Send us Fan Mail In this episode we're talking to the climate crisis firebrand, Sam Nicholson, who is the Director of Manchester's Climate Change Agency and Deputy Chair of the City's Climate Change Partnership. Our chat kicks off with Sam's first steps into environmentalism through vegetarianism and ends up looking at the huge scale of global urbanisation and what it means for decarbonising the world. We touch on female leadership in the climate movement, how to craft a city framework for climate action, and some of the important areas a city needs to consider like real estate retrofit to reduce emissions, through to the critical need to consider climate adaptation, as well as mitigation. We also cover the role that a city's business community can play in creating a coalition determined to tackle the most pressing environmental issue of our time, before rounding off on Sam's thoughts about personal resilience and the need to double down on our net zero goals. Listen in to get a real insight into the city playbook for climate. Follow GoodGeist for more episodes on sustainability, communications and how creativity can help make the world a better place.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_01Goodgeist a podcast series on sustainability hosted by Damla Eusler and Steve Connor. Brought to you by the DNS Network.
SPEAKER_00Hello, hello everyone. You are listening to Good Guys, the message on sustainability, which is brought to you by the DNS Network, the global network of agencies dedicated to making the world a better place. This is Damlo from your agency Istanbul and This is Steve from Creative Concern in Manchester.
SPEAKER_02This podcast series explores global sustainability issues, how they're communicated, and what creativity can do to make positive change happen.
SPEAKER_00So in this episode, we're going to talk to Sam Nicholson, director of the Manchester Climate Change Agency. Sam has worked for over 25 years in the sustainability field and is passionate about the positive role that cities can play in tackling the climate crisis.
SPEAKER_02So, um, and as deputy director of the Manchester Climate Change Partnership, which is the bigger group, she's grown the membership of the partnership hugely, hugely, um, led on the co-design of the city's climate change targets and secured over 2.75 million pounds uh for climate action in the city. And before all of this amazing work, Sam, uh, you were with the UK NGO that some people may know called groundwork and did business engagement on sustainability. So, Sam, thank you so much for joining Dammer and myself.
SPEAKER_04Thank you so much for inviting me. It's a pleasure.
SPEAKER_02Brilliant. So um let's start where it all began, Samantha. Um so we'd like to know more about your journey. So, what led you down this glittering path towards sustainability?
SPEAKER_04Okay, well, um, there are a few key moments in one's life, aren't there? Um, I think for me, one of the mind-expanding moments was my auntie had multiple sclerosis, and she decided to change her diet to a vegetarian diet to try and manage her symptoms. Just at the time, as I was turning 16 and uh moving back from America where I'd lived on, you know, chicken and beef.
SPEAKER_04And so this was like a whole notion of kind of dietary change that really kind of blew my mind at the time, but I think just unlocked a um a passion that had already been there about kind of social justice and animal welfare. So I think that path continued and it merged into then I thought I was going to be an architect. So I did an architecture degree in Manchester where um my conversations were about oh, let's make this um passive solar design and earth-sheltered housing and design for disassembly.
SPEAKER_04And it was a very long time ago, so the built environment sector at that time was going, What are you talking about? Uh please just tell me how this thing connects to that thing, and then you know, we'll talk about all of your crazy eco stuff another day. So um, yeah, that was a real kind of eye-opener of how particularly that sector was not ready for um for the sustainability conversation.
SPEAKER_04It has definitely changed over the intervening period, but it has a long way to go still. So, yeah, um, as I discovered in that process that I was not going to be an architect, which was devastating at the time, um uh I obviously still have a huge passion for buildings and our built environment and the places in which we live and cities. We've sort of come full circle now, which is very satisfying. Um as you mentioned, Steve, I ended up working with businesses and spent a good chunk of my career uh running large-scale programs, helping thousands of companies across the northwest of England to decarbonize, although we talked about waste minimization or resource efficiency or corporate social responsibility in those days.
SPEAKER_04Um, yeah, so that was a large part of my career looking at how do we learn what works, how do we do it at scale, how do we really track the impact so that we can then better target our support. Um and yeah, on the side of that, then we tagged on some how do we support companies in the climate tech sector to grow, and how do we support businesses in other sectors to take opportunities in that growing climate tech sector?
SPEAKER_04Um, so yeah, business support was a large part of my journey, and now I've sort of stepped sideways a few steps and I'm now working with Manchester.
SPEAKER_00Wow. Well, Sam, when listening to your story, I just realized that in every person's story working towards sustainability or the rights movements, we have common themes like the Dumasil's archetype teams. So there is an enlightenment moment starting the uh career, and then the big chunk of a lot of change, hardly, and then another and bigger chunk of much to do.
SPEAKER_00So this is the story arc we have in our collective uh careers and hopes, maybe I can say, but uh I want to come to Manchester because I love that city so much. I really love it. I've been there like four times now, Steve, and I really want to visit more. I'm sure that if a post-industrial city like Manchester can chart a path towards net zero, then there are big lessons for other cities too.
SPEAKER_00I mean, what are the standout points of Manchester's action plan so that we can learn?
SPEAKER_04Sure thing. Um there are some really key points that I think Manchester is doing well. Um, and I will not say that other cities are not doing excellent things uh as well, but we have really strong political support for this agenda in Manchester. We are an ambitious city in all things that we do, so um, it's not surprising that we have taken this agenda sort of by the horns as well.
SPEAKER_04We, Steve mentioned the partnership earlier. We've taken this slightly different approach so that climate strategy is not just a local government strategy, it is owned by a cross-section of organisations from the public sector, private sector, and our voluntary and community sector as well. And that is a key role for the agency and partnership to do is to convene those actors together to work collaboratively to set the climate change agenda, strategy, vision, and targets for the city.
SPEAKER_04So I think that kind of collaboration in setting a vision and way forward, I think is part of Manchester's success in moving on this agenda. The flip side of that is being really transparent about how you're doing. And again, we we produce reports every year for the city. We've been doing reports on the city's direct emissions for over a decade.
SPEAKER_04We've been, we just added a report on our indirect emissions last year. And we are not decarbonising fast enough. We are not on track to stay within our carbon budget or and not on track at the moment within that carbon budget to um to meet our zero carbon date. The date is still in range, the carbon budget is highly at risk of being expended in the next few years.
SPEAKER_04But I think there is value in the transparency of that conversation, and that seems to be understood from senior political leaders to you know small voluntary organizations that are part of the partnership, and we communicate that out through our work with residents and communities too. So I think those are some key components.
SPEAKER_02Um and yeah, always a sobering moment when the budget tot up comes out, Sam, and we look at it. But I wanted to ask you about business, and uh, I should say at this point, regularly on this podcast, questioning capitalism does come up. So we might go there, we might not, don't know yet. Um, but I mean, Manchester is a very mercantile city, isn't it? So it's a city of business as much as anything. And and you've done a great job of recruiting businesses into the partnership so that it's not, as you said, just a kind of local government-led initiative, but it's you know, business is massively embedded in it.
SPEAKER_02Um, so I think again, sort of in terms of top tips for other cities, what's your corporate pitch when you're seeking to get businesses engaged?
SPEAKER_04So I think that what I learned in all of those years of working with businesses across different sectors is that we need to be able to talk about this agenda in a variety of different ways because different people and therefore different organizations are motivated by different things. We need to be able to talk about risk and why you know the risk of inaction is a driving force. We need to be able to talk about economic opportunities, jobs and skills and growth opportunities.
SPEAKER_04We need to be able to talk about doing the right thing, we need to be able to talk about reputational gains, we need to be able to talk about um attracting and retaining the right talent, young people we know want to work in organizations with good environmental credentials. So having an arsenal of um ways to attract and align our objective with those of organizations that we want to be part of the conversation, I think is absolutely critical.
SPEAKER_04And quite often, and again, backed by the 25 years of being old in this game, um I just just for the record, Sam, uh, because this is the audio only podcast.
SPEAKER_02And you know, I think you look somewhere around the 32-ish.
SPEAKER_04Well, your check's in the post. Thank you, Steve.
SPEAKER_02Anyway, back to you.
SPEAKER_04So quite often with with businesses, well, actually with with with individuals, residents, and communities as well, we don't talk about climate, we talk about co-benefits. Um, that was a key um a key thing that we pulled out in our um current five-year strategy for Manchester was how do we make sure that we make the co-benefits of climate action really visible at every step of the way?
SPEAKER_04So, will this create cost savings for residents? Will this create economic opportunity for businesses? Will this help to address health inequalities? Will this enable more active travel? Will this, you know, all of that co-benefits of action was absolutely critical and I think was really well received by the city, by stakeholders across the city? So we will be continuing that in our next five-year plan.
SPEAKER_00Well, what I was hearing, I don't know. Have you have you watched the show How I Met Your Mother?
unknownI have.
SPEAKER_00Okay, do you remember Barney Stinson's breakup sandwich? No. Sorry. That womanizer Barney Stinson was saying when you break up uh from a loved one, uh, you just first say a good thing and then lay out the breakup, and then on top of it, put another good thing in it. So this is the breakup sandwich, so it no mess will happen. So it is like in the climate action, too. What I'm hearing is you lay up opportunities and then you talk about risk, but then you also lay up another layer of opportunities, and you have the breakup sandwich from business as usual and go to change.
SPEAKER_02Damlock, can I just say you are on fire on the when we write the goodgeist book? You've you've talked about the kind of life arc of people committed to sustainability very eloquently, and you've just invented the carbon action sandwich.
SPEAKER_00That's wonderful. I think, but I haven't invented it. Sam has actually. I don't know.
SPEAKER_02That's fair, that's fair.
SPEAKER_00Okay, so time for the bigger picture. By the middle of the century, 70, 80 uh percent of the population will be living in cities. So the city climate agenda is critical. Which cities do you think are doing well on this? And is there a city and carbon playbook as the sandwich?
SPEAKER_04So I think this might be a slightly annoying answer, but I'm not going to point at any one city that has got everything right. Because I think what the reality is, is that in the same way that we know sometimes that cities share more in common with each other than they do with their sort of rural hinterlands in their own countries, we're all facing the same challenges, and there are loads of great practice and loads of good ideas happening across the globe.
SPEAKER_04So we regularly talk to the core cities in the UK and their climate counterparts, and there is lots of innovation happening in the UK, particularly around how do we unlock long-term patient capital finance into accelerating and delivering net zero. We know that the public purse can't cover this cost alone, and so there is lots of work happening across the UK, in that Manchester and Greater Manchester, of course, are involved, but we are not on our own, and there is um we are there is lots of collaboration uh in that conversation in that space.
SPEAKER_04We are at the moment talking to Stockholm about how Manchester and Stockholm are both tackling health inequalities and climate, as well as kind of that broader community engagement and climate. We were involved in an initiative of the C40 Cities, CDP and World Business Council for Sustainable Development a year and a half or so ago called the City Business Climate Alliance. So there are cities in the global north and south who are looking to do what we're doing in Manchester and bring businesses and organisations into that conversation.
SPEAKER_04So there's loads of great practice happening in that space. We had a really interesting conversation with Seattle last year as part of our annual partnership event, where they share a lot of the same challenges, particularly in terms of interestingly extreme weather, both very rainy cities. Um and yet also differences. So for Manchester, we know that three-quarters of our direct emissions come from buildings and one quarter from transport.
SPEAKER_04Seattle, it was literally the opposite, three-quarters from transport. Um, you know, and that's the kind of American addiction to the car, to the private car. So I think that what you will find is different cities have prioritized different topics, different areas of the challenge, depending on what resonates most with their communities, what is stressing them most in terms of building resilience to a changing climate, what is has most political buy-in.
SPEAKER_04And there are moments of excellence everywhere, which is good in one sense that there are lots of stories, lots of lessons to be learned, and then challenging on the other hand, which is well, who do we talk to first? And how do we all find that extra capacity for those kind of conversations to pull learning in?
SPEAKER_02Pretty good playbook, I think, Damler. That one. So, Sam, on a more personal note, let's get personal. Um, the we're blowing through our carbon budgets. We've got Trump in the White House, we've got a nature emergency that's making the climate emergency even worse. Um uh, and so for those of us working to turn all of this around, there's it can all almost always feel like an impossible task, can't it? So how do you stay sort of positive and motivated and energy energized?
SPEAKER_02How do you how do you keep on trying?
SPEAKER_04So I think I've described before that I think it's our job to, I think if if we lose, if we lose hope and we're the ones working in this space, then how on earth would we ever kind of expect to inspire and encourage and enable others to join in um tackling this crisis, this emergency? So I think you know, one answer is well, it just is beholden on us to do so.
SPEAKER_04But there are definitely moments of joy, and you know, some of those are around individuals. When you see individuals either in a business or in a community, who maybe have thought, oh, I'm being told to do this, or this role has just been given to me, and I'm not really interested, and it feels boring and it's somehow sidelined. And then you see that moment where they achieve something and they make a change and they make a difference, and this kind of world of possibility opens.
SPEAKER_04I love that moment. Um, and then sort of equally there are moments of where it's not just one individual who can see they can make a difference and they go on to kind of advocate for others. There are those moments of collaboration where the kind of the whole is oh, what's that phrase? The sum is more than no, the whole is more than the sum of the parts. Something like that. I'm sure you can put the words in the right order in the edit for me. That collaboration between organizations, between sectors, between different parts of the city, and that the that is where people do get inspired by that, by that learning, by that, oh god, actually, it's quite fun to do this together, isn't it?
SPEAKER_04And it becomes quite a cathartic exercise, I think.
SPEAKER_00Well, that was beautiful because I always believe that people always like to do good things together. So I'm an optimist. Always. I'm sorry, I'm wired that way. Sometimes that can be a little bit naive and romantic, but still I'm keeping that. Yeah, what I hear is will power and solidarity. That's the way we'll go. That we have no other way. So we have had some amazing talks on this podcast about gender, climate, and leadership.
SPEAKER_00And the climate change agency you lead is largely female. That's why I was very excited today. Do you think there is an ever-growing cohort of women leaders in the climate field?
SPEAKER_04Uh absolutely, yes. Um, I most certainly remember as I was starting my career, I was, it was definitely male-dominated at that time. Um, the businesses that I was working in, um, going into manufacturing companies across the region, where the operations manager or the health and safety manager who would have environment thrust upon them as well, were again very predominantly male.
SPEAKER_04Um, and I did always quite enjoy getting uh sort of having being looked at slightly strangely walking around a you know, sort of a uh a large manufacturing company. Um, but uh yes, most definitely it has changed. I think all sectors have seen a change, um, but this one in particular, there are definitely more women entering the profession, coming up in the profession, and leading the profession.
SPEAKER_04Yes.
SPEAKER_02Which is a revolution that's well overdue, I would say. Um So Sam, um almost last question. There's one more from Damlo in a moment, but 2025, yet again, another critical year. I think the last carbon budget from the Committee on Climate Change here in the UK, but also all the work of things like the Copernicus programme looking at what's happening with global weather patterns means that it's it really is a crunch year, isn't it? So for Manchester, what are the kind of key goals, objectives?
SPEAKER_02What's going to be happening in 2025 that's key and germane to the climate agenda?
SPEAKER_04So there's probably uh there's a planning side of that answer, and there's a doing side of that answer, and they're both um important. We are developing our next five-year climate plan, as you said. We are developing an adaptation plan. It's absolutely um uh brilliant that we are now putting more focus on that. How do we build resilience in our built environment, our infrastructure, our businesses and supply chains, and critically our residents and communities and you know, vulnerable communities, particularly.
SPEAKER_04So we're developing an adaptation plan. We Manchester is refreshing its 10-year sort of strategy for the city, and climate has remained one of the top priorities within that, which is another great win. So there's lots of other kind of planning going on, and we mentioned finance before. There is a lot of work happening on how do we create large-scale, play-scale pipelines of net zero programmes that means that we can have really serious conversations with some of that private capital investment.
SPEAKER_04And then in terms of the doing side, there's lots of brilliant work happening that will continue. There are some big strategic regenerations happening in Manchester with climate mitigation and adaptation at the heart of it, notably with and shore Civic Centre and then Victoria Northern Mayfield. So those projects are ongoing. There is large-scale decarbonisation of our public estate and of our social housing, which will continue. And there is a lot of work happening to think about how do we make our energy infrastructure, water infrastructure, and transport infrastructure fit for the kind of new, smart, sustainable, flexible world.
SPEAKER_04So all of that is quite chunky, physical, you can point at it stuff. But equally, Manchester is very much centred in people. And how do we make sure that our people are at the heart of any process and any change and are brought in and um and encouraged and enabled along the way? So we're doing some amazing stuff with communities. We work with a range of organizations and the city council and some fantastic voluntary sector organizations in the city doing really inspiring work uh with communities to build their ability to take action to change and to inspire others.
SPEAKER_04So all of the above.
SPEAKER_00Wow. Sadly, we are running out of time. So I have to ask the final question. And our final question is our network is ironically called Do Not Smile because we need to make sustainability a subject that brings happiness to the people and the world. What object, place, or person always makes you smile?
SPEAKER_04So I've probably pre-answered this with my other question about those moments when you see people um recognize their agency and their ability to create change and and experience the sort of uh the what more we can do through collaboration. So those definitely still stay there. From a if I just add to it from a personal perspective, I love data, but not just for the sake of data.
SPEAKER_04I like it when it tells us something interesting that we perhaps didn't expect, that then means that we can be more effective in creating change. So from back in the day, one of the um one of the things we were able to identify from uh uh analyzing data from thousands of businesses was this notion that, well, if the payback period is right, if the capex is right, then people will do it. Well, it turns out absolutely businesses were equally as likely to do it if the payback period was right as and if they had money as if there was a grant and not.
SPEAKER_04So it wasn't that that made the difference. It was a catalogue of other things that make us human and often irrational that was the thing that made the difference. So the ability for data to kind of challenge the way we think about things and to make us change course and do things differently to have a greater impact is is, I think, um, as we move into this age of kind of AI and big data is is important that we use it wisely.
SPEAKER_02Sam, that was brilliant. The the power of data to prove the irrationality of human beings is something we can all take away with us. Um well, thank you so much. As you as we've heard, and not only have we got the carbon playbook for cities out of this podcast episode, we've got a couple of generic models for change, theories of change, courtesy of Damler, inspired by you. Wow, productive 25 minutes, I would say. Um, so thank you again. Damla, over to you. Do you want to close us up?
SPEAKER_00So thanks to everyone who has listened to our Good Guys podcast, brought to you by the Do Not Smile Network of Agencies.
SPEAKER_02And make sure you've listened to future episodes where we'll be talking to more amazing people like Sam about how we can work together to create a more sustainable future. So, Damler, Sam, see you soon.
SPEAKER_00Hi, thank you.
SPEAKER_01Goodgeist. A podcast series on sustainability hosted by Damla Ozler and Steve Connor. Brought to you by the DNS Network.
Send us Fan Mail Turning the tables on our hosts, Alexander Deliyannis, our DNS agency Team Sympraxis from Athens is in this episode hosting Damla Özlüer! Damla shares the latest news from COP 31, Antalya, where climate...
Send us Fan Mail In this episode we're talking with Bahar Yavuz from Turkey’s Ichtimam Association to ask a critical question: what if the climate crisis is fundamentally a crisis of care, built on an economic model...
Send us Fan Mail Marine heatwaves are doubling, ecosystems are shifting, and the ocean is sending louder signals every year. So what does real progress look like when politics are messy, money is tight, and the climate...
Send us Fan Mail Design sits behind almost everything we touch, use, wear, read, and rely on, which means it also sits behind a lot of the harm driving the climate crisis. In this COP31 special episode we’re joined by...
Send us Fan Mail COP31 is heading to Turkey, but the question that matters is simple: who gets to decide what climate action looks like? We’re joined by Tuğçe Oklay & Kivanç Eliaçık from the People’s Climate Summit...