People's Climate, People's Summit with Tuğçe Oklay & Kivanç Eliaçık
26 minAudio
Send us Fan Mail COP31 is heading to Turkey, but the question that matters is simple: who gets to decide what climate action looks like? We’re joined by Tuğçe Oklay & Kivanç Eliaçık from the People’s Climate Summit steering committee to unpack why alternative summits exist and why the climate crisis cannot be reduced to an environmental policy tweak or a market problem. It's a conversation about climate justice, power and the difference between being “consulted” and actually being able to decide. We dig into the Summit’s four pillars and the practical politics behind them: rights of nature, fossil fuel phase-out with energy democracy, anti-militarism with democracy and peace, and agroecology with food sovereignty. Along the way we get specific about what “system change” means in the real world, including a clear plan to close coal plants while protecting every coal worker’s job and pension rights, and why energy should be in public hands rather than run for private profit. We also face the hard parts: tensions between jobs and climate action, repression of activists, and the hypocrisy of corporate sponsorship inside the UNFCCC process. The thread that holds it together is organising and solidarity, from workers and farmers to frontline communities and environmental defenders. Follow GoodGeist for more episodes on sustainability, communications and how creativity can help make the world a better place.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_03Hello everyone, this is good guys, the message on sustainability, which is brought to you by the DNS Network, the global network of agencies dedicated to making the world a better place. This is Damla from MIRA Agency Istanbul and This is Steve from Creative Concern in Manchester.
SPEAKER_00This series explores global sustainability issues, how they're communicated, and what creativity can do to make positive change happen.
SPEAKER_03And this episode of the COP31 sub-series in Goodgeist, we'll be hosting the People's Climate Summit together with Tuce Oklai and Kwanch Ilyochik from the steering committee. We will explore what COPs mean to everyday people and what we really need to make positive change happen.
SPEAKER_00So, a bit of background for our viewers and listeners, organized annually by the United Nations with the participation of over 190 states, with just one or two noticeable emissions for now. The Climate Summit Conference of Parties COP will take place in Turkey this year. Dumler, congratulations, it's landing in your patch. So three major umbrella organizations of the ecology movement in Turkey, the Climate Justice Coalition, the Ecology Union, and the Environmental Platform of Turkey, who believe that the true solution lies with people, absolutely correct, come together to organize this sort of alternative summit alongside COP31 to safeguard the needs of people and climate justice.
SPEAKER_00So, TJ Kivanj, thank you so much for taking the time to talk to us. Thank you for inviting us. Thank you.
SPEAKER_03So let's start with the alternative gatherings during COPS. So looking back from Pochabamba to recent counter-COPS, what fun foundational demands have remained non-negotiable across decades? And where has the grassroots movement had to rewrite its tactical demands? I mean, what happened and what will happen? That is the big question. Tuce, would you like to go first?
SPEAKER_02Yes, uh, the very first thing is that um climate justice movement has never understood the climate crisis as an isolated environmental problem. So this has been one of the most important, the fundamental contribution of the alternative summits, because uh the climate crisis is not simply a failure of environmental policy. It is the consequence of an economic and political system built on extraction, inequality, colonial relations, and the concentration of power.
SPEAKER_02So climate justice requires not only different policies, but a redistribution of power, who decides, who controls resources, who benefits, and who pays for the damage. And that's because that the alternative summits exist.
SPEAKER_03You also have a very strong rights perspective on the matter.
SPEAKER_01Okay. Thank you. I'm I have a rights perspective because my background is a trade union movement. I'm from the labor movement. So from Coca-Bamba in 2010 to Glasgow 2020 and Bellem last year, some demands have never changed. Let's say climate has changed, but some demands have never changed. So rich countries must pay their climate debt. Carbon markets are not the answer. The crisis is moving much faster now, and every year, 2.4 billion of workers are exposed to extreme heat at work.
SPEAKER_01So now we say it clearly. And fossil fuels start with coal and protect the workers.
SPEAKER_00Interesting. So if we could just stay on, what Kivanshi, you mentioned it there, sort of market mechanisms and the idea that I guess the assumption in that the climate, the climate crisis is somehow market failure. I think we could you guys go a bit deeper than that, just to say the least. I mean, previous people's summits framed climate breakdown actually as a symptom of her editory growth models, extractivist capitalism. There's something more fundamental wrong than just the markets aren't working quite right.
SPEAKER_00So, how what are the steering committee's thoughts on how that turns into a policy agenda that you put forward? What would you put forward as counterpolicy to confront the sort of corporate capture of this narrative?
SPEAKER_02The very first phrase might be like system change, not climate management. So, in this sense, we have four pillars, just exactly as Kvanch mentioned. The first uh one is about uh the rights of nature. So we are defending rights of nature against the ecological destruction. Until now, yes, we have had declaration since 2010, but in practice, we we don't have yet enough mechanisms to practice the recognition of the uh rights of nature.
SPEAKER_02So we have to move forward on this issue. And second point is fossil phase out and energy democracy. It is just a subject which Kumanch is really specialized on, so I'm not going to talk about that much. But it is one side is on workers' rights, and the second uh side is how much energy we really need and how we would like to produce it, how we would like to distribute it, and how we are going to make decisions on this issue. This is the second pillar.
SPEAKER_02And third pillar is about anti-militarism, democracy, anti-militarism, and peace. And on this issue, we have the fundamental rights first, because without fundamental rights, we cannot have climate justice. And uh, militarism because in practice military missions are not uh included in calculations. The very first thing. And the second thing is we have to stop wars for the sake of the planet, not only for people, I mean for every living and non-living entity, we have to stop wars, and also uh the own mentality, we have to fight against militarism because militarism brings us also racism, fascism, etc.
SPEAKER_02And this was the third pillar, as I told you. And fourth pillar is about agroecology. So we have to think about food sovereignty and we have to fight against industrial production of all the food system has to be changed in the sake of like local demands, and also so we have to produce locally, uh, consume locally without uh making richer the industrial agriculture system.
unknownThank you.
SPEAKER_00Vanch, any thoughts from you on predatory growth?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, so just a short addition to what Tucci already said. So we don't just say the system is broken, we bring all alternatives. So People's Climate Summit in Turkey, we we are we launch a campaign. So very fast translation. Translation of the campaign's name is if the work burns, fossil fuels burn it. So this campaign, backed by hundreds of organizations, local, international, or nationwide organizations, so the campaign asked for a clear plan to close coal plants and protection for every coal worker's jobs and pension rights.
SPEAKER_01So let's say Britain closed its last coal plant two years ago, but Turkey, the host of COP31, still has no date. And within the unions, we have a global platform called Trade Unions for Energy Democracy, which is going to organize its interregional big meeting in Antalya alongside People's Climate Summit? In this international trade union platform, we say energy must be in public hands, not run for private profits.
SPEAKER_03Yeah. Come on, you know that I'm rooting for this campaign always. But I have a question: what concrete material victories or policy transformations historically traceable to grassroots country summits, can you point out to us? I mean, have we ever genuinely altered the state corporate consensus before?
SPEAKER_01Okay, so Tuce, if you allow me, I'll just go directly. So look at loss and damage. So for 30 years, poor countries and movements demanded for loss and damage policy. Now there's a found. Or you can take just transition. It goes back to Tony Mazzoggi. Tony Mazzoggi is an American trade unionist from Oil and Chemical Workers' Union. So he was the leader of the democratic American labor movement.
SPEAKER_01So he said, if we close the dirty industries, the workers must not pay the price. Today that idea coming from his legacy is in the Paris Agreement. And last year in Bellem, unions and social movements won the Bellem Action Mechanism. This is the first real space for workers in the UN climate talks. So this is a win, and none of those are gifts.
SPEAKER_01We won them.
SPEAKER_02Oh, actually, I would like to just uh add on what Kwan said, actually, just to summarize in a way, their impact is often not direct, but they make previously marginal demands impossible to ignore. I mean, which is important because they create this political space where movements can formulate alternatives independently from governments or corporations, Because we are not obliged to listen to their solutions. We have to demand our solutions, we have to make this agenda visible.
SPEAKER_02That's how we gain in time these uh like uh the example of loss and damage fund. Uh so in time we can get really some victories.
SPEAKER_00So I've got two thoughts, two questions actually, for you. One is a small one. I don't want it to divert us away from the People's Summit, but I think I am really interested in that complex kind of overlap between workers' rights and the climate agenda, and how I know, if I'm being very honest, we have a track record in our country here in the UK where some workers' unions almost lobby against climate action purely on a protecting jobs agenda, which is kind of crazy because you think, hang on a second, if you see the bigger picture.
SPEAKER_00So I I'd love to come back very briefly to you, Kivansh, on whether you globally see that tension between sort of specifically organized labor and the climate gender. And then after that, as if that's not a big enough question, I'd like to go a little bit further into democracy. You touched on this, Tucio, which is you know, cross-border solidarity, radical autonomy, the role, the role of People Summit when when some of the states taking part are actually repressing activists from having their voice heard, and and what you're doing to fight for democracy.
SPEAKER_00So I'm sorry, there are two big questions there, but should we do the the the trade union one first and the progressive climate agenda?
SPEAKER_01So, you know, it's it's clear there's a kind of challenge or confrontation between ecology movement and trade union movement, and sometimes there is a challenge confrontation inside of the labor movement itself. So this is this is this is a fact. And let's say in Turkey, some of the unions from energy and mining sector they're quite challenging with the ecology movement, it's the same in the global level, and it's the same for some other country, some other issues.
SPEAKER_01They say generally, labor movement is also a peace movement, also an anti-war movement. But nowadays, some union organization says, guys, stop. We need employment, we need jobs. So if this promote defense industry, military sectors, we will have some more employment. So this is a kind of confrontation, confrontation among each other.
SPEAKER_01But let's say globally, everyday trade union movement is more involved with ecology and climate issues. More unions are having climate officers and even climate shop stewards in the workplaces. And let's say only last week I was in London online for a meeting with the British trade unions. It's the campaign against climate change trade unions group. So it was a bunch of different British trade unions from different sectors, so they focused on climate crisis and preparing for Antalya.
SPEAKER_01So we know there is no jobs in a dead planet, so we believe the climate issue is a trade union issue, we should include climate demands in our general policies but also in our collective agreements.
SPEAKER_02Actually, what I would like to say about this, we have to explain to every actor that these are not separate crises. Because if you are not able to pay your rent or like you cannot have an affordable housing, and if you cannot just keep on doing agriculture as you were doing 20 years, 30 years before, then there is something wrong, but it's a systemic uh wrong. So we have to figure we have to show and understand that uh these are interconnected consequences of the same structures of power.
SPEAKER_02So what we need is to understand solidarity as a question of how we can get prepared to organize together. It's not only like being standing behind each other symbolically, but about building collective power that none of us fight alone. Like the struggle of farmers defending their land should feel the solidarity of workers facing an unjust transition. So you have to understand that they are the victims of the same system and they have to act together but in different manners in each sector.
SPEAKER_02That's the idea. And about the democracy, as I told you, very first of all, you need the freedom of expression. Very first of all. Like I just uh said a like a sentence right now, and I shouldn't have a fear of saying that. For example, in France, there are people who are frightened to get out, to march on the streets. So at this point, you cannot just uh say that, yeah, come uh we'll be fighting against this uh capitalist system because you don't want to risk your life.
SPEAKER_02So one of the points that we will tackle in this summit also is defending the defenders.
SPEAKER_03Wow, that's that's a good line. Defending the defendants.
SPEAKER_00I think we found our headline there, Damla. Hey listen, I have I have to say though, can I just come back briefly on the tensions within the left? Um, because I remember, guys, when I was in college. And I it will surprise nobody listening to our podcast that I am on the left. That's not like breaking news or anything like that. And and I was uh I was involved in left politics, but I saw I thought I was really um I was really motivated by animal rights, the environment, and feminism. And I'll never forget my comrades getting me in the corner and saying you are a bourgeois deviant for putting these issues above workers' rights.
SPEAKER_00It's like, what's wrong with you people? Anyway, sorry, Damla, I got distracted by being a bourgeois deviant.
SPEAKER_03Okay, I think that's a good job to do, Steve.
SPEAKER_00I've made a career out of it.
SPEAKER_03So, guys, uh, we're talking about people's summit. Mainstream cops often treat frontline communities and climate displaced populations as a passive stakeholder, like, oh, there are those people there and we will do something about them. Or, well, let's say this for them. But from a rights-based perspective, how do you diagnose the structural inability of the UNFCCCC's process to center human rights and environmental defenders?
SPEAKER_01Oh, yeah, at the COP, COPS, you know, every country must agree. So, oil and gas countries or fossil countries can block almost anything, and people forced from their homes by floats and droughts still have no seat at the table. And uh let's look at the sponsors, it's another issue, so-called climate supporters, but this is kind of sponsor in the business terminology.
SPEAKER_01The climate supporter of COP31, they're building a luxurious hotel on the coast of a national park nowadays. There are some others, famous brands, famous companies who are destroying the environment in Turkey and some other countries as well. And UN experts, you and United Nations experts have written to Turkish government about those echo sites, let's say.
SPEAKER_01So this is a kind of hypocrisy, let's say. And you know, maybe while we are talking about environmental defenders and defending the defenders, we have to recall, we have to remember a dear comrade of ours, Hakan Tosun, a journalist who reported on environmental struggles in Turkey, and he was killed last year. So we took his photos as banners to Belem last year, and this year in Ontario we we will keep his memory alive.
SPEAKER_02Yes, and also all the other victims of the same type in other countries too, because in Latin America too there are too many uh too much oppression on defenders. The problem about the UN's process, uh, frontline communities are often invited to participate as stakeholders, but they are not recognized as political actors. So they don't have a really right to define priorities and making decisions.
SPEAKER_02So being consulted does not mean deciding. And on that point, uh, we have to change something, and the UN triple C needs to move beyond recognizing these rights rhetorically. So they must create mechanisms for accountability, meaningful participation, and protection against uh reprisals.
SPEAKER_00Well, amen to that. Imagine, I I am you know, every every cop that comes and goes, T I'm I'm still amazed at the perseverance, the resilience of some of those stakeholders and actors who time and again have their voices kind of heard, but they take no part in decision making. It's amazing that they stay with this process. It's extraordinary. Hey, listen, so we're almost our last question. I've got one last one for you too, which is when all of the official delegates leave Antalya, what for you would be this kind of threshold of mobilization, new networks of solidarity, or binding popular mandates that for the People's Climate Summit will be a historical success coming out of this COP.
SPEAKER_00What does success look like for you guys?
SPEAKER_02For me, the first point is strengthening the international and intersectional solidarity, as I mentioned before. And a second thing might be like a shared political action plan. Uh, because uh after Belemme, the declaration was quite clear about what we demand. And now it's time to be able to action organize actions together to get uh an answer to arguments.
SPEAKER_01You know, it's it's it's simple, you know. When the delegates fly home, we are still here and still all Organized. So let's say for me in Antalya there will be three big events. So one it's the trade unions energy democ for energy democracy interregional meeting. So we're going to meet with the global trade union friends together and we'll talk about climate crisis and energy policies, public energy policies. Then we will have a big rally, Global Day of Action on 14th.
SPEAKER_01We will take the streets of Antalya. Then we will have People's Climate Summit, workers, farmers, young people, local communities with one shared plan, and that's that's a win. So then that plans must turn into real real fights. So just before finishing, maybe I have to I have to promote our website for People's Climate Summit, which is Hiz. This is PCS in Turkish.org.
SPEAKER_01So just follow us online and come to Antalya.
SPEAKER_03Okay, I will be joining you in Antalya, especially on the day of the walk and the demonstrations. But before that, I have to ask a final question. And before you can resist, we are trying to transform the word sustainability because as it is, we know that it can't be sustained. I know they will re object to that, Steve. That's why I had to say it first. So our network is ironically called Do Not Smile because we need to make that transform sustainability a subject that brings happiness into the world.
SPEAKER_03So what object, place, or person always make you smile? Tuce, you want to go first?
SPEAKER_02Yes, I thought um actually it's not an easy question. I'd say simit, maybe.
SPEAKER_03Yes, it's Turkish bagels, Steve.
SPEAKER_02Because I mean it's simple, affordable, accessible, and makes I think everyone smile a little bit.
SPEAKER_00That's awesome.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I just had I just had my simit a moment ago. Otherwise, I'm going to show it to Steve what Turkish bagel looks like, but I I finished it. So for me, what makes me smile is workers on a picket line. So when people stand together and singing or dancing in front of their workplace, I always smile. That's where the hope lives. Workers in the picket line.
SPEAKER_00I'd like to so if we can bring those two together, can we have workers in a picket line singing whilst eating circus bagels? I mean, come on. Is that not perfect? I think it probably is. Oh, amazing. Well, listen, uh the really best of luck for the people's summer. I hope it goes really, really well, and that you have a really great cop. Uh and let's hope for some lasting changes. It's been really so lovely talking to you both. Thanks, Gavancha and TJ. Brilliant stuff. Damla, we better wrap this one up.
SPEAKER_03So thanks to everyone who has joined our good guys episode brought to you by the Do Not Smile Network of Agencies.
SPEAKER_00And make sure you listen to future episodes where we'll be talking to more amazing people about how we can work together to create a more sustainable. We're gonna have to change the word, Damla. A sustainable word, everybody hates it. I can see Tube Jay's face, she doesn't like it. How about create a better future?
Send us Fan Mail Turning the tables on our hosts, Alexander Deliyannis, our DNS agency Team Sympraxis from Athens is in this episode hosting Damla Özlüer! Damla shares the latest news from COP 31, Antalya, where climate...
Send us Fan Mail In this episode we're talking with Bahar Yavuz from Turkey’s Ichtimam Association to ask a critical question: what if the climate crisis is fundamentally a crisis of care, built on an economic model...
Send us Fan Mail Marine heatwaves are doubling, ecosystems are shifting, and the ocean is sending louder signals every year. So what does real progress look like when politics are messy, money is tight, and the climate...
Send us Fan Mail Design sits behind almost everything we touch, use, wear, read, and rely on, which means it also sits behind a lot of the harm driving the climate crisis. In this COP31 special episode we’re joined by...
Send us Fan Mail On this episode, with our guest host Marian Ventura and also available as a video podcast, we sit down with Rodrigo Cunha, founder and CEO of Profile, a B Corp certified reputation and impact...