judah until Shiloh comes, who's the Messiah. And that would be monarchical. So there's nothing anti-monarchical about the Bible. Rather, it's the reverse. And pretty much as far as I'm aware, every saint in church history were monarchists.

SPEAKER_00I don't know any that were Republican or Democratic proponents in terms of their views of church and state. So this is very challenging, I think, to Americans and to the American mindset when it comes to what the tradition of the church is. It's night and day in terms of the theory of the state. So that's, I think, the huge pill that people don't want to swallow.

SPEAKER_01It's spot on, bro. I was at a very weird event. It was probably 15 years ago now. It was in Naples, Florida. And Sean Hannity was speaking. It was very not many people. And I put this question to him. I won't go on and on. You're going to already recognize, people listening will probably already recognize the angle of the question, which is, You had a whole bunch of variations on, I don't know, pagan governments. Then you had the Greeks try something like a democracy.

SPEAKER_01I get it. It wasn't pure, but it was on many levels. And then you get Christianity. And again, I'm simplifying, but we can go walk through it. You get a Christianity that says something like, it kind of doesn't matter, but we have a king. We have an emperor. And then there's an emperor, as far as we can tell, that kind of goes – and then you get a papal problem. I'll just skip over that for one second. But essentially, the Christians are choosing again and again until the revolution in France and the revolution in the United States.

SPEAKER_01They're choosing to not try to go deep dive on democracy. They're actually staying away from it. And it took these – Let's just call them these rationalists. Or it took this brand of human beings, these enlightened characters, to resurrect democracy. And so I asked him, I said, are we sure that democracy is Christian? Because that's what he was, you know, how he does with the American flag. He was just conflating the two.

SPEAKER_00And literally, people were yelling at me, yelling at me about the question.

SPEAKER_01And then he totally skipped it. And I realized, I'm an idiot. What am I even bothering? Like, why was I bothering Jay to even ask the question in that form? I was trying to be the dick who, like, asked the question.

SPEAKER_00You said Jay, you mean Hannity?

SPEAKER_01No, but I was asking it to Hannity. I was asking you, Jay, why did I do that? Why did I think that it was going to be a good time for him to answer the hard question with all this? It was dripping with history. And he was like, bro... Jesus loves America, basically was his answer. Why did I even bother? But I did. I tried.

SPEAKER_00Well, yeah, that's funny because... Yeah, I think it's like you're saying, it's even a question that probably people like Sean Hannity don't even want to tackle. It's not even within the frame of a valid question.

SPEAKER_01Thank you. That's what the problem was. It wasn't valid. I find it very valid because I'm a Christian. And I think... Let's go to this. I think people... Largely because of you and guys like my brother, they're waking up to this bigger narrative about Orthodox. Look at Tucker. I was really fascinated with the part of the conversation where he kept saying everything's religious, everything's religious. 20 years ago, people were not saying anything like that. Nothing.

SPEAKER_01What do you see going on there?

SPEAKER_00People are waking up to thinking in terms of worldviews. I didn't expect that with Tucker because, as I've said, I didn't know exactly what he wanted to talk about. I suggested six things to Lexi, the producer, and she was like, yeah, let's do that. And I was like, well, do you want to pick one or two of these? Because any one of these could be an entire podcast. And they were like, yeah, sure, let's do them all. But I didn't know that. He would want to go hard on orthodox stuff for the first hour.

SPEAKER_00And it doesn't bother me. I'm happy to talk about whatever. But I think they also kind of want the guest to be a little unclear about what it is so that it's fresh, it's raw, it feels like a real conversation. Too scripted and wrote because I actually crammed a whole bunch about geopolitics thinking that that's what he'd want to talk about because so much of Tucker's shows are about that stuff. So when I got there and I'm like, okay, so you eat breakfast with him and then you're chatting and I'm like, I assume you want to talk about geopolitics. He's like, no, I'm over all that.

SPEAKER_00I'm over it. He's like, I just care about theology. That's all I want to do theology. Okay, yeah, sure. So that's his person. I mean, he might do a lot of geopolitics because the show's politically focused and people love, you know, American, Americans, real religion is politics, even maybe over sport. And so, you know, he does that, I think, because that's where the audience is. But personally, because you spend basically all the way up until the afternoon, three or four with him.

SPEAKER_00And he just basically says, you know, I'm really just interested in theology. That's where I'm at now. He's like, I'm over all the political stuff. I'm really interested in these spiritual questions. So that seemed to be his main personal focus. So that's why I think he hit really hard on that for the first hour. But I did want to mention about democracy and the idea of an idealized republic and all this stuff. So we're doing a series right now. We filmed three episodes with Pavel Shailen, who's

SPEAKER_01the Russian. He'll be there too.

SPEAKER_00I know you and he have done some chats.

SPEAKER_01He's coming down to Islamorada.

SPEAKER_00Oh, good. So we were having this conversation the other day in Nashville, filming these installments of a series. And he made a really profound point that I think touches on one of the issues with Enlightenment thinking and the idea about, you know, democratic republics and all this stuff. And he made the point that people who adopt those ideas abstract the system from actual people. And so they tend to think of it like this.

SPEAKER_00There's this system of democracy that runs America or the republic that runs America. And it's not thought about in terms of the actual people. Who are the representatives, the senators, the Supreme Court, the president, and the system will only be as good as the virtue or the vice in those people. But there's this thought, this enlightenment sales pitch that no, actually, it's a system that will save you that can bring about social salvation,

SPEAKER_00be it a constitutional republic or whatever. But it's really silly if you think about it, because it's only going to be as good as whatever the system is, the individual people's virtue and vice dominance that run that system. So there is no such thing as a salvific, abstracted system. And that's a modern Enlightenment era solution, because all those Enlightenment philosophers, whether it's the governance system, In terms of church and state, or whether it's individual idealized notions of human nature that you get out

SPEAKER_00of these people, none of that actually is reality because it's all just sort of universalized and abstracted because they're worshiping reason.

SPEAKER_01By the way, if you look hard at the saints, St. Seraphim and Seraphim, Once they get up into that conversation about a democratic republic and the institutions of a monarch, they sort of drop out. You notice they're sort of like, oh, yeah, mostly save yourself and those around you might also catch some of your light. Like they they don't really spend a lot of time talking about political structure.

SPEAKER_00Well, politics in history was not the purview of all the people. Right. You know, the politics was the court, you know, and and. The prints would be brought up in statecraft. You don't have the plow share, the plow boy. He's not learning courtly politics, right? So in the history of the church, then it was just never even part of the daily life of the villager or even the merchant, really.

SPEAKER_00So only in the last 100 years do we have this idea that, no, it's everyone's duty to keep up with every single thing in the news and in politics and in international relations. And by the way, that's absurd, right? I mean, how is a guy who's a mechanic We're not going to be able to actually keep up with infinity information of everything that's going on. But that's the idea of the enlightened citizen, you know, in the sort of the, you know, 1700s thought process about what, you know, every American is supposed to be.

SPEAKER_00Guys, the Founding Fathers or whoever, some of those guys were pretty good at that. I mean, they were pretty good at being very talented in statecraft, very talented in engineering, very talented in philosophy, farming. You could have a guy who's a farmer and he's also running all those others. But that's not most people. So the idea that everybody could somehow reach this sort of potentiality. And be that sort of Renaissance man is just not reality. And even, I mean, I'm a huge critic of Plato's Republic.

SPEAKER_00One thing I think he was correct about was he realized that not everybody's fitted to do everything. And that's one of the problems with the Enlightenment idealized perspective is that it assumes that everybody can just sort of become whatever they want to be. And we have all kinds of lies in America too. Like we talked about this with Pavel. You know, this idea, this is one of these boomer, you know, sort of mind matrix things that's collapsed. I think nobody would even, you would laugh at this. When I was a kid, I was always taught, you can become the president if you want in America.

SPEAKER_00Anybody can become the president.

SPEAKER_01I wrote that on one of my dumb college, like, I'm so embarrassed. I wrote, like, I want to be the president. I wrote that.

SPEAKER_00Well, I think every kid, and I'm not saying you're a kid, but I remember being a kid, oh, yeah, I would love to be the president one day. That sounds awesome. I could fix the country. And then, you know, it's this idea like Mr. Smith goes to Washington with Jimmy Stewart, right? Where it's like, I want to go to Washington, give them

SPEAKER_01what for. I'll tell the fat cats what's up.

SPEAKER_00And then it's like, no, that's not how it works. You don't go and tell the fat cats what's up and then all the country, you know, you get the word out and everybody's behind you. That's silly. No, to become the president requires at least hundreds of millions of dollars behind you.

SPEAKER_01First of all, best line that you just came up with ever is tell the fat cats what's up. I'm going to give those fat cats what's for.

SPEAKER_00Have you seen Mr. Smith Goes to Washington?

SPEAKER_01What's that?

SPEAKER_00Have you seen Mr. Smith Goes to Washington? I have. Yeah, that's I mean, that's funny, too, because that movie, I mean, it's a it's a fun, you know, 40s or a movie, but the movie is actually kind of an American propaganda film that that is intended to tell you, like, believe in the system, it works. If you're a good virtuous guy, you know, you can you can you can make the change happen. And I don't mean to be blackpilled. But it's like, again, How would you even make the change happen, you know, without,

SPEAKER_00like Father Turbo always says, you know, first being virtuous yourself, right? You got to first be virtuous yourself. And the reality is just simply that not everybody has the gifts to change society. But the Enlightenment ideals tell you that you have this sort of civic duty to be politically active, first and foremost, to contribute your, you know, Even the boomers had this idea about taxes. I remember hearing all the time growing up, I pay my fair share.

SPEAKER_01That's right.

SPEAKER_00Well, taxes are scam anyway. So you're paying into a scam system. So paying your fair share just shows you that you're duped into thinking that your tax money is actually benefiting society. It's not. So yeah, I think a lot of the boomer era lies about a lot of things have really collapsed. And I don't think that's blackpilling. I think it's just It's opening people's eyes up to other possibilities.

SPEAKER_01I don't think it's blackpilling. It can't be blackpilling at this point because it's too true.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, that's a good point. Truth itself can't be blackpilling because it really just is going to point you the direction of capital T truth, hopefully.

SPEAKER_01You know, the thing, and I bring this up all the time, but. The big ideas you're talking about, you know, this political history stuff, you study it, but it's real and it's around you. But in America, it's hard to see. I basically lived in a 13th century village in West African, Mali. And I got to tell you, I was one of the agents sent because I was in Peace Corps. And because I was literate, they were dogmatizing their language called Bambara.

SPEAKER_01In other words, they were, the state in 1989 and 90 was trying to make their language Bambara into a written language. So if you just think about that, that's happened with every culture. It's pretty wild to be a part of it. And I was an outsider who, because I was literate in the village, nobody else, well, there were two or three others, but they had left. I was teaching them how to write and read their own language. And during that process, they had an election, the first election in a long time,

SPEAKER_01because they chased their, well, they killed the president's wife and they put the president, he was totally corrupt, Musa Traore. Long story short, during the alphabetization of their language, this period, They lost their president and were having their first election since independence in the 60s. And guess what happened? They were asking me who they should vote for. Because they were like, we don't do this. And so I would say, well, who do you think? And then they would just go to the chief, who should we vote for?

SPEAKER_01And then he would say, you're all going to vote for this person. And they'd be like, okay. And then when I would say, why don't you want to vote? I was doing the American boy thing. Don't you, I was doing, don't you want to give them what for? And, you know, and they were like, I just do what the chief says, bro. Like, I don't know about that. That's not my, and it was in real time. And I used to think I got to teach them, I got to teach them the good way. You know what I'm saying? And it was, it just, it was an education all in like a month about politics, you know?

SPEAKER_01Right.

SPEAKER_00I mean, I remember, I've heard a lot of like, You know, people who were former CIA operatives or people that were stationed in other countries and they talk about how, you know, when you actually go and spend time in these other cultures, you realize that, you know, maybe it's not possible to export American democracy and, you know, constitutionalism to every country in the world. It just kind of doesn't really make sense because these are cultures that have for thousands of years not function that way. So there might be some problems and drawbacks with that, obviously.

SPEAKER_00So. There's both. There's both.

SPEAKER_01There's this weird mummification of sort of the noose. I mean, don't get me wrong. They're not on the path toward illumination and deification in the same way, but they still know themselves as part of something bigger. And most of us, at least me growing up, I was sort of neutered of that idea. I was like, this is your world for you to do what you need to do. And there's nothing bigger than you. And I was like, you sure there's nothing bigger than me? It feels like there's a lot of stuff. You know that old phrase when you tell the kid,

SPEAKER_01I don't know, like, I didn't try to tell my kids this, but what are you going to be when you grow up? It's like, that's a hell of a question, man. There's some ontology. Well, I'm going to be me, but taller. Like, what do you mean?

SPEAKER_00Yeah. I mean, I think the idea of America and Americanism I've been saying for a good while now, I'd say it's about half Christian. So we did a live stream on my channel the other day on the 4th of July where we talked about the good and the bad side of America. And if you think of somebody like Jordan Peterson, you know, 10 years ago, some of my first critiques of Peterson were about the classical liberal ethos and how aspects of that really don't match with Christianity.

SPEAKER_00So I wasn't totally critical. There's a lot of positives and appraisal and praise for Jordan Peterson, but The areas where I saw problems were precisely the Enlightenment stuff. And, you know, before he got ill recently, it was interesting because you see this arc from 10 years ago up till now. And before he had gotten ill, he was pretty, pretty heavily criticizing a lot of these Enlightenment ideas. And that led to a lot of the sort of Enlightenment defenders like James Lindsay, you know, going hard against Jordan Peterson.

SPEAKER_00But, you know, Pat, and he was going after Pajot, too, because, again, I think, and I'm not just trying to toot my horn, but I think some of the criticisms that I had have borne out that the more you try to, and the answer is always more freedom, more liberty, more liberalism, which is ironic because that's actually what the so-called leftists, the hardcore leftist progressives, they argue the same thing, right? And then as you find that same idea in Marxism too,

SPEAKER_00like when you bring Bring these issues to the fore, the problems with it, the answer is always, no, we just need more Marxism, more socialism, because it's these dang capitalists and the people that are holding us back. Same idea with, you know, a Jordan Peterson type of response. It's like, and this is something I noticed when I was an undergrad, when I had a really perceptive, he was a leftist, obviously, but I had a professor who had studied Frankfurt School Marxism under one of Habermas's universities.

SPEAKER_00Proteges. And so his whole thing was...

SPEAKER_01The Duke professor? Huh? Hirewas?

SPEAKER_00No, Habermas. You look at Habermas, the Frankfurt School Marxist. So I always like to joke that I have Marxist-Olic succession because Habermas was at Frankfurt School and he taught the guy who taught my advisor. So... Your royalty. Exactly. So my advisor for philosophy, Dr. Timothy Martell, he would... Make this point that, you know, there's kind of the same goals of sort of libertarian ideas and classical Marxism,

SPEAKER_00which is both of them have this idea that at the end of history or towards, you know, the latter stages, we can get to a withering away of the state. I don't know if the Frankfurt School guys had that idea, but Marx did and libertarians do. So they share the same idea that the state can go away, will eventually get away from the state. Through, you know, the dialectical process. But both of these ideas, I think, are just, again, based on a flawed view of anthropology. Like, you're not going to change human nature or re-educate human nature,

SPEAKER_00which is the whole Pelagian basis of a lot of this Enlightenment ideology. Man's a tabula rasa. Another one of the presuppositions about the Enlightenment, guys, isn't just about the universality of reason, which I do think there is a universal principle of reason, but not the way they think about it. They think about it like you can universalize human nature such that it is a tabula rasa that you can mold into whatever you want. But if things have fixed natures and essences, which is the very controversial thing that I brought up on Tucker, which I didn't even think was controversial,

SPEAKER_00but all the Protestants on Twitter just lost their mind the last two days over this.

SPEAKER_01It was very weird. It's very obvious.

SPEAKER_00It was not at all what I expected them to be. I figured people would be going crazy over the conspiracy stuff, but I guess conspiracy is normalized now. So maybe the hallowed sacred cows of the Enlightenment are the real conspiracy hot button. But if man's nature is not tabula rasa, if his mind's not a blank slate, and then you can't mold it into anything you want, if things have essences, then you're bound within the restrictions of those determinations that are objective and external to you. You can't make man into a woman, you can't make him into whatever you want.

SPEAKER_00He's not a Gumby silly putty person. And if that's the case, then that's pretty much the Enlightenment projects is a failure.

SPEAKER_01It's over. But For a Christian, how could it not be what you just said? How could it not be that we have nature? Because we're made in God's image, so we have divine nature. It's very odd that we can't start there on some level. It's very odd. I think it's just literally the absence of the idea of the fall. I feel most of the modern philosophies.

SPEAKER_00Exactly. In that sense, it's Pelagian because they're not taking account of man's nature being itself damaged. And the idea is that nature and man's nature, whatever that is, is just a collection of atoms. And because you can take silly putty and turn it into whatever you want, or you can take Mr. Potato Head and make him into whatever you want, you do the same thing. I mean, this is what H.G. Wells said. He called it plasticity.

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_00And he started with the plasticity of the human mind. And he said, I mean, you can just make it into whatever or human nature. It's not really a nature because this is also bound up with the other sacred cow that everybody worships, which is Darwinian evolution. If man can evolve into whatever, out of whatever, then you could steer that evolution into whatever.

SPEAKER_01Yep. Yep. I just had a friend, he's an evolutionist. He's just a classic. Let's just call him an atheist, secular guy. I love him. But he just wrote me and he goes, do you remember way back when, this is like 2000, when we used to fight and I used to say things like, man is so unique because of their opposable thumb. And I was like, I remember he used to say that. He goes, I can't even say that stuff anymore because nobody cares about that conversation anymore.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. He was admitting his own inability to make that. People don't want that to be why we're special anymore. Even in his circles, he's like, yeah, people are looking for more. I'm like, okay, so what more are you looking for, you? And he's like, I'm just trying to be a good father. Then the hard questions set in, and my secular friends just, they sort of lean away, like, okay, I'm giving you that. I agree, things have changed, but I'm not giving you Jesus in the sky.

SPEAKER_01They don't want to quite go there.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, you know, St. Gregory Palomas predicted a long time ago that the alterations in the West and theology would eventually lead to large scale atheism. And I think that prophecy has borne out because, and this is what I argued on Tucker that everybody sort of lost their minds over was there is a consequence to ideas and it might not manifest in that immediate generation, right? You might not have Immanuel Kant being ready to immediately embrace atheism or something like postmodernism.

SPEAKER_00But the philosophical assumptions that Kant has, for example, like dividing the mind from the external world and knowing the external world, this is a phenomenal numeral distinction, which is not controversial. Everybody knows that if you study philosophy, that that's what Kant taught. The end result of that, it might take a few centuries is, well, if we don't know the external world, then we don't know anything. So we're sort of caught in a solipsistic box. We're subjectivists. We're relativists now. Everything's purely just the mind. And then eventually that eats itself.

SPEAKER_00And there's no such thing as a mind because you don't see a mind under a microscope. So now you're just reduced to physical qualities, physicalism. Yeah, materialism. And that's obviously the logical result. So then you get to after that, postmodernism. Well, everything is just storytelling and myth making. And there's no more grand narratives because it's just competing power structures that have that enforce a narrative. So yeah, that's pretty clearly keep going result.

SPEAKER_01Keep going with that. I don't think I think in 10 years, everyone's going to know the narrative that you just said is true. But what happens next, though? Keep going with that. Be a political philosopher for a second. What do you think would happen if you had to bet on a lot of money? How would you bet big money? What comes next politically and philosophically?

SPEAKER_00I mean, things are so crazy, it's really hard to say. I mean, there's always, you know, black swan events and events. Crazy stuff. I mean, who would have ever thought that we'd see Trump as president and that we would have, I don't know, Tucker Carlson, one of the biggest podcasts talking about nominalism and orthodoxy. I mean, so things are so crazy that I don't even know what to say could come in five or 10 years. But based on the present situation, I would guess that there will probably be a lot more conversions to orthodoxy,

SPEAKER_00a lot more people looking for An authentic, historic religion and expression of that religion to kind of ground their worldview. Perhaps we could begin to see people start to think in terms of worldviews. That was the thing that surprised me, as you said, with Tucker saying everything is a religious commitment. That's something we've been hammering on my channel for many, many, many years. I think also Jordan Peterson indirectly brought that out. With a lot of the atheists who have kind of died out in terms of,

SPEAKER_00you know, Sam Harris and the Dawkins and that whole sphere, which was very popular in the 2000s, that's kind of died down. That's not nearly as popular as it was. A lot of those guys were flying on Epstein's flights. So we're realizing that they're not as scientifically, ideologically neutral as they claim they were. So I think people, the idea of neutrality and, you know, Scientific Objectivism. I think a lot of that is going to collapse. A lot of those sacred cows think that people are going to begin to realize even more

SPEAKER_00that the political process itself, which is a kind of a religion, is an idol. It's stupid. It's not at all real or what you think it is. It's controlled by forces behind the scenes.

SPEAKER_01It's oligarchy. Almost always everywhere.

SPEAKER_00It's an oligarchy. Yes, exactly. So I would say realization will continue. How that realization will be countered by the establishment, who knows? I mean, it's anybody's guess, but I don't know.

SPEAKER_01I go back and forth. I know I'm with you. We can't really know. I go back and forth between some kind of, let's just call it cool. I don't know if it's cool, but some kind of cool decentralization where people start going to their corners, but those places don't. They have their own flavor, their own fronima, their own culture.

SPEAKER_00There's one idol that's been erected here that maybe will collapse, which is the idea that what happens at a national level with political presidential elections is if that's that important, really.

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_00I mean, like you're saying, isn't it way more important what's actually going on in your town versus the stuff that's 1,000, 2,000 miles away in D.C. that you have no connection to, these people you have no connection to. You don't really know anything about these people's lives or what they're actually all about. You don't know the structure of lobbyists and how much power and influence they have. So I think a lot of those illusions will change. We'll fall away, we'll collapse. And maybe like you're saying, maybe people will focus more intently on kind

SPEAKER_00of what's actually happening around them because you're not really able to affect a presidential election.

SPEAKER_01No.

SPEAKER_00And presidents themselves are limited. Yeah.

SPEAKER_01It's fake and gay, like you say all the time.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, we were watching Star Wars. That's my last analogy. I don't mean to keep interrupting you, but I'm not a huge fan of the Phantom Menace and the one with Natalie Portman and Hayden Christensen or whatever. But what is interesting about that one is that when Palpatine is coming to power, and it's basically an analogy of Rome going from republic to an empire, So it's the crossing of the Rubicon type stuff.

SPEAKER_00You basically have Palpatine engineering a bunch of conflicts, trade problems and false flags that lead to an emergency dictatorship situation. I'm not saying America is going to be in an emergency dictatorship situation. I'm just saying that the funniest part of all that was that Palpatine actually understands how politics really works, because even though he's deceiving Padme When he's telling her all this stuff, he's like, you know who really runs the Senate, the galactic Senate?

SPEAKER_00It's the bureaucracy. And they control things through the trading guild. So it's these behind the scenes bureaucrats that are really running things. And because Palpatine's figured that out, he figured out that if he could co-opt the trading guild and take over the bureaucracy, he could become the emperor. So it's just a movie analogy for, you know, even kids' movies are telling you that It's run by bureaucrats and people behind the scenes. It's not run by these goobers that are elected and come and go every four years.

SPEAKER_01I look at it in my own life. It's like the bureaucratic power in my house is my wife. I do a lot of talking about how things could work. I'm like, I've got a speech loaded up. Girls, be ready. But you know what's really happening? Pretty much whatever the bureaucracy tells me.

SPEAKER_00The wifely bureaucracy.

SPEAKER_01Let's be honest. You're like, she's got all the plans for the actual trip. And I'm like, then we're going to go here. And then we're going to go here.

SPEAKER_00Tell me as we go, as we finish

SPEAKER_01up, you, like me, My favorite thing is to sort of, I don't know, half elevate. I would say you full elevate, but I like to half elevate the conversation and then throw humor on it until it's just ridiculous. And I know you like that too. What are you doing? What's the future look like on your channel? I know you're doing humor right now. Are you going to keep going? Is that your thing? It's my thing. I'm always trying.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, we love to do that. I mean, you know, it's... The funnest time I have is on the podcast with the comedians. That's always a lot of fun. We've done a lot of those. Before we did these recent big podcasts, we did a podcast tour where we did coast to coast about 20 different shows. We did everything from me debating Tim Pool and TimCast. Then we drove to Austin and Dallas and did Crowder and

SPEAKER_00With Gerald and we did Alex. Oh, you did Crowder?

SPEAKER_01I didn't know that.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, that one, if you look it up on Rumble, it's got a huge, it got close to a million views over there on Rumble. But then we went out and did Jesse Lee Peterson and we did Jamie Kennedy. And I had a blast doing Jesse Lee Peterson because he's more or less a comedian, you could say. Jamie Kennedy.

SPEAKER_01He's hilarious.

SPEAKER_00We had fun. Did you see that podcast? It was so crazy.

SPEAKER_01Forgive me.

SPEAKER_00You should watch it because it was very similar to Tucker. I didn't know what he wanted to talk about. And then the first thing as we get there and he goes, what is orthodox? What is orthodox? And he said, I was just going to do the same. Why would you choose to be orthodox and not normal?

SPEAKER_01I'm going to go watch it right now. That was the second question. The whole thing is funny.

SPEAKER_00And he just keeps asking me, you know, just crazy questions. He goes, do you cry every Friday for Mother Mary? And I'm like, cry for Mother Mary? What are you talking about? I heard that Roman Catholic cry for Mary on every Friday. Is that what you do? And I'm like, no, we don't do that. So the whole thing is just crazy questions.

SPEAKER_01I wish I was him. On some days, that's how I want to do all my podcasts. I love that dude.

SPEAKER_00Just troll podcasts. Yeah. Well, you know, you mentioned the comedic stuff. So on the Sam Hyde show, which I've been writing for that for the first season of it. And the first, I really enjoyed the first several episodes because it was just sort of Sam monologuing on hot button topics. And those were getting like, the Dear Elon episode got like 20 million views. It went crazy viral.

SPEAKER_01I saw that.

SPEAKER_00And then it moved into... A lot of interviews and some of the people who came on for the interviews are just really ridiculous people. And so those ended up being troll questions and silly questions with some of those. There's a guy who believes in drinking his own pee. And so a lot of those were silly questions. There was a boomer episode where they just brought on a random boomer to have Questions with that one's the funny one like that. But yeah, those are the funnest types.

SPEAKER_00And then, you know, we've done Sam Tripoli's podcast probably 10 times. That's always a blast. So long story short, like for me, those are the most fun because you can just really cut up and talk about serious issues. But there's, you know, a lot of podcasts are, you know, super serious in tone and I don't mind those. It's just not the most fun for me.

SPEAKER_01I'm going to. I'm going to pester you to help me get a couple of those guys to come over here and talk orthodoxy, but also ridiculousness. I can do it and I'm looking for it. There's a point in a Supra when a Tamada should either tell a dirty joke or have his Melikipe to tell a dirty joke. And I'm talking about dirty.

SPEAKER_00I remember the one about what was the pigs in the village.

SPEAKER_01Yes.

SPEAKER_00I remember that one from the Supra. Yeah. It was pretty dirty. That one grossed me out. And I have a pretty, you know, I'm pretty tolerant with gross jokes.

SPEAKER_01I got that joke from a very unlikely character named Gould. And he's an architect. We both know him. I know of him. I've not met him. Andrew. And what happens is when you do it, you start to realize that. Why that tradition exists is because you're covering all the aspects of human, like the absurdities. If you can't do that, then you can't, I'm not going to say you can't become fully human. I know there's a conversation, did Christ laugh? I get it. I don't want to, I've had that with my brother.

SPEAKER_01But what I'm trying to say is, is our existence as these fallen creatures includes that. And if you do not talk to that, at some point, you're not doing a proper table. And I would say the table reflects reality. Yeah. You have to. Otherwise, we all go crazy. Another thing is, is we can't get the right answers anyway. Even if we stay like very important, we still aren't getting the right answers. So calm down. That's why I like when you go on. I like when you go harsh. Sometimes I feel a little sad.

SPEAKER_01Like I'm an empath. I'm like kind of a pansy, OK? I'm like, oh, that poor guy. That's my only problem. I'm not even saying it's your problem. It's a me problem. On the other hand, Sometimes that's what humor is. That's just what it is. You know what I mean? Well, you know, the internet

SPEAKER_00is funny because, you know, if you begin to gain an audience, you're going to get made fun of and you're going to get called every name in the book. I don't care if you do a podcast on doing your nails. If you do a podcast on stitching, I mean, you're going to get, you know, you're going to get run through the mill in the comments. So I think you got to be, you got to just expect that.

SPEAKER_01Well, I thank our common friend, Neil, and your little power parish down there. I really like your priest. I just like your crew down there. I thank Neil for connecting us, bro. And I'm glad you're going to. Well, I'm not just glad. I'm kind of honored.

SPEAKER_00I knew you before I knew Neil. Because

SPEAKER_01I went to your wedding.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, you were there. And I remember, I think I did your podcast before I even knew Neil. Is that true? I think the first time, yeah.

SPEAKER_01I think. I think you're right about that. You're right about that.

SPEAKER_00I didn't meet Neil until fairly, because he just went to our parish, because they moved parishes in Florida. And then he showed up. I didn't know who he was. And he showed up. He was like, just talking. And he's like, oh, yeah, I know. He's like, I know John Heers. And I'm like, who is this guy? Like, I've never, I've never heard of this guy.

SPEAKER_01By the way, right? I thought he was sent. I thought some, I thought the middle, I thought CIA sent him. I was like, who is this guy?

SPEAKER_00But yeah.

SPEAKER_01Well, You're right. It was a reconnect in that sense. But he helped me to get you. Let me just put it like this. I thank you. And Jonathan Peugeot has come now. And I thank you guys. Because my other life is running this nonprofit that I just have to say. And I know everybody says this about their quote. I don't even like the term nonprofit. It's stupid. But the thing that I do that is supposed to be, I don't know, good. That thing has given me so much life.

SPEAKER_01And the people who join First Things and go for two years who live in these crazy places, there's so much beauty in it. And then guys like you who have your show, you're doing your thing, give their time to come and help me to raise funds. Like that stuff matters, bro. I don't know how to say this to people because people are pretty cynical. But it kind of matters where you... Let's cut. You put your energies and you got a lot of options. So I thank you.

SPEAKER_00And everybody has a podcast. And now I ran their grandmother as a podcast. So, yeah, I'm happy to come on. And I didn't mean that as a knock on you. I'm just saying, like, no, I everybody. So the market is saturated. So I try to choose, you know, people that I like and respect and think are doing good work. So happy to come on any time.

SPEAKER_01All right, say hi to your wife, too, who's also, I think she beat you down there at the conference on, from, what was it, Jerusalem?

SPEAKER_00No, I did a super technical, boring talk. And I literally put Metropolitan Jonah to sleep. Everybody was into Jamie's talk. So I'm going to try to do something a little more interesting next time. It won't be a super technical topic. But are you... Is there a place where people go get these tickets for this event? Because I was going to push it, but I know exactly what.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, it's a really weird thing because it's, I'm automata and I'm trying to make it, give it that cultural, you know, that phronema. They write me directly. So I'm going to give my email because I take care of this one.

SPEAKER_00If we collab, then it'll be below, right?

SPEAKER_01Okay, yeah, that's right. So we'll put this on mine, but we'll connect. And then, guys, you just write me, johnheersatfirst-things.org, and Jay will put it over on his stuff, too.

SPEAKER_00I'll put this on X and everything, too. Ah, I love you, bro. Because if we put on X, it'll get a whole other audience of its own. And sometimes, every now and then, even the X ones will get more views than a YouTube channel.

SPEAKER_01I got to tell you, I'm weak on X. In fact, I got locked out and I got so tired trying to get back in. I couldn't even figure it out. I just stopped. They won.

SPEAKER_00But I'm back now.

SPEAKER_01I love you, bro. So I'll look for you down there. I'm also coming to St. Augustine right after because I know you guys are having – well, I know Jay – I'm invited. I don't know about you guys, but I know that the parish and Neil is doing a conference.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, but I think they've decided to move that to next year because they were having a hard time finding a venue. Oh, they did? Yeah, we're limited for venues in St. Augustine.

SPEAKER_01Okay, well, I'll talk to Neil. But – Mostly, yeah, greet your wife. And then I'll be in touch and people go see Jay. Even people like Jay is mean. It's not so mean. It's not so mean. We try to match the energy.

SPEAKER_00So if people come in and they're nasty, then I'll give them an aggressive pushback. But when people are civil, for example, we just had an atheist guy. We did a three-hour debate on Modern Day Debate the other day. Totally civil. We had a three-hour conversation. No meanness whatsoever. So there's plenty of examples of non-mean debates that are out there.

SPEAKER_01My brother gets the same rep. And I'm like, my brother is not mean. If you ever spend 10 minutes with him, he's a baby. But if you're going to try to go tit for tat on church history, he's just going to get aggressive. That's just what he does. What's the problem? Michael Jordan won title. You think he was like a sweet guy? Everybody calm down.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, well, I mean, similarly, there's only a couple areas where I will just get really aggressive. Like if it's something theological or like, you know, some, you know, moral issue, like I'm debating a feminist, like those are the times I'm going to be aggressive. Any other other stuff, I don't care. I'm not going to argue with you.

SPEAKER_01All right. Well, I'll be in touch. Greetings from South Carolina. Are you in Nashville right now?

SPEAKER_00Well, no, we're outside Nashville. We're like an hour and a half away from Nashville.

SPEAKER_01Oh, I thought you were in Nashville hanging out with Candace.

SPEAKER_00I don't think Candace will ever have me on.

SPEAKER_01I don't know.

SPEAKER_00We were in Nashville for Pavel Shalen to be with him last weekend on Saturday. I just say Nashville sometimes because it's easier to tell people outside Nashville than it is to explain exactly where.

SPEAKER_01You know, Pavel, I just connected him with the author of Loras. Because, you know, Vodolotskin. Do you know Pavel in Russia is no joke? Like, people are paying attention.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I knew that, but I'm not familiar with it. You said Loras?

SPEAKER_01The book Loras. Oh, no. I highly recommend it. I don't know why we're doing this. Don't cut it, Andrew. I like this. Loras is... It's just fantastic. It's just, it's a book about a holy fool, essentially written in ways that make you think you're losing your mind because that's the point. Interesting. His mind isn't quite like yours. It's a really good book. Voda Lotzkin is the author. So I'll see you. God bless you, man. All right. Thank you, John.

SPEAKER_00Great conversation.

SPEAKER_01All right, there's Jay. You know, with the interwebs being everywhere all the time, you start to wonder, like, is there anything new you can ask people? I'd say this about the interwebs. I think the newness is in the degree of authenticity offered by those who are speaking one to the other. My favorite thing is It's when someone is just being human because people are beautiful. And then you're like, no, that guy said terrible stuff.

SPEAKER_01I know, I know, but it's his, it's his vulnerability in saying something like what he believes. And just because the belief isn't yours doesn't mean that the person isn't trying. You know what I'm saying? I'm not saying this about Jay. Jay's not like this. What I'm trying to say about people is when they're just straight lining Like something like their honest self. It doesn't matter what the platitudes and principles are.

SPEAKER_01If you look properly, you can see like gorgeous stuff. You know what I mean? Like a short tree is pretty because it's alive, but a majestic Oak is easier to see as, as beautiful as pretty, but both have this magnificence of life, like inside of them. And Humans are even better than trees. That's what I think. So, I don't know. We should all be easier and we should be better to each other, but we should also pursue truth.

SPEAKER_01I don't know, and then have some dinner. Here's a thought, opposable thumbs. I should just hang up now, but hold on, opposable thumbs. I want all you young people to know something. Your depression has been given to you. I know a lot of you are depressed under 40. I know. I know it. You can't fake me out. I know you're depressed. I know you're gonna be like, not me. I know, but like then all the other friends you have are depressed.

SPEAKER_01You can see it in their eyes. They just look like they're not sure why they would step outside of their own door, out of their own house on this day. That's called depression. So all of you guys are depressed. Just know something you're loved, but you were gifted. You were gifted the gift of depression by all the people in life who gave this answer to the uniqueness of your being. In other words, why are you?

SPEAKER_01Why are humans unique? Because a lot of people in very important positions in places like universities and on television gave this answer for why you're very special. Because you have opposable thumbs. Because you have opposable thumbs. You are special. You know, you've elevated yourself above the animal kingdom or something.

SPEAKER_01Opposable thumbs is not an answer to the question of what makes human beings special. And if you keep answering that, you guys who do that, you probably also say we should go to space so we can find new products like Tang or something. Or I don't know, powdered drinks. That's one thing that came out of the space race. Thank goodness. If you're also pushing opposable thumbs as making humans, you know, as the key to anthropological difference, if that's you...

SPEAKER_01Clip it. You should stop. I don't want to put you in a prison for dumb answers. The prison for people with dumb answers. I don't want to make a prison for people with dumb answers. That's a dumb answer to that question. You have to stop answering because someone might put you in prison one day for that. And it's not going to be me. Someone is going to devise a reason to put those kind of people in prison. And I don't want to be, I'm trying to save you from that bad prison. Because it's not a good answer.

SPEAKER_01We shouldn't say it anymore. Should stop saying it. Okay. Love you. Goodbye from Heavy Things Lightly. Right on. Absolutely. Go England. No, they just lost yesterday. If you're a sports fan, it was kind of an interesting couple of weeks, but nothing was as good as go New York, go New York, go. Bye.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Demons, Deception, and Why Your Spiritual Practices Might Be Dangerous

    Oct 2, 20261 hr 18 minAudio

    Find this episode on YouTube: "Justine Alter" - a pseudonym - returns to chat with John Heers in a raw Heavy Things Lightly conversation you have to hear to believe.Justine worked for years as a professional psychic,...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. The Fox News Reporter Who Quit to Live an Orthodox Homesteading Life

    Sep 25, 20261 hr 35 minAudio

    Find this episode on YouTube: Holly Hickman went from Columbia Journalism and Fox News Radio covering NASA and the 2008 election - to milking cows, making cheese, and converting to Orthodoxy.In this episode of Heavy...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Why They Left NASA to Start St. George's Classical Academy

    Sep 21, 20261 hr 2 minAudio

    Can you teach kids the truth AND prepare them for a secular world?On this episode of Heavy Things Lightly, host John Heers talks with James and Juliana Joyce, founders of St. George's Classical Academy in Boxford,...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. An Odyssean Tale: The Man Who Would Not Quit

    Sep 4, 20261 hr 37 minAudio

    Find this episode on YouTube: Crow walked America searching for his father - and found the Father.From West Virginia hollers to LA gangs, from wolves in the Mojave desert to an Orthodox cross, this is an Odyssean tale...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. From Broadway to the Supra: Carrie Manolakos on Life After Lockdown

    Sep 1, 20261 hr 51 minAudio

    Welcome to the first episode of “Save Me a Spot at the Supra” on Heavy Things Lightly where John Heers hosts singer and Broadway performer Carrie Manolakos (best known for her performances in Mama Mia! and Wicked) at...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode