Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Heavy Things Lightly

Heavy Things Lightly artwork

Time and Despondency w/ Nicole Roccas

Apr 30, 20261 hr 15 minAudio
  • Apple Podcasts
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Find this episode on YouTube: Dr. Nicole Roccas has been researching and writing about time from both a historical and theological perspective for nearly ten years. In addition to being a writer and editor, she lectures at the Orthodox School of Theology at Trinity College (Toronto). You can find more of her writing on her Ancient Faith podcast and blog, Time Eternal.Discover more about Nicole: https://www.nicoleroccas.com-----------------------Conrad's Deli - The best jerky you'll ever have: https://conradsdeli.com/ use promo code "FIRST THINGS" for 10% off.-----------------------✒ Substack: https://johnheersftf.substack.com/ⓧ https://x.com/johnfromftf🍷The best dinner party you've ever experienced - Supra Dinner Society: https://supradinner.com/🏖️ Tailormade tours that give back: https://www.gratitude-travels.com/home🔎 Discover the non-profit behind Heavy Things Lightly: https://first-things.org/ ✈ Become a Field Worker with FTF: https://first-things.org/opportunities📢 First Things Telegram: https://t.me/firstthingsfoundation🥂 Keipi Restaurant: https://keipirestaurant.orgPlease leave a review with your comments! Your support keeps this podcast alive and allows us to broaden our discussion. ---This “Enlightened” New World utopia isn’t turning out to be all it was cracked up to be. Society is disenchanting, but are the only alternatives hiding out in the hills or burying yourself in books? With an air of levity and a touch of humor, John Heers teaches how to examine the confusing New World by calling upon the mind and wisdom of oft-forgotten Old. Heavy Things, Lightly.--- Credits Music: Intro / Outro Provided by Greg Gilbertson & Band This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit johnheersftf.substack.com/subscribe

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

We all need the opportunity right like to write people off as well they're just I disagree with them and therefore like they're never going to change that's as dehumanizing as trolls coming out of the woodwork and saying crap about people that's not true right so we have to that's part of treating one another as human

SPEAKER_00beings is is at least at least offering one another the dignity and opportunity of making a choice guys that's uh nicole we have a great talk today we even get into a little bit of the conversation about online orthodoxy how it works we got into of course time and despondency her book which i'm greatly thankful for and so is

my family and we got

SPEAKER_01into Sort of, what is psychology? How does it work? And it was a great conversation. Nicole was a long-term get I was trying to get for our podcast, and now she's here. Also, we did not do this together, Ms. Rokas and I. We did not eat beef jerky together, but I'm convinced that if we were sharing a space, we could have eaten beef jerky together. Conrad's Jerky.

Conrad Jerky Company up in Pennsylvania You can find it right here in the link

SPEAKER_01Click it, buy it First Things is your It's your promo code And when you buy it you get 10% off And you support First Things and you support Mr. Andrew and his beautiful family In Pennsylvania Please eat This beef jerky from Conrad And from Conrad's Jerky Company And that would make all of us happy. So let's do some Greg Gilbertson. And on the other side, talk to Nicole Romus.

SPEAKER_01Okay, Nicole, so how are you doing? You've come on, you've deigned to come hang out with us on Heavy Things Lightly. So we'll do Heavy Things Lightly, but you've got a great book and I want you to talk about it, but can I just tell people how I met you, your book? Yeah, sure. Then I'll stop talking a little bit. But Nicole, my girls, I have four daughters and a wife.

SPEAKER_01And at one point we had a Great Dane that was also a female. And she was bigger than some of my kids. And so in that milieu about, I don't know, a year ago, they do a book club. And usually their books are about anything. It's not just books. beautiful thesis on orthodox spirituality like your book but this was your book I think my wife picked it and then that's all the text string was

about for like I don't know three weeks just went over and over again everyone was talking about

SPEAKER_01your book in my world well all the women in my world I'm sorry I know I'm gonna you're gonna have to I don't know you have to pay the show to come on because it was fascinating so then I said why don't to one of my daughters who is a booking agent for this this this outfit that you're involved with right now first things that sounds official but mostly she just it's nepotism but she said why don't we get

Nicole Rokasan and I said yeah why don't we why don't you take care of that and then she was excited so it's sort of like a star coming on to the podcast now you're like a star so at least my world I know a lot of pressure so how did you get into writing about time and this fantasy which is essentially something about well

SPEAKER_01you tell us and by the way you've got other work so share that too but just tell us how you became a writer and why you wrote this book anyway the one that I really am tied into which is time and despondency how did that happen so I've uh written since I was little you know I always wrote in journals actually one of these shelves over

SPEAKER_00here is just full of all my journals going back to when I was little um Just always, always was tied to words and reading and putting words together and describing things in words. So I always knew that I wanted to do something with writing. I never knew growing up that you could just be a writer. I come from like a very blue collar background. And so that wasn't, you know, I always just envisioned writing as something that you just

kind of did for

SPEAKER_00yourself on the side. And so I went through undergraduate and at that time had a lot of encouragement to go on to graduate school I was very into the humanities and so I went on to graduate school I ended up getting my PhD in history with a minor like one of my minor field was church history and during that time became orthodox

so at the same like that was kind of on a on an academic level when you do history you do a crap ton of writing like it's a very writing heavy field and you're always getting feedback on your writing it's academic writing but I as I finished my doctorate I realized like I don't actually enjoy this I I love writing I love

SPEAKER_00learning about history I love the critical thought that's involved. I loved getting my hands dirty in the sources, like really getting into the sources and learning the languages and just trying to take on the world of people of the past. I just find that extremely enriching. I didn't like writing strictly for academics. I knew I wanted to write for a broader audience at that point, which is kind of frowned upon in certain areas of academia it's like if you can make yourself

comprehensible to a broad audience it's kind of seen as a like what's wrong with you you know it's more you you want to be speaking to kind of your niche field um right so yeah so I was kind of coming out of academia I had the thesis that I had written for my dissertation

SPEAKER_00was about how people viewed time in early modern Germany um specifically during the 17th century. Well, 16th and early 17th century. And I won't get into that, but there was a lot of things happening in broader culture and religion at the time to shift how people experienced time, specifically the year as a unit of time. You know, the calendar reforms and a few other things were happening to

affect how people

SPEAKER_00were just experiencing time. I want to get into this idea of time for sure but okay keep going because we can go because I think I'll get the broad the broad arc and then yeah do it and then we'll dive in because it's it's really interesting on a philosophical level yeah um so that got me thinking you know I I began to see time as very much I guess in like sociological terms as a construct um but in spiritual terms I was you know I had converted to

orthodoxy and stuff and I was beginning to see time as this sacred um dimension in which we experience God we live our lives we grasp the arc of salvation you know time is the unfolding of

SPEAKER_00salvation so as I was coming out of my doctorate I was really hungry for opportunities to take all the ways I have learned to think about time historically and like integrate that with Orthodox theology in a way, not in a heady way, but in a way to make sense of it for myself primarily. So that's how I started that's that's what the impulse that got

me to start my time eternal podcast on ancient faith which is you can still listen to episodes they no longer produce episodes but they're still you know they're still live on ancient faith radio and very soon into starting that podcast I did a mini series during

SPEAKER_00Lent on the spiritual sickness of despondency or in Greek akithia in latin acedia which is the spiritual sickness of well akivia in greek literally means the absence of care so it's a spiritual sickness essentially of apathy and and a little bit of like sloth thrown in there it's kind of this hybrid hybrid concept so i focused on that during lent because i have always

Been Drawn To That Spiritual Sickness Because I Feel It Is One Of My Primary You Know Issues In Life Or Has Been In The Past Still Is So I Just Wanted To Explore Like Okay What Has Been Said About This In Our Tradition And Because It Was A Podcast About Time I Had To Find A Way To Approach It Through The Lens Of Time And

SPEAKER_00I Started To Realize You Know A Lot Of Times Despondency Comes Through the way we approach time seeing time as meaningless boring being sort of nostalgic for the past like preferring the past over the present or preferring our ambitions and ideals for the future over the present and these things can lead to this like despair and paralysis in the present so that was like the seed of my book I ended

SPEAKER_00up you know doing a six part series that eventually became my book So Nicole in the book You're kind of I had the thought of you as being Like an inverse kid in other words You saw time As going fast I think most little kids see time As going slow So there's something really weird Let's I like It's a dumb word

SPEAKER_01weird but there's something Unique Early on, you sensed death or something in a way that I think allowed you to write this great book. Can you talk about your childhood? Because it seemed like you were considering things most kids don't. Do I have that right? I mean, I think it's all a spectrum because I've heard from plenty of parents.

SPEAKER_00So for those of you who haven't read the book, I start off the introduction with sort of an anecdote experience from my childhood about my father turning 40. It's ironic because I just turned 40 this past summer. Anyway, it was very troubling for me that he was turning 40 because to me that meant he was old and I was very much preoccupied with his mortality and pretty much the mortality of everybody around me and had to process that with

the school counselor

SPEAKER_00and whatnot. So I start with that experience as an early, you know, something that from an early age made me sort of grapple with what do we do with time how do we live in time and yet not despair so is that uncommon you know I don't know probably would need a psychologist to you know analyze that for me but I have heard from parents since writing that book sharing

you know I have a child who's also very existential and reminds me a lot of the questions you were asking at that age in your book I've also heard from adults who are like I was the same way and no one understood me um you know so I think it I don't think maybe it's a bell curve you know but I will say I have always been you know that is something if you ask my friends who've known me for any length of time um my siblings I have always had a fairly morbid sense of

humor I've always

SPEAKER_00been Preoccupied by death not in a goth way but in a very like very existential way that often has troubled me um but it's also allowed me probably more than many people I know to feel comfortable around death and around those who are dying and um those those who are sick or have terminal illness in my life because

in a certain sense to me that's like I'm always thinking about those questions and very little scandalizes me very little makes me feel like oh that's taboo you know so it's a blessing and a curse I think I see it in some people that I love is there's so okay so my question is but I'll make a comment my question is is I've the philosophers of old in antiquity they would sort of and I

think the Christians took this up is there wouldn't be time if there wasn't death it's something I would

SPEAKER_01like you to comment on that but what I found in your book which is really reminiscent of what I found in the people I love including my wife is that Being aware of death allows you to sort of talk about it like you were describing and to be present with it in a way that makes other people peaceful and I think your book is like a call to peace on some level and so is that because you were young and wrestling with death therefore with time are those

two ideas connected do

SPEAKER_01you think?

SPEAKER_00I think so because I think again this is all just experiential But I think part of what, for example, the example of my dad turning 40, part of what so troubled me is that I have always felt time to be this thing that's moving too fast. I mean, sure, I can look at experiences where I was in a 15 minute timeout and it just felt like it took forever, right? So I have those experiences too,

but by and large on just a baseline level, I always feel that I'm running out of time and if you watch me move around my life or ask my husband or anything this is something that is fairly obvious about the neurotic way I go about my life because I am always in a hurry for no real reason most of the time so I'm always feeling time time is in a rush that goes back to

SPEAKER_00childhood I you know so that feeling of I'm going to run out of time um pairs with then how do you think about your life and what what does it mean to come to contemplate death you know memento mori um in a life where you sort of perpetually feel like it's moving too fast and you're going to run out of time you know now the question of

SPEAKER_01No, go ahead. Go ahead. Forgive me.

SPEAKER_00I was going to go back to your question of time. There would be no time without death because I disagree.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. Do that. Do that.

SPEAKER_00Time existed before Adam and Eve. Time existed before the fall. If you read the Genesis narrative, God creates the world in seven days. He creates the sun, moon and stars to mark the seasons and the times. as part of that creation God himself is in some ways he's a God of eternity but he's also from the very beginning a God of time and Adam and Eve come on the scene

and yeah there's already a rhythm baked into creation the creation that is good so

SPEAKER_00I don't see time as a marker of death or Bad or Evil I see it as sort of an unnecessary dimension that God has baked into creation probably largely for our sake because we aren't we aren't God and we can only come to understand him a little at a time we can't understand things all at once because we're creatures and so that unfolds now it's a gift if it's a gift

I mean in the beginning it's a gift then what happens is so in the beginning time

SPEAKER_00you can find this in St. Basil's Hexa-Emeron his set of sermons on the creation he talks about the time that existed in the beginning as aeonic having to do with eons they were these sort of endless repetitions of coming back to God and coming back to God and coming back to God the ages of ages of ages that was time in the beginning and you know time as this process of

completion and process of like bounty and abundance so time always being this thing that helps us see like see things grow and see things come to completion and fulfillment in Christ Now in the fall afterwards you see that one of the it's called the curses but one of the pronouncements that God makes over Adam is that he's got

to now go out and like plow the fields by the sweat of his brow he's got to labor he's got to basically go into yeah go into survival mode best case scenario so in the garden the earth couldn't help but produce life like that was the default was abundance in life after the fall outside of the garden they're expelled from the garden the default is death and the best case scenario is you work the

ground and you work the ground and you make enough to survive for that season and then you've got to do it all over again you're not going to get ahead of that cycle you're not going to make

SPEAKER_00enough crops um to sustain you perpetually. You're always going to have to go back and go back and go back because death is going to be like a weed. It's just going to be cropping up and cropping up and you're always going to be have to be fighting it back. So time becomes this like survival game. Time becomes this march to mortality and futility. And we have to now work just as we have to work to

SPEAKER_00Bring fruit from the ground and crops from the ground, we have to work in time to bring fruit from time and to reclaim and redeem time as something more than a cycle that leads to death. And is to get out of that cycle well let me to get the mind out of that cycle is there some kind of healing in staying in the present because your book really emphasizes this idea of the now is that one way for us to be present with God and

avoid past and future as a type of dead end cycle do I have that would you would

SPEAKER_01you argue that's true I mean so yeah in my book I focus a lot on the present um because it's it's really the only mode of time that's real in the sense that it's the only mode of time that we have agency that we can exercise free will it's the only mode of time that we can encounter Christ it's the only mode of time in which we can work out our salvation in fear and trembling practice virtue love

self-sacrificially um come to know ourselves come to know God we can't do that when we're thinking about the past I can't you know I have regrets from the past I can't no matter how much in my mind I like go back and ruminate on those things I can't actually change those things I can't actually meet Christ in the past I can't meet him in the future I can only meet him now so I think that that is yeah

that's where we start

SPEAKER_00but I also would like to point out that when we say living in the present as as Christians and specifically as like Christians with a sacramental worldview it's not it's not the present as like completely cut off from past and future because God was also at work in the past to bring me to the present and God will continue to be at work in the future so you know since since writing that book I've done

SPEAKER_00and my professional path has shifted a bit. I've done training in trauma work. I do trauma recovery coaching. And one thing that comes up with trauma, people who've been through trauma is like, what do you do with the past? Because as much as you would like to dwell in the present, you've got intrusive memories from the past, really distressing things that have happened from the past that you've not yet worked through. You've not yet integrated fully in the present. That's what part of what trauma is. and I like to say we live with the past we don't live in the

past so we live with what has happened to us we live with the regrets we may have we live with the teeming waves of history our own personal history civilizational history human history that has brought us in all sorts of complex ways to be the person we are in

SPEAKER_00the life we have in this Present Hour we live with all of that and that all of that while we can't be present in those past realities they are real because they have brought us to the present they're manifest in who we are that's one thing i was taught in the old world living living in africa is that history is a narrative it's it's just a story that helps understand your your present moment right it's like this is the story of

SPEAKER_01you yeah so they get manifest and I wonder like did you yourself I think a lot of people read your book and they go oh she's talking let's just let's just do some like pop words like oh she's talking about depression and I wonder if she had depression and I wonder if this book is about helping her with her depression is that true or is that not really well I mean I say in the book that I've had that I

SPEAKER_00struggle with depression so I I mean I'm pretty transparent about that but is it depression because in a lot of ways in the book you kind of veer away from from that paradigm you know you bring in the same I'm not saying that you're you're you're not you know I think it's a book about depression on some level but it seems like you're trying to redefine it do I have do you think that I'm getting

SPEAKER_01on to that right or not really

SPEAKER_00I don't think I'm trying to redefine clinical depression. I think clinical depression is a thing that many people suffer with. And what I, you know, what I see more, how do I put this? Is there a question, is depression and spiritual despondency the same thing?

SPEAKER_01Right. That's kind of what I'm wondering about. so I think this gets at a deeper issue or a deeper question correct me if I'm wrong and that is are like let's say western medical views compatible with orthodox concepts of the human person great and human sickness I think that's the core

SPEAKER_00question yeah me too um and I am I'm definitely someone who sees um okay so my you know my understanding of what it means to be human what it means to be a broken human being in need of healing is founded in an orthodox you know I look to orthodoxy for to understand myself

as a human being to understand what makes me feel that so many things in life are challenging what

SPEAKER_00makes me What does it mean to be healed? I think all of that for me starts in Orthodoxy. We have a very rich anthropology that helps us understand where does brokenness come from? What were we made for in the beginning? What does it mean to be the image bearers of God in a broken world? We have all of that in Orthodoxy. Now, we also live in a society where things like Western medicine exist, psychotherapy exists,

um and what do we do with that I think that uh if we believe that God is everywhere present and filling all things as we pray in the Trisagan prayers um that it's

SPEAKER_00It's fully possible for God to be in those healing modalities. We have so many saints in our tradition who were physicians. We have St. Luke, St. Samson, St. Zenaida, the Unmercenary Healer, have a lot of saints in our tradition who they were, you know, spiritual people and pious, faithful people and were physicians and concerned with healing the mind, body and soul using both prayer and whatever medical Interventions and therapies were available and known to them at

that time.

SPEAKER_00So I see, you know, I see a lot of compatibility. I see I'm very grateful for like Western medicine. And it's what it helps us do in terms of healing the body and the mind sometimes. So then the question is, Depression and despondency. What's the difference? Is there a difference? Well, depression comes out of modern clinical understanding.

SPEAKER_00That's a clinical word. It's a word that describes a certain set of symptoms in a medical context. Despondency, acivea, came out of second, third, fourth century ascetical theology that thought about the human person a little bit differently. um and I think frankly has a bigger picture of what healing looks like when I go to my doctor because I do have depression I take antidepressants

I've had to do a number of things over the years to deal with that frankly I would not be alive today without those things so I give I'm immensely gratitude grateful for those interventions I give thanks to God every you know every day when I take my

SPEAKER_00antidepressants because it's allowed me to live more fully for him and to have more time in this life to repent. But when I go to my doctor, I have very helpful and skilled doctors and I love them. They're not concerned about my spiritual healing. They're concerned with can we can we sort of help you do some things in your lifestyle and your nutrition and maybe some medication to help you get more to like a baseline level where you can function in your life and from there go on

to do the things

SPEAKER_00that are important to you. That's a very narrow understanding of healing. It's helpful. It gets me to a baseline level where I can go to church. I can lead a fairly normal life when I'm able to manage depression. But then you come to orthodoxy and it's like healing is so much more than that. so I see depression as like one slice of the pie it's an important slice of the pie for people who suffer from it it's a real thing and it is

spiritual because everything is spiritual everything affects us spiritually depression is hard it's really really hard and I think modern life exposes us to more things and puts more

SPEAKER_00stressors on our nervous system that probably makes depression As A Phenomenon More Common Than It Ever Has Been Before That's My Personal Belief But That's Only One Slice Of The Pie For Me And Orthodoxy Helps Me Remember The Whole Pie Of Healing Do You Think As A Historian Is Is The Sin Let's Use The Word Of The Enlightenment That Everything Got Microscoped In Other

Words You Use The

SPEAKER_01Word Narrow I use the word like it became the one muscle that grew beyond in a steroidal way was the muscle of the intellect which sort of fueled science and that science lens is very particular and narrow not without use it's useful but it's narrow and the narrowing vision of the science of the age of science

maybe it just can't see all the other ways that we can heal is that if would you attribute that that's a kind way to read the enlightenment and the scientific you know movement would you jump in that boat with me or not really oh you know I'll be

SPEAKER_00honest I I just, I see the dangers of the Enlightenment, but I'm just not, personally, I'm just not into eschewing whole eras of history as bad or wholly destructive.

SPEAKER_01Come on, we'll have fun. We can do it together. Just trust me. I'm going to play devil's advocate.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I'm going to push back because, sure, did, you know, the scientific revolution, which started before the Enlightenment proper, And then the sort of coming enlightenment, did they have the sort of broad effect and gradual effect of sort of creating a

SPEAKER_00fragmented sense of what it means to be human, meaning we've now got the mind the mind like the intellectual mind as having primacy over other aspects of our being sure it it created a kind of worldview that created some fragmentation in our experience of what it means to be human but i would say that tendency goes all the way back to the garden of eden that tendency is not just a

western modern western

SPEAKER_00tendency because we're bad for being Western. It goes back to like our human condition and our typical way of dealing with what we don't understand, which is to cut off parts of reality that are inconvenient to look at or that we can't comprehend. So Adam and Eve in the garden, you know, they Eve listened to a particular way of understanding herself as it

was told to her by the serpent and cut herself off from what you know from what God had said right um and that's what allowed her to eat of this tree of knowledge for which they didn't have they didn't have the capacity to bear that knowledge yet so right I think my point is the enlightenment I I think is an unfortunately very prominent example of

SPEAKER_00the human Universal human tendency to cut ourselves up and cut ourselves off from the fullness of reality.

SPEAKER_01Well, I think we're on the same page. This is why my whole podcast kind of started out of this idea. And here's what I think, which is what you basically expressed, but I'll throw it back at you. It's like... there are certain temptations in the world actually your book even talks about the the eight evil thoughts that turned into you know saint leo was it was it leo the great yeah that it became in the west yeah john cassian anyway there are

SPEAKER_01temptations but what happens is is cultures People start to embrace them and then cultures follow sort of the lights of the culture and then pretty soon the you know the bright lights that and in the enlightenment the bright lights were the scientists who were manipulating matter and then the way I see this is is That's just one type of temptation, but the West, let's call it the West, embraced that particular temptation. You could look back at pagan Northern Europe before the

Enlightenment and they were

SPEAKER_01embracing sort of the bottom half of us, the Eros of us. They were into the god of war, they were into certain types of ways to fix their problems that started sort of in the nether, in the below regions of our being. Every culture has to choose sort of how they're gonna go. And I agree with you. There's never really been a culture that's just been the royal path. There's no real Christian culture There's Christian saints But I do think we should

And this is my pushback It's pretty wimpy I do think we should as orthodox We should be ready to point that out As a form of healing It's like hey guys Yeah

SPEAKER_01we're all westerners And I'm really happy about it But also A, B, and C are really messy and we shouldn't probably embrace those and those come out of the heritage of I think it's like you said the heritage of changing the anthropology of human beings we started to talk differently about what a human being is and that was very dangerous not that they were getting it right before But the embrace of it has caused us to misdiagnose. Well, your whole book is about a misdiagnosis on some level of this

notion of depression,

SPEAKER_01which, by the way, is a beautiful way to fulfill the whole goal toward health, which is to say there's all these other ways to understand depression. And I think that's why it's really resonant with me and with the people I know that read it. I wonder if People outside of orthodoxy Do they pick up your book too? Can they see what you're talking about? Let's call it secular The secular professional world of psychology How has it been

SPEAKER_01received in terms of that? It's from a fair number of Christians who are not orthodox Who read it And there

SPEAKER_00have been a few Every few years I host a coaching group During Lent that we go through the book and we sort of talk about how to apply certain discipline, you know, spiritual disciplines or ausgesis to our lives around despondency. And I usually have a few people in that group always who are not not Orthodox. Usually they're some some kind of Christian.

I've had a few friends who are not Christian at all read the book but I think because they're my friends and they enjoyed it but I mean I was pretty conscious in that book to write in a way like I wanted people who were not orthodox to not just like I wanted more people to read my book but I wanted them to feel safe and welcome in reading the words like I wanted them to feel a sense of connection and so I hope you know I hope I did a good job in this but I

was I tried very hard in the way I phrase things and the way I talked about things to be just welcoming and not use jargon and not assume like okay we're all orthodox and I'm preaching to the choir here or something but to keep it yeah to keep it welcoming yeah the jargon you're right about jargon it's a very personal narrative it's it's not

SPEAKER_01It's not clinical in that sense, which is really nice. I think it opens up.

SPEAKER_00You know, interestingly, back to this enlightenment thing, one sort of picture that I think is helpful is the pendulum. As human beings, we're very prone to extremes. So the enlightenment and the kinds of thinking that led to it were an attempt to correct some extremes that preceded it. um you know basic things like what's at the center of the solar

system and and this is timely because as we're recording the Artemis uh to mission is happening and we're getting all of these pictures of the earth and all of that you know um

SPEAKER_00attempts to to correct for some extremes that were happening and We don't do a good job at that because no sooner do we start to correct one extreme than we swing to the other and I personally find it helpful to look at you know aspects of history that I struggle with and try to find out okay what's like what's the good in this period or what like what truth were they trying to work out and one of the truths that I think the enlightenment was trying to get at was we were

SPEAKER_00created with rationality we were created with minds to be able to like Seek Truth and that is an important that's an important spiritual faculty unfortunately we're prone to extremes right so we really took that and ran with it interestingly now like if you look at psychotherapy and I work as a coach but I use a lot of similar methodologies to that to what you would find in psychotherapy I

SPEAKER_00just use them a little bit differently in my practice a lot of them today are trying to find ways back to the body and back to bringing mind and body together and what we're learning is that you know healing modalities and therapies that work only with the brain like cognitive behavioral therapy where you're just only looking at the thoughts I shouldn't say brain looking only at the conscious thoughts and trying to like come up with arguments and talk

yourself out of those

SPEAKER_00thoughts are not as complete as modalities that find a way to bring your mind into your body and heal that rift. So modalities like EMDR, polyvagal therapy, things that try to regulate nervous system, all of these are efforts, yes, in a secular context, but they're a recognition that we're more than what's up here. We're psychosomatic creatures. We're mind, body and spirit.

and you know so there's i think that that's um that's really beautiful like there there's there's truth to ancient christian concepts of the human person as being this incarnational creature made in the image of god and you see that now even in secular psychotherapy modalities that are like trying to trying to bring those

SPEAKER_00things back together for the sake of healing do you think there's So to me, what words are chosen in a particular arena are really important.

SPEAKER_01So what words are allowed in, what words are not allowed in? Because we run an organization where I hire non-Orthodox Christians all the time. And I always tell them, if you come to this organization, then I'm going to use words like theosis. And I really don't care what you call it. it doesn't matter to me but we're on a journey where you go live in a mud hut in part to get closer to God and I'll say but you can you use your words I'll use mine

like I like lay it out like that when in the interview and what I'm finding is is

SPEAKER_01there's a um There's a warming going on that's sort of the ice is melting in terms of the secular space and the allowance of let's call it religious language. I really don't like that term, but you get what I'm saying. Do you see that in your work where certain vocabularies are being is being allowed into the let's call it the academy or into the professional sphere in a way where you can kind of speak orthodoxy into the secular space and vice

versa or not

SPEAKER_01really? um for sure but I should also say I've never I've never really experienced people talk about oh how hostile academics are to Christianity or secular you know this

SPEAKER_00whole secularism thing I have never experienced that I come from a very fun like I grew up very evangelical and like a very fundamentalist expression of evangelicalism that was very anti intellectual anti secular university I went to a secular university because that's all my family could afford like I just went to my hometown university because it was a public school and my parents would not have been able to afford some private Christian university

and granted that was in the early 2000s um but I never I just went in so grateful to be getting an education so grateful to be the first person in my family to be

SPEAKER_00going to college and then get to go to graduate school on top of it and I encountered people that were not Christian and I just thought you know I had I had a few I was thankful to have blessed to have a few like Professors in my undergraduate university who just happened to be christian but they were they were very much like just be yourself just do good work and be um be loving be kind be honest be rigorous and don't don't go into

public arenas with

SPEAKER_00this like preemptive persecution complexes like that's just annoying um and that's what i did i i have only my experience has always been and maybe this is just my privilege my you know the i've just had a good experience my experience has only ever been curiosity and i find but but you know i i was never annoying about my faith also because i just don't do that kind of stuff

i had a professor in

SPEAKER_00um graduate school he was the head of our department at the time and you know I talked a lot about faith in my doctoral thesis I studied a lot of like religious history and talked a lot about theology um you know history of theology in my doctoral thesis and he read it and after I kind of was done with the doctor I was like finishing up and graduating he came up to me and he said um he said I just want to tell you off the record that no one has

made me think she said I'm not a person of faith I don't believe in God but no one has made me has made me more curious about God than reading your academic work and and like you know I don't know where he's at now or you know what where his journey has taken

SPEAKER_00him but that was the head of my department and and I wasn't even trying to to win people I was honestly just trying to do good work to stay curious to stay humble and treat people like human beings including the people that I was studying in the past you know for the historical figures and whatnot I and I think that was in the early you know that was I finished in 2015 I think

SPEAKER_00So much has happened in the world. There is so much hopelessness and a sense of powerlessness and chaos, both sides of the political spectrum that I think many, I think there is space in the conversation for words of hope.

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_00You know, and If you show up as a cattle prod, then people will feel like they're going to get electrocuted.

SPEAKER_01So I bet half of the battle is showing up in love with a proper Christian temperament that people are already closer to being your brother or sister than they are to being your enemy.

SPEAKER_00And frankly, I learn a lot from people. who do not share the same beliefs as me. I learned a whole hell of a lot. I don't know if I can swear on this podcast. You can swear.

SPEAKER_01Believe me, it's not good, but I fall into that. I'll take sitting down for a conversation with an atheist person who's just trying

SPEAKER_00to be honest with themselves and heal and get out of addiction i'll take i'll take a person like that any day over an orthodox person who thinks they have all the answers and who's ready to tell me what i can and can't do because i'm a woman or not as good as them or don't have can't whatever like i'll take the atheist trying to be real over an orthodox person who's got it all figured out any day of the week

Amen I mean look someone's gonna push back on this probably in the comments but what you said is obvious I'll put it differently for you I don't know about in the

SPEAKER_01end who I stand with in you know the heavenly banquet I don't know about the Orthodox guy and I don't know we can argue about it who's going to get the roses at the end you know in the next life I will say this I'd rather sit at a table with the person you just described who's curious and honest and vulnerable than the Orthodox guy and I sit at a lot of tables and one of the things I always say is you know the best sound the sound at a table that's most

beautiful is the

SPEAKER_01sound of humility and everyone will be drawn to that person and then that person will actually have the power to change others through their their humility and you ain't lying sister we got we got it's a problem that we're always working on right um is telling the truth with with love it's pretty hard to do sometimes well and telling the truth

SPEAKER_00first and foremost to ourselves Well that's your business that's that's what you do that's what your book is about like what's tell us a story or two you don't have to share personal you know I get other people's business you don't want to share it but what's a pattern that you see in people trying to heal from their trauma when you're coaching what's a pattern that you just go oh here it comes again can you share some of that with us

SPEAKER_01where you see how people get stuck um

SPEAKER_00Sure, I'll share patterns that I myself have experienced that I also see in others, but I can share just out of my own experience as well. One thing is realizing we can't save anybody. We can't fix anybody. I think you know those of us who've grown up with there's a

scale you can find easily online called the aces scale adverse childhood experiences scale and it's a 10 point scale it asks about different types of experiences that you had early in

SPEAKER_00life for example did you have a parent or caregiver who was an addict or who's actively you know addicted to substances did you experience um different forms of chaos or abuse early in life and um if you have I think a four on that scale that's considered a high aces score four or higher out of ten it's considered a high aces score correlated with uh

mental and physical higher incidence of mental and physical health issues along into adulthood because what we experience early in life continues and so like my

SPEAKER_00ACES score is an 8 out of 10 And there are certain things that when you experience them early in life, the one of the coping mechanisms you cling to is the idea that you can fix things. That's a belief that you cling to to just help you survive with what you're experiencing. Truthfully, you're powerless, for the most part, particularly as a child. But yeah, you know, depending on the dynamics in your family of origin,

you may be blamed you may be scapegoated or you may just cling to this idea that well if I do this differently dad won't do this or if I do this differently our financial situation will improve in this way or whatever and it's really hard to shed that when you then come into adulthood and are in relationships that are

SPEAKER_00supposed to be mature relationships and you realize that I can't actually fix this person. I can't actually stop this. I only have control over myself. So we may blame ourselves. We may engage in self-hatred, self-loathing. And it's really hard to shed that. And this is, again, where I find the interplay between orthodoxy and other like like

modern psychotherapy really interesting because I have a lot of tools for myself to work on that pattern you know to work within myself on that pattern you know things I can do when I have certain thought patterns so I can kind of get my mind out of those thought patterns

SPEAKER_00things I can do in terms of breathing and body awareness to help myself realize when those kind of that savior that that feeling that it's all on me to save come up and that gets me a little bit helps me move forward and then I step into orthodoxy and an umbrella over all of those tools is the fact that only God saves only Christ saves and I was never asked to save anybody like I was never asked to be responsible for anybody

else's sin but my own

SPEAKER_00um and the extent to which I continue believing or acting out that impulse to save and rescue and be codependent like the extent to which I continue acting that out is keeping me from resting in the salvation that I and all people have been offered in Christ and it's also potentially preventing the other person that I'm trying to rescue from really engaging in their free will and experiencing the

consequences of their choices and their sins and maybe facing reality to the point where like maybe they

SPEAKER_00out of free will eventually choose that salvation. If I'm constantly rescuing them, they can never face that reality.

SPEAKER_01Right. So I think that's like a huge that's just one of many patterns that I see in myself

SPEAKER_00as like a lifelong Just Pattern That I Have To Be Aware Of In Myself And Continuously Offer To Christ And Continue To Seek Modes Of Healing That Help Me With That But I Also See It In In Other People Who Have Been Through Similar Experiences Well It's Holy Week And

SPEAKER_01We're Heading Into This Will Come Out Probably After Pascha So I I just want to say your book is it's like a companion to sort of the the pattern of going into the grave and then coming back out the pattern of death and resurrection it's a really good it's a really good book and it's really kind in the way that it it treats like honest curiosity both inside the church and outside

SPEAKER_01people are invited in both ways I really like it what else what are you working on like you got a Substack where I just saw an article you wrote about divorce well it wasn't you just wrote it it was actually a while ago but what are you working on yeah it was a while ago but it popped on because I started researching I actually tried to prepare Nicole I should get a pat on the back for that I'm trying you know not everyone who interviews on podcasts does that

SPEAKER_00so I appreciate that Well I had to because one is is I have heard so much about the book and then also when when this comes out then I'm going to be in a house with people who are going to be mad at me if I didn't pay attention carefully they love you so so let me ask

SPEAKER_01you this question one of the I mean I'm amazed by the traumas that pop out both in the news and in people's lives as I get to know them I'm older now and I'm married for a long time but the amount of people that are really in pain within their marriages both non-orthodox and orthodox it's pretty wild like I don't really know a worse pain than that when I meet my friends I mean people lose limbs and it's bad but wow Wow, that's like high trauma, a bad marriage.

SPEAKER_01What do you say to that kind of trauma? And how do you respond to that pain as a counselor, but also as someone who went through it? I mean, I'm a coach, not a counselor, but I'll just say that for legal reasons.

SPEAKER_00Forgive me. It's okay.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, they're all getting meld together.

SPEAKER_00No, I don't expect you to know. I just want to be clear that I do not claim myself to be a counselor. But yeah, the, you know, experiences of a destructive marriage is really hard. The loss that comes along with that, the loss of a involved with divorce it's a death and there's different kinds of losses I would say it's what's called an ambiguous loss meaning we don't

really have a strong social script in how we grieve things like a lost marriage and in orthodoxy like we

SPEAKER_00don't we don't have a really vibrant theological imagination for how to come alongside people and not just like we allow divorce in many circumstances but beyond that it's like how do we then help people live again how do we help people integrate that with what they know to be true of God and Christ I don't know that there's anything specific I say to people except I when I

encounter people who like

SPEAKER_00me have been through divorce I listen to what Whatever it is they want to share and what wisdom have they gained from those steps? What have they learned about themselves through that experience? What's still painful for them? What's still hard? What's getting easier? And just be alongside people for that loss. There's no there's no advice. There's no five point

SPEAKER_00Plan to get your life back together. It's a whole process. And I, you know, I'm remarried now, very gratefully so. And, and I still, I still have days where I feel that loss, and I'm still working through stuff, because it is a death. And it's a death. Yeah, it's a, it's a death. And in some ways, it's a, it's a, I don't want to say it's harder than if a person actually dies. But at least when a person actually dies,

there's like a funeral and people cry with you.

SPEAKER_00And when you get divorced, you lose friends. I mean, you learn who your friends are, let's put it that way. But there's not like people judge you instead of grieving with you.

SPEAKER_01People assume things. People, like in my case, I was the one who left and people assume that means I'm to blame.

SPEAKER_00or whatever. They come up with all these ideas. They have no idea. They have no idea what in every divorce is this way. You have no idea what led to that. Healthy people in a healthy marriage don't leave for the heck of it. And that's the truth. So if someone left, there's a bigger story. There's a bigger problem than the fact that they left the marriage.

yeah especially if especially if which I think is the case your case but it doesn't matter just as a general rule if both people are really trying to apply something like faith in in Christ and they're really trying to do it or let me put it differently they're at least aware of the context you know and there's still a divorce and someone's counseling it you know there's a priest saying yeah this seems like I mean this should be it should be rare obviously but the point is is

Man how can you judge that clearly there's a lot there when both sides are trying or at least appear to be trying and they still need to get a divorce at that point

SPEAKER_01yeah it's a death it's a death and you just to judge all that I've always said the biggest mystery is in the Trinity and also in any given marriage try to figure out a marriage like a marriage counselor whoever those people are good luck that is that is a real the two priests out there trying to do that good strength because that is not an easy concept it's a very hard idea to try to understand such a spiritual union is well you know

I never so the reason I started writing about divorce on my blog is because I had written another a different article which I don't want which I don't want to get into but it was about something a very public priest had said about women that I felt was was very not helpful a helpful thing to say and so I wrote an article

SPEAKER_00about that I wasn't I basically just wrote an article advocating that we treat women like human beings and maybe not endorse priests who talk about them as sex objects on public platforms. So I wrote an article that should not have been controversial that blew up as things do on the internet.

SPEAKER_00And from there, had all sorts of trolls posting public records and stuff about me and my divorce and you know I hadn't kept that a secret but they just chose that opportunity to be like oh she's divorced and she calls herself orthodox and she calls herself Christian and then people commenting things like no one should ever leave a marriage and maybe she should have tried

seeing a marriage counselor and maybe she should have tried this I would never I

SPEAKER_00would work through it with a counselor and first of all again it's really interesting that we think we know so much about people that we've never met but second of all when you meet people who have experienced divorce maybe they've done all those things and a whole lot more Like maybe Of course The divorce was the absolute best they could do And And maybe

Like I'm grateful that some people don't get it Because it means They haven't had to experience that pain Because it's awful And I truly wouldn't wish it On anybody So We can't make assumptions We just can't No No It's a messy And difficult type of trauma and that's all you need to know i mean when empathy kicks in really in the end if we can just see other people and just know that

they're suffering like us at some point you can kind of make sense of it all as christ has and then you you don't you don't have to get it all right for other people you should

SPEAKER_01probably try harder to get it right for yourself I mean I don't know these things seem obvious to me but again you're right this fear of the internet and politics and then overlaying spiritual it's a really dangerous thing because people can always judge my hypocrisy like because I am a hypocrite so you can go for it guys yeah you'll get it you'll you'll nail me I lost I get it already you got me go go find my public records you won but

when you can when you can own that for yourself there's nothing anyone can say to throw you off the rails that's right you know and like when this was happening to me it's yes it's it's distressing on one level and on the other level I didn't it didn't really throw me for a loop because I'm like what if you've read any of my work right I never put myself out there as a perfect person like if anything maybe

SPEAKER_00I'm too hard on myself Sometimes, you know, like you can't say anything about me that I haven't already recognized about myself.

SPEAKER_01I've got people in my life, including my dear brother. He went through the same thing, maybe in a different political context. Let's call it that. But it's the same. It's like, unquote, the left or the right. It's the same. Like, Put on your belt Get ready People are coming at you But in the end It's only because I have this weird technology That even allows me to be present In your life right now Without that I would just be judging my neighbor Like literally right next door So we should stop Whether it's online or wherever

However There's this difficult thing Let's stop here I'll ask you one question There is There is a

SPEAKER_01demand on us though To express the truth At Least To Try Which You Do Very Well In The Book And I Think In The End When We Try And It's A Humble Attempt We're Still Going To Get Arrows But I Do Like People That Try I really I like that I like I like you talking about divorce right now it's a hard thing most people just want to drive around it I don't want to talk about that but I like that you're trying and I really commend people who try to tell the truth lovingly and I think it's actually changing people the internet

can be good that way I do I think so well we are we all need the opportunity right like to write people off as well they're just I disagree with them and therefore like they're

SPEAKER_00never going to change That's as dehumanizing as trolls coming out of the woodwork and saying crap about people. That's not true, right? So that's part of treating one another as human beings is at least offering one another the dignity and opportunity of making a choice.

SPEAKER_01That's great. That's great. Hard to do it's hard to do when they're you know when people say things that are hurtful or whatever but we can try with God's help well okay so um blessed feast to you because I think this will come out after pasca yeah um uh blessed rest of holy week and um thank you for your work Tell people where they can find you and and if you know what

you're working on if you want us to know any of that that'd be cool Absolutely so probably the places I'm most active at the moment on Substack and on my podcast my Substack is just

SPEAKER_00whatever Nicole Rokas onSubstack yeah and I there I just I write about life and sometimes about my coaching work, but mostly just about experiences in my life and trying to integrate them with faith. I also co-host a podcast with my dear friend Eleni Aprawal, who's a registered therapist in our area. We live in the same town and it's called The Recreation Podcast

and it's about

SPEAKER_00being human in a broken world. So we explore conversations around trauma and healing from an ancient Christian perspective trying to integrate what we do as professionals with what we believe as Orthodox Christians but doing it in a way that again all people feel welcome to listen in we're working on a book currently that is an Orthodox theology of trauma so the

podcast is sort of our effort to wrestle through thoughts and stuff that we're

SPEAKER_00trying to I get that to work through in order to write this book together. So that's called the recreation podcast. And then my website about my coaching work is just Nicole Rokas.com.

SPEAKER_01All right, sister. But the book that I love that I know well is Time and Despondency and people should find it. And thanks for coming on our podcast and helping us do our thing here. Peace to you.

SPEAKER_00Thank you so much for having me. It's been a pleasure.

SPEAKER_01Well, again, you know, we got three kinds of pods on here. We kind of do these nine-minute riffs. I want you to listen to them. I don't know that I have any bona fides for them other than this experience of being older and lived overseas and speak like four languages and lived in a certain way and teach a certain way and do a certain thing that leads me to believe that sometimes we forget who we are in America. That conversation helped us to remember, by the way.

SPEAKER_01That pod, the riff, is just sort of, it's a hope and a joy that I could do a nine-minute stand-up of some sort that also enlightens folks. The second kind of pod we have is what I call the Watar pod, the old pod. It's kind of a breakdown. Sometimes it's in parts. It's longer. It's historical. And it sort of takes you and makes you go, hmm, never thought of it like that. That's my hope. and then the third part is we have his interviews where the

star is hopefully not

SPEAKER_01me and you should be commenting that dude shut up anyway Nicole helped me understand some things but also It's just so fascinating watching people deal with this divide between what is psychology and what is orthodox psychotherapy. In other words, what is the spiritual life? How do they go together? It's just I love people that wrestle with that. So keep supporting us. First Things Foundation, we can use you to become something like a monthly donor.

SPEAKER_01I also have a ton of stuff these days that we're trying to do, which includes we're running a First Things Foundation field school. What do you do for six You learn the local language but what you really do is you take a deep dive into the culture and you do a program that is consistent or a project that is consistent with the First Things Foundation ethos which is consistent really with the Christian ethos of assistance which is consistent really with crucifying yourself someone just went wait I gotta crucify myself Look man you gotta crucify your desires if you can actually do

a good project with anybody anywhere where you're a guest you have to die to your desires to make them in your image yeah you do we also have the restaurant which is about to get a little bigger that restaurant could use a refrigerator and a broiler and all kinds of stuff if you're into really donating and watching things grow this is the best

SPEAKER_01way to do it hit me up We have a lot of other stuff going on. If you'd like to do a Supra, Super Dinner Society and First Things, we'll help you. If you'd like to become a Tomada, get ready. We are going to collect you. We're collecting Tomadas from all around the world because we have, we've got big plans. Do we though? I just want to get through today. Even, I don't even, maybe tomorrow morning? I don't know, a giant Mets losing streak? I gotta go guys.

SPEAKER_01Who loves you? God is good little by little.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Demons, Deception, and Why Your Spiritual Practices Might Be Dangerous

    Oct 2, 20261 hr 18 minAudio

    Find this episode on YouTube: "Justine Alter" - a pseudonym - returns to chat with John Heers in a raw Heavy Things Lightly conversation you have to hear to believe.Justine worked for years as a professional psychic,...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. The Fox News Reporter Who Quit to Live an Orthodox Homesteading Life

    Sep 25, 20261 hr 35 minAudio

    Find this episode on YouTube: Holly Hickman went from Columbia Journalism and Fox News Radio covering NASA and the 2008 election - to milking cows, making cheese, and converting to Orthodoxy.In this episode of Heavy...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Why They Left NASA to Start St. George's Classical Academy

    Sep 21, 20261 hr 2 minAudio

    Can you teach kids the truth AND prepare them for a secular world?On this episode of Heavy Things Lightly, host John Heers talks with James and Juliana Joyce, founders of St. George's Classical Academy in Boxford,...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. An Odyssean Tale: The Man Who Would Not Quit

    Sep 4, 20261 hr 37 minAudio

    Find this episode on YouTube: Crow walked America searching for his father - and found the Father.From West Virginia hollers to LA gangs, from wolves in the Mojave desert to an Orthodox cross, this is an Odyssean tale...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. From Broadway to the Supra: Carrie Manolakos on Life After Lockdown

    Sep 1, 20261 hr 51 minAudio

    Welcome to the first episode of “Save Me a Spot at the Supra” on Heavy Things Lightly where John Heers hosts singer and Broadway performer Carrie Manolakos (best known for her performances in Mama Mia! and Wicked) at...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode