Find this episode on YouTube: https://youtu.be/RGfvsPHGBlU Gregg Hurwitz, New York Times best-selling author of the Orphan X series, joins John to talk about writing, our changing new world view, and the terrifying new tools taking over our lives. Discover more about Gregg here: https://gregghurwitz.net/ Visit us at https://first-things.org/ 2 years. Deep cultural immersion. Intense personal discovery. See what it means to become a Field Worker with FTF: https://first-things.org/opportunities or email Daniel at danielpadrnos@first-things.org for more information. Like the podcast? Join us for more on Substack: https://johnheersftf.substack.com/ Telegram: https://t.me/firstthingsfoundation And you should definitely check out Keipi Restaurant 👉 https://keipirestaurant.org Please leave a review with your comments! Your support keeps this podcast alive and allows us to broaden our discussion. --- This “Enlightened” New World utopia isn’t turning out to be all it was cracked up to be. Society is disenchanting, but are the only alternatives hiding out in the hills or burying yourself in books? With an air of levity and a touch of humor, John Heers teaches how to examine the confusing New World by calling upon the mind and wisdom of oft-forgotten Old. Heavy Things, Lightly. --- Credits Music: Intro / Outro Provided by Greg Gilbertson & Band This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit johnheersftf.substack.com/subscribe
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_00It is heavy things lightly. It's John. It's First Things. And today, New York Times, literally number one bestselling author, Greg Hurwitz. He's written like 24 books in the Orphan X series, which first of all, we talk about how do you even do that? He was preternatural. He was a writer from the beginning. And he talks about the notion of art, the technocratic mind. gorging, like eating too many pheasants. That's a thing as a metaphor about society.
SPEAKER_00We get into democracy and being a Democrat. That's interesting. Greg Hurwitz recently just did the gospel series, the New Testament series with Jonathan Peugeot. Jordan Peterson, a whole bunch of folks. This was a great talk. I'm glad to have been able to talk with Greg. And I'm glad to be able to invite you to the Art of Tomada. That's our First Things Foundation fundraiser. There's two of them this year in July, 7, 8, 9, 10 at Leavenworth Sleeping Lady Resort. Guys, come on. Like, the only reason you go is because you don't have the money, and then you should still call me.
SPEAKER_00I'll probably find a way to give you the money. I feel like everyone should go, but then it wouldn't be a fundraiser. It would be a fundrainer. Okay, whatever. There's also one in Isla Morada. That's right, Isla Morada in Florida, in the Keys, like we did last year. That's Jordan Hall speaking there, and a guest speaker yet to be known. Out in Washington, it's Vesper Stamper and Richard Rowland. He of... universal history guys come we need your assistance and support but you kind of
SPEAKER_00need a good weekend don't even lie chilling chilling with the brothers and sisters this is heavy things lightly or talk with greg hurwitz peace out guys it's uh it's greg greg hurwitz am i saying that right i don't want to sound like an idiot no you
SPEAKER_01got it you got it right yeah
SPEAKER_00So you're on this thing, heavy, heavy things lightly. And people are going to know you when you pop on from your great conversations with Jonathan, who a lot of people, we have a lot of crossover there, um, As we were talking about off air, I hosted the Symbolic World, tried to make it a little lighter. They did the heavy stuff. I tried to do the light stuff. I did some stand-up. And now I've been able to run into you. So I'm an author in my own right, and I love writers. I love, love, love how you guys think.
SPEAKER_00So just how did it happen that you started to write? What's that about?
SPEAKER_02It's so funny. I've been thinking about this again. I had an amazing conversation with Pajot, who now and then will just say something that's stupendous more often than once in a while around symbolism. I said, where do you get that, man? And he's like, I just get these gifts. There's these gifts from God where he'll see something in the symbology and it just comes to him. It's very interesting. So I started to think about that in terms of my writing. You know, the only thing I ever wanted to do is write. I mean, I think in stories when people say, where do you get your ideas?
SPEAKER_02I always go, I don't know. Where do you get your ideas? It's just the way I think. And more and more, I've been thinking about it. Like if I'm writing the next day, if I'm this morning, I get these like gifts. It's like, It's dialogue. It's scenes. It's the whole way my brain worked. You know, I used to go to bed and sleep with a dictionary when I was in third, fourth grade. I wrote my first short story, Mysteries, when I was in fifth grade. I illustrated them with crayons. Started my first novel. I was 19. I was an undergrad. I was young and dumb enough still to just think if you wrote a good book, it could get published.
SPEAKER_02The arrogance of youth. I had a ton of luck early. I sold it basically right out of college. I did a kind of stall year at grad school. I won a fellowship to go study Shakespearean tragedy because I figured that's the most useful degree. If I needed a backup career, they'd come kicking down my door to hire, you know, somebody with a master's in Shakespearean tragedy. If my, if my novelist career didn't work out, I mean, but I was just, I was on the scene. It's all I ever wanted to do. And I had luck early and I've been writing full time pretty much my whole life. it's just been an unbelievable blessing um with a lot of luck around along the way
SPEAKER_02i don't deny that hard work plays a role but you you know very well you need doors to open you need people to open those doors and i've just been very fortunate so i've had you know 24 novels out now i wrote comics i wrote batman wolverine i've had a couple movies made some tv um And it's just been great. It's been a wonderful ride.
SPEAKER_00You let me right into a question I wanted to ask you. How long... Guys, Orphan X, that's your longest series, right?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, the ninth one just came out.
SPEAKER_00So how long can a writer stay in one series before you can't go any longer?
SPEAKER_02I'll tell you, I just did a panel. Yesterday was the LA Times Festival of Books. We just did a panel on this topic. You know, there's some people, John Sanford's getting better and better. Like some people, the series starts to fade. Part of what's very different with the Orphan X series, and I think your readers in particular are going to notice, there's a lot of... thematic and character, character, logical shifts that are happening that are markedly different than what happens in most series.
SPEAKER_02And so look, the, the, the premise is, is relatively simple. Young kid taken out of a foster home at the age of 12, he's trained offline to be an assassin and, to go where the U.S. government can't go, to kill people in violation of international law. And if he's ever caught or tortured to pieces, no one cares and he doesn't know enough to be in trouble. And so one of the big revelations that I had when I was sort of terrified to start the series and I kept putting it off and putting it off and writing another book first was what if his handler and father figure actually loved him,
SPEAKER_02just loved this kid. And he takes him out of this broke-ass foster home in East Baltimore, trains him in, you know, mixed martial arts, drown-proofing, psy-ops, you know, foreign etiquette, language, military history. He turns him into kind of a blue-collar Renaissance man. Or I use the quote from the OSS that predated the CIA. You know, they said their ideal recruit is a PhD who could win a bar fight. So he's educated, but it's grounded. And one of the things his father figure tells him is the hard part's not making you a killer.
SPEAKER_02The hard part is keeping you human. And it's a series about somebody who is discovering what it means to be human. I think of it in some ways, looking back, that at the opening of Orphan X, it's almost like he realizes he's this archetypal thriller hero. He's Pinocchio, but he wants to be a real boy. And as he learns his humanity, as he starts to learn how to speak, which he was never taught, I say he's learning to speak the strange language of intimacy. As he becomes more human, he sees those around him as more human.
SPEAKER_02And then his targets. So he's left the program now and he has an encrypted 1-855-to-nowhere phone number, which you can call and someone answers. in the real world. And he helps people who are in desperate need with no return.
SPEAKER_00That's very cool.
SPEAKER_02But as the series progresses, as he gets more human, the type of book changes quite drastically. It becomes much more about morality. There's a lot of spiritual themes that start to run through it. And so for me with the series, I'm more excited to having this ninth book come out and the 10th book I'm working on than I was writing books two and three. It's been unbelievable to write a series where the main character is transforming and then he transforms the characters and world around him. And then I'm writing a completely different kind of thriller.
SPEAKER_00So one of the things... Like Paggio, I'm an Orthodox guy. There's this idea that you progress through something like purification, illumination, theosis. And it's a pattern that we adhere to. And theosis looks like becoming like God. Now, not God, but becoming like God. Or it's a total awakening. And it's a union. And I wonder if the asceticism of writing, do you think what's happening to your character
SPEAKER_00Because of your writing, is something like being mirrored in you? Are you growing in the same way that this character is starting to be like, well, I'm waking up to the idea of intimacy and to being a real human. Is it happening to you?
SPEAKER_02There's no question. I think it always is in the arts. I think it always was, but I never knew till after. I'd write a whole book and look back at it two months after I was done and go, oh, that was about my terror of the vulnerability to becoming a parent. What's happened with Orphan X that's wild, John, that I'm barely, I feel like I'm holding onto a ball I can barely keep hold of is I know what's happening as I'm writing it. I'm working. Joan Didion has a great quotation. She says, I write so I know what I think.
SPEAKER_02And it's like I've caught up to it where the things I'm contending with, my intrusions or excavations or interventions in the political and cultural world are starting to mirror what I'm working on. Everything becomes fractal, which you orthodox types know better than anybody. Yeah, we love that stuff. It's what's going on. What I'm dealing with with my wife and my daughter and communication is what I'm working on in the books. The realizations I'm figuring out about the political landscape is opening up what the ethical dilemmas are in the books.
SPEAKER_02I'm writing about these themes about, you know, conscience versus like AI, digital drone warfare, you know, algorithmic conscience. Like all the themes that are starting to take place are around suffering and meaning. It's unbelievable. I started the first Orphan X book when I was on the cusp of 40, and I don't think it's any coincidence. I think I was right at the point of letting go of the set of rules, the story that had governed what I hope is the first half of my life, if I don't get hit by a falling Acme safe or baby grand piano.
SPEAKER_02And, you know, and, and how do I reconstitute a new set of rules? Well, that's what Evan smoke is doing. My character orphan X, he's, he has the 10 commandments. He was given the 10 assassins commandments. And it's not a coincidence that I call them the commandments. And the first book, he breaks every single one of them. And he's trying to shatter into a new understanding of how to exist in the world. And it's precisely what I was doing in my forties. And we're like in lockstep. I'm writing stuff that I'm figuring out from him and, right i'm researching things that are giving me awareness to put into the writing
SPEAKER_02he's stuff's happening on the page and i don't mean to talk preciously or mystically about like beckoning the views but it's a very weird process of expansion for me and you know the themes the sixth book is called prodigal son um there's a lot of um um spiritual, you know, examining different methods of meaning making. And then I have these extraordinary situations. Like I went off and did the Exodus seminar for Daily Wire with,
SPEAKER_02you know, some pretty spectacular religious thinkers. You know, I'm from a different sort of background, though I'm wide open with enormous respect for religious communities as a result of how much they've given me in my life. And that changed a lot of the ways I was in the world.
SPEAKER_00You're being called to some awakening, bro. You're being called in the same way we're all being called every day. I think writing is a type of way in to an awakening. But I hear it in your words, like, what's happening? I feel like a lot of people on the internet are like, what's happening? So the internet's doing two things. It's asking really hard questions of how we use our time, but it's also allowing us to meet things we would never meet without it.
SPEAKER_00And it's forming, I think it's allowing us to have a kind of, kind of a renaissance of of we'll say religion i don't really like that word but a renaissance of the spiritual spirituality yeah i mean yeah i think one of the
SPEAKER_02things that's happening is you is we're seeing more and more the secular i'm just going to call it the symbolic world meaning spiritual religious mythological storytelling world to just throw a net over all of it There's a total unhooking of the secular world and the symbolic world. And I think that part of that is we're just in thrall to these unconscious projections everywhere right now, because the two parts aren't talking to each other and the changes that are coming. With artificial intelligence, with the role that social media is playing in our lives,
SPEAKER_02the way that our phones are eating our brains, the way that we're subject to deep machine algorithmic learning, the surges of ideology, the purely secular brain is not equipped to contend with the complex change before us. It's just simply not. We can't just go in and order all the facts in the right way. And it's one of the key themes in Exodus, And Dennis Prager said this quite beautifully. It's about the law wrapped in the sacred. If it's not wrapped in the sacred, what you have is what we're seeing.
SPEAKER_02It's like overgrown human resource departments setting endless complex rules that no one can ever catch up with. There has to be some parameter which contains and beckons and is in conversation with what the law is. And that's a hierarchy of values. It's subsidiary value sets. You know, no one talks about that. I'm sure you could talk about that much more eloquently than I can as Orthodox. You know, part of my friendship with Jonathan has really opened up. I mentioned to you briefly before the call,
SPEAKER_02I was sent, I'm from a secular Jewish longtime atheist background, though I myself am not an atheist and have not been for some time. But my parents sent me to a Jesuit high school. And the Jesuits, man, they can educate. And the first thing they did was say, you know, first year we're sitting down, you're reading the Old Testament. You won't understand anything in the culture. Old Testament, first year, New Testament, second year, Christian morality, third year. And by the way, here's the arts and here's literature and here's Dostoevsky and here's Dante.
SPEAKER_02And it was just extraordinary. And so for me, with the openness that I have, the gifts that I've been shown, you know, through different communities in the Christian world are just unbelievable. And there's something in orthodoxy that I'm very drawn to. I mean, I have a lot of close friends who are evangelical and that kind of beaming goodwill. from evangelicals is something that's so wonderful.
SPEAKER_00But with Orthodox... I like that characterization.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, it's like, you know, Oz Guinness was in the accident. He just like beams evangelical goodwill. He's just this like shining soul, right?
SPEAKER_00When you meet him.
SPEAKER_02But with Orthodoxy, there's such amazing like complexity and nuance and There's a, there's a darkness that's balanced. It's just, it's been, it's been incredible, you know, having so much overlap with Jonathan in so many ways.
SPEAKER_00But your writing, your writing's rich like that. So, and, but thank you. And it's, and it's attractive. You know what I mean? In the sense that I think my phone just went off. No, stop it. My phone is talking to me. By the way, that's my question. Or it's listening to you. Or it's listening to me. Yeah. That's my question I want to ask right now. But, well, let me ask it. You talked about your character, Evan Smoke.
SPEAKER_00So, man, I had this idea as you were saying this. It sounds like someone got a hold of him. We'll say they had murder on their mind or they had, you know, this... the CIA, or they had the notion that I'm going to create something that's necessary for us. And then the character, Evan Smoak, wakes up to his humanity. Here's what I think. I think right now, algorithms... in the internet or whatever you want to call this worldview,
SPEAKER_00this technocratic worldview, is akin to that institutionalization of these young men who then have to wake up to a humanity. The algorithms are terrifying to me. They're the thing that is putting It's making our young men and women, too, something like tools of something else. And I wonder what you think about that.
SPEAKER_02It's descendants of Tubal Cain building the Tower of Babel.
SPEAKER_00That's right. That's interesting, man. And so what do we do? How does your character get loose in the end? And I wonder, you don't have to give it away, but I wonder how young people get loose. Do they have to put the phone down?
SPEAKER_01Oh, sorry.
SPEAKER_00No, go ahead.
SPEAKER_02Well, one of his code names is the Nowhere Man. He's got no imprint. He's got no digital footprint. And so part of it is that he's not plugged into... Right now, part of what we're seeing is people, especially young people, are so overpowered online that it's just staggering. You have people, these kids, young boys, girls, they don't even have fully grown in prefrontal cortexes yet. The prefrontal cortex isn't even myelinated. They're up against corporations employing teams of addiction specialists backed by deep machine algorithmic
SPEAKER_02learning to target them for maximum stickiness on an app. So is that outrage, insecurity, longing, lust? We're units. We've turned our kids into these sort of consumer units. They're a future voting block. They're a buying block. I have a friend who said, anytime you're online and you feel something, someone's making money. And I think the solution very much is twofold. I mean, one is in ritual that is not online. I mean, part of it can be online. it's ritual, which you guys know something about.
SPEAKER_02And the other thing is relational, the local and relational. And then we need to do with technology is technology is great. I mean, AI can be wonderful. It's got to be in its proper place. It's got to be like to use a Fantasia reference. We want to be sorcerer Mickey. We don't want to be the eyeless mops hauling buckets of water around. Like we need to be in charge of technology, not vice versa. And the tools are so powerful that it's subverting it. And, Look, that subversion we're seeing everywhere. I mean, I'm increasingly convinced that that,
SPEAKER_02you know, look, it's hardly a unique observation to say that like roaring leftist ideology is a religion. These things have to go somewhere. If you don't understand a notion of original sin, let's say original sin. What's great with original sin is it. And one thing I love so much about Christianity is that. there's sort of a twofold process to keep you from just getting swallowed up by unconscious projection. One is original sin. You're never going to be perfect, no matter what.
SPEAKER_02Sorry. No one ever has been in the history of the world. And two, somebody else died for the sins that you yourself committed. are necessarily going to come at. And that notion that you're striving after something that is a perfect ideal that you can never reach, you have to submit to something that you could never reach, but that you should nonetheless aspire for is what keeps you out of anxiety, depression, OCD, looping, shame.
SPEAKER_00You are speaking it right now.
SPEAKER_02And Well, and I think that in some ways, if you ignore those things, they just shove underground and then they pop out in all these weird ways where it's like, well, original sin, let's say mommy, mother nature's mad at us. Like nature's higher than man. Now we're going to worship the gods of nature instead. And so that means that, you know, we can't use straws because they'll choke a turtle and we can't do this and everything's broken down all these ways that are. And look, I'm all for stewardship, responsible stewardship of the environment. But again, it's like if only we had a template for how that was,
SPEAKER_02for how we need to name nature and interact with it. But for me, it's all about when these values get out of control and they float up. It's like Douglas Murray said at one point in a speech about man and nature and kind of global out of control globalism. He said, man isn't the problem. We're the point. And so it's like, can we take steps to steward our environment better? Of course. Should we be worshiping nature and then not having kids and discouraging people in this way that's very anti-life?
SPEAKER_02And so I think that the principles that are intact in, let's call it for now, a Hellenic Jewish Judeo-Christian ethic that undergirds the Western world have the templates for us not to just continuously spin after some ideal that we're supposed to be nonstop perfect and then we're shoving these projections into other aspects of the world whether it's towers of babel that we're building technologically or elevating nature to some place where it's the furious devouring mother and we can't kind of keep control of it we need a language that is a symbolic narrative based language
SPEAKER_02and as we return to these foundational stories Guess what? There's some pretty good ones we have at hand within the culture of the West.
SPEAKER_00Let me ask you a hard question on that. I don't know if it's hard. It might make us seem like weirdos. And this really challenges – you were talking to Jordan Peterson, and I know that you guys have a nice history together. But I – And he's interesting. I'm not saying you're the same person, but you had a chance to speak with him. And this conversation comes up all the time in my head as I live in this world that I live in at First Things and doing our work. So let me premise it with one thing.
SPEAKER_00We kind of do like Orthodox Christian Peace Corps. So we're around the world. And we send people for two years at a time. And they live in communities that don't tell as their origin narrative. They don't tell the evolutionary story. So we live and work in Sierra Leone and in Mozambique. The people there, I'm talking about the common people, they don't know themselves as the outcome of evolution. So their anthros, their anthropology is not naturally scientific or evolutionary.
SPEAKER_00The Georgians are the same way, Guatemalan, Mayan, the same way. And what I've noticed is I don't think we take seriously enough, you know, 150 years of telling a narrative about sludge as our mother. Like, I don't think we take seriously enough how powerful narrative is toward leading us toward truth and the stories we tell matter. And we keep telling a story. Jordan's the worst at it, in my opinion.
SPEAKER_00that we've... In other words, he cites evolutionary evidence constantly as ways to understand our being in the present. It drives me nuts because it could be that that evolutionary narrative is actually the thing that's killing us. So this isn't to say the world's 6,000 years old. I'm not saying that. But what do you think of the evolution narrative as a way to understand who we are? I think it's dangerous. What do you think?
SPEAKER_02You know, again... I think – look, I'm a huge proponent of a liberal arts education. I think it's the greatest American invention aside from jazz or bourbon. I think it's just extraordinary.
SPEAKER_00Right on for jazz. I love it. I like mezcal myself. It's my favorite.
SPEAKER_02Mezcal is pretty wonderful, especially with a little crushed worm salt and a slice of orange. Oh, I get it. You know, and so part of it is, again, for me, part of what a liberal arts education is – is that everything is held that we're occupying different spaces and disciplines, and most importantly, different ethics. So if I'm in a lab in college, I'm thinking like a scientist. If I'm in a history class, I'm thinking like a historian. If I'm in a theology class, I'm trying to think like a theologian.
SPEAKER_02And part of what we've had is this total deterioration of an ability to occupy different mindsets. And so one of the things that starts to change is if I say, oh, well, I'm Jewish. So I'm a Jew in a theology class. I'm a Jew in a science class. I have anxiety. My anxiety is primary in lab. And it's not to say that people don't have mental difficulties that they need help for but what should be a safe space is not a college classroom it's your time with your family or with your priest or your rabbi or your psychologist that's your safe space you should submit to different
SPEAKER_02forms of thinking I think the biggest problem we've gotten into is that the secular world to some extent has detached itself completely from theological thinking. If you look at Harvard, my alma mater, I went there when it was still vaguely something to be proud of, I like to think. I mean, now it's a disaster. But, you know, it started as a seminary. And one of the things that religion does that is unique in religion is that it puts everything in a culture in its proper place. It's a means, like Exodus is about how are things distributed horizontally across the tribes and
SPEAKER_02vertically up Mount Sinai? How are things, how do we establish something in a way that has meaning and carries us forward? Then within that, it's not a big threat if you're in science class thinking like a scientist and you're talking about the evolutionary process, which is quite captivating. But when that becomes everything and theology is denigrated, then it becomes very complicated. And so I do think that we have lost the ability in some ways theology or foundational thinking or what mythology was,
SPEAKER_02right? Or like for the Hellenists, it was their panoply of the gods or their – It was something that ordered and gave rise to then science and math and all these other forms. And I think what's happening is we've narrowed them out and we've given rise to the individual identity within each discipline that's more important than the discipline. Our lawyers don't act like lawyers. Our Supreme Court justices don't act like Supreme Court justices. Our students aren't acting like students where they're humble and learning from people of experts. Everyone's acting like them, that the personal partisan ideological pattern of their whole heart
SPEAKER_02should be reflected everywhere in the culture, in their party, in the political system, like 350 individuals. And there's not a shared story that exists under. And so I think that what's missing a lot is humility and knowing one's place. And a big part of me going to Exodus as somebody who's of and from, in some ways, the secular world, though I'm very open and I've had a lot of experiences that differentiate me from that and from my background, was also me knowing my place at that table,
SPEAKER_02which is like... what am i listening what am i here to learn what are the different viewpoints how do they integrate with mine where are the bridges how are we going to connect this how can we connect it in this time of polarization and where's the meaning that we can share to move forward it's not about being right or winning certainly not about elevating the idiosyncratic pattern of my own soul as being the fractal basis from which i want education and politics in the country in the global order to derive it's insanity
SPEAKER_00That's right. I wonder, the Enlightenment Project, which is not synonymous with science. I think science and the Enlightenment are not the same thing. Science is a method. And the Enlightenment, I think, is a very religious movement. I wonder if they saw what you just... described was this categorization sort of habituation where I do it naturally. I was taught to do it in school is to categorize in a way and imagine each category
SPEAKER_00has its own reality when it but we're an integrated Creature where nobody's ever just doing science. It's a weird concept, actually, to imagine that if I just perfect the doing of science, then somehow life will get better. I wonder, do you throw out like... I kind of tend to, the podcast focuses on old world and new world. The life, you know, before the enlightenment, life after the enlightenment, and how we've lost certain lessons that are fundamental to health.
SPEAKER_00That's kind of what we do on this podcast, back and forth. And I tend to, really for dramatic purposes, take science and atheism and enlightenment, the secular world, and kind of shit on it. to have a moment when I can introduce something from the old leeches as actually having a reason to be. This is why leeches on your sores make sense, even though that's like a common trope that we make fun of dumb people from the past.
SPEAKER_02I wonder- Yeah, you're talking about maggots in your Civil War gut wound.
SPEAKER_00Right, exactly. And everyone's like, they were so idiotic. And I'd like to suddenly say, you know, it wasn't so bad. It wasn't so crazy. It actually had its own place, its own sense. Oh, that was my grandson, I think. And it has a reason to be when you see the whole integrated human as something more than just a science being. So my question is this. How do we filter this out right now? Because I love your writing really takes on this age of technology.
SPEAKER_00Is there... How do we get back to sort of... sort of the simple lessons, proverbial things that, you know, used to make sense. Now they're sort of made fun as old fashioned. Is there a way?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, there is. Like, I've been thinking about this a lot. And, you know, you said you kind of, in a way, when it comes to atheism or secularism, there's an instinct to denigrate it just as being so short-sighted or modern or foolish. I think in some ways, when we talk about this, when we talk about like kids or this younger generation that's just lost, right? In some ways, our disgust or denigration or negative judgment, I think is a cover for our shame. I think we have allowed the world to fall in so many ways.
SPEAKER_02I mean, if you think about just pornography with boys, which is a scourge, right? It's a scourge that literally like boys don't even know how to interact or be intimate with girls anymore. Can you imagine when we were growing up, if somebody said, listen, you know, John's going to go to school. There's going to be porn in his desk. There's porn in his locker. It's in the bathroom. It's on the walk home. It's everywhere all the time with him whenever he wants it. And we're just helpless to do anything about it. We can't possibly control it. How could we do that? There's thing after thing after thing where I feel like the institutions that we're
SPEAKER_02all part of have abdicated their responsibility. And so one of the things that's been very hard for me, because I can, you know, I have a strong work ethic. I don't like, you know, it's easy for me to get denigrating about laziness or softness. It's much harder to look with empathy about there's a lot of younger people in the younger generation who are actually that sensitive. They're not just snowflakes faking it like we see. And we have seen that. And there's plenty of people, dark triad personality type,
SPEAKER_02which is narcissism, sadism, Machiavellianism and psychopathy. who are messing around at the edges. We know who they are. There's a lot of, there's a lot of people who are just lost. They're just lost.
SPEAKER_00Thank you for that.
SPEAKER_02And in some ways the lost, if we look at that with the responsibility to try and reach, and that involves trying to speak different languages and trying to be open and to try and carry meaning to them. I think it works a lot better than the sort of anger and outrage, which in a lot of ways comes more naturally in our frustration.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. We talk about sometimes on the show that A proper understanding of Christianity is as a hospital. And so when you see someone flailing about, it's not for you to identify necessarily the flailing, it's for you to see that they're suffering. And if you're able to see such a thing, most people just stop flailing in front of me, bro.
SPEAKER_00I remember riding, I'm from New York and riding the subway around. you get a lot of characters, and the first thing you're always trying to figure out is, is this character going to cause me a problem? Like, a proper disposition might be, is what does this person need for me in order to become something like more fully human? What a hard thing to do. And I think that's the way I've started. I taught for a long time. I see students as that now. I struggled in the classroom though. You know, I wanted them to be like, get it together, stop being such a snowflake.
SPEAKER_00But I start to see now that this actually, this generation has a possibility to do something really profound. And that is to actually wake up to to the reality of a broken America right now and maybe be salvific in some way as a generation. Maybe it could happen. It's a lot of forces working against it. You talk about them as a writer often. I mean, the whole idea of nowhere, man. And how relevant is that right now about people not knowing their purpose?
SPEAKER_00I see it all the time. I see a lot of people that come and join our organization. You know what they actually say in the interview? I think you'll appreciate this. Probably 70% of the people who want to come to First Things, you know what they say? I realize something's wrong, and I feel like if I'm dropped down in the middle. I mean, our guys live in mud huts and stuff. If I'm dropped there, everything will be exposed, and I won't be able to hide anymore. Like, that's a cry. That's a cry out.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, that's powerful.
SPEAKER_00It is. Now, they don't always make the best field workers because when they're out there, you can learn about yourself. that's fine but it's hot and you're getting malaria and all of those accompanying asceticisms and they're not as fun you know what i mean like you got to have sort of a military mission mentality to stick well if you stay here it's like you know
SPEAKER_02one of the things i've thought for a long time now is that luxury is just going to be the death of us i mean everything's so easy You know, it's like, oh, I want to collect stamps. I go on eBay and click two buttons. It's like there I have a world class stamp collection. Right. What next? Right. I need to go. I need to find a rare book. I used to drive around to try and find, you know, I did my undergrad work on Young. That's when I first met Jordan, who's my thesis advisor. I remember driving around looking for Ion in bookstores. It's like, go online, click, there it is.
SPEAKER_02Then I have more than I can read. It's like the obstacles are lowered and C.S. Lewis says something great in Screwtape Letters when he's giving advice to his nephew who's a demon trying to corrupt the man on earth. He has two lines that just stuck with me really well. The first thing he says, so his nephew demon who's kind of trying to corrupt this guy on earth, this guy's living with his older mom. And I think C.S. Lewis is a brilliant psychologist. It's part of what really helped connect me more deeply to understanding Christianity.
SPEAKER_02Young was my kind of path down from psychology, intellectualism to the spiritual. And then C.S. Lewis is a master psychologist kind of met there. And then I could follow him up a little bit. But he says, look, this guy who's living in a home with his older mom, he said, have him always concerned with the lofty ideal of the salvation of her soul and never with the state of her arthritis. Right? Like keep holier than thou. Like don't get in the dirt, you know?
SPEAKER_00That's right. Which is so great. I think that's what the meek are. The meek say, oh, I lost my foot. The donkey cart just ran it over. But... It may be for my salvation. I feel like when Christ is talking about the meek, that's what he's talking about.
SPEAKER_02Oh, to your previous point, he's got this other line where he says that the aim, the ultimate aim of the devil, of course, who's the great glorious one in Screwtape Letters, is to have us spend more and more time on vices that give us less and less pleasure. And that's great because, you know, C.S. Lewis is like, look, if you're going to drink and have a good time once in a while, drink and have a good time once in a while, right? If you have, you know, sensuality in an appropriate place in your marriage, go have that.
SPEAKER_02But if you think about pornography, if you think about addiction, if you think about alcohol, if you think about, you know, sitting on our bed, clicking through Apple TV with a trillion dollars of free content and nothing seems special anymore, it's like... We're gorging. We're gorging. It's like the pheasant is still stuck in our teeth from the last feast as we're dying.
SPEAKER_00Wow, that's brilliant. Yeah, my very first priest that I ever had used to say, this is when I was courting him, I was still single. And he would say, make sure when you're looking for a wife, he would tell all the guys. Yeah, okay. Does she believe? Is she pious? Is she fast? He goes, but pay attention carefully to how she feasts. How does one feast? How does one actually come to enjoy the party?
SPEAKER_00And if you see a proper feaster, you probably have a proper fast there. In other words, to understand the low trough, properly, you probably will do well at the high drop at the, at the high, at the high. Yeah.
SPEAKER_02Everything in its place. I mean, that's our recurrent leitmotif of this interview.
SPEAKER_00I know. I think you're right. We do keep coming back to that. Here's a question. And I, Well, I want to ask you this, and then will you take a little test of ours that we do? Can I tell you about it for two seconds? Sure. It's a five-question little test that I'll give you if you'll take it, and it just sort of says, are you an old world thinker or a new world thinker? I gave this to Paggio and all those cats at Symbolic World, so it's kind of fun. Maybe we'll finish with that.
SPEAKER_01All right.
SPEAKER_00Is that cool? But I want to ask you this. Sure. I feel like your novels have this undergirding of some deep, profound psychology. And I think you would agree with that. And the protagonist, there's something like a moment where I feel like it's almost like Peterson always talks about, just go make your bed. The habits will create the reality. Do you think the habits we develop can actually reshape reality?
SPEAKER_00We can have a bearing on what is real in the world by creating different habits?
SPEAKER_02I do, absolutely. I think we can even change the past with them.
SPEAKER_00Explain that. That's interesting.
SPEAKER_02Well, let's say you have an altercation based on one of your flaws with your kid. And, you know, let's say you drink too much or you have a temper or, I mean, fill in the blank, right? There's plenty of ways that people have friction in relationships. Well, if you keep doing it and disappointing them and they articulate it and you do it and you disappoint them and they articulate it, The story by the time you're dead and gone, if you've never made headway or worked on it is, oh, my dad drank too much. My dad had a temper. My dad never spent time with me.
SPEAKER_02But if you're aware and you're working towards connection with your kid, with someone who you love, And the conversation becomes quite different of like, wow, I can't believe I lost my cool again. I'm really sorry. I'm so glad you spoke up. If you can move towards into that and then heal that, especially, let's say, if it's a father to a daughter who's looking to date whoever she's going to date or have a template with, or let's say it's a son that you're too hard on.
SPEAKER_02If you can move through your own flaws and your own shortcomings and see them and illuminate them in your love for another human and you're wanting to change for them, then the story becomes very different, which is, gosh, I had a dad who was flawed like every other human on the planet and cared so much about me that moved towards me. And in walking me through that, I could also figure out my communication when I feel uncomfortable around other people, whether it's friends or potential spouse or whoever I date.
SPEAKER_02And so then we can kind of alter the past by shaping how we're moving in the future. And it's a beautiful opportunity.
SPEAKER_00How do you think you... Okay, so that's a theme you keep turning to in this talk. How did you acquire this worldview that involves deep humility? You seem to have a humility quotient. But you're this big time writer. First of all, how do you battle against not becoming the opposite of humble. But where did you get this from?
SPEAKER_02I think I had a pretty good run of not being humble, John. I think I had a pretty good case study. I mean, look, when I was younger, I only wish I knew as much about everything in the world as my senior year of high school through my junior year of college. I knew everything if you met me. There was nothing more for me to figure out. I had every answer to everything. And then I think part of it is Look, part of this is I've had a lot of interventions in the political and cultural world,
SPEAKER_02let's just say. In my heart, I'm a novelist. I think that's my first identity. And when you're a novelist, when you're writing characters, what I'm trying to do is pull on their face mask and see the world through their eye holes. I'm trying to occupy them in full. And the more that I do that, and I'm driven to that, I'm deeply curious, you know, before I did political excavations, I mean, I've been, had deep conversations all the way around the political wheel and all sorts of different stuff, but I've interviewed killers.
SPEAKER_02I've interviewed outlaw bikers. I've interviewed porn stars, professors. Like if you get on the list and I want to understand them so well, that it's the opposite of straw man or it's even different from steel man. I want to be able to articulate them and their worldview and meaning making even better maybe than they can. And once that's an aim, it's not just like, oh, here I am, I've learned something. And by articulated better than them, I don't mean occupy or embody it better than them. I mean, in a book format where I can make an argument that is compelling because my
SPEAKER_02understanding it and trying to connect readers to it, I do that with like hacking or some of the guns in the series. It's a thriller series. I talk to people who are way smarter than I am in a field, but my inner engagement with them helps me connect more people to it, let's say. that's right and so when you do that enough part of it is is it's hammering yourself out of shape and then you try and get back in shape but you accommodate and assimilate new information and doing that enough times i'm just aware like there's so much that i don't know that other people know and i love being out over
SPEAKER_02my skis and so like when we did this exodus seminar with the daily wire. I mean, everybody there is a, is, I mean, I, I was an expert in story in storytelling in a lot of regards. I think there's other things that I, you know, I think I can speak and keep up and process. Okay. There's a lot of psychology. There's a lot of things where I wasn't, you know, cowering to go into it, but I'm really with world-class experts in a topic where I'm out over my skis on, and that's my favorite place to be. And, you know, one of the lines Jordan says a lot is the fool precedes the master.
SPEAKER_02And it's like, once I've done enough of it, I'm just okay being a fool. Like, I'll come on and talk to you. I mean, you and Pajot know more about you know, orthodoxy and your pinky fingernail than I've been exposed to, but it's, it's just, it's captivating for me and I love to hear about it. And so I think it's, you know, that's part of what it is. I don't like teeing up and becoming a bigger and bigger fish in a smaller pond. I like being thrown into other situations that I have to catch up from people who
SPEAKER_02are much wiser than I am in particular arenas.
SPEAKER_00Maybe that's the writer's Maybe you're describing exactly the writer's job, which is to be the glue between the expert and the inquirer, because the reader is an inquirer. I mean, look, I want to go, you're going to make a movie, right? I think there's a movie deal for some of your books coming out. Is that right?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, a couple of them. And I'm just steering Orphan X in. And, you know, I've had a couple other movies made.
SPEAKER_00I mean, I've played in that space some. So I'm going to go watch a movie with me. I'm just talking about me. Or go read a book. In part because I'm inquiring about that world that the writer has created. And you couldn't be a writer if you actually were the expert. In some ways, if you think about it, even if you are the expert on whatever you're writing about, you still are translating in a way that an expert doesn't have to. I think about engineers. We hire a lot of engineers.
SPEAKER_00They're terrible at translating, which is I think what the writer is good at. They're really good at.
SPEAKER_02Well, it's mediation, it's negotiation. And more and more, I don't, I don't write since the very beginning of my career, I don't write heroes and villains. I write antagonists and protagonists. I want the antagonist to be like whispering darkly in your ear where you're like 49% convinced they might be right. I want my protagonist to stumble. I love that. Right? So I want to kind of build these things out. And so, I mean... I, there is a big part of, of trying to, trying to connect. And along the way, you know, I hope I can learn enough that I can be fluent in a lot of different sets of language,
SPEAKER_02but there's, it's, you know, it's, it is part of what I love. It's part of what I love doing.
SPEAKER_00Well, it's, it's good stuff. I want to, I want to place you in our world with this little quiz. If I feel like there's more to say, but I'm not, I'm going to try to keep it under an hour because it's, I don't know about you these days, I could keep talking. But maybe we can we can meet again. And well, just real quick, what's coming up next for you before I put you in this quiz, because I think you'll like this, it's gonna start a whole new conversation. What's coming up. So lone wolf is out right now, or it's not a lone wolf came out last month.
SPEAKER_02That's the ninth in the orphan x series. I really dive into a lot of the stuff we're talking about with technology and where the future goes. It's through the prism of a very personal thriller story. In some ways, it's my most personal book, but also deals with the furthest reaching issues we're contending with. So that's coming out. I have a couple film TV projects that are shaping up. That's always development. It's never really worth talking about until something's, I'm standing on set and it's day two of production.
SPEAKER_02I have a comic that came out a while ago called New Think that is sort of like my Black Mirror meets... The Twilight Zone. Pajot and I did a discussion with that on his podcast.
SPEAKER_00Oh yeah, he loved it.
SPEAKER_02He loved it. Yeah, that was a lot of fun. And we have the sequel to Exodus coming out that was the big project on the Daily Wire. And that'll be announced soon. That's also going to be out on the Daily Wire. I'm working on that. And I'm still continuing to do a lot of work on anti-polarization in the culture. I've shifted more from political engagement. I did a lot of work initially trying to wrangle and pull the Democrats back from the far left. And increasingly, I'm interested in interventions direct to the culture. I don't think we're going to elect a new slate of politicians who are going to save the day.
SPEAKER_02I think we need to invigorate and nourish people in the culture and move the culture so that everybody, politicians included, are looking to a direction of meaning that everyone can kind of tack towards.
SPEAKER_00Beautiful. I have a whole set of questions. That's what we'll do next time. But because I think you just nailed it. The body will give birth to the politicians that... we actually need, but the body's not able right now. I love it. We're working on anti-polarization, which makes a lot of sense. And I think these conversations in this part of the internet are part of that. I think they are.
SPEAKER_01I agree. I agree with you.
SPEAKER_00Let's figure out if you're old world or new world. This will take about five minutes. So the old world is that age before the Enlightenment, and the reason I know a lot about this is I feel like my work has placed me in those cultures. I lived in Mali where this was like 12th century life, and I loved it. It was hard, but I loved it. So sometimes people don't know how they think. So I think we've invented – and I'm joking here – A perfect MIT-tested scientific examination that will place you in a certain spot.
SPEAKER_00So here we go. Here's your test. I'm going to write down your scores. People who like our podcast always want to find out, like, what do you think that guy was? So here we go. Greg, five questions. You answer three as strongly agree, like full on. Zero is strongly disagree. Two is mostly agree. One is mostly disagree. Got it? Makes sense?
SPEAKER_01Yes, sir.
SPEAKER_00Here's the question. When you die, you won't really die all the way. It's more like you'll be asleep or something, waiting for some sort of next world. Three, strongly agree. Three. Oh, there it is. There's a three. Look at that. You came in strong on that, Greg. Very strong. Here's your next question. The best way for you to know yourself is to ask someone else about yourself.
SPEAKER_00The best way to know yourself is to ask someone else about yourself.
SPEAKER_02I'm neutral because it depends on who you ask.
SPEAKER_00So I'm one and a half.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. I think, I think there's a place for reflection and there's a place for input socially. So.
SPEAKER_00Got it. Got it. Now remember it's, we've studied this exam and it's perfect. Okay. So it's not an exam problem. It's probably a you problem, Greg.
SPEAKER_01I'm just trying to have, I'll add it to the list. Okay.
SPEAKER_00All right, number three. So when you carry a picture around, let's say, of someone that you love, there's a picture, it's in your wallet or wherever it is. It's in your pocket. You're actually carrying that person around with you. Like they're there, actually close to you in some way.
SPEAKER_01Strongly agree.
SPEAKER_00Oh, really? Interesting. That's where a lot of people get, they kind of come back. Let's see. Here's another one. Question four, two more. Respect isn't earned. Respect is owed by you to others. Respect isn't earned. It's owed by you to others.
SPEAKER_01These are so tricky, man. It's tricky because...
SPEAKER_00First of all, we love you because you're actually, look at, look guys, his brain is like, it's smoking. I love it.
SPEAKER_02I think it's owed. I think it's owed until it's proven otherwise. And if it's proven otherwise, then it needs to be earned.
SPEAKER_00Hmm. So something like a two? Mostly agree?
SPEAKER_02Mostly agree.
SPEAKER_00Last question. Trying not to give anything away because, you know, this will change your life forever. I told Jordan that this is, this is pretty, you can, psychology is over when you, when you, we, we fixed it. You don't have to have psychology anymore. Here's your fifth question. I hope and expect to take my parents in. So it's like, It's a mirror type question. So I hope and expect to take my parents in and have them live with me when they get old and infirm or flip it around. I fully expect to live near my kids, even preferably in their home when I get old and infirm.
SPEAKER_01Strong agree.
SPEAKER_00Three. All right. So here's your totals. Six, nine, ten, eleven, twelve and a half. So I'm going to tell you what this means. Are you ready?
SPEAKER_02Does it mean I'm never going to get invited back on this podcast?
SPEAKER_00No, not at all. I love it, though. So if you scored, which we did have someone score this recently on this show. I can't even explain who he is. He's a very interesting character. Malcolm is his name. I'm forgetting his last name. Anyway. Guys who watch this, they know. He scored a zero. If you scored a zero, which you did not, you'd be the Francis Bacon Award, which is old world thinking has the same appeal to you as placing leeches on an
SPEAKER_00open sore. You're such a light person. You're so enlightened in the scientific way that you enjoy concocting new ways to study the effects that scientific studies have on science students. So that's not you. You're not a high nooner. That would be two to four. That's something like everywhere you go, science just follows you around like a halo.
SPEAKER_01High nooner.
SPEAKER_00It's a high nooner. You're not the shining city dweller on the hill. That's someone that really trusts the modern world. Like they go to Reddit to figure out the right answers. It's people who would do what science told them to do. If everyone did that, then the world would be better off. You think Columbus was a jerk, but also you weirdly appreciate the new world philosophies he held. So you're not a suburbanite either. Check this out. You are a villager.
SPEAKER_00Here's now again, this will change your life. So I'm just glad you came here for this because I feel better. It's what we can offer on this show. There's a good chance, Greg, that you hate malls. Places like Algeria and Ethiopia roll out the red carpet for you. Your Spotify collection includes chants from hard to pronounce provinces. And you wish there was a little more hierarchy in the world. This is you. I feel good about offering this service to people when they come on the show.
SPEAKER_02I think you nailed it. I think that I no longer need to wrestle with God. I feel like it's complete. My journey, it's done. I'm enlightened.
SPEAKER_00It's over. Do you feel better? A lot of people are, like a lot of what will happen is, is you'll start calling me a lot just to talk more about this test. And I'll help you get through life. Your marriage is going to, everything gets better from here on out.
SPEAKER_01I'll take it.
SPEAKER_00I thank you for doing it. What happens is when some of our guests come on, we joke about it, my team and I. But they generally tend to – the numbers tend to fit sort of the psychology of the people. All right. Here's what I hope you'll do. I hope – you'll check out what we're doing, but mostly I hope you'll come back because these podcasts really help us. And there's something else that goes on is I'm able to figure out our place in the world.
SPEAKER_00And people like you are bending culture. with your books and your art. And it helps me to understand where our little organization needs to go. I really appreciate it. Very kind.
SPEAKER_01Well, it's really been, it's good talking to you. I really enjoy it.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, come to our restaurant. Our nonprofit opened a restaurant called KP Restaurant. It's a Georgian restaurant where we do the, it's called the Georgian Supra. It's a special dinner with a Tamada Toastmaster. I don't know if you've ever been to the Georgian Republic.
SPEAKER_01No, where is it?
SPEAKER_00It's in Greenville, South Carolina. man that sounds amazing yeah it's a it's a 16 toast the tamada leads you through these traditions we do it with the community on friday nights meaning if you and your wife came you would sit with 20 people you don't know and we all sit together and do these toasts i did them in georgia and learned how to do it and uh We have events during the year. We have two of them called the Art of Tamada, where we bring people for a weekend. We teach this unique dinner and share time together.
SPEAKER_00Paggio came last year. Well, he was on his way there. He had a little side emergency, but he was one of the folks we had, Neil DeGrade. And we all got together and we do it every year. I highly recommend that too. That sounds amazing. Thank you. Thank you, Greg. And we'll look for your work. And thanks for being, I don't know, thanks for being accessible in the deep ideas. It's really nice to talk to you. Likewise.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_00I appreciate it. Guys, www.first-things.org. We do something called... create momentum for the extreme poor. We do it in Africa, East and West, the Caucasus. We do it in Guatemala. We just put a new guy there named Matt. He's like 7 feet 11 inches tall. Well, he'll feel that tall to the Guatemalans in Momocenango who he's going to work with
SPEAKER_00because he's actually 6'7". He said 6'6". I think he's 6'7". He's my friend. He works for us now. He's in the field. More to go, more to come. I hope all of you can support us. Just do $20 a month. Okay, or $5 a month. Okay, or $200 a month. Or help us train Adrian, who's coming in to work as their executive field director because Daniel Paternos is leaving, but he's staying with First Things in a special capacity. Adrian's coming in.
SPEAKER_00We've got to train him. I've got to take him to site. Stuff costs money, and I hate it. Guys, we love you. Goodbye. Wasn't that a nice talk, though? I loved it. And hopefully Greg will come back and eat dinner with us. I think he is. In fact, we talked even after, and it's cool. Love you. Peace out. Great to have you here. Gagimarjos, and isn't it a lovely spring? Pascha has paschid. Christe agsta.
SPEAKER_00Christos vos kres. Christe aneste. Christos anesti. It is good to be alive. See you soon.
Find this episode on YouTube: "Justine Alter" - a pseudonym - returns to chat with John Heers in a raw Heavy Things Lightly conversation you have to hear to believe.Justine worked for years as a professional psychic,...
Find this episode on YouTube: Holly Hickman went from Columbia Journalism and Fox News Radio covering NASA and the 2008 election - to milking cows, making cheese, and converting to Orthodoxy.In this episode of Heavy...
Can you teach kids the truth AND prepare them for a secular world?On this episode of Heavy Things Lightly, host John Heers talks with James and Juliana Joyce, founders of St. George's Classical Academy in Boxford,...
Find this episode on YouTube: Crow walked America searching for his father - and found the Father.From West Virginia hollers to LA gangs, from wolves in the Mojave desert to an Orthodox cross, this is an Odyssean tale...
Welcome to the first episode of “Save Me a Spot at the Supra” on Heavy Things Lightly where John Heers hosts singer and Broadway performer Carrie Manolakos (best known for her performances in Mama Mia! and Wicked) at...