Find this episode on YouTube: https://youtu.be/3t4deihkPyk Perhaps no type of modern media has had the level of impact as movies. But from their inception until now so much has changed. Are movies redemptive? Can modern movies be redeemed? John talks to the Bazed Lit Analyzer to find out. More on Bazed Lit: @BAZEDLITANALYZER Visit us at https://first-things.org/ 2 years. Deep cultural immersion. Intense personal discovery. See what it means to become a Field Worker with FTF: https://first-things.org/opportunities or email Daniel at danielpadrnos@first-things.org for more information. Like the podcast? Join us for more on Substack: https://johnheersftf.substack.com/ Telegram: https://t.me/firstthingsfoundation And you should definitely check out Keipi Restaurant π https://keipirestaurant.org Please leave a review with your comments! Your support keeps this podcast alive and allows us to broaden our discussion. --- This βEnlightenedβ New World utopia isnβt turning out to be all it was cracked up to be. Society is disenchanting, but are the only alternatives hiding out in the hills or burying yourself in books? With an air of levity and a touch of humor, John Heers teaches how to examine the confusing New World by calling upon the mind and wisdom of oft-forgotten Old. Heavy Things, Lightly. --- Credits Music: Intro / Outro Provided by Greg Gilbertson & Band This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit johnheersftf.substack.com/subscribe
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_02Hello, it's Heavy Things Lightly. My friend Henley comes and talks with us, aka bathed lit analyzer, a movie savant. Talk about a brilliant person doing great things on the internet and with a unique understanding of art. I really like this conversation. We take the light meter test. We talk about Civil War, the movie. There's a couple of spoiler alerts. Be careful. We get into, well, his answer about his favorite, quote, religious movie of all times.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. You got to write a comment about that. I love it. Before we jump in, Art of Tamada Tickets. That's the First Things Foundation fundraiser. Got a couple more. I don't even know if they're still going to be there by the time this hits the interwebs. Maybe not, but it's still a couple more tickets available. Florida tickets still available because we really haven't even really fully put them on sale yet. But those are about halfway gone. Guys, I know it's expensive, but you give money to First Things when you come and you get a ton of cool stuff
SPEAKER_02fishing on the ocean. You get hiking in the mountains. You get live, beautiful jazz musicians and Georgian feasts and all kinds. Come on. That's enough. On heavy things, lightly, today. This is, I'm going to say Henley, but it's really Baze Lit because I've been watching your stuff. So you're a movie aficionado and a literature guy. So here's a question to start off just to let my people know who you are. Like, should we be even watching movies today? 2024? Come on, man.
SPEAKER_02Did they even make movies anymore that are worth watching?
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Um, I think that we should be watching movies. Um, it's kind of a, it's, that's an interesting question because both are true. Um, I think that we should be watching movies and we should be, we should be owning movies and owning physical media, but reading books more importantly, but yeah, we should be watching movies. They, do they make good movies anymore? Um, they're few and far between many of the movies that I've tried to do a deep analysis of recently are, are interesting because there's something synthetic about the movie.
SPEAKER_01That seems obvious to a lot of people, but the production of those movies, the writing, there's something synthetic and inhuman about movies recently. And I think that this is, there's a, that's a complex thing. There are a lot of things that go into that, but we need to watch movies because first of all, Film is the major propaganda influencer in the world. It continues to be. Even with the advent of the infinite scroll and TikTok and the internet,
SPEAKER_01movies are still the major thing. The infinite scroll. Yeah, the infinite scroll, the doom scrollers. We need to watch movies because they really proliferate. propaganda and they are revelatory and relevant and they and they are chock full of predictive programming so we need to watch them to be aware of things uh in the first place but also movies are still cinema is still a new art it's still it's still a you know burgeoning art form and we need to uh be exposed to things that
SPEAKER_01uplift us you know truth beauty and goodness are still they still happen in movies and they still are it's still capable of doing that So I think that it's important.
SPEAKER_02So you're... You really... Like, you know your stuff. Like, it's a deep, really nice deep dive when you do your live streams. I'm going to talk to you about Civil War in a minute. But how did you... How did you come to... Why? Why do you love movies? What happened to you coming up? Were you exposed to them? Were you a writer?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I'm a... Well, I am... I was raised in literature and books and I was blessed to, you know, have parents that read to me and I, you know, had a great education. I had a wonderful childhood. I had a great education. I have a, I have a graduate degree in literature and I've been all over the world and I've been reading and watching films since I was little. And I think part of that is also, you know, my generation.
SPEAKER_01I mean, I was born in 1980 and, And the things that we did when we were little are β they've gone away in many ways. But what we had was movies. Movies were a big thing. I mean I play β it's not like I sat inside watching movies all day. I played outside most of my life when I was a little kid. But movies have always been important to me, and I've always had a β a thing where I can watch a film and, and, um, get drawn into a film, uh, in, in ways that I guess now that I'm older, many people don't.
SPEAKER_01And I can remember my whole family's like this. We can watch a movie and remember the entire movie. Also, um, you know, I was a, I was a trained actor. I trained at, uh, Bristol Old Vic theater school. Hmm. And I was β I worked briefly as an actor before I went back to school for English and writing. And so drama is important to me in terms of both creation but also analysis and watching films and watching theater drama.
SPEAKER_02Do you think you have to β All right. Want to do some epistemology, like philosophy? Let's do it real quick. So you're taking in a movie. You're taking in images. You're processing them. And I would argue you're processing them through some, I don't like content really that much, but let's call it a lens. Let's call it a reality, a being. It's your being. And you have certain experiences and traumas and excitements and joys. And then you're spitting back out an analysis.
SPEAKER_02By the way, You're spitting back on an analyzer's analysis. That's right. Guys, I'll ask you, please explain the name. But Bayes Lit Analyzer, best ever. And smoking on screen. This is another thing I love. I would do it, but my wife will kill me, bro. Like, totally kill me. So, well, so anyway. So... So I love Dostoevsky. So what he's going to talk about is in order for you to properly be able to talk
SPEAKER_02about art, you've got to be able to not know, not like know, like a professor knows, but you have to be aware of some foundational spiritual realities. So for one... he would say all art has to be processed through something like there's a creator and there's a creature and you ain't the creator. It's like, so he's going to say that to properly understand art, you have to be humble. That's like a, like a, do you, do you believe in any of this or how do you know like what you're saying?
SPEAKER_02Are you aware of a lens by which you process like your top three bad-ass movies that you like?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, of course. I think that, In terms of a paradigm or seeing the world or especially seeing art, I think that everything is grounded in. In faith and especially in a Christian faith in in understanding the father, son and Holy Spirit. I think that there is no paradigm. There's no moral grounding. There's nothing without Christ, without without a Christian religious worldview. And I think that is brought out just in just the simplest way.
SPEAKER_01I think that's brought out in terms of the canon of literature. and of understanding art in terms of the fact that just take it at its basic level, that if I love English literature, English, English literature dominates the world, English language and English literature. It's, it's the foundational art now in the world. I mean, and, and of course we have Greco Roman literature and their Spanish literature and world literature, but, but in terms of what I cover, especially, and if I, if I take,
SPEAKER_01for example, Shakespeare, which I think is, the foundation of the English language. Now there's two, there are two foundations, Shakespeare and the King James. Yeah.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. There you go.
SPEAKER_01And all people had to read for hundreds of years was a Bible. The thing that is the font of all literature is biblical literature. That's where all illusions come from. It's where all, you know, parables within, um, any, any kind of system of English literature or movies, it all comes from that. So I see everything through that lens and that, and, and in a platonic sense, I think that truth, beauty, and goodness are what uplift the human soul and the human spirit and point towards God.
SPEAKER_01So that that's the way that I see everything. And I think that, you know, one doesn't necessarily have to live an experience in order to understand it. I don't, I don't think you need to... I don't need to be in the war to understand and to sympathize and to understand what the soldier goes through. I can do that through reading. I don't have the lived experience of that, but I can understand it in terms of an intellectual sense or even in terms of my feelings.
SPEAKER_01So I think that's important. That's how I'd answer that.
SPEAKER_02So in that sense, would there be... Okay, so we can go down this postmodern hole for a second. Would there then be top five Muslim movies, top five neo-pagan movies, or is there just top five movies? Or is it totally relative? How would you work with that concept?
SPEAKER_01Yeah. I would answer that according to β so I went to β when I was a junior in high school, I was in an AP English class, and I went to see the poet laureate Robert Pinsky. Do a reading in Virginia. And I asked him a question like that, which it took me a long time to understand. And what I asked him was, what was his opinion of the beat generation and beat literature? Because as a high schooler, as a high school male, that's what I was into at the time. A lot of people are they get their access to literature through through that genre.
SPEAKER_01Sure. And the way he answered me, which really bugged me at the time, was there are many different circles, let's say, of literature. There are confessional poets. There's postmodern poets. There are the British Romantic poets. There's the neoclassical poets. But in the end, those are little circles, and there's only two circles that really matter. there's good and there's bad. And the bad circle is huge. It almost dwarfs everything good for a reason, because for, this is the same thing that Ezra Pound said when,
SPEAKER_01you know, he was, I have the facsimiles of his, in a station of the Metro. And he, he tried to write this long poem after coming out of the Metropolitan in Paris. And he was trying to, you know, focus, meditate on modernism and modernity and what it meant. And he ended up with a, three line poem, right? Uh, in a station of the Metro, the apparition of these faces in the crowd pedals on a wet black belt, which is two lines, but including the title, it's really a three line poem. And basically what he said was, um, It's like when you β it's like when someone close to you dies and you're a writer
SPEAKER_01and you try and write about it immediately. It's going to be bad. That's not the work you're going to publish. But you do need to do β you need to write in order to exercise your instrument so that when it comes time six months or six years down the line to write about it and it's going to be the published work, that's the good work. And good work is not necessarily β it's not always uplifting. It can be something incredibly dark. Macbeth is my favorite play, and it's incredibly dark, megalomaniacal,
SPEAKER_01almost nihilistic, but it's a beautiful work. Yeah, that's right. I agree with that. And so I think that β That there are small circles of what are the top five military movies? What are the top five comedies? What are the top five β and that's fine. That's fine for people to talk about. But in terms of great art, I think that great art, no matter the medium, will transcend those smaller circles.
SPEAKER_02I feel like the marketplace created β A lot of the categories, I don't think they're real. I don't think there's such a thing as a comedy. For instance, I think the best comedy is also going to be, they're going to have the trough of lowness or what the Georgians call in their super toasting, low toasts. There's going to be low toast. There's going to be something allusion to death. There's going to be sadness. Now, it may not be a profound sadness, but a good comedy has to have that in order to get the high. I think every act of art is something like...
SPEAKER_02the piece that's found between the high and the low, I think, but I think the marketplace creates a comedy or a drama or whatever. I don't think those things are real. What do you think about that?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, you definitely have a point, especially in contemporary works. It certainly creates, you know, I think in fact, going beyond a sort of a, a synthetic, you know, um, almost like a consumerist look at what creates comedies. I think that, um, It's obviously culture creation plays a role in this, but a lot of the things that are pushed are what are completely temporary.
SPEAKER_01And for instance, the great comedies are things that are comedies that stand for all time. They're funny regardless of the temporary problems or the temporary issues in it, which is why something like, for instance, you know, not to, you know, be hard on something like, like I'll take Anchorman as an example. Yeah, go for it. I like this.
SPEAKER_02We can mess around with this stuff. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01So Anchorman Ron Burgundy is like β it's a classic comedy. It's a funny movie, and I watched the movie like a million times in the 2000s. In fact, when I went back to Belfast in grad school, I had this Dell computer, and I had one DVD, and it was Anchorman. And I watched this thing. So it's comforting to me to watch it. It just happened to be the DVD that I had. It's so weird. But when you watch it now, when I watch it now, I look back and it's been 20 years and I think a lot of this isn't really that funny. It's silly and it's temporary and that's fine and it gives me chuckles,
SPEAKER_01but it's not like funny that surpasses time. And I think that when you look at the classical comedies and tragedies like with Shakespeare, for example, or in the Renaissance or Elizabethan playwrights or even the Greek playwrights, The thing that separates comedy and tragedy is very small. There's a very thin line. So like Much Ado About Nothing, for example, could be an extremely dark work, right? A woman is lied to. She's told that her future husband has cheated on her.
SPEAKER_01She fakes her own death. And we could have Claudio killing himself, and then it's the end, right? That could be extremely dark. But instead, she reveals herself, and we have a wedding at the end. So the classical comedy β The only difference between comedy and tragedy is that a comedy ends on a high note with happiness and a tragedy ends in darkness and death. And that's why comedies even now in movies oftentimes end with weddings because it's a symbol of promise and future.
SPEAKER_02Do you think the writers, just let's say you and I walked into a writer's room in, I don't know, Los Angeles, Burbank. Do they know the rules you're talking about right now? But do you think they don't know him anymore? Do you think it doesn't matter?
SPEAKER_01I think that the great writers know the rules. I think that they're versed in this sort of stuff. They're especially versed in things like The Hero's Journey and in Joseph Campbell. But that can go two ways. It can either go out the window and go for what's lucrative, and that also goes β that can also go into the territory of the artist compromises β There's β okay. So a great example of this, there's a Family Guy episode of all things, right, where Peter Griffin and his friends have written a cartoon comedy about a bunch of
SPEAKER_01ducks that are going on vacation. And the only joke they make in the cartoon is he walks up to the hotel cashier or whatever, and the guy says, okay, you owe us $100. And he says, put it on my bill. And that's the only joke, right? And then so he gets it to the producer, and the producer says, I like your ideas. I like where you're coming from, but what if we change the ducks to rabbits, right, or whatever it is? And he's like, no. No, that's not going to happen. And he says, you know what?
SPEAKER_01I like your integrity. I like how you're willing to stick with things, and you're willing to stick with your original idea. We'll stay with ducks. And then Peter says, no, I'm not making it, which is β So he never makes the work at all. But I think that what I'm saying is that compromise in integrity and art can go two ways. One, it can completely ruin the work because a producer has decided that they want to owe a favor to somebody and put in something in the movie that which has nothing to do with it. Or it can be a good decision, something for the β a holistic decision for the work.
SPEAKER_01But I think most of the times these things are so driven by money and written by committee that they end up being, again, like synthetic. They lose their humanity. It's so difficult to write a comedy. Like there's so few comedies in Hollywood because most of them are improvised. Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Right.
SPEAKER_01There's a lot of ad living that gets stale for the actors and they just they just don't have any money in comedy. So they make sort of schlocky horror movies or things that are temporary that are money driven.
SPEAKER_02But it's actually. Oh, go ahead. Go ahead. Go ahead.
SPEAKER_01Well, I was just going to say that it's actually β they talk about brave decisions, right? That was a brave decision to do that role however you did it, which is so wanky or whatever. But there are brave β like for instance, if Leonardo DiCaprio decided to become a comedic actor, that would be like a brave decision for his career because it could kill his career or it could uplift it and do something new that he hasn't done. You can only see so many Leonardo DiCaprio movies where he's crying in the role. I mean, it's like he's a great actor and he's done these roles,
SPEAKER_01but there's so many of them now and that's all he does. So do something funny.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. Do you know what I mean?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, for sure. Do something new. 100%.
SPEAKER_02When you're out there, you're reviewing, man. You've got a lot of movies under your belt. So I stumbled into you talking about Civil War, the movie that's just out. And so as this guy who's trying to figure out old world, new world, the way it looked is I was... I didn't go. It looked like I was going to have... modern Hollywood people tell me about it coming civil war, but that's not the way you talked about it. That's not what happened in the movie, right?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, what happened in the movie was incredible. Okay, so this movie, I saw it so you all don't have to. Okay. This reminded me a lot of Ridley Scott's Napoleon.
SPEAKER_02Can we talk about that too? Oh, Lord.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_02By the way, spoiler alerts. This is fun on Heavy Things Lightly today, guys. We're doing movies and art. And by the way, this is fun, Henley. I appreciate this big time.
SPEAKER_01Good, good. Yeah, well, I mean movies are β even bad movies and movies that you hate are supposed to be fun. And I think the thing with Napoleon that really bothered me was that I saw β I did a whole stream on great Ridley Scott movies before that as a prerequisite, before I saw Napoleon. And I did a bunch of reading, and I read a bunch of books on Napoleon, and I was really looking forward to this movie. And then I saw it, and I could not believe what I saw. I β
SPEAKER_01It seems too simplistic to put it down to something like AI wrote the script, but that seems to be a big part of it. So this ties in with the strike that happened in Hollywood, which is interesting because they brought in AI. They are the ones who brought in AI, and they are deep-faking actors who have passed away. And then it becomes this synthetic exercise in performance that it's not a performance for the work of art. It's like look what we can accomplish quickly for money that people will be dumb enough to go see.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. And the Napoleon movie was just β honestly, it was sickening to me how bad it was. I could not believe how inhuman the movie was. And I don't mean inhuman in terms of like battle scenes or war crimes. I'm saying it was inhuman in terms of there was nothing to grasp onto in terms of the humanity of this character.
SPEAKER_02We kept waiting for β my wife and I, we really liked β I mean β We got artists running through our family and we got singers and painters and all this stuff and we enjoy it and we'll do what you do, but we don't, but you're good at it, man. I highly recommend you guys go check them out. But here's the thing. We kept waiting because historically that's an interesting story. Even if you don't like, you know, Mr. Light person, Mr. Enlightenment person, Napoleon, but there's a lot there. And the love story was a disaster.
SPEAKER_01Yes. Yeah.
SPEAKER_02Like there was no reason to like either of those people ever.
SPEAKER_01It's a great point. They were totally unlikable. And that's one of the problems in movies now that all of the characters are so unlikable. So who are we? And I think this is a symptom of, like you were saying, post-enlightenment, also a kind of what I call a post, post, post-modernism.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, yeah, nice.
SPEAKER_01We've gone past β modernity ends in 1945. We have the A-bomb. Then we have a postmodern period from 1945 to like 2001. That's the postmodern era. Then we have the war on terror from 2001 to 2020, and now we're in great reset era, which is triple postmodern era, which is an era of β complete it's not even nihilistic nothingness it's a war on the self it's aesthetic terror yeah and so you go and see this napoleon movie which looks beautiful in
SPEAKER_01terms of the trailers you know there's the scene of napoleon like standing by the sphinx in egypt and you think okay this is going to be where he did these things but the entire movie was basically things just happen It was like, oh, a guy who could have been anybody is standing there and these battles are occurring and he could have been anybody else.
SPEAKER_02Anybody else. Anybody.
SPEAKER_01But like the little things in the movie, like for instance, they showed Napoleon eating in almost every scene in the movie. But every book about Napoleon talks about how he hated eating. He spent as little time eating as possible. He hated meals. He hated like fancy dinners. Total workaholic. Total workaholic. He was a workaholic. He was Spartan. He was militaristic in terms of his eating. He had stomach problems because of his eating. So he spent as little time doing it as possible.
SPEAKER_02I gobbled up a bunch of Napoleon biographies for a little while there in my early 20s. And this is sort of before I... You know, whatever. I kind of woke up to things in Africa and became an Orthodox Christian and yada yada. But he was really interesting to me. And the other thing is, is his biographers, they honored, he had, he was like an asshole who wanted to love. none of that came across in the film none of it came across it was wild yeah yeah
SPEAKER_01he look if you have a guy who regardless of what you think of him and obviously napoleon is a kind of proto antichrist figure you know he stormed you know like russia this is one of the instances where the russians were like no we don't want fighting we don't want war but we got to fight against this guy he's destroying peace just millions of people are dead right he's conquering europe um he leaves Bodies in his wake everywhere. But on the other hand, you have to look at him and go, okay, this is a militaristic guy in the tradition of the great conquerors of the world
SPEAKER_01who compromise nothing for the sake of their nation or whatever their vision is. So it's like Scipio and Hannibal and all these characters. But in the movie, we see a kind of postmodern figure walking. with an actor playing him who says, you know, it would be a really interesting decision if I stand here and, and brood trip into this. Yeah. I'm brooding. And I trip into a sarcophagus and you're like, this is, this is just not, this gives me nothing for his, this isn't a human characteristic.
SPEAKER_02And civil war was doing something like that.
SPEAKER_01Civil war was so weird to me because I saw it and I thought this can't possibly be this bad. It can't possibly be this surface level. There has to be some sort of depth that I'm missing in the movie. So here's the thing. If you have a movie about a balkanized United States and a civil war β Then we have to ask ourselves as thinking human beings, what is going on? Why did they do this? Is it reflective of the world we live in now?
SPEAKER_01And if it's not, is it predictive of the world in the future? But the movie didn't ask any of those questions. And I'm not talking like characters with exposition talking about it. I'm saying there was nothing. I get it that they come across a sniper, and they say, who are you fighting? And he says, I don't know. That guy's trying to kill us, and we're trying to kill them. Okay, that makes sense. That's truthful in terms of the microcosmic locus of a war setting, right? In the end, it doesn't matter the size. It just matters you're trying to kill the guy who's trying to kill you.
SPEAKER_01I get it. But the rest of the movie is like, okay, so the virtuous people are going to be the journalists who don't get involved and think that the virtue of objectivity is a holy thing when they obviously believe in nothing. They don't care about human life, and then they participate in the last scene in the movie, which is the execution scene. Spoiler. It's just, I saw that as just pure political top-down pushing of some sort of false pieties,
SPEAKER_01false virtue in a world of postmodern.
SPEAKER_02Were they afraid? So here's what Mike thought when I kept seeing the trailer coming, you know, the trailer was coming at you for like the last six months. I kept thinking, those are some really irresponsible people to spend a hundred million dollars to expose a civil war that feels possible. And, and then I see what happened is they probably got scared of that. They must've gotten scared of it.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, no, that's an excellent point. I thought the same thing that I think, and I think that is probably that accounted for one thing in the movie. I think that's the reason why they, the, the, the two sides in the movie are the government forces and the so-called Western Alliance or Western forces, which is like the Republics of California and Texas. To me, that only made sense. A lot of people had a problem with that, but to me, that only made sense in the, in the, in the fact that, the filmmakers were aware of their irresponsibility because of how close the civil war is in this country and the way people feel and all the various things we've
SPEAKER_01been going through for years, whether it's going to happen or not. And I don't want it to, you know, we want peace, but, but I'm saying, um, I think that they did that because they were like, look, California and Texas, in no world are they ever going to align. They are complete opposites. So why don't we have them be allies so that we can have that to latch on to? And make our movie.
SPEAKER_02Then we can make our movie.
SPEAKER_01Then we can make our movie, yeah. That's it.
SPEAKER_02But you said, did you go to the theaters to see it?
SPEAKER_01I did, yeah.
SPEAKER_02Are you a popcorn guy?
SPEAKER_01No, no.
SPEAKER_02I almost go for the popcorn.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I don't because my first job that I ever had was working in a movie theater. Oh, so this now. Yeah. So, so I don't, so when I go to the movies, I usually like for this one, I went by myself on like a, I think I went like in the morning. And I sit at the back of the theater and I watch it and then I leave. Cause when I, when I worked at the movie theater, I, that's what I did all the time. You know, when I was on my break, I would watch a movie and you know, it's good for people to go on dates to movies and, you know, go with your friends and stuff like that.
SPEAKER_01But also you don't have to do that. You can, you know, I rarely go to the movie theater at all anymore. Yeah. you know, it's, it's not worth it. You're going to pay.
SPEAKER_02So you don't have that romantic. I actually still have a romantic movie mojo. I still, I still think like that.
SPEAKER_01Well, I, I do in the sense that like, I love the movies and I love, you know, seeing this screen,
SPEAKER_02but you can watch it at home and it's fine,
SPEAKER_01but I can watch it at home. Yeah, I can. I, you know, and I feel like, uh for me watching movies um or watching a television series or whatever i do i treat it like i'm uh like i read which is like active reading so when i read i read very fast um but i when i read i make notes you do and you do that with movies you do with movies but when i'm but when i watch movies i make mental notes i don't write anything down but i but i treat watching a movie the same way that i'm reading a book interesting
SPEAKER_01So, yeah, I mean, I think it's important to β When you do your reviews β That's not to say that
SPEAKER_02people β Sorry. When you do your reviews, are you working with some notes in front of you or are you just ripping?
SPEAKER_01No. No, I'm just riffing, yeah. And when I'm doing book analysis, I have β notes in terms of annotation in the book, but I don't make a list of notes or write on a piece of paper notes. I just cover the book in terms of an overall thesis for what I got from the book and in terms of using the text as evidence and explicating the book and breaking it down. But I think that I only think that I'm capable of doing that because I've been doing it my whole life and that,
SPEAKER_01you know, I did that in school. I did that in college and university and graduate school. I do that for a living, you know? So I think that after a while, that just becomes a thing.
SPEAKER_02Do you, this is cool. This is nice. When you guys see his, his reviews, you, this is nice information. And I feel like there's an art to your podcast. I also feel like there's an art to watching a film like we talked about earlier, but here's one. Do you think, Well, let me ask you just straightforward. Do you think there's such thing as a religious movie? And do you have a favorite, quote, religious movie?
SPEAKER_01Absolutely. Yeah, I think that the Thin Red Line comes to mind. The Terrence Malick film is a religious movie.
SPEAKER_02That's my wife's favorite movie, me and her. We watched it.
SPEAKER_01Really?
SPEAKER_02Because, oh, we could get into that. Really? Keep going. I'm sorry, I interrupted you. Thin Red Line, right on.
SPEAKER_01Well, I mean, so if people haven't seen The Thin Red Line, it came out at the same time as Saving Private Ryan. And it's almost like a dialectic. Saving Private Ryan is a European theater, and Thin Red Line is the Pacific theater. This is World War II. And we're looking at Iwo Jima or Guadalcanal. And Saving Private Ryan was sold as an anti-war movie, but it really is a pro-war movie that's kind of masquerading as an anti-war movie.
SPEAKER_01And The Thin Red Line was marketed as nothing. It was just β it just came out. But The Thin Red Line is an impressionistic prose poem. It's subjective. It's totally β it's almost a nebulous spiritual meditation, and it's Christian. The lead character is Christian in the movie, and it's about β beautiful it's about beauty in life and you have various characters remember nick
SPEAKER_00nolte's character nature's cruel starles right you're gonna go up that hill this is what you're gonna do you're gonna go up that hill and you're gonna get up there and god damn it if i have to hear from you one more time So some of the men are thirsty. Okay, we'll get them some water. See the vines circling around everything? Nature's cruel, Starles.
SPEAKER_02Nature's cruel, best line. And remember, Starles, he's lighting candles the night before the battle. And he's a Greek guy, so we know what that was about.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, and he is really suffering in the movie because he hates war, and he doesn't want his men to suffer, and he's painted as a coward in the movie. But the various characters β there's various kinds of β bravery and courage in the movie. And there's a moral courage and a moral bravery in that movie where, for instance, the Jim Caviezel character in the movie is, is obviously a kind of, he kind of is a, it's like almost like a Christ-like parable journey within the movie.
SPEAKER_01He's willing to sacrifice himself for, for others. He's gentle, he's kind, but he's a great warrior, right? He's, he is, he's meek. He fights for the injured and, But he also doesn't flinch and he doesn't cry. He's not, you know, he doesn't run away.
SPEAKER_02Remember when he says, where'd all this evil come from? How'd it get into us? It's just fantastic. One of my favorites.
SPEAKER_01And they're surrounded. They're surrounded by this lush, green, unspoiled nature. But we then we sort of. We sense that we're just outside Eden when we're watching the movie. It's like Eden was there, we've been cast out, and now we're in a war. And this is the result. That's beautiful. And so something like Civil War has none of those things. There was one scene... where kirsten dunst who plays a journalist who sounds like me in the movie by the
SPEAKER_00way which is really weird that is really weird i'm like this is like a woman you
SPEAKER_02how did it work like look i'm a journalist i'm a journalist and also hi baby like how does that sound yeah i have to watch it now just for that
SPEAKER_01There's a scene where she's lying down and the snipers are shooting each other and we get a focus into a bluebell in a field. And so we get a kind of close-up and we get the wider world. There's beauty still within this war. But all that does in the movie, I think β and this actually is pretty good in the movie. All that does is show us that the war that β in the movie happens in america will be one where there's so much distance there's so much space between people and characters there's so much land that we have that
SPEAKER_01there will be a lot of quietude you know there's there's a sense of stillness and the trees are still there and the flowers are still growing but a guy's got a you know a a Ford Expedition and there's a flatbed trailer full of bodies right which didn't really make sense in the movie but sort of makes sense truthfully but the way that
SPEAKER_02they pulled it off was not it feels like somebody was watching Thin Red Line from that description you're getting A little bit.
SPEAKER_01Well, they might have been watching it, but they had a committee overtake the script. I have a feeling that Al Scarland had to make a lot of compromises to make this movie, which is a shame because his other movies are so good. Ex Machina, his series Deus is great. I did analysis on the book, The Beach, which is a great, great book. And The movie Annihilation, which is a kind of a Gnostic space journey backwards through time,
SPEAKER_01which is very odd. But his works are high-tech and revelatory for the future age, and they've become now. And big vision films. Especially with X-Men.
SPEAKER_02Big vision films.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, it's very visionary and unique and tight. They're tightly wound in a tight script, and I just have the feeling that there's no way that he could have written this movie. Yeah. This is what happens when a committee takes over and they make decisions.
SPEAKER_02So I stumbled β well, we met each other, too, however the interwebs work. And I stumbled onto some of your stuff with my friend, DPH, who I've done some podcasts with. Jay Dyer, which I haven't yet, but Jay scares me when I like him. And β no, but he's that cat, you know, like β you're going to put your tongue on the cold ice, cold pole. It's going to stick. So like, that's, you're going to get stuck there and it's going to,
SPEAKER_02but it, but it, you know, it might be worth the risk to mess around and listen to Jay. And I think he does good work, but how did, how did you, how did you follow him with those guys?
SPEAKER_01Well, it's interesting because I've been β I was watching Jay's YouTube for years, like going back to 2012 or 2014. And so it's funny because I watched the process of videos and then into live streams and then as a mod on the channel and all this stuff. And then I just met a kind community of like-minded people. People do that on the internet. You find your group. And I've met a lot of my friends through that.
SPEAKER_01But Jay and Jamie are very kind and very genuine people. And I think β not to harp on it too much, but I think that this speaks to something in the world now that there is a huge emphasis in the world now on the so-called virtue of being nice. And especially as I've gotten older, I've learned that β Being β it's like with literature. You look at text and subtext, and I think that the virtue is kindness,
SPEAKER_01and sometimes we have to be β hold people to account or stand up for our ideas or be scathing in the things that we believe in because look at the other side. Yeah. The people, they cry out as they strike you, the other side. So I think that it's great that there are people in the world. And then I'm blessed to have met people in the world. Shouts out to David Patrick Harry, who's a great example of this, who is someone who is incredibly intelligent. Took punches.
SPEAKER_02He had a huge following and took punches.
SPEAKER_01J2. And could not... They could not be sweeter or more genuine.
SPEAKER_02I went to Jay Dyer's wedding. I sat at his reception and I'll say he was wonderful. What I mean by the tongue gets stuck on the freezing cold pole is that's just what it is. He's going to come at you and he's going to tell a lie. If you stick your tongue out, don't be like, it's just what it is if you walk into that arena. I actually think I mean, I think that he's so smart that sometimes he's speaking to folks.
SPEAKER_02that's way over their head and all they catch is the little barbs and they don't catch the other stuff. That's what I think happens a lot.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Well, there's, there's also, there's also a culture that's promoted now, which is certainly top down of rate reaction. I mean, half of, you know, you, of all internet is reaction.
SPEAKER_02This is my problem. That's why I said my style. I'm with you. Cause I mean, I got a brother who he's pumping stuff out there and I, It is a lot of that. It is a lot of, it's almost like the reaction almost sometimes fuels the content and vice versa. But I don't think those guys are trying to do, that's not what I want to say. What I want to say is they're in that scene, you know?
SPEAKER_01Yes, certainly. Well, that's how people react to them, and I think that β it's like if I make a three-hour analysis of Blood Meridian and I pour my heart and soul into a total deconstruction of this book, and then you get a β the react, the reaction is, uh, you know, a comment based on the like screenshot or something, or,
SPEAKER_00you know,
SPEAKER_01the first five seconds of, you know, it's, it's emotional and reactionary. And I think that it's important, especially for, especially for men and for Christians, not to give any, I don't have any advice to give. I'm just saying it's important for Christians and men to realize that you should stand up for yourself there. You pick your battles. Well, that's, that's a great people like Jay. Yeah. Yeah, it's good to see people like Jay that stand up for themselves and for what they believe in. I think that's really important. And that sets a good precedent for men. So how about this idea?
SPEAKER_02We can get back to movies in a second because you can get this. Maybe there's just room for both. So I try to go the other way. So I try to elicit humor and degrees of beauty as a way to be, I don't know, convincing about something. So I'd much rather sit with someone and laugh about their life and share a bourbon or I prefer mezcal. And I may never actually bring up the point or attack the thesis or challenge the wrong thesis.
SPEAKER_02But I think there's a role for that where we get up from the table and I'll say, I'll see you next week. And there's a role for Jay and others to come at you when things are wrong. I think, in other words, I'm not really saying this. I can't believe I'm saying this. It takes a village or some shit like that. It just takes a lot of different types of people to sort of rescue culture. What do you think about that?
SPEAKER_01Well, yeah, I think that you were a teacher, and I think that it's important when dealing with people just like when dealing with β like when you're dealing with students, which is that you have to pick your battles and you have to β Be a real human being who I mean, look, here's what I'll say. I'm not I don't debate. I'm very bad at debating. You know, I like to engage in I like to be funny and silly and stupid and ironic and deadpan
SPEAKER_01and all those things. And that's how I deal with people. But there comes a moment, though, when especially in the world now where. You can deal with people in that way, but then they take you for a fool or they use you as the butt of a joke, and that can be the line.
SPEAKER_02I know about this for sure.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, it's that if I make jokes β And this is especially this is happening with people that, you know, as men, we might have friends that we've had our whole lives and we come across people who all of a sudden will do this to us. And and it's because of it's being it's a divide and conquer and it's being pushed on people and what we went through four years ago. You know, but I think that there comes a moment where just because we're making jokes or talking about movies or talking lightly about things doesn't mean that we're not serious people when it comes down to it.
SPEAKER_01And I think that. Sorry, go ahead. Go ahead. Well, I think that β yeah, it's like there's a lot going on in the world, and there are some people that cover politics and that cover protests, and people can cover anything they want. I happen to cover books and movies, but those are also important. We see life through literature. Christ spoke in parables. We see things in parallel. Sometimes we get more truth out of a work of fiction.
SPEAKER_01It may not be factual, but it's truthful. And that speaks to the human experience and what we're doing here. Because in my opinion, all art is focused on two things. It's focused on what are we doing here? What's our relationship with God? and how do we get along while we're here what's our relationship with yeah there it is and all of the art that is yeah all the art that is not focused on things on those things is specifically as a reaction or an anti against those things so like
SPEAKER_01when the guy you know post the um when duchamp posted the urinal on the wall right at the art exhibit That's β yes, it's a thing, and a thing is a thing is a thing, and it's modernity. But he's also saying β he's also making a statement. He's saying the world is a toilet. And that is in and of itself a kind of β that delves into a kind of spiritual look into the way that we're living in the world.
SPEAKER_03Mm-hmm.
SPEAKER_01So things are things, but symbolism is also real. Nouns are concrete and abstract. That's right. I can pick up a pack of cigarettes or a lighter, and that's a thing. I can see it, touch it, taste it, smell it, hear it. And love, I can't touch, taste, smell it, but that doesn't make it less real or truthful. It's just abstract.
SPEAKER_02I think we've been trained, though. to imagine that it is less real. Even if everyone says, like, I'll do a toast at the restaurant about love and everyone loves it and they're all happy. I still think if you really put those same good people to the test who heard this beautiful toast about love, I still think they would somehow, deep down, think less real than, I don't know, mechanical engineering. I believe that they would... There's a default from teaching kids, and you do it too, where I used to ask always my seniors.
SPEAKER_02We did four years together in these seminar programs. Our last class, the capstone as seniors was the history of love. And I would always ask them in there, we would take a look, like a survey. I would say, tell me over these last 12 years or 16 years, however long, if you go all the way back to pre-K, where are the classes where you learned the stuff that was really true? Where's the stuff where you learned the stuff that was really pretty or nice that you liked the most? But where's the true stuff? Always, always math and science, math and science, math and science.
SPEAKER_0290% of the kids went, well, I learned the truth over there, but I really liked my art class. Yeah. And then you're like, okay, so what does that mean? Like, that's a deep concept right there.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Well, Hamlet says, bring me to the test, and I, the matter, will reword that which madness would gamble from. Mother, for love of grace, lay not that flattering unction to your soul that not your trespass, but my madness brings. It will but skin and fill in the ulcerous place, while its rank corruption, reaming all within, infects unseen. He's talking about love, right? He's saying, bring me to the test. I may seem mad, but... But this is love, right? So, yeah, it's interesting you bring me to the test.
SPEAKER_02I'm going to give you a test in a second. Is that okay?
SPEAKER_01Okay.
SPEAKER_02It's this light-o-meter test. And you know, people who... people know about it in our little corner of the world and so i'm going to give it to you but i want to ask one more question and then um we can we can like do the test it's five questions it'll take 10 seconds yeah um do you think you see a lot of art you read it and you watch it Do you think we're poised for something like a bounce?
SPEAKER_02I don't want to even say a bounce back. I'm not, I'm not real convinced about, you know, 1960 America or 1955 America. This is not impressive time for me. I'm not like, Ooh, I wish I could. I'm not like that at all. Okay. I'm looking at a bigger panoramic view of something like a destruction of the spirit starting really with like Francis Bacon. Okay. That's what I'm talking about. So, but let's just say this postmodernism is, is here and, Can it lead to something, a restructuring, a recapturing of something that you and I,
SPEAKER_02who are in this sort of traditional space, do you think we can see that? Do you think it's possible?
SPEAKER_01I think so. I mean, you know, God can make the crooked way straight. He can use evil for good ends. And I think that as far as art is concernedβ We go through arcs and eons and eras of art, which seem to be reactions against β it's almost like when they β I don't know physics, but an equal and opposite reaction to the thing that's just happened. And it would make sense that with all of the β Just obviously the negative stuff in the world is so palpable right now that it
SPEAKER_01seems like it would lead to a kind of backlash leading to goodness. But at the same time, I keep in mind something previous β I mean like look. Look at the plague. Right. Look at the Black Plague that lasts so long and there's there's death everywhere and there's so much bad stuff. But good comes out of it and good, good works, good works of art come out of the plague. And I think that, you know, and eventually leading to the Renaissance. And I think that. I don't know. I think it will be recognizable when we see it, but we've got a whole lot more degradation in the works.
SPEAKER_01I don't mean to blackmail anybody. I feel the same way.
SPEAKER_02I think there's a technocratic elite that literally, like a computer, does not have technology. does not have value. Like they don't hold values like there's nothing eternal. And it's it's all utilitarian. And that's pretty scary crew, in my mind.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I think that goodness and virtue are such active things that Satan can't create anything. It's all mimicry. It's all mimicry and surface-level imitation, right? And some sort of offering for something monetary or whatever it happens to be. And that seems to override all art right now. For instance, in publishing, there's hardly anything β good being published right now because of a number of different factors people are
SPEAKER_01afraid to publish anything edgy um they're afraid to go against the the type the people who run the publishing industry and all the major industries that that run art are all part of what you know like you said a technocratic elite that is pushing something that wants to depopulate and kill the human spirit and and terrorize people on a on a individual basic level but we have a we We have ways around that, and we have ways of seeing through that, which is personal connection, religion,
SPEAKER_01personal connection, family, and friends. And no matter what happens, the only things that can stop that from happening β like, for instance, friendship and real-life friendship. The only things that can impede that are when we decide β that we don't want to do that anymore. You know, we have to be the active people that like make the phone call, you know, or call our friends or ask how you're doing. And, and I, and another thing I've gotten, you know, not advice, but I'll just say that for people is that oftentimes people,
SPEAKER_01especially in this, in this time, it's like a test. You want to put your friends to the test and they will never pass that test. They'll never be good enough for that. So all you can do is treat people how you want to be treated. If you want to be called like when you get your tooth out and you're in pain or your girlfriend broke up with you, you call your friends when you figure that's happening to them because they're not going to call you when it happens. If they do, it's a blessing. If not, you can't rebuke them for it.
SPEAKER_02You're actually β that's crazy. That's a situation going on at this moment in my life, and I am going to make a call. See that? I'm not kidding with you. I should call it right now, but I'm not kidding. That's amazing and beautiful. Yeah, man.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I mean it's just β I'll say this. I have one of my best friends who had a real sort of father figure in his older cousin who passed away. We were about 20, and his cousin was six years older, but it seemed like he was so much older. But one of the things that he β my friend shared with me recently was that β He had a book and my friend asked him, what's this book? And he said, every Sunday I sit down and I call people on a different page of this book because
SPEAKER_01your friends are going to disappear and you've got to reach out to them and call them. You've got to talk to them while you can. One day we're all going to be gone. Everyone who ever lived died. And you've got to call. And it's ironic because he died so young and it was such sagacious advice for somebody who was so young, you know, speaking to a 20 year old, but it's so true. You got to reach out.
SPEAKER_02Right. And that might be what the phone is actually for. You know, like if you think about it and, With like a Christian telos, someone says, what's the phone for? I'm writing a blog on this right now where I'm not sure the technocratic modern mind, there's no telos, so they don't know what stuff is for. They default to, we do it so we can learn more. Learn more is everything. It's the default. right? Talos for the modern person as if in and of itself, that's good.
SPEAKER_02And it's not, you know, there has to be something bigger. I'm looking at my test. You want to take it with me? Yeah.
SPEAKER_01All right.
SPEAKER_02Here's the thing. I'm going to go over here. Probably got to put on my other glasses. I'm getting old Henley guys. This I'm online. He's BLA. Could you tell us while I just queue this up? Didn't Jay, didn't Jay Dyer give you the name?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I got it from a Jay stream from years ago where he said he was the Bayes analyzer. So, yeah, you can find me at Bayes lit analyzer. It's the base lit lit for literature analyzer. Analyzer is not a word. I know that I made this. I made it hilarious.
SPEAKER_00It's really great. Yeah, dude, you're a lit analyzer. Right.
SPEAKER_01You're right. Yeah. I do a deep dives into mainly literature, but literature and, and film and music and art. So you can find,
SPEAKER_02we'll put you guys, we'll put it in the, in the show notes, all the interweb stuff, which is, which is great. It's good to have you. So, but it's not over. Cause you're going to take, so here's the thing with our show for people who are going to come over and watch you and then be like, Hey, what is that weird guy doing? So here's what we're doing. It's a, I use a little bit of training. like master's degree in history, and then lots of overseas experience talking about lived in five different places, no running water, no electricity, Guatemala for over six,
SPEAKER_02seven years, Georgian Republic, Mali, West Africa, doing development work. and came to some conclusions is that there really is an old world. I lived in it, and there really is a new world. And I lived in that, and I came up in that. And this podcast tries to use humor and stuff to go, hey, new world people, we forgot some stuff. And so we try to tease out historical events and talk about how we've lost a bit of our soul. So that's what I'm doing.
SPEAKER_02And this test... places my guests or people that listen in something like a matrix that says, Oh, you're very old world or you're very new world. So you want to take it?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, let's go.
SPEAKER_02I don't know, guys. What do you think Henley Bay's lit analyzer is going to be? I don't know. This is kind of nerve-wracking. By the way, it always works because it's science. I'm looking for my pen because I'll forget. It always works. You guys should know this who are listening. It's perfect scientific examination. Here we go. You're going to rate each question with just an answer of three. strongly agree like i'm all in on that two i agree but see how scientific it is one
SPEAKER_02yeah i disagree mostly zero no i i'm out i'm all the way out zero i'm out three i'm all the way in two mostly one mostly not Make sense? See that? It's complicated, I know, because, you know, we're getting right to the truth, right at it. We're getting right at it. First of all, thank you for still being on the call right now. I appreciate it, Henley. Here we go. Thank you. Here we go. All right, guys, here we go. When you die, you won't really die all the way.
SPEAKER_02I just want to use all the scientific language properly. It's more like I'm asleep or you're asleep waiting for a next world of some sort. Three, strongly agree. Two, mostly. One, mostly not. Zero, strongly disagree.
SPEAKER_01that's can i answer it without a number first can i explore oh we can explore
SPEAKER_02that's half the fun difficult but i just want to tell you if you challenge the test too much the light-o-meter will explode and it'll kill me okay okay don't kill me
SPEAKER_01uh well i don't believe that i'm asleep uh in terms of i don't believe i'm asleep in terms of uh waiting for Walt Disney reanimation uh oh like a brain like a brain in a bottle thing yeah I don't yeah but I do believe that I'm asleep in terms of uh the big sleep or um the undiscovered country and uh the afterlife and judgment certainly awaits so what is that I suppose that's a
SPEAKER_01Feels like there is another world.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. I don't like the coach because, you know, scientifically it's perfectly calibrated. I feel like you just do it. When you die, you won't really die all the way. It's more like you're asleep waiting for a next world of some sort. Three, two, one, zero.
SPEAKER_01OK, I guess I guess three. Hopefully I will be in that number and I will, you know, and hopefully, hopefully, hopefully I'll be in that number and I can join Christ.
SPEAKER_02OK, so you got you got an afterworld coming. All right. Here we go to I mean, in your worldview. That sounds like it. Okay, perfect. See? See, we're close. By the way, I told Jordan Peterson, literally, I said, we went at a conference, the Symbolic World, and just to the side, I said, psychology is over because of this exam. You don't have to do it anymore. And I really, I'm sticking with that. All right, the best way. And he said, depends on what you mean by over.
SPEAKER_00He was like, I've been thinking. No, no, no, no, no, no. I've been thinking about that. I always like when he's been thinking about that.
SPEAKER_02That is my favorite. I'm like, I believe he's been thinking about that because he's just thinking all the time. So question two, there's five. The best way for you to know about yourself, Henley, is to ask someone else about yourself. zero oh strongly disagree yeah strongly disagree all right we don't have to we can get into it though you can chatter it up but i yeah well well i'm not changing your
SPEAKER_01score that was a gut i like that don't change my score people are able to uh give you some sort of impression uh or interpretation of what you're doing but um or can call you to account but But oftentimes who we are and our deepest self is totally unknown to people. Got it. Interesting. All right.
SPEAKER_02I like that. You guys hear that? Nice expose of his. It was the answer. I like that. I think scientifically that's allowed. I'll have to cut you off if it's too long though, because MIT told me to do that. All right. Here's number three. When you carry a picture of someone you love in a wallet, let's say, or in your pocket or something, you're actually carrying that person around with you. Like they're there somehow, like actually close to you.
SPEAKER_01Um, i'll say i'll say one on that one um yeah uh i think that we i think that we carry around the memory the memories of people um but physical objects hold no uh power
SPEAKER_02over the pixelation we hold in our wallet the pixelation doesn't no not yeah not at
SPEAKER_01all that's that's That's like when you go on a trip to Switzerland and you come back and you're like, hey, everybody, look at my pictures of Switzerland. They're like, I don't care.
SPEAKER_00Well, they definitely don't care. I know I don't care when you show me your pictures.
SPEAKER_02However, I wonder... This isn't a debate. I'm just trying to administer science. All right, here we go. I'll just say one thing about that that's interesting. After being in Africa and Guatemala especially, There's something about the way traditional old world people understand the image. And it's a natural understanding in the same way that Orthodox Christianity
SPEAKER_02expresses an understanding of the image. It's like, hold on a minute. That thing's really essential. And if you're going to have it, I need to know who you are. And it's sort of like if I took an Orthodox icon and just sort of like, I don't know, jammed it on the hood of my car and drove around. It's like, whoa, whoa, whoa, whoa. There's something really important about that image. And there's something really important. Like, you don't just take a picture of your grandmother and just put it in the toilet. What I mean by that is certain pictures go in the bathroom and certain pictures don't.
SPEAKER_02You see what I'm saying? It's because something happens. They get close to you. And I mean that. So anyway, we might disagree, but I'm not taking the test. You're taking it. All right.
SPEAKER_01No, those are good. I think those are good points. Yeah, I think there's a difference between religious iconography and icons and a picture of, you know, a picture of my grandmother. But I do see what you mean. There is a potency and a power.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, there's a potency to the imagery. But let's do four. Here's four. We've got three answers for you. BLA, respect isn't earned. Respect is owed by you to others.
SPEAKER_01Um, yeah, I would say that's, uh, I would say that's a, that's a two, um, yeah, that's a two. Um, I certainly don't believe that. I think it's almost a mantra that people say, listen, I'm going to respect people as long as they respect me. Right. Well, then you're never getting respect. You have to, you, you, you know, honor the father and mother. Right. Um, that's a great point.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_01I owe respect to my elders and to people in the sense of decorum and dignity and respecting the beauty of human creation. But at the same time β That's not at all costs. For sure. There are lines.
SPEAKER_02For me, I like what you're saying. I think there is just a confusion that has settled in with that idea of, yeah, I'll give respect. When I get respect, I give it. What I think people are trying to say there is it becomes really hard for me to give you respect. I always believe, and this is, again, an orthodox idea, that your inability to make it easy for me does not let me off the hook.
SPEAKER_02I'm still on the hook to respect you. You're making it hard, and I feel like punching you in the face. I still think I owe it to you.
SPEAKER_01Well, respect can also be something like β look at Richard I and Saladin, right, who are arch enemies but who have a respect for each other's capabilities and leadership and power and dignity. So respect isn't exclusive to liking anything. Yeah. Right. Oftentimes it's more, it's more important. Oftentimes in terms of our social situations, I think to be, I think being likable is very important.
SPEAKER_01You know, um, I think that like, for instance, you can be the best programmer in the world and work in an office, you know, work in it or something as an example, but if you're not likable, you're not going to get a job and people aren't going to work with you. But respect is something that is sort of another level of that, but you have to, um, A lot of times we don't like the people that we respect.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, that goes back to the early part of our convo, which is something like a Christian worldview. I think other worldviews also include this. but not an evolutionary worldview, does not. But the Christian worldview sort of demands something like an honor of the creature that was made in the same image as God. And so in that sense, I think it demands something enough. All right, last question.
SPEAKER_02Question five, and then we're going to give you your total, and I'm going to give you your grade. You're going to love it because it's going to change your life, change Jordan Peterson's life. Let's not forget that. All right, question five. I hope and expect... to take my parents in and have them live with me when they get old and infirm or flip it, because maybe the parent situation in your life is, you know, flip it. I expect to live near my kids, even preferably in their home when I get old and infirm. And that's, I'm speaking to you.
SPEAKER_01Well, that's difficult. That's difficult for me because I don't have kids and I would, you know, I would I would love kids. We've got, you know, it's in God's providence. So hopefully one day I would have kids. And if I did, I would love to, you know, I would love. to be able to live with them as far as my parents are concerned i live with my parents for much of my life and my parents have done everything for me and um and if it comes to it then i would love to be able to take care of my parents but my parents are also extremely with it and uh competent and um are are together um and
SPEAKER_01i'm that's very rare in the world now and so uh you know, I think that my sister and I certainly, if we, if we, if you know, I don't want my parents to be in a home, that's for sure. I don't think they ever would be. But I, if, if that was the case, then yeah, they would be, you know, I would, I would take them in.
SPEAKER_02But so I guess that's the expectation, like three all the way to one zero. I guess it's a two.
SPEAKER_01I guess it's a two. All right. Yeah.
SPEAKER_02I'm adding it up now. This is where Andrew, the music does the, the, the mathematical machine sounds don't always, sometimes they don't show up, but they're going, if you listen carefully, they're happening right now. Right. And then three, four, five, six, seven, eight. Okay. Henley, you scored an eight. I want to read to you what that means. So here's what you did not score. 14 or a 15.
SPEAKER_02That would have made you the sovereign. So you could have actually called yourself that on the show next time you do a podcast, but you didn't score. A monarch. Yeah, the monarch. You didn't score that. That would be your full retro. You think enlightenment is what happens when you open your eyes after a long nap? If you had scored the sovereign, you'd probably drink from a goblet, your eyebrows are unkempt, and there's a good chance you own a handmade weapon. This is not you.
SPEAKER_01Right, no.
SPEAKER_02Now, you could have scored a little lower, like in the 2-4 range, you would be called the high nooner. This is not you, but I want you to know what you avoided. This, again, it's just math. It's just science, bro. Shining down like a halo from a perfectly engineered drone, science illuminates your every move. You probably know exactly how the drone works, too.
SPEAKER_00I'm a pleading priest of scientism.
SPEAKER_02You love manuals. You trust your brain more than your mother. HR is a necessary evil. And truth be told, you're kind of like HR. Education is the key to everything. Like, I mean, everything. That's the high nooner. That's not you. That's not you.
SPEAKER_01Okay, that's not me.
SPEAKER_02I'm going to read yours. Can I just tell you what you almost scored? You were one point away from this. Yes. You were one point away from the shining city dweller on the hill. You can hear the references. You're a literary guy. You get it. You have hope. You did not score this. You're very close, though. Again, I can't help it that this is what you are now. You took the test. You're not this, though. Thank God. So you have the hope for the modern world because you trust spreadsheets and Reddit.
SPEAKER_02If people... I love you, Henry. If people would just follow reason, we could all have more stuff. You think Columbus was heavy-handed, but also, if you think about it for a minute, he was kind of a badass. Symbolic language feels like a waste of time, but it's still kind of hot on a first date. And when you think of Siri, the phrase, she gets me, comes to mind.
SPEAKER_02All right.
SPEAKER_01That sounds like it. It's not you, though.
SPEAKER_02It's close, though.
SPEAKER_01That's not me. That's a Coomer pod dweller who loves Reagan speeches about the Shining City. 100%. Dude, you know.
SPEAKER_02You know. I love you. You got it. All right. Last one. Now, you did qualify. This is an 8, 9, or 10. And I want you to live with it. I'm also this. I am also a suburbanite. You feel romantic about the old world and love a good metaphor, but actually using them gives you hives. You get a warm feeling all over when you think of hierarchy, but hierarchs are mostly people you'd rather read about in a book. You want to obey your elders much more than you actually do.
SPEAKER_02You prefer a car with four doors and nearly ran for president of your homeowner's association. Yeah. You love that you turned your garage into a gym. Oh, man. I'm sorry. It's just science, okay? I can't change it. I can't change it.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. I'm that too. Yeah. That's pretty good.
SPEAKER_02I didn't even read them all. I didn't read them all to you.
SPEAKER_01The hierarchy thing is really interesting because I β love and respect authority, but I also usually hate authority figures and rules. This is it.
SPEAKER_02I don't think the metaphor one works with you, but I do believe there's some little truth in there because we scored the same thing and I can hear it. We had a fun time here, man. You can find that on our website. You guys can find the first things on our website, but mostly... we joked around because people would always not know what old world meant. And from our guys who have all lived in Africa or lived in Georgia Republic or in these old places, we intuited and kind of knew what it meant.
SPEAKER_02And we realized nobody knew what we were talking about. So that's a, that's a way of seeing the world, but bro, so we can find you at Bay's late analyzer. Yes, yes.
SPEAKER_01Baselet Analyzer at YouTube and Instagram. I do two or three streams a week. I've got one coming up. People can sponsor streams. I've got memberships. I'm doing a stream coming up on this book right here, which is Our Band Could Be Your Life. This one is a sponsor stream. It's on 80s and 90s. alternative rock and the foundations of that. I've got a appearance tomorrow night with Jason Burmess on TNT Radio. I'm a contributor to TNT Radio every week, and I'll be talking about Shea,
SPEAKER_01Fidel Castro, and Tom Wolfe, and Radical Chic, and the birth of the hippie movement from satirical Tom Wolfe text, and a bunch of stuff. You can find me doing just about anything in the canon.
SPEAKER_02I love it. We were really... I'm glad we hooked up. And anytime you want to talk, I can't keep up with you in terms of literature and movies, but I can talk to you about overseas stuff. If you ever want to learn about old cultures, I got your back.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, sweet.
SPEAKER_02Guys, this is Henley. We'll talk to you soon, man. And thank you. This was really, really nice.
SPEAKER_01Thank you so much, man. I really appreciate it. Peace.
SPEAKER_02Peace out. That was Bay's Lit Analyzer. I love his name because there's no such thing as an analyzer. Just, I don't know, irony just, I think it's the best. Guys, will you help me to be more serious though? Because I feel like my life depends on it sometimes. Guys, we're right around the corner. If you're a Holy Week person, you probably already did it. Well, you did. And if you're a Pascha person, you already did it. And if you're not either one of you, don't know what the hell I'm talking about. You probably did that, too.
SPEAKER_02So good to have you here. www.first-things.org. Guys, we do work around the world to serve the poorest of the poor. I hate that phrase even because they're the richest of the rich in many ways. But what we do is bow down before brilliant people in the field in Mozambique and Sierra Leone and Georgia and Guatemala, South Africa soon. And what we do is just bow down and say, hey, I'm here to help. And then we connect really bright people to really good resources, not just money, human resources,
SPEAKER_02consulting, all kinds of things. We're basically Peace Corps with a heart. Like a cool heart. An orthodox heart. But we're not missionaries. Or are we? www.first-things.org Check us out. Much love. Just had a new guy go in the field. A beloved person named Matt. Love that guy. Much love. See you soon on Heavy Things Lightly.
Find this episode on YouTube: "Justine Alter" - a pseudonym - returns to chat with John Heers in a raw Heavy Things Lightly conversation you have to hear to believe.Justine worked for years as a professional psychic,...
Find this episode on YouTube: Holly Hickman went from Columbia Journalism and Fox News Radio covering NASA and the 2008 election - to milking cows, making cheese, and converting to Orthodoxy.In this episode of Heavy...
Can you teach kids the truth AND prepare them for a secular world?On this episode of Heavy Things Lightly, host John Heers talks with James and Juliana Joyce, founders of St. George's Classical Academy in Boxford,...
Find this episode on YouTube: Crow walked America searching for his father - and found the Father.From West Virginia hollers to LA gangs, from wolves in the Mojave desert to an Orthodox cross, this is an Odyssean tale...
Welcome to the first episode of βSave Me a Spot at the Supraβ on Heavy Things Lightly where John Heers hosts singer and Broadway performer Carrie Manolakos (best known for her performances in Mama Mia! and Wicked) at...